+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Fish and Crayfish Completed)

Fish and Crayfish Completed)

Date post: 06-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: astrini-nurul-sentanu
View: 218 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 185

Transcript
  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    1/185

    Fishandcrayfishcommunitiesof

    theBlackwood

    River:

    migrations,

    ecology,andinfluenceofsurface

    andgroundwater

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    2/185

    Fishandcrayfishcommunitiesofthe

    BlackwoodRiver:

    migrations,

    ecology,

    and

    influenceofsurfaceandgroundwater

    Preparedfor

    SouthWestCatchmentsCouncil

    &DepartmentofWater

    December,2006

    Preparedby

    Section1

    MigrationpatternsofthefishandcrayfishfaunaoftheBlackwoodRiverSJBeatty,FJMcAleer&DLMorgan

    CentreforFish&FisheriesResearch

    MurdochUniversity

    SouthStMurdoch

    WesternAustraliaEmail:[email protected]

    Section2

    CrayfishburrowingactivityintheregionoftheYarragadeeDischarge

    Zone,BlackwoodRiver

    AKoenders

    &

    PHJ

    Horwitz

    CentreforEcosystemManagement

    EdithCowanUniversity

    100JoondalupDrive,Joondalup

    WesternAustralia

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    3/185

    Summary

    Section1 Migration patterns of the fish and crayfish

    faunaoftheBlackwoodRiver

    SouthwesternAustraliahasahighlyendemicfreshwateraquaticfauna,with

    80%ofthefishesand100%ofthecrayfishesfoundnowhereelse. Eachofthe

    endemic fishes is found within the Blackwood River catchment, with two

    beingrestrictedtothefloodplainsoftheScottRiver;amajortributaryofthe

    Blackwood. Salinisation of the catchment has compromised the natural

    rangesofmanyofthefishes,withmanyofthenonhalotolerantspeciesnow

    restrictedtoforestedtributarieswithinthelowercatchmentandinthesection

    ofthemainchannelwheresalinity isreducedasaconsequenceofdischarge

    fromtheYarragadeeandLeedervilleaquifers.

    Prior to thisstudy,onlysnapshot fishsurveysaround themajorregionsof

    LeedervilleandYarragadeegroundwaterdischargeintotheBlackwoodRiver

    existed allowing only a limited understanding of the ecology of the fish

    communities and their relationship with key environmental variables;

    particularly surface and groundwater hydrology. This knowledge is

    important in the light of potential future increased groundwater extraction

    andclimatechange. Tofurthertheunderstandingofthefishcommunitiesof

    thisregion,Section1ofthisstudyexaminedthetemporalmigrationpatterns

    of fish and freshwater crayfish in this zone of the Blackwood catchment.

    Specifically, upstream and downstream migration patterns of fishes in the

    BlackwoodRiverand itstributarieswereexaminedandrelated toanumber

    ofkeyenvironmentalvariables,suchassurfaceandgroundwaterdischarge.Predictions of the effects on faunaby projected changes in environmental

    variables,forexample,duetoaquiferdrawdown(e.g.reduceddischargeand

    increasedsalinity)wereexamined.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    4/185

    Substantial differences in fish densities and migration patterns existed

    between and within the main channel and major tributaries. The main

    channel was dominatedby estuarine and salttolerant species at all sites.

    However, main channel sites receiving most groundwater discharge (i.e.

    receiving both Leederville and Yarragadee Aquifer discharge) had much

    greaterabundancesofnonsalt tolerant freshwaternativespecies than those

    sitesupstreamoftheYarragadeedischarge. Thissuggeststhatalthoughthe

    fish community in the main channel may have changed to primarily salt

    tolerantspeciesinresponsetoincreasingsaltlevels,freshgroundwaterinputinsummer(whenmanytributariesceasetoflowordrycompletely),maybe

    enablingthosespeciestocontinuetosurviveinthemainchannel.

    ThestudyalsorecordedaconsiderableupstreammigrationoftheFreshwater

    Cobbler at all main channel sites in spring and summer; a period that

    coincided with their spawning. It was found that upstream Freshwater

    Cobblermigrations inmain channelsiteswerehighlycorrelated tosummer

    discharge. Thisspeciesisconsideredtobeidealforlongtermmonitoringof

    riverconnectivity.

    The Marron population was assessed in the main channel and a slightly

    higherrelativeabundance(althoughnotstatisticallysignificant)wasrecorded

    withinsitesreceivingmostgroundwaterdischarge(i.e.bothLeedervilleandYarragadee Aquifer discharge) than those upstream. Marron catches have

    recentlybeen found tobepositivelycorrelatedwith river flowand thishas

    implications for the recreational fishery within the Blackwood River under

    reducedflowscenarios.

    Considerabledifferences in the timingandstrengthsoffishmigrationswere

    recordedbetweentributariesfortheWesternMinnow,NightfishandWestern

    Pygmy Perch, that utilised all four tributaries to varying degrees. It was

    foundthatthetributariesactasthemajorspawninghabitatsforthesespecies

    and the section of the main channel that receives the most groundwater

    discharge acts as a refuge to the summer contraction or drying of most of

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    5/185

    MilyeannupBrook isoneofonly two (alongwithPoisongully)perennially

    flowingtributariesinthisregionoftheBlackwoodandaredirectlyrelianton

    YarragadeeAquiferdischarge. Itwasapparent that thissystem isofcritical

    conservation importance as it houses the only population of the Balstons

    Pygmy Perch in the Blackwood River catchment (listed asVulnerable under

    the EPBC Act 1999). This study found a clear upstream and downstream

    spawningmigrationofBalstonsPygmyPerchinthissystemandfoundonly

    limitedupstreammovementfromthemainchannelsuggestingitisacrucial

    refuge to Balstons Pygmy Perch in the Blackwood River catchment. Bymapping fishdistributionsalong its length insummer, thestudyalso found

    thatBalstonsPygmyPerchonlyutilisedthelower~1300mofthe~2500mbase

    flowstreamlengthsuggestingthatonly~52%containedsuitablehabitat(e.g.

    adequatedepth)foroccupation. Theminimumpopulationofthisspecies in

    thissystemwas found tobe~38042 fishbasedon theirdensity. This low

    populationminimummakes thisspeciesparticularlyvulnerable topotential

    habitat decline; particularly if main channel summer water quality decline

    exceedsthisspeciesenvironmentaltolerance.

    A number of key knowledge gaps pertaining to the ecology of the fish

    communitiesare identified. Majorknowledgegaps includedetermining the

    degreeofinterannualvariationingroundwaterrelianceofthesecommunities,

    salinity tolerancesof thesespecies,and identifyingcriticalrifflezones in theBlackwoodRiverthatareimportantinmaintainingriverconnectivity.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    6/185

    Section2 Crayfishburrowingactivityintheregionofthe

    YarragadeeDischarge

    Zone,

    Blackwood

    River

    Astudyoftheburrowingactivityoffreshwatercrayfish intheregionof the

    Yarragadee Discharge Zone was conducted over the period of one year,

    starting September 2005. The aims of the study were to determine seasonal

    effects onburrowing activity for freshwater crayfish species in response to

    groundwater and surface water changes, and to relate these to emergentcrayfish. In addition, a pilot study of the chemical characteristics of surface

    andgroundwaterintheareawasundertakentodetermineifdischargefrom

    the Yarragadee wasdetectable and if it was a migratory cue for freshwater

    crayfish.

    TransectsweresetupincreeksreceivinginputfromtheYarragadee(LaymanBrook, Poison Gully and Milyeannup Brook), as well as in control sites

    upstream(McAteeBrook)anddownstream(RosaBrook).Burrowingdensity

    andactivityweremonitoredfromOctober2005toSeptember2006,aswellas

    basic surface water and groundwater physicochemistry. In addition,

    observationsweremadeofemergentcrayfishduringthedayandatnight.

    The study area appears tobe typicalburrowing habitat for southwesternAustralianfreshwatercrayfish.Fourspeciesoffreshwatercrayfishwerebeen

    identified:Marron(Cheraxcainii),Gilgie(C.quinquecarinatus),RestrictedGilgie

    (C.crassimanus)andKoonac(C.preissii).Burrowsandburrowingactivitywere

    highlyseasonalandprovidebaselinedataonfreshwatercrayfishresponsesto

    declinesinsurfaceandgroundwater.

    The very dry autumn and early winter experienced in 2006 resulted in a

    slower than usual recovery of water levels (i.e. water levels experienced in

    September 2005 were much higher than those found in the corresponding

    monthin2006).Whilesomemethodologicalproblemswereencountered(i.e.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    7/185

    - Koonacsaremorelikelytooccurinhabitatswithadeeperreachtothe

    watertable;

    - the Restricted Gilgie may have resident populations in the twopermanent streams receiving Yarragadee discharge throughout the

    year.

    Future monitoring of transects or other sites can test the following

    hypotheses:

    A.

    If

    groundwater

    decline

    in

    Milyeannup

    Brook

    and

    Poison

    Gully

    is

    extending

    beyond historical ranges then the burrowing activity of freshwater crayfish will

    produce soil from a lower stratigraphic soil layer than previously observed.

    B. Ifgroundwater decline is extending beyond historical ranges, thenperiods of

    burrowing activitywill occur earlier in spring, andburrowswill open later in the

    autumnorwinter.

    Water samples were also collected in November/December 2005 before

    surface waters had receded, where the influence of groundwater discharge

    wasrelativelyminimal,andinMarch2006whengroundwaterdischargewas

    a more significant contributor to surface waters. The elemental suites of

    samples from transect surface waters, and other selected sites were

    determined.Thepilotstudyofelementalwaterchemistrydemonstrated the

    potential for characterising the Yarragadee discharge. In addition, highS:(Ca+Mg) ratios in Poison Gully and Milyeannup Brook indicate poor

    buffering and, if confirmed, may show potential for acidification should

    sedimentsbecomeexposedduetodroughtand/orgroundwaterdecline.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    8/185

    Contents

    Summary...............................................................................................................3

    Contents................................................................................................................8

    Section1Migrationpatternsoffishandcrayfishfauna

    ofthe

    Blackwood

    River

    ... 10

    Background.............................................................................................................11FishandfreshwatercrayfishesoftheBlackwoodRiver...11

    Importanceofgroundwatertoaquaticfauna..12

    GroundwatercontributionstoBlackwoodRiverflow.... 13

    MilyeannupBrookandPoisonGully..... 14

    Aimsofthestudy... 14

    Methodology...........................................................................................................15Studysiteselection...15

    Waterqualitymonitoring...17

    Fishandcrayfishmonitoringprotocols....... 20

    Resultsanddiscussion.........................................................................................25

    Water

    quality

    in

    the

    main

    channel

    and

    tributaries....25Speciescapturesummary.....34

    FreshwaterCobbler..... 36

    WesternMinnow.....45

    MudMinnow......56

    BalstonsPygmyPerch....59

    WesternPygmyPerch.....63

    Nightfish......71

    Southwestern

    Goby.....79

    SwanRiverGoby.....84

    WesternHardyhead.....88

    PouchedLamprey.....94

    EasternMosquitofish..... 97

    Goldfish....... 100

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    9/185

    Section 2 Crayfish burrowing activity in the region of

    Yarragadee

    Discharge

    Zone,

    Blackwood

    River...140

    Aimsandobjectives........................................................................................141

    Crayfishburrowing...........................................................................................142Methods....................................................................................................................142Transectestablishmentanddesign....142

    Watercharacteristics....142

    Crayfishburrowmonitoring...144

    Results.......................................................................................................................146Transectdata.... 146

    BlackwoodRiverStPatricksElbow.....146

    LaymanBrookLaymanRoad........147

    LaymanBrooktributaryLaymanRoad....148

    LaymanBrookCrouchRd........149

    MilyeannupBrook

    Helyar

    Rd........151

    MilyeannupBrookMilyeannupRd..152

    McAteeBrookCrouchRd.........153

    McAteeBrooktributaryCrouchRd..154

    PoisonGullyBlackwoodRd..156

    RosaBrookCrouchRd..157

    RosaBrooktributaryCrouchRd...159

    RosaBrookheadwaterMowenRd....160

    RosaBrook

    gully

    Mowen

    Rd....161

    Transectcomparisons......162

    Burrowingactivityandmigratorybehaviourofspecies...164

    Discussionandrecommendations..... 166

    Waterchemistry.................................................................................................168Introduction...........168

    Methods.................. 168Results............. 169

    Discussionandrecommendations......171

    Appendices.........174

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    10/185

    Section 1

    Migrationpatterns

    of

    the

    fish

    and

    crayfish

    fauna

    of

    theBlackwoodRiver

    SJBeatty,FJMcAleer&DLMorgan

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    11/185

    BACKGROUND

    FishandfreshwatercrayfishesoftheBlackwoodRiver

    ThefishfaunaoftheBlackwoodRivercatchmentwasdocumentedinMorgan

    etal.(1998,2003)andthereareadditionalrecordsofthefishesintheWestern

    Australian Museum collections and in the unpublished literature. These

    includeabaselinestudyonfishesintheYarragadeeAquiferDischargeZone

    (hereafternamedYADZ)byMorgan&Beatty (2005)andbyCENRM (2005)andastudyonRosaBrook(Morganetal.2004). Distributionalinformationon

    freshwater crayfish in the region is detailed in Morrissy (1978), Austin &

    Knott(1996),Horwitz&Adams(2000),Nickoll&Horwitz(2000),Morganet

    al.(2004a)andMorgan&Beatty(2005).

    Ofnoteisthefactthatalleightspeciesoffreshwaterteleostthatareendemicto southwestern Western Australia are found within the Blackwood River

    catchment(Morganetal.1998,2003). Salinisationthroughoutbothmostofthe

    upper catchment and the main channel has led to adecline in the range of

    manyofthesaltintolerantfishesandmuchoftheuppercatchmentandmain

    channel is dominatedby salttolerant species (Morgan et al. 2003). Thus,

    salinisationofthecatchmenthasseenmanyofthespeciesthatarenottolerant

    tohighersalinitylevelsbecomerestrictedtotheforestedsectionsoftheriverthat receive discharge from sources such as the Leederville Aquifer and

    YarragadeeAquifer(Morganetal.2003,Morgan&Beatty2005). Thereislittle

    historical information on the fish and freshwater crayfish fauna of the

    receivingenvironmentsurroundingtheYarragadeedischargearea,however,

    CENRM (2005)recordedamaximumof fournativeandone introducedfish

    speciesfrom19mainchannelsitesandamaximumofthreenativefishspeciesfrom13tributarysitesfromsamplingduringJuly2004. Incontrast,Morgan

    &Beatty (2005) foundninenativeand two introduced fish species from six

    mainchannelsitessampledandninenativeandtwo introducedfishspecies

    from 21 tributary sites in this area of the catchment. Differences in the

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    12/185

    receivesummerinputfromtheYarragadee,11speciesoffishandfourspecies

    crayfishwere captured compared to four species of fishand two species of

    crayfishupstreamofthedischargezone. Furthermore,thefourspeciesoffishin the main channel in the upper riverine part of the study area were all

    halotolerant,whereasmostoftheadditionalspeciespresentinthesitesinthe

    lowersectionoftheriverarethoughttotolerateonlyrelativelylowsalinities.

    Anumberofspeciesfoundinthemainchannelaregenerallyabsentfromthe

    tributary sites sampled and vice versa. For example, Freshwater Cobbler(Tandanus bostocki), Western Hardyhead (Leptatherina wallacei), Swan River

    Goby(Pseudogobiusolorum)andSouthwesternGoby(Afurcogobiussuppositus)

    wereallpredominantlycaptured in themainchannel,whileMudMinnows

    (Galaxiella munda) and Balstons Pygmy Perch (Nannatherina balstoni) were

    restricted to tributariesand, in thecaseof the latter species, toessentiallya

    singletributary.

    Of the fish species known from the Blackwood River catchment: four are

    listedon theAustralianSociety forFishBiologysListofThreatenedFishes,

    whileone,BalstonsPygmyPerchhasrecently(2006)beenlistedasVulnerable

    undertheEPBCAct1999,and,alongwiththeMudMinnow isalso listedas

    Schedule1byCALMundertheWildlifeConservationAct1950. Theseendemic

    fisheshaveundergonemassivereductionsintheiroverallrangeoverthelast100years (Morganetal.1998), largelyasaresultofmodificationofhabitats,

    with salinisation of the major catchments a key threatening process (see

    Morganetal.2003).

    The11speciesof freshwatercrayfishesofWesternAustraliaareallendemic

    to the southwest region. Six of these belong to the genus Cherax, and

    although this

    is the most widely distributed freshwater crayfish genus in

    Australia, thenativeWesternAustralianCheraxspecieshavebeenshown to

    be monophyletic probably due to the long period of separation of south

    western Australia to the rest of the continent (Crandall et al. 1999). The

    remaining five native species of freshwater crayfish in Western Australia

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    13/185

    degree of dependency on groundwater (Boulton & Hancock 2006).

    Groundwaterdependentecosystemsare complex,often support a relatively

    diverse fauna and may provide refugia for relictual species, however theyvary in their degree of dependency on groundwater to maintain their

    compositionandfunction(Hattons&Evans1998,Poweretal.1999,Murrayet

    al.2003,Humphreys2006). Localisedareasofgroundwaterwaterdischarge

    into streams creates a unique environment known as the hyporheic zone.

    Characteristics of this region are important in maintaining populations of

    aquatic species, including fish. For example, the hyporheic zone oftenprovides a thermal refuge for aquatic speciesbybuffering against extreme

    upper and lower lethal temperatures (Power et al. 1999, Hayashi &

    Rosenberry 2002). The hyporheic zone influences water quality by

    maintaining flows independent of surface runoff, supplying dissolved

    oxygen, maintaining stream productivity, and providing habitat and

    maintainingmigratoryroutes. Thereareanumberofspecificexamplesthat

    document the importanceofgroundwater toparticular species inparticularsystems, however, Sear et al. (1999) considered that the nature of the

    importance of groundwater is difficult to determine at a regional scale,but

    shouldbeassessedatalocalorcatchmentlevel.

    Amajoraimofthestudywastodeterminetherelationshipbetweenfishand

    freshwater crayfish communities and environmental variables within theBlackwoodRiver;includingdegreeofgroundwaterdependency.

    GroundwatercontributionstoBlackwoodRiverflow

    The Yarragadee Aquifer groundwater currently discharges into the

    Blackwood River in the reachjust downstream of Laymans Brook tojust

    upstream of Milyeannup Brook (Figure 1). Although the Yarragadeegroundwaterdischarge contributesonly~1%of the940GLyr1of theannual

    Blackwood River discharge during the dry months, groundwater from the

    Yarragadee and Leederville Aquifers contribute tobetween 30100% of the

    dischargedependingontheamountofsummerrainfall(Strategen2006).This

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    14/185

    the freshwater native fish moving into the main channel in the Yarragadee

    Aquifer discharge zone. A previous study by Morgan & Beatty (2005)

    revealedthatmostofthesespecieswereabletoexistinthisdiluteddischargezone in the main channel during summeryet werenot found in significant

    numbersupstreamofthatzone.

    MilyeannupBrookandPoisonGully

    Asmentioned,MilyeannupBrookandPoisonGullyaretheonlypermanently

    flowingstreamsinthisregionoftheBlackwoodRiver. Theirbaseflows(dryperiod)aremaintainedbydirectdischargefromtheYarragadeeAquifertoa

    distanceof~2500and3500mfromtheirconfluencewiththemainchannelof

    theBlackwoodRiverduring2006. MilyeannupBrookhasarelativelydistinct

    channel form whereas Poison Gully is more diffuse with a lower gradient

    creatingalmostawetlandappearance insomesections. Due to thereliance

    ongroundwaterforpermanency,watertablereduction inthe lowersectionsof both Milyeannup Brook and Poison Gully would reduce baseflow

    dischargeandalsostreamlength(Strategen2006).

    Aimsofthestudy:Theoverallaimofthestudywastorelatepatternsoffishandcrayfish

    migrationstoprevailingenvironmentalvariablesintheBlackwoodRiver.

    Specificaims

    were

    to:

    Comparethepopulationdemographicsandmigrationsofthefish

    andfreshwatercrayfishfaunawithinareasoftheBlackwoodRiver

    main channel that receivemajor groundwater discharge to those

    upstreamsitesthatdonot.

    Describethepopulationdemographicsandmigrationsof thefish

    and freshwatercrayfish faunaassociatedwithin the tributariesofthe Blackwood River within the Yarragadee Aquifer discharge

    zone (i.e. Milyeannup Brook, Poison Gully and Layman Brook)

    andcompare these toadjacent tributaries thatarenot fedby this

    aquifer(i.e.RosaBrookandMcAteeBrook).

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    15/185

    METHODOLOGY

    Studysiteselection

    BlackwoodRivermainchannel

    Site selection for determining the temporal changes in population

    demographicsandmigrationsofthefishandcrayfishfaunaintheBlackwood

    Rivermainchannelwasbasedontheirdifferingproximitiestothemajorzone

    ofgroundwaterdischarge. Forexample,thefishfaunafoundwithintwositesintheBlackwoodRivermainchannelthatissubjectedtothemajordischarge

    of ground water (from the Yarragadee Aquifer) was compared to two sites

    upstreamofthisdischarge.

    The twositeswithin themainchannel that receivegroundwater inputwere

    immediately downstream of the mouth of Milyeannup Brook (34.0909

    o

    S115.5661oE) and just upstream of the mouth Rosa Brook (34.1081oS,

    115.4505oE). The two upstream sites include Jalbarragup Road crossing

    (34.0421oS,115.6025oE)andQuigup(33.9736oS,115.7008oE)(seeFigure1).

    Sampling was conducted in October, November and December 2005 and

    February, March,June, August and September 2006. See page 20 for the

    biologicalsamplingregime.

    BlackwoodRivertributaries

    MilyeannupBrookandPoisonGullyaredirectlymaintained indrymonths

    by groundwater discharge. Layman Brook receives groundwater discharge

    during winter and springbut not summer; when it ceases to flow. The

    temporalchangesinthepopulationdemographicsandmigrationsofthefishandcrayfishfaunawithinthesetributarieswerecomparedwithtwoadjacent

    tributariesthatflowseasonally,i.e.RosaBrookandMcAteeBrook;withinthe

    LeedervilleAquiferdischargezone.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    16/185

    Rosa Brook Layman Bk

    Milyeannup PoolDenny Rd

    Poison Gully

    Milyeannup Brook

    Jalbarragup

    McAtee Bk

    Quigup

    Main channel sites

    Tributary fyke net sites

    Seine/electrofishing tributary sites

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    17/185

    Waterqualitymonitoring

    In order to characterise the climatic regime during the sampling period,relative to thehistoricalclimateof the region, rainfalland temperaturedata

    were obtained for the Australian Bureau of Meteorology for Bridgetown; a

    locationforwhichlongtermdatawereavailable. Thisisimportantasithas

    implications in terms of the appropriateness of the biological data as a

    baselineand forunderstanding interannualvariations in futuremonitoring

    programs.

    Inordertogainamorepreciseunderstandingoftemperatureregimesofthe

    various tributaries sampled in this study, temperature data loggers

    (TinytagTM)wereplacedinsituintomigrationsamplingsitesinthetributaries

    (Figure 1) and programmed to log temperature every three hours.

    Temperature loggers were also put in situ at the Blackwood River main

    channel sites. Data from the loggers were downloaded and temperatureregimesofthevariousaquaticsystemsweregraphicallycompared.

    Oneach samplingoccasionat each site, the temperature (in addition to the

    temperature data loggers), conductivity, pH, and dissolved oxygen were

    obtainedfromthemiddleofthewatercolumnatthreelocationsateachsites

    andamean(1SE)determined.

    MonthlydischargeestimatesineachtributarysiteweretakenbyDepartment

    ofWater(Bunburybranch)staffattheapproximatetimesthatsamplingtook

    place for fishmigrations. Main channel dischargeswereobtained from the

    DepartmentofWatergaugingstationsatNannup(approximatingtheQuigup

    sampling site), Darradup (upstream of the Yarragadee discharge,

    approximatingJalbarragupsamplingsite),Gingilup(receivingthemajorityoftheYarragadeedischarge in themainchannel,approximating theDennyRd

    samplingsite). ThemonthlydischargefortheMilyeannupPoolsamplingsite

    (at the uppermost point of the Yarragadee discharge) was estimated as the

    average of the monthly Darradup and Gingilup discharges (see Figure 2)

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    18/185

    Lower Blackwood River

    HutPool

    Sues

    Bridge

    Gingilup

    0.0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    0.7

    0.8

    0.9

    1.0

    40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120Dist f rom Molloy Is. (km)

    Flow(m3/s)

    Flow (Mar2003)Flow (Mar2004)Flow (Feb2005)Flow (Mar2006)"LimitsBaseflowLBF (Mar2006)LBF (Mar2003)LBF (Mar2004)LBF (Feb2005)

    Layman Brook

    Darradup

    Poison Confl

    Milyeannup Confl

    609-1362

    Figure2 Snapshotofdischargewithin the studyarea inMarch2003,2004,2005and

    2006. N.B.verticaldotted linesapproximateYarragadeeAquifer discharge

    boundaries. FigurebyDepartmentofWater,Bunbury.

    Determiningkey

    environmental

    variables

    for

    migration

    strengths

    data

    analysis

    The relationships between the strength of native fish migrations in the

    tributaries and the main channel and key environmental parameters were

    examinedviaregressionanalyses. Fortributaries,thenativespeciesincluded

    in analyses were those where adequate migration data were recorded (i.e.utilised themostnumberof tributaries)and included theWesternMinnow,

    Western Pygmy Perch, and Nightfish. For the main channel, the analysis

    focused on the Freshwater Cobbler, which was captured in the greatest

    numbersatallsites.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    19/185

    this major flow and/or breeding period explained the most variation in

    upstreamanddownstreammigrationsofthosespecies.

    WithinthemainchanneloftheBlackwoodRiver,theassociationbetweenthe

    strength of upstream and downstream Freshwater Cobbler movements and

    the above key environmental variables (with discharge data obtained from

    the Department of Water gauging stations at Nannup, Darradup and

    Gingilup)weresimilarlyexamined. Firstly,allsamplingoccasionsatallsites

    were included in stepwise regression analysis to determine which of theenvironmentalvariablesexplained thevariation inupstreamordownstream

    Freshwater Cobbler movements in the Blackwood River. Secondly, overall

    meanupstreamanddownstreamFreshwaterCobblermovements ineachof

    the four main channel sites, pooled for the major migration period (i.e.

    betweenNovemberandJuly),werecorrelatedwiththeaboveenvironmental

    variables during that period to determine which, if any, accounted for the

    observeddifferencesinmigrationstrengthsbetweenthosesites.

    For the above analyses, ShapiroWilk statistical tests for normality were

    undertaken for each variable and all data were subsequently log10

    transformed prior to analysis. Bivariate correlations between each

    environmental variable were calculated (Pearsons correlation coefficient)

    prior to each stepwise regression analysis to initially examine relationshipsbetween environmental variables. Mean velocity was consistently highly

    correlated with discharge and was therefore excluded from the analyses to

    avoidproblemswithcolinearity.

    Inthesubsequentstepwiseregressionanalyses,levelsofcolinearitybetween

    independent variables were investigated via determining condition indexes

    and eigenvalues. The more conservative, adjusted coefficients of

    determination(r2)wereexaminedineachmodelastheadjustedvaluesclosely

    reflect thegoodnessof fitof themodel. The significanceof the modelsare

    alsopresented(pvalues)(SPSS,2005).

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    20/185

    Fishandcrayfishmonitoringprotocols

    A number of techniques were employed to examine the fish and crayfish

    faunaofthemainchannelandtributarysitesintheBlackwoodRiver(Figure

    3). Eachmethodisoutlinedbelow,i.e.theuseoffykenets(11.2minwidth,

    includingtwo5mwingsanda1.2mwidemouthfishingtoadepthof0.8m,

    5mlongpocketwithtwofunnelsallcomprisedof2mmwovenmesh);seine

    nets(5,10and15mnetscomprisedof2mmwovenmesh;anda26mseine

    netconsistingoftwo9mwingsof6mmwovenmeshandan8mbuntof3mmmesh);240and12velectrofishers;andcrayfishtraps.

    BlackwoodRivermainchannel

    Speciesmigrations

    At the fourmainchannelsites (seeFigures1and3), fykenetswereused to

    determine temporal trends inspeciesmigrations. Fykenetswereset facingupstream, to determine downstream movements of fish, and facing

    downstream, todetermineupstreammovementsof fish. Each fykenetwas

    setforaperiodof24hwiththreereplicatestakenoneachsamplingoccasion.

    Each fish and freshwater crayfish captured was identified, a subsample

    measured (total length (TL) for fish and orbital carapace length (OCL) for

    crayfish) to the nearest 1 mm and where possible sexed and released. Asubsampleofmostspecieswasretainedforanalysesofbiologicalindicessuch

    as gonadal development and aging, some of which are provided in this

    report,butmostofwhicharetobeinvestigatedfurther.

    Duetothehighvolumeofwaterandlargewidthofthemainchannelitwas

    rarely possible to completely block the main channel sites and thereforecapture all fish moving upstream or downstream past a point at the site.

    Therefore, themeannumberofeachspeciescapturedoneachoccasionwas

    adjusted to account for total number of each species migrating through a

    sectionof the river. Forexample, ifour fykenetsblocked90%of themain

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    21/185

    Figure3 Fykenetsset in (A) themostupperBlackwoodRivermainchannelsite, i.e.

    Quigup, (BC)Jalbarragup, (DE)upstreamofRosaBrook (DennyRd),and(F)MilyeannupPooldownstreamofMilyeannupBrookmouth.

    Speciesabundances

    A

    C

    B

    D

    E

    F

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    22/185

    BlackwoodRivertributaries

    On each sampling occasion (if the system was flowing), fyke nets were setover three days and nights in Milyeannup Brook (2 sites), Layman Brook,

    RosaBrookandMcAteeBrook(Figure4). Ateachsite,onenetwassetfacing

    upstream,tocapture fish thatweremovingdownstream,whileanotherwas

    set facing downstream (to capture fish moving upstream) and each was

    checkedevery24h (Figure4). Aswith themain channel site captures, the

    percentcoverageofeachsetwasdeterminedandthecatcheslateradjustedto100%ofthestreamwidth.

    A

    C

    B

    F

    D

    E

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    23/185

    Theshallow,diffusenatureofPoisonGullyprohibitedeffectivesamplingfor

    fish migration; therefore, a seasonal quantitative analysis of the fish and

    freshwater crayfish was undertaken using abackpack electrofisher. Threereplicate density estimates were taken with up to 90 m2 sampled on each

    occasion. In addition, electrofishing was employed in October 2005 in

    McAtee, Rosa and Layman Brooks and again in December 2005 in McAtee

    Brooktoexaminespeciesdemographics. Regardlessofcapturemethod,fish

    species were identified, with a large subsample measured for total length

    (mm TL) for fish and orbital carapace length (mm OCL) for freshwatercrayfishandbeforebeingreleased. Thosenotmeasuredwere identifiedand

    counted to determine total numbers. A small subsample of native species

    wasretainedforbiologicalinvestigationintothegonadaldevelopment(upto

    ~30permonth)andforfuturegeneticanalysis.

    Freshwatercrayfishwereidentified,measuredtothenearestmmOCL,sexed

    and released. A small number were retained for determination of size at

    sexualmaturity.

    Marronpopulationanalysis

    Samplingregime

    In order to compare the relative abundances of Marron at sites within the

    mainchanneloftheBlackwoodRiver,samplingforMarronoccurredatatotalof six sites in the Blackwood River on seven sampling occasions;

    correspondingwiththefishmigrationsampling. Inadditiontothefoursites

    sampled for fish migrations, an additional two were selected (near the

    confluence of Red Gully, upstream of the YADZ, and near the entrance of

    Laymans Brook, at the most downstream point of the YADZ) in order to

    sample a greater range of representative habitats within and outside of the

    majorzoneofgroundwaterdischarge toavoidpotentialbias resulting from

    accessibilitybyrecreationalfishers(Figure2).

    Oneachsamplingoccasion,up to13boxstylecrayfish trapsweredeployed

    i ht d i t l 15 t T b it d ith lt

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    24/185

    trappernight. ThestatisticalsignificanceofCPUEwastestedusinggeneral

    linearmodels (ANOVA)withLevenes testofhomogeneityofvariance first

    beingconductedanddatabeinglogtransformedwhennecessary.

    In order to compare population structures of Marron in the sites receiving

    YADZ (i.e. Milyeannup Pool; near the Laymans Brook confluence, and at

    DennyRoad;near theRosaBrookconfluence) to thosesitesupstreamof the

    zone (i.e.near the confluenceofRedGully,JalbarragupRoad crossing,and

    Quigup), lengthfrequency distributions over the sampling months wereproducedforeachof thetwozones. ThemajorspawningperiodofMarron

    was determinedby examination of the temporal pattern in proportions of

    femaleovarianstages(seeBeattyetal.2003,2005).

    The OCL at which 50 (L50) and 95% (L95) of female Marron mature in the

    BlackwoodRiverwasdeterminedbyundertakinglogisticregressionanalysis

    ofthepercentagecontributionsmadetoeachlengthclassbyindividualsthat

    containeddeveloping/maturegonads(stagesIIIVII). Datawererandomly

    resampled and reanalysed to create 500 sets ofbootstrap estimates. The

    logisticequationis:

    POCL=1/[1+eln19(OCL OCL50)/OCL95 OCL50)]

    wherePOCLis the proportion of Marron with mature gonads (seebelow) at

    lengthintervalOCL. OnlythoseindividualscapturedinJulyandAugust(i.e.

    immediatelyprior toand throughout thebreedingperiod,seeResults)were

    usedintheanalysis(forfullmethodologyseeBeattyetal.2004).

    FreshwaterCobblerpopulationanalysis

    Inorder to furtherexaminepatterns inmigrationsofFreshwaterCobbler,a

    totalof437weretaggedusingindividuallynumberedtbartagsateachmain

    channelsiteoverthestudyperiod(seeTable3). Thetotallengthofeachfish

    tagged and recaptured was measured to aid in the future validation of

    growthandmovementsof this species. Furthermore, ineachmonthof the

    i i ti i d (l t i l t Fi 17) th

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    25/185

    RESULTSandDISCUSSION

    Waterqualityinthemainchannelandtributaries

    Climateduringthestudyperiod

    The analysis of the seasonal pattern in climate for the region revealed an

    atypical pattern in air temperature and rainfall for the sampling year(s)

    comparedwithhistoricaldata(Figures5and6). Specifically,thefirsthalfof

    thesamplingperiod(i.e.spring2005andsummer20052006)wasunusuallycoolcomparedwiththelongtermaverage(Figure5). Furthermore,therewas

    an unusually late start to the wet season in 2006 (i.e.July compared with

    April/May historically) (Figure 6). Therefore, the seasonal patterns in fish

    movementsdescribed in this reportmaydiffer to thatofa typicalyearand

    this interannual variation requires quantification by further seasonal

    sampling. For example, the relatively late onset of winter rains in 2006probablyresultedindelayedseasonalsurfaceflowsinRosaBrook,Laymans

    BrookandMcAteeBrookthatarenotmaintainedbygroundwaterdischarge

    comparedtoMilyeannupBrookandPoisonGully,whichhaveperennialflow

    duetoYarragadeeAquiferdischarge.

    Temperature

    (C)

    20

    22

    24

    26

    28

    30

    32Study period

    Long term (1887-2004)

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    26/185

    Month

    Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep

    Rainfa

    ll(mm)

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    160

    180

    Monthly rainfall during study

    Long term monthly rainfall (1887-2004)

    2005 2006

    Figure6 Monthly rainfall in Bridgetown during the study period compared with the

    longtermaverage(18872004,source:AustralianBureauofMeteorology). N.B

    theaboveaveragerainfallfromOctober2005January2006andconsiderably

    laterstarttothewinterrainfall(i.e.July2006)andverydryautumncompared

    withthelongtermaverage.

    Aquaticenvironmentalvariables

    From the temperature data loggers (from which weekly means were

    determined to smooth the data), it was apparent that patterns of water

    temperatures in the Blackwood River and its tributaries corresponded with

    variationsinairtemperature(Figure7). However,theleastseasonalvariation

    (i.e. remained coolest in summer and warmest in winter), and thus more

    stable temperatures, were recorded in Milyeannup Brook. As noted, this

    system receives direct discharge from the Yarragadee Aquifer which

    maintainsperennial flow for the lower~2500mofstream length (seesection

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    27/185

    Month

    Nov Jan Mar May Jul Sep

    Watertem

    perature(C)

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    Milyeannup Brook - Brockman Hwy

    Rosa Brook - Denny Rd

    McAtee Brook - Longbottom Rd

    Laymans Brook - Denny Rd

    Blackwood River- Milyeannup Pool

    Milyeannup Brook - Blackwood Rd

    Bridgetown mean maximum air temperature

    Blackwood River - Denny Rd

    Figure7 Mean weekly temperatures (1 SE) at the sampling sites in the tributaries, two

    main channel sites (Milyeannup Pool at the upstream point of Yarragadee

    discharge and Denny Rd receiving all of the Yarragadee discharge), and themaximumairtemperatureatBridgetown. N.B.the lowerseasonalfluctuationof

    the mean temperature in lowerMilyeannupBrook (maintainedbygroundwater

    discharge) compared with those reliant on surface flows, and the marked

    influenceofairtemperatureonwatertemperatureatthesesites.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    28/185

    Month

    Oct Nov Dec Feb Mar Jun Aug Sep

    Temperature

    (C)

    10

    12

    14

    16

    18

    20

    22

    24

    26 Denny Rd

    Milyeannup Pool

    Jalbarragup

    Quigup

    2005 2006

    Figure8 Meantemperatures(1S.E.)atthesamplingsitesinthemainchannelofthe

    BlackwoodRiveroneachsamplingoccasion.

    This consistency of water quality in the two perennial tributaries was

    highlighted by the relatively consistent conductivities recorded in these

    systems compared with systems that cease flowing. Those latter systemsincrease in conductivity during summer as a result of evapoconcentration

    (Figure 9a). The increased cumulative discharge of groundwater into the

    mainchannelduringsummerattheMilyeannupPoolandDennyRdresults

    in those sites having reduced conductivities (e.g. ~2030 S/cm at Denny Rd in

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    29/185

    A

    Month

    Oct Nov Dec Feb Mar Jun Aug Sep

    Conductivity(S/cm)

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    Rosa Brook

    Laymans Brook

    McAtee BrookMilyeannup Brook - upstream

    Milyeannup Brook - downstream

    St Johns Brook

    Poison Gully

    2005 2006

    B

    Conductiv

    ity(S/cm)

    2000

    3000

    4000

    5000

    6000

    7000

    8000

    Denny Rd

    Milyeannup Pool

    JalbaragupQuigup

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    30/185

    Month

    Oct Nov Dec Feb Mar Jun Aug Sep

    pH

    3.5

    4.0

    4.5

    5.0

    5.5

    6.0

    6.5

    7.0

    7.5

    Rosa Brook

    Laymans Brook

    McAtee Brook

    Milyeannup Brook - upstream

    Milyeannup Brook - downstream

    St John

    Poison Gully

    2005 2006

    Figure10 MeanpH(1S.E.)atthesamplingsitesinthetributaries. N.B.theincreased

    acidityinRosaBrookduringthedryperiodinMarchandJune2006.

    pH7.0

    7.5

    8.0

    8.5

    Denny Rd

    Milyeannup Pool

    Jalbaragup Rd

    Quigup

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    31/185

    Month

    Oct Nov Dec Feb Mar Jun Aug Sep

    Dissolvedoxygen(ppm)

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    16

    18

    Rosa Brook

    Laymans Brook

    McAtee Brook

    Milyeannup Brook - upstream

    Milyeannup Brook - downstreamSt Johns Brook

    Poison Gully

    2005 2006

    Figure12 Meandissolvedoxygen(1S.E.)atthesamplingsitesinthetributariesofthe

    BlackwoodRiveratthetimesofsampling. N.B.thelessseasonalfluctuation

    in lower Milyeannup Brook compared with tributaries not receiving

    YarragadeeAquifergroundwater.

    solvedoxygen(pp

    m)

    10

    12

    14

    16

    18

    20

    Denny Rd

    Milyeannup Pool

    Jalbarragup

    Quigup

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    32/185

    Rosa Brookhad the greatestdischargeof any tributary; peaking inOctober2005, at the start of the study (Figure 14). Milyeannup Brook and Poison

    Gully (although not gauged) continued to flow throughout the dry months

    due togroundwaterdischarge (Figure14). Therewasageneral increase in

    thedischargeratesmovingdownstream inthemainchannelsites(Figures2

    and15). Asmentioned,climaticallythiswasanatypicalyearasreflectedby

    relativelylowdischargeupuntilAugust2006(Figure15). OfparticularnoteisthegreaterdischargeatGingilupcomparedwithDarradupduringthedry

    months (FebruaryJuly, Figure 2). This is due to Gingilup receiving the

    majorityoftheYarragadeeAquiferdischargeintothemainchannelwhereas

    Darradup isupstream from thedischargezone (Figure15). Thishighlights

    thefactthatgroundwatercontributestobetween30and100%ofthesummer

    dischargeoftheBlackwoodRiver(Strategen2006).

    Oct Nov Dec Feb Mar Jun Aug Sep

    Meandischarge(m3/sec

    )

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4Rosa Brook

    Laymans Brook

    McAtee Brook

    Milyeannup Brook - upstream

    Milyeannup Brook - downstream

    Poison Gully

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    33/185

    Month

    Oct05

    Nov05

    Dec05

    Jan06

    Feb06

    Mar06

    Apr06

    May06

    Jun06

    Jul06

    Aug06

    Sep06

    Oct06

    Nov06

    Dec06

    Disch

    arge(m3/sec

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35Nannup

    Darradup

    GingilupHut pool

    Figure15 Monthlymeandischarges(1SE)inmainchannelsitesoftheBlackwoodRiver

    at the times of sampling. N.B. the greater discharge in Gingilup (receiving

    downstream of groundwater discharge zones) compared with Darradup

    (upstreamof theYarragadeedischargezone) fromFebruaryJune2006 (see

    alsoFigure2).

    Themaintenanceofrelativelylowmainchannelsalinitiesasaconsequenceof

    groundwater intrusions has considerable ecological implications as during

    summer, when the majority of tributaries cease flowing, many fish must

    retreatintothemainchannel. Duringwinter,whenthehighestconductivities

    areexperienced(Figure9),thoseindividualscanutilisethethenflowingfresh

    tributariestoescapetheelevatedmainchannelsalinitiesthatmayexceedtheir

    tolerance levels. Therefore, saltintolerant species, particularly Balstons

    PygmyPerch,WesternPygmyPerchandNightfish,thatarecurrentlyableto

    utilise thisdilutedsectionof theBlackwoodRiver,maynotbeable todoso

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    34/185

    Speciescapturesummary

    During this study, six endemic freshwater fish species, three estuarine fishspecies and three introduced fish species were captured. The anadromous

    (i.e. migrates into rivers from the ocean to breed) Pouched Lamprey, a

    southernhemisphereagnathan (i.e.jawless fish)wasalsocaptured,butwas

    foundinonlytwotributaries. Thesixfishspeciescapturedthatareendemic

    to southwestern Australia were the Freshwater Cobbler, Western Minnow,

    Mud Minnow, Balstons Pygmy Perch, Western Pygmy Perch, and the

    Nightfish. The estuarine species captured were the Western Hardyhead,

    SouthwesternGobyandtheSwanRiverGoby. The three introduced fishes

    capturedweretheEasternMosquitofish,GoldfishandRainbowTrout.

    Four species of endemic freshwater crayfish were captured, including the

    Marron,Gilgie,RestrictedGilgieandKoonac.

    Below is an account of the distribution, population demographics and

    migration patterns of each species. See also Section 2 for information

    regardingcrayfishburrowingactivity.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    35/185

    Table1 Thetotal(andadjusted)numberofeachspeciesoffishandfreshwater

    crayfishcapturedinfykenetsintheBlackwoodRivermainchannelsites.

    Total number (adjusted for stream width) of individuals caught in

    the Blackwood main channel using Fyke nets.

    MOVEMENT

    SPECIES

    Downstream Upstream Total # Captured

    Endemic

    freshwater fishesFreshwater Cobbler 526 (1539.3) 1280 (5729.5) 1806 (7268.8)

    Western Minnow 22 (175) 463 (3193.3) 485 (3368.3)

    Mud Minnow 0 0 0

    Balstons Pygmy Perch 0 2 (40) 2 (40)

    Western Pygmy Perch 14 (54) 0 14 (54)

    Nightfish 11 (73) 4 (28.3) 15 (101.3)

    Estuarine fishes

    South-west Goby 94 (563) 26 (158.3) 120 (721.3)

    Swan River Goby 6 (34.7) 4 (10) 10 (44.7)

    Western Hardyhead 13 (59.7) 12 (69.7) 25 (129.3)

    Introduced fishes

    Eastern Mosquitofish 14 (75) 13 (45) 27 (120)

    Goldfish 0 0 0

    Rainbow Trout 0 0 0

    Endemic crayfishes

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    36/185

    FreshwaterCobbler

    Habitatassociations

    The Freshwater Cobbler is essentially restricted to the main channel of the

    Blackwood River (Figure 16, Appendices 1 and 2). The few individuals

    capturedinthetributariesweregenerallysmallerfishwithonlyfive,twoand

    17 captured in Rosa Brook, McAtee Brook and Milyeannup Brook,respectively (Figure 17). This was expected given this relatively large

    (comparedtoothernativespeciesoftheregion)fishismorecommonlyfound

    inthelargerriversandreservoirsinthisregion.

    Migrationpatterns

    Onalmostallsamplingoccasions, thestrengthof theupstreammigrationofFreshwaterCobblerwasgreaterthan thedownstreammigration(Figure16).

    The migration strength peaked in late spring and summer, with greatest

    migrationstrengthbeingrecordedinthemoredownstreamsitesthatreceived

    greater groundwater discharge (i.e. Denny Rd and Milyeannup Pool)

    compared to the upstream sites (i.e. Jalbarragup and Quigup). Spatial

    differences in migratory patterns existed within the main channel with the

    peak upstream migrations in the downstream sites occurring duringFebruary, compared to March and November in Quigup andJalbarragup,

    respectively(Figure16). MovementofFreshwaterCobblerwasataminimum

    duringwinter.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    37/185

    the fact that Freshwater Cobbler movements increased during periods of

    elevatedwatertemperatures(i.e.summer).

    ThemeanstrengthofupstreammovementofFreshwaterCobbleratthemain

    channel sitesduring the peakmovementperiod (i.e. late spring to autumn:

    November toJuly samples inclusive) was highly correlated with the mean

    discharge at those sites over that period (Figure 21). Regression analysis

    revealed that the overall mean monthly dischargebetween November and

    July at these sites explained ~96% (p=0.014) of the variationbetween main

    channelsitesinFreshwaterCobblermovementintheBlackwoodRiver. That

    is,thegreaterthesummerdischargeatthesesites,thegreaterthestrengthof

    migration of this species. This movement is probably due to this species

    accessinghabitatsforspawningandfeeding.

    Of the437 taggedFreshwaterCobbler,a totalof86 (19.7%)wererecaptured

    (Table3). Of these,68wererecapturedonce,12 twice, four three timesandtwowererecapturedfourtimes(Table3). Withtheexceptionofonefish,all

    were caught at the initial tagcapture site. This suggests that there is a

    relativelyhighdegreeofsitefidelitybythisspeciesintheBlackwoodRiver.

    Although a high degree of site fidelity occurs in this system, there are

    nonethelesslarge localisedupstreammigrationsbythisspeciesduringtimesoflowflowasaprecursortospawning. Asmuchofthedryperioddischarge

    intheBlackwoodRiver isadirectresultofgroundwaterdischarge(30100%

    in the driest two months), this species appears reliant on this groundwater

    discharge to facilitate such spawning migrations. This groundwater

    dischargeisthereforeimportantinprovidingadequatepassagethroughriffle

    zones that would otherwise be barriers to its migration; and would be

    particularimportantinyearsoflowinputofsurfaceflows.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    38/185

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    1400

    Downstream movementUpstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    1400

    Denny Road

    Milyeannup Pool

    Me

    annumberoffish

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    1400

    Jalbarragup

    1400

    Freshwater Cobbler (T. bostocki)

    NS NS

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    39/185

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    Rosa Brook

    Layman Brook

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    Milyeannup Brook

    eroffish

    6

    8

    10

    McAtee Brook

    Freshwater Cobbler (T. bostocki)

    DRY DRY

    NFNF

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    40/185

    Mean Gonadosomatic Indices (+1SE)

    Month

    November December February March

    Gonados

    omaticindex

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    Female

    Male

    19

    37

    47

    65

    3 2211

    20

    Figure18 Meangonadosomatic indices(GSI) (+1SE)formaleandfemaleFreshwater

    CobblerinthemainchanneloftheBlackwoodRiverbetweenlatespringand

    earlyautumn.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    41/185

    log10 mean temperature (oC)

    1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4

    log10meanfrequencyof

    fish

    0.5

    1.0

    1.5

    2.0

    2.5

    3.0

    3.5log10N = 4.77*log10T- 3.86r2 = 0.54

    Figure19 RelationshipbetweenthemeanstrengthoftheupstreammigrationofFreshwater

    Cobbler and the mean temperature in the Blackwood River main channelthroughoutthesamplingperiod.N.B.datawerelog10transformedandmigration

    numberwasstandardisedforeffort,seetextfordetails.

    eanfrequencyoffis

    h

    1.0

    1.5

    2.0

    2.5

    log10N = 3.53*log10D- 3.22r2

    = 0.37

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    42/185

    log10 mean discharge (M3/sec)

    -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25

    log1

    0meanfrequencyoffish

    1.8

    2.0

    2.2

    2.4

    2.6

    2.8

    log10N = 2.63*log10D+2.11r2

    = 0.97

    Figure21 Relationship between the mean strength of the upstream migration of

    Freshwater Cobbler and the mean discharge in the Blackwood River main

    channelbetweenNovemberandJuly.N.B.Datawerelog10transformedand

    migrationnumberwasstandardisedforeffort,seetextfordetails.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    43/185

    43

    Table2 CorrelationsbetweenoverallmeanupstreamanddownstreammovementsofFreshwaterCobberinthe

    mainchannelsitesoftheBlackwoodRiverandprevailingenvironmentalvariablesduringthemigration

    period(NovembertoJuly).N.B.Datawerelog10transformed,*denotescorrelationissignificantatthe

    0.05level(2tailed).

    Logtemperature

    Logconductivity Log pH Log O2

    Logdischarge

    Upstreammovement

    Log conductivity Pearson Correlation .358

    Sig. (2-tailed) .642

    Log pH Pearson Correlation .733 .414

    Sig. (2-tailed) .267 .586

    Log O2 Pearson Correlation -.498 -.983* -.444

    Sig. (2-tailed) .502 .017 .556

    Log discharge Pearson Correlation -.470 -.787 -.837 .752

    Sig. (2-tailed) .530 .213 .163 .248

    Upstream movement Pearson Correlation -.426 -.680 -.871 .634 .986*

    Sig. (2-tailed) .574 .320 .129 .366 .014

    Downstreammovement

    Pearson Correlation.273 -.690 -.241 .550 .700 .687

    Sig. (2-tailed) .727 .310 .759 .450 .300 .313

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    44/185

    44

    Table3 FreshwaterCobblertaggedandrecapturedinmainchannelsitesoftheBlackwoodRiver.N.B.Includes%recapturedper

    siteand%totalofallrecaptureswhencomparedtototalnumbertagged.

    SITE Number

    Tagged

    # Recaptured

    (%)

    # Recaptured Twice

    (%)

    # Recaptured 3 times

    (%)

    #Recaptured 4 Times

    (%)

    Denny Road 215 42

    (19.5)

    8

    (3.7)

    1

    (0.5)

    MilyeannupPool 42 7(16.7)

    Jalbarragup 110 17

    (15.5)

    4

    (3.6)

    3

    (2.7)

    2

    (1.8)

    Quigup 70 2

    (2.9)

    TOTAL

    (%)

    437 68

    (15.6)

    12

    (2.7)

    4

    (0.9)

    2

    (0.5)

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    45/185

    WesternMinnow

    Habitatassociations

    TheWesternMinnowwascapturedatthemajorityofsitessampledonmost

    occasions, with large numbers recorded in both the main channel sites

    (Appendix 1) and in the tributaries (Appendix 2). This widespread

    distribution,beingpresentinnearlyallhabitatssampled,reflectsthisspecies

    tolerance to a wide range of salinities; having previouslybeen recorded insalinitiesup to~24pptor~two thirds thesalinityofseawater (Morganand

    Beatty2004).

    Migrationpatterns

    TherewerelimitedmovementsofWesternMinnowinthetwomostupstream

    main channel sites compared to the more downstream sites, i.e. Denny Rdand Milyeannup Pool (Figure 22). Within these latter sites, the upstream

    movement of Western Minnow was strongest during winter and peaked in

    Augustwith,onaverage,over300individualsrecordedmovingupstreamper

    day. Thesefishwerelargeadultsthatwerelikelytobemovingasaprecursor

    tospawning (Figures2325). Migration intoMilyeannupBrookwashigh in

    Augustandtherewaslimitedmovementofadultsintotheothertributariesat

    this time. Latermigration ofadults was recorded into the other tributariesfromAugusttoNovember. UpstreammigrationsofadultWesternMinnow

    continued in Milyeannup Brook throughout the entire sampling period;

    presumablyasaconsequenceof theperennial flowsof thesystem resulting

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    46/185

    to December for Rosa Brook and McAtee Brook. Only limited recruitment

    occurredinLaymanBrook.

    TheearlierrecruitmentoffishfromMilyeannupBrookisfurtherhighlighted

    bythelargersizeofthiscohortcomparedtothoseinRosaBrookinDecember

    (i.e.modallength5055mmTLcomparedto2530mmTL)(Figure27). This

    earlier spawning in Milyeannup Brook, presumably as a consequence of

    perennialflowsallowingearlieraccesstothetributary,isfurtherhighlighted

    whenconsideringthatthenewrecruitsinthisstreamhadamodal lengthof

    3540mmTLduringOctober,whichis10mmgreaterthanthenewrecruitsin

    RosaBrooktwomonthslater(Figure27).

    Examinationof lengthfrequencyhistogramsof fish caught inmain channel

    sites compared to tributary sites reveals that the vast majority of Western

    Minnows thatwe captured that were less than40 mm TL wereonly found

    withinthetributaries. Thisstronglysuggeststhatbreedingtakesplacewithintributariesand that thesehabitatsare thereforevitalspawningareas for this

    species.

    TherearesubstantialdifferencesinthepopulationdemographicsofWestern

    Minnows in the main channel sites. Specifically, fish captured in the two

    mostdownstreamsitesgrew toasubstantially largersize implying that the

    species hadgreater longevityat thedownstream sites compared to the two

    upstreamsites. Forexample,of the fish thatweregreater than100mmTL,

    almostallwerefoundattheDennyRdandMilyeannupPoolsites(thatboth

    receiveYarragadeeAquiferdischarge).

    The upstream and downstream migration of the Western Minnow in the

    varioustributarieswerebothfoundtobepositivelycorrelatedwiththemeandischarge from the tributaries during the major flow period (August to

    December)(Table4). Fromtheregressionanalysis,meandischargeexplained

    ~92% (p=0.027)and87% (p=0.044)of thevariation in themeandownstream

    d t i ti f W t Mi b t th t ib t i d i

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    47/185

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    600

    700

    Denny Road

    Milyeannup Pool

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    Jalbarragup

    eroffish

    300

    400

    500 Quigup

    Western Minnow (G. occidentalis)

    NS NS

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    48/185

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20Downstream Migration

    Upstream Migration

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    30

    40

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    n=37

    n=2

    n=4

    n=163

    n= 177

    n=6

    n=17

    Western Minnow (Galaxias occidentalis)

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    49/185

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Numberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    20

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June/July

    August

    September

    Denny Rd

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    Numberoffish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    60

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June/July

    August

    September

    Milyeannup Pool

    NS

    NS

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    50/185

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Numberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    20

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June/July

    August

    September

    Jalbarragup

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Numberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    20

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June/July

    August

    September

    Quigup

    NS

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    51/185

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    Rosa Brook

    Layman Brook

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    Milyeannup Brook

    offish 200

    250

    McAtee Brook

    Western Minnow (G. occidentalis)

    DRY DRY

    NFNF

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    52/185

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    Rosa Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    Milyeannup Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Western Minnow (Galaxias occidentalis)

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

    n=16

    n=53

    n=310

    n=17

    n=46

    n=339

    n=306

    n=117

    n=241

    n=162

    n=34

    n=13

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    53/185

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40 Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    Layman Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    McAtee Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    20

    30

    40

    Downstream

    Upstream

    Western Minnow (Galaxias occidentalis)

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    DRY

    DRY

    DRY

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

    n=58

    n=68

    n=37

    n=10

    n=113

    n=60

    n=25

    n=0

    n=22

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    54/185

    log10 mean discharge (M3/sec)

    -1.4 -1.2 -1.0 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0

    log10meanfrequ

    encyoffish

    0.6

    0.7

    0.8

    0.9

    1.0

    1.1

    1.2

    1.3log10N = 0.39*log10D+ 1.19r2 = 0.91

    Figure29 Relationshipbetween themean strength ofupstream migrationof Western

    Minnows within the major flow period (August and December) and the

    mean discharge in the four tributaries during that period. N.B. Data were

    log10 transformed and migration was standardised for effort, see text for

    details.

    og10meanfrequencyoffish

    1.0

    1.2

    1.4

    1.6

    1.8

    2.0log10N = 0.74*log10D+ 1.89r2 = 0.95

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    55/185

    55

    Table4 CorrelationsbetweenupstreamanddownstreammovementofWesternMinnowsinthetributariesoftheBlackwoodRiverandprevailing

    environmentalvariablesduringthemigrationperiod.N.B.Datawerelog10transformed,*denotescorrelationissignificantatthe0.05level

    (2tailed).

    Logtemperature

    Logconductivity Log pH Log O2

    Logdischarge

    Upstreammovement

    Log conductivity Pearson Correlation .686

    Sig. (2-tailed) .314

    Log pH Pearson Correlation -.508 -.677

    Sig. (2-tailed) .492 .323

    Log O2 Pearson Correlation .229 .589 .182

    Sig. (2-tailed) .771 .411 .818

    Log discharge Pearson Correlation -.131 .600 -.573 .311

    Sig. (2-tailed) .869 .400 .427 .689

    Upstream movement Pearson Correlation -.129 .633 -.379 .563 .956*

    Sig. (2-tailed) .871 .367 .621 .437 .044

    Downstreammovement

    Pearson Correlation.025 .666 -.747 .187 .973* .879

    Sig. (2-tailed) .975 .334 .253 .813 .027 .121

    Mud Mi o

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    56/185

    MudMinnow

    Habitatassociations

    The Mud Minnow was only captured in the tributaries of the Blackwood

    River(Appendix2)andthereforeisolationofthepopulationsinthesesystems

    maybeoccurringwiththemainchanneleffectivelyactingasasaltbarrierto

    population mixing; however, this requires further investigation. It was

    recordedinPoisonGully,MilyeannupBrook,RosaBrookandMcAteeBrook;however,notinLaymansBrook(Appendix2). Thissuggeststhatthisspecies

    prefers tributaries with either permanent (Milyeannup Brook and Psoin

    Gully)orextended(RosaBrookandMcAteeBrook;thatbothhavesubstantial

    remnant pools when they cease to flow) flow periods. Mud Minnows

    naturallyexist in lowabundancescompared toothernativespecies (suchas

    the Western Minnow) as was the case in this study with the speciesbeing

    recordedinlowernumbersthananyothernativefreshwaterfish;andonly90individualsbeingcaptured. Morgan&Beatty(2005)alsoreportedthisspecies

    in StJohn Brook and Red Gully. The upper reaches of Rosa Brook, which

    receiveLeedervilleAquiferdischarge,areaknown refuge for thespecies in

    thatsystem(Morganetal.2004a).

    Migration

    patterns

    Due to the relatively low numbers of Mud Minnows, there were few clear

    obvious trends in the movement patterns of this species in these systems

    (Figure31). The largestnumbersrecorded infykenetswere inMilyeannup

    Brook where on average 12 and six fish were recorded moving downstream

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    57/185

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    RosaBrook

    Layman Brook

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    Milyeannup Brook

    beroffish

    15

    20

    McAtee Brook

    Mud Minnow (G. munda)

    NF NF

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    58/185

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    68

    10

    Rosa Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    46

    8

    10

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    Milyeannup Brook

    Nu

    mberofFish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    8

    10

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Mud minnow (Galaxiella munda)

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

    n=0

    n=0

    n=2

    n=2

    n=2

    n=15

    n=18

    n=0

    n=0

    n=1

    n=3

    n=10

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    59/185

    BalstonsPygmyPerch

    Habitatassociations

    Balstons Pygmy Perch is the most restricted fish species found within the

    BlackwoodRivercatchmentandhasrecently(2006)been listedasVulnerable

    undertheEPBCActandlistedbyCALMasSchedule1(WildlifeConservation

    Act, 1950). Balstons Pygmy Perch was effectively only captured within

    MilyeannupBrookwith3160of the 3177 fish (or99.46%)being recorded in

    this stream; many of thesejuveniles with thebase population found tobemuch lessmuch less (seesectionMilyeannupBrookCaseStudy) (Figure33,

    Appendix2). Thus,MilyeannupBrook is the crucial refugehabitat for this

    speciesintheBlackwoodRivercatchment;probablyduetotheconsistencyof

    suitable available habitat facilitated by the permanency of flow due to

    groundwaterdischargeinthissystem.

    FourindividualswerecapturedinMcAteeBrookduringAugust2006;whilea

    further 13 fish were captured in Milyeannup Pool near the mouth of

    Milyeannup Brook. The lengths recorded for this species in Milyeannup

    Brook were considerably greater than has previouslybeen reported for the

    species (see Morgan et al. 1995). The lengthfrequency distribution of this

    species suggest that themodal lengthof the fish captured in August (5070

    mmTL)arelikelytobe1yearold;whilethosefishgreaterthan70mmTLare

    most likelyat theendof their secondor third year of life (Figure 34). The

    relativelyhighlongevityoftheMilyeannupBrookpopulationcontrastswith

    thoseelsewherethathaveonlybeenfoundtoliveforjustoveroneyear(see

    Thus,thisupstreammigrationwasundoubtedlyadultsreadytospawn;likely

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    60/185

    p g y y p y

    moving upstream to offset the downstream movement of eggs and/or

    larvae/juveniles. During September there was a considerable downstreammovement of spent (recently spawned) fish; suggesting the peak spawning

    period was August in Milyeannup Brook. Subsequently, large numbers of

    new recruits were captured moving downstream in November and

    December.

    During December a few individuals were captured near the mouth of

    MilyeannupBrook(inthemainchannel)anditisevidentthatthesefishhadleftthestream. However,anumberalsomovedbackintothestreamatthis

    time. DuringAugust,asmallnumberofadultswerealsocapturedmoving

    upstreaminMilyeannupPool,presumablyontheirwaytoMilyeannupBrook

    tocommencespawning(Figure35).

    Meannum

    beroffish

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Rosa Brook

    Layman Brook

    beroffish

    200

    500

    600

    700

    800

    Milyeannup Brook

    Balston's Pygmy Perch (N. balstoni)

    NF NF

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    61/185

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    40

    80

    120

    0

    20

    40

    60

    Milyeannup Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    20

    30

    40

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Balston's Pgymy Perch (N. balstoni)

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    62/185

    Meannumberoffis

    h

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Denny Road

    Milyeannup Pool

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    Jalbarragup

    roffish

    60

    80

    100 Quigup

    Baltston's Pgymy Perch (N. balstoni)

    NS NS

    h

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    63/185

    WesternPygmyPerch

    Habitatassociations

    WesternPygmyPerchwererecordedmovingateachsitewithinRosaBrook,

    MilyeannupBrookandMcAteeBrookoneachsamplingoccasion(Figure36).

    This species was not captured in Layman Brook and very few were found

    moving in the main channel sites; with none found migrating at the most

    upstreamsite,Quigup(Figure37). Veryfewindividualswerecapturedinthe

    main channel sites during the quantitative sampling (Appendix 1). This

    suggeststhatthisspeciesislargelyreliantonthefreshwatertributariesinthis

    region;reflectingarelativelylowtolerancetosalineconditions.

    Migrationpatterns

    BothupstreamanddownstreammovementsofWesternPygmyPerchwererecorded at most tributary sites on most sampling occasions (Figure 36).

    Migration strength was greatest within Rosa Brook; which appeared to

    support the largestpopulationofWesternPygmyPerchofany system. As

    thisspeciesisknowntobreedinspring,itislikelythatmuchoftheupstream

    migration impetus were for reproductive purposes. The subsequent

    downstreammovementbythisspeciesinRosaBrookinDecember,aswellas

    inMilyeannupBrookandMcAteeBrook,appearedtoconsistoffishthathad

    spawned(i.e.spent)andwereleavingthesystemasflowsubsidedwithsome

    newrecruitsalsobeingrecordedinMilyeannupBrook. However,withinthe

    perennial Milyeannup Brook there continued to be upstream and

    The upstream movement of the Western Pygmy Perch in tributaries was

    iti l l t d ith di l d l l d i th fl

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    64/185

    positively correlated with mean dissolved oxygen levels during the flow

    period in the tributaries (althoughatasignificance levelofp

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    65/185

    Meannumberoff

    ish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Denny Road

    Milyeannup Pool

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    Jalbarragup

    eroffish

    30

    40 Quigup

    Western Pygmy Perch (E.vittata)

    NS NS

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    66/185

    0

    5

    10 Downstream Migration

    Upstream Migration

    0

    5

    10

    0

    10

    20

    3040

    50

    60

    Rosa Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    Downstream Migration

    Upstream Migration

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    Milyeannup Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    5

    10

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Western Pygmy Perch (Edelia vittata)

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

    n=19

    n=18

    n=194

    n=64

    n=27

    n=11

    n= 6

    n=29

    n= 6

    n= 5

    n=13

    n=39

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    67/185

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    McAtee Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    0

    5

    10

    40

    50

    Western Pygmy Perch (Edelia vittata)

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    n=12

    n=54

    n=19

    n=18

    155

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

    Downstream

    Upstream

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    68/185

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10 Downstream Migration

    Upstream Migration

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    46

    8

    10

    NumberofFish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    6

    8

    10

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Western Pygmy Perch (Edelia vittata)

    n=7

    n=2

    n=9

    n=13

    n=0

    n=0

    n=1

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    69/185

    log10 mean dissolved O2 (ppm)

    0.98 1.00 1.02 1.04 1.06

    log10

    meanfrequencyoffish

    -1.5

    -1.0

    -0.5

    0.0

    0.5

    1.0

    log10N = 31.38*log10O2

    - 32.06

    r2

    = 0.99

    Figure41 Relationship between the mean strength of the upstream migration of

    WesternPygmyPerch within the major flow period (August to December)

    and the mean dissolved oxygen in the four tributaries during that period.

    N.B.Datawerelog10transformedandmigrationwasstandardisedforeffort,

    seetextfordetails.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    70/185

    70

    Table5 Correlations between upstream and downstream movement of Western Pygmy Perch in the tributaries of the Blackwood River and

    prevailingenvironmentalvariablesduringthemigrationperiod.N.B.Datawerelog10transformed.

    Log

    temperature

    Log

    conductivity Log pH Log O2

    Log

    discharge

    Upstream

    movement

    Log conductivity Pearson Correlation .686

    Sig. (2-tailed) .314

    Log pH Pearson Correlation -.508 -.677

    Sig. (2-tailed) .492 .323

    Log O2 Pearson Correlation .229 .589 .182

    Sig. (2-tailed) .771 .411 .818

    Log discharge Pearson Correlation -.131 .600 -.573 .311

    Sig. (2-tailed) .869 .400 .427 .689

    Upstream movement Pearson Correlation .354 .868 .406 .991 .422

    Sig. (2-tailed) .769 .330 .734 .088 .722

    Downstreammovement

    Pearson Correlation .493 .934 .262 .958 .279 .988

    Sig. (2-tailed) .672 .233 .831 .185 .820 .098

    Nightfish

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    71/185

    Habitatassociations

    The Nightfish was almost exclusively captured within the tributaries of the

    BlackwoodRiver,whichaccountedfor99%ofcapturesofthisspecies(Figure

    42, Appendix 2). As with the Western Pygmy Perch, the species therefore

    appears tobe largely intolerant of conditions in the main channel of the

    BlackwoodRiverandisreliantontributaryhabitats;particularlywithregards

    tospawningandrecruitment.

    Migrationpatterns

    ThehighestnumbersofNightfishcaptured in fykenetswere fromLayman

    Brook(629),largelyasaconsequenceofamassexodusofjuveniles(1020mm

    TL)fromthissystemduringDecember(Figure42). Similarmovementswere

    also recordedwithinMilyeannup Brookand Rosa Brook. Thedownstreammigration ispresumablya response toa reduction indischargeat that time

    withassociatedwater levelandhabitatdecline. Upstreammigrationswere

    more ambiguous, however in most systems there were relatively weak

    upstream migrations in winter and early spring. There is evidence for an

    earlierandmoreprotractedspawning (andrecruitment)periodofNightfish

    inMilyeannupBrookaslargersizesofthemigratingjuvenileswererecorded

    inthis tributary inDecember. Forexample,withinMilyeannupBrook these

    new recruits ranged in length from 1039 mm TL in this month, compared

    with1024mmTLinRosaBrookandLaymanBrook(Figures43,44).

    movementofNightfish(Figure47). ThisrelationshipsuggeststhatNightfish

    may prefer more highly oxygenated streams for spawning, although

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    72/185

    undoubtedly other habitat parameters of these streams would also be of

    importance(suchasdegreeofinstreamstructureforeggdeposition)andasa

    daytimerefugetothisnocturnalspecies.

    Meannum

    beroffish

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumb

    eroffish

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    350

    Rosa Brook

    Layman Brook

    Meannumbe

    roffish

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    Milyeannup Brook

    Nightfish (B. porosa)

    DRY DRY DRY

    NF NF

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    73/185

    0

    5

    10Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    5

    10

    0

    25

    50

    75

    100

    125

    150

    Rosa Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    5

    10

    0

    10

    20

    3040

    50

    60

    Milyeannup Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    5

    10

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Nightfish (Bostockia porosa)

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    74/185

    0

    5

    10 Downstream

    Upstream

    0

    5

    10

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    Layman Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    McAtee Brook

    NumberofFish

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    0

    5

    10

    5

    10

    Downstream

    Upstream

    Nightfish (Bostockia porosa)

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    DRY

    DRY

    DRY

    NOT FLOWING

    NOT FLOWING

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    75/185

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    Downstream movement

    Upstream movement

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    Denny Road

    Milyeannup Pool

    Meannumberoffish

    0

    10

    20

    30

    Jalbarragup

    fish

    30 Quigup

    Nightfish (B. porosa)

    NS NS

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    76/185

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10 Downstream Migration

    Upstream Migration

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    NumberofFish

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    0

    24

    6

    8

    10

    8

    10

    2005October

    November

    December

    2006February

    March

    June

    August

    Nightfish (Bostockia porosa)

    n=1

    n=1

    n=2

    n=3

    n=5

    n=0

    n=3

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    77/185

    log10 mean dissolved O2 (ppm)

    0.98 1.00 1.02 1.04 1.06

    log10meanfrequencyoffish

    -1.2

    -1.0

    -0.8

    -0.6

    -0.4

    -0.2

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    log10N = 23.49*log10O2

    - 24.30

    r2

    = 0.98

    Figure47 RelationshipbetweenthemeanstrengthofupstreammigrationofNightfish

    within the major flow period (August and December) and the mean

    dissolvedoxygen in the four tributariesduring thatperiod.N.B.Datawere

    log10 transformed and migration number was standardised for effort, see

    textfordetails.

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    78/185

    78

    Table6 CorrelationsbetweenupstreamanddownstreammovementofNightfish intheBlackwoodRivertributariesandprevailingenvironmental

    variablesduringthemigrationperiod.N.B.Datawerelog10transformed,**denotescorrelationissignificantatthe0.01level(2tailed).

    Log

    temperature

    Log

    conductivity Log pH Log O2

    Log

    discharge

    Upstream

    movementLog conductivity Pearson Correlation .686

    Sig. (2-tailed) .314

    Log pH Pearson Correlation -.508 -.677

    Sig. (2-tailed) .492 .323

    Log O2 Pearson Correlation .229 .589 .182

    Sig. (2-tailed) .771 .411 .818

    Log discharge Pearson Correlation -.131 .600 -.573 .311

    Sig. (2-tailed) .869 .400 .427 .689

    Upstream movement Pearson Correlation .181 .552 .220 .999** .307

    Sig. (2-tailed) .819 .448 .780 .001 .693

    Downstreammovement

    Pearson Correlation-.858 -.907 .831 -.248 -.380 -.201

    Sig. (2-tailed) .142 .093 .169 .752 .620 .799

    SouthwesternGoby

  • 8/3/2019 Fish and Crayfish Completed)

    79/185

    Habitatassociations

    Although Southwestern Goby is typically encountered within estuaries,

    duringthisstudy,itwasmostcommonlyrecordedwithinmostmainchannel

    sites;accountingfor~92%ofcapturesofthisspecies(Figure48,Appendix1).

    Asmallnumberofindividualsofwerealsocapturedinthelowerreachesof

    Milyeannup Brook (eight) and Rosa Brook (14) (Figure 51). This species is

    therefore largely reliant on the main channel habitats; an expected finding

    given it is a known estuarine species and the main channel has become

    salinised.

    Migrationpatterns

    In most months at the downstream main channel sites (receiving most

    groundwaterdischarge), themajorityofSouthwesternGobiesweremovingdownstream(Figure48). DownstreammovementwasgreatestattheDenny

    Road siteduringFebruary,when>100 fish/daywere captured. Thesewere

    largelysmallfishthatwereprobablynewrecruits(1039mmTL)(Figures49,

    50). The downstream movement of this cohort continued through to

    September,with


Recommended