Post on 31-Jan-2021
transcript
Bitcoin Microstructure and the Kimchi PremiumKJ Choi Alfred Lehar Ryan Stauffer
�1
Kimchi premium
▪ Bitcoin frequently trade at a higher price in Korea, a phenomenon referred to as the Kimchi Premium
On average 4.73% more expensive in Korea than the US with a maximum observed of 54.48% (Jan 2016 – Feb 2018)
▪ In frictionless financial markets such a price difference should be quickly arbitraged away • Buy bitcoin in US, for USD • Transfer to Korean exchange • Sell for KRW • Convert to USD and transfer back to US
▪ Frictions here are generated by exchanges, capital controls, and the Bitcoin microstructure itself
�2
Kimchi Premium Over Time
�3
Bitcoin microstructure
▪ Transaction verification on the Bitcoin blockchain will take ~1 hour in the best case. Up to 10 minutes to be included in the next block, plus 5 more blocks as confirmation.
▪ The transaction inclusion on the next block depends on the fee offered to miners. — Daily median confirmation time (inclusion on a block):
11 minutes average for our sample; as high as 47 min
➢Endogeneity between confirmation time, transaction fee, and volume
�4
Bitcoin exchange/microstructure frictions
▪ Exchange vs private wallets — When trading on an exchange, BTC are held on blockchain in wallet of exchange — Transfer of BTC: must request move from exchange account to private wallet — No data on processing times available, no regulation
▪ anecdotal evidence suggests waits can be very long
▪ Transfer of funds — Many exchanges find it hard to connect to payment systems — Credit card companies refuse payments — Banks do not process payments — e.g. Quadriga, number 2 exchange in Canada, uses a Portuguese bank
▪ Price risk during Arbitrage — US exchange -> private wallet -> Korean exchange — Price might change, posing risk for arbitrageur
▪ Fees directly reduce arbitrage profits
▪ Volatility: fluctuations in bitcoin price expose arbitrageurs to more risk during the trade
�5
Capital controls in Korea
▪ Limits to the amount of money than can be sent abroad —USD 3000 per transfer, with a max of USD 50,000 per year
—Credit card transactions max USD 10,000 outside Korea p.a.; this transaction is also considered a commodity purchase so customs must be paid on it.
▪ Ambiguous laws make it unclear if cryptocurrency transfers from a Korean exchange elsewhere are capital in/out-flow or commodity export/import
▪ Threats from the government to ban/restrict/regulate cryptocurrency trading
�6
Arbitrage attempts
�7
KRW bitcoin premium
�8
EUR Bitcoin Premium
�9
EUR bitcoin premium
�10
Comparison EUR and KRW
▪ In both markets the same microstructure frictions drive price deviations —Higher volatility and higher fees coincide with higher premia
▪ Effects are 10 times larger in Korea
▪ We argue this is due to capital controls
�11
Bitcoin premia and financial freedom 2017-03-01 to 2018-02-28
�12
Financial freedom
�13
▪ Economic Freedom Ranking (EFR): Fraser Institute ▪ 42 distinct variables ▪ size of government ▪ legal system and security of property rights ▪ sound money ▪ freedom to trade internationally ▪ regulation
▪ Index on capital controls (CCI) by Fernández, Klein, Rebucci, Schindler, and Uribe (2015) (IMF)
▪ Collect in great detail capital controls for a variety of financial instruments
▪ We use the sub-index on restrictions of outflows of money market instruments
▪ Use Germany as proxy for EUR area
Financial freedom and bitcoin premium
�14
Economic magnitude - EFR
�15
▪ Move from the median (Turkey, score 6.83) to the 75th percentile (Peru, score 7.47):
reduction in bitcoin premium by 1.4%
▪ Move from 75th percentile to top (Hong Kong, score 8.95): reduction in bitcoin premium by 3.2%
Complete arbitrage with other cryptos?
Korea premiums in other cryptocurrencies
�16
Upbit Bithumb Coinone Korbit Gopax
KRW/USD exchange rate
Similar premia in other cryptocurrencies
�17
Premia are highly correlated across cryptocurrencies
�18
Conclusion
▪ Many countries including Korea pay a premium to purchase Bitcoin
▪ Microstructure frictions — Allow prices to deviate across exchanges — Price deviations are larger when arbitrage is more:
▪ Risky: delay, volatility ▪ Costly: fees
▪ Capital controls — Amplify existing frictions in arbitrage trading — Allow BTC to trade at a high premium
▪ Greater financial freedom is associated with lower premia
▪ Similar findings across other cryptocurrencies
�19