8/3/2019 Comments on the Kiyota-Stern Study by Jeffrey J. Schott

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comments-on-the-kiyota-stern-study-by-jeffrey-j-schott 1/6

 

8/3/2019 Comments on the Kiyota-Stern Study by Jeffrey J. Schott

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comments-on-the-kiyota-stern-study-by-jeffrey-j-schott 2/6

CJO]@O]S

Uw`nhc` / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / /

Uhw} B9 ]a` @cjojkbc @nn`c}s jn h Djw`h+P/S/ N]H

Cjocfpsbjos hom Bkufbch}bjos njw Npw}a`w W`s`hwca hom Ujfbcr

@qc`wu} nwjk @cjojkbc @nn`c}s jn h Djw`h+P/S/ Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o})

 Djyj Dbrj}h hom Wjg`w} K/ S}`wo / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 8

Cjkk`o}s jo }a` Dbrj}h+S}`wo S}pmr

 I`nnw`r I/ Scaj}} / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / /0

Bkufbch}bjos jn }a` P/S/+Djw`h Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o}9 H L`o`whf

@xpbfbgwbpk Huuwjhca

 W`oho Yaphol hom \jo \/ Djj / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / /<

Uhw} BB9 Mrohkbc @nn`c}s jn ho N]H

]a` Uhrjnn }j Sjp}a Djw`h Nwjk Lfjghfbyh}bjo

Lhwr Apnghp`w hom Hlps}ëo Cjwo`ij / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 72

Aj| Nbohocbhf Kpf}bfh}`whfbsk Cho Bocw`hs` Sps}hbohgf` Jp}up}& @kufjrk`o}& hom

Bocjk` bo }a` Uhcbnbc W`lbjo

 Mjplfhs A/ Gwjjds hom Mh~bm Wjfhom+Ajfs} / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 08

Uhw} BBB9 Scju` njw Mrohkbc @nn`c}s bo Djw`h‒s @cjojkr

Mrohkbc Cjos`xp`oc`s jn h Djw`h+P/S/ Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o}9 Njw`blo Mbw`c}Bo~`s}k`o}

 Hw}apw Hf`qhom`w / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / <3

Bs H Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o} h Wjrhf Wjhm }j Uwjsu`wb}r: M`krs}bnrbol ]whm`

W`lbjohfbsk

Spolijjo Caj / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 12

W`lbjohf Bo}`lwh}bjo hom h Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o} Hkjol Caboh& Ihuho& hom Djw`h

 A``+ijjo Dhol / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 852

8/3/2019 Comments on the Kiyota-Stern Study by Jeffrey J. Schott

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comments-on-the-kiyota-stern-study-by-jeffrey-j-schott 3/6

Cjkk`o}9 Scju` njw Mrohkbc @nn`c}s bo Djw`h‒s @cjojkr

Cajb Ohdlrjjo / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 873

Uhw} B^9 Cjon`w`oc` Mbscpssbjo hom Cjocfpsbjos

Spkkhwr jn Uwjc``mbols

 G`wohwm D/ Ljwmjo / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / 872

) jfpk` = bo D@B Su`cbhf S}pmb s S`wb s& upgfbsa`m gr Djw h @cjojkbc Bos}b}p}`

jn Hk`wbch

8/3/2019 Comments on the Kiyota-Stern Study by Jeffrey J. Schott

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comments-on-the-kiyota-stern-study-by-jeffrey-j-schott 4/6

S}h}bc hom Mrohkbc Cjos`xp`oc`s jn h DJWPS N]H 0

Cjkk`o}s jo }a` Dbrj}h+S}`wo S}pmr

) I`nnw`r I/ Scaj}} 

]a` P/S/+Djw`h Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o}& jw DJWPS N]H& bs h abs}jwbc hlw``k`o}

}ah} sajpfm `oahoc` gbfh}`whf `cjojkbc w`fh}bjos hom w`bonjwc` }a` fjol+s}hombol

 uhw}o`wsabu jn }a` Pob}`m S}h}`s hom Djw`h jo ujfb}bchf hom s`cpwb}r kh}}`ws/

]a` DJWPS N]H bs m`sblo`m }j uwjkj}` cjku`}b}bjo hom w`lpfh}jwr w`njwk sj }ah}

}a` }whm` uhc} cjkuf`k`o}s j}a`w mjk`s}bc ujfbcb`s bkuf`k`o}`m }j gjjs} uwjmpc}b~b}r

hom `cjojkbc lwj|}a bo gj}a cjpo}wb`s/ Uhw} jn }a`s` lhbos bs hcab`~`m }awjpla

cjkkb}k`o}s }j lw`h}`w }whosuhw`ocr jn hmkbobs}wh}b~` hom w`lpfh}jwr uwjc`mpw`s

hom }awjpla ijbo} |jwdbol lwjpus jo hp}js hom j}a`w bssp`s/ Spca w`spf}s& jn cjpws`&cjonjpom hohfrs}s |aj mj oj} doj| aj| }j hccjkkjmh}` }a`k bo }a`bw cjojkbc

kjm`fs(

]a` DJWPS N]H uwj~bm`s spgs}ho}bhf o`| juujw}pob}b`s njw }whm` hom bo~`s}k`o} bo

ljjms hom s`w~bc`s/ Kjs} }hwbnns jo gbfh}`whf }whm` |bff g` w`kj~`m |b}abo }aw`` r`hws/

@~`o bo hlwbcpf}pw`& khor }hwbnns |bff g` uahs`m jp} j~`w }bk` hom khor xpj}hs |bff g`

`quhom`m4 jofr wbc` |bff g` `q`ku}`m nwjk }a` fbg`whfbyh}bjo/ ]a` bkuhc} jn }a`s`

 gbfh}`whf uw`n`w`oc`s |bff m`u`om& jn cjpws`& jo |ah} ahuu`os bo }a` Mjah Wjpom& jo

aj| xpbcdfr }a` kpf}bfh}`whf fbg`whfbyh}bjo bs bkuf`k`o}`m& hom jo }a` ~jfp}bjo jn j}a`w N]Hs hkjol Hsbh+Uhcbnbc cjpo}wb`s/

]a` hohfrsbs gr Dbrj}h hom S}`wo !755<" chu}pw`s sjk` jn }a`s` hsu`c}s jn }a`

hlw``k`o}/ ]a` hp}ajws m`s`w~` uwhbs` njw hm~hocbol doj|f`ml` jo aj| }j s}bkh}`

w`spf}s nwjk }whm` o`lj}bh}bjos/ ]a`bw cpww`o} kjm`f s`}s jp} ho f`lho} k`}ajmjfjlr

}ah} ahs upsa`m }a` `o~`fju` jn hchm`kbc w`s`hwca/ Gp} njw }a` upwujs`s jn ujfbcr

hohfrsbs& b} s}bff f`h~`s kpca }j g` m`sbw`m/

]a` hp}ajws uwj~bm` h ps`npf fb}`wh}pw` w`~b`| jn j}a`w s}pmb`s jo }a` uj}`o}bhf jp}cjk`jn h DJWPS N]H/ Hff }ajs` s}pmb`s s`} njw}a s}bkh}`s jn uj}`o}bhf cahol`s bn }a`bw 

sbkufbnb`m hsspku}bjos hgjp} }a` cjo}`o} hom bkuf`k`o}h}bjo jn }a` uhc} hw` hmju}`m/

]a`r hw` oj} uw`mbc}bjos jn |ah} |bff ahuu`o pom`w }a` }`wks jn }a` m`hf cjocfpm`m bo

`hwfr Huwbf 755</

) I`nnw`r I/ Scaj}} bs h S`objw N`ffj| h} }a` U`}`wsjo Bos}b}p}` njw Bo}`woh}bjohf 

 @cjojkbcs& \hsabol}jo& M/C/

8/3/2019 Comments on the Kiyota-Stern Study by Jeffrey J. Schott

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comments-on-the-kiyota-stern-study-by-jeffrey-j-schott 5/6

> ]a` Djw`h @cjojkbc Bos}b}p}`

Hs bo hor kjm`fbol q`wcbs`& }a` jp}up} bs jofr hs ljjm hs }a` boup}/ Bo }abs w`lhwm& B

hk cjoc`wo`m hgjp} s`~`whf uhw}s jn }a` Dbrj}h+S}`wo s}pmr/ Nbws}& }a` s`c}jwhf w`spf}s

jo hlwbcpf}pw` s``k |hr jnn }a` khwd/ B chooj} cjoc`b~` aj| }a` hp}ajws cho qufhbo

ho bocw`hs` bo Djw`ho jp}up} hom kufjrk`o} bo wbc`& |a`h}& hom fb~`s}jcd j|bol }j

m`khom nhc}jws/ Wbsbol bocjk`s l`o`wh}` wbca`w mb`}s& gp} nhwkfhom bo Djw`h |bff g`

}hd`o jp} jn uwjmpc}bjo njw ps` gr bomps}wr hom s`w~bc` cjkuhob`s/ S`cjom& }a`w` hw`

jg~bjps lfb}ca`s bo }a` cjos}wpc}bjo jn }a` mh}hghs` jo s`w~bc`s }whm` w`s}wbc}bjos/

]hgf`s 88 hom 83 w`ujw} }ah} P/S/ ghwwb`ws hw` abla`w }aho }ajs` bo Djw`h njw hff

s`lk`o}s jn }a` s`w~bc` cjojkr4 }a` mh}h hw` sbkufr oj} w`fbhgf` hom }ah} sd`|s }a`

j~`whff `s}bkh}`s nwjk }a` kjm`f/ ]abwm& }a` hp}ajws kbspom`ws}jjm hom }aps

kbsw`uw`s`o} }a` s`c}jwhf w`spf}s hgjp} }a` |`fnhw` hom `kufjrk`o} `nn`c}s jn }a`

N]H w`ujw}`m gr Scaj}}& Gwhmnjwm& hom Kjff !755>"/ Bn jo` `qhkbo`s }a` Scaj}}+

Gwhmnjwm+Kjff sc`ohwbj }ah} `qcfpm`s wbc`”hs }ajs` hp}ajws w`cjkk`om lb~`o

kjm`fbol uwjgf`ks |b}a }a` j}a`w sc`ohwbjs }ah} }a`r w`ujw}`m”}a`w` hw` nhw n`|`w 

mbnn`w`oc`s |b}a }a` w`spf}s jn }a` Dbrj}h+S}`wo kjm`f/

Ujfbcrkhd`ws khr f`hwo }a` kjs} nwjk }a` spuuf`k`o}hwr qu`wbk`o}s w`ujw}`m bo

]hgf` 73/ ]a` hp}ajws }`s} }a` bkuhc} jn h 8 u`wc`o} hom 0 u`wc`o} bocw`hs` bo Djw`h‒s

 ghs` s}jcd jn chub}hf hs h spwwjlh}` njw mrohkbc cahol`s }ah} cjpfm hccwp` bo w`sujos`

}j }a` DJWPS N]H/ @~`o }a` ~`wr cjos`w~h}b~` s}bkh}` jn h 8 u`wc`o} gjjs} bo }a`

chub}hf s}jcd rb`fms ho hmmb}bjohf |`fnhw` lhbo njw Djw`h jn -82/3 gbffbjo jw 7/>7 u`wc`o}

jn LMU/ ]abs nbombol ~hfbmh}`s h d`r jgi`c}b~` jn khor uhw}bcbuho}s bo o}`wbol bo}j

nw`` }whm` uhc}s9 }ah} bs& }a` kjs} bkujw}ho} g`o`nb}s khr m`wb~` nwjk bocw`hs`mbo~`s}k`o}”bn }a` }whm` uhc} bs bkuf`k`o}`m bo cjoipoc}bjo |b}a j}a`w mjk`s}bc

`cjojkbc w`njwks& su`cbhffr bo }a` s`w~bc`s s`c}jw/

F`} k` cjocfpm` |b}a h oj}` jn chp}bjo/ Ujfb}bcbhos fbd` }j ah~` cjocw`}` opkg`ws }j

saj| }a`bw bo}`ff`c}phf m`q}`wb}r& hom }a`r }hd` }a` sjk`|ah} kpsar opkg`ws l`o`wh}`m

 gr }a`s` kjm`fs hs ahwm ~bm`oc`/ ]a` Dbrj}h+S}`wo s}pmr bs uwjo` }j spca bo}`ff`c}phf

hgps`/ B} bs h ~hfphgf` ub`c` jn |jwd gp} uwj~bm`s jofr jo` ub`c` jn `~bm`oc` hgjp} }a`

 uj}`o}bhf cjojkbc bkufbch}bjos jn }a` DJWPS N]H/ B}s nbombols sajpfm g` cjosbm`w`m

bo cjoipoc}bjo |b}a uhw}bhf xpbfbgwbpk hohfrs`s jn su`cbnbc uwj~bsbjos jn }a uhc}& |abcacho g` mjo` joc` }a` hc}phf m`}hbfs hw` khm` upgfbc/

W@N@W@OC@S

Dbrj}h& Djyj& hom Wjg`w} K/ S}`wo/ 755</ @cjojkbc @nn`c}s jn h Djw`h+P/S/ Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``+

k`o}/ \hsabol}jo& M/C/9 Djw`h @cjojkbc Bos}b}p}`/

Scaj}}& I`nnw`r I/& Scj}} C/ Gwhmnjwm& hom ]ajkhs Kjff/ 755>/ O`lj}bh}bol }a` Djw`h+Pob}`m

S}h}`s Nw`` ]whm` Hlw``k`o}/ Ujfbcr Gwb`ns bo Bo}`woh}bjohf @cjojkbcs& oj/ 5>+=/\hsabol}jo& M/C/9 Bos}b}p}` njw Bo}`woh}bjohf @cjojkbcs/

8/3/2019 Comments on the Kiyota-Stern Study by Jeffrey J. Schott

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comments-on-the-kiyota-stern-study-by-jeffrey-j-schott 6/6