Experimental Modal Analysis
Slides to accompany lectures in ME 599/699:
Vibro-Acoustic Design in Mechanical Systems© 2002 by A. F. Seybert
Department of Mechanical EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
Lexington, KY 40506-0503Tel: 859-257-6336 x 80645
Fax: [email protected]
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
2
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Goals of the Lecture
• Understand how experimental modal analysis complements other methods of vibration analysis
• Learn to perform experimental modal analysis on a simple system
• Understand how modal information is extracted from measured data
• Correlate measured natural frequencies and modes with those obtained analytically and numerically
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
3
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Principles
• Every mechanical system (structure) has a large number (theoretically infinite) natural frequencies.
• Associated with each natural frequency is a displacement pattern (mode) in which the structure prefers to vibrate.
First vibration mode Second vibration mode
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
4
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
• A natural frequency may be detected experimentally by exciting the structure with a harmonic force and varying the frequency until “resonance” is achieved. At resonance, the mode associated with the natural frequency may be observed.
• By roving an accelerometer over the surface, the mode may be recorded and plotted.
Principles (cont.)
F tsinω 1 F tsinω 2
First vibration mode Second vibration mode
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
5
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
• Excitation by an impulsive load (impact force) will produce a transient response consisting of a superposition of all the modes of vibration and their corresponding natural frequencies.
• Accelerometer is moved and impact test is repeated at as many points where a mode is desired.
Principles (cont.)
impulse response
Acc
eler
ation
(m/s
2 )
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
6
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Hammer Delivers Measurable Impact Force
Piezoelectric load cell
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
7
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Freq (Hz)
Hij
FFT
Principles (cont.)
Impulse response and frequency response function (FRF) at point i due to impact at point j. Hij is invariant because it is a ratio of the response to the input.
Repeat for all points i = 1 to N while holding j fixed (requiresmoving the accelerometer of having a large number of them.)
HAFij
i
j
=( )( )ωω
Acc
eler
ation
(m/s
2 )
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
8
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Point-Picking to get Mode Shape
Freq (Hz)
Hij
These are the relative values of each mode at point i: Hij(? 1), Hij(? 2), etc.
We can visualize each mode k by plotting Hij(? k), i = 1 to N, over the surface of the structure.
Hij(? k):+
-i = 1
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
9
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Point-Picking Method
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
10
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Reciprocity
Static beam deflection by reciprocity
y
x
P(xo)
y(x)y
x
P(x)
y(xo)
)|()|( xxyxxy oo =
For dynamic (FRF) measurement: jiij HH =
Thus, we can fix the accelerometer (i) and move the impact point (j).
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
11
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Modal Analysis Example
Foam Pad
Steel beam (1/2”x1/2”x18-1/8”)
&& ( )x tj F ti ( )
HAFji
j
i
( )( )( )
ωωω
=
PC
• Determine first four modes and natural frequencies experimentally• Compare with theory (see vibration book) for free-free beam• Compare with ANSYS model
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
12
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Modal Parameter Extraction
For each mode of thestructure we want:
• Natural frequency• Damping• Mode shape
Methods:
• Peak picking (SDOF)• Circle fit (SDOF)• MDOF curve fitting
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
13
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Peak Picking Method
H ji k( )ω
H ji k( )ω 2
ωk
ω2ω1ω ω
ςω ω
ω
n k
k
≈
≈−2 1
2The mode shapes are found by plotting the peak value at ωk for all the FRF’s measured (from the excitation point j to each point i).
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
14
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Peak Picking Method - Features
• assumes a SDOF FRF• accuracy depends on the reliability of the peak value• modes must be well-separated (little modal overlap)• damping must be small (so that ωn ≈ ωk) but not too small
so that peak value has high measurement uncertainty• a quick approach for preliminary evaluation and trouble shooting
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
15
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Circle Fit Method
• Also assumes SDOF FRF (same shortcomings of PPM)• Plot of mobility (reciprocal of impedance) is a circle
in the complex (Nyquist) plane• Process fits SDOF mobility function to measured
data using least squares (better than PPM)• Natural frequency, damping, and mode shapes are
found from fitted functions
Re (1/Zm)
Im (1/Zm)
FRF data
SDOF model
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
16
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
MDOF Curve Fitting
Every FRF has the form:
H sb b s b sa a s a s
m pmm
pp( ) ( )=
+ + ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ++ + ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ +
≤0 1
0 1
The roots of the characteristic equation are the eigenvalues:∆ ( ) ( )( ) ( )
,
s a a s a s s s s
j
pp
p
i i i i i i
= + + ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ + = + + ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ + =
= ± −∗
0 1 1 2
2
0
1
λ λ λ
λ λ ς ω ω ς Natural frequency and damping ratio for each mode
Partial fraction expansion to obtain residues:
( )H sA
s sA H s s si
i i ii
n
i i i i s i
( ) ( )=+ +
→ = ⋅ + += =∑ 2 2
1
2 2
22
ς ω ως ω ω
λ
a’s and b’s from curve fit
Ai for all FRF’s are used to plot mode shape for each mode i
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
17
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Example – MDOF Curve Fit
Dept. of Mech. EngineeringUniversity of Kentucky
18
Experimental Modal Analysis
ME 599/699 Vibro-Acoustic Design
Example – MDOF Curve Fit