Post on 02-Jun-2018
transcript
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
1/72
June 2009
www.cibsejournal.com
ENERGY STAROlympics trainingcentre given an 'A'
OFFICE MOVESThe new Guide toSpecification
MASTER PLANHospitals to getgreen treatment
DesignvisionaryAtkins's Keith Clarke is on
a mission to cut carbon
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
2/72
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
3/72www.cibsejournal.com 3
Contents
June 2009 CIBSE Journal
June 2009
18
36
30
News
6 NewsA round-up of the latestdevelopments across the industry.
13 CIBSE NewsLatest news from CIBSE.
16 News analysisIn the wake of EPCs being providedwithout site visits, the governmentis tightening up the rules. CarinaBailey reports.
18 CIBSE national conferenceA round-up of speeches anddiscussions from this years event.
Opinion
22 LettersReaders share their opinions with theindustry.
24 Team effortMorwenna Wilson says buildingimplementors and operators hold thekey to sustainable buildings.
26 OpinionRoderick Pettigrew criticises thegovernments wind strategy.
28 LegalThe new Gas Safe Register revealed.
Features30 COVER STORY
InterviewKeith Clarkes mission to save the planet.
36 Buildings: OfficesThe changing BCO Guide toSpecifcations.
40 Buildings: Case studySimon Ellery reports on the passiveengineering at Lee Valley athletics centre.
46 Masterplanning: HospitalsPaul Haddlesey reviews plans to double
the size of an English teaching hospital.
50 Air systems: ProcurementA wind of change is blowing throughthe fan procurement process.
Classified
54 ProductsProducts and services from acrossthe sector.
57 DirectorySuppliers from the building services
industry.
People & Jobs
59 CPDAnother module for your continuedpersonal development.
64 Looking aheadIndustry focused seminars andtraining events.
66 AppointmentsFind your new job in the buildingservices industry here.
70 Movers & ShakersNew appointments are announcedacross the industry and DavidAtkinson describes a typical dayworking as a principal engineer.
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
4/72
NewWolf joinsour exclusive pack
Walter Meier (Climate UK) LtdHighlands Road, Shirley, SolihullWest Midlands B90 4NLFreephone: 0800 801 819Fax: 0871 663 1664uk.climate@waltermeier.comwww.waltermeier.com
Water Chillers
Close Control
Air Handling UnitsFan Coils
VRF
Humidification
Service & MaintenanceAdding the outstanding Wolf KG Top range of air handling units to our portfolio of exclusive top brandnames, brings you an even greater choice of innovative, leading edge air conditioning technology.
With our extensive product ranges from Hitachi and Blue Box, our unrivalled UK experience andtechnical knowledge, Walter Meier moves even further ahead as leader of the pack, providing everything
you require for your air conditioning needs.
Filled with innovative technology, the new Wolf KG Top expresses a perfect combination of new ideas,
embracing all areas of design, quality and flexibility.
16 Unit sizes from 0.3m3/s to 28m3/s
Internal and external units with high quality powder coated finish to RAL colours
Eurovent Certified Products
For more on our new arrival or any of our famous name family, just call Freephone 0800 801 819and well send you a pack of information.
The New Wolf range of air handling unitsexclusively from Walter Meier
AIR CONDITIONING &HUMIDIFICATION SYSTEMS
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
5/72June 2009 CIBSE Journalwww.cibsejournal.com 5
CIBSE Journal is written and produced by CambridgePublishers Ltd. Tel: 01223 477411. www.cpl.biz275 Newmarket Road, Cambridge CB5 8JE.
Editorial copy deadline:First day of the monthpreceding publication
The opinions expressed in editorial material do notnecessarily represent the views of the CharteredInstitution of Building Services Engineers (CIBSE).Unless specifically stated, goods or services mentionedin editorial or advertisements are not formally endorsedby CIBSE, which does not guarantee or endorse or acceptany liability for any goods and/or services featured in thispublication.
CIBSE, 222 Balham High Road, London SW12 9BSTel: 020 8675 5211. www.cibse.org
CIBSE Services Ltd. ISSN 1759-846X
Subscription EnquiriesIf you are not a CIBSE member but would like to receiveCIBSE Journal, subscribe now! Costs are 80 (UK) and
100 (international). For subscription enquiries, and anychange of address information, please contact:Nicola Golledgeatngolledge@cibse.orgor telephone020 8772 3697.Individual copies are also available at a cost of 7 per copyplus postage.
Cover photo:Simon Weir
www.cibsejournal.com
EditorialEditor:Bob CerviTel: 01223 273520Email: bcervi@cibsejournal.com
Reporter: Carina BaileyTel: 01223 273521Email: cbailey@cibsejournal.com
Senior Designer: David Houghton
Advertisement Sales
Head of Business Development:Aaron NichollsTel: 020 7880 8547Email: aaron.nicholls@redactive.co.uk
Display Sales Manager: Steve SoffeTel: 020 7324 2785Email: steve.soffe@redactive.co.uk
Display Sales Consultant:Jim FolleyTel: 020 7324 2786Email: jim.folley@redactive.co.uk
Recruitment/Classied Sales: Ali ScottTel: 020 7324 2787Email: ali.scott@redactive.co.uk
Advertising Production:Jane EastermanTel: 020 7880 6248Email: jane.easterman@redactive.co.uk
For CIBSE
Publishing Co-ordinator: Nicola GolledgeTel: 020 8772 3697Email: ngolledge@cibse.org
Editorial advisory panel
Laurence Aston, Director of MechanicalEngineering, Morgan Professional Services
David Clark, Partner, Max FordhamConsulting Engineers
Patrick Conaghan, Partner, Hoare LeaConsulting Engineers
David Hughes, Building Services Consultant,MTT Consulting
Philip King, Director, Hilson Moran
Chani Leahong, Senior Associate,Fulcrum Consulting
Stephen Lisk, President, The Society of Lightand Lighting
Professor John Swafeld, CIBSE PastPresident
Ged Tyrrell, Managing Director,Tyrrell Systems
Ant Wilson, Director, AECOM
Morwenna Wilson, Graduate Engineer, ArupTerry Wyatt, Consultant to Hoare Lea
From the
editor
A
s the property slump bites, dont
be surprised if the person coming
to assess the energy rating of yourbuilding is an out-of-work junior
estate agent. Yes, by all accounts, any old Tom,
Dick or Harriet has been filling the ranks of the
nations energy assessors those professionals
charged with the important task of awarding
energy performance certificates to properties.
I borrow this dig against estates agents
bless em from Professor David Fisk, whose
mirthful speech was one of the highlights of
the recent CIBSE national conference (see
page 18). But his very serious point was that
there has been strong
evidence of unqualified
people being employed
to conduct building
assessments with
the accredited energy
assessor (EA) signing
this off without ever
visiting the property.
The Journal itself
highlighted this problem
in March, when we quoted some EAs who hadcomplained about this practice, likening it to
driving a car using someone elses licence.
Policymakers, however, have not been turning
a blind eye. As we reveal (pages 8 and 16),
the Department for Communities and Local
Government last month issued a guidance note
that, in effect, bans this practice from the end of
this month (June).
This is all well and good. Those applying any
rating system on the ground need to have full
credibility for the process to have any value.
Whether this guidance will have the impact
required remains to be seen: there will always
be some EA-accreditation firms that will want
to cut corners and provide a quick-and-dirty
service. So, as well as guidance, perhaps we
also need a robust register of accreditors with
a licensing regime of inspections.But, as we approach the first full year of the
energy performance certificate regime this
autumn, a more fundamental question is
whether the system is in danger of becoming
another box-ticking exercise in which clients
are satisfied and can forget energy efficiency
for another year. As such, the DEC system will
become a sticking plaster for the lack of day-
to-day attention to the performance of living,
changing buildings.
Hopefully the round of assessments this year
will provide more incentivesto clients to improve their
ratings. But if a DEC is
used simply as a badge of
rectitude this is all we need
to do and ratings dont
improve noticeably overall,
then the system is clearly
failing to work. The truth we
must face, though, is that
a snapshot of a buildings
energy performance, converted into a carbon-emissions rating, is never going to be a
substitute for the proper running, maintenance
and usage of a building. And this is where
facilities management services could play a
greater role in making sure that DECs are more
than just a paper exercise. DECs and EPCs are
welcome, and theyre here to stay. But, as with
BREEAM, LEED and other ratings systems, we
must ensure that clients are persuaded to see
them as just one stage in the overall, difficult
and ongoing process of reducing the carbon
footprints of their building stock.
Bob Cervi, Editor
bcervi@cibsejournal.com
Perhaps wealso need
a robust register ofaccreditors with alicensingregime.
Editorial
Improvement or paper exercise?
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
6/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com6
News
nThe majority of new schoolbuildings are not performing
to a high level, according to theirenergy performance certificate(EPC) ratings.
By the end of 2008, 28 secondaryschools and 64 primary schoolshad had EPCs but, of these, only 43were graded between bands A to C.
The rest fell into the lower D to Gefficiency bands. The average non-domestic EPC rating is currently a C.
The results also show only oneper cent of primary schools andtwo per cent of secondary schoolsscored an A.
The largest percentage of primaryschools (15 per cent) received aD, whilst the largest percentage ofsecondary schools (14 per cent)fared better, scoring a B.
The findings were revealed by aparliamentary question asked by
shadow climate change ministerGregory Barker to schools ministerJim Knight.
But when Barker asked howmany schools had been penalisedfor failing to display a DEC, Knightwas unable to answer because norecord of any penalties or issues ofnon-compliance are kept. He wasalso unable to answer how many
schools were actually displaying
their DECs.New schools with a floor areagreater than 1,000 sq m arerequired to have an EPC. Existingschools that are being refurbishedonly require a display energycertificate (DEC).
Both are legal requirements,with local trading standards officesresponsible for enforcement.
Both DECs and EPCs are
recorded on a national register(www.ndepcregister.com)but, togain access to an individual schoolscertificate, its unique referencenumber must be known. Thismeans schools can access their owndata, but members of the publiccannot. Knight added that thereare no plans at present to publishindividual school energy data.
Schools are failing torecord high energyperformance
Research laysout path todecarbonisingbuildings
Researchers say they will soonbe able to map out exactly what
steps need to be taken to meetcarbon reduction targets for
non-domestic buildings, and atwhat cost.
The Carbon Trust, anindependent advisory body, has
used a computer model namedDeCODE (Determining Carbon
Opportunities in the DevelopedEnvironment) to create a
report which will recommend
to government the optimumpath to help meet the target ofat least an 80 per cent cut in
emissions from non-domesticbuildings by 2050. According to
the trust, for the first time themodel will help to provide the
evidence to show that everythingfrom energy efficiency, micro-
renewables and decarbonisingthe grid will have to be done to
reach the target, while emissionscould increase significantly if
nothing is done.
DeCODE consolidates allthe Carbon Trusts knowledgedeveloped to date into one tool,
enabling the organisation toanalyse all its data.
It works by showing howmuch carbon can be reduced
when certain energy saving
measures are chosen, and howmuch this is likely to cost.
Information included inthe scenarios can range from
building demolition andnew-build rates to the use of
energy efficiency measures andrenewable technologies.
Stuart Farmer, head ofbuildings strategy at the trust,
said: Its not a questionof whether we should be
focusing on energy supplydecarbonisation or building
energy demand reduction;its not a choice between
energy efficiency measures orrenewables, new or existing
buildings. The challenge is sogreat that we need to do all of
these. The Carbon Trust reportwill concentrate the national
policy position.The report is expected to be
ready in early autumn.
Shutterstock
Smart meters are to be installed inevery British home by 2020 makingthe UK the first nation to attempt anoverhaul of electricity and gas meterson this scale.
The Department of Energy andClimate Change (DECC) estimatesthat it will cost between 7bn and9bn, or an average of 269 to 346per household, to implement theplan.
But it says the change should helpmake homes more energy-efficientand reduce utility bills.
However, consultancy Ernst andYoung believes the governmentcould have underestimated the costby as much as 6.4bn. The companybelieves the true figure to be as highas 13.4bn, or 515 per household.
A DECC spokesperson rejectedthe claim: The figures that we havepublished in our impact assessmentare a result of a lot of analysis andindependent expert advice as well asinput from stakeholders. We believeweve got our stats right.
Furthermore, the governmentsown consultation impactassessment found that rolling outsmart meters to all householdswill deliver net benefits of between2.5bn and 3.6bn over the next 20years, which would fall to suppliers,to customers and to the country as awhole, DECC said.
Smart meters would enablemeter readings to be taken remotelyand give householders real-timeinformation, helping consumers see
what energy they are using.They are seen as a key steptowards future smart grids, makingit easier for renewable generation tofeed into the grid including microand community level generation and will support the decarbonisationof heat and transport through thegreater use of electric and plug-inhybrid vehicles. Suppliers will alsobe able to offer more tariffs andservices aimed at encouraging moreefficient and economical energy use,according to DECC.
A consultation has now beenlaunched atwww.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/consultations/smart_
metering/smart_metering.aspx The deadline for comments is
24 July 2009.
Plan for smart meters in all homes in 10 years
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
7/72June 2009 CIBSE Journalwww.cibsejournal.com 7
News
New design standard for schoolsset to spread across public sector
nA UK government advisorybody has been given the
power to veto new school designsusing a new minimum designstandard.
The Commission for Architecture
and the Built Environment (CABE)has been pressing for such astandard for the past three years.
Schools minister Jim Knightannounced the standardsintroduction for the BuildingSchools for the Future (BSF)programme in an attempt toprevent more unfit-for-purposeschools being built. It is envisagedthis will eventually lead to all publicsector buildings having a minimumdesign standard in the future.
Designs for BSF schools are
already assessed by the CABE
schools design panel, but nowonly those graded as very good orpass will proceed to procurementand construction. Designs gradedunsatisfactory or poor at theirthird and final review will not be
built.Knight said: This is the first timeever that independently-assessed,clear, objective and robust designstandards have been laid down for apublic sector building constructionprogramme. It adds real teeth tothe design process. It will make thedesign process faster and moreefficient by promoting best practiceand thinking in school design.
Features of the new minimumdesign standard include: A new, simpler four-point grading
system;
The inclusion of educationalists,
sustainability and landscapespecialists on the peer review panel; Teachers and students views; Random checks on non-sample
scheme schools; and
CABE will provide more in-depthfeedback reports, education andinformational support.
CABE believes the standard willhave a longer-term impact on thequality of schools than almost anyother educational reform.lCABE and the Homes andCommunities Agency havecompleted the first national surveyon the design quality of affordablehousing, which found just 18 percent of schemes were judged to beeither good or very good.
www.cabe.org.uk/news
We need morecommunityheating, saysDECC official
The UK government wants to setup a forum to encourage the useof waste heat in buildings to helpthe industry meet its 80 per centcarbon emissions target.
Hergen Haye, an official atthe Department of Energy andClimate Change, said setting upsomething like a heat-marketsforum would enable industry, theenergy regulator Ofgem and thegovernment to collectively createa set of codes and conducts for
community heating. Speaking ata recent conference organisedby the Renewable Energy
Association, he said: If we donttackle heat we have no chance ofmeeting our target for 2050.
He said that district heatingneeded to be installed at a locallevel, and a large-scale heatand combined heat and powerpolicy framework was needed todrive energy efficiency in largebusinesses.
On the domestic front, just
two per cent of homes in the UKcurrently receive heat from districtheating systems. It is estimatedthat 5.5m homes could bebenefiting from these.
He believes feed-in tariffs,which should come into force inApril 2010, and the renewableheat incentive, will be key tomeeting the governmentsrenewable energy target of 15per cent by 2020. A consultationon renewable heat incentives isscheduled to begin this summer.
l l l l
T: +44 (0)1995 640 844 l F: +44 (0)1995 640 798
E: enquiries@powerplan.co.uk l W: www.powerplan.co.uk
CMD Ltd. POWERPLAN, Brockholes Way, Claughton-on-Brock, Preston, Lancashire PR3 0PZ
LONDON SHOWROOM CMD Ltd. 99 Charterhouse Street, Clerkenwell, London EC1M 6HR
_ _ _ _ _ _
Design-led: minimum standards will now apply to new school builds
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
8/72
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
9/72
NEOflo
This unique range of high efficiency condensing
stainless steel storage water heaters from
Andrews offers a revolutionary conceptin water heating.
Established values.Leading edge technology.
Baxi Commercial Division
0845 070 1055
www.andrewswaterheaters.co.ukwww.pottertoncommercial.co.uk
The UKs No1
NEW
PRODUCT!
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
10/72www.cibsejournal.com10
News
CIBSE Journal June 2009
n
Most wind turbines deliver
very disappointing resultsif they are installed in an urbansetting, according to new researchproduced by London South BankUniversity (LSBU).
Professor Tony Day told a recentmeeting of the CIBSE/ASHRAEgroup that manufacturers tellus how marvellous they are, butproper statistical analysis tells adifferent story.
LSBU studied a 6kW horizontalaxis turbine installed 42 metresabove street level on an 11-
storey south London residentialapartment block for a year. Itdelivered less than nine per centof its total maximum capacity ofbetween 8 and 9 MW/h. As theturbine cost 32,000 to install, Daysaid that equated to about 1,200per tonne of carbon saved.
He added that a 36 percent discrepancy betweenthe manufacturers claimedperformance and the data histeam gathered should be takeninto account when local authority
planners are considering whether awind installation meets carbon-saving criteria set down byinitiatives like the London Plan.
Turbines need to be moreintelligently sited, said fellowresearcher Dr Steve Dance, whostudied the noise and vibrationimpacts of the installation. In thiskind of location it will effectivelydeliver nothing for eight monthsof the year as the wind speeds[averaging 3.8m/s over the year] aretoo low.
However, he pointed out that
an identical turbine in a moresensible location had generated 50
per cent more electricity; and bothpresenters agreed there was hopefor the future of the technology.
Wind technology is wherecars were about 100 years ago,said Day. People laughed at theModel T Ford and it could well bethat future versions of turbineswill make a more meaningfulcontribution to carbon saving.
In a separate development,Britains only wind turbinemanufacturing plant, on the Isle ofWight, faces closure because of a
lack of demand in the UK.
The plants owner, Danish firmVestas, partly blamed a lack of
political initiatives in Britain for thesituation.But the companys comments
came as plans for the worldsbiggest off-shore wind farm, in theThames estuary, were given the go-ahead by the UK government withthe aim of supplying electricity forthe London Olympics in 2012.
In addition, Europes largeston-shore wind farm in EastRenfrewshire, Scotland, has beencompleted with a total of 140turbines. The installation aims to
provide power for 180,000 homes.
Urban wind turbines deliverpoor results, says new research
Building works worth 60m havebeen approved on a further 47new projects at 26 universities.
The funding was authorisedby the Higher Education FundingCouncil for England (HEFCE) aspart of the governments secondround of the accelerated capitalprojects spending programmeto help stimulate Britainseconomic recovery.
The programme wasannounced in December 2008,with the first round of projectsapproved in February.
60m for uni builds
News in brief
Scheme for sustainabilityleadership created
Engineering consultancy
Arup has joined forces withCambridge University tocreate the new CambridgeProgramme for SustainabilityLeadership, which aims todevelop and spread bestpractice in combating climatechange by creating jobs andimproving quality of life incities.
R&D centre to be builtConsultancy Mott MacDonaldhas been appointed to work
on the construction of anew four-storey researchand development (R&D)centre in Cheshire, UK,by pharmaceutical groupAstraZeneca. Mott MacDonaldwill provide structural, civil andarchitectural design, as well asoverall design co-ordinationand construction support.
WYG to design new prisonMulti-disciplinary consultantWYG has won a three-year
contract to manage the designand build of a new 800-cellprison in Londonderry for theNorthern Ireland Prison Serviceon an existing prison site.
Free pipe-joining trainingCIBSE members can getfree training in pipe-joiningmethods from Victaulic. TheCIBSE-accredited presentationintroduces the technology,explains how it works and itsbenefits in welding, flanging
and threading. To arrange apresentation call Andy Carter,product engineer, on 01438310690.
South London schools refurbA 200m partnership torebuild seven schools, put uptwo new ones and completefour building refurbishments,has been signed by BalfourBeatty, Southwark Council,Partnerships for Schoolsand Building Schools for theFuture. All construction andfacilities management will becarried out by Balfour Beatty,an engineering, construction,investment and services group.
Wind turbines need to be more intelligently sited
Shutterstock
Nominations are now beingaccepted for the 10th Karen BurtAwards.
The awards, by the WomensEngineering Society (WES), areopen to women in engineeringor a related discipline who haveachieved chartered status sinceJuly 2008.
WES asks professional bodiesaffiliated to the EngineeringCouncil to nominate their
highest-calibre, newly-charteredfemale engineer, applied scientistor IT professional, who hasdemonstrated a commitment tothe promotion of her profession.
The award commemorates thelate Dr Karen Burt, an eminentphysicist. The closing date fornominations is 1 July. For moreinformation call WES on 01438765506, email info@wes.org.uk,or visit www.wes.org.uk
Nominations open for theWES Karen Burt Awards
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
11/72
Introducing AECOMOur practices in Europe are becoming AECOM.
Our professionals who serve you...Our focus on quality service and products...Our commitment to our employees...
Remain unchanged. We are AECOM.
One company. One AECOM.
Faber Maunsell
43,000 employees worldwide.Operations in over 100 countries.
To discover more please visit us at:www.aecom.com
EDAW
ENSR
ERA
Earth Tech
Savant
Building EngineeringDesign & Planning
EnvironmentEnergyProgramme ManagementTransportationWater
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
12/72
Many different sizes
- but only one colour
GOLD are complete air handling units for comfort ventilation. Energy-saving fans, efficientheat recovery and full control of temperatures, airflows and operating times offer optimaloperational economy. The units require very little space and offer plug-and-play installation.The GOLD has built-in IQnomic type control equipment with a large number of functions,including communication.
Visit our homepage or contact your local Swegon-office or more information about GOLDand our other products for the worlds best indoor climate!
Swegon LtdPhone: 01992-45 04 00Fax: 01992-45 05 00e-mail: info@swegon.co.ukwww.swegon.com
From0,08m3/s...
NewGOLDsize12
upto1,3m3/s
...Upto8,2m3/s
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
13/72June 2009 CIBSE Journalwww.cibsejournal.com 13
CIBSE News
newsTel: 020 8675 5211 Fax: 020 8675 5449 Email:secretary@cibse.orgPresident:Mike Simpson FCIBSE, FSLL, FILE, FIET Chief executive and secretary:Stephen Matthews
News in brief
Mosss outstandingcontributionBrian Moss,chairman ofCIBSE ServicesBoard andpast CIBSEpresident, has
been awardeda Tercentenary Medal by theWorshipful Company of FanMakers for his outstandingcontribution to fan engineeringand the BS industry.
Walking in LondonThe Society of FaadeEngineering is holding itsannual City Walk Buildings inthe Euston Area on Thursday25 June. The event will start at4.30pm at Arup, 8 Fitzroy Street,
London W1T 4BQ with a talk byguest speaker Henk De Bleeckerfrom Permasteelisa on DynamicFacades. The walk starts at6.30pm. To register visit www.facadeengineeringsociety.org
Honorary FellowshipCIBSE has awarded ProfessorDeian Hopkins, retiring vice-chancellor and chief executiveofficer at London SouthBank University (LSBU), anHonorary Fellowship. The award
recognises his commitmentto and enthusiastic support ofBS courses and research, andhis support for the universitysassociation with CIBSE.
Join CIBSECompetent BS professionalswith CEng/IEng qualificationswho are registered with otherengineering institutions canbecome a CIBSE member atAssociate, Member or Fellowgrade. A CV, competencestatement, development actionplan and details of one sponsorare required.
Contact Bobby Wright on 0208772 3639 or bwright@cibse.org
A new CIBSE group has beenformed in Qatar.
Qatar, one of the wealthiest
states in the Gulf region, iscurrently experiencing a boom in itsconstruction industry. This has ledto the requirement for internationalexpertise to complement theconstruction industry. A smallnumber of these specialists are UKBS engineers.
The founder members are JohnMakaronas, David Baker, MichaelDaly, Philip Dyer, Joseph Smith,Ramzi Qumsieh, Tony Boothmanand Peter Carew. Daly has now beenappointed as Qatars representative.
The members have a wealthof experience in design andmanagement and are currentlyworking on prestigious projectsin Doha, including: the NewDoha International Airport; Qatar
National Convention Centre; andthe International World ClassMedical Research Hospital for theQatar Foundation.
The group will provide bestpractice advice in Qatar to anyinterested parties. It intends toorganise site visits and technicalseminars, and to liaise with otherengineering groups in Qatar.
To join or contact thegroup email Michael.Daly@CansultMaunsell.comorjmakaronas@hotmail.com
New group forms in Qatar
Cooper gets awardDavid Cooper, managingdirector of consultingengineers LECS (UK) Ltd andFellow of CIBSE, becomes aLiveryman of the WorshipfulCompany of Engineers fromthe master of the company,Tony Roche. The companysmembers are required to bechartered engineers, a Fellowof a recognised engineeringinstitution, and also to holdthe Freedom of the City ofLondon.
Follow the code or facethe consequencesn
CIBSE would like to remindmembers of the Code of
Conduct they sign up to on joining.With money tight, an
increasingly litigious society andmore building services engineers
doing domestic work, you may bemore likely to be under scrutinyfrom your client and membersof the design team looking forscapegoats.
We would like to stress thatCIBSE does not receive manycomplaints about its members;however a recent case serves as atimely reminder that you are boundby the code.
Recently a CIBSE memberwas formally reprimanded by theinstitution and warned as to his
future conduct as the result of acomplaint made against him. Thecase centered on communicationand was complicated by theintricacies of being on a designteam in a large domestic project.From the evidence provided, other
members of the design teamwere also felt by the DisciplinaryCommittee to be at fault but itwas the CIBSE member that theclient complained about. Thisdemonstrates the need to keep
communication open and to betimely with your contributionsto the process. If you are held upby others, then say so keep theclient and others in the designteam informed. And maintainwritten communication so that youhave evidence of the facts, shouldanything go wrong.
If a complaint is made againstyou it will be considered by theProfessional Practice Committee,which is delegated by the Board tothe Disciplinary Committee. Cases
are examined to ensure they are notmerely malicious and that they aregenuinely centered on membersconduct. CIBSE does not becomeinvolved in contractual matters ordispute resolution.
In recent years a number of
complaints were not pursuedbecause they were primarilydisputes over fees or failure todeliver under the contract. Oneor two cases have revealed thatthere was no contract to begin
with, and CIBSE would encouragemembers always to have a contractor a letter of appointment, and tomaintain written communicationbefore a contract or appointment isformalised.
If you are found to be in breachof the Code of Conduct after adisciplinary hearing, you will besubject to one of four sanctions:a warning as to future conduct; areprimand; suspension for a periodup to a maximum of two years; orexpulsion from the institution.
Suspension and expulsion will bepublished in the CIBSE Journal as a
matter of public record. Membershave the right to appeal. For full
information on the code and the
disciplinary rules, visit www.cibse.
org and go to About CIBSE.
Members of the new Qatar group
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
14/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com14
CIBSE News
Training andDevelopmentTraining and developmentsubmissions
The closing dates for annualsubmissions to be consideredat the July and October 2009Training and DevelopmentPanel meetings are 20 June and8 September respectively.
For training submissions andqueries, employers enquiriesand applications for approvedcompany training schemes,contact Olwen Williams, trainingand development administrator,on 020 8772 3605 or atowilliams@cibse.org
CPD Directory updateCPD course providers whowould like to apply for an entryinto the Directory of CPDCourse Providers should contactOlwen Williams, training anddevelopment administrator,on 020 8772 3605 or emailowilliams@cibse.org
We also accept applicationsfor online courses. We willwelcome more e-learningapplications.
The following organisationhas recently been added to thedirectory:
The Institution of Engineering
and Technology (IET).A concessionary rate is
available for entries into somecategories.
CIBSE is inviting final-year buildingservices students to enter theCIBSE Undergraduate Award.
Does your final-year projectdemonstrate engineeringexcellence? Do you have an originalidea that deserves recognition?And can you show a strongunderstanding of engineeringscience and design? Simply sendus a 2,000-word synopsis of your
final-year project. Judges will belooking for clear, easy-to-readsubmissions with a strong idea,understanding of engineeringscience and design, originality, andgood visual quality with high-qualitydrawings.
The award is open to final-yearBS engineering BSc, BEng andMEng students in the UK andinternationally. The first prize is
500, plus one years free CIBSEgraduate membership, and twoplaces at the CIBSE presidentsdinner. There are also two highlycommended prizes of 100.
The closing date is 31 July 2009.Download the application formfrom the CIBSE Young MembersBlog at www.cibseyoungmembers.co.ukand send all your entries toclacey@cibse.org
New Part L is arriving soon and we need your views
n
The long-awaited
consultation on the newPart L should be arriving in yourinbox any day now. And with itthe challenge for the institution tounderstand and respond to thismajor piece of regulation.
As building services engineers,you are the people who know bestabout how Part L works and wherechanges need to be made. It istherefore essential that we find away of tapping into this expertiseand utilising the knowledge andexperience that is already out there.
We will be organising events todiscuss the consultation, and to getthe views of practising engineersto ensure that we are feeding yourcomments and ideas back to DCLG(Department of Communitiesand Local Government). But letsalso remember that, in order tomake a difference to the energydemand and carbon emissions
of our buildings, we need to take
the sort of action set out in theconsultation. It will largely be downto CIBSE members to meet theproposed target to cut aggregatecarbon emissions in new buildingsby 25 per cent. The knowledge andexperience to deliver low-carbonbuildings sits largely within CIBSE:CIBSE low-carbon consultants andlow-carbon energy assessors leadin terms of delivering accreditedcompetence in low-carbon designand operation of buildings.
It is not enough to achieve low-
carbon design we need to achievelow-carbon buildings, where theoperational performance matchesthe design intent. In short, we needto achieve compliance of the asbuilt (or refurbished) project withthe goals of Part L. Only by workingtogether and pooling the knowledgeand experience of designers,builders, clients and regulators can
we meet the targets and ensure
compliance with the legislation.In particular, we need a regime inwhich building services engineerswork closely with building control,to ensure targets are really met notjust on the CAD screen, but onsite.
Through this greater teamworking, those with the right skillsto assess and certify complianceare able to do that, freeing buildingcontrol officers to focus onhigher risk projects where theirenforcement skills are needed.
This close working, open
communication and sharedproblem-solving will ensure latestPart L targets can be met. And,as experts in low carbon design,it is our responsibility to take theopportunity to make this work. Iencourage you all to make sure youhave your say. For more informationvisit www.cibse.org/partlStephen Matthews
Undergraduate award entries invited
CIBSE and the Federation ofEuropean HVAC Associations(REHVA) have met to explore howwe can work together more closely.As an umbrella body, REHVAis an important conduit to theEuropean Commission. There arecurrently two principal areas ofinfluence for REHVA in Europe the EPBD (now being recast) andalso the Energy Using ProductsDirective. The group discussedopportunities to promote CIBSEpublications, training, the flexible
learning scheme and websiteaccess. The free REHVA Dictionaryis now available at www.rehvadictionary.orgto translatebuilding services related terms
between 15 languages. More willbe added when the translationsare prepared.
Consultation responsesCIBSE has recently responded tothe following consultations: CLG and DECC Heat and EnergySaving Strategy (HESS); DECC consultation on the termcarbon neutral; and CLG Carbon ReductionCommitment
In the HESS response we
particularly emphasised theimportance of using trained andaccredited professionals to deliveradvice on improving the energyperformance of existing buildings.
For details visit www.cibse.organdlook up Consultations underKnowledge Bank.
Building information modelling
Following CIBSEs adoption of theindustry-wide BIM definition, weare now stepping up our activity inthis area.
If you are doing BIM now orusing any of the currently availableenabling software please letus know and we will keep youinformed. We also want to learn
from you so please send anemail to Samantha McDonough:smcdonough@cibse.org, statingyour interest and views on whatthe issues are for practitioners.
REHVA and CIBSE in talks on cooperation
CIBSE assessor presentsDEC to London Marriott
Gordon Ormond, Londoncluster director ofengineering at The LondonMarriott Hotel Marble Arch,accepts the hotels first DEC(display energy certificate)from Andrew Gardner, CIBSELow Carbon Energy Assessorof CCL Consulting Limited.The Marriott is one of the firstbranded hotels in the UK tocomplete a DEC.
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
15/72
the all new ecolution KX6Now Mitsubishi Heavy Industries introduces even further advances inefficiency with the new ecolution KX6 mini VRF system.
Compact, lightweight, single fan outdoor units from 11.2kW to 15.5kWcooling capacity with the highest levels of efficiency available and a
completely new range of indoor unitswith enhanced control logic.
SIXTHSense
FM Air Conditioning
Tel: 01707 378685 Fax: 01707 378697, sales@fmair.co.uk, www.fmair.co.uk
HRP Limited
Tel: 01359 270888 Fax: 01359 271132, headoffice@hrpltd.co.uk, www.hrponline.co.uk
3D Air Sales
Tel: 01753 495720 Fax: 01753 495721, sales@3dair.co.uk, www.3dair.co.uk
Scotland Tel: 0141 777 5007, Ireland Tel: 00 353 (0) 1463 8604
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
16/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com16
News analysis EPCs
All presentand correct?Earlier this year the practice of providing energyperformance certificates for buildings without evervisiting a site caused a furore. Now the government isresponding by tightening the rules. Carina Bailey reports
nWhen the system ofcertifying a buildings
energy performance wasintroduced last autumn, the
move was widely welcomed as asignificant step towards cutting
the carbon footprint of the
UKs building stock. But, whileattention was focused on theratings applied to properties via
the new energy performance anddisplay energy certificates (EPCs
and DECs), underlying problemswith the certification process were
threatening to undermine thewhole structure.
One key problem that emergedwas so-called remote lodgement,
which was highlighted in theMarch issue of the Journal. A
number of energy assessors
those responsible for providingcertificates complained aboutpractice of awarding a certificate
via third-party data gatherers,likening this to driving a car using
someone elses licence.The Department of
Communities and LocalGovernment (DCLG) is now,
in effect, banning this practicefor DECs and EPCs, which
are applied to public-sectorbuildings. According to a DCLG
guidance document sent to
accrediting bodies in May, thepractice of remote lodgementsof DECs will be regarded as
unacceptable from the end ofthis month.
During a CIBSE seminar lastmonth on EPCs, an official from
DCLG, Peter Matthew, disclosedthat departments in Whitehall had
become increasingly wobblyabout the quality of EPCs. Is it
really worth basing our policieson this if a lot of messages
were hearing is that there are
Energy assessors will be
required to visit a site to
award a certifcate
iStock/LisaFXPhotographicDesigns
THERMAL TECHNOLOGY(Sales)Ltd Bridge House, Station Road, Westbury, Wilts BA13 4HRTelephone: (01373) 865454 Facsimile: (01373) 864425
e-mail: sales@thermaltechnology.co.uk website: www.thermaltechnology.co.uk
Balanced Ventilation and Heat Recovery Units
with the TT Series Seven Range
24pageRecupovent
leafletavailable
Series Seven Range - 12 sizesFresh and exhaust air with heat recoveryAir volumes 25 to 2500 l/sEurovent certified Recuperators up to
80% efficiencyHorizontal, vertical, indoor and outdoor
models with Duplex fans for standby and duty
Direct drive speed controllable fans with no maintenanceHigh quality build pentapost and double skin panels
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
17/72June 2009 CIBSE Journalwww.cibsejournal.com 17
News analysis EPCs
www.mitsubishielectric.co.uk/aircon
Time is running out for R22
Email time2replace@meuk.mee.comor Call 01707 278601
Dates:June 4th, June 16th, July 1st and July 14th
Venue: Mitsubishi Electric, Travellers Lane
Hatfield, Hertfordshire AL10 8XB
After 31st December 2009 it will be illegal to use virgin R22 refrigerant for the maintenance or
servicing of air conditioning. Mitsubishi Electric are hosting a series of informative seminars
which will help you understand the impact of this ban on both you and your customers.
To make the most of the business opportunities oered by the phase out of R22:
quality issues? he asked. If ourdepartments are getting wobblythen I need to actually turn themaround, I need to give them theconfidence that EPCs and DECsare a brilliant starting point. Ibelieve its really important thatwe build confidence in EPCs.
Matthew added that an auditof accreditation schemes shouldsoon provide the DCLG withan idea of the poorer-quality
schemes, which the departmentcan then monitor more closely.He has also mooted the idea ofcommissioning an audit lookingat the value and quality of EPCs to be assessed by DCLG itself.
But Matthew also stressed thatthe guidance DCLG provides isthe bare minimum that assessorsshould be striving for, and that hewould like to discuss ways withthe industry about how to raisethe bar on quality. It is hopedthis would lead to a range of
good-practice guides.Jacqueline Balian, managingdirector of CIBSE Services Ltd,agrees that quality is a seriousissue, especially as some trainingcourses claim to be able to teachdelegates with no previousexperience to become energyassessors in as little as three days.
Currently there are a numberof accrediting bodies for energyassessors one of which isCIBSE Certification and somebodies are allegedly advising
EPCs:
An EPC is an Energy PerformanceCertificate that all non-publicsector properties must have whenthey are sold, built or rented. Theytook effect fully last October.
The EPC records how energyefficient a building is by ratingit from A (most efficient) to G(least efficient). It also includes areport giving recommendations forimprovement. Each improvementincludes the indicative paybackperiod and carbon impact.
The rating is based on the
performance of the building andits services, for example heating,rather than the appliances withinit. This is known as an asset rating.
DECs:
A DEC, or Display EnergyCertificate, shows the actualenergy consumption, or energyperformance, of a building interms of the carbon dioxideproduced. It uses a rating scorebetween A and G to show how
well a building is performing
based on gas and electricity meterreadings. A supplementary reportis also supplied with the certificatesuggesting ways in which theenergy performance of buildingcould be improved. CurrentlyDECs are only required in publicbuildings over 1,000 sq m andneed to be publicly displayed.
The certificate is valid for oneyear, while the accompanyingreport is valid for seven.Source: www.businesslink.gov.uk
Displaying energy performance
assessors not to remove any ofthe recommendations routinelyincluded by the software toimprove a buildings EPC rating,regardless of how inappropriatesome of these might be, saysBalian.
The economic recession hasalso impacted on the certificationprocess. When EPCs were firstintroduced it was expected that140,000 would be produced overa year. The real figure lodged todate is about 80,000. DECs havefared worse, with an estimated42,000 expected, but just 25,000lodged by mid-May 2009. But,despite the obvious problemsof quality voiced by Matthewand Balian, industry leaders anddevelopers seem to share the view
that EPCs and DECs are a step inthe right direction.
Paul Edwards, head ofsustainability at Hammerson, hascome round to the idea of EPCsafter initially branding them adisaster. He argues there wasconfusion over what buildingsneeded to be included and says
he still doesnt understand why anEPC is needed on an empty shellthat just has a cable running to itbut no actual services. He is alsocritical of why a second surveyneeds to be done to complete aDEC when a survey was already
completed to do an EPC.But he adds: I see great
opportunities for benchmarkingand understanding where wesit against other people in thebusiness and also in the industry.Once we get benchmarkingthen we can start to value thesethings.
John Field, director of PowerEfficiency Ltd, insists EPCs andDECs have raised the profile ofenergy efficiency and carbonreduction, but believes that
their introduction has created asegmented market: high qualityversus minimum compliance.
Richard Hipkiss, sales andmarketing director at i-ProphetsEnergy Services, believes thereis also a third market thevoluntary market, where peopleactually take an interest in their
EPC and recognise its value. TheEPC and DEC are very powerfultogether. The DEC is an annualstatement of performance. Its avery, very powerful tool because ofits simplicity.
But Ant Wilson, a director of
consultancy AECOM (formerlyFaber Maunsell), argues that anEPC has nothing to do with energyor performance, because it isbased on expected CO2 emissions while the reality of a buildingsenergy usage is that it can end upbeing more heavily occupied thanwas intended, for example, and soappears to be less energy-efficient.
In the longer term, the DCLGis aiming to build EPCs andthe European Performance ofBuildings Directive under
which EPCs fall into the UKgovernments Heat and EnergySaving Strategy, according toMatthew. In order to do this,discussions surrounding howEPCs should be regulated alsoneed to be resolved, with anarms-length body to police it apossible option.l
Its really importantthat we buildconfdence in EPCs. DCLG official
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
18/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com18
CIBSE national conference
nBuilding services engineershold the keys to some of
the biggest solutions in cuttingcarbon emissions in Britain, saidProfessor Julia King, a member ofthe Committee on Climate Change(CCC), an independent advisorybody to government.
The need to increase energy
efficiency in residential andcommercial buildings presents anexciting opportunity for engineers,she added although, amid aneconomic recession, it was a testingtime too. King said current policyon increasing energy efficiency inresidential buildings would producea reduction of 9m tonnes ofcarbon dioxide (9 MtCO2). But thetechnical potential in the sectormeant a possible cut of 43 MtCO2.
She pointed out that the
government has pledged to offer7m homes in the UK whole-housecarbon-reduction packages by 2020 estimated to be worth 42bn.
In the meantime, she reported,the CCC is soon to issue anassessment of the impact of therecession. A second report togovernment on carbon-reduction
progress would be issued at the endof this year, she added.Professor David Fisk, of
Imperial College, London, wascritical of the UKs display energyperformance certificates (DEC)regime, describing it as one of thesloppiest in the world, addingjokingly: Were now getting out-of-work estate agents to get your DEC... by telephone!
He said this was part of theprocess of tick-box engineering
getting an environmental briefby a client and sending this off toget a green rating. So the questionbeing asked is not, how can weget a building thats great for theenvironment?, but how can weget a BREEAM Excellent rating?He added: Thats where tick-boxengineering becomes dangerous.
Engineering a more
sustainable futureThe realities of cutting carbon emissions, the future for renewables, ensuringschools are properly ventilated, and involving clients and users in the designprocess were among the cutting-edge issues discussed at the CIBSE nationalconference 2009. Reports by Carina Baileyand Bob Cervi
What does zero-carbon buildingsmean and how can they bedelivered? This difficult questionwas posed by Stephen Ward, asustainability director at AECOM.
He said he believed that themost significant evolution tocome out of the UK governmentsconsultation document on definingzero carbon was not having tomeet the zero-carbon target purelyon-site: Were talking about zerocarbon on a net zero basis, so werenot saying buildings have to be zerocarbon every minute of the day, soas long as [they are] net zero overthe year.
The Department for Communitesand Local Government (DCLG)had introduced the idea of carboncompliance, which is the targetthat the industry has to meet,whether it be done using on-site
generated energy or physicallylinking the development to a nearbyenergy centre. The consultationset out three options for what thaton-site compliance target shouldbe, ranging from 44 to 100 percent below current 2006 TER. ButDCLG is expected to discouragedevelopments being connected tooff-site renewables by a private wire,which previously counted towardsachieving the Code for SustainableHomes. And, according to Ward,an open question still hangs overwhether unregulated energy usewill be included in the definition fornon-domestic buildings.
Engineers canhelp with cuttingwater waste
How do we ensure a water-saver friendly building, askedCharlotte Parkes of AECOM, whopointed out that 89 per cent ofcarbon emissions arising fromwater systems relate to usage inthe home.
Savings can be made througha change in peoples behaviour
and the use of better technology,she said, arguing: As buildingservices engineers we hope toinfluence the second and thirdaspects in this list.
It is down to the individual todecide what is necessary usageof water in the home, but someof the seemingly unnecessaryconsumption can be blamed onthe technology used in showers,toilet flushing, and so on.
Industry would have to meetrevisions to Part G of the Building
Regulations, a consultationdocument which proposedapplying a calculator to waterappliances to determine usage,Parkes said. The final revisionswere still awaited.
But she added that suchmeasures should not push theboundaries of user acceptabilityand should meet the practicalaspects of a building, such asdrainage and plumbing.
Chris Northey, of publichealth engineering group BDSPPartnership, said that, withgovernment subsidy and taxrelief, the costs of installingwaste-water recycling systemscould be recouped within a year.
Climate change a great opportunity forengineers but cut out the box-ticking
In search of a definition of zero-carbon
King says BS engineers hold the key
Ward: zero carbon can be on- and off-site
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
19/72June 2009 CIBSE Journalwww.cibsejournal.com 19
CIBSE national conference
n
The question of which
ventilation strategy to use innew school buildings in particular,natural or mechanical dominated a
number of speaker sessions.Terry Wyatt, a consultant to Hoare
Lea, insisted that schools shouldhave demand and control systems
to ensure they are used efficiently:If left to the teacher, faced with one
switch, shell turn it on and leave iton. Anything set by hand must have
a default control. Wyatt also pointedto a lack of use of variable speed
drives on motors: We are designing
systems for maximum capability,which is rarely used using variablespeed means saving energy.
John Palmer, a regional directorat AECOM, argued that natural
ventilation should be consideredas a first design option in schools,
believing that pupils and teacherscould be relied upon to open
windows and turn off switches: Wehave to think about the knock-on
effects of mechanical ventilation... Itmeans lots of kit, and where are the
POEs [post occupancy evaluations] of
this in schools?
Martin Liddament, of VEETECH
Ltd, said that, according to theCarbon Trust, mechanical ventilation
systems and air conditioning requirecontinuing maintenance to ensure
safety and correct performance.Edward Murphy, technical director
of Mott MacDonald, presenteda study of his consultancy work
on naturally ventilated schools inSheffield, UK. But, in a Q&A session,
Terry Wyatt described the picture
presented by the preceding speakers
as real fairy land, adding: Howmany schools are built in beautiful
settings? How can you switch offacoustic noise [from outside the
school]? New schools are nowherenear the performance that you are
referring to. One young delegate saidhe was staggered by the amount of
conflict, adding that CIBSE shouldhelp to resolve such issues, so we
can go forward. Another delegatesaid: We have been discussing this
for 20 years.
CHP energysaving benefitsare over-hypedThe ability of tri- and co-generation
systems to save energy has been
over-hyped, suggested Dr JamesThonger, an associate director ofArup.
Some uses of these systems, suchas combined heat and power (CHP)
fuelled by natural gas, could be lessefficient than fossil fuel-powered
boilers, he argued.Pointing to figures from Dukes
2008 showing that 71 per cent ofCHPs are powered by natural gas,
he queried why this should be so,and suggested that energy savings
from such systems had been
overestimated.Thonger argued that various
tricks had been used to elevate
energy savings from CHPs. Forexample, while CHP could be shown
to be 18 per cent more efficient thanconventional heating, this saving is
halved to nine per cent if heat lossis included in the calculation. In
analysing whether a co-generationsystem is more energy-efficient than
a conventional one using the samefuel supply, the industry should use
the governments CHPQA Standard,
Thonger said.
Relying on renewables alone toslash carbon emissions is notenough: nuclear needs to beconsidered to meet stringentgovernment targets, insisted youngengineer Rick Wheel of Arup duringthe CIBSE Young Engineers debate:Is the recession killing the marketfor renewable technologies?
Wheel and three other youngengineers Mary Ann Clarke andNigel Banks from AECOM, andBecci Taylor from Arup weregrilled for more than an hour by
delegates at the YEN dinner anddebate.
Wheel added: I dont believenuclear is sustainable by anydefinition of the word. However, itsa very, very low-carbon solution. Ifclimate change is going to be takenseriously, then nuclear has a veryreal place over the next 50 years.
Banks stressed his concernsabout unearthing future sourcesof oil and gas: If oil reserves arelow and declining Im sure gasprices and electrical prices will
rise as a result. The really worryingthing is that the next best availablesource of oil is the tar sands fromCanada and other places, whichare horrendously unstable andcarbon polluting. If you dont stopthat, then youve got no chance ofstopping climate change.
The idea of capturing carbonfrom burning fossil fuels isnt astrategy that Taylor advocateseither: Investing money in carboncapture would be better spent onrenewables.
Taylor believes that clients donthave a choice on renewables:Legislation requires that thosebuildings contribute to a low-carbon
economy. They wont necessarilybe on-site renewables. An off-siteobligation can cater for that as well.
Its particularly interesting inthe context of the recession arecession makes things moreefficient, companies have to bemore streamlined.
We shouldnt be putting
renewables where they dont workanymore.Clarke agreed that the issue
now should be to put the rightrenewables in the right place andmake sure that the location andbuilding demand actually match therenewables that engineers propose.
She added: Perhaps we shouldconsider, if we cant put smallrenewables on buildings, whetherwe should be looking at havinga levy where maybe we actuallycontribute to having a largerrenewable strategy.
A vote at the end revealed themajority of delegates disagreethat the recession will kill off therenewables market.
Debate highlights perils for renewables
Natural ventilation row promptscall from delegates for resolution
Two of the young-engineer speakers,
Mary Ann Clarke, left, and Becci Taylor
School debate: Martin Liddament, left, with John Palmer
CIBSE members grilled the young engineers for more than an hour
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
20/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com20
CIBSE national conference
nAn insight into a new draftframework to keep clients
involved in the decision-makingprocess during building design hasbeen provided by building servicesresearch group BSRIA, delegatesheard.
Soft Landings is a framework ofactivities for all key members of aproject team to work to, explainedRoderic Bunn from the group.
One of its aims is to give the
project team more information aboutclient needs and what they requirefrom the building to try to combatsome of the problems consistentlydiscovered in post-occupancyevaluations (POEs).
Users often consider the controlsystems to be dysfunctional,operating illogically as far as theoccupants are concerned, said Bunn,because information about howsystems should be operated have notbeen passed on adequately.
He added: Rarely do automatedsystems give proper feedback to theoccupants on why theyre operatingand what theyre doing.
So users find themselveslocked out of the decision-makingprocess. It alienates them and itsalways a strong sign that theyreseriously alienated when theystart breaking them. Theres anincreasing unmanageable complexityin buildings. We see this time and
time again with teachers and schooladministrators, who are givencontrol systems they simply dontunderstand.
This can leave buildings sufferingchronic under-performance that nevergets resolved. Value engineering canbe another source for problems, ascan the positioning of the schoolitself, in terms of sunlight and solargain, and poor facade engineering.
But it is hoped this new frameworkwill help resolve some of the
operating problems. Crucially, itrequires a Soft Landings team tobe on site when a building is firstopened; the design team to remaininvolved up to three years after thebuilding becomes operational; andfor the process to be client-led.
The draft framework is apartnership between BSRIA, theUsable Buildings Trust and theDarwin Consultancy.www.softlandings.org.uk
Designing building controls thatwork first time isnt as commonplaceas one might think, said Bill Bordassof the Useable Buildings Trust.
He confessed to being highlycritical of current controls systems.We sell dreams and installnightmares. Designers dont followthrough into operation and theydont pass their knowledge on. Wehave very little feedback so we do notlearn fast from emerging issues andunintended consequences.
The simple things are the onesthat the industry generally hasntgot right, he said like usingphotovoltaics but being unable to
turn the lights off.Issues like this lead to offices
and new schools using far greateramounts of energy than waspredicted, resulting in muchhigher CO2 emissions. Butsolutions do exist, Bordass said,advising engineers to improvethe transparency between designestimates and the actual energyconsumed; design controls whichusers can understand, in terms ofwhat they are and how they weredesigned to be used; find outhow the systems and controls areworking once the building is in use;and, most of all, keep it simple.
Stewart Langdown, businessdevelopment manager atTridonicAtco, agreed that simplicityis the key: Robust [design] doesntnecessarily mean something thathas been heavily engineered. Itmeans that someones thoughtabout how the technology goestogether.
Technology today is advancingat such a rate that one of the majorproblems facing the industry ishow to get end-users to controlcomplicated systems easily, headded. Technology education iskey to combating the problem, hesuggested.
Give the standardsfor energy efficientproductsGreater harmonisation of
standards across Europe is key
to getting consumers to buymore energy efficient products,said Paul Wendon, engineering
director of air solutionsmanufacturer Flkt Woods.
He insisted that legislationsuch as the Energy Using
Products Directive,which aims to reduce the
consumption by energy-usingproducts, is essential in
meeting environmental andpolitical targets and helping
manufacturers survive the
recession.We see harmonisation
of standards as key and
standardisation of products askey so we can optimise the cost
to the customer.If we continue to develop
three standards one for theUK, one for the EU and one
for the further-afield markets well start to see that we
will have a bit of a mess asmanufacturers will start to
introduce complexity where it
shouldnt be necessary.Currently manufacturersare dealing with different
regulations for the UK, Europeand the wider world.
Added to this problem aredwindling budgets and the
customers desire for thecheapest solution possible
regardless of energy efficiency.We are being asked
to innovate and developproducts with budgets that are
declining and markets that are
disappearing, Wenden said.Without legislation and
regulation, very few of theinvestments that we make to
offer you better-performing,more efficient products will
come to fruition because themarket does not phone us
every day and ask for the mostefficient solution. Today, most
of our customers phone us andask for the cheapest solution.
For manufacturers tocontinue to export their
products, they need to be ableto produce a standard product
that can be supplied to thewidest possible market, he
argued.
Clients and users of buildings
locked out of design process
Key to control systems is: keep them simple
Roderic Bunn, right, with Bill Bordass
(see report below)
Delegates learn about the
European laws affecting
building services, new
client-led strategies and
how to master controls
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
21/72
Believe it! Its here.Flkt Woods new eQ range of AHUs are
everything you imagined. And more.
The eQ AHU range from Flkt Woods is no sudden wonder
- its the result of intensive R&D and over 100 years of
experience. The range covers every possible need and
situation, from single supply air units to integrated solutions
with heat recovery and advanced controls. The features range
from show-stealing overall energy efficiency to the handy
tricks of the innovative Flkt Woods control system.
In every imaginable aspect its the best thing weve ever
pulled out of our hat.
Flkt Woods LimitedAxial Way, Colchester, Essex, C04 5ZD
t01206 222 555 f01206 222 777
esystems.uk@flaktwoods.com wwww.flaktwoods.co.uk
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
22/72
Letters
www.cibsejournal.com22 CIBSE Journal June 2009
LettersServing the powers that beThe thermodynamic garbage that constitutes
the UK Energy Bill grates a little. I refer of
course to the proposed feed-in tariffs for small-
scale, renewable energy.
It is self-evident (or should be if you
subscribe to this eminent publication) that
both the efficiency and the financial viability of
renewable technology increases with scale. Our
elected representatives are now proposing feed-
in tariffs for domestic generation, subsidising
the least-efficient form of renewable energy.
Am I overly cynical in thinking that lobbying
by major power generation companies may be
behind this, ensuring that whatever meagrefunds are available are squandered on the
least-effective technology, helping to ensure a
continuing monopoly of vested interests?
Surely our political masters cannot be that
corruptible?
Peter Hill,CEng, MCIBSE
Misleading figures on heat pumpsI note with concern figures and information
quoted in the CPD module on Heat pump
technology (Journal, May, page 59). Figure
3 of the module quotes comparative heatingmethods and operating costs. From the figures
quoted, it would appear that electricity is
purchased at 6p/kWh and oil at 78p/litre. Both
of these figures are far from reality and present
a very biased and unrealistic comparison, very
much in favour of the electric heat pump
systems proposed. Current electricity prices
available to most of the general public would
put a totally different spin on the comparative
benefits of air-source heat pumps against other
fuels.
I am also concerned that the text below
the graphs on page 61 state that with a COPbetween 3.0 and 3.6, heat pumps outperform
all other types of heating shown. I would
suggest that, with true electricity and oil prices,
heat pumps perform slightly poorer than
most fossil fuels, especially when seasonal
variations in COP are considered. In addition,
no mention is made of the cost of biomass
systems, which offer lower figures than all
of those quoted using wood chip at current
commercial figures, and provide better carbon
savings.
Michael Cade,CEng, FCIBSE
What is the true cost of renewables?After reading the Under Achievers article
in the March edition (page 26) and the item
referring to throwing renewables at buildings
to reduce the carbon footprints, I sometimes
wonder whether we have been hijacked by the
green lobbyist and our governments have been
ill advised.
I do not want to appear to be a sceptic on
renewable energies, as some Im sure are
effective, but I would like to see a data case
on the carbon offsets and the production costsin terms of carbon emissions to manufacture
the renewable energy equipment, taking into
account the sourcing and treatment of the raw
materials, production costs and life-cycles of
the equipment.
I bet that the carbon savings provided by the
renewable equipment in no way covers the
carbon emissions in the whole production,
shipping and installation process!
D Horridge,UK
Consensus ignores arguments
on carbon emissionsNick Cullen is a brave man to question the
causes of climate change, but his point is
very valid (March, page 20). The consensus
on the causes of global warming looks and
feels like a bureaucratic convenience, needed
by politicians as a policy, and reinforced by
scientists wary of their promotion prospects
or simply wanting to be on the bandwagon.
As Cullen says, the fractional increase in
CO2 concentration is not large. But even this
does not give a realistic idea of the increase
in absorption by CO2. The overlap of theCO2 absorption bands with the water vapour
absorption bands halves the net effect of any
increase and reduces it further in humid
conditions.
The consensus arguments also seem to
ignore those CO2 absorption bands where
there is already saturation absorption. Those
pointing to increased solar activity present
this point obliquely by pointing out that
the percentage increase in solar output is
comparable to the most simplistic overestimate
of the effects of CO2.
They also point out that the intensityof incoming radiation in the greenhouse
bands is orders of magnitude greater than
the intensity of reradiation from the Earths
surface in the same bands, so that an increase
in solar intensity is doubly important.
I am not saying anybody is wrong, but I
am questioning their overdeveloped sense of
rectitude and their shortness of (presented)
detail.
However, there is every reason to reduce our
energy consumption as soon as possible and
to live more efficiently fuel shortages acting
as they do on everything from food supply toforestry and every reason for being much
more careful about the way we abuse our over-
populated planet.
John MossMCIBSE (retired)
CIBSE Journalwelcomes article proposals fromany reader, wherever you are whether it beletters, longer opinion pieces, news stories,people or events listings, humorous items, or anyideas for possible articles.
Please send all letters and any other items forpossible publication to:bcervi@cibsejournal.
com, or write to Bob Cervi, Editor, CIBSE Journal,Cambridge Publishers Ltd, 275 Newmarket Road,Cambridge, CB5 8JE, UK. We reserve the right toedit all letters. Please indicate how you wish yourletter to be attributed, and whether you wish tohave your contact details included.
S
hutterstock
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
23/72
Wednesday 17 June 2009
For general enquiries,please contact Katie Chinnock:
T: +44 (0) 20 7560 4272E: katie.chinnock@ubm.com
W: bsdlive.co.uk/awards
LAST CHANCE TO BOOK!The Building Services Awards have firmly
established themselves as the biggest nightof the year in the industrys calendar the one
night you just cant miss.
Don't miss out - join us and networkwith senior professionals from across the
Building Services industry.
For sponsorship opportunitiesand table bookings,
please contact Carlo Menezes:T: +44 (0) 20 7560 4074
E: carlo.menezes@ubm.com
London Hilton, Park Lane
TO BOOK YOUR TABLE VISIT:BSDLIVE.CO.UK/AWARDS
Sponsored by
In partnership with
Organised by
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
24/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com24
Opinion
we hand them over and that means an increased role
for the post-occupancy evaluation engineer, whetheran FM or independent consultant. Post-occupancy
evaluation has the potential to inform not only the
maintenance, but the delivery of a building. It is only
through monitoring the performance of a building
when it is in use that we can determine whether it is
truly performing as intended
and meeting sustainability
targets. And, perhaps more
importantly, post-occupancy
data can help engineers
establish whether their design
assumptions were correct andinform future design choices.
We must also look even
further back into the process.
Japan, for example, has long
had a tradition of building
services design engineers
working for manufacturers
if you are aiming for
long-term sustainability,
that makes perfect sense.
Without the recruitment of
intelligent young engineers into the building services
manufacturing sector, the future innovation anddevelopment of new and existing technologies will
decline. We should be aiming for passive design
wherever possible, but our ability to source and apply
efficient plant and renewable technologies will be
central to achieving our sustainability aspirations.
I understand there used to be an air of the
old English class system about the structure of
engineering teams and everyone was expected to
know their place. In todays context, that is nonsense.
The new membership grades within CIBSE reflect
how our profession is becoming more inclusive and
our goal now must be to use this to broaden ourappeal to potential recruits.l
Why is it that so many of our buildings are
disappointing? Every project team comestogether with the best of intentions, but
too often the outcome is a letdown. I
believe much of this is due to the way that projects
are delivered.
A recent report produced by the Specialist
Engineering Alliance (SEA) and launched at the
House of Lords highlighted the fact that the inability of
the industry to work in integrated teams was making
it almost impossible for us to deliver sustainable
buildings.
Often, from the day our teams are put together, we
face an uphill struggle because the design processis not adequately inclusive. Every profession in the
chain has a critical role to play and, unless we are all
working together from day one, the implementation
will not match the design intent.
However, most young engineers attracted to the
building services profession seem to be inspired by
design work. They are excited by the opportunity of
working towards sustainable solutions and see the
front end, where the decisions are made, as the best
place to be. This has led to a traditional front loading
of the industry, with installation and commissioning
skills given secondary billing. However, the
sustainability agenda has actually increased theopportunity for engineers working on the later stages
of projects to make their mark.
We at the design end must keep our feet on the
ground and make sure the building systems we design
are easy to install, commission, operate and maintain
and the best way to make sure that happens is to
work in close collaboration with the contracting
teams, which have to implement our designs, and
the facilities managers who must keep them going
for years to come.
To meet our goals, we will have to engage the technical
knowledge and practical application skills of FMs muchearlier in the design process, which should make this
profession more attractive to potential recruits.
We also need to dramatically improve our
understanding of what happens to our designs once
Team effortWe must accept that good design alone will not deliversustainable buildings. It is the practitioners and operatorswho hold the keys, says young engineer Morwenna Wilson
Morwenna Wilsonworks for Arup and chairs the CIBSEYoung Engineers Network London Centre
Most youngengineers are
excited by the opportunityof working towardssustainable solutions andsee the front end, wherethe decisions are made,as the bestplace to be.
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
25/72
NEWITSR
EALLYNOTH
ING
BUTVISIBLY
SECURE
The new generation of metal pressfittings
with press indicator and cap.
Thanks to its press indicator, the new Mapress fitting offers a higher
level of security. In addition to the contour seal ring in every fitting, it is
now possible to check for unpressed joints even before performing
a pressure test. In addition, all of the pressfitting ends come equipped
with a cap, so the seal ring remains protected right up to the time of
installation, shielding it from contamination with dirt and dust.
Thats what we mean by Know-How Installed.
www.geberit.co.uk
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
26/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com26
Opinion
Our most pressing problem is reducing energyconsumption in existing buildings. Homes account
for 27 per cent of our total energy bill, and the building
services industry already has a whole range of
cost-effective solutions to tackle that problem. Think
how much could be achieved with winds 12bn if
it were spent on upgrading ageing heating systems;
fitting loft and cavity wall insulation; double glazing;
better heating controls; variable speed pumps,
and so on.
We could even look at a comprehensive programme
to fit whole house ventilation systems that reclaim
heat while simultaneouslyreducing the condensation
and airborne bacter ia
problems that blight so
many homes in deprived
areas.
That money could also
help to tackle fuel poverty,
which is on the rise again
after more than a decade of
falling numbers.
A fraction of those billions
could also significantly
boost the modest 45mannounced in the Budget for
small-scale renewables and
micro-generation technologies. The Renewable
Energy Association estimates that 625m would
provide a meaningful boost to the solar thermal
market and other carbon-reducing building projects,
while also delivering much quicker and more
impressive results.
It would also help to stimulate the market for
traditional building services engineering and give
employers the confidence to retain and retrain both
experienced and apprentice engineers, so preservingand creating thousands of jobs. l
The British government is forever telling us thatclimate change is the biggest issue we face,
but of the 175bn the Chancellor is borrowing
this year to prop up the public finances, only
a fraction will be spent on really getting to grips with
carbon emissions.
There is no coherent strategy for tackling our energy
problems. The government has approved 11 sites for
new nuclear power stations at an eye-watering cost of
4.5bn each, but the first of these will not be on stream
for at least 15 years assuming they are built at all.
The British Wind Energy Association also wants the
government to bail out off-shore wind farms to thetune of 2bn. Nine major projects are already in the
pipeline at a total cost of 12bn, but investors say they
will not be completed without this extra money. The
government has put a lot of faith in wind energy and
the London Array in the Thames Estuary, set to be the
worlds largest offshore wind farm, has now been given
the go-ahead. The first phase alone will cost 2.2bn
to build.
We are being held to ransom because taxpayer
support will not end with these huge construction costs.
Off-shore wind farms will also need generous public
subsidies for the next 25 years at least, if they are to
make economic sense; this is according to the energyfirms themselves, who will be raking in the profits.
Wind farms are simply not economically viable;
moreover, their carbon credentials are questionable.
Each new wind farm has to be backed up by a
conventional power station for those days when the
wind inconveniently refuses to blow. So, not only
does wind come with no guarantees, the electricity
it generates is far more expensive than our existing
supplies and could actually increase our carbon
footprint. Look at Denmark, where wind turbines cover
the countryside. Their carbon emissions, like ours, are
still rising.If the giant energy firms holding out the begging
bowl to the British taxpayer want to pull the plug
let them! We have much better things to spend the
money on.
Its a wind-upRoderick Pettigrew urges the UK government not to carryon wasting any more taxpayers money on wind power whenthe money could be better spent elsewhere
Roderick Pettigrewis deputy chief executive of the Heatingand Ventilating Contractors Association. www.hvca.org.uk
Wind farmsare simply
not economicallyviable; moreover,their carboncredentials arequestionable.
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
27/72June 2009 CIBSE Journalwww.cibsejournal.com 27
VENTILATION
ventilation syst ems
MOST EFFICIENTTHE UK's
www.titon.co.uk/hrv
Tel: 01206 713800
HEAT RECOVERY
YOU CAN FITSmall enough to fit in an airing
cupboard, the HRV1 Q Plus from
Titon is up to 91% efficient. It is
both SAP Q registered and an ESTBest Practice product and whats
more, its dead easy to install.
Download a spec sheet from ourwebsite - youll be surprised.
Call 0845 330 1047 Visit www.airflow.co.uk
Air Handling with heat recoveryImprove indoor climate with cleaner, fresher air.
Saves money too by recovering lost heat!
Air handling units with heatrecovery
Designed for schools, offices,retail and leisure facilities
Quiet, effective and efficient
Counter flow exchanger with upto 80% heat recovery
Low energy, EC fan control
Indoor and outdoor versions
1,500 m3/hr to 15,000 m3/hr
BMS controls for on-demandventilation
Incorporate into BREEAMassessments
Lochinvar Ltd 7 Lombard Way The MXL Centre Banbury Oxon OX16 4TJ
CleanerGreenerEcoForce - the latest addition to
Lochinvars range of High Efficiency
Condensing Water Heaters.
Both clean and green our EcoForce rangehas operating efficiencies up to 108%net and NOx emissions lower than15mg/kWh.
And of course, we also offer high
efficiency Condensing Boilersand Renewable packages.
W A T E R H E A T E R S | B O I L E R S
R E N E W A B L E P A C K A G E S
For details, call us on
01295 269981email info@lochinvar.ltd.uk or visit
www.lochinvar.ltd.uk
8/10/2019 CIBSE Journal 2009 06
28/72CIBSE Journal June 2009 www.cibsejournal.com28
Legal
and their family at risk; and they may also be liable in
a civil court if there is an accident and others sufferloss. In addition, a gas safety check must be carried
out annually.
Landlords must issue a gas safety certificate to each
of their tenants within 28 days
of the check being completed
and to any new tenants before
they move in. Records must
be kept for at least two years.
Landlords must also show
tenants how to turn off the gas
supply in the event of a gas
leak.Employers or the self-
employed have duties under
health and safety law when
engaging someone to work on
gas fittings. In the event of a
gas-related incident, the HSE will look at the checks
made by the employer to ensure that the work was
being carried out by someone legally competent to
do so.
Everyone engaged in the procurement of gas-
related work needs to be familiar with the rules,
ready to use the new facilities for checking technician
qualifications and, if need be, use the facility on theGas Safe Register website to report anyone working
illegally.
In addition, the HSE strongly recommends the use
of carbon monoxide alarms to detect the presence of
the highly toxic gas, which can be produced by gas
appliances. On average 25 people a year die from
carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning, and many more
suffer health problems from CO exposure directly
related to gas.
Alarms should comply with BS EN 50291 and
carry a British or European approval mark. But such
alarms are not a substitute for regular maintenanceand safety checks.
l
On 1 April 2009 the Gas Safe Register
replaced CORGI as the approvedscheme for gas installers in Great Britain
and the Isle of Man under the Gas
Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998.
These state that no person shall carry out any work
in relation to a gas fitting or gas storage vessel unless
he is competent to do so. That competence is based
on belonging to a scheme approved by the Health
and Safety Executive (HSE). Gas Safe is now the only
approved scheme for gas technicians.
While most gas work is in domestic premises,
this change affects anyone procuring gas work.
Consultants and contractors need to understand thenew rules, as they have duties under the Health and
Safety at Work etc Act when appointing anyone to
undertake gas work. It is also particularly relevant
to residential landlords who must, by law, have gas
appliances in flats and lodgings inspected.
With some 40 people a year killed or injured in
gas explosions, and 14 people dying from carbon
monoxide (CO) poisoning in 2008 due to badly
installed, repaired and maintained gas appliances,
this is a matter of life and death.
The regulations require that anyone employed
to work on any gas fitting be a Gas Safe-registered
technician. The term gas fitting covers gas pipework,valves, regulators and meters, and any other fittings,
apparatus and appliances designed for use by
consumers of gas for heating, including portable
heaters, lighting, cooking or other non-industrial
purposes.
All Gas Safe-registered technicians have ID cards
confirming their registration and show which fittings
and appliances they are qualified to work on.
The Gas Safe Register has routine monitoring
procedures for those registered, and for investigating
complaints over gas work. Anyone can nominate
work done for them for inspection via the Gas Safewebsite.
It is not an offence for a householder to engage
an unregistered technician to work on their own
appliances, although they may be putting themselves
Consultants andcontractors need
to understand the newrules, as they have duties
under the healthand safetylegislation.
Fit for purposeNow that CORGI is no longer with us, how can specifiersof gas appliances ensure that these are being fitted safely?Hywel Daviesexplains the new accreditation scheme
Hywel Daviesis techni