Date post: | 02-Jun-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | nopipelines |
View: | 220 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 65
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
1/65
1 | P a g e
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)
and
Natural Gas Pipelines
Prepared by Dory Hippauf
Research Committee Chair
Gas Drilling Awareness Coalition
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
2/65
2 | P a g e
Contents
Timing and Steps for a New Project............................................................................................ 5
MARKET INTEREST/OPEN SEASON: ............................................................................................ 6
Pre-Filing Review Process ........................................................................................................... 7
OPEN HOUSE ............................................................................................................................... 9
FERC HEARING .......................................................................................................................... 10
Appendix 1 Ideas for Better Stakeholder Involvement In the Interstate Natural Gas Pipeline
Planning Pre-Filing Process ........................................................................................................... 16
Appendix 2 Ferc eFiling ................................................................................................................. 30
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
3/65
3 | P a g e
What is FERC?
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) is the United States federal agency with
jurisdiction over interstate electricity sales, wholesale electric rates, hydroelectric licensing,
natural gas pricing, and oil pipeline rates. FERC also reviews and authorizes liquefied natural gas
(LNG) terminals, interstate natural gas pipelines and non-federal hydropower projects.
How the Commission is Appointed1
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is composed of five commissioners who are
appointed by the President of the United States with the advice and consent of the Senate.
Commissioners serve five-year terms, and have an equal vote on regulatory matters.
To avoid any undue political influence or pressure, no more than three commissioners may
belong to the same political party. There is no review of FERC decisions by the President or
Congress, maintaining FERC's independence as a regulatory agency, and providing for fair andunbiased decisions. The Commission is funded through costs recovered by the fees and annual
charges from the industries it regulates.
One member of the Commission is designated by the President to serve as Chair and FERC's
administrative head.
FERC is an independent regulatory agency within the United States Department of Energy.
President and Congress do not generally review FERC decisions, but the decisions are
reviewable by the federal courts. FERC is self-funding, in that it pays for its own operations by
imposing annual charges and fees on the industries it regulates.
FERC is independent of the Department of Energy because FERC activities "shall not be subject
to further view by the Secretary [of Energy] or any officer or employee of the Department". The
Department of Energy can, however, participate in FERC proceedings as a third party.
Conflict of Interest
In February 2014, a lawsuit filed by NO GAS PIPELINE,PETITIONER v. FEDERAL ENERGY
REGULATORY COMMISSION, RESPONDENT and STATOIL NATURAL GAS, LLC, ETAL.,INTERVENORS
2was heard in US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Part
1About FERC |http://www.ferc.gov/for-citizens/about-ferc.asp
2US Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit | Decided july 1, 2014 | NO GAS PIPELINE,PETITIONER v.
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, RESPONDENT and STATOIL NATURAL GAS, LLC, ET
AL.,INTERVENORS | http://www.ferc.gov/legal/court-cases/opinions/2014/12-1470.pdf
http://www.ferc.gov/for-citizens/about-ferc.asphttp://www.ferc.gov/for-citizens/about-ferc.asphttp://www.ferc.gov/for-citizens/about-ferc.asphttp://www.ferc.gov/for-citizens/about-ferc.asp8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
4/65
4 | P a g e
of the lawsuit included a petition from Jersey City.
The Jersey City petition contends because FERC is beholden to the pipelines applying to it for
certificates of public convenience and necessity, and may not constitutionally adjudicate their
application.
The court rejected the petition on what appears to be technical reasons and did not address the
conflict of interest issue. Technical reasons included:
US Court of Appeals has no jurisdiction on the conflict of interest assertion
Jersey City has no standing
Jersey City waited too long to object
What FERC does and does not do:
3
FERC Responsibilities:
Regulates the transmission and wholesale sales of electricity in interstate commerce;
Reviews certain mergers and acquisitions and corporate transactions by electricity
companies;
Regulates the transmission and sale of natural gas for resale in interstate commerce;
Regulates the transportation of oil by pipeline in interstate commerce;
Approves the siting and abandonment of interstate natural gas pipelines and storage
facilities; Reviews the siting application for electric transmission projects under limited
circumstances;
Ensures the safe operation and reliability of proposed and operating LNG terminals;
Licenses and inspects private, municipal, and state hydroelectric projects;
Protects the reliability of the high voltage interstate transmission system through
mandatory reliability standards;
Monitors and investigates energy markets;
Enforces FERC regulatory requirements through imposition of civil penalties and other
means;
Oversees environmental matters related to natural gas and hydroelectricity projects and
other matters;
Administers accounting and financial reporting regulations and conduct of regulated
companies.
3What FERC Does | http://www.ferc.gov/about/ferc-does.asp
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
5/65
5 | P a g e
Areas considered outside of FERC's responsibility include:
Regulation of retail electricity and natural gas sales to consumers;
Approval for the physical construction of electric generation facilities;
Regulation of activities of the municipal power systems, federal power marketing
agencies like the Tennessee Valley Authority and most rural electric cooperatives;
Regulation of nuclear power plants by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission External Link;
Issuance of State Water Quality Certificates;
Oversight for the construction of oil pipelines;
Abandonment of service as related to oil facilities;
Mergers and acquisitions as related to natural gas and oil companies;
Responsibility for pipeline safety or for pipeline transportation on or across the Outer
Continental Shelf;
Regulation of local distribution pipelines of natural gas;
Development and operation of natural gas vehicles;
Reliability problems related to failures of local distribution facilities; and
Tree trimmings near local distribution power lines in residential neighborhoods.
Natural Gas Pipeline Development and Expansion4
Timing and Steps for a New Project
An interstate natural gas pipeline construction or expansion project takes an average of about
three years from the time it is first announced until the new pipe is placed in service. The
project can take longer if it encounters major environmental obstacles or public opposition.
A pipeline development or expansion project involves several steps:
Determining demand/market interest
Publicly announcing the project
Obtaining regulatory approval
Construction and testing
4Energy Information Administration | Natural Gas Pipeline Development and Expansion |
http://www.eia.gov/pub/oil_gas/natural_gas/analysis_publications/ngpipeline/develop.html
The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) is a principal agency of the U.S. Federal Statistical System
responsible for collecting, analyzing, and disseminating energy information to promote sound policymaking,
efficient markets, and public understanding of energy and its interaction with the economy and the environment.
The Department of Energy Organization Act of 1977 established EIA as the primary federal government authority
on energy statistics and analysis, building upon systems and organizations first established in 1974 following the oil
market disruption of 1973.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
6/65
6 | P a g e
MARKET INTEREST/OPEN SEASON:
Once a corporation has decided to build
or expand a pipeline, the first step it
must take is to determine market
interest through an OPEN SEASON
process.
An open season is held for 1-2 months,
giving potential customers an
opportunity to enter into a nonbinding
agreement to sign up for a portion of
the capacity rights that will be available.
If enough interest is shown during the
open season, the sponsors will develop
a preliminary project design and move
forward. If not enough interest is
evident, the project will most likely be
dropped or placed on indefinite hold.
The public may first learn of the project
prior to or at the time of the Open
Season announcement. Ideally, if the public is opposed, this is the time to start organizing. It is
rare but not unheard of that a project has been canceled or put on hold due to lack of marketinterest.
DEVELOP PIPELINE DESIGN:
The next step is for the corporation to develop the pipeline design.
Options for Pipeline Design
Building an entirely new pipeline
Converting an oil or product pipeline to a natural gas pipeline
Adding a parallel pipeline along a segment of pipeline, called looping
Installing a lateral or extension off the existing mainline
Upgrading and expanding facilities, such as compressor stations, along an existing route.
This option is usually the quickest, least expensive, and has the least environmental
impacts.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
7/65
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
8/65
8 | P a g e
traditional application review process.
Most corporations opt to wait later and file with FERC. In order to comply with NEPA, FERC
must prepare the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the project.
FERC will assign Pre-File Docket number to the project. The number is prefixed as PF followed
by numbers. The Williams Company Atlantic Sunrise Pipeline was assigned pre-filing docket
number PF14-8. The CP prefix is for Certificates for Interstate Natural Gas Pipeline Companies
and assign during the final approval stage.
The Pre-Filing Review Process is where public input may have the greatest impact by attending
the corporations open house, attending and commenting at FERC hearings, and filing
comments with FERC.
Public meetings with local elected officials to discuss the pipeline, informational meetings for
residents, letters to the editor and call-in to local talk radio shows are other ways to rally
participation in the pre-file hearings and open houses.
Corporations are required by FERC to hold public open houses and contact stake holders.
Stake holders are public officials, property owners where the pipeline will be routed, and
agencies etc.
Per FERC 2001 publication Ideas for Better Stakeholder Involvement In the Interstate Natural
Gas Pipeline8: Plan for Public Stakeholder Input Throughout the Process contains ideas for
citizens: (see Appendix 1 for full Document)
As soon as you can become involved, seek out information pro-actively; dont wait for it to
come to you. If you wait, you could lose an opportunity.
Constructive participation will get you more answers and information. Participate from
a foundation of knowledge and fact rather than emotion and rumors.
Let the company know if you are interested in participating in the planning stage (where the
route is determined) and not just the permitting stage (where the route is reviewed by
regulators and agencies).
Recognize what information the companies are obligated to provide and what information
is not available.
8OEP Gas Outreach Team December 2001 | Ideas for Better Stakeholder Involvement In the Interstate Natural Gas
Pipeline | Planning Pre-Filing Process | Industry, Agencies, Citizens, and FERC Staff
http://www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/land-docs/stakeholder.pdf
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
9/65
9 | P a g e
Ask questions and follow through until they are answered to your satisfaction.
Although you should be prepared to wait for answers, you should also balance that with
being assertive when it comes to asking for information you should have.
Lots of information is on web sites (companies, agencies); make use of it.
See the Industry Action Options for information about what resources should be madeavailable to citizens; ask about them.
Make sure you get the project managers name and contact information so that you
have someone to call if you have questions.
Understand that your active participation in a companys project can add value. Regardless
of your opinion, it is in the companys best interest to work with you rather than against
you.
Decide if you want to be involved in decisions regarding routing and/or construction
impact mitigation.
When you send in comments to FERC, also send a copy to the company so they are
immediately aware of your opinions.
Explore whether your local municipality, county, or citizen organization will represent you
as a group.
Know the name and phone number of the company land agents supervisor or the number
of the company/landowner hotline. Dont hesitate to call if you feel you are not getting
answers or if you think you are being treated unfairly; the company wants to know.
Consider asking the company if any aid to public participation such as reimbursement for
time and expenses is offered so you can be involved in the process. Every company has a
different approach to how to handle this so dont be surprised if the company you are
working with tells you it is against their policy to provide compensation for your time or
expenses.
OPEN HOUSE
A corporation will hold open house meetings in various communities along the pipeline route.
This is your first opportunity to ask questions and collect informationcome prepared.
The Open House may be in the format of a presentation, followed by a Question-Answer
period. In this format questions asked and answered will be heard by everyone at the same
time. The disadvantage is you may be limited to one question per person. To overcome this
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
10/65
10 | P a g e
disadvantage, have questions prepared in advance and distribute one question to each person
in your group.
Another format the corporation may use is a table-display model. Tables and displays are set
up in a large area and people wander about and talk to corporation representatives. The
disadvantage is the questions you ask are only heard by yourself and those immediately around
you. However, you arent limited to one question only, and you can ask the same question to a
number of corporate representatives to compare their answers. Similarly, with a large enough
group asking similar questions will allow you to compare answers for consistency.
Prior to the open house, whatever format, you will want to review the information you have,
determine what information you do not have and prepare a list of questions.
FERC HEARING
FERC will hold hearings in various locations along the pipeline route in preparation for the
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). At these hearings, citizens are allowed to comment on
the pipeline and submit documents. Ideally, comments should be in a hard copy form and
submitted to the FERC board at the hearing.
Comments should also be submitted on-line at the FERC e-file website and sent to the pipeline
corporation. (See Appendix 2 for using FERC e-file).
For landowners, filing comments as a unified group on common issues is preferable to filing
dozens of comments (though all landowners should intervene as individuals as well as part of a
group).
FERC is an executive agency, not a legislative body. As such, it is not influenced by hundreds of
identical letters or petitionsurging rejection of the pipeline. Comments should be in your own
words even if they contain the same concerns and issues.
What should be included in the comments?
While a list of pipeline accidents and violations by the corporation may be important to you,
FERC does not enforce regulation once a pipeline is in operation. This is the responsibility of
PHMSA, which does not participate in the FERC process. Nonetheless, if such a list is prepared
it should be read at the actual hearing so others attending the hearing (and news reporters) are
made aware of it. It makes good theater, but will not affect FERCs decisions.
In 2014 Delaware Riverkeeper challenged FERCs EIS regarding Tennessee Gas Pipeline
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
11/65
11 | P a g e
Companys Northeast Upgrade Project (NEUP)9 Delaware Riverkeeper maintained the EIS
should have included existing pipelines, pipelines under construction and any other proposed
pipeline that would be part of the existing system.
In May 2012 the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued a certificate of public
convenience and necessity to Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company authorizing construction and
operation of its Northeast Upgrade Project. Delaware Riverkeeper Network, the NJ Sierra Cluband New Jersey Highlands Coalition argued that the approval was inappropriate because FERC
had illegally segmented its environmental review of the Northeast Project by failing to consider
three other connected and interdependent projectsthe 300 Line Project, the Northeast
Supply Diversification Project, the MPP Projectand by failing to provide a meaningful analysis
of the cumulative impacts of the projects.
In a decision issued June 6, 2014, the United States Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia, ruled that the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, the NJ Sierra Club and New Jersey
Highlands Coalition were correct in their legal challenge to the Tennessee Gas Pipeline
Companys Northeast Upgrade Project and ordered additional analysis and review.
The Court stated: On the record before us, we hold that in conducting its environmental review
of the Northeast Project without considering the other connected, closely related, and
interdependent projects on the Eastern Leg, FERC impermissibly segmented the environmental
review in violation of NEPA. We also find that FERCs EA is deficient in its failure to include any
meaningful analysis of the cumulative impacts of the upgrade projects. We therefore grant the
petition for review and remand the case to the Commission for further consideration of
segmentation and cumulative impacts.
On the record before us, we find that FERC acted arbitrarily in deciding to evaluate the
environment effects of the Northeast Project independent of the other connected action on theEastern Leg.
FERC was ordered to perform a new EIS and include the cumulative impacts.
Considering Luzerne County has the existing Transco pipeline which is being expanded to
include the Leidy Loop in Bear Creek, the Atlantic Sunrise Pipeline which will connect to and
share midstream Transco facilities, and the proposed PennEast and Diamond East projects
comments should be made on the cumulative impact.
Another comment should focus on public convenience and necessity. Are these pipelinesnecessary? Are they a public convenience?
9United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit | Decided June 6, 2014 | No. 13-1015 |
Delaware Riverkeeper Network, Et Al.,Petitioners V. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Respondent,
Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, Llc And Statoil Natural Gas, Llc, Intervenors |On Petition for Review of an Order
of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
http://www.cadc.uscourts.gov/internet/opinions.nsf/30B6F48600A85C1E85257CEF004E34F1/$file/13-1015-
1496336.pdf
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
12/65
12 | P a g e
Per Spectra EnergyThe Regulatory Process10
:
To determine public convenience and necessity, FERC conducts a comprehensive
environmental review of proposed projects, in accordance with the National
Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). FERC works closely with federal, state, and localagencies such as the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, state
departments of environmental protection, and other state and local agencies. Other
stakeholders, including project neighbors and landowners, are also invited to participate
in the FERC process by attending meetings and providing comments or concerns at
particular times in the process.
One of the concerns with these pipelines is the EXPORTING of natural gas. To the layperson,
exporting natural gas is not a public convenience and necessity.
PennEast has said a number of times the gas won't be exported. Let's add the caveat thatPennEast has no plans to export AT THIS TIME.
The following are my thoughts, and not CONFIRMED anywhere:
There are 3 possible routes to bring the PennEast NG gas to export facilities.
First: The immediate one is Cove Point, MD which has recently been approved by FERC would
be the most likely choice at this time.
Second: Crown Landing in NJ. Important to note. When originally owned by BP, the plan was to
upgrade Crown Landing for IMPORT back in 2003 and had moved along the FERC process and
received Final Environmental Impact Statement on 2006.
The State of Delaware, which opposed the project, argued that its authority extends to the New
Jersey bank of the Delaware River, and that it had jurisdiction over the 2,000-foot pier that is
part of the project.
BP sold Crown Landing to Hess in 2009. Hess said it intended to restart the FERC approval
process in 2011. NOTE: HESS still wanted Crown Landing as IMPORT facility.
Two things happened in 2012: The industry has a gas glut, so spending money to build anIMPORT facility was financially impractical. Secondly: timetable has been disrupted by a little-
known ruling that a widely used model for calculating spill and fire risks at LNG terminals could
result in "truly gross underestimates of the hazard."
10Spectra EnergyThe Regulatory Process |
http://www.spectraenergy.com/content/documents/Media_Resources_PDFs/RegulatoryProcess.pdf
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
13/65
13 | P a g e
HESS abandoned its plans for Crown Landing in 2012.
There's no indication that Crown Landing couldn't be revived as an EXPORT TERMINAL at some
future date.
Third: Marcus Hook in Philadelphia - Sunoco Logistics was one of the first to recognize theethane market, and it committed to spending $600 million to build the Mariner East and a
similar project to transport ethane to petrochemical plants in Sarnia, Ontario. That pipeline
went into operation in late 2013.
In the Mariner East project, Sunoco plans to pump 70,000 barrels of ethane and propane a day
across the state to Marcus Hook, where the material must be chilled so it can be stored in
unpressurized tanks. The ethane will be exported, as there is no regional market for it. The
propane can be sold locally or exported.
NOTE: MARCUS HOOK is for ethane/propane not METHANE (natural gas). So at this timeexporting Natural Gas from this area is NOT being considered.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
14/65
14 | P a g e
Also NOTE: Williams Company is planning on building Diamond East which will take the
approximate same route as PennEast from Luzerne County PA to Trenton NJ. Diamond East will
run parallel to the PennEast pipeline and the Transco.
As far as Williams looking at EXPORTS - Diamond East most likely WON'T be used for exports.
Williams has already indicated its Atlantic Sunrise pipeline is an "integral part" of their plans to
EXPORT via Cove Point LNG in MD and Sabine Pass in the Gulf.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
15/65
15 | P a g e
Per Williams Partners Reports First-Quarter 2014 Financial Results, 4/30/201411
, Alan
Armstrong, chief executive officer of Williams Partners' general partner, made the following
comments:
"We're excited about the accelerating pace of expansion projects at Transco, including
Atlantic Sunrise, Dalton Lateral and our newly announced Gulf Trace project. The
Atlantic Sunriseand Gulf Trace projects will serve as important infrastructure for future
LNG export facilities at Cove Point and Sabine Pass .
More research and information is needed to determine what issues should be addressed for
comments.
Please read: Knowing and Protecting Your Rights When an Interstate Gas Pipeline Comes to
Your Community: A Legal and Practical Guide for States, Local Government Units, Non-
Governmental Organizations and Landowners On How the FERC Pipeline Certification Process
Works and How You Can Participate, Prepared by Carolyn Elefant, Law Offices of Carolyn
Elefant, Washington D.C. (http://lawofficesofcarolynelefant.com/)
Obviously, we will need to educate ourselves further, share the information and encourage
public involvement on a large scale. This will not be a weekend project and will required
commitment for the long term.
The expansion of pipelines and the rush to export will continue, and we can expect more plans
to further industrialize our community.
11Williams Partners Reports First-Quarter 2014 Financial Results | 4/30/2014
http://www.williamslp.com/profiles/investor/ResLibraryView.asp?BzID=1296&ResLibraryID=69789&Category=180
0
http://lawofficesofcarolynelefant.com/http://lawofficesofcarolynelefant.com/http://lawofficesofcarolynelefant.com/http://lawofficesofcarolynelefant.com/8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
16/65
16 | P a g e
Appendix 1
Ideas for Better Stakeholder Involvement In the Interstate
Natural Gas Pipeline Planning Pre-Filing Process
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
17/65
17 | P a g e
Ideas for Better Stakeholder
Involvement In the Interstate Natural
Gas Pipeline Planning Pre-Filing
Process
Industry, Agencies, Citizens, and FERC
Staff
Prepared by:
FERC Staff
OEP Gas Outreach Team
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
18/65
18 | P a g e
December 2001
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
19/65
i
Table of Contents
Introduction p ii
Action Options
Overview p
Early Involvement Develops BetterSolutions....p.1What All Stakeholders Need toKnow.p.2Tips For AllStakeholders.p.3
Industry Options p 4
Start Early, Involve KeyStakeholders..p.4Demonstrate YourCommitmentp.4Maintain Open Communications withAgenciesp.6Train Company Representatives and LandAgents...p.7Plan for Stakeholder Input Throughout theProcess..p.7Project Announcements andInformation...p.8
Make Route Information Easy andUnderstandable.....p.9Explain Mitigation, Compensation andBenefits...p.10Conclusionp.10
Agency
Options p
Coordinate Multiple OversightResponsibilitiesp.11
Address Project Issues/ConcernsEarly.p.11Consider Multiple AgencyCoordination...p.12Define Agency Information NeedsEarly..p.12Address Mitigation NeedsEarly...p.13
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
20/65
i
Conclusion.p.13
Citizen
Options p 4
Citizens Have a UniqueRolep.14Get Involved Early and StayInformed.....p.14Do YourHomework..p.16Know thePlayers..p.16Know theProcess..p.16Becoming aPartner..p.17
Conclusion.p.17
FERC
Options p 8FERCSRole..p.18 Commitment to ProvidingInformation..p.18Training to Improve theProcess...p.19
A Commitment to EarlyInvolvement.p.19Conclusionp.20
Glossary p 2
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
21/65
ii
Introduction
This document was developed by the Office of Energy Projects (OEP) Gas Outreach Teamusing the feedback and ideas collected from stakeholders at our pre- filing outreach seminars.It will be updated from time to time as needed, to incorporate new knowledge, techniques, oroptions that can help achieve consensus and a better application to the Federal Energy Regu-latory Commission.
If you are viewing this document on the web site, click on the words that appear in blue tolink to the glossary or to an appropriate web site. A full glossary also follows the documentfor further reference.
The concepts presented in this document are for discussion only, and do not necessarily rep-resent the views of the Commission or its individual members.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
22/65
1
Action Options Overview For InterstateNatural Gas Pipeline Siting
Early Involvement by All Stakeholders
Can
Develop Better Solutions
As a result of the comments and discussions at six InterstateNatural Gas Pipeline Facility Planning Seminars, the OEP GasOutreach Team developed a set of Outreach Action Options forpipeline companies, age ncies, citizens, and the FERC staff. TheAction Options identify concepts, actions, and activities that willhelp each stakeholder group achieve more effective participationin the process of planning a natural gas pipeline.
The objective is to provide the best
For moreinformation on
how to beinvolved in a
project from alandowners
perspec- tive, seeAn Interstate
Natural GasPipeline on My
Land? WhatDo I Need to
Know?The U.S.Depart-
ment ofTransporta-tion (DOT) isre-sponsible forsettingfederal safetystan-dards fornatural
gas pipelinesandrelated facilities.
possible guidance on different pre-filingtechniques that can be used to addressissues that are raised. Every pipeline project is different - its size,its location, the companys approach to working with stakeholders,the communitysinterest in participating, the agenciesexperiencewith similar projects, etc. The goal of the Action Options is to offer some ideas that all stakeholders can customize for their needs.
Pipeline companies are encouraged to
The Office ofPipe-line Safety atDOT
is atwww.dot.gov. seek out greaterinvolvement from thevarious groups early inthe planning so those
http://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.dot.gov/http://www.dot.gov/http://www.dot.gov/http://www.dot.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdf8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
23/65
2
who are interested canparticipate in thedecision- makingprocess. Age n-
Working together will payoff by helping to achieve
agreements.cies and citizens are encouraged to get involved early and maketheir views known to the companies as soon as they learn about apotential project. The goal is to achieve consensus and settle-ments among the groups and the company about an acceptableproject design. FERC staff has been asked to offer assistanceearly in the process to support all stakeholders. Earlier and moreproductive involvement will lead to better project designs and lesscontentious applications to FERC and other agencies.
Spending time
up front willsave time later.Consensus willbe more easily
achievedthrough
implementingthese ideas.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
24/65
3
What All Stakeholders Need to Know
The Players
There are many different participants in the pipeline planning process.
FERC - is charged by Congress with determining whether interstate natural gas transmis-
sion projects are in thepublic convenience and necessity.
Pipeline Companies - These are the companies that build and operate interstate natural
gas pipelines. They must justify the need, plan the route, and obtain numerous local,state and federal permits and clearances prior to construction.Federal, State and Local Agencies - The best way to find out who is involved from yo ur
local and state government is to call a local town official or a pipeline company represen-tative and ask. Some typical agencies involved in the planning process include:
Local: Town and County Councils, planning boards, zoning boards, and othersState: Environmental agencies, historic preservation offices, fish and wildlifeagencies, and othersFederal: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S.Environmental Protection Agency, Bureau of Land Management and ForestService
Local citizens and landowners - have interests in whether the proposed natural gas line
will impact their land or their community. Local citizens and landowners are encouraged
to make their views known at any time in the process.
Pre-filing Timeline Example For a Major Project Requiring an
EISGeneral set of actions followed for most projects:
OpenSeaso
n
Consider
Routes
for
Pipeline
Meet
with
Agencies
Communicatio
ns with
Landowners
and Citizens
Select
Propose
d Routes
Complet
e
Surveys
File atFERC
Number of
Months
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
25/65
4
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
26/65
3
The Process
Generally, the formal process for evaluating a pipeline companys proposal to build an in-terstate natural gas pipeline begins when the company files an application with the FERC.
The application includes maps showing the preferred route, the proposed facilities, thestatus of permit applications with local, state and federal agencies, affected landowners,and information on how the pipeline will affect the environment.
The FERCs review of the application and determination of need involves the balancing oftheprojectsadverse impact against its benefits. The FERCsenvironmental analysis of theapplication under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) is part of thatbalancing. Public participation is a key element in FERCs environmental analysis.
The goal of the Action Options is to encourage participation in a process where all stake-holders have the opportunity to have input before the development of the application, sothat issues are raised and addressed and solutions crafted and presented as part of the com-
panys proposal.
Some Tips For All Stakeholders
Ask other stakeholders how they want to be com-
municated with throughout this process.
Agree up front on how stakeholders will be in-
volved to set expectations at the start.
Be patientworking together on a complex project
requires understanding from all participants.
Develop summary transcripts from meetings and
share information with all stakeholders to keep the
lines of communication open.
Set up a process for what can be done if any stake-
holder feels their needs are not being met. If eve-
ryone agrees on the process up front, there will be
a way to address concerns.
Remember that each stakeholder has control over
their own actions and decisions. This is a volun-
tary process for all stakeholders.
Formalize agreements in writing so everyone can
be sure they understand and agree to what is decided.
NEPA IS...
The National
Environmental Policy
Act of 1969 is legis-lation that requires
federal agencies to
consider the
environmental
impacts of their
actions.
It outlines a process
for public input into
the agencies
decision-making
process.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
27/65
4
It requires that for major projects, a
detailed envi- ronmental study be pre-
pared, including the analy- sis of
appropriate alterna- tives to the
proposal.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
28/65
5
Industry Action Options
Start Early, Be Pro-active, Involve Key Stakeholders
Natural gas pipeline companies and their consultants, contractors, and industry groups are thecenterpiece of the pipeline siting process because they are the project planners and pro-ponents. This group carries a large part of the responsibility to implement and coordinate theproject activities that occur during thepre-filing time frame. There are a number of separatecomponents to the actions that the company will need to take, including developing a com-panyphilosophy of commitment, ensuring agency participation, training company represen-tatives and land agents, developing a publicparticipation plan, collecting data, and having aplan for potential mitigation and compensation.
As part of its pre-filing groundwork the company should address internal and external pla n-
ning and coordination issues. Pre- filing actions should be part of a coordinated plan, sincethey involve so many facets of a company and its consultants. Decisions on how to involveothers should be made internally before they are implemented. It will also be important totrain the project development team on the company philosophy and policy.
Dealing with agencies and citizens in a participatory decision- making process can help buildconsensus and resolve issues prior to filing. There will likely be some initial costs of timeand money, but these up- front actions should result in quicker processing of an applicationand presentation of the record to the Commission for a decision.
Demonstrate Your Commitment to
Public Involvement
Companies should create a project team to
interact with stakeholders. For large projects,the team should include environmental, engi-neering, and public relations professionals, in
addition to other valuable experts. At leastone company has formed a separate team spe-
cifically created for stakeholder outreach.
Make sure the team is trained to per-form the public involvement plan.Build the concept of public participa-tion into training for all facets of theproject development team.
The company should decide early that it will
be pro-active in getting agencies and land-
HAVE YOU:
Asked the community howtheyd like to receiveinformation?
Described the project ingreat detail tolandowners?
Explained tostakeholders how youwill work with them inthe pre-filing process?
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
29/65
6
Told landowners about yourcompany?
Shared safety information?
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
30/65
5
owners involved in the process and the resolution of issues. Commit to being honest andopen and following through in relationships with other stakeholders.
As part of determining potential stakeholders for a project, identify and establish key
contacts with:
Governor(s) and federal, state, and local politiciansEnvironmental agencies and groupsEnergy agencies/ PUCsFERC staffNon-governmental organizationsFederal and state land managersLocal distribution companiesLandowner and community representatives
Develop a positive attitude and company philosophy that includes a historical company
mission perspective. Make sure employees at every level and in every division of thecompany understand the concept of public participation.
When developing a public participation plan, consider how project announcements and
first contacts will be made, and to whom meetings will be open. Be inclusive, get others
involved early.
Consider involving stakeholders in early efforts to develop the route.
Be prepared to explain the need for the project to agencies and landowners. Explain thesupport the company has for the project at opportunities such as meetings and open
houses, etc. Explain supply/demand and get help and/or information from public utilitycommissions (PUCs), the Energy Information Administration (EIA), independent systemoperators (ISOs) and local entities on regional issues important to landowners.
In addition to sharing information about the benefits of a pipeline,
commit to being open about the down sides too. The public will
respect honesty and it may prevent future misunderstandings.
Maintain Strong, Open Channels of
Communication with AgenciesDevelop a multifaceted, grass-roots strategy for announcing the pro-
ject to federal, state, and local agencies (and to landowners), which
maximizes their opportunity for input into identifying potential issues
and their resolution.
Involv
e
stakehold
ers early
and share
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
31/65
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
32/65
7
Describe the time table for the project and try to get agency contacts to commit to have
their staffs work at the requested pace.
Be clear about when and how landowners and agencies can best contribute to the pla n-
ning process.
Set up big picture meetings/briefings with agency policy staffs, but be sure to also hold
detailed working sessions with technical staff.
Conduct field visits to help get a better understanding of an issue.
Consider the source of the information and whether it is really representative ofthe agency's assessment.
Explore the potential for team permitting options among agencies.
The value of early coordination and notification of problems is
high.
Tell federal agencies, local and regional officials, and state age n-cies about the project as early as possible, with as much detailed
information as is available, so that they may tell citizens when they
call. Ensure that the information is updated when events or sched-ules change. Consider developing materials that agencies can pro-
vide to interested stakeholders and develop a website with the
latest information.
The valueof early
coordination
and
notification of
problems is
high.
When and if limited resources prevent agencies from timely responses or actions, con-
sider funding third-party contractors to work for them.
Provide the FERC staff with accurate, advanced project information in as much detail as
possible so that they can help coordinate outreach to other agencies.
Train Company Representatives and Land Agents
Develop specific training for company representatives and land agents on the importance
of company philosophy and their role in establishing good communication with land-
owners and continuing it. Landowners want to deal with someone who is personable,
honest, and respectful.
Land agents are either building or hurting the reputation of the company with allaffected parties they meet.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
33/65
8
Landowner trust will be based in part on experience with theindustry as a whole.Consider using local land agents or hiring local assistance to familiarize out-of-town land agents with local culture and geography.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
34/65
9
Train land agents in dealing with people and on the companys
public participation plan.
When people are upset, find out what people are upsetabout.Land agents should be willing to put commitments in writ-ing or not make them.
Land agents
are your
representativ
es to the
community.
Plan for Public Stakeholder Input Throughout the
Process
Make a commitment to involve affected landowners and other interested citizens in the
project planning process. Inform them, listen to, and record landowner's ideas and
knowledge of the area and environment. Make sure communication is clear and easily
understandable, and respond to them constructively and with empathy.
Ask the community how they would like to be communicated with. What worksin one area may not work in another.Develop a public participation plan early, share it with landowners, and ask forcomments and suggestions.Try to have one consistent contact person that landowners can call, and make surethat person is clearly identified to the public. Provide the land agent's name andnumber and also the supervisor at the company or a company hotline to call.Bear in mind first contact issues and their potential sensitivity to landowners - acall, a letter, a visit? Consider issuing a public notice in the local newspaper or onother media (television, radio) before contacting landowners for a survey so thatlandowners have some awareness of the project before they are first contacted.Post information and updates on town bulletin boards and other public places.Ask town officials for help contacting local stakeholders so it can be determinedwhether or not everyone impacted by the project has been contacted.Share where the company gets its information and what resources the companyrelies upon.Give people time to react to requests, documents etc. Don't expect overnight
feedback.During the process, setup a feedback system so citizens know when they will getanswers to their questions. Put answers to general questions on a web site orother public place so all citizens can see the information.Stay away from industry jargon: use language carefully and be aware of how thepublic perceives the company at all times. Using words like marketingin pub-
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
35/65
10
lic settings can give the company a negative image because the word has differentmeanings to different people.Understand stakeholdersknowledge and background.Consider establishing an ombudsman for neutrality in information and contacts.Consider funding of studies requested by stakeholders.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
36/65
11
Project Announcements and Ongoing Information
Collection
When announcing the project, be specific and thoroughcarefully spell out the processand timeline for other stakeholders.
When announcing the project, consider the most effective meeting types. Again, ask
stakeholders how they want to be communicated with.
Do they prefer open houses, or one-on-one meetings, or a letter first?Should the initial contact be formal or informal?Consider meeting locations and times. For example, in an agricultural area, donthold a meeting in the planting/harvest season; or dont hold a meeting on a reli-gious holiday; etc.
Have qualified engineers and technical staff available to an-swer safety and design questions, perhaps with a sample pieceof pipeline, to describe how it is designed and operated.
For an open house, notify all stakeholders in the study corridor. Per-
haps present a slide show on pipeline construction and other general
issues so that people unfamiliar with pipeline siting and construction
can get a clear idea of what is proposed.
Whenannounci
ng the
project,
consider
the most
effective
meeting.
Describe the size and types of equipment that would be used.Ensure all documents are accurate and consistent. Avoid giving conflicting infor-mation to stakeholders.
Distribute the following information, whether in pamphlet- form or by other means:
A general biography of the company,
General information on environmental and other benefits of natural gas,Discussion of todaysenergy market and the need for expanded infrastructure,FERC background information,
Discussion of pre- filing activities,Post-filing review process,Construction information,Safety information, plans for safety training and the companys past safety re-cord, andIntended time frame for completing various activities (a project time line).
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
37/65
12
Share the pre- filing process with landowners in detail so that they can better understand
the steps and decide how to get involved.
Suggest unbiased sources (academics, web sites, government statistics) that are not affili-
ated with the company so that stakeholders can get information that is trustworthy in
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
38/65
13
their eyes. Avoid using the term proprietary informationbecause it can raise suspicionsand create distrust.
Make sure that all of the information that is used and shared with the public (including
maps, studies, etc) is current and up-to-date.
Follow up on outstanding questions and let people know how the answers will be com-
municated.
Conduct post-project interviews or evaluations with key stakeholders to make future im-
provements.
Make Route Development and Data
Collection Easy and Understandable
The stage of the process where surveys are performed, data collected androutes proposed may be the most confusing and complicated for manystakeholders. When its time to do the detailed route planning, makesure the landowner knows what to expect and has given permission to
Share
the pre-
filing
process
with
landowners
in detail.
proceed with the survey(s). Survey permission forms should be readable with full disclosure
of survey requirements.
What does survey permission mean? Recognize and state clearly that landownerconcurrence to allow a survey is not approval of a right-of-way. Know the differ-ence.Explain the types of surveys (crew size, survey methods).Describe the work to be done (such as: is tree cutting or clearing required? Willtest holesbe dug?).Ensure the survey corridor is wide enough to accommodate route variations.Describe alternative routes the company considered in addition to the proposedroute.
Explain Mitigation, Compensation and Benefits in
Laymans Terms
Many landowners are unfamiliar with the rules, process, and procedure of how a right-
of-way payment is made. So, explain the compensation/payment method to landowners.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
39/65
14
Explain the typical procedures which the landowner can expect will be used.Explain procedures and specifics around payments for easements - how are theydetermined?Share information about additional damage payment(s) made after construction
Provide options of what a landowner could request as compensation.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
40/65
15
Explain the energy benefits which will result from the project, or other benefits which
could be locally significant.
Develop a benefits plan and educate stakeholders about local benefits of the pro-ject (i.e. payments to landowners, local tax payments, etc).If the landowner requests sidejobs,explain what is or is not allowed and howthe job might be performed for the landowner.
Since practices vary among different pipelines, it is important to be up-front about the
companys usual custom and whether or not it involves monetary compensation. If any
funding to aid public participation is available, tell stakeholders early.
Conclusion
The proper preparation and stakeholder involvement in the pre- filing process can make the
entire process easier, quicker, and ultimately less expensive. The companysreputation withthe community and involved agencies will benefit from a well-devised, well-executed par-tic ipation plan.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
41/65
16
Agency Action Options
Coordinate to Address Multiple Oversight
Responsi- bilities
Numerous agencies (federal, state and local) have a role in natural gas facility siting. Allserve the public and may have overlapping responsibilities. Agenciesfocus on managementand regulatory requirements span a very wide spectrum of cultural, natural, economic, edu-cational, political, and other resource interests. As a result, different agencies may have con-flicting priorities or responsibilities due to their unique focus and or function. What is idealfor one agency may be detrimental to another. The challenge here is to identify what isneeded to avoid or at least minimize obstacles to providing coordination and service, and
how to achieve better results early in the facility planning process. There are several steps tocoordination, including addressing project issues early, discussingjoint participation, defin-ing agency needs early, and addressing mitigation needs as soon as possible.
Address Project Issues/Concerns Early for Better Results
With many agencies and potential overlapping needs, it is important to get your agencys in-terests into the mix early so your role is clearly defined and understood from the beginning.Some of the things agencies can do upon getting an initial contact from a company includethe following.
Know what project components will involve
your agency.
Get support from agency management to
commit resources for early involvement
Determine the lead federal agency (usually
FERC) and lead state agency, if one, and pro-
vide a key agency contact to ask and answer
questions early.
Establish coordination and early participation
procedures among agencies.
Consider attending public meetings in order
to provide your agencys perspective and ex-
plain your role in the process.
HAVE YOU:
Identified where youragency should getinvolved?
Gotten support fromagency management?
Identified key issuesand informationneeds
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
42/65
17
Decided on coordinationprocedures?
Attended public meetings?
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
43/65
12
Consider Multiple Agency Coordination and Joint
Participation
Encourage team permitting to improve your agency's internal and
external processes. Team permitting could reduce redundant re-view and provide information concurrently to all interested par-
ties.
Federal agencies should coordinate regulatory review and ap-
provals at the federal level early.
State agencies should coordinate regulatory review and approvals
at the state and local level early.
Coordination
with other
agencies can
reduce timing
for reviews and
approvals.
Determine whether your agency has public notification rules and/or needs to hold public
meetings. Consider whether another agencys meeting could fulfill the requirements.
Agencies that must involve the affected public and stakeholders before making their rec-
ommendations and decisions.
Even if your agency cannot commit to early involvement, know where to get information
and stay informed.
Consider creating a document that shows how agencies work with other agencies so citi-
zens know how to work with the system.
Consider creating an agency forum for discussion and resolution of common issues.
If resources prevent agencies from timely responses or actions, consider third-party fund-
ing by the project proponent to assist the agency.
Ensure that decision- makers and required technical staff are involved early in the process
so that accurate issues and needs are reflected early and decisions can be made more ac-
curately and quickly.
Define Agency Information Needs and Timing
Requirements Early
It is very important to identify information and timing requirements as early in the process aspossible. When issues about the project, the process, and likely conflicts or potential out-comes are defined and acted on early, the process can go more smoothly and efficiently.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
44/65
13
Be clear about what information your agency needs and when you need ithave your
requirements published clearly. Examples may be specific route surveys, survey results,
landowner information (approved or denied survey access, etc.), and timing of when all
remaining information must be submitted.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
45/65
14
Identify where and when decisions will be made and who will
make them.
If there are any "show stoppers" identify them as soon as possible.
Examples: If state/local agency code/regulations have siting
guid elines or requirements that conflict with FERC's routingcriteria, or would require use of established "utility corridors"that are not conducive to a proposed project's end points.
Identif
y show-
stoppers as
early as
possible.
Agencies should give early and honest feedback on route alternatives. Make sure you
supply whatever information you have.
Agencies should identify any known cumulative effects (both beneficial and adverse im-
pacts) and any growth that will occur in the project area. These should include locationand timing information about any known development or other projects in the vicinity of
the proposed pipeline.
Address Mitigation Needs As Soon As Possible
If resource impacts are unavoidable, but can be mitigated or otherwise compensated for,identify potential options which satisfy your concerns, as early as possible.
Identify if compensation will be required.
Explain who is responsible for developing mitigation plans.
Conclusion
Although different agencies can often have conflicting priorities and responsibilities, earlyand effective coordination can help prevent obstacles. It is important to know how to get in-formation and to decide early on how different federal, state, and local agencies will worktogether in the most effective manne r.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
46/65
14
Citizen Action Options
Citizens Have a Unique Role: Take Advantage of
Your Opportunity to Participate
Citizens and landowners are unique in the natural gas pipeline siting process for several rea-sons. While the pipeline company is proposing the action, and the government agencies areactively involved in the permitting process, citizens are often passively swept into the proc-ess. While the pipeline companies and the agencies participate in the process in the contextof doing their jobs, the citizens not only must take time off from their jobs to participate, buttheir stake in the outcome may be more personal; the project affects their own property and/
or community.
The challenge for citizens is to develop resources that enable active engagement in the proc-ess, objective application of the process, easier identification of direct or indirect projectbenefits, and greater access to information. In order to be involved in the most productiveway, citizens should get involved early and make an effort to understand the process.
Get Involved Early and Stay
Informed
Every pipeline company and every natural gas pipeline siting project is different. Projectsthat are large or new take longer to plan thansmaller expansions of existing systems. The dif-
ference can depend on geography, the companysculture and the type of community that may be im-pacted by the siting process. Getting involvedearly and staying informed is a citizens best strat-egy for ensuring that their needs are met and theirquestions answered.
As soon as you can become involved, seek out
information pro-actively; dont wait for it tocome to you. If you wait, you could lose an
opportunity.
Constructive participation will get youmore answers and information. Partic i-pate from a foundation of knowledge
and fact rather than emotionand ru- mors.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
47/65
14
HAVE YOU:
Identified Company contacts?
Learned about the sitingprocess?
Checked the pipeline com-panys web site?
Given feedback on how thecompany or agencies can im-prove communication?
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
48/65
15
Let the company know if you are interested in participating in the planning stage (where
the route is determined) and not just the permitting stage (where the route is reviewed by
regulators and agencies).
Recognize what information the companies
are obligated to provide and what informa-
tion is not available.
Ask questions and follow throughuntil they are answered to your sat-isfaction.Although you should be prepared towait for answers, you should alsobalance that with being assertivewhen it comes to asking for infor-
mation you should have.Lots of information is on web sites(companies, agencies); make use ofit.See the Industry Action Options forinformation about what resourcesshould be made available to citi-zens; ask about them.Make sure you get the project ma n-agers name and contact information
SOME SOURCES OF
INFORMATION
INCLUDE:
FERC Regulations18CFR380
FERC Landowner Notification
Rule
18CFR157.6(D)FERC Websitehttp://rimsweb1.ferc.gov/rimshttp://cips.ferc.gov/cips
Interstate Natural GasAssociation of America
www.ingaa.org
CompaniesWebsites(See links atwww.ferc.gov)
so that you have someone to call if you have questions.
Understand that your active participation in a companys project can add value. Regard-
less of your opinion, it is in the companys best interest to work with you rather than
against you.
Decide if you want to be involved in decisions regarding routing and/or construc-tion impact mitigation.
When you send in comments to FERC, also send a copy to the company so theyare immediately aware of your opinions.
Explore whether your local municipality, county, or citizen organization will represent
you as a group.
http://www.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/index.htmlhttp://www.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/index.htmlhttp://cips.ferc.fed.us/q/cips/rules/rm/rm98-17.00d.txthttp://cips.ferc.fed.us/q/cips/rules/rm/rm98-17.00d.txthttp://rimsweb1.ferc.fed.us/rimshttp://rimsweb1.ferc.fed.us/rimshttp://cips.ferc.fed.us/cipshttp://www.ingaa.org/http://www.ingaa.org/http://www.ferc.gov/gas/pipecomp.htmhttp://www.ferc.gov/gas/pipecomp.htmhttp://www.ferc.gov/gas/pipecomp.htmhttp://www.ferc.gov/gas/pipecomp.htmhttp://www.ferc.gov/gas/pipecomp.htmhttp://www.ingaa.org/http://cips.ferc.fed.us/cipshttp://rimsweb1.ferc.fed.us/rimshttp://rimsweb1.ferc.fed.us/rimshttp://cips.ferc.fed.us/q/cips/rules/rm/rm98-17.00d.txthttp://www.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/index.html8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
49/65
16
Know the name and phone number of the company land agents supervisor or the num-
ber of the company/landowner hotline. Dont hesitate to call if you feel you are not ge t-
ting answers or if you think you are being treated unfairly; the company wants to know.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
50/65
17
Consider asking the company if any aid to public participationsuch as reimbursement for time and expenses is offered so you
can be involved in the process. Every company has a differentapproach to how to ha ndle this so dontbe surprised if the com-
pany you are working with tells you it is against their policy to
provide compensation for your time or expenses.
Do Your Homework to Ensure Your
Involvement is
Productive
The process of siting natural gas pipelines is complicated and in-volves lots of participants and details. The following can help you be
Your
participation
can add
valuable
project
information to
the pipeline
companys
planning
process.
sure you are informed about the process and how you can become a partner in that process.
Know the Participants
Understand the mission and business plan of the company proposing the project.
Check their web site and public mailings.
Understand the role and mission of the FERC and its processes.
Check the FERC web site atwww.ferc.gov.
Understand the role of federal, state, and local agencies.
Understand how your first tier local government can work for you. Your local govern-
ment or community may be able to be your advocate.
Know the Process
Understand the concepts of eminent domain, federal preemption, andpublic convenience
and necessity.
http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
51/65
18
Understand the process of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA). It is
a statute that requires a federal agency to be aware of the environmental impacts of its
decisions.
Understand that the pipeline company will respect you for your honesty, just as you re-
spect them for theirs.
Understand that the regulatory review and approval process may not move as quickly as
you would like once a project is agreed upon. Have patience with the gas company and
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
52/65
19
the agencies involved to ensure a smoother process.
Find out what survey permission is and what survey companies do (e.g. number of days,
extent of work, etc). Be informed.
Becoming a Partner
Determine whether there are, or could be,
direct or indirect benefits of the project to
your community and to you personally.
Your knowledge can help accomplish the
goals of the company in a way that meets
your needs at the same time.
Allowing surveys is not the same as grantinga construction easement. Consider allowingthe company to complete its surveys on your
property as they may document environ-mental or engineering constraints if they ex-ist. You may seek the advice of counsel ifyou are concerned.
Improve informational resources. If FERCs
or a pipeline companys landowner brochure
doesnt meet your needs, tell them and sug-
gest ways to improve them.
Conclusion
TYPICAL TYPES
OF SURVEYS
INCLUDE:
Civil surveys,Geotechnicalsurveys, Culturalresource surveys,
Wetland delineationsurveys, and Threatenedand endangered speciessurveys.
Some types, (especiallygeotechnical and culturalresource surveys), typi- callyrequire localized excavations
at predetermined intervals.
All surveys require that thesurveyor have access to theland. Once access is granted,various surveyors mayvisit the propertyintermittently over a periodof time.
There are ways for interested citizens to get involved in the pre- filing stages of natur al gas
pipelines that could affect their community. It is important that all stakeholder groups worktogether to ensure that citizens are actively engaged in the process, understand direct and in-direct project benefits, and have greater access to information. Early involvement and betterunderstanding will increase public participation and allows citizens to make their viewsknown.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
53/65
20
FERC Staff Action Options
FERC
S Role as the Lead Agency
There are many questions regarding FERC's role in siting natural gas pipeline facilities andhow FERC's process is connected to those at other agencies, particularly state agencies.Landowners clearly look to FERC to provide more information than is currently available.Further, natural gas companies look for additional help from FERC to coordinate the effortsof all the other permitting authorities. There are several action options that can address re-quests for greater staff participation and other resources to aid the various stakeholders in theplanning process. Options include: making an effort to keep information up-to-date, offeringtraining to share information, and committing to get involved in the process early.
Commitment to Providing Up-to-Date Information
TheFERC web site was revised in the spring of 2001 and represents a marked improve-
ment in appearance and the organization of information. Al-
though it is more user friendly and it's easier to find the informa-tion you need, no new functionality was built into the latest re-lease. FERC is considering further upgrades. Comments receivedat the seminars regarding the web site included requests for:
Summary and status information for major projects. The
The FERC staffcan
becomeinvolved
in projects
duringthe pre-filing
stage.summaries could also include links to the applicants' project web site.
Criteria, requirements, and documentation for getting approval for the NEPA pre-filing process.A homefor pre- filing (pre-docket number) project information.State-by-state links to relevant agencies so landowners can use the FERC site toget local info.A guide on how to contact FERC and ask that they get involved in a project.
A landowner chat room where subject matter experts could respond to questions.Other specific requests to solve problems such as retrieving filed informationfrom the RIMS system.Data on future projects.A list of contacts if people have further questions.
FERC staff and/or other resource agencies (the Energy Information Administration,
PUCs) should work to generate information about the big-picture market for natural gas
http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
54/65
21
and the need for natural gas on a regional basis that could be presented to various stake-
holder groups.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
55/65
22
During the decision- making process, FERC should be sensitive to the difference between
survey permission and landowner support of a project.
FERC should enhance the existing brochure"An Interstate Natural Gas Pipeline on My
Land? What Do I Need to Know?" to include information such as:
The availability of information on the FERC's web site.Resources available to landowners (e.g.,INGAA web site).Materials that companies are required to provide to landowners and others undertheLandowner Notification Rule -when it is provided and to whom.What types of routing changes and landowner benefits in easement agreementscan be negotiated without FERC approval, as FERC will not be involved in ease-ment negotiations.Clarification on how a landowner can become an intervenor.
FERC should conduct exit interviews with landowners after each project that implements
pre-filing involvement to better understand where problems were and how those prob-lems were solved. Debriefings on completed projects could be used to determine im-
provements to future projects.
FERC should prepare a scoping summary to address issues raised during scoping.
Consider establishing a single point of contact to answer questions.
Training to Improve the Process
FERC will offer training (mainly for industry and consultants) on Revised Regulations forEnvironmental Reports (Minimum Environmental Filing Requirements). FERC is currentlyplanning a series of training sessions; please seewww.ferc.gov for session dates, locations,and other details. Training will also be offered on Environmental Compliance. FERC canalso use these training sessions to provide information to professional participants and to dis-seminate information on new methods and protocols that improve theNEPAprocess.
A Commitment to Early Involvement by
FERC Staf f
Improve programmatic coordination between the FERC andother permitting agencies to expedite natural gas projects.
FERC can make staff available to attend agency coordina-tion meetings either before or after the filing of an applica-tion (subject to staffing limitations).If needed, help develop interagency or project-related
Bygetting
involved
early, FERCcan helpcoordinate
agency andcitizen
participation.
http://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ingaa.org/http://www.ingaa.org/http://www.ingaa.org/http://cips.ferc.fed.us/Q/CIPS/RULES/RM/RM98-17.00D.TXThttp://cips.ferc.fed.us/Q/CIPS/RULES/RM/RM98-17.00D.TXThttp://cips.ferc.fed.us/Q/CIPS/RULES/RM/RM98-17.00D.TXThttp://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://cips.ferc.fed.us/Q/CIPS/RULES/RM/RM98-17.00D.TXThttp://www.ingaa.org/http://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdfhttp://www.ferc.gov/about/doing/6513gpo.pdf8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
56/65
23
Memoranda of Understanding between FERC and interested agencies to establishjurisdiction and responsibilities.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
57/65
24
FERC could help achieve consensus in route planning and issue identification and reso-lution at the earliest possible point (i.e., before the filing of an application). FERC is cur-rently in the process of initiating pre- filing environmental reviews. It is likely thatFERCs involvement in each project will be slightly different depending on the case-specific circumstances. Typically the goal would be to issue a draft EIS very shortly af-ter an application is filed. Adequate time should be allotted in the pre- filing phase to
conduct scoping meetings, field surveys, and to compile the reports that are required tosupport the coordinated review by agencies, FERC, and third-party consultants.
As the lead federal agency, FERC could advise other agencies of their role in the pre-
filing application process.
FERC should consider expanding its process to include giving responses to all levels of
government officials. This response policy would help pipelines in addressing issues at
the local level.
Conclusion
FERC could provide more information to stakeholders and coordinate efforts among age n-cies. FERCs early involvement should improve communication between stakeholders andcould expedite the process.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
58/65
25
Glossary
Construction easementThe area of land, or footprintthat is disturbed or used for construction of the pipeline.This area is typically larger than the permanent easementand includes extra work areas foractivities such as equipment staging, topsoil storage, stream and road crossings, and right-of-way access during construction.
Construction impact mitigationThose measures that are implemented in order to reduce or undo the potential damages in-curred during pipeline construction such as soil erosion on slopes that have been cleared andgraded. In this example, water bars or slope breakers could be installed across the slope to
minimize erosion caused by precipitation and the resultant siltation of nearby streams. Stateand Federal agencies often attach many construction mitigation requirements to their li-censes and permits.
Draft EISA draft Environmental Impact Statement issued by the lead federal agency for a 45-day com-ment period.
Easement agreementsThe legal document, signed by both the pipeline company official and the landowner, thatspecifies the route, work areas, amount and method of payment, if any, and other terms such
as restrictions on the use of the land, and possible future expansions of the pipeline.
Easement and damage paymentsPayments made by the pipeline company to the landowner or land- managing agency for theeasement or damages resulting from pipeline construction. Damage payments, if necessary,would be in addition to standard payments for the right-of-way easement.
Easement negotiationsThose discussions between pipeline-company official and landowner about the specificterms of the easement that may or may not result in a signed agreement. These discussionsare usually conducted by land agents representing the pipeline companies.
Eminent domainThe right of a government to seize private property for public use in exchange for paymentof fair market value.
Energy Information Administration EIA)The Energy Information Administration (EIA), created by Congress in 1977, is a statistical
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
59/65
26
agency of the U.S. Department of Energy. They provide policy-independent data, forecasts,
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
60/65
27
and analyses to promote sound policy making, efficient markets, and public understandingregarding energy and its interaction with the economy and the environment.
Environmental review
From the Federal perspective, implementing the independent review, agency consultations,and scoping out of issues that are part of administering the mandates of the National Envi-ronmental Policy Act (NEPA). Depending on theprojectssize, complexity and level ofcontroversy, this review may take between three months to over one year.
Federal preemptionWith respect to natural gas pipeline systems under the jurisdiction of the FERC, this broadlegal concept means that Federal authority supersedes the state or local authority.
Formal certificate reviewThe formal review of an application under the Natural Gas Act which considers, in addition
to environmental issues, rates, markets, financing, and other business issues.
Independent System Operator ISO)Organizations that manage the transmission portion (as opposed to the generation portion) ofthe electric industry.
IntervenorSomeone who wishes to participate in a proceeding and therefore files a petition to intervenewith the Commission for a particular case. In their filing, an intervenor may additionallystate whether or not they wish to protest the application and whether or not they seek a for-mal hearing on the application.
Land agentsThose representatives of the pipeline companies who are dispatched to acquire the right-of-way for the proposed pipeline project.
Lead federal agencyWhen more than one federal agency has permitting authority for a project, the agencies oftendesignate a lead Federal agency to supervise the preparation of the EA or EIS. The FERC isfrequently the lead Federal agency for natural gas pipeline projects.
Open seasonA process in which a pipeline company solicits market interest for new pipeline transporta-tion services. This is done as part of the pipeline company's planning process to help it deter-mine the economic feasibility for a project.
Pre-filing time frameThe period of time before an application is filed at the FERC.
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
61/65
28
Public convenience and necessitySynonymous with "for the good of the general public". Generally, if the Commission deter-
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
62/65
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Gas Drilling Awareness Coalition
29 | P a g e
mines that there is sufficient need for a project after the consideration of all relevant factors,then it is determined to be in the public convenience and necessity and, it will be processed andissued a "certificate of public convenience and necessity" or license. These "certificates" carrywith them the power of eminent domain.
RIMSThe Record Information Management System (RIMS) is the database where case-specificinformation is stored electronically. It is accessed via the Internet at www.ferc.gov.
Route variationRelatively small deviations from the proposed route that are meant to avoid some environ-mentally sensitive area. Route variations usually depart from and then rejoin the proposedroute within a short distance.
Scoping
In the context of NEPA, scoping is the process of asking the public and other agencies toidentify any environmental issue s that should be considered in the environmental analysis ofthe pipeline project.
Side jobsActivities which are not related to work required for the pipeline construction but which thepipeline company may be willing to do for a landowner as part of the easement negotiation.
SurveyTypical types of surveys include civil surveys, geotechnical surveys, cultural resource sur-veys, wetland delineation surveys, and threatened and endangered species surveys. Some
types, especially geotechnical and cultural resource surveys, typically involve localized ex-cavation at predetermined intervals in order to collect the desired data. The other types ofsurveys usually only involve walking the pipeline right-of-way, taking measurements andobservations and may involve taking small samples such as soil and plant samples. All sur-veys require that the surveyor have access to the land being surveyed. Survey permissionforms may be used to document landowne r agreement to allow access. Once access to theland is granted by the landowner, surveyors may visit the property intermittently over a pe-riod of time.
Team permittingAn approach that some states have adopted to issuing the many various environmental per-
mits for a particular project whereby the agencies involved coordinate with each other (and theapplicant, public, and cooperating agencies) and issue all their respective permits in oneaction.
Test holesSmall excavations or borings performed in the process of surveys such as cultural resourcesurveys or geotechnical surveys.
http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/http://www.ferc.gov/8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
63/65
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Gas Drilling Awareness Coalition
30 | P a g e
Appendix 2
Ferc eFiling
8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
64/65
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Gas Drilling Awareness Coalition
31 | P a g e
FERC eFiling
To file a comment you will need to know the docket number. This is a number FERC has
assigned to a project.
You will need to create an Online Account with FERC if you wish to access FERC documents
associated with the pipeline project. http://www.ferc.gov/docs-filing/ferconline.asp
Click the eRegister Button to create an account. By registering, you will receive a single user id
and password that allows you to transact virtually all of your business with FERC. eRegistration
does not grant access to non-public material in eLibrary .
eRegistration is valuable to any person who transacts business with the FERC on behalf of
themselves or another organization (e.g. companies or corporations). It provides authentication
support to the FERC Online applications that ensures safe and secure transactions, therebyprotecting the integrity of your data.
To register, pick a user name and password. The system will then prompt you for a user profile.
http://www.ferc.gov/docs-filing/ferconline.asphttp://www.ferc.gov/docs-filing/ferconline.asphttp://www.ferc.gov/docs-filing/ferconline.asp8/11/2019 FERC and Natural Gas Pipelines
65/65
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Gas Drilling Awareness Coalition
If you are making a comment on a pipeline, you will need to know the DOCKET NUMBER.
Commenting on a pipeline project DOES NOT require you to create an eRegistration account.
August 13, 2013eFiling and eComment are now compliant with Internet Explorer v10
IMPORTANT - READ BEFORE YOU BEGIN: After you submit an eComment request, you willreceive an email from ferc.gov with a link to the comment system. Your system must not block
emails from ferc.gov.
Please create your comments in a Word or Text file (up to 6,000 characters) before you begin,
then copy/paste them in the eComment Text Box to avoid time-out limits. The application will
time-out after 35 minutes of inactivity.
If you are not filing as an individual or if you are filing a motion to intervene, you must have an
eRegistration account and use the Commission's efiling system.
FERC's eComment Option is limited to individuals filing up to 6,000 characters of text-only
comments on their own behalf in the following proceedings:
Hydroelectric License/Re-license Proceedings (P - Project Number),
Pre-Filing Activity for Planned Natural Gas Projects (PF Docket),
Applications for Authorization to Construct a Natural Gas Pipeline,Liquefied Natural Gas
(LNG) or Other Facility (CP Dockets),
Pre-Filing Activity for Permits to Site Interstate Electric Transmission Lines (PT
Dockets), and
Applications for a Permit to Site Interstate Electric Transmission Lines (ET Dockets).
IMPORTANT - READ BEFORE YOU BEGIN:
After you submit an eComment request, you will receive an email from ferc.gov with a link to the
comment system. Your system must not block emails from ferc.gov. Please create your comments in
a Word or Text file (up to 6,000 characters) before you begin, then copy/paste them in the
eComment Text Box to avoid time-out limits. If you are not filing as an individual or if you are filing a
motion to intervene, you must have an e