+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2...

01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2...

Date post: 03-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
30
!"#$%& ()*+,$%& (-*./$% (01 2&!"3 4*+56% 7!8 "#$%&' "(#)*+#, "(#)- "./0 "1)2345 "(6 7,89# :*;. ".8<5 =,0 ># ?-)@+A 89&45, "B)CD45, "1)2345 "EFG$+45 H0$I45 )J KL EN O45 "EP58QRS45, T UE+;+45, >@Q45 "V)EV ># >DQ45 WX 7,89'5 5YZ [S\., )V ]G)^ O45 SE^_+45 `ab c# de)F45 f)%&45 gh i HSj kl, k)FGX g*4 k$@m#, 8o pC;+45 i d<5 kl ?(B q$3r)e K)FVs# )\+4)V0 kl, "(Q+F#, H 8o faBt5 gQG uZ "EFEj845 p.);@(4 )QCP "#$*<5 "V)EV "Cv58#, K)#$(;'5, 0)Cbw5 +45 "4,S45 [8P c# )\E(B xy)3'5 "E4,S45 dEz5$'5, "EFG$ T H05{, >&# ?(B q8<5 $Z 7,89'5 5YZ L ER )# UZl c#, 5YZ |&#, 89&45, "1)2345 k,s- i gbS+45 c# "E(b5S45 B pC;+45 go58# >E} i "Ej)mQ45 "D(F45 WX q)3+b~5 c 0)Cbw5, K)#$(;'5 gQG, 50Ä5, 0)*1w5 :ÅG i f5L+4~5 ># c# O45 y$EQ45, K)CÇ5$4)e ]v$45 >@+6 i )É)B58# Ñ,8Å'5 )Z0)PX i `L&+A O45 [5SZw5 cB SEÖ ~ Üo uP58QRy T u(. )@E1 7,89'5 5Yá "EV)Vw5 K)oàQ'5 `5L+b5 c*R, â ! " $%&'() *(+ ,-./() $0123 4567 829:'() ;<:=() >12?9@ AB?9C $DE. FEGHI J)KL+ M ,-=<() N 7 O " *(+ PE<%() ;Q RSS<:=() AHTU2GC7 V $1U2H WG@ EX2YZ7 KE5.[)7 \E]-B?'() R] $(^E_'B( 7I V`ZEa $&b cI R] \E3-de() ,EGfI R] WGf c[ RS62?] )-Z-G1 gI g7L E&Z72Y%1 ;9() \E]-B?'() 7I E&Z7/51 ;9() ^)Kh) WbI M i *(+ !j " $1E'H k] l(P Wa V $1U 2m $S<:=() KLE='() M W=<() !! " ! n " 5 äEbà45 f)%&e g@;45 )ã4X å&Q' 89&e d(;+'5 > çm.$;A, "E(b5S45 H05{, éS4 ".0,S45 è2345, K)Å4s'5 i gê, UE(FA cZ0 89&45 ?QC. ~ Üo ëí |.83A f)%&e ]G)^ "\Ç ìl c# î4ï ñ `$3Å45 ! , "# ó ! o " RSBXp'() qErf[) /1/:C /=s Ftuv) \E_mp] ;Q $S(E'() $SQE<Y(E@ $DE. FEGHI J)KL+ ,E] TIK ;Q $'XE_'B( $S(t09m) gE'67 $?]Ew() $1KE5.v) $d5=() \)P $1K7/() >:=() \E_mp] $S5%b[)7 $SB:'() $S(E'() P-<%() ks)-] ^)x+ Ftuv) M R] ,-=<() no *(+ o! " ! j " 2SQ-C7 E&Qt9.)7 \E]-B?'()7 ^)Kh) ,7)/C $1U2H ;Q A:() gE'e( $1LU /?9(E@ $DE. FEGHI J)KL+ '() ;Q yU-%9() R] *ZLI /H zSa29()7 KEG9H{) 2X)-| R] }SB09(E@ l(P7 ;]tuv) /&Y
Transcript
Page 1: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!"#$%&'()*+,$%&'(-*./$%'(01'2&!"3

'

4*+56%'7!8'

!

!"#$%&'!"(#)*+#,!"(#)-!"./0!"1)2345!"(6!7,89#!:*;.!".8<5! =,0! >#! ?-)@+A! 89&45,! "B)CD45,! "1)2345

"EFG$+45!H0$I45!)J!KLMEN!O45!"EP58QRS45,T!

!UE+;+45,!>@Q45!"V)EV!>#!>DQ45!WX!7,89'5!5YZ![S\.,)V! ]G)^! O45!SE^_+45! `ab! c#! de)F45! f)%&45! gh! i! HSj

!kl,! k)FGX! g*4! k$@m#,! n8o! pC;+45! i! d<5! kl! ?(B! q$3r)eK)FVs#)\+4)V0!kl,!"(Q+F#,!Hn8o!faBt5!!gQG!uZ!"EFEj845!

!p.);@(4! )QCP! "#$*<5! "V)EV! "Cv58#,! K)#$(;'5,! 0)Cbw5+45!"4,S45![8P!c#!)\E(B!xy)3'5!"E4,S45!dEz5$'5,"EFG$T!

!H05{,!>&#!?(B!q8<5!$Z!7,89'5!5YZ!LMER!)#!UZl!c#,!!5YZ! |&#,! 89&45,! "1)2345! k,s-! i! gbS+45! c#! "E(b5S45B! pC;+45! go58#! >E}! i! "Ej)mQ45! "D(F45! WX! q)3+b~5c!

!0)Cbw5,!K)#$(;'5!gQG,!�50Ä5,!0)*1w5!:ÅG!i!f5L+4~5!>#!c#!O45!y$EQ45,!K)CÇ5$4)e!]v$45!>@+6!i!)É)B58#!Ñ,8Å'5

)Z0)PX!i!`L&+A!O45![5SZw5!cB!SEÖ!~!Üo!uP58QRyT!

u(.!)@E1!7,89'5!5Yá!"EV)Vw5!K)oàQ'5!`5L+b5!c*R,â!

!"#$%&'()# *(+# ,-./()# $0123# 4567# 829:'()# ;<:=()# >12?9@# AB?9C# $DE.# FEGHI# J)KL+M#,-=<()N#7O#"#*(+#PE<%()#;Q#RSS<:=()#AH#TU2GC7#V#$1U2H#WG@#EX2YZ7#KE5.[)7#\E]-B?'()

#R]#$(^E_'B(#7I#V`ZEa#$&b#cI#R]#\E3-de()#,EGfI#R]#WGf#c[#RS62?]#)-Z-G1#gI#g7L# E&Z72Y%1# ;9()#\E]-B?'()# 7I# E&Z7/51# ;9()# ^)Kh)# WbIMi#*(+#!j"$1E'H# k]#l(P#Wa# V$1U2m##

#$S<:=()#KLE='()M#W=<()!!"!##n"5! äEbà45! f)%&e! g@;45! �)ã4Xå&Q'!89&e! d(;+'5! >

!çm.$;A,!"E(b5S45!H05{,!éS4!".0,S45!è2345,!K)Å4s'5!i! gê,! UE(FA! cZ0! 89&45! ?QC.! ~! Üo! ëí! |.83A! f)%&e

!]G)^!"\Ç!ìl!c#!î4ïñ!`$3Å45!!,"#ó!o"#RSBXp'()# qErf[)# /1/:C# /=s# Ftuv)# \E_mp]# ;Q# $S(E'()# $SQE<Y(E@# $DE.# FEGHI# J)KL+

,E]# TIK# ;Q# $'XE_'B(#$S(t09m)# gE'67# $?]Ew()# $1KE5.v)# $d5=()# \)P# $1K7/()# >:=()#

\E_mp]#$S5%b[)7#$SB:'()#$S(E'()#P-<%()#ks)-]#^)x+#Ftuv)#M#R]#,-=<()no#*(+#o!"!

j"#2SQ-C7#E&Qt9.)7#\E]-B?'()7#^)Kh)#,7)/C#$1U2H#;Q#A:()#gE'e(#$1LU/?9(E@#$DE.#FEGHI#J)KL+

'()# ;Q# yU-%9()# R]# *ZLI# /H#zSa29()7# KEG9H{)# 2X)-|# R]# }SB09(E@# l(P7# ;]tuv)# /&Y

Page 2: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

# *Bu# ~2�S_()# k%]# $1Ed(# cLE=9s{)\E_mp]#$12H# ;Q# A:()# Ä-?1# WGY@# $@-9G'()# Ftuv)#

#2S5?9()M#R]#,-=<()on#*(+#oÅ"!

Ç"#E&e1-?C7#É9Y()7#ÑBÖ()#ÉÜ)2w@#$0B?9'()#lBC#q-=r(E@7#$12bz()#FEGH[)#á?5@#W'?()#^Ed(+

#\E@-0?@#$S(E]M#,-=<()Çj7#ÇÇ7#ÇÅ"V##k]#$0B?9'()#~2S�r()#ÉÜ)2w()#;Q#$SZ/5()#\E@-0?()#2=H

àE=9â{)#7I#Ñ&%()#7I#>%?()#7I#W90()#*Bu#\E@E9G()#7I#,)-s[)#7I#Ñ�r()#$�m)-@#á12:9(E@V#

7/?()# k]# g7E?9()# 7I#àEXKv)# 7I# $SZE_Zv)# /6# 7I#à2:()# ÉÜ)2w@# ä1-%9()# 7IM# W=<()Çã"V#7I#

~-u/()#7I# zSS'9()# *Bu# Ee12:C# WÖ'1# WGY@# gEG_()# 7I# gE1L[)# 7I#TE%b[)#RS@#áâE59()# *(+#

#>%?()#7I# ~7)/?()M#W=<()Ç!"V#àE=9â{)#ÉÜ)2b#,-H#\E]-B?]#k1x-C7#2YZ#7I#I7##å2:9()

;_%w()#! "#$%&!'()*! +,-.! /0123! +(45# 7I!*6! ",7#8! *6! 9&"4:5&! *6! ";1! *6! <,=>8! *6!?2:1@

4A!*6!<4.!*6!B")C2DEF&!G)!+4A2.@!9&>H!I=2!M#W=<()ÇN"#V#Wa#\)^)2b+#$?b)2]#k]##l(P

#$'12w()#y-6-]#\E5ç+#;Q#RSS<:=()#*Bu#^Ñ?()#>S<rC#éEwC)#;Q#kU599()M#W=<()Çi"V#RSG'C7#

# $BXp'()# \ES?'w()M# W=<()N!# "##ÉÜ)2w()# R]# y-%()# )èX# k599(# ~2fE5'()# ê-u/(E@# FES0()# R]

M#R]#,-=<()ÅN#*(+#NÅ"!

Å"+#$Bw'()#éè&@#~LK)-()#FEGHë(#$SQE%'()#,E?Q[)#k59C#*(+#8/&C#$S@Er9Z{)#$SB'?(E@#$DE.#FEGHI#J)KL

q-=r(E@# E&%]7#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#>B9r]#;Q#;@z:()#KE&fv)#k%]#M#W=<()oã"##7#,E'?9m)

#$SmES_()7#$S@z:()#$1Eu/B(#$S]-'?()#\)K)Lv)7#~LE5?()#\-S@M#,-=<()jn7#jN7#Ço#7N!"!

##

Page 3: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!! !!!! !!! !!! !!! !!!!! ! !!!!!! !! ! !! !!!

' 9:)' ;<5!=%>' ' ?' (#@$'!"##' A' BCDE=%'>' ' ?'!"##'F(-*./$%'(01'D%:GHI'J0KL=%'

!

ò]vs'5!".0$\@ô5!:Ej0!åkX!!

!=aêt5,!H0$I45![5SZl!dEQ2+4!)E(;45!"öEá5!c#!=5àv)e,!"zSõ5!uP58QRS45!`)Q+G~5,!uV)EF45!ySB!f$V8'5!?m+Qú

$!"&F4!%&""!i!ù0s'5!"'!ì8ÅE1!%&""ò!ò`,w5!8.{$45!ìl0!?(B!7aP~5!S;e,!

!ç3G!uAÄ5!f$V8'5!0S3.â!

!

'M/N$%#O'!pC;+45! ".8o! ".)@û! "Q(;+'5,! u(.! )@E1! H0$9&'5! q$3&45!ò"1)2345!"(6!è4sA!ü+*45!>Ee,!89&45,!"B)CD45,!"1)2345,

LEo!"(†5!°YZ!gbSA,!c#!�5S+e5!YEÅ&+45!ó!!!ñ!%&""T!

'M/N$%!O'

!YEÅ&+45! LEo! "1)2345! "(6! `$by! ¢.0)A! c#! �5S+e5! ]Eã4l

!ySB!k$G)Q45!"ê)b,!"Å4)£'5!"Qe)F45!q$3&45!>E}(%!"&F4!

"#)!! i! ùn0s'5!%'! g.81l!"#)!!"1)2345! "(6! 05Sê§e! d(;+'5!

3&45!>E},ç4!"2Q&'5,!"@M@+'5!"Qoa45!q$!`$3Å45,!(#),!*&*!

,*&!!ySB!k$G)Q45!c#!%)!"&F4!"#$$!i!ù0s'5!(&!g.81l!"#$$!gã945!"(6!05Sê§e!d(;+'5T!

!

Page 4: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

'M/N$%$O'!"EFG$+45! ".0$\@•(4! u¶845! Sj584)e! ! f$V8'5! 5YZ! 89&ß.

"4,S45!®G5$v!c#!k$G)Q^!YÅ&.,T!

!i!©)P8v!83Qe!!f$V8'5!5YZ!0Sê,ó!!ñ!%&""T!

!

! !! !! !! !! !! !PE=%'(QD<RST%'UVWDX'

2Y+=%'9%E-'

!

!

!! !!!! !!! !!! !!! !!!!! ! !!!!!!!!

Z&6%'4*+$%O(3*)';*[\]'##

'M/N$%#O'!K)FVs#!"E4aQ+V5,!89&45,!"B)CD45,!"1)2345,!pC;+45!".n8o!S\;45! f)*ow! )Q1,! ™0)N,! "G$@m#! )\B$G! k)^! )@\#! faBt5!"E4,S45! dEz5$'5! "EQe,! "EV)EF45,! "EGS'5! x$Q2(4! ë,S45

E(B!xy)3'5"EFG$+45!".0$\@ô5!gCv!c#!)\T!

"T!u;.89A!äG!?m+Qú!~X! pC;+45!".n8o! c#! SEEQ+45!c*R! ~´89e,â!

í!i! gI@+A! "B,89#! "2(3#! dEQÖ! ç&#! ".)ã45! k$*A! klf);45!f)%&45!¨Åo!,l!c.8bÄ5!"#58^,!x$Qo!f5ào5!!

í!c#! °ï)≠5! fL(.! )#! >#! "CV)&+#,! ".0,8Æ! k$*A! kl,P58QRy!>@+6!i!K5�58ÇXuT

!'M/N$%!O'

!K)2(D3')e!S3Q.,!òpC;+45!".8o!UE%&A!WX!f$V8'5!5YZ![S\."E4)+45â!

í"ê)r5!K)\ô5!â!c.Y45!k$.0)C+B~5!,l!k$E;ECD45!q)£-w5!"&\#!ìl!,l!uB)@+Ç5!,l!ì0)Ø!´)9G!ì_e!f)EQ45!k$4$+.

"ê)bTí"E#$@;45! K)\ô5! â!ìl! c#! 5�LÇ! g*9A! O45! K)\ô5! g^

1! c#! 781! ,l! é$+F#!K∞9&'5,! K)FVs'5! g^,! "4,S45! 7,8!d18#! YEÅ&+e! "Å(*#! k$*A! O45! K)öEá5! g^,! "E#$@;45

f)BT

Page 5: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

ígE•F+45! â!WX! [SÉ! O45! ±Å45! >e)D45! K5ï! `)@Bw5! g^uG$G)Q45!75S.≤4!";Æ)r5!K)Å&3'5!äE£9AT

íuG$G)Q45!75S.t5!â!¢FG!c#!H05yt5!®*N!i!gI@+.!�58ÇX!K)Å&3'5!c#!è&3#!g^!c#![S\.,!"(†5!°YJ!)\E(B!q$3&'5

"E&P$45!H8^5Y45!?(B!≥)Å<5!WX,!dEz$+45!WXTíJ2)>KLM%&N!2O(PQ!R23!2MOH!+)2KL%&!J2S>:TH!<4MSU

íJ2DVT#M%&N!!WX25*! GH!Y%Z! "4[! *6! I9V"\M%&! C&>]F&! *6! ^>#%&! *6! _>5"%&! *6!J2.2:P%&! W3!

+4)*-.!+`>DaH!*6!b^*!'()!+1V*7H!0123!':H!"4Kc:%&!2d"4[!*6!+4M]^!*6!+LTeMH!*6!+fg2A!

C*&7:(%!IV7cM%&!J2fg2a%&!GH!U!!

íh2:P%&!N!W3!'()!WM:;8!+4M]^!*6!+)>KLH!+,^*9!"4[!+,";1*#!+(i&9!"4[!W]F&!'()!+aDj!

kle%&!J2aDj!Y%Z!mgU!!

í! +,^*7%&N!W3!!*6! +.^2$:H! C2Sn!mg! 7A&*! R&>T)!0a8! ^7#8! 2O(PQ! R23! 2MOH! +,^*9! +,";1

%*! I7)2K:H<.2:8!R6*! I9*7aH!"4[! I7M%! &^"$H! 2O(o(o8!R>P,! R6!p";.! +Mf:TH! "4[!0123! >!

! /q4]":%&*! R2Hr%&! s4A! GH! 2d9&7)6! "K:c8*J2,^*9!+4H>4%&! 7X&"\%&! t>#u%&! vS*! '()!

J24%>a%&*!I^>#M%&*!+.>:PM%&!J2,^*7%&*!Jl\M%&*!+,"OQ!w#T%&*!+4)>K5F&*U

í)Cbt5!"ãC345!K5ï!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345";#)ô5!".0!â!g^!è(+¥! gQG! c@m+A! "EeLo! ,l! "#)B! ".0,y! ,l! "ÅE2ê!"EV)EF45! "ãC345! K5ï! �50Ä5! ,! K)#$(;'5,! 0)Cbw5!f$@B! WX! f);45! k_94)e! "Q(;+'5! 0)Cbw5! c#! )Zpµ,

™)&45T!!

'M/N$%$O)Z05SêX!U+.!O45!K)Åå&3'5!g^!kl!ü∂!òge)Q#!pãe!,l!ge)Qú!

$+#! k5$&B,! UV5! g@Ö!,l! 8-)&45! ,l! ∑+&'5! ,l! >CD45! ë7å{$'5!T!

g3Å45!5YZ!c#!W,w5!H8QÅ45!f)*ol!c#!∏I+FA,!â!

í!π".05yt5!K)B$CD'5!íπ".0)•+45!K)B$CD'5!íπ"&.S'5!K)B$CDú!)\&B!8MC;.!O45!Hpã345!K)B$CD'5í"E4)'5!UEQ45!f$V0,!K)e)£+G~5!K)B$CD#T

'5! "ö1! c#! nS;A! O45! K)B$CD'5! >m≠,!O45,! ".0,S45! K)Åå&3!∫4)I45! ª)C45! f)*ol! WX! "@%+&#! pµ! ,l! "@%+&#! "Å3e! 0S3A

"(†5!°YZ!c#T!

!

^_*`$%'4*+$%O'(V#N$%&'(VI96%&'(Q![N$%'a*N$E=%'A'

Page 6: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

''M/N$%%O'

!g3Å45! c#! W,w5! H8QÅ4)e! )\E4X! 0)9'5! K)Åå&3'5! >E}! gn•FA! ,l! >e)D45! gCv! c#! "ê)b! 8A)1y! i! °aBl! ∫4)I45!,l! ∑+&'5

!ySB,! ¢.0)A! gE•FA! g*4! äM3º,! ò`)<5! üFo! 7{$'5! ,l! 8-)&45";DQ&#!pµ!"(F(V!i!ΩA0T

'M/N$%&O'!K)Åå&3'5!c#!èå&3'!`)<5!üFo!8-)G!,l!∑+&#!,l!>e)P!g^!W$+.!g3Å45!c#!W,w5!H8QÅ4)e!)\E4X!0)9'5!".0,S45!pµ!"B$CD'5

çÇ)+GX! >v,! )næ! f$V8'5! 5YZ! c#! ∫4)I45!çÇ)+GX! Hy)BX! ,l!!H05{$45! ø)3#! éS4! 8j)%G! ";e0l! 75S.X! "EFG$+45! yaC4)e

f$@;45!ü(P!]Ö!ç;Æ,!gCv!î4ï,!faBt)e!"Å(*'5!W,w5T!!!75S.t5!U+.!kl!ü∂!©)+Gt5!i!®(b5S+#!HSB!"^0)9#!H0$ê!i,

UZ8bí![8P!c#T!>v,! O45! ".0,S45! pµ! K)Åå&3@(4! "CF&4)e! 75S.t5! U+.,

\Ç)+GX!c#! >EC45! Ñ8ã4! "EFG$+45! yaC(4! )á)byX,! ©0)r)e! )!"Å(*'5! W,w5! H05{$45! ø)3#! éS4! So5,! p%G! i! 7å{$'5! [8P

f$@;45!ü(P!]Ö!)\;Æ,!gCv!î4ï,!faBt)eT!ø)3'5! ?(B,!!c#! c.p%G! U(FA! kl! W,w5! H05{$4)e! H0$^Y'5

! ".0,y! pã45,! "B$CD'5! )\.S4! "By$'5! ";e0w5! K)Å&3'5!)æ!"C+*'5!WX!"EFG$+45!yaC4)e!çÇ)+GX!Hy)BX!,l!çÇ)+GX!>v,

"ME&P$45!H8^5Y45!?(B!≥)Å<5,!dEz$+45!".)ã4!"E&P$45T!!

'M/N$%'O'!uG$G)Q45! 75S.t5,! gE•F+45! K5�58ÇX! è4)º! c#! g^! üv);.

!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿!°aBl!)@\E4X!0)9'5!&&,!"&&&50)&.y!T!!!!

'b$*`$%'4*+$%O'VN./$%'A(QD&:$%'c./$%'A&'d'

Z&6%'e@f$%O'dVN./$%'g<f\'A&'hij%'^N./$%'A!

'M/N$%(O'ä£-!g^!f$V8'5!5YZ!f)*ow!)QCP!)1à¡!)EÅ2ê!nS;.!?(B!g#)o!

"E@(;45! Sj)\945! c#! )áy);.! )#! ,l! H{)Ç≤4! gvw5!gI@+.!

Page 7: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

,! 0)Cbw5,! K)#$(;'5! 89G,! >}! i! uFEj845! çP)9G!�50Ä5,QG,! 0)*1w5!i! "@%+&#! H0$3e,! ë)#! ge)Qú! f$@;45! WX! )\(

!K~)^,!i!,l!".0,y!,l!"E#$.!"1)23(4!K)FMVs#!HSB!,l!"FMVs#!ì83C45! u;@F45! faB≤4! K)FMVs#! HSB! ,l! "FMVs#! i! ,l! �)CGw5

"E(êw5!°y05$#!)\&#!S@+F.!kl!´89e!uG,à*4t5!`)3Aa4!,lT!! ,l! :G$+e! gV58'5! [à¡! uÅ2ê! )m.l! nS;.,!kl! ´89e! ©0)r)e

"Qe)F45!H8QÅ45!)\+m+v5!O45!´,8945!çE1!81$+AT!!°aBl! W,w5! H8QÅ4)e! U\E4X! 0)9'5! ®1àõ5! ®EÅ234)e! d2(.

! H8-)C#! Uá! k,SB)F'5$}à'5! k,0n8õ)^! kk$Qz$'5! k,0n8õ5,!!k,¬£'5,!�)&I+V)e!ìLÅ(+45!,l!uF@945!,l!ì,SE45!8.$3+4)e

},!0)\-t5!k5$Blk)^!)@\#!"EÆ8B!HSB)F#!~X!fSQ.!~!c#!>E!)\(*-T!

! !!

'M/N$%)O'c#!"GM$*+#!"&ô![8P!c#![àõ5!uÅ2345!"v)De!U(FAâ!

#'kZ&]'7if3'O'í"zazU+.!�)mBl!!U\o5àv5!!c#"@%&#!gCv!8I^w5!®EÅ2345!

aEIN!ík5$mB)@\o5àv5! U+.!!! c#"@%&#! gCv!K)FVs#! ì8.S#!

q)r5!faBt5!aEIN!8I^w5íu#$@;45!faBt5!K)FVs#!ì8.S#!gCv!c#!ço5àv5!U+.!$mBí! $mB!®;.! `)3A~5,! faBt5! k$G)v! i! H�)Å*4)e! ç4! y$\9#

�50{$45! :(6! c#! =5àv)e! 8#_e!! ñ! ! !!c#! =5àv)e! ,l!"&•(45!ó!f)\ú!>(DmE445!:Ej8

4!c*R!~(!K$ê!k$*.,!)\j)mBl!uI(z!0$mû!~X!`,5S+A!kl!"&•)2nÇ8#!)\FEj0K5$êw5!ì,)FA!S&B!T

!)\C2V!x8P,!)\+Eo$(ê!HS#,!"v)DC45!UE(FA!´,8-!ynSÖ!8#_e!c#!=5àv)e[àõ5!uÅ2345!Hy)\-!y)&V5!"&ô!T!

!i!:G$+e![)&ö+V~5!"@*¡!f)#l!"&•(45!K5058v!i!c;D45!c*R!?(B,! 058Q4)e! faBt5! ¢.0)A! c#! �5S+e5! )#$.! ®zaz! gÇl

i! c;D45! i! ]CA! kl! "@*õ5!√SQ+4! ®E45$'5! c.8\945! [8h!é$BS45T!

!"(e)v!:G$+e![)&ö+V~5!"@*¡!cB!0S3A!O45!K5058Q45!k$*A,!ì0)ô5!>.89+(4!)QCP!"M.05yt5!"@*õ5!f)#l!üEQ;+4)e!c;D(4

g@;45!çe!T!!

'M/N$%*O

Page 8: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!k,y!`$Ö!,l!K)#$(;'5!`,5SA!".n8o!x$;A!y$Ev!ìl!Ñ81!>&RMVs#!è(+¥!®e!q8Å45!s1)*A!K)#$(;'5!?(B!`$3<5!i!faBt5!K)F

!ìynS;A,! n8o! faBX! i! cP5$'5! do! gED;A! )ƒ_-! c#! k$*.! ,l[)Å-,T!

'M/N$%#"O'!0)Cbw5,! K)#$(;'5! ?(B! `$3<5,! ï)Å&45! do! uÅ23(4!,l! "E;.89A! ]G)^! �5$V! "E#$@;45! 0y)3'5! c#! K)Ej)3ot5,!≈E345,! ´,89(4! )QCP! ".05yX! ,l! "E#$*o! ,l! "Ej)mv

,)\E(B! äG! O45! K5�58Çt5!! ySB! f$V8'5*"! i! ù0s'5!%$!ì)#!

d(;+'5!%&""".05yt5! dj)z$45! WX! ï)Å&4)e!!g^)E\(4!

"E#$@;45!ySB!f$V8')e!|Q&'5!"#$!ù0s'5""!k5$Ç!%&""T!!K)#$(;'5! cB! H0$^Y'5! K)\ô5! 8FÅ+F.! kl! uÅ23(4! c*R

A!∆!)#!)É{$û!k$*A!O45!K)Ej)3ot5,!0)Cbw5,!y5$'5!°YZ!c*!c#!çE(B!g32+.!)#!89G!do!uÅ23(4!)@^!òk$G)Q45!U*û!".n8V

K)Ej)3oX,!0)Cbl,!K)#$(;#T!!K5,S&45!g^!0$mo!uÅ2345!ç(@B!".y_A!gECV!i!)m.l!uÅ23(4,

"#);45!K)B)@+Ç~5,!K58Ns'5,T!!

'M/N$%##O'!K)#$(;'5!,l!uÅ2345!cB!0S3.!ìY45!ìl845!k$*.!kl!{$∂!~

89&.! O45!".SFô5! ç+#8o,! ç+#58*e! ™)F@(4! )CCV! )Z".$&;'5,T!

'M/N$%#!O'!{$∂!~!)@^!ò"D(V!ìl!üG)Ç!c#!«ãÆ!ìw!uÅ2345!».8;A!{$∂!~

!çA)#$(;#!0y)3#!�)91X!?(B!ç(…!"(I@+'5!ç#)\'!ç+V0)æ!S&Bf$@;45!WX!0)Cbw5!gQG!iT!

!

'M/N$%#$O'w! )QCP! ç.SC.! ìl0! ?(B! uÅ2ê! ìl! "4�)F#! {$Ø! ~![58B

!ç+4�)F#! {$Ø! ~! )@^! )Z89&.! K)#$(;#! ,l! "&\'5! K)Evabl,!"(†5! °YJ! Hy05$45! f)*ow)e! ç4abX! ]Cz! 5ïX! ~X! ç(@B! üCFe!>Q.!ìY45!"&\'5![8-!x)IEú!HynS¡!uZ!)@^!"E&\'5!çA)CÇ5$e,

![8P!c#!°y5SBX®EÅ23(4!"E(EI@+45!g^)Eá5T!!

'M/N$%#%O'

Page 9: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!`$3Å45!è4)º!c#!g^!üv);."",!"%,!"(,!f$V8'5!5YZ!c#!!g^!,l!H0)-t5!,l!`$Q4)e!çE(B!éS;A!,l!)EÅ2ê!k)Zl!c#!g;Å45

! ,lç(@;4! çA8-)C#! `)o! S.S\+45!çC-! ?(B! �5S+B~5! "e$Q;e!

!g3Å4)e!H08Q'5!u#$@B!èh$#"%("Ej5Lô5!"(†5!c#!T!!

^_*`$%'e@f$%O'a*QD&:$%&'c./$%'A(V#l<$%'!

'M/N$%#&O'"ÅE2ê!g^!89G!k$*.!>#!dCF#!äEb8A!k,Se,!58o!".0,y!g^,!

! g3Å4)e! çE4X! 0)9'5! |.83+45! K5�58ÇX! f5ào5"'!°YZ! c#!"(†5T!

!

'M/N$%#'O'k$*.!kl!ü∂g*4!!!,l!"ÅE2ê".0,y!≈4)e!uFG$A!`,sF#!8.S#!

>+@+#,! S-845! cV!ü∂! )@^! ò"EV)EF45,! "EGS'5! çv$Qo! >E@ !ïX,! ò"EFG$+45! yaC4)e! f$(;#! 8Q#! ç4! k$*.! kl!]G)^! 5

!0)E+b5! ü∂! ì$&;#! ä£-! cB! H0y)ê! ".0,S45! ,l! "ÅE2345Bl! ®e! c#! `)<5! üFo! )Z8.S#!®e! c#! ,l! H05yt5! :(6! �)m

)\j)mBl!HpF'5T!!ü∂!)#!"G)3û!);+@+#!"ÅE2345!8.S#!k)^!5ïX,!8.S#!0)E+b5

)á!8bíT!

5'M/N$#(O'MVs#! g^! i! g3Å45! U+.! kl! ü∂MEÅ2ê! "FH05yt5! OÅEh,! ®e! "!

!)@^!ò8.82+45,!8.S#!".0,y!g*4!,l!"ÅE2ê!g*4!k$*.!kl!ü∂!c*.! ∆! 5ïX! 8.8Ö! "öEZ! ?(B! 5y)@+B5! ç#)\#! ™0)R! 8.82+(4!°YZ! i! 8.82+45! 8.S#! cME;.,! ò[àõ5! uÅ2345! "Åê! )Z8.S'

!c#!"4)<5gCvMVs'5!".0,S(4!,l!"ÅE23(4!"*4)'5!"F!T!! ò)MEFG$A! k$*.! kl! 8.82+45! 8.S#! i! ´à9.,!8@;45! c#! )ã4)e

!"EGS'5! çv$Qo! >E@ ! );+@+#,! ògvw5! ?(B! "&V! k$zaz"EV)EF45,T!

!

'M/N$%#)O'!"Ej5S+e~5!"@*õ5!:Ej0!WX!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!8.S#!fSQ.!g#)o!x0,!?(B!)Ee)+^!)À83A!05SêX!`,l!gCv!)Ee58A!ä+£'5!»10!H0$ê!i,!òî4ï!i!aê,!ç@E(FA!ge)Q#!i!uj)Cô5!>e)D(4!`$ê$45! "G$@m#! "4)V0! "DV5$e! ≈E(C+45! f$Q.! gê$45! UE(FA

î4ï!i!gê$45!f)Q#!H0$^Y'5!"\ô5!WX!Ã$(C4)e!faBt5!>#!T!

Page 10: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

u(.!)#!|.83+45!5YZ!c@m+.!,â!

í#21/]#Ñ0(7#Ém)$1K7/()#7I#$<S:=()7#7#äCL{7#ì1KEC#é20]7#ä9S_%bí$<S:=()#g)-%u#7I#$1K7/()E&CK)L+#U20]7#EXK7/D#/Su)-]7###í()9m#;9()#$?5�'#*(-9$<S:=()#k53$SZ729G(v)#$<S:=()#ê/u#E]#$1K7/()#7I#í#~/'9?'()#212:9()#\Ed(#7I#$d(íWw_()#R]#$r_ZcKEw9()##í#R]#-eu#Wa#20]7#$%&]7#Ñ0(7#Ém)[)#^Eeu()12S_'R#$1K7/()#7I#$<S:=B(î

# Ftu+#Ñw1# étuI# E&S(+# KEY'()#\EZES5()# *Bu# W./1# 2SSdC# Wa7'G:'()#ïSÜK# $SÜ)/9@{)# $#82|#;Q# ä@$_'.2Yu##E]-1étuI#*(7[)#~20<(E@#E&SBu#q-=%'()#\)^)2bv)#ï<%(#E0Q7#ä(-=H#ì1KEC#R]#î##

!

5'M/N$#*O!!H05{$45! ø)3#! éS4! 8j)%G! ";e0l! i! uG$G)Q45! 75S.t5! U+.

H05{$45! °YZ! ø)3#! ?(B,! òfaBt)e! "Å(*'5! W,w5!!U(FA! kl! ";e0w5! 8j)%&45! c#! ®+£FG!"C+*'5! WX! )\.S4! "By$'5

!i,!ò"E&P$45!H8^5Y45!?(B!≥)Å<5,!dEz$+45!".)ã4!"E&P$45!".0,S45! ,l! "ÅE2345! 8.S#! üv);.! �58Çt5! 5YZ! "Å4)¥! H0$ê

!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿%&&&,!!&&&0)&.y!T!'

'M/N$%!"O'!i!]CI.!kl!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!"ÅE2ê!8.S#!g^!?(B!ü∂

Å2ê! gã9.! çGl! ]v,! ìl!gQ.! ~! ]v$45! g#)^! ç.S4! k$(@;.! ®E!"v)DC(4! ®(#)o! k$G$*.! ò8.82+45! d.81! è3G! cB! UZySB!i! ™,0S45! U+b! i! ! Hy)\-! ?(B! c.{8¡! ,l! "E&P$45! "E&\'5!g^! ?(B! ü∂! )@^! ò)áy);.! )#! ,l! 0)Cbw5! f$(B,! "1)2345!]v$45!g#)^!gã9A!kl!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!"E#$.!"ÅE2ê

~! 8.8Ö! d.81!ü∂,! ò®1à¡! ®EÅ2ê! H89B! cB! çj)mBl! ySB! gQ.!!"ÅE2ê!,l!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!"EB$CVl!"ÅE2ê!g^!?(B

gQ.!~!8.8Ö!d.81!gã9A!kl!"EG,à*4X!"E#$.!!cB!çj)mBl!ySBK)Em+Q'5!°YZ!"Å4)¥!H0$ê!i,!ò®1à¡!®EÅ2ê!"+V!!üv);.8.S#!

"ÅE2345!!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿"&&&,!%&&&0)&.y!T!!

'M/N$%!#O'!®(3Å45!K)Em+Q#!"Å4)¥!H0$ê!i"',!"#!üv);.!"(†5!°YZ!c#!

".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!8.S#!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿!%&&&,!!&&&!ò0)&.y!(4! c*R! ~,".0,S45! ,l! "ÅE23!S;e! ~X! 0,S345! i! 8@+FA! kl!

H0$^Y'5!`$3Å45!K)CÇ$#!f)NXT!

Page 11: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

5! pµ! ".0,S45! ,l! "ÅE2345! 058@+V5! H0$ê! i,i! )J! =83'!

0,S345! üv);.!8.S#)Z!! )Z0Sv! "ED¿"&&!ySB! g^! cB! 0)&.y!°aBl!H0$^Y'5!f)*oÕ4!"Å4)¥!H0$3e!0S3.T!

!c#!�5S+e5!f).l!H89;45!gÇl!�)mQG5!S;e!"EDr5!°YZ!YÅ&A,!8-);45! f$E45! c#! �5S+e5! ,l! ì0$m<5! U*<5! 0,Sê! ¢.0)A

mo!¬+;'5!,l!ue)Eã45!U*<)e!faB≤4!ë5$'5ì0$T!!èEv$+e! kï_A! kl! î4ï! ?(B! H,aB! "3+£'5! "@*2@(4! c*R,!!çÇ,l!c#!çÇ,!ìw!ge)v!pµ!058v!?m+Qú!8\-l!"zaz!HS'!89&45

c;D45T!!¢.0)A! c#! f).l! H89B! gÇl! i! [)&ö+V~5! do! çE(B! f$*2@(4,!ç#aBX!¢.0)A!c#!gÇw5!:ÅG!i!Ñ5àB~5!,l!ì0$m<5!U*<5!0,Sê

ue)Eã45!U*<)e!)E3£-T!!

'M/N$%!!O'!0)9'5! uG$G)Q45! 75S.t5,! gE•F+45! K5�58ÇX! 8#_e! ! «CmA

!`$3Å4)e!)\E4X*,!!,!"#"(†5!°YZ!c#!T!!

b$*`$%'e@f$%O(V-*N"$*I'J0KLm';*[\]'!

'M/N$%!$O'!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!".0,y!,l!"ÅE2ê!gã+FA!"FVs#!g^!?(B!ü∂

"ÅE2345!HS@Bl!?(B!89&e!f$QA!kl!";#)Çâ!

6!x! !97)!W3!mg!N!!

"!Œ!"FMVs'5!]G)^!5ïX!®*4)'5!®E;ECD45!q)£-w5!ª)Q4l,!�)¶_e".$&;'5!"E3£94)e!";å+@+#!pµ!

%! Œ!UV5,! )Zn8Q#,! )á)#! ™l0,! uB)@+Ç~5! )\¶5,! "FMVs'5! g*9eò)ÉnS#,! ®EFEj845! "zaI45! )\j)^8-! �)¶l,! uG$G)Q45! )\(Iæ!

"M.$&;'5!K5Y45!"Åê!)á!"FMVs'5!]G)^!5ïXT!

(Œ!¶)e8.82+45!8.S#,!"ÅE2345!8.S#!u!

*! ŒeO45! ¢F&45! yS;! W$+A!05SêX! g^! S&B! )\C2V!yS;e! ,l!EG,à*4t5!"ÅE23(4!"CF&4)e!)\j58v"!

h!x!!+,^2\%&!+4%2M%&!+To%&!GH!<52:%&!"O;%&!Cli+41*":P%y&*!+4]^>%&!2O4:uo1!'()*!N

"!Œe,!)É05yX!k$V0)R!c#!�)¶_l,l!)\(E^,!�)¶!!O45!"^8945FA)\(ã+òMVs'5!]G)^!5ïX!òHn8o!"4)^,!g¡!"F!!

%! Œ!ú!)\+G{5$#,! ò"EmQ&'5! "E4)'5! "&F45! `ab! )\C2V! `S;!S&B! x$18#! òH8-)&45! "FVs@(4! ∑j)+&45! ª)Fo,! ".$&F45

e! ,l! �a^$45! ,l! gE^$45! �)¶_e! �)m+v~5!H05yt5! :(6! "CE^à"Cv58'5! :(6! �)mBl,! "EB)@ô5! )É05yX! "öEZ! �)mB_e! ,l!

Page 12: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

! ™l0! i! ®œ)F'5! "@j)v,á)#!ø)3'5! >@Ø! �)mBl! �)¶_e! ,l! ò)!uB)@ô5! UV~5! ,l! UV~5,! çE4X! u@+&A! ìY45! "M.y)3+v~5

K)^8945! >@•+4! ,l! ç4! "G$*'5! K)^89(4!!çE4X! u@+&A! ìY45!u(;Å45!,l!uG$G)Q45!)Zï$ÅG!]Ö!SÇ$A!O45!fw5!"^8945!UV5,

! ";Ç5845! U\Vw5! ySB! ?(B! äE3&+45! >#! g*4"^8-!,!"1)^"FVs'5!)\(ã+FA!O45!c.,)&;45H8-)&45!T!

! ®e! =,5àA! "E4)#! "ED¿! f)*ow5! °YZ! è4)º! c#! g^! üv);.,!&!

,"&&f)*ow5!°Yá!"Å4)¥!H0$3e!°89G!U+.!ySB!g^!cB!0)&.y!T!

'M/N$%!%O'!`)#! ™l0! gIN! O45! K)œ)F'5! "E¶5! K)œ)F#! g*-! Y£+A! kl! ü∂

.0,y! ,l! "ÅE2ê! "FVs#!K)œ)F#,! ";#)Ç! ".0)CbX! "ãCê! K5ï! "

!gvw5!?(B!H8-)C#!pµ!,l!H8-)C#!"Å3e!î(+N!O45!K)^8945%&!

%"FVs#! i! ].$3+45! x$Qo! c#! ,l! `)'5! ™l0! c#!!!,l! "ÅE2ê";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!".0,y!T!

!"4)oX! g^! ?(B! "vy)3'5! "e)v845! ,l! H05yt5! :(6! ?(B! ü∂FVs#! `)#! ™l0! i! gbSA! "œ)F#!"ãCê! K5ï! ".0,y! ,l! "ÅE2ê! "

!c#! "4)ot)e! SB$45! ,l! "4)ot5! ]G)^! 5ïX,! ò";#)Ç! ".0)CbX

!–4!H8-)C'5!pµ!,l!8-)C'5!—a+#~5!WX!~,s.!kl!)@ƒ_-%&!%!!"ãCê! K5ï! ".0,y! ,l! "ÅE2ê! "FVs#! `)#! ™l0! c#! gvw5! ?(B!è2345!,l!"ÅE2345!i!)@\&#!kaBX!©50yX!ü∂!";#)Ç!".0)CbX

!";e)+45"FVs@(4T!

'M/N$%!&O'!K5ï! "ÅE2ê! î4)'! "Q.8P! "._e! ç¶5! 0)Bl! çGl! ]Cz! ä£-! g^!î4)'5! "E3£-! ü•o! gÇl! c#! )á$@'! ,l! ";#)Ç! ".0)CbX! "ãCê!ò0)&.y!è4l!®;e0l,![~í!H89B!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿!üv);.!uQEQ<5!?(B! ,l! H05yt5! :(6! :Ej0! ?(B! "Ej5Lô5! "E4,sF'5! ü2F&A,

58'5!:(6!:Ej0!]N!5ïX!c.8MEF'5!g^!?(B,!gE^$45!?(B!,l!"Cv".$&;#!K5ï!gCv!c#!UV~5!H0)BX!"E(@BT!

!

'M/N$%!'O'!"zaz!HS'!«CmA!kl!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!"ÅE2ê!g^!?(B!"Å.8;A! �)m+v~5! S&B,! ! )J! q)r5! 0)\-t5! "Å.8;A! 8\-l!"ãCê! K5ï! è2ê! HSB! ,l! ".0,y! "ÅE2ê! >#! "^à9'5! )Z0)\-X

0)CbX!i,! òf$@;45! î4Ye! U(;A! kl! )\E(B,! òé8bl! ";#)Ç! ".

Page 13: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!=,5àA!"ED¿!"ÅE2345!î4)#!üv);.!K)Em+Q'5!°YZ!"Å4)¥!H0$ê

!®e%&&&,!!&&&0)&.y!T!!

'M/N$%!(O'!,l! "ÅE2ê! g^! 8.8Ö! 8.S#! ,l! î4)#! |&ú! SB$45! ,l! |&'5! kX!,l! `5$#w! �~sZ! `$Cv! ,l! ";#)Ç! ".0)CbX! "ãCê! K5ï! ".0,y

ìl!c#!>1)&#!?(B!pz_+45!S3Qe!"ê)b!,l!"E#$@B!]G)^!"\Ç!!cB! ".,)F#! "ED¿! )\C*A8#! üv);.! ò"ÅE23(4! ì8.82+45! «r5

"Q.8D45!°YJ!)\E(B!g32+'5!>1)&'5!è;ÆT!!

'M/N$%!)O'".0,y!,l!"ÅE2ê!g^!?(B!>&R!!?(B,!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï

!"#$*o! ìl! c#! >1)&#! ,l! `5$#l! `$Cv! )\;#! ®(#);+'5! g^C&Çl!"E#$*<5!pµ!,l!"E#$*<5!K)\ô5!K5SB)F#!éSB!)@E1!ò"E

!,l! "^à9'5! K5,S&45! UE%&A,! c.$*+4)e! "Q(;+'5! "EC&Çw5!)\E(B! g32+A! O45! 0)\-t5! K)GaBX,! K)^5à-~5,! K);EC'5

)\j)18o!WX!)\.SFA!O45!K)#Sr5!ge)Q#!!T!

'M/N$%!*O'!,l!çQCFA!kl!ü∂!0)\-X!g*-!i!0S3.!`)Q#!g^!H0)CB!çCQ;A

ñ0)\-X!ó!,lñkaBX!ó!,lñÃaeó!g*-!i!çRSQA!>Q.!kl!ü∂!)@^!ò!°YZ! "Å4)¥! H0$ê! i,! òK~)Q'5,! 0)Cbw5! "EQe! cB! °LER! {0)e

! 8.S#! üv);.! f)*ow5"ÅE2345!>1)&'5! è;Æ! cB! ".,)F#! "ED¿!

!cB!gQA!kl!?(B!uG)ô5!)\E(B!g3Ö!O45!&&&0)&.y!T!!"ÅE2ê!î4)#!g^!?(B!>&R!8.S#!,l!)Z8.S#!?(B!,l!".0,y!,l

!`)'5! c#! )ã(C#! `$Cv! )J! ®(ã+9'5,! ®EÅ2345! ?(B,! ! )Z8.8Ö!¬r5!"ãCê!�)ÅÆX!S3v!"E4)#!"@Ev!K5ï!é8bl!>1)&#!".l!,l

0)\-t5!kaBX!?(B!`)Q'5!,lT!!g3Å45!5YZ!c#!"EG)I45!H8QÅ45!K)Em+Q#!è4)º!c#!g^!üv);.,

(C@(4! ".,)F#! k$*A! "E4)#! "ED¿!~! kl! ?(B! çE(B! g32+'5! ≈!>#!y$;45!H0$ê!i!"EDr5!èB)mA,!ò0)&.y!è4l!H89B!cB!gQA!:“! ®e! =,5àA! HnS#! )\Co)ê! c#! uÅ23(4! "E&\'5! "v)DC45! ü2V

K5$&V!89B,T!!

'M/N$%$"O'!)#!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!".0,y!,l!"ÅE2ê!g^!?(B!>&R

BX! g*-! i! ".)BS4)e! f)EQ45! "MEeL<5! è2345! éSB!0)\-X! K)Ga!f)*ow5!°YZ!"Å4)¥!H0$ê!i,!ò"EV)EF45!ª5Low5!Sol!HSj)Å4

Page 14: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

! 8.S#! üv);."ÅE2345!≈(C@(4! ".,)F#! k$*A! "E4)#! "ED¿!!èB)mA,! ò0)&.y! è4l! H89B! cB! gQA! ~! kl! ?(B! çE(B! g32+'5

y$;45!H0$ê!i!"EDr5T!!

'M/N$%$#O'à#! ,l! "E(êw5! ç+ã4! i! )EjLÇ! ,l! )E(^! 0);+F#! `)Q#! g^!)}

!"Å4)¥! g^! ¬+;A,! ò°0S3#! k)ECe! )e$23#! k$*.! kl! ü∂! )\&B

! c#! "ED¿! çC*A8#! üv);.! ~)2+G5! f)*ow5! °Yá%&&&! WX!(&&&!!çe!ü4)D.!kl!c*R!ìY45!08m45!f8µ!cB!8%&45!>DQe!ò0)&.y

08m+'5T!!

nI%!$%'e@f$%O(Q9C:KL$*I'J0KLm';*[\]'''

'M/N$%$!O')#!k)^!�5$V!òSo5$45!ä£9(4!c*R!,l!î(R!kl!ò).$&;#!,l!).y

!K5ï! ®+.0,y,! ®+ÅE2ê! i! ò8.SQA! ?3vl! ?(B! òU*2+.! ,l! 8.S.!)á!k$*A,!8.82+45!"ã4!∫Eo!c#!k)Å(+≠!";#)Ç!".0)CbX!"ãCê!O45! u(@ô5! ü2F45! {,)•+.! kl! c*R! ~,! ò0,S345! ".0,y! :ÅG!"j)')e!k$zaz!So5,!ä£-!)\E1!U*2+.!,l!)Z8.S.!,l!)\*(+R

ü2F45! c#!"ãC345! K5ï! K).0,S45,! "E#$E45! è23(4! u(@ô5!"EFG$+45!yaC4)e!H0$9&'5!";#)ô5,!"EV)EF45!".0)Cbt5T!

'M/N$%$$O'�)&+v5! >&R!";#)Ç,! "EV)EV! ".0)CbX! "ãCê! K5ï! "ÅE2ê!!,l

!,l!].$3+45!x$Qû!,l!`)'5!™l0!i!"EC(µw)e!)\E(B!H8DEF45!°YZ!k_-!c#!k)^!5ïX!Hn8<5!"4)^$45!SQ;e!`,sA!kl!"E(@;45

!c#! >@6! WX! ,l! ®.$&;'5! ,l! ®E;ECD45! q)£-w5! Sol! ®*N! WX!"Å3e! H8DEF45! ,l! —a+#5! c#! ®.$&;'5! ,l! ®E;ECD45! q)£-w5

?(B!H8-)C#!pµ!,l!H8-)C#!!".0)CbX!"ãCê!K5ï!K).0,y,!è2ê

!u(@ô5!)\C2V!!ySB!x$Å.!";#)Ç,!"EV)EV(&%!u(@ô5!yS;45!c#!5!5Yá!ü2F(4K).0,S45!c#!7$&4T!

'M/N$%$%O!"EC(µw5!,l!"E*('5!�)&+v5!,l!"4)oX!fL+;.!ä£-!g^!?(B!ü∂

?(B! "ME(;Å45! H8DEF45! ç4! `M$≠! O45!!"ÅE2ê! 89&A! "FVs#! g^!:(†! î4Ye! |.83+45! ";#)Ç,! "EV)EV! ".0)CbX! "ãCê! K5ï

"F1)&'5TDe!)#X,!uj)Q(+45!S\;+45!x)DG!i!)#X!"F1)&'5!:(†!c*R,!ü(

!î4ï!i!"2(3#!ç4!cæ!pã45!c#!,l!H0)•+4)e!è(*'5!8.{$45!c#

Page 15: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!"#);45!H05yt5!k5$Bl!"DV5$e!,l!ç.08Q#!"DV5$e!òü(D.!kl!"#{a45! K5y)-0t5! g^! q)£-w5,! K505yt5! c#! ò"F1)&@(4!°YJ!Hy05$45!f)*ow)e!K).0,S45!,l!è2345!SEQA!éS#!"Cv58'

£-w5,! K505y≤4! c*R! ~,! ò"(†5!i! ò�58Çt5! 5YJ! ®E&;'5! q)!?(B! "%1)õ5! üÇ5$e! îF@+45! ò"Å4)¥! "EG$G)v! f)*ol! ª)Eµ

±\'5!n8F45T!!

'M/N$%$&O'!c#!`$3Å4)e!Hy05$45!f)*ow5!è4)º!c#!g^!üv);.(%!WX!(*!c#!

!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿!"(†5!°YZ!&+&&&,!"&&+&&&0)&.y!T!!

'M/N$%$'O'#!08mA!c#!g*4,!"F1)&'5!:(†!"E1)Å94)e!"(£'5!K)V0)@'5!c

!c#!`$3Å4)e!)\E4X!0)9'5!ìy)3+v~5!LE^à45!fSB,!"E4)'5%(!

! WX()!K)Å4)£'5! °YZ! 8Ç{! "3+£'5! U^)õ5! c#! ü(D.! kl! °aBl!08m45!f8µ!cB!8%&45!>DQe!î4ï,!)á!So!>Æ,,T!

!

'M/N$%$(O'!"ãCê! K5ï! ".0,y! ,l! "ÅE2ê! î(+N! O45! K)^8945! g^! ?(B

"M.0)CbX!uV)Vw5!)\#)%G!>mA!kl!"(†5!°YZ!0,Sê!gCv!";#)Ç!f)*ol! >#! de)DA! g¡!c#! >e5845,! ∫4)I45,! uG)I45! f)Fvw5!

ª)C45!5YZ!LMEo!"(†5!°YZ!`$by!¢.0)A!c#!8\-l!"zaz![8h!i!YEÅ&+45T!

!U3*o%'e@f$%OC9!$%'J\&'pV./L$%'!

'M/N$%$)O'j)h,!`)@Bl!äº!)@E1!"#);45!"D(F45!u(I@'!dÀ!g^!|E23A!U\Å

!kl!?(B!|E23A!WX!"Ç)o!i!)ƒ,¬+;.!K)#$(;#!çE1!Ky0,!`)Q#|E23+45!7$Æ$#!`)Q'5!U•o!î4ï!{,)•+.!~T!

!yS;45!i!)G)6,!)e$Ç,!|E23+45!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!89&A,î4Ye!)\#aBX!f$E4!ë5$'5T!

!

'M/N$%$*O'g*9e,!"E&@Æ!,l!"À8ê!"Å3e!çE4X!Ñ8;+45!>v,!ä£-!g*4!dÀ!

y845!do!™0)R!kl!"E3£945!çv$Qû!08Æ!x)<X!WX!ìys.T!!y5SBw5!Sol!i!)G)6,!)e$Ç,!y845!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!89&A

c#! "E45$'5! "zaI45!!WX! "CF&4)e! y845! `)Q#! )ãE(CA! ¢.0)A

Page 16: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!"EQe! WX! "CF&4)e! ë5$'5! yS;45! i,! "E#$E45! Sj58ô5K).0,S45T!

&e,! ! >v$'5! :ÅG! i! y845! ©0S.,!!`$P! y,So! i,! [,8<5! :Å!k5$&;45! 0)C+B5! k,y,! f)2v5! ìl! k,y! çE(B! üQ;'5! `)Q'5!{,)•+.! kl! c*R! ~,! ò�)m#t5,! "1$4_'5! K)#SQ'5,! K)E2+45,

!y845%&&!üEQ;A!g^!|+Å.,!î4ï!c#!`$Pl!`)Q'5!k)^!$4,!8DV!SB5$Q45!:Å&4!)QCP!y845!i!5S.SÇ!)QoT!

'M/N$%%"O!(3Å45!"Å4)¥!cB!üåAàA!®(',!(#!®e!=,5àA!"E4)#!"EDb!°aBl!

"&&&,!(&&&!kït5!"EG)*#X,!08m45!f8µ!cB!8%&45!>DQe!0)&.y!

!g3Å45!f)*ow!)QCP!©50yt)e!)@*o!89&e*""(†5!°YZ!c#!T!!

'M/N$%%#O!!,l! "ÅE2345! 8Q#! )É8j5Se! cj)*45! "Ej5S+e~5! "@*õ5! W$+A

+#~)e!"Q(;+'5!é,)BS45!i!8%&45!".0,S45!do!©50yX!cB!7)&!i! 8%&45! W$+A! )@^! òë)•;+V~5! �)mQ45! K5�58Çt! )QCP! y845!K50)CB!ç&@mA!H0$ê!i!y845!d<!So!>Æ,!WX![SÉ!O45!é,)BS45!)ƒ_-! c#! ,l! pã(4! "B,89'5! "2(3@(4! ,l! k$G)Q(4! "Å4)¥

ç+;¶!,l!`)Q'5!üo)ê![8-!c#!gE&45T!'5! f).l! H89;45! [8h! i! ! "@*õ5! ]CA,!>10! ¢.0)+4! "E45$

!©50yt)e!kït)e!0y)345!U*<5!kl!0n8QA!kl!)á!c*R,!ò"EmQ45!,l!Ñ5àB~5!cB!8%&45!>DQe!!Hy$F'5!?(B!°8.8Ö!y8•ú!YÅ&.!H0$ê! i,! ò©50yt)e! d(;+'5! çB81! y,So! i! c*4,! [)&ö+V~5!f).l!89B!"F@r5![8h!i!"3+£'5!"@*õ5!]CA![)&ö+V~)e!c;D45

"E45$'5"@*õ5!"e)+*e![)&ö+V~5!ü(D#!gE•FA!¢.0)+4!T!!

'M/N$%%!'O'!çE(B! q$3&'5! ©50yt5! gÇl! "B)V! c.89B,! >e0l! WX! »Å£&.!d(;+.! )@E1! î4ï,! "Ee)£+G~5! HS'5! `ab! de)F45! g3Å4)e!WX! y845! ≈(C.! kl! "4)<5! °YZ! i! ü∂,! ò"E#$E45! è234)e

'5! "ÅE2345! >CP! ]v,! c#! K)B)V! ]V! gCv! "ÅE2345!"&@m+!c#! �5S+e5! "ÅE2345! ?(B,! òçE(B! üEQ;+45! y58'5! `)Q@(4!"E#$@;45! "e)E&45! U(;A! kl! "Ee)£+G~5! HS'5! xaDG5! ¢.0)A!K)e$Q;(4! "Æ8B! k$*A! ~X,! "ÅE2345! >CP! i! 7,8945! ]v$e!0$m2(4! �)BS+V~5! {$∂,! òde)F45! g3Å4)e! )\E(B! q$3&'5

õ5! :Ej0! c#! kï§e! é8bl! WX! "B)V! c#! "F(ô)e!"Ej5S+e~5!"@*!uÆ)Q45! U*<5! YEÅ&+e! kï_A! kl! "@*2@(4! c*R,! ò"3+£'5!,l! Ñ5àB~)e! c;P! g^! cB! 8%&45! >DQe! Hy$F'5! ?(B! ©50yt)e

Page 17: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!üv);.,! ò©50yt)e! d(;+'5! çB81! y,So! i! c*4,! [)&ö+V~)e!>e0l![8h!i!©50yt)e!U*2(4!`)I+#~5!»18.!ìY45!çE(B!f$*õ5

! ¢.0)A! c#! "B)V! c.89B,! ®e! =,5àA! "ED¿! °0,Sê(&&&,!!&&&!0)&.yT!

!

'M/N$%%$O'!]#)v!5ïX!y845!,l!|E23+45!é$By!»10!"3+£'5!"@*2@(4!c*R

!"ÅE2345,l!"E(;1!"Å3e!ìys.!|E23A!89&e!)Ej)Q(A!".0,S45!pã4)e!ç+Q<l!ìY45!08m45!"ô);#!WXT

'M/N$%%%O'!g3Å4)e!çE(B!q$3&'5!y845!do!"V0)æ!c*R(#Z!c#!!c#!"(†5!°Y

!H0$ê! i! k)FGt5! x$Qo! cB! 7)1S(4! "(Zs'5! K)E;@ô5! gCv!,l! è2345! éSoX! i! q)£-w5! c#! "B$@6! ,l! ä£-! [5S\+V5!U\18-!,l!U\+#58^!c#!gE&45!)ƒ_-!c#!K5�)By5!WX!K).0,S45!kl! "E;}! ìw! {$∂! ~,! òc.S45! ,l! :&ô5! ,l! gêw5! ™)Vl! ?(B

|.8ê!äEb8A!k,y!d<5!5YZ!™0)N!d(;A!)#!5ïX!8#w)e!±;'5!c#!UÉ5Ye!®&E;#!q)£-_e!,l!ä£9e!�)By~5T

!

'M/N$%%&O'!c#! �5S+e5! 8\-l! "+V! umú! ©50yt)e! "Q(;+'5! é$BS45! «QFA

y845!7$Æ$#!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!ySB!0,Sê!¢.0)AT!

nI%!$%'4*+$%O';*K$%'JQ!,$*I'JV0KL$%'A'''

'M/N$%%'O'"CF&4)e! ".S(C45! :Ej0! W$+.!ë5$45,! ".S(C45! "QD&@(4!

!)3E3b! HS;'5! c^)#w5! ®E;A! ".S(C45! pµ! dP)&@(4! "CF&4)e!ò"#);45! "D(F45! cB! H0y)345! "B$CD'5! q$3&45! dE(;+4!c^)#w5! °YZ! i! "ê)r5! K)B$CD'5! dE(;A! W$+.! c#! g^! üv);.,

!g3Å4)e!H0n8Q'5!"EDr)e("!"Ej5Lô5!"(†5!c#!0n8*#!T!!

'M/N$%%(O'ynSÖ!K)GaBt5! dE(;+4! "33£'5! c^)#w5! "3+£'5! "D(F45!

!"Q(;+'5! ®G5$Q4)e! "&EC'5! ´,8945! d1,! "Ee)£+G~5)\1)&êl!è(+£ú!K)e)£+G~)eT!

'M/N$%%)O'

Page 18: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!c#!=,5àA!"ED¿!üv);.!&&!WX!"&&&!"45{X!S@;+.!c#!g^!0)&.y!!`,s.!g*9e,!]G)^!"Q.8P!ì_e!ç.$9A!,l!"EDãA!,l!d.LN!,l

pEãA! WX!ä3£'5! k)*'5! i! )\QE(;A! ”! "Ee)£+G5! "Q(;#! é$+¡!"&*æ!pµ!)É�58v!g;Ç!,l!)áT!

!

U3*o%'4*+$%'O'(-*./$%'(,5%<I'(+[m!=%'eW%!T%'A'!"#$%'MW*5&'q3'(0V5&'(QrI'&]'

Z&6%'e@f$%OA'p#T%'4*[mD%'s0)'tQ!.L$%'!

'M/N$%%*O\.!wj>,! R6! GPM,! 2H!h2P8^&! mg! G43^2;M3!z]2c,! W#D%&! 'TcH! '()! +aT!&{7c.! 2H*!!&|d! GH!

_>5"M%&!2)>K:H!R>P,! 2VMH!"3Z! 2H!h2P8^&!'()!t2uQ6!IV7)!*6! 2#uQ!I"Q2KH!R>}V"a,!G,|%&!W3!

!*6!J2)>KLM%&!+L5&>.!2H@*!+4H>Mc%&!G32HF&!mg!7,7O:%&!*6!C&>]F&!*6!zLu%&!+L5&>.!2H@!Y%Z*!WcD.

PQ!~-.!*6!=>H"%&!*6!J2Q>$TM%&!*6!^>#%&!*6!<4K(%! +}*"cM%&! I^>#M%&!*6! +.>:PM%&!C2PQF&!GH!W

!"fT%!+}*"cM%&!J21l)�&*!J2$(cM%&!+L5&>.!2H@*!+4H>Mc%&!J2)2M:Sy&!*6!G32HF&!mg!_>Mc%&!"fT%

~"#K%&!mcMo%&!C2#8y&!WX25*!GH!+(45*!~6!+L5&>.!2H@*!_>Mc%&m1*":P%y&!*6!U!!

*!J24Ä:$M%!2$g*!h2$c(%!+KS>H!+%*2aM%&%&!W#D!#+4X&r\%&!+(\M%&!GH!U!!

!!

M/N$%'&"O#R]# $S�r@7# F)-uI# $çtç#*(+# FEu#R]#Rw_(E@#ÑsE?1!ããã#*(+#Çããã#~2fE5]#ñU2:1#R]#Wa#KE%1L#

#$]2:()#*Bu# ^)/9u{)#7I# W90()# ÉÜ)2b#àEGCK)#*Bu#A@E_()# W=<(E@# $%US5'()# WÜEm-()#R]# $BSm7# $�m)-@(P7#Ñ&%()#7I#àE=9â{)#7I#gE_Zó(#$1/_w()#l(P#k%'1#gI#g7/@#,-?<'@#Eu-59]#á12:9()#RG1#É(# )P+#l

#W=<()#AS5�C#R]on$SÜ)zw()#$Bw'()#R]##*(+#àE0?()#*=sI#kQ2SQ#,-?<'@#Eu-59]#á12:9()#gEa#)P+#E]I#E%wm#F)-uI#ï'.#î##

#7I#étuI#*(7[)#~20<(E@# E&SBu#q-=%'()#ÉÜ)2w(E@#WÜEm-()#ï<Z#$�m)-@#éU-%1#R]#àE0?()#ï<%@#ÑsE?17#/6#7I#à2:()#ÉÜ)2w@7I#$SZE_Zv)7/?()#k]#g7E?9()#î

'M/N$%&#'O!c#!"ED¿,!f5$Bl!"zaz!WX!f)B!c#!c•F4)e!üv);."&&&!WX!%&&&!

!gj)V$45! c#! "(EV,! "DV5$e! H8-)C#! $BS.! c#! g^! 0)&.y

!g3Å4)e!"&MEC'5*#!,l!™)&Çw5!®e!"EZ58*45!WX!"(†5!°YZ!c#!4)e! î4ï,! k)*F45! ,l! k).yw5!`)@;+V5,! LEE@+45! ?(B! ».82+

!LE'5!?(B!"@j)v!0)*1l!89G!,l!è&;45!,l!"Ej5S;45!gj)V$45!".$\ô5! K58;&45! ?(B! ,l! ±.S45! [n8D+45! ,l! ì83&;45

"E(CQ45,T!

'M/N$%&!O! c#! "ED¿! üv);."&&&! WX!%&&&!K$Ee! g@;+F.! c#! g^! 0)&.y!

,l! dE(;A! ,l! `5$vw5! ,l! üDr5! "DV5$e! Hy)C;45!!>.{$A

Page 19: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

'5! òK)GaBt5,! K)B$CD4!,l! "EeL<5! ".)BS4)e! f)EQ(! `);1w5! ª)*A05! H0$ê! i! "EDr5! i! èn;m.,! ò"EV)EF45!0)9'5

"Ee)£+G~5!"(@<5!`ab!)\E4X!!

^_*`$%'e@f$%'Ou*v86%'C:w'p#T%'A''M/N$%&$O

!c#!"ED¿!üv);.!&&&!WX!"&&&&!gj)V$4)e!S@;+.!c#!g^!0)&.y!

!g3Å4)e!H0$^Y'5*#l!!0)Cbl!89G!Hy)BX!,l!∑.,8A!,l!89G!°aBpã(4!"e$F&#!"F4S#!,l!";&D3#!x50,l!,l!"Åj5{!T!

'M/N$%&%'O!c#!"E&(B!H0$3e!|E2ê!pµ!�u-!"CFG!,l!�)By5!g^!)C(z!¬+;.!cB!üAà.!kl!´89e!®;#!ä£-!0)C+B5!,l![8-!c#!`)&.!kl!çG_-

[S\+F'5!ä£9(4!8-)C#,!u3£-!08Æ!î4ïT!~5!î4ï!kaBX,!"DV5$e!,l!H8-)C#!H0$3e!"CF&45!î(A!,l!�)By

!,l!`)@+o~5!"ãEê!i!î4ï!>v,!$4,!Üo!çC*A8#!üv);.!gQ&45!?(B!"o58ê!)\+E@FA!>QA!∆!"E¶0!"öEZ!,l!ä£-!çe!S3Q.!k)^!üDr5! i! Hy05$45! K50)C;45! é$21! °8MFE.! )\E4X! �5S+Z~5! åkl

B$CD'5! ,l! K)e)+*45! ,l! K5S.S\+45! ,l! K5�5S&45! ,l!,l! K)"EG,à*4t5!K50$9&'5!,l!K)GaBt5!,l!f$V845!,l!K)Q(;'5!T!

!

'M/N$%&&O!g3Å4)e!"&EC'5!x8D45!éSo§e!ü(I4)e!�5S+B~5!ü*A8#!üv);.

*#! c#! "ED¿! "(†5! °YZ! c#!(&&&! WX!"&&&&!î4ï,! 0)&.y! [~í!08m45!f8µ!cB!8%&45!>DQeT

'M/N$%&'O8*45!c#!`)&A!H0)CB!g^!)@+-!¬+;A!,l!0)Q+o5!"%Å4!,l!"#5

®;#!�u-!"CFG!c@m+A!~!üVT!

!g3Å4)e!"&EC'5!gj)V$4)e!U+94)e!�5S+B~5,*#!çC*A8#!üv);.!

!c#!"ED¿%&&&!WX!!&&&0)&.y!!T

!!

'M/N$%&('O!!`$3Å45!f)*ol!ì8FA!~!*,!!!!,!$!ü(I45!?(B!"(†5!°YZ!c#!

! ,lU+945S3Qß.! O45! 0$345! i! ~X! K5$#w5! SÆ! çÇ$'5!!)\E1!!,l! ©5,{w5! ,l! "z0$45! 0)C+B5! ,l! [8-! ?(B! )E3£-! �5S+B~5

H)E<5!SEQe!UZ!c.Y45!®Cê);45T!

Page 20: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!H)E<5! SEQe! UZ! c.Y45! ®Cê);45! ,l! ©5,{w5! ,l! "z0$(4,

!g3Å4)e!çE(B!q$3&'5!y845!do!"V0)æ(#!�5$V!"(†5!°YZ!c#!!,l! U\18-! ?(B! �5S+B~5! ü(I45! ü*A8#! S3Q.! ∆! ,l! S3v

Z0)C+B5UT!

'M/N$%&)'O'!"Ej58Çt5! "(6! K)Em+Q'! )QCP! ü(I45! 7$Æ$#! K)CzX! c*R!WX! üFG! 5ïX! )#! H0$ê! i! "Dr)e! )Q(;+#! k)^! 5ïX! "Ej5Lô5!WX! ,l! $ô5,! 82C45! ,l! M¬45! ‘$EÇ! WX! ,l! "E¶845! K)öEá5

"E#$@;45!K505yt5T!!"Dr)e! )Q(;+#! k)^! 5ïX! )m.l! ü(I45! 7$Æ$#! K)CzX! c*R! )@^

#,!ò«Q1!,l!"EB)&ê!"FVs#!g^!i!®183+'5!,l!ì8.S#!SÆ!)\Ç$!,l! 0)by~5! `5$#l! ?(B! "EGaB! S@+;A! "E4)#! ,l! ".0)Ø

Ñ58vt5T!"EAÄ5!0$345!i!ü(I45!7$Æ$#!K)CzX!c*R!~â!

πä£9(4!"ê)r5!H)E<)e!d(;+.!ª$F&'5!8#w5!k)^!5ïX!–!l!

Å;4)e!]Æ8QG5!"R8 !d(;+.!ª$F&'5!8#w5!k)^!5ïX!–!ª!,l!$x$Q<5!y5yàV5!)\(’!"e$Q;e!,l!fy)Q+4)eT!

!q$3&'5! U+945,! ü(I45! Uj58Ç! i! Hy)m'5! "•<)e! �~yt5! c*R

!`$3Å4)e!)\E(B!*!,!!!,!$!5ïX!>C++45!èv$.,!ò"(†5!°YZ!c#!ü(I45!7$Æ$#!]Cz,!ò!uBS'5!?(B!ü(I45!7$Æ$#!K)CzX!�üB!g@À

!d(;+.!�u945!"CFG!,l!�)By~5!k)^!)#!5ïXf);45!k_94)eT!!"e)E&45!c#!ü(De!uj5LÇ!>MC+A!7$Æ$#!ª$F&'5!8#w5!k)^!5ïX!K5�58ÇX! k§1! çE1! k$&%'5! c#! é$*-! ?(B! �)&e! ,l! "E#$@;45!`)@Bl! �)\+G5! ®<! èv$A! ü(I45! "Emv! i! "@^)õ5,! >C++45

uj5Lô5!>C++45T!!

nI%!$%'e@f$%O'(G*o%'(_*/x%&'()<#S=%'a*Q!"#$%'A'2*-:$*I'

!

$%'M/N&*O!c•F4)e!üv);.c#f)B!f5$Bl!"zaz!WX!!c#!"ED¿,!(&&&!WX!!&&&!

!W$+.!c#!g^!0)&.y![~í!gQGK)#$(;#!cB~5!Uj58Ç!ª)3+µ!,l!n82+45!uF&ô5!‘SÆ!83Q45!,!"._e!UV5!8^ï!5S@;+#!]G)^!"(EV

)J!è.8;+4)e!|@FA!Sv!K)#$(;#!".l!ü.8FA!,l!"E2m45T!.! c#! g^! "e$Q;45! :Å&e! üv);.,M@;+! S!8.S3A,! >.{$A,! S.0$A

!,l!©)+GX!89G!,l!cB!"Eo)eX!y5$#!H{)Eo!,l!>Ee!,l!Ñ8B!,l`)ÅPw5T!

!

Page 21: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

'M/N$%'"O'!"EGaB! "F(Ç! i! )É,aA! gCv! dEQ2+45! dj)z,,! 8Æ)¡! 89G! 8n•À

!®e!=,5àA!"ED¿!î4ï!ü*A8#!üv);.,"&&&!WX!%&&&0)&.y!T!òuj)mv! kïX! k,y! 89&.! c#! ?(B! ª)Q;45! :ÅG! «(F.,!"Q.8De!

!,l! "45$ô5! èA5$á)e! )@EV! ~! gj)V$45! ]G)^! )@\#! gQ&45!0$ê! ,l! f$V845! ,l! H0$3'5! ‘$Q&45! ,l! uF@945! 8.$3+4)e!K)@^)õ)e!"DEõ5![,8%45!c#!)m;e!,l!a^!ò!fa1w5!,l!q)£-w5

! `$3Å4)e! )\E(B! q$3&'5! |&ô5! ,l! Uj58ô)e! "Q(;+'5%&"!WX!

%*&"Ej5Lô5!"(†5!c#!T!!

%M/N$''#'O!q$3&'5! 0$345! i! ü(I45! ).)mv! c#! "Emv! "._e! faBt5! 8n•À

! g3Å45! c#! ª! –! l! ®A8QÅ4)e! )\E(B!#!î4Y^,! "(†5! °YZ! c#!Ñ)\Çt5,!xaD45,!üF&45!K$Cz!).)mQe!"Q(;+'5!K~,5S'5!T!

!)Z89G!]v,!g^!i!{$∂!O45!f)*ow5!u(B!p•2+45!5YZ!dCD&.!~j)mQ45!"D(F45!c#!kï§e"ET!

!89G! p•Ö! :4)†5,! 8j5,S(4! c*R! "EGS'5! ).)mQ45! g^! i,ò).)mQ45! gEê)ÅA,!!8j5,S45! K)Æ,)Å#! 058Vl! 89G! )m.l! 8n•À

U^)õ5,!T!

!`)@;+V5! U^)õ5! K)F(Ç! K)B)v! gb5y,! K);158'5! �)&zl! 8n•À!,l! uF@945! 8.$3+45! K~í,! uA$345! gE•F+45! HL\Çl

8bl! "(EV,! ".l! ,l! i58µ$A)@&EF45!î4ï! i! K0Sê! 5ïX! ~X! é!°Yá! "Å4)¥! g^,! ò8%&45! K5ï! "Ej)mQ45! "D(F45! c#! "3b0

! c#! "ED¿! )\&B! üv);.! f)*ow5&#'! WX!#''!L•o! >#! 0)&.y!Ñ8ã45!î4Y4!"(@;+F'5!gj)V$45T!

!

'M/N$%'!O!î(A! ]G)^! 5ïX! )\&B! kaBt5! ,l! K)e)++^~5! |+1! 8n•À

0)3#! ,l! ).)Db! S.SFA! WX! u#8A! K)e)++^~5!K)#58µ! ,l! è.!üv);.,!"Ej5Lô5!).)mQ45!i!"E4S;45!U^)õ5![8P!c#!)J!f$*¡

!c#!"ED¿!è4)£'5!&&!WX!"&&&0)&.y!T!

'M/N$%'$'O'!0Sê!kX!üG)ô5!UmZ!,l!ü(I45!gÇl!c#!é$BSe!f)EQ45!c*R!~!8.0)Q+(4!,l!U^)õ5!éS4!K);158@(4!de)D#!èê,!"EG!cFo!cB

)\E4X!"#nSQ'5T!+@(4!c*R!"Ej5Lô5!"EmQ45!i!)18P!c*.!∆!ìY45!ü(I45!c#!08m

f)EQ45!"EGS'5!é$BS4)e!K~)<5!>E}!iT!

Page 22: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

'M/N$%'%O'!kï_A! kl! HSn\;+'5! U^)2@(4! c*R! "G5yt)e! U*o! 0Sê! 5ïX!,l! f$V845! ,l! K)Q(;'5! ,l! K)B$CD'5! ,l! K)e)+*45! H0y)3ú

@'5! "P8-w5! ,l! K)G5$DV~5! ,l! fa1w5! ,l! K)GaBt5!,l! "D&ã!ò>C++45! 7$Æ$#! $Z! )æ! î4ï! pµ! ,l! uG,à*4~5! 89&45! gj)V,!>E}![aA§e!,l!`)De§e!,l!L•û!kï_A!kl!0$345!>E}!i!)á!)@^!0)%Gl! ]Ö! "B$Æ$'5! ,l! "B{$'5! ,l! >EC(4! "Æ,8;'5! ¢F&45![aA§e!,l![Yû!kït5!?(B!83+QA!kl!)m.l!)á!c*R,!òf$@;45

#!"£FG!g^!c#!�5LÇl!»;eH{$•õ5!¢F&45!cT!!8•&.! p\9+4)e! S.S\+45! WX! y$;45! gÇl! c#! ª)Q;4)e! U*o! åg^!`)I+#5!®o!WX!)\;C+A!>v5$45!".0,S45!".89&45![)Q.X!ç&B!"(†5!f)*ol!cB!8%&45!>DQe!î4ï,!U^)õ5!çe!K8#l!)'!)\Co)ê

p\9+4)e!S.S\+45!"2& !"Q(;+'5!"Ej5Lô5T!!

y9*@$%'4*+$%O'a*K+LL$%'A'a*I<fK$%&!'

Z&6%'e@f$%O'a*Q*#T%'q)'z<$&E@=%'u*v86%'A!

(-*./$%'(,5%<I'(+[m!=%'p#T%&'

!!

!"#$%&'(!)!!

!Uj58ô5!)\CÇ$+FA!O45!K)e$Q;4)e!®E(êl!®(B)1!"Å3e!üv);."1)2345!"DV5$e!"C*A8'5â##

F{|&]! ,8.S#!k,8-)&45! ,l! ".0,S45! è2345!]G)^! )@\#!

πUÉ)E@FA!,l!U\&\#!F*V_*}πk$Å4s'5!ò8^ï!c#!y$Ç,!fSB!S&B!!'F*`$*}!π>&345!,l!>CD45!5$4$+#!ò®Å4s'5!y$Ç,!fSB!S&B!' F*KI%D!"B)C45! ò>&345! ,l! >CD45! ë$+#! y$Ç,! fSB! S&B

K)Q(;'5!5$;Æ5,,!k$B{$'5,T!

!"#$%&''!)!!

! ,8.S#! k)^! 5ïXè2345!".0,S45!i! ®4$@9#! k,8-)&45! ,l!e!U\;C+A!>Q.!k$Å4s')1!K);C++45®^0)9#!"Å3T##

!SÆ!0$345!>E}!i,!"Å345!î(A!:Å&e!K);C++45!�58ÇX!{$∂!)@^

!g3Å45!U\E(B!dCD&.!kl!c*R!c.Y45!q)£-w5!>E}(%!"(†5!c#!!u(B!g3Å45!5YZ!dECDA!c*R!~,!"Ej5Lô5ë$+#!äº!)@E1!>CD45!

"B)CD45!`)@BlT!0,Sê!H0$ê!i!—0)9#!ç+Å3e!>CD45!ë$+#!>C+A!c*R!çGl!?(B!

!8.S#!WX!"CF&4)e!"Ej5Lô5!"E4,sF'5!�)Å+G)e!U*o"ÅE2345!,l".0,S45!T!8\-l!"+V!gÇl!i!H0$345!°YZ!i!>C++45!>Q.,!

!{,)•+.!~!gÇl!i!8.SQA!?3vl!?(B,!"R8ô5!ª)*A05!¢.0)A!c#

Page 23: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!8.S#!"E4,sF#!�)Å+G5!K$Cz!¢.0)A!c#!8\-l!"+V!"ÅE2345!,l!".0,S45T!

!

!"#$%&'*)!!

'5! u*4)#! åkX!,l! "Ej8'5! ,l! "EA$345! ,l! "B$CD'5! K)Å&3"E@v845!®(3Å4)e! ®&E;'5! q)£-w5! >#! )EGS#! k$4,sF#!

!K)#58ã45,! ).)Dr5! �5y_e! äbw5! ?(B! k$#L(#,! ®Qe)F45U\E(B!f$*õ5!>#!c#)m+4)eT'

!"#$%&'+!)!!

!i!"E#$@;45!é$BS45!cB!"(3Å&#!"EGS#!é$BSe!f)EQ45!c*R!~(B!q$3&'5!ü(I45!|&Ç!ü*A8#!H)1,!O4)o!i!~X!"(†5!°YJ!)\E

f);45!$Å;4)e!ç;+N!,l!"2&ô5T!

'M/N$%'*'O'

!¢.0)A! i! "&V! Y&#! gvw5! ?(B! )\FEV_A! ]Cz! "E;}! g*4! c*R!uV)Vw5!)\#)%G!?m+Qú!"(Zs#!k$*A!kl!´89e!òg;Å45!ª)*A05

! WX!:&ô5! ,l! gêw5! ?(B! "FVs'5! LEE@+45! `)*-l! >E}! "mZ)&#!c.S45!,l!é$BS45!™0)N!kl!òk)FGt5!x$Qo!cB!7)1S45!WX!,l

! "DCA8'5! "ê)r5! g3Å4)e! )\E(B! q$3&'5! "R8ô)e!"!°YZ! c#!!SÆ!]C*A05!Sv!"R8ô5!]G)^!5ïX!çGl!?(B!ò"(†5!q)£-l!®&E;#

!"Q15$ú! ~X! é$BS45! °YZ! H8-)Cú! )á! |@F.! ~! çG§1! òUÉ5Yew)e!®E&;'5!q)£-w5!c#!"À8ê,!"Ee)+^8#T!

'

!"#$%&*,!)!!

!"._e! ,l! "1)2345! "DV5$e! "C*A8'5! |&ô5! i! K);C++45! åkX!f)*oÕ4! )QCP! )Z/58ÇX! U+.! faBt5! gj)V,! c#! é8bl! "(EV,

"EAÄ5â##

F{|&]!g3Å4)e!çE(B!q$3&'5!ü(I45!H0$ê!i!!*!i,!"(†5!°YZ!c#!

! g3Å4)e! çE(B! q$3&'5! U+945! H0$ê!$!~X! >C++45! U+.! ~!5! c#! ".)*9e!çGl! u(B! òU+945! ,l! ü(I45! çE4X! çÇ$'5! ä£94

!"E#$@;45! "e)E&45! [8P! c#! )#X! )Vl0! >C++4)e! f)EQ45! c*R!)QCP! "ê)r5! é$BS45! H8-)C'! "(Zs'5! K)E;@ô5! [8P! c#! )#X,

! g3Å45! f)*ow)"!U+945! ,l! ü(I45! k)^! 5ïX! "(†5! °YZ! c#!!WX!k$@+&.!cæ!q)£-w5!c#!"öÅ4!®\Ç$#!x8B!WX!,l!gêl!WX!,l

®;#! c.y! ç&#! ".)ã45! ]G)^,!!®e! »µ)C+45! ?(B! ».82+45!`)@Bw5! `)@;+V)e! î4ï,! k)*F45! ,l! k).yw5! ,l! ™)&Çw5!LE'5! ?(B! "@j)v! 0)*1l! 89G! WX! ,l! è&;45! ,l! "Ej5S;45

!g3Å45!f)*ow!)QCP!ì83&;45!""(†5!°YZ!c#!π!

Page 24: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

' F*V_*}!U+.!~! SZ)-! SÆ! çÇ$'5! U+945! ,l! ü(I45! H0$ê! i

5!ü(I45! kl! uBS.! ìY45! SZ)945! cB! H0y)ê! ".)*9e! ~X! >C++4π°SÆ!çÇ$#!U+945,'

F*`$*}!`,S45!�)V/0!SÆ!çÇ$'5!U+945!,l!ü(I45!H0$ê!i!

!k§1! "EV)#$(eS45! K)I;C45! �)V/0,! "EC&Çw5! K)#$*<5,çE(B!éS+;'5!c#!ü(De!U+.!>C++45!T!H05{,!WX!ü(D45!çÇ$.,

?(B! ç(EÖ! O45! "EÇ0)r5! k,s945!�58ǧe! kï≤4! `S;45! H05{,!>C++45T

!

!"#$%&*-)!!

!c#!`$3Å(4!5YEÅ&A!K);C+A!`$3o!H0$ê!i*#!WX!!)!c#,!!$&!

!WX$$!7)¶!S;e!gêw5!i!8%&A!O45!"@*2@(4!c*R!"(†5!°YZ!c#!!é0$945!H8•û!]CA!kl!)#$.!89B!"F“![8h!i,!"E&;'5![58Pw5

45!7$Æ$#!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!èEv$A!i!HS'!>C++~!!{,)•+A!8\-l! "+V! HS',! "E#$E45! Sj58ô5! WX! "CF&4)e! 8\-l! "zaI45

"E#$E45!pµ!Sj58ô5!WX!"CF&4)eT

!WX!0$m<5!gÇl!«À,*'!®\Ç$'5!U+945!,l!ü(I45!H0$ê!i!"B)V!!ª)e! |+1! ¢.0)A! c#! �5S+e5! î4ï,! "Ee)£+G5! "Dr! |-à#! WX

WX!"F(ô5!pb_A!c*R!~,!òK)2-à45!cB!de)F45!f$E45!S;e!)#!!f)*ol! dCD&A! ~! H0$345! °YZ! i,! K)e)£+Ga4! ®;'5! f$E45

!®(3Å45)%,!)(,!)*,!)!"(†5!°YZ!c#!T!!>DQe!Ov$45!YEÅ&+(4!ae)v!"@*õ5!°Y£+A!ìY45!058Q45!k$*.,![8h! i! [)&ö+V~5! "@*¡! ]CA,! ò[)&ö+V~)e!c;P! g^! cB! 8%&45

A!c#!�5S+e5!)#$.!89B!"F“"@*õ5!"e)+*e!ü(D'5!√SQA!¢.0)T!!î4ï! ?(B! H8@+F#! ¬+;A,! 0,S345! cB! "Åv$'5! HS.8ô5! >DQ&A,![,8%45!c#!®CA!5ïX!u(êw5!)ƒ5$&B!pµ!k5$&B!]Ö!K0Sê!$4,!®(#);45! c#! »;C45! ,l! g*45! "^0)9#! c#! "ê)b,! "E;v5$45

"(D;'5!HS.8•(4!058@+V5!"QEQ<5!i!)ƒ_e!)\E1T!á! `$;Å#! ~,!«e8A! ]G)^! O45! gã945! y$QB! ?(B! èEv$+45! 5Y

!,l! ".Sv);+45! K)#5L+4~5! g#)*4! a@2+#! ?QC.! ìY45! gã+F'5H0$^Y'5!y$Q;45!cB!"Ø)&45!"EG$G)Q45T!

!cB! "1$v$#! ".0,y! "ÅE2ê! 05SêX! ?(B! 8@+F.! c#! g^! üv);.,

!"ED¿!uj)mv!U*û!0,S345!)Z05SQ#"&"£FG!g^!cB!pG)Gy!T!

!"#$%&*.!)!!

l!ü∂!?*+9'5!g;Å45!èê,!çEC&+45!,l!�)BS+V~)e!®C.,!|Æ$.!k!>v,! 5ïX,! ò>C++45! çE(B! ±C&.! ìY45! uG$G)Q45! ä&45,! ç&#!°8Q#!®E;A!u(B!ì$+À!kl!uãC&.!".)*945!üo)ê!c#!�)BS+V~5

Page 25: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!>Q.,! é$BS45! )\.S4! "B$18'5! "@*õ5! )J! "C3+&'5! "&.S')e$@;45! "e)E&45,! U\+'5! c#! g*4! î4ï! ≈E(CA!gDCE1! ~X,! "E#

>C++45T!!)#$.!k,89B!"@*õ5!éS4!0$m<5,!�)BS+V~5!®e!gÇw5!k$*.,T

'!"#$%&!"!)!!

!f)*ow! )QCP! ü(I45! "R8Ç! f5S;G5! K)CzX! U\+'5! y50l! 5ïX

!g3Å45!#!"E#$@;45!"e)E&45!WX!fSQ.!kl!çE(;1!"(†5!°YZ!c#!Y45!gõ)e!u^)945!WX!,l!"@*õ5!"e)+*4!|.83A!"DV5$e!°Y≠5!ì

!c#!,l!`,w5!c#!ü(De!50y)ê!�)BS+V~5!k$*.!)#!üFû!ç4!58Q#!�)BS+V~5!Ã$(e!c#!f).l!H89B!°0Sv!gÇl!i!î4ï,!uG)I45â##

' F{&]!,l! çEC&+4)e! "1$ê$'5,! "e$F&'5! `);1w5! i! )G)Ee

π)\+2ê!K)CzX!S.8.!O45,!�)BS+V~5!F*V_*}π)J!"Q(;+'5!K5S&+F'5,!dj)z$45!c#!"£FG!!

}F*`$*!UÉ5y)\9e! ©)•+o~5! S.8.! c.Y45! y$\945! �)¶l!

UÉ5n8Q#,!U\&\#,T!!i!çA8e)¥!g¡!gÇw5!:ÅG!i!®;.!kl!î4ï!u(B!H,aB!U\+'5!?(B,

ç4!"\Ç$'5!ü(I45!"@É!y0!i!çQo!«QV!~X,!"@*õ5!H8j5yT!!

!"#$%&*/!)!!

!)@(;.! kl! `)<5! üFo! "E#$@;45! "e)E&45! ,l! u^)945! ?(Bab! U\+'5!g^! i,! ò�)BS+V~5! ¢.0)+4! "E45$'5! f).l! "F@r5! `

!`SB! "DV5$e! `,w)1! òf).l! "zaIe! "F(ô5! y)Q;G5! gCv! K~)<5!�)¶l,! dj)z$45! ¢FG! k_e! ".05yt5! "Q.8D4)e! uG)I45,! YÅ&#

! S.8.! c.Y45! y$\945U\+DV5$e!î4Y^,! Hy)m'5! "•<)e! �~yt5!õ5!"e)+*e!ç+#ï!?(B!];Æ,!UÉ58Q#,!U\&\#"@*T##

!"#$%&*(!)!!

!q$3&'5! U+945,! ü(I45! Uj58Ç! i! )@*û! |.83+45! "@*õ5! ?(B!`$3Å4)e!)\E(B!*,!!!,!!$!58\-!°)3vl!gÇl!i!"(†5!°YZ!c#!

W,w5!"F(ô5!¢.0)A!c#!�5S+e5T!

!"#$%&*'!)!!

!|&ô5!cB!k)AS4$+'5!"EGS'5!é$BS45,!"E#$@;45!é$BS45!«QFAJ!)\E(B!q$3&'5!K)Å4)£'5!,l!"(#)^!8\-l!"+V!umú!"(†5!°Y

>C++(4!uj58ÇX!g@B!8bí!f$.!c#!,l!)\B$v,!¢.0)A!c#T!

!"#$%&**)!!

!g3Å45!dECDA!c*R!(!Hy05$45!0$345!>E}!i!"Ej5Lô5!"(†5!c#!"(†5!°YJT'

Page 26: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!

!!!!! ! !! !!!!!!!!! !!!! !!"##!! !! !! !!!!!!!!!"##!!

!! !!! !!!!!!!!!!! !! !!!! !! !!! !!!!!!! ! !!! ! !!!!!!!!!!! !!"##!!!

!! !! !! !!!!!!!!!"##!! !!!! !!! !!! !!! !!!!! ! !!!!!! !!! !!!!!!!!

!!

ò"EFG$+45!".0$\@•(4!]vs'5!:Ej845!ò7LC'5!y5s1!c÷!

ySB!f$V8'5!?(B!)&BaP5!S;e!TTT!"&F4%&""!"&F4!%&""!i!ù0s'5!

!óTTTñ%&""ò"1)2345!"(6!05Sê§e!d(;+'5!!"öEá5! c#! =5àv)e,!=aêt5,! H0$I45! [5SZl! dEQ2+4! )E(;45!

! ySB! f$V8'5! ?m+Qú! "zSõ5! uP58QRS45! `)Q+G~5,! uV)EF45$!

!"&F4%&""!"&F4!%&""!!i!ù0s'5!"'!ì8ÅE1!%&""ò!ò`,w5!8.{$45!ìl0!?(B!7aP~5!S;e,!

ò!".05yt5!"@*õ5!ìl0!?(B,!5YZ!)G8#l!0S3Gâ!

Page 27: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

Z&6%'4*+$%'O'(QD&:$%'c./$%!'M/N$%#O'

!q$3&'5! |.83+45! )\&@m+.! O45! K)G)EC45! ?(B! gbS.! pEãA! g^

!g3Å4)e!çE(B"'ySB!f$V8'5!c#!!TTT!"&F4%&""!05Sê§e!d(;+'5!"ãE345!:ÅG!i!5S.SÇ!)À83A!üÇ$+F.!"1)2345!"(6T!

|.83A!g^!cB!gê,!U(F.,T!!

'M/N$%!O'!¢.0)A!c#!8\-l!"+V!gÇl!i!)Z05SêX!U+.!∆!".0,y!,l!"ÅE2ê!g^

FA5S.SÇ!)À83A!üÇ$+FA!gê$45!UE(T!|.83+45!5YZ!cB!S.SÇ!gê,!U(F.,T!

!

^_*`$%'4*+$%O!^_<_*f$%'2%:Q~%!Z&6%'e@f$%O'(3*)';*[\]'

'M/N$%$O'!`$3Å4)e!)\E4X!0)9'5!K)B5S.t5!è(+¥,!gE•F+45!kX*,!!,!"#!

ySB!f$V8'5!c#!TTT!"&F4%&""!i!ù0s'5!!óTTTñ%&""!f)EQ45!ü∂!!H8-)C#!)Jk_94)e!"E&;'5!ø)3'5!c#!"2(3#!g^!éS4T!

!!

!

^_*`$%'e@f$%O^I<�<$%'ÄV/#L$%'''M/N$%%O'

!".0,S45! pµ! ,l! ".0,S45!K)Å&3'5!8j)%G!>E}! i! ©0SA!kl! ü∂!";Æ)r5,!"EFG$+45!yaC4)e!)\Ç)+GX!Hy)BX!,l!)\Ç)+GX!>v5$45

"EAÄ5!K)G)EC45!uG$G)Q45!75S.t5!�58Çtâ!

"ÅT%&!*6!Ç:TM%&!q5&+o5ÉM%&!"$H*!",7M%&!*6!"Q2!!

%Å2d"$H*!~^2\:%&!2OM5&*!+cKLM%&

(Å{";1!*6!w%ÉM%&!?2:1@!Ñ,^28

*Åm%*7%&!q4]":%&!97)

!Å!I^2K)Öm1>12]!Ü&7,@!Öm1>12$%&!Ü&7,�2.!2O%li!_24$%&!z\,!m:%&!"OQ6!+álà%&*!+To%&!R24.!<H

$Å!<.2L%&!C2M)6!+(o(5!mg!mK8"%&!97c%&6*!"Q2T%&

∑+&'!c*R!çGl!pµ!)\Ç)+GX!Hy)BX!i!d<5!ç4!c'!,l!"EF’!0$ê!!K)Å&3'5! u•+&'! c*R! )@^! òç+#aB,! ç¶5! >Æ,! ?(B! 83+Q.! kl!,l! )\Ç)+GX! Hy)BX! i! d<5! ç4! c'! ,l! "E@v845! ,l! "D&ã@'5!UV5,!"%1)<5!?(B!ç;&ê!"#aB,!ç¶5!>Æ,!?(B!83+Q.!kl!)\;.{$A

t5!8^ï!>#!èE4_+45!k5$&B,!®Å4s'5!,l!è4s'5!uG$G)Q45!75S.

Page 28: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!Uv845!î4Y^,!75S.t5!5YZ!)áab!”!O45!8\-l!"zaI45,!"&F45,∑+&'5!`)@Bl!"B$@†!ΩEAà45T!

'M/N$%&O'!òü2F45!5YZ!¢.0)A!S.SÇ!c#!)\C2V!>v5$45!¢F&45!c@m+A!kl!ü∂!°aBl! >e5845! g3Å4)e! Hy05$45! K)G)EC45! c@m+A! kl! ü∂! )@^

45! ¢.0)A! ?(B! äE3&+45! WX! "1)ÆX!75S.t5! K5�58ǧe! f)EQH8#!`,l!i!uG$G)Q45T!

!

'M/N$%'O'uG$G)Q45!75S.t)e!"Q(;+'5!K)G)EC45!©50yX!ü∂â!

"Å+)>KLM%&!J2DT#M(%!+KoT%2.!N!â7A@!'()!*6!+,^*7%&!+D4a#%&!*6!w4%-:%&!R&>T)!2O.!m:%&!+aD#%2.

v%!+4%2:%&!J2aD#%&!â7A@!'()!*6!äT%&!"in!mg!*6!+$.2o%&!J2aD#%&!!

%ÅoT%2.J2Q>$TH!*6!ãX&"i!*6!^>j!*6!_>5^!WPQ!mg!^7#8!m:%&!J2DT#M(%!+K!N!2O4OS*!7A6!'()

(Å+LTeMM%&!J2DT#M(%!+KoT%2.*+4M]"%&!*6!!N2OD(i!*6!2OOS*!'()U

"#$%#&!'()#&*!+$,-.&!/0$123!456(7#&!!

'M/N$%(O'!�58Çt! ";Æ)r5,! :G$A! i! HL•&'5! 89&45! ,l! >CD45! `)@Bl! >E}

)Q45!75S.t5!üEA8A!dCP!)Z{)◊X!¢.0)A!üFo!)\(E•FA!ü∂!uG$G!°YZ! c@m+A,! k,8-)&45,! k$;e)D45! )\*FR! 8A)1Se! gF(F+#!";Æ)r5! K)Å4s'5! 8j)%G! >E}! i! "Ç0S'5! K)G)EC45! KaE•F+45

uG$G)Q45!75S.t5!�58ÇtT!!çÇ50yX! ü∂! ìY45! yS;45! :Å&45! $Z! "(F(F45! i! ΩA845! yS;45,

g3Å(4!)QCP!p%&45!?(B!*°aBl!!T!!

'M/N$%)O'!K).0,S45! ,! è2345! >m≠! "(z)@'5! KaE•F+45! yS;A! ìy)Å+4!>E}!?(B!ç¶0!ü∂!Uv0!)á!S&F.,!"&F45!"EQC4!ø)ê!So5,!gE•F+4!U+.!kl!?(B!òHS'5!î(A!`ab!H0$9&'5!".0,S45!,l!è2345!y5SBl!"&F45! i! 0S3.! ySB! `,w! "Q.8D45! :Å&e! S.SÇ! gE•F+e! f)EQ45

E45$'5"T!!".0,S45!,l!"ÅE2345!?(B!gbyl!5ïX!S.SÇ!gE•F+e!f)EQ45!ü∂,

!g3Å4)e!çE(B!q$3&'5!|.83+45!i!)J!WS'5!K)G)EC45!i!pEãA"'!

ySB! °aBl! çE4X! 0)9'5! f$V8'5! c#! TTT! "&F4%&""!i! ù0s'5!

!óTTTñ%&""T

Page 29: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

!

'M/N$%*O'#! W,w5! H8QÅ4)e! H0$^Y'5! K)Å&3'5! uG$G)Q45! 75S.≤4! >m≠!c

! g3Å45(ySB! °aBl! çE4X! 0)9'5! f$V8'5! c#!! TTT! "&F4%&""!

!i!ù0s'5!óTTTñ%&""!)\E(B!q$3&'5!f)*oÕ4!)QCP!)\(E•FA!ü∂,!

!g3Å4)e)°aBl!!T!

'M/N$%#"O'!ò8j)%G!"zaz!i!|.83+e!)e$23#!uG$G)Q45!75S.t5!k$*.!kl!ü∂

"EAÄ5!K)G)EC(4!"(#)o,!H)mæ,!"b0s#â!

"Å.2L%&!R&>T)*!q5&Ü=>M%&!*6!"Q2T%&!*6!Ç:TM%&!*6!<!!

%Åzao%&!v87X2D%!~"S6!~|%&!~>TcM%&!*6!~92M%&!äu;%&!+Dj*!R&>T)*!q5&

(Åw4T#:%&!R&>T)

*Åw%ÉM%&!q5&

!Åm%*7%&!q4]":%&!97)

$Åz:P(%!+KoT%2.!J&":M:To%2.!q\a%&!Y%|3*!7,7\%&!zao(%!*6!";T(%!mK8"%&!97c%&*!zao%&!+4M3

)Å<KL%&!å2O:1&!Ñ,^28

'ÅmK8"%&!97c%&C2eQF&!":g9!mg!w4T#:(%!7ToM%&!

!K)G)EC45!?(B!K).0,S45!,l!è2345!äº!)@E1!|.83+45!83+Q.,"E4)+45â

"Å+D4a#%&!R&>T)*6!+,^*7%&!!!

%Åzao%&!+4M3

(Å7,7\%&!zao(%!*6!";T(%!mK8"%&!97c%&U

*Åm%*7%&!q4]":%&!97)

!>e)P!a#)o!75S.t)e!Uj)Q45!WX!"zaI45!8j)%&45!c#!p%G!>Ç8.,!"2(3'5)\.S4!75S.t5!”!O45!T!faBt5!f)Q#!p%&45!5YZ!f$Q.,Ã$(C4)eT!

!

'M/N$%##O!ç3º!)@E1!g^!7{$'5!,l!8-)&45!,l!∑+&'5!,l!>e)D45!?(B!ü∂!çE(B!q$3&'5!q)r5!à1S4)e!`)@Bl!c#!g•V!)@E1!"@j)v!y5SBX!S&B!"@j)Q45!°YZ!c#!p%G!çÇ$.,!ò8#w5!5YZ!c#!™y)F45!g3Å4)e

! g^! �)\+G5!75S.t5! )\.S4! U+.! O45! "2(3'5! WX! 8\-l! "+VuG$G)Q45T!

!

'M/N$%#!O'!"v)De!75S.X!g^!>#!fSQ.!kl!ç#)Q#!f$Q.!c#!,l!8-)&45!?(B

8j)%G!"zaz!i!"E158µ$E(CEeT!!

Page 30: 01'2&!3 - Centre for Law and Democracy#$12H#;Q#A:()#Ä-?1#WGY@#$@-9G'()#Ftuv)#\E_mp]#*Bu#~2 S_()#k%]#$1Ed(#cLE=9s{)!"oÅ#*(+#on#R]#,-=

'M/N$%#$O'!5YZ! YEÅ&+e! ç3º! )@E1! g^! `S;45! 8.{,,! `,w5! 8.{$45! è(*.

45!".0$\@•(4!u¶845!Sj584)e!89&.!ìY45!8#w5"EFG$+T!

!i!©)P8v!83Qe!8#w5!5YZ!0Sê,!óTTTñ%&""T!!

!]vs'5!:Ej845"EFG$+45!".0$\@•(4!

2Y+=%'9%E-'


Recommended