Post on 07-Aug-2020
transcript
Urban Renovation Methodology
KPI-driven methodology for urban renovation atdistrict level. Sustainable Strategic UrbanPlanning
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
Introduction
The CITyFiED Methodology for city renovation at district level
CITyFiED KPIs for district renovation
Evaluation of KPIs definition
CITyFiED: Three levels of indicators
• City Level Indicators (L1)
Project Level KPIs (L2)
Impact Assessment Indicators at city level (L3)
Conclusions
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
KPI-driven methodology for urban renovation at district level. Sustainable Strategic Urban Planning
Introduction Energy consumption and CO2 emissions increased during the last
decades1
Improvement potential in the residential sector: CO2 emissions can be reduced by 90% by 20502
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
+
1 Smart Cities Council. 2013.2 European Commission. COM/2011/0112 final. 2011.
Multiple factorstechnical, socio-economic, environmental
and ethical
Administrative structures
Stakeholders
Decision-making processSHORT term
CIT
yF
iED
Meth
od
olo
gy
KP
I-d
riven
ap
pro
ach
Strategies for Sustainable
Urban City Renovation
Sustainable
City
Present
Future -Vision
MEDIUM term
LONG term
The CITyFiED Methodology
The CITyFiED Methodology is a KPI-driven approach for urban renovation at district level designed as a consultancy tool for Sustainable Urban Planning.
for city renovation at district level
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
Sustainable Urban
Planning
Energy efficiency
main pillar
Understand the city to deliver a set of tailored Strategies for the Sustainable Urban Renovation
Enable replicability and mass market deployment of energy-efficient retrofit of districts
objectives
client
Local Authorities / Public Administration
CITY scale
DISTRICT scale
PHASE I
SSUR *
Guidelines on Business model
Recommendations:
Execution and Monitoring
Financial mechanisms
Correctiveactions
Understanding the CITY
DIAGNOSIS of the city at DISTRICT
LEVEL
Definition and analysis of the intervention MEASURES & SCENARIOS
Prioritization and selection
of the intervention SCENARIO
Strategies for SUSTAINABLE
URBAN RENOVATION
EXECUTION MONITORING and IMPACT assessment evaluation
Pre-diagnosis Data
collectionMEASURES
analysis and selection
SCENARIOS generation
and definition
L1 City
SELECTED SCENARIO
L1 District
PHASE II PHASE III PHASE IV PHASE V PHASE VI PHASE VII
Process stage
General objectives
ECG
L2 Project**
L3 Impact
L2 Project**
Barriers and opportunities
Diagnosis Data
collection
Baselinescenario
Specificobjectives
Evaluation of scenarios Delivery methods
and Tender
Execution
Definitionand pre-
selection of measures
Sustainable Evaluation Plan
SupervisionImpact after
renovation
Monitoring and Evaluation
Priorizitationof scenarios
Assessment core – External Consultancy GroupECGIndicators *SSUR: Strategies for Sustainable Urban Renovation
**KPIs: Key performance indicators
Public PARTICIPATION
7 phases
city and district scales
public participation
guidelines and recommendations (step by step)
L1 City L1 District L2 Project**
L3 Impact
L2 Project**
3 levels of KPIs
The CITyFiED Methodologyfor city renovation at district level
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
The CITyFiED Methodologyfor city renovation at district level
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
Experts representing the Municipality
Professionals that form part of the Public Administration or Local authorities.
ECG Multidisciplinary group to closely
cooperate with the local authorities todefine the initial situation, select measuresand propose customized SSUR.
Consultant experts and stakeholders from the building, energy and financial sector
Public participation
CITyFiED KPIs for district renovationEvolution of KPIs definition
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
CITyFiED KPIs for district renovation
Three levels of indicators are integrated in the CITyFiED MethodologyKPI-driven approach:
City Level Indicators (city & district) (L1)
Project Level Indicators (L2)
Impact Assessment Indicators (L3)
CITyFiED: three levels of indicators
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
City Level Indicators (city & district)
Project Level Indicators
Impact Assessment Indicators
L1 L2 L3
CITyFiED KPIs for district renovationCity Level Indicators (L1)
City Level Indicators (city & district)
Objective: Understand the city and district identifying barriers and opportunities to set the sustainable objectives.
KPIs matrix 3 x 5 areas. MT (17) | BU (14) | EN (14)
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
Builtenvironment
(BE)
Economy & Innovation
(EI)
Social wellbeing
(SO)
Governance(GO)
Environment& Resources
(ER)
Mobility & Transport (MT)
Buildings (BU)
Energy (generation and distribution) (EN)
City Strategic Areas
Ap
plic
atio
nA
reas
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
CITyFiED KPIs for district renovationProject Level KPIs (L2)
Project Level Indicators (L2)
Objective: detailed evaluation of the environmental, technical, economic and social viability of the different interventions.
Environmental (E1-E5), Technical (T1-T9), Economic (Ec1-Ec8) and Social indicators (background and acceptance).
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
Environmental indicators (E)
Technical indicators (T)
Economic indicators (Ec)
Social indicators
Project
KPIs
CITyFiED KPIs for district renovationImpact Assessment Indicators at city level (L3)
Impact Assessment Indicators (L3)
Objective: assess the impact of the measures at district and city level.
Energy impact (E1,E2), Environment impact (Ev5), Economy impact (Ec1, Ec7, Ec8) and Benefit for SMEs (B1-B6).
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
Energy impact (E)
Environment impact (Ev)
Benefit for SMEs (B)
Economic impact (Ec)
DISTRICT
RETROFITTING
CITYCity
District
Conclusions
… is a KPI-driven approach for urban renovation at district level designed as a consultancy tool for Sustainable Urban Planning.
… includes three levels of indicators to understand the city (L1), assess the solutions (L2) and evaluate the impact (L3).
…. facilitates the decision-making process in the selection of the strategies to be implemented.
… considers as reference the large CITyFiEDdemonstration cases and is validated through the active participation of the CITyFiED network of cities, guaranteeing its replicability.
The CITyFiED methodology…
Sustainable Places 2017, June 28-30. Middlesbrough, UK.
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Seventh Programme for research, technological development and
demonstration under grant agreement N° 609129.
@cityfied_euCITyFiED ProjectMy Smart City District
http://www.cityfied.eu/
Thank you for your attention!