+ All Categories
Home > Documents > DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5...

DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5...

Date post: 25-Oct-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
35
2014-06-21 1 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications TAIMOOR ABBAS DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, LUND UNIVERSITY, SWEDEN Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications [email protected] 2/69 Outline Lund University and Department of EIT (overview) Overview of intelligent transportation systems Properties of propagation channels Fundamentals Radio channel research V2V channels V2V channel measurements Initial Lund’07 measurements Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements Antenna placement and diversity measurements Channel characterization and modeling Summary & Discussion Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications [email protected] 2/42
Transcript
Page 1: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

1

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and

Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

TAIMOOR ABBASDEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, LUND UNIVERSITY, SWEDEN

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 2/69

Outline

• Lund University and Department of EIT (overview)

• Overview of intelligent transportation systems

• Properties of propagation channels

– Fundamentals

– Radio channel research

– V2V channels

• V2V channel measurements

– Initial Lund’07 measurements

– Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

– Antenna placement and diversity measurements

• Channel characterization and modeling

• Summary & Discussion

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 2/42

Page 2: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

2

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 3/69

A world-class university

• Founded in 1666

• 8 faculties

• 47 000 students

• Almost 3 000 research students

• 6 800 employees

• Around 650 professors

• 800 senior lecturers

• 1 200 lecturers and other research staff

• Turnover EUR 760 million – 1/3 education, 2/3 research

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 4/69

Department of EIT

• Research labs at EIT

– Broadband Communication

– Electronics

– Communication

– Network and Security

– Signal Processing

– Electromagnetic theory

• Information Theory

• Radio Systems

• Telecommunication Theory

• Radio Systems

– Channel measurements and modeling

– Algorithm development for digital transmitter/receiver

Page 3: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

3

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 5/69

Outline

• Lund University and Department of EIT (overview)

• Overview of intelligent transportation systems

• Properties of propagation channels

– Fundamentals

– Radio channel research

– V2V channels

• V2V channel measurements

– Initial Lund’07 measurements

– Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

– Antenna placement and diversity measurements

• Channel characterization and modeling

• Summary & Discussion

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 6/69

Current road traffic related problems

Problems:

• According to world health organization report in 2004,1.2 million people die in road accidents per year.

• 50% of these are vulnerable road users,• 23% motorcyclists,• 22% pedestrains,• 4% cyclists.

• By 2020, road crashes will be third leading cause of disability/death worldwide.

• The ever increasing number of vehicles demands efficient use of available roads.

Fact:

Land transportation systems have become crucial components of modern world.

Page 4: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

4

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 7/69

Main communication paradigms,• Vehicle-to-Ifrastructure (V2I)• Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V)Benefits,• Road traffic safety• Road traffic efficiency

Intelligent Transportation Systems

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 8/69

In short...

It is the channel that determines the ultimate performance limits of any communication system.

Vehicle-to-vehicle communications

• Vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) communication at 5.9 GHz frequency will mainly be used for safety related applications.

• The reliability of safety applications highly depends on the latency and the quality of the communication link.

• The quality of the communication link relies on the properties of the propagation channel.

Page 5: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

5

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 9/69

Outline

• Lund University and Department of EIT (overview)

• Overview of intelligent transportation systems

• Properties of propagation channels

– Fundamentals

– Radio channel research

– V2V channels

• V2V channel measurements

– Initial Lund’07 measurements

– Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

– Antenna placement and diversity measurements

• Channel characterization and modeling

• Summary & Discussion

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 10/69

What is Channel?

Transmit

antenna

Receiver

anetnna

Propagation

channel Radiochannel

• Usually channel model is made of three constituents

− Path-loss determines the average (over local space and time) power received for a given TX-RX range

− Shadowing is added to the path-loss to account for local large-scale effects (Obstruction, static multi-paths, etc.)

− Fading represents the short-term variations of the received power and is caused by multipath propagation

Page 6: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

6

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 11/69

Free-space loss

d

ARX

If we assume RX antenna to be isotropic:

2

4RX TXP P

d

λ

π

=

Attenuation between twoisotropic antennas in freespace is (free-space loss):

( )2

4

=

λ

πddL free

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 12/69

Free-space loss

Friis’ law

Received power, with antenna gains GTX and GRX:

( )( )

2

4

RX TXRX TX TX RX TX

free

G GP d P P G G

L d d

λ

π

= =

( ) ( )| | | | |

2

| | 10 |

410log

RX dB TX dB TX dB free dB RX dB

TX dB TX dB RX dB

P d P G L d G

dP G G

π

λ

= + − +

= + − +

Valid in the far field only

In free space, the received power decays with distance at a rate = 20 dB/decade

Page 7: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

7

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 13/69

Free-space loss

What is far field?

The free-space loss calculations are onlyvalid in the far field of the antennas.

Far-field conditions are assumed ”far

beyond” the Rayleigh distance (also knownas Fraunhofer distance):

λ

22 a

R

Ld =

where La is the largest dimesion ofthe antenna.

-dipole2/λ

2/λ

2/λ=aL

2/λ=Rd

Parabolic

rLa 2=

λ

28rdR =

r2

Another rule of thumb is:”At least 10 wavelengths”

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 14/69

The reference distance d0

• For path-loss propagation models, a close-in distance d0 is selected such that it lies in the far-field region.

• For practical systems in the 1-2 GHz region, d0 is typically chosen to be 1 m in indoor environments, and 100 m or 1 km for outdoor environments.

• For distances d>dbreak , the above equation doesn’t hold anymore.

��� � ��� � 10�� ������

�.����� 20log�

��� d� ��

Page 8: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

8

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 15/69

Propagation mechanisms

iΘrΘ

Reflection and transmissionDiffraction

Scattering Waveguiding

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 16/69

The WSSUS model

Assumptions

A very common wide-band channel model is the WSSUS-model. Roughly speaking it means that the statistical properties remain

the same over the considered time (or area)

Recalling that the channel is composed of a number of differentcontributions (incoming waves), the following is assumed:

The channel is Wide-Sense Stationary (WSS), meaningthat the time correlation of the channel is invariant over time.

The channel is built up by Uncorrelated Scatterers (US), meaningthat contributions with different delays are uncorrelated.

Page 9: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

9

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 17/69

What is large scale and small scale?

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 18/69

Large-scale fading

Basic principle

d

Received power

Position

A B C C

A

B

C

D

Page 10: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

10

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 19/69

Small-scale fading, two waves:

location-dependent, time-varying fading

• If no movement is involved, Rx sees different signal strength (location-

dependent fading)• If Rx moves, Rx experiences time-varying fading (small-scale fading, short-

term fading)

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 20/69

Outline

• Lund University and Department of EIT (overview)

• Overview of intelligent transportation systems

• Properties of propagation channels

– Fundamentals

– Radio channel research

– V2V channels

• V2V channel measurements

– Initial Lund’07 measurements

– Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

– Antenna placement and diversity measurements

• Channel characterization and modeling

• Summary & Discussion

Page 11: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

11

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 21/69

Radio channel research

Main objective is to understand the underlying mechanisms behind the propagation of a signal from transmitter to receiver in order to construct a mathematical model for controlled synthesis of channels

• Static Model

– Spectral-based, e.g., beamforming

– Stochastic maximum likelihood

– Deterministic maximum likelihood

• Dynamic Model

– Kalman filters, e.g., EKF, UKF

– Sequential Monte Carlo, e.g., Particle filter

• Measurement based

– SAGE, RIMAX

• 3D ray-optical based

– Ray tracing

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 22/69

Cellular Channels vs. V2V ChannelsBase station

• Elevated position• Fewer scatters• Static

Mobile station

• Close to ground• Many scatterers in the surrounding• Static or Dynamic

Vehicle-to-vehicle

• Both antennas are close to ground• Many scatterers in the surrounding (moving/static)• Highly dynamic• Typically higher frequency compared to cellular

systems.

The catch: V2V channels are fundamentally different from cellular channels and are subject to faster fluctuations.

Page 12: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

12

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 23/69

Outline

• Lund University and Department of EIT (overview)

• Overview of intelligent transportation systems

• Properties of propagation channels

– Fundamentals

– Radio channel research

– V2V channels

• V2V channel measurements

– Initial Lund’07 measurements

– Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

– Antenna placement and diversity measurements

• Channel characterization and modeling

• Summary & Discussion

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 24/69

Channel measurements

• Principle of channel measurements

− Transmit a known signal �� �− Estimate the channel! , # from the received signal $� �

Commonly used channel measurement tools:

• Vector network analyzer

• Channel sounder

Page 13: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

13

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 25/69

Channel Sounder

• Separate TX and RX unlike VNA• Needs a joint clock (Rubidium or GPS)• Phase and frequency synchronization• End-to-end calibration• Calibrated antenna elements for directional estimation

Channel Measurements and Modelling for Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 10/42

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 26/69

Measurement based channel modelling

1

2 3

4

Page 14: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

14

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 27/69

• Obtain a general understanding of vehicle-to-vehicle propagation channels− Underlying mechanisms− System impact− Gain from multiple-antenna systems− Antenna/channel interaction

• Build simulations models for system evaluation− Vehicle-to-vehicle propagation channels are different

from many other propagation channels

V2V channel measurements objectives

Next step: Preparation for measurements

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 28/69

Antenna calibration

Measurement campaign step by step

Channel sounder

mounting

Conduction measure-

ments

Page 15: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

15

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 29/69

Antenna calibration

Measurement campaign step by step

Channel sounder

mounting

Conduction measure-

ments

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 30/69

Antenna calibration

Measurement campaign step by step

Channel sounder

mounting

Conduction measure-

ments

Page 16: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

16

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 31/69

Antenna calibration

Measurement campaign step by step

Channel sounder

mounting

Conduction measure-

ments

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 32/69

• TX/RX mounted on small trucks

• 4x4 MIMO measurement campaign at 5.2 GHz

• Measurements with cars in same and opposite lanes

Initial Lund’07 V2V channel measurements

Antenna elements

Non-omni-directional antenna patterns

Page 17: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

17

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 33/69

Measured Traffic Scenarios

Highway Measurements:

• Two lane (each direction) highway

• Direction of travel was separated by 0.5m high wall

• TX/RX speed (80-90km/h)

• Many moving vehicles

• LOS and OLOS conditions

• Only convoy measurements

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 34/69

Measured Traffic Scenarios

Urban Measurements Lund:

• Width 9-14 m

• Single lane

• Parked cars along street

• Some traffic

Urban Measurements Malmö:

• Width 14-40 m

• Two lanes and turn lanes

• Parked Cars along street

• Busy traffic

Page 18: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

18

Measured Traffic Scenarios

Rural Measurements:

• Single lane country road

• TX/RX speed (60-70km/h)

• No moving vehicles

• Always LOS conditions

• Measurements while driving in Convoy and in Opposite direction

Rural measurements can be treated

as reference; where no or very few

scatterers are around.

Channel Measurements and Modelling for Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 18/42

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 36/69

We found that:

• Vehicle-to-vehicle propagation channels are fundamentally different from cellular propagation channels

• Vehicle-to-vehicle propagation channels are non-stationary

• A geometric-stochastic propagation channel model is suitable

…but also concluded that:

• Measurements with trucks are practical, but will influence the measured channel (antenna height)

• Measurement conduct (cars in convoy or opposite directions on highways etc.) is commonly used, but not representative for many vehicle-to-vehicle applications (e.g., intersection collision avoidance)

Conclusions from Initial ’07 Masurements

Page 19: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

19

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 37/69

DRIVEWAY’09 measurements partners

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 38/69

DRIVEWAY’09 measurements preparation

• Preparation time: 7 months• Time for channel measurements: 5 days• Time for antenna calibration: 8 days• Total milage: 3800km• Channel sounder IR: 120 GB• Audio/Video documentation: 14GB• Antenna calibration: 7GB• .xls notes: 600kB

Page 20: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

20

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 39/69

Vehicle-to-vehicle measurements:

• Regular cars:

standard hatchback style

• Realistic antenna design:

4-element linear array of patch antennas integrated in rooftop radome

• Realistic antenna placementConsequences:• Shadowing by car roof

inclination• Shared space with other

antennas (e.g., GPS)

DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 40/69

Identified scenarios where V2V comunications will be (particularly) useful, e.g.,

– collision avoidance,

– emergency vehicle warning,

– hazardous location notification,

– wrong-way driving warning,

– co-operative merging assistance,

– slow vehicle warning,

– lane change assistance

Application specific measured scenarios

Page 21: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

21

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 41/69

Outline

• Lund University and Department of EIT (overview)

• Overview of intelligent transportation systems

• Properties of propagation channels

– Fundamentals

– Radio channel research

– V2V channels

• V2V channel measurements

– Initial Lund’07 measurements

– Follow up DRIVEWAY’09 measurements

– Antenna placement and diversity measurements

• Channel characterization and modeling

• Summary & Discussion

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 42/69

Time-delay characteristics:

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 0 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 0.2 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 0.4 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 0.6 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 0.8 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 1 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 1.3 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 1.5 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 1.7 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 1.9 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 2.1 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 2.3 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 2.5 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 2.8 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 3 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 3.2 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 3.4 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 3.6 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 3.8 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 4.1 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 4.3 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 4.5 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 4.7 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 4.9 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 5.1 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 5.3 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 5.6 sRX

TX

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 5.8 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 6 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 6.2 sLOS

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 6.4 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 6.6 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 6.9 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 7.1 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 7.3 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 7.5 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 7.7 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 7.9 s

0 100 200 300 400Propagation distance [m]

Pow

er

t = 8.1 sDiscrete comp.

Diffuse comp.

Other vehicles

Houses, road signs etc.

• Rapidly varying channel

• Discrete components carry significant energy and change delay bin with time

• Diffuse components following LOS

General Observations – Time/Delay

Page 22: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

22

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 43/69

Non line-of-sight (NLOS)

V2V communication link categorization

Line-of-sight (LOS)

Obstructed line-of-sight (OLOS)

• Safety critical situations• Poor signal reception• Significant losses at 5.9 GHz• Lacking research

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 44/69

Non Line-of-sight (NLOS) signal reception

TX

RX

BlockedLOS

• NLOS signal reception is enabled due to scattering of radio waves, e.g.,

• single or multiple boucereflections,

• diffraction.

• Factors that influence the NLOS-reception are:

• Objects such as buildings, road-signs, light poles, parked and moving vehicles

• Structure and material propertiesor these objects

• Street width, distance of TX/RX vehicles from the intersectioncenter

Reflection

Diffraction

Page 23: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

23

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 45/69

Directional analysisA high-resolution algorithm (SAGE) is used for a refined identification of interacting objects in,• LOS situations• OLOS situations• NLOS situations

Power contributions

Identified propagation mechanisms at 6s

The results show that:1. Single and double bounce reflection processes are

dominating in the absence of LOS2. Reflections from other vehicles are not “seen” as

major contributors to the received signal power. 3. Large directional spread motivates use of multiple

antennas to exploit diversity

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 46/69

Merging lanes vs. urban intersections

Received power is negligible in

NLOS. Scatterers contributes only

when there is LOS.

TXRX

Merging lane scenario

Page 24: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

24

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 47/69

Merging lanes vs. urban intersections

TX

RX

� � � � � �� �Relatively better NLOS reception than

merging lane scenario due to

multiple scatterers (mainly buildings

at the corners) .

Urban intersection scenario

• Both scenarios are safety critical with NLOS propagation conditions.

• The merging lanes scenario has worse propagation conditions than the urban intersections due to open surroundings.

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 48/69

Merging lanes vs. urban intersections

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20−115

−105

−95

−85

−75

−65

Time [s]

Channel gain

[dB

]

LOSNLOS

All TX − RX1

All TX − RX2

• Received power drops up to 20 dB depending

upon the DOA and the differences in antenna

gain of the RX elements.

• This motivates to use TX/RX antennas that

has omni-directional pattern otherwise

multiple antennas should be used.

Snapshot at 10.58 s

Snapshot at 17.56 s

Estimation of direction-of-arrival and departure

Page 25: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

25

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 49/69

• Deterministic approach, can be very realistic

• Solve approximation to Maxwell’s equation, using high-frequency approximation

[Maurer et al. 2004]

Ray tracing

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 50/69

• 3D virtual scenario is created which includes buildings, traffic signs, lamp posts as wellas parked cars along roadside.

• Only the direct path, specular reflections (1st and 2nd order) and non-specular reflections (1st order) are considered to characterize the channel.

• Measured polarimetric antenna patterns are used.

• GPS coordinates of TX/RX, logged during measurement, are used for simulation.

Goal: Comparison of ray-tracing channel simulator and channel measurements

Validation of ray-tracing based model

Page 26: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

26

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 51/69

Validation of ray-tracing based model

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 52/69

Time [s]

Dis

tan

ce

[m

]

(E)

(D)

(B)(A)(C)

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

300

250

200

150

100

50

0

−120 −110 −100 −90 −80 −70 −60 dBm

0 2 4 6 8 10−130

−120

−110

−100

−90

−80

−70

−60

Time [s]

Channel gain

[dB

]

Measured

Simulation

• Very good agreement in LOS and near LOS regions.

• In NLOS, the ray tracing model underestimates the channel gain.

• Gap can be reduced by increasing the order of reflection.

• Contribution of third and higher-order specular and non-specular reflections is missing in the simulator.

Time [s]

Dis

tan

ce

[m

]

(E)

(D)

(B)(A)(C)

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

300

250

200

150

100

50

0

−120 −110 −100 −90 −80 −70 −60 dBm

Measuremed PDP Simulated PDP (Ray-tracing)

Channel gain

Validation of ray-tracing based model

LOSNLOS

Page 27: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

27

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 53/69

[1] T. Mangel, O. Klemp, and H. Hartenstein, “5.9 GHz inter-vehicle communication at intersections: a validated non-line-of- sight path-loss and fading model,” EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking, vol. 2011, no. 1, p. 182, 2011.

• Mangel et. al. in [1] has presented a NLOS path-loss model at 5.9 GHz named VirtualSource11p.

• The model is based on an extensive measurement campaign conducted in Munich, Germany.

• The NLOS path-loss model is claimed to be flexible and incorporated specific geometry aspects.

• Question: Is the model valid only in the intersections where the measurements were taken?

Validate the model with independent data?

Validation of NLOS path loss model

Reference non-line-of-sight path loss model

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 54/69

Validation of NLOS path loss model

Page 28: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

28

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 55/69

The results in this study suggest to introduce an intersection dependent gain parameter in the reference NLOS model to cope with varying scattering. But otherwise the proposed model seems to be accurate.

Validation of NLOS path loss model

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 56/69

Scenario n PL0 σ

Urban Convoy

LOS 1.81 2.85 63.9 4.15

OLOS 1.93 2.74 72.3 6.67

Measured channel gain for urban scenario

10 dB

10 dB extra attenuation translates to a 3 time reduction of communication range, e.g. 100 m instead of 300 m.

Page 29: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

29

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 57/69

Network simulations

Simulation scenario,

• 10 km long highway

• 4 lanes (2 on each side)

• 400 byte long CAM messages

• Channel access procedure is carrier sense multiple access (CSMA)

• Vehicle speeds independent Gaussian distributed with mean (23, 30) m/s per lane and standard deviation 1 m/s

• Vehicles Poisson distributed with inter-arrival rate of 1 s, 2 s, 3 s.

• Channel models comparison,

– Nakagami dual slope

– LOS/OLOS dual slope model

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 58/69

• Reflects key properties:

– Scattering occurs around TX and RX

– Both TX and RX are moving

• Closed-form equations for Doppler spectra

[Patel et al. 2005]58 / 30

Two-ring model

Page 30: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

30

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 59/69

• Segmented time-invariant

tapped delay line

• Time-varying tapped delay line[Acosta and Ingram 2007]

[Matolak 2008]

Tap-delay line model

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 60/69

Distributed antenna measurements

• Measurements in the past have been conducted with same type of antenna arrangements

– Usually roof mounted antenna

– Single exception exists with antenna placed Inside-windscreen

• Position of antenna is expected to have large impact

– Both TX and RX antennas are at same height

– Relatively close to ground level (1-2m above ground)

– Shadowing effects are expected

Page 31: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

31

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 61/69

1

3

2

4

Roof AntennaBumper AntennaInside Windscreen AntennaLeft-side Mirror AntennaAntenna Placement

Antennas used are omni-directional

TXRX

DIVERSITY’11 measurement setup

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 62/69

0 5 10 15 20 25-100

-90

-80

-70

-60

-50

-40

Time [s]

Channel G

ain

[dB

]

Roof

Bumper

Windscreen

Left-Side Mirror

0 5 10 15 20 25-100

-90

-80

-70

-60

-50

-40

Time [s]

Channel G

ain

[dB

]

Roof

Bumper

Windscreen

Left-Side Mirror

Rural - Convoy Urban - Convoy

Leftside-mirror antenna

location has strongest channel

gain

Roof antenna location has

strongest channel gain

• Leftside-mirror antenna is sensitive to the alignment of cars

Impact of antenna placement

Page 32: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

32

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 63/69

0 5 10 15 20 25−100

−90

−80

−70

−60

−50

−40

Time [s]

Channel G

ain

[dB

]

Roof

Bumper

Windscreen

Left−Side Mirror

0 5 10 15 20 25−100

−90

−80

−70

−60

−50

−40

Time [s]

Channel G

ain

[dB

]

Roof

Bumper

Windscreen

Left−Side Mirror

Rural - Opposite Urban - Opposite

Bumper antenna location has

strongest channel gain before cars

cross each other

Roof antenna location has

strongest channel gain after cars

cross each other

Impact of antenna placement

Diversity arrangements with complementary antennas seems to be the preferred solution, e.g., roof or left-side-mirror together with the bumper antenna.

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 64/69

• A. Paier, J. Kåredal, N. Czink, C. Dumard, T. Zemen, F. Tufvesson, A. Molisch, C. F. Mecklenbräuker, ”Characterization of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Radio Channels from Measurements at 5.2GHz,” Wireless

Personal Communications, vol. 50, no. 1, pp. 19-29, 2009.

• J. Kåredal, F. Tufvesson, N. Czink, A. Paier, C. Dumard, T. Zemen, C. Mecklenbräuker, A. Molisch, ”A geometry-based stochastic MIMO model for vehicle-to-vehicle communications,” IEEE Transactions on

Wireless Communications, vol. 8, no. 7, pp. 3646-3657, 2009.

• A. Molisch, F. Tufvesson, J. Kåredal, C. F. Mecklenbräuker, ”A Survey on Vehicle-to-Vehicle Propagation Channels,” IEEE Wireless Communications, vol. 16, no. 6, pp. 12-22, 2009.

• J. Kåredal, F. Tufvesson, T. Abbas, O. Klemp, A. Paier, L. Bernadó, A. Molisch, ”Radio channelmeasurements at street intersections for vehicle-to-vehicle applications,” Proc. IEEE Vehicular Technology

Conference (VTC2010-spring), Taipei, Taiwan, pp. 1-5, May 16-19, 2010.

• A. Paier, L. Bernadó, J. Kåredal, O. Klemp, A. Kwoczek, ”Overview of vehicle-to-vehicle radio channel measurements for collision avoidance applications,” Proc. IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference

(VTC2010-spring), Taipei, Taiwan, pp. 1-5, May 16-19, 2010.

• A. Molisch, F. Tufvesson, J. Kåredal, C. Mecklenbräuker, ”Propagation aspects of vehicle-to-vehicle communications - an overview,” Proc. IEEE Radio and Wirless Symposium (RWS), San Diego, CA, USA, pp. 179-182, Jan. 18-22, 2009.

• J. Kåredal, F. Tufvesson, N. Czink, A. Paier, C. Dumard, T. Zemen, C. Mecklenbräuker, A. Molisch, ”Measurement-based modeling of vehicle-to-vehicle MIMO channels,” Proc. IEEE International

Conference on Communications (ICC), Dresden, Germany, June 14-18, 2009.

Selected publications

Page 33: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

33

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 65/69

• A. Paier, T. Zemen, J. Kåredal, N. Czink, C. Dumard, F. Tufvesson, C. Mecklenbräuker, A. Molisch, ”Spatial diversity and spatial correlation evaluation of measured vehicle-to-vehicle radio channels at 5.2 GHz,” Proc. IEEE Digital Signal Processing Workshop/Signal Processing Education Workshop

(DSP/SPE), pp. 326-330, Jan 1-4, 2009.

• L. Bernadó, T. Zemen, A. Paier, J. Kåredal, B. Fleury, ”Parametrization of the local scattering function estimator for vehicular-to-vehicular channels,” Proc. IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference (VTC2009-

fall), Anchorage, AK, USA, pp. 1-5, Sept. 20-23, 2009.

• A. Paier, T. Zemen, L. Bernado, G. Matz, J. Kåredal, N. Czink, C. Dumard, F. Tufvesson, A. Molisch, C. Mecklenbräuker, ”Non-WSSUS vehicular channel characterization in highway and urban scenarios at 5.2 GHz using the local scattering function,” Proc. International Workshop on Smart Antennas (WSA), pp. 9-15, 2008.

• L. Bernadó, T. Zemen, A. Paier, G. Matz, J. Kåredal, N. Czink, C. Dumard, F. Tufvesson, M. Hagenauer, A. Molisch, C. F. Mecklenbräuker, ”Non-WSSUS Vehicular Channel Characterization at 5.2 GHz - Spectral Divergence and Time-Variant Coherence Parameters,” Proc. URSI General Assembly, 2008.

• A. Paier, J. Kåredal, N. Czink, H. Hofstetter, C. Dumard, T. Zemen, F. Tufvesson, C. Mecklenbräuker, A. Molisch, ”First results from car-to-car and car-to-infrastructure radio channel measurements at 5.2GHz,” Proc. IEEE

International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications (PIMRC), Athens, Greece, pp. 1-5, Sept. 3-7, 2007.

• A. Paier, J. Kåredal, N. Czink, H. Hofstetter, C. Dumard, T. Zemen, F. Tufvesson, A. Molisch, C. Mecklenbräuker, ”Car-to-car radio channel measurements at 5 GHz: Pathloss, power-delay profile, and delay-Doppler spectrum,” Proc. IEEE International Symposium on Wireless Communication Systems

(ISWCS), Trondheim, Norway, pp. 224-228, Oct. 17-19, 2007.

Selected publications (cont.)

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 66/69

• C. Mecklenbräuker, A. Molisch, J. Karedal, F. Tufvesson, A. Paier, L. Bernadó, T. Zemen, O. Klemp, N. Czink: Vehicular channel characterization and its implications for wireless system design and performance, Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol. 99, No. 7, pp. 1189-1212, 2011.

• T. Abbas, J. Karedal, F. Tufvesson, A. Paier, L. Bernadó, A. Molisch: Directional Analysis of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Propagation Channels, IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference, IEEE 73rd Vehicular Technology Conference 2011-spring, Budapest, Hungary, 2011-05-15/2011-05-18.

• T. Abbas, and F. Tufvesson: Line-of-Sight Obstruction Analysis for Vehicle-to-Vehicle Network Simulations in a Two Lane Highway Scenario, Hindawi International Journal of Antennas and Propagation, Special Issue on Radio Wave Propagation and Wireless Channel Modeling (In press)

• T. Abbas, L. Bernadó, A. Thiel, C. F. Mecklenbräuker, and F. Tufvesson: Radio Channel Properties for Vehicular Communication: Merging Lanes Versus Urban Intersections, IEEE Vehicular Technology Magazine, December, 2013 (Invited paper)

• T. Abbas, J. Kåredal, and F. Tufvesson: Measurement-Based Analysis: The Effect of Complementary Antennas and Diversity on Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communication, IEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters, 2012.

• T. Abbas, J. Nuckelt, T. Kürner, T. Zemen, C. Mecklenbräuker, and F. Tufvesson: Simulation and Measurement Based Vehicle-to-Vehicle Channel Characterization: Accuracy and Constraint Analysis (Accepted with major revision, 2014 to IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagations).

• T. Abbas: Measurement Based Channel Characterization and Modeling for Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications, Series of licentiate and doctoral dissertations, ISSN 1654-790X (No. 58), Department of Electrical and Information Technology, Lund University, Sweden, 2014.

• For details please visit: Vehicle-to-vehicle channel modeling at EIT

Selected publications (cont.)

Page 34: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

34

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 67/69

• V2V channels differ significantly from standard cellular channels

– do not expect satisfactory performance for standard WLAN equipment

• For network simulations – include shadowing effects

– buildings, vehicles,

– long correlation time for shadowing from other vehicles

• For link simulations – include non-stationarities and consider the double selective channel

– high Doppler spread – short correlation time

– high excess delay – small coherence bandwidth

• Multiple antenna arrangements might be required to get reliable links

– Rx diversity

• Many challenges and opportunities still remain

Conclusions

Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 68/69

Thank you!

Taimoor [email protected]

Channel Measurements and Modelling for Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

[email protected] 42/42

Page 35: DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND INFORMATION ......properties of the propagation channel. 2014-06-21 5 Measurement-based Channel Characterization and Modelling of Vehicle-to-Vehicle Communications

2014-06-21

35


Recommended