LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 1
FNAL Contributions to CMS Upgrades
Erik GottschalkJune 6, 2013
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 2
Motivation and scope of U.S. CMS upgrades
CMS upgrades and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) schedule
U.S. CMS upgrades HCAL upgrade FPIX upgrade Trigger upgrade
LHC CMS Detector Upgrade Project Key Performance Parameters Project Organization Schedule
FNAL contributions to the “LHC CMS Detector Upgrade Project”
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Overview
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 3
Motivation & Scopeof the U.S. CMS Upgrades
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 4
U.S. CMS Upgrades are LUMINOSITY DRIVEN Pileup mitigation is the biggest issue Radiation damage is also an issue
The goal of the upgrades is to preserve the ability to reconstruct all Standard Model objects and Missing Et at higher luminosity than the original design, but which it now seems the LHC will reach.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
U.S. CMS Upgrade Motivation
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 5Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
CMS Detector
MuonDetectors
Magnet
ElectromagneticCalorimeter
Si StripTracker Pixel
Detector
Hadron Calorimeter
Not shown (off-detector)• Muon Trigger• Calorimeter Trigger
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 6Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
U.S. CMS Detector Upgrades
MuonDetectors
Magnet
ElectromagneticCalorimeter
Si StripTracker Pixel
Detector
Hadron Calorimeter
Not shown (off-detector)• Muon Trigger• Calorimeter Trigger
401.02
401.03 401.04
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 7
This presentation covers U.S. CMS Upgrades that are part of the CMS upgrades that are referred to as “Phase 1 upgrades”.
This presentation does NOT cover the following: LS1 improvements – these are improvements to CMS that are occurring now,
during Long Shutdown 1 (LS1)
Phase 1 upgrades (e.g. BPIX) that are not part of the scope of U.S. CMS Upgrades.
Phase 2 upgrades – these are upgrades that are being planned for construction in 10+ years
CMS Operations Program – this is the program that receives funding to operate CMS, and will take responsibility for the operation of the upgraded detectors
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
What is NOT included in this talk…
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 8
CMS Upgrades andthe LHC Schedule
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 9Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
CMS at LHC Point 5
No access when beam is running
Can be accessed when beam is running
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 10
CMS was built to operate up to a luminosity of 1 E34 cm-2s-1 at 25 ns bunch spacing.
After Long Shutdown 1 (LS1) the projected luminosity is expected to surpass 1 E34 cm-2s-1, and will start up at 50ns bunch spacing.
This sets the time scale for CMS upgrades.Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Projected LHC Performance
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 11Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
CMS Upgrade Program
LS1 LS2 LS3
LS1 Projects: in production• Complete muon coverage (ME4)• Improve muon operation (ME1), DT electronics• Replace HCAL photo-detectors in HF (new PMTs)
and HO (HPDSiPM)
Phase 1 Upgrades• Pixel detector replacement (FPIX)• HCAL electronics upgrade (HCAL)• L1-Trigger upgrade (Trigger)
Phase 2 Upgrades (scope to be defined)• Tracker Replacement, Track Trigger• Forward Region: Calorimetry and Muons?• Further Trigger upgrade?
2015 2018 >2022
Goal of Phase 1 Upgrades: achieve at least the same efficiency, and hopefully better, than we had at 7x1033 at 8 TeV with the LHC operating at 2x1034 at 14 TeV for 25 ns or 50 ns bunch spacing.
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 12
U.S. CMS Upgrades(specifically “Phase 1 Upgrades”)
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 13Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Evolution of the Phase 1 Plans
Technical Proposal for the Upgrade of the CMS detector through 2020 (CERN-LHCC-2011-006)
HCAL Phase 1 TDR (CERN-LHCC-2012-015 ; CMS-TDR-10. – 2012)
Pixel Phase 1 Upgrade TDR (CERN-LHCC-2012-016 ; CMS-TDR-11, 9/2012)
TRIGGER Phase 1 TDR in preparation for submission to the June 11-13 LHCC meeting
• TDRs provide a strong physics case• LHCC : “The LHCC endorses the HCAL and
pixel upgrade without reservations”
2011
2013
2012
U.S. CMS plans and CDR for the Upgrade Project are based on the 3 TDRs in which U.S. groups have a leading role.
13
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 14Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
U.S. CMS Detector Upgrades
MuonDetectors
Magnet
ElectromagneticCalorimeter
Si StripTracker Pixel
Detector
Hadron Calorimeter
Not shown (off-detector)• Muon Trigger• Calorimeter Trigger
401.02
401.03 401.04
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 15Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Hadron Calorimeter (HCAL) Upgrade
Hadron Calorimeter
401.02
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 16
Description of scope of HCAL upgrade Improve performance by increasing depth segmentation and bandwidth, new
triggering capabilities, and reduction of backgrounds. Replace the hybrid-photo detectors in the Barrel and Endcap with silicon photomultipliers. Replace readout electronics to increase the bandwidth. Upgrade the off detector electronics to allow for a higher bandwidth and improved trigger information.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
HCAL Upgrade
BeforeUpgrade
AfterUpgrade
HCAL upgrade provides:• Improved separation of hadronic clusters• Longitudinal isolation of electrons and muons• Uniform energy density for hadron showers as a function of readout depth• Minimization of resolution degradation due to radiation damage to scintillators & WLS fibers
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 17Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Forward Pixel (FPIX) Upgrade
PixelDetector
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 18Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Forward Pixel (FPIX) Upgrade
PixelDetector
Barrel PixelDetector (BPIX)
Forward PixelDetector (FPIX)
401.03
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 19
Description of scope of FPIX upgrade Provision of two endcap pixel detectors, each consisting of modules
of 100m x 150m pixels, organized into 6 half-disks, housed in 2 half-cylinders capable of integration into the CMS services, data acquisition system, and slow control system.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
FPIX Upgrade
FPIX upgrade provides:• Improved identification of primary and secondary vertices and secondary tracks• Reduction in loss of data due to larger number of tracks at higher luminosity• Reduction of material in tracking volume, reduces multiple scattering and photon conversions
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 20Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Trigger Upgrade
ElectromagneticCalorimeter
Hadron Calorimeter
MuonDetectors
Not shown (off-detector)• Muon Trigger• Calorimeter Trigger
401.04
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 21
Description of scope of Trigger Upgrade Layer-1 of the Upgrade Calorimeter Trigger consisting of calorimeter trigger
cards in Micro-TCA crates with fiber optics and associated infrastructure and spares. Upgrade Endcap Muon Trigger consisting of Muon Port Card Mezzanines plus Sector Processor Cards and Muon Sorter Card in Micro-TCA crates with fiber optics, associated infrastructure and spares.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Trigger Upgrade
Trigger upgrade provides:• Improved calorimeter trigger with higher granularity, better algorithms, and integration of
calorimeter and muon data for muon isolation• Improved muon trigger consolidates track-stub finding & better coverage for overlap regions• Improved global trigger with more powerful object algorithms
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 22
U.S. CMS Upgrade Project
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 23
Key Performance Parameters (KPPs) define the scope and deliverables of the Project, and define successful completion (CD-4) for the Project.
Threshold KPP – Minimum acceptable outcome for CD-4 Objective KPP – Desired outcome for CD-4
U.S. CMS Upgrade Project has 3 KPPs HCAL FPIX Trigger
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Key Performance Parameters
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
USCMS Operations Review -- Overview of Phase I Upgrade 24
HCAL Threshold – Completed production of the HCAL Front End and Back
End electronics for HF and HB/HE. Installation and commissioning of the HCAL Back End electronics for HF and HB/HE. Demonstration that the Front End electronics can be read out and has the full design functionality. Demonstration that the HCAL Front End electronics is ready to install. Test stand integration of the HCAL electronics and demonstration of the full design functionality.
Objective – Complete installation and commissioning of the HCAL Front End in UXC5 and Back End in USC5. Integrated with the CMS data acquisition and reading out data. Demonstrated to have the full design functionality.
FPIX
TriggerErik Gottschalk, 4 Mar 2013
Key Performance Parameters
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
USCMS Operations Review -- Overview of Phase I Upgrade 25
HCAL
FPIX Threshold – Complete four half cylinders, each with three disks.
System is demonstrated by read out in test stand at CERN and turned over to CMS Technical Coordination to install.
Objective – Four half cylinders, each with three disks and one spare half disk for rapid replacement. System is demonstrated by read out in test stand at CERN and turned over to CMS Technical Coordination to install.
Trigger
Erik Gottschalk, 4 Mar 2013
Key Performance Parameters
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
USCMS Operations Review -- Overview of Phase I Upgrade 26
HCAL
FPIX
Trigger Threshold – Demonstration of 98% agreement between upgrade
trigger electronics and software emulation of the electronics through test pattern injection based on data taken after LS1, followed by demonstration of reduction of calorimeter and endcap muon trigger rates for electrons, photons, muons and taus with respect to the present system by a factor of two for a reduction of less than 15% efficiency using the trigger emulator run on data taken after LS1. Incorporation of unganged ME1/1a data into the endcap muon trigger logic.
Erik Gottschalk, 4 Mar 2013
Key Performance Parameters
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 27Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
DOE Project Organization
DOE Integrated Project Team (IPT) includes NSF representative.NSF CA PI (assuming the Cooperative Agreement is approved) is Deputy Project Manager.
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 28Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Organization Chart to Level 2
401.01 LHC CMS Detector Upgrade Project
Project Office
Interim Project Manager: Joel ButlerInterim Deputy Project Manager: Erik GottschalkInterim Deputy Project Manager: Aaron DominguezES&H Coordinator: Stefan GruenendahlProject Controls:
Travis FranklinProject Finance:
Jenny TengRisk Manager: Lucas Taylor
401.02 HCAL
L2 Manager: Jeremy MansDeputy L2 Manager: Frank Chlebana
401.03 FPIX
L2 Manager: Simon KwanDeputy L2 Manager: Will Johns
401.04 Trigger
L2 Manager: Wesley SmithDeputy L2 Manager: Darin Acosta
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 29Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Organization Chart to Level 3 401.01 LHC CMS Detector Upgrade Project
Project Office
Interim Project Manager: Joel ButlerInterim Deputy Project Manager: Erik GottschalkInterim Deputy Project Manager: Aaron DominguezES&H Coordinator: Stefan GruenendahlProject Controls:
Travis FranklinProject Finance:
Jenny TengRisk Manager: Lucas Taylor 401.02 HCAL
L2 Manager: Jeremy MansDeputy L2 Manager: Frank Chlebana
401.02.03 HF Front End
L3 Managers: Ulrich Heintz
Drew Baden
401.02.04 HB/HE Front End
L3 Manager: Julie Whitmore
401.02.05 HCAL Back End
L3 Manager: Yuichi Kubota
401.03 FPIX
L2 Manager: Simon KwanDeputy L2 Manager: Will Johns
41.03.03 FPIX Components
L3 Manager: Harry Cheung
401.03.04 FPIX Assembly & Testing
L3 Managers: Cecilia Gerber
Marco Verzocchi
401.03.05 FPIX Pilot System
L3 Manager: Kevin Stenson
401.04 Trigger
L2 Manager: Wesley SmithDeputy L2 Manager: Darin Acosta
401.04.03 Muon Trigger
L3 Manager: Darin Acosta
401.04.04 Calorimeter Trigger
L3 Manager: Sridhara Dasu
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
USCMS Operations Review -- Overview of Phase I Upgrade 30Erik Gottschalk, 4 Mar 2013
401.02 HCAL WBS
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
USCMS Operations Review -- Overview of Phase I Upgrade 31Erik Gottschalk, 4 Mar 2013
401.03 FPIX WBS
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
USCMS Operations Review -- Overview of Phase I Upgrade 32Erik Gottschalk, 4 Mar 2013
401.04 Trigger WBS
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 33
CD-0: Approve Mission Need (Sept. 2012) Director’s Independent Conceptual Design Review (May 14-16, 2013) Cost and Schedule Assessment (May 15-17, 2013) Director’s CD-1 Readiness Review (July 16-18, 2013) DOE CD-1 Review (August 26-27, 2013)
CD-1: Approve Alternative Selection and Cost Range (FY13)
CD-2: Approve Performance Baseline (FY13)
CD-3: Approve Start of Construction (FY14)
CD-4: Approve Project Completion (FY18)
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
CD Schedule
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 34
FNAL Contributions to LHC CMS Detector Upgrade Project
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 35
FNAL is contributing to Project Management (401.01), HCAL (401.02), and FPIX (401.03).
FNAL is not contributing to the Trigger (401.04), but is assisting with the effort needed to prepare for upcoming reviews.
The following cost table is preliminary. Costs will change in the next 2 weeks, but the table provides a rough estimate of FNAL involvement in the Project.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
U.S. CMS Upgrade – Preliminary Cost Table
Labor M & S Univ. Labor Total
Base Cost Base Cost Base Cost Base Cost
401.01 Project Management 3,630 520 601 4,751
401.02 Haydron Calorimiter (HCAL) Detector Upgrade 482 8,639 2,354 11,475
401.03 Forward Pixels (FPIX) Detector Upgrade 2,762 5,996 3,578 12,335
401.04 Trigger Upgrade 2,893 3,733 6,626
Grand Total 6,874 18,047 10,266 35,187
Fermilab
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 36
Project Management (401.01) Project Manager and Deputy Project Controls and Finance Project Risk Manager, Project Mech. Engineer, Project Elec. Engineer
HCAL (401.02) QIE ASIC Most front-end electronics Work with others on SiPM R&D and production
FPIX (401.03) L2 Manager Engineering design Electronics readout chain Module testing calibration Integration center for disks and half cylinders
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
FNAL Roles in the Upgrade
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 37
QIE ASIC engineering (Tom Zimmerman, Jim Hoff). FADC chip for HCAL upgrade.
Expertise developing front end cards based on QIE (Sergey Los, Teri Shaw). Design front end card for HCAL upgrade.
SiPM system design (Sergey Los). Based on HO Upgrade, focus into central HCAL environment and specs.
Firmware programming (Tom Fitzpatrick). Firmware for front end card FPGA (replaces CCA ASIC in new upgrades).
ASIC automated testing (Al Baumbaugh, Scott Holm). Test QIE among other new chips.
Thermo-electric system design for front ends (Sergey Los). Power management and cooling design for HCAL upgrade.
Large scale front end system design and integration (Terri Shaw). System engineering for HCAL front end system.
Optical fiber polishing (Eileen Hahn). Polish ODUs for HCAL upgrade. Vacuum deposition (Eileen Hahn). Mirroring fibers, depositing exotic materials
like PTP and ZnO for R&D for HCAL Phase 2 upgrade.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
FNAL Involvement in HCAL
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 38
Electrical/electronics: Al cable testing, port card design: Sergey Los HDI design and testing: Mike Matulik and a layout technician in PPD. For testing, a postdoc or
graduate student and technician help from SIDET will be needed. DC-DC conversion testing: Simon Kwan, Lalith Perera and Ryan Rivera are working on prototype
testing. Jeff Andresen will be needed to work on layout for pilot detector board. Pixel Opto-hybrid: Alan Prosser, John Chramowicz and Jeff Andresen working on design, testing, and
review. Pixel ROC and TBM wafer probing: Cristian Gingu will work on probing and ask for a postdoc or
graduate student to help with testing.
Mechanical: Operation of the CO2 cooling plant: Erik Voirin Design, prototype fabrication, and testing of the C-C ring and TPG: Cm Lei, David Butler, Eileen Hahn,
Bert Gonzalez, and a designer. Lead mechanical engineer: Greg Derylo Installation of pilot system at CERN: David Butler and a second technician. Consultation on mechanics for pilot system: Joe Howell.
Sensor testing: Support from SIDET: Bert Gonzalez, Tammy Hawkes. Sensor testing: Lorenzo Uplegger.
System test: Support from SIDET technicians, Mike Roman and his team.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
FNAL Involvement in FPIX
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 39
PAC Charge: The U.S. contributions to the CMS upgrade continue to be better defined and developed. We ask
the PAC to comment on the proposed contributions, and what will be needed from the laboratory to make the upgrade successful.
The LHC CMS Detector Upgrade Project is well defined and developed. A resource loaded schedule is being developed for the next Director’s Review (July 2013) and subsequent DOE CD-1 Review (August 2013).
Quoting a statement from the final report for the May 14-16, 2013 Director’s Independent Conceptual Design Review:
“The designs are in all cases judged to be well advanced and in most cases are beyond the conceptual design level. They provide a good basis for establishing the cost and schedule range and are therefore a good foundation for proceeding to DOE CD-1.”
To make the upgrade successful, we encourage the Lab to support the Fermilab contributions that are identified in the Project’s resource loaded schedule.
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
Conclusion
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 40
Additional Slides
Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013
LHC CMSDetectorUpgrade
Project
Fermilab PAC, June 2013 Meeting -- CMS Upgrades 41Erik Gottschalk, 6 June 2013