1

Evaporative EmissionStandards for Boats

Presented By:John McKnightDirector of Environmental & Safety ComplianceDecember 2008

2

Outline• Overview of new program

• Evaporative emission types

• New Standards

• Program details

• Small businesses

• Certification

• Questions

3

Final Rule• On September 4, 2008, EPA Administrator Steve Johnson

signed, into law, new exhaust and evaporative emission standards for spark-ignition marine engines and vessels.

• These standards apply only to new engines and vessels sold for use in the United States.

• The standards will help reduce harmful health effects of ozone and carbon monoxide from these products.

4

Final Standards: Overview• HC+NOx exhaust emission standards for

SI marine engines are similar in stringency to existing standards in California

• New CO exhaust emission standards for all SI marine engines

• New Not-to-Exceed provisions

• New evaporative emission standards

5

Refueling/spillage Venting emissions (diurnal, hot soak, running loss)

Permeation (fuel tank, hoses, other)

6

Highway Evap Standards

Three decades of automotive evaporative emission control(full vehicle test/standards)

Nonroad equipment are just now becoming

subject to evaporative emission control

7

Existing Nonroad Standards• Component based standards

– Fuel and tank permeation– Component test for diurnal control– Design-based certification

• Existing standards– Large SI equipment (2007)– Recreational vehicles (2008)– Portable gas cans (2009)

8

New StandardsSI Marine• Portable tanks

– Tank permeation– Self-sealing vent

• Vessels– Hose and tank permeation– Diurnal emissions– Refueling spillage

Small SI as well– Hose and tank permeation– Running loss

9

Marine Evap StandardsStandard/Category

Hose Permeation

Tank Permeation

Diurnal

Standard level 15 g/m2/day 1.5 g/m2/day 0.40 g/gal/day

Portable tanks 2009a 2011 2010b

PWC 2009 2011 2010

Other tanks 2009a 2012 2011c,d

a 2011 for primer bulbs. Phase-in for under cowl fuel lines, by length, on OB engines: 30% 2010, 60% 2011, 90% 2012, 100% 2015.b Design standard.c Fuel tanks installed in nontrailerable boats (> 26 ft. in length or >8.5 ft. in width) may meet a standard of 0.16 g/gal/day over an alternative test cycle.d The standard is effective July 31, 2011. For boats with installed fuel tanks, this standard is phased-in 50%/100% over the first two years. As an alternative, small manufacturers may participate in a diurnal allowance program.

10

Program DetailsHose

Permeation

Diurnal

RefuelingSpillage

TankPermeation

Small Business

Provisions

Certification

11

Fuel Line Permeation• Fuel line

– 15 g/m2/day, 2009• Fuel CE10, 23°C

– Boat and engine hose• Phase-in for under cowl fuel line

– Primer bulbs, 2011

• Vent and fill lines– Standards do not apply unless hose will hold

standing fuel

• Fuel line manufacturers will certify

12

Technical Approaches• Straight-run hose

– Low permeation hose widely available– Fluoroelastomer/fluoroplastic barriers– SAE J1527 includes specification for 15 g/m2/day hose

• Molded hose and other rubber components– Fluoroelastomer construction– Alternative primer bulb products

rubber

barrier layerreinforcement

cover

13

Fuel Tank Permeation• 1.5 g/m2/day

– E10 fuel, 28°C– Preconditioning

• Fuel soak• Durability testing

• Design-based certification– Metal tanks– Automotive type multi-layer tanks

• Tank manufacturer will certify

14

Technical Approaches

• Multi-layer constructions• Alternative materials• Barrier treatments• Barrier platelets• Coatings• Nanocomposites

15

Diurnal Standards• Portable fuel tanks

– Self-sealing valve

• Installed tanks– Trailerable boats (<26 ft)

• 0.40 g/gal/day• 25.6-32.2°C

– Nontrailerable boats• 0.16 g/gal/day• 27.6-30.2°C

• Tank manufacturer will certify

25.0

26.0

27.0

28.0

29.0

30.0

31.0

32.0

33.0

0 4 8 12 16 20 24

H oursF

uel

Tem

p, D

egre

es C

<26 ft

26 ft +

16

Technical Approaches• Design-based certification

– Seal tank (up to 1.0 psi)• Can use pressure mitigation (e.g. bladder)

– Passive-purge carbon canister• Prevent fuel from entering

canister• Carbon and canister

specifications

17

Examples of Carbon Canisters

18

• Fuel nozzle standards– Marinas must use standard nozzles whenever they

replace existing nozzles or install new ones– Same to those already used for motor vehicle pumps

• Standardized dimensions• Automatic shut-off

• System integration– Fuel systems should be designed to allow flow to

nozzle for automatic shut-off– Will help with carbon canister installation designs and

reduce spillage

Refueling

19

System Integration• Industry consensus standards

– SAE J1527 addresses hose permeation– ABYC H24 potential vehicle for specifying best practices for

fuel system designs– NMMA certification

• Canister installation standards– Industry is developing canister installation practices in context

of EPA & USCG standards– ABYC is assessing fuel/air separators and fuel system designs

for spillage control

20

Potential Canister Installation

Fill neck

Vapor space(for fuel expansion)

Valve ororifice

Vent line

CanisterFuel tank

21

XYZ BOAT COMPANY

22

How to Download the Rule

1. Go to http://www.epa.gov/otaq/marinesi.htm

2. Under “Regulations and Guidance,” click on Final Rule.

23

How to Download the Rule

3. The Final Rule will be a PDF document.

4. Go to Federal Register page 59298, which is actually page 266 in the document.

24

Other Resources

jmcknight@nmma.org or 202-737-9757

Three communication programs in late January 2009

– Engine Workshop– Component Manufacturer Workshop– Web based workshop for boat builders