Post on 05-Apr-2022
transcript
iii
DETERMINATION OF THE EFFECT ON GAIT ASYMMETRY IN THE LONG-TIME RUNNING
2019, Jun. Student: Peng, Li-yao
Advisor: Shiang, Tzyy-Yuang
Abstract Most of previous gait asymmetry studies collected few gait cycles in a laboratory.
Besides, the research of asymmetry usually focused on patients and athletes. The
change in gait asymmetry during long-time outdoor running in general health group
needed to be further clarified. Purpose: To determine the effect of long-time outdoor
running on gait asymmetry in general health group. Method: Fifteen participants run
at 75% of maximum speed for 30-minutes outdoors. Five Inertial Measurement Unit
sensors were fixed on upper limbs, lower limbs, and trunk to calculate asymmetry index.
One way ANOVA with repeated measures was used to assess the change in gait
asymmetry during 30-minutes running. Result: The results showed that the asymmetry
index reduced with fatigue. Conclusion: The gait in general health group is more
symmetry with fatigue during 30-minutes running.
Keywords: Asymmetry index Functional gait asymmetry Outdoor track
iv
p
……………………………………………………………………………… R
R
R
d … &
……… &
r &
&
(
o (
o )
d ……………… ……………………p …………………… …
r o y …………………………………………… ………………………………………………………… …
……………………
e a &
d i &
d &
(
r )
z
v
…………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………
o ……………………………o o ……………………
d …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… ……… &
………………………………………………………………………………………………… &
d ………………………………………… &
………………………………………………………… &
r ……………………………………………… &
vi
o y ………… ………………………………………… ………
………… ………………………………………… ………
e o e …………………… ………………
& e o e …………………………… …
又 e o e …… ………………………………… &
( 又 e o e …… ………… ……… ……
) p IMU i o o ……..…..&
p IMU k o o …… … &&
p IMU o o …… … &
p IMU z o o … &(
p IMU i o o …………&)
p IMU k o o ... &
p IMU o o ... &
& p IMU z o o
又 p IMU i o o …
( 又 p IMU k o o …
) 又 p IMU o o …
又 p IMU z o o … &
又 p IMU i o o
又 p IMU k o o … (
又 p IMU o o …….…… )
又 p IMU z o o
vii
15 ................................................................................15
15 ..................................................................................16
............................................................................................18
& o .........................................................................................19
…………...........................................................................20
& z人 ………………………………… ……… 21
& 下 .......................................................26
& 下 ..................................................27
& & 又 下 ...............................................................28
& 又 下 ...............................................................29
1
u V 。上 V V
i : X , g
V g ,
(Lee et al., 2017)V p V
bz 了 V
V g o V X
V o、 o o
e (Van Mechelen, 1992)V
p V X
o uV & to
V 人 V o
i o V
o Vg
(Ferber, Davis, Hamill, & Pollard, 2003; Rumpf et al., 2014; Zifchock, Davis, &
Hamill, 2006)V o V
o V 下 V
o 下 (Carpes, Mota, & Faria, 2010; Zifchock,
Davis, Higginson, McCaw, & Royer, 2008)V V o
e p X o o
V o V
o (Carpes et al., 2010)V
? V 了 pV o jV
2
X
V o ㄧ i V
iV (Kaufman, Miller, &
Sutherland, 1996; Laroche, Cook, & Mackala, 2012)X V
go V , V
g o V V
o V V , V。上
V V
(Potdevin, Gillet, Barbier, Coello, & Moretto, 2008;
Sadeghi, Allard, & Duhaime, 1997; Sadeghi, Allard, Prince, & Labelle, 2000)X u
o m 了 V z V
V (Pierotti,
Brand, Gabel, Pedersen, & Clarke, 1991; Plotnik, Bartsch, Zeev, Giladi, & Hausdorff,
2013)V i f f V
V V i 二
V g V f f
o (Radzak, Putnam, Tamura, Hetzler, & Stickley, 2017; Robadey, Schween,
Gehring, & Staudenmann, 2013; Staudenmann, Robadey, Lorenzetti, & Taube, 2013)X
V V
一 V
(Ammann, Taube, & Wyss, 2015; Ammann, Taube, & Wyss,
2017)V V o o 下V
Vo 下 -N JM PT .Nu BJ KK 5BPTIBN
X -JJ KK V y
e o o 三
X V eV o
3
三 (Ammann et al., 2015)V 2018 g
(Hanley & Tucker, 2018)X 了 e
o 三 V X
V m
fV 力 o
V X fg
Inertial Measurement Unit, IMU) 上 Vo
V i o
o (Brandes, Zijlstra,
Heikens, van Lummel, & Rosenbaum, 2006; Butte, Ekelund, & Westerterp, 2012; Chen,
Janz, Zhu, & Brychta, 2012)V i (Chan,
Estève, Fourniols, Escriba, & Campo, 2012; Reilly et al., 2008)V V
V e V
e o X
e o 三 V 了
V jV V
g (Luca, 1983; Noakes, 2000; Van Gheluwe & Madsen,
1997)X V f
X
o 了 i V
V i V
g V
i z V V
4
V e o X
d
eV o
三
V Y
eV V o X
r
20~30 V o
o o X
V V
V X
Y z Vz (Stance
phase) (Swing phase)V 、
V 、 (Novacheck, 1998)X
o Y 上 pV
下 V o (Gabbard, 1997)X
d Y RPE 17 f (Hanley &
Tucker, 2018)X
6
人。上 一 V o
V o U &
Vt V p 人
X
o
人 七 V g
一 V p 一 V
o V ? f V Y
。上 iV a iVi 15~20%V
3.7%V(Kaufman et al., 1996; Laroche et al., 2012)V
V p
(Clanton & Wood, 2010; Griffin, Olney, & McBride, 1995; James
& Jones, 1990; Laroche et al., 2012; Paschalis et al., 2007; Plotnik, Giladi, Balash,
Peretz, & Hausdorff, 2005)V z V f f
o V o c s
Sadeghi o V p。上
o o V V
V 了 V
p V g o V m
: (Potdevin et al., 2008; Sadeghi et al., 1997; Sadeghi et al., 2000)X
7
o
o V p V
一V
X f V i
e V f f
o (Radzak et al., 2017; Robadey et al., 2013;
Staudenmann et al., 2013)X
V o o 下V
V o 下 (Lee, Sutter, Askew, & Burkett, 2010;
Radzak et al., 2017)X Ammann V
e i y V y o 三
V V HJV o 下 三 X
o 下 o V
。上 a
-JJ KK BP I V g
y V V
下 0 KIB 9 HBN X
e o V V f
V V f o
人 V V
e o V
X
8
d
V jV 上 Y a
e f ~ ~
V(Luca, 1983; Noakes, 2000; Van
Gheluwe & Madsen, 1997)V a e
(Cowley, Dingwell, & Gates, 2014)V p
jX
V e V
aVMarchetti V o
V 十 a i
(Marchetti, Orselli, & Duarte, 2013); Seeley V
a f Vg 十 V e
V ? V eV Y
V e (Seeley, Umberger, & Shapiro, 2008)X
V 了 V m z Vo
V a 三
(Brown, Zifchock, & Hillstrom, 2014)X
p
z z f (Perry &
Burnfield, 2010)V z
V V
1990 e 了 也
(Willemsen, van Alsté, & Boom, 1990)V o
。上 kVo V
9
X (Kavanagh & Menz, 2008)V
V o o V bz V
m o o V
o g 。上f Vg
Vn 人 f X(Lee et al.,
2015)
r o y
o V y
o ik V y
V y V o y
V8 4 Vz V
ik V ik o V
了 8L K LK 0BNTL 6
) X
!" = [%&'](*+,).
× 100 y
? V zj f V o
V y V ik V
o V o ik 3 N J K A -N JM PT
.N BJ KK , 3K M H . J K 2LKB 0 NN ; K X
2!"(%) = |(%&')|(%6')
78× 100 y
Vg K I
o V y dV N I
K I 5 H BNG .L B )& X
9"(%) = :1 − %'< × 100 y d
10
L BR y P - JJBPN - V
y V8 4 X L BR 7ILPK H
7BNBPT I A 0 ALN ) X
=>(%) = :?@ %'< × 100 y
f y V y
f l V V p y
y y V Vo V
ik V y o X
o z V o m
o X e
p o V X
V V V
了 o V X
11
.
.
ASI = % |Xr − Xl|1/2(01 + 03)5 × 100
1 3
Knapik et al. (1991)
Karamanidis et al. (2003)
Zifchock et al (2006)
Błażkiewicz et al.(2014)
Gouwanda et al (2011, 2015)
SI = [R − L](< + =)
2× 100
1 3
Robinson et al. (1987)
Cuk et al. (2001)
Alex Shortera (2007)
Lee et al. (2009)
Błażkiewicz et al.(2014)
RI = >1 − 0103? × 100 1 3
2
Ganguli et al. (1974)
Seliktar et al. (1986)
Błażkiewicz et al.(2014)
12
Ga = 100 × B3C <_EF=_EFB 1 3 Yogev et al. (2007)
Plotnik et al. (2005, 2013)
Błażkiewicz et al.(2014)
13
P
15 。 □St s
; f &
k 2cm (3.7%) f k 10%
i
」 P P 「
2
P D-
( ) ( v) ( ) o
(%)
i ( /k )
23.2±2.6 175.8±5.1 71.4±10.4 4.0±2.5 16.3±1.7
_ P
) f
, &
P
f & & k 2
v (3.7%) (Kaufman et al., 1996)
14
_Pf
(S4pro, Biodex, US) f
( :&□ 60 & □ 3
5 □ 30 3 s i 5 p
i k 3
k 10% (Vagenas & Hoshizaki, 1991)
n
eP i
i g 8.5km/h 3 v上
9.7km/h & ) i 30 s 0.5km/h 「
l m f □ v
v (Scott & Houmard, 1994)
e P
P
IMU (IM, Shimmer, USA)s e
e □ 150 Hz m
o (Ahmed, Mehmood,
Nadeem, Mehmood, & Rizwan, 2017; Giggins, Kelly, & Caulfield, 2013; Guzsvinecz,
Szucs, & Sik, 2015; Lin & Kulić, 2012) v ( g Pf P二 5
g ( P f ( k p
二 ( (L3~L4) 3-1 R S &
X & □ □ X P
□ Y P 「 □ Z : & □ X Ps
18
P
_
P 」
t P
□So & ( ) □
( P二 ) e &P: & P「
po p ( P ) ( i P k P
P v ) a o
3-5
「 七 10 上
Matlab 2015 y
(Butterworth low pass filter 10 Hz) Gouwanda Arosha
Senanayake (2011) y f e
&P: & po ( P ) v □S
i P k P v
v
19
y S
!"#$%(") =!(") − !%*"!%+, − !%*"
+ 1
S(n) n ; !max i ; !min
k
o S (ASI) □o fS
012(%) = |(5 − 6)|(5 + 6)
28× 100
SR ; L
o 一S v上 v□r 一 (0%P25%P50%P75%P100%)
v f
&Po 一
20
P v
SPSS for windows 22.0 v
v v o 一
Bonferroni □ α = .05 η2 i .14
□ & & (Rosenthal, Cooper, & Hedges, 1994)
21
P
f p o y
v力 o ( P「
) 2 v ( P ) 3 (g P二 Pf )
6 (A-x PA-y PA-z 「 & G-x / PG-y s
/ PG-z s/ : &) 4 ( i P k P
v ) o (ASI.) o &
&v□S0%□ P100%□ v□ 25%P50%P75%
& P v力
22
o 「 P Po g Pf P二 Pv
P P . LP. MP. NP1 LP1 MP1 N i P
k P P v o & e t
o 一s o i £ o
k ¤ 一 gf
ik *N - η2 □ partial
eta square
P「 f & o 一f
Straight Stance Swing
A-x A-y A-z A-x A-y A-z
g
Max - - - - - ¤η2.31
Min - - - - - -
Mean - - - - - ¤η2.38
Int - - - - - ¤η2.31
Straight Stance Swing
A-x A-y A-z A-x A-y A-z
f
Max - - - - - -
Min - - - - - -
Mean - - ¤η2.23 ¤η2.23 - -
Int - - ¤η2.24 - ¤η2.20 -
Straight Stance Swing
A-x A-y A-z A-x A-y A-z
二
Max - - - - - -
Min - - - - - -
Mean ¤η2.22 - - ¤η2.24 - -
Int - - ¤η2.39 - - ¤η2.33
£ i; ¤ k; - 一s
; η2 eta square ; Max i ; Min k ; Mean ; Int
v
23
&P「 f : & o 一f
Straight Stance Swing
G-x G-y G-z G-x G-y G-z
g
Max - - - - ¤η2.21 -
Min ¤η2.25 ¤η2.23 - - - -
Mean ¤η2.25 - - ¤η2.21 - ¤η2.23
Int - ¤η2.24 - - - -
Straight Stance Swing
G-x G-y G-z G-x G-y G-z
f
Max - - - £η2.32 ¤η2.24 -
Min ¤η2.25 - ¤η2.39 - - -
Mean - - - ¤η2.25 - -
Int - ¤η2.24 - - - -
Straight Stance Swing
G-x G-y G-z G-x G-y G-z
二
Max - - - - - -
Min - - - - - -
Mean - - ¤η2.29 - - ¤η2.31
Int - - ¤η2.27 - - ¤η2.20
£ i; ¤ k; - 一s
; η2 eta square ; Max i ; Min k ; Mean ; Int
v
24
P f & o 一f
Curved Stance Swing
A-x A-y A-z A-x A-y A-z
g
Max - - ¤η2.28 - ¤η2.14 -
Min - - - ¤η2.21 - -
Mean - - - - - -
Int - - - - - ¤η2.28
Curved Stance Swing
A-x A-y A-z A-x A-y A-z
f
Max - - ¤η2.28 - - -
Min - - ¤η2.23 - - -
Mean - - - - ¤η2.21 -
Int - - - - ¤η2.45 -
Curved Stance Swing
A-x A-y A-z A-x A-y A-z
二
Max - - - - - -
Min - - - - - -
Mean - £η2.17 - - - ¤η2.22
Int - - - - - ¤η2.31
£ i; ¤ k; - 一s
; η2 eta square ; Max i ; Min k ; Mean ; Int
v
25
(P f : & o 一f
Curved Stance Swing
G-x G-y G-z G-x G-y G-z
g
Max - - - ¤η224 - -
Min - - - - - ¤η2.21
Mean - - - ¤η2.39 - ¤η2.22
Int - - - ¤η2.36 ¤η2.24 ¤η2.20
Curved Stance Swing
G-x G-y G-z G-x G-y G-z
f
Max - - - £η2.08 - -
Min - - ¤η2.28 - £η2.11 -
Mean - - - - - -
Int - - - - - £η2.28
Curved Stance Swing
G-x G-y G-z G-x G-y G-z
二
Max - - ¤η2.23 - - -
Min - - - - - -
Mean - - ¤η2.29 ¤η2.05 - ¤η2.33
Int - - ¤η2.32 - - ¤η2.36
£ i; ¤ k; - 一s
; η2 eta square ; Max i ; Min k ; Mean ; Int
v
30
P v□ v □ o
y _ □ o o 「 P o p
P o
o f
h .82 k o )
i
) o &
.G C IN I , 3 I , 7 ;N A I ) o
f □ o i
o p o :
P )
o )
o 6 I; D I , 8 ; I ), 8 ; I
&f o & i &
f G I , 0 D 4 G D ( l
f o & i o
f o & f
&
) f
) o f o f
o h
31
p o 、 □
、 □
f p 、 i
& o o 、
.CC DD I
g i h (Hanley & Tucker, 2018)
□ h f
□ 也
h o □
h o
G I h
(Fleisig, Chu, Weber, & Andrews, 2009; Hanley & Tucker, 2018)
□ □
□ n
_ P o o
「 o & :
& g Pf P二
g P 「 & o
y (Lee et al., 2015; Nigg, Vienneau, Maurer, & Nigg, 2013)
o g A-z 「 & f G-y g
PA-z 「 & f
G-y □ □ DI G = L D
; G = L D
o f . N
32
「 & □ 下 5
h o
o h i
(Donoghue,
Harrison, Laxton, & Jones, 2008; Nigg et al., 2013) 「 g二 1 N
□ g h 二 人
□ y □
□ 、 P
p 二 人
「 o v力 v p o
g g 1 L
□ ㄧ s s
□ □
一o g
! i d h
p d g
5 I
e P
f o
o f
□
o )
o
七
34
Uncategorized References
Ahmed, M., Mehmood, N., Nadeem, A., Mehmood, A., & Rizwan, K. (2017). Fall
detection system for the elderly based on the classification of shimmer sensor
prototype data. Healthcare Informatics Research, 23(3), 147-158.
Alt, T., Heinrich, K., Funken, J., & Potthast, W. (2015). Lower extremity kinematics
of athletics curve sprinting. Journal of Sports Sciences, 33(6), 552-560.
Ammann, R., Taube, W., & Wyss, T. (2015). Gait asymmetry during a 5-km time trial in elite runners: a descriptive study. Paper presented at the International
Congress on Sports Science Research and Technology Support.
Arampatzis, A., Brüggemann, G.-P., & Metzler, V. (1999). The effect of speed on leg
stiffness and joint kinetics in human running. Journal of Biomechanics, 32(12), 1349-1353.
Borg, G., & Borg, G. (1975). Simple rating methods for estimation of perceived
exertion. Physical Work and Effort. Borg G.
Brandes, M., Zijlstra, W., Heikens, S., van Lummel, R., & Rosenbaum, D. (2006).
Accelerometry based assessment of gait parameters in children. Gait & Posture, 24(4), 482-486.
Brown, A. M., Zifchock, R. A., & Hillstrom, H. J. (2014). The effects of limb
dominance and fatigue on running biomechanics. Gait & Posture, 39(3), 915-
919.
Butte, N. F., Ekelund, U., & Westerterp, K. R. (2012). Assessing physical activity
using wearable monitors: measures of physical activity. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 44(1 Suppl 1), S5-12.
doi:10.1249/MSS.0b013e3182399c0e
Carpes, F. P., Mota, C. B., & Faria, I. E. (2010). On the bilateral asymmetry during
running and cycling–A review considering leg preference. Physical Therapy in Sport, 11(4), 136-142.
Chan, M., Estève, D., Fourniols, J.-Y., Escriba, C., & Campo, E. (2012). Smart
wearable systems: Current status and future challenges. Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, 56(3), 137-156.
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.artmed.2012.09.003
Chen, K. Y., Janz, K. F., Zhu, W., & Brychta, R. J. (2012). Redefining the roles of
sensors in objective physical activity monitoring. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 44(1 Suppl 1), S13-23.
doi:10.1249/MSS.0b013e3182399bc8
Churchill, S. M., Salo, A. I., & Trewartha, G. (2015). The effect of the bend on
technique and performance during maximal effort sprinting. Sports
35
Biomechanics, 14(1), 106-121.
Clanton, T. O., & Wood, R. M. (2010). Etiology of injury to the foot and ankle. In J.
DeLee & D. Drez (Eds.), DeLee & Drez's Orthopaedic Sports Medicine: Principles and Practice (3 ed., pp. 2224-2323). Philadelphia, PA, US:
Saunders/Elsevier.
Cowley, J., Dingwell, J., & Gates, D. (2014). Effects of local and widespread muscle
fatigue on movement timing. Experimental Brain Research, 232(12), 3939-
3948.
De Luca, C. J. (1983). Myoelectrical manifestations of localized muscular fatigue in
humans. Critical Reviews in Biomedical Engineering, 11(4), 251-279.
Dingwell, J. B., & Marin, L. C. (2006). Kinematic variability and local dynamic
stability of upper body motions when walking at different speeds. Journal of Biomechanics, 39(3), 444-452.
Donoghue, O. A., Harrison, A. J., Laxton, P., & Jones, R. K. (2008). Lower limb
kinematics of subjects with chronic achilles tendon injury during running.
Research in Sports Medicine, 16(1), 23-38.
Ferber, R., Davis, I. M., Hamill, J., & Pollard, C. D. (2003). Prospective
biomechanical investigation of iliotibial band syndrome in competitive female
runners. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 35(5), S91.
Fleisig, G., Chu, Y., Weber, A., & Andrews, J. (2009). Variability in baseball pitching
biomechanics among various levels of competition. Sports Biomechanics, 8(1), 10-21.
Gabbard, C. (1997). Coming to Terms With Laterality. The Journal of Psychology, 131(5), 561-564.
Giggins, O., Kelly, D., & Caulfield, B. (2013). Evaluating rehabilitation exercise performance using a single inertial measurement unit. Paper presented at the
Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Pervasive Computing
Technologies for Healthcare.
Gilgen-Ammann, R., Taube, W., & Wyss, T. (2017). Gait asymmetry during 400-to
1000-m high-intensity track running in relation to injury history. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 12(Suppl 2), S2-157-S152-
160.
Griffin, M. P., Olney, S. J., & McBride, I. D. (1995). Role of symmetry in gait
performance of stroke subjects with hemiplegia. Gait & Posture, 3(3), 132-
142. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0966-6362(95)99063-Q
Guzsvinecz, T., Szucs, V., & Sik, C. L. (2015). Developing movement recognition
application with the use of Shimmer sensor and Microsoft Kinect sensor.
Studies in Health Technology and Informatics, 217, 767-772.
36
Hanley, B., & Tucker, C. B. (2018). Gait variability and symmetry remain consistent
during high-intensity 10,000 m treadmill running. Journal of Biomechanics, 79, 129-134.
James, S. L., & Jones, D. C. (1990). Biomechanics aspects of distance running
injuries. In P. R. Cavanagh (Ed.), Biomechanics of Distance Running (pp. 249-
246). Champaig, IL, US: Human Kinetics.
Karamanidis, K., Arampatzis, A., & Bruggemann, G. P. (2003). Symmetry and
reproducibility of kinematic parameters during various running techniques.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 35(6), 1009-1016.
Kaufman, K. R., Miller, L. S., & Sutherland, D. H. (1996). Gait asymmetry in patients
with limb-length inequality. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, 16(2), 144-
150.
Kavanagh, J. J., & Menz, H. B. (2008). Accelerometry: A technique for quantifying
movement patterns during walking. Gait & Posture, 28(1), 1-15.
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2007.10.010
Knapik, J. J., Bauman, C. L., Jones, B. H., Harris, J. M., & Vaughan, L. (1991).
Preseason strength and flexibility imbalances associated with athletic injuries
in female collegiate athletes. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 19(1),
76-81. doi:10.1177/036354659101900113
Laroche, D. P., Cook, S. B., & Mackala, K. (2012). Strength asymmetry increases gait
asymmetry and variability in older women. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 44(11), 2172-2181. doi:10.1249/MSS.0b013e31825e1d31
Lee, Brellenthin, A. G., Thompson, P. D., Sui, X., Lee, I.-M., & Lavie, C. J. (2017).
Running as a key lifestyle medicine for longevity. Progress in Cardiovascular Diseases, 60(1), 45-55.
Lee, Sutter, K. J., Askew, C. D., & Burkett, B. J. (2010). Identifying symmetry in
running gait using a single inertial sensor. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 13(5), 559-563.
Lee, Y.-S., Ho, C.-S., Shih, Y., Chang, S.-Y., Róbert, F. J., & Shiang, T.-Y. (2015).
Assessment of walking, running, and jumping movement features by using the
inertial measurement unit. Gait &Pposture, 41(4), 877-881.
Lin, J. F., & Kulić, D. (2012). Human pose recovery using wireless inertial
measurement units. Physiological measurement, 33(12), 2099.
Marchetti, P. H., Orselli, M. I., & Duarte, M. (2013). The effects of uni-and bilateral
fatigue on postural and power tasks. Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 29(1),
44-48.
Nigg, S., Vienneau, J., Maurer, C., & Nigg, B. M. (2013). Development of a
symmetry index using discrete variables. Gait & Posture, 38(1), 115-119.
37
Noakes, T. D. (2000). Physiological models to understand exercise fatigue and the
adaptations that predict or enhance athletic performance. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 10(3), 123-145. doi:10.1034/j.1600-
0838.2000.010003123.x
Novacheck, T. F. (1998). The biomechanics of running. Gait & Posture, 7(1), 77-95.
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0966-6362(97)00038-6
Paschalis, V., Giakas, G., Baltzopoulos, V., Jamurtas, A. Z., Theoharis, V.,
Kotzamanidis, C., & Koutedakis, Y. (2007). The effects of muscle damage
following eccentric exercise on gait biomechanics. Gait & Posture, 25(2),
236-242. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.gaitpost.2006.04.002
Perry, J., & Burnfield, J. M. (2010). Gait Analysis: Normal and Pathological Function. Thorofare, NJ, US: SLACK.
Pierotti, S. E., Brand, R. A., Gabel, R. H., Pedersen, D. R., & Clarke, W. R. (1991).
Are leg electromyogram profiles symmetrical? Journal of Orthopaedic Research, 9(5), 720-729.
Plotnik, M., Bartsch, R. P., Zeev, A., Giladi, N., & Hausdorff, J. M. (2013). Effects of
walking speed on asymmetry and bilateral coordination of gait. Gait & Posture, 38(4), 864-869.
Plotnik, M., Giladi, N., Balash, Y., Peretz, C., & Hausdorff, J. M. (2005). Is freezing
of gait in Parkinson's disease related to asymmetric motor function? Annals of Neurology, 57(5), 656-663. doi:10.1002/ana.20452
Potdevin, F., Gillet, C., Barbier, F., Coello, Y., & Moretto, P. (2008). Propulsion and
braking in the study of asymmetry in able-bodied men's gaits. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 107(3), 849-861.
Radzak, K. N., Putnam, A. M., Tamura, K., Hetzler, R. K., & Stickley, C. D. (2017).
Asymmetry between lower limbs during rested and fatigued state running gait
in healthy individuals. Gait & Posture, 51, 268-274.
Reilly, J. J., Penpraze, V., Hislop, J., Davies, G., Grant, S., & Paton, J. Y. (2008).
Objective measurement of physical activity and sedentary behaviour: review
with new data. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 93(7), 614-619.
doi:10.1136/adc.2007.133272
Robadey, J., Schween, R., Gehring, D., & Staudenmann, D. (2013). Change of symmetry between overground and treadmill running with a chronic knee injury. Paper presented at the 19th Congress of the European Society of
Biomechanics, Patras, Greece.
Robinson, R. O., Herzog, W., & Nigg, B. M. (1987). Use of force platform variables
to quantify the effects of chiropractic manipulation on gait symmetry. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics, 10(4), 172-176.
38
Rosenthal, R., Cooper, H., & Hedges, L. (1994). Parametric measures of effect size.
The handbook of research synthesis, 621, 231-244.
Rumpf, M. C., Cronin, J. B., Mohamad, I. N., Mohamad, S., Oliver, J. L., & Hughes,
M. G. (2014). Kinetic asymmetries during running in male youth. Physical Therapy in Sport, 15(1), 53-57.
Sadeghi, H., Allard, P., & Duhaime, M. (1997). Functional gait asymmetry in able-
bodied subjects. Human Movement Science, 16(2-3), 243-258.
Sadeghi, H., Allard, P., Prince, F., & Labelle, H. (2000). Symmetry and limb
dominance in able-bodied gait: a review. Gait & Posture, 12(1), 34-45.
Scott, B. K., & Houmard, J. A. (1994). Peak running velocity is highly related to
distance running performance. International Journal of Sports Medicine, 15(8), 504-507.
Seeley, M. K., Umberger, B. R., & Shapiro, R. (2008). A test of the functional
asymmetry hypothesis in walking. Gait & Posture, 28(1), 24-28.
Staudenmann, D., Robadey, J., Lorenzetti, S., & Taube, W. (2013).
BIOMECHANICAL DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OVER GROUND AND
TREADMILL WALKING AND RUNNING. ESB Abstracts, pp-070.
Vagenas, G., & Hoshizaki, B. (1991). Functional asymmetries and lateral dominance
in the lower limbs of distance runners. International Journal of Sport Biomechanics, 7(4), 311-329.
Van Gheluwe, B., & Madsen, C. (1997). Frontal rearfoot kinematics in running prior
to volitional exhaustion. Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 13, 66-75.
Van Mechelen, W. (1992). Running injuries. Sports Medicine, 14(5), 320-335.
Willemsen, A. T. M., van Alsté, J. A., & Boom, H. B. K. (1990). Real-time gait
assessment utilizing a new way of accelerometry. Journal of Biomechanics, 23(8), 859-863. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0021-9290(90)90033-Y
Zifchock, R. A., Davis, I., & Hamill, J. (2006). Kinetic asymmetry in female runners
with and without retrospective tibial stress fractures. Journal of Biomechanics, 39(15), 2792-2797.
Zifchock, R. A., Davis, I., Higginson, J., McCaw, S., & Royer, T. (2008). Side-to-side
differences in overuse running injury susceptibility: a retrospective study.
Human Movement Science, 27(6), 888-902.
41
eP
f
十 o
S9999999999999999
S999999999999999999
S9999999999 v
S9999999999
t s f P P P S
S99999999999999999999999999999999999
S
i 又 ; g
43
rP
(stance)
「 - i S
「 p & ASI. i 7
7P「 p IMU i o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 18.62±11.53 10.71±10.95 9.81±11.67 8.08±5.96 12.16±12.18
A-y 20.47±12.64 15.81±16.22 11.55±11.26 14.60±8.42 16.40±9.45
A-z 8.07±4.16 4.58±2.59 5.23±2.43 4.71±3.36 5.29±3.59
G-x 7.73±3.67 10.33±7.73 12.30±8.22 9.25±6.69 8.61±4.92
G-y 19.67±16.41 16.65±9.06 14.23±12.33 8.02±9.48 15.19±12.08
G-z 8.08±6.63 7.73±6.53 2.89±2.24 6.45±9.22 6.40±7.62
f
A-x 18.71±7.51 18.27±8.05 15.76±11.83 13.77±9.98 15.22±9.80
A-y 5.77±3.92 5.44±4.95 6.81±4.72 6.92±5.49 6.49±7.46
A-z 13.99±10.39 13.52±10.18 14.79±10.80 11.45±11.66 10.51±12.11
G-x 7.40±6.35 7.59±8.40 7.93±5.98 9.49±9.52 9.26±8.42
G-y 5.51±6.14 5.45±6.06 5.01±5.40 4.42±4.54 5.38±5.05
G-z 12.06±9.39 11.44±8.17 12.03±8.95 10.03±10.37 9.45±9.32
二
A-x 3.96±2.95 2.09±2.18 2.46±2.31 3.92±2.35 3.41±3.42
A-y 3.98±4.53 2.76±3.43 6.51±4.69 6.26±6.34 3.45±4.56
A-z 1.03±1.23 1.44±1.58 1.15±1.54 0.49±0.91 0.81±0.77
G-x 4.75±3.75 3.25±4.83 3.51±4.02 5.54±4.32 5.09±4.13
G-y 2.65±3.56 1.63±1.75 1.77±2.38 1.87±1.54 2.08±1.87
G-z 5.34±4.02 4.37±5.34 3.85±5.35 3.06±3.25 6.18±7.41
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
44
(stance)
「 - k S
「 v p & ASI. i 8 g
G-xPG-y f G-xPG-z ASI. &
(F1.7,23.2=4.255, p<.01) (F1.9,25.9=3.849, p<.01) (F1.5,19.9=3.923, p<.01)
(F1.5,20=8.103, p<.01) ASI. k
8P「 p IMU k o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 20.25±16.07 18.94±14.72 23.93±16.79 20.52±14.88 18.19±17.81
A-y 12.48±9.48 17.27±11.14 18.30±8.1 18.45±22.87 8.58±6.73
A-z 6.22±3.36 6.26±4.44 4.68±3.40 7.29±5.48 4.02±4.26
G-x 20.15±19.99d 23.34±22.56 10.54±16.10d 14.23±11.95ac 4.61±5.34
G-y 11.19±11.23 14.02±8.70e 11.79±8.72e 12.04±7.55 8.54±7.02bc
G-z 28.78±15.27 22.96±15.77 18.44±18.54 24.94±17.14 22.57±21.58
f
A-x 11.22±6.85 10.71±5.36 9.89±7.64 8.83±7.52 10.88±7.30
A-y 18.83±4.43 25.69±10.49 24.09±11.83 23.78±8.98 18.81±12.06
A-z 10.57±6.64 10.55±7.63 9.81±8.28 9.98±7.62 11.84±5.94
G-x 18.03±9.21 16.30±13.32 11.01±8.31de 10.83±8.32c 17.80±13.44c
G-y 33.29±16.04 35.29±15.66 27.35±18.19 28.64±19.54 28.90±19.85
G-z 28.95±18.59d 31.04±15.99d 22.93±17.82 18.44±16.53ab 15.32±12.04
二
A-x 4.24±4.72 4.17±2.30 2.72±2.74 3.29±3.06 3.67±4.06
A-y 0.74±0.63 0.37±0.34 0.34±0.32 0.30±0.29 0.44±0.33
A-z 2.61±2.86 2.11±2.12 2.82±1.78 2.73±4.35 3.84±6.68
G-x 0.48±0.35 0.70±1.20 0.21±0.18 0.56±0.54 0.23±0.20
G-y 6.15±5.54 5.54±4.45 2.83±3.56 5.21±5.18 7.55±6.12
G-z 0.57±0.63 0.24±0.28 0.57±0.48 0.89±1.25 1.29±2.12
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
45
(stance)
「 - S
「 p & ASI. 9 g
G-x Pf A-z 二 A-xPG-z ASI. &
(F4,52=5.147, p<.01) (F4,52=3.893, p<.01) (F1.8,24.1=3.622, p<.01)
(F2.6,34.9=5.181, p<.01) ASI. k
9P「 p IMU o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 19.74±15.36 18.00±14.61 18.38±15.29 15.83±12.63 16.92±15.42
A-y 14.66±7.34 15.96±13.00 15.82±7.18 14.13±6.68 9.76±8.15
A-z 5.13±3.68 1.72±1.85 3.99±3.00 4.55±4.09 3.65±4.31
G-x 10.41±6.17cde 10.78±7.39 7.80±3.12a 4.99±4.79a 6.33±2.32a
G-y 17.17±5.62 10.84±5.24 8.70±5.73 7.06±4.72 11.61±8.57
G-z 18.81±8.03 16.45±13.87 11.65±7.96 15.46±8.83 14.02±10.00
f
A-x 12.22±3.84 10.37±6.36 9.67±6.50 9.17±6.92 10.60±5.96
A-y 7.88±6.55 7.64±5.83 8.12±8.43 9.05±6.79 7.26±6.81
A-z 14.51±10.12e 13.13±10.34 13.86±8.75 12.45±10.66 10.39±10.31a
G-x 9.29±8.50 11.84±8.38 8.50±6.19 10.63±7.61 10.89±7.35
G-y 20.28±15.48 21.31±15.53 17.65±16.89 17.30±16.49 17.83±15.87
G-z 16.90±12.16 17.42±9.91 15.59±12.21 14.42±11.60 14.81±10.93
二
A-x 3.92±3.48 3.13±3.40c 2.77±2.79b 1.01±0.67 2.64±1.66
A-y 3.69±2.96 2.40±1.35 4.67±4.46 3.45±3.39 3.38±2.34
A-z 4.97±4.55 3.29±2.35 4.57±3.54 3.49±2.64 3.37±1.65
G-x 4.40±3.33 3.48±2.95 3.15±3.62 3.83±2.39 3.69±2.35
G-y 4.02±2.43 3.31±3.42 2.61±1.99 3.18±3.04 4.32±2.80
G-z 4.56±4.46d 4.48±2.71d 2.65±2.25 2.50±1.99ab 1.66±1.89
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
46
(stance)
「 - v S
「 p & ASI. v 10 g
G-yPf A-zPG-y 二 A-zPG-z ASI. &
(F21.6,28=4.054, p<.01) (F4,52=4.171, p<.01) (F1.9,23.8=4.144, p<.01)
(F2.3,30.3=8.139, p<.01) (F2.7,35.1=4.799, p<.01) ASI. k
10P「 p IMU v o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 22.74±19.95 21.77±18.75 22.57±16.90 19.41±13.39 16.90±17.09
A-y 15.92±9.15 15.78±12.67 15.00±8.92 13.63±6.59 12.69±9.35
A-z 7.97±5.04 6.46±5.12 7.09±6.28 7.03±9.05 5.77±4.65
G-x 7.64±8.41 9.97±8.63 7.69±4.82 7.17±5.11 7.70±6.55
G-y 18.84±12.71 13.42±7.77c 9.27±6.05b 5.69±3.68 14.63±11.18
G-z 16.59±9.45 13.33±14.37 8.31±7.12 13.07±9.69 15.15±13.26
f
A-x 13.81±7.98 11.92±6.94 11.10±7.79 11.53±8.45 10.29±6.47
A-y 9.06±5.80 10.01±5.58 8.30±6.73 8.33±6.35 8.34±6.69
A-z 11.98±8.48 10.73±7.84 11.08±5.83d 9.88±8.74c 7.86±7.87
G-x 7.58±6.98 9.35±6.89 7.22±4.23 8.90±7.25 8.41±6.98
G-y 23.12±18.77c 24.18±19.82 20.62±20.47a 19.31±20.88e 20.55±19.24d
G-z 19.95±15.06 20.42±14.03 19.16±14.69 16.81±15.92 17.33±14.10
二
A-x 6.48±3.68 6.09±5.94 6.45±5.27 4.22±6.08 4.56±5.13
A-y 6.54±2.56 5.73±3.46 8.29±6.04 6.30±7.24 5.83±3.90
A-z 8.51±5.33cd 7.71±3.61cd 7.33±5.42ab 4.01±3.15ab 4.69±2.59
G-x 7.36±4.01 6.40±3.46 6.03±8.64 6.73±8.25 4.23±3.04
G-y 5.42±2.53 4.34±3.23 4.96±4.94 3.55±2.50 3.27±2.47
G-z 10.05±5.86 7.60±5.93 5.33±2.55 4.03±3.60e 4.75±4.46d
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
47
(swing)
「 - i S
p & ASI. i 11 f G-x
ASI. & (F4,52=6.01, p<.01)
ASI. k
11P「 p IMU i o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 7.20±6.55 6.08±5.36 7.30±6.33 6.34±8.09 8.48±8.42
A-y 9.74±9.26 11.08±7.39 13.95±8.80 13.33±8.98 12.52±10.13
A-z 9.24±6.94 8.64±8.42 9.31±8.15 5.68±4.04 4.94±3.70
G-x 10.60±10.03 11.24±9.35 14.25±13.90 6.73±4.91 10.02±5.96
G-y 14.71±11.89 4.73±4.18 2.78±2.64 8.97±10.76 8.79±7.02
G-z 7.85±6.38 11.08±5.30 7.01±6.48 11.29±16.37 3.59±2.48
f
A-x 13.25±12.89 13.37±13.13 10.20±9.87 11.84±12.03 10.00±10.45
A-y 6.91±5.05 7.96±6.45 6.48±4.39 6.04±5.60 4.35±3.22
A-z 8.37±10.04 9.41±8.81 8.40±9.43 7.43±8.66 4.70±6.06
G-x 6.56±5.39 5.48±3.53 6.89±5.20e 9.11±6.92e 8.91±5.22cd
G-y 0.89±0.97 0.94±1.25 1.14±1.12 1.14±1.09 0.45±0.42
G-z 6.05±6.64 6.65±7.40 6.24±7.65 5.81±10.32 7.29±7.87
二
A-x 2.76±2.84 2.08±1.65 2.08±2.09 1.42±1.56 2.65±2.35
A-y 5.11±5.71 1.38±1.72 4.99±6.01 5.57±7.95 3.60±6.18
A-z 0.87±1.27 0.97±1.30 0.82±1.34 0.56±0.97 0.71±0.80
G-x 4.61±3.77 2.77±3.66 3.34±3.10 4.02±3.51 2.53±1.13
G-y 2.69±2.86 1.99±1.88 3.38±3.51 2.27±1.15 1.56±1.52
G-z 3.58±3.90 3.12±4.08 2.41±2.79 1.42±2.18 3.99±4.57
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
48
(swing)
「 - k S
「 p & ASI. k 12
12P「 p IMU k o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 9.24±7.91 10.46±5.74 8.66±6.18 7.63±7.78 10.40±5.83
A-y 10.71±9.34 15.56±9.64 22.47±12.68 16.97±21.73 13.29±11.19
A-z 5.18±3.38 6.02±3.19 6.61±6.04 5.67±5.43 5.68±3.56
G-x 24.56±28.56 19.52±23.29 14.67±17.03 8.91±9.39 6.64±4.26
G-y 11.25±7.16 10.49±6.37 5.02±1.57 7.41±5.28 6.65±4.82
G-z 20.82±13.82 20.82±14.22 20.53±17.49 17.28±10.10 16.24±9.76
f
A-x 6.52±4.89 8.09±6.08 6.96±14.90 7.02±5.75 6.30±4.46
A-y 18.66±8.87 19.40±10.83 17.66±12.99 16.16±12.15 14.50±7.72
A-z 6.45±4.19 8.10±6.09 7.06±4.08 9.48±5.26 9.08±4.49
G-x 14.61±8.37 15.14±12.73 11.34±11.04 13.05±7.69 15.50±9.91
G-y 15.34±16.67 16.24±11.74 15.41±16.13 15.72±19.42 21.19±19.67
G-z 13.53±11.40 12.60±8.36 10.43±7.67 8.85±7.94 8.41±5.66
二
A-x 2.99±3.06 3.98±1.93 1.64±1.96 3.17±3.12 2.83±3.48
A-y 0.23±0.17 0.15±0.11 0.24±0.21 0.30±0.21 0.32±0.48
A-z 0.83±1.12 1.44±1.36 2.21±1.27 1.34±1.86 1.30±1.73
G-x 0.22±0.15 0.17±0.22 0.19±0.17 0.26±0.23 0.18±0.19
G-y 3.29±5.45 2.92±2.83 3.38±3.35 5.65±4.91 3.62±4.46
G-z 0.07±0.06 0.16±0.16 0.25±0.18 0.27±0.19 0.44±0.51
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
49
(swing)
「 - S
「 p & ASI. 13 g
A-zPG-zPf G-x 二 A-xPG-z ASI. &
(F1.3,17.2=7.562, p<.01) (F1.5,19.8=3.923, p<.01) (F1.7,22.6=4.4, p<.01)
(F1.9,25.2=4.053, p<.01) (F2.7,35.5=5.782, p<.01) ASI. k
13P「 p IMU o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 9.38±8.89 8.62±8.17 10.56±4.99 10.31±4.83 9.25±5.76
A-y 7.58±8.70 11.84±4.93 16.64±10.95 15.60±11.42 11.89±10.84
A-z 4.92±3.78de 6.87±3.75d 6.92±6.83a 2.60±1.43ab 2.78±1.73
G-x 8.41±5.92 8.48±4.40 6.61±3.11 5.80±5.70 5.67±3.88
G-y 8.89±7.40 10.26±6.42 4.13±3.27 7.92±4.40 9.23±8.44
G-z 17.63±10.16b 16.61±7.21a 9.43±7.99 11.51±10.78 9.44±7.02
f
A-x 10.73±3.63 11.04±5.00 8.29±4.54 7.83±5.49 8.07±5.45
A-y 9.33±4.80 12.32±5.62 9.79±6.47 8.10±5.45 6.98±5.70
A-z 7.46±6.12 7.48±5.18 8.21±5.64 6.71±5.73 6.17±4.85
G-x 10.49±3.91e 10.72±4.98e 9.59±6.87d 8.36±6.60c 9.91±7.34ab
G-y 12.77±9.33 12.98±9.38 11.15±10.01 11.73±10.00 12.76±9.85
G-z 8.94±7.97 8.93±8.24 7.44±8.32 8.28±8.96 10.86±9.97
二
A-x 2.88±2.35 2.35±2.48c 2.19±1.86be 0.83±0.62 2.06±1.37c
A-y 2.56±1.98 1.49±1.03 3.43±3.18 2.58±2.72 2.84±2.42
A-z 3.69±3.29 2.36±2.22 3.53±2.76 2.97±2.42 2.63±1.23
G-x 3.22±1.40 2.40±2.09 2.26±2.15 2.88±1.11 2.75±1.64
G-y 2.57±1.38 2.04±2.05 2.01±1.64 2.19±1.91 3.20±1.81
G-z 3.10±2.99d 3.41±1.96d 1.95±1.49 1.66±1.28ab 1.24±0.94
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
50
(swing)
「 - v S
「 p & ASI. v 14 g
A-zPf A-y 二 A-z ASI. &
(F1.8,24=5.854, p<.01) (F2.2,29=3.294, p<.01) (F2.3,30.8=6.441, p<.01)
ASI. k
14P「 p IMU v o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
g
A-x 12.16±12.62 10.89±11.45 12.81±8.27 11.85±7.15 11.32±6.69
A-y 5.50±6.96 9.86±4.62 15.23±10.88 13.98±12.58 12.57±9.27
A-z 7.09±5.38d 8.69±5.14d 9.57±6.54 4.73±4.92ab 4.73±3.00
G-x 8.79±5.63 7.52±5.10 7.76±4.38 7.46±5.99 7.37±3.35
G-y 12.73±9.42 11.13±8.41 6.74±4.30 8.24±3.39 11.22±10.72
G-z 15.95±11.03 14.20±6.64 6.92±5.41 9.75±8.76 10.09±8.07
f
A-x 9.57±5.24 8.79±6.02 6.49±4.50 6.02±6.03 6.89±3.11
A-y 7.41±5.37d 10.01±5.91 7.92±7.98 5.70±5.35a 5.73±4.81
A-z 6.47±3.66 6.11±3.29 8.01±1.82 6.10±4.61 4.96±4.69
G-x 8.07±4.58 8.51±5.78 9.44±5.40 7.72±6.27 8.92±7.40
G-y 15.29±11.55 15.61±11.95 14.03±11.98 13.63±12.46 14.69±12.47
G-z 11.19±12.20 10.90±12.22 10.10±11.15 10.41±11.00 12.54±12.67
二
A-x 4.09±2.15 3.88±3.86 4.19±3.11 2.89±3.58 3.23±3.46
A-y 4.28±1.51 3.81±2.26 5.55±3.76 4.59±4.92 4.25±2.64
A-z 5.56±3.91d 5.13±2.56cd 5.19±3.67b 3.06±2.52ab 3.28±1.67
G-x 4.80±2.69 4.23±2.22 4.28±5.62 4.65±5.18 3.02±2.37
G-y 3.55±1.37 2.78±2.27 3.65±3.33 2.71±1.68 2.56±1.63
G-z 6.54±3.88 5.02±4.19 3.51±1.54 2.82±2.34 3.08±2.86
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
51
(stance)
- i S
p & ASI. i 15 g
A-zPG-y f A-z 二 G-z ASI. &
(F4,52=5.095, p<.01) (F2.3,30=4.726, p<.01) (F1.9,25=4.983, p<.01)
(F2.2,29=3.735, p<.01) ASI. k
15P p IMU i o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 16.32±12.86 10.53±8.63 13.11±14.08 5.91±2.11 9.00±10.58
A-y 14.83±14.12 14.85±10.01 16.21±9.37 16.93±12.67 17.78±9.13
A-z 9.37±2.88 4.80±1.79 3.57±1.81e 4.44±2.43 2.87±1.77c
G-x 9.92±4.93 11.23±7.82 7.30±4.61 10.18±11.17 6.66±4.28
G-y 16.23±14.87c 19.72±9.96c 18.11±12.41abde 8.32±7.25c 18.76±13.91c
G-z 9.36±8.45 5.84±6.26 5.12±3.47 6.17±7.27 4.30±3.70
f A-x 19.25±5.94 19.83±8.13 20.13±8.62 12.18±10.28 14.56±9.26
A-y 5.33±5.43 5.82±4.93 6.64±5.27 4.99±2.68 8.84±8.80
A-z 15.40±9.12 12.19±8.72d 15.65±9.92 11.32±11.98b 10.76±11.39
G-x 7.51±8.42 7.93±5.07 10.94±7.05 9.57±9.30 9.09±8.04
G-y 6.52±6.11 4.58±4.89 4.92±6.09 6.94±6.40 5.09±5.92
G-z 9.78±10.55 8.35±6.92 12.28±7.45 9.11±10.89 10.49±9.80
二
A-x 3.56±2.88 3.23±1.84 2.63±1.54 3.25±2.59 3.11±2.82
A-y 4.05±2.60 4.78±5.52 9.88±11.06 3.27±6.18 4.17±4.49
A-z 1.12±1.05 1.05±1.32 0.95±1.27 0.84±0.86 0.57±0.69
G-x 4.69±4.83 3.13±3.14 2.79±2.83 4.22±4.06 4.56±3.73
G-y 3.18±3.97 1.69±1.89 2.61±2.72 3.52±2.03 3.54±3.45
G-z 7.20±5.42 6.60±5.39 5.00±3.61e 2.13±2.95 3.29±2.69c
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
52
(stance)
- k S
p & ASI. k 16 f
A-zPG-z ASI. & (F4,52=3.962,
p<.01) (F1.3,16.6=5.025, p<.01) ASI. k
16P p IMU k o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 26.53±12.38 20.37±14.66 25.01±17.34 18.77±13.86 17.32±14.51
A-y 18.28±18.14 23.37±20.75 14.83±11.18 17.41±18.75 16.28±17.66
A-z 6.78±5.44 7.50±4.82 6.74±2.88 5.97±4.05 6.62±6.14
G-x 7.10±6.91 13.09±14.35 8.21±9.02 17.54±14.70 9.03±7.40
G-y 5.81±7.41 14.94±10.53 11.19±7.45 15.39±8.43 12.73±8.90
G-z 25.33±17.86 20.27±16.49 25.89±19.24 20.03±15.07 22.40±18.47
f
A-x 10.85±7.15 8.28±5.79 11.78±5.28 9.28±6.63 10.31±6.15
A-y 24.71±10.11 24.78±9.91 25.70±15.33 26.28±8.64 21.91±17.33
A-z 9.71±7.79e 5.78±8.66 9.53±5.55 9.32±5.98 8.57±4.25a
G-x 15.71±11.05 9.61±7.41 12.67±13.65 9.71±12.29 14.84±12.42
G-y 33.47±15.10 31.87±15.71 34.12±13.54 27.91±19.16 27.88±19.74
G-z 28.16±18.02e 27.23±13.29e 28.52±16.05 20.69±17.53 18.25±17.83ab
二
A-x 2.90±3.46 2.87±2.64 2.43±2.67 2.99±4.34 4.49±4.33
A-y 0.41±0.23 0.31±0.28 0.23±0.17 0.21±0.28 0.22±0.17
A-z 2.83±2.32 1.77±1.88 3.56±3.07 3.46±5.43 2.36±4.33
G-x 0.54±0.53 0.75±1.35 0.28±0.40 0.59±0.55 0.45±0.24
G-y 6.23±5.53 6.59±4.42 4.22±2.70 4.17±4.81 7.81±6.92
G-z 0.79±1.37 0.98±1.78 0.83±0.76 0.31±0.33 0.79±1.43
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
53
(stance)
- S
p & ASI. 17 二
A-yPG-z ASI. & (F2.5,32=3.408,
p<.01) (F1.5,19=5.273, p<.01) ASI. k
17P p IMU o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 24.81±12.25 16.64±13.32 22.27±16.56 14.45±14.15 17.68±13.51
A-y 14.67±10.26 18.01±12.74 13.98±9.84 15.08±12.97 15.09±10.69
A-z 4.70±3.86 2.05±1.74 2.94±2.69 3.73±2.55 3.25±2.92
G-x 6.53±5.44 10.06±9.45 5.56±6.25 6.17±2.27 6.16±5.42
G-y 11.36±8.95 11.23±8.07 11.53±7.10 5.44±1.84 13.81±11.61
G-z 19.87±7.33 14.89±12.37 14.37±9.61 19.12±14.76 12.45±6.22
f
A-x 11.92±3.24 9.83±7.37 11.77±6.49 8.00±7.46 9.76±5.85
A-y 10.86±9.13 8.72±5.42 9.88±7.69 8.45±6.79 7.44±5.80
A-z 15.73±8.12 10.97±9.10 13.16±8.05 11.68±10.07 10.53±9.14
G-x 8.88±8.63 9.01±6.82 13.55±8.35 9.79±8.10 10.68±7.32
G-y 22.63±14.67 17.46±13.24 20.00±15.36 18.22±16.89 16.95±16.50
G-z 17.05±11.81 13.42±8.60 17.37±9.17 15.00±11.68 16.22±11.63
二
A-x 2.90±3.80 3.58±4.45 2.58±1.94 0.91±1.08 1.42±1.12
A-y 2.89±1.95 3.64±2.40d 6.36±4.46d 2.49±2.77bc 4.04±3.44
A-z 4.33±4.90 3.78±3.07 4.65±2.86 2.93±2.51 2.87±2.06
G-x 5.58±3.61 3.78±3.20 2.23±1.50 3.25±3.79 3.13±2.60
G-y 4.10±2.46 4.33±2.61 3.59±2.45 3.19±3.63 4.62±3.24
G-z 6.09±5.52b 5.57±3.50a 2.87±1.86 3.02±2.29 2.28±1.86
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
54
(stance)
- v S
p & ASI. v 18 二
G-z ASI. & (F4,52=5.997,
p<.01) ASI. k
18P p IMU v o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 28.08±17.59 19.61±17.30 24.96±20.20 18.21±18.88 20.62±13.08
A-y 14.62±12.11 14.17±14.26 16.13±9.25 16.34±13.43 17.47±9.05
A-z 9.45±4.34 7.85±9.37 3.68±4.13 6.97±4.60 5.08±4.82
G-x 6.34±6.81 13.63±12.74 4.32±2.55 6.40±1.72 7.76±6.15
G-y 15.33±11.91 16.72±9.86 14.41±9.72 7.77±5.29 16.53±15.54
G-z 16.68±8.52 17.10±13.47 12.54±11.35 16.23±14.76 14.40±9.07
f
A-x 14.46±8.16 15.97±7.73 13.21±6.98 9.77±7.41 10.95±5.81
A-y 12.27±8.24 10.93±7.89 9.61±7.06 8.43±5.96 8.35±6.07
A-z 13.46±7.56 13.09±13.65 11.03±6.20 8.99±7.71 8.80±6.20
G-x 6.36±5.60 11.33±11.04 11.06±8.16 6.74±5.78 7.97±6.17
G-y 25.23±18.33 19.89±16.45 21.84±19.44 20.53±21.74 19.35±19.87
G-z 19.57±15.81 15.49±11.75 19.51±12.18 17.75±16.28 18.19±15.07
二
A-x 5.98±3.5 9.69±10.70 5.23±4.70 4.44±4.78 3.15±4.32
A-y 7.32±3.60 8.13±7.92 9.27±6.69 5.51±4.73 6.12±4.35
A-z 7.79±6.26 10.90±9.65 7.18±4.09 5.01±3.82 4.21±3.07
G-x 8.01±5.50 7.50±7.67 4.71±5.84 6.15±8.65 6.22±4.80
G-y 5.27±2.62 9.23±10.21 4.30±3.72 3.41±2.10 3.04±2.69
G-z 12.18±6.68 11.10±8.35 6.40±3.34 3.74±3.42 3.06±3.19
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
55
(swing)
- i S
p & ASI. i 19 g
G-xPf A-y 二 A-y ASI. &
(F4,52=4.17, p<.01) (F1.9,25.8=8.694, p<.01) (F4,52=5.15, p<.01) ASI.
k
19P p IMU i o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 9.59±5.48 7.42±6.24 4.99±3.49 8.30±6.29 8.69±8.23
A-y 15.32±13.82 12.66±5.29 14.64±7.19 18.16±12.47 17.36±3.88
A-z 9.12±8.76 9.40±7.03 9.80±7.25 6.57±3.70 6.51±5.01
G-x 11.51±9.76bce 14.93±12.04a 9.09±9.28a 7.94±9.26 12.10±14.45a
G-y 11.63±8.79 5.92±5.18 8.19±7.97 6.33±7.77 10.40±10.41
G-z 8.55±6.81 10.38±7.62 8.16±7.51 9.86±11.66 6.87±4.41
f A-x 12.12±11.03 11.87±12.00 11.02±9.72 10.28±10.74 12.56±10.78
A-y 6.79±6.04 9.83±7.79de 8.62±5.90e 5.64±4.74b 3.55±4.03bc
A-z 9.92±10.06 8.03±8.71 4.62±7.10 6.48±7.49 5.01±6.05
G-x 7.67±5.11 4.13±4.09 6.62±5.45 8.69±7.13 9.64±5.30
G-y 0.95±0.92 2.55±2.97 0.96±1.22 1.48±1.38 1.09±0.87
G-z 5.77±7.90 5.95±3.83 5.07±6.04 6.52±8.79 7.52±9.75
二
A-x 2.67±2.66 2.01±1.32 1.62±1.31 1.73±1.43 0.99±0.78
A-y 5.92±7.67 5.20±6.29c 6.71±7.88b 2.13±3.45 5.64±7.49
A-z 0.84±1.07 0.87±1.18 0.89±1.32 0.92±0.87 0.61±0.62
G-x 3.15±3.15 2.71±2.85 1.86±3.34 3.42±4.01 2.41±3.45
G-y 2.13±2.37 2.82±1.87 4.73±5.12 3.14±2.08 3.63±3.08
G-z 6.36±5.22 4.26±4.93 3.53±3.38 2.12±2.00 3.24±2.50
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
56
(swing)
- k S
p & ASI. k 20 g
A-xPG-y f G-y ASI. &
(F2.1,28.4=3.468, p<.01) (F4,52=3.258, p<.01) (F4,52=4.279, p<.01) ASI.
k
20P p IMU k o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 13.07±9.59 5.94±5.85c 9.75±6.28be 5.24±4.77 7.08±4.37c
A-y 22.99±27.42 23.31±21.17 18.56±12.48 17.38±12.76 22.20±18.56
A-z 4.96±2.49 6.82±3.68 6.15±3.04 4.48±3.26 5.50±4.93
G-x 24.67±23.65 8.98±5.92 7.45±10.41 17.49±9.28 14.24±20.67
G-y 8.02±4.69 12.45±9.44 8.99±5.79e 5.14±3.21 10.37±4.46c
G-z 18.62±11.37 15.75±14.99 23.12±16.31 13.94±19.53 9.58±6.30
f A-x 6.30±5.26 5.41±5.43 6.50±5.95 7.02±5.29 4.84±5.52
A-y 19.90±9.93 18.54±15.47 17.71±12.67 16.58±10.29 12.32±9.23
A-z 7.07±5.40 7.31±6.20 6.37±3.97 6.79±4.10 8.86±7.05
G-x 13.70±8.81 14.64±11.01 10.75±8.03 11.08±7.23 14.97±8.78
G-y 14.21±15.86b 15.72±10.93a 19.60±16.37 18.91±18.85 22.37±17.07
G-z 14.83±14.68 14.14±8.23 7.79±8.28 7.25±5.07 10.56±6.49
二
A-x 3.55±3.25 2.88±2.40 2.33±2.89 3.38±4.62 3.90±3.84
A-y 0.18±0.23 0.31±0.24 0.24±0.22 0.15±0.14 0.29±0.26
A-z 0.71±1.02 1.31±1.31 2.15±1.95 1.28±1.69 0.80±0.75
G-x 0.17±0.09 0.19±0.09 0.17±0.16 0.20±0.20 0.22±0.18
G-y 4.16±4.68 2.58±1.99 2.96±3.32 4.14±4.28 3.04±4.79
G-z 0.41±0.37 0.24±0.19 0.37±0.40 0.28±0.20 0.34±0.19
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
57
(swing)
- S
p & ASI. 21 g
G-xPG-yPG-z 二 A-yPA-zPG-z ASI. &
(F2.4,31=8.333, p<.01) (F2.5,32.8=3.261, p<.01) (F2.2,28.8=3.729,
p<.01) (F2.2,29.6=3.18, p<.01) (F2.2,29=3.68, p<.01) (F1.7,22.2=6.38, p<.01)
ASI. k
21P p IMU o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 12.16±8.22 6.86±9.80 9.88±9.40 8.62±5.88 11.05±4.39
A-y 11.95±12.55 12.83±10.55 15.81±10.65 16.45±13.61 17.99±11.13
A-z 5.49±5.21 6.47±6.06 4.53±3.83 4.20±0.45 4.06±2.10
G-x 11.51±7.29bde 10.60±5.20a 4.14±3.54 8.81±5.98a 3.53±3.07a
G-y 8.28±6.10c 10.27±4.24 7.85±6.69ae 6.35±4.04 9.44±9.85c
G-z 11.68±9.29e 14.75±7.28 9.29±7.53 14.56±8.87 8.77±4.61a
f
A-x 10.32±4.17 9.27±4.94 9.27±5.20 8.23±5.12 8.35±5.60
A-y 11.64±8.27 10.01±6.77 8.56±7.67 6.83±4.54 6.67±4.93
A-z 7.44±7.15 5.37±5.24 6.44±5.14 7.31±5.03 6.10±4.48
G-x 9.11±4.36 7.96±4.73 8.86±6.53 8.04±6.65 10.14±7.01
G-y 12.46±9.22 9.67±8.64 12.19±9.89 12.01±10.29 13.05±9.04
G-z 9.94±6.98 6.55±6.13 7.60±6.97 8.70±8.97 11.47±9.58
二
A-x 2.95±2.60 2.29±2.68 1.86±1.55 0.86±0.98 1.13±1.02
A-y 2.40±0.78 2.58±1.28cd 4.39±3.45b 2.04±2.39b 3.56±2.68
A-z 3.63±2.94 3.11±2.54e 3.25±2.89 2.39±2.33 2.32±2.49b
G-x 3.88±2.25 2.46±2.04 1.10±1.12 2.40±2.23 2.29±2.08
G-y 2.73±1.59 2.75±1.81 2.73±1.85 2.43±2.37 3.30±2.33
G-z 4.49±3.31b 3.94±2.32a 1.83±1.08 1.97±1.68 1.91±1.68
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%
58
(swing)
- v S
p & ASI. v 22 g
A-zPG-xPG-yPG-z f A-yPG-z ASI. &
(F1.7,22.6=4.976, p<.01) (F2.5,33.1=7.507, p<.01) (F2.9,37.6=4.13,
p<.01) (F2.5,32=3.36, p<.01) (F1.7,21.6=10.418, p<.01) (F1.9,25=4.912, p<.01)
ASI. k
22P p IMU v o 一 o
0% 25% 50% 75% 100% g A-x 13.23±11.98 11.94±12.08 13.47±11.65 10.49±9.18 13.13±6.47
A-y 10.64±10.05 16.09±15.66 13.08±11.06 15.96±12.89 19.04±10.70
A-z 8.43±5.08b 10.13±6.33a 6.48±5.13 5.80±4.01 6.64±3.86
G-x 12.12±6.96bde 11.50±5.92ac 5.15±6.11b 6.69±3.88a 5.33±3.18a
G-y 11.64±8.39c 10.94±7.55e 9.27±9.36ae 8.21±4.89 12.03±12.44bc
G-z 11.90±8.44b 14.45±7.43a 6.64±5.58 12.40±8.87 9.90±6.52
f
A-x 9.79±4.52 9.92±9.599 8.17±4.01 6.85±3.82 7.57±4.48
A-y 10.10±8.15de 10.96±7.03c 7.54±6.43b 5.90±5.18a 5.72±4.76a
A-z 6.46±3.83 8.47±7.43 5.98±3.10 6.32±1.22 5.06±2.86
G-x 7.06±3.85 8.00±7.16 8.69±5.87 7.83±4.67 8.95±7.69
G-y 15.12±11.40 11.72±10.51 13.37±13.10 14.55±12.66 16.37±12.02
G-z 11.69±11.18 6.81±9.20de 8.63±10.59 11.26±12.37b 13.83±13.01b
二
A-x 3.46±2.38 6.18±8.36 3.33±2.60 2.90±2.66 2.16±2.99
A-y 5.35±1.78 5.29±6.15 5.84±4.91 3.86±2.84 5.12±2.56
A-z 5.53±3.84 7.10±8.08 4.63±3.02 3.43±2.52 3.52±2.50
G-x 5.38±4.10 4.22±5.92 2.70±3.63 4.10±5.50 4.77±3.44
G-y 3.20±1.58 6.28±7.89 2.91±2.56 1.94±1.46 2.80±2.59
G-z 8.40±3.73 6.62±6.74 3.58±2.24 3.19±1.97 2.00±2.55
Sa 0% Pb 25% Pc 50% Pd
75% Pe 100%