+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30...

0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30...

Date post: 02-Mar-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
15
b0 0 a 0 N23/6272-1s cg. boo3060 XII aa. N6 11111111111111111111111111111 II Ill 2373160361672 www.l nfo.court. ge 000.3 06ca(Y).(Y')80ooob 0 063om0Mooob aob080(Y')mo: 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b 3 oOo <t>036000m b0:J8om0 04.01.2016 I
Transcript
Page 1: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

b00a0 N23/6272-1s

14.03.2016\lo~o

moo~obob b0:J0~0:J(Y). b0b080(Y')m~(Y).

cg. 0~80006oo~ob boo3060 XII aa. N6

11111111111111111111111111111 II Ill 2373160361672 www.lnfo.court.ge

000.3 06ca(Y).(Y')80ooob m03ob~ca~ooob 0063om0Mooob o6booo~oo aob080(Y')mo: :J.moo~obo. 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· N~ 3

oOo <t>036000m moo~obob b0:J0~0:J(Y). b0b080(Y')m~(Y).b 0cg806ob()M0Go~~o b0:J8om0 j(Y).~oooob 04.01.2016 \)~ob 00cg0\)83000~000.

I

Page 2: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

oQGQGwgG0c;<G 0800QwQpc;Si o~ogG<Gmc;m 0Gog <)W~co0c;gc;<lc;<l T£

OQGQGwgG0c;<G 0800QwQpc;Si •t:

c;m q~G~0c;q c;gqg

·coo~o0Gf\ 600-ST/vOoN qo~o0£<: 91 qo~f\ SIO'G c;8wqcoowg c;gQGQoQqgo qoQG0c;wo8gc;<G qoQG~SiG<)o8c;w qoo~kg0wSigo £0( c; )c; C~C~0c;qwg 8o~Ggw0 'C<;bqCDot'c;q go c;gC8c;Q qoo8c;g0wSigo w0c;Xc;q q0Gqc;<)g<:q <)OQC~8c;qwgCB £0\lll CqG<)<:£WQ qw~c;8Cc;ru

c;g8wqcowg w~G~0c;<lc;<l · 1

o~o~c;g OCDOQW~o0G~wc;

<:QG~c;8c;m qoQC~Go80wqgc;Q qoQGruGgp :ogc;<Gc;q <)08<'m

ogc;oqG~C8Q c;o~c;Qc;g -o~G9G<Gmc;gwg0<'~

00Gqc;qgc;q qoQC~8c;qwgGB £0\l{) -CqG<)c;£wg

Gpc;0Gqoc;g wo8c;ru 'o~o8Bo~c;8c; gc;8C~ -OQG~gG<Gmc;gwg0c;~

oQGQoQqgo <)OQG0c;wo89c;<G <)OQG~SiGqo8c;w qoo8c;g0wSigo £O(c;)c; -G~G~0\'<)Wg

0~08B<:QC0c:q 0c:gc;w ogc;8orug qogwruqq c;o~Gqc:0c;ru c;gc;g G~w0c;gc;qwg

c;o<GG~wt' c;wCgpc;<l ~Go8c;0Qqogogruc; <)W~cn0c;gc;<)c;q wpc;~c;pc;q qoqo~OQCD

oqo~OQCD ·p

.:ifi·w10; GJUl"f.\Nw'/I

9£SOF06S6lL£l

t1111111111m111111111111111t111

o~o~c;g o~c;8c;<)GB

wo~Gqc;<) qw~C8w0c;pc;q

"<JC~oQC8R~"U>"~

o~Gf\ 910('; '00c;8gc;o t

SI-'GL'G9/£oN Cgpc;q

Page 3: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

.1. 2015 \)~ob 16 .::i.3<Y>o~b .::i(.::i)o.3 o6<(3(Y}M8.::ieoob m03ob'CJ<z3~05ob 0063om0<Y>o5ob 6booo 'CJo8.::i 006eb0wo5om aoa.::i<Y>m.::i bbo.3 ooa(Y}b03~05ob b.::iab.::ib'CJ<Y>b w.::i b.::i00<Y>m3o~(Y}b

'b(Y}()0<;:p0 0<;:p8o6olJ0M0QO'CJ~O J(Y}W0obob 37-38-o, 80-40 8jb~o()olJ oob.::i().::,8ob0<;:p, 8(Y}OOJb(Y}30 o6<8(Y}M80Goob 00Go80: 0.::i6b(Y}MGOO~W0 ITT'CJ .::i<Y>.::i 008(Y}b03~05ob b.::i8b.::ibj<Y>ob 8oo<Y> lJ Q <Y>m3o~(Y}OO .::i<Y>bo5'CJ~O OJOOJ(Y}O'C)~O m03obj<(30~o o6<;:pjbOMO'CJ~O <\)(Y}6ob 008("}\)80()0 " 3 lJ•::JCCp~o o6<;:pjbOMOj~O <\)(Y}6ob ood86ob, 8(Y}\)fj(Y}()ob.::i <;:p0 <(3'CJ6oGO(Y}6o<Y>o5ob \)obo5ob

Go5ob . oob.::ibo5" b0d0<Y>m3o~(Y}b 8m03<Y>(Y}()ob 2008 \)~ob 3 036obob N9 131

1), CS' -o~o5ob Bo-4 BCCJb~ob .3o<Y>30~0 .3'CJ6doob ".::," d30.3CCJ6doob oob.::i5.::i8ob.::i<;:p. .::i8030 b (9Q5om, 8omomo5'CJ~O ooB(Y}\)Bo5ob 0.::i6b(Y}MG00~05ob 008mb303000, 8(Y}OJb(Y}360~

t 1; JI 1,•, OJOOJ(Y}O'C)~O oo8(Y}\)8o5ob .::i8b0b30~0 <;:p0b336ob .::i6 (Y}d8ob 8o\)(Y}<;:p050

<'l"'' )1) j • cgor>~ob0m3ob.

1 M).~ 1 5CCJ~o5.::i, <Y>(Y}ao~b.::iG m.1<Y>w6(Y}()0 b.::ib.::ia.::i<Y>m~(Y}: :) (, )o 06<(3(Y}<Y>a0Goob m03ob'CJ<z3~05ob 0063om0<Y>o5ob o6booo'CJoob 2015 \)~olJ 16 .::i.3<Y>o~o1J 1 04115-009 006Gb0w05.::i (b.£3. 14) .

. 1.2. lJlJo.3 008<"lb03~05ob b08b0bj<Y>80 2015 \)~ob 4 8.::iobob N921-03/44852 \)o<Y>o~om .::i(.::i)o.3 (Y}M80Goob m03ob'CJ<z3~0()ob 0063001.::i<Y>or>ob o6booo'CJob OG6<"l50, M(Y}8 (Y}M006o'b0Goo1J

o 2015 \)~ob 16 .::i0<Y>o~ob 0.::i6Gb.::iwor>om a(Y}mb(Y}360~0 06<(30'l<Y>80Go0 b.::i00<Y>m3o~(Y}oo , (Y) \)[)e, ~ OOJ(").Q'C]~O o6<;:p'C)bOMO'CJ~O <\)(Y}6ob oo8(Y}\)8o5ob oob.::ibo5, b000<Y>m3o~(Y}b

Odll \j 39-o BCCJb~ob oolJ.::i5.::i8olJ.::i<;:p, \).::i<Y>a(Y}.::iw0o6b lJ.::i0.::i<;:p.::ilJ.::ib.::i<;:p(Y}

o' · ~' · , M(").a0~u.::iG oti<Y>CS? ("). u.::iu.::ia.::i<Y>m~("). : QO(").b.:>3~05ob b08b0b'C)Mob 2015 \)~ob 4 80obob N°21-03/44852 \7o<Y>o~o (lJ. <(3 . 16).

3.1. 3. 2015 \)~olJ 8 03601J1J 0( 0 )o.3 o6<(3<"lM80Goob m03ob'CJ<(3~05o1J 0063om0<Y>or>ob 061Jooo'CJ080 0<;:p806obo<Y>0GO'CJ~O b0~03<Y>om 8080<Y>m0 bboo 008(").b03~05ob b081J0bCCJ<Y>b <;:p0 a(Y}o0Jb<"l30 b0X,0M<"l 06<(3(").M80GOOb 00Goa0, M<"l80~0G aomomo5'CJ~O Ofj<"l 2015 \)~olJ 16 0.3<Y>o~ob OPD04/15-009 006Gb0wor>000.

a03oeo5CCJ~o50, <Y>(Y}ao~1J0G 08<Y>w6(Y}()0 b0b080<Y>m~(Y} :

- 2015 \)~ob 8 03601Jo1J 0wao6obo<Y>0Go'CJ~o 1J0~030<Y>o (b.£3. 51-55).

3.1.4. bbo.3 008<"lb03~05ob b08b0bCCJMOb 8o<;:po0Goob b05.J(Y}b 2015 ()(Y)d0605om 0M <;:p0J80fj(Y}<(30~<;:p0 0( 0 )o.3 06<(3<"lM80Goob

o6booo'CJOOb .::i<;:p806obo<Y>0GO'CJ~O b0~030<Y>o.

8030Go5CCJ~o50, M<"lBo~bG Ol:JM<;:p6(Y}().) b0b08.::i<Y>m~(Y}:

- blJo.3 008<"lb03~05ob b08b0bj<Y>o1J Bowo0Goob b05J(Y}1J 2015 ()(Y)d06050 (b.<(3. 56-58).

2

Page 4: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

II

!I

'}

I I I

b0dao 0Mboo'CJ~o a0L10~oool.I aoa("}vaoool.I, ab000m0 0bl.lfo-00oa000000ool.I a<'lliaoool.10 Q?0 b R[J (.!! b b0800m~oo0030 l.10<z3'CJd3~0060'loob ao80lv8ooob 'OOQ?Oo0Q?, l.10l.10800m~<"l 8030Q?0

0 u:ih.1 ~ BQ?o, 00'l8 b.:>0Ro~o 'CJOQ?0 Q?03808<"l<z30~Q?Oli.

" ', ,,, 1, );'•LH lJ 'l3~oo0m0 030<"l0'CJ~o .3<"l5305800, b0j00m30~(Y}l.\ 30l6booo'CJG00, l.l0j00m30~("}l.\

Q?8o5olio00eo'CJ~o .3<"lQ?Odlio, b0j00m3o~(Y}l.\ l.l000Q?0li0b0Q?<"l .3<"l\!?odlio, I ··: I·· • 1! I : l:J <"lU 300("}00 ,, m03oli'C)<z30~0 OOQ?'CJliOMO'CJ~O 'b0l5ooob aol.10boo"' l.10j00m3o~("}U

\j 2011 v~ob 5 00630ob N9 1 l Q?0Q?Q060~ooom Q?0803oeoo'CJ~O "m03ob'CJ<z30~0 d86ol.10m3ob v00l.10Q?005o 00006ooob <"lQ?05<"loob, m03ob'CJ<z30~o 'b0'l5ob aoj85ob l.l0 Q?0 bj0l5~ob aofob3ob aol.10boo" o5bo0'CJdG00, l.10j00m30~0lb 8m030<"loob 2008

Vt"' ll · 36ol.lob NQ131 Q?0Q?0o5o~ooom Q?0803oeoo'CJ~o "m03ob'CJ<z3.:>~o o5Q?'CJbo0o'CJ~o ' od85olJ, O<'lV8<'lool.10 Q?0 £3'CJ5deo0l5o0ooob vobooo".

("). ~o .3<"l6306eoolJ ao-10 O'C)b~o 0003\J bb30m0 OQ?Ooooll

00Q? Goa01J. llo oo'CJ~ a'CJb~ol.I CJou u ~, (!2{)~ u 'CJ ~ \j ti 0~01 M(!? Q.;l \j ~ ~MO

li. j . <1 ' O~Ml> <"l6UC)06'CJG00 00'80'lM800oob m03ob'CJ<z3~0001J V't r:i630~8<"l<(30U Boo 0 M06000b od~o30 Q?0 b0bo~8vo<z3<"ll.l 03oll0oob 000 8b<"l~MQ? 60000 'CJM 30~Q?OO'CJ~oob, bo~o 0M OO'CJ00~0lb 0o00'l36000b OO<z3<"lM00GOOb ao~oo0Clo, 0M08QQ? 00'l'booo'CJM 30~Q?OO'CJ~oo01J - 00l.l0oll Sol.I bo~m 00l.loo'CJ~o o5<z30'l0a0800. l.l0j00m30~("}ll J<"l5liooo'CJG00 8b<"l~<'lQ? oa ao8mb3030ao 'b~'CJQ?03b 0~60'06'CJ~ 'CJ'l3~000b m'C) O<"lmb<"l30~0 OO<z3<"lM80Q00 aooo03b b0bo~8vo<z3<"l, 000l<z3Ql.IO'CJ~ 05 .3<"l80MGO'CJ~ b00Q?'C)O~<"l000b.

3

Page 5: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i)

fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.), (i)(Y).8[)~0G Q?.)J.)300MQ00~0.) .)Q?.)8o.)6ob ~.)58(Y)mo~(Y).o.)bm.)5, Sob £30fo6boom.)6 .)6 bb3.) JQMd(Y). b.)3omboom.)6, .)M.)3obm3ob .)M 06Q?.)

Of:J(Y).b bo~aob.)\73Q?(Y).8o m3om .)a .)Q?.)8m6ob m.)5b8(Y).oob 0.)MQOQ, 0.)MQ?.) J.)5(Y).5om

/

<:Q.)Q?OQ5o~o 008mb303ooob.), M(Y).(Q[)b.)G [)b .)0GO~[)O[)~O.) b.)bQ~8\)o'(3(Y). 0000M(Y).[)Oob .)6 b.)'b(Y).().)Q?(Y).[)OMo30 0b.)1(3MOJb(Y).[)OOb 0'b(Y)063o~b.)f:J(Y).1(3.)Q?, X,.)58Mm[J~(Y).OOb, bb3.)m.) 0'23~ooooob.) Q?.) m.)3ob0£3~[)0Qoob Q?.)b.)G.)3.)Q?.

~L b.)d.)Mm3o~(Y).b J(Y).6booo0Goom MQ0~.)ao5o0Moo0~0 IJ.)X,.)M(Y). o6£3(Y).M8.)Goob bo~aob\)3Q?(Y).8(Y).00b 'boa(Y)..)~60060~0 'b(Y).().)Q?O ..3M06Go..3o J(Y).5JM[)OO'bOMQ00~0.) 'b(Y).().)Q?O .)Q?8o5oboM.)G00~0 J(Y).Q?Oobob 80-3 m.)300 (,,o5!(3(Y).M8.)GOOb m.)3ob0£3~Qo.)") . .)~60060~0 m.)3ob 28-o 80b~o o8o(Y).M[)ob J(Y).6booo0Go0M 6(Y).(i)8.)b, (i)(Y).8 b.)X,.)M(Y). o6!(3(Y).MfoGo.) ~O.).),

0.)MQ?.) J.)6(Y).6om 0.)m3.)~ob\)06000~0 008mb303ooob.) Q?.) Q?.)Q?oo6o~o \)obo~ IJ.)bo~8\)o'(3(Y)., J(Y).8[)MG00~ <:Q.) dOM.)Q? b.)OQ?08~(Y).[)O.)b 8030m36000~0 05!(3(Y).M8.)GOOb.), 0).)3ob 8b(i)o3, b.)X,.)M(Y). 061(3(Y).M8.)Goob ~Qo.)~0M Q?QC(306oGo.)b od~Q3.), 'b(Y).().)Q?O .)Q?8o5oboM.)G00~o

J(Y).<:s?Odbob 8[)(Y).MQ 80b~ob ,,8" 030..306doo, (i)(Y).8~ob oob.)o.)8ob.)Q?, b.)X,.)M(Y). o6!(3(Y).M8.)GO.) .)Mob (Y).£30G0.)~0(i)o Q?(Y).J0Bo600 (8.)m o(Y).(i)ob, fob.)'bo, 8.)300 0, 0008.), bdo8.), '23(Y).o(Y).b0M.)mo, o~odoM(Y).60~0 05!(3(Y).M8.)GO.), 3owo(Y).- (g.) .)0Q?0(Y).~.)fo\)QM[)OO ), .)60 b.)X,.)M(Y). Q?.)\)QU[)o'C)~Qo.)oo Q?.)G0~o, .)()M[Jm30 b.)X,.)M(Y). Q?.)\)oboo0~ooob .)5 8(Y).b.)8b.)b'C)Mob 8oo(i) b.)8b.)b'C)M[)0Mo3 b.)d8o.)6(Y).o.)bm.)5 Q?.)J.)300Mooom 80~000~0, Q?.)8'C)o.)3Qo'C)~o, 000860~0 .)5 0.)0 'b.:i360~0 o6'8(Y).M8 GO.'.>, .)IJ030 b.)X,.)M(Y). Q?.)\)oboo'CJ~[)OOb aoo(i) dM(Y)..)doo'CJ~.)Q?

0.)8(Y).d30l:J6QO'CJ~O o6'8(Y).M o .

cno' u u d 'CJ~o (Y).~o0uou ao-v CC::' O• <!? O G .)Q?0[)6b, 0M.8 l:J30~ lJ J lJ 'CJ'8~Qo.) 0.)QG5(Y).ll

o5 ll() .)G ~ 0 5 ' .) uoo'CJ~ U.)X,.)M(Y). o6!(3(Y).M8.)GO.)U, .:i00 o 30 Soo~(Y).b 8.)mo .)u~ooo, m0 ollo6o .)('} ·aooe.)306 b.)bo~8\)o!(3(Y)., ..30(Y).£3obo0~ .)6 J(Y).So0Go~~ b.)OQ?'CJB~(Y).oo.)b

.:i5 Jo0b(Y).fo~'CJ0 a(Y).fo00aoau.

4

Page 6: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

1111111

~

Cq,W':>COJq8\'0J<;''J 11oOJ<;>q\'ll\'OJ<;''J 0R,w9<;>'J0w WOJ\'q\'ll\'OJ<;''J\'11 8w0 '<;>9o'JOJ<;'<;'OJ 8wu:Dw0\'8\'ll\'ll '9\'Wll\'8\' '9\'WQCqwoP\'ll wp0CP <;>8q11 <;'OJ 9\'<.0QC119<;>9of.O '9\'<.0ll\'QWW':>C<.0089\'X <;'O~GQC00R,8<;>t'<;'OJ OocaCW':>8w0 '<J.QCefl~8 oW':>GQCll0\' OR,QC0C~\'9\'<cJ 0GW':><;>o8of.Ow -<;>08\'80wf.090 0W':>GQC90AA0"£sew\'i~~i. >; p9Gt,> C0wC8 110W':>qG8 C-1 t 11008GQoQ119wP <;>9po W':>GQC0c:t,\'W8 oR,f.OGQX~(o0rJ%~fi . X C809COJW8\'0 <;>f.OwfkOJ 11008<;>80-wf.090 0W':>GQC90~110W':><;>8w<;>'J / '·:-. .-? (J 1i)

woW':>qG ':·~fr:~ t ~~008 = Q119wP 11wu:DC8w0\'P\'ll 0W':>GC9<ao8 <;>9po OJ\'W':>QCW':>pc;i11CR. woQCW':> ~:G~~\'~ ~~ 09w\'W8Cc:t, 11wu:Dw0\'8\'ll\'ll woOGQoQ119wP\'ll 11wu:DC8w0\'P\'ll

~~~~~ ~·· y 'll<;'8<;>8\'ll\'ll llOQCQCW':>f.O~~\'llOQCQCW':>f.OG <;'<.0<;'8q11 'llOQWW':>Cw089\'X 'ru<;>f.Owfk11W':>C89G0q,G 110QCwqw0f.0<;>11G 0800QCWOJ<;''JWc:t,\'ll 9\' llOQCW0R,OR,G wf.00~8W':>Cq<;>11 <;'O~CQCW':>o8G7,<;> 11C 8<;>11Cruw0 '\'llOQC8C8qw8CR. 0W':>o9C'Jru<;>ru <.009w9\'P \'ll0\'<J 'CR.C0<;>'J llOQW8q9\'<.0 1109<;>08\'ll\' 8\' wo8w 08WOJ8~\'ll08W':>Cq 11wRo \'OJ9G 0\' 1108w1108\'0\' '9\'wQCqwoP\'11 wp0CP <;>8q11 9\' 9<;><.0QC119<;>9of.O 1108 '9\'<.0ll\'QwW':>Cw089\'X 1109\'08\'ll\' <;>0W':>GQC00R.8\'P<;>ru 80W':>C8w0 '<;>08<;>80wf.090 oW':>GQCllSY\' OR,QC0C~\'9\'<cl 0GW':><;>o8of.Ow 'OJ\'8Q"9"w 110W':>8w0 'Cq,QpgGt,> C0wC8 110W':>qGg C-L v 11uu8GQoQ119wP 11wu:DC8w0\'~\'ll l\QCwuc.oCJ.ug 8\'W':l8P wu:Dw0\'8c;'ll\''I

11a<:a1

qo<~)<' <.'o~)<'R':>wf liQ

<Ol\\'QU <.'Qt.><~CX11g ri0Q110~<.'0~JG~<1 CCCq" Q gw~<.00<.'8<.'()<.'<") '<")<.'QW~QC~f?<'l)C~ 11u08c;it'utz>uQ9Cruo

01108 c;i8CW':>po o8C8c;igw8 c;iu:DC8R oW':>GQCll0" Cq,W':>GOJqgc;iroc;iQ l)oruc;iqc;il)<.'OJ<;>'J ·wc;i8 118c;iq<;>11c;i \'OJ 9\'WQCQww0Cow0G wro<;>q<;>11<;>ro<;>'J<;>11 <;>0W':>GQG00R.8"t'c;iro c;i08c;ig0wf.090 00Cog110QG9 oW':>GQG0c:t,\'wg OR,<;>QCwW':>8GOJo\'ll WOJ\'q\'ll\'OJ\''J\'ll 8W0 'c;io9<aoo8 OJ\'11C9<;>8wu:DG98g,098G C8C11c;i 8WW':><.00\'8\'ll<;'ll ·Q)<;>QCillCR, 11011COw0£ 110QC000Q1109080J\' llOQCOJ\'Q\''l\'OJ<;''J 110080 118<;><.0 OR,QCw9<;>'J0w wru<;>q<;>q<;>ru<;>'Jc;iq 110 8W0 '8oqo qQC9<;>0<.00C<;> 11<;>08<;>g0wf.090 W':>GQC98wGt'o8 'l\'QCwW':>8Gruoc;iq wru<;>q<;>q<;>ro<;>'J<;>q ·ogC8<;>9w8 oW':>GQCwW':>8Groo\'qc;i<2 00Cog110QC9 \'QCqCCR, 8<;>qW':>C8w0 'oW':>Cillq8\'0J\''J 11oruc;iqc;iq<;>ru<;>Q -oQpCoQGq 00"8"w8 c;iww0C"ll ''l\'QWW':>QCW':>oOGc;i 110QCQoW':><;>fiwg<;>'cJ 11008oq,wt,> 0800QCW':>w0c;ig<;>q0Go8GQ0Q119wt' 09<;>ow0C W0\'808 qog llQCQW00£\'9\''J Oc;i0 '09<;>R,09 oW':>CQCw<;>oq<;>q<;>g ww0G<;>q 'owoQC1t0" G809C0Jw8\'0 q8pc;i '<;>qoQC98w0Cf.OW':><;>8<;>08 oqog ru<;>8c;iOJCqGog 'q<;>o8<;>80wf.090 W':>GQC98wGt'o8 lt\'QCwW':>gGroo<;>q wro<;>qc;iq<;>ru<;>'J<;>q gw0 '<;>Q0<;>g9<;>'J gwW':><.00\'8\''l\''I 'rowp0CP ·woQC00R,8<;>t'c;iru 9<;>wq<;>o8"80wf.090 W':>GQC98wGP08 'l\'QCwu:D8Gilloc;iq wruc;iq<;>q<;>ru<;>'J<;>q <;>wCt'<;><;>Q \'QCQ0<;>g9<;>'J

09<;>8wu:DC98R,098 8wu:Dw0c;i8\''1<;''1 8c;iwou:Dgw0 'Cq, \'QCW':>oQC8R~<;>ru<;>Q 80t /90t /8/GoN qo0Q8wQPw ,,;-, OS qou:D~ 800G qw~w0c;i8c;'ll<;'(). wo8GQ0Qq9wt'c;iq 11w~C8w0c;ip<;>q llQC<..oowGo8 w~<.00\'8\''l\''I

''1\'QCw~8Gruo<;>11 wro<;>qc;iq<;>ro<;>'J<;>ll \'QCg8wGPCg<;>'J g<;>rooQgC8we qog<;>8fi<;> Cq,<;>8q800w\' wOJ<;>q<;>q<;>ro<;>'J<;>q oqog '<;>qoo8<;>g0wf.090 w0<;>X<;>q o~GQC000Qqo<JC0

oR,0QqCC0 qoQC00£ o~Goruo0Go (o~Go80C8wt'\'0\') wC80"~C8"11"0" <;>ru <;>WC80\'~Cg c;iro "lloo8<;>80wf.090 QCq"llCR. 110QCg<;>o~c;i8c;iru wro<;>q<;>qc;iro<;>'Jc;iq 'c;iqo08wg woO<;>t'of.OoQgCO'Joc;i '<;>11ow0\'8\'lloe '<;>qoQCillw~~Cq<;>q '<;>qo11GQ<;>Qq 11o~Cruq8"ro<;>'J 11oroc;iq<;>11<;>ro~·

<;>ru0c;i'J 'c;io8<;>g0wf.090 00Co81toQC9 o~GQCwog QCqc;i11CR. 11o~Cruqg<;>ru<;>Q 11oru<;>q"ll"ru·

Pl? fflr=:tt-===== -==-== ,I, -------

Page 7: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

bG'C'.J~O 06ez3(Y).M80G00 .'.>MOU ,,(Y).ez30G00~jM 80fo\)ocY>or>oo 0cY>bor>'C'.J~O 06ez3(Y).M80G00", :>Bcgofow0G b000cg0b0b0cg(Y). (Y).000601.or>o b0bo~avocs(Y). eio'C'.Jxooocg06 w0csofo6uoei'C'.J~o w0 :>bo~8\)oez3(Y). 08(Y).G06D()ob 00680b01.MGOD~D()D~O 01.M0.:>601.or>o0 cg.:> od m038(Y).tjMO~o

6or>obaoo0o <(3(Y).M8ob 06ez3(Y).M80GOOU UMj~O b.3odo0o oooa~oei0 od6ob 006bo~j~O,

M01.001.MG ,,01.ez30G00~jM 80fo\)00o5oo 0MUQ5j~O 06ez301.M80G00". b0b08.'.>M(J)~(Y).a 00o'bo000 b.3oGo.:>~oboob 8(Y).b0'bcY>or>0 080bm06 cg0303oocY>or>om, 001.8 b000cg0b0b0cg01. b0ocgj8~01.Dr>0ll

803jm3605'C'.J~O 8(Y).foGo8or>o csofo6bor>b j3.:>3000cgo50. b0b0800m~(Y).a 00680000, 001.8 ,,csofo6bor>m06 cg0303oocY>or>0~0 o5cs01.080eo0" 801.oe03b cs0~0cg 0cY>moocY>m01.r>or>m06 cg0303oocY>or>0~ o5cs01.080eo0b cg0 o.o. b000cg.'.>b.'.>b.'.>CQ01. 0cY>moocY>m01.r>or>m.'.>6 CQ.'.>J.'.>3oocY>or>0~

06ez301.M80G00U. 0Bcgofocg, b000cg0b0b0cg01. b0ocg08~01.or>0b 803jm36or>'C'.J~O 05ez301.M80G00, M01.80~0G b\)01.MOCQ b00cg0b0b0(?01. '['.JM(J)OOM(J)(Y).()or>b 0303oocY>cgo().), \).'.>M801.0CQQD5b ,,csofo6bo5m06 cg0303oocY>o50~ 06cs01.cY>80Go0b" cg0 8(Y).dG00~00 b0d00m30~01.b

J01.6booo0Goob 41-o a0b~ob ao(Y).00 006doom CQ.'.><;.?0060~ J01.6booo0eo0cY>b.'.>800m~o5003 cY>otJo8oo.

b0b08.'.>0m~(Y). 0~6oofo3b, 001.8 006b0bo~30~0 cg03ob b006ob0 cg0 b0b008o~(Y). 8(Y).mb01.3fobm06 cg0303000o50~0 801..30b0bob o(Y).'boeoob 00m30~ob\)0605om, 8600360~01.30600 cg0cg006cgob -\)00801.0CQ006b m0 000 a(Y).b008o~ob o6oocY>obob bcso001.oo 008030~0 o6ez301.080Go0 m03obo oofo00llom 0803000 b000cg.'.>b0CQ01. 801.foGo8o5ob oo8G30~ 06cs(Y).cY>80Go.'.>b, M0G b0d.'.>0m30~01.b

b000<:.g0b0 0<:.Q01. JCVl<:.QOdbob 39-o 80b~ob 00m30~ob\)0605om b0j:oM01.Q5b b0ocg08~01.CQ

oofob3ou 0'CJGo~o()~(Yll:) b. .'.>8.'.>3cgcY>01.'C'.J~0cg, 06w0 w.)w006cgob - aou0a~o5o~o.) m0 00 0 Bomomo()'CJ~ M. Od b ~ob 8MG08'CJ~ Clo m 3030b 05 8ob cg ().-, d (~M~[)?i ' M ou a\"Jt> 0 v ~ \) LI 'Yl l :11\ . ), h r ,..., I 1'>0\') I ( ~) ' • li ll·\ 1.i: 1'rJ< c•'>t)' ·n~'" l >ot~ob 'Jnn<'> ol vwH:>!J' o b ( c v:.i' Q.;>t·1~ · J• · l · 101\ ! '." 0 <.:.: 1 ~>('J' b ( 0

U • b ,. < ) > 1 1 8 ) . · ''t ')11ll<·ilJ: J~1ob ll ), l~'M UC'"1\\. (~>P, ~ b 6c..~XJMQ lJb

~ cV, '00 b \y1r , <t'.'< 'CJUOMO'['.J~O 'bCVl6ob ' Od b, M.\)tj01.5oll .':> cg0

ez306dGoCVl6oMQC'>ob ~ObOC'> b .'.>Cl630Go5ob oob.'.>bo5" b0d0<'>m3Q~CVlll 8 .:i3~M.C'>o ll 2008 \)~ob 3 036ollob NQ131 <:.g0cg005o~o5oll Bo-4 80b~ob .30<'>30~0 006dooll "0" d30.306doob OQU.':>5080U0<:.Q, OQ801.U.':>3~Q()OU U.':>8U.':>b'['.JMOU 80QM U.':>d.':>Mm3Q~01.00 0MUQ5'['.j~O (J)O(J)01.Q'['.j~O

m03ob0cs0~0 06cg0bocY>o0~0 'bCVl5ob oo801.\)8o5ob 006b01.MGOO~O()ob ez3.'.>doob cg0<:.g0bo00o50, ooB01.\)Bo5ob 005b01.MGOO~o5oll 00Bmb303000 30, mom01.Q'['.J~O oo801.\)Bo5ob 08b0b30~0 cg0ll336oll 06 01.d8oll 8ollm3ob 00w0Goa0.

~c_.)af'J /~ C LJ.,. t

M01.()01.MG .'.>~o5oofo , a(Y).bcY>Bo~ob 0600Mobo cg03.'.>3000o50~00 a~ -~- · .'.>b'['.J<'>ob Boo<'> ll.'.>d0cY>m3o~(Y).00 00llo50~0 (J)O(J)(Y).0'['.J~O m03oll0cs0~~ ~ '['.) . M . ~ 'b01.6oll oo801.\)8o5ob ().'.>5b(Y).MGOO~o5ob oob.'.>bo() 05<(3CVlM8.'.>GOOU 801.001.30 . ~ f; ' M~,~ .) .) ··:er: 06cg.'.>

0801.U mom(Y).0'['.J~O oo801.\)8o5ob .'.>8b.'.>b3Q~, OQ801.b.'.>3~05oll O.'.>~ ~?2~, ~o~!:,~o 0060~ CQ.'.>ll33fooo .'.>5 (Y).d8oo. m.'.>3ob 8b<'>o3, oo8(Y).\)Bo5.'.> CQ.'.> Sol.lo 'OOCQ000~ l!i'-zo~#~~~~(>-)5· o 06cg.'.>

~ p~ · • ~-. /, 0801.ll "m03oll0£30~0 06cg0bocY>o0~0 'b01.5oll ood85ob, a(Y).\)801.5olls· .... ~ . 0(Y).5o<'>o5ob \)obo5ob cg0803oeo5ob oob0bo5" b0d.'.>0m30~01.b 8m030(Y).5ob 2008 \)~ob 3 036obob N9 131 CQ.'.>W0060~05ob ao-4 a0b~ob .30030~0 006doob ".)" d30.306dooll a(Y).mb(Y).3fobm.'.>6.

6

Page 8: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

b0800m~(Y} 800momo5b "m03ob0£30~0 06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}6o5ob oob0bo5" b0d00m3o~(Y}b ~6(Y}6'bo, 0(Y}8o~oG .:>Q?0o6b m.:>3ob0£3.:>~o 06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}6o5ob ood86ob.:> Q?.'.> ~OJ30Q?0QOOb VObb, o.'.>6b.:>'b~30.:>3b m.:>3ob0£3.'.>~0 06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}6o5ob 8.:>0m3ob.'.> Q?.'.> 08 'b(Y}6o5ob £3.:>00~o5oo 88.:>0m3o~(Y}5ob.:> Q?.'.> 8(Y}8b.:>b0005ob/'boQ?08boC?3o~(Y}5ob (Y}0o.'.>6(Y}o5ob ood86ob.'.> Q?.'.> b.:>d8o.'.>6(Y}5ob vobb, .'.>Q?oo6b m.:>3ob0£3.'.>~0 06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}6ob b.:>v.:>08(Y}o5ob.:>m3ob Q?.'.>8.:>oo5om 0o0(Y}5o5b, b.:>0.:>Q?.:>b.:>b.'.>Q?(Y} oo~.:>3.:>mo5b.:> Q?.'.> .:>8 'b(Y}6o5ob b.:>d8m6(Y}5.:>bm.:>6 Q?.:>303000050~ bb3.:> b.:>3ombo5b.

0~60060~0 J06(Y}6ob 80-3 80b~ob 00030~0 006doob m.:>fob8.'.>Q?, m.:>3ob0£3.'.>~0

06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}fo .:>0ob b.:>d.:>0m3o~(Y}b b00.:>Q?.:>b.:>b.:>Q?(Y} d(Y}C?odbom 0.:>m3.:>~obvo602>0~0 m.:>3ob0£3.:>~o 'b(Y}6ob foo0b0bo(Y}5.'.>, b.:>Q?.'.>G 8(Y}d80Q?05b Q?.'.>8.:>oo5omo 0o0(Y}5o5o Q?.'.> b.'.>o.'.>Q?.'.>b.'.>b.'.>Q?(Y} oo~.:>3.:>mo5o. .:>8.:>30 80b~ob ao(Y}0o 006doob oob.:>5.:>8ob.'.>Q?, m.:>3ob0£3.'.>~0

06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}fo .:>0ob b.:>d.:>0m3o~(Y}b oo0oo(Y}0oob fovo~o 0.:>6b.:>'b~300~0

b0'b~30o5om.:> Q?.'.> J.'.>6(Y}6om 8060.Jo2>0~0 · b00Go.:>~00o bo.:>00bom. 80-3 006doob m0fob80Q?, m03ob0£30~0 06Q?0bo000~0 'b(Y}fo 0.:>6b.:>'b~300~0 3.'.>Q?OO"> ().'.>8("}08("}£3.'.> OJ(\'}6("}8030 0 0 b.:>d8o.:>6(Y}5ob.:>m3ob Q?.'.> 8ob £3000~o5oo 0o0o5o od308Q?o5.:>0o5006 b00Go0~00 03("}6("}80300 Q?0 b8.:>0m~o5003 0ot:Jo8b, 0(Y}8o~oG Q?0Q?0o6o~o.:> 08 a06(Y}6om.

7

Page 9: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

f)006(Y).orio 0b(Y).(Y)000~02>06 b0j0(Y)m3o~(Y).b b000Q?0b0b0Q?(Y). 306(Y).6BQ?o2>~(Y).2>ob 0<;!?bM'CJ~o2>ob ty)(Y).Goboo ); 3) b000Q?0b0b0Q?(Y). b00Q?0B~(Y).02>000 a(Y).0~(Y)o2>0~0 602>obaoocY>0 06<(3(Y).Ma08oob

,p3oo(Y)o b000Q?0b0b0Q?(Y). 'CJMmoo(Y)m(Y).<'>o<'>m06; 4) 00Q?0b0b0Q?ob 00Q?08bQ?O~~O 0(Y)bo50~0 830~0 B(Y).foGoBoQ?06 Bobo OQ?06oo<(30J0GOOb oob0d~o(')~(Y).l)0 Q?0 5) ()0Q?0b0b0Q?Ob

0.'.>Q?0Bb<:s.>o~~o .'.>Mbo50~0 06<(3(').(Y)B0Goob 303oo(Y)o <(3ofo6bo<'>m06, Bobo 0.'.>02p30<'>0 <(30fo6bo<'>m.'.>6 Q?0303oo(Y)o<'>0~ 06<(3(').M80Go0bm.'.>6.

'CJQ?03(').0, M(').B m03ob'CJ<(30~0 06Q?'C)b<.8)MO'CJ~O ~(').6ob ooj86ob o60G00<_8)(').M0 oood~o<'>0 Ofj(Y).b b.'.>v0(Y)8('). ( (Y).(Y)0060~0<_8)(Y).MO), (Y)(').Bo~oG oob05.'.>Bobo (Y).(Y)0060~0Go0~-b0B0(Y)m~o5(Y)o30 <(3(').MBom (Y)o0ob<_8)(Y)o(Y)o<'>0~00 306(').6BQ?o<'>~(').5om Q?0Q?0o6o~o vobom Q?0 .'.>803Q?M(').'CJ~.'.>Q?,

.'.><;!?MOGb30~00 00Q?0b0b.'.>Q?ob 00Q?.'.>BbQ?O~ ll05oodO.'.>Q?. ool\05.'.>Bob.'.>Q?, Bobo, (Y)(').0(').(Y)G

00Q?.'.>b0b0Q?ob 0.'.>Q?.'.>BbQ?o~ob oob0bo<'> Bo<;!?o<'>0~0 6o<'>obBoo(Y)o 06<(3(').M80Go0, 00MQ?0 b0j0(Y)m3o~(Y).b b00.'.>Q?.'.>b0b0Q?(Y). .3(').<:s.>odbob 39-o B0b~ob .3o(Y)30~ fovo~oo Bomomo<'>0~0

00B(').fo3~obo<'>ob0, Q?0G'CJ~O 06Q?0 OEJ(Y).b 00Bbo~ob.'.>006. 0B0bm.'.>6, 0B030(Y)o 06<(3(').MB0Goob b00Q?'CJB~01Q? oofob30~0 OMm-o(Y)m .30b0bobB00<'>0~ dOM0Q? ().'.>6b.'.>~<;!?3M'CJ~O.) b0()0Q?0b.'.>b0Q?('). (').(Y)006('). (b.'.>d.'.>Mm30~(').b b00.'.>Q?0b.'.>b0Q?('). J(Y).Q?Odllob 48-o B0b~ob ool\02>.'.>Bob.'.>Q?: 00B (').003~o<'>ob b0Bb0b0(Y)o Q?.'.> Bob 00B0Q?0o6~(').5000 00B030~0, ll0d0(Y)m30~(').l\ <(3ofo6bm0 Bo5oo<_8)<'0oo Boo(Y) 006b0~<;!?3M'CJ~O b<_8)(Y)'CJdO'CJM'CJ~O o(Y)mo0~05o ).

B(').G08'CJ~ CJ08mb3Q3.'.>oo Q?.'.>Q?oo60~00, M(').B Q?.'.>3ob l\00060 Q?.'.>303oo(Y)o<'>0~0.'.> b0j.'.>Mm30~(').oo 0MbQ()'CJ~ m.'.>3ob<J<(3 .'.>~o o6Q?<J0<_8)MO'CJ~O ~(').6ob ooB(').vBo<'>ob

01(1? o <'1MO ooo 80<;!?0<'> .'.>bm06. JQMd(').Q?, 801l\0(Y)~o~ob o5 a (I? b .'.>, t r vv,, ( . 1~..,, 11 ~ , • 0· o.

CJ00a ~a

,, ' 3 U'CJ<z3 ' J l> m3ob V.'.>MO.'.>Q?Q06o <'15olJ Cloj85olJ .30(1?(').(')0()olJ0 (90 IJ .'.> j(Y).6~ob oofob300

~Ol> b 'Clot.> O~ Ll~c 'CJOG ob <:Q0B<.8)30Go<'>ob m0(').<'> 0~0" b0j0Mm30~(').IJ Bm03<'0(').5ob (90<:Qo05o~o()om 0061J0'b<;!?3 <">0~ a(').mb(').35o5m06.

8

Page 10: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

06006'.J~O 06b6M'.J0Goob 80(Y}MO 01.)30 oooboo.) 0.)M.)600.)b. 30Md(Y}cp, 80-3 8'.Jb~ob

Jo(v)30~0 d'.J6doob 01.)fob8.)cp, 01'b-ob (Y}M0.)60'b.)6(Y}Mb 03.)~oo.) 0.)M.)6ooob V.)MQ?0ofo . .)8.)30 a'.Jb~ob 8o(Y}MO .3'.J6doob 01.)foba.)cp, .)8 8'.Jb~oo 800100100'.J~o 0.)(v).)60 0.) 'Q.)M8(Y}.)cp006b: .)) ,,01.)3ob'.J<z3''>~0 o6cp'.JbOMO'.J~O 'b(Y}6ooob oob.)boo" l\.)o.)M0130~(Y}b 3.)6("}6001 0.)013.)~ob'Qo600'.J~ Q?.) l\.)d.)(v)013o~(Y}b £30fo6b01.) l\.)8o6obo(v)(Y}b 88.)(v)013o~(Y}oob b£30M(Y}oo 008.)3.)~ b.)J(;'>M(Y} l\.)8.)(v)01~ob O'.JMOQ?O'.J~ .30M01.)6 - 008(Y}l\.)3~0C':>ob l\.)8l\.)b',JM01.)6 (oo8Q?0(Y}8oo - l\.)8l\.)b'.JMO) 0001.)6b80C':>'.J~ 01'b-ob 8(Y}'Q8(Y}(')ob 0008.)oO .)l\.)b'.J~O l\.)o.)i)(Y} 3(Y}66M(Y}~Ob dM(Y}GOQ?'.JMOC':>ob 0.)6b(Y}MGOO~ooob.)013ob b.).JOM(Y} 006(Y}(').)-fo00C':>(Y}(')oC':>ob, o6£3M.)b6M'.JoO'.JMOb, ood603.)-Q?.)foQ?0.)MOC':>ob l\.)8',JO.)(Y} MOiJ08oo £3'.J6oGo(Y}6o(v)ooob '.J'bM'.J630~8(Y}£30b l\.)o',J.)~Oo.)b; (')) 01'b-ob £3'.J6oGo(Y}6o(v)ooob .3o(v)o(Y}cpoo oob.)d~(Y}

V.)M8(Y}d86o~o l\.)0.)Q?.)b.)b.)(p(Y} 3.)~Q?OO'.J~ooob oobM'.J~ooob '.J'bM'C)630~8(Y}£30b 0.)M.)600.)b . .)8.)30 8'.Jb~ob 80-9 .3'.J6ooob 01.)fobfocp, .)8 8'.Jb~o01 0.)013.)~ob'Qo6oo'.J~O 0.)M.)600.) 'Q.)MOQ?~p6oC':> .) l\.)8l\.)b'.JMb.

061.loM'.JJGOOb 80-3 01.)30 oooboo.) 01.)3ob',J£3.)~0 o6cp'.JllOMO'.J~O 'b(Y}6ob 8(Y}'Q8(Y}(').)b01.)6 cp.)3.)3CJo(v)oo'.J~ 000603'.JM, Ll.)(Y}M0.)6o'b.)8o(Y} Q?.) bb3.) 8(Y}01b(Y}360ob. 30Ma(Y}cp, 80-6 8'.Jb~ob

d0M3Q~O d'.J6doob 01.)fob8.)cp, l\.)3.)~Q?OO',J~(Y}.) 01'b-b 0.).)fS6cpob OOMOO(Y}MOOb 8010~0

.3QMO OoMob 00801.8b.)'b~3(v)o~o, 3.).300.)~',JM.)Q? Q?.)8("}60.)iJOO'.J~O 8.)l\.)~ob .)(v).)fo3~00 2 Booe<'> b 80~~ol\ ~(Y}C':>[J, 0.)MQ?.) 08 00801b303olJ.), (Y)(Y}cpob.)G .3o0o8oo0ob Q0(Y}00.)£30'.J~O

Bcp[Jo ( 'Q'Cl'Q0~(Y}Q? 'b~3ol\, 8cpofo0ol\, .J0(Y}ool\, 3~cpob 8(Y}80i(fo30Q? .)0l\oo'.J~O

.3ocV> 0 a ( ) 'Q ~ cpob ~(Y}ool\ .)~8.)0013.)l\, .)6 001.cp[Jl\.)G .)0l\oo'.J~O Jo0o8oo0ob

M.8 0 0 Q01.(J)3.)~013.)~ol\ l\ollooao01 .)~Jio030~0 2 ao MO h 1•,,»l1 b. , b n ~) .c ob en ~ ) c -, ~, C!?· lJcpQ, [) < :) (\); I>: :J<">· .

. . , ·1: ft1: i .• 1, ·n: 11iv1t·i,· 1 1 :. 1 ~~)1~ ·1r\1 \I .i: J l1: J1.1..•1' 1:i . ,,<:>[] utc,.10~.'lb IJl"'JU~' · oo • 0 11 ( , L> • ·ci 0 ·a ·.i ·Jl1 11.'1 1iu1·11\ o\J l:i1•,<'>:Jl'>•: ·i "'1> (~ 1»<.:.:.'' 'J' c;,~ u tJ 'CJ o L> £3 <;> ( ·a (l\.)a3iombocpou

ill LI ,:, u Y'JU u. t)(T1 ~ - ~oo so 1J06008000ou0), MM. o~'boG 8'Q3060 £3o0ou '(3 6 0 momcV> '(30M (J) d 'O~ Q?0 060~0U'.JM o6oo'bo '.J6Q?0 0801.b V.)M'Qo00: ,,b.)O.)i)(Y} 3M.66MM.~ol\ 'bM.fo" - ,,Customs Control Zone"; 080l\0106, £30M6ooo cp08'b0cpoo'.J~O '.J6cp0 08(Y}l\ ,,a0fo0101.oo~o" l\0~0003ol\ 0.)801.80600001. 8o(Y}0o .3'.J6doob 8obocp3001, 01'b-ol\ oo0oo(Y}000'bo .)0boo'.J~O 8o'Qob'b[JQ?.) Q?0 8o'Qobd3000 00601.o.)-fo0oo(Y}oooo Q?0 bb3.) 6ooob8o000 301.5boM'.JdG00 (00Mcp.) oob0b3~0~-0.)8(Y}l\0b3~0~o l\.)o.)t:J(Y} 00ao3ooo .3'.J6doooob0, 01Jo30 v80~a(").a.)0000C':>ob, 3030000008'.J~(Y}C':>ol\ o~od6M(Y}- cp0 00'b8(Y}8.)0000C':>ob 3(Y}6l\o(v)'.JoGoooob0) 0M '.J6cp0 33001cpob 01<:\J-ol\ ~(Y}ool\ 300003.)~'00 boo0o80b. 80-3 d'.J6dool\ 01.)fob80cp 30, 01'b-oo 3.)6(Y}68cpo(')~(Y}0001 cp0cp0060~0 'Qobo01 ( 01'b-ob (Y}M0.)6o'b0001.0ob Boo(v) Q?.) 8obo30 b.)0xo01) a(Y}OV8(Y}o.) 01'b-oo ~ O~oC':>o Q?.)

008(Y}b01J3~0~0C':>o - b000t:J(Y} 00803000 .3'.J6doooo. ~P.% :,·i·-,? 4 £~ " r)

o5l>Q<'>'<'.'.Jdoool> ao-7 a';'.'.Jb~ol> 30<'>30~0 3';'.'.j5jQol> mofobaow. l>ojo<'> ·~~\~l m3ol> 01'b-ob ood86ob 060Go0003001 01.0006o'b0o(Y}Mob 8000 b0d0(v)oti~~~ ~~6~8~?R .) cp0

acp0(v)0cpo 0053001000C':>ob b0ao6ob0 0(Y}l\.)013ob cp0u336ou 8(Y}8'b0cp6~~~~~~~fi~~ 060~ 006Gb.)cpoC':>0b b0806obo0(Y} 0106cp0001'.J~ (p(Y}3'.J8o60.)GO.)lJ010 , d~~}. "~ · 'b036ob 008(Y}l\03~0C':>ob l\.)8b0b'.JMLI. 8001.00 .3'.J6doob oob0C':>08ob0cp, 0106cp0M01'.J J568o66.)Goob b0bo01 'Q00Q?0060~0 '.J6cp0 od6ob ob o6£3(Y}08.)G00, M0G l\.)380(v)obo.) lJ.)C':>0iJ(Y} 3(Y}66M(Y}~ob

9

Page 11: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

l

ry(Y).GOCQ'JMo5ob ()05bC'lMGOO~o5ob.::im3ob b0JoMC'l b<V>j~O 05<(3M0bo<Y>'JoO'JMOLI o~o8o5oo5ob, 00060,30-c.:p0foc.:p()0M05ob b0boC'l5ob, bo8d~03<V>ob, jb0<(3MITTbC'lo5ob, cY>0C'lc.:po6C'l()ob, ()05~0w5ob, c.:p0.3<V>C'loooo5ol\, l\08000C'l cY>otJo8oo <(3'J6oG0015o<Y>o5ol\0m3ol\, 0l\030 l\b30 .30<V>08oo<Y>o5ol\ oob0bo() b08bbj<V>ol\ 8oo<V> 801mbC'l3605ol\ ()05l\0'bQ23cY>ol\0m3ol\, 0()<Y>om30 30~c.:po()'J~o50b <z306oGoC'16ocY>o()ob c.:p0\5805ol\ 30c.:pob <z30M()~O()Clo 08 8C'lmbC'l3605ol\ oobcY>j~o()ob ITT0C'l50'bo, 06 8030Go50~0()05b, <Y>018 c.:p03808C'l<(30~o50~00 m'b-ob 00086ob0m3ob b08b0bj<Y>ob 8oo<V> ()05b0'bQ23Mj~O 801mbC'l360()0. 80-3 .3j5ooob m0fob80c.:p, 08 008mb303000, MC'1G0 m'b-ol\0m3ob ()0630m360~0 oocY>oo01<V>oob b0'bQ23<Y>o5ob ()05~0()05ol\

8oboc.:p3om 06/ c.:p0 01M()05o'b00C'l<Y>ob llj<Y>3o~om b000<Y>m30~01l\ b050tJC'l oo<Y>ooC'l<Y>o0'bo .3o<Y>ol\ oob3~0, L100016~ob 06/c.:p0 t.100 tv>06b.301cY>o(Y). b0000~05ob ooo0fo, 06 b000tv>m80~01b l\050tJ01 OOMOOC'1Mooc.:p06 .3o<V>ol\ ()0l\3~0, l\00016~0\J 06/c.:p0 l\0o<Y>06\J.301MOC'l b0oj0~0()ol\ ()000fo ()05b01MGOO~CQ050 jOj0~C'l(p m'b-ob0m3ol\ ()053jm360~0 OOMOOC'1Mooc.:p06, 0'JG0~0()0~00 \)0MCQ()05o~ oo5ob 06<(3C'lM80Go0 l\06000<Y>oj~-b030<V>06006C'l, b0bo~8\)0<(3C'l 3000Mofo<Y>j~o l\0l\0 'bQ23MC'l-b030<Y>06006C'l, b0bo~8\)0<(3C'l <(300C'lb06000<Y>oj~O b0b0 'bQ23MC'l-l\030<Y>06006C'l, 000603jMO bo06c.:p0<Y>oo5ob0c.:p80 oob0()08obC'l()ob0 <.:p0 b0<V>ol\bob 06/ c.:p0 l\b30 l\050tJ01

JC'l6ocY>01~ol\ ()05bC'lMG00~05ol\0m3ol\ l.10JocY>C'l l\cY>j~o 06<(3<Y>0l\o<Y>'JoO'JMob 0~08060050\J ,

0 0060,p-c.:p0 foc.:p00cY>o<'>ob b0boC'l<'>ol\ , bo8d~03cY>ol\, 0ll0<(3<Y>mbC'lo<'>ob, M.'lC'1CQ0601C'>ol\ , ()05~00o()ol\, c.:p0.3cY>C'loooo()ob, b.'J80 00C'l <Y>otJo8oo <z3'J5oGoC'15o<Y>o()ob, 00tv>0m30, bb30 .30cY>08oocY>o<'>ol\ ool\0bo<'> 801mb0136o<'>ol\ ()05l\0'bQ23<Y>ol\0m3ob. 80-4 .3j5oooll m0fob80c.:p, 08 8jb~ol\ 80-2 <.:p0 80-3 .3j6000<'>00 801Go8'J~O o5<(3C'lM80Gool\ b0<(3jd3o~'bO m'b-ol\ ood86ol\0m3ol\ l\03'o<Y>01 OOM(Y}<'>o<'>ol\ 8C'l8'b0c.:po<'>ol\ 8o'b5om ()05Gb.::ic.:po<'>ol\ MO()Ob6M0GOO(g06

M(J)o CQQ20b CQ0'Clo b0 b.::ib'Q<Y>ol\ 'Q~M01l\o 008(Y).l\Go8l\ 06c.:po3ocg'C)0~'QM 0CQ8o6o 3)<') ( 'CJ >

:J H , <:!!' \ CJ{) U 1

0 b080cY>m~o5<Y>o30 00('.)ob

30~06c.:p0Mj~O CQ\'.20·

o5llocY>'JoGoob 80- l l 8jb~ob 80-3 .3'Q6oooll m.'lfob80c.:p, X,()j<(30b 08C'lG0fo0, c.:p00c.:p.::illo0cY>01l\ 06 00<Y>801l\ m'b-ob 000850\J ooll0bo<'> L1000tv>m30~01l\ 8m03<Y>01<'>ob 00c.:p0\5830oo~o<'>om ().'l6l\0'bQ23Mj~ 8C'lmbC'l36o<'>m06 m'b-ol\ ool\0()08ob01<'>0. 80-4 .3j5oool\ m0fob80c.:p, l\08jCl0C'l X,()'['.)<(30 ()05b0'bQ23M03b m'b-ob c.:p0m30~00MOC'>ol\ ITT0MOQ2b (?.'.:> 0Q25oCJ5j~Ol\ oob0bo<'> 008C'l<'>o6o<'>b 01<V>006o'b0o(Y).<Y>\J. 80-S .3j5ooob m0fob80c.:p 30, m'b-ob c.:p0m30~oocY>o<'>ol\0b CQ()0<'>0

c.:p0m30~oo<Y>o<'>oll oo<.:?O()O<'>ob 08b0b30~0. 0000, M(Y).8o~ll0G bo~b .'JV~~ ob 830~0 A::! C"'::,....,. {~

~ ·~~ . R i.t \503<Y>o. h';) \.1';s.='1.~ u, d

~ ,, 08030 o5bocY>'JoGoob 80-12 8jb~ob m0fob80c.:p, m'b-ob 000860~ :o o<'> LI ''7.!1~ ~C'lb 8m03<Y>(Y).<'>ob ()0c.:p0\5830oo~o<'>om ()06b0'bQ23M'J~ a(Y).mb(Y).36o<'>m0 ;;; 't>-ou J.0ob0<'> ~· . C'l<'>oll ~ ~ "';) '/ ' c.:p.'lc.:p0llo'J<Y>o5ob 008mb303000 C'lM()06o'b00C'ltv>b c.:p0 b0806obo<Y> ~· ~ ffil1%~'G<f?~~Ji ~ 0360\J 801mb(Y).3fob 08 o5boM'JOGOOm ()0ITT30~o\J\)o5o5'J~O o0M05ooob ojt~~~?~U0b0<.:pC'l C'lM()060100 c.:p0<Y>o()obo<Y>o<Y>o<'>ob m0C'l<'>0'b0, b(Y).~(Y). ()0cY>050 oob <Y>o()obocY>~~o b08000(Y). CQQ20b (Y}M006o'b00C'l<Y>b0 ~.::i b.::i8o5obo<Y>(Y}b b08l\0b0<Y>o 'J() 'b036ol\ 0008C'l<'>o60<'>0b m'b-ob

10

Page 12: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

'bo801.)~60060~0Q_>.)6 0.)8018Q_>ofo(Y)o015b, (Y)018 m.)3ob0ez3.)~o 06Q?0bo(Y)o0~0 'b016ob 801\)f.!015.)bm.)6 Q_>.)J.)3oo(Y)o50~0 601(Y)8.)000~0 .)doo5ob 801mb013605oQ_>.)6 0.)a018Q_>ofo(Y)o, 'b016ob ez306deo(Y).6o(Y)o5ob Q?.)\7f.!o5obm3ob .)0Go~o5o~o \)ofo.3o(Y)(Y).5o5ob .)Mbo5015.) 06Q?.) Q_>.)Q_>.)b60MQ?Ob 008(Y).b.)3~05ob b.)8b.)b0(Y)ob 8bMOQ_>.)6 oob.)5.)8obo d80Q?05o5ob

0.)6b01(Y)eoo~o5om - \).)MQ?oo6o~o 06ez301M8.)eoob ( M.)G 'bo801.)~60060~0 6(Y).(Y)8o5oQ_>.)6

0.)8018Q_>ofo(Y)o, b.)38.)(Y)obo 06Q?.) Of.!01b b.)5.)t:J01 3016o(Y)01~ob .3M01GoQ?0M05ob

0.)6b01MGOO~o5ob.)m3ob b.)JoM01 b(Y)0~0 o6C(3M.)b6M0D00Mob 0~08o6oo5ob, 6od603.)­Q_>.)foQ_>0.)MQ5ob b.)bo(Y).5ob, boaa~.)3(Y)ob, 0b.)C(3Mmb0105ob, M.)(Y).Q?o6015ob, 0.)6~.)0o5ob, Q_>.).3(Y)01odoo5ob, b.)800.)01 MOt:JoSao ez306dG0016o(Y)o5ob.)m3ob, .)bo30 bb3.) ..).)(Y).)8oo(Y)o5ob oob.)bo5 b.)8b.)b0(Y)ob aoo(Y) a(Y).mb(Y).3605ob ().)6b.)'b~3(Y)ob.)m3ob Q_>.) bb3.) b.)ez30d3o~'bo , mo'bob CJod8601..\.)m3ob b.)j:OM(Y). .3o(Y)(Y).5o()ob 8018'b.)Q_>O()ob 8o'b6om, b.)800.)01 Xo0ez30b ood86om ((Y).)'bOQ?.)G 0.)801Go8~~ ~6Q_>.) od6ob aob.){).)8obo .)Q_>806oboM.)Go~~-L\.)8.)Mm~o()(Y)o30 .)d()o), mo'bob Clod86obm3ob b.)JoM01 .3o(Y)01()o()ob 0.)6b.)'b~3(Y)ob m.)01().)'bo .)6 0.)6b.)'b~3(Y).)'bo ~.)Mob mo ob Clob.)bo5 06Q_>o30Q_>0.)~0MO .)Q_>806oboM.)GO~~-b.)8.)(Y)m~o()(Y)o30 .)doob 0.)801eo8om, \J.)a~CJ 01 Xo~ez3ob 8oo(Y) 6(Y).(Y)8.)oo~~o .)doom 0.)6b.)'b~3(Y)~~ 801mb0136o()m.)6 mo'bob Clo\J ob(Y).()ob Q_>.)Q?0o6om, m.)3ob0ez3.)~o 06Q?0bo(Y)o~~o 'b016ob Q_>.)m3.)~oo(Y)o()om Q_>.) Q?.'.>m ~ oMo5ob ooQ?ooo5ob .)ab.)b30~0 .)doob ooQ?oo6om, b01~(Y). 0.)6b.)'b~3(Y)~~ 801ml'.)01 I m06 mo'bob aob().)8ob01()ob Q_>.)Q_).'.>b6~MO()ob 008mb3030Clo, 01M(>.)5o'b.)001Mb.'.> Q_>.) L\.)j (f) 0~ b 0 01601Bo3ob.) Q_>.) 8Q_>0M.)Q_>O 0.)63om.)MQ5ob b.)806ob()M01b0m3ob

Cl 01\J ~ b b \J ~ ol.\ OOM 06b()M0d0oom 00m30~ob\)0605~~o 0.:>0 6 9 ool\ h ,')l ,'lb. <~ r ·a ~ cY>o ol.\ u M <fio() \J en n

o < '>o u VY ~ou LI <23~6dG0016ocY>o5ob

b.)d8ob 8.)1..\.)~Q()OQ_>.)5 (8.)m 001Mob - 06ez301M8.'.>Goob 0.)eo8ob oob.)bo() 801b.)MRQ~ob BoQM .)Q_>8o5oboM.)QO~~ 01(Y)0060100 \).:>MQ?()05o~o 0.)5Gb.'.>Q_>Q()oQ_>.'.>5), 8b0(Y)om0 0.)68.'.>MOO()o()oQ_>.'.>5 Q?.'.:> b.'.>Q?.)3(Y). ~(Y)moo(Y)m015ob 8.::i(Y)o00~o(Y)o5o~o 601(Y)8o()ob oofo0(Y)boQ_>.)6 0.)8(Y).8Q_>ofo(Y)o, b0b08.)Mm~01b Q?.'.>Q?()060~0Q_> 800R60.), (Y)018 801b0(Y)Ro~ob 8o'b06b 0(Y) \).)M8(Y)..)Q_>Q05b m03ob~C(3.'.>~o 06Q_>~boM00~0 'b016ob ood85ob (Y).M006o'b0o(Y).MO .3o(Y)ob - 00Q_>0b0b0Q_>ob ().'.>Q?.'.>8bQ?O~.'.>Q? .)~MOGb~~o 80\)0M80 b~()oodoob C(30fo5b~MO SQ_)(>(Y).8.'.>MO(Y).()ob, Bobo

0.)Q_>.'.>bQ_>ob~fo(Y)o0601()ob 08b0b30~0 06<(301M8.)Goob 80~0().), .)Q_>806oboM.)GO~~ 01M0.)50100 S(Y}b.::i(Y)Ro~ob Soo(Y) \).'.>MQ?()05o~o 006Gb.'.>Q_>Q{).) o6ez301M8.'.>Goob 0.)GoBob m001()0'bo, m03obo

oofo0(Y)bom .'.>M od~Q3.) o8030(Y)o Q?.'.>b336ob 003omo()ob oob.)d~< ~-- ·· ~ (Y)018 806

().'.>Q?.'.>b.'.>b.'.>Q_>Ob ().'.>Q_>.'.>8bQ?O~.)Q_> MQ()Ob6MOMO()~~ So\)0(Y)8obm06 ~<iQ •. , . . J~r~ 0 (M.'.>G 8(Y}G08~~ ~(Y)mooMm(Y).()000 aood~o()0 \)0(Y)8010Q_>0Q5Q?ob 01(Y)0060 ·~~t~®\>lJ Q?O()ob

.:>Q_>8o5obo(Y)o(Y)o()ob 0M01Goboo B(Y).00130()~~0 C(30fo6b0(Y)o 06C(301M8; <== ~: ~ou~~~ 1~;·:·~ . ~ ;:. Jbflr;; ··J PJi.

M.'.:>G aoobo()0 b0()06301 0.::i(Y).)5000\J - 0~6006~~0 0(Y) oood~ . . ~~~u~g~&~~ . od5ob

00Q_>01..\0b.::iwob 0.)Q?.'.>SbQ?o~ob aob0bo() 00MQ_>000Mo 06ez301Ma00oob o~ 0 • ~~'CJ' 06om06, M(Y}S~ob So\J.)80 .3o(Y)o()ob.::im3ob 0.'.:>Q?.)Go8om.'.>G oood~o50 oood85.a~~.::ib.)b.)Q_>ob

11

Page 13: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

0cg08bcgo~o\J £30fo6\J'c'.J0o 8cg001.806001.C'.>o\J 08\J0b30~0 06£301.680000\J 008tJ~0360<'.>o\J b0£36mbo. \J0\J0806m~01. 0~600603\J, 001.8 \J0<'.>06301. 00606000 801.(308'c'.J~ 'c'.J0moo0m01.C'.>0\Jm06 80806mo<'.>000, o0mo\J 8b(Y)o3 \)00801.0(!?()06\J ,,m030\J'C.)C(30~0 06Q?'c'.JU000'c'.J~O 'b01.60C'.>O\J oo\J0bo<'.>" \J0j06m3o~(Y).\J 30601.6om 00m30~0\J\)060<'.>'c'.J~ (!?0 00801.\J03~0<'.>o\J \J08\J0b'C.)6m06 oom06b80<'.>'c'.J~ mo'tJo\J 801.\)801.C'.>o\J o0o8000 0U0b'c'.J~O U0C'.>0tJ01. 301.60001.~0\J .3001.(30Q?'c'.J00C'.>o\J 006b01.6(300~o<'.>o\J0m30\J b0.Jo601. 00601.C'.>0-foQOC'.>01.C'.>o<'.>o\J, 06£300\Jo0'c'.Jdo'c'.J00IJ, ood6030-cg0focgo060<'.>o\J \J08'c'.Jo001. 0otJo8oo £3'c'.J6dco01.6o0o<'.>o\J 'c'.J't>6'c'.J630~801.£3ob \J0o'c'.J0~0<'.>0\J, b01.~(Y). 8001.00 8b603 - mo'bo\J C(3'C.)6j(3001.6060C'.>o\J .306001.Q?OO oo\J0d~01. \)06801.j860~0

U0o0Q?0U0b0Q?01. 30~cgo<'.>'c'.J~OC'.>OIJ oob0'c'.J~OC'.>OIJ 'c'.J't>0'C.)630~801.£30U 00606000\J. 086000(!?, fomo~o0, 001.8 08 'C.)30fo\J360~ 008mb303000, \J0<'.>06301. 00606000\J 06\Jo<'.>01.C'.>o\J j8ocgomo0 8bM.~01.Q? mo<t>o\J £3'c'.J6dco01.6060C'.>o\J .306001.cgoo 00cg0\J0b0cgo\J · 00cg08bcgo~IJ0 cg0 \J000cg0\J0b0cg01. 01.000601.\J 001.60\J 8o8cgofo0o 'c'.J0moo0m01.C'.>o\J cg0cg0o6o~ 801.mb01.360<'.>m06 'Clo'c'.Jb0C'.>0801.Q? \)06806m30\J 008mb303000, 00(3 'C.)6(!?0 o0801.ob0001.IJ o0Q?0\J0b0cgo\J 00cg0bcg0'bo 30~Q?OC'.>'c'.J~O \J0\)06801.\J 8006 \J000cg0\J0b0cg01. 30~Q?OC'.>'c'.J~OC'.>o\J 60<'.>0801.£3~01.C'.>om

Clo'c'.JbM'c'.J~OC'.>~01.C'.>000. 080\J 0cg0bo'c'.J60<'.>IJ \J0j06m3o~(Y).\J 8m03601.C'.>o\J 2011 \)~o\J 5 006360\J N2l l Q?0C!?oo6o~o<'.>om cg0803000<'.>'c'.J~O m03ob'c'.JC(30~0 'b01.6o\J ooj860\J0m30\J \)06\J0cgoo60

000?06000\J 01.Q?0601.C'.>o\J, m03ob'c'.J£30~o 'b01.6o\J ooj86o\J .30601.C'.>o<'.>o\J0 cg0 \J0j01.6~0\J oofob30\J \)ol.lo\J CJ0\J0bo<'.> o6\Jo0'c'.Jj(300U 21-o 8';'.)b~OG. 306a01.Q?, 0~6006';'.)~0 8'c'.Jb~o\J .30630~0

d'c'.J5doo\J m0fob80cg, 08 8'c'.Jb~o\J 8o'b60<'.>o\J0m30\J m'b-o\J0m30\J Q?0Q?oo6o~o 801.mb01.360<'.>o\J oo'c'.JbM'c'.J~OC'.>~01.C'.>0cg om3~0<'.>0 m'b-o\J ooj86o\J m001.C'.>0'bo \J0j06m3o~(Y).\J 8m03601.C'.>o\J

00cg0vt1306 ~o<'.>ol\ 80~0<'.>o\J oo8cg001.8 .306001.cgoo 6o<'.>o\J8oo0o \)o\Jo\J/ .30601.C'.>o\J cg06~3030

(80m ClM.C'?ol\, ('}Mo 6o<t0001.C'?o\J 8006 l\000cg0l\0b0cg(Y). 30~cgo<'.>'c'.J~OC'.>o<'.>o\J O[J'c'.JUM'J~O ~(").' ), (; \ l( ;)~ ( II. :I :in~ l\ l) ()~ ~ <:!? ~· - G '() 11dl (> \) . r I

'.'l'.' ')l l, Jc \t H' 111 l( • n 1) >h .' 1t J): I I\ . U:w'" >:J ',' •JG:]~ LI ' u. ) ,. -ob 3 l.l 0 ~ )\o1(1)l1(t) IJlJU u ll ' J u ·: ~ ll ( .. )'tJ'Tll I• ~11•) { \j I l>, (Y). o~ OG ~0 006 .) .:ia 06\J()M'c'.JdGOOO)

3 Li\? o' v I 00 06ooob ooll0'c'.J~OC'.>OIJ (600~o'b0(300b) 801.mb01.3fo\J 06

000?050 oocg06 b0J:o6(Y} 01.Q?[)601.5o\J £3'c'.J~0cgo m06bo\J ~0801..J60\J 0b01.6Goo~o<'.>IJ \J08l\0b'c'.JC'?o.

<t>o801.0~6006'c'.J~o\J 00m30~0\J\)060<'.>om, m03ob'c'.J£30~o o6cg'C.)\Jo0o'C.)~o 'b01.5o\J £3'c'.J60Go01.6060<'.>o\J cg0\)80<'.>o\J 000.3'b[J, l\0<'.>06301. 00606000l\ 06 oooa~o<'.>0 006obo~o<'.>01.Q?OIJ 080306 06£301.680000cg, 001.8~ob 00Go8om0G, \J0j06m3o~(Y).\J l.l000cg0b0b0cg01. 301.C!?Odbob 39-o 8'c'.Jb~o\J .30630~0 fo\)o~ocg06 o08(Y}8cgofo0o, oooa~o<'.>0 cg06~3[J'C.)~ oj6o\J o0Q?0\J0b0cgo\J

00cg08bcgo~m06 cg03030060<'.>'c'.J~o 06£301.680Goo\J \J0ocg'c'.J8~01.0C'.>0 .

12

Page 14: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

0080'lbbo6or,0~0 b080(Y)01~ob 6<"lMaor,ob0 Q?0 b0d8ob ez30d6(Y).5(Y)o30 00(Y)o8<"lo5o5ob

~M01oo(Y)01oo:xo(Y)o5ob b0ez30d3o~<t>o, b0l.\080(Y)01~<"l 800860315, M<"l8 v0M8<"lQ?Q060~0

b0(Y)80~0 b0ez30d3~00600, 06<:?0 Q;_>0380l:J<"lez30~Q?Ob Q?0 0080'lb03~05ob b08b0b0(Y)b 0(0)0.3 o6ez3<"lM80Goob 0103ob0ez3~05ob 00630010(Y)o5ob 06b60606ob b0b(Y)0o5~<"lQ? 06Q?0 <:?0030~0'lb 00bGob b0b0(Y)8o~(Y). 80'l01b<"l3foao 8001001050~0 b0:x0M<"l 06ez30'lM80800.

b0d0(Y)013o~<"lb 0Q;_>806ob6M0Go0~0 b0.3M<"lGOb<"l J<"lQ?Odbob .3o(Y)30~0 80b~ob 80<"lM0 fovo~ob 8oboQ?3001, 010 08 J<"lQ?Odbo01 bb30 (Y)08 0(Y) 0(Y)ob Q?0Q?'Qo6o~o 0Q;_>806oboM0Go0~ b080(Y)010~v0M80'lo50ao 0080'lo8060ei0 b0d0M0130~(Y).b b08(Y).d0~0d(Y). b0.3M(Y).Gob(Y). 3(Y).<:?odbob

Q?050~05060.

b0d0M0130~(Y).b l.108<"ld0~0d(Y). b0.3M(Y).Gob(Y). 3(Y).<:?odbob 53-o a0b~o 0<:?00615 bb080(Y)01~<"l

b:i(Y):xo5ob 0:ifovo~o5ob vobb. JOMd(Y).Q?, 8(Y).G080~0 80b~ob .3o(Y)30~0 fovo~ob

oob0508ob0Q?, 08 8b0(Y)ob 8oo(Y) 00~.w50~0 b0MX,05ob 00Q;_>0bQ;_>0, M(Y).8~ob b0b0(Y)0o5~(Y).Q?0G odfo 008<"l6060~0 00Q?0Vl:J306o~o50 03ob(Y)o50 Bo(Y).MO 8b0(Y)ob, 0106Q?0G ob 8b0(Y)o

0060103ob0ez3~oei0~0 o8(Y).b b0bo~avoez3(Y). 500:xo600 b0b080(Y)01~(Y). b0M:Xo5ob

00Q;_>0b ob0006.

Q?0Q?0o6o~o:i , b b (Y) o5~(Y).

b0b080(Y)01~(Y).8 obo~8d(?3060~0 b0d0(Y)013o~(Y).b 0Q;_>8o6ob6M0G00~o b0.3M(Y).GOb(Y). 3(Y).Q?Odbob .3oM30~o, a0(Y).M0, a0-12, 24-0, 331 a0b~0eio01, b.'.>d0M0130~(Y).b b080'ld0~0d(Y). b0.3M(Y).Gob(Y).

3(Y).<:?odbob a0-8, 53-0, 244-0, 248-0, 249-0, 257-0, 364-0, 367-0, 369-o a0b~o5001 Q?.'.>

1. 0(0)0.3 o6ez3(Y).M80Goob 0103ob0ez3~05ob 00630010(Y)o5ob 06b60606ob b0(Y)80~0

Q;_>0380l:J(Y).ez30~Q?ob. .,) ~ J a 0 /·~ .... , L ~ t

2. w>o3>~<'>b OoO<'>b>3~o~ob b>Ob>b':'.JO'>b 2015 \)~ob 16 >30\o~ob~; ~"fl >wo~om 8(Y).01b(Y).360~0 b0X,0M(Y). o6ez3(Y).M80Goob 8(Y).b0(Y)8o~ob0013ob (>0Q?0GO?:~\ · ' .Q.~ )~::1:

"::;;\ - ~~ --;, //)/·

3. 8(Y)..30b0bo 008(Y).b.'.>3~or,ob b08b.'.>b0Mb Q?00JObM(Y).b 8(Y).b.'.>M80~~~.::f.i~~~~M80GOOb 0103ob0ez3~05ob 00630010Mo5ob 06b60606ob b0b0(Y)0o5~01Q? 100 (0U~T§i~~.<>w0bQ;_>0.

13

Page 15: 0 0MOO(Y).Q(g(Y).30b O· - IDFI Ruling Tax secret.pdf · BoMG00~ b.)rn;:g0a~(Y).oo.)b. .)a.)30 a0b~ob ao(Y).MQ ..305000 .)Q?0o5b, M(Y).a (Y).£30Go.)~0(i) fo\)oM[)OOO .)Mboo0~0 05£_j(Y).M8.)GO.),

/

14


Recommended