7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

1/34

HCQXVCAX LG ALETIFC@ ALTVX LG @^^D@EQ

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

Ol/ ]VDH@AXDHY

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

]HDGDOH@OXY%

]Hdgdoh`oxY%w/

TOCXDH QX@XDQ LG @IDVCA@%

@~~deedd/

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

@~~d`e gvli Hdacqclo lg xbd Qt~dvclv Altvx lg xbdHcqxvcax lg Aletifc` Avcico`e Hcwcqclo

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

FVCDG GLV @^^DEE@OX

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

]VDH@AXDHY

]VDH@AXDHY

]VDH@AXDHY]VDH@AXDHY

]VDH@AXDHY

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

2/34

) 0 )

X@FED LG ALXDXQ

^@JD

X@FED LG @TXBLVCXCDQ / 6

CQQTD VDQDOXDH / 1

QX@XDIDOX LG XBD A@QD // 8

QX@XDIDOX LG G@AXQ///// 4

@VJTIDOX 07

C/ XBD ELZDV ALTVX G@CEDH XL ALOHTAX @O @HDPT@XD COPTCVSCOXL @^^DEE@OXQ ^VDXVC@E CODGGDAXCWD @QQCQX@OAD AE@CI

CC/ XBD XVC@E ALTVX DVVDH CO HDOSCOJ HDGDOH@OXQ ILXCLOQ XLALOXCOTD

ALOAETQCLO 16

ADVXCGCA@XD LG QDVWCAD 18

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

3/34

) 6 )

X@FED LG @TXBLVCXCDQ

A@QDQ ^@JD

G`vvdee w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 130 @/6h :44 :7> "H/A/ 03:2#///////07% 0:% 61

Gcdehq w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 877 @/6h 266 "H/A/ 0321#///////0:

Glvxd w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 247 @/6h 47: "H/A/ 6>>8# ////0:

Msed w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% :43 @/6h 036 "H/A/ 6>>>#// 1>

I`xxbdzq w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 843 @/6h 0>71 "H/A/ 0321#///0:% 02% 61

IaG`hhdo w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 708 @/6h 00 "H/A/0336#/07% 02% 64% 62

Iceeq w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% :37 @/6h 67 "H/A/ 6>>6#//07% 66% 63

Ilovld w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 123 @/6h 200"H/A/ 03:2#/////07% 0:% 62

Itojl w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% ::6 @/6h 68> "H/A/ 6>>0#7

Odeqlo w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 7>0 @/6h 426 "H/A/0330#62

LAloolv w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 133 @/6h 60"H/A/ 03:3#63% 1>

^lzdee w/ @e`f`i`% 62: T/Q/ 84 "0316# // 16

Zcoj`xd w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 773 @/6h 06:4 "H/A/0334# 07% 64

S`oads w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% :44 @/6h 860 "H/A/ 6>>># 16

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

4/34

) 1 )

CQQTDQ ^VDQDXDH

C/ Zbdxbdv xbd xvc`e altvx i`hd `o `hdpt`xd coptcvs coxl Hdgdoh`oxq ~vd)xvc`e codggdaxcwdaltoqde ae`ci/

CC/ Zbdxbdv xbd xvc`e altvx `ftqdh cxq hcqavdxclo `oh wcle`xdh @~~dee`oxq Qcrxb @idohidoxvcjbxq fs hdoscoj itexc~ed vdptdqxq glv ` aloxcot`oad f`qdh lo otidvltq w`ech jvltohq

coaethcoj% coxdv `ec`; "0# xbd jlwdvoidoxq gcecoj lg ` ilvocoj lg xbd xvc`e qt~dvqdhcoj

coglvi`xclo ab`vjcoj ` odz% ilvd qdvcltq lggdoqd xb`x altoqde z`q olx ~vd~`vdh xl hdgdoh= `oh

"6# xbd jlwdvoidoxq g`cetvd xl xtvo lwdvFv`hs `oh Kdoamq i`xdvc`eq vdptdqxdh co ~vd)xvc`e

hcqalwdvs `oh avcxca`e xl xbd dggdaxcwd dr`ico`xclo lg xbd jlwdvoidoxq loes zcxodqq/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

5/34

) 8 )

QX@XDIDX LG XBD A@QD

]Xbd Ali~e`co`oxY% ` alvvdaxclo`e lggcadv% `aatqdh @~~dee`ox ]Hdgdoh`oxY lg `qq`texcoj

bdv `x xbd H/A/ K`ce% zbdvd ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q `o coi`xd% lo Ktod :% 6>00/ "Xv/6;3#/0

Lo Laxlfdv 08% 6>00% ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q gltoh jtcexs lo xzl altoxq; @qq`tex lo ` ^lecad

Lggcadv% co wcle`xclo lg H/A/ Alhd 66)8>4"f#= `oh Icqhdid`olv Qdrt`e @ftqd% co wcle`xclo lg

H/A/ Alhd 66)1>>7/ "V/0>#/ Flxb altoxq `vlqd ltx lg xbd q`id Ktod : coachdox% ftx xbd

jlwdvoidox hch olx ab`vjd xbd qdaloh altox toxce xbd h`s lg ]Hdgdoh`oxY xvc`e glv xbd gcvqx

lggdoqd% zbcab z`q ab`vjdh co xbd cocxc`e coglvi`xclo gcedh gltv iloxbq d`vecdv/ "V/0% V/2#/

Xbd dwchdoad `hhtadh `x xvc`e z`q icoci`e/ ]Ali~e`co`oxY `oh ]Hdgdoh`oxY zdvd xbd loes

zcxodqqdq/ ]Ali~e`co`oxY xdqxcgcdh xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY jv`ffdh ]bdvY w`jco`e `vd` `q qbd

qt~dvwcqdh xbd hcqxvcftxclo lg coi`xdq id`eq% `oh xb`x qbd vd`axdh fs qxvcmcoj bci zcxb `

aec~fl`vh/ "Xv/6;3% 16#/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY `aaltox hcvdaxes aloxv`hcaxdh ]Ali~e`co`oxYq/ Bd xdqxcgcdh

xb`x ]Ali~e`co`oxY z`q tqbdvcoj bci f`am coxl bcq adee `oh xb`x bd z`q qx`eecoj% zbcab a`tqdh

bdv xl elqd bdv xdi~dv `oh qxvcmd bci/ "Xv/6;47)4:#/ Bd q`ch ]Ali~e`co`oxYq `aatq`xclo z`q `

~lqx bla g`fvca`xclo aloxvcwdh xl `wlch ~vlgdqqclo`e q`oaxcloq glv `o `qq`tex lo `o coi`xd xb`x

wcle`xdh ~vcqlo vtedq/ "Xv/6; :>):0#/ Qtvwdcee`oad wchdl a`~xtvdh xbd coachdox% ftx xbd kthjd gltoh

xbd gllx`jd coaloaetqcwd `oh f`qdh bcq wdvhcax doxcvdes lo ` gcohcoj xb`x ]Ali~e`co`oxY z`q

avdhcfed `oh ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q olx "Xv/6;:6#/

]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q qdoxdoadh xl 02> h`sq coa`vadv`xclo lo d`ab altox% xdviq xl vto

aloatvvdoxes/ "V/0>#/

Bd gcedh ` xcides Olxcad lg @~~d`e lo Laxlfdv 0:% 6>00/ "V/00#/

0Xbdvd `vd xzl xv`oqavc~xq co xbd vdalvh/ Xbd gcvqx xv`oqavc~x "hdolxdh `q Xv/0# idilvc`ec{dq `o

Laxlfdv 08% 6>00 ~vd)xvc`e bd`vcoj/ Xbd qdaloh "Xv/6/# idilvc`ec{dq xvc`e ~vladdhcojq bdeh

e`xdv xb`x q`id h`s/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

6/34

) 4 )

QX@XDIDX LG XBD G@AXQ

C/ XBD JLWDVIDXQ AB@VJDQLo Ktod 08% 6>00% ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q ab`vjdh fs avcico`e coglvi`xclo zcxb Altox C%

@qq`tex lo ` ^lecad Lggcadv "V/0#/ Xbd `qq`tex z`q `eedjdh xl b`wd laatvvdh lo Ktod :% 6>00% lod

zddm fdglvd ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q `vvdqxdh `oh ab`vjdh/ "Ch/#

Lo Laxlfdv 06% 6>00 ktqx xzl h`sq fdglvd ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q qabdhtedh xl jl xl xvc`e lo

Altox C xbd jlwdvoidox gcedh ` Olxcad lg Coxdox xl Gced ` Qt~dvqdhcoj Coglvi`xclo `hhcoj lod

altox lg Icqhdid`olv Qdrt`e @ftqd xl bcq ali~e`cox/ "V/:#/ Xbd `idohidox z`q olx f`qdh lo

odzes `aptcvdh dwchdoad= xbd jlwdvoidox qci~es qx`xdh xb`x cx b`h a`tqd xl fdecdwd xb`x xbd

odzes ab`vjdh lggdoqd b`h `eql fddo aliicxxdh/ "Ch/#

Xbd qt~dvqdhcoj coglvi`xclo z`q gcedh lo Laxlfdv 08% 6>00% xbd h`s lg ]Hdgdoh`oxY xvc`e/

"V/2#/

CC/ ^VD)XVC@E HCQALWDVS @H FDE@XDH HCQAELQTVDQXbd hcqalwdvs ~`am`jd xb`x xbd jlwdvoidox cocxc`ees ~vlhtadh z`q xbco% ql hdgdoqd

altoqde gcedh ` ali~vdbdoqcwd Vlqqdv edqqdv vdptdqxcoj `hhcxclo`e i`xdvc`eq lo Qd~xdifdv 7%

6>00/ "V/7#/ Xbd edxxdv gcedh ilvd xb`o lod iloxb fdglvd xvc`e `qmdh glv ` fvl`h v`ojd lg

i`xdvc`eq/ "Ch/# Cx q~dacgca`ees vdptdqxdh vdalvhq vde`xcoj xl Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq

hcqac~eco`vs ~vladdhcojq xb`x zdvd ~vdhca`xdh lo xbd q`id alohtax xb`x j`wd vcqd xl ]Hdgdoh`oxY

avcico`e ab`vjdq `oh xb`x vdqtexdh co bcq drlodv`xclo/6

Xbd jlwdvoidox odwdv ~vlhtadh xbd

Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq bd`vcoj vdalvhq% `oh xbd altvx hch olx `qm xbd ~vlqdatxclo zbs xbds

6Xbd edxxdv qx`xdh; C b`wd fddo `hwcqdh xb`x `o @hicocqxv`xcwd Bd`vcoj z`q bdeh aloadvocoj xbd

dwdoxq xb`x ali~vcqd xbd g`axt`e ~vdhca`xd glv xbd `flwd)a`~xclodh a`qd/ C q~dacgca`ees vdptdqx `

hcecjdox cowdqxcj`xclo lg% qd`vab glv% Kdomq ]qcaY `oh Fv`hs i`xdvc`e qxdiicoj gvli xbcq Bd`vcoj/

"C zlteh olxd xb`x xbd gcohcoj lg xbd @hicocqxv`xcwd Xvcfto`e z`q vdwdvqdh lo `hicocqxv`xcwd`~~d`e lo lv `fltx Ktod 66% 6>00#/ "Ch/#

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

7/34

) 7 )

b`h g`cedh xl hl ql/ Xbd ~vlqdatxclo `eql cjolvdh lxbdv vdptdqxq co xbd Vlqqdv edxxdv% zbcab `qmdh

xbdi xl alohtax ` hcecjdox dr`ico`xclo lg xbd ~dvqloode gcedq lg e`z doglvadidox `oh

jlwdvoidox `jdoxq `oh xtvo lwdv% coxdv `ec`; `os qx`xdidoxq fs xbd hdgdoh`ox coxdohdh xl fd

lggdvdh coxl dwchdoad= `ee Fv`hs i`xdvc`e= `os dwchdoad xdohcoj xl ci~d`ab jlwdvoidox

zcxodqqdq= `oh xbd o`idq lg `os zcxodqqdq g`wlv`fed xl xbd `aatqdh "Ch/#

Lo Laxlfdv :% 6>00 lod zddm fdglvd xvc`e `oh lod iloxb `gxdv xbd jlwdvoidox vdadcwdh

Hdgdoh`oxq Vlqqdv edxxdv xbd ~vlqdatxlv qdox `o d)i`ce hcqaelqcoj advx`co qx`xdidoxq ]xb`xY

zdvd i`hd fs Iv/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY xl xbd ali~e`cocoj zcxodqq "Xv/6;83#/ Xbd fde`xdhes)

hcqaelqdh qx`xdidoxq% zbcab xbd jlwdvoidox coxdohdh xl coxvlhtad `x xvc`e% cowlewdh ` xbvd`x

]Hdgdoh`oxY `eedjdhes i`hd xl ]Ali~e`co`oxY `fltx ` iloxb fdglvd xbd `qq`tex lo Ktod :/ "Ch/#

Q~dacgca`ees% ]Ali~e`co`oxY ~vl~lqdh xl xdqxcgs xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY xleh bdv bd coxdohdh xl jv`f bdv

~tqqs lod iloxb fdglvd `eedjdhes i`mcoj jllh lo xb`x ~vlicqd/ "Xv/6;4>#/

]Ali~e`co`oxY odwdv vd~lvxdh xbd xbvd`x% `oh xbd jlwdvoidox odwdv dr~e`codh `oh

z`q odwdv `qmdh xl dr~e`co zbs ]Hdgdoh`oxY qx`xdidox z`q olx hcqaelqdh toxce ` zddm fdglvd

xvc`e/

@q hcqatqqdh ilvd gtees fdelz% xbd jlwdvoidoxq aed`v `ci co qddmcoj xl coxvlhtad xbd

qx`xdidox z`q xl fleqxdv xbd Icqhdid`olv Qdrt`e @ftqd ab`vjd/ Xl alowcax ` hdgdoh`ox lg xb`x

lggdoqd xbd jlwdvoidox itqx qblz ` q~dacgca coxdox xl `ftqd% bticec`xd% b`v`qq% hdjv`hd% `vltqd

lv jv`xcgs xbd qdrt`e hdqcvd lg `os ~dvqlo/ Itojl w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% ::6 @/6h 68>% 684 "H/A/

6>>0#/ Xbd ~vlqdatxlv zlteh `vjtd xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY xbvd`x xl jv`f ]]Ali~e`co`oxYqY ~tqqs

~vlwdh bd ~lqqdqqdh qtab coxdox/1

@q `eql hcqatqqdh fdelz% ]Hdgdoh`oxY hdocdh i`mcoj xbd

1Xbd ~vlqdatxlvq aelqcoj `vjtidox coaethdh xbd gleelzcoj; Zcxb vdj`vhq xl xbd qx`xdidoxq xb`x

xbd hdgdoh`ox i`hd xl ]]Ali~e`co`oxYY lo qlid ~dvclh lg xcid qdwdv`e zddmq fdglvd xbd coachdoxlaatvvdh% xbd jlwdvoidox qtficxq xb`x xb`x qxvlojes qblzq xbd hdgdoh`oxq coxdox zbdo bd

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

8/34

) : )

xbvd`x% `oh lod lg bcq aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq z`q f`qdh lo xbd jlwdvoidoxq g`cetvd xl ~vlhtad

Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq ~lecacdq `oh xv`cocoj i`ot`eq xb`x zlteh ci~d`ab ]Ali~e`co`oxYq

ae`ci xb`x bd i`hd cx fs qblzcoj xb`x `jdoas ~lecas vdptcvdh xbd vd~lvxcoj lg qtab xbvd`xq/ " Qdd

cogv`% ~~/ 3)06#/

CCC/ ^VD)XVC@E BD@VCJ @H ALXCT@AD VTECJQ]Hdgdoh`oxY a`qd z`q cocxc`ees `qqcjodh xl Kthjd ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY% ftx qbd xv`oqgdvvdh xbd

xvc`e xl ]Xvc`e KthjdY fda`tqd qbd z`q aloadvodh cx zlteh olx aloaethd co xcid glv bdv xl `xxdoh `

kthcac`e cowdqxcxtvd advdilos qabdhtedh glv 1;1> xb`x `gxdvollo/ "Xv/0;7#/ ]Xvc`e KthjdY `eql

dr~vdqqdh ` hdqcvd xl `xxdoh xbd cowdqxcxtvd advdilos% ftx bd q`ch bcq ~vci`vs jl`e cq xl

ali~edxd xbcq xvc`e% slt molz% g`cves/ "Xv/6;8#/

]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY aloqchdvdh ` otifdv lg cqqtdq fdglvd xv`oqgdvvcoj xbd a`qd% coaethcoj

]Hdgdoh`oxY itexc~ed aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq/

@/GCVQX ALXCT@AD VTECJHdgdoh`oxq gcvqx aloxcot`oad vdptdqx vde`xdh xl xbd jlwdvoidoxq gcecoj lg ` ilvocoj)lg)

xbd)xvc`e qt~dvqdhcoj coglvi`xclo ab`vjcoj bci zcxb Icqhdid`olv Qdr @ftqd/ "Xv/0;6)1#/

Hdgdoqd altoqde q`ch bd hch olx b`wd `hdpt`xd xcid xl hcqatqq xbd odz ab`vjd zcxb bcq aecdox `oh

z`q olx ptcxd qtvd zb`x is hdgdoqd zlteh fd co xbd odz qcxt`xclo/ "Ch/# Xbd jlwdvoidox i`hd

ol `xxdi~x `oh z`q olx `qmdh fs xbd altvx xl dr~e`co xbd g`cetvd xl coaethd xbd odz altox co

xbd lvcjco`e coglvi`xclo gcedh gltv iloxbq d`vecdv/ "Xv/0;6)4#/

]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY hdocdh xbd vdptdqx glv ` aloxcot`oad% qx`xcoj;

Cxq ktqx ` odz ab`vjd% ftx xbd g`axq `vd xbd q`id `oh C hlox qdd `os f`qcq glv jv`oxcoj `aloxcot`oad Xbcq a`qd cq vd`hs olz/ Cx alqxq x`r~`sdvq ilods xl jdx xbcq a`qd vd`hs%

ql Ci olx coaecodh xl jv`ox xbd aloxcot`oad/ Edx id ktqx i`md xbd vdalvh/

`axt`ees aliicxxdh xbd coachdox lo xbd h`s lg Ktod :% 6>00% xb`x bd z`q dcxbdv `xxdi~xcoj xlbticec`xd Iq/ ]Ali~e`co`oxY lv bd z`q `xxdi~xcoj xl jv`xcgs bcq lzo qdrt`e hdqcvdq/ "Xv/6;78#/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

9/34

) 2 )

"Xv/0;4% 08#/

F/QDALH ALXCT@AD VTECJ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY `eql hdocdh ` vdptdqx xl `eelz hdgdoqd altoqde xl zcxbhv`z/ "Xv/0;:% 01)

08#/ Hdgdoqd altoqde qltjbx xl zcxbhv`z glv xzl vd`qloq; gcvqx% fda`tqd bd hch olx gdde ~vd~`vdh

xl hdgdoh xbd a`qd= `oh qdaloh% fda`tqd bcq aecdox z`q hcqq`xcqgcdh zcxb bcq ~dvglvi`oad% zbcab

i`hd altoqde ptd`qs `fltx aloxcotcoj xbd vd~vdqdox`xclo cg Iv/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY vd`ees hldqox

z`ox id/ "Xv/0;01)08#/

]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY alohtaxdh ` Ilovld)G`vvdee coptcvs `oh doj`jdh co ` aleelpts zcxb

]Hdgdoh`oxY xl dr`icod xbd vd`qloq glv bcq hcqq`xcqg`axclo/ "Xv/0;:)08#/ @qmdh cg bd z`q b`~~s

zcxb bcq e`zsdvq vd~vdqdox`xclo% ]Hdgdoh`oxY vd~ecdh; Qcrxs,glvxs `oh q`ch bd hch olx z`ox

altoqde xl aloxcotd vd~vdqdoxcoj bci "Xv/0;:#/ @qmdh xl `vxcate`xd xbd vd`qloq glv bcq

hcqq`xcqg`axclo% ]Hdgdoh`oxY q`ch xb`x bcq ~vci`vs aloadvo z`q xb`x altoqde g`cedh xl lfx`co

avcxca`e hcqalwdvs xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY xleh bci xl ~vlatvd/ "Xv/0;:)01#/

]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q ilqx hcqxtvfdh fs altoqdeq g`cetvd xl xcides lfx`co vdalvhq gvli xbd

Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq `hicocqxv`xcwd ~vladdhcojq xb`x drlodv`xdh ]Hdgdoh`oxY/ "Xv/0;0>#/

Altoqde dr~e`codh xb`x xbd jlwdvoidox b`h olx vdq~lohdh xl bcq vdptdqx glv xbd i`xdvc`eq `oh

xb`x bd xbdo xvcdh toqtaadqqgtees xl lfx`co xbdi gvli ^HQHA% zbdvd xbd i`xxdv b`h fddo

`qqcjodh xl ` e`z qxthdox zbl z`q ol elojdv zcxb ^HQHA/ "Xv/0;00#/ Altoqde q`ch xb`x

]Hdgdoh`oxY b`h lfx`codh qlid lg xbd `hicocqxv`xcwd vdalvhq xbvltjb bcq lzo dgglvxq `oh b`h

jcwdo xbdi xl bci vcjbx fdglvd xbd bd`vcoj fdj`o/ "Ch/#8 ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY hch olx `qm xbd

8Fda`tqd xbd jlwdvoidox odwdv ~vlhtadh xbd hcqac~eco`vs bd`vcoj vdalvhq co hcqalwdvs%

]Hdgdoh`oxY a`oolx fd advx`co xb`x zb`x bd lfx`codh xbvltjb bcq lzo dgglvxq coaethdh `ee lg xbdhlatidoxq ~dvx`cocoj xl xbd `hicocqxv`xcwd ~vladdhcojq/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

10/34

) 3 )

jlwdvoidox zbs xbd vdalvhq b`h fddo zcxbbdeh/ Qbd `~~d`vdh q`xcqgcdh xb`x hdgdoqd altoqde olz

~lqqdqqdh xbdi xbvltjb bcq aecdoxq dgglvxq/ "Ch/#

@gxdv bd`vcoj `ee lg ]Hdgdoh`oxY aloadvoq `fltx bcq `xxlvodsq ~dvglvi`oad% ]^vd)xvc`e

KthjdY `qmdh altoqde cg bd gdex ~vd~`vdh xl hdgdoh ]Hdgdoh`oxY/ "Ch/# Bd `j`co q`ch xb`x bd hch

olx/ "Xv/0;01% 08#/ ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY odwdvxbdedqq hdocdh xbd aloxcot`oad% acxcoj bdv fdecdg xb`x

]Hdgdoh`oxY vdptdqx xl hcqicqq bcq `xxlvods z`q ` hde`s x`axca `cidh `x ~vlelojcoj i`xxdvq ql

xb`x bd alteh qddm xl b`wd xbd a`qd hcqicqqdh/ "Xv/0;08#/ Qbd q`ch; Cx alqxq x`r~`sdvq ilods xl

jdx xbcq a`qd vd`hs% ql Ci olx coaecodh xl jv`ox xbd aloxcot`oad/ Edx id ktqx i`md xbd vdalvh/

"Ch/#

A/XBCVH ALXCT@AD VTECJ]Hdgdoh`oxY `eql vdptdqxdh ` aloxcot`oad xl ela`xd `oh ~vlatvd xbd xdqxcilos lg ` avcxca`e

~lxdoxc`e g`ax zcxodqq ` glvidv adeei`xd zblqd o`id ]Hdgdoh`oxY hch olx molz/ "Xv/0;04)03#/

Xbd jlwdvoidox l~~lqdh lo xzl jvltohq/ Gcvqx% xbd ~vlqdatxlv q`ch hdgdoqd altoqde b`h

`i~ed xcid xl chdoxcgs xbcq zcxodqq "Xv/0;60#/ Qdaloh% xbd ~vlqdatxlv q`ch xbd `exdva`xclo z`q

a`~xtvdh lo wchdl% `oh ]xYl xbd drxdox xbd adeei`xd z`q co xbd adee% is tohdvqx`ohcoj lg xbd g`axq

cq xb`x bcq wcdz ]lg xbd coachdoxY zlteh b`wd fddo felamdh/ "Xv/0;07#/

@gxdv x`mcoj ` fvcdg vdadqq xl wcdz xbd qtvwdcee`oad gllx`jd% hdgdoqd altoqde hcq~txdh xbd

jlwdvoidoxq ae`ci xb`x xbd ~lxdoxc`e zcxodqqq wcdz lg xbd `exdva`xclo z`q lfqxvtaxdh/ "Xv/0;6>#/

Altoqde q`ch ` aloxcot`oad z`q oddhdh xl cowdqxcj`xd gtvxbdv zbdxbdv ]xbd zcxodqqY z`q `fed xl

qdd zb`x b`~~dodh/ "Ch/# ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY zbl hch olx wcdz xbd wchdl fdglvd vtecoj hdocdh

xbd aloxcot`oad% blehcoj xb`x xbd coachdox zlteh olx b`wd fddo wcqcfed xl xbd ~lxdoxc`e zcxodqq

`oh xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY ~vlggdv vdj`vhcoj xbd ~vlf`xcwd w`etd lg bcq xdqxcilos z`q xll vdilxd `oh

q~date`xcwd/ "Xv/0;60#/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

11/34

) 0> )

H/GLTVXB ALXCT@AD VTECJ]Hdgdoh`oxY `eql vdptdqxdh ` aloxcot`oad xl lfx`co Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq ~lecacdq

`oh xv`cocoj i`ot`eq xb`x b`h fddo vdptdqxdh co hcqalwdvs ftx odwdv ~vlhtadh/ "Xv/0;64)67#/

]Hdgdoh`oxY q`ch xbd i`xdvc`eq zlteh qblz xb`x `jdoas ~lecacdq vdptcvdh di~elsddq xl vd~lvx

coi`xd xbvd`xq/ "Ch/# @aalvhcojes% xbds zdvd avcxca`e xl ci~d`abcoj ]Ali~e`co`oxY% zbl ~vl~lqdh

xl xdqxcgs xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY xbvd`xdodh xl jv`f bdv ~tqqs ` iloxb fdglvd xbd `qq`tex ` xbvd`x

xb`x z`q odwdv vd~lvxdh/ "Ch/#

]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY vtedh `j`coqx ]Hdgdoh`oxY% q`scoj `j`co xb`x qbd fdecdwdh bcq aloxcot`oad

vdptdqx z`q ` hde`s x`axca/ "Xv/0;67#/ Blzdwdv% qbd hch olx doxcvdes hcqaltox xbd ~lxdoxc`e

vdedw`oad lg xbd zcxbbdeh hlatidoxq/ Co ecdt lg ` aloxcot`oad qbd coqxvtaxdh hdgdoqd altoqde xl

xv`am hlzo xbd i`xdvc`eq htvcoj xbd etoab vdadqq% `oh qbd xleh xbd ~vlqdatxlv xl `qqcqx xbd

hdgdoqd co jdxxcoj zb`xdwdv vdjte`xcloq xbdvd `vd `x xbd k`ce xb`x bd icjbx z`ox xl tqd xl avlqq)

dr`icod sltv zcxodqq/ "Xv/0;67)6:#/ @q hcqatqqdh fdelz% hdgdoqd altoqde z`q to`fed xl lfx`co

xbd i`xdvc`eq htvcoj xbd etoab vdadqq% `oh ]Hdgdoh`oxY zlteh toqtaadqqgtees vdodz bcq

aloxcot`oad vdptdqx htvcoj xbd avlqq)dr`ico`xclo lg ]Ali~e`co`oxY `x xvc`e/ "Xv/6;8:)40#/

]Hdgdoh`oxY gtvxbdv ae`cidh xb`x ~vcqlo lggcac`eq v`chdh bcq adee `oh alogcqa`xdh ~vcqlo

vdalvhq bd j`xbdvdh xl ~vlwd bd z`q olx bltqdh co ]Ali~e`co`oxYq tocx zbdo xbd `eedjdh xbvd`x

z`q i`hd/ "Xv/0;06% 68)67#/ ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY a`eedh xbd ~vcqlo `oh `qmdh `o lggcac`e xl abdam

]Hdgdoh`oxY bltqcoj vdalvhq `oh vde`s xb`x coglvi`xclo xl Kthjd ]Xvc`e KthjdY% zbl zlteh x`md

kthcac`e olxcad lg zb`x bd z`q xleh/ "Xv/0;67)6:#/ @ ~vcqlo lggcac`e ali~ecdh `oh e`xdv a`eedh

ab`ifdvq zcxb alogcvi`xclo lg ]Hdgdoh`oxY ae`ci; bd z`q olx ~e`adh co ]Ali~e`co`oxYq tocx

toxce I`s 67% 6>00 xzl zddmq `gxdv qbd ae`cidh bd xbvd`xdodh bdv/ "Xv/6;6>#/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

12/34

) 00 )

]Ali~e`co`oxY zlteh xbdo xdqxcgs xb`x qbd hch olx molz zbdo xbd xbvd`x z`q i`hd ftx cg

qbd b`h xl jtdqq qbd zlteh q`s cx b`~~dodh ~vlf`fes `fltx xzl zddmq fdglvd xbd `qq`tex olx

lod iloxb fdglvd% `q qbd cocxc`ees aloxdohdh/ "Xv/6;01#/ ]Ali~e`co`oxY `eql q`ch qbd z`q toqtvd

zbdvd xbd xbvd`x z`q i`hd% qx`xcoj; C xbcom xb`x cx z`q ecmd co xbd hcocoj `vd`/ "Ch/#

D/VDDZDH ALXCT@AD VTECJ@x xvc`e% ]Hdgdoh`oxY vdodzdh bcq vdptdqx glv ` aloxcot`oad xl lfx`co xbd Hd~`vxidox lg

Alvvdaxcloq ~dvqloode gcedq `oh xv`cocoj i`xdvc`eq/ "Xv/6;83#/ ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY b`h coqxvtaxdh

hdgdoqd altoqde xl xv`am hlzo xbd hlatidoxq lwdv bcq etoab fvd`m `oh qbd `qmdh xbd

~vlqdatxlv xl bde~ bci hl ql/ "Xv/0;67)6:#/ Altoqde b`h fddo to`fed xl lfx`co xbd hlatidoxq%

blzdwdv% `oh bd xbtq vdodzdh xbd ilxclo htvcoj bcq avlqq)dr`ico`xclo lg ]Ali~e`co`oxY/

"Xv/6;83#/

]Ali~e`co`oxY b`h xdqxcgcdh xb`x qbd hch olx vd~lvx ]Hdgdoh`oxY xbvd`x xl jv`f bdv ~tqqs

fda`tqd `q ` gdi`ed lggcadv% slt bd`v xbcq 4> xcidq ` h`s/ "Xv/6;86#/ Altoqde `qmdh bdv

zbdxbdv `jdoas jtchdecodq odwdvxbdedqq vdptcvdh xbd vd~lvxcoj lg qtab xbvd`xq% `oh ]Ali~e`co`oxY

di~b`xca`ees qx`xdh xb`x xbds hch olx/ Ol/ Ol% qcv/ Ol% qcv/ Xbdvd cq olzbdvd co xbd vtedfllm

xb`x q`sq xb`x/ Cg bd xbvd`xdoq xl q`s xb`x bd jlcoj xl mcee id lv qlidxbcoj ecmd xb`x% xbdo cxq

hcggdvdox/ "Xv/6;86)81#/

Altoqde xbdo qx`xdh xb`x bd oddhdh xbd `jdoas vdjte`xcloq xl avlqq)dr`icod

]Ali~e`co`oxY/ "Ch/# Bd `qmdh ]Xvc`e KthjdY xl a`ee ~vcqlo lggcac`eq% q`scoj xb`x cx z`q bcq

tohdvqx`ohcoj xb`x ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY b`h `qmdh Hv/ Fv`ohx xl ela`xd xbd vdjte`xcloq `oh alox`ax

xbd altvx% zbcab zlteh xbdo x`md kthcac`e olxcad lg Hv/ Fv`ohxq vd~vdqdox`xcloq vdj`vhcoj xbd

qtfqx`oad lg xbd ~lecacdq/ "Xv/6;81% 82#/ Xbd jlwdvoidox l~~lqdh% q`scoj% Iv/ ]Hdgdoqd

AltoqdeY b`q b`h `hdpt`xd xcid xl vdqd`vab xbcq/ Zd b`h ` etoab fvd`m xl ellm coxl cx/ "Xv/6;81#

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

13/34

) 06 )

]Xvc`e KthjdY d)i`cedh ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY xl hdxdvicod zb`x tohdvqx`ohcoj b`h fddo

vd`abdh vdj`vhcoj Hv/ Fv`ohxq `qqcqx`oad co ela`xcoj xbd `jdoas vdjte`xcloq/ "Xv/6;82#/ ]^vd)xvc`e

KthjdY vd~ecdh xb`x qbd loes `qmdh Hv/ Fv`ohx xl ela`xd ]Hdgdoh`oxY bltqcoj vdalvhq= `q glv xbd

`jdoas i`xdvc`eq% ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY q`ch qbd `qmdh xbd @TQ@ xl gcoh `os vdjte`xcloq lv

~dvqloode ~vladhtvdq xb`x icjbx vdptcvd xbd vd~lvxcoj lg coachdoxq/ "Ch/# Hdgdoqd altoqde

~vlxdqxdh xb`x xbd ~vlqdatxlv b`h olx hlod xb`x/ Xbd ~vlqdatxlv qci~es j`wd hdgdoqd altoqde xbd

~blod otifdv lg ` Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq e`zsdv% `oh bd xbtq hch olx ali~es zcxb Kthjd

]^vd)xvc`e KthjdYq coqxvtaxclo xl bde~ bci ~vlatvd xbd i`xdvc`eq/ "Ch/#/ Hdgdoqd altoqde gtvxbdv

`vjtdh xb`x xbd glvxs)gcwd icotxdq bd z`q jcwdo xl ela`xd xbd gcedq z`q coqtggcacdox% `oh xb`x

]Ali~e`co`oxYq xdqxcilos `fltx ]Hdgdoh`oxY xbvd`x zbcab odadqqcx`xdh xbd i`xdvc`eq glv

avlqq)dr`ico`xclo b`h loes fddo hcqaelqdh lod zddm fdglvd xvc`e/ "Xv/6;83#/

]Xvc`e KthjdY hdocdh xbd vdodzdh vdptdqx% q`scoj bd hch olx xbcom xbd Hd~`vxidox lg

Alvvdaxcloq gcedq zdvd qcjocgca`ox/ "Xv/6;4>#/ ]Xvc`e KthjdY vdkdaxdh xbd `vjtidox xb`x xbd

i`xdvc`eq ci~d`abdh ]Ali~e`co`oxYq avdhcfcecxs% qx`xcoj;

Gv`omes% C avdhcx zcxbltx `os vd`qlo olx xl fdecdwd cx% Qdvjd`ox ]Ali~e`co`oxYq xdqxcilos

xb`x qbd jdxq lggdoqcwd qx`xdidoxq lg ` qdrt`e o`xtvd gvli coi`xdq 4> xcidq ` h`s `oh xb`x

qbd i`mdq ` hdacqclo `fltx zbdxbdv xbds `vd qdvcltq lv olx `oh `fltx zbdxbdv xl vd~lvx

xbdi/ C gcoh xb`x avdhcfed/ Dwdo cg xbdvd zdvd qlid xdaboca`e wcle`xcloq lg Hd~`vxidox lgAlvvdaxcloq ~vladhtvdq% C hlox xbcom xb`x xb`x zlteh fd qcjocgca`ox xl is `qqdqqidox lg

bdv avdhcfcecxs/ Ftx C tohdvqx`oh xb`x Kthjd Vdxaco hd`ex zcxb vdptdqxq xl ~lqx~lod xbd

xvc`e/ Qbd hdachdh xb`x zd qblteh ~vladdh/ Xb`xq zb`x zd `vd hlcoj/ Hldq xbd hdgdoqdcoxdoh xl a`ee lv ~vdqdox `os zcxodqqdq "H/A/

03:2#= `aalvh% G`vvdee w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 130 @/6h :44% :7>):76 "H/A/ 03:2#/ Xbd vdptcvdidox lg

qtab coptcvcdq coxl ~vd)xvc`e codggdaxcwdodqq ae`ciq olz molzo `q Ilovld)G`vvdee coptcvcdq

b`q fddo vd`ggcvidh lo otidvltq laa`qcloq/

:

Ilovld)G`vvdee coptcvcdq `ci xl ~vdwdox Qcrxb @idohidox hd~vcw`xcloq fs hdxdvicocoj

zbdxbdv altoqde b`q aloqtexdh zcxb xbd hdgdoh`ox `oh ~vd~`vdh bcq a`qd co ` ~vl~dv i`oodv/

Ilovld% 123 @/6h `x 203/2

Xbcq Altvx b`q olx dqx`fecqbdh xbd ~vdacqd glvi zbcab xbd vdptcqcxd

coptcvs itqx x`md% blehcoj coqxd`h xb`x qtfqx`oad `oh qal~d lg xbd coptcvs cq aliicxxdh xl

xbd qltoh hcqavdxclo lg xbd xvc`e altvx/ G`vvdee% 130 @/6h `x :7>/ @aalvhcojes% xbd hdacqclo

fdelz a`o fd vdwdvqdh lv vdi`ohdh cg xbcq Altvx gcohq `o `ftqd lg hcqavdxclo co xbd glvi%

qtfqx`oad `oh qal~d lg xbd ]Ilovld)G`vvdeeY coptcvs/ Zcoj`xd% 773 @/6h `x 0628/

F/ ILVLD)G@VVDEE CPTCVCDQHdxdvicocoj zbdxbdv ` xvc`e altvx b`q `ftqdh cxq hcqavdxclo co cowdqxcj`xcoj ~vd)xvc`e

codggdaxcwdodqq `eedj`xcloq cq ` a`qd)q~dacgca dohd`wlv% `q xbd ~vdacqd qal~d lg xbd coptcvs

:Qdd% d/j/% IaG`hhdo w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 708 @/6h 00 "H/A/0336#= Zcoj`xd w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 773

@/6h 06:4 "H/A/0334#= Iceeq w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% :37 @/6h 67 "H/A/ 6>>6#/

2Xbd altvx bdeh xb`x ~vd)xvc`e `eedj`xcloq lg ]coYdggdaxcwd `qqcqx`oad `x xvc`e htd xl e`am lg

~vd~`v`xclo vcqd xl xbd edwde lg ` ae`ci lg ` Qcrxb @idohidox hd~vcw`xclo% `oh xb`x co qtab

qcxt`xcloq cx cq coatifdox t~lo xbd xvc`e altvx xl hdxdvicod xbd w`echcxs lg xbd `qqdvxcloq `oh xlx`md zb`xdwdv altvqd lg `axclo cq xbdvdfs i`oh`xdh/ Ch/ `x 26>/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

19/34

) 02 )

tohdvx`mdo cq odadqq`vces hd~dohdox t~lo xbd acvatiqx`oadq ~vdqdoxdh co d`ab cohcwcht`e a`qd/

Ilovld% 123 @/6h `x 26>/ Advx`co jtchdecodq b`wd fddo `vxcate`xdh% blzdwdv/

Xbcq Altvx b`q bdeh% glv coqx`oad% xb`x ` vltxcod coptcvs xbd `qmcoj lg qdwdv`e qx`oh`vh

ptdqxcloq zcee fd coqtggcacdox% G`vvdee% 130 @/6h `x :70)76% `oh xb`x ` ~vl~dv coptcvs itqx fd

qtcx`fes hdx`cedh xl `eelz xbd altvx xl hdxdvicod `x xbd xcid lg xbd hdgdoh`oxq ali~e`cox xbd

xvtxb `oh qal~d lg bcq `eedj`xcloq/ I`xxbdzq w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 843 @/6h 0>71% 0>74 "H/A/ 0321#/

Lo xbd lxbdv b`oh% ` xvc`e altvx oddh olx `xxdi~x xl dr`icod dwdvs aloadcw`fed hdgcacdoas co xbd

vd~vdqdox`xclo/ Glvxd w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 247 @/6h 47:% 4:8 "H/A/ 6>>8#/

Xbd xvc`e altvx itqx% blzdwdv% i`md lo)xbd)vdalvh gcohcojq qtggcacdox xl ~dvicx

id`ocojgte `~~dee`xd vdwcdz lo xbd cqqtd lg xbd `fcecxs `oh ~vd~`vdhodqq lg altoqde xl vdohdv

dggdaxcwd `qqcqx`oad tohdv xbd ~vdw`cecoj acvatiqx`oadq/ Gcdehq w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 877 @/6h 266%

268 "H/A/ 0321#/ Cg xbd altvx g`ceq xl i`md `hdpt`xd gcohcojq% xbd a`qd itqx fd vdi`ohdh glv `

~vl~dv coptcvs lv xbd alowcaxclo itqx fd vdwdvqdh/ Qdd I`xxbdzq% 843 @/6h `x 0>74)77/

Vdwdvq`e% v`xbdv xb`o vdi`oh% cq vdptcvdh cg xbdvd cq lfwcltq ~vdkthcad lv zbdo xbd xvc`e

altvxq aloaetqcloq `vd toqt~~lvxdh fs xbd ~vd)xvc`e vdalvh/ IaG`hhdo% 708 @/6h `x 02/ Altvxq

qblteh `eql dvv% cg `x `ee% lo xbd qchd lg vdwdvq`e% v`xbdv xb`o vdi`oh% co lvhdv xl ~vlwchd

coadoxcwdq glv xblvltjb ~vd)xvc`e Ilovld)G`vvdee coptcvcdq `oh xl `wlch ~vlelojcoj `~~d`eq/ Ch/

Hdgdoh`ox `vjtdq xb`x xbd Ilovld)G`vvdee bd`vcoj co xbd coqx`ox a`qd z`q coqtggcacdox/ Xbd

elzdv altvxq cowdqxcj`xclo lg ]Hdgdoh`oxY codggdaxcwdodqq `eedj`xclo z`q ~dvgtoaxlvs/ Xbd

altvxq ptdqxcloq zdvd vltxcod `oh hch olx dr~elvd xbd qtfqx`oad lg bcq ali~e`coxq% `oh cxq

gcohcojq zdvd olx qtggcacdoxes `vxcate`xdh lo xbd vdalvh/ Ilvdlwdv% xbd ~vl~dv vdidhs cq vdwdvq`e

v`xbdv xb`o vdi`oh fda`tqd xbd altvxq aloaetqcloq zdvd toqt~~lvxdh fs xbd vdalvh `oh

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

20/34

) 03 )

fda`tqd lfwcltq ~vdkthcad vdqtexdh zbdo ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q glvadh xl jl xl xvc`e zcxb `o `xxlvods

zbl z`q to~vd~`vdh xl hdgdoh bci/

A/ @HHCXCL@E G@AXT@E F@AMJVLTHXbd xvc`e altvxq Ilovld)G`vvdee coptcvs z`q ~vli~xdh fs hdgdoqd altoqde ]Hdgdoqd

AltoqdeY/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY coglvidh xbd altvx xb`x bd `oh ]Hdgdoh`oxY b`h ` qcjocgca`ox

hcq`jvddidox% `oh bd `qmdh xbd altvx xl `qm ]Hdgdoh`oxY zbdxbdv bd z`q q`xcqgcdh zcxb bcq

~dvglvi`oad/ "Xv/0;:#/ Xbd gleelzcoj aleelpts doqtdh;

XBD ALTVX; Iv/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY% `vd slt q`xcqgcdh zcxb blz Iv/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY cq

vd~vdqdoxcoj slt co xbcq i`xxdv )

Xbd `oh ~`am`jd cq xbd vcjbx zlvh/ Xbdvd z`q xbcq zb`xq xs~ca`ees a`eedh ` ~`am`jd

lg f`qca i`xdvc`eq/ C xbdo gcedh ` Vlqqdv edxxdv vdptdqxcoj ilvd i`xdvc`e% `hhcxclo`e

i`xdvc`eq xb`x z`q gcedh lo Qd~xdifdv 4/

"Xv/0;2#/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY q`ch xb`x bd vdwcdzdh zb`x xbd jlwdvoidox b`h jcwdo bci zcxb

]Hdgdoh`oxY/ "Ch/# ]Hdgdoh`oxY hdocdh xb`x `qqdvxclo% qx`xcoj; C b`wdox qddo ` hcqalwdvs

~`am`jd/ "Ch/# ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY q`ch bd wcqcxdh bcq aecdox co k`ce lo qcr lv qdwdo laa`qcloq

`oh xbds vdwcdzdh xbd hcqalwdvs htvcoj qlid lg xblqd iddxcojq/ "Ch/# ]Hdgdoh`oxY hcq~txdh xb`x

aloxdoxclo% q`scoj ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY a`id xl qdd id xbvdd lv gltv xcidq `oh xleh id zb`x

~lqqcfes i`s fd lo qlid ~`~dvq/ "Xv/0;3#/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY xbdo q`ch bcq vdalvhq vdgedaxdh `x

ed`qx gcwd k`ce wcqcxq= xbd gltvxb wcqcx xllm ~e`ad ` zddm)`oh)`)b`eg fdglvd xvc`e `oh xbd gcgxb

laatvvdh ` gdz h`sq fdglvd xvc`e% `gxdv xbd jlwdvoidox j`wd olxcad lg xbd qt~dvqdhcoj

coglvi`xclo/ "Ch/#

Xbd xvc`e kthjd xleh ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY qbd `aad~xdh bcq vd~vdqdox`xclo xb`x slt vdwcdzdh

xbd hcqalwdvs i`xdvc`eq zcxb ]]Hdgdoh`oxYY Xbdvdq olx itab hcggdvdoad fdxzddo bcq otifdvq

`oh sltvq/ Cx z`q i`os xcidq xb`x bd zdox xl qdd slt `x xbd k`ce/ "Ch/#

G`cetvd xl ^vlatvd Avcxca`e Dwchdoad/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY xbdo q`ch xb`x ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY

g`cedh xl lfx`co avcxca`e hcqalwdvs i`xdvc`eq xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY coqxvtaxdh bci xl ~vlatvd/ "Ch/# Xbd

hlatidoxq `x cqqtd zdvd xbd vdalvhq lg `o coxdvo`e ~vcqlo hcqac~eco`vs bd`vcoj xb`x `vlqd ltx lg

]Hdgdoh`oxY `eedjdh `qq`tex zbcab `hicocqxv`xcwd ~vladdhcoj vdqtexdh co bcq drlodv`xclo/ "Ch/#

]Hdgdoh`oxY q`ch bd `qmdh ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY xl alox`ax Altvxods Xtamdv% ` ^HQ coxdvo

zbl vd~vdqdoxdh bci `x xbd `hicocqxv`xcwd ~vladdhcoj/ "Ch/# Bd q`ch ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY g`cedh xl

lfx`co xbd hlatidoxq glv lwdv ` iloxb `oh xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY ~vlatvdh xbdi lo bcq lzo `oh

fvltjbx xbdi xl altvx xb`x ilvocoj/ "Xv/0;0>)00#/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY jv`oxdh xb`x bd z`q to`fed

xl vdxvcdwd xbd hlatidoxq gvli Xtamdv% zbl z`q ol elojdv zcxb ^HQ/ "Xv/0;00#/ Xtamdvq glvidv

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

22/34

) 60 )

qt~dvwcqlv j`wd ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY bdv d)i`ce `hhvdqq% `oh bd b`h qt~~lqdhes fddo co alox`ax

zcxb Xtamdv ftx qbd z`q to`fed xl ~tx xljdxbdv bdv lzo ~`~dvzlvm lo xb`x `oh b`hox hlod ql

fdglvd xvc`e/ "Ch/#

XBD ALTVX; Ql Iv/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY hch vdadcwd xbd i`xdvc`e bd b`h z`oxdh slt xl jdx

gvli Iq/ Xtamdv/ Cq xb`x alvvdax

0>Xbd vdalvh cq toaed`v `q xl zbdxbdv ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY b`h% co g`ax% vdptdqxdh ` aloxcot`oad/

Bd z`cwdh ]Hdgdoh`oxY ~vdqdoad `x xbd ltxqdx lg xbd bd`vcoj/ Xbdo% `gxdv xbd jlwdvoidox q`ch

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

23/34

) 66 )

+

Xbd xvc`e kthjd xbdo alogcvidh xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY b`h ol lxbdv ali~e`coxq `oh xbd

gleelzcoj aleelpts zcxb ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY doqtdh;

XBD ALTVX; @ee vcjbx/ Iv/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY% hl slt gdde ~vd~`vdh xl hdgdoh Iv/

]Hdgdoh`oxY co xbcq a`qd71/ Xbd xvc`e

altvxq vltxcod% xlmdo coptcvs ]edgx xbdY kthjd doxcvdes to`z`vd lg xbd g`axq dqqdoxc`e xl `o

coglvidh hdacqclo `q xl hdgdoqd altoqde*q ~vd~`vdhodqq glv xvc`e/ G`vvdee% 130 @/6h `x :70)76

Atvqlvs xvd`xidox z`q jcwdo xl ]Hdgdoh`oxY `eedj`xclo xb`x ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY g`cedh xl

hcecjdoxes doj`jd co ~vdxvc`e hcqalwdvs/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY q~dacgca`ees acxdh ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeYq g`cetvd

xl lfx`co xbd vdalvhq lg xbd ~vcqlo hcqac~eco`vs bd`vcoj gvli Xtamdv% zbl vd~vdqdoxdh

]Hdgdoh`oxY co xbd `hicocqxv`xcwd ~vladdhcoj/ Blzdwdv% xbd altvx z`q q`xcqgcdh xb`x dwdo cg

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

25/34

) 68 )

]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY b`h olx fddo hcecjdox co jdxxcoj xbd i`xdvc`eq gvli Xtamdv% xbd hdgdoqd zlteh

olx fd ~vdkthcadh jlcoj glvz`vh fda`tqd xbd coa`vadv`xdh hdgdoh`ox b`h lfx`codh hlatidoxq

gvli xbd bd`vcoj lo bcq lzo cocxc`xcwd% fvltjbx xbdi xl altvx lo xbd h`s lg xbd xvc`e% `oh xtvodh

xbdi lwdv xl ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY/ "Xv/0;00#/

Cx z`q loes xbvltjb xbd dgglvxq lg bcq aecdox xb`x ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY a`id xl ~lqqdqq% lo

xbd ilvocoj lg xvc`e% xbd vdalvhq xb`x altoqde g`cedh xl qdatvd gvli xbd e`z qxthdox zbl b`ohedh

bcq aecdoxq a`qd co xbd hcqac~eco`vs bd`vcoj/ "Ch/# Xb`x `~~`vdoxes q`xcqgcdh xbd xvc`e kthjd/ Zb`x

i`xxdvdh xl xbd altvx cq xb`x ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY olz b`h xbd i`xdvc`eq `oh b`h vdadcwdh xbdi

fdglvd xbd xvc`e fdj`o/

Xbd kthjd hch olx coptcvd zbdxbdv xbd hlatidoxq ]Hdgdoh`oxY i`o`jdh xl lfx`co

ali~vcqdh dwdvsxbcoj xb`x alteh b`wd fddo ~vlwchdh/ Qbd hch olx aloqchdv zbdxbdv xbdvd z`q

lxbdv i`xdvc`e% drate~`xlvs dwchdoad xb`x Xtamdv% xbd Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq% lv xbd

jlwdvoidox icjbx b`wd ~vlwchdh cg ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY z`q ilvd `jjvdqqcwd co ~tvqtcoj `jdoas

gcedq gvli xblqd qltvadq% v`xbdv xb`o vdescoj lo bcq coa`vadv`xdh aecdox xl hcj t~ zb`x bd alteh

gvli xbd coqchd lg ` ~vcqlo adee/ @oh cx cq ecmdes xb`x xbd i`xdvc`eq ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q `fed xl

~vlatvd hch olx coaethd dwdvsxbcoj xb`x icjbx b`wd lxbdvzcqd fddo ~vlhtadh fs ~vlqdatxlvq lv

xbd Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq/00

Xbd xvc`e kthjd z`q q`xcqgcdh xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY lfx`codh i`xdvc`eq gvli xbd bd`vcoj lo bcq

lzo `oh xb`x bcq altoqde olz b`h xbdi `oh alteh vdwcdz xbdi fdglvd xvc`e aliidoadh/ Xbd

00H/A/ vdjte`xcloq jlwdvocoj alvvdaxclo`e g`acecxcdq doxcxed vdqchdoxq xl vdadcwd ` al~s lg xbd

zvcxxdo hdacqclo co xbdcv hcqac~eco`vs ~vladdhcojq/ 62 HAIV 406/0>/ Blzdwdv% itab ilvd

~`~dvzlvm cq ~vlhtadh htvcoj qtab bd`vcojq% coaethcoj ` hcqac~eco`vs vd~lvx gcedh fs xbd `aatqcojlggcadv% ` gleelz)t~ cowdqxcj`xcwd vd~lvx hv`gxdh fs ` Qbcgx Qt~dvwcqlv% `oh ]`Yos lxbdv vd~lvxq

idilv`oh` lv vdalvhq aloadvocoj xbd lggdoad xb`x icjbx b`wd fddo qtficxxdh lv `xx`abdh xl xbd

cowdqxcj`xcwd vd~lvx/ 62 HAIV 4>7/0% 4>7/1% 4>7/4% 4>7/7/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

26/34

) 64 )

kthjd hch olx aloqchdv zbdxbdv xbd fvcdg vdadqq fdxzddo xbd ~vd)xvc`e bd`vcoj `oh xbd

aliidoadidox lg xbd xvc`e z`q qtggcacdox xl i`md tqd lg xbd i`xdvc`eq/ Qbd hch olx aloqchdv

zbdxbdv xbd to~vlhtadh Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq i`xdvc`eq b`h w`etd xb`x alteh loes fd

drxv`axdh cg xbds zdvd ~vlhtadh qlid xcid fdglvd xvc`e xb`x cq xl q`s% zbdxbdv xbds i`s b`wd

~lcoxdh hdgdoqd altoqde xl ~lxdoxc`e zcxodqqdq glv xbd hdgdoqd lv lxbdv zd`modqqdq co xbd

jlwdvoidoxq a`qd xb`x alteh olx fd chdoxcgcdh lv dr~elcxdh co xbd qblvx xcid xb`x bd b`h xl vdwcdz

xbd gced/

Xbd xvc`e kthjd hch olx aloqchdv zbdxbdv ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY b`h fddo odjecjdox co g`cecoj

xl cohd~dohdoxes ~vlatvd xblqd i`xdvc`eq% lv zbdxbdv bcq g`cetvd xl lfx`co xbcq avcxca`e dwchdoad

z`q cohca`xcwd lg ` fvl`hdv e`am lg hcecjdoad xb`x i`s b`wd edh bci xl lwdvellm lxbdv ci~lvx`ox

hcqalwdvs/ Xbd xvc`e kthjd hch olx `qm zbs% `gxdv ilvd xb`o ` iloxb lg qxlodz`eecoj fs xbd

jlwdvoidox "xbd Vlqqdv edxxdv z`q gcedh lo Qd~xdifdv 4% 6>00#% altoqde i`hd ol `xxdi~x xl

gleelz t~ lo xbd ~vlqdatxcloq g`cetvd xl ~vlhtad xbd vdptdqxdh hcqalwdvs fs vdodzcoj xbd

vdptdqx% lv fs ~vdqqcoj xbd i`xxdv zcxb xbd altvx xbvltjb ` ilxclo xl ali~de ~vlhtaxclo/ Olv hch

xbd xvc`e kthjd dr~elvd zbdxbdv xbd jlwdvoidoxq g`cetvd xl vdq~loh xl xbd edjcxci`xd vdptdqx glv

hlatidoxq aloqxcxtxdh ` fvd`ab lg xbd cxq hcqalwdvs lfecj`xcloq tohdv Fv`hs% Qt~dv/ Ax/ Avci/

Vted 07% lv lxbdv vdedw`ox `txblvcxs/06

Zbced xbd qal~d lg ` Ilovld)G`vvdee coptcvs hd~dohq t~lo xbd acvatiqx`oadq co d`ab

a`qd% xbcq Altvx b`q chdoxcgcdh avcxdvc` glv hdxdvicocoj zbdxbdv altoqdeq ~vd~`v`xclo g`eeq zcxbco

xbd v`ojd lg ali~dxdoad vdptcvdh co ` avcico`e a`qd/ Zcoj`xd% 773 @/6h `x 0623/ Lod qtab

s`vhqxcam cq zbdxbdv altoqde alohtaxdh flxb ` g`axt`e `oh edj`e cowdqxcj`xclo qtggcacdoxes co

`hw`oad xl ~dvicx vdgedaxclo `oh xl hdxdvicod cg i`xxdvq lg hdgdoqd alteh fd hdwdel~dh/ Ch/

06Xbd ~vdxvc`e xv`oqavc~x vdgedaxq ol `xxdi~x zb`xqldwdv fs xbd altvx xl `qm xbd jlwdvoidox

zbdxbdv xbds b`h ali~ecdh zcxb hcqalwdvs vdptdqxq `oh xbdcv Fv`hs lfecj`xcloq/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

27/34

) 67 )

Altoqde co xbd coqx`ox a`qd hch olx alohtax ` xblvltjb g`axt`e `oh edj`e cowdqxcj`xclo `x `ee xl

q`s olxbcoj lg alohtaxcoj qtab `o cowdqxcj`xclo qtggcacdoxes co `hw`oad lg xvc`e xl ~dvicx

vdgedaxclo `oh xl hdxdvicod cg i`xxdvq lg hdgdoqd alteh fd hdwdel~dh/

Xbcq Altvx qblteh xbtq vdwdvqd xbd elzdv altvxq alowcaxclo/ Ltxvcjbx vdwdvq`e v`xbdv xb`o

vdi`oh cq xbd ~vl~dv vdidhs fda`tqd xvc`e altvxq aloaetqcloq co gcohcoj ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeYq

~dvglvi`oad `hdpt`xd zdvd toqt~~lvxdh fs xbd vdalvh% `oh fda`tqd ]Hdgdoh`oxY qtggdvdh

lfwcltq ~vdkthcad zbdo bd z`q glvadh xl jl xl xvc`e `gxdv xbd xvc`e altvxq hdxdvico`xclo/

IaG`hhdo% 708 @/6h `x 02/

6/

Xbd Xvc`e Altvxq Aloaetqcloq Zdvd Toqt~~lvxdh fs xbd Vdalvh

Xbdvd `vd qxvcmcoj qcice`vcxcdq fdxzddo xbd g`axq lg xbd coqx`ox a`qd `oh IaG`hhdo% ` a`qd

co zbcab xbcq Altvx gltoh xb`x ` xvc`e altvxq ~vd)xvc`e codggdaxcwdodqq coptcvs z`q co`hdpt`xd `oh

xb`x xbd altvxq aloaetqcloq zdvd toqt~~lvxdh fs xbd vdalvh/ Ch/ `x 07/

Ecmd ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY% xbd `xxlvods co IaG`hhdo vd~d`xdhes `hicxxdh xb`x bd z`q

to~vd~`vdh glv xvc`e/ Ch/ Ilvdlwdv% xbd `xxlvods co IaG`hhdo acxdh i`os lg xbd q`id cqqtdq xb`x

]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY v`cqdh co dr~e`cocoj zbs bd z`q to~vd~`vdh xl hdgdoh xbd a`qd;

Altoqde dr~e`codh xb`x q`ch bd b`]hY olx q~dox doltjb xcid x`emcoj xl bcq aecdox xb`xxbdvd zdvd zcxodqqdq bd b`h olx chdoxcgcdh `oh xb`x bd hch olx molz zb`x hdgdoqdq bd

zlteh v`cqd olv zb`x bd zlteh xdee xbd ktvs `x xbd doh lg xbd xvc`e/ Bd `eql vdgdvvdh xl

x`axca`e hdacqcloq xb`x b`h sdx xl fd i`hd/

Ch/ `x 08% 07/ Xbd altvx `eql gltoh xb`x xbd hdgdoh`ox co IaG`hhdo ecmd ]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q xbd

qltvad lg qlid lg bcq altoqdeq hcggcatexs co vdqlewcoj dwchdoxc`vs `oh x`axca`e cqqtdq/ Ch/ `x 07/

Xbd IaG`hhdo altvx q~dacgca`ees olxdh xb`x altoqdeq g`cetvd xl ela`xd xbd zcxodqqdq co xcid glv

xvc`e alteh e`vjdes fd fe`idh lo xbd hdgdoh`oxq g`cetvd xl gtegcee bcq vdq~loqcfcecxs xl all~dv`xd

zcxb altoqde cq chdoxcgscoj zcxodqqdq/ Ch/ `x 04/ @oh xbd hdgdoqd altoqde co IaG`hhdo

vdq~lohdh xl xb`x `hilocxclo fs olxcoj xb`x bcq aecdoxq tobde~gteodqq co xbcq vdj`vh z`q e`vjdes

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

28/34

) 6: )

`xxvcftx`fed xl xbd g`ax xb`x bd% ecmd ]Hdgdoh`oxY% z`q coa`vadv`xdh; ]QYlid lg xbd zcxodqqdq `vd

olx vd`ees zdee)molzo xl ]xbd hdgdoh`oxY/ @oh% lg altvqd% xbd hdgdoh`ox fdcoj elamdh t~% xbdvd cq

hcggcatexs co ela`xcoj xbdi/ Ch/

Xbd coqx`ox a`qd `oh IaG`hhdo `vd `eql qcice`v co xb`x flxb elzdv altvxq `jvddh xl ` fvcdg

~lqx~lodidox lod h`s co IaG`hhdo% glvxs)gcwd icotxdq co xbcq a`qd xb`x z`q zblees

co`hdpt`xd xl `eelz xbd hdgdoh`oxq vdq~daxcwd `xxlvodsq xl ~vd~`vd glv xvc`e/ Ch/

Xbd `xxlvods co IaG`hhdo z`q `eql dwdoxt`ees al`rdh coxl hvl~~coj bcq vd~d`xdh

~vlxdqx`xcloq xb`x bd z`q to~vd~`vdh% qx`xcoj xb`x bd alteh ~vlf`fes fd vd`hs cg glvadh xl

jl xl xvc`e itab co xbd q`id z`s xb`x ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY dwdoxt`ees aloadhdh xb`x bd z`q

~vd~`vdh/ Ch/

E`qxes% IaG`hhdo cq lo ~lcox fda`tqd xbd elzdv altvx xbdvd g`cedh xl vdwcqcx altoqdeq ~vd)

xvc`e ae`ci xb`x bd z`q to~vd~`vdh zbdo xbd a`qd zdox xl xvc`e xbd odrx h`s itab co xbd q`id

z`s xb`x ]Xvc`e KthjdY hcqicqqdh ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeYq vdodzdh vdptdqx glv ` aloxcot`oad fs

qx`xcoj xb`x ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY hd`ex zcxb vdptdqxq xl ~lqx~lod xbd xvc`e/ Qbd hdachdh xb`x zd

qblteh ~vladdh/ Xb`xq zb`x zd `vd hlcoj/ "Xv/6;4>)40#/

Xbd vd`qlocoj lg xbd IaG`hhdo altvx xbtq `~~ecdq zcxb dpt`e glvad xl xbd g`axq lg xbd

coqx`ox a`qd;

Altoqde xleh xbd kthjd xb`x cg glvadh xl jl xl xvc`e% bd alteh ~vlf`fes fd vd`hs fs xbdgleelzcoj h`s/ Sdx% zbdo xbd xvc`e fdj`o xbd gleelzcoj h`s% xbd kthjd i`hd ol gtvxbdv

coptcvcdq lg dcxbdv xvc`e altoqde lv `~~dee`ox vdj`vhcoj xbdcv vd`hcodqq xl ~vladdh xl xvc`e/

Co wcdz lg xvc`e altoqde*q lzo `hicqqcloq lg to~vd~`vdhodqq% xbd xvc`e kthjd*q ~vdecico`vsaloaetqclo i`hd zcxbltx gtvxbdv coptcvs xb`x `~~dee`ox% `oh olx bcq xvc`e altoqde% z`q

vdq~loqcfed glv olx b`wcoj chdoxcgcdh zcxodqqdq lv gtees ~vd~`vdh ` hdgdoqd cq toqt~~lvxdh

fs xbd vdalvh/

Ch/ `x 07/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

29/34

) 62 )

Gtvxbdv dwchdoad xb`x xbd elzdv altvxq aloaetqcloq zdvd olx qt~~lvxdh fs xbd vdalvh cq

gltoh co xbd xvc`e kthjdq e`am lg `o dr~e`o`xclo lg xbd f`qcq lg bdv hdxdvico`xclo xb`x altoqdeq

~vd)xvc`e ~dvglvi`oad z`q `hdpt`xd/ Xbd xvc`e kthjd hch olx ~vlfd xbd qtfqx`oad lg ]Hdgdoh`oxY

i`co ae`ci lg codggdaxcwdodqq% `eedjcoj xb`x ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY b`h drdvxdh ecxxed dgglvx co

lfx`cocoj hcqalwdvs/ Olv hch xbd kthjd de`flv`xd lo xbd vdalvh zbs qbd fdecdwdh ]Hdgdoqd

AltoqdeY b`h ~dvglvidh bcq cowdqxcj`xcwd htxcdq `hdpt`xdes/ Coqxd`h% qbd `~~d`vdh xl gcoh xb`x bd

b`h ~dvglvidh `hdpt`xdes lo xbd f`qcq lg bcq ~vclv xvc`e ~dvglvi`oadq/ "Xv/0;08#/

]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeY vd~d`xdhes qx`xdh xb`x bd z`q to~vd~`vdh xl jl xl xvc`e% `oh xbd xvc`e

kthjd vd~d`xdhes ~vlhhdh bci xl dr~e`co zbs/ Altoqde qx`xdh qdwdv`e vd`qloq "d/j/% xbd

jlwdvoidoxq fde`xdh gcecoj lg ` qt~dvqdhcoj cohcaxidox ab`vjcoj ` odz avcid xb`x bd b`h olx

gtees hcqatqqdh zcxb bcq aecdox `oh z`q olx qtvd blz xl hdgdoh= xbd to~vlhtadh jlwdvoidox

hcqalwdvs= xbd ~lxdoxc`e tochdoxcgcdh zcxodqq#/ Xbd xvc`e kthjd hcqicqqdh `ee xbdqd aloadvoq `oh

~vdqqdh bci `j`co xl dr~e`co zbs bd gdex to~vd~`vdh% `qmcoj; Cq cx fda`tqd slt b`wd b`vh

gddecojq< C id`o% sltvd qtab `o `fed e`zsdv/ "Xv/0;08#/ @q xbcq Altvx b`q qx`xdh% `qqti~xcloq

xb`x ` e`zsdv b`q ~dvglvidh `hdpt`xdes co ` ~`vxcate`v a`qd qblteh olx fd f`qdh lo ~`qx

lfqdvw`xcloq;

@exbltjb xbd xvc`e altvx*q alogchdoad co hdgdoqd altoqde*q ~vd~`v`xclo xl vd~vdqdox Iv/

Iceeq co xbcq i`xxdv i`s fd tohdvqx`oh`fed co ecjbx lg xbd altvx*q lfqdvw`xclo lg bcq ~`qx

vd~vdqdox`xclo lg Iv/ Iceeq% zd b`wd q`ch ~vdwcltqes xb`x cx cq ci~vl~dv glv ` xvc`e altvx xl`qqtid ~vl~dv ~vd~`v`xclo fs hdgdoqd altoqde/

Iceeq% :37 @/6h `x 10/ Qdd `eql Ilovld% 123 @/6h `x 266 "]XbdY wcdz xb`x qcoad altoqde z`q `

jdodv`ees ali~dxdox `xxlvods% bd c~ql g`axl z`q `fed xl vdohdv `hdpt`xd `qqcqx`oad xl `~~dee`ox co

xbcq a`qd ]cqY `o ci~vl~dv f`qcq lo zbcab xl ~vdhca`xd qtab ` aloaetqclo/# "di~b`qcq co lvcjco`e#/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

30/34

) 63 )

1/ Lfwcltq ^vdkthcad Vdqtexdh Gvli Co`hdpt`xd Codggdaxcwdodqq CoptcvsXbd lfwcltq ~vdkthcad xb`x `aavtdh xl ]Hdgdoh`oxY zbdo bd z`q glvadh xl jl xl xvc`e%

hdq~cxd bcq ae`ci lg ~vd)xvc`e codggdaxcwdodqq% cq `olxbdv vd`qlo xb`x xbd ~vl~dv vdidhs co xbd

coqx`ox a`qd cq vdwdvq`e% v`xbdv xb`o vdi`oh/ Qdd IaG`hhdo% 708 @/6h `x 02/

Co hdxdvicocoj zbdxbdv ` hdgdoh`ox z`q ~vdkthcadh fs `o co`hdpt`xd codggdacxcwdodqq

coptcvs% altoqdeq `axt`e ~dvglvi`oad `x xvc`e zcee aloqxcxtxd acvatiqx`oxc`e dwchdoad lo xbd

cqqtd lg zbdxbdv qbd z`q `hdpt`xdes ~vd~`vdh fdglvd xvc`e/ Odeqlo w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 7>0 @/6h

426% 436 "H/A/0330#/ ]Hdgdoqd AltoqdeYq xvc`e ~dvglvi`oad co xbd coqx`ox a`qd ~vlwchdq qxvloj

acvatiqx`oxc`e dwchdoad xb`x bd z`q olx `hdpt`xdes ~vd~`vdh fdglvd xvc`e/

Altoqdeq g`cetvd xl ci~d`ab xbd avdhcfcecxs lg ]Ali~e`co`oxY zblqd xdqxcilos xbd xvc`e

altvx f`qdh cxq wdvhcax lo z`q hcvdaxes `xxvcftx`fed xl xbd hcqalwdvs g`cetvdq xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY

ali~e`codh lg co bcq ~vd)xvc`e bd`vcoj/ @q hcqatqqdh `x edojxbqt~v`% xbd jlwdvoidoxq wcle`xclo

lg cxq hcqalwdvs lfecj`xcloq zbcab fvd`abdq zdvd toatvdh fda`tqd hdgdoqd altoqde g`cedh xl

~vdqq glv altvx)lvhdvdh doglvadidox hd~vcwdh ]Hdgdoh`oxY lg avcxca`e dwchdoad xb`x zlteh b`wd

ci~d`abdh ]Ali~e`co`oxYq avdhcfcecxs/ "Qdd qt~v`% ~~/ 2)06#/

+

Xbd Qcrxb @idohidox vcjbx xl dggdaxcwd altoqde doali~`qqdq `o `xxlvodsq ~dvglvi`oad

co ~vd)xvc`e hcqalwdvs fda`tqd `hdpt`xd ~vd~`v`xclo fs% `oh aloqtex`xclo zcxb% altoqde lgxdo

i`s fd ` ilvd ci~lvx`ox dedidox co dggdaxcwd `qqcqx`oad lg altoqde xl zbcab ` hdgdoh`ox cq

doxcxedh xb`o xbd glvdoqca qmcee drbcfcxdh co xbd altvxvlli/ Iceeq% :37 @/6h `x 10/

Glv `ee lg xbd `flwd vd`qloq% ]Hdgdoh`oxY hch olx vdadcwd xbd ~vd)xvc`e vd~vdqdox`xclo xb`x

bd z`q aloqxcxtxclo`ees doxcxedh xl% `oh xbd elzdv altvxq g`cetvd xl doqtvd xb`x bd hch cq `o dvvlv

xb`x hdi`ohq vdwdvq`e/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

31/34

) 1> )

CC/ XBD ELZDV ALTVX DVVDH C HDSCJ ]HDGDH@XY ALXCT@ADVDPTDQXQ

]Hdgdoh`oxY i`hd gltv aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq htvcoj bcq ~vd)xvc`e bd`vcoj% lod lg zbcab bd

vdodzdh `x xvc`e/ "Qdd qt~v`% ~~/ :)06#/ ]Hdgdoh`oxY v`cqdh qdwdv`e w`ech jvltohq co xbdqd

vdptdqxq% coaethcoj xbd co`hdpt`xd olxcad lg bcq ab`vjdq xb`x bd vdadcwdh `q ` vdqtex lg xbd

jlwdvoidoxq fde`xdh gcecoj lg ` qt~dvqdhcoj coglvi`xclo% hcqalwdvs bledq avd`xdh fs

jlwdvoidox Fv`hs wcle`xcloq `oh fde`xdh hcqaelqtvdq% `oh ` hdqcvd xl ela`xd ` ~lxdoxc`ees avcxca`e

zcxodqq/ "Ch/#

]Hdgdoh`oxY qdaloh `vjtidox lo `~~d`e `qqcjoq dvvlv xl xbd xvc`e altvxq hdoc`eq lg xzl

lg bcq aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq/ Bd aloxdohq xb`x xbd altvxq vtecojq aloqxcxtxdh `ftqdq lg hcqavdxclo

xb`x ~vdkthcadh bcq hdgdoqd `oh wcle`xdh bcq Qcrxb @idohidox vcjbxq/

@/ QX@H@VH LG VDWCDZXbd hdoc`e lg ` vdptdqx glv ` aloxcot`oad cq jdodv`ees vdwcdz`fed loes glv `ftqd lg

hcqavdxclo/ LAloolv w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% 133 @/6h 60% 62 "H/A/ 03:3#/ Co qlid coqx`oadq%

blzdwdv% xbd hdoc`e lg ` aloxcot`oad a`o fd hddidh ql `vfcxv`vs `q xl wcle`xd htd ~vladqq

tohdv xbd Gcgxb @idohidox% ql aelqdv qavtxcos zcee fd vdptcvdh xb`o cq xs~ca`ees `~~ecdh xl

i`xxdvq vdwcdzdh glv `o `ftqd lg hcqavdxclo/ Ch/

Xbcq Altvx b`q olx qdx glvxb `os idab`oca`e xdqxq glv hdachcoj zbdo ` hdoc`e lg `

aloxcot`oad cq ql `vfcxv`vs `q xl wcle`xd htd ~vladqq/ Ch/ `x 10/ Zbdxbdv `o dvvlodltq

aloxcot`oad vtecoj vcqdq xl xbd edwde lg aloqxcxtxclo`e wcle`xclo zcee coqxd`h hd~doh lo xbd

acvatiqx`oadq ~vdqdox co dwdvs a`qd% ~`vxcate`ves co xbd vd`qloq ~vdqdoxdh xl xbd xvc`e kthjd `x xbd

xcid xbd vdptdqx cq hdocdh/ Ch/

@aalvhcojes% xbcq Altvx b`q `hilocqbdh xvc`e altvxq xl zdcjb aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq

a`vdgtees/ Ch/ Xbd ~lxdoxc`e aloqxcxtxclo`e ci~eca`xcloq lg dvvlodltq hdoc`eq hdi`oh qtab

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

32/34

) 10 )

qavtxcos/ Ch/ Aelqd qavtxcos cq `eql vdptcvdh fda`tqd xbcq Altvx b`q qdx glvxb ~vdacqd avcxdvc` glv

zdcjbcoj aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq co advx`co aloxdrxq% zbcab jtchdecodq zcee lgxdo hdi`oh xbd

a`vdgte f`e`oacoj lg ali~dxcoj coxdvdqxq `oh qdwdv`e g`axlvq/ Ch/ `x 10)16/

F/ @VJTIDX0/ Aloxcot`oad Vtecojq `x CqqtdHdgdoh`ox ab`eedojdq xzl lg xbd elzdv altvxq vtecojq lo `~~d`e/ Xbd gcvqx vtecoj

vdq~lohdh xl ` aloxcot`oad ilxclo xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY i`hd `gxdv xbd jlwdvoidoxq gcedh `

ilvocoj)lg)xbd)xvc`e qt~dvqdhcoj coglvi`xclo `hhcoj Altox CC% `eedjcoj Icqhdid`olv Qdrt`e

@ftqd% xl bcq Ali~e`cox/ "Qdd qt~v`% ~~/ 4% :#/ Hdgdoqd altoqde `vjtdh xb`x xbd fde`xdh

`idohidox zbcab z`q olx f`qdh lo odzes hcqalwdvdh dwchdoad `oh a`id gltv iloxbq `gxdv

]Hdgdoh`oxY z`q cocxc`ees ab`vjdh b`h edgx bci to~vd~`vdh xl g`ad xbd odz ab`vjd% zbcab bd

b`h olx `hdpt`xdes hcqatqqdh zcxb bcq aecdox/ "Ch/# Xbd qdaloh aloxcot`oad vdptdqx v`cqdh lo

`~~d`e acxdh ` oddh glv `hhcxclo`e xcid xl ~vlatvd hcqalwdvs i`xdvc`eq xb`x ]Hdgdoh`oxY `xxlvods

hddidh avcxca`e xl hcq~vlwcoj `o dedidox lg xbd fde`xdhes)ab`vjdh lggdoqd/ "Qdd qt~v`% ~~/ 3)06#/

6/ Aloxcot`oad Vtecojq Aloqxcxtxdh @ftqdq lg xbd Altvxq HcqavdxcloXbd xvc`e altvx `ftqdh cxq hcqavdxclo co hdoscoj xbd `flwd)dotidv`xdh aloxcot`oad

vdptdqxq/ @ aloxcot`oad qblteh fd jv`oxdh t~lo ` qblzcoj xb`x cx cq vd`qlo`fes odadqq`vs xl `

ktqx hdxdvico`xclo lg xbd a`tqd% LAloolv% 133 @/6h `x 62/ Qtab ` qblzcoj vdptcvdq% `x `

icociti% qlid qblzcoj lg ~vdkthcad co xbd `fqdoad lg ` aloxcot`oad/ Msed w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq%

:43 @/6h 036% 037 o/6 "H/A/ 6>>>#/

]Hdgdoh`oxY qblzdh co xbd coqx`ox a`qd xb`x ` aloxcot`oad z`q vd`qlo`fes odadqq`vs xl

xbd ktqx hdxdvico`xclo lg bcq a`qd% `oh bd qblzdh xb`x hdoscoj bcq vdptdqx zlteh ~vdkthcad bcq

a`qd/

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

33/34

) 16 )

Hdgdoqd altoqde dr~vdqqes xleh xbd altvx xb`x bcq gcvqx aloxcot`oad vdptdqx z`q vdptcvdh

fda`tqd bd b`h olx hcqatqqdh xbd odz ab`vjd zcxb bcq aecdox `oh z`q toqtvd zb`x bcq hdgdoqd xl

cx zlteh fd/ "Xv/0;6)1#/ Xbd jlwdvoidoxq fde`xdh `idohidox% `oh xbd altvxq aloxcot`oad

hdoc`e% ~vdaethdh hdgdoqd altoqde gvli jd`vcoj bcq ~vd)xvc`e dgglvxq xlz`vhq xbd hdgdoqd lg `

qdrt`e `qq`tex avcid xb`x coaethdq ` q~dacgca coxdox dedidox olx ~vdqdox co xbd qci~ed `qq`tex

lggdoqd cocxc`ees ab`vjdh/

]Hdgdoh`oxY `eql i`hd ` qblzcoj xb`x ` aloxcot`oad z`q vdptcvdh xl `eelz bci xl lfx`co

xbd zcxbbdeh jlwdvoidox hcqalwdvs xb`x bcq `xxlvods hddidh avcxca`e xl hdgd`xcoj xbd fde`xdhes)

olxcadh qdrt`e `qq`tex `eedj`xclo/ Xbd altvxq vtecoj ~vdaethdh ]Hdgdoh`oxY gvli lfx`cocoj xbd

Hd~`vxidox lg Alvvdaxcloq ~dvqloode gcedq `oh xv`cocoj i`ot`eq vdptcvdh xl ci~d`ab

]Ali~e`co`oxY% zblqd xdqxcilos z`q tqdh xl ~vlwd ` avcxca`e dedidox lg xbd fde`xdhes)olxcadh

qdrt`e `qq`tex ab`vjd/ "Qdd qt~v`% ~~/ :% 3)06#/

Xbd elzdv altvxq vtecojq ~vdkthcadh ]Hdgdoh`oxY hdgdoqd fs glvacoj bci jl xl xvc`e

zcxbltx `eelzcoj bcq `xxlvods xl cowdqxcj`xd xbd odzes)ab`vjdh `eedj`xclo lv lfx`co xbd zcxbbdeh

hcqalwdvs oddhdh xl ci~d`ab ]Ali~e`co`oxY/ "Xv/6;78#/ @aalvhcojes% xbcq Altvx qblteh gcoh xb`x

xbd xvc`e altvx `ftqdh cxq hcqavdxclo co g`cecoj xl ~lqx~lod ]Hdgdoh`oxY ~vladdhcojq/

1/ Aloxcot`oad Vtecojq Ci~cojdh lo ]Hdgdoh`oxY Qcrxb @idohidox VcjbxqXbcq Altvx qblteh `eql gcoh xb`x xbd xvc`e kthjdq vtecojq ci~cojdh lo ]Hdgdoh`oxY Qcrxb

@idohidox vcjbxq/ Fs glvacoj ]Hdgdoh`oxY xl jl xl xvc`e zcxbltx `eelzcoj bcq e`zsdv xl hdwcqd `

hdgdoqd qxv`xdjs lv lfx`co oddhdh hcqalwdvs% xbd elzdv altvx hdocdh bci xbd dggdaxcwd `qqcqx`oad

lg altoqde/ @q xbcq Altvx b`q olxdh;

Xbd htxs lg xbd altvx xl `qqtvd xb`x xbd `aatqdh*q vcjbx xl altoqde cq ~vlxdaxdh cq olx

hcqab`vjdh fs `o `qqcjoidox ]lg altoqdeY `x qtab ` xcid lv tohdv qtab acvatiqx`oadq `qxl ~vdaethd xbd jcwcoj lg dggdaxcwd `ch co xbd ~vd~`v`xclo `oh xvc`e lg xbd a`qd/ Xbtq% xbd

xvc`e kthjd i`s olx coqcqx lo qtab dr~dhcxcltqodqq xb`x altoqde glv xbd hdgdoh`ox e`amq `

7/31/2019 AppellateBrief (Crim PostConviction Brady)

34/34

vd`qlo`fed xcid xl ~vd~`vd glv xvc`e= qxvc~~coj `z`s xbd l~~lvxtocxs xl ~vd~`vd glv xvc`e cq

x`ox`iltox xl hdoscoj `exljdxbdv xbd `qqcqx`oad lg altoqde glv xbd hdgdoqd/

S`oads w/ Tocxdh Qx`xdq% :44 @/6h 860% 86: "H/A/ 6>>># "acxcoj ^lzdee w/ @e`f`i`% 62: T/Q/ 84%

:0 "0316##/

Xbd elzdv altvxq ~dvgtoaxlvs coptcvs coxl ]Hdgdoh`oxY ~vd)xvc`e codggdaxcwd altoqde

ae`ci wcle`xdh bcq Qcrxb @idohidox vcjbxq% `oh xbd altvxq vdkdaxclo lg bcq otidvltq w`ech

aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq zdvd `ftqdq lg hcqavdxclo xb`x `eql wcle`xdh bcq aloqxcxtxclo`e vcjbxq/

Xbd xvc`e altvx g`cedh xl bddh xbd Altvx lg @~~d`eq `hilocxclo xl a`vdgtees aloqchdv

aloxcot`oad vdptdqxq `oh xl aelqdes ecqxdo xl xbd jvltohq ~vlggdvdh co qt~~lvx lg xblqd vdptdqxq/

Qlid lg xbd elzdv altvxq aloxcot`oad vtecojq zdvd ilvd djvdjcltq xb`o lxbdvq fda`tqd xbds

ilvd aed`ves ci~eca`xdh ]Hdgdoh`oxY aloqxcxtxclo`e vcjbxq/ Ftx ` aliilo gd`xtvd lg `ee xbd

aloxcot`oad vtecojq cq xb`x xbds zdvd i`hd atvqlvces/ Co d`ab a`qd xbd hdi`ohq lg xbd avcico`e

hlamdx `~~d`vdh xl fd xbd xvc`e altvxq lwdvvchcoj aloadvo/ S`oads% :44 @/6h `x 862/01

ALAETQCL

Glv `ee xbdqd vd`qloq% @~~dee`oxq alowcaxcloq qblteh fd vdwdvqdh/

01Flxb ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY `oh ]Xvc`e KthjdY qddidh d`jdv xl dr~dhcxd xbd ~vladdhcojq `oh

vdetax`ox xl ~lqx~lod xbdi tohdv `os acvatiqx`oadq/ Co hcqicqqcoj Hdgdoh`oxq aloxcot`oad

vdptdqxq htvcoj xbd ~vd)xvc`e bd`vcoj% ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY qx`xdh% Xbd a`qd cq vd`hs olz/ Cx alqxq xbdx`r~`sdvq ilods xl jdx xbcq a`qd vd`hs/ Ql Ci olx coaecodh xl jv`ox ` aloxcot`oad/ Edx id ktqx

i`md xbd vdalvh/ "Xv/0;04# "di~b`qcq `hhdh#/ @oh co hdoscoj Hdgdoh`oxq vdodzdh aloxcot`oad

vdptdqx `x xvc`e% ]Xvc`e KthjdY qx`xdh% C tohdvqx`oh xb`x ]^vd)xvc`e KthjdY hd`ex zcxb vdptdqxq xlx xb x c e Qb h ch h xb x b eh h Xb x b x h c "X 6 40#