COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
EXPERT WITNESS ANALYSIS
DR. JOHN DOE, M.D.
FAMILY AND EMERGENCY MEDICINE EXPERT WITNESS
REPORT PREPARED ON MARCH 3, 2018
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Areas Of Expertise .............................................................................................................................................................. 1
Additional Contact Information#1 .............................................................................................................................. 1
Additional Contact Information#2 .............................................................................................................................. 2
Additional Contact Information#3 .............................................................................................................................. 2
Additional Contact Information#4 .............................................................................................................................. 2
Additional Contact Information#5 .............................................................................................................................. 2
Additional Address#1 ....................................................................................................................................................... 2
Additional Address#2 ....................................................................................................................................................... 3
Additional Address#3 ....................................................................................................................................................... 3
Additional Address#4 ....................................................................................................................................................... 3
Additional Information ..................................................................................................................................................... 3
CV/ Resumes ............................................................................................................................................................................. 4
Court Filed Resume ............................................................................................................................................................ 4
Overview ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 5
Retained By (Overall) ........................................................................................................................................................ 5
Case Involvement................................................................................................................................................................ 5
By Area of Law ..................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Grounds of Challenge ........................................................................................................................................................ 6
Challenge Disposition ....................................................................................................................................................... 7
Jury Verdict Analysis ......................................................................................................................................................... 7
Publications ........................................................................................................................................................................... 8
Other Documents Available ............................................................................................................................................ 8
Case Law ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Direct Challenges .............................................................................................................................................................. 10
Indirect Challenges .......................................................................................................................................................... 20
Other Cases Involving John Doe .................................................................................................................................. 26
Personal Litigation History ........................................................................................................................................... 56
Jury Verdict Reports Mentioning Doe As An Expert Witness ......................................................................... 57
Certain Cases In Which Doe’s Deposition Was Filed .......................................................................................... 60
Certain Cases In Which Doe Was Mentioned In Other Expert’s Deposition ............................................. 61
Certain Cases In Which Doe’s Affidavit Was Filed .............................................................................................. 62
Professional History ............................................................................................................................................................. 64
Employment / Teaching / Research ......................................................................................................................... 64
Employment History .................................................................................................................................................. 64
Teaching / Research History ................................................................................................................................... 66
Education ............................................................................................................................................................................. 67
References ........................................................................................................................................................................... 68
Association Memberships ............................................................................................................................................. 69
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Board Memberships ........................................................................................................................................................ 69
Awards and Honors ......................................................................................................................................................... 69
Conferences / Presentations / Seminars ................................................................................................................ 69
Intellectual Property Owned ........................................................................................................................................ 69
Patents .............................................................................................................................................................................. 69
Trademarks .................................................................................................................................................................... 69
Expert Rates ........................................................................................................................................................................ 70
Publications ......................................................................................................................................................................... 70
Book ................................................................................................................................................................................... 70
Article................................................................................................................................................................................ 70
Book Review .................................................................................................................................................................. 70
Abstracts .......................................................................................................................................................................... 70
Editorial ........................................................................................................................................................................... 70
Publications Mentioning the Expert ..................................................................................................................... 71
Certificates and Licenses ............................................................................................................................................... 71
Websites and Links .......................................................................................................................................................... 71
Expert Directories ............................................................................................................................................................ 72
Social Networking ............................................................................................................................................................ 73
Public Profiles .................................................................................................................................................................... 73
Groups ................................................................................................................................................................................... 75
Blogs ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 75
Multimedia .......................................................................................................................................................................... 75
News Articles ...................................................................................................................................................................... 76
Disciplinary Actions ......................................................................................................................................................... 78
Personal Information ........................................................................................................................................................... 79
Relations ............................................................................................................................................................................... 79
Bankruptcies ....................................................................................................................................................................... 79
Judgments and Liens ....................................................................................................................................................... 79
UCC Filings ........................................................................................................................................................................... 79
SEC Filings ........................................................................................................................................................................... 80
Properties Owned ............................................................................................................................................................. 80
Political Contributions .................................................................................................................................................... 81
Donations ............................................................................................................................................................................. 84
Criminal History ................................................................................................................................................................ 86
Sexual Offenses .................................................................................................................................................................. 86
Interests / Hobbies .......................................................................................................................................................... 86
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Disclaimer
The use of this Expert Witness Analysis should not be considered a substitute for independent
investigation and due diligence regarding experts, or sound technical and business judgment.
American Medical Forensic Specialists (“AMFS”) compiles the information in the reports from a
wide variety of publicly available sources (“Third Party Information”). Although AMFS uses
commercially reasonable efforts to accurately summarize and report the Third Party Information,
AMFS is not responsible for, and does not warrant accuracy of the Third Party Information. AMFS
also does not warrant the quality, accuracy, qualifications, skills, or effectiveness of any expert you
retain, consult with, or oppose, or for the acts or omissions of such experts.
Although AMFS updates its information sources regularly, the information in the reports is not
provided in real time. The providers of the Third Party Information may not update their records
on a timely basis or may have updated their records since AMFS last updated the report or since
you downloaded it.
The information provided in the Report should not be construed to constitute legal advice or
provide a substitute for reviewing the qualifications of experts independently.
This report is not intended and you may not use it to determine eligibility for consumer credit, to
decide whether to hire, retain, or promote employees, to decide whether to underwrite insurance
for a consumer, or for any other purpose set forth in section 1681b of the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
This report is solely for the use of one individual user. If additional users want to use a report,
AMFS requires the purchase of additional copies.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
1
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
INTRODUCTION Dr. John Doe, M.D., also known as John Doe-Miller, is a licensed physician from Ohio. He is also
certified by the American Board of Family Medicine and the American Board of Emergency
Medicine. He has received his B.A. in 1974 and M.D. in 1978 from the Case Western Reserve
University School of Medicine. He then completed his residency and fellowship from the Akron City
Hospital and Maryland Institute of Emergency Medical Service Systems. Presently, he is employed
at Memorial Health System, located in Marietta, Ohio. Dr. Doe is associated with the Ohio State
Medical Association and the Challenger's Physician Advisory Board. He has also received the “Hall
Of Fame” in 2010 from James Ford Rhodes High School and listed as the “Best Doctor in America” by
the Ohio Medicine in 2015.
AREAS OF EXPERTISE
Emergency Medicine
Family Practice
Occupational Medicine
ADDITIONAL CONTACT INFORMATION#1
Address: 1742 Rockhill Lane
Akron, Ohio 44313
Phone (s): (330) 864-5336, +1 (800) 425-6105
Sources:
1. https://license.ohio.gov/lookup/default.asp?division=78
2. Expert’s CV found in proprietary database
3. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Dr. John Doe, M.D.
Family and Emergency Medicine Expert Witness
Memorial Health System
Address: 401 Matthew Street
Marietta
Ohio 45750
P: (740) 374-1722 | F: (740) 374-1693
Web: http://bit.ly/T774vL
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
2
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
4. http://www.city-data.com/summit-county/R/Rock-Hill-Lane-1.html
5. https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
6. http://www.city-data.com/summit-county/R/Rock-Hill-Lane-1.html
ADDITIONAL CONTACT INFORMATION#2
Address: 2351 E 22nd St
Cleveland, Ohio 44115
Phone: (216) 228-4780
Source: http://www.ohiohealthchoice.com/pdf/ahcfinal/ahccuy.pdf
ADDITIONAL CONTACT INFORMATION#3
Phone: (740) 568-2000
Source: http://bit.ly/2jUF23T
ADDITIONAL CONTACT INFORMATION#4
Phone: (330) 819-0189
Fax: (330) 836-2837
Email: [email protected]
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
ADDITIONAL CONTACT INFORMATION#5
Phone: (330) 569-5418
Sources:
1. http://www.hiram.edu/staff/dr-John-Doe/
2. http://bit.ly/2oxwPck
ADDITIONAL ADDRESS#1
672 N Hawkins Ave.
Akron, Ohio 44313
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
3
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
ADDITIONAL ADDRESS#2
2057 Thurmont Rd.
Akron, Ohio 44313
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
ADDITIONAL ADDRESS#3
1627 Vicgross Ave.
Akron, Ohio 44310
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
ADDITIONAL ADDRESS#4
310 McDowell Ave.
Akron, Ohio 44313
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Year of Birth: December 1952
Place of Birth: Cleveland, Ohio
Source: https://license.ohio.gov/lookup/default.asp?division=78
NPI Number: 1134133747
Sources:
1. http://www.hipaaspace.com/Medical_Billing/Coding/NPI/Codes/NPI_1134133747.aspx
2. http://docnpi.com/npi/1134133747/
3. http://bit.ly/1m5Ns27
4. http://www.npivalidator.com/Medical_Data/NPI/1134133747.html
5. http://www.healthcare4ppl.com/physician/ohio/marietta/John-a-Doe-1134133747.html
6. http://www.topnpi.com/oh1134133747/dr-John-Doe
7. http://www.healthcare6.com/physician/marietta-oh/John-a-Doe-1145158.html
8. http://www.physicianus.org/dr-John-a-Doe-md-emergency-medicine/
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
4
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
CV/ RESUMES
COURT FILED RESUME
1. Ham V. Marshall County, Kentucky Et Al, U.S.D.C. – Kentucky (Western) | Request
Document
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
5
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
1
2
2
14
4
19
1
2
1
4
0 5 10 15 20
CO
FL
KY
MD
MI
OH
OK
PA
SC
WV
By State:
CO
FL
KY
MD
MI
OH
OK
PA
SC
WV
PLAINTIFF 47%
DEFENDANT 53%
OVERVIEW Time Period Covered: 2003 to 2016
RETAINED BY (OVERALL)
CASE INVOLVEMENT
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
6
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
BY AREA OF LAW
GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE
5
3
3
5
4
3
2
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Others
Obvious Conclusion
Legal Conclusion
Relevance
Methodology
Qualification
Unknown
BY GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE
18%
4%
4%
40%
24%
2% 2%
2%
4% Civil Law
Civil Rights
Contracts
Medical Malpractice
Negligence
Other Statutory Actions
Personal Injury
Tort Law
Unknown
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
7
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Verdict forPlaintiff
Verdict forDefendant
Settlement Unknown
1
6 8
45
4 7
2
7
Retained By Plaintiff Retained by Defendant
CHALLENGE DISPOSITION
JURY VERDICT ANALYSIS
OUTCOME BY RETAINING PARTY
5
2
2
1
2
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Others
Outcome Unknown
No Ruling
Admitted In Part
Admitted
BY OUTCOME
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
8
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
PUBLICATIONS
OTHER DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE Direct link to documents available for immediate access have been provided. For documents listed in this report and
appended with a Request Document link, a procurement fee of $15 per document is applicable. All other documents
listed which do not have the Request Document link may not be available through AMFS.
Deposition Transcripts/ Excerpts: 0
Trial Transcripts: 0
Full Text Opinions: 6
Federal Agency Decisions: 0
State Agency Decisions: 0
Expert Reports/ Affidavits: 3
1 1 1 1
1996 1997 1998 2006
By Year
By Year
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
9
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
CASE LAW This case law section provides references to an expert who has been cited or mentioned in case opinions (reported and
unreported), briefs (where available), jury verdicts, dockets, and expert challenges for both state and federal courts. It is
again noted that not every jurisdiction and every court makes their case law available, and this profile is limited as such.
The following search strings were run to ensure that all available cases and briefs are
captured.
(((Jon or John) w/2 (Doe or “Doe-Miller”)) or ((“Doe-Miller” or Doe) w/50 Expert and
(Emergen! or Medicine or Family))) and not ("John R. Doe")
The following legal databases were looked at during the preparation of this report:
1. Federal and State Cases Combined, Jury Verdicts and Settlements, Federal Agency Decisions,
State Agency Decisions
2. Court Documents – Trial Filings, Appellate Briefs, Trial Orders, Dockets
3. PACER was searched to retrieve original documents, if available.
4. Google Scholar – Legal Opinion Search
Availability of Supporting Documents
In the course of research, many relevant documents such as opinions, briefs, pleadings,
deposition transcripts, motions to exclude, rulings, expert reports, expert CVs etc. are retrieved
from various sources. These documents are divided into three categories:
1. Available for Download for no additional cost (These are mainly opinions for which no cost
is incurred on the part of AMFS.)
2. Available for Instant Delivery (These are documents which can be delivered within one
business day after payment.) To know the cost of these documents and to order, click on
(Request Document) next to the document to send an email with the relevant document
title and the Case Caption.
3. These are documents which cannot be procured electronically and can be obtained only
from the court. These documents do not have (Request Document) mentioned against
them. To know how these documents can be procured, please send a mail to
[email protected] with the relevant document title and the Case Caption.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
10
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
DIRECT CHALLENGES
This section includes reported, and numerous unreported cases from both state and federal jurisdictions where a
“gatekeeping authority” has been cited or mentioned in a decision and the testifying expert’s methodology or
qualifications have been challenged. Gatekeeping authority is defined as a seminal decision or rule of evidence that
defines or interprets the standards for admissibility or expert witness testimony for the corresponding jurisdiction. This
section includes results from over 165 gatekeeping authorities, including but not limited to Daubert v. Merrell Dow, Frye v.
United States, and their progeny. Sources for unreported decisions include docket sheets, litigation reports, jury verdicts,
and other online resources. Although care has been followed to gather this information, not all cases involving expert
challenges are reported.
Motion to strike denied.
Case Source: Trial Pleading, Trial Order
Case Caption: Payne V. Reasoner
Docket Number: 07-CV-3110
Case Cite(s): 2008 WL 5636762; 2008 WL 5636764; 2008 WL 5636778; 2008 WL 5694136
Grounds of Challenge: Relevance
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Colorado
Court Name: District Court Of Colorado, El Paso County
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): John D. Hayes, # 21060, Joanne C. Crebassa #29484, Address: Senter Goldfarb & Rice, L.L.C., 1700 Broadway, Suite 1700, Denver, CO 80290, Phone No.: 303-320-0509, Fax No.: 303-320-0210, E-mail: [email protected], jcrebassa @sgrllc.com
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Stephen J. Hensen (Atty. Reg. #16893), C. Todd Drake (Atty. Reg. #27258), Montgomery Little Soran & Murray, P.C., 5445 Dtc Parkway, Suite 800, Greenwood Village, CO 80111, Telephone: (303) 773-8100, Fax No.: (303) 220-0412, E-mail: shensen @montgomerylittle.com, [email protected]
Judge(s): Theresa M. Cisneros
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
11
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Date(s): 08/18/2008
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an emergency medicine expert in the instant case. Defendant argued that his testimony was cumulative and irrelevant and moved to strike it. The Court denied the motion to strike without a hearing.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Defendants' Joint Motion To Strike Commerce & Industry's & Plaintiffs' Expert Dr. John Doe
2. Defendants' Joint Reply In Support Of Motion To Strike Commerce & Industry's & Plaintiffs' Expert Dr. John Doe
3. Trial Order
Testimony properly limited; affirmed.
Case Source: Opinion, Brief Bank, Docket
Case Caption: Ross V. St. Elizabeth Health Ctr.
Docket Number: 2008 MA 00017
Case Cite(s): 181 Ohio App. 3d 710; 2009-Ohio-1506; 910 N.E.2d 1047; 2009 Ohio App. LEXIS 1288; 2008 OH App. Ct. Briefs 817; 2008 OH App. Ct. Briefs LEXIS 2509; 2008 OH App. Ct. Briefs LEXIS 2508; 2008 OH App. Ct. Briefs LEXIS 2507
Grounds of Challenge: Relevance, Methodology
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Appeals Of Ohio, Seventh Appellate District, Mahoning County
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Brian P. Kopp, Attorney Christopher A. Maruca, Betras, Maruca, Kopp & Harshman, Canfield, OH
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
12
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Michael J. Hudak, Attorney Michael J. Fuchs, Roetzel & Andress, LPA, Akron, OH
Judge(s): Mary DeGenaro, Joseph J. Vukovich, Gene Donofrio
Date(s): 03/26/2009
Summary of Involvement: Doe an emergency room physician, was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case. The Appellate Court observed “Prior to trial, Ross filed a motion in limine requesting, inter alia, an order prohibiting MVES from introducing any evidence or testimony from Dr. John Doe regarding the existence of a condition called thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP), or the issue of survivability. The trial court overruled the motion in limine.” The Appellate Court further observed “The trial court initially denied the motion in limine. However, prior to Dr. Doe's testimony at trial, Ross renewed the motion, and after an initial sidebar an incamera hearing was held to decide it. The court ultimately ruled that Dr. Doe could not testify about any medical conditions that were not known to Dr. Jackson when he treated Darlene. Thus, the trial court precluded proximate cause testimony, limiting Dr. Doe to testify only about the standard of care. MVES contends this limitation constitutes prejudicial error. Ross counters that MVES failed to proffer Dr. Doe as a proximate cause witness.” The Appellate Court concluded “All of MVES' arguments are meritless. With regard to the evidentiary matter, MVES failed to adequately proffer the testimony at issue. MVES failed to explain during the in-camera hearing that Dr. Doe would provide proximate cause testimony relating to the issue of medical management.” The judgment was affirmed.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Opinion dated March 26, 2009
2. Reply Brief Of Appellant, Mahoning Valley Emergency Specialists Inc.
3. Brief Of Appellee, Steven W. Ross, Admr. Of The Est. Of Darlene Marie Ross, Deceased
4. Appellant's Brief Of Mahoning Valley Emergency Specialists Inc.
5. Motion To Supplement The Record By Filing Transcript Of Testimony Of Dr John Doe Filed
6. Je>On September 5, 2008 Appellant Filed A Motion To Supplement The Record On Appeal With The Transcript Of The Testimony Of Dr John Doe. As Such Testimony Was Inadvertently Omitted From The Record Transmitted To This Court It Is Ordered That The Motion To Supplement Is
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
13
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Sustained And Such Testimony Is Included In The Record Before This Court
Motion to exclude filed; not ruled upon due to dismissal of the suit pursuant to settlement.
Case Source: Trial Pleading, Docket
Case Caption: Warren V. Cuna Mutual Group
Docket Number: 6:11-CV-00439
Case Cite(s): 2012 WL 6722389; 2012 WL 6703783; 2012 WL 6703803; 2012 WL 6703741; 2012 WL 6722388; 2012 WL 6593910; 2012 WL 6593912
Grounds of Challenge: Relevance, Methodology, Qualification, Obvious Conclusion, Legal Conclusion
Area of Law: Contracts
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: Oklahoma
Court Name: United States District Court, E.D. Oklahoma
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): James T. Branam
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Lyndon W. Whitmire
Judge(s): Frank H. Seay
Date(s): 01/30/2013
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as a medical expert in the instant case. Defendant filed a motion to exclude his testimony pursuant to Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharm., 509 U.S. 579 (1993). Defendant’s motion to exclude his testimony was not ruled upon due to dismissal of the suit pursuant to settlement.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Reply To Response To Motion (Re: Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Medical Expert, Dr. John Doe ) By Cuna
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
14
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Mutual Insurance Society (Request Document)
2. Response To Motion (Re: Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Medical Expert, Dr. John Doe ) By Everlina Warren(Individually), Everlina Warren(Administrator Of The Estate Of Wendell F. Warren, Deceased) (Request Document)
3. Minute Order By Judge Frank H. Seay Granting Unopposed Motion For Extension Of Time To Respond To Motions In Limine; Responses Due By 12/10/2012 (Re: Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Bad Faith/Claims Handling Expert, Susie Sullivan, Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Medical Expert, Dr. John Doe, First Motion In Limine, Motion In Limine (Consolidated), Motion To Exclude Testimony Of Defendants' Expert William D. Hager ) (Request Document)
4. Unopposed Motion For Extension Of Time To Respond To Motion (Re: Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Bad Faith/Claims Handling Expert, Susie Sullivan, Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Medical Expert, Dr. John Doe, Motion To Exclude Testimony Of Defendants' Expert William D. Hager, Motion In Limine (Consolidated), First Motion In Limine ) By All Plaintiffs. Responses Due (Request Document)
5. Motion In Limine To Exclude Plaintiff's Medical Expert, Dr. John Doe By Cuna Mutual Group, Cuna Mutual Insurance Society. Responses Due (Request Document)
6. Judgment Dismissing Action By Reason Of Settlement By Judge Frank H. Seay Administratively Closing The Case (Request Document)
7. Defendant Cmfg Life Insurance Company F/K/A Cuna Mutual Insurance Society's Motion For Summary Judgment And Brief In Support (Request Document)
8. Defendant Cmfg Life Insurance Company F/K/A Cuna Mutual Insurance Society's Motion To Exclude Plaintiff's Medical Expert, Dr. John Doe, And Brief In Support (Request Document)
9. Defendant Cmfg Life Insurance Company F/K/A Cuna Mutual Insurance Society's Reply Brief In Support Of Its Motion For Summary Judgment (Request Document)
10. Plaintiff's First Motion In Limine And Brief In Support (Request Document)
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
15
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
11. Plaintiff's Response To Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment (Request Document)
12. Expert Report Submitted By William D. Hager Of William D. Hager
13. Affidavit Of Susie Sullivan
Motion in limine to limit overruled.
Case Source: Trial Pleading, Trial Order
Case Caption: Davis V. Johnston
Docket Number: 2009CV05228
Case Cite(s): 2012 WL 9246903; 2012 WL 9246905; 2012 WL 9246910; 2012 WL 9246918; 2012 WL 9190081
Grounds of Challenge: Relevance, Methodology, Qualification, Obvious Conclusion, Legal Conclusion
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Alvarene N. Owens (0009556), Alvarene N. Owens Co. L.P.A., 1101 Salem Avenue, Dayton, Ohio 45406, Tel: (937) 275-6842, Fax: (937) 275-7839, Aowens @owenslawofc.com
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Patrick K. Adkinson (0016980), Adkinson Law Office, 4244 Indian Ripple Rd., Suite 150, Dayton, Ohio 45440, (937) 431-9660 phone, (937) 431-9670 fax, [email protected]
Judge(s): Timothy N. O'Connell
Date(s): 02/06/2012
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
16
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case. Plaintiff filed a motion in limine to limit his testimony because it failed to meet the admissibility requirements of Ohio Rules of Evidence 702 and 703 and/or the reliability requirement of Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, 509 U.S. 579 (1993) and Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael, 119 S.Ct. 1167 (1999). The Court overruled Plaintiff’s motion in limine to limit his testimony.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Defendant's Memorandum In Opposition To Plaintiff's Daubert Motion And Motion Re: Coroner's Report
2. Plaintiff's Motion In Limine/Daubert Challenge To Limit Defendant's Expert, John Doe, M.D. Testimony At Trial
3. Plaintiff's Motion In Limine To Preclude Defendants From Presenting Any Evidence Contradictory To The Coroner's Report At Trial
4. Plaintiff's Motion In Limine To Exclude Any Reference To The Polarizable Foreign Material Found In Horace Davis' Lungs And Any Reference To Horace Davis' Alleged Use Of Illegal Drugs
5. Decision and Entry Overruling Plaintiff's Motion in Limine/Daubert Challenge to Limit Defendant's Expert, John Doe, M.D., Testimony at Trial
Motion to preclude filed; not ruled upon due to dismissal of the suit with prejudice pursuant to Local Rule 41.1(B).
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Coburn V. Night Hawk Radiology Services, LLC
Docket Number: 2:09-CV-06050
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Grounds of Challenge: Methodology, Qualification, Relevance, Legal Conclusion, Obvious Conclusion
Area of Law: Personal Injury
Jurisdiction: Federal
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
17
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
State: Pennsylvania
Court Name: U.S. District Court, Eastern District Of Pennsylvania
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Laura A. Feldman
Defendant’s Attorney(s): James R. Kahn
Judge(s): Legrome D. Davis
Date(s): 09/15/2011
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case. Defendant filed a motion to preclude his testimony. Defendant’s motion to preclude his testimony was not ruled upon due to dismissal of the suit with prejudice pursuant to Local Rule 41.1(B).
Supporting Document(s): 1. Answer In Opposition Re Motion To Preclude Testimony And Evidence Of Plaintiff's Expert John Doe, M.D. Filed By Thomas Coburn, Memorandum, Certificate Of Service. (Attachments: # 1 Text Of Proposed Order, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit) (Request Document)
2. Motion To Preclude Testimony And Evidence Of Plaintiff's Expert John Doe, M.D. Filed By Night Hawk Radiology Services, LLC. Memorandum, Certificate Of Service. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit) (Request Document)
3. Order Dismissing Action with Prejudice Pursuant To Local Rule 41.1(B). Signed By Honorable Legrome D. Davis (Request Document)
Motion in limine to limit filed; outcome unknown.
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Rendano, Ralph Exec Of Theest Of Victoria Rendano V. St. Elizabeth Health
Center Et Al Mac
Docket Number: 2003-CV-02264
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
18
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Grounds of Challenge: Unknown
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas, Mahoning County, Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Brian Kopp
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Edward H. Blakemore
Judge(s): Maureen A. Cronin
Date(s): 11/13/2006
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case. Plaintiff filed a motion in limine to limit his testimony. The outcome of Plaintiff’s motion in limine to limit his testimony is unknown.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Deposition Of John Doe MD Filed By Pltf
2. Pltf's Motion In Limine To Limit The Testimony Of John Doe MD Filed
Motion in limine to exclude filed; outcome unknown.
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Roshell Blue V. University Of Maryland Medical Systems Corporation
Docket Number: 24-C-10-006438
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Grounds of Challenge: Unknown
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
19
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court, Baltimore City County, Maryland
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Julia R. Arfaa
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Catherine W. Steiner
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 11/05/2012
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case. Plaintiff filed a motion in limine to exclude his testimony. The outcome of Plaintiff’s motion in limine to exclude his testimony is unknown.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Defendant's Opposition To Plaintiff's Motion In Limine To Exclude The Affirmative Causation Opinion Of John Doe, M.D.
2. Plaintiff's Motion In Limine To Exclude The Affirmative Causation Opinion Of John Doe M.D. Granted
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
20
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
INDIRECT CHALLENGES
This section includes reported, and numerous unreported cases from both state and federal jurisdictions where the
expert’s testimony has been cited or mentioned in a decision and the testifying expert’s testimony has been offered in
support of, in response to, or in opposition to motion for summary judgment, class certification, preliminary injunction,
motion for a new trial or judgment notwithstanding the verdict. Sources for unreported decisions include docket sheets,
litigation reports, jury verdicts, and other online resources. Although care has been followed to gather this information,
not all cases involving such indirect expert challenges are reported.
Testimony found credible.
Case Source: Opinion
Case Caption: Giambalvo V. United States
Docket Number: 1:11-CV-14
Case Cite(s): 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 30212
Grounds of Challenge: Others
Area of Law: Tort Law
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: West Virginia
Court Name: United States District Court For The Northern District Of West Virginia
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Jay T. McCamic, Joseph R. Blalock, Lead Attorney, McCamic, Sacco & McCoid, PLLC, Wheeling, WV, USA
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Alan G. McGonigal, Helen Campbell Altmeyer, Rita R. Valdrini, Lead Attorney, U.S. Attorney's Office - Whg, Wheeling, WV USA; Erin K. Reisenweber, Lead Attorney, U.S. Attorney's Office - Mrt., Martinsburg, WV USA
Judge(s): James E. Seibert
Date(s): 03/12/2015
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case. The Court held that “With respect to the removal of Giambalvo's toenail by Azumah, this Court finds the testimony of Dr. Doe to be more credible and useful than that of any other testifying
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
21
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
physician.”
Supporting Document(s): 1. Opinion dated March 12, 2015
Testimony filed in support of motion for summary judgment; motion denied as moot.
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Bentley V. Highlands Hospital Corporation Et Al
Docket Number: 7:15cv97
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Grounds of Challenge: Others
Area of Law: Other Statutory Actions
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: Kentucky
Court Name: U.S. District - Kentucky Eastern
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Charles Allen Foster
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Timothy H. Napier
Judge(s): Amul R. Thapar
Date(s): 12/28/2016
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case. Defendant filed his testimony in support of its motion for summary judgment. The Court denied as moot Defendant’s motion for summary judgment.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Deposition Transcript Of John Doe, M.D. Taken On June 6, 2016 By Robyn Bentley. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 5) (Request Document)
2. Response Brief To Defendants' Motions For Summary Judgment Regarding Statute Of Limitations Filed By Robyn
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
22
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Bentley. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Burroughs Testimony Re Fiduciary Duty, # 2 Exhibit 2 - McGinty Testimony Re Fiduciary Duty, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Major Testimony Re Fiduciary Duty, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Affidavit Of Robyn Bentley, # 5 Exhibit 5 - Bentley Testimony Re Pardo, # 6 Exhibit 6 - Pardo Testimony Re Bentley, # 7 Exhibit 7 - Rocky Adams Testimony Re Pardo, # 8 Exhibit 8 - Bentley Testimony Re Cb Admission, # 9 Exhibit 10 - Jhh Info Re Transverse Myelitis, # 10 Exhibit 11 - Doe Expert Report, # 11 Exhibit 12 - Corwin Expert Report, # 12 Exhibit 13 - Gebel Expert Report, # 13 Exhibit 14 - Bentley Testimony Re Letter, # 14 Exhibit 15 - Documentation Of Cardinal Hill Admission Dates, # 15 Exhibit 16 - Blankenship Re Billing Dispute, # 16 Exhibit 17 - Major Re Billing Dispute, # 17 Exhibit 18 - Schmidt Expert Report, # 18 Exhibit 19 - Burroughs Expert Report, # 19 Exhibit 20 - Bentley Testimony Re Purported Release, # 20 Exhibit 21 - Hardin Testimony Re 3d Party Debt Collectors, # 21 Exhibit 22 - Major Testimony Re 3d Party Billing, # 22 Exhibit 23 - Major Testimony Re Vendor Management Of 3d Party Collectors) (Request Document)
3. Notice To Take Deposition Of John Doe, M.D. On Monday, June 6, 2016 At 8:00 A.M. Local Time By Robyn Bentley (Request Document)
4. Order: (1) Highlands's Motion For Summary Judgment, R., Is Denied As Moot. (2) Highlands's Objections To Bentley's Pretrial Disclosures, R., Are Overruled As Moot. (3) Highlands's Motion To Join In Paintsville Hospital Company's Motion For A Status Conference, R., Is Denied As Moot. (4) Bentley's Objections To Highlands's Pretrial Disclosures, R., Are Overruled As Moot. (5) Dr. Hall's Motion For Summary Judgment, R., Is Denied As Moot. (6) Dr. Hall's Motion In Limine, R., Is Denied As Moot. (7) Bentley's Objections To Dr. Hall's Pretrial Disclosures, R., Are Overruled As Moot. Signed By Judge Amul R. Thapar On 12/28/2016 (Request Document)
Testimony sufficient to win grant of motion for summary judgment; reversed and remanded.
Case Source: Opinion, Brief Bank
Case Caption: Crise V. Md. Gen. Hosp., Inc.
Docket Number: 2562
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
23
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Cite(s): 212 Md. App. 492; 69 A.3d 536; 2013 Md. App. LEXIS 82; 2012 WL 5508557; 2012 WL 7802722
Grounds of Challenge: Others
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Court Of Special Appeals Of Maryland
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Argued By: Michael A. Pulver (Thomas F. Yost, Jr., The Yost Legal Group On The Brief)
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Christopher R. Daily (J. Mark Coulson, Miles & Stockbridge PC On The Brief)
Judge(s): Deborah S. Eyler, Watts, Lawrence F Rodowsky
Date(s): 06/27/2013
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case. Defendant filed his testimony in support of its motion for summary judgment. The trial court had granted Defendant’s motion for summary judgment. Plaintiff appealed. The judgment was reversed and remanded.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Opinion dated June 27, 2013 (Request Document)
2. Brief Of Appellant
3. Reply Brief
Testimony not relied upon; affirmed.
Case Source: Opinion, Brief Bank
Case Caption: Gelesh V. State Med. Bd.
Docket Number: 10AP-169
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
24
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Cite(s): 2010-Ohio-4378; 2010 Ohio App. LEXIS 3698
Grounds of Challenge: Others
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Appeals Of Ohio, Tenth Appellate District, Franklin County
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Dinsmore & Shohl, LLP, Eric J. Plinke And Gregory P. Mathews; Lambert & Macdonald, Co., LPA, John D. Lambert And Ida L. Macdonald
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Richard Cordray, Attorney General, And Kyle C. Wilcox
Judge(s): Tyack, Brown And McGrath
Date(s): 09/16/2010
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case. The Court did not rely upon his testimony. The judgment was affirmed.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Opinion dated September 16, 2010
2. Notice Of Appeal Of Appellant Gary C. Gelesh, D.O.
Testimony relied upon; affirmed.
Case Source: Opinion, Brief Bank
Case Caption: Nance V. Univ. Emergency Specialists, Inc.
Docket Number: 91512
Case Cite(s): 2009-Ohio-2133; 2009 Ohio App. LEXIS 1823; 2008 WL 6677486; 2008 WL 6677485
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
25
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Grounds of Challenge: Others
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Appeals Of Ohio, Eighth Appellate District, Cuyahoga County
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Heather L. Tonsing Volosin, Esq., Andrew Agati, Esq., Robin G. Weaver, Esq., Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, L.L.P., Cleveland, Ohio
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Mark R. Jones, Esq., Douglas G. Leak, Esq., Tammi J. Lees, Esq., Roetzel & Andress, Cleveland, Ohio
Judge(s): Ann Dyke, Melody J. Stewart And Larry A. Jones
Date(s): 05/07/2009
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an emergency room expert in the instant case. The Appellate Court held “We find no abuse of discretion in this matter in light of the [**14] evidence presented which indicated that, following the third intubation, bilateral breath sounds were observed, Kevin was noted to be emitting CO2, and his pulse oxygen level increased to 98 percent, all of which signified a successful insertion of the endotracheal tube. According to Dr. Doe, the successfully placed tube could have moved due to movement of the decedent's head prior to autopsy, so there was evidence from which the jury could conclude that the physical facts as determined at the time of autopsy were not the same as those existing following the third intubation. We therefore find that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the motion for a new trial.” The judgment was affirmed.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Opinion dated May 7, 2009
2. Brief Of Appellee, University Emergency Specialists, Inc.
3. Brief Of Appellant
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
26
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
OTHER CASES INVOLVING JOHN DOE
These are cases where the expert was retained. However, no challenge or credibility assessment activity for the expert
was found in these cases. Please note that not all cases where an expert is retained mention the name of the expert and
hence, these cases do not constitute an exhaustive list of the expert's testimonial history.
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Takacs V. Hospital
Docket Number: 09-9629
Case Cite(s): 2012 WL 8666673
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Pennsylvania
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas Of Pennsylvania
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Roland Stock, LLC, Edwin L. Stock, Esquire, Attorney I.D. #43787, 627 North Fourth Street, P.O. Box 902, Reading, Pa 19603, (610) 372-5588
Judge(s): Timothy J. Rowley
Date(s): 12/06/2012
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an emergency medicine expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Pretrial Memorandum Of Defendants The Reading Hospital And Medical Center And Duane D. Siberski. D.O.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
27
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Lombardini V. Harbor Hospital, Inc.
Docket Number: 24C10005172
Case Cite(s): 2011 WL 8844431
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): H. Briggs Bedigian, Keith D. Forman, Wais, Vogelstein & Bedigian, LLC, 1829 Reisterstown Road, Suite 425, Baltimore, Maryland 21208, (410) 998-3600 T/ (410) 998-3600 F
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Jennifer E Phillips
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 01/13/2011
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. First Amended Complaint And Request For Jury Trial
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Brooks V. Maryland General Hospital, Inc.
Docket Number: 24-C06-007573-0T
Case Cite(s): 2007 WL 7711715
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
28
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Gary A. Wais
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 09/17/2007
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Plaintiffs Response In Opposition To Defendant's Motion To Bifurcate Damages And Liability Phases Of Trial And To Exclude Crystal Babb's Day-In-The-Life Video From Trial
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Niven V. Baltimore Washington Medical Center, Inc.
Docket Number: 02-C-11-163591
Case Cite(s): 2013 WL 1386932
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Jon W. Brassel, Jennifer M. Alexander, Brassel Alexander & Rice, LLC, 900 Bestgate Road, Suite 402, Annapolis, MD 21401, 443-837-9800
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Mairi Pat Maguire, Esquire, [email protected], Caroline Cathell, Esquire, [email protected], Pessin Katz Law, P.A., 901
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
29
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Dulaney Valley Road, Suite 400, Towson, Maryland 21204, 410-339-5795
Judge(s): Paul G. Goetzke
Date(s): 01/14/2013
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an emergency medicine expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Defendants' Amended Pretrial Statement
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Crawford V. Boehmer
Docket Number: 05CVA-09-10362
Case Cite(s): 2006 WL 3540676; 2006 WL 3540675
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): T. Jeffrey Beausay (0039436), Twyford & Donahey, 495 South High St., Suite 100, Columbus, OH 43215-5058, Telephone: (614) 224-8166, Fax: (614) 849-0475
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Arnold Todaro & Welch Co., LPA, Peter Van Ligten (0066916), John E. Arnold (0022068), 2075 Marble Cliff Office Park, Columbus, OH 43215, [email protected], Direct: (614) 324-4540, Fax: (614) 485-1944
Judge(s): Richard A. Frye
Date(s): 08/18/2006
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an emergency medicine
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
30
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Pretrial Statement Of Defendants, David C. Boehmer, D.O. And Mid-Ohio Emergency Services, LLC
2. Memorandum Contra Plaintiff's Motion For Order Limiting Number Of Expert Witnesses
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Patricia V. South Pointe Hospital Systems
Docket Number: 482025
Case Cite(s): 2004 WL 3665378; 2004 WL 3543702
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Michael D. Shroge (0072667), Ronald A. Mingus (0047217), Reminger & Reminger Co., L.P.A., 1400 Midland Building, 101 Prospect Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44115, (216) 687-1311
Judge(s): Lillian J. Greene
Date(s): 01/26/2004
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Trial Brief Of Defendants Lisa Deranek, M.D. And Lakeland Emergency Associates, Inc.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
31
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Source: Trial Order
Case Caption: Prater V. Ma
Docket Number: 09-029707
Case Cite(s): 2011 WL 8997453
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Michigan
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Michigan, Wayne County
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Alan B Posner P27981, Kelman Loria, PLLC, 17000 W. 10 Mile Road, Suite 100, Southfield, MI 48075-2923, Direct Dial: (248) 228-8169, Fax: (248) 228-8875, [email protected]
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Anthony G. Arnone P28126, Cheryl A. Cardelli P36017, Susan Healy Zitterman P33392, Kitch, Drutchas, Wagner, et al, 1 Woodward Ave., Suite 2400, Detroit, Michigan 48226, (313) 965-7900, Fax: (313) 965-7403, [email protected], [email protected]
Judge(s): Kathleen Macdonald
Date(s): 04/06/2011
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case. Plaintiff filed a motion to replace his with another expert. The Court granted Plaintiff’s motion to replace his as an expert and file a new expert.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Order Permitting Plaintiff To Name New Expert, Denying Summary Disposition, And Adjourning Trial
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
32
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Source: Brief Bank
Case Caption: Griffin V. MDK Food Services, Inc.
Docket Number: 03 082314
Case Cite(s): 2003 WL 24296645
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Appeals Of Ohio, Eighth District, Cuyahoga County
Retained By: Not Applicable
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Steven A. Sindell, Esq. (0002508), James P. Boyle, Esq. (0055299), Sindell, Young, Guidubaldi & Sucher, 55 Public Square, Suite 1020, Cleveland, Ohio 44113, (216) 623-1123
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 08/10/2003
Summary of Involvement: Doe’s prior litigation captioned “Nickler v. Mercy Medical Center, Case No. 00169, 2003 Ohio LEXIS 535, 2003 Ohio 545 at (Stark Cty. Feb. 3, 2003)” was referred to in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Reply Brief Of Appellants, Michael Kafantaris And MDK Food Service, Inc.
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Jacobs V. Helgason
Docket Number: 02CVA-12-13572
Case Cite(s): 2005 WL 3681992
Area of Law: Negligence
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
33
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Tim Van Eman (0002015), Lamkin, Van Eman, Trimble, Beals & Dougherty, 500 South Front Street, Suite 200, Columbus, OH 43215, (614) 224-8187
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Arnold Todaro & Welch Co., L.P.A., By: Peter Van Ligten (0066916), 2075 MaibleCliff Office Park, Columbus, Ohio 43215, [email protected], Direct: (614) 324-4540, Fax: (614) 485-1944
Judge(s): Richard A. Frye
Date(s): 05/18/2005
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Motion In Limine To Preclude Plaintiff At Trial From Introducing Evidence Of, Mentioning, Or Questioning Of Any Medical Board Investigation Of Stephen D. Waite, M.D.
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Roberts V. Gadzinski
Docket Number: 11-010725
Case Cite(s): 2012 WL 8305257
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Michigan
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Michigan
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
34
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Norman S. Miller (P68199), David M. Cobb (P73243), Health Advocates Law, P.L.L.C., 2760 East Lansing Drive, Suite 3, East Lansing, Michigan 48823, Phone: (517) 507-0407, Fax: (517) 803-4387
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Michael D. Dolenga (P48794), Jeffrey R. Nowicki (P58880), Dolenga & Dolenga, P.L.L.C., 24001 Orchard Lake Road, Suite 190, Farmington, Michigan 48336, (248) 478-9922; Fax: 478-9933
Judge(s): Daphne Means Curtis
Date(s): 07/16/2012
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an emergency medicine expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Plaintiff's First Amended Witness List
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Antolik V. Csortan
Docket Number: 461513
Case Cite(s): 2003 WL 24161903; 2003 WL 24181936
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Henry W. Chamberlain, Esq. #0046682, Weisman, Goldberg & Weisman Co., L.P.A., 1600 Midland Building, 101 Prospect Avenue, West, Cleveland, Ohio 44115, (216) 781-1111, [email protected]
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Thomas B. Kilbane, Esq. (0066943), Kathleen A. Atkinson, Esq. (0074665), Reminger & Reminger Co., L.P.A., 1400 Midland Building, 101 Prospect Avenue West, Cleveland, Ohio 44115-1093,
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
35
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
(216) 687-1311
Judge(s): Timothy McCormick
Date(s): 08/06/2003
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Trial Brief On Behalf Of Defendants, Eric Csortan, M.D. And Lake Emergency Services, Inc.
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Acosta, Yordanka (Pers Rep) V. Er Physicians Svcs At Cedars (LLC)
Docket Number: 2005-001355-CA-01
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Florida
Court Name: 11th Judicial Circuit Of Florida, Miami-Dade County, Florida
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Judd G Rosen
Defendant’s Attorney(s): James J Nosich
Judge(s): Thomas S. Wilson
Date(s): 03/28/2006
Summary of Involvement: Doe was deposed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Notice Of Filing: Deposition Of John Doe, M.D.
2. Copy Of: Deposition Of John Doe, M.D.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
36
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Brunner V. United States Of America
Docket Number: 5:12-CV-00141
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: West Virginia
Court Name: U.S. District Court, Northern District Of West Virginia
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Chad C. Groome
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Alan G. McGonigal
Judge(s): John Preston Bailey
Date(s): 11/25/2013
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed by the Defendant in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Certificate Of Service By United States Of America Re Deposition Of John Doe MD (Request Document)
2. Certificate Of Service By United States Of America Re Notice Of Deposition Of John Doe MD (Request Document)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Daniel Tyson V. Fisher Titus
Docket Number: G-4801-CI-200305024
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
37
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas, Lucas County, Ohio
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Charles E. Boyk
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Patrick B Cavanaugh
Judge(s): James D. Bates
Date(s): 10/26/2004
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Title : Pld: Notice Of Deposition To John Doe MD
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Evelyn Hoban, Et Al V. Henry L Francis, Et Al
Docket Number: 02-C-12-168092
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court, Anne Arundel County, Maryland
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Diane M. Littlepage
Defendant’s Attorney(s): John T. Sly
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
38
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 01/15/2013
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Plaintiffs' Response To Opposition To Plaintiffs' Motion To Set Fees For Discovery Depositions Of John Doe, M.D., And Other Defendant’s Expert Witnesses With Exhibits
2. Opposition To Plaintiffs' Motion To Set Fees For Discovery Depositions Of John Doe M.D. And Other Defense Expert Depositions With Exhibits
3. Plaintiffs' Motion To Set Fees For Discovery Depositions Of John Doe M.D. And Other Defense Expert Witnesses With Exhibits Filed By Plt001-Hoban, Plt002-Schatz, Plt003-Schatz
4. Notice Of Discovery (Notice To Take Deposition Of Dr. John Doe)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Ham V. Marshall County, Kentucky Et Al
Docket Number: 5:11-CV-00011
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Rights
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: Kentucky
Court Name: U.S. District Court, Western District Of Kentucky
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Gregory A. Belzley
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Stacey A. Blankenship
Judge(s): Thomas B. Russell
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
39
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Date(s): 06/15/2012
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Witness List By Sterling Emergency Services Of The Midwest, Inc, Scott Wilson. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Expert Report Of John Doe, M.D., # 2 Exhibit B - Expert Report Of Phillip Tibbs, M.D. (Part 1), # 3 Exhibit B Cont'd - Expert Report Of Phillip Tibbs, M.D. (Part 2)) (Request Document)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: John Clark V. Sukhpal Jassi, Et Al
Docket Number: 02-C-08-130823
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court, Anne Arundel County, Maryland
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Philip C Federico
Defendant’s Attorney(s): E Philip Franke III
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 08/13/2009
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Notice Of Discovery Notice To Take Deposition Of Dr. John Doe
Case Source: Docket
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
40
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Caption: Associates In Orthopaedics, Inc. Et Al V. St. Vincent Charity Hospital
Docket Number: 1:02cv1312
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Rights
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: Ohio
Court Name: U.S. District - Ohio Northern
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Mark J. Savage
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Colleen C. Curran
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 11/05/2003
Summary of Involvement: A subpoena was served on Doe in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Subpoena Returned Executed; Served Upon John Doe, M.D. By Personal Service On 11/03/03 Filed By St. Vincent Charity Hospital (Request Document)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Baire V. Acute Care
Docket Number: 04CV138126
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
41
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Court Name: OH Court of Common Pleas - Lorain
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): John R. Miraldi
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Christine S. Reid
Judge(s): Edward Zaleski
Date(s): 08/28/2006
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Pltfs' Notice of Filing of Deposition Transcripts of Christopher Adelman, M.D. Deeppreet Singh, M.D. James F. Thoburn, Pa-C, John Doe, M.D., Richard A. Josephson, M.S., M.D. And Andrea Graziano Filed
2. Deposition of John Doe, M.D., Taken 12-22-05, Filed
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Burdine V. Bryan Community
Docket Number: G-4801-CI-200205800
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: OH Court of Common Pleas - Lucas
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Stephen J. Charms
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Thomas P. Mannion
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
42
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Judge(s): Denise Ann Dartt
Date(s): 10/13/2005
Summary of Involvement: Doe was deposed by the Plaintiff in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Return Of Service On Subpoena, P1 - Burdine George III, John A Doe Residence Service At 3:40 PM 6 16 05
2. Pld: Deposition, P1 - Burdine George III, John Doe MD
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Rogers, Frederick And Rogers, Helen V. Bulgrin, Kathryn, Et Al.
Docket Number: 2003CV2919
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: OH Court of Common Pleas - Trumbull
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Carol A. Sopkovich
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Thomas Treadon
Judge(s): John M. Stuard
Date(s): 09/15/2006
Summary of Involvement: Doe was deposed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Deposition Of: John Ann Doe MD Filed
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
43
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Virginia Natoli V. Massillon Community Hospital Et Al
Docket Number: 2005CV01939
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas, Stark County, Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Theresa Ann Tarchinski
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Donald Hugh Switzer
Judge(s): Charles E. Brown
Date(s): 05/12/2006
Summary of Involvement: A notice to take deposition of Doe was filed by the Plaintiff in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Plaintiff Virginia Natoli - Notice To Take Deposition Of Dr John Doe With Proof Of Service
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Stephan Germanoff V. Aultman Hospital, Et Al
Docket Number: 2000CV01475
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
44
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Common Pleas, Stark County, Ohio
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Charles Israel Kampinski
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Philip E. Howes
Judge(s): Sara E. Lioi
Date(s): 08/24/2001
Summary of Involvement: Doe was deposed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Deposition Of John Doe MD
2. Certificate Of Compliance Filed (Deposition) For Stacey Hollaway MD, John Doe MD And Norman Schneiderman MD
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Ward V. Lai
Docket Number: 24C08006946
Case Cite(s): 2009 WL 8632683
Area of Law: Unknown
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland
Retained By: Not Applicable
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
45
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Date(s): 05/04/2009
Summary of Involvement: Doe was mentioned in the report authored by Dr. Timothy Bessent, M.D. in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Report Of Timothy Bessent, M.D.
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Helton V. Caloia
Docket Number: 08122004NH
Case Cite(s): 2008 WL 8153582
Area of Law: Unknown
Jurisdiction: State
State: Michigan
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Michigan
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 08/26/2008
Summary of Involvement: An affidavit authored by Doe was filed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Affidavit Of John Doe, MD FACEP
Case Source: Opinion, Docket
Case Caption: Nickler V. Mercy Med. Ctr.
Docket Number: 2002CA00169
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
46
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Cite(s): 2003-Ohio-545; 2003 Ohio App. LEXIS 535
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Ohio
Court Name: Court Of Appeals Of Ohio, Fifth Appellate District, Stark County, Court Of Common Pleas, Stark County, Ohio
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Jack Morrison, Jr., Theresa A. Tarchinski, Akron, OH
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Alicia M. Wyler, Jill C. McQueen, Canton, OH, Stephan Kremer, Akron, OH
Judge(s): William B. Hoffman, Sheila G. Farmer, John W. Wise
Date(s): 02/03/2003
Summary of Involvement: Doe, an emergency room physician, was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Opinion dated February 3, 2003
2. Plaintiffs Memorandum Opposing Mercy's Motion In Limine Concerning Opinions Offered By Dr. Doe With Proof Of Service
3. Deposition Of John A Doe Filed
4. Certificate Of Compliance Filed (Deposition) For Depositions For Dave Rascona, Alfred Granson Jr. M.D., Robert E Kramer M.D., Rosemary Brace, Thomas W Watson M.D., Robert L Vogelsang M.D., Dean Dobkin M.D., Walter W. Stauser M.D., John A Doe M.D., Nathan Levitan M.D, Nathan Levitan M.D., Rebecca Eiwen M.D., Linda L. Porter R.N., Vernon Keith Sondak M.D., Scott D Weiner M.D., Douglas R Keyser M.D. And Proof Of Service Filed
5. Plaintiff's Notice Of Filing Deposition Of Dave Rascona, Alfred Granson Jr. M.D., Robert E. Kramer M.D., Rosemary Brace, Thomas W. Watson, Robert L. Vogelzang M.D., Dean Dobkin M.D., Walter W. Strauser M.D., John Doe M.D., Nathan Levitan M.D., Nathan Levitan M.D., Rebecca Eiwen M.D, Linda L. Porter R N., Vernon Keith Sondak M.D., Scott D Weiner M.D. And
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
47
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Douglas R Keyser M.D. And Proof Of Service Filed
6. Certificate Of Compliance Filed (Deposition) Of John A Doe MD
7. Plaintiffs Notice Of Filing Depositions Of Richard S Krause MD, Nino Diiullo MD, Robert H Quin MD, John A Doe MD With Proof Of Service
8. Plaintiffs - Notice To Take Deposition Of Robert Bogelzang MD And John Doe MD With Proof Of Service
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Sue Lewis V. Raleigh General Hospital, LLC, A West Vi Et Al
Docket Number: 14-C-748
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Civil Law
Jurisdiction: State
State: West Virginia
Court Name: WV Circuit - Raleigh
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Kelly R. Reed
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Robert A. Burnside, Jr.
Date(s): 06/07/2016
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed by the Defendant in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Cert of Serv For "notice of Videotaped Deposition of John Doe Md. Glh (B.C.)
2. Cert of Serv "raleigh General Hospital Llc's Amended Notice to
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
48
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Take Videotaped Deposition of John Doe M.D." (Amy) (Jed)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Estate Of Deceased Joseph Henry Manfreda V. Mt Clemens Regional Medical Center
Docket Number: 2016-003116
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Michigan
Court Name: 16th Judicial Circuit Court, Macomb County, Michigan
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Ronald F. Denardis
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Victoria Shay Lehman
Judge(s): Jennifer M. Faunce
Date(s): 08/31/2016
Summary of Involvement: An affidavit authored by Doe was filed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Affidavit Of Merit Of John Doe MD FACEP
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Mandeville Et Al V. Nathanson Et Al
Docket Number: 5:14cv25013
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
49
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: West Virginia
Court Name: U.S. District - West Virginia Southern
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): David B. Lunsford
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Bernard S. Vallejos
Judge(s): Irene C. Berger
Date(s): 06/16/2015
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed by the Defendant in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Second Amended Notice To Take Deposition Subpoena Duces Tecum By Steven Harry Nathanson Of John Doe, M.D. (Second Amended Notice) On July 17, 2015 At 10:30 A.M. (Request Document)
2. Amended Notice To Take Deposition Subpoena Duces Tecum By Steven Harry Nathanson Of John Doe, M.D. On July 17, 2015 At 12:00 P.M. (Request Document)
3. Notice To Take Deposition Subpoena Duces Tecum By Steven Harry Nathanson Of John Doe, M.D. On July 17, 2015 At 10:30 A.M. (Request Document)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Phillip Harris, Et Al. V. Baltimore Washington Medical Center, Inc.
Docket Number: C-02-CV-15-000322
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
50
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court, Anne Arundel County, Maryland
Retained By: Not Mentioned
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Jonathan Schochor, Esq.
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Neal M. Brown
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 08/21/2015
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Notice Of Service Of Discovery (Notice To Take Deposition Of John Doe, M.D.) Notice Of Discovery
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Pressley V. Hopehealth Inc. Et Al
Docket Number: 4:16cv86
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: South Carolina
Court Name: U.S. District - South Carolina
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Robert Daniel Dodson
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Barbara Murcier Bowens
Judge(s): R. Bryan Harwell
Date(s): 08/08/2016
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
51
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Plaintiff's ID Of Expert Witnesses By Monique S Pressley. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit 1 Expert Report Of Dr. John Doe, # 2 Exhibit Exhibit 2 Expert Report Of Dr. Brent Rody) (Request Document)
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Sobo, Kodjo V. Hayes, Vincent Depaul MD
Docket Number: 394103
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court, Montgomery County, Maryland
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): H. Briggs Bedigian
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Benjamin S. Vaughan
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 12/07/2015
Summary of Involvement: A notice to depose Doe was filed by the Defendant in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Motion, Appropriate Relief Plaintiffs' Motion For Ruling On Objections Posed During The De Bene Esse Deposition Of John Doe, M.D., Request For Hearing And Attachments, Filed. Motion
2. Hearing Hearing (Albright, J.) On Plaintiff's Motion For Ruling On Objections Posed During The De Bene Esse Deposition Of John Doe, M.D. (#81) - Granted In Part And Denied In Part As Set Forth On The Record.Audio Media: 00-120215 Start:
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
52
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
13:26:22 Stop: 17:02:49 Ruling Anne Korbel Albright
3. Certificate Regarding Discovery Defendants' Certificate Regarding Discovery As To Amended Notices To Take Deposition Duces Tecum Of John Doe, M.D., John Schweiger, M.D., Martin Raff, JD. MD: Nancy Bond And Thomas Borzilleri, Ph.D., Docket
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Jaskulski-Tripp V. Franklin Square Hospital Center, Inc. And Cobert
Docket Number: 03-C-15-009680
Case Cite(s): 2015 WL 5920459
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland, Baltimore County
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Paul M. D'Amore, Ruslan Kondratyuk, Wais, Vogelstein & Forman, LLC, 1829 Reisterstown Road, Suite 425, Baltimore, Maryland 21208, (410) 998-3600, (410) 998-3680 Fax
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 09/08/2015
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Complaint And Demand For Jury Trial
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
53
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Case Source: Brief Bank
Case Caption: Kirby V. Johns Hopkins Hospital
Docket Number: 02357
Case Cite(s): 2016 WL 3039102
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Maryland Court Of Special Appeals
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Keith D. Forman, Esquire, Wais, Vogelstein, Forman & Offutt, LLC, 1829 Reisterstown Road, Suite 425, Baltimore, Maryland 21208, (410) 998-3600, [email protected]
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Jeannie J. Hong
Date(s): 05/02/2016
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Brief Of Appellants
Case Source: Trial Pleading
Case Caption: Steele V. Dimensions Health Corporation
Docket Number: CAL15 -- 13593
Case Cite(s): 2015 WL 1924368
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
54
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland, Prince George's County
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Hendrick Briggs Bedigian, Gilman & Bedigian, LLC, 108 W. Timonium Road, Suite 203, Timonium, Maryland 21093, 410 560-4999
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Not Mentioned
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 04/22/2015
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Complaint And Demand For Jury Trial
Case Source: Trial Pleading, Brief Bank
Case Caption: Blue V. University Of Maryland Medical Systems Corp.
Docket Number: 24-C-006438, 1541
Case Cite(s): 2015 WL 11116809; 2014 WL 6696722; 2014 WL 6696721; 2014 WL 6696723
Area of Law: Medical Malpractice
Jurisdiction: State
State: Maryland
Court Name: Circuit Court Of Maryland, Baltimore City, Maryland Court Of Special Appeals
Retained By: Plaintiff
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Emily C. Malarkey, Salsbury, Clements, Bekman, Marder & Adkins, LLC, 300 West Pratt Street, Suite 450, Baltimore, Maryland 21201, 410-539-6633
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
55
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Mairi Pat Maguire, Esq., James R. Benjamin, Jr., Esq., Pessin Katz Law, P.A., 901 Dulaney Valley Road, Suite 400, Towson, Maryland 21204, (410) 938-8800, [email protected], [email protected]
Judge(s): Althea M. Handy
Date(s): 01/01/2015
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Plaintiff as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Motion To Compel Deposition Of Corporate Designee Of University Of Maryland Billing Department
2. Brief For Appellant
3. Reply Brief For Appellant
4. Brief Of Appellee
Case Source: Docket, Brief Bank
Case Caption: Garcia, Carmen V. Kranichfeld, William H (Jr.) (MD)
Docket Number: 2004-021711-CA-01
Case Cite(s): 2008 WL 2036838
Area of Law: Negligence
Jurisdiction: State
State: Florida
Court Name: 11th Judicial Circuit Of Florida, Miami-Dade County, Florida, District Court Of Appeal Of Florida, Third District
Retained By: Defendant
Plaintiff’s Attorney(s): Hersch & Talisman and Patrice A. Talisman; Ratiner, Lagos & Mirabal
Defendant’s Attorney(s): Hugh L. Wood, Jr.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
56
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
PERSONAL LITIGATION HISTORY
If the expert has been a party to a litigation, such cases are documented in this section.
Judge(s): Jose M. Rodriguez
Date(s): 01/01/2008
Summary of Involvement: Doe was retained by the Defendant as an expert in the instant case.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Direct Examination Of John Doe Taken
2. Motion To Strike Defense Expert, John Doe, MD
3. Appellants' Initial Brief
Case Source: Docket
Case Caption: Tout, Et Al V. Medpartners, Inc., Et Al
Docket Number: 1:97-CV-00474
Case Cite(s): Not Applicable
Area of Law: Contracts
Jurisdiction: Federal
State: Ohio
Court Name: U.S. District Court Northern District Of Ohio
Judge(s): Not Mentioned
Date(s): 02/25/1997
Summary of Involvement: Doe was mentioned as a party in the instant civil suit.
Supporting Document(s): 1. Docket Summary
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
57
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
JURY VERDICT REPORTS MENTIONING DOE AS AN EXPERT WITNESS
The following Jury Verdict Reports/ Summaries mentioned Doe as an expert witness involved in the case.
1 Andry V. Joseph A. Perkins, D.O., Rachael Karchner, Cpn, And Emergency Physicians Of Northwest Ohio, G-4801-Ci-201502544-000-4801
2 Antolik, Theodore Admin V. Lake Emergency Services Inc; Et Al, Cv 02 461513, Medical Malpractice, Trial, August, 2003, Ohio
3 Baire, Charles L; Et Al V. Singh, Deepreet Md; Et Al, 04cv138126, Medical Malpractice, Trial, September, 2006, Ohio
4 Bass V. Henry Alden Kirk, No Number In Original
5 Bass V. Keith Ian Stokes, 466.120457, Medical Malpractice, March 21, 2014, Mississippi
6 Bentley V. Paul B. Hall Regional Medical Center; Et Al, 15-Ci-00625; 7:15-Cv-00097-Art; 7:15-Cv-97
7 Blue V. Umms, 24-C-10-006438, Medical Malpractice, September 30, 2011, Maryland
8 Bristol, Clay Gordon V. Integris Mayes County Medical Center, Cj-05-128, Medical Malpractice, Other, June 27, 2007, Oklahoma
9 Brothers; Et Al V. Robert Petrarca D.O., Medical Malpractice, August 30, 2011, West Virginia
10 Burkhart V. Oakwood Healthcare, Inc., Et Al, 14-0050803-Nh
11 Busch; Et Al. V. Lisa M. Deranek, M.D.; Et Al., 482025, Medical Malpractice, Trial, February, 2004, Ohio
12 Capirchio V. New Britain General Hospital, Hhb Cv10 6007518, Medical Malpractice, October 08, 2012, Connecticut
13 Crawford V. Broadlawns Medical Center; Tracy Dickel, 05771 Lacl126102
14 Crawford V. Spanier, 06-0085, January 12, 2011, April 2011, 2011 Ky Trial Ct. Rev. Lexis 22
15 Crise V. Maryland General Hospital, 24c09006235
16 Davis, Jr., Et Al. V. Martha Johnston, M.D., Et Al., 2009cv5228, Medical Malpractice - Wrongful Death, February 15, 2012, July 30, 2012, Ohio
17 Devault V. Mark L Johnson, Md, 10-C-617, Medical Malpractice, August 02, 2011, West Virginia
18 Draina V. Fine, Et Al., Case No. 062004ca002053, 2009 Fl Jury Verdicts Review Lexis 2689
19 Earnheart, Judy V. Maxwell, Jon T Do; McCurtain Mem Med Mngt, Cj-02-736, Medical Malpractice, Settlement, March, 2007, Oklahoma
20 Estate Of Anonymous V. Anonymous Emergency Service And Anonymous Doctor, Wrongful Death - Medical Malpractice - Medical Malpractice - Failure To Diagnose, August 14, 2003, February 14, 2004, Ohio
21 Farnsworth, William & Melinda V. Camden-Clark Memorial Hospital, #98-C-98h, Medical Malpractice, Settlement, June 23, 1999, West Virginia
22 Frazier V. Keith McCoy, M.D., Medical Malpractice, October 10, 2012, Mississippi
23 Garcia Vs. William H. Kranichfeld, M.D. And Jose Escalante, M.D., Et Al., Docket No.: 04-21711 Ca 31;, Fjvr Reference No. 06:12-27, Verdict Date: September 29, 2006;, 2006 Fl Jury Verdicts Rptr. Lexis 1527
24 Gibson V. Ronald D. Bowe, Et Al., 09-Cv-0923, Medical Malpractice, Other, February 02, 2010, West Virginia
25 Gray V. Henry Ford Health System, 2015147576nh
26 Guerra V. Rockford Memorial Hospital; David L. McCarty, M.D.; Rockford Health Physicians, Et Al, 2014-L-0000157
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
58
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
27 Haser V. Falls Emergency Physicians, Inc. And Eric Schwiger, D.O., Cv-2010-10-7078, Medical Malpractice, November 08, 2011, April 23, 2012, Ohio
28 Helton, John V. Oakwood Hospital, Medical Malpractice, Other, March 11, 2010
29 Hiam, Timothy V. Heirendt, Stephen Do, Medical Malpractice, Other, July 07, 2010
30 Holbrook, William J V. University Of Kentucky Medical Center; Et Al, 04-Ci-1122, Medical Malpractice, Settlement, November, 2008, Kentucky
31 Hosler V. Rick Compton, No Number In Original
32 Houston V. Catawba Valley Medical Group, Inc., Medical Malpractice, October 07, 2013, North Carolina
33 Hughes, Erika V. North Ridge Medical Center; Et Al, Cace04009550, Medical Malpractice, Other, August 29, 2007, Florida
34 Jacobs V. Jehangir Meer, M.D.; St. Agnes Health Care, Inc.; Canton Emergency Physicians, Et Al, 24c13008166
35 Jacobs, Sheila; Et Al V. Helgason, Jay Md; Et Al, 02cva-12-13572, Medical Malpractice, Trial, March, 2005, Ohio
36 Johnson V. Thomas Smyth, 15-C-274
37 Kirby V. The Johns Hopkins Hospital; Robert Stevens, M.D.; Greater Baltimore Medical Center, Inc., Et Al, 24c15003893
38 Knock V. St Elizabeth Medical Center; Et Al., 09-Ci-01373, Medical Malpractice, Scheduled, June 10, 2010, Kentucky
39 Kois V. Salutis Emergency Specialists, 13-C-848
40 Lane V. Brian T. Hawkins, 10-Ci-01007, Medical Malpractice, August 15, 2011, Kentucky
41 Lee V. Johns Hopkins Hospital, 24-C-14-006273
42 Mandeville V. Southeastern Emergency Physicians, Llc; Steven Harry Nathanson, M.D, 5:14cv25013
43 Matteson, Josephine V. General Emergency Medicine, Cv-2001-11-5580, Medical Malpractice, Trial, February, 2003, Ohio
44 Maxwell Estate, Et Al. V. Dr. Marion A. Florida, Cv-2010-900098, Medical Malpractice, Other, November 05, 2010, Alabama
45 McCroskey V. Northshore University Health System; Northshore University Hospital; John Flaherty, M.D., Et Al, 2010-L-000505
46 Miller V. Jayapal Reddy, M.D, 11-C-77
47 Miller V. Mitchell Fuscardo, Medical Malpractice, August 03, 2012, West Virginia
48 Morris III V. Lisa Hrutkay, D.O., Medical Malpractice, October 26, 2010, West Virginia
49 Mosser V. Rite Aid, 12-C-21
50 Nance V. University Hospitals Of Cleveland; University Emergency Specialists, Inc., Cv 04 524392, Medical Malpractice, Trial, March 28, 2008, Ohio
51 Nerren, Gordon V. Mochizvki, Ronald Mark Md, 91 L 16007, Medical Malpractice, Other, October 16, 1995, Illinois
52 Niven V. Baltimore Washington Medical Center, 02-C-11-163591-Pm, Medical Malpractice, August 29, 2012, Maryland
53 Overstreet V. Richard Kline, 11-C-127, Medical Malpractice, Settlement, June, 2012, West Virginia
54 Payne V. John Reasoner Md, Et Al., 07cv3110, Medical Malpractice, Trial, September 08, 2008, Colorado
55 Plaintiff V. Baptist Medical Plaza, No Number In Original
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
59
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
56 Plaintiff V. Lammico, No Number In Original
57 Plumb V. Northwest Hospital Center; Michael L Dewit Md, 03-C-15-009933
58 Prater, Virgil V. Moudgil, Dr Syam, 09-029707-Nh, Medical Malpractice, Other, September 27, 2010, Michigan
59 Reid V. Eric McDonald, M.D., Medical Emergency Professionals, Llc, Southern Maryland Hospital Inc., Stuart Goodman And Felicia Nicholson Brown, Cal13-37243
60 Rendano V. St. Elizabeth Health Center, 03-Cv-2264, Medical Malpractice - Hospital Negligence - Wrongful Death, November 21, 2006, March 12, 2011, Ohio
61 Ritz V. Timothy D. Genetta, D.O.; John Nickerson, 12-C-444; 14-Cv-134
62 Rivas, Et Al. V. Ronson Hughes, M.D., Et Al., 2009ev008822c, Medical Malpractice, Other, December 31, 2009, Georgia
63 Robertson V. Good Samaritan Hospital, 24c12001824, Medical Malpractice, August 24, 2012, Maryland
64 Rosa V. Vincent Monseau, M.D.; Erx, Llc; Wetzel County Hospital Association, 14-C-4
65 Ross, Steven W V. Mahoning Valley Emergency Specialists, Medical Malpractice, Other, October 04, 2007, Ohio
66 Shotwell V. Jason Riesinger, M.D.; Rockford Health System, 2013 L 341
67 Sigon V. Epmg Of Wv, Inc.; William Brocklehurst, M.D.; Wheeling Hospital, Inc, 13-C-226
68 Siskovic, Carole N; Et Al V. Southwest General Health Center; Et Al, Medical Malpractice, Other, April 24, 2009
69 Smith V. Howard, 14-C-49
70 Snider, Christine V. Hca-Healthone Llc Dba Swedish Medical Center, Medical Malpractice, Other, May 17, 2010
71 Snowden, Jerrelle V. Holy Cross Hospital, Medical Malpractice, Other, March 25, 2010
72 Stewart, Jennings H Jr V. Richardson, Brian K Md, Medical Malpractice, Other, August 19, 2010, West Virginia
73 Takacs V. Reading Hospital And Medical Center And Duane D. Siberski, D.O., 09-9629, Medical Malpractice - Negligent Treatment - Medical Malpractice - Failure To Diagnose - Medical Malpractice - Emergency Room - Medical Malpractice - Hospital - Medical Malpractice - Failure To Treat - Wrongful Death - Survival Damages, June 14, 2013, August 05, 2013, Pennsylvania
74 Tedford, Susan M V. Lindsey, John Brett Md, Cv-08-900604, Medical Malpractice, Other, February 04, 2010, Alabama
75 Tolentino V. Frankford Hospital Health Care, Et Al., 0907003911; July 2009 #3911, Medical Malpractice, December 07, 2011, Pennsylvania
76 Tolentino, Anna R V. Night Hawk Radiology Services Llc, 2:09-Cv-06050-Ldd, Medical Malpractice, Other, March 08, 2010, Pennsylvania
77 Valdes V. Baptist Hospital Of Miami, Inc. D/B/A Baptist Medical Plaza At West Kendall: Urgent Care Center; Variety Children's Hospital D/B/A Miami Children's Hospital West Kendall Outpatient Center And Miami Children's Hospital; Anthony Pizarro, M.D., P.A., Et Al, 2012-039570-Ca-01
78 Valdez V. Lewis Leavitt, M.D., 2011-2971, Medical Malpractice, October 28, 2011, Texas
79 Ward, Francis Walter V. Lai, Loan Nhu Md, 24c08006946, Medical Malpractice, Other, January 22, 2010, Maryland
80 Watts V. Irene Buckner, 14-Ci-14-0080
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
60
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
CERTAIN CASES IN WHICH DOE’S DEPOSITION WAS FILED
These are cases in which Doe’s deposition was filed.
1 Cunningham V. Helgason, Case No. 02cva12-13572, Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio,
Franklin County, February 18, 2005, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of John Doe,
M.D.
2 Everllna Warren, Individually And As Administrator Of The Estate Of Wendell F. Warren,
Deceased, Plaintiff, V. Cuna Mutual Group, A Foreign Corporation And Cuna Mutual
Insurance Society, A Foreign Corporation, Defendants.; No. Cv-11-439-Fhs.; 2012 WL
6593914; United States District Court, E.D. Oklahoma.; Transcript Of The Testimony Of John
Doe, M.D.
3 Frederick R. Nance, Etc., Plaintiff, V. University Hospitals Of Cleveland, Et Al., Defendants.;
No. Cv-04-524392.; 2007 WL 7682620; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of John
Doe, Md
4 Joseph V. North Miami Med. Ctr., Ltd., Case No. 03-10110ca32, Circuit Court Of Florida,
Miami-Dade County, Eleventh Judicial District, March 8, 2005, Expert Witness
Deposition, Videoconference Deposition Of John Doe, M.D.
5 Judy Crawford, Adm., Plaintiff, V. David C. Boehmer, D.O., Et Al., Defendants.; No. 05 Cva
10362.; 2006 WL 3861359; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of John Doe, Md
6 Nance V. University Hosps. Of Cleveland, Case No. Cv-04-524392, Court Of Common Pleas Of
Ohio, Cuyahoga County, June 21, 2007, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of John Doe,
M.D.
7 Prater V. Ma, Case No. 09-029707-Nh, Circuit Court Of Michigan, Wayne County, October 27,
2010, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of John Doe, M.D.
8 Ralph Rendano, Executor Of The Estate Of Victoria Rendano, Plaintiff, V. St. Elizabeth Health
Center, Et Al., Defendants.; No. 2003 Cv 2264.; 2006 WL 4394667; Court Of Common Pleas
Of Ohio.; Deposition Of John Doe, Md
9 Robert Coleman, Plaintiff, V. T & S Management, Inc., Dba McDonald's, Defendant.; No.
451483.; 2002 WL 32946339; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of John Doe, Md
10 Stonestreet V. Camc Teays Valley Hosp., Inc., Case No. 11-C-127, Circuit Court Of West
Virginia, Putnam County, May 11, 2012, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of John Doe,
M.D.
11 Theodore Antolik, Executor Of The Estate Of Mildred Antolik, Plaintiff, V. Lake Hospital
Systems, Et Al., Defendants.; No. Cv461513.; 2003 WL 24196483; Court Of Common Pleas Of
Ohio.; Deposition Of John Doe, Md
12 Virgil Prater And Gale Unger, Plaintiffs, V. Dr. M. Ma, Jr., M.D., Dr. Shyam Moudgil, M.D., St.
John Health, A Michigan Domestic Nonprofit Corporation Jointly And Severally, Defendants.;
No. 09-029707-Nh.; 2010 WL 9037062; Circuit Court Of Michigan.; Deposition Of John Doe,
M.D.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
61
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
CERTAIN CASES IN WHICH DOE WAS MENTIONED IN OTHER EXPERT’S DEPOSITION
These are cases where Doe was mentioned in other expert’s deposition.
1 Bridgett Johnson, Et Al, V. St. Agnes Health Care, Inc., Et Al.; No. 24c13008166.; 2015 WL 4602304; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Partial Testimony Of Alan Lisbon, M.D.
2 Busch V. South Pointe Hosp., Case No. 482025, Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio, Cuyahoga County, January 9, 2004, Expert Witness Deposition, Telephonic Deposition Of Eric M. Wasserman
3 Busch V. South Pointe Hosp., Case No. 482025, Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio, Cuyahoga County, January 9, 2004, Expert Witness Deposition, Telephonic Deposition Of: Eric M. Wasserman
4 Busch V. South Pointe Hosp., Case No. 482025, Ohio Common Pleas Court, Cuyahoga County, January 08, 2004, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of: Dean Dobkin, Md.
5 Case No.: 03-10110 Ca 32, Circuit Court Of Florida, Miami-Dade County, Eleventh Judicial Circuit, General Jurisdiction Division, April 19, 2005, Expert Witness Deposition, Videoconferenced And Telephonic Deposition Of Mark D. Baker, M.D.
6 In The Court Of Common Pleas Patricia Busch, Et Al, Plaintiffs, V. South Pointe Hospital, Et Al, Defendants.; No. 482025.; 2004 WL 3660926; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Telephonic Deposition Of: Eric M. Wasserman
7 No. 98-C-98-H, Circuit Court Of West Virginia, Wood County, October 7, 1999, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of Lowell S. Young, M.D.
8 No. Cv01475, Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio, Stark County, July 9, 2001, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of Thomas J. Kaiser, M.D.
9 Reid V. Southern Maryland Hosp., Inc., Case No. Cal 13-37243, 2015 Depo. Trans. Lexis 12, Deposition Of Ronald Paynter, M.D.
10 Roseann Ziraks, Individually And As Mother And Natural Guardian Of Richard Shaffer, A Minor, Plaintiff, V. Philip Howren, D.O., Et Al., Defendants.; No. 407330.; 2002 WL 32942363; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of Bruce D. Janiak M.D.
11 Roseann Ziraks, Individually And As Mother And Natural Guardian Of Richard Shaffer, A Minor, Plaintiff, V. Philip Howren, D.O., Et Al., Defendants.; No. Cv03492950.; 2002 WL 34671823; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of Dr. William L. Crawford, M.D.
12 Roseann Ziraks, Individually And As Mother And Natural Guardian Of Richard Shaffer, A Minor, Plaintiff, V. Philip Howren, D.O., Et Al., Defendants.; No. Cv03492950.; 2002 WL 34671825; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of Bruce D. Janiak M.D.
13 Rush V. Samaritan Emergency Physicians, Num. 14-Civ-007, 2014 Depo. Trans. Lexis 1206, Testimony Of Brianswirsky, M.D., F.A.C.C.
14 Theodore Antolik, Individually And As Executor Of The Estate Of Mildred Antolik, Plaintiff, V. Kaiser Permanente, Et Al., Defendants.; No. Cv 461513.; 2003 WL 24187227; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Deposition Of Colleen Victory, M.D. Tuesday, January 9, 2002
15 Ziraks V. Howren, 407330, Ohio Common Pleas Court, Cuyahoga County, January 17, 2002, Expert Witness Deposition, Deposition Of Bruce D. Janiak Md
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
62
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
CERTAIN CASES IN WHICH DOE’S AFFIDAVIT WAS FILED
These are cases in which Doe’s affidavit was filed.
1 Battle, V. Oliver Et Al.; No. 427528.; 2000 WL 34553554; Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.;
Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
2 Brobert Babb, Et Al., Plaintiffs, V. Maryland General Hospital, Inc., Et Al., Defendants.; No. 24-
C-06-007573.; 2007 WL 7711611; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
3 Christian Lombardini, Individually, And As Personal Representative Of The Estate Of Jessica
Lombardini, Et Al., Claimants, V. Harbor Hospital, Inc. And Adela Navarro, M.D., Defendant
Health Care Providers.; No. 24c10005172.; 2011 WL 8946574; Circuit Court Of Maryland.;
Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
4 Coburn, V. Night Hawk Radiology Services, Llc.; No. 209cv06050.; 2011 WL 7664204; United
States District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
5 Corinthian Brooks, Et Al., V. Maryland General Hospital, Inc., Et Al.; No. 24-C-06-007573.;
2007 WL 7711612; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
6 Cynthia Durkalski, V. Summa Health System, Et Al.; No. Cv2010117543.; 2011 WL 9960828;
Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
7 Eleanor Ward, Et Al., Claimants, V. Loan N. Lai, Et Al., Defendant Health Care Providers.; No.
24c08006946.; 2008 WL 8851812; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
8 Eleanor Ward, Et Al., V. Loan N. Lai, Et Al.; No. 24c08006946.; 2008 WL 8851813; Circuit
Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
9 Helton V. Caloia, 08-122004-Nh, Circuit Court Of Michigan, Wayne County, Third Judicial
District, August 26, 2008, Affidavit, Affidavit Of John Doe, Md Facep
10 Lombardini, V. Harbor Hospital, Et Al.; No. 24c10005172.; 2011 WL 8946575; Circuit Court
Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
11 Nancy Swingle, Plaintiff, V. Zia A. Zakai, M.D., Md., Et Al, Defendants.; No. 03c12000351.;
2012 WL 10759387; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
12 Nancy Swingle, V. Zia Zakai, M.D., Et Al.; No. 03c12000351.; 2012 WL 10759388; Circuit
Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
13 Nickler V. Mercy Med. Ctr., June 27, 2001, Expert Report- Failure To Diagnose/Treat Deep
Vein Thrombosis In Leg; Hip Disarticulation, Expert Witness Report Of Dr. John Ann Doe,
M.D.
14 Patricia Mahoney, Et Al, V. Howard County General Hospital, Inc., Et Al.; No. 13c09078458.;
2009 WL 8689986; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
15 Patricia Maloney, Individually And As Personal Representative Of The Estate Of John L.
Cobb, Decedent, Et Al., Plaintiffs, V. Howard County General Hospital, Inc., Et Al.,
Defendants.; No. 13-C-09-078458.; 2009 WL 8689985; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit
Of John Doe, Md
16 Penny L. Haser, V. Summa Health System, Et Al.; No. Cv 2009 01 00615.; 2010 WL 9936953;
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
63
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Court Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
17 Prater V. St. John Health, 09-029707-Nh, Circuit Court Of Michigan, Wayne County, Third
Judicial Circuit, August 15, 2009, Affidavit, Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
18 Roseann Ziraks, Et. Al., V. Philip Howren, D.O.; No. Cv03 492950.; 2005 WL 3571022; Court
Of Common Pleas Of Ohio.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
19 Shamar Davenport, As Personal Representative Of The Estate Of John H. Tate, Et Al.,
Plaintiffs, V. Bon Secours Hospital Baltimore, Inc. Et Al., Defendant.; No. 24-C-07-007209.;
2008 WL 9015397; Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
20 Shamar Davenport, As Personal Representative Of The Estate Of John H. Tate, V. Bon
Secours Hospital Baltimore, Inc., Et Al.; No. 24-C-07-007209.; 2008 WL 9015398; Circuit
Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
21 Terrell W. Ham, V. Marshall County, Kentucky, Et Al.; No. 5:11-Cv-11-R.; 2012 WL 6760163;
United States District Court, W.D. Kentucky, Paducah Division.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
22 Thomas W. Furlow, Jr., V. Samuel J. Brown, Et Al.; No. 02c08129013.; 2008 WL 8866919;
Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
23 Thomas W. Furlow, Jr., V. Samuel J. Brown, Et Al.; No. 02c08129013.; 2008 WL 8866920;
Circuit Court Of Maryland.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
24 Virgil Prater, V. Dr. M. Ma, Jr., M.D., Et Al.; No. 09029707.; 2009 WL 8684731; Circuit Court
Of Michigan.; Affidavit Of John Doe, Md
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
64
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
PROFESSIONAL HISTORY The expert’s professional information is assembled from the curriculum vita, where available, or online resources such as websites, directories, and public databases.
EMPLOYMENT / TEACHING / RESEARCH
Employment History
Employment history is gathered from the expert’s curriculum vita, directories, employer websites and other online resources.
Marietta Hospital System
Chairman, Emergency Medical Education | Present
Chairman, Emergency Medicine | 2009 – 2012
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Memorial Health System
Physician | Present
Sources:
1. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?sid=2&physician=1437
2. http://www.mmhospital.org/upload/docs/00701.01_Physician_Directory_Update_vf.pdf
3. http://www.ohiocore.org/gfx/media/contribute/WebsiteSEOhioCORE.pdf
4. http://bit.ly/1n4hrKV
5. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?&physician=8
6. http://www.mhsystem.org/upload/docs/pdf/00700_CHL_Summer2012_vf.pdf
7. http://www.mmhospital.org/upload/docs/pdf/00699_CHL_Spring2012_vf(revised).pdf
8. http://blog.cleveland.com/parmasunpost/2010/10/rock_photographer_inducted_int.html
9. http://bit.ly/2iCT0Gv
10. http://bit.ly/2nvs7Ha
11. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Results.aspx?sid=1&LastName=G
12. https://www.mhsystem.org/upload/docs/00168_CHL_Summer_vf.pdf
13. http://www.mhsystem.org/providerbased
Hiram College
College Physician/Student Health Services
Director
Sources:
1. http://bit.ly/U732nK
2. http://bit.ly/1kiqPvI
3. http://bit.ly/2oxwPck
4. http://bit.ly/2nTgzzg
5. http://www.hiram.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/hc-catalog-2012-2013.pdf
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
65
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
6. http://www.hiram.edu/staff/dr-John-Doe/
7. http://hiram.us/h/images/pdfs/registrar/hccatalog1314final.pdf
8. http://hiram.us/h/images/pdfs/registrar/catalog2008.pdf
9. http://hiram.us/h/images/pdfs/registrar/hiram-college-catalog-2005-2006.pdf
Southwest General Hospital
Physician, Division of Emergency Medicine
Chairman, Emergency Medical Education | 2005 - 2009
Sources:
1. http://bit.ly/1p0USaC
2. http://bit.ly/1kAYv1O
3. http://bit.ly/2ossvur
4. http://challengercme.com/About/OurLeadership.aspx
5. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
St Vincent Charity Hospital
Physician
Chairman, Emergency Medicine | January 1997 – 2005
Associate Director, Emergency Medicine | 1983 - 1989
Sources:
1. https://www.crossexam.com/samples/preview-8238.pdf
2. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Selby General Hospital
Physician | Present
Director
Sources:
1. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?sid=2&physician=1437
2. http://bit.ly/2iCT0Gv
3. http://bit.ly/2jUF23T
4. http://bit.ly/2nvqrxa
University Hospitals of Cleveland
Chairman, Emergency Medicine | 1994 - 1997
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
St. Joseph Riverside Hospital, Warren, Ohio
Director, Emergency Department | 1991 – 1994
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
66
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
British Petroleum of America, Inc.
Director | 1991 – 1994
Assistant Director, Occupational Medicine | 1987 - 1989
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Wooster Community Hospital
Director, Emergency Department | 1989 - 1991
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Barberton Citizens Hospital, Barberton, Ohio
Emergency Staff Physician | 1982 - 1983
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Summa Health System (Formerly known as St. Thomas Hospital, Akron, Ohio)
Associate Director, Family Medicine | 1981 - 1982
Source: Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Teaching / Research History
Teaching/ Research history is gathered from the expert’s curriculum vita, directories, university websites and other online resources.
Northeastern Ohio College of Medicine
Assistant Professor, Family Medicine
Sources:
1. https://www.crossexam.com/samples/preview-8238.pdf
2. http://challengercme.com/About/OurLeadership.aspx
3. http://bit.ly/2ossvur
4. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
Case Western Reserve University
Assistant Clinical Professor, Emergency Medicine
Sources:
1. http://buswk.co/1tBxIYv
2. https://www.crossexam.com/samples/preview-8238.pdf
3. http://challengercme.com/About/OurLeadership.aspx
4. http://bit.ly/2ossvur
5. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
67
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Ohio University Heritage College of Osteopathic Medicine
Clinical Associate Professor, Emergency Medicine
Sources:
1. http://www.oucom.ohiou.edu/dfm/AnnualReport2012-13.pdf
2. http://www.ohiocore.org/gfx/media/contribute/CCFDeptFamMed.pdf
3. http://www.oucom.ohiou.edu/dfm/AnnualReport2011-12.pdf
4. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
EDUCATION
Educational history is gathered from the expert’s curriculum vita, university websites, the National Student Clearinghouse and other online resources. The expert's attendance and degrees granted is not independently verified unless the expert's date of birth is known, and the school's registrar will release that information.
Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine
Degree: Bachelor of Arts, B.A.
Years: 1970 - 1974
Degree: Doctor of Medicine, M.D.
Year: 1978
Sources:
1. https://license.ohio.gov/lookup/default.asp?division=78
2. http://www.mhsystem.org/physicians/details.aspx?physician=8&sid=1
3. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?sid=2&physician=1437
4. http://hiramweb.org/h/images/pdfs/registrar/hiram-college-catalog-2011-2012.pdf
5. http://bit.ly/1n4hrKV
6. http://www.hiram.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/hc-catalog-2012-2013.pdf
7. https://my.hiram.edu/ords/hprd/f?p=419:1:::NO::P1_CAT_ID:95187
8. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?&physician=8
9. http://hiram.us/h/images/pdfs/registrar/hccatalog1314final.pdf
10. http://hiram.us/h/images/pdfs/registrar/catalog2008.pdf
11. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
12. National Student Clearinghouse
*One of the above mentioned degrees has been verified from the National Student Clearinghouse
(NSC). The following information was furnished by the NSC on verification:
Name on School's Records: JOHN DOE-MILLER
Date Awarded: 05/01/1974
Degree Title: BACHELOR OF ARTS
Official Name of School: CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
68
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Major Course(s) of Study: CHEMISTRY
Dates of Attendance: 01/01/1970 TO 05/01/1974
Akron City Hospital
Degree: Residency, Family Practice
Year: Research did not reveal this information
Sources:
1. http://www.mhsystem.org/physicians/details.aspx?physician=8&sid=1
2. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?sid=2&physician=1437
3. http://bit.ly/1n4hrKV
4. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?&physician=8
Maryland Institute of Emergency Medical Service Systems
Degree: Postgraduate Fellowship, Trauma
Year: Research did not reveal this information
Sources:
1. http://www.mhsystem.org/physicians/details.aspx?physician=8&sid=1
2. http://bit.ly/1n4hrKV
3. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?&physician=8
James Ford Rhodes High School
Degree: High School Graduation
Year: 1970
Sources:
1. http://blog.cleveland.com/parmasunpost/2010/10/rock_photographer_inducted_int.html
2. http://jamesfordrhodes.org/halloffame.htm
3. http://www.oldbrooklyn.com/OBN/10NovOBN.pdf
4. Expert’s CV filed in Ham V. Marshall County (Docket Number: 5:11cv11)
REFERENCES
In some instances, an expert will list the names of references to parties or law firms with whom the expert has worked. These can often be found through online resources. These references are provided when available.
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases did not reveal any
references.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
69
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
ASSOCIATION MEMBERSHIPS
Information about an expert’s membership in associations is found in this section. This may include the association name, the location, information about the association, any committee or positions held, and the years the expert has been a member.
1. Member, Ohio State Medical Association
2. Member Emeritus, Challenger's Physician Advisory Board
BOARD MEMBERSHIPS
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases with search terms “John
Doe”, “John Doe-Miller”, “John Doe Miller”, “John Doe-Miller”, “J. Doe”, “J. Doe-Miller” and “J. Doe
Miller” did not reveal any board memberships.
AWARDS AND HONORS
1. Recipient “Hall Of Fame”, James Ford Rhodes High School | 2010
2. Listed as “2015 Best Doctor In America”, Ohio Medicine | 2015
CONFERENCES / PRESENTATIONS / SEMINARS
1. Attended, Portage Country Club Holiday Event | 2010
2. Presenter, Risk Management Update | March 2013
Additional Source: http://www.areaagency8.org/pub/RiskMgtBrochure%202013.pdf
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY OWNED
Patents
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online database of the United States Patent and Trademark
Office (http://patft.uspto.gov/) did not reveal any patents owned by Dr. Doe.
Trademarks
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online database of the United States Patent and Trademark
Office (http://tess2.uspto.gov/) did not reveal any trademarks owned by Dr. Doe.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
70
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
EXPERT RATES
If an expert has posted his or his rates on their website, published their fee schedule, or otherwise made public their expert rates, then that information is provided in this section.
Trial fee: $ 6,000 per day
Reviewing documents: $ 375 per hour
Providing deposition testimony: $ 3000 flat fee for deposition per day
Retainer fee: $2000
Source: Expert’s Deposition filed in Prater V. Ma (Docket Number: 09-029707)
PUBLICATIONS
Search results of over 10 million expert authored books, articles, newsletters, law reviews, and/or other scholarly papers and journals are included here. This section may include summaries, source information, dates, and any co-authors (if applicable).
Book
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases did not reveal any book
written by the expert.
Article
1. Impact of Race on the Severity of Acute Episodes of Asthma and Adrenergic Responsiveness |
2006
Book Review
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases did not reveal any book
review by the expert.
Abstracts
1. Comparison of Two Dosage Regimens of Albuterol in Acute Asthma | 1998
2. Observations on the Effects of Aerosolized Albuterol in Acute Asthma | 1997
3. The Influence of Parasympatholytics on the Resolution of Acute Attacks of Asthma | 1996
Editorial
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases did not reveal any editorial
written by the expert.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
71
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Publications Mentioning the Expert
1. Official National Hospital Blue Book | 2002
2. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine: An Official Journal of the American
Thoracic Society, Medical Section of the American Lung Association, Volume 174 | 2006
3. The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art | 1994
4. 1990 Annual Report, The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art | 1990
5. 1991 Annual Report, The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art | 1991
6. 1992 Annual Report, The Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art | 1992
CERTIFICATES AND LICENSES
If the expert has listed any licenses or certifications, that information has been researched, and the result of the investigation is included here. This section may include the expert’s occupation, the state, the authority, the license or certification number, the date acquired, and the date of expiration.
1. Licensed Physician, State Medical Board Of Ohio
2. Certified in Family Medicine, The American Board of Family Medicine
3. Certified in Emergency Medicine, The American Board of Emergency Medicine
WEBSITES AND LINKS
Besides the current website, this section includes archived website and web pages to track any change to the expert’s website. If there are any sites that link to or from the expert’s website, those are included in this section.
Current Websites
1. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?&physician=8
2. http://www.mhsystem.org/Physicians/Details.aspx?sid=2&physician=1437
3. http://www.hiram.edu/staff/dr-John-Doe/
Archived Website
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources did not reveal any archived website.
Sites linked from Current Websites
URL#1: https://www.linkedin.com/company/memorial-health-system
URL#2: https://www.facebook.com/mhsystem
URL#3: https://www.youtube.com/user/MemHealthSys
URL#4: https://twitter.com/mymhsystem
URL#5: https://in.pinterest.com/memorialhealths/
URL#6: https://www.flickr.com/photos/hiramcollege/
URL#7: https://www.youtube.com/user/hiramcollege
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
72
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
URL#8: https://www.instagram.com/hiramcollege/
URL#9: https://twitter.com/hiramcollege
URL#10: https://www.facebook.com/hiramcollege/
Site linked to Current Websites
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources did not reveal any site linked to current
websites.
EXPERT DIRECTORIES
Expert directories provide a wealth of information about experts, and this information can be compared to the information that expert has provided through formal discovery efforts as well as on his/her website. A simple comparison of the information provided by the expert with his/her directory listing might reveal discrepancies. A list of the expert’s directory listings is provided in this section.
1. Expert Profile on Courtroom Insight Expert Witness Directory
Other Directories:
Directory Name Date Checked Result
All Law 3/3/2018 No Listing
ALM Experts 3/3/2018 No Listing
ARC 3/3/2018 No Listing
CA Experts 3/3/2018 No Listing
Exify 3/3/2018 No Listing
Expert Law 3/3/2018 No Listing
Expert Pages 3/3/2018 No Listing
Experts.com 3/3/2018 No Listing
FEWA 3/3/2018 No Listing
FindLaw 3/3/2018 No Listing
HG Experts 3/3/2018 No Listing
JurisPro 3/3/2018 No Listing
Martindale 3/3/2018 No Listing
LA County Bar Association 3/3/2018 No Listing
Rominger Legal 3/3/2018 No Listing
SEAK 3/3/2018 No Listing
SF Bar Association 3/3/2018 No Listing
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
73
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
SOCIAL NETWORKING
This section includes any results for the expert’s posts, and references to the expert, in blogs and major social networking sites up to the date and time listed. These social networking sites include, but are not limited to, LinkedIn, Facebook, and Twitter.
https://www.linkedin.com/in/John-Doe-3504b63b
As of 3/3/2018, it was not revealed that this expert was registered with Facebook.
As of 3/3/2018, it was not revealed that this expert was registered with Twitter.
Google +
As of 3/3/2018, it was not revealed that this expert was registered with Google +.
PUBLIC PROFILES
There are several websites which create public profiles of individuals based on information gathered from the internet. Such public profiles of the expert are listed in this section.
UCompareHealthCare
http://www.ucomparehealthcare.com/drs/John_Doe/
MD.com
http://JohnDoe.md.com/specialties/emergency-medicine
Healthgrades
http://www.healthgrades.com/provider/John-Doe-2j2pm
Vitals
http://www.vitals.com/doctors/Dr_John_Doe/profile
Zoominfo
URL#1: http://bit.ly/2nS6LaN
URL#2: http://bit.ly/2ooXC7w
Wellness
http://www.wellness.com/dir/1144267/family-doctor/oh/akron/John-Doe-md
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
74
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Zocdoc
http://www.zocdoc.com/doctor/John-Doe-md
Hipaaspace
http://www.hipaaspace.com/Medical_Billing/Coding/NPI/Codes/NPI_1134133747.aspx
Google +
https://plus.google.com/113497225707460677143/about
Spoke
http://www.spoke.com/people/John-Doe-3e1429c09e597c1005ddd7d0
Angie’s List
http://www.angieslist.com/companylist/us/oh/cleveland/John-Doe-md-reviews-7019574.htm
Trialscentral
http://www.trialscentral.org/dr--77490.htm
Healthjoy
https://healthjoy.com/doctor/John-a-Doe/
Health Care for People
http://www.healthcare4ppl.com/physician/ohio/marietta/John-a-Doe-1134133747.html
Health Care 6
http://www.healthcare6.com/physician/marietta-oh/John-a-Doe-1145158.html
Doctors Working In USA
http://www.physicianus.org/dr-John-a-Doe-md-emergency-medicine/
Leadferret
https://leadferret.com/directory/person/John-Doe/11967496
Spoke
http://www.spoke.com/people/3e1429c09e597c1005ddd7d0
CarionLTD
http://careon.me/doc.php?st=oh&cy=akron&pn=John-Doe&id=84201
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
75
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Find a Doc
http://www.findadoc.com/doctors/Ohio/Akron/Emergency_Medicine/629949-
John%20%20Doe.aspx
GROUPS
Some experts will join an online discussion group, or will be mentioned in such a group. Results of an archive of more than 700 million Usenet postings from a period of more than 20 years are included here.
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases with search terms “John
Doe”, “John Doe-Miller”, “John Doe Miller”, “John Doe-Miller”, “J. Doe”, “J. Doe-Miller” and “J. Doe
Miller” did not reveal any groups.
BLOGS
If an expert maintains a blog, or has been mentioned in a blog post, those results are included here.
My final LEAD course
Widow Walk | 02/09/2014
Rock photographer inducted into Rhodes High School hall of fame: Rick Haase
Cleveland.com | 10/27/2010
Liberia: Karl & John Donate to Ymca
Allafrica | 04/13/2005
MULTIMEDIA
When located, the source for the audio, video, and podcasts (audio programs distributed over the Internet) are included here.
Audio
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases with search terms “John
Doe”, “John Doe-Miller”, “John Doe Miller”, “John Doe-Miller”, “J. Doe”, “J. Doe-Miller” and “J. Doe
Miller” did not reveal any audio.
Video
Video File containing the resume of the expert
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
76
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Podcast
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and public databases with search terms “John
Doe”, “John Doe-Miller”, “John Doe Miller”, “John Doe-Miller”, “J. Doe”, “J. Doe-Miller” and “J. Doe
Miller” did not reveal any podcast.
NEWS ARTICLES
Thousands of publications, newspapers, and articles have been searched to locate information, quotes, or references about this expert. It should be noted that not every publication and newspaper is available to be searched for every year. If information about the expert has been located, then this section includes the headline, name and location of the publication, date, and excerpt regarding this expert.
2011 Foundation Events
AMEF Newsletter
2011
Berks Co. Jury Awards $1.7 Mil. In Infant Death Case
The Legal Intelligencer
06/18/2013
The Academy of Medicine Education Foundation Co-Sponsors Medical Legal Summit
AMEF News
2013
The Academy of Medicine Education Foundation Co-Sponsors Educational Seminar for Physicians
and Attorneys
AMEF News
2012
President’s Message
The CJD Foundation Newsletter
2014
Cold Weather Dangers
The News Center
01/07/2014
2006 ‘Student’ D.O.C. Awards honor faculty, staff and students
Ohio University
2006
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
77
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Prominent Risk Management Expert Appointed to Challenger Advisory Board
Challenger
05/20/2007
Art That Lives Moves and Sings at the Akron Art Museum - Jean-Pierre Gauthier: Machines At Play
Footer
Akron Art Museum
08/20/2008
Hall of Fame Senior Olympics results for June 6
CantonRep.com
06/07/2011
Akron Area YMCA holds 142nd Annual Dinner Celebration
Akron.com
07/04/2013
Witness Firsthand the Installation of Jean-Pierre Gauthier: Machines at Play
Akron Art Museum
09/04/2008
Additional Source: http://bit.ly/2jqVsoi
Jean-Pierre Gauthier: Machines at Play
Akron Art Museum
09/27/2008
Doctors Now First Line of Care
Memorial Health Bulletin
2009
Drug O.D. - The Indiscriminate Epidemic
The News Center
11/05/2015
Berks Co. Jury Awards $1.7 Mil. In Infant Death Case
The Legal Intelligencer
06/18/2013
Unique Sport Is Taking Off Locally
The Marietta Times
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
78
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
01/17/2017
New outfit takes over O'Bleness ER
The Athens News
11/07/2005
The 102 members of the Class of 2016 gained acceptances at 212 different colleges and universities
in the United States, Canada and abroad
The WRA Fund Magazine
2016
DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS
All state governments and some professional associations maintain records of professional misconduct. When located, the type of misconduct, the action take, the date of the action, and the authority are included.
A search on February 28, 2018 of online resources and proprietary databases did not reveal any
disciplinary actions taken against this expert.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
79
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
PERSONAL INFORMATION Personal information about this expert, if found, is included in this section. This includes the expert's family history, political contributions, and public information such as bankruptcies, liens, and UCC filings, if any.
RELATIONS
Husband: Karl A. Reuther (also known as Karl A. A. Reuther Jr.)
Sources:
1. http://www.akron.com/pages.asp?aID=19781
2. http://allafrica.com/stories/200504130550.html
3. http://www.mariettatimes.com/news/local-news/2015/12/unique-sport-is-taking-off-locally/
4. http://bit.ly/2oEkvqI
*Research revealed that the expert along with his husband, Karl A. A. Reuther, was one of
the top five YMCA fundraisers.
Source: http://www.akron.com/pages.asp?aID=19781
BANKRUPTCIES
If the expert, or his company, has filed for bankruptcy, then information about that proceeding can be found here. This information is taken from public records and court filings.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online resources (Pacer and other legal databases) did not reveal any bankruptcies.
JUDGMENTS AND LIENS
If a judgment or lien has been filed by or against the expert, then this information is found here. Drawn from public records, the information includes the claimant information, type of lien or judgment, amount, and date.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online resources (Pacer and other legal databases) did not
reveal any judgments and liens.
UCC FILINGS
If a UCC filing has been made involving the expert, then this information is found here. Drawn from public records, the information includes the claimant information, description of filing, amount, and date.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online resources (Pacer and other legal databases) did not
reveal any UCC filings.
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
80
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
SEC FILINGS
If an SEC filing has been made involving the expert, then this information is found here. Drawn from public records, the information includes the form type, filing no., and date.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online resources (Pacer and other legal databases) did not
reveal any SEC filings.
PROPERTIES OWNED
If the expert owns a property, that information can be found here. The information is drawn from public records and includes the description, location and consideration paid for the property.
672 N Hawkins Ave.
Akron, Ohio 44313
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
2057 Thurmont Rd.
Akron, Ohio 44313
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
1627 Vicgross Ave.
Akron, Ohio 44310
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
310 Mc Dowell Ave.
Akron, Ohio 44313
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
1742 Rock Hill Lane
Akron, Ohio 44313
Sources:
1. https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
2. http://www.city-data.com/summit-county/R/Rock-Hill-Lane-1.html
*Research revealed that the expert co-owns the above mentioned property with Karl A. Reuther.
Source: https://fiscaloffice.summitoh.net/index.php/property-tax-search
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
81
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
POLITICAL CONTRIBUTIONS
Political contributions, and the expert’s likely political persuasion, are generally gathered from the Federal Election Commission (FEC), an independent regulatory agency that tracks federal campaign contributions over $200. Information about this section may have also been gathered through other government public records.
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: OHIO STATE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
Date: 09/21/2010
Donation Amount: $250
Source: http://www.city-data.com/elec2/10/elec-AKRON-OH-10.html
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: WOOD, RICHARD (RICK) F VIA FRIENDS OF RICK WOOD
Date: 09/21/2010
Donation Amount: $500
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?20990219076
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 03/14/2013
Donation Amount: $-400
Sources:
1. http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?13964514719
2. http://realtime.influenceexplorer.com/filings/884700/SA/
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 03/14/2013
Donation Amount: $400
Sources:
1. http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?13964514719
2. http://realtime.influenceexplorer.com/filings/884700/SA/
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 03/14/2013
Donation Amount: $3000
Sources:
1. http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?13964514719
2. http://realtime.influenceexplorer.com/filings/884700/SA/
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
82
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: NATIONAL EMERGENCY MEDICINE POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
Date: 07/14/2010
Donation Amount: $1000
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?11931315309
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: NATIONAL EMERGENCY MEDICINE POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
Date: 10/14/2011
Donation Amount: $500
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?12950268335
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: NATIONAL EMERGENCY MEDICINE POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
Date: 11/08/2006
Donation Amount: $200
Sources:
1. http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?27930644874
2. http://www.city-data.com/elec2/06/elec-AKRON-OH-06-part1.html
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 08/25/2010
Donation Amount: $2400
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?10991328793
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 08/18/2011
Donation Amount: $1000
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?11953027902
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 09/22/2011
Donation Amount: $500
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?11953027912
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
83
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Political Persuasion: Republican
Cause/ Campaign: JOHNSON, BILL VIA JOHNSON FOR CONGRESS
Date: 12/12/2011
Donation Amount: $500
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?12951398746
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: OHIO STATE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
(OSMAPAC)
Date: 09/21/2010
Donation Amount: $250
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?10991312867
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: OHIO STATE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
(OSMAPAC)
Date: 08/01/2011
Donation Amount: $250
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?12970141259
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: OHIO STATE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
(OSMAPAC)
Date: 09/17/2012
Donation Amount: $250
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?13961277667
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: JOTTE, RANDALL (RANDY) STEPHEN VIA JOTTE FOR CONGRESS
Date: 12/30/2011
Donation Amount: $500
Source: http://docquery.fec.gov/cgi-bin/fecimg/?12952246394
Political Persuasion: Unknown
Cause/ Campaign: American College Of Emergency Physicians
Date: 11/08/2006
Donation Amount: $200
Source: http://bit.ly/2jUmtNa
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
84
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
DONATIONS
This section contains all non-political donations made by the expert. The information may be procured from various sources found on the internet, such as donor’s directory, event brochures etc.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors for an amount of $500 – 999, Academy of
Medicine Education Foundation, 2011.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors for an amount of $500 – 999, Academy of
Medicine Education Foundation, 2013.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors for an amount of $500 – 999, Academy of
Medicine Education Foundation, 2012.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount of The CJD Foundation’s Annual Fund
Campaign, 2014, (along with Karl Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Akron Community Foundation, 2011(along with Karl
Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Alpha Omega Alpha, 2013.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Alpha Omega Alpha, 2014.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount of $250, The Ohio State Medical
Association, 2014.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount of $250, The Ohio State Medical
Association, 2015.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, The Ohio State Medical Association, 2016.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Akron Community Foundation, 2013 (along with
Karl A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Akron Community Foundation, 2015 (along with
Karl A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount $10,000 or more , Hattie Larlham,
2013 (along with Karl A. Reuther).
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
85
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount $249, Hattie Larlham, 2010 (along
with Karl A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Akron Community Foundation, 2009 (along with
Karl Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, South American Missionary Society of the Episcopal
Church, 2000.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors, for an amount up to $500 – 999, Academy of
Medicine of Cleveland & Northern Ohio, 2011.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors, for an amount up to $500 – 999, Academy of
Medicine of Cleveland & Northern Ohio, 2012.
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors, for an amount up to $500 – 999, Academy of
Medicine of Cleveland & Northern Ohio, 2013.
Additional Source: http://bit.ly/2oPdy2i
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount up to $3,000 - $4,999, Hiram College,
(along with Karl Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount up to $500 to $999, Hattie Larlham,
2015 (along with Karl A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount up to $500 to $999, Western Reserve
Academy, 2008-2009 (along with Mr. Karl A. A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of contributors, for an amount up to $500 to $999, Akron Art
Museum, 2013 -2014 (along with Mr. Karl A. A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount up to $500 to $999, Western Reserve
Academy, 2007-2008 (along with Mr. Karl A. A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, for an amount up to $139,509, Western Reserve
Academy, 2008-2009 (along with Mr. Karl A. A. Reuther).
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Western Reserve Academy, 2009-2010 (along with
Mr. Karl A. Galan).
AMFS Expert Witness Analysis of Dr. John Doe, M.D. Prepared exclusively for Dan Sandman, Esq.
86
COPYRIGHT 2018 AMFS
Expert's name mentioned in the list of donors, Marietta Community Foundation, 2011 (along with
Mr. Karl Reuther).
*Several other donations of the expert are available at:
http://bit.ly/2p4eno2
http://bit.ly/2oEuDjc
http://bit.ly/2oEs3Kf
http://bit.ly/2o0vfwz
http://bit.ly/2ocRnWF
http://bit.ly/2nNBCT3
http://bit.ly/2oGSm1V
http://bit.ly/1HQa4Vi
CRIMINAL HISTORY
Not every criminal record is available for public viewing. As such, the information included here is not exhaustive. If any information from criminal records is located about this expert, then this information is found here.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online resources (Pacer and other legal databases) did not reveal any criminal history.
SEXUAL OFFENSES
Information about any sexual offenses is derived from public information found through the Dru Sjodin National Sex Offender Public Website (NSOPW). Coordinated by the U.S. Department of Justice, The NSOPW is a Millerative effort between Jurisdictions hosting public sex offender registries and the federal government.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the online resources (Dru Sjodin National Sex Offender Public
Website (NSOPW) and legal databases) did not reveal any sexual offenses.
INTERESTS / HOBBIES
If the expert has made public any interests or hobbies, that information is included here. Information about the expert’s interests and hobbies is derived from the expert’s website, curriculum vitae, and other online sources.
A search on February 28, 2018 of the expert’s online resources and public databases revealed that
he has keen interest in pickleball batter, cymbal clanger and songwriting.
Source: http://pub.lucidpress.com/wramag-winter2017/#XgGYXzLQaXyHP