ASBESTOSANDREGULATEDWASTEASSESSMENTREPORT
Bridge#69834
27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
PreparedFor:
MinnesotaDepartmentofTransportationOfficeofEnvironmentalServices
395JohnIrelandBoulevard,M.S.620St.Paul,Minnesota55155
PreparedBy:
WSBandAssociates,Inc.701XeniaAvenueSouth,Suite300
Minneapolis,MN55416763‐541‐4800
May 2017
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
CONTENTS:
Section1‐SiteSpecificsandCertification
Section2‐SummaryofActionsRequiredForThisDemolition
Section3‐SummaryofAllAsbestosandRegulatedWastes
AppendixI‐AnalyticalResultsandChain‐of‐CustodyFormsAsbestosContainingMaterials–ReservoirsEnvironmental,Inc.Lead‐in‐Paint‐ReservoirsEnvironmental,Inc.PolychlorinatedBiphenyls–LegendTechnicalServices,Inc.
AppendixII‐StructureLocation,BridgeDrawingsandPhotographs
SiteLocationMapSampleLocationMaps Photographs
AppendixIII–LicensesandCertifications
MDHInspector’sLicenses
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
SECTION1SiteSpecificsandCertification
Bridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
StateProjectNumber:6982‐322Bridge#: 69834Location:27thAvenueWestoverInterstateI‐35,Duluth,Minnesota(seecopiesofSiteLocationMapinAppendix II).NumberandTypeofStructure/s:1Structure,Bridge69834CurrentOwner:MinnesotaDepartmentofTransportationExpectedDispositionoftheStructure:BridgeDemolitionLicensure:MDH‐certifiedasbestosinspectorsconductedtheinspection(AppendixIII).LaboratorycertificationsareonfileatWSB,andareavailableuponrequest.Certification:The undersigned certifiesthat this asbestos inspection was performed incompliancewithMNRules4620.3460.
Signature: DanRangitsch,CertifiedAsbestosInspector#AI11414
Date:May9,2017
Certification: Theundersigned certifies that this asbestos and regulatedwaste assessment andreportwasperformedundermydirectsupervisionandIhaverevieweditscontentsandfindittomeetorexceedcontractrequirements.
Signature: JeffreyRice,CHMM#14655,CertifiedAsbestosInspector#AI8364Date:May9,2017
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
U
SECTION2SummaryofActionsRequiredForThisDemolition
Bridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
ReviewBridgeDrawings: Construction drawings from 1965 and 1984were reviewed toidentifysuspect asbestos‐containingmaterials(ACM)andotherregulatedmaterialsatthebridge.AsbestosSummary:A totalof14homogeneousmaterialswere identifiedat thebridgethatweresuspect for containingasbestos.SamplelocationmapsareprovidedinAppendixII.ThefollowingmaterialswereidentifiedasACM:
Theasbestos‐containing,blackbituminousfeltislocatedintheseambetweentheslopeandtheabutment.Thematerialisnon‐friableandingoodcondition.
Theasbestos‐containing,blackbituminous felt is locatedon thegroundnear the southwest
corner of the bridge deck. The material is non‐friable and in damaged condition. Thebituminousfeltwasidentifiedinthe1965bridgeplans.The1984bridgeplansidentifiedbridgeapproachrepairs,includingthereplacementofthebituminousfeltidentifiedinthe1984bridgeplans.
ThefollowinglocationswereinspectedforACM:
Thebridgedeck,roadwearsurfaces,guardrails,piers,abutments,wingwalls,slopes,utilitiesandsuperstructure.
Constructionjointswereidentifiedatthebridgeabutments/maskwalls.Anelectriccoredrillwasusedtoinspectforwaterproofingmaterialsatthebacksideoftheeastabutment/maskwall.No3‐plyjointwaterproofingmaterialwasidentified.
Handexcavationwascompletedatconstructionjointsbetweentheabutmentandthewing
wallsandno3‐plyjointwaterproofingorotherwaterproofingmaterialswereidentified.
Therewerenoutilities forwater, gas,communications,orotherservicesobservedonorbelowthebridge. Conduitsforelectrical utilities wereidentified belowthebridgedeck.Inspection of the electrical components identifiedacoatingontheflexibleconduitlocatedbelowthebridge.SampleanalysisoftheconduitcoatingdeterminedthatitisnotanACM.
RegulatedWaste Summary: The following regulated waste was found on the bridge oralongtheroadwayimmediatelybeforeandafterthebridge. Thiswasteisrequiredtoberemovedpriorto demolition (See attached documents in Section 3 for the detailed inventory of all regulatedwastes):Lead: LeadPlates(7½”x4½”)–35each.Belowbearingassembliesatabutmentsand
piers LeadPlates(3”x6”)–68each.Belowornamentalrailingposts
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota LeadPaint–None.Sampleswerecollectedfrom2painttypesandlead‐basedpaint
(0.5%orgreatertotallead‐by‐weight)wasnotidentified. LEDLights–2each.Polemountedlightsonbridgedeck. PeelingPaint: NoneMercury: HIDLights–NonePCBs: Lightballasts–None
Transformers/electricalboxes–NoneCaulking(<50ppm)–Sampleswerecollectedfrom7caulktypesatthebridge.TwoofthesamplescontaineddetectableconcentrationsofPCBslessthan(<)50ppm.120SF–Blackcaulkinsidewalkseams232SF–GraycaulkatseamsinpierandslopeCaulking(>50ppm)–Sampleswerecollectedfrom7caulktypesatthebridge.TwoofthesamplescontaineddetectableconcentrationsofPCBs>50ppm.116SF–Blackbituminousfeltatseambetweenslopeandabutment116SF–BlackjointfilleratseambetweenslopeandabutmentCapacitors–None
TreatedWood: Green‐TreatedPosts(6”x8”)–23each.Guardrailpostsalong27thAvenuebridge
approachandbelowthebridgealongI‐35.
CreosotePilings–NoneSolidWaste: None
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
SECTION3SummaryofallAsbestosandRegulatedWastes
Bridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
Thefollowingasbestosandregulatedmaterials/wastesmustberemovedpriortodemolition.
ParcelNumber NotapplicableStructureName Bridge69834AddressofStructure27thAvenueWestoverI‐35,Duluth,MinnesotaInspectionDate(s) 4/3/17,4/4/2017
CategoryIandIINon‐friableAsbestos
LocationSampleDescription %Asbestos
Quantity(ft2) Item Condition
SampleNumbers
LabAnalysis/COCEnclosed
SWcornerofbridge–onground
BlackBituminousFelt
3%Chrysotile
5SF
BitFelt
Damaged
33
Yes
Slopeandabutmentseam
BlackBituminousFelt
2%Chrysotile
116SF
BitFelt
Good
16,17,18
Yes
TotalSquareFeet
121SF
FriableAsbestos
Location SampleDescription
%Asbestos
Quantity(ft2) Item Condition Sample
NumbersLabAnalysis/COCEnclosed
NoneIdentified TotalSquareFeet 0SF
Definitions‐SampleDescriptionTypeofHomogeneousmateriali.e.sheetrock,siding,etc.Condition Excellent
Good
PoorQuantity Onlyifcontains>1%asbestosotherwiseNA
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
RegulatedWasteInspectionForm OneFormperStructureCompanyPerformingtheInspection WSB&Associates,Inc.(WSB)Company'sStateWorkOrderNumber NotApplicableCompanyAddress 701XeniaAvenueSouth,Suite300 Minneapolis,Minnesota55416CompanyTelephone 763‐541‐4800InspectorsName JeffreyRice,DanRangitsch MnDOTDistrict 1StateProjectNumber 6982‐322BridgeNumber 69834BridgeName N/AAddressofStructure 27thAvenueWestoverI‐35,Duluth,MinnesotaInspectionDate 4/3/2017,4/4/2017
InspectedItems Item Quantity Location
Ballasts None Transformer/electricalbox None Capacitors None PCBCaulking(<50ppm) Blackcaulk 120SF Sidewalkseams Graycaulk 232SF Baseofpiersandslope PCBCaulking(>50ppm) Bituminousfelt 116SF Slopeandabutmentseam Jointfiller 116SF SlopeandabutmentseamOther(name) None
FluorescentBulbs NoneHIDLamps None Other(name) None
LeadPlates Plates(7½”x4½”)35each BearingassembliesLeadPlates Plates(3”x6”) 68each OrnamentalrailingpostsLeadPaintSystems None PrintedCircuitBoard NoneLEDlightsLights 2each Polemountedonbridgedeck
PeelingPaint None
Creosote None CCA(greentreat) Post(6”x8”) 23each GuardrailPostsOther(nameifpossible) None
MunicipalSolidWaste(MSW) None
PCB
Mercury
Lead
PeelingPaint
TreatedWood
Other
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
AppendixIBridge69834
AnalyticalResultsandChain‐of‐CustodyForms
AsbestosContainingMaterials–ReservoirsEnvironmental,Inc.Lead‐in‐Paint‐ReservoirsEnvironmental,Inc.
PolychlorinatedBiphenyls–LegendTechnicalServices,Inc.
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc.
Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2015
T:\QAQC\Lab\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
Subcontract Number: NA
Laboratory Report: RES 376161-1
Project # / P.O. # 03321-060
Project Description: MnDOT Bridge 69834 Duluth MN
RES 376161-1
Sincerely,
April 14, 2017
Dear Customer,
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. is an analytical laboratory accredited for the analysis of Industrial Hygiene and
Environmental matrices by the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP), Lab Code 101896-0
for Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) analysis and the American
Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA), Lab ID 101533 - Accreditation Certificate #480 for Phase Contrast
Microscopy (PCM) analysis. This laboratory is currently proficient in both Proficiency Testing and PAT programs
respectively.
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. has analyzed the following samples for asbestos content as per your request. The
analysis has been completed in general accordance with the appropriate methodology as stated in the attached
analysis table. The results have been submitted to your office.
WSB & Associates, Inc.
701 Xenia Avenue South Suite 300
Minneapolis MN 55416
is the job number assigned to this study. This report is considered highly confidential
and the sole property of the customer. Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. will not discuss any part of this study with
personnel other than those of the client. The results described in this report only apply to the samples analyzed.
This report must not be used to claim endorsement of products or analytical results by NVLAP or any agency of the
U.S. Government. This report shall not be reproduced except in full, without written approval from Reservoirs
Environmental, Inc. Samples will be disposed of after sixty days unless longer storage is requested. If you have any
questions about this report, please feel free to call 303-964-1986.
Jeanne Spencer
President
P: 303-964-1986
F: 303-477-4275
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100 Denver, CO 80216
Page 1 of 1
1-866-RESI-ENV
www.reilab.com
RES Job Number:
Client:
Client Project Number / P.O.:
Client Project Description:
Date Samples Received:
Turnaround:
Date Samples Analyzed:
RES 376161-1
WSB & Associates, Inc.
03321-060
MnDOT Bridge 69834 Duluth MN
April 06, 2017
3-5 Day
April 14, 2017
TABLE: PLM BULK ANALYSIS, PERCENTAGE COMPOSITION BY VOLUME
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc.
Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2015
Q:\QAQC\LAB\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
RESERVOIRS ENVIRONMENTAL INC.
NVLAP Lab Code 101896-0
Client
Sample
Number
Lab
ID Number
LAYER
Mineral
Method: EPA 600/R-93/116 - Short Report, Bulk
PhysicalDescription
SubPart
(%)
Visual
Estimate
(%)
ND=None DetectedTR=Trace, <1% Visual EstimateTrem/Act=Tremolite/Actinolite
NonAsbestosFibrous
Components(%)
Non-Fibrous
Components
(%)
Asbestos Content
1000#1 EM 1834750 Black caulkA 100 ND
1000#2 EM 1834751 Black caulkA 100 ND
1000#3 EM 1834752 Off white granular cementitious materialA 20 ND
1000Black caulkB 80 ND
2080#4 EM 1834753 Brown feltA 100 ND
2080#5 EM 1834754 Brown feltA 100 ND
2080#6 EM 1834755 Brown feltA 100 ND
1000#7 EM 1834756 Black caulkA 100 ND
1000#8 EM 1834757 Black caulkA 100 ND
1000#9 EM 1834758 Black caulkA 100 ND
1000#10 EM 1834759 Black resinous materialA 100 ND
1000#11 EM 1834760 Black resinous materialA 100 ND
1000#12 EM 1834761 Tan sealantA 100 ND
TEM Analysis recommended for organically bound material (i.e. floor tile) if PLM results are <1%.
P: 303-964-1986
F: 303-477-4275
1-866-RESI-ENV
www.reilab.com
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100, Denver, CO 80216
Page 1 of 4
RES Job Number:
Client:
Client Project Number / P.O.:
Client Project Description:
Date Samples Received:
Turnaround:
Date Samples Analyzed:
RES 376161-1
WSB & Associates, Inc.
03321-060
MnDOT Bridge 69834 Duluth MN
April 06, 2017
3-5 Day
April 14, 2017
TABLE: PLM BULK ANALYSIS, PERCENTAGE COMPOSITION BY VOLUME
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc.
Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2015
Q:\QAQC\LAB\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
RESERVOIRS ENVIRONMENTAL INC.
NVLAP Lab Code 101896-0
Client
Sample
Number
Lab
ID Number
LAYER
Mineral
Method: EPA 600/R-93/116 - Short Report, Bulk
PhysicalDescription
SubPart
(%)
Visual
Estimate
(%)
ND=None DetectedTR=Trace, <1% Visual EstimateTrem/Act=Tremolite/Actinolite
NonAsbestosFibrous
Components(%)
Non-Fibrous
Components
(%)
Asbestos Content
928#13 EM 1834762 Black adhesiveA 4 TR Chrysotile
1000Black resinous materialB 96 ND
946#14 EM 1834763 Black adhesiveA 3 TR Chrysotile
1000Black resinous materialB 97 ND
964#15 EM 1834764 Black adhesiveA 5 TR Chrysotile
1000Black resinous materialB 95 ND
7030#16 EM 1834765 Black feltA 100 TR Chrysotile
6830#17 EM 1834766 Black feltA 100 2 Chrysotile
6830#18 EM 1834767 Black feltA 100 2 Chrysotile
955#19 EM 1834768 Black adhesiveA TR TR Chrysotile
1000Black caulkB 100 ND
955#20 EM 1834769 Black adhesiveA TR TR Chrysotile
1000Black caulkB 100 ND
TEM Analysis recommended for organically bound material (i.e. floor tile) if PLM results are <1%.
P: 303-964-1986
F: 303-477-4275
1-866-RESI-ENV
www.reilab.com
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100, Denver, CO 80216
Page 2 of 4
RES Job Number:
Client:
Client Project Number / P.O.:
Client Project Description:
Date Samples Received:
Turnaround:
Date Samples Analyzed:
RES 376161-1
WSB & Associates, Inc.
03321-060
MnDOT Bridge 69834 Duluth MN
April 06, 2017
3-5 Day
April 14, 2017
TABLE: PLM BULK ANALYSIS, PERCENTAGE COMPOSITION BY VOLUME
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc.
Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2015
Q:\QAQC\LAB\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
RESERVOIRS ENVIRONMENTAL INC.
NVLAP Lab Code 101896-0
Client
Sample
Number
Lab
ID Number
LAYER
Mineral
Method: EPA 600/R-93/116 - Short Report, Bulk
PhysicalDescription
SubPart
(%)
Visual
Estimate
(%)
ND=None DetectedTR=Trace, <1% Visual EstimateTrem/Act=Tremolite/Actinolite
NonAsbestosFibrous
Components(%)
Non-Fibrous
Components
(%)
Asbestos Content
1000#21 EM 1834770 Black caulkA 100 ND
1000#22 EM 1834771 Gray caulkA 100 ND
1000#23 EM 1834772 Gray caulkA 100 ND
1000#24 EM 1834773 Gray caulkA 100 ND
1000#25 EM 1834774 White caulkA 100 ND
1000#26 EM 1834775 White caulkA 100 ND
1000#27 EM 1834776 White caulkA 100 ND
1000#28 EM 1834777 Yellow adhesiveA 20 ND
3070Brown corkB 80 ND
1000#29 EM 1834778 Yellow adhesiveA 5 ND
3070Brown corkB 95 ND
1000#30 EM 1834779 Yellow adhesiveA 15 ND
3070Brown corkB 85 ND
1000#31 EM 1834780 Black gasketA 100 ND
TEM Analysis recommended for organically bound material (i.e. floor tile) if PLM results are <1%.
P: 303-964-1986
F: 303-477-4275
1-866-RESI-ENV
www.reilab.com
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100, Denver, CO 80216
Page 3 of 4
RES Job Number:
Client:
Client Project Number / P.O.:
Client Project Description:
Date Samples Received:
Turnaround:
Date Samples Analyzed:
RES 376161-1
WSB & Associates, Inc.
03321-060
MnDOT Bridge 69834 Duluth MN
April 06, 2017
3-5 Day
April 14, 2017
TABLE: PLM BULK ANALYSIS, PERCENTAGE COMPOSITION BY VOLUME
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc.
Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2015
Q:\QAQC\LAB\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
RESERVOIRS ENVIRONMENTAL INC.
NVLAP Lab Code 101896-0
Client
Sample
Number
Lab
ID Number
LAYER
Mineral
Method: EPA 600/R-93/116 - Short Report, Bulk
PhysicalDescription
SubPart
(%)
Visual
Estimate
(%)
ND=None DetectedTR=Trace, <1% Visual EstimateTrem/Act=Tremolite/Actinolite
NonAsbestosFibrous
Components(%)
Non-Fibrous
Components
(%)
Asbestos Content
1000#32 EM 1834781 Black resinous materialA 100 ND
6235#33 EM 1834782 Black feltA 100 3 Chrysotile
TEM Analysis recommended for organically bound material (i.e. floor tile) if PLM results are <1%.
Analyst / Data QAAnalystAnalystAnalystAnalyst
P: 303-964-1986
F: 303-477-4275
1-866-RESI-ENV
www.reilab.com
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100, Denver, CO 80216
Page 4 of 4
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2016T:\QAQC\Lab\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
Laboratory Code: RESSubcontract Number: NALaboratory Report: RES 376147-1Project # / PO #: 03321-060Project Description:
RES 376147-1
Sincerely,
April 10, 2017
Dear Customer,
Reservoirs has analyzed the following sample(s) using Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy (AAS) / Atomic EmissionSpectroscopy - Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) per your request. Reported sample results were not blank corrected. Theanalysis has been completed in general accordance with the appropriate methodology as stated in the analysis table.Results have been sent to your office.
property of the customer. Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. will not discuss any part of this study with personnel other thanthose authorized by the client. The results described in this report only apply to the samples analyzed. This report shallnot be reproduced except in full, without written approval from Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. Samples will be disposedof after sixty days unless longer storage is requested. If you should have any questions about this report, please feelfree to call me at 303-964-1986.
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. is an analytical laboratory accredited for the analysis of Industrial Hygiene andEnvironmental matrices by the American Industrial Hygiene Association, Lab ID 101533 - Accreditation Certificate #480.The laboratory is currently proficient in both IHPAT & ELPAT programs respectively.
is the job number assigned to this study. This report is considered highly confidential and the sole
MnDOT - Duluth Br. 69834
Minneapolis MN 55416701 Xenia Avenue South Suite 300WSB & Associates, Inc.
Jeanne Spencer
President
P: 303-964-1986F: 303-477-4275
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100 Denver, CO 80216
Page 1 of 2
1-866-RESI-ENVwww.reilab.com
Reservoirs Environmental, Inc. Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual
Effective January 1, 2016T:\QAQC\Lab\Reservoirs Environmental QA Manual.doc
RES Job Number:Client:Client Project Number / P.O.:Client Project Description:Date Samples Received:Analysis Type:Turnaround:Date Samples Analyzed:
Client Lab Reporting LEAD
ID Number ID Number Limit CONCENTRATION(%) (%)
P-1 EM 1834669 0.0013 0.017
P-2 EM 1834670 0.0038 0.050
Analyst / Data QA:________________________
3-5 Day
RESERVOIRS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC.5801 Logan St., Suite 100
Denver CO 80216
TABLE ANALYSIS: LEAD IN PAINT
RES 376147-1
April 10, 2017
* Unless otherwise noted all quality control samples performed within specifications established by the laboratory.
WSB & Associates, Inc.03321-060MnDOT - Duluth Br. 69834April 6, 2017USEPA SW846 3050B / AA (7420)
BRL = Below Reporting Limit
P: 303-964-1986F: 303-477-4275
5801 Logan Street, Suite 100 Denver, CO 80216
Page 2 of 2
1-866-RESI-ENVwww.reilab.com
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
RE: PCB in Caulk
Minneapolis, MN 55416
April 18, 2017
Work Order Number: 1701458
Bach PhamClient Manager II
WSB & Associates, Inc.
Enclosed are the results of analyses for samples received by the laboratory on 04/05/17. If you have any questions concerning this report, please feel free to contact me.
Results are not blank corrected unless noted within the report. Additionally, all QC results meet requirements unless noted.
All samples will be retained by Legend Technical Services, Inc., unless consumed in the analysis, at ambient conditions for 30 days from the date of this report and then discarded unless other arrangements are made. All samples were received in acceptable condition unless otherwise noted.
All test results and QC meet requirements of the 2003 NELAC standard.
MDH (NELAP) Accreditation #027-123-295
Prepared by,LEGEND TECHNICAL SERVICES, INC
Mr. Jeff Rice
701 Xenia Avenue South, Suite 300
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
Project:
Project Number:
Project Manager:
PCB in Caulk
03321-060 Bridge 69834
Mr. Jeff RiceMinneapolis, MN 55416 04/18/17Date Reported:
WSB & Associates, Inc.
Work Order #: 1701458701 Xenia Avenue South, Suite 300
Sample ID Laboratory ID Date Sampled
ANALYTICAL REPORT FOR SAMPLES
Date ReceivedMatrix
PCB-1 1701458-01 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
PCB-2 1701458-02 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
PCB-3 1701458-03 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
PCB-4 1701458-04 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
PCB-5 1701458-05 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
PCB-6 1701458-06 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
PCB-7 1701458-07 Caulk 04/03/17 00:00 04/05/17 13:05
Shipping Container Information
Default Cooler Temperature (°C):
Received on ice: No Temperature blank was not present Received on ice pack: NoReceived on melt water: No Ambient: Yes Acceptable (IH/ISO only): No
Custody seals: No
Case Narrative:
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
Page 2 of 7
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
Project:
Project Number:
Project Manager:
PCB in Caulk
03321-060 Bridge 69834
Mr. Jeff RiceMinneapolis, MN 55416 04/18/17Date Reported:
WSB & Associates, Inc.
Work Order #: 1701458701 Xenia Avenue South, Suite 300
PCB 8082ALegend Technical Services, Inc.
Result Analyte RL Units Dilution Batch Prepared Analyzed Method Notes MDL
PCB-1 (1701458-01) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/07/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 2.0<2.0 0.023 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 2.0<2.0 0.060 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 2.0<2.0 0.021 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 2.0<2.0 0.018 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1248 2.0<2.0 0.015 1
" " 04/10/17 mg/kgAroclor 1254 18 "36 0.11 9
"" 04/07/17 mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 2.0<2.0 0.013 1
" " 04/10/17 " S-04183 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
" " 04/07/17 "79.5 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
D1PCB-2 (1701458-02) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/11/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 8.0<8.0 0.092 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 8.0<8.0 0.24 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 8.0<8.0 0.084 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 8.0<8.0 0.072 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1248 8.0<8.0 0.060 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1254 8.0<8.0 0.048 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 8.0<8.0 0.052 4
" " " "58.0 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
" " " "72.0 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
D1PCB-3 (1701458-03) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/11/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 8.0<8.0 0.092 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 8.0<8.0 0.24 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 8.0<8.0 0.084 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 8.0<8.0 0.072 4
" " 04/12/17 mg/kgAroclor 1248 100 "310 0.75 50
"" 04/11/17 mg/kg "Aroclor 1254 8.0<8.0 0.048 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 8.0<8.0 0.052 4
" " " "80.0 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
" " " "86.0 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
PCB-4 (1701458-04) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/07/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 2.0<2.0 0.023 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 2.0<2.0 0.060 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 2.0<2.0 0.021 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 2.0<2.0 0.018 1
" " 04/17/17 mg/kgAroclor 1248 100 "250 0.75 50
"" 04/10/17 mg/kg "Aroclor 1254 2.0<2.0 0.012 1
"" 04/07/17 mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 2.0<2.0 0.013 1
" " 04/10/17 " S-04360 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
Page 3 of 7
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
Project:
Project Number:
Project Manager:
PCB in Caulk
03321-060 Bridge 69834
Mr. Jeff RiceMinneapolis, MN 55416 04/18/17Date Reported:
WSB & Associates, Inc.
Work Order #: 1701458701 Xenia Avenue South, Suite 300
PCB 8082ALegend Technical Services, Inc.
Result Analyte RL Units Dilution Batch Prepared Analyzed Method Notes MDL
PCB-4 (1701458-04) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
B7D0706 04/07/17 04/07/17 EPA 8082A81.5 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
PCB-5 (1701458-05) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/07/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 2.0<2.0 0.023 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 2.0<2.0 0.060 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 2.0<2.0 0.021 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 2.0<2.0 0.018 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1248 2.0<2.0 0.015 1
" " 04/10/17 mg/kgAroclor 1254 2.0 "3.7 0.012 1
"" 04/07/17 mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 2.0<2.0 0.013 1
" " " "80.0 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
" " " "80.0 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
PCB-6 (1701458-06) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/07/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 2.0<2.0 0.023 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 2.0<2.0 0.060 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 2.0<2.0 0.021 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 2.0<2.0 0.018 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1248 2.0<2.0 0.015 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1254 2.0<2.0 0.012 1
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 2.0<2.0 0.013 1
" " " "80.0 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
" " " "78.5 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
D1PCB-7 (1701458-07) Caulk Sampled: 04/03/17 00:00 Received: 04/05/17 13:05
EPA 8082A04/07/17 04/11/17 mg/kg B7D0706Aroclor 1016 8.0<8.0 0.092 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1221 8.0<8.0 0.24 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1232 8.0<8.0 0.084 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1242 8.0<8.0 0.072 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1248 8.0<8.0 0.060 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1254 8.0<8.0 0.048 4
"" "mg/kg "Aroclor 1260 8.0<8.0 0.052 4
" " " "54.0 44.2-127 %Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl
" " " "68.0 40-122 %Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
Page 4 of 7
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
Project:
Project Number:
Project Manager:
PCB in Caulk
03321-060 Bridge 69834
Mr. Jeff RiceMinneapolis, MN 55416 04/18/17Date Reported:
WSB & Associates, Inc.
Work Order #: 1701458701 Xenia Avenue South, Suite 300
Result Units LevelSpike
ResultSource
%REC%RECLimits %RPD
%RPDLimit Notes Analyte
PCB 8082A - Quality ControlLegend Technical Services, Inc.
RL MDL
Batch B7D0706 - EPA 3550C
Blank (B7D0706-BLK1) Prepared & Analyzed: 04/07/17
Aroclor 1016 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0023
Aroclor 1221 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0060
Aroclor 1232 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0021
Aroclor 1242 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0018
Aroclor 1248 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0015
Aroclor 1254 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0012
Aroclor 1260 mg/kg< 0.20 0.20 0.0013
mg/kg 0.0667 44.2-127Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl 50.00.0333
mg/kg 0.0667 40-122Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene 47.50.0317
LCS (B7D0706-BS1) Prepared: 04/07/17 Analyzed: 04/10/17
Aroclor 1016 mg/kg 0.333 70-13073.20.244 <0.200.20 0.0023
Aroclor 1260 mg/kg 0.333 70-13070.00.233 <0.200.20 0.0013
mg/kg 0.0667 44.2-127Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl 77.50.0517
mg/kg 0.0667 40-122Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene 78.00.0520
Matrix Spike (B7D0706-MS1) Prepared: 04/07/17 Analyzed: 04/10/17 Source: 1701375-01
Aroclor 1016 mg/kg 3.25 70-13085.22.77 <2.02.0 0.023
Aroclor 1260 mg/kg 3.25 70-13071.72.33 <2.02.0 0.013
mg/kg 0.649 S-0444.2-127Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl NR219
mg/kg 0.649 40-122Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene 80.00.519
Matrix Spike Dup (B7D0706-MSD1) Prepared: 04/07/17 Analyzed: 04/10/17 Source: 1701375-01
Aroclor 1016 mg/kg 3.21 70-13073.3 16.32.35 <2.02.0 0.023 42
Aroclor 1260 mg/kg 3.21 M270-13066.5 8.812.13 <2.02.0 0.013 39.5
mg/kg 0.641 S-0444.2-127Surrogate: Decachlorobiphenyl NR186
mg/kg 0.641 40-122Surrogate: Tetrachloro-meta-xylene 74.00.474
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
Page 5 of 7
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
Project:
Project Number:
Project Manager:
PCB in Caulk
03321-060 Bridge 69834
Mr. Jeff RiceMinneapolis, MN 55416 04/18/17Date Reported:
WSB & Associates, Inc.
Work Order #: 1701458701 Xenia Avenue South, Suite 300
Notes and Definitions
S-04 The surrogate recovery for this sample is outside of established control limits due to a sample matrix effect.
M2 Matrix spike recovery was low, the associated blank spike recovery was acceptable.
D1 Sample required dilution due to matrix.
Sample results reported on a dry weight basis
Relative Percent DifferenceRPD
dry
Less than value listed<
Not applicable. The %RPD is not calculated from values less than the reporting limit.NA
MDL Method Detection Limit; Equivalent to the method LOD (Limit of Detection)
RL Reporting Limit
LCS
MS
Laboratory Control Spike = Blank Spike (BS) = Laboratory Fortified Blank (LFB)
Matrix Spike = Laboratory Fortified Matrix (LFM)
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
Page 6 of 7
88 Empire DriveSt Paul, MN 55103Tel: 651-642-1150Fax: 651-642-1239
Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.
Page 7 of 7
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
AppendixIIBridge69834
StructureLocation,BridgeDrawingsandPhotographs
SiteLocationMapSampleLocationMapsSitePhotographs
SiteLocationMap
Bridge#69834
27thAvenueWestoverI‐35
Duluth,Minnesota
N
Bridge #69834
NOTTOSCALE.
MUSTBEPRINTED
INCOLOR.
SampleLocationMap—BridgeOverview
Bridge#69834
27thAvenueWestoverI‐35
Duluth,Minnesota
Bridge Overview
NOTTOSCALE.
MUSTBEPRINTED
INCOLOR.
1 ‐ Asbestos Sample Loca on (<1% asbestos) 1 ‐ Asbestos Sample Loca on (>1% asbestos) P‐1— Paint Sample Loca on PCB‐1—PCB Sample Loca on (No PCBs Detected) PCB‐1—PCB Sample Loca on (PCBs Detected)
N
P‐1
2
8
12
6 1 5
PCB‐1
PCB‐2
7
32
4 3
31
P‐2
P‐1 11
10
33, PCB‐7
Sample Collected Below Bridge Deck
9
SampleLocationMap—BridgeAbutments
Bridge#69834
27thAvenueWestoverI‐35
Duluth,Minnesota
NOTTOSCALE.
MUSTBEPRINTED
INCOLOR.
West Abutment East Abutment
1 ‐ Asbestos Sample Loca on (<1% asbestos) 1 ‐ Asbestos Sample Loca on (>1% asbestos) P‐1— Paint Sample Loca on PCB‐1—PCB Sample Loca on (No PCBs Detected) PCB‐1—PCB Sample Loca on (PCBs detected)
Slope Slope
Wing Wall Wing Wall
Abutment Abutment
24
21, 15, 18
23
19, 16, 13, PCB‐3 14, 17, 20, PCB‐4
SampleLocationMap—BridgePiers
Bridge#69834
27thAvenueWestoverI‐35
Duluth,Minnesota
NOTTOSCALE.
MUSTBEPRINTED
INCOLOR.
West Pier East Pier
1 ‐ Asbestos Sample Loca on (<1% asbestos) 1 ‐ Asbestos Sample Loca on (>1% asbestos) P‐1— Paint Sample Loca on PCB‐1—PCB Sample Loca on PCB‐1—PCB‐containing Sample Loca on
PCB‐5
30
29 PCB‐6
27
22
28 25 26
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 1 – PCB‐containing (<50 ppm) black caulk at sidewalk seams
Sample 2 – PCB‐containing (<50 ppm) black caulk at sidewalk seams
1
2
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 3 and PCB‐1 – PCB‐containing (<50 ppm) black caulk at sidewalk seams
Sample 4 – Brown expansion felt at sidewalk seam
3,PCB‐1
4
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 5 – Brown expansion felt at sidewalk seam
Sample 6 – Brown expansion felt at sidewalk seam
5
6
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 7 and PCB‐2 – Black caulk at seam on roadway surface
Sample 8 – Black caulk at seam on roadway surface
7,PCB‐2
8
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 9 – Black caulk at seam on roadway surface
Sample 10 – Gray coating on electrical flex conduit
9
10
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 11 – Gray coating on electrical flex conduit
Sample 12 – Amber sealant on sidewalk crack
11
12
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 13 – Black vinyl sheeting with black adhesive at abutment and slope seam.
Samples 14 and 15 – Black vinyl sheeting with black adhesive at abutment and slope seam
13
14,15
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 16 and PCB‐3 – ACM and PCB‐containing (>50 ppm) black bituminous felt between abutment and slope
Samples 17 and 18 – ACM and PCB‐containing (>50 ppm) black bituminous felt between abutment and slope
16,PCB‐3
17,18
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 19 – PCB‐containing (>50 ppm) black/gray, joint filler between abutment and slope
Samples 20 and PCB‐4 – PCB‐containing (>50 ppm) black/gray joint filler between abutment and slope
19
20,PCB‐4
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 21 – PCB‐containing (>50 ppm) black/gray joint filler between abutment and slope
Sample 22 – PCB‐containing (<50 ppm) gray caulk at base of concrete guardrail
21
22
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 23 and PCB‐5 – PCB‐containing (<50 ppm) gray caulk at base of concrete guardrail
Sample 24 – PCB‐containing (<50 ppm) gray caulk at base of slope seam
23,PCB‐5
24
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 25 and PCB‐6 – White caulk over cork spacer between pier and concrete barrier seam
Samples 26 and 27 – White caulk over cork spacer between pier and concrete barrier seam
25,PCB‐6
26,27
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 28 and 29 – ½‐inch cork spacer with yellow adhesive between pier and concrete barrier
Sample 30– ½ inch cork spacer with yellow adhesive between pier and concrete barrier
28,29
30
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample 31 – Black gasket at electrical box
Sample 32 – Black rubber gland at roadway surface seam
31
32
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Samples 33 and PCB‐7 – Asbestos‐containing black bituminous felt at southwest wing wall seam
Sample P‐1 – Red paint on structural steel I‐beams
33,PCB‐7
P‐1
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Sample P‐2 – Gray/brown paint on steel utility conduit
Typical of green‐treated posts at metal guardrails
P‐2
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Typical of pole‐mounted LED lights at the bridge
Lead sheet plates between concrete guardrail and metal guardrail post.
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Lead sheet plates at bearing assemblies
An electric core drill was used to inspect for 3‐ply joint waterproofing behind the construction joint at the east mask wall, but none was identified.
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Concrete core and metal backing identified in/behind the mask wall
Typical of vinyl clad wiring identified in the LED light pole bases
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportMnDOT–Bridge69834
S.P.6982‐322Duluth,Minnesota
Bridge plate identification
AsbestosandRegulatedWasteAssessmentReportBridge69834,27thAvenueWestoverI‐35Duluth,Minnesota
AppendixIIIBridge69834
Licenses&Certifications
Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, section 144.99, this licensemay be suspended or revoked for failure to conduct asbestos-related work in compliance with applicable regulations.
Issued on: January 10, 2017License Number: AC875
Asbestos Contractor License
Minnesota Department of Health
To:
Asbestos-related work must be conducted according to MinnesotaStatutes, sections 326.70 to 326.81 and Minnesota Rules,parts 4620.000 to 4620.3724.
WSB & Associates Inc.701 Xenia Ave S
Suite 300Minneapolis, Minnesota 55416-
Responsible Individual: Ryan G. Spencer
This license is valid from February 16, 2017 to February 15, 2018.
Thomas P. Hogan, DirectorEnvironmental Health Division