Post on 15-Jul-2015
transcript
Discussion Points What are Derivatives: An Introduction
Global growth of Derivatives
Domestic Derivatives Market
Overview of different types of derivatives Forwards Futures Options
Derivatives Defined An instrument whose value is derived from
another security or any other variable
Is has no independent value
The underlying could be financial instruments, metals, agri products, oil etc.
Example
Dependence on other variables and pre-defined nature of contract make it an excellent vehicle for managing risk
In the preceding example: Wheat was the underlying asset
The predefined contract provides certainty to both the farmer and the baker about the future proceeds and help them mitigate risk associated with uncertainty
Development and Growth of Derivatives Market Increase in Macroeconomic instability during the crisis of
1970s
Oil crisis of 1970s exposed the financial systems to the risk inherent in commodities
Collapse of Bretton Woods system that led to most currencies adopting free-float exchange rate
Increased currency risk
Increased Globalization of Business Activities resulting in higher foreign trade and a need for managing FX exposure
First Option Pricing formula was given by Black Scholes in 1970
Markets were flooded with various refined and sophisticated and complex derivative pricing models
Advanced computation facilities
Derivatives Contract
Primarily of 2 kinds
Traded on Exchange (organized derivatives trading)
Traded on OTC (unorganized trading)
OTC is a generic term used for the market outside the exchange
Derivatives in India Exchange Traded Equity Derivatives (derivatives
whose value is dependent on equities / stocks) – Launched in year 2000
Index Derivatives (underlying is an Index like Nifty or Sensex) – Launched in year 2001
The most preferred products Single stock futures account for about 55% of total
volume Nifty Futures account for about 35% of total volume
Commodity Derivatives Commodity Derivatives are contracts where the
underlying asset is a commodity like oil, gold, metals etc.
FCRA – Forward Contract Regulation Act governs Commodity Derivatives in India
Two nationwide online commodity exchanges NCDEX – National Commodity and Derivatives
exchange (mostly agri products are traded)
MCX – Multi Commodity Exchange (trading mostly bullion, metals and energy products)
Currency Derivatives Underlying asset is currency of a country
Recently launched in India
OTC currency derivative market large and active
Participation is mainly by Banks who trade on behalf of their clients (mostly companies)
Interest Rate Derivatives Value is derived from future interest rates
Underlying instrument is Interest Rate
Might be launched in India in coming years
Active in OTC market
Need for Derivative Products
Need for products which can be used to mitigate risk exposure
To guard against uncertainties arising out of fluctuations in asset prices
Products that work in both domestic as well as in the global markets
Types of derivatives Derivative Products Case Studies on application of derivatives Forwards Contracts Disadvantages and Advantages Futures Contract Forwards versus Futures: Comparison
Chart
Derivatives Products
Products UnderlyingEquity Derivative StocksCommodity Derivative Metals, Bullion, OilExchange Rate Derivative Exchange RateInterest rate Derivative Interest RatesIndex Derivative Market Index (e.g. Nifty)
Illustrations Example 1.
Scenario - Tata Steel plans to obtain bank loan of INR 500 crores two months from now
Risk – Interest Rate uncertainty
If interest rate climbs by 1% Tata Steel will have to pay additional INR 5 crores for the loan (1% on 500 crores)
Solution: The company would like to lock in the prevailing interest rate for obtaining the loan using an interest rate derivative contract and hedge the risk exposure
Example 2.
Scenario – An investor expects a cash outflow of INR 50 thousand one month from now
To meet the cash requirement she has to sell a part of her portfolio (say shares of Stock X)
Stock X is currently trading at INR 1000 (she is required to sell 50 stocks to make the payment)
Risk – Asset price (Stock Volatility) uncertainty
If price of the stock falls to INR 900 after one month she will have to sell 56 shares resulting in further liquidation of her portfolio
Solution – She would like to lock in the prevailing market price using a equity derivative contract and hedge the risk exposure today rather than wait for one month and suffer loss from adverse price movements
Example 3.
Scenario – A company providing IT services (mainly exporting to US) would sell product worth USD 50 million in 3 months from now. Prevailing exchange rate is INR 50 per USD.
So, after three months the company will get a cash inflow of INR 250 crores from selling the product
Risk – Exchange Rate Risk
If after three months the Rupee appreciates to INR 45 / dollar. The company would make a loss of INR 25 crores
Solution – The company would like to lock in the prevailing exchange rate using currency derivative contract and hedge the risk exposure today rather than wait for three month and suffer loss from exchange rate movements
Example 4.
Scenario – A domestic airlines company needs to import 2 million barrels of oil for meeting operational requirements in two months from now.
Oil is trading at $65/bbl in the international market and INR USD exchange rate is INR 45/USD.
Company is required to have approx INR 585 crores to purchase oil
Risk – Oil price risk and exchange rate risk
If after two months Oil prices rise to $75/bbl and exchange rate moves to INR 50/ USD, the company would end up paying INR 750 crores (excess of INR 165 crores) to purchase 2MMbbl oil.
Solution – The company would like to lock in the prevailing spot price of Oil ($65/bbl) in the international markets using commodity derivatives on oil.
Further, the company shall use currency derivatives to sell INR and buy USD two months in future at the prevailing exchange rate of INR45/$.
The strategy will help the company to hedge the risk exposure of the firm from any uncertain movement in asset price or exchange rate.
Forward Contract Agreement to buy/sell (transact) an asset
at a pre-determined price and quantity on a pre-specified date in future
Price, quantity and date are pre-specified at the time of entering into the contract (generally spot unless and otherwise specified)
The contract is obligatory in nature and default warrants legal action
Terminologies
Technically speaking:
The party agreeing to buy the asset assumes a Long position
The party agreeing to sell the asset assumes a Short position
Contract is traded off-exchange i.e. in the OTC market and settlement takes place as per mutual agreements (pre-decided terms and conditions)
Customization of contract along with risk hedging makes it an attractive product
No standardization of terms and condition is required for forward contracts
Example (asset/goods)
Party A <<<<<<< Party B Buyer Seller Long Position Short Position
T = After 2 months (specific date)P = @ INR 350/unitQ = 100 units
Contrary to spot contracts T, P and Q are pre-determined. At the time of delivery the goods and cash shall exchange hands.
Common concerns while using forward contracts
Two major risks involved in Forward Contracts:
1/ Liquidity
No secondary market
Customization makes it a non-standard product
Trading happens on a one-on-one basis
Non-availability on exchange makes it extremely difficult to locate counterparty for transaction
2/ Default Risk
No exchange driven clearing and settlement procedure
Adverse price movements might tempt either counterparty to dishonor the contract
At any time, only one counter-party has the incentive to default
In the previous example if the spot price after two months rises to INR 400/unit, seller would gain by selling on spot and shall default on the contract
Advantages of Forward Contracts No listing requirement
Activity is highly customized and negotiable (non-standardized)
Counterparties can mutually decide upon What to trade (asset / product and type) Where to trade (delivery location) How much to trade (quantity) What price to trade (price) When to trade (date)
No transaction cost, taxes etc.
No margin requirement
Futures Contract
Agreement to buy/sell (transact) an asset at a pre-determined price and quantity on a pre-specified date in future
Price, quantity and date are pre-specified at the time of entering into the contract
The contract is obligatory in nature and default warrants for legal action
Understanding Futures Contract w.r.t. Forward Contracts
Exchange traded forward contracts
Standardized forward contracts
Attractive for large set of market participants
High liquidity
No counter-party risk or default risk as counterparty is the exchange itself
Comparison ChartFutures Forwards
Default Risk: Borne by Clearinghouse Borne by Counter-Parties
What to Trade: Standardized Negotiable
The Forward/Futures Agreed on at Time Agreed on at TimePrice of Trade Then, of Trade. Payment at
Marked-to-Market Contract Termination
Where to Trade: Standardized Negotiable
When to Trade: Standardized Negotiable
Liquidity Risk: Clearinghouse Makes it Cannot Exit as Easily:Easy to Exit Commitment Must Make an Entire
New Contrtact
How Much to Trade: Standardized Negotiable
What Type to Trade: Standardized Negotiable
Margin Required Collateral is negotiable
Typical Holding Pd. Offset prior to delivery Delivery takes place
One major advantage of Futures contract over Forward contracts
Complication of final settlement if the contract is traded subsequently can be avoided in Futures contract
Futures market would account the net final positions and declare two counterparties thereby facilitating hassle free transaction
Key Terminologies Forward Contract Futures Contract Long Position Short Position Underlying OTC Mark-to-market Hedgers Speculators Arbitragers
Commonly Traded futures contracts
Index Futures
Single stock futures
Interest Rate Futures
Commodity Futures
Futures on Financial Assets At any time three Futures contract trade in the market on
Stock Futures and Index Futures
1 month, 2 months and 3 months
E.g. November Futures, December Futures and January Futures
Futures contract expire on the last Thursday of the month. E.g. Nov Futures contract will expire on Thursday, 20 Nov 08.
On expiry a new 3 month contract is formed, the 2 months contract becomes the 1 month contract and 3 months contract becomes the 2 months contract
Positions Opening a Position
Having a long or short position in a contract. Eg. Mr X shorts 5 Jan Futures contracts on
Infosys
Outstanding or unsettled long or short positions
Closing a Position Buying or selling a contract that results in the
reduction of open positions e.g. Buying or selling two contra futures E.g. Mr X longs 5 Jan Futures contacts on
Infosys
Terminologies Basis – Spot Price minus the Futures Price
Spread – Difference between the prices of two futures contract
Cost of Carry – The cost incurred to finance the trading in derivatives. E.g. transaction cost, opportunity cost (interest lost on the balance in the margin account), storage cost (physical commodities) etc.
Open Interest Open Interest: Number of outstanding and unsettled
positions in a contract
Total number of contracts that have not expired or squared-off
Contract specific measure
Total of long position would exactly offset total of short positions and hence only one side of the contract is counted for the purpose of calculating the open interest
Interpretation of Open Interest Indicates level of trading activity in the F&O
segment of the underlying security
E.g. Sudden increase in Open Interest indicates increase in security’s volatility in near term on account of corporate news (insider)
Open Interest indicates that new money is flowing into the marketplace
General Interpretations of OI An increase in Open Interest along with an increase in
price is said to confirm an upward trend (market is strong)
An decrease in Open Interest along with a rise in price is said to confirm (signals) a downward trend
An increase in Open Interest along with decrease in price indicates market is weak
A decrease in both Open interest and Prices indicates market is strengthening
Volume Trading activity in the market with regard
to a specific contract, over a period of time, e.g. a day, a week or the entire life of the contact
Defined in terms of either: Number of contracts traded during a specific
period of time, or
Value of all the contracts traded
Open Interest and Volume Increase in Open Interest along with increase in volume
when prices rise indicates that more traders likely entering long positions
Thumb rules for interpreting changes in volume and open interest in futures market: Rising Vol. and rising OI confirms a trend Rising Vol. and falling OI indicates position
liquidation Falling Vol. and rising OI indicates cautious and
slow accumulation Falling Vol. and falling OI depicts a congestion
phase
Daily Price Movement Limits – Price Band
Daily Price Movement Limits are specified by the exchange for every contract
If the price hits lower limit it is called Limit Down
If the price hits upper limit it is called Limit Up
Normally trading ceases for the day in that contract once the contract is limit up or limit down
Purpose of limits is to prevent large price movements occurring because of speculative excess
What do Futures Prices indicate? Futures are normally traded daily as stocks
and laws of supply and demand apply to arrive at the price of the contract
Assume a Nifty November 2008 Futures Contract is trading at 3123 on 10 Nov 2008. What does that indicate?
As the contract is trading for the settlement on the last Thursday of November 2008, the trading level of 3123 indicates that at the close of market on expiry, the market expects the cash index to settle at 2989
All market participants seek to predict the cash index level at contract maturity
This results in price discovery of the cash index at a specific point
Futures prices are essentially the expected cash prices of the underlying asset at the maturity of the futures contract
Convergence of Futures Price to Spot Price Futures price converge to spot price as the
expiry approaches
On expiry the futures price equals the spot price and all futures contract are settled at the underlying cash market settlement price
Non convergence would result in an arbitrage opportunity
Convergence of Futures Price to Spot Price
Example of an Arbitrage:
Suppose the futures price is above the spot price at expiry. The arbitragers would Short a futures contract Buy the asset Deliver the assets
Margin Requirement Futures contract settlement on the exchange is the
responsibility of the exchange clearing house
To minimize the default risk on a contract due to unfavorable price movements the exchange mandates the counterparties to deposit a minimum amount as specified by the exchange
The amount is deposited in the margin account
This minimum amount deposited at the time of contract initiation is called the Initial Margin
Margin requirements might vary depending upon the volatility in the markets. Securities can also be deposited in lieu of cash.
Minimum initial margins on different positions are prescribed by the clearing house based on specified risk algorithm using Standard Portfolio Analysis of Risk (SPAN)
Maintenance Margin – Minimum margin level to be always maintained in the margin account
MM requirement is lower than the initial margin and it ensures that the margin account never becomes negative
If the margin account falls below the MM, investor receives a margin call and is expected to top up the margin account to the Initial Margin level the next day
The extra funds deposited are known as Variation Margin
Margin account is adjusted at the end of each trading day considering the day’s closing price to reflect the investor’s gain or loss. This practice is referred to as Marking to Market
Non paying of the variation margin results in closing out (liquidation) of the position by the broker
The purpose of margining system is to reduce the possibility of market participants sustaining losses because of defaults
Losses arising from defaults in contacts at major exchanges have been almost nonexistent
Using margins the risk is divided into smaller pieces daily
The losses are collected from the losers and given to the gainers
Pay-in and Pay-out happens on T+1 basis
V-a-R model is used to estimate potential losses on any given day using certain confidence interval (probability)
V-a-R also helps deciding the margin limits (SPAN)
Margin Calculation and Margin Call E.g. ICICI Futures – Lot size is 700 shares and
Futures Price is INR 430/ share
Initial Margin (10% of contract value) – INR 30,100/ contract
Let us say; A buys 4 contracts on 07 Nov 2008 B sells 4 contracts on 07 Nov 2008
A and B pay INR 120,400 as Initial Margin
MM is 75% of IM – INR 90,300
IM = INR 120,400MM = INR 90,300
DateFutures Price (INR) Daily Gain(Loss)
Cumulative Gain (Loss)
Margin Account Balance Margin Call
430.00 120,40007 Nov 2008 435.00 14,000.00 14,000.00 134,400.0010 Nov 2008 438.00 8,400.00 22,400.00 142,800.0011 Nov 2008 426.00 -33,600.00 -11,200.00 109,200.0012 Nov 2008 420.00 -16,800.00 -28,000.00 92,400.0013 Nov 2008 398.00 -61,600.00 -89,600.00 30,800.00 89,600.0014 Nov 2008 405.00 19,600.00 -70,000.00 140,000.0017 Nov 2008 405.00 0 -70,000.00 140,000.0018 Nov 2008 403.00 -5,600.00 -75,600.00 134,400.0019 Nov 2008 385.00 -50,400.00 -126,000.00 84,000.00 36,400.0020 Nov 2008 398.00 36,400.00 -89,600.00 156,800.00
Margin Calculation for A
Assumptions No transaction costs and taxes
Market participants can borrow money at the same risk-free rate of interest
Borrowing rates equal lending rates
Arbitrage opportunities are exploited as they occur
No income is accrued on the asset like dividend etc.
No storage costs
Forward and futures prices are same
Notations T: time until expiry
S0: Spot price of the underlying asset
F0: Futures / Forward price today
r: Risk free rate of interest per annum, expressed with continuous compounding
Pay-off from Futures Contract
Pay-off is like profit/loss accruing to the investor
Since the contracts are MTM on a daily basis pay-offs are calculated based on the change in the market price of the contract daily
Pay-off from Long Futures: Unlimited gain if the prices rise and huge
losses if prices decline
Pay-off from Short Futures: Huge gains if the prices fall and
unlimited losses if the prices rise
Pricing Futures
F = S0e^(rT)
r is cost of financing using continuous compounding
T is time till expiration
Example:
Security XYZ Ltd trades in the spot market at INR 1150. Assuming risk free rate to be 3% p.a. Calculate the fair value (theoretical value) of the 2 months futures contract (assume the security to be non dividend paying). INR 1156
Strategies open to an arbitrageur if the futures price is: INR 1175 or, INR 1140
Strategy, if futures price @ INR 1170: Cash and Carry Arbitrage
Step 1/ : Borrow INR 1150 at risk-free rate
Step 2/ : Invest the proceeds to buy the underlying asset at INR 1150
Step 3/ : Short 2 month futures contract to sell the asset for INR 1175
Gain from the strategy: INR 25 is the gain on price differential INR 6 is the interest paid on borrowed amount INR 19 is the overall gain { F - S0e^(rT) }
Strategy, if futures price @ INR 1140: Reverse Cash and Carry Arbitrage
Step 1/ : Sell the security on spotStep 2/ : Invest the proceeds at risk-free rateStep 3/ : Take a long position in a two month
futures contract for INR 1140
Gain from the strategy: INR 6 is the risk-free interest earned Price differential INR(1150-1140) = INR 10 INR 16 is the overall gain { S0e^(rT) - F }
So if;
F > S0e^(rT) {buy the asset and short the forward contract on the asset} – Contango
F < S0e^(rT) {sell the asset and long the forward contract} – Backwardation
The price should be equal to INR 1156 for no arbitrage opportunity to exist
Cash and Carry Arbitrage prevents futures prices from being above the theoretical price
Reverse cash and carry arbitrage prevents prices from dipping below the theoretical price
Example: Non dividend paying stock trading at INR
120
Risk free rate is 5%
Calculate the fair value of 1 year forward contract
Strategy if the forward price is INR 128?
1/ Borrow INR 120 at 5%2/ Invest to buy the stock on spot3/ Sell the one year forward @ INR 128
Gain: Price differential less interest INR (8 – 6) = INR 2 per contract
Application of Futures: Key Strategies Hedging: Long Security, sell futures
Speculation: Bullish security, buy futures
Speculation: Bearish security, sell futures
Arbitrage: Overpriced futures: buy spot, sell futures
Arbitrage: Underpriced futures: buy futures, sell spot
Short Hedging: Long Security, sell futures Investor holding a stock sees the current price falling
from INR 450 to INR 390
In the absence of stock futures he would sell the security (or suffer from hypertension)
Using security futures he can minimize his price risk
Sell a futures contract to off-set the downside risk due to the fall in stock price
Index futures can be effectively used to get rid of the market risk of the portfolio – Long Portfolio + Short Nifty
Speculation: Bullish security, buy futures Futures provide a high leverage on
investment
A speculator is bullish on a stock and decides to buy securities to take the advantage of price rise. Invests INR 100,000 (100 shares * 1000/share)
One month later the price rises to INR 1010, his profit is INR 1,000 on INR 100,000 investment (i.e. return of 6%)
Other speculator takes the same position using one futures contract trading at 1006. Assume contract value is INR 100,600 (100 shares/contract) and approx 20% is the margin i.e. INR 20,000
On expiry the contract closes on INR 1010 (equal to spot price) providing a profit of INR 400 (i.e. annual return of 12% on INR 20,000 invested)
Speculation: Bearish security, sell futures
What if a speculator finds an overvalued stock?
How can he trade based on his opinion?
Sell stock futures
If his prediction is correct the spot price would fall
Arbitragers would ensure that futures price move closely to that of the spot price
If spot prices fall futures are most likely to experience a fall as well
Since the speculator takes a short position he shall benefit from the fall in the futures price
Arbitrage: Overpriced futures: buy spot, sell futures Cost of carry ensures that the futures price
stay in tune with the spot price
If the futures price deviates from the spot arbitrage opportunity arise
E.g. ABC Ltd trading at INR 1000 and ABC Futures trading at INR 1025
Strategies for an arbitrageur ?
Borrow funds at risk free rate and buy the security
Simultaneously, sell the futures at INR 1025
Hold the security till expiry
On expiry the prices will converge
Say on expiry spot price is INR 1015, sell the security. Profit INR 15 from sale in spot position
Futures expire with a profit of INR 10
Overall profit is INR 25 minus the interest cost
Return the borrowed funds
Cost of borrowing must be less than the price differential
What if the futures price is below the spot price?
How would an arbitrager benefit from the opportunity?