ffU!L~fD) - Washington Petition for Review.pdf · filed ffu!l~fd) oct 1 :, 2014 s clerk of_the...

FILED

ffU!L~fD) OCT 1 :, 2014

CLERK OF_THE SUPREME COURT S STATE OF WASHlf~GTON (jx:"

THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

OCT 0 8 2014 COURT OF APPEALS

DIVISION Ill STATE OF WASHINGTON By ___ _

STATE OF WASHINGTON Plaintiff,

Case No. 3\Ytfi 0- 4- \ \ \

v.

Petitioner,

I. IDENTITY OF MOVING PARTY

MOTION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW

COMES NOW, 3"" A.R"o0 V E 1: t.. k E \) i designated in part II.

Petitioner, seeks the relief

II. STATEMENT OF RELIEF SOUGHT

.... lSSUE p.,.- \::)k?M+SC:?AL WL-r\1\, eRcxs.:()s.c.C f)uc-

"Io seany ~\IZTAL R~G}\\ A-t\lO Ouc Panee-t,? V):...oLATJ:.O.VS.

- I?SV e ~- - i<..£MA!\}'{) Foft RE)Q\JrrNCJ:-Nfr !)Vt

In M1SCALCuL~=y L-oN o( OEEtNOt(J..S Po):N1S.

-3:-??vE c .. - IZEVet{~AL Pd-1:0 Cl.i'MANO 6trt)( To uu~l

fofl.. «E: -\\'2_ ~'f\:L {)u C \o \j\l C PQo CCSS \/T.-0 Lv\TJdJ r\JS.

Motion for Discretionary Review - Page 1 of 3

III. FACTS

mg. \/£IL LeV X Lv~ Cot\JVLC 3 e:O OF f 1R.s-( Oe-Gfl_cE lJtV

LAwfvL Pos'JBS:iorJ o? rl tL:tlO\ClM hll ow kN& A- :Sv!'"f n1 Ir\ L.

~t \J:MfL '( AffetrLeO \1\:-S Co-v\hJu:rl:-&~ =x6 3Jdf! Cau lT of AMe-nu7.J f)rvt-~ r:.aru JTI: • \\~s Cov\)vs.cnJJrU WAc., \\tt"t:ilN\ e:.o. MR. Vt:J:t..Le-\JX NalkJ "S"J:-Mt:L:( MOT1-DINc, B>e ... i)t:-sca.e:rr.oNA:-ai {Ze

Vkw '<:> """}\ e s v PP..m£ eoua:r o £ -s-vt E ?'fi'Y1]f o t=

IV. ARGUMENT

A.

B.


c.

V. CONCLUSION

Based on the above, this Court should accept review.

DATED this 5-_day of QC\0 \2tfZ , 2orJ..

Signa$211&&./

CcYoTC RIOGf" coa..llc-n-rni\J Ct.t .. jfcl ?o f?OX q~q 'f ts\- 3 '2


Issue- A ..

SJ~:ATA.:i\JCr 1)\E '10 DeY T1.-Me:= Ltr'h'tT VNOEQ. Cr R :5.3 .. QN AvC.HuH Q L.{J dO IOl "1).\.£" S\e::tC f<.EGvc=>Yc:tl AN € X\t:N~?I,oAJ 0; \"!Mli :to

Accv ~11\e-.QA'\E A X~A"iNl-.VG- Ext.e-a.r"l zc ""JJ\-'1 \\\Ex.~ L EAO Drr£c.t:r« Kvlti $fys.;yt 1\JsEQ E(\ To AntNO, No o6~EC.T1::cu\J CAM£' b~oM "'\}\t

~EEeN'J( t3erNCr 1r\:A\ \Hf Cot-f\LI\hJAP-.H':l( S1:LLL £fLL IAJ~JHIIO "tHt

S9c-El\y' 'TR~AL l1-M"L"YAJ±ON.

CJN 5£(JI£M6fft fz 1 9ol.:l 3\\£ 1;(('1-r\L CoutT Grl.ANTS AM ExTEN)IotU

\ILL 0C}o8E4. $1

<9C:ll8 QlfcQ "Y\-\( SIERt\1 0~)"5t(\IoN Of THE

DrFei'JSt ,])\:X~ !A)~~ :so t'\CC.OMA'I,)AI£ rna. VEtLLflJ)( '~ C.o-11EFCNt2Aiffl5

ArroAAlE'(.

OtU OC=t o6ER y ' ao id \t\.f 0[FENS({" W\QTl:oAI EO 'lJlC ('o;~RT ~or\

A Iwo DAY CoNT1.N\Je-tJC£ 1 Ff<oN\ OtTo6e-,g, tt5Ttf TLLt 0CT06Ef<. IQTHJ

tA)IilCH tJAs :5TI( I iAJ.iJ"HT11l Tl-\C ctO QA Y '2vlC UNOc-~ C C J< 3a3. TWJ'?

WAS f\U£ 3o \\\E -DcEEiV?E t\Jro,-2rUtY 1'\t;r.N{r 'l.I$Vc\!ILED it..l ANn\-\Ei<..

\\\( eeo?CCV1"(hl RtOdE"TEO AN £PfN7I:o N 0 F T!,JO wat<S To AcCat!'\A nArt

A f?R£-PLArVNEQ v'AcAT:-s:oN fl'( 0tT6CI}:.V/L K£'0ff. \\\£ "\1.JO WEEt4

exrEN~lnN Pu-r MR. Vt:ILL £Vi WHL PAs-r 1HC qo DAy LIM£T "'>f"T /,'(

C.rR 3.3 AND So \\£ o&-:serrt.O.

Aus-r :s: f y 3J\c MoT~o,V Em(! -r\:\r Coi\JTttJtltrruc{. EY.P.Meu: I. f. J (',c,PrE'?

OF eQccF Of ea.>-oR VACAT"LOA) NOTtCE: Ftl.oN\ ?\-\t:RR.35E? 0EfA(rM8\JT,fgc

QAifl A1<?.lrN£ :r:r.ct<ET'?I HOTfL oR MH£L Rct;N'\";l I Crt\'{{ e~rN"IAI oR

\\\ IAJPt.QD 51=1../1

S:f, 11 t:'fbl Q.;j.{) G,.:;) l •AN OR<\eQ.. "'\o GiANT J\1\} . tl '' tt ,,

EXT£JVS:r.oi\J IAJ~·n\ GooD C.Av2( ANO {)ve- O!:L L.G-tNCC :tHE' Cav.(T

ANO STATE Nce::t)2 'Yo ?\\twJ OoCvME'NTA"\t:.o.V oF THlh So CeLLEQ

€R.E- Al<itA.VG-e-0 \/oCA"Tk.cuV .. SEE" 5TBTC \/, Kobo\ 1 '{d lc)tJ. AfP. :133) r"f/J, t'.JQ 1\,~\ (MANI.££ST A8V7£ Of O~~C~ar.artJ).:t\-\£ 1"~'tt\L CouR.I A(!,u~cO I.\'2 OrsCt£I~oN :I..V GeANT"tNk "1"\!f CaN1INUt:NCtr

f\,l£ 'o LAc..S. o £ Su etbrts 1:-N& £v:s: i\€)\JCf: Ar\JQ OoCuM£"NTAr.ral\).

3\.\£ Ccl.VCl uC,Iot\J oE \HIS H£A~:I=N6- t..JA? A CoA.!TI-t\)IJ£/lJC£ tlNTIL

}}$ s-·n-1 oF U01/£M&dt I cxCJ\Cj I Q2G, OA't'? PA6"T 3)\F: ?PEEO'{=sfh.AL O!JLt:

\\\( G~AN"I x.NCr o;:: :n\£" STATE'S CoAJIJ:.NlJeNCC :ro Acco M!'\ilA=r£ A STr'\lT

"J~"WJE~? ANQ CouNT'( eMeLoYce: DEr£c:r l...!IE: K£Ysefc/ tMJ?Uflc!.Jt:O

PR£:::-eLI'\NNeO v'Ae~:xs.oAJ xs AN A&Jsr C?t= i)J:.scRE"T~o.u.me. lkrLLEVX'

Coi\J"IeNOl.:> :t\\AT ::n\( Rn ottO WA-? TtiSll fFLC:r:e--,VT To ~~,Pt?oA3 A

Cov\tt"LNlJeNCG:.T\\'A."I \\\e-lU: fA.JA? i\lo\\ii:rV(.. Sul8.c?' tt1.JC. :r"e=t: A

SuP->eot:tJA wAc, t;veQ "I ??ue-r') Mvc.t-1 LES~ Sv F!=-'S CJ:e-MT O!jcuMEN!t\I

"iON 'So SuPPuP:r ~nlf ~ A Co!VT~NV(dlC:£. Sec 5TAIC v. WA\(E1

5(e w~5t\.AeP. lf'1d. J 1f>3 e,;jtJ \\:S l • :S\\E S:o Ll o t ... >-r.Nb- Mcq:t.o!$ \=oi A Co A ITT r\J (JFMCtC WAS Fr.Lc:Yl ()'(

Qt:Ffr\J?E J..t.J 0 R.Ot€.. 'n Ace c. N\ e OATt 3\\cri E'!Re,g-r Wt-INfS'::z1

\)ccJ"o,e, \)AVEc\) PoRI. 3")\15 t\E!A--R~Nl'r "Joo.( eLACi( 0 I\) :o.\C '~'" Of.

0<:--ro~e-R, J Q<:)l@ • \\\\:C, WAS A !\kf.(C'T ~£SVL"1: of O:H\C Cq.JRi GrlANTIAJl

~( (.'c".n +r"VJ ci\JC£ To IVCe M~1lii'\"YC =rttr Paa~cCvTTa!\10 tAJr:nJE:':b

\lnc::crkve= K£YSE"J'2 aM 0cTo6U · t..C a>wa. S)ocJoR. Ol\vt:r\>Pogr WA-S

AvAJ.LAf,t £ "lo A:rrcrNO :S)$ :r-a.1:,H ~cr W1:-ri-\TA1 \\\t: "10 Q!t\<(

Ct ocr( Q r JHC se~,ov \l'tlAL T'hMC LJ,.M:tT .~£CAUC)f =rUt SlATE A,sl(f()

Eo« Ttl[ Co.VTI..Vvt-rUCC FoR l'ler£C.T I:.VL Kc-t?t-&, Doc}Oi{ 0AvtrtVPorfT wAs dli!IA) UN.'\&L( \o AltV\JO \H£ 1\Jev.J T€.I>A L C)e.-r£ o£ i)Qll£ri/\6E.l, ~J.

O?Cj1a. UL\x.mATttl(1

MR. \/ctll Eui WAS 1\Jc;,J (?u-r Lrtl A Po;,k"T:t.oi\J WREr?r

He NE,OcD To C\.\DO";z£ E. I r\.\ER.. "To PileSER.vtC r\I-s R-x&K\ "To e h"ti?T

AwfJ e::,PrEQY 312-~AL oR. \\X-S <Z"LGHT =xo M"'b£ At\J AO£ ctvAJT {)£ffNSE.

OF Ccvtl'Ji 1

tiE C\-\c?t :s-o £g£']1[t.Vf: \-\v? Os<t\ii \o \A"> AOcQv"'J{;

PAc.. [ a

S)EFstvt::>t;". tJo eEi~oA) SHwt...y') 6£" Pv=r ~N >A fo?lT~()..u Wr\<rttr" '\}leY

t$E£0 3"o CHoo?C 6o-wt::EutJ \wo Co.vSTL.,.-u\~o!I\Ul L ({:>::G-1:\T?. :::n\£

Covl.T GfoN1E'O "l\\E" Co.V:CLNVcl)VCt:L =to r\Ja,te=M6Er2 ac,) ;Jo I Q.

3\\E \-l-NAL Co.VTJ:NIIt;t'JC~ LULl\? A MO-r-IoN '\:="tLEQ 6'/ 1\\C

5yt-J£ OAJ oR. A&ouT 3\\E \)A'f' Of T<l3:AL- 5t:T o.V fJOJetV\6Efl ;;HoJ CioQ_

\\-\1.-? WA7 ""Io A~ oM !'\QAT€: 6Nc:n\E:(l STAT£ I.V:k"Jt\1£7? j tt12. Ot:wc-'f;

INt\0 LCFT "!"\:\[ STATE o E [,)A~t\ING.iON AMO lAJovLO t\JoT i'ltlvlriJ IJIJTJL

At:" re-a. Tic- HoltOAY' 5f)'\Srr-AJ /)u E Yo A PascN eA. l --s:..~CoNVEfJI.ENCE.

lJ"L\\\OliT 2vf£LC~E"NT SvffotTI{\JG- QoCvMt:r\JIS 31$ ·•tno.JC wd 5

G{lArvTeO A 5Evt-.u W<e-v< CoA):Cr AJUENCC ov~( -x»c SJ"-e=lrV 06-

~eCTI:o..V.!> OF '11\t 0£FeNSC

\\vt;,I)A!\.!0 \-\y),.'i') CAMCf"tL']}\.t_'? All £Cce:O C1 A-LN\ L!I\C.ICE:Q AtV'I t£"614L

'Oc('uN\t<:t\ftlf\T to A.) 0( PRoo (: s(J PPat2xs:.M(r Tktrs \\£A(( C,A '( STAT€Me=NT.

3\\E s-JeTE""" FA-x LeO "To PRov:dle= MeQI.~ "I Rt-c£tC? of< (\oc:Tottc, NoTe-?

\o bN K. TW't..? Au fTd•~ccLoAJ. 3J\£ 5TATC tMV"zT P~oOucC ()crvN\t1VTAIIe~ :to SvPfotl.r 11 Goo0 CAvSf"~ SEC RCvJ 5. L/4 oO'iO, A CoN\TNuet(}Ct

Gll.Af\J"It~O f:>Ey'q.v 0 3)\( see-eo 1' :t-&1 tl\ I {)e:a.J:.oQ V\1.V?\ l!:,t: ?vPPcR.ItO fi( t:rNOI-NCr':? S\\oWI.N(,.. A N!eQ FDR. A CoJJr"t.A)\JC:NCEC ");"' =n.tt= c<'OVIZ

') AOMI.t\JL?rtY'T"b-ON 0~ ~~~.,~:CCC·. se:-c ?l)tt(" \/. A0AMS(r J Ill LJtV?t\.JO 51'-f , 5j5 t /1~ I f. JD bt¥ I •

lJAlM l..JEAT~ER J:rV A«sZaNA "To -rHC fu.-ncf t:ou2 of SPaKANI;,- 1

V..JAsrttNG-loA). Me,. De:4>t:Y 'R.efu?eQ :s-o R<ZTU(N 3"C) 1'\"Ue!\}0 3\\.( x«.:r.A-L

tift($ 3\\tlU(d\ 5\\C wJ\? 5"f.,Ponu~d\. \\\£ SJ=A"J[ Svtl~ L'( LAc.Ks -r~t t:.. Cl Q \l z\-\Ow:l:N ft. 0 EVE {) Ll :t.. Gt£N0C ~ N T}h:.S M ~lrE,g, \!) '( t\)oT Aft£SI J:.Nfr

Nlc., {Jcwc-;y ANO /3ht0GJ:,t\J(r \-\£12 =so ('ouR"\ • A S)E Ee~J0At\IT1

S sr'Eeil1' 1th .. AL R-"L<r\\.'1''2 t\c\ t\Jo\ ()cPtNO oN t\c.v CcAJVC:r\JI.c!NT :s-\:\( \\'{I.IAL

Q AIC" rs :=s=o PoT ff)\>T l.\4 L I.J Ll N £4S£? • 5rr S\ Ai £' \1. TN 3--G v E z j ]1./3 CA)N.AIP. $:It;) ll{,O .P.30 $55" (6ZooC6). Vvtt1rl£Y<..Mo&C -s...l\.)

{l

3::~An:_GllEZ :n\E Covlt"!S {)CC'j:£)£0 :n\!A:\ ""'\"\\( dr.Jt\ViL\I.LA&:t-LSTy' OF fA Crt 3

1\ '6£Y (,di.J")\1~?6 :t..S A VALt.~ t'<.EASci\J FoR. J\e.LA'fr:..Vk A :n<.-~A-LJ

'fo<t 2vttfoc;,es OF II\ sPc--e:Q 'r' I12:s.:.AL 14,()Al..Y.SJS; How eve~ I f"oR. "IIdi.S

Rc:;p.soA) \0 ?C.~Vt: II\? B 1/ALI() :SVc,=n:Fl:C!A.TLoAJ foR 0£L11Y1 TJ/1£

GoveWME"rJ\ MV~I No\ 6tr RES-foiJ~!.&kE' Foe. Til£ I.JLTNe-'2'2 '2 uN

AvA~LA-6LLl.XY ANO :t.T IMV?I o~LLG£1\fiL'( r\TT6'MPT :tO LOC14-TC

'l II-\£ W:r.rNE?? otZ. Cffi.\ett\iJ"k5£ mA~f '""D!gt\1\ Av~:s:L.~~+l7LC :to Tcc,TifY.

bJ\\r.q\ :ntc Q~o7£C.v=r "t-oN CLcAJL\f \J):.t) ~)cu flo. "'l.t.JtzJe-AO "'!r\r

STA-TE ~LLoW'] "Y~J./2 LJ:L""ti1./E-?C::.., \o f:,~o .. ~ \H£ (tAlA.) AND :to MAN

"l..i'!v LII\\C :t\\£ CoullT SYsTe-M.

3\\£ {)EFEf07C AI2.Crve-0 3\\A"J "L~ '\}$" STAre-c., AI LifG£v') Cl A1:w'\ 6c -ntvt= :D\{t2.C:: >:s, "')TkLL \\Jo SvPPogx LAl<.- Evr.OeNC£ :nlAT Me,. 0£LveY CA.v r\lo=r LEAve: l'HL CoMPP..rJY of \1£R \\u&.z6AN0 Fol. A: Q'd t\ovl(

£e-~~oo I""\"\\£ <'>EFf)Vljt ARCrue-c, 3)\A-"'t Ms. \JEWE'{ sttovL.-v1 0 F ISee-ttJ FLo~.uN I.\\.J 'TO \fS\Lf-\f F-ot? T€.l:-eL e.v "!>\£OAr& Sf'eCLF-I.e=r? 6'(

11115' Su6Pa ENA .tdcrr Lvt!£"0 TH£ t.d+' "''Y"J pg_£ Fe:t? :s-o CoMC To

\'R:tAL \0 \e'23t.£'{.

3'\\£ C'o,VCUJ?""Lof$ Tc) :n.\.J:.S k\e:Ai?..I6.J(t INr\S THC Owii2T G,gANTrN(..

A SEVEN IA/t:E.,( CaN:s-J:..NUe:t\)Ct: :to =nlC :1''-' oC: --s-ANVAR.'f1 ~0 13«>

\\\~h WAc.. A Mv+N:t.FES:r ~6vst::- oF Qr.sCO«TI:DN &Y :tHL Cou,fTS.

Ar\lfl\\£"€. L/J. \)All? If? AA I tNoRMo v? E(TttN-;,:totV :1t> GJ:I/€"" "TO ·

Acc.oMAOA\£" A llr\JCooPe-t-A:I :r.vE: S:rAJE \"lJ: .. :rN<T'-2£,. fs!Ecx.,p. 11 1(1

W:t-\\\ OV"T eQ.o~e-il LC"CrAL i)c('vN\eNii'\""lJ"oAl ArJO PgoeF 3D T).{rrg,

ALL[<TAT.LoNS."X-10 STA\C \./, WocOAt..L 3d. WfV.AfP. L(ot::JJ(,4'1 P.;JQ ft I

/051 (lqt6J.) =r\:\E Co,Jers f<t,! e:=Q nl~T A Coonx;rVLIE"A!C£ Lor11G-E'(( :nidi\.)

nlc q QA'i PaToQ ?cr t=ov!-rk\ T.t\) Cr€. 3.~ Dae:s 1\lO:f Rt:avr~C D.t"i&Uc,~A L oF "Ttl( CHAlG-tC;l Wtte-1\.J =rrtc CovVrt:.ttJcJDVC£ iAJAs ~t:-J4ScNA6Lt

-:tN T\!t LUT\\=t oF "' t\JA1vtt"'L Ol.7at;.-re-r<: W\\to\ PA(<.Al tzea "'t~A.v2-

Poe.-rAJJ:o.0 'L.r\) 'Yr$ Al<.e;A '.1 tYl?- $EJ •. u-y EN)OYtAJfr- ::\}$wARM WEmHcl.

OF SvNNi Ath:ZaN4 3:.5 Ealt Fftc-.,"' A NATVfAl t?rsASIE£. Pr l3Rt€F 4 Ottlf ('oAl}"tNUe)\JCC fA/A") Gt<eNTe:Q {)'f nl~.~- Cavt::r kN- ST!A\!E Vo

t\ow£Ll 1 II~ WN.AIP. Co4'1J 71 P.30 1./5'1. ~N 5IAit Vo X"oN£"? 1 \11 PAC-E t.f

IAJN.eee. 7-f}l) 7d £.31) Ill 0 \\:\£ CovQj" CdLAI\l\trQ A 1./ aAv EXTEN?J...oN :s-o Ace oM A OAT#! I\.\£ Ae.ee-STI.dKc Off!.Ce-t!.?' 111ANPAToj{l(

\!tA"tN~i\J(J- f.JCe:RC:~z.E. I.-3 G-.JtANre=O TIAJO ON.C .OAY CoNTLNIICrVC£'?

\Juc \{? =nt( e~o?tf(:lJ\OB.. ~£1:,0\r- :t.A) ANoT~tle-.( :::s::t<.~A-L. ""I\\f:

Ccu&T dlt;,o Gf<!AN1~{) A oNe 1..../QK fXrtrJ2L.C1.V \o ACCoMMo0ATF A

~(((,flANNeO v'eCtATLoA.J. ALL oF rlkst CrrNr~.VIIfNCct? Wt-fbc r\JoT

f\,\J A6v?t oF ili:scr<.e:JJ:o.V 6ECAu5C UcV fc..u;g(' f>t2ItF fJELv4tf?. A 5EV£rV weeK C.oN\I-vtJue:!UCC \o Ace oMMOOare: e =>"t.VC.LC ?r;nL.:

Wr.:n.JCS':> 'l..c, MAN.L£-E?TLLf' VN~cA?o.VAguc ANO 6Ac,r£0 cuV vtVTc,VA.6l6

GttuJt\J0'.;) ANO lAJ A? MAOC: S:O.( \lt\Jitfi$A(?,l C lt£ASot1l?• 5EC 5T14TC \/,

wAI,{c:=J 51a WMt\ .AfP. Y1d, :tn3 e.~'() ,,-s 1 0

~'LNAlLY :D$ APPAil!AN"I ARG.uF? :X\:\A-'"'f :nrrs !">"LTuATroA) WAS . .

/\loT AN UNA\Io'I.OA6L£ oR. VNFoa.~EeJ\J CTR.<'uNV?TI4MCC3\\E ~7D\3C

\\AO KNatAlLEQG.£ o£ Ms. DWEY~5 ST=ruAXIoAJ I..JEEK? I£ t1.1oT zt1cJ,uTHS

&Fair Alove:Mf::,e-f<. QC.) 2o1;) Ill£ 01'\Y oF TY<I..f4L."l:.N STAT£ \/.

LJA\(€"1 50 iJL1c,t\ « Af'e? Lf7:J) 1153 e. ;)O 1131, :sJ\[ coug-rs FovNO

bJH&IZE '!"ll[ Pf!o?C:TvTc>~ KNGY oF ··q\£ Co.0fl.ICT l\kmorzT 02 WEEK?

fl£Foll{" :::s-e"X-AL !JAS Sc.UCOUL-6'0) AM 0 HAO MJ oPfo a.TvNlS'( TO Ml'\1(6

At.. TE(N ATL v£ A£a.A!$G-£MCNT4J WA? t\JoT A-N UN AliO'L0A6/.,£ o tZ

V..V Fot(se--e-,1) CLl.CvM?TAr\JCf f,r'rP.vO T~l~ Co.vTR.oL of nlC 5TIATE".

3"\\"l-'2 X"'i f\ CLe:P.&. vV\A!\Jr.£ct;I A&ost" ";: OrsctcTroAJ 6 Y TJir

Pczo~:zcc~nxa"J ANO If\£ Tf<-J:J+L Cat1IT. \="AtLv.1C" =s-o SMx.C:T LY CvMft'(

W I-nl niC ?fEe-O'f =s:is:A-L i<vLc a. E;Gvrfu·:, 0l:S&"'i:4~A L 1 R.£GAi.Q LCSS

oF ~/Hcrttca =n\£ 0EFEtJOANT CAtV 51\o<A.l fu£-:s-L-brcc:=.Crl 3.3(aw1) SEE S\P.\€ V. Q~sct\$~,J.;>vf !.A)N.t\ft< /03>j tOO £;30 33'1.

GAk.bA\+N CovtVTYJ Md NTANA;.I~l I\\~T X"-H=o.tVV\AT:t-oAJ :l.T

J::.S 5-yA:r£0 (\"\o"IAI... PoT£ffi".!-AL :t.rJ\J>I<.):,SCNtvlfr\JT oF 310 rrAft, AT \\\E S}"A\c eai--5ot$ Followc-0 ()y 13 1/.Q YEA'IlS It\J 31\t

) . CouNTY :;sAl\-~ 5£t-An~c.\\dJ A£ee=r\JQIX A-Ct>PYo£ ,-}!txNfO-

Q.MAY"l:c!\.)1 PAC.E 43o 9-. UMOER MoNIANA L..t\u [Ac.\-\ v\NO EVEY<Y CIZ3=-ME c,r,MMI.\1l'O

Mu~-r RvN C:o.vStQV\I.\1£ w-x,.-n\ ON( 61\NO\\\E'A.,.(}NLES? sOe-cr tJ..C.

C\3:-i?..C'VM?J:ANCC'::l eoM£" l.VIO PLr\Y.3)\E!\) UNOER. MrA t(b-1~

t.{o I · 1\\£ 5Et\JTe-r0Cx:NCr """.SvO(;C CAAJ r2ut( O·n\er'l WI.St. SEt -AnMCHfl)

Affc~O=s:..x B- MoNT~.Vv\ STA\\JTC Ar\) a CoMM ~ ~bTOf\.) ;\)!')Te=? ..

Wth .. c.t\ cJAS :n.\r c~4.Curo?TANCf 1.V MlL V&"ILlfUx'? r0mo;J-02oo3

Co ")V 1: Q x.o 1.) • T\\E C' 0!1 fl:r frl.i) tJ o"I IM Po s£ c 0 1\.) t, t:O \) 1 :I v tL SEAJIEI\JCES ns MA-A20Aie0 ()<t rYJCIA Yb-ltn-401 ('l).j4s P2GIILOu~L'1" tJoT60 \\\£ CoMMI ?6IOtU CoMMft\JTC:J NaTt- T\\f..l Su{2,StC.TI.nr1J[Y)

hlA2 'l NCL\JQ£0 IN t4N A=rie-M~T \o Av01:Q Ccu\l4f"Qv:t.tvt S£;t;T

EtJC£S £Jt\t.;t([ ONLi A SING-I C CR.~M"i-tdAt EPrsod£ LJA? £ovNL).

\\\E :ryq_e-.L ~o-.ntr Q.uL€0 ""!\\A'"'S :rn£C,E" c.G.>.ME"C, WEfl.£ AI\/ A cr 0 f A

ST.-AJGL£ CvtiM'LNP.L Ellt00tJ£ AAJO 5o SENTe-NCtO A~ ON£', \\\1.6 I~

5t\owt0 6i{ TBE" SWTfiVCT.NC.. cif £A.O\ CyA{lbf Co.vcu.tll.t!";,.([ Ldi-1\:\ e>NG""

ANoxl-\flt. M.t<. ll£tLI..£V X. LVAs Nor 5EtJTENCEQ To }]t 3d3 4 Ye6fZ~ Tt\AI C:ouqJ o( 6E~rV X.MPo~cO :t..£ "J"\\iS LJM No\ f:ov!V(} To ()!" 14

SING-LE Cfi-M-s:NA L £P:r:?ot?c, 1=\r LJA? SeNIEf.JCt:D To Po Ycl\-12~ W'L'tl-\ /;J Yt"l~as SvShN0EO ANO Io StAve 0' lfeA~S Ar THE f}1o,vT14tll'A

SIAl( ea"Lsot\) '"$) 6c f2..A(t,) CoNCvlZR~rd"I fAJ"LU\ EAC.ti . OTHii(.

i\ ") .11A SHcwLO G-Y1Mn ANO HoNo.Q.. £uLL £A:t:n\ P,l\10 caEOI.-r 30 31\f" ULONTI41VA

5e::tVTEr$CJ;t\JG- Cou..2T.-f\\E U.S.C A. Ccr\J~T. JC\~1".-uz= Su6-'2£C.rJ:..ol\j (\)

5TATE"S '' ~vLL tAk-·n\ &NO Ci2Er?I-T 5 HAkL /)E G:t.lle-tV IN Eil\ C.t.\ SIAl£

1 o T\\E 9uR>LL-C. Ac:=rc, r'Z£co.Q.Os. ANO 3uO}:.C'I:.IAk fRoce-('0"LNtr? o £- EVt£i I fAG-E" Co

\l Q"IHE.A. $TP.IE". CoN(;-ftE"C.LJ EAJAC:rfQ J:MPLiit\1\iiN"tJ.N{,. l EG.!.SU\T1:,(;1\J f-ol 11\t

CLAut,c= 3:-N \1-90 AruO 1-l~s AMEf\lQE() lt\V\I LCG:tSU~,u.u oNL'{ ONCt1 TN ((

lqL(cd.~)t\"t.c\\ SHows 3\r:,:s \\nw tvrVOAMf"NI !I)L l""Hyyr CLI'\v"zf 1:6. fvLL

t~ALit! ANO C rlt=-a.r.=r QleuS( it£ Q v ;t.~e-s 3\:\IA--s (AJA~rttAJG-xo..V Counc;, Rt

CoGN:t:Zii "'tl-\e VAt..t0I:IY Or A S-.cf,-r£ft SJ"AifC, CR:LM):.NAL CoN

VLC..\~oN5 : 1 SEt- STA-3 f V. 6u 7\-\

1 I OJ W..V A£P. 3'1-ci J q P. 30 d \OJ • I. N

AiJA.R. V. SmLTH, ~3'l f.3Q 1'1(,, 153 (C. A. 5 (L.A.) dol\),\\-\[ SuPJ2e-)i1f'

CovR"I 0oo.v «.t:SC::C.Te-0 Tt$ A<?.C .. V;N\IfN1 31111\""i fvLL fAJ:.TH 1'\AJO C Ue-OLT

Of'1L:r_(,.JAT:.t:ot$<) tt\.JIAI.L£0 A Wlt=(le £VI.fl£!\)TI,AR,I.{ ({EOV~t'rl\tllJT1 'AN!? 1:N)T!.40

HELO \}h\T STAJif? Couh-'2 fAJovL.x? f>r (')P..,Lr.C.£0 TO. AFEottO A "7I.'2Tc-r( -5.-TJ4iC

TvOG-rnENT ir\C SAMt Res- "'IvO~CAT A EfFECT W1\J:ct! 3J:\E" A.SSVETNG:

Cou.Q:r r..JDuLQ G+-vf"3:,:y.,-W\tLL7 V. \Jvf?..YE£1

/I U.?.(1C.{f'\.vctf) 4'61;'-/S~ 3 L.ro. ~II (1'6'13) (~\ot1YJ--s-.);-r\IJ\M-J?ToN \/. tylc-coNNEl L

1 Jfo U.5.

(3 WHfA-\ .) ~34, d-35", ?{ L.£1). 31"6 (tt61~) {MA«'>l-\flL; C.-:J.). SINCC:

\}\r;,VJ AOt\CR.:tN& :to \\-$ OIZ.J:G.t:.f\}A L ev ~eo 2& 0£ :n\[ C:Ltt\uCz£) '\\[

C N-Ovll:.T \-\'th -:t.-N TtRJI£LATC0 :nil( .tF Qu""C-.:2 Mf)VT oF tuLL F1AI1H A NO ,,

C~f':0LT QI.UEO ::ro )l>Q(rM(N"I'? l..n:--n\ Tr\1( eth!\JeT.PL[S ()f )2e?-

:Sv Ox..CA"S"A. b3q F.30 AT 15L.f (Quo\E?) (No r£0e(Zr\! QucC,TLir'V

A\\'ibc'z u.v1 :i:.L A '2TrArC Coue::r tA:rLC, \O c ... ·ut(( fuLl kiAL-·uJ 11.vt'

Ci2EQ;r:r :s-a yx\[ l1Au.J ot= A 7J:s-re:a ?\AT£.) 3\\£ l,Ajtl;.HrA.Jfr.ToA) £1 _ II

'I"«.>-\1\1. CCJJ tt'r St\ovLO Hvwc C..- eve \:uL L FAL'"!H 14Aia CrltO cr "to THC

\h~- "Su O'I.C\1\'\ A of It\( Ma,uTArla\ Y«s r\1 Cc)\/rtr's Tv 0G-yVlfr\JT1 VAAl 0 • I\ H.ov'JO<lfO 3)\E S£1$\e-rJc~.v& o.:: ·nt£ CHAOr..-cS A~ A 5k-Ml:Lir C t?-t-MI Nr1 L

ll .AI1 \} \ Eei5o0£ ANO r\lo\ EN\\'AtdCfi:Q ma.rrueux s OtffttJ06£ 5Co£t.

A iiAL'krJ '£o&EI(;r\J .JutJ(d'V\£t\J1' 1'1\AY 6£ Cf!LLA-TE"ft41 L '( ATTACV:EO

ONLY I£ 3J$ Cou,fi LAO<EO ""SuR.k50:tCTiot\J or1 CaM?TATV\IoA.JAL V;r.o

Lt41I:o.V? Ue-a.e= "¥-t\.l\/OL.V£(1: ABStiV\ 3}\~?f: G!louA)V?; A IJA?tiiAIG-TotV I' $

Co\) A.:T w\ u s 1 G4. v£ f v k l fA 3= 1 t\ A Alil ()fr;tJ,!..T ""o \\-\,;- Fe t2e LG r0 3u0GMErt21 fW0 ,1_(<r,.tU) \~C' "LSSUEI) "1"\\tr<.E6Y A~--s\J0(]f0 TO (j~ eac\lv0f0 J::rv A h_)ASt\:LfJ&\oAJ B2oc(Et2r.N& .. SEE- SIATE V. ~E g,(~.'( 1 P-il (.t li\l.JO

)JI 1 5 P.3D 05fi, \\\r tl']a,\JIANA ~vQ{,..MeNf fVvQ 5GrJIENC( t\f\S fACr E If

RAT.c,£0 i\lf I TYe:-R. A A\IQ k-SOI:cT -roNAL 'l-~~v E oR.. e Ca N~Tl.I v!.to,QAL ((

v~oL..A"\kQ!\} AND ?o SHovL£} HA-\1£ l?>c:-~,0 GJ;IIE~l Fvl.k EAIJH ArVv1 ,, Ce £0!:..y , ""\\\E :SvOb-Mfl\f\ il,.~NO liR.~O \/Au{) 6Y A CcJv&T of Or\l £ ?UJit;" X£ VAL:r.()J ~7 tNTI.TLt:=O :ro 'RE"CoC,Ab:xi:c .V 1:-t\J Covths of Jl\t\JoTHn{

.S3er \ f" ()lf Vr(tTIJC o E "YH£ £v LL \=AJ:Tt\ v\NO C'REIJ:r.\ 0LtAuSt. USC.~ Cc.v:->T. A{}._\, JST B \ •

Ci\J l I( STATE? TO #.£CO (...r\) I-:2 fi' !t\r\JD Er\J £o a CG' nlt: :s--ut¥TM £NT? 0 F

1J\t CollRTc., OE orH.eR. 5IATE"C,J Aru 0 31:\u:.. G-r Vt "!"\:\()?£" AiuX!MtNI? '"YHt

5AMc PR£Clv ?:t 1/C Fo2C£ Tt\€ Y IAJclutO £N'SO't "I.N 1)\t: Oh-<irN AY:l:Ntt

STAT/;=1"1}\E vi61ll E T\.\A"\ :3;.M~L(MEI\JTS 3")\E full fAI-T}=\ ANO

CQr<ln LLA-vS<..-- CotE:? FuQ.\V\e-fi Ttl A-N \}iE: Co"> :i\~' v '\I.ON AL CL..wsc~NO Re; GttL€.£? tdldAL r\S t.JtJ.L v\5 $TATE: C.a.tlT!? :to GIVe STATC

Couf2:y :SvOG-Mtr\JT? =nl£" 5AMt facCLV?'LVC EFFECT ""1}\.M \\\£"' ?TrAit

Cou£T? :Y>1A-T ~';?SvtCO -:tt\E :Su06-MfNI'2 lA 1ouLt1 {';:t.v£ 3\\£M. SEE

\J£Gvc:LLE v. CAMALLI J ttatJ f.:so 'ls3, (c.A.1 Cwr-5.)ao13), ~ 1A?tiTNG1oN ~ftvtrE: \\'AS <LE'sPFc:Te-Q VVloNTMA :Y12l:.A L CotJaT?

~VOG.MfiD ANO (o..V\/LC3J:OtV A-S £Atl Ac, Bt:J:.N(..- A-(2,1 £To Ctl.Ag(rC MRo \/ULktVX: IAJIJJ-\ bi-~ST .Oeu-tZ.e;-e- llNk!AW}:uL €os'7E4S>To)() of- e tltUA,ZM.

\\-\~ s-s-~-xF AcKaJowLt.:cte-:s -\}\.'A\ MtL v'c-TLLI:::v,X IAJAA 0Zev:rovsL '( Co,VVLc,-e-0 o~ lA 8ur2G-LA(!'f" A..N =n\C ':>Tit\YE" Oy tY!OA)TANt4-.""\}\l:,-

3"tb.:AL Co"LJ' \-\AO A)o 'Lf>Su£s T\\£et: fm-c IS IAJR.o,VG- 1 MrSLEJA'()ING-1 AtJf) 3-NCoA.lSI.STA!\JT ~N :n\E Fec:r :D\~e.\ "J:J" Q"I:-i) r\)ci G"LV(cr fvLL

FA:t.ll\ AND CtlfQ~I 11 :t-o 311( WlO,U!IANIA \{(.k-Ak Co\Jt2=tS ~uLr.AJG- oA..l Ttl[ 0 {! ,,

Lh:.M( SPA.rr ')ETNCr A S T.NG L~ C£-c.Ml-1\.)A 1 £fJL?ot2c-..

N\oAJT!l\NA Sci\J'Te-Nce;c, MUST QuN Co.v~tfQv3"LV£'L'( Uv1.}L£S? :nl(

Courl.T o~flEil..'? OY\\t:R.,I,.,lk-S£, 1\r\JQ AS CaNCuJtY!CNY SE/\JII{r\)CfS ocevR >-N AN ~-x1Eol\eT To A\/a~o CaAlSc=O vxx,vc- SC:ll.n£tVC£C, WHe-Q f OdJLi

1\ ~

A 51:-r\IGLf Cf!:"5cM"i:NPrL f.f~soOe- kVA? ~NIIo\...V£0, ~' SHows "31\v\T

~"~r en

([

1\\£ MMJH\t\JA Covlt=r Meac e ~'I:NQb-NG- Xlitl-T TIAI-5 WM A ?k'AJ<;LC Cl(-s;.tf1-,, '1-NAL Eh?o0£. SvLH A £IN0J:Aif.- 1:.'? £""0.v1:VAL,e-NT =to tJo"h-ti:dJG-'\uN~ ~ ,, SAMC c.e:s:MXNAL Co,vi>v cr AN.O Tkfu~ C,ltovkO HAiG CouNT tO M ON~

Po.t:NJ" ON 1:\:\t Oe-Fe;NOANT~ ?TANOrtaO .C,llUTf.OC"LNC- r1.A-t\lC£,

'I}\( ()uROtt\J !AlA? aN Tt(C SThtT£ ro QcZovr (7t::'(oA)0 A ,e047oNA-6Lt

(h.;C:>T .J:yAX THE: alJLT"-'(r ""S:,r\J Ttl£ MaNTA1\.l;\ CouR.T, oc OQ~C)450f) Wi'l'2 rJor ~ ,,

A S):.NC.lC Cvh M>-NAl E{Ji-soOf. :\\\f~ "FA-yLr-0 To £euvwC ;1M I( CouRr

OoCJuV\E.tvTe-.:u:oN 'TD P2we: =rl1E CoJJ'ttA-RY. SE-c-(<.cwA -5".44. Otf0.5et t3Lso-\j;&!A. "YT:ILfd.SL3vOrCxA<t'i ANO :::SvOl:C't-AL r0t2oa-Dl1RE ?&ttrY. Pelut(OV~E CHAfTt;{l. \\5. {.111-*rVCf:-j QoCvlV\ECoVTA G"f Su65ctTJ::or1) \'137£.

S1)"''fC ANO Tt"itlT.'lo a'( 7TA1VTCS AN a :)"u o-r:c "' ( Pltoce:£0'k61G--7: fuLL hu-TH t\

AfvO C.ZfOI."C 511\TCC, 'r).\E ltECof.t2s A.N o ""3"vQ'LCJ:!Itl. Ptl occeO~NkS f!l C: tiN'('

SuLH "'YIJAr£1 Te1l.€xroA.Y utt Po??C5~Iqr1l,ot2 e-oet:,e-S TH.e.teoF, ?HJA:LL P,£

Q~o ve-Q o !Z A0MI.3It0 -r;_ IJ c··nte tt CCJu tt-x-c, lJUhJ 11 i.V "TWC'- \ 1' S. A rvtJ =tT7

Te:,U.LIOrh:e-s Arvt2 Po<zs;;:-4SJ:-aw? 6Y Tld€ AIT<r4Tl4"LJ;.trN oF Tile CU!Iltl. MfJ

5t"ttl oF TH{(' COutZ:r I'\NNt:-;x'e0 1'L£ Y'l '?e'WL £XL"'?TS/\oG.n H~tt urt:uj A Ctftr

'!:.F~Ctt\I.S:aFA ;"Sv(JG.£ <:l[Tiif:' CouR-y 'YWA-1: 1)1C?fl.n2 Atl(;[?Tt'r.to-A.J 'J:S:t.V

faoeert S:OttM. Sunl f\C.\5 j ae-LotW~ ANO '3"n03:CA-L PRcCQ'Ol-N'S o(( Cpfi£S

TIIt"Jlto G: 1 So Av1tlfr\.JTx:CATt!"Q 11 SHALL }.b\Vt= TWC ?lAM£ flJL l FArq/ ANO

Clltor,- >d\J tully- Cou/l:r Wl:.TtlrtV TfdtC U.S. A.vtl "l:T6 T!ttlfLTcd re·?

MJO eaY?e-'hi..C!i\!ll? 1'\S '!"}fey }=\-AVe td Lt1w ol1. u;z!Akc 't:.t\J 1WC coull.TS af

f>uoj 7TAH~ 1 T<:!ZK'\:.Toei.t'S o.e Pat;sCSS!oAJS Fdaro u/tll-Oi :ole'-( P,ll.t

~f\7f0 0(\) IH£ O.JA-12Cr.~yj,. >N i=oltMATt/lr\ I ANO nit:= ';?C:JIJIENC..:t-Nk tlATf!,

6t:uJ(,. ON 31/C '?ArvlC OA'( !ArVO "lldl'\-1: roll. Ve:nLE"!JX'? 6>oo3 rvl,tVT~t1JA

5t.VTiilllCC I-? t2.vr.)AJI:-M( ... u.vcvlt<t("!\ttl '('. ?EC-AT(tAUieO Affa11?r.i C

(AJA5r\I.AlC.Io,v't, \vOG-MtNT Af\10 7£!1JrzrNCt"; ft1CC? 3-t-i.S££"-fVfcNOJ:.X \:)-t>tfei\JOA~uT's Ci'?.J..M~!Vttl \"\):C,Ia,1Y .. ?C£ At.'20-Arreuwo t\P?wo:r.x li-t-r...vO~tJCr

or F"'nc,1

PAC.( 3 f?t.""\ToM.N)e. V£rLU;ut AaGves 3i1AI Tile LJlM;H£tV6.'ruN i\

Tt~,:trn Ccvl\ CoMM:t."Ctf50 e;,etttJa.. r,JHl:fN L.T (h.O NoT GrvC Fuu £&:Lrtl 1 I , 1

ANO CtltOi.T \0 -u{[' {VloN\!A,-NI'\ -""S'ilOttW\t::N:( ANO eoLL(l!C-o M~. vrrUcu/ f'l'\G- F q

6fLT.EVfS t\i-? OfEekJOffi '?Cor<.£ SHouLr1 6c Tf\€-E"~ Wk-'IH A- 5TttNOM.O 5EtVT€tJ':T.NG: {{ftrvGC o b= 3 1- Y \ V\1\o.,JIH!zp

I SSuf Co 3&A.t'<d!'\ V£ru £0 X \\'A'D \\1.'2 Mcn~oN ~y\) LIMI.tU£ t\€At'?.:t~C

OJ\J Yet,vvAltY =11 Cio L'>. &3 1}\I-? \-\E&Bs.NC= n~;ac weo MuLt.tr?LC J:S~uE'7

A(lW€0. I\!( T?SU( TJ.\!1\\ J?~~se-;, ,v\0 \/[Ht t:UX '':> t\tG-!lMHJT t\tf<£' I? :X"C

fX'ClvSTotV Ot WLINfS';?et!', Mor~oi\J GrtANTE/1 ()Y THE: Caul\ oJO 6CHI1tF

Of IHf ~e~c.VSE.5EC-AT1JAcHell ttfPe=J\JO.r.K £ -3J?:tr\L tft~t-N::ci.r.Pr,;f/orrcA.J ~N LtM):.NE1 ~AGr? 7-3-7-L/."""\\\( C.ovRI AOvr:c,e:O 6o:rrt ?TrtrC V+NO Oct6VS( \c AOv~.c,c;= ALL WLT.Vf92£S \\:\~\ Ud CovLi) tOO\ 5I.I IN \l.tf""

Cov ltrtt() o VV\ tOo It TA q< Mo uT 11\e-:r{.( 'lC2T:i:M a tV Y UNIT k r\ FTErt 'l~ c '(

b\ A-0 "TESJ" r: £\:eO D

AI IUt' tZfGVe?\ o 0 1'\ PActrY ""YH( Cou,ZT M!'\1 oa.(k-(J... W.Fs-N~c,c:, ~7 cxCLul2fi0 5o \}\k'\--r 3"\\t:-'i CAIJ 1\Jo=r \\t:.ert'Z ·n\f' xe:?\:t..Moi\JI( of o-rHef?. wrrNcst-,51 A.vP I.T MA"( M~~t: =ru£' cM.Oc-a o,: :s::y"? ouJ.O f'YloTioN. "I~Ib -Rvt.t

.Ooc~ No\ AvTJ\oft.:s:..zc Etc\...v?\:oN o (- (1) A Pt=:asc,A.J w~o .r.? e Nr\II)J1r\L

PE(l?or\J, oil.. (9)AN OFFlfEtl of. crv\'PLo'fefi' of- A fA.1T'{ Wk\>:CH l:.S rtJoT A

r\}AilUtA {>E:I<.&.yJN 'f)E$:tCNATEQ A~ J:.\5 ftcP~cse:l'\.JTkTLV/L I)'( J:T? AnOdN{~

cA.. (.3) A ~t:;,2C,o,V tv!-loc,C ~R.f?1£AJC:~ ~~ StiOI!.Jt\ J 6Y A PAa:J'f :to DC R~:t\?o.t)

A6LV A.Jc::cESlJAA.Y "o \\:$ t>d~s~rVTAYl:oN o£ 1'\le- PA4.Il-tt'? CLt+us€. EVrO. RvL[ 015". £')(CLV~IovV oF tv.tJ:NB~e?.T\U.3 Q!Jl( oF EVI0l'NC:~ t.dA? WAc.rm

To Kce't' CoLlvS"'Lvt resrtMoNi A6snvr FteuM lA Clawn-r.A)AL Mocro?~N'=.

$£r£c,T:rv;; KVlT Kttfseg k\ltlS -n\C 5TAIES £XeMh w~TI\JE?S To St!E

f>..vLt. \\( W~'? 1"\1 LowtO =r-o f,I:r I:rU OUt'hNk :CilJ:r\L "\O CoAJFfK1 wrxl-\ . t\ ·ntc Pf(oC,fflrTx..o..(J. WHtrV J)\£" £'(eLu;:ror1h<\-vl 'i tuL!' >-2 J:.fi\JVCKt0

1 '"I..T rs

CtbTQW\ Ai.l.f To £X€MPT o,vt WLTzVt:t,S "SC> CoN fe'ft W;t.'!tl 31\t flot:,e=C.uiDtZ ll n

Ov~u;{,. 3\\E: ~I.A;L. 6££- SJI'\TE" \/. I!J~t\ve:<S 1 6o WAJ.;:J() 'V7J371 r.eX>D JOO{,

(19't}).~ Er( ALSC- SII\T[ \f. Wk'~J:.£L~ J ld'l LJA?tl. rSYJddY ~ 5S"ty. DJe. ll£r.LL€"\J X \\;'\'? tOO AAGVMEWI To "Xk\L~ RvL.C, buT :s-o I\![' CnNPvLT A.uO tun: ee~ce-sc, \/.tollt\r x:o.us {1,'( T\:\( ?rAil:- ANO '1g,~AL C.oda-r "}}2 t.)fift:[

f'<AI:SE:? r\t.7 '1:'2SUC? t\£(E.

~£TECTl.Vf ~£YS£f< WA~ t'A.trc,EMI Oul"'bNk =n\f MoA:aN IIAI t.;r:rru:rVE

HEI\tx:Nlr ArVO ?o \\EAfO IHC Sfl£C:r.rr.C o~oras oF Ttl& 'luO&C f'AY>..vb- NC

rYI.tNQJ t)£TECT~Vt vZ!'1'$ER, IJ.I€N\ tsfrl'\fAI'ii 3J\ot.,t- ?fee.--s;. t=xC ~li LI&L-7

PA.r.t "

hlV£!\J 6'1 THE: Tfh::AL Cav&T -s-v Or .. t: r'WO CoLLvO!O w:r.-x\\ AT LI£A7T Two

6THCr't '?TAT£" WLTNES?E:'-2 orV MvLrLft.t( OCCA.'"t?J:of\.1~.--n\t $£dUESTgr\I.IO,{)

<MOcrt O:cuJOI.AJlt WI:qJe-':hfS ):toM TI\£' Cov4:CrR.l)cM l=? ;,o :n.\£V CauLO No1 H£Ai AND CaN Fo,{M 3\\lZtd "ICS\i- MON'( \0 -nl.v\T Of- on!t:~ WLINt:::s?£?,

5££:-FEO. a.. £Vi.-.O. l415ltJA. l..r.vw. ~15. \~Jb EvrO~NIIAOy r\NO Ptoc£Qo~AL I

Ptie:c 11\UTLo-iJ >6 0Eh!..GNE'O :to Cut.6 (c Llv2I.O A.) 6Y WI.YIIJC¥:>£5 ()vi doe-S

i\J6:r A00R.E:72 ""X}JG" ?£f(iAIC P€b6t e-M Ot W~sNC'Z?£!2 r..oto CooRO!:NAT£ JUf.r~

5\ol:t.e:':l f)EfoQ,e; \E~3:\-£ r'l:,o(,. .. Sf£-{). 5. v. f>Q\lOcl1 53t} E.30 Lflfl;

Yt££ (C.r....1 (lNO.} ;;loe>'o~.""'\\\S-S t\JA::z n. Cu::Ait VPJLArroA) of

EVr.OcNCE t2.vLC Gt4" 6(' 1)Jt STAit:.lJAAt\rM&\t>fJ e~(\C,\ICif '0\t\leS 11

{1} \t\Lf\\ ND [AILTi\JCSS "LC, ftlM~\fdl ""ir\J rye Coutf'Clvo-t(\ IA)\hu: 5t'll:.AL Is

TN egocr2~? EtcePr t..JHe,V IHA-=t WT.TNcSS 1:'"> T¢5=rit:Ur!l' J(¢;1) THAT

AFTt:l<. ;\ W.i:,Nf¥2 MA? TE5zl+f-re-0 H £' Mi6t '1 t11o! yJV?cuss \\LS :Yc5T1:MorV'z"

WDH AN'i OJHtQ WI..11\J£4S iJNiiL ALL WI-\NGSEC, 1\>Av'ck4TtErG0 1 ANO

(3)3\\Vts CovvS£L WlAI{ !Uar OIGcuss ::rHt CM,tr' v-r:r:.nf orVC t.Jt:=stVES~ "61J =n\[' eg~SOOC£ Or fl\ StiaNO lNLTNif"4~ olAlJ4. €tf2ttc. s~rtrlfS lluL.I3) 5v67C"L\U)r\.2 L./30-tJ 1 fAC.f 013L/ • '"1\\f: 5\ffif' CoN"'\"l.r\JUEQ h uNOEP.,fU.A)t:'

THE" Coufl PttocE$S 6'1 14tLoWL\Jfr QET£C.TI:!I£. U£i.Stif TO OJLLuOc: Wr.rt/

On\{t c.~..U .. TrVe=S<Jtf? 6cEo/l£;- AN 'f eN<L oF :ute-M :rc-sTx,FLe-o.

tYJAt\J c( £A~ I l( f,JA5HtNG-roN CM£7 fovN0 tJo ER.~t"f ~A) f~tmr:Trr.N6-

1J!( Ot-soh t:tl1e11.rr tdi.1NEt,? To Tt:STI-ri" 5o La NCr M =oJC ~r( CAu .. rtt)6::

THC cdili\JEhc., t\A-v1 Nt>l YA1tt!:C1 (lAurO -r:-.o JJ-!( \h1Jt..AT>:ot1.J. C,w STAT[

V. fAI.~ fA)( J L/J Wfht/.d{J 11'1 4 d-tifi €.J0 l~hJ (114'3)- _5TP~It V. ILON\A)():) 'dO W>45tl. GJ9J 154 e. 7573 (tqos=)- ?lst\T[" v'. ColOTLS]

15 I kJn5tL 'i£1 ) ~'1C, e. 5S51 (l'ldCf), Ma. \}Et. LL F ux AIZ(xucs TlJL41 THC'

5IATC: C,.!AS PALI;\:,Cct.7ATI:Mh- X-N S"H!b Ouc ecZoC(5S Vl--Ol 14-T.z:ot<J. 1:11AI

0£TE:cTLVt KeYS<ffZ t.MS THC SIAT£5 E'{t:MPT c.JrsNC4~ r'\dJ¥2 '~·1!41 t\17

biA-S ~N r-Ac.:f ColllliJIN(~ W}'.:n\ oxldect ST14IC !'A)I.TrUe-s?~S (Jgs..o{ ~ AIV y TE7\::t.vV1Dtll '( GI.v£rV fd AltJ Y 4 /.I-TrV£?? ."I\\LS J:.C, 6AC KEO 6Y TliC T&-SnMW'f

QF tt1R. SH1..Vt:SJ ctV C..g_oC;>fJ PXANHNA-y" rn1 11 WtiiU/1. WAS t\L5o A- SrArF

[AJLIAJ E9). 5EC- Aiv!\utt·o '1\flooOri G-- }e:x:.AL TrtM15Clrlr- MR. ?HJN(s oN C~ofb f7AGt 1J

£'f.AIV'~NAS"LOVJ fACC \1"61 o 1'}\€" Pae?(C.uTot. {)st1 NoT CommfrV"f otV A.)Og,

?ToP -u\E~f" 0J:vc6Et,Mt A,C-\~N£2 ()'( t\i.S EXEMfi W~'Uif% .Q£I£CHVh )

\{EY1EfZ .31\Ib I:-? A. Q:=t'le=c.:l V>.c LftTI.cJ..U Or n\~ Trt~A L CouttT$ ~vL t!\Jf

1'\!lJO -ro g\1)~. Vt:IU .. eUXS ILf Cc~~V7\. AM!NrJrne-rtrf o~ t?uC ~~aC($S o

W1uliiPL£ 1>'i'2uC7 Ou~i61Cr Tth:AL.Qt\J£ a£ 'JJ\fSE ~'??<Je-7 f,eov6-H\ 6tTo(le

\~t :rRs\1\ L Cr;vt:r WA? :yrle= CoLLVS 1:.orV 6tTt...Jtnti\J s-ti<\Jt IJ..J:r.1t1Je:SscS .'IN

see.c:r..flC "S:"T WA? OEie:C;U..v'C KcYSE&..,MP. ?tlrNe'"li A=N(/ Qf'ft.rr'{ Pert:d.sorU.

Oag-<;n:.v£ KEvseR. rt=.~A:;, ovet<. 1-\.tA-tO 5A't'rAJG- 11 J)lC: oNC WI.It{ A ?H~v&O Ht:A~J \)!( s\-\ofnra Ot\J~ \i1~-r :I:? rl1Q. \jenL[V,X' !J 5E£"- AnA<:t{e-0 effw'Ol.'( H -Yf1:f1L T~A-t\.)S~W-r-Mo\Io-r\} fal M~S"'\'€I;At..lfAGC? 3'6£-3~". nmvttu, I~[ !)[fE,\JS( Pv3 J:N A w~~TI£A) ritlc~Qt\) foLLawe:'D ()l( oR.t+l ARCUNlHLT

fJ~FofZ.E \}lf 'SuOfr~""Y\\f \R1-=AL Cov~ f~S.l EO 3D Y\'\t-.'it[ M'f ~vLl:Nfr,'"D\)

FdcTJ=n\~ Tvh:AL Cou/lT 'f.Jf:Vt£e. f:v£!\.1 ALKNowu~ouo TJJC 1:5-;,vr flrr ALL,

au![ Gl5"' SPc-<J,£IeS !\10 PAlT"i:-Cvl!Aa. ?ANC\LevS ro.e. A \h: .. QuAn:oN

OF -ulf: £XCLv~-c.an l A<tY oi.Qdt ol< T>iC CcvOT'S A()MoNI:5HM£NT NoT ro o~scur,? THE: CA-7£ W:UH 01J{f]( {VITlVCSSCS ,'"t}l;i{ff SACT:X:0!\/52 Ail.C GeNtMW(

~e:CoC.t\ts:.:z eLJ- CoNTe;MPTJ CaroM fNT 6 'f nJc Coutl.T =ro 'Die :Solt0€51

AN!}

llEFu7eL To PetlM:t.T TI:IC Off£!\JOJ:MG- r..n:.:-rru£'c,C, "'"!o TffilF'('. t'\11.-ST'JtJ:IA-L?

t\~v't" OCCt\?'iOAJAI.t.. i I!>Cc!J GftAN'\trQ ~or< \lrokvtrr_o!{)S Q£" fluLE '-'lq •.

SEt -INA. ~r2ACI. 1 [VIfJffJCC (6co.,( 51) )

1 ?tGTL£Yn) G l5.6.lJI!e.flt= TL/C \tlrtl L

Cr~t!fZ"i \-\AO GrZAAn(Q QrF€kJOA,..n's V'llo·n:R"'> 'TQ £"XCLV061- N~.vf1'tftr'1 r.Jp .....

llJG':?E:? File"" xde-- cuJ &Igor~ tV\ 1 '1)1{" TrtLA=J Ct>.;ftr 02oeea L ~ Sl(uo< -s-wt;

TtS1TMoM'f Of A r'JfFe-IVSt: W:i:.Tr\Jcss Afrea. THC IAl:t."lNtf?S A0Mk-5tt0 o.U

Cllo'7? t:XAN\XNArrcAJ \Hifr'! t\f \:\,M K~O / uAJCt-j W:LTH Tilt fk£WQif;TS

f~u.:r.Ot'MI AI\JO 0tFtt\J5r CCJqtt!C,eL \0 r2r:c,Co?6 :s::Yt: ce-S!" (Juter:Nlr I~>-t4Lo Set-SErtlllf f%6(:, EUv1PmCN\ co. V. 0ovTrln'\sl £Q.vr.PMt:tlJT Co,JT1JC.J

ti511 'f.rif) 3'-/Q (5rltf Cr.#,. lCft01:).C-r-x-1:AiC ESL ~f£1 THf 3)b.At CovA.:r

fXf?AtNt:'O Tvi~r 6K'vz"'- A.vO 7h-ruct:ra.·s CoNve-R.?Art:aAl Ui\1tlel'!m:rNeO -r~c

TIZl:~ l. Covas's !2-£V\'=>qNS Fo.i fXCLutlttV~ t?PEtliCtdl. y,(q.M. SkiC c.ovrtn'Zoot\'1

Ovh.N{t SKuZIIfS T€"7}J:N\OAJY. Td( TfiA-l C'opt"t eac't\!:6 :C.Tl£0 ?iv::zd-rAC.[ 13

fRoM CALI-"LN(,. sPcNC~r<. A? A (AI1:Tt\!fSS >-N \-\J=-C, 06 FEM5£· 5EC 5TATt

v. SiuZA" l5b LUU.l\Pe '()~~ J 1>4&; a?c; e. 30 f5 c.JJ .. \ l(XAL ear)/{T (A/ As lJLTl1tl\) :k)S thscl<ITJ:nt\J ~N Grte-Mrx:t\JCc Oc-FeNOA-NTS y\1Ar+oN FoRA

Y\1LSD'(l:AL.St:E-(J.S. \h Qar-)~13 F.@fl 5'1'f (to,Y~cka. }tf~3). ma. IIEr LLtv X 6ELI: e;ves 311A:f TH~f 5!1&!-Tt;- VLeLereO fvq')CNCE ~vt. 6

~15 ftNO 111~ ?kc:r.t--r.c. RuL~NCr Of =n./e- y(l.J:tU .. C..ou.eT. c,y aok-&Cr l:?o M~. \/rru.~:;u?( s 3'1lJ:AL (..Jet~ Tt\l:NT!!:O b't ColLu)r.oA). me. VEILLeux AL'20

bt:Ltt!"Je-s 3'dA3 nte.- Trh:.YVL CosJg-s= EftRo1tW 1:-N J""HA'f I-T IMA'Oe- t\JO

Ot:c-csi.oA) 0~ ftv l.L4JCr ON :oJC Mo:rl:P.V (?k'cwG-t\Y for2wAf0 6 '1 THt

Ot:FfilWANI. Tilts t.vA? A MA:I<) fl \/!:oL ATI:-tJN o)::- CaN7Tt:'D.JTf" MAGNrivOF

\JNOt:lt 1)1C Ovc 92oCC52 CLv\usr of Trlf: Jid "\1'1 &mmfv\JOMWT oF xll£

Co tiJ ~TJ>r "'1: o !\J ,

APPENDIX A

WORKING COP'.._---------------------------------------~

.GALLATIN COUNl Y CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

LORRAINE V.;\.tl ;\USDOL Todd s. Whipple, Chief Deputy County Attorney Gallatin County Attorney's Office '02 OCT 9 prJ y 53 615 South 16th Avenue Bozeman, Montana 59715 phone: {406) 582-2145

MONTANA EIGHTEENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT

THE STATE OF MONTANA,

Plaintiff, No. DC-02- ;t.l'\

v. INFORMATION

JARROD EUGENE VEILLEUX

Defendant.

* * * * * * * * * * * * *

In open court comes Todd s. Whipple, a Deputy Gallatin County

Attorney, having first obtained leave of this court and by this

Information accuses the defendant with committing the following

crimes in Gallatin County, Montana:

COUNT 1: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, conunitted on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or ·remained in the cabin owned by Ted Jacobsen, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 2: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Ted Jacobsen without consent; to wit, damaged a window and a padlock.

COUNT 3 : CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant ~nowingly entered or remained unlawfully in a garage owned by Ted Jacobsen.

COUNT 4: THEFT, common scheme, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to Ted Jacobsen, consisting of Sears Craftsman

34

4300j

WORKINGCOPv------------------------------------------------------------------------------------,

tool box; Craftsman socket set; Craftsman box end and open-end wrenches-standard and metric; Electric drill; Craftsman crescent wrenches; a socket set-unknown brand; "Solar" battery charger-10/2 amp-Model# 1010; a "Makita" air compressor (oil less)-Model # MAC500; One green in color, plastic tackle box containing miscellaneous fishing tackle-value; a metallic blue and gray tackle box containing miscellaneous fishing tackle and a Penn Fly Fishing Reel, with the purpose to deprive Jacobsen of his property. The aggregate value of the property exceeds $1000.00.

COUNT 5: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Harold Jenson, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 6: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Harold Jenson without consent; to wit, damaged a window and garage door.

COUNT 7: CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly entered or remained unlawfully in a garage owned by Harold Jenson.

COUNT 8: THEFT, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to Harold Jenson with the purpose of depriving Jenson of his property; specifically, One electric drill-unknown brand; Numerous drill bits; One electric saw possibly a Craftsman; One air compressor; Ten end wrenches; Twelve sockets; Paper towels, toilet paper, snack food, and spices.

COUNT 9: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Doug Child (Cabin #1) without consent; to wit, damaged a door.

COUNT 10: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Doug Child (Cabin #1), an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

4301

WORKING COP~---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

COUNT 11: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Doug Child (Cabin #2) without consent; to wit, damaged a door.

COUNT 12: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Doug Child (Cabin #2), an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 13: CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly entered or remained unlawfully upon the premises owned by George Caine.

COUNT 14: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Dan Russell, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 15: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Dan Russell without consent; to wit, damaged a screen and hasp.

COUNT 16: THEFT, common scheme, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to Dan Russell with the purpose of depriving Russell of his property; specifically, a "V Tech" digital 2.4 OHZ cordless telephone; One "RCA" 20 inch television with a remote control; "Sharp" VCR; One Honda water pump; a portable multi-band radio; one hunting knife in a black sheath; Twenty fishing flies;

One pair of binoculars-b power; One CB base station radio; One blue in color terry cloth bathrobe. The aggregate value of the property exceeds $1000.00.

COUNT 17: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by James Lyon, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a the~t therein.

COUNT 18: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Felony, 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about

in violation of Section May 15, 2002, when the

4302

WORKING COP I I

Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by James Lyon without consent; to wit, damaged a door, two windows, a screen and an interior sliding door. The value of the property injured, damaged or destroyed exceeds $1_000. 00.

COUNT 19: THEFT, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to James Lyon with the purpose of depriving Lyon of his property; specifically, two pairs of gloves; an air compressor, a garden sprayer; and a fishing tackle box:

COUNT 20: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Ernest Lee, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 21: CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly entered or remained unlawfully upon the premises (a garage) owned by Ernest Lee.

COUNT 22: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Ernest Lee without consent; to wit, damaged a garage door, a window blind and a padlock.

COUNT 23: THEFT, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to Ernest Lee with the purpose of depriving Lee of his property; specifically, a Makita reciprocating saw.

COUNT 24: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Nicholas Bishop, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 25: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Nicholas Bishop without consent; to wit·, damaged a shutter, a screen, closet door, bed frame, baby crib, and a vacuum.

COUNT 26: THEFT, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant

430~.

WORKINGCOPv-------------------------------------------

purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to Nicholas Bishop with the purpose of depriving Bishop of his property; specifically, a shotgun and a pair of spurs.

COUNT 27: CRIMINAL TRESPASS TO VEHICLES, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-202, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly or purposely and without authority entered a vehicle owned by Nicholas Bishop.

COUNT 28: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Earl Booth, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 29: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Felony, ·in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Earl Booth without consent; to wit, damaged a 4 padlocks, 3 doors, a window, rock wall, bed box, briefcase, screwdriver, reading glasses, van window and van door. The value of the property injured, damaged or destroyed exceeds $1000.00.

COUNT 30: THEFT, common scheme, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to Earl Booth with the purpose of depriving Booth of his property; specifically, 2 L.E.D. flashlights ; One "Coleman" propane lantern; Three canisters of "Coleman" propane;

One green in color "Coleman" lantern and battery; One "Coleman" florescent lantern and battery; One steel camp grill-9"xl 1"; One camp candle holder One folding travel clock;.Silver jewelry ~hich includes a necklace, earrings, a bracelet, tie pins, and cuff links; Five gallons of gasoline; One pair of binoculars; One black in color camp sink; A first aid kit; A brown and beige in color fishing tackle box and fishing tackle; A "Coleman" air pump; Two "Wrist Rocket" slingshots; A gold in color twin sheet; One black in color, titanium folding "Buck" knife; One brass and teak wood folding "Buck" knife; One "Old Timer" pocket knife; Two "Coleman" handheld radios; Two "Cobra" handheld radios; One "Cabelas" fly tying kit in a wood case; One multifunction ratchet; One leatherman; One small buck knife with a orange and black belt tie; One boat key on a float; Several door keys; A cast iron hook with a bear design; One "Makita" saws-all; One gray in color toolbox with miscellaneous tools; One grinder-two grinding wheels; Two air rifles;.One "Daisy" BB gun, and one cast iron griddle. The aggregate value of the property exceeds $1000.00.

430

WORKINGCOPv-------------------------------------------

COUNT 31: CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly entered or remained unlawfully upon the premises (a garage) owned by Earl Booth.

COUNT 32: . CRIMINAL TRESPASS TO VEHICLES, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-202, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly or purposely and without authority entered a vehicle owned by Earl Booth.

COUNT 33: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by George Fischer, an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 34: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by George Fischer without consent; to wit, damaged a window, 4 shutters, 3 screens, and latches.

COUNT 35: THEFT, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to George Fischer with the purpose of depriving Fischer of his property; specifically, a chainsaw, and a butane stove.

COUNT 36: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Bill Hess (Cabin #1), an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 3 7: . CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Bill Hess without consent; to wit, damaged 4 padlocks.

COUNT 38: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by Bill Hess (Cabin #2), an occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 39: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Bill Hess without consent; to wit, damaged 4

430~

WORKING COPy-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

padlocks and a lantern globe.

COUNT 40: CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed, on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly entered or remained unlawfully upon the premises (a garage) owned by Zane Hall.

COUNT 41: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by Zane Hall without consent; to wit, damaged a door jamb and knob.

COUNT 42: BURGLARY, a Felony, in violation of Section 45-6-204, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant, knowingly entered or remained in the cabin owned by George Troy, an.occupied structure, with the purpose to commit a theft therein.

COUNT 43: CRIMINAL TRESPASS, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-203, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant knowingly entered or remained unlawfully upon the premises (a garage) owned by George Troy.

COUNT 44: CRIMINAL MISCHIEF, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-101 committed on or about May 15, 2002, when. the Defendant purposely or knowingly injured, damaged or destroyed property owned by George Troy without consent; to wit, damaged a screen and padlock.

COUNT 45: THEFT, a Misdemeanor, in violation of Section 45-6-301, MCA, committed on or about May 15, 2002, when the Defendant purposely or knowingly exerted unauthorized control over property belonging to George Troy with the purpose of depriving Troy of his property; specifically, a coins and cans of food.

DATED

A person convicted of the offense of Thef , imprisoned in the state prison for a term not be fined an amount not to exceed $50, 000, COUNT)

a Felony, shall be to exceed 10 years, or both. (FOR EACH

A person convicted of the offense of Theft, a Misdemeanor, shall

4306

WORKING COP'(-----------------------------------------

be imprisoned in the county jail for a term not more than 6 months and fined an amount not more than $1000 or both (FOR EACH COUNT)

A person convicted of the offense of Burglary shall be imprisoned in the state prison for any term not to exceed 20 years or be fined not to exceed $50,000 or both. (FOR EACH COUNT)

A person convicted of the offense of Criminal Trespass to property or vehicles shall be imprisoned in the county jail for a term not more than 6 months and fined an amount not more than $500 or both. (FOR EACH COUNT)

A person convicted of Criminal Mischief a Felony shall be imprisoned in the state prison for a term not more than 10 years and fined an amount not more than $50,000 or both (FOR EACH COUNT)

A person convicted of Criminal Mischief a Misdemeanor, shall be imprisoned in the county jail for a term not more than 6 months and fined an amount not more that $500 or both (FOR EACH COUNT)

(Total potential imprisonment 310 years at the state prison followed by 13 ~ years in the county jail)

WITNESSES: TED JACOBSEN HAROLD JENSON DOUG CHILD GEORGE CAINE DAN RUSSELL JAMES LYON ERNEST LEE NICK BISHOP NICHOLAS "JACOB" BISHOP EARL BOOTH BILL HESS GEORGE FISCHER ZANE HALL GEORGE TROY MATT DAUGHERTY TOM PALLACH SHANE BARSTAD RYAN STRATMAN BILL PRONOVOST TODD RUDNER STEVE ETTE JASON JARRETT DAN SPRINGER RUSS SANKEY CRAIG BUSHMAN CALVIN DUNBAR

430'('

WORKING COP

CLARI HOWARD DUSTIN SLOAN NATHAN GEORGE BISHOP GEORGE ASBOE CARRIE BOURNE BLUE FLORES STEVEN LITTLEFIELD TODD WILLOUGHBY MATT JAMISON BRIAN GILLETTE NATHAN KRAFT DALE GRIFFITHS JAY REED SHANNA CASTLEBURY JANENE GINES

STATE OF MONTANA} ss

Ccunty of Gallatin JENNIFER BRANDON, CleFk of the Montana Eighteenth .Ju11iciaf Di.strict Court. Gaffatin County, do h'.reby cerhi tilut !t:~ .!tltWr>. i!l a f~tli, trut~ ~rH1 r.orre:;r copy or the Oi!i1'!;.1: ;:s ~:·1l' s~m~ J~•i:C.!.'$ ir: l;::: ~i'0:: ~;:r: rt:co;ds r;t tiJis Office. 'tViT ·SS M'/ H .. :~NC.• <~nd tno $~.::! cr ll;is Cou;·t ti,;'Jj.b._.day of

.,_"P'~, "-~""" I y _ Jc:~NJfER BRANDON. CLERK By - Deputy

4308

APPENDlX'

MofJTAN A S1AT\JT£ At\JfJ CoMrYlL:{:>r.<JrU Y'JCITfS

MC.A c..f~-Jr£-401 C'-l)

WORKINGCOPv-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

46-18-401. Consecutive sentences, MCA 46·18..-401

West's Montana Code Annotated currentneS«

Title 46. Criminal Procedure Chapter 18. Sentence and Judgment (Refs & Annos)

Part 4. Factors That Reduce Sentence

MCA 46-18-401 46-18-401. Consecutive sentences

{1) Unless the judge otherwise orders:

(a) whenever a person serving a term of commitment imposed by a court in this state is committed for another offense, the shorter term or shorter remaining term may not be merged in the other term; and

(b) whenever a person under suspended sentence or on probation for an offense committed in this state is sentenced for another offense, the period still to be served on suspended sentence or probation may not be merged in any new sentence of commitment or probation.

(2) The court, whether or not it merges the sentences, shall immediately furnish each of the other courts and the penal institutions in which the defendant is confined under sentence with authenticated copies of its sentence, which must cite any sentence that is merged.

(3) If an unexpired sentence is merged pursuant to subsection (1), the court that imposed the sentence shall modify it in accordance with the effect of the merger.

(4) Separate sentences for two or more offenses must run consecutively unless the court otherwise orders.

Credits Enacted 95-2213 by Laws 1967, ch. 196, § 1. Amended by Laws 1977, ch. 340, § 2; Revised Code of Montana 1947, 95-2213; amended by Laws 1979, ch. 116, § 23; amended by Laws 1981, ch. 583, § 11; amended by Laws 1989, ch. 76, § 1; amended by Laws 1995, ch. 372, § 2.

COMMISSION COMMENTS

Source: Model Sentencing Act, sections 19,21 and 22, General Laws of Massachusetts Chapter 279, Section 27.

The merger is not mandatory, but is in the discretion of the judge, although the language suggests that in most instances the merger should occur. The result of this approach is a unified sentence rather than a multiplicity of sentences.

Subsection [(4)] is included in an attempt to avoid consecutive sentences where only a single criminal episode was involved. ------------·-----·---" ·----------··-·--···-··-·-·-·"''_. __ .. _____ _

WORKING COPY

46-18-401. Consecutive sentences, MCA 46-18-401 ------·--·-·-·---············ --------------- --.. ··--·--···------ ····-- ····-·

Notes of Decisions (22)

MCA46-18-401, MT ST 46-18-401

Statutes are current ~ith all20lllaws, 2011 Code Commissioner changes,_!lnd 2010 ballot measures.

End of Documt"nt -~) 21.113 TI!OffiS('ll Rt"lltcrs. NP rlaim t<' original U.S. Gov,;mment Work.;.

....... --··----------· ---··---···-----·-· .. ·-------·---... -·-·· --··--

SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON COUNTY OF SPOKANE STATE OF WASHINGTON )

) Plaintiff, )

)

No. 12-1-01185-1

PA# 12-9-44582-0 RPT# CT Ill: 109-12-0056736 v. )

) RCW CT Ill: 9.41.040(1)(A)-F (#37060) JARROD E. VEILLEUX ) WM 12/03/82 )

) FELONY JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE (FJS) Prison

Defendant. ) ) ) )

l)Q Clerk's Action Required, para 2.1, 4.1, 4.3, 5.2, 5.3, 5.5 and 5.7

[ ) Defendant Used Motor Vehicle [ ) Juvenile Decline [ ] Mandatory [ ] Discretionary

I. Hearing 1.1 The court conducted a sentencing hearing this date; the defendant, the defendant's

lawyer and the (deputy) prosecuting attorney were present.

II. Findings 2.1 Current Offenses: The defendant is guilty of the following offenses, based upon

[ ] guilty plea (date) [x] jury verdict (date) 01/18/13 [ ] bench trial (date) __ _

Count No.: Ill FIRST DEGREE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF A FIREARM RCW 9.41.040(1)(A)-F (#37060) Date of Crime February 24, 2012 Incident No. 109-12-0056736

Class: FA (Felony-A), FB (Felony-B), FC (Felony-C)

to the Information

[ ] Additional current offenses are attached in Appendix 2.1 a.

FELONY JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE {FJS) {Prison)(Nonsex Offender) ((RCW 9.94A.500,.505)(WPF CR 84.0400 {7/2011)

Page 1

The jury returned a special verdict or the court made a special finding with regard to the following:

[ ] The defendant used a firearm in the commission of the offense in Count(s) ___ _:. RCW 9.94A.825, 9.94A.533.

[ ] The defendant used a deadly weapon other than a firearm in committing the offense in Count(s) . RCW 9.94A.825, 9.94A.533.

[ ] For the crime(s) charged in Count , domestic violence was pled and proved. RCW 1 0.99.020. (For offenses pled and proven on or after August 11, 2011.)

[ ] Count , Violation of the Uniform Controlled Substances Act (VUCSA), RCW 69.50.401 and RCW 69.50.435 took place in a school, school bus, within 1000 feet of the perimeter of a school grounds or within 1000 feet of a school bus route stop designated by the school district; or in a public park, in a public transit vehicle, or public transit stop shelter; or in, or within 1000 feet of the perimeter of a civic center designated as a drug-free zone by a local government authority, or in a public housing project designated by a local governing authority as a drug-free zone.

[ ] The defendant committed a crime involving the manufacture of methamphetamine including its salts, isomers, and salts of isomers, when a juvenile was present in or upon the premises of manufacture in Count(s) . RCW 9.94A.605, RCW 69.50.401, RCW 69.50.440.

[ ] Count is a criminal street gang-related felony offense in which the defendant compensated, threatened, or solicited a minor in order to involve that minor in the commission of the offense. 9.94A.833. Count is the crime of unlawful possession of a firearm. The defendant was a criminal street gang member or associate when the defendant committed the crime. RCW 9.94A.702. 9.94A._.

[ ] The defendant committed [ 1 vehicular homicide [ 1 vehicular assault proximately caused by driving a vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor or drug or by operating a vehicle in a reckless manner. The offense is, therefore, deemed a violent offense. RCW 9.94A.030.

[ ] Count involves attempting to elude a police vehicle and during the commission of the crime the defendant endangered one or more persons other than the defendant or the pursuing law enforcement officer. RCW 9.94A.834.

[ ] In Count the defendant has been convicted of assaulting a law enforcement officer or other employee of a law enforcement agency who was performing his or her official duties at the time of the assault, as provided under RCW 9A.36.031, and the defendant intentionally committed the assault with what appeared to be a firearm. RCW 9.94A.831, 9.94A.533.

[ ] Count is a felony in the commission of which the defendant used a motor vehicle. RCW 46.20.285.

b4, The defendant has a chemical dependency that has contributed to the offense(s). RCW 9.94A.607.

[ ] In Count , assault in the first degree (RCW 9A.36.011) or assault of a child in the first degree (RCW 9A.36.120), the offender used force or means likely to result in death or intended to kill the victim and shall be subject to a mandatory minimum term of 5 ~ears (RCW 9.94A.540).

[)(] Counts 9. :J)i..f-..P13 encompass the same criminal conduct and count as one crime in determining the offender score (RCW 9.94A.589) N\o~A ~..P'13 ·~Oli1,3

2. CJ2_,h1"•N.t-t ..,.~lll~f'.F FELONY JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE (FJS) Page 2 (Prison)(Nonsex Offender) ((RCW 9.94A.500,.505)(WPF CR 84.0400 (7/2011)

~~ ()Vt'V\'~

~ar

~

[ ] Other current convictions listed under different cause numbers used in calculating the offender score are (list offense and cause number):

Crime Cause Number Court ~ounty & state) 1.

2.

* DV: Domestic Violence was plead and proved. [ ] Additional current convictions listed under different cause numbers used in calculating

the offender score are attached in Appendix 2.1 b.

2.2 Criminal History: {RCW 9.94A.525):

Crime Date of Type of ~dult Sentencing Court Date of DV* Crime Crime orJuv (County & State) Sent. Yes

BURGLARY 103108 A LEWIS AND CLARK CO, MT 012209 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLA TIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 Tt.lliiiiZJ (F) 1QQ69Z!o A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 THE!* (F) 16858£ A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203

'THEj;:f (5~ 19968@ A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 Thi~5T w~ 1QC5Q;t A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203 CRIP4 h41it;;t.ll~v 10050:l A C?Aiai.A+~ CO, MT 052203 CWM MleGIIII!iF 19969>2 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203

*DV: Domestic Violence was pled and proved.

[ ] Additional criminal history is attached in Appendix 2.2 [ ] The defendant committed a current offense while on community placement/community

custody (adds one point to score). RCW 9.94A.525. [ ] The prior convictions listed as number(s) above, or in appendix 2.2, are

one offense for purposes of determining the offender score (RCW 9.94A.525). [ ] The prior convictions listed as number(s) above, or in appendix 2.2, are

not counted as points but as enhancements pursuant to RCW 46.61.520:

FELONY JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE (FJS) (Prison)(Nonsex Offender) ((RCW 9.94A.500,.505)(WPF CR 84.0400 (7/2011)

Page 3

2.3 SENTENCING DATA:

CTNO Offender Seriousness Standard Range Plus Total Maximum (not including enhancements)

Score Level enhance- Standard Term ments* Range

(including enhancements)

l I '·fr VI\ ~2.;~~~ ib "tl"r~QJ'U

.. *(F) F1rearm, (D) Other deadly weapons, M VUCSA 1n a protected zone, (VH) Veh1cular Hom1c1de, See RCW 46.61.520, (JP) Juvenile present, (CSG) criminal street gang involving minor, (AE) endangerment while Jtle~p ing to elu.de, (ALF) assault Ia~ enforcement with firearm, RCW 9.94A.533(12). T ' . i'VPfe.,VUJ -~fl·- kJt -3

[ ] A ditionafCU'rrent offense sentencing data in Appendix 2.3.

For violent offenses, most serious offenses, or armed offenders, recommended sentencing agreements or plea agreements are [ ] attached [ ] as follows:

2.4 [ ] Exceptional Sentence: The Court finds substantial and compelling reasons that justify an exceptional sentence: [ ] below the standard range for Count(s) __ _ [ ] above the standard range for Count(s) __ _

[ ] The defendant and state stipulate that justice is best served by imposition of the exceptional sentence above the standard range and the court finds the exceptional sentence furthers and is consistent with the interests of justice and the purposes of the sentencing reform act. [ ] Aggravating factors were [ ] stipulated by the defendant, [ ] found by the court after the defendant waived jury trial, [ ] found by jury by special interrogatory.

] within the standard range for Count(s) , but served consecutively to Count(s) ___ _

Findings of fact and conclusions of law are attached in Appendix 2.4. [ ] Jury's special interrogatory is attached. The Prosecuting Attorney [ ] did [ ] did not recommend a similar sentence.

2.5 Legal Financial Obligations/Restitution. The court has considered the total amount owing, the defendant's present and future ability to pay legal financial obligations, including the defendant's financial resources and the likelihood that the defendant's status will change. (RCW 1 0.01.160).The court makes the following specific findings: [ ] The following extraordinary circumstances exist that make restitution

inappropriate (RCW 9.94A. 753):

[ ] The defendant has the present means to pay costs of incarceration. RCW 9.94A.760.


Page4

Ill. Judgment 3.1 The defendant is guilty of the Counts and Charges listed in paragraph 2.1 and Appendix

2.1

3.2 ~ The defendant is found NOT GUlL TY of Counts J4.- \\ in the charging document.

[ ] The Court DISMISSES Counts _ in the charging document.

IV. Sentence And Order IT IS ORDERED: 4.1 Confinement. The court sentences the defendant to total confinement as follows:

(a) Confinement. RCW 9.94A.589. A term of total confinement in the custody of the Department of Corrections (DOC):

l \ lo (months) on Count No.--"'} __

(b)

(c)

____ (months) on Count No. ___ _

____ (months) on Count No. ___ _

[]The confinement time on Count(s) _______ contain(s) a mandatory minimum term of _____________________ _

[ ] The confinement time on Count includes ____ _ months as enhancement for [ ] firearm [ ] deadly weapon [ ] VUCSA in a protected zone [ ] manufacture of methamphetamine with juvenile present.

Actual number of months of total confinement ordered is: I \ (p (}1 0 A.IJ"l-l-- .5 All counts shall be served concurrently, except for the portion of those counts for which there is an enhancement as set forth at Section 2.3, and except for the following counts which shall be served consecutively: _________ __;,

The sentence herein shall run consecutively with the sentence in cause number(s) --------------- but concurrently to any other felony cause not referred to in this Judgment. RCW 9.94A.589.

Confinement shall commence immediately unless otherwise set forth here: __ _

Credit for Time Served. The defendant shall receive credit for time served prior to sentencing if that confinement was solely under this cause number. RCW 1 1 J_ St.,Ji(l., 9.94A.505. The jail shall compute time served. - S. e..E Sevl't D/\J , ' ~- ./ [] Work Ethic Program. RCW 9.94A.690, RCW 72.09.41 0. The court finds that '5/tol /2-the defendant is eligible and is likely to qualify for work ethic program. The court recommends that the defendant serve the sentence at a work ethic program. Upon completion of work ethic program, the defendant shall be released on community custody for any remaining time of total confinement, subject to the conditions in Section 4.2. Violation of the conditions of community custody may result in a retum to total confinement for the balance of the defendant's remaining time of confinement.

FELONY JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE (FJS) (Prison)(Nonsex Offender)

Page 5

((RCW 9.94A.500,.505)(WPF CR 84.0400 (7/2011)

4.2 Community Custody. (To determine which offenses are eligible for or required for community custody see RCW 9.94A.701)

(A) The defendant shall be on community custody for the longer of: (1) the period of early release. RCW 9.94A.728(1)(2); or (2) the period imposed by the court, as follows: Count(s) 36 months for Serious Violent Offenses. Count(s) 18 months for Violent Offenses. Count(s) 12 months (for crimes against a person, drug offenses, or offenses involving the unlawful possession of a firearm by a street gang member or associate) The DOC is directed that the total terms of confinement and community custody must not exceed the statutory maximum sentence for the convicted offense(s).

(B) While on community custody, the defendant shall: (1) report to and be available for contact with the assigned community corrections officer as directed; (2) work at DOC-approved education, employment and/or community restitution (service); (3) notify DOC of any change in defendant's address or employment; (4) not consume controlled substances except pursuant to lawfully issued prescriptions; (5) not unlawfully possess controlled substances while on community custody; {6) not own, use, or possess firearms or ammunition; (7) pay supervision fees as determined by DOC; (8) perform affirmative acts as required by DOC to confirm compliance with the orders of the court; and (9) abide by any additional conditions imposed by DOC under RCW 9.94A.704 and .706. The defendant's residence location and living arrangements are subject to the prior approval of DOC while on community custody.

The court orders that during the period of supervision the defendant shall:

[ ] consume no alcohol. [ ] have no contact with: _____________________ ___:. [ ) remain [ ) within [ ) outside of a specified geographical boundary, to wit: __ _

[ ] not serve in any paid or volunteer capacity where he or she has control or supervision of minors under 13 years of age.

[ ] participate in the following crime-related treatment or counseling services: ___ _

[ ) undergo an evaluation for treatment for [ ]domestic violence [ ]substance abuse [ )mental health [ ]anger management and fully comply with all recommended treatment.

[ ) comply with the following crime-related prohibitions:

[ ) Other conditions: ______________________ _

Court Ordered Treatment: If any court orders mental health or chemical dependency treatment, the defendant must notify DOC and the defendant must release treatment information to DOC for the duration of incarceration and supervision. RCW 9.94A.562.


Page 6

4.3 Legal Financial Obligations: The defendant shall pay to the clerk of this court: JASS CODE

PCV

PDV

CRC

PUB

WRF

$500.00 Victim Assessment RCW 7.68.035 $ Domestic Violence Assessment RCW 10.99.080 $200.00 Court costs, including: RCW 9.94A.760, 9.94A.505, 10.01.160,10.46.190

Criminal Filing fee $ FRc

Witness costs $ WFR

Sheriff service fees $ 31~ SFRISFS/SFW/SRF

Jury demand fee $ JFR

Extradition costs $ EXT

Other $

$ _____ Fees for court appointed attorney RCW 9.94A. 760 $ Court appointed defense expert and other defense costs RCW 9.94A.760

FCMtMTH $ ____ Fine RCW 9A.20.021; [ ] VUCSA chapter 69.50 RCW, [ ] VUCSA additional fine deferred due to indigency RCW 69.50.430

CDF/LDI/

FCD/NTF/

sAotsoJ $ _____ Drug enforcement fund of RCW 9.94A. 760 MTH

CLF

FVP

RTN/RJN

RTN/RJN

$ _____ Meth/Amphetamine Cleanup Fine, $3000. RCW 69.50.440, 69.50.401 (a)(1 )(ii)

$ DUI fines, fees and assessments ·-----

$ Crime lab fee [ ] suspended due to indigency RCW 43.43.690

$ 1 00 DNA collection fee RCW 43.43. 7541

$ Specialized forest produces RCW 76.48.140

$ Other fines or costs for: ________________ _

$

$

$

_____ Emergency response costs (Vehicular Assault, Vehicular Homicide . I Felony DUI only, $1 ,000 maximum) RCW 38.52.430

_ _:.N_.:::..;~=;_;:~=--Restitution to:---------------------

_____ Restitution to:---------------------

$

$

[ ] The above total does not include all restitution or other legal financial obligations, which may be set by later order of the court. An agreed restitution order may be entered. RCW 9.94A.753. A restitution hearing: [ ] shall be set by the prosecutor [ ] is scheduled for--------------------

FELONY JUDGMENT AND SENTENCE (FJS) (Prison)(Nonsex Offender)

Page 7

((RCW 9.94A.500,.505)(WPF CR 84.0400 (7/2011)

RJN

[ ] The defendant waives any right to be present at any restitution hearing (sign initials): _________________________ _

[ ] Restitution. Schedule attached.

[ ] Restitution ordered above shall be paid jointly and severally with: NAME of other defendant Cause Number (Victim Name) (Amount$)

[~ The Department of Corrections (DOC) or clerk of the court shall immediately issue a Notice of Payroll Deduction. RCW 9.94A.7602, RCW 9.94A.760(8)

fX All payments shall be made in accordance with the policies of the clerk of the court and on a schedule established by the DOC or the clerk of the court, commencing imm~i~ely, unless the court specifically set~rth the rate here: Not less than $ 'Jd.S per month commencing o~ /•~ 1 3 RCW 9.94A.760.

The defendant SHALL report to the Spokane County Superior Court Clerk's Office immediately after sentencing if out of custody or within 48 hours after release from confinement if in custody. The defendant is required to keep an accurate address on file with the Clerk's Office and to provide financial information when requested by the Clerk's Office. The defendant is also required to make payments on the legal-financial obligations set by the court. Failure to do any of the above will result in a warrant for your arrest. RCW 9.94A.760(7)(b).

[ ] The Court orders the defendant to pay costs of incarceration at the rate of$ ____ per day, (actual costs not to exceed $100 per day). (JLR) RCW 9. 94A. 760. (This provision does not apply to costs of incarceration collected by DOC under RCW 72.09.111 and 72.09.480.)

The financial obligations imposed in this judgment shall bear interest from the date of the judgment until payment in full, at the rate applicable to civil judgments. RCW 1 0.82.090. An award of costs on appeal against the defendant may be added to the total legal financial obligations. RCW 10.73.160

4.4 DNA Testing. The defendant shall have a biological sample collected for purposes of DNA identification analysis and the defendant shall fully cooperate in the testing. The appropriate agency shall be responsible for obtaining the sample prior to the defendant's release from confinement. This paragraph does not apply if it is established that the Washington State Patrol crime laboratory already has a sample from the defendant for a qualifying offense. RCW 43.43.754 FAILURE TO REPORT FOR TESTING MAY BE CONSIDERED CONTEMPT OF COURT.

[ ] HIV Testing. The defendant shall submit to HIV testing. If out of custody, the defendant shall provide documentation of HIV testing to Spokane County Prosecutor's Office no later than 14 days after sentencing or release from custody, whichever comes first. RCW 70.24.340 FAILURE TO PROVIDE DOCUMENTATION FOR TESTING MAY BE CONSIDERED CONTEMPT OF COURT.

] The victim, based upon their request, shall be notified of the results of the HIV test whether negative or positive. (Applies only to victims of sexual offenses under RCW 9A.44.) RCW 70.24.1 05(7)


Page 8

4.5 No Contact:

4.6

4.7

[ )(L The Defendant shall not have contact with _..:,_.;_s_~--=-..:...;;.._;_;_ ___ _;_

__________ (name, DOB) including, but not limited o, personal, verbal, telephonic, written or contact through a third party until 01 Oc' t which does not exceed the maximum statutory sentence.)

[ ] The defendant is excluded or prohibited from coming within ______ _ (distance) of: [ ] (name of protected person(s))'s [ ] home/residence [ ]work place [ ]school [ ](other location(s)) ______ _

----------------------------------'or [ ] other location: -------------------------' until. __________ (which does not exceed the maximum statutory sentence).

[ ] A separate Domestic Violence No-Contact Order or Anti-Harassment No-Contact Order is filed concurrent with this Judgmen and Sentence.

Other: \ 1

~ n mE_ ~ ff21LfJ) ~~~~~ J,Uilh

S{iDt?- Wft&\1 ~ fltilhSJ:-A~1J;)l;;r= r~ 1\/lj

Off-Limits Order. (Known drug trafficker) RCW 10.66.020. The following areas are off ~"WE. limits to the defendant while under the supervision of the County Jail or Department of·4I:fl= Corrections:------------------------------ ""Wf"At!::_

V. Notices and Signatures

5.1 Collateral Attack on Judgment. If you wish to petition or move for collateral attack on this Judgment and Sentence, including but not limited to any personal restraint petition, state habeas corpus petition, motion to vacate judgment, motion to withdraw guilty plea, motion for new trial or motion to arrest judgment, you must do so within one year of the final judgment in this matter, except as provided for in RCW 10.73.1 00. RCW 10.73.090

5.2 Length of Supervision. If you committed your offense prior to July 1, 2000, you shall remain under the court's jurisdiction and the supervision of the Department of Corrections for a period up to ten years from the date of sentence or release from confinement, whichever is longer, to assure payment of all legal financial obligations unless the court extends the criminal judgment an additional 1 0 years. If you committed your offense on or after July 1, 2000, the court shall retain jurisdiction over you, for the purposes of your compliance with payment of the legal financial obligations, until you have completely satisfied your obligation, regardless of the statutory maximum for the crime. RCW 9.94A. 760 and RCW 9.94A.505(5). The clerk of the court has authority to collect unpaid legal financial obligations at any time while you remain under the jurisdiction of the court for purposes of your legal financial obligations. RCW 9.94A.760(4) and RCW 9.94A.753(4).

5.3 Notice of Income-Withholding Action. If the court has not ordered an immediate notice of payroll deduction in Section 4.1, you are notified that the Department of Corrections (DOC) or the clerk of the court may issue a notice of payroll deduction without notice to you if you are more than 30 days past due in monthly payments in an


Page9

amount equal to or greater than the amount payable for one month. RCW 9.94A.7602. Other income-withholding action under RCW 9.94A. 760 may be taken without further notice. RCW 9.94A.7606

5.4 Community Custody Violation. (a) If you are subject to a first or second violation hearing and DOC finds that you committed the violation, you may receive as a sanction up to 60 days of confinement per violation. RCW 9.94A.633. (b) If you have not completed your maximum term of total confinement and you are subject to a third violation hearing and DOC finds that you committed the violation, DOC may return you to a state correctional facility to serve up to the remaining portion of your sentence. RCW 9.94A.714.

5.5 Firearms. You may not own, use or possess any firearm and under federal law any firearm or ammunition, unless your right to do so is restored by the court in which your are convicted or the superior court in Washington State where you live, and by a federal court if required. You must immediately surrender any concealed pistol license. (The clerk of the court shall forward a copy of the defendant's driver's license, identicard, or comparable identification, to the Department of Licensing along with the date of conviction or commitment). RCW 9.41.040, 9.41.047.

5.6 Reserved.

5. 7 Motor Vehicle: If the court found that you used a motor vehicle in the commission of the offense, then the Department of Licensing will revoke your driver's license. The clerk of the court is directed to immediately forward an Abstract of Court Record to the Department of Licensing, which must revoke your driver's license. RCW 46.20.285.

5.8 Other: Any pre-trial surety bond not previously forfeited shall be exonerated.

DCJ..!1e in Open Court in the presence of7h de t'fB ft\)-M!J ,2013.

DALE A. NAGY Deputy Prosecuting Attorney WSBA# 33619


JUDGE Print n

Defendant

Page 10

Voting Rights Statement: I acknowledge that I have lost my right to vote because of this felony conviction. If I am registered to vote, my voter registration will be cancelled.

My right to vote is provisionally restored as long as I am not under the authority of DOC (not serving a sentence of confinement in the custody of DOC and not subject to community custody as defined in RCW 9.94A.030). I must re-register before voting. The provisional right to vote may be revoked if I fail to comply with all the terms of my legal financial obligations or an agreement for the payment of legal financial obligations.

My right to vote may be permanently restored by one of the following for each felony conviction: a) a certificate of discharge issued by the sentencing court, RCW 9.94A.637; b) a court order issued by the sentencing court restoring the right, RCW 9.92.066; c) a final order of discharge issued by the indeterminate sentence review board, RCW 9.96.050; or d) a certificate of restoration issued by the governor, RCW 9.96.020. Voting before the right is restored is a class C felony, RCW 29A.84.660. Registering to vote before the right is restored is a class C felony, RCW 29A.84.140.

Defendant's signature:

I am a certified or registered interpreter, or the court has found me otherwise qualified to interpret, in the language, which the defendant understands. I interpreted this Judgment and Sentence for the defendant into that language.

I certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the state of Washington that the foregoing is true and correct.

Signedat __________________________________ ~on ____________________ __

(city) (state) (date)

Interpreter


Print Name

Page 11

VI. Identification of the Defendant

SID No. Date of Birth 12/03/1982

(If no SID complete a separate Applicant card form FD-258 for State Patrol)

FBI No. LocaiiD No. 0376617

PCN No. Other

DOS 12/03/1982

Alias name

Race: Ethnicity: Sex:

] Asian/Pacific ] Black/African- [ vrC"aucasian [ ] Hispanic ~le Islander American

] Native American ] Other: [v{Non- [ ] Female

hispanic

Fingerprints I attest that I saw the same defendant who appeared in Court affix his or her fingerprints and signature on this document.

THOMAS R. FALLQUIST, Clerk of the Court /

% -------=-tr_.....r--------' Deputy Clerk.

~/.;;/zols Dated: I I

Left 4 fingers take


Left Thumb

Right Thumb

taken

Page 12

APPENDIX u

WORKINGCOP•v--------........---------------------~----------

........ •

FILED FEB 0 6 2013

THOMAS R FALLOUIST SPOKANE COUNTY CLERK

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SPOKANE

STATE OF WASHINGTON

v.

JARROD E. VEILLEUX WM 12103/82

Plaintiff,

Defendant(s).

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

No. 12-1-01185-1

PA# 12-9-44582-0 RPT# CT Ill: 109-12-0056736 RCW CT Ill: 9.41.040(1)(A)-F (#37060)

UNDERSTANDING OF DEFENDANT'S CRIMINAL HISTORY (ST)

Pursuant to CrR 4.2 (e) the parties set out the following:

1.4 PROSECUTOR'S UNDERSTANDING OF DEFENDANT'S CRIMINAL HISTORY (RCW 9.94A.525):

Crime Date of Type of Adult Sentencing Court Date of Crime Crime or (County & State) Sent.

Juv BURGLARY 103108 A LEWIS AND CLARK CO, 012209

MT

~it BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203

~~ BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203

~ BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203

1f BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLA TIN CO, MT 052203

~~ BURGLARY 100502 A GALLA TIN C01 MT 052203 BURGLARY 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203

~~ THiiT(s) 100M? A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 (l.At~ Tf'Eo/ (lA) 188581! A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203

Cti\J A\Jll(. · ~ IEF~ fF' IOOee! A GALLATIN C01 MT 052203 f,A:)tJ liiEFF \F) iotJ50Z"' A GALLATIN CO, MT 052203

ONbEAsfANOINd DEFENbAArs cRIMINXL RisfoRv (RCW 9.94A.080, 1 00)

ov· Yes

PAGE 1

t,

J

WORKING COP'y-------------------...-----------,------~-----------

·-· ., .. ..

~ 100502 A GALLATIN CO, MT .S~ MtSSHIEF

eftiM- 100502 A GALLA TIN CO, MT 052203

052203

QbM·~~~~~H~IE~F----------------------------------------------CoN41Jl7'('

( ) Prior convictions counted as one offense in determining offender score (RCW 9.94A.525(5)): ---------------

1.4(a) This statement of Prosecutor's Understanding of Defendant's Criminal History is based upon present information known to the Prosecutor and does not limit the use of additional criminal history if later ascertained.

1.5 Defendant's understanding of defendant's criminal history is as set out above. Defendant agrees that, unless otherwise noted in writing here, each of the listed convictions counts in the computation of the offender score and that any out-of-state or foreign conviction is the equivalent of a Washington felony offense.

( )

Date:~

Date: OZ./ os' /t3 I

(RCW 9.94A.080, 1 00)

Lawyer to Defendant

DAJU!J.I Deputy Prosecuting Attorney

WSBA#

33619 WSBA#

WORKING COPY---------------,-----------------------------,

.. ·-· .... _

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

-._.

FILED MAR -7 2013

THOMAS R. FALLOUIST SPOKN!E CCIJmY GL::r::~

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SPOKANE

STATE OF WASHINGTON ) No. 12-1-01185-1

Plaintiff,

v.

JAR ROD E. VEl LLEUX WM 12/03/82

Defendant(s).

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

&&Pi I 11!'8 P? m F ~ c FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW RE:DEFENDANT'S OFFENDER SCORE

n;(. THIS MA TIER came before the court on February i, 2013, for sentencing after a jury trial

Present were the defendant, JARROD E. VEILLEUX, his attorney, KARl REARDON, and forth

State of Washington, DALE A NAGY, Deputy Prosecuting Attorney. The court having reviewed th

motions, responses and replies submitted by the parties and after having heard from all the above

now makes the following findings and conclusions:

UNDISPUTED FACTS

1. Mr. Veilleux was convicted of Burglary in Montana in 2009, under Montana Cause number 21 CDC 2008-420. The parties stipulated that this crime is factually compatible to either

Washington's residential burglary or second degree burglary. A certified copy of the 22 Judgment and Commitment in this matter was admitted by the court into the case file

during trial. 23

2. Mr. Veilleux was convicted of on 45 counts to include: 13 counts of Burglary, 4 counts of 24 theft and 2 counts of Criminal Mischief in Montana in 2003 under Montana Cause number

DC-02-289. A certified copy of the Sentence and Judgment in this matter was admitted by 25 the court into the case file during trial.

Page 1 SPOKANE COUNTY PROSECUTING ATIORNEY COUNTY CITY PUBLIC SAFETY BUILDING SPOKANE, WA 99260 (509) 477-3662

WORKING COPY'----------------------------------------

,_ . -·~-.•

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

FINDINGS OF FACT

1. The defendant committed this crime in Washington, he was convicted in Washington and he is sentenced pursuant to Washington law. The court does not use Montana law to determine the defendant's offender score, the court uses Washington law.

2. Under cause number DC-02-289 the following Montana Burglary convictions are factually comparable to Washington's residential burglary statutes. They all occurred at residences or dwellings. Counts 1, 5, 10, 14, 17, 20, 24, 28, 33, 36, and 42 all have different victims. All 13 counts below occurred at different locations. It is mandatory that the court count each conviction below as one point toward the defendant's offender score :

a. Count 1 -Jacobson garage and cabin b. Count 5- Jenson garage and cabin c. Count 10- Child cabin #1 d. Count 12- Child cabin #2 e. Count 14 - Russell cabin f. Count 17- Lyons cabin g. Count 20 - Lee cabin and garage h. Count 24 - Bishop cabin i. Count 28- Booth cabin and garage j. Count 33- Fisher cabin k. Count 36 - Hess cabin #1 I. Count 38 - Hess cabin #2 m. Count 42 -Troy cabin

3. It does not matter that Mr. Veilleux went from one cabin to the next cabin in committing 14 these crimes. They are separate incidents. They count as 13 points in Mr. Veilleux's

offender score. 15

4. Under cause number DC-02-289 the following Montana Theft convictions are legally 16 comparable to theft in Washington (second degree theft) however the court, exercising its

discretion, finds they are the same criminal conduct, same victim and same location, as the 17 residential burglaries discussed above: :

a. Count 4- Victim Jacobson, same conduct, same location, same victim as Count 1 18 b. Count 16- Victim Russell, same conduct, same location, same victim as Count 14

c. Count 19- Victim Lyons, same conduct, same location, same victim as Count 17 19

5. Under cause number DC-02-289 the following Criminal Mischief convictions are factually 20 comparable to malicious mischief in Washington (second degree malicious mischief)

however the court, exercising its discretion, finds they are the same criminal conduct, same 21 victim and same location, as the residential burglaries discussed above::

a. Count 18- Victim Lyons, same conduct, same location, same victim as Count 17 22 b. Count 29 -Victim Booth, same conduct, same location, same victim as Count 28

23 6. Mr. Veilleux was on probation from Montana when he committed this crime. As part of his parole conditions he was not permitted to leave the state of Montana, he was not permitted

24 to possess a firearm, and he was not pennitted to drink alcohol. He violated all of these conditions in committing this crime.

25

Page2 SPOKANE COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY COUNTY CITY PUBUC SAFETY BUILDING SPOKANE, WA 99260 (509) 477-3662

WO~INGCOPY-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

'··

• 1..- ...

7. Mr. Veilleux's Montana conviction for burglary in 2008 is factually comparable to 1 Washington's residential burglary and brings Mr. Veilleux's offender score to 14.

2 8. It does not matter whether the court found the 14 Montana burglaries above to be equivalent to residential burglaries or second degree burglaries in Washington, they would

3 result in the same offender score (14).

4 CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

5 1. Based on the above, the defendant's offender score in this matter for the purpose o sentencing is 14.

6 2. The standard range for First Degree Unlawful Possession of a Firearm with an offende score of 9 is 87 to 116 months.

7 3. The court is not imposing an exceptional sentence; but with an offender score of 14 th court is imposing the high end of the standard range, 116 months.

8 4. The sentencing alternatives of Work Ethic Camp and DOSA would not be appropriate i this case.

9 The court's oral ruling is incorporated by reference.

10 The Verbatim Report of Proceedings, February 5, 2013, was provided to defendant and i

11 attached to the court copy.

12 ~l SO ORDERED this ..:1..._ day of Febl'tJafY, 2013

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

~3 24

25

Presented by:

~!JLY~ Deputy Prosecuting Attorney WSBA#33619

;;;::_j~~~:}J~s noted:

~b 3 KARl REARDON Attorney for Defendant WSBA#26142

. d.t~ o.v~WA aA.G,\\cMJs,~d R.~~~l~~~~ The defense disputes finding 2 and 3, and conclusion 1 and 2. The defense believes that full fait and credit should have been given to Montana's running the cases concurrently, which indicates finding that the burglaries were part of a single criminal episode and that those burglaries shoul have counted as one point. The defense believes that the appropriate offender score is 3. Th defense further believes that there was insufficient evidence contained in the Montana lnformatio and Judgment to find that the Count 10 and Qgu_nt ~-q,c~urr~c;l ~tQ.if!~~Eln~l~~un.d J.hat Coun 36 and Count 38 occurred at different places~' ~~cetn~Cfs .. ~n'l and were on separate curtilage and no evidence that Hess cabin 1 and 2 were separate curtilage.

b.~~,~~C(M~t£-)V""~~d,~t)C.. ~~ Th.t-~tJIC't-~\~\®DI\ Of~ ~V"Z. • SPOKANECOUNTYPROSECUTINGAiTORNEY -r\A,\'S. t9f~~ ~ \"\0{; ~r~ t COUNTY CITY PUBLIC SAFETY BUILDING t'tu. Co\4rt~ fln~U\~ · SPOKANE, WA 99260 (509)477-3662

TlZ~ A L Tt<.v\ l\J~lfL"'S:- \)\S J PAGES '7-3-7-4 rVlOT.LOI\Jtj lV\.J LTMt-Nt:

MOTIONS IN LIMINE

1 the law. But my main concern is that we ask people to use

2 names as much as possible. It is my ultimate thing I

3 dislike the most when law enforcement is up there the

4 entire time and instead of saying, you know, I interviewed

5 Mr. Haymond or spoke to Mr. Haymond, and they're always

6 calling him the victim, or they're always calling

7 Mr. Veilleux and Mr. Riley, the defendant. As much as

8 possible, I think it's very, you know, for law enforcement,

9 it clearly know names at this point in time. so I think

10 asking them to use names as much as possible for regular

11 lay witnesses, it doesn't disturb me quite as much. I

12 think maybe just because they don't have that professional

13 role com1ng into court.

14

15

THE COURT: so your motion is?

MS. REARDON: To ask that everybody use names as

16 much as possible and not descriptive terms of defendant and

17 victim.

18 THE COURT: I'm certainly, in this case, it would be

19 for a clarity issue. If a witness were to say the

20 defendant, I mean, it's hard to tell who they are talking

21 about. we have two defendants. so I think for that reason

22 alone it makes sense to always try to refer to each

23 defendant individually by name.

24 MS. REARDON: I had written into my motions 1n

25 limine to exclude all witnesses except Mr. villeux and

REBECCA J. WEEKS CCR #2597 official court Reporter

1116 w. Broadway Dept. #3 Spokane, washington 99260

73

A?PEI\\ Dr X G

T6Z.Y..'r\L TtZA(\JS(J~L\)15 .. PAGE 1'61-

Kl:lJI-f\J 5~1 rtJES t((os~ £XAvVl.

1

2

3

4

SHINES/Cross

Ms. Reardon.

CROSS EXAMINATION

BY MS. REARDON:

Q Mr. shines, you've been waiting some time to testify.

Is that correct?

A Yes\

Q In fact, you waited in the hallway for a couple of

hours yesterday?

A About, yeah, pretty close.

Q And then you were in the hallway this morning again;

1s that correct?

~.,if~"#A:;Yes.

Q And in the hallway with you yesterday was Deputy

Petersen?

'{A Yes.

Q And in the hallway with you this morn1ng was Deputy

Petersen?

-x'A· -·'Yes r

Q And when I left the courtroom this morn1ng, I saw you

and Deputy Petersen and Detective Keyser speaking.

t,;'~~YeS~"

Q Do you recall being interviewed by me on August 17 of

this, it's now this past year, but within the last few

months, August 17?



187

Td<.I_A. L T~At\J5C-{t1:_'{JTS :1 PAGES 3eos--.3~C,

fY) ~""t "LD 1\J 1- cn'Z. M LS \ (("'LA L-

DEFENDANT RILEY MOTION FOR MISTRIAL

1 make it very unpretty.

2 I may be able to deal with the issue of Ms. Pease.

3 I'm scheduling an interview with her. I think I can fix

4 things. The issue becomes my office doesn't have the money

5 to get her back from Montana, and I may need to ask the

6 court that we take her testimony over the telephone because

7 I just wasn't -- I very repeatedly asked that the State

8 provide me notice of which order the witnesses were coming

9 in. And while I got dates and times, I have asked Mr. Nagy

10 and he gave me ones for today. I imagine we have messed

11 his schedule up again at this point, but I need to know

12 when they're coming up because it throws you when just

13 somebody out of the blue pops up. so that's the issue.

14 The other issue I will say, Judge, I am very, very

15 concerned, my understanding that Detective Keyser was

16 outside yesterday telling witnesses, the one with the

17 shaved head, it's the shorter one, "that's Mr. Veilleux."

18 It is so inappropriate for him to be telling witnesses

·19 those things. He may be able to sit here in trial. That's

20 to assist Mr. Nagy. It is not to go outside and help

21 witnesses testify in a different manner.

22 And it was a very clear motion that witnesses were

23 not to discuss their testimony with each other. He is a

24 witness. He should not be discussing testimony with

25 anybody, which means you're discussing the case at this



385

DEFENDANT RILEY MOTION FOR MISTRIAL

1 point 1n time. So that is also a basis for a mistrial

2 because he has been assisting the witnesses and I don't

3 believe that's appropriate.

4

5

THE COURT: Mr. Nagy.

MR. NAGY: Thank you, Your Honor.

6 I will start with the last one first, Your Honor.

7 All of the witnesses have been instructed not to talk to

8 one another. I don't believe they have talked to one

9 another. Ms. wade is out there to make sure they don't

10 talk about one another. I repeatedly instructed them to

11 make sure they don't talk about this. And I know that

12 Detective Keyser certainly is not out there coaching

13 witnesses. I don't believe that's a point, but, if you

14 want me to put them on the stand, I will certainly be

15 willing to do so, Your Honor.

16 There is no new evidence. As Ms. Reardon said, her

17 new evidence is evidence she discovered through her

18 investigator, not new evidence from the State. Your Honor,

19 and I ask for time, that's fine, I will do this orally and

20 submit it later in an affidavit. on october 31st,

21 Detective Keyser completed a report, which included

22 everything Ms. Pease was going to say and, in fact, did say

23 while she was on the stand. Most of the stuff actually

24 a lot of stuff was left out, all about the drug dealings

25 and she worried about Mr. Veilleux dealing drugs and her

REBECCA J. WEEKS CCR #2597 Official Court Reporter

1116 w. Broadway Dept. #3 spokane, washington 99260

386

FILED AUG 12,2014

In the Office of the Clerk of Court WA State Court of Appeals, Division Ill

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON DNISION THREE

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

Respondent,

v.

JARROD VEILLEUX,

Appellant.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

No. 31480-4-III

UNPUBLISHED OPINION

KORSMO, J. - Jarrod Veilleux appeals his conviction for unlawful possession of a

firearm, arguing that he was denied a timely trial and that the court should have given a

mitigated exceptional sentence. We affinn.

FACTS

Mr. Veilleux, who was on parole from the state of Montana, visited a tavern in

Spokane Valley with a friend, Terrance Riley, on February 24, 2012. Mr. Veilleux, who

was not allowed to possess any guns, carried a gun in his waistband. An altercation later

developed and Mr. Veilleux shot Aaron Haymond.

Charges of attempted first degree murder, first degree assault, and first degree

unlawful possession of a firearm were filed against Mr. Veilleux, while Mr. Riley was

charged with first degree rendering criminal assistance. An arrest warrant was issued for

No. 31480-4-111 State v. Veilleux

Mr. Veilleux on April 9, 2012. The warrant noted that Mr. Veilleux was in prison in

Montana.

Mr. Veilleux was returned to Spokane County and arraigned on July 12, 2012.

His trial date was initially set for September 4, 2012, but was re-set to September 1 0, at a

pre-trial hearing. Riley's counsel moved to continue the trial as he was in trial on another

case before Judge Eitzen, who ultimately was assigned to the Veilleux and Riley trial.

Veilleux's counsel objected, arguing that her expert witness could appear less

expensively in September before the college school year started up. She requested that

the court sever the cases and retain the September 10, trial date. The prosecutor argued

against severance, noting that he had 24 witnesses who would then be subjected to two

trials instead of one and that the pre-school discount for one witness paled in comparison

to the additional costs to the court and prosecutor. The court denied severance and set the

joint trials for October 8.

Mr. Veilleux's counsel sought to continue trial from October 8 to October 10, but

a State's witness had a vacation schedule conflict starting October 12, so the court found

good cause to continue the case and re-scheduled trial for November 5. The defense

expert had a conflict with the new trial date and Mr. Veilleux's counsel sought an

additional continuance. The court found good cause to continue the case and set trial for

November 26. The prosecutor learned that a witness would be unavailable for that date

2

No. 31480-4-III State v. Veilleux

and sought a continuance to January 7, 2013. The court again found good cause for the

continuance and granted the extension over defense objection.

Jury trial began January 7. The defense conceded the unlawful possession charge,

but raised self-defense and lawful use of force defenses to the remaining counts. The jury

subsequently acquitted Mr. Veilleux on the attempted murder and assault charges, but

convicted him on the unlawful possession charge. Mr. Riley also was acquitted.

The trial court imposed a top-end sentence of 116-months on the unlawful

possession conviction despite a defense request for an exceptional sentence below the

standard range, and declined to reduce the sentence after hearing a defense motion for

reconsideration. The court reasoned that Mr. Veilleux had violated his parole by leaving

Montana, going to a bar, and possessing the gun. Mr. Veilleux then timely appealed to

this court.

ANALYSIS

Mr. Veilleux argues that the trial continuances violated his right to a timely trial

under CrR 3.3 and his constitutional right to a speedy trial. He also contends that the

court erred in not granting him a mitigated sentence. We will address those contentions

in the order stated.

3

No. 31480-4-111 State v. Veilleux

CrR 3.3

Mr. Veilleux argues initially that his time for trial rights were violated by the

continuances of the initial trial date rather than severing the defendants. As the trial court

properly found good cause to grant the continuances, this argument is without merit.

CrR 3.3 requires trial within 60 days of arraignment for defendants who are

detained on the current charges, while requiring trial within 90 days for all others,

including those held in custody on unrelated matters. CrR 3.3(a)(3)(v); CrR 3.3(b)(l),

(2). When a trial is continued in accordance with CrR 3.3(f)(2), the effect of the

continuance is to exclude the period of the continuance from the time for trial

period. CrR 3.3(e)(3). 1 The decision to grant or deny a continuance is reviewed for

abuse of discretion. State v. 0/livier, 178 Wn.2d 813,822-23,312 P.3d 1 (2013).

Discretion is abused when it is exercised on untenable grounds or for untenable reasons.

State ex rei. Carroll v. Junker, 79 Wn.2d 12, 26,482 P.2d 775 (1971).

Mr. Veilleux primarily argues that the trial court erred in continuing the cases

from the September 10 trial date to October 8 in order to keep the two defendants joined.

As Mr. Veilleux was in custody in Montana, the 90 day time for trial period applied to his

case. CrR 3.3(a)(3)(v). Since he had been arraigned on July 12, trial was required to be

held by October 10, 2012. Thus, even if the court had erred in granting severance and

1 When there is an excluded period, the time for trial does not expire until 30 days after the end of the excluded period. CrR 3.3(b)(5). This is colloquially known as a "buffer" period.

4


continuing the trial from the September 1Oth date, there was no violation of the rule

because the new October 8th trial date was still set within the original 90-day period.

Mr. Veilleux's argument is of no consequence.2

His real complaint is with the ensuing continuances, although he quite

understandably does not take issue with them, particularly since two of them were at

defense request. 3 Continuances in order to obtain a witness for trial or to accommodate

a witness or attorney's vacation are long recognized as valid under CrR 3.3. E.g.,

Torres, 111 Wn. App. at 331; State v. Se/am, 97 Wn. App. 140, 143, 982 P.2d 679

(1999); State v. Grilley, 67 Wn. App. 795, 799, 840 P.2d 903 (1992). Since each of the

continuances beyond the original trial date were for the valid purpose of obtaining or

accommodating witness schedules, there was no abuse of discretion.

Mr. Veilleux received a timely trial under CrR 3.3.

Constitutional Speedy Trial

Mr. Veilleux also contends that his constitutionally guaranteed right to a speedy

trial was also violated. Since he was tried within six months of his arraignment, he has

failed to articulate a constitutional speedy trial claim.

2 Joinder of defendants and maintaining joinder of defendants are valid bases for continuing a case. State v. Torres, 111 Wn. App. 323, 332, 44 P.3d 903 (2002). Thus, the court did not err in granting the continuance and denying severance.

3 The continuance rule concludes with this observation: "The bringing of such motion by or on behalf of any party waives that party's objection to the requested delay." CrR 3.3(f)(2) (final sentence).

5


Both the Sixth Amendment and article I, section 22 of the Washington

Constitution provide a right to a speedy trial. The rights provided by the two

constitutions are equivalent. State v. Iniguez, 167 Wn.2d 273, 290, 217 P.3d 768 (2009).

We review de novo an allegation that these rights have been violated. /d. at 280.

Because some delay is both necessary and inevitable, the appellant bears the burden of

demonstrating that the delay between the initial accusation and the trial was unreasonable

and created a "presumptively prejudicial" delay. /d. at 283. Once this showing is made,

courts must consider several nonexclusive factors in order to determine whether the

appellant's constitutional speedy trial rights were violated. /d. These factors include the

length and reason for the delay, whether the defendant has asserted his right, and the

ways in which the delay caused prejudice. Barker v. Wingo, 407 U.S. 514, 530,

92 S. Ct. 2182,33 L. Ed. 2d 101 (1972). None of the Barker factors are either sufficient

or necessary to demonstrate a constitutional violation. Iniguez, 167 Wn.2d at 283.

A delay ofless than 8 to 12 months will seldom even present a constitutional

question. /d. at 291-93. The more limited delay at issue here is not enough to raise a

claim of presumptive prejudice and there is no need to even conduct an analysis of the

other factors. /d. at 282-83. Our Supreme Court has expressly rejected any formulaic

presumption that leads to a threshold showing of presumptive prejudice; rather, it has

stated that this inquiry is necessarily dependent upon the specific circumstances of each

case. /d. at 283. Several factors to be considered in this initial inquiry include not only

6


the length of the delay, but the complexity ofthe charges and reliance on eyewitness

testimony. /d. at 292.

Those factors suggest a much lengthier delay in this case would have been

justified under the constitutions. The State listed 24 witnesses, and the defense would

need to interview many of those people. The defense also had its own witnesses,

including an important expert, and had to develop its self-defense case. As the charges

included attempted first degree murder, this was not a simple case to prepare. It is

impressive that the parties were able to bring the matter to a jury as rapidly as they did.

Mr. Veilleux has not established that there was a significantly long delay to justify

an inquiry into the constitutional speedy trial rights. Accordingly, there was no violation

of either constitutional speedy trial guarantee.

Sentencing

Lastly, both appellate counsel and Mr. Veilleux, in his Statement of Additional

Grounds (SAG), claim that the court erred in not granting him a mitigated sentence.4

Appellant presents no reviewable issue for our consideration.

The general rule is that a standard range sentence cannot be appealed.

RCW 9.94A.585(1). Accordingly, when the trial court declines to impose an exceptional

4 The SAG also raises a claim, without adequate supporting argument, that the officers improperly communicated with each other during trial. The claim presents no basis for relief. We also note that since he was acquitted on the other counts and admitted his guilt on the unlawful possession charge, he could not possibly have been prejudiced by any trial errors.

7


sentence, the only available method of attacking that decision is to establish that the

trial court failed to do something it was required to do at sentencing. State v. Mail,

121 Wn.2d 707, 712, 854 P.2d 1042 (1993). A defendant may also challenge the trial

court's usage of an impermissible basis for refusing an exceptional sentence.

State v. Garcia-Martinez, 88 Wn. App. 322, 329-30, 944 P.2d 1104 (I 997).

Here, Mr. Veilleux has not identified any required procedures that the sentencing

judge failed to follow. She considered, and ultimately rejected, his request for a

mitigated sentence. She similarly considered, and again rejected, his request that she

reconsider the sentence. He simply presented insufficient grounds for an exceptional

sentence.

Mr. Veilleux has not presented any basis for challenging the standard range

sentence imposed in this case. This argument, too, is without merit.

The conviction is affirmed.

A majority of the panel has determined this opinion will not be printed in the

Washington Appellate Reports, but it will be filed for public record pursuant to

RCW 2.06.040.

WE CONCUR:

Brown, J.

8

Date post:	09-Jun-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	vanthien
View:	217 times
Download:	0 times

ffU!L~fD) - Washington Petition for Review.pdf · filed ffu!l~fd) oct 1 :, 2014 s clerk of_the...

Documents