14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 1
V14 Dynamic Cellular Processes
John Tyson Bela Novak
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 2
Positive feedback: Mutual activation
Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
E: a protein involved with REP: phosphorylated form of E
Here, R activates E by phosphorylation, and EP enhances the synthesis of R.
4343
210
,,, JJkRkGRE
RkSkREkdtdR
P
P
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 3
mutual activation: one-way switch
As S increases, the response is low until S exceeds a critical value Scrit at which point the response increases abruptly to a high value.Then, if S decreases, the response stays high.
between 0 and Scrit, the control system is „bistable“ – it has two stable
steady-state response values (on the upper and lower branches, the solid lines) separated by an unstable steady state (on the intermediate branch, the dashed line).
This is called a one-parameter bifurcation. Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 4
mutual inhibition
Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
Here, R inhibits E, and E promotes the degradation of R.
4343
'
2210
,,, JJRkkGRE
RREkRkSkkdtdR
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 5
mutual inhibition: toggle switch
This bifurcation is called toggle switch („Kippschalter“):if S is decreased enough, the switch will go back to the off-state.
For intermediate stimulus strengh (Scrit1 < S < Scrit2), the response of the system
can be either small or large, depending on how S was changed.This is often called „hysteresis“.
Examples: lac operon in bacteria, activation of M-phase promoting factor in frog egg extracts, and the autocatalytic conversion of normal prion protein to its pathogenic form.
Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 6
Negative feedback: homeostasis
Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
In negative feedback, the response counteracts the effect of the stimulus.Here, the response element R inhibits the enzyme E catalyzing its synthesis.Therefore, the rate of production of R is a sigmoidal decreasing function of S.
4343
20
,,, JJRkkGRE
RSkREkdtdR
Negative feedback in a two-component system X R | X can also exhibit damped oscillations to a stable steady state but not sustained oscillations.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 7
Negative feedback: oscillatory response
Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
There are two ways to close the negative feedback loop:(1) RP inhibits the synthesis of X(2) RP activates the degradation of X.
Sustained oscillations require at least 3 components:X Y R |XLeft: example for a negative-feedback control loop.
Pm
P
PTm
PTPP
Pm
P
PTm
PTP
P
RKRk
RRKRRYk
dtdR
YKYk
YYKYYXk
dtdY
XRkXkSkkdtdX
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3
'
2210
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 8
Negative feedback: oscillatory response
Feedback loop leads to oscillations of X (black), YP (red), and RP (blue).
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
Within the range Scrit1 < S
< Scrit2, the steady-state
response RP,ss is unstable.
Within this range, RP(t) oscillates between RPmin
and RPmax.
Again, Scrit1 and Scrit2 are bifurcation points.The oscillations arise by a generic mechanism called „Hopf bifurcation“.
Negative feedback has ben proposed as a basis for oscillations in protein synthesis, MPF activity, MAPK signaling pathways, and circadian rhythms.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 9
Positive and negative feedback: Activator-inhibitor oscillations
R is created in an autocatalyticprocess, and then promotes the production of an inhibitor X,which speeds up R removal.
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
4343
65
'
2210
,,, JJkRkGRE
XkRkdtdX
RXkRkSkREkdtdR
P
P
The classic example of such a system is cyclic AMP production in the slime mold. External cAMP binds to a surface receptor, which stimulates adenylate cyclase to produce and excrete more cAMP. At the same time, cAMP-bindingpushes the receptor into an inactive form. After cAMP falls off, the inactive form slowly recovers its ability tobind cAMP and stimulate adenylate cyclase again.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 10
Substrate-depletion oscillations
X is converted into R in an autocatalytic process.
Suppose at first, X is abundant and R is scarce.As R builds up, the production of R accelerates until there is an explosive conversion of the entire pool of X into R. Then, the autocatalytic reaction shuts off for lack of substrate, X. R is degraded, and X must build up again.
This is the mechanism of MPF oscillations in frog egg extract.
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 11
Complex networksAll the signal-response elements just described, buzzers, sniffers, toggles and blinkers, usually appear as components of more complex networks.
Example: wiring diagram for the Cdk network regulating DNA synthesis and mitosis.
The network involving proteins that regulate the activity of Cdk1-cyclin B heterodimers consists of 3 modules that oversee the- G1/S- G2/M, and- M/G1 transitions of the cell cycle.
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 12
Cell cycle control system
Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 13
cell-cycle machineryThe signalling dynamics can become multi-stable when two or more bistable cycles form a cascade, such as a MAPK cascade. The biological outcome of multistability is the ability to control multiple irreversible transitions, for instance, sequential transitions in the cell cycle.
Central components of the cell-cycle machinery are cyclin-dependent kinases (such as CDK1/ CDC2), the sequential activation and inactivation of which govern cell-cycle transitions. The activity of CDK1/CDC2 is low (off) in the G1 phase and has to be high (on) for entry into mitosis (M phase). Tyson et al., Curr.Opin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 14
Cell cycle control system
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
signal: synthesis of Cdk1:CycB
response: Cdk1/CycB
The G1/S module is a toggle switch, based on mutual inhibition betweenCdk1-cyclin B and CKI, a stoichiometric cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 15
Cell cycle control system
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
The G2/M module is a second toggle switch, based on mutual activation between Cdk1-cyclinB and Cdc25 (a phosphotase that activates the dimer) and mutual inhibition between Cdk1-cyclin B and Wee1 (a kinase that inactivates the dimer).
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 16
Cell cycle control system
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
The M/G1 module is an oscillator, based on a negative-feedback loop:Cdk1-cyclin B activates the anaphase-promoting complex (APC), which activates Cdc20, which degrades cyclin B.
The „signal“ that drives cell proliferation is cell growth: a newborn cell cannotleave G1 and enter the DNA synthesis/division process (S/G2/M) until it growsto a critical size.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 17
Cell cycle control systemThe signal-response curve is a plot of steady-state activity of Cdk1-cyclin B as a function of cell size.
Progress through the cell cycle is viewed as a sequence of bifurcations.
A very small newborn cell is attracted to the stable G1 steady state. As it grows, it eventually passes the saddle-point bifurcation SN3 where the G1 steady state disappears.The cell makes an irreversible transition into S/G2 until it grows so large that the S/G2 steady state disappears, giving way to an infinite period oscillation (SN/IP).
Tyson et al., Curr.Pin.Cell.Biol. 15, 221 (2003)
Cyclin-B-dependent kinase activity soars, driving the cell into mitosis, and then plummets, as cyclin B is degraded by APC–Cdc20. The drop in Cdk1–cyclin B activity is the signal for the cell to divide, causing cell size to be halved from 1.46 to 0.73, and the control system is returned to its starting point, in the domain of attraction of the G1 steady state.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 18
cell-cycle machineryHysteresis and bistability were recently shown to occur in the activation/ inactivation of CDK1/CDC2, an observation that confirmed a theoretical prediction by Novak and Tyson 10 years ago.
Bistability in the CDK1/CDC2 cycle arises from positive and double-negative feedback loops in the reactions. CDK1/CDC2 activates its activator (the phosphatase CDC25) and inactivates its inhibitors (the kinases Wee1 and Myt1).
Negative feedback from the anaphase-promoting complex (APC) turns the CDK1/CDC2 bistable switch into a relaxation oscillator that drives the cell cycle.
Intriguingly, CDC25 and Wee1 can be phosphorylated on multiple sites and can therefore potentially exhibit bistability, which implies that the entire CDK/cyclin system can display multiple steady states — this prediction is awaiting experimental verification.
Sequential bifurcations of multiple steady states provide more flexibility in the control of the cell fate and allow for several checkpoints in the cell cycle.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 19
V17 Modelling signalling cascades
Cells respond to external stimuli using a limited number of signalling pathways that are activated by plasmamembrane receptors, such as G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs).
These pathways do not simply transmit, but they also process, encode and integrate internal and external signals.
Distinct spatio-temporal activation profiles of the same repertoire of signalling proteins may´result in different gene-expression patterns and diverse physiological responses pivotal cellular decisions, such as cytoskeletal reorganization, cell-cycle checkpoints and cell death (apoptosis), depend on the precise temporal control and relative spatial distribution of activated signal transducers.
B.N. Kholodenko, Nature Rev. Mol. Cell. Biol. 7, 165 (2006)
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 20
receptor tyrosine kinasesRTK-mediated signalling pathways have a central role in the regulation of embryogenesis, cell survival, motility, proliferation, differentiation, glucose metabolism and apoptosis.
Malfunction of RTK signalling is a leading cause of important human diseases involving e.g. developmental defects, cancer, chronic inflammatory syndromes and diabetes.
Upon stimulation, RTKs undergo dimerization (e.g. the epidermal growth factor receptor. EGFR) or allosteric transitions (insulin receptor) that result in the activation of the intrinsic tyrosine-kinase activity.
Subsequent phosphorylation of multiple tyrosine residues on the receptor transmits a biochemical signal to numerous cytoplasmic proteins, thereby triggering their mobilization to the cell surface.
The resulting cellular responses occur through complex biochemical circuits of protein–protein interactions and covalent-modification cascades.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 21
receptor tyrosine kinasesEarlier concept: discrete linear pathways that relate extracellular signals to the expression of specific concepts.
New concept: interconnected signalling networks. Several triggers use the same pathway in different fashions to achieve different output signals. How?
E.g. PC12 cell-line stimulation with epidermal growth factor (EGF) and nerve growth factor (NGF). Both stimulate the MAPK cascade.
EGF induces transient MAPK activation which results in cell proliferation.NGF creates a sustained MAPK activation that changes the cell fate and induces cell differentiation.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 22
Cycle and cascade motifsA universal motif that is found in cellular networks is the cycle that is formed by two or more interconvertible forms of a signalling protein.
This protein is modified by two opposing enzymes.These are a kinase and a phosphatase for phospho proteins, and a guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) and a GTPase-activating protein (GAP) for small G proteins.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 23
Feedback loops induce complex dynamicsFeedback is one of the most fundamental concepts in biological control. An increase in the number of interconnecting cycles in a cascade or positive feedback further increases the sensitivity of the target to the input signal.
Positive feedback amplifies the signal, whereas negative feedback attenuates it. However, feedback loops not only change steady-state responses, but also favour the occurrence of instabilities. When a steady state becomes unstable, a system can jump to another stable state, start to oscillate or exhibit chaotic behaviour.
Positive feedback can cause bistability. Furthermore, positive feedback, alone or in combination with negative feedback, can trigger oscillations; for example, the Ca2+ oscillations that arise from Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release and the cell-cycle oscillations.Such positive-feedback oscillations generally donot have sinusoidal shapes and are referred to as relaxation oscillations, operating in a pulsatory manner: a part of a dynamic system is bistable, and there is a slow process that periodically forces the system to jump between ‘off ’ and ‘on’ states, generating oscillations.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 24
complex dynamicsComplex dynamic properties have traditionally been associated with cascades of cycles. Yet, even single cycles can exhibit complex dynamics, such as bistability and relaxation oscillations (see previous slide).
A simple one-site modification cycle can turn into a bistable switch by four different regulatory mechanisms, in which one of the protein forms stimulates its own production or inhibits its consumption, thereby creating a destabilizing control loop.
An extra (stabilizing) feedback loop that affects the rate of synthesis or degradation of a converting enzyme can render this bistable switch into a relaxation oscillator (32 distinct feedback designs result that can give rise to oscillations).
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 25
receptor tyrosine kinasesFeedback designs that can turn a universal signalling cycle into a bistable switch and relaxation oscillator. A simple cycle can turn bistable in 4 distinct ways: either a protein M or its phosphorylated form Mp stimulates its own production (positive feedback) by product activation or substrate inhibition of the kinase (Kin) or phosphatase (Phos) reactions.
Each of the 4 rows of feedback designscorresponds to a different bistable switch, provided that the kinase and the phosphatase abundances are assumed constant and only a single feedback (within the M cycle) is present.
Sixteen relaxation-oscillation designs are generated by extra negative feedback brought about by negative or positive regulation of the synthesis or degradation rates of the kinase protein or phosphatase protein by M or Mp. Designs a*–h* are mirror images of designs a–h.
Although synthesis and degradation reactions are shown for both the kinase and the phosphatase proteins, the protein concentration that is not controlled by feedback from the M cycle is considered constant, therefore it results in only two differential equations for each diagram. All the feedback regulations are described by simple Michaelis–Menten-type equations.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 26
receptor tyrosine kinases
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 27
Signal Transduction (II)
Study receptor-stimulated kinase/phosphotase signaling cascades as a model case of signal transduction networks.- amplitude of the signal output- rate and duration of signaling
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 28
Signal Transduction (II)To simplify the analysis, we first consider a simple linear signaling cascade in which stimulation of a receptor leads to the consecutive activation of several downstream protein kinases (Figure 1).
The signal output of this pathway is the phosphorylation of the last kinase which, in turn, can elicit a cellular response (e.g., activation of a transcription factor). Signaling is terminated by phosphatases, which dephosphorylate the kinases, by inactivation of the receptor, which can involve receptor dephosphorylation, internalization of the receptor ligand complex, and/or degradation of the receptor or ligand. This general scheme is representative of many signaling pathways. E.g., growth factors such as EGF, PDGF, or NGF stimulate a receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK), which
leads to the activation of three or four consecutive downstream kinases (e.g., Raf, MEK, ERK, and RSK). Growth factor signals are terminated by protein-tyrosine phosphatases, RTK endocytosis and degradation, protein serine-threonine phosphatases, and dual-specificity and tyrosine-specific MAP kinase phosphatases. The same type scheme can model pathways that include lipid kinases, such as PI3K, whose reaction products help to activate downstream kinases such as PDK1 and Akt.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 29
Linear Signalling CascadesDescribe each phosphorylation step as a reaction between thephosphorylated form Xi-1 of kinase i – 1 and
the non-phosphorylated form Xi of a downstream kinase i.
Phosphorylation rate: second-order rate constant (2 proteins involved):
~
iiiip XX ~~1,
It is assumed that the concentration of each kinase-substrate complex is small compared with the total concentration of the reaction partners.
Assuming that the concentration of active phosphatase is constant, dephosphorylation can be modeled as a first order reaction:
iiid X ,
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 30
Linear Signalling CascadesFor all but the first activated kinase in the pathway, the concentration of each activated kinase i as a function of time, Xi(t) is:
1 ,~~1,,
iXXX
dtdX
iiiiiidipi
Define as the total concentration of kinase i and
as a pseudo-first order tate constant. The above equation becomes
iiiXXC ~
iii C ~
ii
i
iii
i XCXX
dtdX
11
For the first kinase (X1), activation occurs via the stimulated receptor, and
inactivation is mediated by phosphatase 1. Therefore, we have instead
11
1
11
1 1 XCXtR
dtdX
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 31
Linear Signalling CascadesAssume that all pathway components are inactive at the start and they undergo rapid stimulation by setting the concentration of active receptor at t = 0 to R.
Model receptor inactivation by
3 key questions are:(1) How fast does the signal arrive at its destination?(2) How long does the signal last?(3) How strong is the signal?
ttR exp
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 32
Signalling timeThe signalling time i is the average time to activate kinase i.
0
0
dtttXT
dttXI
IT
ii
ii
i
ii
Ii, the integrated response of Xi is the total amount of active kinase i generated during the signaling period.Ii corresponds to the area under the
curve of Xi versus time.
Ti / Ii is an average, analogous to the mean value of a statistical distribution.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 33
Signal durationThe signal duration is given by
0
22 where, dttXtQIQ
iii
i
ii
i gives a measure of how extended the signaling response is around the mean time.
The signaling amplitude Si is given by
In a geometric representation, Si is the height of a rectangle whose length is 2i
and whose area equals the area under the curve Xi(t).
i
ii
IS2
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 34
Weakly activated pathwaysA pathway is termed „weakly activated“ if all its component kinases are phosphorylated to a low degree (Xi << Ci). This may occur when the concentration of activated receptor is low, when the receptor is rapidly inactivated, and/or when the kinases are present at high concentrations.
and the key parameters can be calculated explicitly. E.g.
ii
i
iii
i XCXX
dtdX
11 iiii
i XXdtdX
1
2 ,
110
1 2
2
10 RSS
Sn
jj
n
kk
k
S depends on the kinetic properties of all pathway components.High signal amplitudes are obtained with fast kinases and slow phosphatases.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 35
Weakly activated pathways
n
jj
n
jj
n
jj
n
kk
kSS
1 221
1 2
2
10 11 ,11 ,
11
The signaling time and duration do not depend on the kinase rate constants.
Thus, in a weakly activated pathway, kinases regulate only signal amplitude, not signaling time or duration. In contrast, phosphatases affect all of these parameters, and in the same direction.
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 36
Amplification and dampening
n
jj
n
kk
kSS
1 2
2
10
11
At any step in a signaling cascade, a signal can be amplified (Si > Si-1),
dampened (Si < Si-1), or remain constant. Amplification at step i will occur if
2
1
2
11
ii
ii
Amplification at step i requires that the phosphate rate constant i for a given
reaction is small compared to the kinase rate constant i.
Amplification at step i also depends on the signal duration at the preceding step(i-1). When the signal duration was long, amplification can be achieved even
when the phosphatase rate constant at step i is high (but still smaller than i).
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 37
Amplification and dampening
14. Lecture WS 2008/09
Bioinformatics III 38
SummaryKinetic modelling of signal transduction networks by systems of coupled ordinary differential equations:- challenge consists of deriving the appropriate sets of equations- solving their time-dependent behavior is routine when done numerically, may be very challenging (or impossible) if done analytically.
Other approaches for „data-driven“ modelling of signal-transduction networks:- clustering- principal component analysis- partial least squares regressionSee e.g. Janes & Yaffe, Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell. Biol. 7, 820 (2006)