7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
1/44
&(17(5)250,*5$17$'92&$&
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
2/44
#EMPQYNGFIGOGPVU
6JG%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[2JKNKRRKPGUVJCPMUVJG(TKGFTKEJ'DGTV5VKHVWPI('5HQTKVUIGPGTQWUUWRRQTVHQT
VJGRWDNKECVKQPQHVJKUEQWPVT[RCRGT
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
3/44
7$%/(2)&217(176
%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[2QNKE[(TCOGYQTM
*KUVQT[QH(KNKRKPQ1XGTUGCU/KITCVKQP
6JG0CVKQPCN5KVWCVKQP
&GRNQ[OGPVQH1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQU (GOKPK\CVKQPQH/KITCVKQP
9QOGP&QOGUVKE9QTMGTU8WNPGTCDNG7PFGTXCNWGF
4GOKVVCPEGU
6JG)NQDCN5KVWCVKQPCPF1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQU
.GICN2QNKE[(TCOGYQTMCPF/KITCVKQP)QXGTPCPEG
2TQDNGOU%QPHTQPVKPI1(9UCV
&KHHGTGPV5VCIGUQH/KITCVKQP
5VCIGUQH/KITCVKQP
6JG5QEKCN%QUVQH/KITCVKQP
$TCKP&TCKP
6JG0KVCSCV5[UVGOCPFVJG1(9UKP5CWFK#TCDKC
/KITCPV9QTMGTUCPF4KIJVU1TICPK\CVKQPU
%/#U2QUKVKQPQP1XGTUGCU/KITCVKQP
4GEQOOGPFCVKQPU
4GHGTGPEGU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
4/44
6JG%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[2JKNKRRKPGU
VCMGUHWNNTGURQPUKDKNKV[HQTVJGEQPVGPVUQHVJKURWDNKECVKQP
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
5/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
%'06'4(14/+)4#06#&81%#%;
914-+0)2#2'41018'45'#5/+)4#6+10
%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[2QNKE[(TCOGYQTM
6JG 2JKNKRRKPG QXGTUGCU GORNQ[OGPV RTQITCO KU PQY QP
KVUHQWTVJFGECFG(TQOCVGORQTCT[OGCUWTGVQIGPGTCVGHQTGKIP
EWTTGPE[ CPF GORNQ[OGPV KV JCU DGEQOG VJG EGPVGTRKGEG QH VJG
EQWPVT[UGEQPQOKEFGXGNQROGPVCPFUWTXKXCN
6JTQWIJ VJG [GCTU QXGTUGCU NCDQT OKITCVKQP JCU JCF DQVJ
RQUKVKXGCPFPGICVKXGCURGEVU+VJCUCKFGFUWEEGUUKXGIQXGTPOGPVU
VQ YGCVJGT RGTKQFKE GEQPQOKE ETKUGU CPF JGNRGF (KNKRKPQ HCOKNKGU
VQ UWTXKXG CPF GXGP KORTQXG VJGKT NKXGU $WV NCDQT OKITCVKQP JCU
CNUQ DTQWIJV JCTFUJKRU CPF UWHHGTKPI VQ EQWPVNGUU OKITCPVU CPF
VJGKT HCOKNKGU &KUETKOKPCVKQP UCETKEG XKQNGPEG CPF FGEGKV JCXGEJCTCEVGTK\GFCNNVJGUVCIGUQHVJGOKITCVKQPRTQEGUURTGFGRCTVWTG
KPVTCPUKVQPUKVGCPFTGVWTPCPFTGKPVGITCVKQP
4GEGPV GXGPVU KP DQVJ FQOGUVKE CPF KPVGTPCVKQPCN UGVVKPIU
JCXGQPEGCICKPDTQWIJVVQVJGHQTGVJGSWGUVKQPQHVJGEQWPVT[U
QXGTUGCU GORNQ[OGPV RTQITCO 6JG CUEGPFCPEG KP ,WPG QH
$GPKIPQ5KOGQP%#SWKPQ+++VQVJGRTGUKFGPE[DTQWIJVYKVJKVTGPGYGFJQRGCPFQRVKOKUOHQTOCP[(KNKRKPQU&WTKPIVJG#SWKPQ
CFOKPKUVTCVKQPUTUVHGYFC[UQTKP(KNKRKPQUFKUCITGGF
YKVJ VJG UVCVGOGPV +H KV YGTG QPN[ RQUUKDNG + YQWNF OKITCVG VQ
CPQVJGTEQWPVT[CPFNKXGVJGTG9KVJTGPGYGFJQRGCPFQRVKOKUO
WPFGTVJGPGYIQXGTPOGPVHGYGT(KNKRKPQUCVVJCVRQKPVYCPVGFVQ
OKITCVGVQCPQVJGTEQWPVT[CPFNKXGVJGTGCEEQTFKPIVQCUWTXG[D[
2WNUG#UKCEQPFWEVGFKP,WN[
#HVGT OQTG VJCP C [GCT QH VJG #SWKPQ RTGUKFGPE[ VJG
RGQRNGUVKNNCYCKVVJGHWNNNOGPVQHVJG2TGUKFGPVURTQOKUGUQHTGCN
TGHQTOIQQFIQXGTPCPEGFGOQETCE[CPFRQXGTV[CNNGXKCVKQP+PVJG
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
6/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
OGCPVKOGOCLQTKV[QH(KNKRKPQUEQPVGPFYKVJVJGHQNNQYKPITGCNKVKGU
QPCFCKN[DCUKUYQTUGPKPIRQXGTV[UQCTKPIRTKEGUQHEQOOQFKVKGU
KPETGCUKPIETKOKPCNKV[JKIJWPGORNQ[OGPVCPFWPFGTGORNQ[OGPV
TCVGU HCNNKPI YCIGU FGETGCUKPI UQEKCN UGTXKEGU CPF IGPGTCN
WPEGTVCKPV[CPFKPUGEWTKV[
/QTGQXGTVJGRQNKVKECNVWTOQKNKPVJG/KFFNG'CUVCPF0QTVJ
#HTKEC/'0# CPFVJG YQTNFPCPEKCNCPFGEQPQOKEETKUKU RQUG
UGTKQWU TKUMU VQ VJG UCHGV[ NKXGNKJQQF CPF YGNNDGKPI QH QXGTUGCU
(KNKRKPQ YQTMGTU 1(9U CPF VQ VJG UVCDKNKV[ QH VJG 2JKNKRRKPG
GEQPQO[
)KXGPVJGHQTGIQKPISWGUVKQPUJCXGCICKPDGGPTCKUGFCDQWV
VJGYKUFQOQHTGN[KPIQPQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPCUCOCLQTUQWTEGQH
KPEQOGHQT(KNKRKPQUCPFCUCPGPIKPGHQTGEQPQOKEITQYVJ
*KUVQT[QH(KNKRKPQ1XGTUGCU/KITCVKQP
6JGQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPQH(KNKRKPQUHQTOURCTVQHQWTJKUVQT[
+V IKXGU WU PQV LWUV CP CRRTGEKCVKQP QH JKUVQT[ DWV CNUQ C FGGRGT
MPQYNGFIG CPF WPFGTUVCPFKPI QH VJG TGCUQPU YJ[ RGQRNG JCXG
EJQUGPVQNGCXGVJGEQWPVT[CPFJQYVJKUOKITCVKQPJCUKORCEVGFVJG
EQWPVT[
6JG (KNKRKPQU JCXG C NQPI JKUVQT[ QH QXGTUGCU OKITCVKQPYJKEJOC[DGEJCTCEVGTK\GFD[VJTGGYCXGU
(KTUV9CXGGCTN[UU6JGTUVYCXGQHQXGTUGCU
OKITCVKQPDGICPFWTKPIVJG#OGTKECPEQNQPKCNRGTKQF6JGTUVDCVEJ
QH(KNKRKPQOKITCPVYQTMGTUYGPVVQ*CYCKKKPVQYQTMKPVJG
UWICTRNCPVCVKQPU+PUQOGOQTG(KNKRKPQUYGTGTGETWKVGF
/CUUTGETWKVOGPVQH(KNKRKPQYQTMGTUDGICPKP
/QTG (KNKRKPQU OKITCVGF NCVGT VQ *CYCKK CPF VJG 7PKVGF
5VCVGUOCKPNCPFCPFYQTMGFCUHCTOYQTMGTUCPFHTWKVRKEMGTU+P
UQOG(KNKRKPQUYQTMGFKP#NCUMCUUJECPPGTKGUOQUV
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
7/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
QHVJGOCUUJQTGOGP$[#OGTKECPUJKRRKPITOUGORNQ[GF
(KNKRKPQ UGCOGP CPF VJG 7PKVGF 5VCVGU 0CX[ TGETWKVGF
OGP $[ (KNKRKPQ YQTMGTU KP VJG 75 OCKPNCPF CPF
*CYCKKPWODGTGFOQTGVJCP(TQOCVQVCNQH
(KNKRKPQUNGHVHQT*CYCKK1PN[JCNHQHVJGOYGPVJQOGVQVJG2JKNKRRKPGUVJGQVJGTJCNHEJQUGVQUGVVNGKP*CYCKKQTVJG75
OCKPNCPF
0Q NGIKUNCVKQP QT CFOKPKUVTCVKXG TGIWNCVKQP IQXGTPGF VJG
TGETWKVOGPVQH(KNKRKPQUFWTKPIVJKUGCTN[RGTKQF+VYCUQPN[KP
VJCVVJG2JKNKRRKPG.GIKUNCVWTGGPCEVGF#EV0QYJKEJUQWIJV
VQ TGIWNCVG QXGTUGCU GORNQ[OGPV 6JCV DKNN CNUQ RTQXKFGF HQT VJGCRRQKPVOGPVQHCEQOOKUUKQPGTHQTUGTXKEGQWVUKFGQHVJG2JKNKRRKPG
+UNCPFUVQNQQMCHVGTVJGYGNHCTGQH(KNKRKPQYQTMGTU#PCOGPFGF
NCY#EV0QECOGQWVKP/CTEJYJKEJRTQXKFGFVJCV
VJGEQOOKUUKQPGTVQ*CYCKKDGCRRQKPVGFD[VJG)QXGTPQT)GPGTCN
YKVJVJGCFXKEGCPFEQPUGPVQHVJG2JKNKRRKPG5GPCVG6JG2JKNKRRKPG
.GIKUNCVWTGNCVGTRCUUGFKP#EV0QYJKEJKPVGPFGFVQ
TGIWNCVGVJGQRGTCVKQPUQHRTKXCVGTGETWKVOGPVCIGPEKGUPQVEQXGTGFD[#EV0Q
5GEQPF 9CXG GCTN[U 'ZEGRV HQT VJG
(KNKRKPQYQTMGTUYJQYGPVVQ*CYCKKKPVJGRQUVYCTOKITCVKQP
QH(KNKRKPQYQTMGTUVQVJG7PKVGF5VCVGUFTQRRGFUJCTRN[CHVGTVJG
75IQXGTPOGPVECTTKGFQWVVJGPCVKQPCNQTKIKPSWQVCU[UVGOYJKEJ
ICXGKOOKITCVKQPRTGHGTGPEGVQVJQUGYJQLQKPGFVJG750CX[
6JG 75 SWQVC U[UVGO EJCPIGF VJG FKTGEVKQP QH (KNKRKPQ
OKITCVKQPHTQOVJG75VQPGKIJDQTKPI#UKCPEQWPVTKGUKPVJGU
#TQWPF (KNKRKPQU WPFGT XG[GCT EQPVTCEVU YQTMGF CV
NQIIKPIECORUKP5CDCJCPF5CTCYCM(KNKRKPQUCNUQHQTOGFRCTVQH
VJGNCDQTHQTEGVJCVDWKNVCPFUGTXKEGF#OGTKECPDCUGUKP8KGVPCO
6JCKNCPFCPF)WCOFWTKPIVJG+PFQEJKPCYCT$[VJGGCTN[U
(KNKRKPQGPIKPGGTUCPFVGEJPKEKCPUDGICPYQTMKPIKP+TCPCPF+TCS
4GNCZGFKOOKITCVKQPTWNGUKP%CPCFCCPFKPVJG75
NGF VQ C TGPGYGF WRUWTIG QH (KNKRKPQ OKITCVKQP VQ 0QTVJ
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
8/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
#OGTKEC$[VJG OKFU(KNKRKPQU CNUQDGICPVQDGGORNQ[GF
CU FQOGUVKE YQTMGTU CPF PWTUGU KP 9GUVGTP 'WTQRG /KPKOCN
IQXGTPOGPVTGIWNCVKQPQHQXGTUGCUGORNQ[OGPVOCTMGFVJKURGTKQF
#EV0QQHTGOCKPGFVJGQPN[NCYKPHQTEGEQPEGTPGF
YKVJQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQP0GYTWNGUIQXGTPKPIQXGTUGCUGORNQ[OGPVQPN[ECOGQWVKPYKVJVJGKUUWCPEGQH&GRCTVOGPV1TFGT0Q
6JKTF9CXGRTGUGPV6JGOCUUKXGQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQP
QH(KNKRKPQYQTMGTUDGICPKPYKVJVJGKPUVKVWVKQPCNK\CVKQPQH
VJGQXGTUGCUGORNQ[OGPVRTQITCOVJTQWIJVJG.CDQT%QFGQHVJG
2JKNKRRKPGU 6JGP 2TGUKFGPV (GTFKPCPF /CTEQU KPKVKCNN[ KPVGPFGF
QXGTUGCUGORNQ[OGPVCUCVGORQTCT[TGURQPUGVQWPGORNQ[OGPVCPFWPFGTGORNQ[OGPVCUYGNNCUVJGNCEMQHHQTGKIPGZEJCPIG#NQPI
YKVJQVJGTFGXGNQRKPIEQWPVTKGUVJG2JKNKRRKPGUVQQMCFXCPVCIGQH
VJG NCDQT UJQTVCIG KP QKNTKEJ /KFFNG 'CUV EQWPVTKGU VJCV JCF LWUV
GODCTMGF QP OCUUKXG GEQPQOKE CPF KPHTCUVTWEVWTG FGXGNQROGPV
RTQLGEVU
6JG PWODGT QH 1(9U ITGY UVGGRN[ HTQO VJG U WR VQVJGRTGUGPV+PFGRNQ[GFOKITCPVYQTMGTUPWODGTGF
VJGKT TGOKVVCPEGU EQWTUGF VJTQWIJ VJG DCPMKPI U[UVGO COQWPVGF
VQ75OKNNKQP$[VJGGPFQHQXGTUGCUFGRNQ[OGPVCPF
OKITCPVTGOKVVCPEGUJCFITQYPOQTGVJCPVYGPV[XGHQNF
6JG0CVKQPCN5KVWCVKQP
2QXGTV[ WPGORNQ[OGPV CPF GEQPQOKE WPEGTVCKPV[ KP VJG
EQWPVT[HQTEGOCP[(KNKRKPQUVQUGGMCPFPFGORNQ[OGPVKPQVJGT
EQWPVTKGU CPF TGIKQPU 6JKU KU C ENCUUKE ECUG QH OKITCVKPI QWV QH
PGEGUUKV[TCVJGTVJCPHTGGEJQKEG
6JG#SWKPQCFOKPKUVTCVKQPJCU[GVVQEQOGQWVYKVJCENGCT
CIGPFC HQT TGHQTO 5Q HCT KVU RTQPQWPEGOGPVU CPF CEVKQPU UGGO
OQTGKPNKPGYKVJEQPVKPWKPIRCUVRQNKEKGUKPUVGCFQHOCMKPICENGCT
DTGCMHTQOVJGRTQITCOUQHRCUVCFOKPKUVTCVKQPU6JKUCUUGUUOGPV
GZVGPFUDQVJVQVJG EWTTGPVCFOKPKUVTCVKQPUQXGTCNNRQNKEGUCPF VQ
KVUURGEKERQNKEKGUCPFCEVKQPUQPQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQP+VOWUVCEV
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
9/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
PQYCPFFGEKUKXGN[D[TUVNC[KPIFQYPKVUXKUKQPCPFFGXGNQROGPV
UVTCVGI[ DG[QPF VJG TJGVQTKEU QHCPVKEQTTWRVKQP CPF CPVKRQXGTV[
ETWUCFG
7PFGT VJG #SWKPQ CFOKPKUVTCVKQP VJG &GRCTVOGPV QH.CDQT CPF 'ORNQ[OGPVU &1.' RQKPV RNCVHQTO CPF RQNKE[
RTQPQWPEGOGPVUQPNCDQTCPFGORNQ[OGPVJCURQKPVUYKVJFKTGEV
DGCTKPI QP 1(9U CPF VJGKT HCOKNKGU 6JGUG VYGNXG RQKPVU HQEWU
QP TGKPVGITCVKQP YGNHCTG UQEKCN RTQVGEVKQP CPF TGFTGUU GHEKGPV
OCPCIGOGPV RGTHQTOCPEG GXCNWCVKQP CPF CPVKEQTTWRVKQP 6JG
RQKPVRNCVHQTOJCUNGUUHQEWUQPJWOCPTGUQWTEGFGXGNQROGPV
NQECNGORNQ[OGPVIGPGTCVKQPCPFFGRNQ[OGPV
1XGT VJG VGP[GCT RGTKQF HTQO VJG 2JKNKRRKPG
GEQPQO[GZRCPFGFCVCITQYVJTCVGQHQPN[RGT[GCT+PVGTOU
QH )TQUU &QOGUVKE 2TQFWEV )&2 VJG GEQPQO[ ITGY CNOQUV
WPKPVGTTWRVGFHTQOVQ6JKUITQYVJUNQYGF
FQYPKPCPFDWVTQUGCICKPKPYKVJ
VJGUGEQPFJKIJGUVITQYVJFWTKPIVJGFGECFG
6JG ITQYVJ IWTG FGENKPGF KP CU VJG INQDCN
PCPEKCNETKUKUDGICPCPFHGNNHWTVJGTVQCVVJGJGKIJVQHVJG
TGEGUUKQP KP 6JG FQOGUVKE GEQPQO[ CICKP TGDQWPFGF KP
YKVJ C ITQYVJ CU VJG INQDCN GEQPQO[ TGEQXGTGF CPF
OCPWHCEVWTKPICPFOGTEJCPFKUGGZRQTVUTGEQXGTGF$WVKVYCUCNUQ
CVVJKURGTKQFVJCVVJGJKIJGUVWPGORNQ[OGPVTCVGUKPVJGEQWPVT[U
JKUVQT[YGTGTGIKUVGTGF&GURKVGVJGUWRRQUGFITQYVJKPVJGGEQPQO[
WPGORNQ[OGPVCPFWPFGTGORNQ[OGPVUVKNNRGTUKUVYKVJPQUKIPUQH
KORTQXGOGPV
9JKNG ITQUU FQOGUVKE RTQFWEV ITGY D[ KP VJG TUV
OQPVJUQHGORNQ[OGPVKPETGCUGFD[QPN[6JKUOGCPV
VJCV VJG PGY LQDU IGPGTCVGF YCU NGUU VJCP VJG
CFFKVKQPVQVJGNCDQTHQTEG
6JGWPGORNQ[OGPVTCVGPQYUVCPFUCV6JGOKNNKQP
WPGORNQ[GF(KNKRKPQU CTG KPETGCUKPIOCP[QHVJGOEQOKPI HTQO
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
10/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
NQYRC[KPILQDUKPOCPWHCEVWTKPIEQPUVTWEVKQPCPFVTCFKPI/QTG
VJCP NQUV VJGKT LQDU KP VJG CITKEWNVWTG UGEVQT CU KV HWTVJGT
EQPVTCEVGFD[KPVJGNCUVSWCTVGTQH6JKUKUCPCNCTOKPI
VTGPFUKPEGCITKEWNVWTCNYQTMGTUCNTGCF[UWHHGTHTQOXGT[NQYRC[
#PQVJGT CNCTOKPI VTGPF KU VJG SWCNKV[ QH VJG WPGORNQ[GF
UGEVQT0KPGQWVQHGXGT[VGPWPGORNQ[GF(KNKRKPQUCTG
JKIJUEJQQN ITCFWCVGU QTYKVJUQOGEQNNGIGGFWECVKQP/QTGVJCP
JCNHCTGDGVYGGP[GCTUYJKEJOC[DGEQPUKFGTGFCU
COQPIVJGRTKOG[GCTUKPVGTOUQHRTQFWEVKXKV[6JKUKPFKECVGUVJCV
VJGRTQDNGOQHWPGORNQ[OGPVFQGUPQVNKGKPVJGNCEMQHGFWECVKQPQT
UMKNNUDWVKPVJGGEQPQO[UKPCDKNKV[VQIGPGTCVGGPQWIJGORNQ[OGPVCPFQRRQTVWPKVKGUVQCDUQTDVJGNCDQTHQTEG
#U WPGORNQ[OGPV CPF WPFGTGORNQ[OGPV TGOCKP JKIJ
RTKEGU QH EQOOQFKVKGU TGOCKP JKIJ CU YGNN #TQWPF QH VJG
RQRWNCVKQPQTOKNNKQPUWTXKXGQPCFCKN[KPEQOGQH2
KP6JGRQQTGUVUGEVQTUGXGPUWDUKUVQPNGUUVJCPVJKUCOQWPV /QTG VJCP OKNNKQP (KNKRKPQU YGPV JWPIT[ KP VJG NCUV
SWCTVGTQH#NOQUVOKNNKQPQTJCNHQHVJGRQRWNCVKQPNCEMGF
RTQRGTPWVTKVKQP
6JG TKUG KP VJG OKPKOWO YCIG KU GXGP UOCNNGT VJCP VJG
KPETGCUGKPRTKEGUQHIQQFUCPFEQUVQHNKXKPI+PVJG0CVKQPCN%CRKVCN
4GIKQP0%4VJGOKPKOWOYCIGKPETGCUGFD[QPN[XGRGUQUKP
TGCNVGTOUDGVYGGPCPF#GUVKOCVGRWVUVJGTGCN
YCIG QH 2 KP KP 0%4 CU COQWPVKPI VQ QPN[
2#/CTEJUVWF[TGXGCNUVJCVVJGEQUVQHNKXKPI
HQTCHCOKN[QHUKZKP/GVTQ/CPKNCKUCNTGCF[2CFC[
.CDQT EQPVTCEVWCNK\CVKQP KU CPQVJGT CNCTOKPI FGXGNQROGPV6JTQWIJ UWDEQPVTCEVKPI VJG RTKXCVG UGEVQT OKPKOK\GU EQUVU CPF
QDNKICVKQPU VQ VJGKT GORNQ[GGU D[ MGGRKPI VJGO QP UJQTVVGTO
EQPVTCEVU6JGRGTKQFKEVGTOKPCVKQPQHGORNQ[OGPVHWTVJGTEQPFGOPU
YQTMGTUKPVQFGGRGTRQXGTV[GURGEKCNN[CVCVKOGQHGEQPQOKEETKUKU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
11/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
#VVJGQVJGTGZVTGOGVJGPGVYQTVJQHVJGTKEJGUVHCOKNKGU
KPVJGEQWPVT[TGCEJGFCNOQUV75DKNNKQPQTOQTGVJCPVTKNNKQP
RGUQU KP 6JKU COQWPV TQUG HTQO VJG FCVC QH 75
DKNNKQP +TQPKECNN[ KPETGCUKPI KORQXGTKUJOGPV QH OCLQTKV[ QH VJG
(KNKRKPQUQEEWTUCOKFRQUKVKXGITQYVJTKUKPIEQTRQTCVGRTQVUCPFITQYKPIRTKXCVGYGCNVJ
# PCVKQPYKFG UWTXG[ OCFG D[ VJG 5QEKCN 9GCVJGT 5VCVKQP
KPGCTN[/CTEJUCKFPGVRWDNKEUCVKUHCEVKQPYKVJVJG#SWKPQ
CFOKPKUVTCVKQPURGTHQTOCPEGFTQRRGFVQRGTEGPVHTQORGT
EGPVKP5GRVGODGTCPF0QXGODGTKP6JGRGTEGPVFTQR
WPFGTUEQTGU YJCV VJG RGQRNG CNTGCF[ HGGN KU C FKUCRRQKPVKPI UVCTVHQTVJG#SWKPQCFOKPKUVTCVKQP5QHCTDG[QPFVJGCPVKEQTTWRVKQP
RTQPQWPEGOGPVUCPFTGE[ENKPIQHQNFRTQITCOUVJGPGYIQXGTPOGPV
JCUPQVRTQFWEGFCP[EQPETGVGTGHQTOCIGPFC
&GRNQ[OGPVQH1(9U
&KHEWNV UQEKQGEQPQOKE EQPFKVKQPU EQPVKPWG VQ OCMG(KNKRKPQU YKVJ CEEGUU VQ PCPEKCN CPF UQEKCN TGUQWTEGU EQPUKFGT
QXGTUGCU GORNQ[OGPV QT GXGP RGTOCPGPV GOKITCVKQP 6JG FKTG
EQPFKVKQP QH VJG EQWPVT[ JCU PGXGT DGGP OQTG RTQPQWPEGF CU VJG
NCUV VGP [GCTUWPFGTVJG CFOKPKUVTCVKQP QHHQTOGT 2TGUKFGPV )NQTKC
#TTQ[QYJQRWTUWGFKVUNCDQTGZRQTVRQNKE[CIITGUUKXGN[+VVCTIGVGF
CPCPPWCNFGRNQ[OGPVQHCVNGCUVCOKNNKQPYQTMGTUVQOQTGVJCP
EQWPVTKGUCPFFGUVKPCVKQPUGORJCUK\GFVJGOCTMGVKPIHWPEVKQPUQH
VJG2JKNKRRKPG1XGTUGCU'ORNQ[OGPV#FOKPKUVTCVKQP21'#CPF
QTKGPVGF VJG GFWECVKQPCN U[UVGO CPF VJG 2TQHGUUKQPCN 4GIWNCVKQP
%QOOKUUKQP 24% VQYCTFU RTQFWEKPI RTQHGUUKQPCNU YJQ YKNN
DG CVVTCEVKXG KP VJG INQDCN OCTMGV #PQVJGT EQPVTQXGTUKCN RQNKE[
RTQPQWPEGOGPVWPFGTVJG#TTQ[QCFOKPKUVTCVKQPYCUVJGKUUWCPEG
QHVYKP#FOKPKUVTCVKXG1TFGTU#1CPFKP&GEGODGT
RWTRQTVGFN[VQOKVKICVGOCUUUECNGFKURNCEGOGPVQHVJG1(9UCPF
VQOKPKOK\GVJGCFXGTUGKORCEVQHVJGINQDCNPCPEKCNCPFGEQPQOKE
ETKUKU#1KPRCTVKEWNCTFKTGEVGFVJG21'#VQUGVCUKFGTGIWNCVKQP
CPFIQHWNNDNCUVYKVJKVUOCTMGVKPIFGXGNQROGPVGHHQTVUGZRNQTCVKQP
QHHTQPVKGTUCPFHGTVKNGLQDOCTMGVUCDTQCFHQT1(9U
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
12/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
&CVC HTQO VJG 21'# KPFKECVGU VJCV C VQVCN QH
TGIKUVGTGF NCPF CPF UGCDCUGF 1(9U YGTG FGRNQ[GF QXGTUGCU KP
6JKU YCU UNKIJVN[ JKIJGT VJCP VJG VQVCN FGRNQ[OGPV
QH%NQUGTUETWVKP[QHVJGFCVCTGXGCNUVJCVVJGTGYGTG
CEVWCNN[HGYGTPGYLQDRNCEGOGPVUCDTQCFCUKPFKECVGFD[VJGFTQRKPVJGPWODGTQHPGYJKTGUHTQOKPVQKP
6JWUVJGKPETGCUGKPFGRNQ[OGPVIWTGKUOQTGCHWPEVKQPQH
VJGKPETGCUGKPVJGPWODGTQH1(9UYJQTGPGYGFVJGKTEQPVTCEVU
TGJKTGUCHVGTVJGKTTUVYQTMEQPVTCEVUKPHTQOVQ
KP
6CDNG&GRNQ[OGPVQH1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQ9QTMGTU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
13/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
6JGIQXGTPOGPVRQKPVUVQVJGKORNGOGPVCVKQPQHVJGPGYN[
COGPFGF/KITCPV9QTMGTU#EVCUVJGQHEKCNTGCUQPHQTVJGFTQRKP
PGYJKTGU6JGPGYNCYOCPFCVGUCOQPIQVJGTUCEQORTGJGPUKXG
KPUWTCPEG EQXGTCIG HQT GXGT[ (KNKRKPQ YQTMGT VQ DG FGRNQ[GF
CDTQCF D[ TGETWKVOGPV CIGPEKGU CPF HQT FGUVKPCVKQP EQWPVTKGU VQJCXG EGTVKECVGU QH EQORNKCPEG CU UCHG FGUVKPCVKQPU HTQO VJG
&GRCTVOGPVQH(QTGKIP#HHCKTU&(#
.CDQTTGETWKVGTUJQYGXGTUCKFVJKUYCUECWUGFD[GORNQ[GTU
GURGEKCNN[ KP /KFFNG 'CUV EQWPVTKGU YJQ OCKPVCKPGF C NQYRC[
UVTWEVWTGFWGVQYQTMGTUHTQOQVJGTNCDQTOCTMGVUYJQCTGYKNNKPI
VQIGVRCKFNGUUVJCPYJCV(KNKRKPQUTGEGKXG1VJGTTGETWKVGTUCTIWGVJCVVJGCXCKNCDNGUVQEMQHSWCNKGF(KNKRKPQUJCUIQPGFQYPEKVKPI
VJGKTHCKNWTGVQNNWRTGSWGUVUHTQO/KFFNG'CUVHQTSWCNKGFPWTUGU
(WTVJGTVJG[CUUGTVVJCVQVJGTUGPFKPIEQWPVTKGUUWEJCU2CMKUVCP
CPF+PFKCJCXGCDKIIGTRQQNQHUMKNNGFYQTMGTUCPFRTQHGUUKQPCNU
5KPEG VYQVJKTFU QH QXGTUGCU FGRNQ[OGPVU YGTG TG
JKTGUQT1(9UTGPGYKPIEQPVTCEVU6JGUVGCF[KPETGCUGQHTGJKTGUCVVJGXGT[NGCUVKUKPFKECVKXGQHIQXGTPOGPVUHCKNWTGVQCVVTCEVVJG
1(9UDCEMJQOG
$[ 1(9U YGTG KP CRRTQZKOCVGN[ EQWPVTKGU CPF
VGTTKVQTKGUCTQWPFVJGINQDG +P &GEGODGT VQVCNGUVKOCVGU QH
RQRWNCVKQP QH QXGTUGCU (KNKRKPQU PWODGTGF OKNNKQP CNUQ KP
VJGUCOGPWODGTQHEQWPVTKGUCPFVGTTKVQTKGU/QTGVJCPOKNNKQP
JCXG RGTOCPGPV TGUKFGPEG UVCVWU CTG
1(9UCPFCNKVVNGOQTGVJCPJCNHCOKNNKQPCTGWPFQEWOGPVGF
QTJCXGKTTGIWNCTUVCVWU
6JG ENCUUKECVKQP QH QXGTUGCU (KNKRKPQU CEEQTFKPI VQ VJGKT
KOOKITCVKQP UVCVWU RTQXKFGU CP KPFKECVQT QP VJGKT XWNPGTCDKNKVKGU
CUPQPEKVK\GPUCPFOKITCPVU2GTOCPGPVTGUKFGPVUJCXGNGUUTKUMU
CPF XWNPGTCDKNKVKGU EQORCTGF VQ VGORQTCT[OKITCPV YQTMGTU
6JG WPFQEWOGPVGF (KNKRKPQU CTG KP VJG OQUV TKUM[ KPUGEWTG CPF
XWNPGTCDNGRQUKVKQP
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
14/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
#TQWPFJCNHQHCPPWCNFGRNQ[OGPVKUVQVJG/KFFNG'CUVYKVJ
5CWFK#TCDKCEQPUVCPVN[QPVQRQHVJGNKUV6JGTGOCTMCDNGKPETGCUG
KPFGRNQ[OGPVVQVJG7#'CPF3CVCTKUCNUQPQVCDNG
(GOKPK\CVKQPQH/KITCVKQP
1XGTUGCU OKITCVKQP JCU IQPG VJTQWIJ C RTQEGUU QH
HGOKPK\CVKQP1XGTVJGNCUV[GCTU(KNKRKPQOKITCPVYQOGPJCXG
UVGCFKN[ KPETGCUGF VJGKT UJCTG KP VJG OKITCVKQP RKG #NOQUV VJTGG
FGECFGU CIQ (KNKRKPQ YQOGP OCFG WR QPN[ QH VJG QXGTUGCU
YQTMHQTEG +P VJG[ CNTGCF[ EQORTKUGF QH QXGTUGCUFGRNQ[OGPV+PYQOGPOCFGWRQHFGRNQ[OGPV+P
OKITCPVYQOGPCNTGCF[CEEQWPVGFHQTQHQXGTUGCUFGRNQ[OGPV
6JG[CTGRTQOKPGPVCEVQTUKPVJGINQDCNECTGEJCKP6JGINQDCNECTG
EJCKPTGHGTUVQCUGTKGUQHRGTUQPCNNKPMUDGVYGGPRGQRNGCETQUUVJG
INQDGDCUGFQPVJGRCKFQTWPRCKFYQTMQHECTKPI
9QOGP OKITCPVU YQTM CU RTQHGUUKQPCN CPF VGEJPKECNGORNQ[GGU CU PWTUGU ENGTKECN CPF UCNGU YQTMGTU GPVGTVCKPGTU
ECTGIKXGTUCPFFQOGUVKEYQTMGTU/CP[QHVJGOYGTGWPGORNQ[GF
QT JCF WPRCKF QT WPFGTXCNWGF LQDU KP VJG 2JKNKRRKPGU #RCTV
HTQO GEQPQOKE TGCUQPU IGPFGTDCUGF XKQNGPEG CV JQOG OCTKVCN
UGRCTCVKQPCPFCDCPFQPOGPVD[URQWUGCTGCOQPIVJGTGCUQPUYJ[
YQOGPFGEKFGVQYQTMQXGTUGCU#OQPI[QWPIUKPINGYQOGPVJGTG
KUCNUQVJGKPVGTGUVCPFFGUKTGVQNKXGCPFYQTMKPHQTGKIPNCPFUCUCPGZGTEKUGQHVJGKTRGTUQPCNCWVQPQO[CPFKPRWTUWKVQHRGTUQPCN
FGXGNQROGPVIQCNU
9QOGPCTGCNUQENCUUKGFCOQPIVJGRGTOCPGPVOKITCPVUCU
CPEGUCPF URQWUGUQHHQTGKIPPCVKQPCNU$GVYGGPVQ
(KNKRKPQ YQOGP NGHV VJG EQWPVT[ CU URQWUGU QH HQTGKIP
PCVKQPCNU6JGIGPFGTTCVKQDGVYGGPHGOCNGCPFOCNGYQTMGTUTGCEJGFKPDWVJCUFTQRRGFDCEMVQCTQWPFUKPEG,CRCP
TGUVTKEVGFVJGGPVT[QHGPVGTVCKPGTUKPCPF21'#KORNGOGPVGF
CPGYUGVQHRQNKEKGUHQTVJGRTQVGEVKQPQHFQOGUVKEYQTMGTUKP
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
15/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
6CDNG0WODGTQH&GRNQ[GF.CPFDCUGF1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQU
KP6QR6GP1EEWRCVKQPCN%CVGIQTKGUCPFD[5GZ
:RUOG5HJLRQ 0DOH )HPDOH %RWK6H[HV
$OO2FFXSDWLRQDO&DWHJRULHV7RWDO
+RXVHKROG6HUYLFH:RUNHUV
&KDUZRUNHUV&OHDQHUVDQG5HODWHG
:RUNHUV
1XUVHV3URIHVVLRQDO
&DUHJLYHUVDQG&DUHWDNHUV
:RUOG5HJLRQ 0DOH )HPDOH %RWK6H[HV
:DLWHUV%DUWHQGHUVDQG5HODWHG:RUNHUV
:LUHPHQDQG(OHFWULFDO:RUNHUV
3OXPEHUVDQG3LSH)LWWHUV
:HOGHUVDQG)ODPH&XWWHUV
+RXVHNHHSLQJDQG5HODWHG6HUYLFH:RUNHUV
%ULFNOD\HUV6WRQHPDVRQVDQG7LOH6HWWHUV
6RXUFH32($2YHUVHDV(PSOR\PHQW6WDWLVWLFV
9JKNG YQOGP OKITCPVU CNTGCF[ QWVRCEG OGP OKITCPVU
VJGKTTGOKVVCPEGUOCMGWRQPN[QHYJCVVJGOGPTGOKV6JKU
UVTQPIN[ UWIIGUVU VJCV YQOGP OKITCPVU YQTM KP KPHQTOCNK\GF
NQYN[XCNWGFCPFWPRTQVGEVGFLQDU6JGPCVWTGQHHGOKPK\GFLQDURTGFKURQUGUYQOGPPQVQPN[VQNQYGTYCIGNGXGNUDWVCNUQVQJKIJGT
TKUMUCPFXWNPGTCDKNKVKGU#UYQOGPEQOKPIHTQOCNGUUFGXGNQRGF
EQWPVT[VJG[GPEQWPVGTFKUETKOKPCVKQPDCUGFQPIGPFGTENCUUCPF
PCVKQPCNKV[
6JG OCIPKVWFG CPF KPUVKVWVKQPCNK\CVKQP QH QXGTUGCU
GORNQ[OGPVOC[JCXGKPCFXGTVGPVN[HCEKNKVCVGFNQECNCPFKPVGTPCVKQPCN
VTCHEMKPI KP IKTNU CPF YQOGP 6JG 75 5VCVG &GRCTVOGPV KP KVU
6TCHEMKPIKP2GTUQPU4GRQTVJCUOQXGFVJGTCPMKPIQHVJG
2JKNKRRKPGU HTQO 6KGT 9CVEJNKUV VQ 6KGT 6JKU OGCPU VJCV VJG
2JKNKRRKPGUKUOCMKPIUKIPKECPVGHHQTVUVQFQUQCNVJQWIJKVUVKNN
FQGUPQVHWNN[EQORN[YKVJOKPKOWOUVCPFCTFU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
16/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
9QOGP&QOGUVKE9QTMGTU8WNPGTCDNG7PFGTXCNWGF
6JGDKIPWODGTQHFQOGUVKEYQTMGTUOGCPUVJCVVJG[RNC[
CP KORQTVCPV TQNG KP MGGRKPI VJG 2JKNKRRKPGU GEQPQO[ CQCV
&WTKPIVJGTGEGPVPCPEKCNETKUKUTGOKVVCPEGUHTQO(KNKRKPQUCDTQCFCEVWCNN[KPETGCUGFEQORCTGFVQQVJGTNCDQTGZRQTVKPIEQWPVTKGUUWEJ
CU+PFQPGUKCCPF$CPINCFGUJCPF YQOGPKPRCTVKEWNCTJCXGDGGP
EQPUKUVGPVKPUGPFKPIOQPG[VQVJGKTHCOKNKGUDCEMJQOG
&GURKVG VJG FQOGUVKE YQTMGTU UKIPKECPV EQPVTKDWVKQP
VJG[TGOCKPNGCUVCEMPQYNGFIGFCUCHQTEGHQTGEQPQOKEITQYVJ
&QOGUVKEYQTMTGOCKPUWPTGEQIPK\GFCUTGCNYQTMDGECWUGKVFQGUPQV V KP VJG EWTTGPV HTCOGYQTM QH YJCV KU YQTM 5QEKGV[ JQNFU
EGTVCKPPQVKQPUQPYJCVEQPUVKVWVGYQTMUWEJVJCVKVKUUQOGVJKPI
FQPGQWVUKFGVJGJQOGKURCKFCPFETGCVGUUWTRNWUXCNWG&QOGUVKE
NCDQT KU XKGYGF CU YQOGPU TGURQPUKDKNKV[ CPF CUUWOGF VQ DG C
FQPCVKQPVJG[UJQWNFOCMGVQVJGGEQPQO[6JGTGKUXGT[NKVVNGQTPQ
OQPGVCT[XCNWGCVVCEJGFVQKV6JWUKVKUGZENWFGFKPVJGNCDQTCPF
UQEKCNNCYUQHOQUVEQWPVTKGU
4GOKVVCPEGU
6JG/KFFNG'CUVCEEQWPVGFHQTCDQWVRGTEGPVQHVJGVQVCN
1(9TGOKVVCPEGUKP4GOKVVCPEGUHTQOVJG/KFFNG'CUVRQUVGF
CFQWDNGFKIKVITQYVJQHRGTEGPVVQ75DKNNKQPNCUV[GCTHTQO75DKNNKQPKP/QTGVJCPJCNHQT75DKNNKQP
ECOG HTQO 5CWFK #TCDKC HQNNQYGF D[ VJG 7PKVGF #TCD 'OKTCVGU
YKVJ75OKNNKQP3CVCTYKVJ75OKNNKQP$CJTCKPYKVJ
75 OKNNKQP -WYCKV YKVJ 75 OKNNKQP +UTCGN YKVJ
75OKNNKQP1OCPYKVJ75OKNNKQPCPFQVJGTU
0QTVJ #OGTKECP EQWPVTKGU CEEQWPVGF HQT QH VQVCNTGOKVVCPEGU KP YKVJ 75 DKNNKQP HQNNQYGF D[ 'WTQRGCP
EQWPVTKGUYKVJQT75DKNNKQPCPF#UKCPEQWPVTKGUYKVJ
QT75DKNNKQP
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
17/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
1(9TGOKVVCPEGUTGCEJGFCTGEQTF75DKNNKQPKP
6JKU[GCTUTGOKVVCPEGUCTGGZRGEVGFVQITQYD[#NTGCF[OQPG[
UGPV JQOG D[ 1(9U KP (GDTWCT[ ITGY HTQO C [GCT CIQ VQ
75DKNNKQP(QTVJGTUVOQPVJUQHTGOKVVCPEGUYGTGWR
CV75DKNNKQP+PVJGCPPWCNTGOKVVCPEGUUGPVVJTQWIJHQTOCNEJCPPGNUTGCEJGF75$#TQWPFQHVJG2JKNKRRKPG
RQRWNCVKQPTGNKGUQPVJGUGTGOKVVCPEGUHQTHQQFEJKNFTGPUGFWECVKQP
CPFUJGNVGT
6JG[GCTN[1(9TGOKVVCPEGUJCXGITQYPKPVJGNCUVXG[GCTU
CVCPCXGTCIGQH6JG[CEEQWPVHQTQHVJGEQWPVT[U
)TQUU0CVKQPCN2TQFWEV)021(9UCTGPQYVJGEQWPVT[UVQRGZRQTVRTQFWEVQWVRCEKPIVTCFKVKQPCNGZRQTVUD[
6CDNG1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQU4GOKVVCPEGUD[%QWPVT[CPF$[
5QWTEGKP75&QNNCTU,CPWCT[&GEGODGT
&RXQWU\
7RWDO
/DQG%DVHG/%
6HD%DVHG
6%
$VLD
/%
6%
%UXQHL
+RQJ.RQJ
-DSDQ
.RUHD
0DOD\VLD
6LQJDSRUH
7DLZDQ
$PHULFDV
/%
6%
&DQDGD
*XDP
86$
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
18/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
&RXQWU\
2&($1,$
/%
6%
$XVWUDOLD
1HZ=HDODQG
31*
(XURSH
/%
6%
$XVWULD
%HOJLXP
&\SUXV
'HQPDUN
*HUPDQ\
)LQODQG
)UDQFH
*UHHFH
,UHODQG
,WDO\
1HWKHUODQGV
1RUZD\
6SDLQ
6ZHGHQ
6ZLW]HUODQG
8QLWHG
.LQJGRP
0LGGOH(DVW
/%
6%
%DKUDLQ
(J\SW
,VUDHO
-RUGDQ
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
19/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
&RXQWU\
.XZDLW
/HEDQRQ
/LE\D
2PDQ 4DWDU
6DXGL
$UDELD
6\ULD
8$(
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
20/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
YJQCTGWPCDNGVQPFLQDUKPVJG2JKNKRRKPGUYKNNOQTGNKMGN[GPF
WRKPVJGUGLQDUKHVJG[VCMGVJGOKITCVKQPTQWVGVJGTGD[TGUWNVKPIKP
DTCKPFTCKPKGYCUVGFVCNGPVCPFUMKNN
#V NGCUV RGT EGPV QH 1(9U HCOKNKGU TGOCKP RQQT 6JKUKU DGECWUG VJG 1(9U CPF VJGKT HCOKNKGU CTG OQUVN[ ENCUUKGF CU
WPUMKNNGF QT UGOKUMKNNGF UWEJ CU JQWUGJQNF UGTXKEG YQTMGTU
&QOGUVKEYQTMGTUQHVGPGPFWRGORV[JCPFGFYJGPVJG[TGVWTPVQ
VJGEQWPVT[CUYCIGUTGEGKXGFCTGNQYGTVJCPRTQOKUGFCPFVJG[
JCXGVQRC[QHHFGDVUKPEWTTGFKPRTGRCTKPIHQTQXGTUGCUYQTM/CP[
UWHHGTHTQOCDWUKXGGORNQ[GTUQTHCNNRTG[VQJWOCPVTCHEMGTU
OKUHQTVWPGUVJCVGPVCKNDQVJJWOCPCPFPCPEKCNEQUVU
6JG)NQDCN5KVWCVKQPCPF1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQU
9QTNF EQPFKVKQPU KP VJG EWTTGPV CIG QH INQDCNK\CVKQP KU
EJCTCEVGTK\GF D[ C ITQYKPI KPVGITCVKQP CPF KPVGTFGRGPFGPEG QH
PCVKQPCN GEQPQOKGU QRGPKPI WR QH OCTMGVU VQ HQTGKIP VTCFG CPF
EQORGVKVKQPNQYGTKPIQHVCTKHHUCPFQVJGTVTCFGDCTTKGTUCPFUKIPKECPV
CFXCPEGUKPVGEJPQNQI[VTCPURQTVCVKQPCPFEQOOWPKECVKQPU
/KITCPV NCDQT KU C MG[ HGCVWTG QH INQDCNK\CVKQP +V OCMGU
C UKIPKECPV KORCEV QP VJG YQTNF GEQPQO[ 'XGT[ [GCT OKITCPV
YQTMGTUUGPFJQOGVJGGSWKXCNGPVQH75DKNNKQPKPTGOKVVCPEGU
VQUWRRQTVHCOKNKGUCPFEQOOWPKVKGU
,WUV CU KORQTVCPV CU VJGKT EQPVTKDWVKQP VQ VJGKT JQOG
EQWPVTKGU OKITCPV YQTMGTU OCMG C UWDUVCPVKCN GEQPQOKE CPF
UQEKCN EQPVTKDWVKQP VQ VJG GEQPQOKGU QH FGUVKPCVKQP EQWPVTKGU
/KITCPV YQTMGTU URGPF OQUV QH VJGKT KPEQOG KP JQUV EQWPVTKGU
YJKNGTGOKVVCPEGUCXGTCIGVJG[RC[VCZGUCPFUQEKCN
UGEWTKV[EQPVTKDWVKQPUKHVJG[CTGCNNQYGFVQYQTMNGICNN[TGURQPFVQTGCNNCDQTPGGFUKPTGEGKXKPIEQWPVTKGUD[HWNNNKPIWPOGVNCDQT
TGSWKTGOGPVU DTKPI PGY UEKGPVKE VGEJPQNQIKECN CPF EWNVWTCN
TGUQWTEGU VQ TGEGKXKPI EQWPVTKGU 6JG[ EQPVTKDWVG VQ FKXGTUKH[KPI
CPFGPTKEJKPIVJGFGUVKPCVKQPEQWPVTKGUGEQPQOKECPFEWNVWTCNDCUG
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
21/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
KPETGCUGFQOGUVKEEQPUWORVKQPCPFVCZTGXGPWGTGOKVVCPEGQYU
IGPGTCVG KORQTV FGOCPF HQT FGUVKPCVKQPEQWPVT[ GZRQTVU KP QTKIKP
EQWPVTKGUCPFEQPVTKDWVGVQVJGGZRCPUKQPQHINQDCNVTCFGYKVJVJGKT
MPQYNGFIGQHQTKIKPEQWPVT[OCTMGVU
1XGTUGCUOKITCVKQPVTGPFUJCXGCFCRVGFVQEJCPIKPIYQTNF
EQPFKVKQPU6JG7PKVGF0CVKQPU&GXGNQROGPV2TQITCO70&2JCU
KFGPVKGFVJTGGVTGPFUKPQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPKPVJKUEWTTGPVCIG
INQDCN GORNQ[OGPV QRRQTVWPKVKGU CTG QRGPKPI WR VQ JKIJUMKNNGF
NCDQT DWV ENQUKPI HQT OQUV QVJGTU 6JG KPVGTPCVKQPCN OCTMGV HQT
JKIJN[UMKNNGFNCDQTJCUDGEQOGOQTGKPVGITCVGFJKIJN[OQDKNGCPF
IKXGUUVCPFCTFYCIGU7PUMKNNGFNCDQTOGCPYJKNGUVKNNCEEQWPVUHQTCNCTIGTUJCTGQHKPVGTPCVKQPCNOKITCVKQPDWVKUJKIJN[TGUVTKEVGFD[
PCVKQPCNDCTTKGTUWPFQEWOGPVGFOKITCVKQPEQPVKPWGUWPCDCVGF
CPFVJGHGOKPK\CVKQPQHQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPKPETGCUGU
)NQDCNK\CVKQPJQYGXGTJCUKVUPGICVKXGKORCEVQP(KNKRKPQ
OKITCPVU YQTMKPI EQPFKVKQPU TCEKUO TCEKCN FKUETKOKPCVKQP CPF
ZGPQRJQDKC VQYCTFU OKITCPVU NCEM QH NGICN CPF UQEKCN RTQVGEVKQPHQTOKITCPVUKPVJGCDUGPEGQHPCVKQPCNNCYUTGUVTKEVKXGCPFRWPKVKXG
KOOKITCVKQPNCYUCPFRTCEVKEGUNGCFKPIVQJWOCPTKIJVUXKQNCVKQPU
CPF GXGP FGCVJU CV VJG DQTFGT KPJWOCPG YQTMKPI EQPFKVKQPU QH
OKITCPVYQTMGTURCTVKEWNCTN[YQOGPFQOGUVKEYQTMGTUCPFUGCUQPCN
YQTMGTU
&GURKVGVJGHQTGIQKPICPFVJGRGTKQFKEPCPEKCNCPFGEQPQOKE
ETKUGUVJCVDGUGVVJGECRKVCNKUVYQTNFVJGFGRNQ[OGPVQH(KNKRKPQU
QXGTUGCUJCUEQPVKPWGFVQKPETGCUG6JGYQTNFPCPEKCNETKUKUUVCTVGF
KPDWVVJG2JKNKRRKPGUUVKNNTGEQTFGFCRGTEGPVKPETGCUGKP
FGRNQ[OGPVHTQOKPVQ#XGTCIGOQPVJN[
TGOKVVCPEGUGPVRGT1(9UNKIJVN[KPETGCUGFHTQO2KP
VQ 2 KP 6JG CXGTCIG OQPVJN[ TGOKVVCPEG TGEGKXGF RGT
JQWUGJQNFNKMGYKUGITGYHTQO2KPVQ2KP
+PTGCNVGTOUJQYGXGTCUNKIJVFGENKPGKPTGOKVVCPEGUYCUTGEQTFGF
6JGCXGTCIGOQPVJN[TGOKVVCPEGUGPVD[1(9UYGPVFQYPD[
CPFVJGCXGTCIGTGOKVVCPEGTGEGKXGFD[HCOKNKGUHGNND[
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
22/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
9JKNGVJGTGKUPQEQPETGVGTGRQTVCXCKNCDNG[GVQPVJGKORCEV
QHVJGINQDCNPCPEKCNETKUKUQPOKITCVKQPUGXGTCNNCTIGN[PGICVKXG
GHHGEVUJCXGDGGPQDUGTXGF6JGUGKPENWFGLQDNQUUGUGURGEKCNN[KP
EQPUVTWEVKQPOCPWHCEVWTKPIPCPEGUGTXKEGUTGVCKNCPFVQWTKUO
TGFWEVKQP KP YCIGU CPF RQQTGT EQPFKVKQPU KP VJG YQTMRNCEG CUYGNNCUEWVUKPUQEKCNUGTXKEGUCPFFKUETKOKPCVKQPCPFZGPQRJQDKC
CUOKITCPVUCTGRGTEGKXGFCUVCMKPIVJGLQDUQHNQECNYQTMGTU6JG
TGVWTPQHWPGORNQ[GFOKITCPVUVQEQWPVTKGUQHQTKIKPOC[PQVDG
XKCDNGDGECWUGVJG[CTGCNUQNKMGN[VQHCEGJKIJWPGORNQ[OGPVCPF
RQXGTV[KPVJGKTQYPEQWPVTKGU
1VJGTGHHGEVUQHVJGINQDCNETKUKUKPENWFGFGENKPGKPTGOKVVCPEGQYU VQ FGXGNQRKPI EQWPVTKGU CU OKITCPVU NQUG VJGKT LQDU OQTG
TGUVTKEVKXG KOOKITCVKQP RQNKEKGU VQ RTQVGEV NQECN NCDQT TGFWEVKQP
KP NCDQT OKITCVKQP QYU CU RQVGPVKCN OKITCPVU QRV VQ UVC[ JQOG
KPETGCUGKPKTTGIWNCTOKITCVKQPCPFVJGUVTGPIVJGPKPIQHVJGKPHQTOCN
NCDQTOCTMGVCUWPGORNQ[GFOKITCPVUKPFGUVKPCVKQPEQWPVTKGUUGGM
VQYQTMYKVJQWVCWVJQTK\CVKQPCPFCUQRRQTVWPKVKGUHQTTGIWNCTNCDQT
OKITCVKQPFGETGCUGTGUWNVKPIKPVJGGOKITCVKQPQHOQTGRGTUQPUHTQOEQWPVTKGUQHQTKIKPOQTGUGTKQWUN[CHHGEVGFD[VJGETKUKU#PKPETGCUG
KPVTCHEMKPIKPJWOCPDGKPIUKUCNUQCRQUUKDKNKV[
6JG %QOOWPKV[$CUGF /QPKVQTKPI 5[UVGO +PVGTPCVKQPCN
0GVYQTM EQPFWEVGF C UWTXG[ COQPI 1(9 HCOKNKGU KP
&GEGODGT (QWT JWPFTGF HQTV[ JCF HCOKN[ OGODGTU
YQTMKPICDTQCF6JGUWTXG[TGXGCNGFVYQOCKPGHHGEVUQHVJGETKUKU
QPVJG1(9HCOKN[OGODGTUCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU1PGKUTGVTGPEJOGPV
QTNC[QHHVJGQVJGTKUYQTMGTUEQPUGPVVQYCIGEWVU
1H VJG QH TGURQPFGPVU YJQ TGRQTVGF 1(9 HCOKN[
OGODGTUYJQTGVWTPGFFWTKPIVJGRGTKQF0QXGODGTVQ#RTKN
RQKPVGF VQ TGVTGPEJOGPV QT NC[QHH CU VJG ECWUG QH
TGRCVTKCVKQPJQOGEQOKPI#DQWVQHTGVTGPEJGF1(9UYQTMGF
KP5CWFK#TCDKCHQNNQYGFD[VJG7PKVGF5VCVGU5GXGPV[RGT
EGPVQHTGVTGPEJGF1(9UYGTGOCNG
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
23/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
4CVJGT VJCP TGVWTP VQ VJG 2JKNKRRKPGU UQOG 1(9U CITGGF
VQYCIGEWVU#DQWVCVGPVJQHVJGJQWUGJQNFUTGRQTVGFVJCV
VJGKT 1(9U GZRGTKGPEGF YCIG TGFWEVKQP 4GCUQPU EKVGF KPENWFGF
TGFWEGFYQTMKPIJQWTUEWVVKPIEQUVOGCUWTGUD[VJGTOYJGTGVJG
1(9YQTMUCPFNQUUGUKPEWTTGFD[VJGTOYJGTGVJG1(9YQTMU
/QTG VJCP RGTEGPV QH VJG JQWUGJQNFU YJQ TGEGKXGF
TGOKVVCPEGUJCFGZRGTKGPEGFTGFWEVKQPKPVJGCOQWPVQHTGOKVVCPEGU
TGEGKXGF#TQWPFQHCNNJQWUGJQNFUGZRGTKGPEGFCFGENKPGKP
VJGHTGSWGPE[QHTGEGKRVQHTGOKVVCPEGU
)QXGTPOGPVFCVCCNUQUJQYGFCUNQYFQYPKPVJGITQYVJQHTGOKVVCPEGUVQQPN[KPVJGTUVUGXGPOQPVJUQHEQORCTGF
VQKPVJGUCOGRGTKQFKP0QQHEKCNTGRQTVUJCXGEQOG
QWVQPVJGGHHGEVUQHVJGQPIQKPI/KFFNG'CUVETKUKUQP1(9UCPF
VJGKTHCOKNKGU
1(9UKPVJG/KFFNG'CUVCPF0QTVJ#HTKECPEQWPVTKGUPQYKP
VWTOQKNQPN[CEEQWPVHQTOQTGVJCPQHVJGVQVCN1(9TGOKVVCPEG#UQH,WPG1(9UPWODGTGFCTQWPF(KNKRKPQUKP'I[RV
KP$CJTCKPKP;GOGPCPFCTQWPFKP.KD[C
$GECWUG KV KU C RTKOG FGUVKPCVKQP HQT QWT UMKNNGF CPF NQY
UMKNNGFYQTMGTUVJG/KFFNG'CUVUKVWCVKQPPQYRWVUVJGYGNNDGKPI
CPFHWVWTGQH1(9UJCPIKPIKPVJGDCNCPEG6JG0CVKQPCN5VCVKUVKEU
%QQTFKPCVKQP$QCTFJCUYCTPGFVJCVVJGVWTOQKNEQWNFYQTUGPVJG
EQWPVT[UWPGORNQ[OGPVUKVWCVKQPCPFVJGQXGTCNNGEQPQO[
+HVJGEQPKEVURTGCFUCRRTQZKOCVGN[OKNNKQP1(9UKP
VJG/KFFNG'CUVEQWNFRQUUKDN[TGVWTPVQVJG2JKNKRRKPGUCPFPQVDG
CDNGVQPFLQDUKPVJGNQECNOCTMGV6JKUYKNNRWUJVJGWPGORNQ[OGPV
TCVGWRVQRGTEGPV
+P CFFKVKQP VJG ETKUKU EQWNF CNUQ CHHGEV QWT QKN UWRRNKGU
KPCVKQP NQECN CPF INQDCN LQD CXCKNCDKNKV[ VCZ TGXGPWG DCUG VJG
/QTQUKVWCVKQPDGECWUGQHVJGKTVKGUVQ#TCDEQWPVTKGUKPVGTPCVKQPCN
VGTTQTKUOCPFVJGEQWPVT[UFGOQETCVKERGQRNGRQYGTNGICE[
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
24/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
.GICN2QNKE[(TCOGYQTMCPF/KITCVKQP)QXGTPCPEG
6JG 2JKNKRRKPGU TCVKGF VJG EQTG JWOCP CPF NCDQT TKIJVU
KPUVTWOGPVU VJCV RTQOQVG JWOCP YQOGP CPF OKITCPVU TKIJVU
KPENWFKPI VJG %QPXGPVKQP QP VJG 4KIJVU QH #NN /KITCPV9QTMGTUCPF/GODGTUQH6JGKT(COKNKGU%QPXGPVKQPQPVJG
'NKOKPCVKQP QH #NN (QTOU QH&KUETKOKPCVKQP CICKPUV 9QOGP CPF
+PVGTPCVKQPCN.CDQT1TICPK\CVKQP+.1%QPXGPVKQPUCPFQP
/KITCPV9QTMGTU
6JG 2JKNKRRKPGU CNUQ YQTMGF CEVKXGN[ YKVJ VJG %QOOKVVGG
QPVJG'NKOKPCVKQPQH#NN(QTOUQH&KUETKOKPCVKQPCICKPUV9QOGPHQT VJG CFQRVKQPKP 0QXGODGT QH )GPGTCN 4GEQOOGPFCVKQP
VJCVUGGMUVQRTQXKFGEQORTGJGPUKXGRTQVGEVKQPHQTCNNYQOGP
OKITCPVU+VYCUCNUQQPGQHVJGEQPUKUVGPVCFXQECVGUHQTVJGCFQRVKQP
QHCUVTQPI+.1%QPXGPVKQPQP&GEGPV9QTMHQT&QOGUVKE9QTMGTU
YJKEJ YCU CFQRVGF D[ VJG +.1 VTKRCTVKVG DQF[ QPN[ KP ,WPG
FWTKPIVJG+.1UEGPVGPPKCNUGUUKQPQHVJG+PVGTPCVKQPCN.CDQT
%QPHGTGPEG
6JGOCKPRQNKE[HTCOGYQTMQHVJGIQXGTPOGPVQPQXGTUGCU
OKITCVKQP KU 4GRWDNKE #EV 4# QT VJG /CIPC %CTVC
HQT9QTMGTUCPF1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQUYJKEJVJG2JKNKRRKPG%QPITGUU
JCUVKN[ GPCEVGF KP HQNNQYKPI VJG UVTQPI RWDNKE QWVTCIG QXGT
VJGGZGEWVKQPQHC(KNKRKPQFQOGUVKEYQTMGTKP5KPICRQTG4#
URGNNU QWVRTQVGEVKQPRTQXKUKQPUHQTOKITCPVUCVGXGT[UVCIGQHVJG
OKITCVKQPE[ENG
6JGNCYJCUDGGPTGXKUGFVYKEGVJGP4#KPVQ
UVTGPIVJGPVJGTGIWNCVQT[RQYGTQHVJG21'#CPFTGRGCNVJGVYQ
RTQXKUKQPUQPFGTGIWNCVKQPCPF4#KPVJCVHWTVJGTUGVU
JKIJGTUVCPFCTFUQHRTQVGEVKQPVQ1(9UKPENWFKPIVJGGZRCPUKQPQH
VJGFGPKVKQPQHKNNGICNTGETWKVOGPVCPFRTQJKDKVGFCEVU
4# CNUQ RTQXKFGU HQT C OCPFCVQT[ EQORTGJGPUKXG
KPUWTCPEGEQXGTCIGHQTOKITCPVYQTMGTUCVPQEQUVVQVJGO/KITCPVU
TKIJVUCFXQECVGUJQYGXGTCTGXGT[EQPEGTPGFVJCVKHVJKURCTVKEWNCT
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
25/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
RTQXKUKQPKUPQVRTQRGTN[KORNGOGPVGFCPFOQPKVQTGFOKITCPVUOC[
GPFWRRC[KPIVJGKPUWTCPEGRTGOKWOVJGOUGNXGU#PQVJGTHGCVWTG
QHVJGCOGPFGFNCYKUVJGTGSWKTGOGPVHQTEQWPVTKGUQHFGUVKPCVKQP
VQ DG KUUWGF EGTVKECVKQPU D[ VJG IQXGTPOGPV VJCV VJGTG CTG ENGCT
IWCTCPVGGUQHRTQVGEVKQPHQT1(9UKPVJGUGEQWPVTKGUQTFGRNQ[OGPVYKNNPQVDGCNNQYGF
6Q IKXG DCEM VJG TKIJV QH UWHHTCIG VQ QXGTUGCU (KNKRKPQU
%QPITGUUCNUQRCUUGF4#QTVJG1XGTUGCU#DUGPVGG8QVKPI.CY
QH1PVJGUCOG[GCTVJG(KNKRKPQ%KVK\GPUJKR4GCESWKUKVKQP
CPF4GVGPVKQP.CYCUYGNNCUVJG#PVK6TCHEMKPIKP9QOGPCPF
%JKNFTGP.CYYGTGCNUQGPCEVGFD[%QPITGUU
8CTKQWUIQXGTPOGPVCIGPEKGUYGTGUGVWRCPFOQDKNK\GFHQT
QXGTUGCU OKITCVKQP OCPCIGOGPVHTQOVJG 1HEGQHVJG 2TGUKFGPV
1HEGQHVJG8KEG2TGUKFGPVVJG&1.'CPFKVUCVVCEJGFCIGPEKGUVJG
199#CPF21'#CUYGNNCUVJG2JKNKRRKPG1XGTUGCU.CDQT1HEGU
21.1UVJG6GEJPKECN'FWECVKQPCPF5MKNNU&GXGNQROGPV#WVJQTKV[
6'5 CU YGNN CU VJG 0CVKQPCN .CDQT 4GNCVKQPU %QOOKUUKQP0.4% YJGTG &1.' GZGTEKUGU CFOKPKUVTCVKXG LWTKUFKEVKQP 4#
OCPFCVGF VJG ETGCVKQP QH VJG 1HEG QH VJG 7PFGTUGETGVCT[
HQT /KITCPV 9QTMGTU #HHCKTU 17/9# KP VJG &GRCTVOGPV QH
(QTGKIP #HHCKTU &(# 17/9# YQTMU YKVJ %QPUWNCT #HHCKTU
CPF#UUKUVCPEGVQ0CVKQPCNU7PKVQHVJG&(#KPJCPFNKPIECUGUQH
OKITCPV(KNKRKPQU6JG[CTGCUUKUVGFCDTQCFD[UQOGGODCUUKGU
CPF EQPUWNCVGU CETQUU VJG INQDG 6JG %QOOKUUKQP QP (KNKRKPQU
1XGTUGCUQPVJGQVJGTJCPFKUOCPFCVGFVQNQQMCHVGTVJGTKIJVUCPF
YGNHCTGQH(KNKRKPQKOOKITCPVUCPFRGTOCPGPVTGUKFGPVU
&GURKVG VJG RTQPQWPEGF CFJGTGPEG CPF EQOOKVOGPV VQ
KPVGTPCVKQPCNCPF PCVKQPCNJWOCP TKIJVU CPF NCDQT TKIJVU NCYUCPF
VJG HQTOCVKQP QH OKITCVKQP KPUVKVWVKQPU VJG IQXGTPOGPV TGOCKPU
YCPVKPIKPVGTOUQHGHHGEVKXGN[RTQOQVKPIVJGTKIJVUCPFYGNHCTGQH
VJG1(9UCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
26/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
2TQDNGOU%QPHTQPVKPI1(9UCV
VJG&KHHGTGPV5VCIGUQH/KITCVKQP
2TKPEKRCNUWDLGEVUQHEQPEGTPUWIIGUVKQPUCPFTGEQOOGPFCVKQPU
6JG%QOOKVVGGPQVGUYKVJKPVGTGUVVJGOWNVKVWFGQHKPKVKCVKXGU
CPFRTQITCOUWPFGTVCMGPD[VJG5VCVGRCTV[KPTGURQPUGVQ
EJCNNGPIGUHCEGFKPKVUNCDQTOKITCVKQPRQNKE[#VVJGUCOG
VKOG VJG %QOOKVVGG KU EQPEGTPGF VJCV KORNGOGPVCVKQP
HQNNQYWRCPFGXCNWCVKQPQHVJGUGRTQITCOUCTGKPUWHEKGPV
6JG%QOOKVVGGTGEQOOGPFURTQRGTHQNNQYWRRTQEGFWTGUCUYGNN CU ENGCTOGCUWTCDNGCPF VKOGDQWPF VCTIGVU KP
QTFGTVQHCEKNKVCVGVTCEMKPIVJGKTKORNGOGPVCVKQP
6JG %QOOKVVGG YGNEQOGU VJG KPHQTOCVKQP IKXGP D[ VJG
5VCVGRCTV[UFGNGICVKQPQPVJGNCDQTOKITCVKQPRQNKE[CPF
KP RCTVKEWNCT KVU GHHQTVU VQ GPUWTG VJCV (KNKRKPQ OKITCPV
YQTMGTU CTG QPN[ FGRNQ[GF VQ EQWPVTKGU YJGTG VJGKT TKIJVUCTG TGURGEVGF *QYGXGT VJG %QOOKVVGG KU EQPEGTPGF VJCV
5VCVG RCTV[U RQNKEKGU GURGEKCNN[ VJTQWIJ #FOKPKUVTCVKXG
1TFGT0QUCPFCPFTGURGEVKXGN[YQWNF
UGGOVQDGCKOGFCVVJGRTQOQVKQPQHHQTGKIPGORNQ[OGPV
QHOKITCPVYQTMGTU
6JG%QOOKVVGGTGEQOOGPFUVJCVVJG5VCVGRCTV[TGXKGY
KVU NCDQT OKITCVKQP RQNKE[ KP QTFGT VQ IKXG RTKOCT[
KORQTVCPEGVQJWOCPTKIJVUQHOKITCPVYQTMGTUKPNKPG
YKVJVJG5VCVGRCTV[UQYPRTQHGUUGFIQCNCUUGVQWVKP4#
6JG CDQXG RCTCITCRJU CTG GZEGTRVU HTQO VJG %QPENWFKPI
1DUGTXCVKQPUQPVJG2JKNKRRKPGUD[VJG%QOOKVVGGQPVJG2TQVGEVKQP
QHVJG4KIJVUQH#NN/KITCPV9QTMGTUCPFOGODGTUQHVJGKTHCOKNKGU
VJ5GUUKQPJGNFQP#RTKN/C[6JGUGVYQRTKPEKRCN
EQPEGTPUQHVJG70%QOOKVVGGECRVWTGVJGHWPFCOGPVCNCYUQHVJG
2JKNKRRKPGNCDQTGZRQTVRTQITCO
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
27/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
5VCIGUQH2JKNKRRKPG/KITCVKQP
C2TGFGRCTVWTGUVCIG
6JG RTGFGRCTVWTG UVCIG KU EJCTCEVGTK\GF D[ VJG QXGTUGCU(KNKRKPQYQTMGTUCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGUUGVVNKPIVJGSWGUVKQPQHFGEKFKPI
YJGVJGTVQIQCDTQCFQTPQVEQOKPIVQVGTOUYKVJQPGUGNHCPFVJG
HCOKN[GURGEKCNN[KPCPVKEKRCVKQPQHDGKPIRJ[UKECNN[UGRCTCVGFHTQO
GCEJQVJGT6JGRTGFGRCTVWTGUVCIGCNUQKPENWFGUVJGTGETWKVOGPVQT
CRRNKECVKQPRTQEGUUVJGEQORNGVKQPQHRCRGTUCPFQVJGTFQEWOGPVU
CPFQVJGTRTGTGSWKUKVGUCPFRTGRCTCVKQPURTKQTVQFGRCTVKPIHQTYQTM
CDTQCF
5VCTVKPI CV VJG RTGFGRCTVWTG UVCIG CRRNKECPVU WUWCNN[ HCNN
RTG[VQKNNGICNTGETWKVGTURC[GZQTDKVCPVHGGUVQNGICNTGETWKVGTUCPF
DGEQOG XKEVKOU QH OKUKPHQTOCVKQP QT FGEGRVKQP 'ZQTDKVCPV HGGU
NGCFVQKPFGDVGFPGUUQHVJGRTQURGEVKXGOKITCPVUCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU
(TQO,CPWCT[VQ5GRVGODGTKNNGICNTGETWKVOGPVECUGUYGPVWRD[VQEQORCTGFVQVJGTGEQTFGFHQTVJG
UCOGPKPGOQPVJRGTKQFKP&GURKVGVJGUGUVCVKUVKEUKVOWUVDG
PQVGFVJCVCUKIPKECPVPWODGTQHCDWUGF(KNKRKPQUCPFVJQUGYJQUG
JWOCPTKIJVUCTGXKQNCVGFFQPQVTGRQTVVJGKTECUGUQTNGEQORNCKPVU
HQTHGCTQHNQUKPIVJGKTLQDUCDTQCFYJKEJVQVJGKTOKPFUEQWNFDG
VJGDKVVGTRKNNVQUYCNNQY
D2QUVFGRCTVWTGCPFQPUKVGUVCIG
2QUVFGRCTVWTG DGIKPU HTQO VJG VKOG VJG 1(9U TKFG VJG
RNCPGQTUJKRVJCVYQWNFDTKPIVJGOCETQUUPCVKQPCNDQTFGTU6JG
1(9UIQDG[QPFVJGCTGCQHLWTKUFKEVKQPQH2JKNKRRKPGNCYUYJGTG
KPVGTPCVKQPCN NCYU CPF UVCPFCTFU CRRN[ CPF VJG TGURQPUKDKNKV[ QH
UGPFKPI IQXGTPOGPVU VQGPUWTG VJGKTTKIJVU CTG RTQVGEVGF CESWKTGU
WVOQUVKORQTVCPEG
6JKU UVCIG KU EJCTCEVGTK\GF D[ VJG 1(9U CTTKXCN KP VJG
EQWPVT[ QH FGUVKPCVKQP VJGKT TUV GPEQWPVGTU YKVJ VJG FGUVKPCVKQP
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
28/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
EQWPVT[ CPF UQEKGV[ OGGVKPI CPF IGVVKPI VQ MPQY VJG GORNQ[GT
YQTMRNCEGCPFQVJGTEQYQTMGTUCPFNKXKPIKPCPGYRNCEG+VCNUQ
KPENWFGUVJGCFLWUVOGPVRTQEGUUCPFGZRGTKGPEGVJCVVJG1(9UIQ
VJTQWIJ
6JKU UVCIG NCUVU CP[YJGTG HTQO C HGY FC[U VQ CU NQPI CU
OQTG VJCP [GCTU 6JG NGPIVJ QH VJKU UVCIG XCTKGU CEEQTFKPI VQ
VJGYQTMGTUYQTMCPFNKXKPIEQPFKVKQPUVJGUQEKCNPGVYQTMUVJG[
FGXGNQR QXGT VKOG CPF VJG FGITGG QH GEQPQOKE TGNKCPEG D[ VJGKT
HCOKNKGU QP TGOKVVCPEGU &WTKPI VJGKT UVC[ CDTQCF 1(9U UGPF
TGOKVVCPEGU VQ VJGKT HCOKNKGU VQ EQXGT VJGKT FCKN[ UWDUKUVGPEG RC[
HQTVJGGFWECVKQPQHVJGEJKNFTGPWUWCNN[KPRTKXCVGUEJQQNURC[HQTJQWUKPICPFQVJGTWVKNKVKGUCPFGZRGPUGU
#V VJKU UVCIG 1(9U OC[ GPEQWPVGT RTQDNGOU KUUWGU
CPF EQPEGTPU RGTVKPGPV VQ VJGKT YQTM RJ[UKECN JGCNVJ EWNVWTCN
CFLWUVOGPVU CPF HCOKNKGU KP VJG 2JKNKRRKPGU 6JG OCUU OGFKC
JCXG GZVGPUKXGN[ EQXGTGF UVQTKGU QH 1(9U YJQ CTG OKUKPHQTOGF
CPF CDWUGF D[ TGETWKVGTU CPF GORNQ[GTU YJQ DGEQOG KNN DWV FQPQV TGEGKXG OGFKECN ECTG YJQ CTG KNNGICNN[ VGTOKPCVGF CPF YJQ
CTG TQWPFGF WR CPF FGRQTVGF 2GTUKUVKPI RTQDNGOU NKMG EQPVTCEV
UWDUVKVWVKQPKPJWOCPNKXKPICPFYQTMKPIEQPFKVKQPUTGOCKPCUYGNN
CU IGPFGTDCUGF XKQNGPEG OGPVCN KNNPGUUGU CPF GXGP UWURKEKQWU
FGCVJU
6JGINQDCNETKUKUPCPEKCNCPFQVJGTYKUGTGUWNVUVQUGXGTG
CPZKGVKGUCPFKPUGEWTKVKGUCOQPIOKITCPVUCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU
E4GVWTPCPF4GKPVGITCVKQPUVCIG
6JKUTGHGTUVQVJGRGTKQFYJGP1(9UTGVWTPJQOGVQUVC[HQT
IQQFYQTMQTTGVKTGCPFTGKPVGITCVGYKVJVJGKTHCOKN[EQOOWPKV[
CPF2JKNKRRKPGUQEKGV[/QUV1(9UJQYGXGTTGPGYVJGKTEQPVTCEVU
QTPFCPQVJGTLQDCDTQCFHQTCUNQPICURQUUKDNGCPFYQTMVJGTG
HQTWRVQCUNQPICU[GCTUTGVWTPKPIJQOGQPN[HQTTGIWNCT
XCECVKQPU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
29/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
6JG TGVWTP QH VJG 1(9 VQ VJG EQWPVT[ OC[ UQOGVKOGU
DG WPVKOGN[ CPF WPRNCPPGF 'ZCORNGU QH VJGUG CTG VJQUG YJQ
YGTG HQTEGF VQ TGVWTP JQOG FWG VQ VJG VUWPCOK KP ,CRCP CPF VJG
FGOQETCVKEWRTKUKPIUVJCVGTWRVGFCPFURTGCFCETQUUVJG/KFFNG'CUV
CPF0QTVJ#HTKEC/'0#TGIKQPKPQVJGTYKUGMPQYPCUVJG#TCD5RTKPI1(9UYGTGHQTEGFVQGGVJGFCPIGT\QPGUCPFTGVWTP
JQOGPQVRTGRCTGFCPFWPUWTGQHYJCVCYCKVUVJGODCEMJQOG
6JKU UVCIG NKMGYKUG ECTTKGU YKVJ KV RTQDNGOU HQT TGVWTPKPI
OKITCPVUTGRCVTKCVKQPRTQDNGOUUVKIOCHTQOVTCWOCVKEGZRGTKGPEGU
YJKNGYQTMKPICDTQCFCPFCDCPFQPOGPVD[QVJGTHCOKN[OGODGTU
4GVWTPGFOKITCPVUPFKVFKHEWNVVQUVC[CPFOCMGCNKXKPIKPVJGEQWPVT[ FWG VQ VJG NCEM QH QT KPCFGSWCVG UWRRQTV OGEJCPKUO HQT
TGKPVGITCVKQP
6JG5QEKCN%QUVQH/KITCVKQP
/KITCPVU CPF VJGKT HCOKNKGU RC[ VJG RU[EJQUQEKCN EQUV QH
QXGTUGCUOKITCVKQP9JKNGTGOKVVCPEGUDTKPIOCVGTKCNCPFGEQPQOKEDGPGVU VQ QVJGT HCOKN[ OGODGTU OKITCPV HCOKNKGU WRQP TGVWTP
JCXGVQEQPVGPFYKVJFKHHGTGPVCPFEJCPIKPIHCOKN[F[PCOKEUTQNGU
CPF GZRGEVCVKQPU 6JG[ ECPPQV CWVQOCVKECNN[ TGCUUWOG VJG TQNGU
CPFTGNCVKQPUJKRUVJG[QPEGJCFYKVJVJGKTURQWUGUCPFQTEJKNFTGP
#VVKVWFGUUWEJCUOCVGTKCNKUOEQPUWOGTKUOCPFEQNQPKCNOGPVCNKV[
JCXG CNUQ DGGP PQVGF KP OKITCPV HCOKNKGU GURGEKCNN[ COQPI
EJKNFTGP
$TCKP&TCKP
$TCKPFTCKPFQGUPQVQPN[TGHGTVQRTQHGUUKQPCNUYJQOKITCVG
CPF RTCEVKEG VJGKT RTQHGUUKQP 9G UJQWNF CEMPQYNGFIG CNN 1(9U
YJQ DTKPI VJGKT UMKNNU YKVJ VJGO EQPUVTWEVKQP YQTMGTU FQOGUVKE
YQTMGTUCPFNQYUMKNNGFYQTMGTUCNNRTQXKFGXCNWCDNGYQTM
.CVGN[VJGGZQFWUQHRTQHGUUKQPCNUJCUDGEQOGCPCNCTOKPI
VTGPFVJCVECOGCVVJGQPUGVQHINQDCNK\CVKQP'EQPQOKEWPEGTVCKPVKGU
CVJQOGCPFVJGIQXGTPOGPVUGZVGPUKXGRTQOQVKQPQHNCDQTGZRQTV
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
30/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
HWTVJGT RWUJ JKIJN[UMKNNGF (KNKRKPQ RTQHGUUKQPCNU VQ UGGM C DGVVGT
NKHGCDTQCF
/QTGVJCPPWTUGUJCXGNGHVVJGEQWPVT[DGVYGGP
CPF 6JG EQWPVT[ NQUGU OQTG VJCP PWTUGU CPPWCNN[OQTGVJCPCP[QVJGTEQWPVT[5QOGOGFKECNFQEVQTUGPTQNNGF
KPPWTUKPIUEJQQNUKPKPVGPFKPIVQIGVLQDUCDTQCFCUPWTUGU
5JQTVCIGQHFQEVQTUCPFPWTUGUJCURCTVN[ECWUGFVJGENQUWTGQHQXGT
JQURKVCNU CTQWPF VJG EQWPVT[ 0WTUGVQRCVKGPV TCVKQ KP OCP[
JQURKVCNUPQYUVCPFUCVCPWPUWUVCKPCDNG+PGHHGEVVJKUJCU
EQORTQOKUGFVJGEQWPVT[UJGCNVJU[UVGOENQUKPIUQOGJQURKVCNU
CPFOGFKECNUEJQQNU
6JQWUCPFUQHUEJQQNVGCEJGTUJCXGNGHVVJGEQWPVT[VQYQTM
CUECTGIKXGTUQTFQOGUVKEYQTMGTU$GVVGTVTCKPGFVGCEJGTUOCPCIGVQ
RTCEVKEGVJGKTVTCFGKPJKIJRC[KPIUEJQQNUCPFWPKXGTUKVKGUCDTQCF
VGCEJKPIURGEKCNK\GFCTGCUNKMG/CVJGOCVKEU5EKGPEG'PINKUJCPF
5RGEKCN'FWECVKQP6JKUEQORTQOKUGUVJGGFWECVKQPQHEWTTGPVCPF
HWVWTGIGPGTCVKQPKPVJG2JKNKRRKPGU6JGVGCEJGTVQUVWFGPVTCVKQKPRWDNKEGNGOGPVCT[CPFJKIJUEJQQNUPQYUVCPFUCVCPWPOCPCIGCDNG
+PQWTVQRVJTGGWPKXGTUKVKGUYJKEJWUGFVQXKGHQTVJGVQR
URQVUCOQPI#UKCPCECFGOKEKPUVKVWVKQPUUNKRRGFVQ0Q0Q
CPF0Q
(QTGKIP CKTNKPGEQORCPKGU JCXG GPVKEGF (KNKRKPQ RKNQVUCPF
CKTETCHV OGEJCPKEU VQ YQTM CDTQCF 6JG PWODGT QH EQOOGTEKCN
RKNQVUNGHVKPVJGEQWPVT[JCUFTQRRGFVQHTQO#KTETCHV
OGEJCPKEUPQYPWODGTQPN[HTQOCJKIJQH5GCUQPGF
YGCVJGTHQTGECUVGTUJCXGCNUQNGHVVJGEQWPVT[VQFQVJGUCOGLQDU
QXGTUGCU DWV YKVJOWEJJKIJGT YCIGU #UGEQPQOKE WPEGTVCKPVKGU
KPVJGEQWPVT[EQPVKPWGJWPFTGFUOQTGQHQWTCKTVTCHEEQPVTQNNGTU
TCFKQHTGSWGPE[GPIKPGGTUNKPGOGPTUVOCVGUCPFRNCPVGPIKPGGTU
YKNNUWTGN[NQQMHQTDGVVGTRC[KPILQDUCDTQCF
/QTG TGEGPVN[ VJG 2JKNKRRKPGU JCU DGGP TGFKTGEVKPI VJG
EQORQUKVKQPQH1(9UVQYCTFUQVJGTJKIJN[UMKNNGFCPFDGVVGTRC[KPI
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
31/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
RTQHGUUKQPU NKMG KPHQTOCVKQP CPF VGEJPQNQI[ YQTMGTU RTQFWEVKQP
VGEJPKEKCPU CPF OGEJCPKECN CPF GNGEVTKECN GPIKPGGTU +V KU CNUQ
NWTKPIGPIKPGGTUVQTGVTCKPKPVQOCTKVKOGGPIKPGGTUVJCVCTGJKIJN[KP
FGOCPFKPVJGUGCHCTKPIOCTMGV
9JKNGVJKUYQWNFDGVVGTGPUWTGVJGKPWZQHVJGOWEJXCNWGF
TGOKVVCPEGUHWTVJGTDTCKPFTCKPNQQOU
6JG DTCKPFTCKP FQGU PQV FTCKP VJG EQWPVT[ QH KVU GZEGUU
NCDQTKVFTCKPUKVQHETKVKECNJWOCPRQYGT9JCVYGICKPKPFQNNCTU
YGNQUGKPXCNWCDNGJWOCPCPFKPVGNNGEVWCNTGUQWTEGU
5JQWNFVJKUVTGPFEQPVKPWGVJGEQWPVT[YKNNKPVKOGUGGVJG
EQNNCRUGQHKVUJGCNVJGFWECVKQPCPFVGNGEQOOWPKECVKQPUUGEVQTUCPF
QHKVUFQOGUVKEUJKRRKPIRGVTQEJGOKECNUVGGNRQYGTCEEQWPVKPI
CPFCXKCVKQPKPFWUVTKGU
6JG0KVCSCV5[UVGOCPFVJG1(9UKP5CWFK#TCDKC
4GURQPFKPI VQ FQOGUVKE RTGUUWTGU FWG VQ TKUKPI
WPGORNQ[OGPVTCVGGURGEKCNN[COQPIVJG[QWVJVJG5CWFK/KPKUVT[
QH.CDQTCPPQWPEGFVJCVKVYKNNUVCTVKORNGOGPVKPIVJG0KVCSCVQT
4CPIGCRTQITCOFGUKIPGFD[VJG5CWFK/KPKUVT[QH.CDQTVQDQQUV
PCVKQPCNK\CVKQPQHLQDUKPVJGRTKXCVGUGEVQT6JKUFKTGEVKPVGTXGPVKQP
KPKVKCVKXGCKOUVQFGNKXGTSWKEMTGUWNVUCPFIKXG5CWFKPCVKQPCNUC
DGVVGTUVCPFKPVJGNCDQTOCTMGV
6QIWKFGVJGYQTMGTUCPFVJGRWDNKECVNCTIGQPVJGUVCVWUQH
VJGRTKXCVGEQORCPKGUXKUCXKUPKVCSCVVJG/KPKUVT[ECOGWRYKVJ
ECVGIQTKGU QT 4CPIGU C )TC[ TCPIG HQT EQORCPKGU VJCV JCXG
GZEGNNGPVPCVKQPCNK\CVKQPKORNGOGPVCVKQPD)TGGPHQTVJQUGYKVJ
IQQFKORNGOGPVCVKQPE;GNNQYHQTDGNQYCXGTCIGKORNGOGPVCVKQP
CPFF4GFHQTRQQTKORNGOGPVCVKQP
&QOGUVKEYQTMGTUCPFRTKXCVGEQORCPKGUVJCVGORNQ[QT
NGUUYQTMGTUCTGPQVEQXGTGFD[VJG0KVCSCVRTQITCO
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
32/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
&GRGPFKPI QP VJG TCVG QH RQUKVKXG EQORNKCPEG D[ VJG
EQORCPKGUVJG[YKNNDGUWDLGEVVQGKVJGTTGYCTFUCPFKPEGPVKXGUQT
UCPEVKQPUCPFTGXQECVKQPQHRGTOKVUCUVJGECUGOC[DG
6JG0KVCSCVKORNGOGPVCVKQPKURJCUGFCUHQNNQYU
2JCUG,WPG#NNRTKXCVGEQORCPKGUCTGVQWRFCVGVJGKT
GORNQ[GGUKPHQTOCVKQPKPQTFGTVQFGVGTOKPGVJGKTPCVKQPCNK\CVKQP
SWQVC
2JCUG5GRVGODGT5VCTVQH0KVCSCVKORNGOGPVCVKQP
5GTXKEGUCPF+PEGPVKXGUCTGRTQXKFGFVQEQORCPKGUKPITC[CPFITGGPTCPIGYJKNGEQORCPKGUKP[GNNQYCPFTGFTCPIGUHCEGUWURGPUKQP
2JCUG0QXGODGTYQTMGTUKPEQORCPKGUKPVJGTGF
TCPIGUJQWNFUVTKXGVQVTCPUHGTVQEQORCPKGUKPITC[QTITGGPTCPIG
UCPUVJGEQPUGPVQHVJGGORNQ[GTHCKNWTGVQFQUQYKNNTGUWNVVQPQP
TGPGYCNQHYQTMRGTOKVWRQPGZRKTCVKQP
2JCUG (GDTWCT[ 9QTMGTU KP EQORCPKGU WPFGT
[GNNQYTCPIGUJQWNFOQXGVQEQORCPKGUKPITC[QTITGGPTCPIGUQT
GNUGTGPGYCNQHVJGKTYQTMRGTOKVHQTVJQUGYQTMKPIHQT[GCTUQT
NGUUYKNNDGEQPFKVKQPCN
6JG KORNGOGPVCVKQP QH VJG 0KVCSCV RTQITCO YKNN EGTVCKPN[
KORCEV QP 1(9U KP VJG RTQHGUUKQPCN JKIJUMKNNGF CPF GXGP NQY
UMKNNGFYQTMECVGIQTKGU6JG[HCEGVJGTKUMQHNQUKPIVJGKTLQDUVQ
IKXG YC[ VQ NQECN YQTMGTU 9JKNG VJG -KPIFQO QH 5CWFK #TCDKC
-5#YKNNEGTVCKPN[PQVUVQRVJGFGOCPFHQTHQTGKIPYQTMGTUVJG
0KVCSCVRTQITCOEGTVCKPN[ECWUGULQDKPUGEWTKVKGUCPFWPEGTVCKPVKGU
VQCNQVQH1(9U6JKUKPVWTPKORCEVUQPVJGQXGTCNNNCDQTOKITCVKQP
QYUHTQOVJG2JKNKRRKPGUVQVJG-KPIFQO
6JG-KPIFQOQH5CWFK#TCDKCKUJQOGVQOQTGVJCPCOKNNKQP
QXGTUGCU(KNKRKPQYQTMGTU(QTCNOQUVHQWTFGECFGUQH(KNKRKPQNCDQT
OKITCVKQP-5#JCUTGOCKPGFVJGVQRFGUVKPCVKQPQH1(9U+VCNUQ
TCPMUHQWTVJCUFGUVKPCVKQPQHYQOGPFQOGUVKEYQTMGTU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
33/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
6CDNG1XGTUGCU(KNKRKPQUKPVJG-KPIFQOQH5CWFK#TCDKC
3DUWLFXODUV 2YHUDOO5DQNLQJ)LJXUHV
(VWLPDWHGQXPEHUDQGSHUFHQWDJHRI
DOOPLJUDQWZRUNHUVYLVjYLVWKHWRWDO
SRSXODWLRQ-XO\
0PLJUDQWVRIDOOQDWLRQDOLWLHVRU
RIWKHWRWDOSRSXODWLRQRI0>2):VFRPSULVHVHFRQG
VHPHVWHURI@
(VWLPDWHGQXPEHURI)LOLSLQRV
VHFRQGVHPHVWHU
)LOLSLQRVLQFOXGLQJ
XQGRFXPHQWHG)LOLSLQRV
UDQNVQGDIWHUWKH86
&RQVLVWHQWO\UDQNVUVWLQDQQXDOGHSOR\PHQWRIUHKLUHVDQGQHZKLUHV
RIGHSOR\PHQWWR0LGGOH(DVW
RIWRWDOODQGEDVHGGHSOR\PHQW
5DQNVUVWDPRQJFRXQWULHVLQWHUPV
RIQXPEHURIDQQXDOGHSOR\PHQW
5DQNVWKLQWRWDODQQXDOGHSOR\PHQW
RIGRPHVWLFZRUNHUVKRXVHKROGVHUYLFHZRUNHUV
5DQNVUVWLQWRWDODQQXDOGHSOR\PHQW
RIQXUVHV
ZLWK6LQJDSRUHDIDUQGDW
5DQNVQGLQWRWDODQQXDOGHSOR\PHQW
RIWHDFKHUVDIWHUWKH86
5DQNVUVWLQWRWDODQQXDOGHSOR\PHQWRI,7SURIHVVLRQDOV
3DUWLFXODUV 2YHUDOO7DQNLQJ)LJXUHV
5DQNVWKLQWRWDODQQXDOGHSOR\PHQW
RIFDUHJLYHUV
5DQNVQGIRUDIWHUWKH86
DQGUGDIWHUWKH86DQG&DQDGDLQLQDQQXDOUHPLWWDQFHV
UHPLWWDQFHRI86
'RPHVWLFZRUNHUVXQGHUWKH
MXULVGLFWLRQRIWKH3KLOLSSLQH
(PEDVV\LQ5L\DGK
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
34/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
6CDNG1(9UKP5CWFK#TCDKC#EEQTFKPIVQ9QTM%CVGIQTKGU
&DWHJRU\ 0DOH )HPDOH 7RWDO
3URIHVVLRQDOV(QJLQHHUVQXUVHVVRIWZDUH
GHYHORSHUVJHRORJLVWVVRLOH[SHUWVDUFKLWHFWVEDQNHUVSURIHVVRUVWHDFKHUVVFLHQWLVWVGRFWRUV
SKDUPDFLVWVRWKHU3URIHVVLRQDO5HJXODWLRQ
&RPPLVVLRQ35&OLFHQVHGLQGLYLGXDOV
+LJKO\6NLOOHG/DERUDWRU\WHFKQLFLDQVFRRNV
FKHIVDQGRWKHUFRQVWUXFWLRQUHODWHGZRUNIRUFH
VXFKDVFDUSHQWHUVZHOGHUVSDLQWHUVVWHHODQG
WLOH[HUVSODVWHUHUVSOXPEHUVSLSHWWHUV
HWF
6HPL6NLOOHG(OHFWULFPHFKDQLFDVVLVWDQWV
JODVVFXWWHUVDVVLVWDQWFRRNVZDLWHUVDQG
NLWFKHQKHOSHUVZDVKHUVZDVKHUVDQG
SUHVVPHQJDUGHQHUV
/DERUFOHDQHUVJXDUGVDQGZDWFKPHQ
FRQVWUXFWLRQZRUNHUVDQGRWKHUW\SHVRI
ODERUHUV
'RPHVWLF:RUNHUVQDQQLHVDQGKRXVHKROGKHOSHUV
8QNQRZQ8QFODVVLHG-HGGDK.6$
6RXUFH')$280:$5HSRUWWR&RQJUHVV-XO\'HFHPEHU
/KITCPVYQTMGTUCPFTKIJVUQTICPK\CVKQPU
/KITCPVYQTMGTUCPFTKIJVUQTICPK\CVKQPURNC[CUKIPKECPVTQNG KP RTQOQVKPI VJG TKIJVU CPF YGNHCTG QH OKITCPV YQTMGTU
6JG[JCXGEQPUKUVGPVN[NGFVJGOQXGOGPVHQTVJGTGEQIPKVKQPCPF
RTQVGEVKQPQHOKITCPVYQTMGTU6JGUGQTICPK\CVKQPURTQXKFGFKTGEV
CPFKOOGFKCVGCUUKUVCPEGVQFKUVTGUUGFOKITCPVYQTMGTUCPFVJGKT
HCOKNKGU
0QPIQXGTPOGPVCNQTICPK\CVKQPU0)1UDGICPCFFTGUUKPIVJG OWNVKHCEGVGF FKOGPUKQPU QH NCDQT QWVOKITCVKQP KP VJG GCTN[
U6JGUG0)1UYGTGHQTOGFKPTGURQPUGVQVJGKPETGCUKPIPGGF
HQTCUUKUVCPEGD[OKITCPVUCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU+PVGTXGPVKQPUXCT[CPF
EQXGT VJG FKHHGTGPV UVCIGU QH OKITCVKQP HTQO RTGFGRCTVWTG RQUV
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
35/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
FGRCTVWTG CPF QPUKVG CPF TGVWTP CPF TGKPVGITCVKQP 6JGUG KPENWFG
RTQXKUKQPU QH XCTKQWU UGTXKEGU VQ OKITCPVU JGCNVJ CPF OGFKECN
NGICNEQWPUGNKPINKXGNKJQQFCUUKUVCPEGCPFVJGNKMG
2TQITCOU HQT OKITCPVU CNUQ KPENWFG QTICPK\KPI UWRRQTV VQHCOKNKGUNGHVDGJKPFXCNWGUHQTOCVKQPKPHQTOCVKQPCPFGFWECVKQP
TGUGCTEJCPFCFXQECE[CPFNKXGNKJQQFHQTTGVWTPKPIOKITCPVU
/KITCPV ITQWRU CTG XCTKGF UQOG CTG HQEWUGF QP YQOGP
OKITCPVU QVJGTU HQEWU QP UGCDCUGF OKITCPVU UJGTHQNMU CPF
UGCHCTGTU UQOG EQPFWEV GFWECVKQP KPHQTOCVKQP CPF CFXQECE[
QVJGTU HQEWU QP NKXGNKJQQF CPF TGKPVGITCVKQP RTQITCOU KPENWFKPIHQTOCVKQPUQH UCXGTU ENWDU EQQRGTCVKXGU CPF OKITCPV UCXKPIU CPF
CNVGTPCVKXGKPXGUVOGPVITQWRU
.CDQT OKITCVKQP OGCPYJKNG KU PQV PGY VQ NQECN VTCFG
WPKQPU5GCHCTGTUJCXGVJGKTQYPVTCFGWPKQPUVJCVCTGRCTVQHVJG
+PVGTPCVKQPCN 6TCPURQTV 9QTMGTU (GFGTCVKQP +6( 6JG EJCNNGPIG
HQTVTCFGWPKQPUJQYGXGTKUVQFGXGNQRTGIWNCTUWRRQTVRTQITCOUCPFVQKPKVKCVGWPKQPQTICPK\KPICOQPINCPFDCUGFYQTMGTU6TCFG
WPKQPU CPF 0)1U JCXG NKMGYKUG UVCTVGF VQ EQOG VQIGVJGT KP +.1
CPFQT70DCUGFRNCVHQTOUCPFECORCKIPUHQT1(9TKIJVU
9KVJOKITCPVKUUWGUKPETGCUKPIVJTQWIJVJG[GCTUCPFCPPWCN
FGRNQ[OGPV VQRRKPI VJG QPG OKNNKQP OCTM VJG PGGF GOGTIGF VQ
EQPUQNKFCVGGHHQTVUQHOKITCPVITQWRUCPF0)1UCPFFGXGNQROQTG
GHHGEVKXGTGURQPUGURCTVKEWNCTN[KPVJGCTGCQHCFXQECE[6JKUTGUWNVGF
KPVJGHQTOCVKQPUQHOKITCPVCNNKCPEGUPGVYQTMUCPFEQCNKVKQPU
1(9 QTICPK\CVKQPU CPF HQTOCVKQPU CDQWPF KP OQUV QH VJG
TGIKQPU CPF EQPVKPGPVU QHFGUVKPCVKQP 6JG ITQWRU XCT[ KP PCVWTG
UEQRG IQCNU CPF QDLGEVKXGU QTKGPVCVKQP CPF EQORQUKVKQP 6JG[
KPENWFG HTCVGTPKVKGU RTQHGUUKQPCN CUUQEKCVKQPU GVJPQNKPIWKUVKE
QTICPK\CVKQPU HCKVJDCUGF CUUQEKCVKQPU NQECNTGIKQPCN ITQWRKPIU
UQEKQEKXKEITQWRUEWNVWTCNITQWRUCPFCNWOPKCUUQEKCVKQPU
5KOKNCTN[ VJGTG CTG ITQWRU VJCV CTG UGTXKEGQTKGPVGF CPF
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
36/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
YJQUGRTQITCOUCTGCKOGFCVGZVGPFKPIQTHCEKNKVCVKPICUUKUVCPEGVQ
1(9UKPPGGFITQWRUVJCVCFXQECVGHQTRQNKE[TGHQTOUKPDQVJVJG
JQOGCPFJQUVEQWPVTKGUCPFRJKNCPVJTQRKEJWOCPKVCTKCPHQTOCVKQPU
VJCV TCKUG HWPFU CPF QVJGT TGUQWTEGU VQ TGURQPF VQ FKUCUVGTU CPF
ECNCOKVKGUCPFRQXGTV[KPVJG2JKNKRRKPGU
1VJGTHQTOCVKQPUCNUQKPENWFGRQNKVKECNRCTVKGUQH1(9UCPF
QXGTUGCU (KNKRKPQU YJKEJ YKNN XKG HQT %QPITGUUKQPCN UGCVU KP VJG
2JKNKRRKPG%QPITGUUWPFGTVJG2CTV[.KUV.CY
4KIJVVQ2CTVKEKRCVGKP)QXGTPOGPVCN'PVKVKGUCPF2TQEGUUGU
6JG 2JKNKRRKPG %QPUVKVWVKQP EKVGF VJG KORQTVCPEG QH
EKXKN UQEKGV[ QTICPK\CVKQPU KP PCVKQPDWKNFKPI +V GPEQWTCIGU VJG
HQTOCVKQP QH EKXKN UQEKGV[ QTICPK\CVKQPU 0)1U CPF EQOOWPKV[
DCUGF QT UGEVQTCN QTICPK\CVKQPU VJCV RTQOQVG VJG YGNHCTG QH VJG
PCVKQP+VFGNKPGCVGUVJG TQNGUCPF TKIJVU QH RGQRNGUQTICPK\CVKQPU
CPFVJGTKIJVUQHVJGRGQRNGCPFVJGKTQTICPK\CVKQPUVQGHHGEVKXGCPF
TGCUQPCDNGRCTVKEKRCVKQPCVCNNNGXGNUQHUQEKCNRQNKVKECNCPFGEQPQOKEFGEKUKQPOCMKPI
+PCFFKVKQPVJG5VCVGUJCNND[NCYHCEKNKVCVGVJGGUVCDNKUJOGPV
QHCFGSWCVGEQPUWNVCVKXGOGEJCPKUOCPFVJGRTQFWEVKXGRCTVPGTUJKR
DGVYGGPEKXKNUQEKGV[QTICPK\CVKQPUCPFIQXGTPOGPVKPVJGRTQVGEVKQP
QH1(9UCPFVJGRTQOQVKQPQHVJGKTYGNHCTG
#P GZCORNG QH C OWNVKUVCMGJQNFGT RCTVPGTUJKR KU VJG
%QPUWNVCVKXG%QWPEKNQP1(9U%%1(9EQORQUGFQHJGCFUQT
TGRTGUGPVCVKXGU QH TGNGXCPV IQXGTPOGPV QTICPK\CVKQPU )1 CPF
OKITCPV0)1UCPFRGQRNGUQTICPK\CVKQPU)10)1EQQRGTCVKQPKU
CNUQOCPKHGUVGFKPQVJGTOWNVKNCVGTCNCPFDKNCVGTCNRCTVPGTUJKRUUWEJ
CUVJGOWNVKCIGPE[CPVKVTCHEMKPIRTQLGEVHWPFGFD[VJG+.1
)QXGTPOGPVNKMGYKUGUGGMU0)1UWRRQTVHQTKPHQTOCVKQP
FKUUGOKPCVKQP 5QOG 0)1U IKXG 2TG&GRCTVWTG 1TKGPVCVKQP
5GOKPCTU2&15CPFCTGGPEQWTCIGFVQEQPFWEV2TG'ORNQ[OGPV
1TKGPVCVKQP5GOKPCTU2'15+PVJG2JKNKRRKPGU0)1UKPENWFKPI
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
37/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
QPUKVGQTICPK\CVKQPUNKMGKP5CWFK#TCDKCEQQTFKPCVGYKVJTGNGXCPV
CIGPEKGU VQ CFFTGUU URGEKE ECUGU QH FKUVTGUUGF 1(9U 4GIWNCT
FKCNQIWGUCPFTQWPFVCDNGFKUEWUUKQPUCTGCNUQJGNFYKVJIQXGTPOGPV
CIGPEKGU
4KIJVVQ8QVG
6JG %QPUVKVWVKQP IWCTCPVGGU VJG TKIJV QH UWHHTCIG VQ
CNNEKVK\GPUQHVJG2JKNKRRKPGUPQVQVJGTYKUGFKUSWCNKGFD[NCY
%QIPK\CPVQHVJGITQYKPIRJGPQOGPQPQHNCDQTOKITCVKQPKVHWTVJGT
UVCVGUVJCV%QPITGUUUJCNNRTQXKFGCU[UVGOHQTUGEWTKPIVJGUGETGE[
CPFUCPEVKV[QHVJGDCNNQVCUYGNNCUU[UVGOHQTCDUGPVGGXQVKPID[SWCNKGF(KNKRKPQUCDTQCF
6JG 2JKNKRRKPG %QPITGUU CHVGT [GCTU QH NQDD[ YQTM
RCUUGF4GRWDNKE#EV4#QT6JG1XGTUGCU#DUGPVGG8QVKPI
#EVQH6JGNCYITCPVGFDCEMVJGTKIJVQHUWHHTCIGVQSWCNKGF
QXGTUGCU (KNKRKPQU +V CKOGF VQ GPHTCPEJKUG CNN SWCNKGF (KNKRKPQU
CDTQCF
6JGNCYFGENCTGFVJCV6JGTKIJVQH(KNKRKPQOKITCPVYQTMGTU
CPFCNNQXGTUGCU(KNKRKPQUVQRCTVKEKRCVGKPVJGFGOQETCVKEFGEKUKQP
OCMKPIRTQEGUUGUQHVJG5VCVGCPFVQDGTGRTGUGPVGFKPKPUVKVWVKQPU
TGNGXCPVVQQXGTUGCUGORNQ[OGPVKUTGEQIPK\GFCPFIWCTCPVGGF
4# GORQYGTU 1(9U CPF QVJGT QXGTUGCU (KNKRKPQU
CDTQCFVQVCMGRCTVKPPCVKQPCNGNGEVKQPUCPFEJQQUGVJGKT2TGUKFGPV
8KEG2TGUKFGPV5GPCVQTUCPFRCTV[NKUV4GRTGUGPVCVKXGUYJQUJCRG
CPF KORNGOGPV NCYURQNKEKGURTQITCOUCPF UGTXKEGUVJCVFKTGEVN[
CHHGEVVJGO
%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[U2QUKVKQPQP1XGTUGCU/KITCVKQP
2JKNKRRKPGQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPDGPGVUDQVJ1(9UCPFVJGKT
HCOKNKGUCPFVJG2JKNKRRKPGU$WVVJGUQEKCNGEQPQOKERQNKVKECNCPF
KPFKXKFWCNEQUVUQHQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPQWVYGKIJKVUDGPGVU
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
38/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
#NOQUV HQTV[ [GCTU QH OKITCVKQP JCU TGUWNVGF KP OQTG CPFOQTG (KNKRKPQU HQTEGF VQ YQTM CDTQCF DTCXKPI WPEGTVCKPVKGU CPF
UWHHGTKPINKHGVJTGCVGPKPIEQPFKVKQPUKPVJGFGUVKPCVKQPEQWPVTKGUCPF
TGIKQPU2QNKEKGUVJCVGCUGTWNGUQPNCDQTFGRNQ[OGPVGPEQWTCIGVJG
FGRNQ[OGPVQH1(9U
2JKNKRRKPGQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPRQNKE[JCUHCKNGFVQUQNXGVJG
EQWPVT[UWPGORNQ[OGPVRTQDNGO#UCVGORQTCT[UQNWVKQPKVJCU
DGEQOGCRGTOCPGPVHGCVWTGQHVJGEQWPVT[UGEQPQO[+VJCUPQV
DGGPCPGHHGEVKXGUVTCVGI[HQTLQDIGPGTCVKQPCUUJQYPD[VJGITGCVGT
RTQRQTVKQPQHTGJKTGU
7PNGUU VJG IQXGTPOGPV KU CDNG VQ UJQY ENGCT UKIPU QH
TGXGTUKPIVJGOKITCVKQPQYUKPHCXQTQHFGEGPVLQDQRVKQPUKPVJG
EQWPVT[ OQUV QH IQXGTPOGPVU GHHQTVU RTQITCOU CPF RQNKEKGU VQ
IWCTCPVGGSWCNKV[UGTXKEGCPFRTQVGEVKQPVQ1(9UCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU
YKNNTGOCKPKPCFGSWCVGCPFYCPVKPI
9G DGNKGXG VJCV ETKVKECN VQ VJG RCVJ VQ VTWG CPF JWOCPGFGXGNQROGPVCTGIQXGTPOGPVRQNKEKGUVJCVYKNN
RTQOQVGCXKDTCPVCPFKPFGRGPFGPVNQECNGEQPQO[
ETGCVGFGEGPVYGNNRCKFCPFUGEWTGNQECNGORNQ[OGPV
RTQOQVGVJGRTQVGEVKQPQHJWOCPTKIJVUQHOKITCPVYQTMGTU
CPFOGODGTUQHVJGKTHCOKNKGUCPF
RTQOQVGVJGGZGTEKUGQHRQNKVKECNYKNNVQGTCFKECVGITCHVCPF
EQTTWRVKQPCPFCFXCPEGIQQFIQXGTPCPEG
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
39/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
4GEQOOGPFCVKQPU
)WKFGFD[CTKIJVUDCUGFHTCOGYQTMVJG%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV
#FXQECE[YKNNEQPVKPWGVQCFXQECVGHQTVJGTKIJVUCPFYGNNDGKPI
QH VJG (KNKRKPQ OKITCPVU CPF VJGKT HCOKNKGU %/# ECNNU QP VJG)QXGTPOGPVVQ
&GXGNQR VJG NQECN GEQPQO[ VQ RTQFWEG FGEGPV CPF UGEWTG
LQDU4GUQWTEGUIGPGTCVGFD[QXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPUJQWNFDG
RCTV QH VJG PCVKQPCN FGXGNQROGPV RTQITCO VQ FGXGNQR VJG
NQECNGEQPQO[
#FQRVCUVTCVGIKETGKPVGITCVKQPRTQITCOVJCVYKNNEQORNGOGPV
VJG UVTGPIVJU QH VJG FQOGUVKE GEQPQO[ CPF CWIOGPV VJG
NKOKVCVKQPUQHVJGFQOGUVKEYQTMHQTEG
#FQRV ENGCT OGCUWTCDNG CPF FQCDNG FGXGNQROGPV VCTIGVU
QPQXGTUGCUOKITCVKQPHQTEQORTGJGPUKXGOQPKVQTKPIQHVJG
JWOCPTKIJVUUKVWCVKQPUQEKCNRTQVGEVKQPOGCUWTGUVJGYGNN
DGKPICPFSWCNKV[QHNKHGQH1(9UCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGUEQPUKUVGPV
YKVJKPVGTPCVKQPCNFGXGNQROGPVIQCNU+PNKPGYKVJVJKUVJG
IQXGTPOGPVKPEQQRGTCVKQPYKVJEKXKNUQEKGV[OWUVUGVENGCT
VKOGDQWPF DGPEJOCTMU VJCV ECP OGCUWTG RGTHQTOCPEG
RTQITGUUCPFCEEQORNKUJOGPVQHVJGIQXGTPOGPV
&GXGNQR CPF CFQRV PGY RQNKEKGU VQYCTFUUQEKCN RTQVGEVKQP
CPFRTQOQVKQPQHVJGTKIJVUQHOKITCPVUCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU2QNKEKGUUJQWNFDGVTCPUNCVGFKPVQKORNGOGPVCDNGGHHGEVKXG
GHEKGPVCPFTGCNKUVKERTQITCOU
'PUWTG UWHEKGPV TGRTGUGPVCVKQP QH CPF EQPUWNVCVKQPU YKVJ
1(9U KP TGNCVKQP VQ VJG 199# (WPF 6JG XQKEGU CPF
KPVGTGUVUQH1(9UOWUVDGRTKQTKVK\GFKPVJGFGXGNQROGPV
CPF CFOKPKUVTCVKQP QH 199# 'PCEV CP 199# %JCTVGT
VQ TGRNCEG VJG 199# $QCTF QH &KTGEVQTURTQOWNICVGF
199#1OPKDWU2QNKEKGU
(QTIGCITGGOGPVUYKVJEQWPVTKGUQHFGUVKPCVKQPQPVJGTKIJVU
QHOKITCPVUVQUQEKCNRTQVGEVKQPCPFUQEKCNUGEWTKV[
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
40/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
&GXGNQRCPFUWUVCKPPCVKQPYKFGKPHQTOCVKQPCPFGFWECVKQP
ECORCKIPUQPVJGTKIJVUCPFTGURQPUKDKNKVKGUQHOKITCPVUVQ
GPCDNGRQVGPVKCN1(9UCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGUVQOCMGKPHQTOGF
EJQKEGU CPF UVTGPIVJGP CEEGUU VQ UGTXKEGU CPF TGFTGUU QH
ITKGXCPEGUD[1(9UCPFVJGKTHCOKNKGU
+ORNGOGPV UVTKEVN[ VJG NCYU CICKPUV KNNGICN TGETWKVGTU CPF
VTCHEMGTUETGCVGCPGPCDNKPIUQEKCNCPFNGICNGPXKTQPOGPV
VJCV YKNN GPEQWTCIG XKEVKOU VQ NG EQORNCKPVU CPF NGCF VQ
RTQUGEWVKQPU
+OOGFKCVGN[ UGV WR VJG 5JCTGF )QXGTPOGPV +PHQTOCVKQP
5[UVGOQP/KITCVKQPVQKORTQXGFCVGEQNNGEVKQPCPFGXKFGPEGDCUGFTGUGCTEJGUQPNCDQTOKITCVKQPHQTRQNKE[OCMKPICPF
IQXGTPOGPV RNCPPKPI #FQRV CPF GHHGEVKXGN[ KORNGOGPV C
ENGCTTKIJVUDCUGFRQNKE[CPFUVTCVGI[VQRTQITGUUKXGN[TGFWEG
VJGPWODGTQH1(9KPEQWPVTKGUCPFVGTTKVQTKGUVJCVFQPQV
OGGVVJGOKPKOWOIWCTCPVGGUQHRTQVGEVKQPHQTOKITCPVU
2TQOQVG OWNVKNCVGTCN TGURQPUGU VQ OKITCVKQP #FXQECVG
HQT VJG ETGCVKQP QH C 70DCUGF KPUVKVWVKQP QP OKITCVKQP
IQXGTPCPEG
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
41/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
4'('4'0%'5
#IECQKNK.CYTGPEG/CTEJ/KFFNG'CUV%TKUKU9QPV#HHGEV
1(9+PQYU/WEJ*5$%JVVRYYYRJKNUVCTEQO#TVKENGCU
RZ!CTVKENG+FRWDNKECVKQP5WD%CVGIQT[+F
#RKNQVEQWPVT[UVWF[2JKNKRRKPG/KITCVKQP4GXKGYQH'ZRGTKGPEGU
2QNKEKGUCPF2TQITCO&GXGNQROGPV#EQOOKUUKQPGFUVWF[QH
VJG/KITCPVU(QTWO#UKC/(#YKVJVJG%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV
#FXQECE[%/#/C[VQ#WIWUV
$CNKUCECP#TUGPKQ5JCTQP(C[G2K\C&GPPKU/CRC%CTNQU#DCF5CPVQUCPF&QPPC/CG1FTC5QEKCN+ORCEVQHVJG
)NQDCN(KPCPEKCN%TKUKUKPVJG2JKNKRRKPGUJVVRYYYCFDQTI
FQEWOGPVUTGRQTVUUQEKCNKORCEVETKUKURJUQEKCNKORCEVETKUKU
RJRFH
%CUKRNG/QP/CTEJ#&GXGNQRKPI/CLQT%TKUKUJVVR
OQPECUKRNGYQTFRTGUUEQOCFGXGNQRKPIOCLQT
ETKUKU
%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[%/#9QTMKPI2CRGTQP1XGTUGCU
/KITCVKQP
%QPVTKDWVKQPQH/KITCPV9QTMGTUVQVJG.QECN'EQPQO[)NQDCN7PKQP
4GUGCTEJ0GVYQTMJVVRYYYIWTPKPHQGPVQRKEUOKITCVKQP
EQPVTKDWVKQPQHOKITCPVYQTMGTUVQVJGINQDCNGEQPQO[
'NNCQ,CPGUU#PP&GEGODGT.CDQT/KITCVKQPKP#
6GTTKDNG;GCTVQ$GCP1(94GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRDWNCVNCVEQO
OCKPNCDQTOKITCVKQPKPCVGTTKDNG[GCTVQDG
CPQHY
*QEJUEJKNF#4)NQDCN%CTG%JCKPUCPF'OQVKQPCN5WTRNWU
8CNWGKP*WVVQP9CPF)KFFGPU#GFU1P6JG'FIG.KXKPIYKVJ)NQDCN%CRKVCNKUO.QPFQP,QPCVJCP%CRGR
+DQP(QWPFCVKQP+PE,CPWCT[2TC[OGT2CODCPUCPI-CNCIC[CP
/IC2CPICMQPI0CRCMQ
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
42/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
+DQP(QWPFCVKQP+PE;GCTGPF4GCN%JCPIGQT/QTGQHVJG5COG!
JVVRYYYKDQPQTIKDQPADKTFVCNMRJR!RCIGKF
+ORCEVQHVJG)NQDCN(KPCPEKCNCPF'EQPQOKE%TKUKUQPVJG2JKNKRRKPGU
2CRGT2TGRCTGFHQTVJG7PKVGF0CVKQPU&GXGNQROGPV2TQITCOOG
5GRVGODGT4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYYWPKEGH
QTIUQEKCNRQNKE[NGU+ORCEVAQHAVJGA)NQDCNA(KPCPKECNACPFA
'EQPQOKEA%TKUKUAQPAVJGA2JKNKRRKPGURFH
+ORCEVQHVJG/KFFNG'CUV%TKUKUQPVJG2JKNKRRKPG'EQPQO[(GDTWCT[
4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVR[QWTKPUKIJVUDNQIURQV
EQOKORCEVQHOKFFNGGCUVETKUKUQPJVON
+ORNGOGPVCVKQPQH'ZRCPFGF1(92TQVGEVKQPVQ5VCTVVJKU#WIWUV
#WIWUV4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRQHYKPHQEGPVGTDNQIURQV
EQOAAACTEJKXGJVON
+PVGTPCVKQPCN/KITCPVU&C[/GUUCIGD[/T,WCP5QOCXKC&KTGEVQT
)GPGTCNQHVJG+.10QX4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYY
KNQQTIINQDCNVQRKEUNCDQWTOKITCVKQP9%/5ANCPIGUKPFGZJVO
.GCFKPIOKITCPVYQTMGTUFGUGTXGRTQVGEVKQP2QNKE[$TKGHU5GTKGU
0Q+PUVKVWVGHQT/KITCVKQPCPF2QNKE[+UUWGU4GVTKGXGF
0QXGODGTHTQOJVVRCNOCPCEQHYRJKNCPVJTQR[QTI
WRNQCFU+/&+RQNKE[DTKGHARFH
/CUJC[GMK/KPC,WN[%QPVTKDWVKQPQH/KITCPVUVQ
&GXGNQROGPV6TCFG+PXGUVOGPVCPF&GXGNQROGPV.KPMCIGU
4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYYWPEVCFQTIGPFQEUGOFKVEVPEFAA
GPRFH
5CWFK/KPKUVT[QH.CDQT2TGUGPVCVKQPCPF(TGSWGPVN[#UMGF3WGUVKQPU
QP0KVCSCV4CPIGU0QXGODGT7RFCVGF0QXGODGT
4GVTKGXGFHTQO
JVVRYYYRJKNGODCUU[TK[CFJQTIKPFGZRJR!QRVKQPEQOAEQ
PVGPVXKGYCTVKENGKFUCWFKOKPKUVT[QHNCDQT
RTGUGPVCVKQPCPFHTGSWGPVN[CUMGFSWGUVKQPUQPPKVCSCV
TCPIGUECVKFUCWFK\CVKQPCPKVCSCV+VGOKF
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
43/44
&0$:RUNLQJ3DSHURQ2YHUVHDV0LJUDWLRQ
1RGP.GVVGTQH#MDC[CP4GR9CNFGP$GNNQVQ2TGU$GPKIPQ5KOGQP
#SWKPQ+++QPVJG%QWPVT[U'EQPQOKE9QGU/C[
4GVTKGXGFHTQO
JVVRYYYCMDC[CPQTIRJPGYUQRGPNGVVGTQHCMDC[CPTGRYCNFGP
DGNNQVQRTGUDGPKIPQUKOGQPCSWKPQKKKQPVJGEQWPVT[U
GEQPQOKEYQGU
1RKPKCPQ,GTGOCKCJ/CTEJ)QXVDCPMUQPVGEJXUKNNGICN
TGETWKVGTU4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYYCDUEDPPGYUEQOINQDCN
NKRKPQIQXVDCPMUVGEJXUKNNGICNTGETWKVGTU
1XGTCNN5CVKUHCEVKQP4CVKPI1P#SWKPQ)QXV&TQRU2QKPVUKP5955WTXG[2JKNKRRKPG&CKN[+PSWKTGT/C[
4GOKVVCPEGUTKUGVQ$KP(GD#RTKN4GVTKGXGFHTQO
JVVRYYYCDUEDPPGYUEQODWUKPGUUTGOKVVCPEGU
TKUGDHGD
4G[GU%GNKC#NGNNKG5QDTGXKCUCPF,GTGO[FG,GUU
+ORCEVQP1(9UTGOKVVCPEGUCPFNQECNGORNQ[OGPVUGGPKPVJG2JKNKRRKPGU%$/50GVYQTMU/WNVK%QWPVT[5VWF[
QP/QPKVQTKPICPF/KVKICVKPIVJG+ORCEVQPVJG2JKNKRRKPGU
4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYYRGRJVVRYYYRGRPGVQTI
NGCFOKPOGFKCURFH%$/5AEQWPVT[ARTQLARTQNGU2JKNKRRKPGU
&GEGODGTA(KPCN'FKVGFRFH
4GVWTPKPI1(9U$CFHQT'EQPQO[4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYYOCPKNCVKOGUPGVPGYUVQRUVQTKGUTGVWTPKPIQHYUDCFHQT
GEQPQO[
4QLCU*GPT[51XGTUGCU#DUGPVGG8QVKPI6JG2JKNKRRKPG
'ZRGTKGPEG3WG\QP%KV[%GPVGTHQT/KITCPV#FXQECE[
6JG2JKNKRRKPG.CDQT'ORNQ[OGPV#IGPFC#FXCPEKPI
+PENWUKXG,QD4KEJ)TQYVJVJTQWIJ&GEGPV9QTM
9CIG*KMGHQT/GVTQ9QTMGTUD[/C[1T,WPG2JKNKRRKPG5VCT/C[
7/29/2019 Working Paper on Overseas Migration 2011
44/44
'PF0QVGU
*QEJUEJKNF#4)NQDCN%CTG%JCKPUCPF'OQVKQPCN5WTRNWU
8CNWG+P*WVVQP9CPF)KFFGPU#GFU1PVJG'FIG
.KXKPIYKVJ)NQDCN%CRKVCNKUO.QPFQP,QPCVJCP%CRG
#UKCP&GXGNQROGPV$CPMCPF+PVGTPCVKQPCN1TICPK\CVKQPHQT
/KITCVKQP6JG+ORCEVQHVJG)NQDCN(KPCPEKCN%TKUKUQP
/KITCPVUCPFVJGKT(COKNKGUKP#UKC#5WTXG[$CUGF#PCN[UKU
$TGCMFQYPOC[PQVCFFWRVQVQVCNUFWGVQTQWPFKPIQHH
6QVCNCOQWPVQHTGOKVVCPEGUQHQXGTUGCU(KNKRKPQU1(UHTQO
EQWPVTKGUPQVGNUGYJGTGENCUUKGF
+PUWTCPEGRTGOKWOEQWNFDGCUJKIJCU75RGT[GCTQTCVQVCNQH
75HQTVJGFWTCVKQPQHCVYQ[GCTEQPVTCEV
70%QOOKVVGGQP/KITCPV9QTMGTU%QPXGPVKQP%QPENWFKPI
1DUGTXCVKQPUQPVJG2JKNKRRKPGUCUC5VCVG2CTV[/C[
5GUUKQP)GPGXC
5CWFK/KPKUVT[QH.CDQT2TGUGPVCVKQPCPF(TGSWGPVN[#UMGF3WGUVKQPUQP0KVCSCV4CPIGU0QXGODGT7RFCVGF0QXGODGT
4GVTKGXGFHTQOJVVRYYYRJKNGODCUU[TK[CFJQTIKPFGZ
RJR!QRVKQPEQOAEQPVGPVXKGYCTVKENGKFUCWFKOKPKUVT[
QHNCDQTRTGUGPVCVKQPCPFHTGSWGPVN[CUMGFSWGUVKQPUQPPKVCSCV
TCPIGUECVKFUCWFK\CVKQPCPKVCSCV+VGOKF
'UVKOCVGQP(KNKRKPQU1XGTUGCU&GEGODGT+PYYYEHQIQXRJ
&(#5GOK#PPWCN4GRQTVVQ%QPITGUU,WN[&GEGODGT6JGTGYCUPQDTGCMFQYPKPVJGFCVCHQT,GFFCJ%QPUWNCVG