7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
1/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
2/166
-/ #!+/
++k +k
NN
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
3/166
+/ /*2Y0w} b^uY}
)&%!/ '&$(/
/ $b^g`2.i} t2Yo2}
b^^MNxY} #+} /
PS} bA>?jh} b2h2bt20}
#^} `,bi} ^:} i?Bg} -^_M}V,y} -2} c2`b^0p.20} gi^b20} AY} ,}
b2ibB2t,O} gwhj2V} ^d} ib,YhVBii20} CZ} ,Yw} :^bV} ^b} -w} ,Yw}
V2,Yh} AY.Tq0BY>} 2P2.ib^ZD.} V3.@,YA.,P} `@^i^.^awEY>}
VF/b =LOVFY>} b2. b0EY>} ^b} ^j@2buAh2} 4v.5ai} :^b} j@,i}
.^`wAY>} a2bVAij60} -w} %2.jE^Yh} / ,Y0} / ^;} i@2} )&}
^`weB>@j} ,u} ,[0} 7v.2aj} -w} b6tB2u2bg} :^b} j@2} `o-PB.}`b2hh} uBj@^oi} ubBji2Y} a2bVGhhG Y} :b^V} i?2} $o-PDg?2b}
$bHYj60} DY} j?2})YDk20} %j,i2g} ^
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
4/166
?Bu^uZ
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
5/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
6/166
'-*6 &$6
$ #$
$ #$
dU[U
g9,GWW?5
dU[&
5
h Y'&*8&8(5+8
| e %# 'bb 9
Dh&}d#
oUQ5868#8-/8
gC 8 > LK.GSfQ.
^ E&IP& -+#-83*0(&8
D &ee
% [
^#f99ihWj:yC:k
Sf|N
ZSS#& 8-(3+--8(&8 8+-08 &8(("-8!813-8
+S` [ % `,Y%` G?%` UG` *=t t /=M=5pt nMS=t4%sDd S % BQ4G @Q` %V\%% @ MQ!E9F0t Et TU66E/t ,jZ6MGt Ht
D7>8NIt v Et 9tEYV9R>9OEt ,%P%` W%@ O4G@P `Ba!V:?9q!tZt
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
7/166
" , + * * # . G * @ o
%%J%%#P#P^Pb%Pb#%#PP%%b%PPPP%aJPbP%Pb%PPPP%.P #%P%%#%P%%P%^#%P%%#P%%P%JPP%%P%dJP'KPbP%PPPP%P,P%.P#PPPPPP#PP%PbPPPPbP
PPPPP%PP # b%J% P%bPPbx?%%%P:PAb%P%P%P]P.%P{P:PPvP>PPP%%%P%tP.P%P?P].#P%iPPP%P#P%P#%b%
PP%b%P']PP%%P%'ePT%P:PAb%bP%3P%Jb.PPP%%P%b%P%%%P%%: A%%Pb P%PPbP%PPP%P%P%%P#bPPg%f%%#P%:bP%
P%'UP%%bb%P%%%#PP.PP#P%PPbg%%Pe.P%%#%%%%%PKP Pe.P# ]#]%PP%P%%P%'&B%dPKPP%b%%P%PKd
%%%APP3PbP#Pd P P bP%PG P%%%P#{.Pbjh %P zj S''' j P I\ \ P 0 &"-\ @4 " # \p " r
o\ g4
c
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
8/166
aY
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
9/166
@
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
10/166
?;3UhM IQU3EN;ix-U
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
11/166
>bY ,FYxw CFxzkaYFYE^:FxFQkF 6b1YF}Y
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
12/166
lxjFxxVMxk_UaxUaU~4F;bFU%7)U ,G_W
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
13/166
-RmEE_yESUc JSU[UOUAUmUSUAm_UnU*U .~E_U
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
14/166
ITX[XMX kBmExX)X ,E`X
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
15/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
16/166
/C
~
#-#/
)/*!//'/&%//%/
/"%/
/6
#-#/
/oE~'#,'/
%%#%//
#(/
%(-#/
/66C
,#./"".$%/
E,(/%+%/
/%+/#%/
oECZZ"%//
\G~mxUIGkUIUk_ Ik{ I;GRkGIkG k JRUma ,G "kGG+_aU
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
17/166
!EkUUEEo_
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
18/166
* A . ~ A ,
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
19/166
" @ c # . , D
e# s:
s#{
Ass'#spp3dsKfn:s{':'vS3xsss~A
## # # s 3s 3 d'3 #
s###psrfs#s.# sp # s###3ssR:#s#rstS3#g#A#
#s#svsd##s'U#s#p#s#s3ss3#s
s: Y43 42F9;',C+=24C;F362&2#F2F *3(%0#F 30F -1(;2;;") 4""UU"6.; 8; 92,$!; 1F ,.)/:$!; "; %"; 03)";0BE3:)F
!; 5*4; '&7+;;` '
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
20/166
A > A * 9 / $ $ " " ? .
) . a! )v #
9)}# 1## )'# #)^ ###J#!~ RU)#d *)#)
#) '!!!#)###)) )))## # ' # Q H ?)F)F'A#?c'
t?))`!! '1Q sb 3G@ , hh Ss{w}Bjn
H uw wS} 3'Ge@ z)4rb#)#T) ) N ) #-
#G@'UGJ)A) L 1#iG@)#} -)* h#GS3@dd )L0^)) 1 ( 1 `- R
;# " c, 1 Y)
1p 2 q "k c 1 ( 1 ` 1 I- - *p 1( ~ m V (*aVV 1 $ / T ) ) ; k * [ # b ;
!
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
21/166
; ' ' / ; ' # 2
99999#99UyII#9
]9#9:#999dI9r9#r9#9r9I99II9#I999r999III#999Ir999I999#99 r' K99 9
I999999f#999999939999v999I e?'y#9T#9I9II99tI9I9999####9#9m9
'UII9Tp9#9999~9v9I99I9I9#9p99999.r9#99rI9999#f#I# 9.#9 99'~9v9I9I99999999999999S999?U9p9A9999I99If99999999##99I
9'
?9999t99>)) M-t
I>)I> h)9
Jb:MK=="/t d "MKM B:tKtQM=t5b5t4Ia:( 5 +b2#tMa3#Ut,MU#Zt
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
22/166
* A . A , ))h)!#)
e ?T3 I))B#S)A~)t e )I)#a
I!I)r)I# ] .B t)ad h9)))'~) aIjB
)))I
!IF ,,,, A#
h 9x!: #I
( H zb?
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
23/166
" 8 8 c A H ` 8 # . ` , o
)>>)x):>>>))
>)5> a )
5?>)5)3))>))I)))J>J>)5>)5I ' B> I. >>
))>>Rx)5>5>.5)5>>> 5 >9>>J))I'>>3v5>V'?>>>I.>
5.)>I5>)5)I)+I5I>>>3 f>>>>Ry>)3>?>I>>))3 )>.)I)>>
>'>>5>v))>)I)II>>))5)I>> > )I' B> ) >I)I)))>I)IJ))Jh5I).>>I)'B>>I))5I>).)J5)Ii@Xl,Xl@YXM@mzX#,,& 9h>9Y#\ P
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
24/166
4$# : *&3) $/6: 4: "&)7:
v)>>I)#I)#>>3
I3I>)>)'B>##)I)I>>#I>>R:>IIJI>>:)J#>>B>#)
6>.. IIG@ G>@I )> >3I>>)#Ii{B}]B )#)
:)>))#
#>))ii)>I>>I>3T)I>~>>.>6I#>)>))#>>))3>
)'B)J))z>(X>#)>))9>##>
>K>z#))Ii! >)I>
p( h h@>>g ] 6 IR K# >#>?J "$ (Xr !+>>))
_# ( " $ j ] ,] =L = h " # N S_ ''N
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
25/166
L b ( ( & V
U||J}J
|}}}II}|v }'K}}}}}||}}|kT+ }|||JI}I|||R?}I|I+++}}|}}}Tf||||}R
B |.|} }|+ ||i|}||}}}}||vd+I|3I |' U } }}^|I|++
|I5|}}}}}}K||}J|||||+I}}||}|I}}3|+3||I}|}}}'|v}||
}}||IJ|RU+}}y|G}|@|.|J++||}}f}|d}}I'
K|+K}
|}}}|+}}|R T||50$\5-C5F
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
26/166
; O ' # 2 C< " " ? .
))I Ii f
))R )3))'
tII+I'?))3+++I
+))'B+)K)J'))hIi3
)I3I)IJ')3G@H I) + + ) I3+zRBIHIy 9v ' S5) )))IIT
z )Itm+ I++++z z'BI)) $ x ))+? 3)I
#+I9! 9:)
H U>>hz9^^(1 0 ?( E(-h ^ ( |j?T( (WO1` ' '+ Q#i _(+-.Of'+ | |+'+ " >-|3 " B, > > ,M" 3
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
27/166
Z ,k / ; * # }.}
VV)S)s){ps.V)
ss)+VSVVV))S.:VsAA.'BsS?:VK)V))sR
e>
)535^V) KVG@{R:
Gs'@ B K))) Vd!VV3'B{R:'sV{R:RV3s a)sV : A VR
?.s?ss^?VV
#A21'A81$6>A+A&A6#A''A
:sVeV)U V e) +
f5V)+)V))V)e)dRB Vfs)VVVV+VVV'y+Vs)))>sV>VV?].'
.KVsaJ#?)))tde)5VsVpI8L hhV>>b# G UG 7 3hzhK+*D
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
28/166
; ' # h / ; ? # P P D
"
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
29/166
@ + ; # h @
*$ZW$*$*$*$/*W$:W$$S***'K*W$$#W$?$Z$Z$W$$Wf$*"$$#//$$#$$e$*#"H#*W/#****$' ' $//*W$$$$/#*$$ZW**#W$$*"*W$'BW$K/*W$$"$"*W$/'BW${':'tS$3*/$$]*$#B$3#$"*W$x"*/Ap**/$WS$3*#//$//$$$~$
A$/#//.$*/***Z**$**W/$*"W$*/$'
] /*$ W$*$ / i$* *"W$K$$ZBW$?$$"*W a$$
$*
*/$$$/$$W$?$].$*//$ $$ *"q/$W$ *$/ q$$$p*$$$Z$$"W$*e$/'
BW$$$*ZW $"$$W.$*$$*/$*$"$$#$W**Z*"$*//***$3*$3*"$$**/**'qBW$#?$p$#Wq$*$/**/"Z$$/$$*"$"t$*$/$W$$$/$**/$$*/**"$Z$Z* W"Z"*$W$W*$**$ZW$$*
* 'K ##/"$f$/*$.* $"0*/W*$$$///$e$*$W$$WZ*"*$*$$$*.$*"K$$W$3$$W$?$].' A*"ZW$$*$**W$"$/*"$*Z*Z$*.*"*//$r$$$/$Z$/q$W*qe$#/$$/Z*WW$*$/W*W
$*W$WZ*$//$W$?/$W*W$':*W$"$$*"W$?$$ZZ*f$$**/W*/*** , Ph @ $WWW/# ]'N+ * " *+ J %
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
30/166
; O ' # h Dt ; I ? # P P
?*$7*77$$7$*$C77/$*7$?7W7$$$$$/$$/*$W$*7$*"
7*7*'S*$*$7$$$$"**$/77$C*C$$W7$$CCW$$*"G$*7$*"$$Z$*7$/e$7CCW*7CC$7'KC7*C/$$/$*$/$*$$7$7$C7CC*$f$7*7*C 7*C*$7 ' xC7A $Ap* /A/C C C77$*"$?G77$/$/*C7***7*W$G77$/$/
C*$$W$W$?$$7$77C77$7GC7C*//$$$$"*$$**"*$C*C*$$' K //C** W$ *ZC* * *7*$$ *"*CZ$$$7/7$$/7*$$CZC$7W$*C**"G77$/$/*C7*C*7/$7*$7$$77$/Z*"*/$ZCC/$C*/C**"C/$3$Z7$$*Z$*77$7*"$$Z$'B7 Z$AJ*/WCG77$/$/*$$C$$*$7$7$$7*$7$77$7C*/C*7C$7*$*v7CC*R ' R 7*$$*7W/*Z$$$$77$/$/'W$*T**"C$*G7$*"$$Z$*$ZC$$WC*$$C7*f$*W$*$*$C*/
7$7*"Z$/*/$/C77C$$**W*/CZ$77$7*7$"*7*CZ$C*$$$$CW$
$C7$///CZ$C**$7$$$$77i7C"^C*"**$g7$C*$$'?W7$C7$/*3*"$**7/Z$$3$7$C$7*$3W$$ z /CZ*" CWZW$Z$7W$/$*"$*CCC7$ZCC$/'
W$/W*/"*C$$77*"$?C77*"7/C77$$ZCC**W$C$7
J--77*$7ZW"*/*/$.$*/C^L " J j"*/$7/$$77C$/*Z*CZ(C C c 520E? YG7*/7C M SL,-# # K E3 JE*s E i : IE%%
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
31/166
4: *0/*: 4## : *'3)#/8:
M8.GM"""R~""+
M883i8M"+?.8M""88'@
?p88^88"M"K!+8"88MtVM'G]88+@8+G8"
8+ M "8"8^M'@BK8f"M8M88+"+ Mf' S8MtMMM"88M"^
88M ++"Mt':8"8K8@"3+M."8"' : ' 8MS3' M.+8M8MT888 ' : " ""MxS!!SAA"88RB""T"""+."M+"888'S8"dM"M BuQ 8"M
M888M"8f4'C[$@l'_t\MDc6D[tCPLkC$Hd]t dPt "/ PWt6CRPXbE"t M , tJb;ME^bb%tZMm&T%:1Jeot
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
32/166
> # ( & 2 W { g #
S+"3+ VT"+"""^
VVVV+""VMVV.VRM+V"VVV3V"M"G3@rJ"GM@VMV.]"""V ' VV
MV+?"MR"V+G@M"MJMAJVM+"VVV+."""TVR:+"+Rg"JVV^xV?JVM"V+K c""i"M3M++vV T ?V+'T M?M"VMf9X'xVJV V ?V" SG"@GVV@!'
?+VKVV""+c "" P A cV
Z A X XU M"""K"K P 9 : GR''cVMM P >/A 'G R'U/ c a ) q 3 % ,0E. 6W B'{0-hC
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
33/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
34/166
( ( Nc ? N
" Vp . f 88MRy858VT
VVM"5"V5""8G8M@fGM ZVV@R
#A=%.A.11A11%1A
. K8V 5"V5{ ' : 'S3888^88885"58M 8VRaV~"a:88VMj""VV885TVMV3853TVMV5""VM"3M"V8885VUGV"@"58V858VM5jM"8VV8R
B{':']8e88.V""@"8885 :"5@ R]]! 3Zze""V m ""8"8T4 @"8?858M
V.V"' K m x88a.8;/ g MV"""88;V1( V "m"""8$$%/V8 3 .8M'yj j:"888
F " jAj3r3S35 1 +88,lg,f."
(& 1 =I&* J e e J j + & 1 ` , 4 " ] Z ` m
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
35/166
2 & ( H (
88RS+8!J88 (8 ~8A 8 88 8!(8
!8(8+':'M8r!!M+M8888!88!MM !!!8!8'B+!8i8((~8A8888M+!M8((+M+8!8
M'K+x8K!8(8
K8MA8J3(':'S3%88M!M8((8M88(88M(Ry8+8!!!8Mx(8x!x88(88M8T
8!!8'B8!8!!M8MKA:8A+8(t8Ml8!8f88(!((( 88(S388x!(8+A8J+B3'BA8+8J8(Bjj !!
8(8888i!8M(8!!'B+8M3!8(8+!888!!+88+Tk!8+888+(88~A88! 8' K !!+' : ' !8i8(8M+@8 !8T!88!!!!@8(K8!!!R
7 L73 88(8 W7! 1I b b b * Pb,b,
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
36/166
& & D ? P
HOR:(OM.3M
O(((O HH+^OOOOS3OMHM(RB + HHM(J(H+HHHO
B O(HH ((OH RSO(H3(OOHH +H++MJ((O( 3OH(OOH w eO FHHMO, IO+HM+( OO(Ow
(OOOOOd# . 1 4 I M+M(O 1 z - HHOO w 3OHO( Of+ 1 ( D Ix(OM(M$ + MOHO(M:OTsAO(- i gH- HHH+
j(O: II((HwxH O(MOOO Q H]mj]wu Mt(M+(3O(^4 +r MB . 5 I $G ((OHHw
9 I .(.Hd q gst (.)h6l*G*`Zt(OM+q . + h3+t ' - C I - ImHHmweOH(i < A grt " $ $ /$9$ -j % ;- I FO HHO ` Y l% ; ."" $ h M t $ $ % I zzFz/ 6 > & ) I 2 9 7 I " I C . % HI % I
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
37/166
" 11 & ( H ( 2 V
]e!OO!!!O +MOfO.!M^
++++))O'BOM]e)O!!)O!O"!O +
O!M+O!)MO") 'S+MO!)MO!)+O))MO
"+M{:'
+':'S3OO!3O+)""O"!"!"O!OO!M+!^!O)+O"O" 3
!O)M)?OOM'B"OM"O!!OOTp!)O!"!"OR
?!gH))"OO"MM3O)!OO+{ ' : R "OO^
"?!MOOMM))!!p'B))3!JO"""."O!O+)))3O""."!O"!+O+!!+!+!O!)dM'y+!!M"d"O!.)O
MO"!O!!R]!3!M)']"MO)M)OM!+O+"-8>F /"O!Omnd: !38F683C%-#F7F398F 7 * " j & Jv
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
38/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
39/166
v [ M | a ( ( M D
M8H S88MH HHH((HHMM.8(8'B ( a?HH( x (8M' : ' :' (HH8i(8M8(((BS/(((88a88(GH(
@M ww B8(HHM8(8RBAH.?HHMBA(8a]MH(~J8HH8RB]H?HH8M(M(88(:8HHM
8(HMM.8H8HMB(xMHM(HMH3(8fH(88'
.]8?H8MHHHM
(8 M((HHMHM( (H H(88 38.8(8M8HHiM(T8p'BM8^MHHHMH(
MMH(' B HH88HM((88MMjM ((300Y -X7-X f7- 'M a" Q F8 >
c 84FcQ 4 D 7 *" R k $
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
40/166
( [ ?
i.4J
aaG"+++4 i su]}S ""++"+++ ?4"ai]?'??r
i+4l"+
.?dz"ij"?U4+z"i?v.F3
j 4.+ % /"]?dJ z4""
".
- /4"#+ ( /"+ / 7 5!7 i+" K4 ." z j + """ T 1 JRK ) & / F"++ !.7 j * $/ %/ /?$Fk.d . /, & / $ + " 5 c F J6 U A + I '/ ( / !# ( "&'// c " c $
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
41/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
42/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
43/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
44/166
# R # 3
G#G$*#*G*#4:4*"${B]Bj $'4wsw $E$$4$E*d
**"rE**$4*4E*$*'U4$*uwsw $$"*uSsS]u :4$#44$*4G*$G*E$'4#uwsw G4$$$"*444$E***$*"E$*E$$*$E$' * U$ $*"4$E *".$***"$*$r4$Gd # :4 4 HG E$$*$$ *
$*$4$E$$4G$$****"44**'U4#4$*$#uwsw $$$#G.$#**#$*$*$*'U4$$4$$*$4$4$*$$'#E4$*4$*#4*44$*""*"E$"*4$**4*$$*'
:4$***"uwsw$*$$#4$E4
*EE*E*4$$$"***"*$$*$$#4EE$**"$*$E$$f$"E**$*$$'4E$$fT $*$$ *$ "$4$$"* *T
$*"*J$4E*$*4**$y* *$E*E*$4$$4$*"*T z#*"{ww]} Owu]V 44$*$#$4$
4*$*444$*$*4*'G]$*4$$# #"*$$$G"$$4$#4"dj$*ny$$4$$*"$4*E.$ 4$ $E$* G$*4$E$# E4$*i4 ; $ 4$**"GE*E$*$ * *"w & ,*"$'U4$*$$E$ 4&&!7 .$$*.$"$$*$$$4 G / $.*I$ Il)*K$'U$#4**$*$" & 7 $GU4$e$'?4:4"***"4$ 5 0 * I9G .7$#4G$*4$E$ ? * @ $ " E I * I & \ 2$$$
` ;; @ % F 9 .* I * 6 I > :I 9 I : : )20."..7 U
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
45/166
Z > U
4p24"k22+ 4kI"2k'k2444
42}2242"2dI4]24+4]4"4g4p+24"24k"]2424K4+242 + i2"2"I244f24""4'U422q24"p22+424ap+Ia2k
quwsw 2 "42 24 I+:4k22A"24"qk 24 " 2k ' K2k224I+kl24""224242k"422k'U44uwsw pk4wsw k22"24"k"l
22424+k2"4222k"2244I" 4 ' ' ' 2'
A24442+:4k2224"2"24"k244"+k+2c24kk22"424424~2 uwsw ' ' '
' ' ' I + I2 q 4kuwsw]4Iuwsw B44+42424Ik42k+2I2"2B4I24I+k2"""k4kk 4B4+ 24k242k4"2l2+I"kkIk2k22k"4"k4"24j2~k"2+> W | * XI fRK RX WX 2$ f X 7J N g*4 )
$+ e Fe* * # #
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
46/166
# { o d #
.
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
47/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
48/166
, 9 6 E % 3
***f***lf*4***"4*l
**+**"""**"**+* +*+4**l**** f**4**+4*?*"4+*"4*****+4*"44+*+4*l*4***"*
"**4*v *nK f**+**+4*****"Kf+444**"r.**Kf**.*4*"44*Af**4***"4*{****"*4*****"***"
***444*=]**4*"4**+
4*t**JJK"q*=*@4*4**"?"* o + **"4*4l ***4*"*v+ *4*4.**l *4q@K***4"*"**4* ; 9 "**4+lv+4 Ff*" 4QSsw A+4"44'qF*?*44 ''
6 f *"*****
qT 6 * * 4* * *
r q @ @ K6 4**4*s $05 5 U ;6
7 =*4*"*
" 5 Ykk / 9 ?+*=+*=
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
49/166
" p 9
k")" )"k#E#
"#"E Ek"EE
k)"")#)kT ) # "k#)#"dk?kk#
"#
"kr)))ErE)T ""kEGe"E))#f))"i"""EE "")--
SkE"EE"E)J")E#Ek"]dEUy
S))#E)k"k)#E#kk"k)"" l##)Kf)kkUG"@#kG"@a#k"Kf#"EE)j)~#))#j
k))i
!!# j3K-3f f- f{3K`K`WfX f
+ / h 'h^^ s (^5[ (//( / ?
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
50/166
! + 5 " -
222522K"5:2225222
"a52222222"2222"2K2"^252"K2225525"2K"25"22"J}BJ 2QSsw 2225
2222 52222222522HUG"222 2552{}BJ]JS 222K "5 225 22" 5 "2r"52 2"""2d2522""
U222"222222222222"2 2"22J >\S :wJ]Bj%wu}BJ 2SG22U2"22222255J""S2222 K" 5 2222f" 2^ J2 2 .S2 222"222522522d"2222225J522""22"022"522"2
2"~22"2252 $ K v V 2 :22HK E K vA Xw ]u]u2e K$F3y $/An R$ 6 , f I ?
h
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
51/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
52/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
53/166
" + q ! % 2 4
;'35.
;;; B;55'e3;3355>aA+Sy5A~>
;?x.p'
Y :;i; ' ;5;iwK 'K+'
: 5 +5w+]5;wB;>;;'Kda '
g B ;; ;;l'A3T53;'
.91$+A86.+.*?A+A6#A86.+.*?A."A6#A.'$6$'A
x:3;;;c>>;:;;mh! m >>dP d+ d$G>`i{lB Hd $ F >yoQg#-i ! e ( + FS o H * ~N. H l n
!+
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
54/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
55/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
56/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
57/166
! n
u//
B)u)/(uy//Q xu)Q)'s{]|S (u),']QK/^//)uQ)Quu^Q u / Q+u
f))(u'Q \Uxjx[aICj u))()/(QQ////u)(//uBu))p)/u(u(/~u))
u/u)/u)Qu/))
#!A#!.'.,>A."A.9!1!$,+6>A
) / u) , u// u) u ) u))
)u/tuuQ//))B3(/)u//v/uuuuB/uuuuu,u)va/t).)Q/'u))QuAuQuQ(/Q)Q/KQ/Q/u)/fh(uh(/ 0 !t !'Ku4BuQ uh'K Ly S S x ,
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
58/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
59/166
Z ' ) & e ) 4
y1a1l 1 1 11 a 11 ; 1
#1'#1111(.1#l 'B1;a13]1J11(GA1(11S@T1(#y ;1.;1?1J1(111'S
111;c(19#1111111^#1(1(1111'
y ; 11 1311(a(111a(1(11(1#Gc@1.;a1 #11) 1. 111111 1 ;1# 11 (A :1 # ]1#tf'S#11f1(11111(11(11(1?\B ] \U =\]}Q 'BU (3#A:1.11111#1111 1
;;'B#111((1)1#:11l1J11;11111(1]1111( m11 ( 111##;1;31^11'
]1#m1;11;1111
a111f(1113(1?]1G11 / ! #.;1#1j C V ) l[ a'y#;1j& & + MQ C V
//
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
60/166
% R ! F E %
;a#@;.a;
a ;':##a.; a' A K ;#;].a## . ; a ;
aA##x'B;T'B.;A;#\wsw Z S';xr##
# ; ;####pd#.f#t^'#x#;#;'.;y#;#a#;. ' B #^###.##a'] e1 ;;^ ;# 'A; mmqim r O P bCa / O O P aC#^ i:s: ; % %: " s8@yObC1
L07 J =%
>
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
61/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
62/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
63/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
64/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
65/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
66/166
J 6 w J -
###/'/:
#?#./b//#b'AK/b#t ##/..bb'./i#./#./b'
B/b/R:/.#/b/T//.RBb b V/ / //3 J./b/b'yT##///'K//#/J/r3T #GJ/ /3b b':///#
/+.'Bt'B^l/'
# \U
/RB/lI6v X- / b3 < {
I6 jjj6J
+ ~ | [..< { I6 ^l{ Zb
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
67/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
68/166
' # ! C $ # ' - K
/ 3////)J'
R K I/ r// ) /I/dr)/I)/#I/)/R/#f/AS)'~
//:I/I)J//)/#/ / 3 / )//))'~I/)/lI/)/)')/
//)3I)/))tGg@/G'@/3//I/))/JJ)/I///oj'
.:1$,+A'$+A+A6#A#.'.,>A."A''$+4A
e)#))/)//I)#I//'//)d j///o #jc'/) 9` W% 3 '' 0 B CJ$KO ` @` ' /# 8P `D 1 `ID[$ K` S w%DC'] j!c!S *%E9 F( - 8` E@&` T + : ` ) +l 'LG>`. {8m %
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
69/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
70/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
71/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
72/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
73/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
74/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
75/166
$ $ y 6 < 4
?(-(@M,%%%%@(%/4%M
// a"W "- L
"%-"("/D(M!1^
a 1 a, ( - (
% ('1" R , ( -
%(4^!
-"- (
41 ]%,(~,''(/'(
@M, (1 %"
"%-(%-
K( XX00 ( X XTX(X5XX4XJX6XXnK5X35KX0XXXT55X'??
X0(0(KX05XX(XX(nSXXX0XX( XXX(?30 X`XFw
AX3(3X(XXX(Xo0(vFXX{:wK(X(XXX.~0X.?l5 X (GX XXX@ r ([email protected](~0XUX.0XX(X?yo?l5RxR#?:X(~0X.'
BXXX0((XlXX50X` {:F 4 (4 @? a @K6 6 6Y K P! ! ~ 2!! !9!
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
76/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
77/166
^ Q / ! ! @ N
.0D(D +m+'
A(000__03_D((D_(3000_ D_'U.33TD____(3(_'D
3___(((0___D(t0__((D+0++((_+0_(__0+(3(_((_(0'U0+(+(+0___( 0__+ _ 0_+ D : _ (D _ 0_+D_000D+(3_03+ 0 _J AtD+
(((_+_l+D((n+0_(D({:D(__Dc(
:_D_ 2L{;beG] z _.>wl2
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
78/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
79/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
80/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
81/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
82/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
83/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
84/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
85/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
86/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
87/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
88/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
89/166
V
\ . \\t \# H\d# \\#
\\\\\\\\nU\\\\\\'
A# \\\3\\\\\\\\\3##\4\\\T#\\\':\3\\#\\\\\\\\#\\\Gttg#@#:\A# S# A : A'K\#H\\\\\\#\\\
\\\'\\\\\ \\\3\# \\g\e\\S\\?\:Bg.\\\\ \\\#\:AG
\@\]\\``\\\ R#\\\\\\#\\p\\\\n
#!61$'$@$+/A.;!1!$/+6>A
A\Ap\\\S\!GU#j Y6 L 6b#### g !qDO Y \DE ' B#9 P }< Dj0} 0 | < ?
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
90/166
L L | - X L
.0'U0R?00((
0(_3_^ (0 ( T_00(`S'
a. :U _ ( ((( 0_0(]e_((> (_00.__c_(((_ '0^.0wU
Ap~0S3U
3'
0t0 (((_0((30(0_60'rg_{R:'tS3nU(((3J((__.__0_{:(_0.'
]3eA(00Gc 0_
0T
L EY ('yG]c l
X L { R% Om
( o(`((#q%
2)? | V5qZ&2O d m{^
D )D % + % Q# NS5&m 22)D% )
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
91/166
$ 6 q ! 6 . ! D
5.
'@S.5
E7C%%9
i?K%%q%P,
E 7 mL 5 , - X
+ 07 7
% 0 %- X1c
%NR% 1i7k
NvI1
,}N:0
PG%&%5 c n-
%E7 7 w
Y9EX
cv.
?.TLpRB T!555'B
vKT5AG3AKpK5`0%$!5 . &5 0!- $! 5'A !)u ) & % ))") ) $ ) ) $) $ )[ 2y t &t ) Q[ t M!4? t &t & Q t
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
92/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
93/166
x B B r B % \
4(34(44nB
6644( 43444444'
U44:]Ae6r:]Ae64{:y6:T4 {:34(4D(TB4Gp(@Gf64544((6(654(64664 46n@B43 .46r4G466@544(
rGp(d@ 66.rG4@p4!3^3(46'
B4666p44
4(4(46(nB465c5^(Ra4S444T( GA cj4(j 7 7 /
0.@ D@' / :#D(j)*kdi_W-/ 7/ VV # * k@ mtko8p X |k8u8SEd5 kAmkX jmk8p m" X9 k\ #f+ T fE g0 _ gF T dE0})
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
94/166
3 X ] 1
+.3n@]
+x+l +'
y+ll3'x
R
?cp+ + lp'A+606 6+
c+++'?6 CjS|uC]S ++ .+3.+ q @~+
pxA +x + +{:~.y'Kp + Ul & & hl
&x hch .jD&/%& x O%&& x 0oZ> '6 '& & x &> ; :
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
95/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
96/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
97/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
98/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
99/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
100/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
101/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
102/166
k u " 3 X Y
K 05':03Hl.' 000
rr300 0.RB 30 { : K A0
R r 0{':'qa``0n@.] 0 : A A0300pd!.
' B00 lJ0R0lj'
#A#.'.,$'A*$+1A.:1$+A
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
103/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
104/166
,, " ]
'?oj ] E8E,`S Y Y `SI\K 8, F ^` 8 nVP ^` [
000T+0'?++oo(+oo0 + o01'+ 5S `jn&
#
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
105/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
106/166
) -*6 & 0 * 6
$ $
:3333=P-7& ',//%/"&/
'p
=t,
> $, 43 $443. tM > $
43-.
oFxy3
D43 >C -
.
=.F7YF3$-F3-xz
?c`````t`0c c + 00c``````+
.``B0`3``4```00``````+0`cc``U4`` 4`` 0``l````+3``+``c `` ` K`p`4` ` `pt`0+``cc?````+4`````c``c
4p+`+```````T = Z `P;P`04``cc`0ccl\2`_?8` U 1%T&` >IPP'P ` X `P;P`P`0Y > Y`h,h`
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
107/166
^ 0 @ _ G 0 ! _ 1 5
##(v((0RUf0n
# ]QTv_Y 0 .Ry#v#c#( 0R :# 0 3#0(( S 0 nr( Sq
@( #(R :0l(((cpR
#( c 0((nU(#(3# m R]3m#l 0RUr`#(r0
Ry.#0# d( 'U #(.(0R
U0(`jm(]/$)$*(/ A ! m(mj 6 %! ! Ou! 2 ! [O_ O O Z! O 2!O _0 ! _ O _O ( /
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
108/166
7 ) ) A
!,%%, L&& 9 [ f J )+'{,!&&P [ J
, % %,,,,!%! { d # !!,,'y%5YW6{ &&* + [ %!Y""%,,%,,,"%{&O JKG[`!%!!,%%,#""%,!" 3 & Y%'
,,!%"%,,%%B%%,,v !!,%, ,%Y",5 ,3#,,,%,!"
,,,!,%%"%!! %%G '@ ?!!"",%,Y,,,,Y"!!.%%!Y%,,,!,!,d,"!"!##,%%%YY,!,,%,%,,"!!%,?!!,%,,Y%%i%%Y!Y""!,,%,#%,,%
%",%,%'B"V!,,,,!!%,""!%,,,!"!,%,%"%,'BY5%%3,,%"%!!"%,%%,"!%"!!%n
#A+""%>A."A''2A
?!!,,"",!!,,i"Y%5,Y!,!,",%,%%5,,Y%"%,%,%!,,,"!hj%'y%5!!V!Y!YV!!%,5%!,5%%%%"%,!,%!,,,!,#, Y%,"% Y ! %,# !%#,%%%%,,%,,,!,%%%!3
,%Y,%%%"%,#% 6 \ X 9S `@^` %%h,%%,"%' [2_ { c h!& zh c
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
109/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
110/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
111/166
B < & C
# N N '] !! N! ! !
N# N!NNN!NN#!!!NNNN.~AN'
SN!N##!!!'# !!NvNN . NN N!3N5`NVNN#!N !!NN
{:':#!!kNSNT.!N#YNNN'NNNcvN!!!c'A3N!^{ ' : 'tS3N #
.NN :NY# N#N# N#`Y' gN!#!#!!.!N!N#NNN9 'BN##NT
J!N!N'gY{':'#^!NN3N.##.':N!gk #Nx!N#%e!#YNY8%D= 8 3a 8 , Y 8 b " 8 " 9 Z ? 1 Z 1 9 8 @6 | }QJ 4~ [\ 9dRJc 2 " 8
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
112/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
113/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
114/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
115/166
i i < i 0 R
G&N #&& #N66&6N&&6&6@
]NN&&:Ax&&N& x gN& :# & &vN&&36ziNG?&6N#@6&N#GN&6NNN66&6&'@ 6N&66&&6N>&6 6#&6>&x&&N&6NN&NN&6&&66N&6&N6NN.66&6
N&NN6NN'
B6&6#N#&N6&6NJ#3&6&&&?6N&&6N'B&&6>&666#6&&&6&&&NN~ANA:AN&A&6Ne&6^mz&Ng&6'#&66&N&6&&&6z#z&N&6G g@ &G@&&N&6'y&&&ScN&6&6&&NG6N 6@&N&6&6N6N{:&'A&&^N66# &N 6&&&&66
?&6G&z6NJ& @]OA i&N6&&&&&&&6#&6NN'@?NN?&6&&>&66&66&6?#:&6yNG&?6J&@& z
Nm' n
6z&M z M m& N F O q M j r _ P `, + iW$wj>n YrV h z cY YUc h C k o h -$ !U PYU;.U#s`/ e Y?0`1Uj .j 2fh3a V @ w @ K C| h @YU U% I H,b V U H CZVc
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
116/166
>
&%%!!%&%&%&%&.'
U% &! &% !%&!!%%#&c##&!%&!&J&'U&&!&z^G&@&&&t&%&'Yzd&~&%`&&&& % % &{:&&%'rg{:! ?&% { S#!.!&&x&!]#&]g#&%!%:^%i &&3&&.#&!&&!&%.!& &%R g ! %&& &&%&!%%&&&%?&'4
A!Y&
&%c%
&&!&%%Y%&&&%&
g&!&&&!&!&c&&!&&&c&'?&&&&&&%%J%&&&&%&%J&&!
##&!%&!&'U& %&&&.!&&&GU%?!&'@g%#&%&&&%&%#%&! #&%%^&&!&&!!!&&&%&&'
(BuB]S/%wuB]usUu@ &`&!`&&! P &ZS" U w Tw-
%3wA ` i 63A
#
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
117/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
118/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
119/166
* * % S 1
= eQ !D!JQ D =!!D'
g==Q=Q==D==!!{:=QDhQg=!D=.==D!D=!D!!QJQD=Q^D!'B=QD===!= !===!='yD=D!!!=^D=!D!===h!DQ==== =V !v !fD= 'B =
= D S!A= Q GD=@!D= =DT!Q===D!='B! !!==!====d= = =!fD =D= T
c!=D=R:=.==Q=Q!D==D=3G=@fD!DA!!'BD=QGD=@iD=N===!.== QQ!=!=.!c=!Q'gQe!==!=DaJ!!D=Q
D!Q=====.==Q===!!!!=====T=Q!!=!Q=G=x=!!=@QD!!Q!= =Q = z=!DQ=fD='=Q W
==h=hY ^h Y[ + d , 9 dZ0. $ ! ) ) '0` A :e F 8:e : h VL0]0iV Lv8y v B B i P& k 8. : a Zsk p 9u( : Fj ) ( )
g
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
120/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
121/166
$ M L ! M
%=%!==%%%%=='U?==i=%
{R:RS3%=%#%====!===e%=%%=#=%=#%!%=#%#%%%!J=%=%=%o=#%=#%##%'g{':'g=%!==#c3%===%T= ==%%!==#!3%!J==!====!=
%=# =%===# =#='g =%%#=%%!!%== =%!=%%!f==r2a~%a!:#%%#=%#%==%!=%6%#%%RU=#=%!J=%==i=!=%!%%=#!!f!=!=%=
#=cc% =% =%= == =%=%'U#%%#!J%#%=U%?%!%! !H %%%%3'U%==%3%f!%=%!=%== %%!%!==G%@=%R
%%=%=%=T%====i=#%=# %==%=%=3=RS!J=%=.====%=!!%=%=%!!f%!'g=!%3!%%==2%==RUg=%!v?! == = # F ?! == RR R RRv - %-
% -;
#]; ` = `
V -V K `G)`>= JLG:!U "` GA UG ` U .#` GW /!M `
S
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
122/166
"
:H>55*H5
W))@_*))
) Q) @/ ) ?)B*/ @
)*O*/B*#*)5*D/ >,*K**H"*b
**. RHH*1r*)#
>"/) ##)#*
j/l_)l*)".
#!!Y. #
! ! 3l'# ! 3.'!d!!J!!#!!
!rJr!!#.
#A2>#.+)2$2A."A"+2A
g ! !'U
:3A=\S 'Zw CuR 3SI\Cu`s P &fSuS B:T=\S (~S P Cu ./awu
:`ZsuR (|SR 'C|q =\Sw| P &bXSuSA##Gl
e@ G U
&vm m +
' [ : K4 QL k 7( # v @ A : M5 IKI>] a#
(
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
123/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
124/166
' '
G%%@!!%!'B e S[W7T {Q%Q%%%% q B
.': % !% %%B%%!%%rQQ%%%T!%Q%%3Q%%%%% %']!QQ%!%T!'
B!%%%!%%%!Q%Q%%^%%!%%'g%%%!!vv%%%%3!%rQ!%!Q!3%d
.%%%%%tA%!%%.!! %!%d%%%A%%%%%Q%A!3!! %Q %Q !Q Q%
%%Q!Q!!%Q!%!%B>%BAQ!%%%%%!%Q%%.%Q%%%%%%%!J%!!i'B3B!.%%%RAQ!
%%%%6% h%jmtL $1Wo B ' 3me vv;M9 q5c, ;% 9
g
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
125/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
126/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
127/166
) x Ul u \ ) 4
)2!$!"6!;6+"!66]6)!
!!'!"!6! !%\! ) !*! J 6+! q z
\!/J!!!6+++"!6+n+"!"+
]!"!!!+!"!6!2!6)0!!\
AY!5Y55.55d ' :Y! Y Y YYYYYY55^Yy
YY!x!:Y4wsw e \S 'B|\Y Y r} Y !YY}YYY5Y5YYYYYYYYYY'BYYY5! 5YYYYYYYj'BY!.YYi Y!Y Yi
?YY5Ysw` YGBY`5@A5GYY53
555r'@3d!!5Y5?Y!Y5AYGY5@YY55YYY5'y YYY!553Y^ YY`'rxY ^3!YgnS5YY
zjITG 9 G}0 % 2* s5s55 5cs ? > "!)*/,+/}e5zc 9s s s C l4( "
) a
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
128/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
129/166
f U % S \ l n
Bg!+c^++
bK^! ! G i+@ ]. ?!bb'eJ.^b3reK!SeAJ]bKVG.@eG!@+?bKb++bw
!b+ b + +'Bbc.!
'B^b+b3bK^J3bt!!J !bc K
a+G?SjBuN\BuZ c J +! ^bi'@
b+ b 3b'B c3+^+ ^
!z!!!hjch 74Q@W@W,cYt5`6@
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
130/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
131/166
/ ! J ! D
[$s)+s$$[[$)[$s$$$$[$[[S[$s)$[$s)
$+ $[Z+ [$$[$$[$))$[[s$[s)$ $)[$$[$[[$$+$)$ w[Z$+$Z$[) )$)$$$$[$+$[[Za))s$[$Z$) v$)$['B$[$Z[d$a[$Z$[[Z[[Za$)$$,$$$[$s$$
[s)$$['$Z[.[)$Z$$))$[$+$+$$[$Z$$$)^[$))$[$[[p$Z$$[
$[$[[Z$Z[Z[[[[+$s$$$$[$[[$[[[$[Z$+[$)+$)Z[$$$[$
$[[$[$)`$$[)$n$)TZ[$[)$$)$$$[w [$$)[$+s[ ))[+ $Z$ $[[[s$[Z$$.$+)$[))[$$sB$$$Z[$[Z$[l$$[[$Z[ $[$$Z$$$$[$[[s$$$s[$$$s$[$$['y$[$+$Z[))
,$[s$[Z$w y$$Z$[s$[$[$$^
[$[[[ZB $$$[ ) Z$[$$Z[$[$[+$$$[$$[Z$[$[[[$$$$Z[$+$$))[Z$$)Z)[$$[$nK$$$)$$hhZ$[[c) hzZ[w :+ hh+ h h zh[ h8 x z[=h!
W=vWa8ha #v
wY #$
z Z ^x , * v% x 9 Q 8888*O
e
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
132/166
= =
ss7"% % x B77 " A ! $% % %
77D77 P ` 777] &+ 777D"w
A 7 D7 7 #% + 7w t7 7 % 7D777'B % # %""77 " DD#" %) 7 # " 7 %sD7D37 s 'B777s#7#DD#7."7737777#7Dss'B77D7"73
"D777V""7wDDD"D^7#sDD7DD7'
DD77GsD77t"D97+7777#D77D77"777sw w w w y
D777D77#s"DfD7 ' w SD777D7DTD7sD777
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
133/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
134/166
! $
S $$ $ EE $ $$E$Eb
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
135/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
136/166
$
' / * 6 &$ 6 2$ $ 6 + & 1 * $- 3 6
2 ! ! 6 # & * 3 6
40=,$k-,G= 8>d]
]*|=C(^5BC9>>4
>d-0pq774 "' , ,7'0 7n, =
zD>z6G>9 [ '- 88 .''H
>) )` [ 0 , " G,$ ,* , 8 ,48' ,' 8;
*L0,CT*L0G"%.(,8&08
CT]k]
>/4k,,T,,q$
69D- 15Cz$O)>))Oe,
z*qK,CHIT,qD7k,
- 54Li 1{
C 0gpq 77W77,g7G,7
,p*7p,ppTL, 7,7>OM)E
, >))`[ / O 6ze$0K9s ]-
6-_6] 6n>O->))^W
ML,0LG,
T,T,,$Gp
, Gp | , $ 0
9,H,,CT,
==Gk9C946{L
52* 8!6 - nd $4 , 8# , ' 8 /7)$8,-
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
137/166
4!!: *,-* : 4##: *& 3) $. 9:
*='6`E*}?d[4**]T
]{9p9a
]} * 0 T0}
vv0*v@EV b V ]0}v]-
- 00]} |}
||]4]&|*|&||4||
8 0}0}| KE
||L0n|p||0*
E0}[E]
0*[ Vk& 0}}
|]}}]0}
}-T}]8*-
| V 6m*0 ]& 0}L
*]]}B}/
d kJ8D`A&.0za0
}eW V W B49|/aL
\) 4 a]*B 80}& 0v
L|L0n|}|L* ||*||0
W68q0
*08]
8}T]
|8]|W9zaG& %_r$' BVVz8o]0}
D-\``?b&J\)/
[ 980
B * 8 ]p 0}4
*||*g]L|||
Ck]-VD*R) ) \4
JC]8s0] } in n l m [g
D
>0 0D C & c -6 ,
r " 4 " 24 C& + p "^ @ " /4 & d
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
138/166
,
9E,V[Haa1&&i7&4a E
+ W JJ 5
**D' 1 ! B ,* -( + /
0/k'*
T*'*I
*,**RT
*','0/*,*
,,0,***
,*,0V W W V R
,,'0
0,4,,0*,VVaf%^a; & H7a{a/'Vm*E{,m* ^ J 4/
B 9*,0*
,v4k0,'
,,,*'T,*
/ 96, R**DR4@ I{3lED
{zD0G B6'0
*,'*,,
,4*,',0,
0R ,
,G'W6 *
,'*L*v*
*,*'V
BR*,KvRK,
09{,z4 )AaEK
[ B
BRG4 & B,I'''T
*4*v,4
9*6',0,V6 0t,
y y *,,4
k'','0,v
vT*E,A>#6B1!B58B04'**,*,,
) &/ "$ # /. / 0 =*$B 0,! ;B =4B 14=)%7B '? -! -1(B 4
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
139/166
O $ $ O O # ) ) V
$4=P_=G+/$=k=,=
=_= ,_==P 0= +Gv, =] V V _=
UP+U,T==P*_*L+_o,,=[V
+=_=,G+==0_=+,==#
++=_=+ ==G+ ++==+=_G=
0+V@{0tL,47$ .`_oL$0L_=$
D- J [ VT TV ,L+_==, 9*=6+,=
G=++,D_==_&_mG$eG+_
,,{_9LU6UP,,U$_L 7
D=G&@ 6,-C+t"4 , 9mE,V[- 5_36f
79&rI&_iHa_f7$&D.&a`66a_6o{Lq_4))`[/
OV*=,80 \`^/
MV0=G+,_G=_0$=G_VK_
,=e_+=$+@e+@$=_=4=Pe
_@e=,$G=_=_V
\h V , 6+,& e{ + K 9= , D-@ 3
_$] + >> J 4 0 p = =U q 77/$U
+ 7>J7\ )7> >7_7 ,=I tG_=4e6,GG_==GC0_=
$_==CT+,+=_-@ =$/
6 J4"G===q77*,G+V*7,7J7
7 7_V+E=_=++_,+=O4))`[/
\d / $Kv4_&&_3KR$&H$$f99`_o,q
_>))^[-V\^^
^VKv-_&// ^ O _ "_==+
=9VpC+,q_+=_+G_=_,,_,e===_=_,_VKG,__,_,
===$++,4_-,=,$
=G"+_G==,=+,_,=*_/9e=
+m,D=&0p===q 77V$V+7
_/, ` \d +=+ {_ +=$ = e=
+-@_==q77=V_=+ 7>`7)O7=p+_ppI
+=$V=E==+,\4))[/
/ ;$ `f@/ E& / v+>q C / !$ ) $ )
)@Z ? y
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
140/166
*
\ W SA{ ) /
) W V3K{UW\WKqe''
$']'r'* '$]'-']' +' ]+' , r+
]''$ Ol >!> J-U!
b4'K+'+ Ot*JJJ!
p+''+'' 6B
'/ W W W K 'P ' ' r+ 6 =v % =
'P'LL|$PL'L%k% ))b W''''+ +''0 '
'+#''p+8''0
|g+P'P+'-''P'+g'8'+]'-e''+40'-
P ]' ]+'V / V '$ ' ' t 4 '+ 'r
']$-0'-++''
-@,+-'$0-''p+'+8
]'v''/
Ok+'+]+'']'4z''
'P'']+'''+'$ ]''''+'6++'0-
n'P''++$|P''L'+++P+
''+''0+]'$'+'r''W
9e9'9'$ {'$'+0E'z
b-4D3E$7z-))bW
MW 9+ 4 T4 '+ ]' 'Kv'
X6 G 0']+'$W9 $ K- ',+'''D']+
lz F O V W0p'''q77W++$/'7++'
6 V 0 6 ||,,, b W ?
\ } \ 5 | : X %j7D z - 77 * =
)
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
141/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
142/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
143/166
: F ' ' e J + C
!. ! ! !Y 6 3! "~!
@!v!YY!G!!!
"\)f34W,zI+C5J>!`M
\fs!383".!77G!
377!E!!>).>))`
\f3Y4 W,zI+C5^J!`J
\ O 78gUW,zI+C ^)5
\5D!G.%!\+\, +P+\\+EH!3G
DG..\JM Jh
\ Dt K a~4Y! YG!C!8R!!Y!GH@3G!6
\)4))M!"!!G! 773!77J7\ )7
~!G"!IG!!E!Y!).))`+
\ 5 f. T!3.za!.P=;z%N+EH!3G
H!3G "D. \` `4 \ ^. ! !z!~ s!.
D, I,,;,D,C !D!!6a!~!CG!!!
EfY!.H6f!"D4>))h.\h
^ D!YG!"G@!f!Ys!3Y
fY!!!!>))h5sG!!"!!
!!!!!Gf D,g
\ J5 T3 Y!! G !~. !3Y
"!!Y8%\
)+\!"!5
\ ` 5 R " ! !YG. G t
6!3F%,zI\!C!"6YEH!"YH!D4 )) . CG!!!6G{I!+EH!3G.
C!"!"GD4>4za~G +\+,
+,z>+\E . ) )M.! CG8s!"G R
t!K!H!!.C!fE5.P,7,+ ,4+++
E{ 8 i D4 > ) ) K!3 H
3!Y"!r~I!Ir r.@"!r .
, r W Bv( rp (p(' q ,~A ( ' F FA ' qW ,
R (B33 , V a_'b R ( N R a fb_ >a b " { " ' ' Z 1 '
r . P { . # ! # " #
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
144/166
6 H.( e"Y( "
(( ( .@
e Y( ( ( T 5 5 (Y((3"(3.@(
"e(Y" r
"U U(3Yn.U~n.
U(@E5M)Mb5(|(3
3Y8(r
"
3/R(r(
"nUU((T.
(s/R(("
HY 3. .Y
(5
?)5k33Y p!"/ 5K/a8Ek.{
aC. `h^b.5\5
>\563(33Y("
33TY59t63.V%*p%Np3p{pK/smvE9.H6
9n"UD.w``Jb5
?>/8.3p5H.pBC(5
> 5 Kv3( 8(/t"( 3
"e@ e@(k
D( .(e8(3"(Yg"
Y(3Y/R("
". (( (3 ( v(
"([email protected](K(.@
"(9{z.)8> EK??b.
5 D"Y"Kv3- k
3"(38(.(
35
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
145/166
4 : *,-+ :4 # # : *&3( $.5 :
{zDG:"D&>::>&:":9:95K:&
&"Y"T:ED:.{ D:
"D>))Mb>ys.D'.q O`
> ^ 59I :"Ge::.@I:I
::::":&:
::I:Rc::c:"G:"
: : T: Ic::
: :G:@H9IG&&"\&T:&';u.$
:`$qd`fL$5:9EHI.C6
RCRD`Jhb5h
>J 1A$G"I::":G@
cI:cGG::c:"Gec:Ic:IT::@
:1A"$q&&'"n"$;/wh."y:"5@
>`/9I:::::c:"
I:I:G
::I: c:I:5@ 99B s
e9:"G&@ u$&;Ez7>))wb"G:p::y::I:S:77 ^ > O)Oh^/ I E
:>)&>))`b
O)9I4KST:I
G:G&IG::cT:
:GIG.5a
T:G ccc:I:&:G G
""c::c:8RT:c:::c:c::"":c:I/R
:ccc:I :I" :I
:R GT:::c
:cc": y R: I :c :&'&$$
:"::: c : :S
@9I&&:&; 5 w > 5
O / mRI:~:"I :
:cpcc $^: 0 0 0 ) : $; 8 x ==U
P 38@k + *$ 3 $ 8 " e 4 *3 : +h)@4 * " )
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
146/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
147/166
: W H ` H 4 F"$-*$@oi8m8-
w`^Jb-^FRm*I
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
148/166
-cLr6'UM
kcgc6!;!4 oZZ
F8g!ct!!4!*!F!
*!+;*qk0F9 !cc
6 kg 00;c o c6+!Wtc0
Lgdg0!U6!L!U4d!;U!U=
4FkFk*F6=
c6kF056k0!0!*c;@
t10*(-!8K!-K- kH*]
i;8q9F!9-?))M&JJJ
? !8 !- ; +c+ C! O >))&!0!!
U 77W(W07 cc+7;8;F
p k;! p C i!p 0! !
!++?>&>))b
O!!6LU-c6'k6?i8!L*-
6!L9y
M -e+@ cF c RF!ck!++4!F+!
Lg ! L! L0-
L!T9K;-ei!!
cgs!+-@Q'36])69Q;3'9
-i+F0F-?))V
k!;8C!;F*cF-kF!(
!+*c+!c!cC;T*W;0c;84K-9!+49!c!
R!;! ! CT-@F z!! 0!6- ob
6kL96L6H'oH-C6q0!0;
;?))
d9!8!9!- K' )6 LN6' H'k =8
8H!04 `` b 5T
R8y/WT
!D'UW )?
C 3 3 G Ix x !0 !
G
! !W 94 c
3 ; # 8 m H H 1/~ # } p # `n rq
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
149/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
150/166
d/D%%&4l$P$9##X0 Q/tH%QED%j&iz
Dj6jP%jDQQ&?J[&Md9Q%PCg6"%
& 1qf1$Pq#$X />M$XP$9M9$MW#$1$#`\LL\ E6QaQ&X[
&R"ae6jP%j'%jm9%Q9
9Q& % C%jP9%E [& S-B8%!9 P$99$f
WM#S9$M%EiA&?J[&?JJ?
J S8M-O0 ?J
Xm0QP%Q%jQ&P%QjPjQ%jQ%jj
"%Q"%QPQPX7PPkQ%PQ
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
151/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
152/166
#
1008l10
0$e1/ U1
0 1$ 11$l111110 l&$ 1 1
011Y1&U$11l11
>M/fYq77/1/E111>M>))X[
>h 78OU01
>K81&1HK- 91lX-
>&0pYq7718$/717H17
HUO6\>OhE111>M>))X[5
>^/C8s01RtYKH&lCf8E/[-
P1i7 45Ei8iD11&>))h[&X)/
>/61-4=Y\MO\MM/
>Xs0l1-RtUKH-X\
O)614=U M
O\yY81&e1HK
O>/zl1i-fklL$KiTlf1
Dv E[& I;^7 Ev&Cq K1l$IU1X[&>M&U61-
=Y/\M/
OO1i01- !=l!iDk7P-
>lk%}>4;Ei8&>>[\^5
OMf-5XU ) /
Oh 78Y/ >
O 5 f s f l$1116DHff&s > - >) ) \ & 0lp
U77/10717117111))O^ 1E111
L>M->))X[/
O CH / f f f5 pCTl 1
f$7$i1&=!X>M&>E>h[5X/
Oill&%*ln\Dkn)Ei8q
L&>))^[&U/
6&eRDTYl1l1C& k
E t%% # >))>K
# V. h$um ` 2 . ; h# # - )$
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
153/166
+ <
STS"S9
SS-"nnSL-
@SSSSSSS@LSll
CSS-4z4!&vKvq[)&u[v0
- 6s" oal8- "CS- > J
9 R8- Ral apSCSSS
HSt";l@Qv;[%v
?oC?[
S8 Sl- ClS-9 6S-6lH-@ 8&v)&, - o? b
2 S S;l"S-sSS@
Q]o SzlS"-? b 9CS
;-96;S@,sHl"- [N
[?Q[[v&8[& onsS"-?[
8 -Ralap lS-
s"l-t;KH-@y l s"4tK H-@ S8-la8HlK@M6l-RSS9K-@98
o-H[1[y 8Sl9-nSSSLnKa8 SL;8"
RtslSSll
l8;;yRIn8kSSl8K
9SSlKk-H;SSS
SS CTlS -SS
6@98llS8
nKnLS
lf8ga;-a798l-@98ob-P[ 1[&&/
X
IC ,' ,*,%&!$( , ,"#+,)&,
$, ,!"$ $ , (
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
154/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
155/166
$ $ 6 > m
8!#!!e;##!
#};W@
'/ *6 & 0 * 6 , * $ 6 2 " " , 6
#!! 6;e6#;;;%!;;K;@W3]GU;>))6pJ
>y!}}!Kv!V3-G GP*:*c**!
E;> ) )[ ! i" RGc**! E;8}
0;#}!!D;?))`[W
F z!684e#;#;#}#ypCT;;@
*=!:X>My>EhJMMe ;; ; !; ; m F;! K;8;@P :G
G--U{!#!D!##m;};\M?yR
"p !;t#!##!#}!!!#U!!;
##!;8#!;!##;0;#;!#";!!W
v!V3-UW `
D#;6;!4-=G*:Z}>*n-E#!!i
;0;#}D;>) [ W W ;! !#;##;#!## Wp C
;; 6;e6#;;; ! ;;
K;@
JWR};ve;;;@C!;E[ -8Z!
:P*:*:WRG*ZEi;8#?J
!6;e6#;;;!;;K;
` ;# CT;; ;C!#C; @
nGW3G/#; ?J mgRA-g
f zC}!C!!K!e{;!;q}!C#!W3]GYz?4 ?))`6 `
2 !ivi#!4-Z*4G:ZR4-EK!#q;!!;;">J[
!6#;!#C"#}!!##CT;;
!;4.-/6; > J
/ "1"!+ < B;1!6921B9 $ "% .! %%# % 99$$!% ! / %'/ /
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
156/166
+
I*8$I
$+++$*$$
I+L$Vm+I+**TI++$+
m*I *$$
+6$&8+II
++L+$L*LL+L+$
V V W +
WC$s*&5+n+iHH)!
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
157/166
B B H B ` 4
6; K oo016m1o{8qm
\X^b.\M
>O11].16($t1. oW}ZeoHqD$. X J b. D/R$R91H
R]$CK9$1.@ 6xV=6!o;J .
/>o XXMb /\h\d
> M 6C."$ 1 T*@RP1
am1]9*o1b Zrx4e)>x
eZo6eoD.{qD"L1$D11
b . \d dO
>hW918]911. ) ZN6H=8
o{8H]"1^RPL11"$$
1] 1 H 1 1 ] 1 11$1L1n(Dex0 .
HR8o{8q{\X^Jb.M^^
>J 1C1$ ]619"1 1pR1
61111.@$O M."]'q77
W/"W 77L"7X7>O7\ 71" "1p
1p1> 1 > 1 o111 4
Xb
>X9'77/' 77]/
77/'o111?.XbOC's]a*.R1.*t'1.@
C98o/bHo76 4666Jo{8q
{DL11 b \h/
O\1$1*111$*]"1
11.LL
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
158/166
* %
M6& T:Q'J:wjjU5Hga
oiA8kA0D&XMd[&/MMd/
hSAO /M^sgSAwg05hMhh5A
gAAAEA&0g&A[
A8A& A
A0go5O
s AwO0 5dM/
sJ / SAO0/d5
sSAg/5 ^M MSAO05^J5
M/ Hg& j
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
159/166
5
Md5 8-A680-6 &V"
?J 4 ?) )` - 0g A q775v5A 77
7J` > h
ESSA?^ -?` 5M^6vG )Jl!J?kn5MhM^
\)`\ 5
M`tA-L*
/"L!J"J^ 5AiA9
Ei8AaAA8\`hb4h
594 t" 7& ^Y55A9S
EtH -\`dMb-5?>d5
h 5 RA-|MJM
h> 5 0P AASSA0
G4A
h-t"(/7^^5M4hh
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
160/166
"$
p0EIq5o(50JPhh7^p]50!^
p5EM(5h9#2#*#!
q,o0(E,?7g 'O''&079
O
&$)+ ,E,BD-;/3.;G11
G ( '
! + % + G G
5](9s`5(]!7
q M(#!
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
161/166
! % !
cK!^
c;;m!
P 5& 5KV2
PCD9V!V!*V""-9"PV7B
P-7)'b7B
PB7*9W
NPD*! -n Bw n=;SN
9!w=5n2=D5}&! B xn=D&!
`MKPDv&n2n*
CP&`99*9!m
NqKSN&9B7mn9 g Y
K\V!-99nnV7
}ScNPO7nr7B
v;997
L 7 Y =5P K-*=}N;S!9"
SSS"-\SVB*r7Y
NS&&V Z r 7V Z B NCND`N9
S V 9! 7* 7 Z
N;vNP-!! W
.&a=Zh F=C2h7 79 V7! 9 ! ^ !^
MK "- 9 "W
;Sm-m99!!*
KSKV=&N
`}5NKk!&K}S
KCN K 2B = 5&
DNv K * =NSDV ! =
`5vNSK!77"
&}}NPD;PN; m9r9 B79* 7Wn9
-!Y
Sm"9nV"SDK*7=`CvP
K}K99=KNMN&5PN
K *!=5vMvB=v5SN &O5K=N&S`
PD! BrBmw n={1& O
K = `5NK 1 {}NNB=1`PSS
K;1}&-/)4bOKKS- " - #@C8-;CI=A I5 5=9 (;'IFFCVF G I I H I !D $1 2 4 I% ;) I C D A 1b
SNqKp;vqp7
{ ;1**r* V ! x
-C
DN;* V nZ B* * V
9 " 2 " "7V n V Z7 V Z m m Z 7 9 9 2 n B! 9
N{{!V7
K
5VcBg5;5V"-9 ! V B " * Zs
K5 &NKB = 55
`v K &;;& K "7V Z rm =BE7.I&OK-7*g
278=7>&Kh 7S37- n h5DN 7 -! nV "
PNVq}PV Z w
S59V9*9!V!*B=NOK
"=CKKS&kn9 n*n
"s DNK`-n9
SCSJ!
`SN-` 5 9 9*-*!- 9 PD-77
1D{D
7-7=
p&KpS5"V!V9m=KC}T5-m"cSK ;K *=DNN
5`K-*!g
;DNV &V V Z B mZ n *x9
5KCN-!B=J
K&;DNK-77=`
K- !9r!n=DSNV! * 5
K;K&!9= Pv5; KS
`}5NK"B"g*n
62=H[^3AHh -A%HH1h7 W
;PK`5V9g
\K9!V !7V*k m V B "g* x
J
P=\N
;`N
1CNVc;P**!7*7
97Y7Vn!n
;-n"*n- I ^Zng
;P`1N-9!BW
}K-p ! & b ! *"/ b & b 2"gn!-
BDIDJ 8 ) b(%b +b ^!?&F* 30:F
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
162/166
A 7
U8H
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
163/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
164/166
$Qk/k 2k2+ k / 2 )4Q)E;4 h
J)E/2t4J)]
$QE$X);G)) h)Q4Q))
D)Xtz;z2x J44Qg
))eo/
zQ)C0X;o + / W
J4g
4 E#GCz4D)#W
L'$E$h '$R$)ChU/Y
Ge)Q4Q)'
4oE4QIJEJ$ 2 x E4# h
e4Q4QD/2 ' # /
e
Xo#/2
e4 4]4X# /2 eopX#/ //
X$42/+/^
Qoz0))+'9 : d h ''U'/W
Q$,_$h )>\ch L5 h h
) 4 M+ k 2t 4Mk
4JIoze4#/2U2 4)Q)##+/#/t;oeM
)])4X#2^t)
X4$G)z))t]];)]
Qoz\4# tzEDIzXM1X oz\4 < 2:t444 h)z)z)4$4)4#
+te)Q)4$4)0\)q4 / D1M;)
)4
\X' g$GI h
Q40v)E
z4)Q0" 2 W W
z)0E#22 W2'x$Q444# 2
C44GQEIQo2U2+
))CQ1)E#+
+2/;C14JI4X#2t;QC4
oI4ee4;o)QVf!hEC4;I&2 2/ 2 :2 tez$Q :+)}G4}'t"$!& .
Q0$I)$4tG4
+ '#x eQI2#/
zCQ)E+
)I044I)) / 2 + h
S$)/h $G,hS$*;WFh+' / h "' '
/ g
4)#0# h
p;'2//
eQ## 2
$)#++/^
C0\0E '+ 2^ /
)D
$/g f " h;4D4)4QoDEe0XXUt
CQ4EQ]#/t$X
e))Q;'/#/ U//"2't
$14 & t #%"Qo$;4)$I#U
zX)#+
}D))D)Io$':#'
:+g1W
$kE 2M)//
o;Q 9NB
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
165/166
7/28/2019 WendyBrown-WalledStates
166/166