+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

Date post: 14-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: samuel-l-rivers
View: 216 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 26

Transcript
  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    1/26

    For Immediate ReleasePress ConferenceWhen: Thursday, October 17, 2013, 9 A.M.Where: Cecil H. Parker Elementary School-416 South 6 th Avenue, Mount Vernon, NYFor More Information Contact: Samuel L. Rivers 914.760.8136

    COMMUNITY LEADER TO DEMAND INVESTIGATION IN ABESTOS COVER UPMount Vernon, NY October 16, 2013- Community Activist Samuel L. Rivers has obtained officialdocuments from the New York State Department of Health that details an ongoing problem with moldand asbestos at the Cecil H. Parker Elementary School.

    On December 5, 2012 NYSDOH inspectors conducted an inspection to assess compliance with theAsbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act (AHERA). During the inspection multiple deficiencies wereidentified. In the report report inspectors found that Asbestos Containing Materials (ACM) are beingpoorly managed and there is a lack of surveillance. According to AHERA inspectors periodic inspectionsof ACMs are required every six months and this has not been performed since 2005. Inspectors alsonoted that the last triennial inspection conducted in 2010 was not thorough. Inspectors also noted thatthere are damaged materials that exist in the school buildings, which should be a priority for response.There was also several cases of mold throughout Cecil H. Parker Elementary school.

    What is even more disturbing is that the City School District of Mount Vernon had a dedicated andtrained asbestos person that received compensation above his regular pay grade to remediate the ACM.John Zambelli, former maintenance foreman for the buildings and grounds department has sinceresigned and a replacement has not been trained to handle ACM.

    The reports dated December 5, 2012 and February 5, 2013 were addressed to Judith Johnson. Johnson incollusion with School Board Vice President Len Sarver hid reports from the other eight school boardmembers. Sarver was the chairperson of the buildings and grounds committee, a committee that directlyoversaw the buildings and grounds department. Sarver is now seeking to bring in a firm he is affiliated

    with that will cost taxpayers $700 per day to oversee the asbestos abatement. The firm is Fuller DAngelo.According to the Fuller DAngelo website fullerdangelo.com they are not licensed by the New York StateDepartment of Labor to remove ACM.

    Adrienne Saunders, who now chairs the buildings and grounds committee has not seen these reportsneither has the other eight school board members. They are attached for public distribution.

    ACMs if airborne and inhaled can lead to severe respiratory problems including lung cancer.

    Attending the press conference will be Samuel L. Rivers, community leaders and parents of children thatattend Cecil H. Parker Elementary School.

    ###

    Reference Phone #s

    Trustee Adrienne Saunders- Current Chair of Buildings and Grounds (914) 774-8909

    Trustee Len Sarver-Former Chair of Buildings and Grounds (845) 656-3985

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    2/26

    NewYork stateDepartmenlof llealth AHllRAAudit/InspectlionReportMountVernonCitYSchoolDistrict '.JudithJohnsonnuPerintendent165NorthColumbusvenue, ountVernon' Y 10553December,7017

    ) Inspected:CeeilH. ParkerElementary chool

    OBJ IVEThe iveof thisAsbestosHazafiEmergencyesponsect (AHERA) nspectionat !? determinef thenonityschoorist,[lisi;;fiiffi; wrtnHnRn$']1iii::^.]:::i:t'ih this bjective'il1":"idffirl"i"*.a and walk-throughnspectionas onductedllCecil 'ParkerstiEI School nDecembet,2012.

    ND INFOR]VIATION

    due o moisture ndmold ssues.

    BA(ThecomThe

    tment receiveda complaint rom the united statesErnvironmental rotectlonAgency(EPA)' Theori i atedhan""";t;;; phonealrece'yd"lLltY::l'"l*ll:: l#" T::l'L?:lli#*'ilH,f!}}fiffiffi;;ffi;;,fiil rbiir"e"ff"r;ciosetoorhatadbeensedosealffrntaininsmaterialipaclassroomcloset.Uponinspection,itwasdetermiTl,tllllT5&'!|ifi:?iiffi'dffi;ffiffi;;ffiil;' oJ*ie'"thetosets.he losetsereapedffto

    audDe1

    r of AHERA nspection asprovidedo the Vlount ernon ity schoolDistrictvia U's' mailon13,2012. n Decembr5,20l2NewYorkstaieD:partmen!f

    HealthNYsDoH) nspectorssee;ffi#:,ffiffiilffiil;;;;;".oJ*,,ui**. porrions.fhe ecilH.Parkerchoold andaclosing onferJnceasheld o reviewhepreliminaryindings f theAHERA:ieswere dentifieduringheaudi'inspectionhatmust eaddressedsperAHERA egulations'ficiencies longwithothJrobservations/recommendalionsreoutlinedbelow'Please ote hatalltuilOing oJationswerenot nspected,herefore therdeficiencies ayexist'

    Y OF FINDINGSANDRECOMMENDATION$Asbestosontaining aterialsACM)arebeing ooily.managednd heresa ackof surveillance'nseof surveitlances to identifydamageduitiiil" anaaOdrellaccordingly'n;riofic.s-11i:t]lT::.t:every6 monthsand hishasnoi been ,erform"d in"r, 2005' Therearedamagedmaterialshatexist

    n;taing, whichshouldbe a priority fo i response. he last riennial e-inspection2010) wasnot-emenfBecauseof this, the Uuiiding inlentoriei of ACM ar:eunreliable making asbestosmanagementSignificant pdatesreneedid o theAsbestos anagementlan'ote hat deficiencies,bservationsnd recornmendlationsentioned lbove re or thosespecificreviewedand ocations isited;however,is stronglyrecommendedllat ft: 1Et,l"]3 i"-':^::il-observationsndrecommendationsnAuru lium o matri mprovementsn rl l LEA records

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    3/26

    Ne!ryork stateDepartmentofHmrthArl*RAAudit/*spoetion ReportCTOSINGCON},ERENCESIGN.INSIIEET

    o?:tc't!$br5nn '$fl

    $' . !

    \-$,r:.1f F ' { u t rift* *r $ f"V d ) * ; ; ,F fl ;., .:'.{ i ,j-' ii' b $ . ;

    T r n $f $ '*:, d ra : i $ Ef l ; f r , g* S r i i i '0f 'ti l:!i d tbl\"r

    il,{!t$FFHF

    ' ;I:ii rltI

    a\t\'[

    I

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    4/26

    Mount VernonCi{g SchoolDistrict165NorthColumbus venueMountVernonNY 10553NYSDOHCorningTower, Room 1325Empire StirtePlazaAlbany, NY L2737

    Dateof IruPectiion:Nameof lndividual to WhomNotice s Given:SuperintendentJudith Johtlson

    ffi F "86-*"iendent/ LEA RepresentativeIVIountVernon City Schooi listrict165North ColumbusAveuueMount Vernon NY 10553The folthereto list

    of potentialdeviationsrom the ffi ffi d regulationsromulgated

    DesignatedPen;on:Notincation:- 7/ge"/

    /' /tut+ 4-a q}/"fr/ /'+'o*'17l,,:::",------r:-*' */:4 ':- /ft ,."'l'/A\ -fo'r* req.utr4/../.-" ,&fr art tj '; r-7'tt fRe-inspection:Bulk Sampling:periodicsuweilianqe:.noa< fui.f C^/*/ '4te/ 16 /"f " ;trrei//roalManagementlan: 4 < .b c-/ /o#Response ctions:operationsndMaintenance:4 v-/ I /t ''4tr'warninglabeki:{ort( /q//i n&A/:::-:rrrEa=--T h e S u m m a r y o f o b , " * u s e a r . a s o f c o n c e r n a t t h e e a r 1 i e s t p o s s i b l e t i m e . I t i sintended o bLa complereist of p;bntial deviatiois fiom therequirements f theToxic Substances onlrol Act and egulationsthereto,ut rather ist of those onclitionsf imme{iate oncern nd/orhoseeadily pparent'

    lintr to nHfRA guidance ools are ocatedat the fQllowingEPA websiLte: ltlr: rvu'iv.epa.gov'rrestouu-4/alreraName/Titleof LEA Representative: 'l5o\^,.-r^b"Ll, wylwneevin Malone, Section Chief

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    5/26

    \ .Ne,

    I

    FOR]1{i!u::r:.:r YorkStrteDeDOCUMENTS

    of llealth AttERAAudit/.InspectionRlrporr

    A uri$i!tfrFs

    '}d.fitt; & Pffi ]tf l |l}fi a.:sfi tr>.di 1$cirlq tf;a}{6jt'l.tt*l{t c*l$0ltmLrfirFrffiF0csn*ffis

    *d'_p.f,m&, LFA$IHASIil#snntVenmnlty $dr*r*Dt*rrl*rDAITltH! H

    $'tsFFgrsftl{to,r{{* usr|.f$Eifr#A nn,f,. rug$wrcnrooecs* d, i.f;r l(rn+Fssliifs$r vsr!fi flry SrdrsolOfrlr{eil{it f*n*t f rdnarh.| A}trra*f,{u*uf.?rlenr, li{y t0tciI

    FidrHffi0f{ lFA VSi Snp*ru fUris*rn mEy erilofirlol@fdBeffin&fion ,Srtcs d&dto,c$*rffi *b rmfuqryhdgn$rtl th*, oeum;,S r*dlrlcwsrtibsy nnfnr'frmenrt rl situXSactJiiriiiiOrsaon* *aiFESCffTBE0$Hlffikxl*i*-i SF.$ SR lFT l f ] t t f . - f f i ' ' " r I ' ' ' %SfcfirPToFoCIcufignt#cLt ;"a,f i ,t" ' t , ".:-*i '" t*,s i ,d;d:' \. rr x- " { tx*+**,.,. *;1 :i i* ,i+so.*." ,L"r.^-^.., _i"*y.,c,""*t Lu" r 1*, *t;.u. "' ] . \ h i ' d , i . i ; . . -

    ' i i \ f** r ."d_"". ' ,' . .-..i ' * *, . . . r . . . " , ! - L - a. ,

    / " ' , : r it l : 1 r ' { , . e . *i , t " , ; , "

    ' i 1

    $$4 .*-.q "t ..f ! . . i, -fite- a.t,

    8.&{.5;G.7"

    u

    &st&t l,13,t&14.16'rraif7,lla' lre.l.10:

    'i

    r|'tsPEfi

    Wr#Afl trA qEP?ESttNTefiVF$t6trtA?{JR1 1 , i,J!- i,'" r.,l'" "ttAftlft(cdhnd,tr0t! l +A [ , t t s l , ' 1 i :\ . i - Y 4 . t ) f , " , r . . i . fri{}. iru r'" {.,:J ,l"r"-; l'.i4 i i ,

    Sioff rftqdd PATf; SlGl'lHt.f ITrTtErg1,r.c,,,ff$L{ :nt r " - . . - . DAWSIGNEOi r-.,8'it,

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    6/26

    +9y -Asbestos-ContainingMarerial+!Py

    -Asbestos-containiigil;i;;;"f fl*o-lsbesros*il fi;;;;+|[A -American"orrrri.rTyeiil"ilyl - Asbestos anagemenrlanllso -NySDoLzN-ycnn uit'souDP-AHERA Designatederson3,,OO,-, t'ironmeitaf f.aUo*toiyIIA -_u.s.nvironmen,"til;;;",tFS * FunptionalSpaceI]?PA High- ffi iencyarricutateAirHA - HomogeneousArea

    !.E.1t^..".a1Ed carinAgencylY]gsg - Nationalnstitut"eoiOccuparicilYl*k *t'i:"ir, :"n,u",uuo.J,J.,N_YsDoHNew*t sr"ir"n urr*ili,liIlDOL - New orkState*O**r", "yYlEDNeworkstateJd;;;9*y - OperarionsndMaint"nun."g:Ij -occuparionarur"iy-iJ iJattir:i:l"r - rresumedAsbestos_ContaininE+vourrrsurrsoeslos_Uontaining Ml9lrl - PhaseContrasrvticroscof;- "llM - polarizedLightMicros;$iTEM Transmissionlectronttior.opyTSI - ThermalSystemnsulationVAT- VinylAsbestos ile (FloorTile)

    ERA Acronyms

    Actiationregulations

    al Program

    SafetyandH.ealthccreditation rogram'HealthLabor

    inistrationial

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    7/26

    Newrrbrk State t of HestthAHERAAUdit/InspectionReport

    for custodittlandmaintenanceing information? f* Yes [;i No f N/ATraining; ecordsshouldinclude ourse imesandshow hata minimumof 2hours s dedicated o asbestosawarenssraining.

    763.ea(a)(t)

    it; 763.e2(a)(2)

    -t63.94(c) Do the traistaff ncludehePprson'sameDate rainingLocationof trainNumberof hours

    job title?

    pleted?Note:Course also recomm,endedo show

    short-term orkerswhomayith asbestosn tlhe chool)withthe ocationsfACBM?

    in writing pargnts.eaghers.ndof theavailabilitvf theas equired?s here dated oPY f

    f* Yes 17No f N/Aid heLEAcomentoinformationNote: Sign-in

    |ir Yes f- No f N/AThenotificationsprovidedyearlynr heschool alendar.

    Did heLEAmanagementthenotification?

    |7 Yes f- No f N/A

    f* ves |7 No r* N/AMustdevelop plan ortraining ithin60days fhire.

    f* Yes [- No 17N/AO&M is not conductedYschool mployees.

    minimumfqllowingopics:Informationeffectsoocationswhich hey work,and ocationofWashis raining

    asbestoswarenessrainingon heing asbestos sesand orms,healthACBM in eachschoolbuilding nition of damage,he DPname

    within69d.aysf hire?

    resultn thedisturbancef ACBMof additionalraining, here

    55O&M(minimum)icensingired

    aativities hatwi lreceivedheapplicable?Note:NYSDOLand ertification

    complianceith .e2(aXl)

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    8/26

    l* Yes l- No F N/A

    I* Yes f* No |7 N/A

    assesEmentgf friablematerialdate andaccreditati-6n?

    t forclassiffingheACBMandassumedo beAIOMn theschoolf the following categories?damagedSIACM.

    friable surfacingACM.icantly arnagedriablemisc.ACM.ial for damage.ial or significantamage.bleor suspectedlACBM.Actions763.90)or requirements

    #24

    #25

    New York State t of HealthAllERAAudit/InspectionRerport

    mpling areawh,erematerialwasand, fpossible, he exact ocations

    ?63.88(aX2)763.85(a)(a)ff)

    763.88(b)

    ( l )(:2)(3)(4)(s)(6)(7\'/63.93(eX2)

    (i)(i )

    the nspectoratrd ncludea

    Did he nspectorwrittensrirspectedCBblrilding nto oneDamagedr siQamagedriableSignificantlyQamagedr siACBMwithACBMwithAnyremainingNote: SeeFor each conducted efirreJ2114/87,bestlle management include:'llhedateof the ton. [* Yes [* No P N/A

    f* Yes [- No |7 NiAblueprint, or writtendescriptionf eachschoolbuilding identifies learlyeachocation ndor linear ootage fanYpproximatelpmogeneousrspmpledorACIIwhere ulkepllection. werecollectecl, nd he datesofA copyofthe yses f anybulk. amPles,ates f f- Yes l* No |7 N/Aanalyses, nda ofanyother aboratoryePortspertainingo the

    (iv)29 A descriptionf l- Yes l- No F N/Arneasuresakenif possible,he and addresses fall contractorsinvolved,tart completionat,esf thework,andrBsultsf anyai analyzeduringanduPoncompletionf work.A descriptionfqnder 763.88, requriredobemade f- Yes

    [* No la N/Amaterialthatwas dentifiedbeforeDecember 4. IquspectedCB , as riableACBM or friableassumedo be A,CM,and he nameand signature, S of accreditation,and if applicable,accreditation

    ly response ctionsor preventivereduceasbestos xposure,ncluding

    theassessments. of eachaccncditedersonmaking

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    9/26

    NewYork State of ,HealthAIIERA Audit/InspeetionRtrport

    #37 763.85(bXr) Did heLEAconrnonfiiable nownbuildinghat heyschool uilding,

    ucta reinspecliotlf all friableandor assumedCBM in each choollease, wn,or otlrerwiseseasa: east once everv three vears?

    l* Yes [- No 17N/A

    #38 763.85(bX2)763.e3(eX3Xi) Were ll reinspecinspector ndareplan?onsconductedyanaccreditedhere ignatures;n hemanagement lF Yes [* No T N1A

    Signedbut not dated.

    #39#40

    #41

    #42

    #43

    #44

    763.8s(bX3)

    (i)(i )

    ( i i i)

    (iv)

    (v)

    (vi)

    Foreacheie4chperson

    areaof a scltoolbuilding,didga reinspection:

    Visuallyeinspeci,nd eassessonder 763'88,hecondition f all frfiablenown rat;sumedCBM?Visuallynspect iraterialhatwaspreviouslyconsideredonfrifible CBM and ouchhematerialodetermine hethdrt hasbecomerriableincehe astinspectionr rein$pection?Identiffanyhomfgeneousreas ithmaterialthatasbpcomeriable ihcehe ast nsperctionrreinspection?Cofectbulksamplesndsubmitur analysis763,86and763.8?)or e[chhomogeneousrea f newlyfriablematerial$at s already ssumedo beACBM?Assess,nder 7Ol.gt, hecondition f thenewlyfriablematerialit areas here amplesrecollected,andnewly riabl! materialsn area,shatareassumedobeACBM?Reassess,nder 763.88,hecondition f friableknown r assumld CBMpreviouslydentified?

    The Ins;oector id not conducta thorourghe-inspectionorthe2010 riennial.

    l* Yes F No f N1A

    [- Yes F No T N/A

    f* Yes f- No P- N/A

    l* Yes [* No |7 NiA

    l* Yes [- No l7 N/A

    l* Yes l* No P N/A

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    10/26

    NewYork StateDepa t ofiHealth,AlflERA udi#InspectionR:eport

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    11/26

    \ NewYork StateDepartmentof HealthAIIERAAUdit/InspectionR,eport

    #98 763.e4(g) Foreachime hr763.91{e)asSname, ignature,performingheaof theactivity,hoccurred, descrname nd ocaticACM?Note:NESHAPf

    t rnajor sbestosctivitY nderrformed, idtheJLEA rovidehemdacmeditationf each ersonrtivity,hestartandcompletionatesI locations here,suchctivityptionand fACElM is removed,her ofstorage rdisposaliteofthenotification requrired

    f- Yes [- No |7 N/A

    #99 763.er(fx|) Did heLEA useminor iber eleathedescribedroceduresftera;eepisodefallingor dislodgingf 3nc dental isturbancerocedures

    l- Yes f* No 17NiAsq. tllf or less)?Note:NYSDOL

    #100 763.el(f)(2) Did theLEA usefibqr release pirthan 3 sq. ft/lf)?Note:AHERA clincidental istut:

    the describedprccedures fter a majotrde(fallingor dislodging f more

    ]arance ampling ndNYSDOL,ance rocedures

    [- Yes l- No F N/A

    # l 0 r 763.94(h) Does he manag(fiber release pitDateand ocatioMethodof repairPreventivemeasNameof eachptIfACBM sremstoragenddisp

    ment lan nclud,e record f eachde with he olkrwingnformation:roftheepisode?)re or responsectionaken?sonperformin$hework?ved, hename nrdocation f thesalsiteof theACM?

    l- Yes l- No F N/A

    sl+";ltj:ifi#ffiffi&.s#102 763.95(a)763.84(e) Did the LEA attaadjacent o any fin routinemaintt

    ni. air"n"rrllocationsand rerlabeleds remov

    chwaryrineabel:immediatelYriableandnonfrizrbleCBM locatedInance reas?

    ;;;[dt;qh],ec-in readiy visiblenainposted ntiltheACBMthat s

    l* Yes F No f NiASome labels have been Placeddirectly nACBM Picture4). Laloelings missingnsome reaspicture ).

    #t03 763.e5(b) l* Yes f- No tr N/A

    #104 763.95(c) Does hewarninvisible n largesCAUTION:AS IDO NOT DISTITRAININCAN

    l label ead, n printwhieh s readilyzeor bright colorr?ESTOS.HAZATI.DOUS.RB WITHOUT PROPER) EQUIPMENT.

    F Yer; l- No T N/A

    N/A= NotApplicable r NotAssessed

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    12/26

    NewYorkState of HealthAIIERA AudiUlnspectionReport

    #82 763.eo(ix2xi)Wereaggressiveaccreditedersorclearanceir samplesollectedbyanr)after esponsections? [- Yes [- No |a N/A

    #83 763.e0(ixzxii) Did heLEA use(AIHA)or TEManalysis ftera rm accreditedaboratoryor PCMNVLAP)air clearanceamplingsponse ction?

    f- Yes [- No l7 N/A

    #84 763.e0(ix3) For esponsectwere J air samlrnsgreaterhan l60sq; t./260f.,escollectedndanalyled yTEM? l* Yes l- No |7 N/A#85#86

    763.eO(ix4)763.e0(ix5)

    FoTTEManalys

    For esponsectft.12601f.0ereby PCM NloslNote orNYSUliters ollected?

    ;was 199 itersor greaterollected?rns esshanor equalo 160 q.air$amplesollectedndanalyzed7400)?L Part 6:was>2LPMand>1200

    f- Yes l* No ta NiA

    [* Yes l* No tu NiA

    #87 763.94(a) Did heLEA retireinspectionorACBM hasbeenin recordsor 3 y'earsfter henextrach omogeneoutsreawhere llrernoved?

    l* Yes [* lto 17N/A

    #88

    #89

    763.e4(b)

    ( l )

    (2\

    Did rhe LEA manea.su-rend reslnonfriableACBIACBM assumedA detailedwritteincludingmethomeasure r actiomeasure r actiowork, namesantand f applicableaccreditationnurnameand ocitirACM.The nameand siair sample equiof certain resp"orlocationswherecollection,he n;analyzingthesaof theanalysis,signature f thestatementhat threquirementsf

    rtain records or eachBrplrentiveonseaction taken or friable andI and riable andnonfriablesuspectedio beACM including:r description f tlhemeasure r action,s used, he ocationwhere her wastaken, easonsor selecting her,startandcomplletion atesof theaddressesf al l r;ontractorsnvolved,their Stateof ac,oreditation,ndrbers. nd fACIlM is removed,hen of storage r disposal iteof the

    inature f anyperson ollectingany:d to be collected t thecomPletionie actions pecified y $ 763.90(i), heampleswerecolllected, ateofme and address f the aboratorYrples, he dateof analysis,he resultsremethodof anallysis,he narneandersonperforming heanalysis,and ar aboratorymeets he aPPlicable763.e0(ix2xii),

    l* Yes f- No |7 N/A

    Yes l-- No |a N/A

    t-.-

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    13/26

    NewYork StateDepartmeirt f Health AllERA.Audit/InspectionBleport

    #qs'#66#67#68

    763.e3(e)(e) Does hemanagerecommendationrA plan or reins!A plan fbr(includingA plan or ppfiodA descriptionfrecommendation763.91(c)(2),s1program,nd hethat ecommenda

    mentplan ncludehe ollowing

    octionequired;nder63.85?ionUandmaintenancegtivitiescleaning)equirerdnder 63.91?ic suwejll4ircqequired nder 63.92?the naJragementlannefsforadditionalle4ningnderrartof anoperatirlnsndmaintenanceresponsef the ,EAto:ion?

    l* Yesr * No Fr N/Af- Yesi [- No li' N/Af* Yes l- No F N/Al* Yesr * No |7 N/A

    #69 763.93(eXl) Does he manageresourc.eseededreinspections,pperiodic urveillrment lan nclud,enevalu4tionfto carryout response ctionsoerationsand maintenance. ndnce and rainingll

    [* Yesr f* No 17N/A

    #70 763.e3(g(2) Did heLEAmaicomplete, pdateschoolundertsntain n itsadministrativegffiped copy of a management lan for eachrdministrativeontrol rdirection?

    f" Yesr F No l* NleNot updated/complete-

    #71 763.e3(eX3) Did each ntain in its admiqistrAtive ffice acomplete, copy of the marnagementlan forthatschool,and ke theplanavailablewithoutcostorrestriction s

    f* Yesr Ii' No f N/ANot updated/complete.

    ffiffi#72#73

    #7i

    763.90(a)

    ?63.r06t--*-

    ffiDid the LEA coriduct esponse cl;ionsn a time.lymanne{ onsisteftwith assessmenits?Were hese esp{nseactionssufficient to protecthumanhealthand heenvironment?For Category) damage{ r. ignificantlydam4gedTSl, didtheLEAat east eoair hedamagedreaorremovehedamriged aterial ndmaintain ll TSI andits coveringn ari ntac! tate ndgndamagedcondition?

    f* Yes f* No |7 N/Al* Yes [* No |7 N/A

    f* Yes Fl No f N/ATSI in custodial toragerea(pictures and5)andn thebasementear heelevator(picture ).

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    14/26

    New York Sta$e of HealthATIERAAudit/InspectionReport

    763.e2(b)(t) Did heLEAcorfducteriodicurveillangqn eachbuildinghat t l$ases,wns, rotherwiseses saschool uildinghatcontainsCIIM or s assumedocontain CBM dt g3st nc.e verysix monjhs?[* Yer; |7 No f N/ATherehaven't een nY ince2005andmanyarmissingprior o thatyear.l* Yes F No T N/A63.e2(b)(2)763.94(d) Did theperson periodic urveillancevisually that are identified n themanagement asACBM, record he datqof thesurveillance,i andanyqhangqsn theconditionof the andsutrmit recordo theDP or i in the management lan?

    [* Yes I- No l7 N/Aid theLEA akeandhaveanalyzedufficient ulksamplesromea$h omogeneousrea, ot assumedobeasbestos?3 samples inimum up o 1000 q. t.5 samples inimum100l-5000q. t.7 samples inimum>5000 q. t.TSI3 samples inimumI sample inimqm fpatches 6 sq. t. or f.In a mannerufficiento determin,e2 rnin.) or fittingsM sc-elaneouSfriable)ln amannerufficiento determino2min.)ln a manner ufficient o determine2 min.)

    includehe ollowinginformation nttJrenalysis f thebulksamplesndhasit been ubmiuedo heDP or nc;lusionn theplanwithin30days f theanalysis:Copies f theanflysis f anybulk. amplesollectedandanalyzed, {meandaddressf any aboratoryhatanalyzedulk safnples, statementhatany aboratoryusedmeetshealplicableaboratoryccreditationrequirementsf p0CFR$ 763.87(a),ates f anyanalyses erforniedand he nameand signatureof thepersonperformifigeachanalysis

    #s3

    (aXl)(aX2)(aX3)(bxl)(bx2)(bx3)(c)(d )763.87(d)763.93(eX3Xiv)

    l- Yes l- No F N/A

    lg!1rE:III F":rry.d"d

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    15/26

    ,NewYork StateDepartme4t of HealthAllERAAudit/Inrpection Report

    SUMMARYOF OBSERVATIONS

    L*"{Nlfis't$kwfl*larilt Ycrreq fllt} 6ehml tltrlttrt165 iorfr Cs{xwttl* Armutllluurt Urmce ilY l{'Ss.}Crrdnglbnrr,H${s lffiif,b$rt$al*FkrrAllnnyn YT ltl?

    $rtd.t*vf Ql $4lds't{itffltf xt: i.$..'l }L"$lwmrc$w:k{$rint \iilnsh tlrr-t fi*tcrltr llrl*rr klIrdrkls*l tor,ti-huijN$ti*{ i} {:ht*:sctrsh&sd.nt Jnffdih rrhrrn

    !{srtfts&n:ifti{ $ &re$f 4a r*/i*&/ }*2s*,$n t#,X- \\,-* /tn*! *ffo*$ (/try* \\.$ir,ar ,tr**^/.r*&* $rfr**,n .i rTtrf

    lfft|$$d r$be l ronrplere itt $f tt$tsn$al Lrnrr*nftn$linrtmilerrrar olsoaM n{SK*{rliic$fpfftiitfttfifin lt l*ostfrr,nrAe ffid;t s$sn{.q}f |hc {$(h $[b$*{tt&ssrofi* .{{t attl nr{Plilffithcrdn,hut{dxrr lirr rr{ttn}xcsrndnirnaof cnnffm ilxU{il.dlrxr n'onli{ypprurnr,

    r", ir-.*;gn.*,".;*4*e4ii"Jlijt:frilj$S&!lt*e' tgpp"af,.fixairCfl$rh ill||om. $$driot ( ht4f

    5 f t * --^,.-^-,6,.- , 'L--****,s"***" ' -- , "",. I

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    16/26

    . { 1

    ii.*tg \# \* \:!lh"trs

    * n ?; i { j S F* " f r . r l |1 & rii itl , I *

    NeryYorh$tateDepr"t**f of1lealthA1il0RAAndit/InspetionReport

    nkfY?"t r * l\. ,,LAfrIii 1l L 'r:gh'It'i1*s*{t',.1:1 l,$:{lr,i*lrfit'

    q.TFi-*;rf?,rbq . t.ii {rw r i l'*uflwI H

    . Fr *F',FSi l " {i { ) lr i &I

    .R)r.LA

    i E ' 'l *,ftr

    t",f, H"iq;b {f**-*

    trlflF!ea{rrc$

    i/t }{r i . s H{ U . r: l 5 i d$ ' ss sl f zS { i{* tst4C'o $,t$i Iiht\.F ',Jr $! !S*!o El it$ $ , $d ds s

    H i l *; ! F " F& t i *f t s tg 8r *& rg $E . Hi l t L,f-r ;[

    t q l

    OPENING CONFERENCESIGN-IN SHEET

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    17/26

    NewYork$tateDepadmentof HealthAfitERAAudit/InspectionReport

    Has.hedeS!nalederson.receiveddequaterai ingon hehealth ffects fasbestos,etection,identification,ndassessmentfACM,optionsorcontrollingACBM,sbestosanagemenfrogramsand egulationsoncemingsbestosin orderoproperly erform is/her uties?

    Has psrsgn.beenesisnatedo ensurehatrequirementsf theAHERA egulationsreproperlyimplemented?F Yes f* No f NiAJohn ambellis hedesignatr:derson.763.84(g)(2) P Yes l- No f N/AMr.Zambelli as adO&Mtraining.We ecommendDesignatedersonraining.

    763.e3(e)@) Doeshernanagementlancontainhename, ddress,and elephoneumber f theDesigmatedersonandthecourse amennddates ndhours f trainingaken?

    l- Yes [* No ta N/A

    [* Yes |7 No T N/AThe "Consultantand LEAInformationand Sign:off'provided n the2010 riennialdoesnot comply with theexpectations rovidedby theEPA or anAHERA TrueandCoffectSlatement.

    Doesheman4gementlancontain trueandqgrrectstate{nenl,^sjgneUythe ndividual lesignatedeison,whichcertifieshanhegeneral EAresponsiUititieshave eenmetor will bemet?Note:Statementhould esigned y c.urrent p

    763.e3(e)(0)

    763.e3(g(a)

    Does he managemgnt lan havea glrssripjionolstepgfo:

    Inform workersandbuildinqoccupar[g.or their legalguardrans,bout nqpections,einsperctions,esponseactions, ndpost,responsectionactivities,nciudingperiodic einspectionsndsurveillancectivities haiareplannedor in progress?Notift in writing,at easr nceayear;parent.teacher.managementlan or review?Havegplkpfs 4nd buildingoccqpants, G.i. f"gulguardians, een nbrmed at leasionei:eachschoolysalabout inspections,esponse ctions,andpost_response ctionactivities,ncludingprariodireinspectionndsurveillancectivities hatareplannedor in progress?

    The2010 e-inspectioneportdiscussesotification, utadesmiptionf stepssnotincluded.rleedo developanddefine teps/ roceduresfornotifications.f-- Yes Fi No f* N/A

    f* Yes l" No f N/A

    l* Yes f- No l"- N/A763.84(c)

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    18/26

    NewYork stateDepartment fHealthAllERAAudit/InepectionReport

    f- Yes [- tVo 17NiA

    f* Yes f* No Fr N/A

    tVas ach nspectiqnonductedy anaccreditedinspectornd sthgre signaturen themanagementplan?f- Yes l* No |7 NiA

    l- Yes l* No |7 N/A

    [- Yes [- No F N/A

    f- Yes [* No ls N/Af- Yes f- No l? N/A

    f- Yes [-'No |7 N1A

    f* Yes l* No |i' N/A

    # t 7

    # r 8

    # t 9#20

    #21#22

    (A)(B)

    (c)(D)

    763.8s(aXaXvi)

    Did theLEA visually nspect ll arers o idgntiqv ll_locations f suspectmaterials, oth I'riable nd non-friable, n eachschbolbuilding?For eachhomogengousrea hat is n,otassumedto beACM,did theLEA collect ndsubmit oranalysis ulk sampfes?Has he ollowine ;rforFatiqn,abouthe nspectionbeen ecorded ndgubmittedo the Dp for inclusion nthe managementl4nwithin30 daysof the nspection?Dated nspection eportsignedby acr:reditednspector.Inventoryof the exqct ocationsof the homogeneousareaswheresampleB erecollectedanddates hatsamples erecolleoted.Description f thernanner sed o determine amplinglocations.List of whetherhe homogeneousreimdentifiedaresurfacingmaterial,hermal ystemnsulation, rmiscellaneousaterial.Assessmentsadeof friablematerialis.

    (E)23

    # r 4 763.85(aX) Did heLEA nspbctach chool uilding.thatheylease,wn,or othprwisese saschool uildingbeforeOctober 2,1988o dentify ll locationsffriable ndnonfriableCBM?School uildingmeans: ) Any structureuitablr,.br use sa classroom.including schoolbcility uch sa laboratoryibrary, chool atinglacility,or fhcilityusedor thepreparationf'food.flAny.gymnasium rother bcilitywhich sspeciallyesignedirralhl,.tic r recrealionaladtivities'or nacadernigoum in physicaldu:ation.3)Anyothertacilityused 'orhe nstnfctionrhousingfstudents r or theadministrationf educatibnalrleTar.qhrogrlms.4)Ar,lynaintenance,torage,r utility ircility,including.anyallway,sscntialorheoperatioi fanyhiility d*cribed inthisdellnition f "schoot uitding" nder oragnrphsi), 2):or (J). (5)Any.ponico r coveredxterior alluayor ualkr.ray.6)Anyexteriorportion fa mechanicalystem sedoconditionnterior pace.763.85(a)(2) For buildings easgd r acquiredon or afterOctober12,1988, id heUEAnspecthese uildingsrior ouse saschool uilding?f emergerncyse f anuninspecteduilding asnecessitatr;d,as hebuildingnspectedithin30days?763.8s(aX3)763.e3(eX3Xi)

    763.85(a)(a)(i)

    763.8s(aXaXiv)

    f- Yes l* No |7 N/A

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    19/26

    mqntof HealthA|IERAAudi#InspqetionReportewbrk StateDepart

    763.e3(e)(3)(i )

    Foreach conductedlutt .2l4187doeshe#31

    managementlarl nclude:Thedate f the nspectionrreinspectionnd henameandstgnature,tate f accreditatiorind, f applicable,theaccreditationumber f eachacueditednspectorerforminghrenspectionor relnspection.Ablueprint,.diagram,r wiittendescriptionf eachschoolbuildinghatdentifieslearlyach oc4tion ndapproximatequare r linear ootatrp f homogeneousareas heremateriial assamplcdbr ACM,t6eexactlocationwhere ach ulksample ascollecied, ateof:*k:tjgn, homogpneousreilswhereriable uspected

    f* Yes [- No Ia NiA

    l- Yes l- No |7 N/A

    f- Yes l* No |7 N/A

    f- Yes [- No 17N/A

    l* Yes f* No lir N/A

    f_ Yes |7 No T N/AAn exclusionary tatementexists or a2002abatement roject.However, heredoesnotappear o an exclusionarvstatementor the parkerElementary ddition hatwascompletedn ZOO7.3:1i"mayemissings

    ACBM sassumedo beACM,andwhere onfriablesuspectedACBMisassumedo beA,cM.(iii)33

    (iv)34

    A descriptionf themanner sedodeterminesamplingocations,nd hename ndsignaturef eachaccreditednspectqrol ecti gsam es,-theState f accreditation,nd f ippticuUle,ri, or heraccreditationumber.A c:py of the analyses f any bulk sramplesollectedandanalyzed,he nameand address fany laboratorythatanalyzedbulk samples, statementtT,-,F lt9".ratorymeeisheapplcalbleequirementsof 763.87(a)hed4te fanalyiis,nd henarnendsignatureftheperponerformingheanalysis.A descriptionof assessments,equird o bemadeunder 763.88, f al l ACBM andsusprectedCBM

    11ume! to beACI\,f,and he name, ignature,State f accreditation,nd f applicab,li, ccreditationnumberof eachaccredited ursonmaking heassessments.

    #35 (v)

    #36 763.9e(a[7)

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    20/26

    763.85(b)(3)(vii)

    #45 l(A)

    763.88(aX2)

    Has he ollowingnformationbouteinspectionseenrecordedndsubmittedo ttleDp for inclusionn themanagementlqnwithin30daysof the einspections:Dateof reinspection,ame/signature/ccreditationflnspector.al{unyhangesntheconditionf known rassumedCBM?Exactocationwhere amples erecollected,lXrf::r::f^1h1 man1e1sedo determnesampngrocatlonsnd hename/signature/ccreditationfinspector hocollectedimples?Anyassessmentsr reassessmentsf friablematerial,dateof theassesspnentamelsignafure/ccreditationfinspector?

    NewYork $fateDepartmpnt f-trearthATTERAAudit/InspcfionReport

    This nformationsfor the2010riennialnlv.

    763.e3(e)(3)(i)

    |7 Yes l* No T N/A

    f* Yes f- No F N/a

    FYes I No f N/A

    This nformations for the2010riennial nly.F Yes l- No f N/Al* Yes |7 No f NiAAccordingo the nformationprovidedn rhe2010trienniaf,heZO04

    Foreacheinspec[iononducted tte, Zil+tfr, Gornemanagementlan nclude:The d,a1ef the nspectionor reinspection ndname/stgnature/acreditation f ealh inspector?A blueprint,.diaqram,or written escriptionf eachscnoot urtdinghat dentifieslearllyachocation ndapproxtmatequarp r linearootage f homogeneousareas.herematerialwassampledm nCU, tfreexact9:lll." wfereeach utk,u*pt" *uu,of r.i"d, date f

    :oj[:tjgn, homogqneousreaswherc riablesuspectedACBM isassumedo beACM,*nO frrrc nlnfriablesuspectedCBM passumedo be CM.A des.criptionf themanner sedodetermine:lTpl,.ng ocations,_ndname/signalrure/ccreditationorme nspectorollectingamples?A copy,ofheanalysesf anybulksarmples,henameandaddressf any aboratory,statemCnt,1"j T:_ t$ratory meetsheapplcable equremenrsof g 763.s7(a),hedate f anaiysis,nd f,J"r*, #signaturef theperson erformng'th" r"ili, fAdescriptionof assessmentsnder7ti3.gg, f al ll:-:lyl ilg suspecredCBM assumedo beACM, andrne. ame/slgnature/ccreditation f each nspectormakingassessments?

    reinspectionasconductedwithout uitding rawings/oragrams.unctionalpacesshould eusedo identirulocationss oomnumberscanchange.f- Yes f- No |7 N/A

    f* Yes l- No F N/A

    f* Yes [* No |a N/A

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    21/26

    M*t* h*"**un' o, *oun r\Hf,RAAud,rlnspectionReport

    F Yeb I- No r N/Al* Yes |7 No f N/ASignificantupdatesreneededo themanagementptan.The nventorvpresentedn theplan s

    #63 763.93(e)(6) Doeshe unus"r.nt ;;;;;- -;;;,esnrin+i^- ^c ____ ..plan contain a $etailed l- Yes f* No 17N/A

    noeshe1ugesemcItebn;;tai;hs .--..-.-resommendatio-rumadeoltreliGjlilicationagencyegardng esponsections,nder e;:.gid;'ihsname,ignature,tateru".r"Jituu._"iX.t, personmakinghe ecommenoutionr,unJjiroo,ari,.,his reraccreditationumberDid a^Ir::raleT,entolaqner{e.vie-wfireesutts f eachInspectton,.reinspection,andissfimunt no.O*, o::::lT"ig inwitingo he EA tr*;;;iu,"response ctions?

    andactionwill be taken- "r"^," ;; *:::::^rrrtr't5urssresonsecro ".o,*,t;;fr:f#::'ff :-.:'?, ,3: i:g:11,1*ndompretirsil;;;dffi measre

    Inaccurate.

    l7 Yes I- No f N/AF Yes f* No f N/A

    f- Yes f- No |7 N/A

    f* Yes f". No l;| NIA

    and esponsection?#64 763.e3(e{8) ?::, *: ::asemnpdil; i;;]ffi f- Yes P No f N/AFloorplansdonot ndicatewnere CBMcanbe ound.j..l.J,lno:tdbeupdaredsingrunctional

    ^oj^ttf,!lleYeppn,r,besta$r;ffi ffiH** j::ly,* urouffiffi r,^",wn, rotherwisese s chooriliilirepi3tl^* Leemaintainana.qpdate'rr r*8,*rr pt*o Keept currentwith ongorng perationsndTl il*i:*, periodcsurieilini,i ;ro.d;,rernspection,ndesponsectivitis Jl*q"i*or

    Y:^*:gasemenrpt;;e;er,op,Ju,* *r.Jir"aanags:mentlanner?

    763.e3(d)

    763.e3(e)(t) Doeshemanagementfl31,"rt,,J:;tir,"f ,t" r*r-Manoicenffi'etherthechootudng a5ffiffi& ;: fi :lfr;ililT|Hil,l3lf and on-friabteuspecedCBM ssumedobe763.e3(e)(s)

    spaces/homogeneousareas.

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    22/26

    #7s f763.e0(c) ff;'!::[Te.ilffiffi:t,o,n"ll^-t *^.'n'up'uufr ,Eiiffiffi uut,,repatr f thedamagedmaterial?notnecessaryoprotect umanreaittr nd hlenvtronmentND removehematerialn thefunctionalpaer,dependingprrn*t rtt ", enclosureor encapsulationouldbesufucientop.oi..t humanhealth nd heenvironment,nclosierrnruprutut"f

    f9r.lCategory ) ,friabte.surfacingACfrA,Sf eCfr4,"ii"fl: misc.CMhat as oi",ii,,joiouiuee, iollre.L.EAt eastimplemenrnopemtionsndmatntenanceO&M)program?

    NewYorkstateDepartment f HearthcTHERAAudit/InspecfionReport

    f91(cate_eory)friabte.urfr;i"s GM, TSIACM,friabte isc. CM har as oi.n?iuio,,ie;nrun,damase,id heLEA:lTll.r:l anO.SM rogram,nsriture;rreventiveeasuresappropriateoeliminatehe easonablenxettnoodnat heACM or itscoveringwill becomelqnincllurdamaged;ererioratea,ritelur-Nui.oNnremove.thematerialas soonas possible f appropriatelfLl"rll.^:^:ll-s cannoreffectivetyrnir"lr"nt ,o,unlessther.response"",ion" " o.i"r,ii."i'i" p-""human ealth nd heenrareaandres*ict"d;ilf#,:Sfil:jf 1li,llfllT:,'h,ubstantialndangermento humai t "Jrt *,f,""'

    {* Yed f- No |7 N/A

    f* Yes P No f N/A

    I- Yes f* No ta N/A

    f- Yes l-- No |7 N/A

    f- Yes f- No |a N/A

    f- Yes l- No 17N/A

    f* Yes f- No |7 N/A

    Ceilingplaster n the boilerroom( picture3) andwaterdamageo plasteraroundawindow in the weststairwell(picture6)Kindergartenlosetmayneedresponsectionpendingresultsf samplingpicturesand2)

    envrronment.#79 763.90(e)

    #80 763.9l(e)

    763.eO(ix)

    Wereesponsections,(otfr".},*ESOIG ien.dbypersonscmeditedodesignprojectDeiigner;andconductesponsectionsWeremaintenancectivities other hanSSSD):::ls:93. personsccedtedoa"sln orion."actionsprojectDesigner)na"onoui,'t?of'p.oon.a_ccreditedocond ct-responsection?At theconclusionfanyac_tionoremovern.uprufu*,or encloseCBMor material ssumedoL"eCgM,was here visgalnspectiuof eachin.tionur pu.ewhere uch ctionwa,conductedod,tterminehethertheactionrasbeen roperlyo*piet.,j'iirr"j'..tMonitor)?

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    23/26

    NewYorkStateDepartment f HealthAHERAAudit/Inspction Report

    763.91(a) Did the LEAdevelop nd mplementnoperationsndmaintenanceO&M)planwheneverny iiableACBMispresentr assurnedo bepresentna buildinghattheLEA eases,wns, r otherwise ses sa schoolbuilding?

    Did heLEAcomplywitheitherheOSHAAsbesrosConstructiontandard29CFR 1926.110l)r theAsbestos orker rotectionule 40CFR763.120)?

    l* Yes F No f N/ASomeof the informationprovided n the O&Mprogram s incorrect. Thisshouldbe updatedo reflectcurrentpractices,procedures,and regulations.763.erb) [* Yes l* No 17N/A

    763.91(cXl)

    763.e1(c)(2)

    763.e4(e)

    763.9t(d)

    763.94(f)

    763.90(g\763.9t(e)

    Did heLEAconductn nitialcleaningrior o theinitiationfaresponsection?Did the management lannermake vrittenrecommendationss o whetheraddiitional leaning sneededond fso, themethods nd irequencyfsuchcleaning?

    Foreachime hatcleaningnder 6;3.91(c)asperformed,id theLEArecordhe name f eachperson erforminghecleaning,he datef suchcleaning,he ocationsleaned,nd hemethods sedto performuch leaning?Did theLEA follow described roceduresor al l O&Mactivities?

    Note:NYSDOL part56 requirements

    Were esponse ctionsor maintenance ctivities

    Foreach ime hatoperationsnd maintenanceactivitiesunder763.91(d)wereperfo,rmed,id theLEA record he nameof eachperson erformingheacfivity, the start andcompletiondaters f the activity,the ocationswhere uchactivityoccurred,description f theactivity ncludingprreventivemeasuressed, nd fACBM is removed,henameandlocationof storage r disposal iteof theACM?

    [- Yes l- No |7 NiA

    l- Yes l- No |7 NiA

    [- Yes [* No 17N/A

    I- Yes l- No |7 N/A

    I* Yes [- No F N/A

    conductedypersonsccreditedo conductesponseactionsO&M,Handleletc.)?#97 f* Yes [- No |7 N/A

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    24/26

    NewYorkState.Departmentf HealthAlHERAAudit/J[nspectioneportINSPECTIONPICTURES CecllH. ParkerElernentarg chosl Decemberr,Z$12

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    25/26

    NewYorkStateDepartment f HcalthAllERAAndit/InspectionReportNOTICE OF INSPECTION

    taso.l tofl ${s9ecfl fiillrndor uthor{y! $cct,a* 0f hcToxhSutctnri:,:$Jsnrrul/iit:Forti* puryd${f*urra*trnglnclucrirrqilri'q$$;'g*:rdffiffi^;-,ars{,*nf.!r an{,o1nor$s6*odr,lrviFiilansl*blitr,nent.acti-I,,,.rotllsr remrsjsn vi,;.ni.*i.,*hu.ii#[il;iilffi, iirtfr,cf,grrtanings{mratran0t**{uro{.0lo(t'$!ttid.rctedr tJra*i"'" oir;1..r1ng,1sr,,i.,ur;r}nncer'".r.src+,,rdild;rgacords,ilas. dper$,of*{og. cofitrols.. n{, ta{itrio$l dn$ &r,y i.,l!?}rn{:9$ beiFq lEsl 1o r6njpon dranlkJaa UbslAncA, i}ttrt& Olfhlog ccnifltylingae,-lr] 'l i(.:r't{;!;.f,i1 irilr :ilrtit ii.;l,r}JL{t.rr i.r'6c,li o,{e ii,1s,u.i!ir*tg{rcL.{.Js,Fs. Da"}fs. procsrtft,dtlrolt. and fsci*'ti*;i Srtarri! ur. /rt*lir._,r i. I .s,c..,lr*.r:rr;,..tst, ..1..1+:i qtc'nipti;el;t iO ttg chgm*Al EU[gtanCfC.ikfurcf' or irtrl'$is$wi:htl, rjt 'lsf Pcia?Edr,!h. .i'rrJr remiri6ar ;onvoynncshavs betx *grfipttsdnai$|.

    Th8 nelur0 and oxionrot rfte filioctior ol guchuari, o*ciligc +rovo rs as trlila$ilIo |.trbtbh c(lrnplhjNll yllh {0 r}"FR prrt :$J .,,ir$B+r$c,it $$tr.ri,s,{tl.ui.it,oftf1i.!cgA}|!.8A/ASHARA

    Sep*! j f r , { tF .q r t , t , i { - ,r i ( . , ; :r \ t ." j I r ' .a td?i, i.!i{r: n if .:.1: f.Jtl

    r.oxlt $us$I$rr\ls s&ltTio|. A6"f',{;ltc oF lr{,*!f cRoffI lil'.1[gTl0litrlr{ tOIHTtFi;i?}O\ 3l[.4t1:{[tE

    llloult V*r'non {:{ry .\thfirri l}lrtrkt

    d, rilspEgrsls^DDfif$s.TY$TN)HCOrnfilSu$rn tlur]n l.ttIf,[|Fl'r $t*tf nrre.*llrnri itili ttl.r?

    $ lfrr AOnnficE1|i::i;i r, ' . ' ..;*t tll i i a*t..r,iltlf.*rflI 'r ! . i r . r r - . r .v ; t i r i i Wlt . . tJ t {lI l+5 Slrth i 'o irrrrrb lr i , trr6gsf lhurr irrlnru liy TUSSSIII

    fl:dd fPA.3rd. _Ccgrerat*ii '.rdr r.ff t,r;iow,:sJ ", rf,iicr{ *n slt,,o,*.:or*fi,"U ,i;;;

    Kavln Matona

    Ssctlon Chtot

  • 7/27/2019 Asbestos Cover Up by MOUNT VERNON SCHOOL CHIEF JUDITH JOHNSON AND VICE PRESIDENT LEN SARVER

    26/26

    AHERA Audit/InsPer:tiqnRecordsThefollowingrecords(ifavailable)shouldbeaccessibtrreduringtheAHERAAudit/Inspection:

    \ List of SchoolBuildings\ Datesbuildings/schoolsoccupied\ Datesof originalconstruction\ Datesof additions/renovations

    Diagrams/FloorPlans\\ Numberof students ndstaffby districtandbuilding

    original rnspection/Managementlans Initial inspectioneportand hemanagementlan developed

    for eachschoolbuilding'6 monthperiodicsurveillanceecords Periodicsurve:illanceeports'conducted t leasteverysixmonths,n buildings hat containACBM'3year(triennial)re-inspections_Re-inspectionreporl;sfrominspectionsconductedeverythreeby a certified nspector/managementlanner' $

    Annualreporting/notifications copiesof annualnotifications egar:dingvailabilityof managementPlansandany resPonsections'Stafftrainingrecords/listof personnel-Documentati'sn f maintenancendcustodialstaff 2- hourasbestoswarenessrainingandany ,ooiri"r"ii+ hc,urrainin! for staffwho conductactivities hatwill result n disturbance'Designated erson_ The nameof the nclividualhat hasbeendesignatedo oversee sbestosctivitiesandJnsure ompliancewith AHERA requirements'

    a Trueandconectstatement Statementigned ythedesignatedersonlhat ertifieshat hegeneral1, t.tpo"tiuilitiesof theLEAhave eenmetorwill bemet'Asbestosbatementecords Documentationf anyabatementorkcompletedy thedistrict'


Recommended