Date post: | 04-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | ziggy00zaggy |
View: | 242 times |
Download: | 0 times |
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 1/106
Ghgthe heidegger circle annual
volume 3, 2013
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual ub h Hgg C, gu h h hv b
g uy Nh A 1966 uh k M Hgg. I h Sg 2010, hbu g h Hgg C, h bh v u u ub h h hugh g M Hgg h. Th
u h u ubh h Sg 2011.
issn 2165–3275 print / issn 2165–3283 online
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 2/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual
editor
D O. Dh, Boston University
associate editors
A J. Mh, Emory University; Rh P, Xavier University
editorial board
Bb Bbh, Fordham University; Rb B, Pennsylvania State University;
W Bg, Villanova University; Pg Bgh, DePaul University; Rh
Cb, Stonehill College; Rb C, Stony Brook University; B Dv,
Loyola University Maryland; Ch Gug, University o South Florida; C
Hy, Loyola University Maryland; L Hb, Old Dominion University;
Ju I, Whitman College; Th K, North Illinois University; W
MN, DePaul University; E N, University o Massachusetts, Lowell; Dv
Pg, Southern Connecticut State University; Fç Ru, Louisiana State
University; Rb Sh, University o New Hampshire; Th Shh, Stanord
University; D Vg-Nu, University o Oregon; P Vv, Marquette
University; Hg Zbk, Philosophisch-Theologische Hochschule Vallendar
submission guidelines
Th g ub ub hu u h h
, h uh’ , ( b). A ubqu g,
h g, hu b ub b vg, g y
h uh h uh’ ub; h ub,
h uh’ ub vu k b b h
. P hu 7,500 , ug , hu b
ub g , T N R , 12 , u h g
: pd, rt , doc , docx . Ay Gk hu b U h. P hu h The Chicago Manual o Style, 16h
( “Ch 14: Du I: N Bbghy”), h
h v h h u. Th y b ub
h u g h Hgg C Gatherings . A hu
b h [email protected], yg “Ghg” h ubj.
design by ajm
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 3/106
G A T H E R I N G Svolume 3, 2013
Hgg Du I Tk: 1Th R A Rh
Jesús Adrián Escudero
Sug/S 18
David Nowell-Smith
Fh’ Kg: O Hgg’ Rg S Pu 30Sophie-Jan Arrien
F h Fy D h Fy Nu: 50Nu, Ay, h Og D
Raoni Padui
book reviews
Tg Cbu 76M Hgg, Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event). Rh Rjz D Vg-Nu
Wayne J. Froman
F J Fbug, v A M 88P Vv, Heidegger and the Romantics
Hakhamanesh Zangeneh
T Hgg bbv u 99
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 4/106
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 5/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual , 3 (2013): 1–17.
Hgg Du I Tk:
Th R A Rh
Jesús Adrián Escudero
A y u h v Hgg’hkg. H g z A’ h-hy h hu Hu’ hgy h b h u h h hg k h hh g hyuh. I A ug h hughuh uvy u h h h , Hggh h u ubgh , hjuy hugh A hhy u bg u hv h hkg.
F h v Fbug Hu’ Juy 1919, Hgg vg h gh h . A , h u Ch gy h g h j g . Hv, h u g gh – h hh h bu h Hu, h h ug h v h-gy g. Ev My 1919, Hgg - hgy gu u h h
h. Bu h 1920–1921 u, Introduction to Phenomenology
o Religion, h y hg h “g uh [ Ch y] h” (GA 60: 121/87). Th -by yg u uy hg y bugh bu h h y vy A, y
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 6/106
2
adrián
by h g k 1922, Phenomenological Interpretations o Aristotle: Directives or the Hermeneutical Situation ,b k h Natorp Report . Th A - (φρόνησις) h k h v gy.Evy, y qu vu h gv ubhv, bu h u , y bgh u k hh Hgg bg gh h “” (Sorge).
Wh h u u hu ? Wh h hubg hhy ? Ty, h hu h b h (ζῷον λόγον ἔχον, animal rationale).
I h quv h Gk hhu ζῷον λόγον ἔχον, Hgg h 1924 u u, Basic Concepts o Aristotelian Philosophy , uy h “h hu bg vg hg h h ”(GA 18: 108/74). F , uh vy ug, ubg. Bu k u h, h h u, Hgg h h hu ζῷον
λόγον ἔχον h h “h hu bg vg hg that has its genuine being-there in conversation and in discourse” (GA 18: 108/74), h b u h bkgu hh hbh h Hgg g. I h g y , u y hu y g uy hy u by uv uv, y u h y y. Whh g gu b, h k uu .
First , gv h g h vu A h h h u 1924, Basic Concepts o Aristotelian Philosophy . Th
A h u y u b uh u u Being and Time, bu qu hh u Hgg -y gg h . Uk P hh
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 7/106
3
Discourse and Idle Talk
u h b u h uh -, Hgg hz h A h y h v h uby h h k y h u. I h h hy, h u h uv u hugh, bu h h h u y b hh hu b hb hu ug. I h y, (δόξα) b (πίστις) , k (Gerede), hh Hgg Being and Time, y v , hy u h u v u h hugh h - gug (λόγος).
A, second , h h Hgg’ A-’ λόγος h h u h y gug -u, bu h g kg .P b k h hg u h h hyh u gug; h , b kbu hg h hy y h h.Bu h h h, hy u h k bg h ub , quy, v hvg guug hg. I Being and Time, Hgg yz hv gv qu h u h hg vyy u, hh gvh h “ k” (Gerede).
i. heidegger’s interpretation of aristotle’s rhetoric
Cy v yz hh, g h 9huy, u h h trivium h b , Hgg h “A’ Rhetoric u b u h y- hu h vyy bg-h--h”(GA 2: 184/SZ2: 138). Th , hh h h -
h y u, g hg; h h, bu g bk A h g- by h vg N-Sh h Ch Fbug h bgg h uy, , h h h, bu
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 8/106
4
adrián
u hh h h buy.Hgg y h buy h bgg hh h h u h u 1924, h h hz h “h hhh - bg-h y u. Rhetoricis nothing other than the interpretation o concrete being-there, the her-meneutic o being-there itsel. Th h A’h” (GA 18: 110/75). Sg h u by bg-gh, Hgg u Dhh A h gug h. C bg-gh b y h h k u-
by , Ru u , h ubjv g- h ub u gug.
Rh by u g : “Ag, bu h h ugh b h bg ub h h h b, bu bg ub h- h h (λόγος), h h u h v hu bg h h u h b” ( Rhetoric I 5, 1355b1–2). I h h v hh h u , bu h h h h (δόξαι). Th v y hg h Ph; h u g h - hg, bu h h gug. Wh u h v h -v u gug, hh u b buh by , h h h v h uv b- gug, hh g u bu by u. Rh hu u u hh h qu h gu u u,
u ju uv .Th y h h g u h h ; u h -g gug by b. Δόξα,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 9/106
5
Discourse and Idle Talk
vu uy, u h g u, hh gu, u, u-, . Th,δόξα u b yu gzb gug. I h , h h h h -ubjvy h h h. Cy h hh h Hgg h y h vu h h h A πρᾶξις h uy, h y Rhetoric uuu h . Hgg h h h- h h ζῷον λόγον ἔχον: “I h hu-
bg hg b , h λόγον ἔχον . H hg b h hears . H h h g hg, bu h h hvg v ” (GA 18: 111/76). Th Gk, yA, y h λόγος h u - bg hu. Fuh, h Gk h hu ζῷον λόγον ἔχον , bu h h h y hhh Gk y u hv h h k h h πόλις ( GA 18: 110/76).
Hgg’ ug Gk hh -gug y vbuy v u u h h- λόγος h hu . Hgg g h hy h λόγος u- y g . I -qu, Hgg ub h hu h u h huy h y – j, y, h h h h K,h hk h hu u h by y(Vernüntigkeit ) by y (Tierheit ), bu h by uy
(Geistigkeit ), h y, by y. Cy h , hh u h hu bg hg g hg,Hgg hghgh h , , uv, g hu . I h , h λόγος
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 10/106
6
adrián
y gug, h by k, , bv , hy v par excellence. I h y h Hgg h u gug h A v λόγος, vg h y, h , hu- ’ . I h g De interpretatione, u h u 1923–24, 1925–26, 1929–30, Hgg , gug g, vy, uvg bhv hh hu -h h h bg u h .
I h λόγος , Hgg -
, “ y u, u bg hubg hz ‘bg-h--h’: κοινωνία. Th bgh k h h , uh, hugh being-with-others ” (GA18: 46/33). Evy, qu bg-----h-h, bu h “being-as-speaking-with-one-another hughug, ug, g” (GA 18: 47/33). Λόγος, k-g, h g b vg-gh (κοινωνία) bg--h-πόλις. I h , Hgg’ A hh gh h hu .
U , uh h b bu h h πάθος y h u 1924, hy y h y u (Bendlichkeit ), (Stimmungen), h uu D h Being and Time. Wh h, u b h h πάθος h H-gg’ Rhetoric.
Th πάθη [hh Hgg Afekte,“”] g u hg,bu h disposition o living things intheir world , h bg
hg, g . Th - y u h bg- h , bg-h---h.(GA 18: 122/83)
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 11/106
7
Discourse and Idle Talk
I u , g hghgh Hgg’ - λόγος δόξα. I 15 h u h u 1924, h, hh Hgg“ hg h h h interpretation o being-there with regard tothe basic possibility o speaking-with-one-another ” (GA 18: 139/96), y δόξα, – h h y – “δόξα h hh vg k u ” (GA 18: 138/94). Ih , “δόξα h hh hv vg h vyy” (GA 18: 138/94). Bu h h λόγος h h- h (δόξαι) h u bj v. Th y h hh
Hgg u h h h “ δόξα, b, h h h h y h v h vyy h h hg. O hv vg vyhg h g ; h hy bu h hk bu ” (GA 18: 151/102).
I h , δόξα v h Hgg yzhgy. Δόξα y h , buh “h u the entire world ” (GA 18: 150/101), h , u u, , h h : “Th h u h--h--h v, v δόξα. Lvg δόξα hvg with others . Th others alsohv bg ” (GA 18: 149/101, g). O hg h, by u, h , h, hg h vg-gh (κοινωνία). Lk, h by - h ug :
Wh ἐπιστήμη, who h . F v , who I am; h -bu hg h u, h bg-u, h k. By , the one having the view
, uh, -v δόξα […] I δόξα, h y k h h uv, bu k h h h v.Agy, h by δόξα uvy
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 12/106
8
adrián
gu h h vy, bu h h h h δόξα. (GA 18: 150/102)
Th hh h h u h h κοινωνία v uy hhhu y guh h hh h (ἦθος) k uhu bvb hh h. Bu h b v. T bg – Hgg u – h by v: “I v u ” (GA 18: 151/102) “h bby being-against-one-another ” (GA 18: 138/94).
Hv, gh h g g -v h h u h ub h h πόλις.Th by g y h h hu bg gu h:
I h by h bg-h bk u b bb h , h, bbb. F h Gkhv, h vg h , beabsorbed h y, to all h hh v, b, hugh gug, h basic
danger o their being-there. Th h h sophistry . (GA 18: 108/74)
Thu, h h- h hh v k ug uh ug h b. O h h, δόξα u u v h h u y bg z h , , h h h,h y h h u g uy bhvg. Δόξα h by g h- by h u vyy
( Man) ( GA 18: 150–51/101–2). Δόξα, h, v h b h u v ( h kg-h--h);h y, δόξα h u “h gu bg-h--h--h-” (GA 18: 151/102). I h ,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 13/106
9
Discourse and Idle Talk
vy y bv h hg b A’ δόξα Hgg’ Gerede.
i i. rede and the peculiar function of gerede
I Being and Time, u ( Rede) u, gh h u- (Bendlichkeit ) ug (Verstehen), h u- g h hu bg. Rede h hh h h by k. Rede hu gby h D by vu -uv , hh, h , h h h h ( GA 2: 214–15/SZ2: 161–62). Uk h -v gug uvy u , Hgg hghgh h g, u-v, v, v u. Du . Th, ug h Hgg uh h g bg uv , bh h h ubjvy h hgug h hh y z.
I y , g Hgg, h uy h huby u gug u u
h . By hg u gug, k y h v y g, bu, uh y, hy hh y kg bu h hg h h b h. Bu h, ug gug v qu- hg u, bu h ug h g h . Kg h kg gug b . Th hy k,hugh u, b qu ug buh hh h . Hv, h , hy b , v,
u hugh u. Sk b kbu hg h hy u h h hy uy u. I h h v gv -qu h vv v, Hgg
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 14/106
10
adrián
hg y vyy h, hh h gh h “ k” (Gerede).
Th y Gerede Being and Time g b v . O h h, k h y kg h h k h ub O (das Man), , v u h . Th uuy v by h v h Fku Sh, u by Hb Mu, h h u h ug Hgg. A, h h h, h u Gerede b h h k h Hgg D’ “g” (Verallenheit ). Th Hgg’
v h , uh, hug , hugh , h, h-u y v g.
F, u bv h h Hgg v Gerede: (1) “I k h by ug vyhghu y vu h ” (GA 2: 224/SZ2:169); (2) “I k u h gg g h g” (GA 2: 224/SZ2: 168). O b h h h vy u y u-v hh k actively gg h “gg g h g,” h h y h passivey gu ug h k y by h kg gug. Whu ub, h h y , bu hy . Lgu h y y y u uggug (uh “gg g h g”), bu hv h . A k h gu u h “gg g h g.” Hv, h u u h g
h vb h gug hv gu uv .Th, uv b Gerede:
v h h v. Th v Gerede ( k),
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 15/106
11
Discourse and Idle Talk
hh vv y uv , h Hgg Rede (u), h , h u h gby hgu h hh D vuy v ( GA 2: 214/SZ2: 161). I v g, Gerede by Rede, y, h by hvg ug hg hu vu h . Ag Hgg, h b bu “ h h -gby, h u hh u b u g hu h g b bg h k bu u hv ug . […] O h same thing bu h same vg
h hv ug h ” (GA 2: 223/SZ2:168). H, Hgg u h bvu h k b k h hg, u g h , hk h h hy h gug, vhu bg y z h h hg hh bgk bu.
F , b h k ug h-u g hv vuy qu kg h. Th, h guhg b gu u-g vg ug. Th vg u-g h hv ug gv per se. Rh h, h u u h h ub k-g u . Th u u k hg b g k h vuy hv h; h, u u b u. I, h hg g uh , uy h h h qu kg h h hv gu ug h k bu, h, h h ubj, h h hv
vg ug . A g h h , u “gg g” y ju by h h hv uhuhy. I , y h qu h gu u-g h h y hv by g h. A h ,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 16/106
12
adrián
k h qu h ug v-g ug , k h h h gug hv – h bgg h k – h . Wh g k h u h v ug h by vu h h b, , uhy, kg bkgu.
Nvh, hg . Bh h v - vyy u h k y vgz,bu by. I, h uv Gerede hy h . Cu-
u u kg by u vu. I , uh h k h u, h y, u vg ug y u u y ug: “W g k y hg y hy, hg v g by uh vg ug.[…] Th h ub y hh hg hv b - h already u v h b bg u”(GA 2: 225/SZ2: 169, ). I h , h Gerede, uuby, y h Rede, , h, h D. Hv, Hgg quky u, u b guhh h b gu ug vgug. Th y h u-, hh “h vg ug h never be able h h b u hugg, h uh ju g” (GA 2: 224/SZ2: 169).
H h bg h gv Gerede,hh, h gy b , h “y - bg h bg k bu” (GA 2: 224/SZ2: 168). Gerede
hu u kg uhv v u h - v h y hg: “D v h vyy y bg hh D h gy. A gu ug, g u,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 17/106
13
Discourse and Idle Talk
vy bu , u g ” (GA 2: 225/SZ2: 169). N Gerede -, h , y bg D, h gy: “D h h by k ub g h hy, g y gu” (GA 2: 235/SZ2: 177). A h b - Gerede, h g . I h y, Gerede uy qu gv . A Hggb , h h D h k gu gu h gg.
D h h y h h vg u-
g h Gerede v. A h h g y h,
k bguy, hvg--vyhg hvg-u-vyhg, v h u- h h D hu vb v u gu D h y,gu, u b b-g. I h -y v h hy, g b gy h h
uh, u ug. (GA 2: 235/SZ2: 177)Bu h by g h h Gerede gv h h y D u-hy by h h vyy u. AL u, u b h h gv v Gerede yz by Hgg “ uuu hg .” Th h h Hggu b Gerede f h hh h k gu h vyy u g h
gu k.Tvz h u u bh D-’ h uhy. I k bg -h vg ug g k y
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 18/106
14
adrián
ug. Th vg ug ju u u. Th h D h gug v hvg h h h h bg. Th u gug h hD y Gerede ug h ,hh y b h g v uv vy. Bu, Hgg u, h vby g h h ub, vg ug u h by g h ug. Being and Time h uh by.
I h, h u gug
gu. I h y y h λόγος h Hgg h h 1924 u, BasicConcepts o Aristotelian Philosophy , y h u gv v by. I λόγος – by “speaking about something [] speaking with others ” (GA 18: 19/15) – “ common in-telligibility gv, hh h u h averageness ”(GA 18: 20/16), bu h λόγος u by h Gk “ h bg h hu bg uy” (GA18: 20/16). F h v h u, b h hh Hgg’ y Rede Gerede h vyy u by ghy ug A h. Ph b u h v hh, h , hug g Being and Time: “A’
Rhetoric u b u h y hu hvyy bg-h--h” (GA 2: 184/SZ2: 138).
This study has been funded by the Spanish Department of Science and Education
(Project reference: FFI2009–13187) and by the Fellowship for Advanced Researches of the
Humboldt Foundation.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 19/106
15
Discourse and Idle Talk
endnotes
1 S, , h u Rh (GA 11: 143–152),h ubgh b My Way in Phenomenol-ogy Zur Sache des Denkens (GA 14: 91–104), h h Frühe Schriten (GA 1: 55–57). Uuby,A h uh h Hgg v -b h g ug h u Fbug Mbug, ug h uh j g bk A, k hk h Natorp Bericht .
2 A Pögg b, 1920 Hgg KLöh h g gg Hu, h
h hg h h hh; O Pögg,“M Hgg u Rghäg” Hei-degger und seine Zeit (Müh: Fk Vg, 1999), 249–252.
3 I h Hgg v h by(δύναμις) h h hqu (τέχνη), y, h b-y kg y; GA 18: 114–119/78–81.
4 Pu Ru, La metáora viva (M: E C,1980), 49.
5 F u v, Politics I, 1, 12539–18 Poli-tics VII, 12, 1332b5.
6 Hgg gz h y h bk Topics h δόξα h b bhv h h u. Δόξα h bg--h-; h h y, h - δόξα ( GA 18: 152–154/103–105).
7 Sy R, “Ph Ogy: A Hgg” R Pzz (.), The Impact o Aristotelianism on Modern
Philosophy (Whg: Th Ch Uvy AP, 2004), 250; Jqu Tu, Heidegger and the Project
o Fundamental Ontology ( Aby: S Uvy N YkP, 1991), 131; W MN, The Glance o the Eye. Hei-degger, Aristotle and the Ends o Theory . (Aby: S Uvy N Yk P, 1999), h. 2–4.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 20/106
16
adrián
8 F h g Hgg’ - h A , Rb M, “A uSein und Zeit ” Ab Dk . (.), Heidegger-Jahrbuch
3. Heidegger und Aristoteles (Fbug/Müh: K Ab,2007), 156–169, D G, “Bg-Mv: Th Ph Hgg’ Rh Ogy” D G AgK (.), Heidegger and Rhetoric (Aby: S Uv-y N Yk P, 2005), 1–45.
9 Hgg k h u g h Be-ing and Time h h g g λόγος ἀπόφανσις:“ bg b hv” (GA 2: 205/SZ2: 154).
Hgg h h h λόγος (k“,” “jug,” “,” “,” “”)v h g g ἀποφάνσις. Bu u h g Being and Time h A- y u, kg u gz h h y hg A u ug h y gug,u, uh, y , g h .
10 Ag h g, GA 17: 13–41/9–31, GA 21: 162– 79/136–51, GA 29/30: 441–73/304–26. F y h u u λόγος y Hgg, Fk R, Praxis und Logos bei Aristoteles. Handlung,Vernunt und Rede in “Nikomachischer Ethik”, “Rhetorik” und “Politik” (Tübg: Mh, 2003); F V, “L Qu ug ’u é hz ju Hgg,u ’A” J-Fç Cu (.), Heidegger 1919–1929: De l’herméneutique à la métaphysique du Dasein (P:J. V 1996), 33–65; Ch Wg, “ Logos Kinesis :Hgg’ I h Physics Grundbegrife der
aristotelischen Philosophie,” Epoché: A Journal or the History o Philosophy , 9/1, (2004): 101–16.11 S u h gh gg h u
(πάθος) hu h y
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 21/106
17
Discourse and Idle Talk
(φόβος) Basic Concepts o Aristotelian Philosophy (GA 18, § 18 § 21 vy).
12 S, , P. Chh Sh, “Th U Abu A’ Rhetoric Hgg’ Fu Ogy: ThLu Cu, Su, 1924” Bb Bbh (.), From
Phenomenology to Thought, Errancy and Desire (Dh:Ku, 1995), 315–33, Th K, The Genesis o Hei-degger’s “Being and Time” (Bky/L Ag: Uvy C P, 1993), 276–308.
13 S GA 2: 221–26/SZ2: 167–70. I k (Gerede) uh u ( Rede). Tgh h bguy (Zweideutig-
keit ) uy (Neugier ), k u D vyy. Ly, Gerede h h, h Gv Ge- , h , h , Gerede hh h y, hk, u h -u . Th, hu v gGerede h jv “g,” “u,” “h,” “.” F gg h h g Gerede Jéu A Eu, El lenguaje de Heidegger.Diccionario losóco 1912–1927 (B: H, 2009), 98–99.
14 Ch L, “W Hgg E?” Inquiry: An
Interdisciplinary Journal o Philosophy , 48/6 (2005): 5–6.15 Ib., 10.16 F u h , Ty C, “Mu W
B Iuh?” Mk Wh J M (.), Hei-degger, Authenticity, and Modernity (Cbg, Mhu:Th MIT P, 2000), 21–22.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 22/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual , 3 (2013): 18–29.
Sug/S
David Nowell-Smith
i
I h uy k h 1934–5 u Fh
Hö’ hy “G” “D Rh,” h h gv Hö’ y, Hgg u h “” h g “G”:
Th h v u u-. Th h y -v g. A hu hy vh y , y, h. […] y, [] , , “”[denn], u, hugh k h ,
h h h h h h gbg jgghy y Ghqu L h gg.(GA 39: 16)
Wh k h Hgg y h h denn “u, hugh k h ”? Fy, h h u Hgg’ y, h h hgy “y hy h.” Th ’ “ug” -g h h g qu hy; y
hy h v h Hgg yg b, y jg hy hv h h “u.” Th “ ” hughhh h “u” y “”; bu h“” u h v; “ug” b
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 23/106
19
Sounding/Silence
h h v uu h hy h. Suh h Hgg bv -h h h gh u. Sy,h “ug” h u h bgu g h h h y gug hh. Th “ug” Hö’ h g vu , denn, bu hby y gu ( “h,” v) y. F h g g y, h u “” “jgg” gg. I y h h “ ” (hh, b , u ) h h “ug.” Hgg’
v ug hu bg u h vy h hk-g gug. I h I h h h qug h, gu h “ug” u u u-g bh h uh-vu y – y bg “u, hugh k h ” – h h “gug k,” hh b gu hhkg 1950 .
i i
Hgg’ hkg h ug gug b g gh h h 1939 u H’ Onthe Origins o Languages . Th ubh v h u u h u , u vhg u gug h hkg hugh h bg . Py h v u-g Hgg g h h h hugh fu. Thughu h hu H’ h h u gug h h bu h “u,” hh h k h,
u bg “ g, h h g sounds ” (GA 85:111/94). Th y h h gg h y h denn “G”: h g -g hugh hy k, h hugh
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 24/106
20
nowell-smit
ug h b gu. Sug – , by qu,gu g – u h b y b y y.
Th v Being and Time’s h“D h bu u” (GA 2: 217/SZ1: 163); hv, v h y u gug. I Being and Time Hgg gug h y vy gug gu h v D. Wh h u gug’ug, h h h h h b h g h v. Hv, h b h ,Hgg guh h “ug” gug h
“” “ ” h y h vb, Wortlaut (-u) Lautgebilde (h ’ “u-”).Hgg gu h h Wortlaut , h ug h bb (, Hgg’ , , gv h 1939, ubg gy, “g”) “--h” uu k h u h g g (GA 85: 34/38). Th ug gug y b- “u” h u h b k bgu g y, h u u byhuk. Th h bv, “Th Nu Lgug” , h h uky“h hy gug, v h, bg quy ,” h “ u u uvy h h by u hyg , h h hyy v h u-u” (GA 12: 193/98).
I u h qu h by b. B h, I h h h h “ug” h denn h g “G”: h “u as though spoken or
the rst time.” Th “ h ” u hughu “ThOg h Wk A” ( b h “G” u h u H), h k’ aletheic -y, hby “ u .” Th h h v h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 25/106
21
Sounding/Silence
u – “Th k b rst bk; h g h, h u h,h u g, h y” (GA 5: 32/24) – bu ubquy -f h uug : h Pu, , “ rst k h vb v,” “ rst bg h h gh y, h bh h ky, h k gh,” h “T, g,g bu, k k rst h v h hu h hy ” (GA 5: 28/21). I h, h k h y hh u bg g, h u g h “ h ,” ju h bg u u h denn -
y h h b. A , h y h, h H u, ug v: “‘ug’ asel-showing as a being, an appearing , h lets appear ” (GA 85: 111/96).Th ug gug bh u y - ( -hg), h bg h hv.
I h, Hgg y g h gu “Og,” hv. A “g-,” u h b hg k gu . Hgg, h , gh g h g gug h h - gug “yg hg” (GA 12: 242/123). I, hg h λόγος “ghg ug” (sam-melndes Lauten) (GA 85: 35/29), h u bg h gug h h .
Th λόγος “ghg ug” k u h u, gv h bh Being and Time On the Way to Language uh λόγος . Y hguv Lauten v u u . H ug h Hgg’, “Og,” h h k g h “”
quy. F Hgg u h ug h “hg h h and ” (GA 85: 54/45, h g), h “ y h u, bu to the open-ness and clearing bg , h , h h g
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 26/106
22
nowell-smit
h h h” (GA 85: 125/107). I u bh h gug u, h k g h ug gh uh, hu k g “”-h. I h qu h I u.
i i i
I h “Og h Wk A,” “h,” h y -u bu hg, by by v “g-h g” (GA 5: 32/24). Hgg ug-g hh h h, “bg g u, v v ” (GA : /), bu u h h hh u h. Th u b “” h y ; u g “ug” u y h h . Hggu h “h” h k’ “k-” u, bu u b h y. Wh hk- y ugh y h – h “bg g” , h “hg” u, h “gg” u – h y’ k-material u b. Hgg h “h” gug “h g h ” (GA 5: 32/24),
bu h h “” , h “hy” bu , y . O fu u g k h“y vb ”: “Th u k gug, hyh, , b, , , h-,” hh “hugh h gh … g h h y h y h .” Bu h g h g: “ g” h , -y gv Hgg’ u h gug g h by u k. Mv, b
g y “u,” h h h hy – u, , ub. Whv yh h gh hv b u.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 27/106
23
Sounding/Silence
I gh h uy, I u k u h “” .I “ug” h “-h,” h u h h vyv gug ug v g ( , reisst )h g v h bu . Bu “,” ug. Ph gh hk h hgk E-g y h v: h, b, h h g vbg h ub, bu h h g hh gu. A y quh h u (y h g by v-y-) k, h h v h h , h b h h h g (
h vb ). Th u hy h denn “G” “u” hugh , h h uy h bk uu – h , h bk, y. I v uby, h, - h uby, h Hgg b Wortlaut h “ preserving keeping – earth o the world ” (GA 85: 109/93). I h“ug” gug, h h h uh y b ub, bu y y, hb h Wortlaut v h Wortlaut u b u.
iv
I h g h u h h ky h Hgg’ g gug, hh b u h H u: h “ ↑ [Geläut ↑ der Stille]” (GA 85: 90/78). I h 1939 u, h -g u “,” g -vby h v h ug, byg h “g-h” h h h . Wh h ubquy , hu k ug ug h by h yg h “gug k h .”Wh h h, h ub: , h h hzh y “” gug b ;
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 28/106
24
nowell-smit
, h h g h v by hh h gy -gug vb u. I bh , h y -v vb u u, h b h by hh h“” . I “Th Wy Lgug,” hh k hu h hkg h , h h u- gug h k, h u u huy:
Th h-u-hyg ug h g h , v h ug hby bugh v [die hierdurch erbrachteBe-stimmung des Lautens ]. (GA 12: 241/121–22, )
Th kg hg bu h g; y, h, hugh h hyh Bestimmung , h h ugg h h vb gug k bgg--v. Th h h g h ’ g by bu u h h hu by. I, H-gg k h “h” vb u uuk h h “hyg” u u hughh v . Sy, h “bgg v” h hv gug , hh u bh u h “”: h “gu ” by hu vy, h by h h ub, h h y h hu by .
Th h b h 1950 u “L-gug,” g Tk’ “E Wb.” H h gu h, Stille ( “”), by h “u-” ( Lautlos ), h , h b u, bu yu-u (GA 12: 26/PLT 204). Th h h - , “Og,” h h k’ “” ( Ruhe) h k
bu h h hgh v (Bewegtheit ) hhuh uh. I, h G Stille bh , g Hgg h “ug” gug v . Th “Syg” hh
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 29/106
25
Sounding/Silence
uh u b / bh by vu yg vb gug by vu v vb gug.Wh h “” , h hg h h h k h bg .
Th “ ” y h h ug, v, . I h - b gug’ “gu ” hu h: h“ hg hu” (GA 12: 27/PLT 205), y h hu h. Th h h “ ,”h u, y : g u, Hggy, “b h g, h bk” (GA 12: 28/PLT
206). Ag u h , h ug gug h h u; , h b h hg v . A y, Ch Fyk h, gug “” hu h, h bkg b h . N y, h, k hugh, , “”; uh “” b -g u h “gu ” .
v
H, h “” h hu h g h gy λόγος. I h 1957–8 u “Th Nu Lgug,”hv, Hgg u hh gug“u.” H, Hgg k u h h h gug y , “h y gug u g vb, hv b” v h vbu h y h by huk h g. A h1939 H u, h h “h” h v uh ug, gg, vbg: “by uh hh’ f gh hh fuh” (GA 12: 194/98).
By h juu Hgg’ hugh, “h” g bgv “” h “,” bu h h “u”h k u h . I h “ky” “hv”(Himmel ), h , v .
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 30/106
26
nowell-smit
Th h ub h h: h h by g-h g v, h hz uh h “h” by “g” u .T h y “h’ f gh” b by gu, Hgg u g Hö, -by h gug “h uh’ f.” Th h,Hgg u, u “h”
h u gug g u h. Fh? F yg hh h h g- . Th u g u h ugby hh, h , hg. . . . Th ug, h hy gug h h h hy [Stimmen] h, yg -gh hu h g h ’ uu,u h h [einstimmt ]. (GA 12:196/101, )
Th “ug” bh u h “h” h fg uh h, u h “yg” hh bg .I h , h “ug gug” hg k h bh v – yg h hh h by gug h g, vb, hv, -b. Y Hgg kg g : h h u y h peal , bu one and the same movement . Th h h by g h “” hh u uv h u u; h , “y-g” “hy” h u bg h, hug h hg h h h . W -u u by gu, h “ug” u h “h” h by, v, “ug,” v
h h y . A ug b Be-stimmung : bgg v hh gug .
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 31/106
27
Sounding/Silence
vi
I u k h by g bfy . Fy, h -u gug’ ug v kg - h gy v. A , g h h g by gug h v, Hgg b g h ggu “h.” Th hg, hv, u b -. Hgg’ “ug” hk h by gug by y vgg h v -g, v by h g h h 1960 “Og h Wk A” “Th Wy Lgug”: “Lgug
By (Su S),” “Sug Byg – By S” (GA 5: 62/47; GA 12: 249), h h “E Wb” u, bv, hh hugug “h g.”
Y Hgg’ hkg h juu gv v (I’ y, “u”) uvhhy. A h u D’ qu h h h Hu u h bu v h kg ubj hugh h “hg--k,”bu bu v uy f h u-
b . Wh Hgg y gug’ ug h“h” “g u” v h, h v h h vy u b. Th by b h gug y b qu – b, , qu . Th gug by h, h , h bk by -, hh h hbk λόγος. Wh u h y h h hu by , ug -,b h y h h u uh h h h- gh. Hgg gug’ gy u “u g ghg” (lautlos ruende Versammeln) (GA 12:204/108); bg , y, “g,” gg
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 32/106
28
nowell-smit
h b, uh h hy u h h-y gug.
Sy, y, I u k u h qu yh hh I . Hgg’ u h ug gug hugh g Hö: “, k f-,” “h uh’ f.” Th h u h u h h h y hh, hh uh h ug “y” y vu g g hhkg bg. A h , vy, g h h, Hgg u h v’ “g u” h , h
h v qu, v hugh h ugg h, g gug h u , hu “y hyh gug,” “h khb g h.” I, h vy “ug” h u- , h Hgg uy h “” h h (h ) h b.
I h g, h I , h u “G,” uu, h ’ “ug” h g vu y u u . Bu h h b, hh Hgg’ g h gh h “ug” h hqu g-y. Th h h ’ “ug” g by g Wortlaut . I h , u h Wortlaut , vv ug, vh hhh k uh ug b. O, h y, uy h Hgg’ h h uh gug – ghg bg g hh hy b
u vby – u h u, h u h hy h k hv u g gu h u gu u-g h , y . T h , y
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 33/106
29
Sounding/Silence
u y gug u h b – g,gu, , h – u u u hh . Th u b hy y, Hgg y, h h h “bk ” h “h h h h u v ” (GA 12: 28/PLT 206), bu y h h ug, hbyb h hh h “bk ” h h ’h. T hk g h b Hgg , I u ugg h h qu h -y’ gg h vb u gh ub ug uv g .
endnotes
1 Mh H, The Song o the Earth , . Rg Ly (B-g: I Uvy P, 1993), 111.
2 Chh Fyk, ‘N h Thh’, Language and Relation (S: S Uvy P, 1996), 27–30.
3 Jqu D, Speech and Phenomena, . Dv B. A
(Ev: Nh Uvy P, 1973), 12.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 34/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual , 3 (2013): 30–49.
Fh’ Kg:
O Hgg’ Rg S Pu
Sophie-Jan Arrien
I h , I u k u h h h-Ch , h h h yug Hgg’hugh. My h h h h, h h , - h g gu h vy y kg hHgg v b u hugh h hghu y. Th y kg , h yug Hgg’ , “-v” “b ” h b h gy gug y gy uh hhy.
I u h hh
h g u h h Hgg’ u,I h :
1. Th u H-gg’ hu . Th k - u h y h -Ch g . I y u, hugh b h, h u h y y: h “ ” ( ormale Anzeige) h - (Vollzugssinn).
2. Th h h h, Hgg u h gh h (- -). I gh g Hgg’ hgy
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 35/106
31
Faith’s Knowledge
g, hy v h h h h k b gz, h h, gyy -h kg.
3. Th h y h h u kg,.., h’ kg, u Ch- y bhvg: “vg” “g.” Ag Hgg, h h u h h - Chy, b by Pu. Buhugh h b h h uh g h u.
i. enactment-sense and formal indication in the
hermeneutics of life
A y 1919, Hgg h h v hhy b “gy -h ,” b ug hqug by , hu g v h h . Th h hg, h g, h h y vg g hh . I h , Hgg k h bz, vz, -hz h v v (GA 56–57: 74/59, 89–90/69–70, 116/88–89; GA 58: 77, 78).
Th h hg y hu y k. I y qu - - (Vorgrife), bu hy u yh h “bj.” Th hg- hu g by ug ,h g hh gv . I u u h Hgg “ ,” u - b vyg h by y h
hz h h .B I g uh h h , I uk y bu h y y h , , y
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 36/106
32
arrien
vy. F Hgg, vy h v h bhv , Sichverhalten. Th y gv h hu y h h u g hh uh. Th uh hg one hu uz g h gv h. Ayh b v bu h h Hgg h “-,” h “-,” h “-” (Bezugssinn, Gehaltssinn, Vollzungssinn).
T u h bfy, h - ( h -
) hz h h hg. Th - , , h Husserlian h-gy b h u.Th -, , h hh h - ; “h -h [Worau ] h -h [Wozu ] h” (GA 61: 53/40, ). Ty, hh y v h - h, h y, v h hy y are (h , k).Fy, h - h by hh - - z h h hz – hby ug h h v uy y ub -. Th -, .., h by y h ug - -, u h g Hgg v hg .
Thugh h gv h -, Hgg h bjvy by h - hy (h ‘’ g h h
u h h ). Bu v h y vy g, h - h h vy v -. I hg h - h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 37/106
33
Faith’s Knowledge
bjv bgg bu gu hv , h -’ y y g h , hh h .
A y h y h h Hgg ubu h (-y u hg) h h “ ,” u h index hz . Th hz b y u,bu h k b . T y y “( pre)-” (Vorg-
rif ) h h hu ug ,hu hg h uv , hu g h h “v” h .
Nh u hg,h h y “ , y pre-caution gu h h [ h h]” (GA60: 64/44, ). Wh “ y h by/by u h - h hg uy ” (GA 60: 82/57,). Th g h k, y, h bh b “h ” “gy hz,” .. u hh, hugh h, u gug h y -h hz . I h h-gy h gu v , h h y h - v h a priori y v: “A y h ; hI uh uh initial direction, h g
h y h h y, hu hg” (GA 61: 33).F gu h gy hh
vg, y by vg u hg uv
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 38/106
34
arrien
u v ( Einstellung ) g , y by vg h h h h hyg. I h , h “v-” h ; h bg ug, k, h h “,” hh y h b g uh v .
A h h h h Ch-y, Hgg h g Pu’ L, bbugh y g h u yh bu h necessity ug h hg (.., h -) h h gy
v k. Th h I h .
i i. faith’s knowledge
Hgg’ hg gu Chy y g Pu’ h b h v h h h bv. W ugh b bg h h Hgg yg u hg k
h. H u h h “hu h-gy gu -Chy.” N, h h-gy bu g? I uh bu ,bu bu . Wh g Hgg y h g -hg Pu’ ; h h h Pu, h , describes v – h h h -bv Ch.Hgg’ Pu bv hgy h -Ch v h.
Th k hu y h Hgg’
quky v bh h h L h G v h L h Th. ThL h G u g Pu’hg, uy g h b h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 39/106
35
Faith’s Knowledge
. T h Hgg , u yh h v -,h , u u h -, h h-z h bu vy (). A , hh v, h L h G u k Hgg’ hugh, h L h Th vh – h v h-g “,” – h by y h Ch, uh Pu b .
Th bg u, I u k ugg h Ch-
h, v , y yh vy h Hgg g h-h . A I u Hgg’ Pu,h v vy kg, -h kg, h uu y h gy gh h hu . Bu u h g bk Hgg’ g Pu h k kg kg bu h.
I h h G, Pu h h: hv Ju, h v, h h g(G 1, 11–24). I h , Pu’ hbg h event: h v h Du. I bgh v h v y G, h v bh g h gu h . I y, h L h Th, Pu k h h h vent h own v h g h. H h v:
Bu yu know [οἴδατε] h have been [ἐγενήθημεν] g yu yu g. A yuhave become [ἐγενήθητε] u hL, vg [δεξάμενοι] h y bu [ἐν θλίψει πολλῇ] h h jy [μετὰ
χαρᾶς] h Hy S; uh yu have become
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 40/106
36
arrien
[γενέσθαι] h bv M Ah […]. (I Th 1, 5–9)
Wh ugh h qu h Pu uby h u h hu bu y g , g h “hvg-b.” Wh hz h bv’u h having become Ch h actual kg h . F h h, h G received hy b h h, hy h h . Th ju bh h; h y,h “hvg-b” Ch h - , u h actual bg (GA 60: 94/65). Thu,“hvg-b” Ch by vg h h uz h u h bv. Cy, h h v g u also b y (παραλαμβάνειν) hknowing h h Ch y : “Yu hv learned u h k G” (I Th 4, 1).
I h , h h v u, -y bu h . Bu y uyu , .., kg “h bhv” h h h. Hgg hu b hvg h
(πιστεύειν) “hg-u” ( Fürwahrhalten) – uuyu h kg hg – bu “uu b v.” O y h v hu by h y kg h h, h - h h kg.
Wh h k, y h Hgg, h h h h v -hkg hh uy bk “bhv,” u- h h u . Ah y h h v y:
, by g (hh G) h - Ch ; , by hzg h h G.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 41/106
37
Faith’s Knowledge
I ugg h k h g, Hgg’ - Pu b . A b , hv h h y h v - v kg h h -Ch , hv k how h kg u y. F h hh y g g hh uvg uh b h h k. Wh, h, h uh b -Ch , by h’ kg?
Hgg uh b, y, “v-g” “g,” hh h h h hgy
gu . Th y one v hh Hgg : “yu hv v G, serve [δουλεύειν] h vg u G wait [ἀναμένειν] hv h S Ju […] h v u hh ” (I Th 1, 9–10).
I , Hgg’ h Pu, I , k uv h vg g “h u h vy h ” h Ch . L u h vg g h g -Ch h, h h u hgy .
i i i. serving (δουλεύειν)
A h bgg h F L h Th, Pu h Ch, hvg v h “,” vg G“ y bu h h jy h Hy S” (I Th- 1, 6). Th b G u bu, , , uuy, jy. Why uh h h jy h , , within h -
? Th hg v gv hh - vg -Ch .Cy “y ” , h hz hh -Ch h by
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 42/106
38
arrien
this bu h h g kg G. This u h k h fh (σάρξ), h y, Hgg , u h h v G.I h u bu h Ch.
Hv, fh y b . I u , y u bg h . Bu h hCh h, y, u bg uuug ; h Ch v h G, h fh. Th hu bg Ch bu “u-.” Ch by fhbu y. O Hgg h v Pu:
“T h; uh h h h hv v hu b hughhvg [ὡς μὴ]; h h y, yg [ὡς μὴ]; hh j, jg [ὡς μὴ]; h h buy, g[ὡς μὴ]; h h u h , ug [ὡς μὴ], bu h h y” (I Ch 7, 29–31).
I h qu h Ch y b - gvy v h y uh outside h ? Th .Hgg u h h, h y, Pu yyg hg positive bu h h. FPu ’ u h vv y yg g Gk (οὐκ), bu gv (ὡς μή) hh v h v h k h g.
Hgg bu h v: “ […]. Th ‘’ h g h -gg h v ” (GA 60: 109/77). Fuh: “Ou b ὡς μή by ‘ ’ bu u’ k.‘A ’ bjv ugg h h Ch hu v h k h uug . N h
ὡς vy g hh . Th μή h Ch ” (GA 60: 120/86, ). I h, h g u h “v” y h-z h - h h , hu g
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 43/106
39
Faith’s Knowledge
bk bjv - , v gv . Th - h y - h (ὡς μή) h h g .Bu h h hz h Ch u y h . O h y, k h u h -, g v. Dy y, h b-v, h h h Pu ju:“k u yu v h bg” (Ph 2, 12).
Th h Ch hu u vg G, hughh ugg g fh, h ghg gh h . N h gh h fh bg
bu h v y hugh h gh . T hy, y h h ’ k vh h gh G : “My g u yu,” yG Pu, “bu my gh h b hugh k”(II Ch 12, 5–9). I h , h k h bv, byvg h g, v h gy G hu b u jy. I y h by h uy h h Ch h v G v jy.
I hu hgy, h y . I, Pu’ h k h u gg h bjv- h v h - hCh v. Ch - v hz by h -; h y, b h h h. I h h hz G h h gb -Ch gy u b u - h, y -. Th h yy, Hgg , h “h g […] ’
[…] vy ” (GA 60: 122/87, ).Bu hv u h vg G u- h uv h ( u h h ). I h h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 44/106
40
arrien
-Ch gy b g gy h h h y? Th y waiting , hh h ky gu -Ch h, h qu hu uy y h g v h h h Hgg’ hu .
iv. waiting (ἀναμένειν)
Wh “g Ju” y, v ? W hv b g h h Ch, v, u G, , v h “” . Th hz - h h h coming , h g h kg- G, ub fh . Fh’ kg,h kg “hvg b” “ u” (καινὴ κτίσις) y kg h to come ( G 6, 15).Th, h hz Ch y’ y h h bu h uture. Th Ch v h“” Pu, h gu u Ch y hL Jug. Bu h k uu h?
O hg Hgg y Pu’ L h g
h u Ch u b u u. B h u h -, Pu cannot b u bjv h. Th hy Pu, g Hgg, y h Th h qu h h when Pu, bu h h bk h vy gug hy Ch. Pu v h u Ch, bu y k u: “Bu h [χρόνων] h [καιρῶν] yu vy k [οἴδατε]h y h L h h gh” (I Th
5, 1–3). Th kg h u Ch, h, y. I h bjv“uh” bjv bu hz hb .
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 45/106
41
Faith’s Knowledge
I h , Pu h “h” Pu y ug h “vent.” Pu’ v u h “h” bu yy jyy “h h ” (GA 60: 102/71–72). F Hgg,h y yg qu h “h” -g “bjv .” Pu y when Ch u buh v “kg” h h hu. Hgg -guh h h καιρός h h bjv hg , h h. Th καιρός hg h ub z, , h y. I , , hu u h uu.
Th kg h h u Ch hu h Ch’ . A Hgg, h h -Chy “kg” uu y hgu h uu u . F , Hgg h g h “h?” Pu, Pu h Ch- bk h u kg h u Ch: “yu vy k [.., yu already k!] h y h L h h gh [….]”
Fuh Pu h h impact h -hkg u h u ; h “” hy g uy h : “Bu hhy y: ‘P uy,’ u h u u,k h bhg , hy ’ . For you my brothers , yu h k, h y ’ u yuk h. […] Let us not sleep like the others but let us be vigilant and sober ” (I Th 5, 3–6). Wh Pu, Hgg y, “h ‘h’ h b h qu ‘h v?’ – [ h ] h ku.” Th hy “P uy” hv h h g h
hh b h qug y .Thy v , bu u huug , h v – h u Ch u h “k h h gh.” Bu h h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 46/106
42
arrien
h ku, .., h h hv h u h Pu yg. F h, h “h” h ; Pu uh v h .
Bu h Pu b u h bv’ , h y “b ” h ? Fy, Hgg , qu vg h h b h y h L Jug,ug h h Ah k u h Ay h g ug h h . Suh y u h bjv uuv. N qu ug h uug , v’ y u h g Pu. Pu h y:
“My h v h v h h h -g” (I Ch 7, 20).
Wg h u Ch y hg – hg – bu y h - h v h - . I ’ hugh . WhPu k , h g bv u h ; h Ch’ h – v. H y, y h - Ch , v h h v. Bu hk, v b h y h uh- h g , h y h u h u Ch. H hu b by ub h h : “[H] ub h uh , g u , h h y h k h v v u h vy” (GA 60: 107/75, ). F h Ch, vu-g h guh u by h hz h u, bu h y, ug . Auh Ch
k uy; uy qu hz hz h u g .
Thu, hu hg v,“g” h uh y g h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 47/106
43
Faith’s Knowledge
h’ -h kg j “vg” h qugbg--h-, uv h v Ch y. I h hz Pu, h gy - u h gy y . I vh hy uh y h gh b hgy g gh.
v. conclusion : the experience of faith and hermeneutical
phenomenology of life
H I u u h u h I hv u ? I v-uy ugg h h h h gy - h yug Hgg’ hgy gu. Th Hgg y “g” “vg,” gbv, h hyh. I, h yHgg uh h contents byCh g S Pu, u h indeter-minateness h . It is this very indeterminateness, claimed inthe name o the enactment-sense specic to Christian lie, that transorms
aith’s pre-theoretical knowledge into a ormally indicative knowledge.By y u, I u k ugg h h u h
hg h -Ch b . F h ugreligious lie uh, h Hgg b vu h y u bh h by h h experience h gy gug y uu καιρός. O h qu Hgg’ hgy gu h v h hu y uh. F u b y h h h -Ch “y” yh g g h-
gy . Th vy vy kg yy h u h Ch “g” uy v Being and Time – h h hz
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 48/106
44
arrien
h uu b y z h y D h z.
I y h h - vy h h h - h. I h h Ch h structurally demands h - v h - h -, u h “y” g- y Chy’ v Hgg’ hgy .
Thu Hgg’ hgy gu test , k, h v h within a concrete and
historical lived experience (.., h h), bvu h vy uu , . Th h y h h h v bu h h yz u gh h , hby, h g Hgg’ y hugh.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 49/106
45
Faith’s Knowledge
endnotes
1 Th kg h never , b , y k h gh g bu y g hh h v h . T g h -h kg by -Ch , Hgg u h Wissen - Erkenntnis (hh u ky ugg h- “” ). Uk G Fh (savoir,Wissen connaissance, Erkenntnis ), Egh hv
uh y . F h , v b h u h, hv I Hgg’ u Wissen GA 60 y , I hv h I “-v” “-h-” kg. F v h , “F ” Le jeune Heidegger (1909–1926).Herméneutique, phénoménologie, théologie, S.-J. A S. C- (é.) (P: V [. Pbè v], 2011),135–151.
2 C. GA 56/57: 96–97/75–76: “Th u b -h
u-h [übertheoretische] , -h , u gy , hh h h- u h g. Th h g […]’ b hy.” GA 56/57: 59/46–47: “Th h h u b bk, […] bu h h bk -h.”
3 S GA 60: 55/38: “Th b ‘ ormal indication’ bg h ‘hy’ h hg h […].”
4 Bu v b g Hgg’ y, u bj: Why hu h Ch b para-digmatic h g gy h h “ g”? I’ uh hby? I y y g. Why h y gu h h, y, h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 50/106
46
arrien
? Why y h -Chy h h y h gy?Bu, Hgg u y, h gu v h y h h (Selbstwelt ). Ih h gu -Chy, “h h hg, v u h ‘-y ju u y’” (GA 58: 60). N, h Selbstwelt hu v ; h h h, v hv b h v gh. I h h uv y h , h expressly k u by h
Ch. Th “k” u b h , hh k h h Pu. Th u gv h h , h by Hgg h, hy hu k y gu h h, y h , hh k. Bu, y ,h h , h y, bu gv v g h u h Hgg Pu.
5 I y, h , v h h L Pu, h h b Hgg Rk’ - hhy vu. C. B.D. C, “Hgg é-k B. Cqu hh vu” Le
jeune Heidegger , 75–93.6 οἴδατε εἴδω/ἰδεῖν () h , g h
hg, “, , k, b k ” , y v Fh,voir; observer, examiner; avoir une entrevue; se représenter, se g-urer; M. se aire voir, d’où se montrer; sembler, paraître; avoir l’air,
aire semblant, eindre de; se rendre semblable; (. A.) savoir, êtreinormé, instruit de; être habile à; être en état de, pouvoir; avoir tels ou tels sentiments (+ . . .).
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 51/106
47
Faith’s Knowledge
7 GA 60: 94/66, : “Th γενέσθαι δέχεσθαι τὸν λόγον, ‘-vg h ’….”
8 GA 60: 108–109/76–77: “steigerungsähiger Vollzugszusammen-hang”; h Hgg II Th1, 3: “W ugh ugy gv hk G, y bh, yu h gg v h v yu h h h bg bu […]”. O h y hkg h, GA 60: 310/235–236.
9 GA 60: 97/67: “δουλεύειν u ἀναμένειν b Gu-hug j Bzug.” M y Hggu h qu Chy
h h (waiting ) h vv h qu D’ gy y.Th h Being and Time h h b y, h h g h h Fbug y vg, hy h g v h h g. A y, h -v hu hgy , I hk h h “vg” b, uy h u h y k h “g.”
10 Ag Hgg, fh y h y “uh y h u-ug ” (GA 60: 124/88, ).
11 C. Ph 1, 21–24: “Bu , v Ch g. I I v h fh, I h u y b; hu I ’ k hh h. I bh, g b h Ch, hg uhb ; h fh, hg y yu.”
12 Hgg v y y b -
g. F , h y h v uh - (GA 60: 109–110/77–78) hHgg II Th 2, 10: “[…] h h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 52/106
48
arrien
h, hy ’ v h v uh bv.”
13 Th uy, h , v k- vuby, u h by u g, y h v gh. C. M Luh, ThHbg Du, 18h h: “I h uuy h by b h vh g Ch”; M Luh, Luther’s Works: Career o the Reormer , H J. G Hu T. Lh (.)(Phh: F P, 1957), 39–58.
14 I h , , h Hg , hh
g “h Ch [], h v h uy ub I” buy h uh Chy.
15 C. GA 60: 150/106–107: “U b [Pu] W ? Nh uh bjkv Zgb, uh Wie, u z Wie bzg gh u Bzug zu Wie, Bzug bz. Vzug Eh Wann!”
16 Καιρός, Pögg bv, “ h z’ g h. [Kg] h k h ; h hy h h h uu.Thy bg ’ hy [] hh b b-j.” C. O Pögg, Martin Heidegger’s Path o Thinking ,. D Mguhk Sgu Bb (A Hgh-, N Jy: Hu P, 1987), 24.
17 Th h -Chy uu hg bu “kg” h gu h u-u h y . Thu uv, Hgg,h v hy (Geschichte) h gyy .
18 Fç Du, Heidegger et la question du temps (P, PUF,1990), 19.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 53/106
49
Faith’s Knowledge
19 F h, Hgg , “h qu ‘h’ bk . Th y Pu u h h uh” (GA 60: 104/73, ).
20 H h k bg h Ch, h b h u, b u h bg b h , vg “ uy.”
21 C. GA 60: 133/94. C. M Luh, . ., Th Hbg D-u, 11h h: “Ag b v u h b u h jug vyk.”
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 54/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual , 3 (2013): 50–75.
F h Fy D
h Fy Nu:
Nu, Ay, Mgy
Raoni Padui
I h uz hgy, h h-g h b gy u v Hu’ k yhg. Thughu h v h j hg gy h ,Hgg’ hhy h h -v -u gy, u u h h u h g h . I h I y u h
Hgg u hugh h guh Dasein Vorhandensein h uy u . Hv, Igu h h g h -, h h Hgg’ b h j- u gy, hh h h u u h g qu, ghu. Th h vug u gy h y j gy, y - h y D h h y u, h h - b u h u u y h
guh D’ bg--h- h ’-vy. I bh h h k y hby Hgg’ g bu h vy by b D u. I h I h,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 55/106
51
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
Hgg u gg h uqu, v hg h u gyb bz, y y.
I k h h h, I bg ( h h ) by bfy vg h bD’ actical bg h actuality uk D-. Th by h h j u gy v Being and Time, v bfyqu h h . I h h I h h h b D Vorhandensein - Hgg’ u, y h
y h bg h Vorhanden h u hughuh . I h h I gu h, h hgg uh , Hgg bg bz h v u h h y hj gy. Fy, I u by hg h Hgguy hk bk h gh v h gh h h h y qu. Iugg h Hgg hu hv uz u D’ bg--h-, v h h h -u v h u b.
i. facticity and the distinction between dasein and
vorhandensein
O h u h Hgg’ Being and Time hh bg h y h Dasein y h bg h . Th y D v h bgg by h Hgg Vorhandensein:
Ogy, existentia bjv [Vorhandenheit ], k bg hh y hz h bg hh hh h D. W v h u
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 56/106
52
padi
by y ug h v bjv [Vorhandenheit ] h existentia, by bug [ Existenz] bg y D. (GA 2: 56/SZ2: 42)
Th “” ( Existenz) g h bg - D, h bg qu, hh h g Vorhandenheit Zuhandenheit v h . Th y hh D h - h . Th vh D Hgg y ,g h u D bjvy yg h y vk D’ g: “D v b u gy gu bg bjvy [einer Gattung von Seiendem als Vorhandenem]” (GA 2: 57/SZ2: 42). O u, uh ug y b, k h bu, u y b ug. Ju bgy (Gattung von Seiendem) bg bj vg, hgy uhygyu g u h hu h vg. Bu Hgg
h g h v bu D’ bg h g.D guh y h by h h
ug bg uv : “Understand-ing o being is itsel a determination o being o Dasein. Th - D h h is g” (GA 2: 16/SZ2: 12).Tg D bj g h bj ubu h g by. Hv, h -bguy h, D y. D is bgg h, y h h ju h gy h h u . U , Hgg h h bu u D h bjv y uh u : “M y, hy b u h h ju
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 57/106
53
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
hg y bjvy ” (GA 2: 74/SZ2: 55). Hv,Hgg y h “ h, u yg ju h u bg-” (GA2: 74–75/SZ2: 55). Wh h y hh D b-jvy g h , h b y k h “ .” I k Hgg h h hk h h bg huv h b D-, u uv. Th bu h ug g h bg- hguh D b. Wh Hgg h h qu y D ( )
g h , , hkg g h u y h g u gy, h g hkghugh h g u D:
Lk h bg, D objectively present as real . Thu bg g qu h g re-ality . Agy, h y h uy h g b. Th yv h h [Dieser verlegt den Weg ] gu y D, v u v
h bg y hg y h[Zuhandenen]. (GA 2: 267/SZ2: 201)
Th , y bu h h D h u y hugh uv ggh , bu h h bj u -y u uu h g, hy (zuhanden). S h b h h v Ry h uy g h y g “k v hh [Überspringen des Phänomens der Weltlich-
keit ]” (GA 2: 88/SZ2: 65).Bu D y h g h -. Th gu bg-hu h h Hgg -g by D’ y. O y hk h h y D,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 58/106
54
padi
bg h h (Geworenheit ) y, g bg h D h h h bg. Hv, h h , Hgg g g guh bh uy gy h bjvy D’y, vg h Tatsächlichkeit h Fak-tizität h . Ju h b h bg (, bjv ), h h h (y, uy): “A y h ‘uy’ h [die ‘Tatsächlichkeit’ der Tatsache] ’ D gy y h u u k . Th uy h [Die Tatsächlichkeit des Faktums ]
D, h y hh vy D uy , acticity [ Faktizität ]” (GA 2: 75/SZ2: 56). O u, h “y” h bg – “h” g h vy y h ( h). Bu Agb h hv , h h y bu hugh h gy (Zuälligkeit ), hhHgg D’ g ,g by Faktizität . Th hh D “” h (Geworenheit , Verallenheit ) h hh (Zuälligkeit ) h . Agb hby h Hgg “h Bg v h.”
Th v h vy Hggu h b D’ y Being and Time, hg u h y h ju h h g : “ Facticity is not the actuality o the u buu o something objectively present, but is a characteristic o the being o Dasein taken on in existence” (GA 2: 180/SZ2: 135). Th hughu h bk h u y b Being and Time. Eh Hgg
uh u D’ bg--h- u uu, h h b - u bjv . F , h vgh h , h bv: “A h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 59/106
55
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
D, [Tatsache] h u -y bjvy . I ‘’ y h k bg D k k [ Faktum] y [ aktischen Existenz]” (GA 2: 357/SZ2: 269). H u hbg h y h D guhg h y hh bjv “” : “EvyD v b , bu hb, bu bu y never b objectively present . Rh, , exists [sondern weil es wesenhat nie vh sein kann, vielmehr, wenn es ist, ]” (GA 2: 503/SZ2: 380). F h h -v u guh Dasein Vorhandensein,
b ug h g gh Being and Time,h Hgg qu h vy :
Th b h bg g D h bg bg uk D ( ,bjv ) y b ug, bu y h point o departure h g b-; hg h hh hhy b [ist doch nur der Augg der ontolo-
gischen Problematik, aber nichts, wobei die Philosophie
sich beruhigen kann]. (GA 2: 576/SZ2: 436–37)A bk h vv v h bg D by g h bg h - , , by bzg h vy j. Th u hh h bg D u hg hu g , bu hg h u h.
i i. on the relationship between vorhandensein and nature
Wh hv h h b Dasein Vorhan-densein v Hgg’ b y uy, y bvu h y h h h u u. I h g I gu h h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 60/106
56
padi
g h b D Vorhan-densein uuy H-gg’ g u. Bu u uyy , hh hy h y v y hh . Th g u- v y, h vy hg hgy b “uu h u ” v hy u g kbu ky ub u qu, h Jh Dué -y “-uu.” I g h Hgg u, h u -Qu
u: y, h hg v h h u uu h hhy, h -u h , h ugh u g. I, g h Hgg’ hhy u, u hv uh b gy , h u y v h “” u h,h hu bg , y h, hh. Th v h Hgg, y Being and Time, h “ gy” (GA 2: 88/SZ2: 65). O h g u u, y hhy h ubu D’ u g g y “u” u b y u. I h gyb ugh u gu v Luu, Sz, Nzh, W S.
Hgg’ y , g hh u, v, gy, h u-v h D. Wh k y h u “” – Hgg’ hh v gy k v (überspringt ) h h-
u y bjvy hg. F h v, D b yh h u g:“I, h h bg h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 61/106
57
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
bg [dem Sein des Seienden] hh bjvy h h [innerweltlich vorhanden] bu h , hv, v b -y v – u” (GA 2: 88/SZ2: 65). Whh ug u h y Hgg bzhughu h k h , b g h b1925 1929 Hgg vy y h Vorhanden h hu, h gy h vyhg Vorhandensein h h gy u. Th b h u u h u 1927, h h h h v Being and Time h u :
Th u y h - [die Welt ist nicht die Natur und überhaupt nicht das Vorhandene], y h h h hhg uug u, h u qu, h vg , h Umwelt . Nu – v k h h h hhh , y u, h uv,h h – h k gh,, , hu, , h ,
v hhy. (GA 24: 235/165)I h Hgg D h Vorhanden by y yg h h u, h h -g b h hu h “y” u. Wh v bu D h g , necessarily h ; h -bgg -. Hv, bg--h- y possible (bu y) hu: “I bg h bg h , u, bg, bu b ” (GA
24: 240/169). A k , bu h - uv bg. Th hg bg“” bg “” h h h b k, Hgg’ , “ bg u’ bg
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 62/106
58
padi
[ gehört nicht zum Sein der Natur ]” (GA 24: 241/269). F uy u, , k, hh hy k h g g g by bg--h-.
Th b D’ bg--h- ( In-der-Welt-sein) h h u ( Innerweltlichkeit ) h -u h b D u- . A h b h h h y D, bu y by u . Hgg g “b bg--h- [ In-der-Welt-sein] h D’ gu [Seinsverassung ] [ Innerweltlichkeit ]
b bu y [des Vorhandenen]” (GA 24: 239–240/168). T gy hk h h y h , h uv, u hSz , bu h u h Hgg by Welt : “W y, , g D . N-u b h D ” (GA 24: 241/170). Whh hk h, u Vorhanden y b byHgg : “Th h hv [Der Stuhl hat keine Welt ]” (GA 24: 236/166). Th hg h y“” h h D h, y D y u- hbg : “Th hg D-h[Die Welt is etwas Daseinsmäßiges ]” (GA 24: 237/166). Th h uy b Hgg’ h K- u, h hu u y bu h u h hh guy b. O u, Hgg y y h ub-jv h , y hyy hz h h u b v ubj. Nh, h u D, h
hu D’ bu : “S D, -h [eine Welt vor-geworen] h D’ bg.T , g h hg, -h [sich Welt vorher-weren]” (GA 24: 239/168).
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 63/106
59
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
Th g-h , y u h h vy - ubj, h Hgg ug h h “-” D. T u u D h b -g hu hb h h y h :“T ju b (g h) D h bg, bu h b u bg[Grundverassung seines Seins ], h b hh D bg h ” (GA 26: 211/165). T h b h hy D u -
“,” hu h g h hh b. Hgg y g h h b D’ug h h g, D’ , D’ y bg--h-: “ bg--h- , bg (u) hv yb v [ist auch schon Seiendes (Natur) übersprungen]” (GA26: 213/166). Th h D h hv b h hz gby, gvg hg b bg bg. Hgg y - h ug h h h D’ - ug h y hh D by hy u hh y y h:
D h, , hughy uhugh b, h h h bg, g hh D hh D bg, u [überschritten]by D. I h , g, D by u, hugh, , v- by u. A g, .. , D
hg u [ Als transzendierendes, d. h.als reies ist das Dasein der Natur etwas Fremdes ]. (GA26: 212/166)
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 64/106
60
padi
Ev D y b by , y y g h, Hgg’ h ju h, bu ( y) hg h bg uy bb by u h , hu y h hu u.
I g h h vy u u hhHgg u h g h y h b D u. Th g h h h b h -y D, D’ bg--h-, h uy u. T bh h bg D
h hh h h ug h y h g. I u h hg , h y kg h u b g , b h bg D h h . Chzg h b D’ bg h u “h y bg [diesem radikalem Unterschied der Seinsweisen]” (GA 24: 250/176), Hgg hh h yy uyg h bg:
Th g b h u h D’ bg h u v b h hugh h y bg b b by y u bg g. (GA24: 250/176)
I u h h “u” bg u b, bg y hgh gu u hh bh D’ u ’ bjv ubu, u
y u h v “ gy.” Wh k Hgg’ h g: h hv y bg h b u u u (v u h h ub
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 65/106
61
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
u), hv h h hg k h u- gy, D y y yg h.
Th h, y, h g h b D- u h b bg bg, h h vy u hhy Hgg . I h, hg u, h h h uh hg uy hh qu h u b h h h bh , g Hgg’. Wh Hgg u h gug “u,”h h h h h z h “v” h
v, h y hh hy u h g- h v : “Pv h h hh , h bg; h y, hy y h , , u” (GA 24: 17/13). Whh hg hy b h h hz u g bj v-g, h v y all hy, gu uv v. Phhb b hg h h u v qub u h hgy, yhgy, vuybgy, . Th g h v h “hg gh y y” (GA 24:466/327). Th u u k hhy h -b uy, Hgg y h hh qug h h g : “Oy bykg h – κρίνειν Gk – b bg h bg bu b bg bg h hh h” (GA 24: 23/17). Th vy by hhy, h v, y g h h by
guhg b bg bg, hh u ug h D h h u .
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 66/106
62
padi
i i i. questioning the distinction
Ev hugh Hgg h g yhughu 1926 1927, hv y h Being and Time by qug h b D h , g u h u b hg u-qu g. Wh h u- y bgg -, y 1928 1929 h h u h h vug u gy h qu y. Bh h Hgg’ u u vv implicit u hg h b
D u, Hgg b uy h hyhv h by ug h vy j h-g gy. I I g h h Hgg’ u gy h h h u.
Th bk b h h 1928 h Metaphysical Foundations o Logic. H Hgg h h v h u gy y “vug [Umschlag ]” (GA 26: 196/154). Thvug y hg u ug, hu u hy bu hv hu
h u u gy. Rh, h ugy “gy” y , hh vg h : “y h z u gy bg bu h bv- vug[Umschlag ] gy u vy ” (GA 26: 200/157). I h h vug ? I y gg by h b D u h v u gy, uh vgg - h h D h h h .
S bg h y bg yh [Da es Sein nur gibt, indem auch schon geradeSeiendes im Da ist ], u gy h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 67/106
63
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
h y , hy- hh b b y hbg u h b. Th - y gy u bk g b by h h hu : h bg “”u bg; ug--bg b bg bg; bg hy h D u bg. (GA 26: 199/156)
Th u gy gy -vv g h v hugh h g hy g D , h uuy . Th g uy h: v hugh h b bg bg h y D , D h y hv ug bg y “ bg y h[indem auch schon gerade Seiendes im Da ist ].”
Why h u u h b u? BuHgg uggg h hk D y gh h y h hv g y. Th -
hy b h y D h uy u h gg bk , h b h Hggu h y h y bg u, h - v y D. Th bu byh , hh, h Hgg’ , g u, uby hg h h y y g :
I h , h by h bg h h ug u h
D [die aktische Existenz des Daseins ], h u u h u u [das aktische Vorhandensein des Natur ]. Rgh h hhz h b bg, h y,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 68/106
64
padi
h h vb b u- bg, y b y bg y h. (GA 26: 199/156–157)
Th u hv b uhkb Being and Time, h Hgg y “quvg” b h y bg u h D, bu g h h y D- u h y u. Th ugg h byh diference b D’ Existenz u’ Vorhandensein,h ( aktische) bg hy h. Fuh,u gy ug “ -b y bg [eine mögliche Totalität von Seiendem],” g y h y v h h z u h “” gy. Wh u h y bg b, h“” h z h h b ? Nvh, h Hgg h y ugh, v h b Being and Time -y h .
O y Fbug, Hgg u - qu h h u h bD u, bu h hugh h u y.
Ay Being and Time, Hgg h h -h b D bjv , h by h h hy: “L h u bjv, D” (GA 2: 67/SZ2: 50). Wh h g Being and Time, h hu hv b Hgg’ y; hv, g h uh b. Hgg uy v hy h u u The Fundamental Concepts o
Metaphysics. H, Hgg u h b h“” u h (hh h h
h h Vorhanden) h “-g” u D (GA 29/30: 263/177). Hv, Hgg h -b gy, uy g h “h poor in world ” (GA 29/30: 263/177). Th vy hgy
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 69/106
65
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
v hugh v vv y D, y h h y u Hgg h . A D h h, Hgg b-v h h D h hg h “-uu” (als-Struktur ) h , v h y b u bu v. Wh h -g, hv – uy hgy “gv” h : “hv hz yg y gv in some way h z, y k h z as k” (GA 29/30: 291/198). A hv h h v, g -
h y Zuhandenheit . Ju I y h as h, y g y as bj--b-h. Hv, D-, C, h hv gu, Hgg ub u-uy u h . H h y Vorhandenheit , bu y h D h h hugh v . I h , h u y, g hg h y h u gy: “Thuh h h ‘h ’ u b”(GA 29/30: 396/273). I , b aporiai h, hh h u u hh Hgg qu hhh g quy hugh ugy, gg ugg h b gy -gh (GA 29/30: 522/359).
I gub h h b y g bg h h h u. Th bu h b- h y D h uy u bu byh vuy u . A y u, y hy y h g Vorhan-
denheit Zuhandenheit , hgg h h u vy by h g. Fuh, h , h D v uqu u h y D Being and
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 70/106
66
padi
Time. M y, h h qu y bg h h h hg k gu – h h b D-h, h b “” g. I h h , h D’ g b b y u k y h u . N y “-” , bu y hu b ,uh h h y b, h v h vyuk g. Th b -vy h vv - h g g h u b quy , mutatis mutandis , hu h y ug
. Th b Hgg bfy kg h yug D h 1928/1929 uu Fbug (GA 27: 123–126). Hgg bu h h-g h ug y yug D h u-g , h y bg h -qu D bu y u v - ug bg. A A Mh, “h h h h kg.” Th h b D hu, b D h , b D u b uh u y , kg h h u h-g b h u v D . I h y hv ug bg ug h g h g, u y b b y b u u. Wh Hgg h “ h - b bg bg [der Vollzug des Unterschiedes von Seinund Seiendem]” (GA 26: 199/156) – hh gy y bh D – by u
hu bg. Whh Hgg kg h y,h qu y gy bg h j u- gy h bk u bug h u h g .
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 71/106
67
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
iv. conclusion
Hv, K hk bk h by hy, H-gg h by u. I hv gu h h , both h b D’ bg h h u and h g vy g u h h uz . Hgg h h b, y hy g h j u -gy. Bu v hugh Hgg gv u u gy qu h h u h qu
bg h uh bg, h v bk h h bg g h y. By h -h, Hgg g h h qu bg h g - b u u: “Th kg h qu , bg uh h, by u bg, uh h g ” (GA40: 6/5). I h Hgg uz h h -y, gg h hv neither v, y : “W yspiritual . Th h [Welt ], y v
[Umwelt ]” (GA 40: 48/47). Th jug y ubg gvh h Hgg’ hg h qu y , by h u, y h h h b. A v Hgg qu,hugh h j gy, hh h bh D h u b h h u u gy, hv bk uh g u h g: “Th hubg . Rk , bu hy . T , bu hy . H , bu hy ” (GA 9: 374/284). Muh h bz h y g , hu ju h h u h v.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 72/106
68
padi
Wh, h, h h y b H-gg’ b h u h h u- hkg y u ? I h v gv h h y bz g g h Hgg’ hgy ? By y u, I ugg y g h u. Wh Hgg hqu h hu hv uh h quy uh, h by Hgg bu h -y u u y reductionistic. W bvh Hgg u v g h “h g-
gh y y” (GA 24: 466/327).Th h h hk u g uy h h h , u h v bu . W u h hv hk u bg, u , u v h uy h gv hy u u. Bu h Hgg y h-hy h u h g y . Th h hh Hgg h h hhy u b h : “I h u ug h h bg v b by bg, bu y y h‘’ vy bg, h h by hh b ” (GA 2: 275/SZ2: 208). H-v, h g h u gu h h u- must u h g h . O u, gv v h u bguy uh u, uh h by L M hghh uy Büh h h, by Pu
Chuh y.
Bu h u ub u by y, h h y y h g ?
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 73/106
69
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
Ty, h h bj u hHgg Hu u h y h y h v y y u. Jh Dué, , h zh u u h h hyv u (, u, ) gy u y ug uh g u. Ny Cgh h qu, g h v “u” uggg u u uy u. Th h g uh hy y v u
u h h/ u-. W bv h u h h g, , gby u kbu u u b hy u,g y y ug bg h b b. S y h h y h vu u hg -, Hgg uh h:
Bu this , h u Bg, ju
u u D k h , y, h b uh uh . I b, h uu u u hgg. Th u Bg ju u; y [Daß wir das Sein verstehen, ist nicht nur wirklich, sondern es ist notwendig ]. (GA 40: 90/88)
Ag h hg u h k h b- D u b y uy u-b h y, Hgg h h v
ug bg h y h g hg uy vv y. Bu y hD’ bg ub h y u b vv, h bg z, h h bg z
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 74/106
70
padi
ub h bg , ju y h y, y y h y b u. A Cgh , “v , h hg, h u, bhvg y.” O u -u bg h y -ub, hgh-v, h bu D’ . I gh h b gy y, Hgg hu , qu-hy,h by h h y D y hy h u . Ou ug Bg could
h b u hv g ,ju h z u b, h u .
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 75/106
71
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
endnotes
I u k hk P Vv D Dh hhgg v qu h ,h h Hgg C EyUvy 2012. Th gy h bh y gu h y v h .
1 C. J. P, F. V, B. Phu, J.-M. Ry (.), Natu-ralizing Phenomenology: Issues in Contemporary Phenomenology and Cognitive Science
(S: S Uvy P, 1999).S Hu h j h vy , , L , “huy qu, h uzg Hu’ hgy.” L L, “Bg Au-A: P 2: Wh A W?” Graduate Faculty Phi-losophy Journal , V. 30: 2 (2009), 220. A g uy hhg u uug h hgy h by h u bu Shu Ggh D Zhv, The Phenomenologi-
cal Mind: an Introduction to Philosophy o Mind and Cognitive Sci-ence (N Yk: Rug, 2008), 19–41.
2 Gg Agb, “Th P Fy,” Potentialities: Collected Essays in Philosophy , by D- H-Rz (S: S Uvy P, 1999),188–189.
3 Agb, “Th P Fy,” 189.4 Th v hughu h ;
, , GA 2: 366–67/SZ2: 276: “D, , -y y. […] Bu h y D -y guh h uy hg bjvy. Eg D u hgbjvy h h .”
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 76/106
72
padi
5 A hy y h b u G K’ “Nu,” The Routledge Companion to Twen-tieth Century Philosophy , by D M (N Yk:Rug, 2008), 254–307.
6 W. V. Qu, “Nu; , Lvg h O’ M,” Quintessence: Basic Readings rom the Philosophy o W. V. Quine , by Rg F. Gb, J. (Cbg: Hv UvyP, 2004), 281.
7 Jh Dué, “H b Nu Whu Bg S h Suy Hu Nu,” Naturalism and Normativ-ity , by M C Dv Mhu (N Yk:
Cub Uvy P, 2010), 290.8 I u b h Hgg, v Being and Time,
uvy u h Vorhanden. Fh u g h y Hgg, yhg “Th Pb Nu Hgg’ MbugP,” Heideggers Marburger Zeit: Themen, Argumente, Kon-stellationen (Fku M: V K, 2013).Th h u, hv, uv h y k u b g h g Hgg’ Vorhandenheit h u u- by h u .
9 Th , y, y by g hu h h Vorhanden ( bv) h u h h (), hVorhanden hu y b y b bg . Hgg y g--h h b u y-h bg.
10 Jh Ru h Hgg “j u -
gug, g h -K, hg, gv , h hhy u bg h h hz u ‘u’ vv h uuug h ”;
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 77/106
73
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
Jh Ru, “Hgg S Nu,” Con-tinental Philosophy o Science, by Gy Gug (M,MA: Bk Pubhg, 2005), 130. Bu Ru h -g h D’ bg--h- h h - h h , y h u Hgg b u u. Th b y uy y - h u “.” Ay,R h “ u yy g -v ubj- hhy, uh gy, g,, u, h u
hz h uy b hhy h.” Ag Ru, Hgg’ u- gy h (b., 130).Bu hv h Hgg bv h h g g h h-hy h v , hh hy Ibv h Ru g u u gyh u Hgg v .
11 Hgg’ hz h g “hy” h h h y : “Ih uy, u gy gy uh hy” (GA 26: 202/158). F ,u u h ub h b -gy, hgy, gy, Sv G C,Husserl, Heidegger, and the Space o Meaning (Ev: Nh- Uvy P, 2001), 222–43.
12 F uy Hgg’ u y, W MN, “L By h Og: A Bg Hgg’ Fbug Lu, 1929–1930,” Animal Others:
On Ethics, Ontology and Animal Lie, by P Sv(Aby, SUNY P, 1999), 197–248. F huvu Hgg’ gg h h y b-g hy h y h ug
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 78/106
74
padi
g , Th K, Phänomenologie des Lebendigen: Heideggers Kritik an den Leitbegrifen der neuzeitlichen Biologie (Vg K Ab, 2011).
13 S, , Mh C, h u h h v, Hgg’ “u y bk h k, ug - g h h b uquy hu .”Mh C, Zoographies: The Question o the Animal romHeidegger to Derrida (N Yk: Cub Uvy P,2008), 36.
14 Jqu D, The Animal that Thereore I Am,
by Dv W (N Yk: Fh Uvy P, 2008),143–160.
15 Hv, v hv h , h vy h vuug, Hgg h h h ug bg hh y -: “W h bg uh h” (GA 29/30: 512/353).Th g-b h h y h Hgg, hu, y, g - “” D: “Nhg h k b u y g” (GA 29/30: 398/274).
16 A J. Mh, “Hgg’ L Thkg Ay:Th E W-Pvy,” Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle
Annual , Vu 1 (2011): 84.17 Ju Oy M, Man a Machine, Fh-Egh E-
(I: O Cu, 1912); Lug Büh, Force and Mat-ter, or the Principles o the Natural Order o the Universe (L:Ah C., 1884); Pu Chuh, “Ev M- h P Au,” Journal o Philosophy , v.
LXXVIII, . 2 (1981): 67–90.18 Jh Dué, The Disorder o Things: Metaphysical Foundations o the Disunity o Science (Cbg: Hv Uvy P,1993).
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 79/106
75
From the Facticity o Dasein to the Facticity o Nature
19 Ny Cgh, The Dappled World: A Study o the Bound-aries o Science (Cbg: Cbg Uvy P, 1999).I , h y - hyv u u I Hkg’ Represent-ing and Intervening: Introductory Topics in the Philosophy o Natural Science (Cbg: Cbg Uvy P, 1983) L D P G’ Objectivity (N Yk:Z Bk, 2007). Th u h g uh v u h y h u v h hgy.
20 S h y M C Dv Mhu’Naturalism and Normativity (N Yk: Cub UvyP, 2010).
21 Cgh, The Dappled World , 1.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 80/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual , 3 (2013): 76–87.
oo reiew
Tg Cbu
Wayne J. Froman
M Hgg. Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event).T by Rh Rjz D Vg-Nu.Bg: I Uvy P, 2012. 433 .
Rh Rjz D Vg-Nu hv j v vg h Hgg’ Beiträge zur Philosophie(Vom Ereignis) h Agh . Hgg’ – b-
1936 1938, bu ubh huuy 1989 (h 1994) vu 65 Hgg’ “C E”(GA 65) – j bh h Hgg’ u hhy u . Th hkg h yu. A, h . I v h h hHgg u ubh uy . Th u - gh v: “P (Vorblick),” “Th Rg (Der An-klang ),” “Th Iy (das Zuspiel ),” “Th L” (der Sprung ), “ThGug” (die Gründung ), “Th Fuu O” (die Zu-küntigen),
“Th L G” (der letzte Gott
), “Byg” (das Seyn
). I h h G , h “Byg” hugh h u. Fh Wh v H,h h G , “E’ A”h g “Byg” , h k h u by Hgg
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 81/106
77
Review: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event)
h u h h h “Byg” hu bh h h , hh , h h ubh f h “Byg.”Th gh v 281 , h h . Th b h h hh uh v g h hgg hkg. A h h hb , , y, h uy . A h Hgg’ g, h gug g by G ug.
I h Der Denkweg Martin Heideggers 1963 ( Martin Hei-
degger’s Path o Thinking , 1993), O Pögg y kh h u h Beiträge h b Hgg’ j bk. W h ub h ,Being and Time, 1927, h h qu g y. F, das Seyn, h das Sein, u h by Hgg h g -, h b bg bg h u Being and Time h k gy. Das Seyn huy h “byg,” hh h Eg-h “bg.” I Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event), Hgg hkg byg y h bg bg, h , h g hy. Wh Being and Time u v y u D-, u g bg, Contributions Hgg y hz D- y, h, . “Th g” “h g,” h gu h k, uh v Contributions . Wh h , h , Contributions ,h - h Hgg “-” (der Zeitraum) hz h Being and Time’s “h -
” (der Augenblick), h uh . Ah h k Contributions h, -g h Hgg h u bu u u h h, k ju bu h Contributions , h h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 82/106
78
roman
f. Eh h “.” Th Hgg’ u “Th Og h Wk A” (GA5: 1–74/1–56), hh h Contributions . I uh h “” (die Auseinandersetzung ) b g uv . Ah h h h h “” (die Verweigerung ) byg, hh Hgghz byg’ hgh g. A h Contributions h y “gug” (die Gründung ), hh Hgg h Being and Time bu hh h h ugh hk h 1929 y “O h E R” (GA 9: 123–175/97–135). Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event) u g
h g j h Hgg’ k.O uh h “hy” (die Technik) g h - u, “h kg” (das Gestell ), hh Hgg h “h” (die Machenschat ). Ah uh h , u, y. A h gug. Wh h g h h bgg h k ukb h, Being and Time h hugh h g hj Contributions . I, h Being and Time hz y h hkg byg, h h h ’ hkg u h hkg byg u, Hgg u g- h quh u Being and Time. H , h v “Th L”:
A u h qu bg hg h hh yg u h u hy. A“,” “,” “” h hu h (Being and Time) g . (191)
Gv h h h h h h 1930, g k bu v Gy h . T J hy hg. O h g v h , “P”:
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 83/106
79
Review: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event)
T k h qu h more dan- gerous h h y h u h v y bu h hu bg(h M, h h yhg h Jh v h Ru-; uv u , h h h Ru ; B-hv gy W, Eu by:h h , uy, hgy, h ygu Chy; , hv, h uy , qu quz vy y -
qu Chy, hh Jh g{. Nzh’ h v v }, B-hv Jh, bu h Chy by Bhv! Whh hby by?). (44)
Th h h v “Rg”:
Sheer idiocy y h h N-G h h, hy, oreign extraction! W u h hv v ub N Lbz g h“J.” I y h j u hmathematical h u h u h y by “experimentation” ug. (127)
Th v bh g v by Hgg h h h y h bg h bu h “J.” Wh h uh h h by yhg u g
y vg N S hu kg , h bh h bv g h h gk, u h h g k h g k
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 84/106
80
roman
uv v -S u - N S Hgg’ .
A h u, Hgg bu h u das Ereignis , hh G “h v.” I h h , Beiträge zur Philosophie (Vom Ereignis), h “ub” u . Th hv h Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event). Th h h vg yg h gzb g das Ereignis . Fu-h, g “v” “,” h hv u uh y h “O h Ev” , , “Cbu Phhy,” vg h
“O h Ev” h Hgg’ .I , h “” h b u gv .Th h b h Contributions to Philosophy (From Enowning), h h Egh - h . Th h u das Ereignis hu, bg h, bu , gh, “v.” I , “g,” hh Egh . I - das Ereignis h eigen, “” “,” eignen, “ b ,” hh uggv, , h v qu h, h u , bg u h h , buhh bby gu h . Wh H-gg ugh u b h G h u h g uh “g” u Egh. Wh Da-sein, , y Hgg v;vh, h G . Hgg h h h h das Ereignis das Eräugnis h h h eräugnen, bg bh y, bg gh. Th b lichten die Li-chtung , bh y by Hgg, h h y
“g” v , uy h, uh g, h “h g.” H die Lichtung -y g g h b , h u , hby “byg
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 85/106
81
Review: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event)
gh u h h h h g” (181). Th - das Ereignis y “h v” hughu h .Wh y b b bg h bv - Egh h ug h b “v,” h g hugh-u h y “h v” u y ugg h y h h “h v” g y ub v, h g h h v- “ hhy” h hy v “ub hhy,” h h . Hgg h-z das Ereignis “gu u.” S gh uy u b . Wh u ,
by h , h v y zg u, uh “Bg” u ( , , u, by h h G u z), h,h h gh hv b . Th das Ereignis y hv h hy h hh h “Bg” h, hby zg “Bg” h y hy hkg.
A h uy h hughu das Wesen “h .” Wh Hgg u h das Ereignis das Wesen byg, u h Hgg h( Introduction to Metaphysics , ) bg y h vb wesen “ ,” “ ,” “ u,” “ b,” “ h,” y vyhg by vu h g das Wesen “h ,” h y hhy . By vu uh bugh - by Hgg, y, h das Wesen “hg”h währen, u, h das Wesen hdie Wahrheit , h , h uh. Th y h h vy h h Hgg’ hugh.
Bgg h h g h Egh “” k b b. O by -, y, “g,” vb , bu “”h hy . Eyg
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 86/106
82
roman
h h h Egh v y h “,” “-Egh” vb, “,” hh h h “ -” “ u.” Ay, h v h h ky h vu “.” Bu g, bgg y h h g h b “” u bb. I h “T’ Iu,” guhg h h h h Egh - (h das Wesen “h y”), h bh das Wesen das Ereignis :
F Hgg, h v juu h hy hhy k by h g bu by ug h . Thu u v h h k g h uuuy h h hugh yg h. F , h “” “v” h u h -g u h . (v)
I g das Wesen, u h Hgg h by ug h h h u h hh “h .” Bu gv h bugh h by Hgg, gv h y h Hgg’ hugh, y hh,k Da-sein, h gh, h , b u hu h h h y. Wh h das We-sen Hgg’ die Wesung , h “ u.” Lvg h uu uby b u. I , y hg u ’ h h uy. Bu uu-
b vg h hughu “h ” “h u” h g hg u.Bgg h v “Th Rg” ug
hugh h , Hgg “h gh” (die Not )
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 87/106
83
Review: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event)
byg. Th h b, u , bg bybyg, h “[]h uh bg ( hu bg ) -y u y h h D- u” (205; GA 65: 261:“D Whh S u b u, u D-”). Th k “h gh” u k h “h gh.” A hu , h - die Not “gh.” Oh, “,” kg h Hgg’ h h byg (bedüren)Da-sein. Wh uu h ugy h g hqu hu y. O h hg “gg h h y,” by Hgg h -
v “Oy G C Sv U,” h u hv g h h juu. I Contributions ,h g qu byg, byg u qu Da-sein. I ghhv b b h y by g die Not “ug gh,” hh u b bh g hu.
Wh g h h h h vdas Zuspiel , h , “Th Iy,” “y” b h b-gg h hh h h bgg ughby Hgg y v h u h Hgg’ g hh h. A h , h G ugg “yg,” “yg ,” h , yg h h b-gg. I h , h vv h h jy h y. I h Egh h , h das Zuspiel “Pyg Fh.” D h h h Egh, h vy h h h y by h G . Ph y ug“Py T” u hv h .
Ry, h h ’ g die Zu-künt-
igen “h uu ,” zuküntig “ .” Hgg u h die Zuküntigen y h h ugg h y hk h “ .” Bu hy g hughu zuküntig “ ,” die
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 88/106
84
roman
Zuküntigen “h uu ,” h h “uu” “huu ,” h h g uu, u -u. F , Hgg hz Hö h zuküntig u u h Hö “ .”Ph gh ugg h Hö’ y, k, y . Bu h h b h, h , h u h u b h y--?
Muh h u u b y g u guh h g h h v “Th L G”:
M Syg, Fg h Su “Mhyk” übu h, Fk zü u Au zu Lu gg. W Läu, Fk uu V-gäg zuäg? D Läu ü, u j ä , u äk Vor -äu, k Nhäu, Evuh, hh k, u “vb” u g. DV-äu ü j u j uügh “V” (. h. h h)-u anängliche ,
E u Sb zu Fg h h,h u ubg zg k. (GA 65: 415)
Th :
Wh h qu byg, hh h v hqu bg hby “hy,” hh g h u-u h g h vu. Wh h u h k u h h h -u? Th u u b ore-u, h h h y
h h . Thy u b -u,h y “v” bu h . Th -u u b inceptual v gy y h h “-u” (h
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 89/106
85
Review: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event)
uy h) u hk y, hy, gh uquy h h u h b qu. (329)
Bu h u h h h u u b gy u h h b (die Vor-lauenden) h uy bh (hinter ) h gy u , h h h h u hy . Ih , h gy u uu, hy h uh uh h (vor ) g h b hugh y, hy, ghuquy, y “ ” h h u.
A h h h jy h “y ”(das Zuspiel ), , h ugy h gh (die Not ) byg h hkg by byg’ b bg. A,h h h h uu h uhy, bugh by Hgg h u hy h Being and Time, g.
A h hkg h Hgg u y, h Er-denken h uh byg. Th Er-
denken “vv hkg.” Th uggv , gh k hh k ( , hk D’ h l’invention de l’autre, “h v hh”). Y, h er-denken “vg” h “hkg hg u,” h g guby h y h Hgg h . O h hh, h, h y hv v h hy y h , h , “uuuy [] h hugh y g h.”
Wh h? Er-denken k bg Da-sein. I hk-
g h byy gu h “,” h “h,” h “h.” I g “hkg bu,” “-f.” Th bygug uy h b hugh y gu (der Urgrund ), hh y, “h v” (das
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 90/106
86
roman
Ereignis ). O gh hk h gv hz, y,“-fv hkg,” bu “-fv” b u h Er-denken, , v, h h h “er .” Th “er ” hv h “g” “k-g,” bu “kg” g h “ug,” h, y, h ugg u. Rug h h “b h h,” Hgg b h “h by g h g h ” (329). I “er ” b u g h , h das Er-denken ub “g hkg,” h “g” u bh h h hkg bu , h ,
y, h k h.O , h u u vy
Contributions , bu h gu y ubqu u-h u by Hgg ubh h Gesamtausgabe uh Besinnung (GA 66), h Auseinandersetzung , hh h Contributions “.”Th g “u h,” “ h”( Auseinander…) g . I h g “u h” h v-à-v h. H h g u y b: g h .
A h bv hvg b , h vy v gh h , g g h h yu hkg Hgg’ , g h g by h , k hk h h u hv hugh uh, , h. Bu h k hy u h by h -, h h Iu, h hF, . I k k h h fuy h , hugh
h u vu v. Hv, h g y hy v G kg hh, vh h h by Hgg, h gug Contributions hg, y h, v,
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 91/106
87
Review: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event)
gv h u h. A , h hvh “ hhy.” Wh u, , g g y hg h g u h byh . O h k h yhg h hy hv y vg h kb h vy vy u , bu h v-g u h vu , hh u h bb h Egh-G G-Egh g v(g h Gk-Egh L-Egh g) h vu,u b . A , h g y h h G- by h Egh u, h Egh
u G bg , bu hg buhy h .
Hvg bgu by g h j v by Rh Rj-z D Vg-Nu vg Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event ) h Agh , h y gu y gu y k-u .
endnotes
1 U h, ub h g ub h bk u v.
2 Contributions to Philosophy (From Enowning), . Pv E Kh My (Bg I: I U-vy P, 1999).
3 Jqu D, Psyché: Inventions de l’Autre, Tomes I et II (P:Gé, 1987/2003); Psyché: Inventions o the Other , Volume I and Volume II , . Pggy Ku Ezbh Rbg (S:
S Uvy P, 2007, 2008).
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 92/106
Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual , 3 (2013): 88–98.
oo reiew
F J Fbug, v A M
Hakhamanesh Zangeneh
P Vv. Heidegger and the Romantics: The Literary Inventiono Meaning. N Yk: Rug, 2011. 202 .
The Romantic estimation of Plato within the history of philosophy
sees precisely not what is actually positive in him: that which
is not well-rounded, is fragmentary, what remains under-
way. That is the genuinely positive element in all research. Of
course, this does not mean that every imperfection would as
such already be positive, but only that it harbors the possibility
of growth.
– Heidegger, Platon: Sophistes, GA 19: 412/285.
P Vv’ Heidegger and the Romantics , y y, g uy. Wh y h hv
k g h b Hgg’ hhy h y G R (Pögg, Fk, Lu-L-bh/Ny – h Vv’ bk), k h, y u h . Bu h bkb u gubkg ju by vu bu
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 93/106
89
Review: Heidegger and the Romantics
h. A Vv h u h quy, h g hg-gg. Th y h h g h bk bh h h R u Hgg. Rh,h u hg h guv by j.Th h bk h h h R ku g hh , hy v h -u uu h u ug u h ;hy k gy. T h u, Vv Hgg’ , y h 1930 y 1940. H h h bk, y, Hgg’ h k Seinsgeschichte. B
ug gg h h j, hv, y b uu h h bk .
Th ub h bk, “Th Ly Iv Mg,”gh k h uy g h h g -u by Nh A y h h. A ub u g g h M hu R h b hhy u, bk h . Vv hh h g, gg h y gh – hugh gh h qu h y, y h h g Hgg. Wh h k h b y h hy bh uy -y, h uy h g h g gy u uh. Th “y” h ub Dichtung , bh h Ey G R Hgg, h, h y u “gu.” Th -u j h bk (hugh gh h b uy), bu u h u Vv’ gu.
Th h bk u R-. Th uh u Fh Shg, Nv Sh-h. Wh gu h uh ( h Athenaeum) ug “Ey G R,”
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 94/106
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 95/106
91
Review: Heidegger and the Romantics
h v h y b gz hh , Vv ugg (22)? T h u gz gy b “y”?
Ay, h Hgg h vg -uh uh v, b b vy, h gh h Hgg Erdenken h h h y sich etwas ausdenken (78). I, bg h g Hgg’ Seinsge-schichte, h reading h hy bk u , h h k h g- Ey G R. Wh Vv
bu h bg, h h hugh h u- h Hgg h, , h : “Zu ghhh W u Bükhg Üb-gg, Bük b, uhg zu hU“ (GA 65: 169/119). I g bgg v y b h, bgg-v hh h h, h hhy h , bu g u v hh gv, uh g h k h Zuspiel h Beiträge, h h ug h b h h h hkg g h h g.
N, h “g” h bu vk u,h h y. O y b h gh “” bj, u by h , k I h K- , y ub. Th g u hu h ub. Bu h qu - b b Vv’ y. Ph hv h uy h uu h u.Bu h h Ey G R
hy y h g, , y, h , h g, hh, h . Th qu h gy h g(h h /h Ey G R-) uuy b gh. A , Vv
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 96/106
92
anene
y y y g h, bu hh Bh Bj, h h hh u g vy v (29–32). Sykg, h v . O gh y h h b hkg h b h g - gh, h “gv ” ( hh Hg u h vy ). Th v, .. hBh/Bj h, u qu uv gvy, hy, - g.
Wh Vv g by uvg h bv u hy. Sug h, h b u-
h “gv” u v. Th g bg. Th uz g bu g , g h k hgh g, hghy. Th z y “” h k , bu “bk,” bh hk k, u. Fuy h h k G hhy h ghh h u (bu h Vv’ Ey G R “-”), – h y – hugh h u. Th , u, u bu -z, v.
Th g u h hu kh kb . I y sketched h R, gu uy. I -y , u h “ gy.” Nu, g bg, uufu, h h hh . Th k fh u by Vv h h Ey G R: , y, . Ih v I y vy hy h h y.
T yg-v bh z gug h ( by g bu vgu , g vy) qu b b-y, g h hy h , hg (39).
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 97/106
93
Review: Heidegger and the Romantics
Py, , h h h vyy, hgh y h . I k bg u hbg, u h fu (55). I h , h v , g Vv, by vu qu h Subj (52). Th z u ubj bj, y uy, hby guy uv(64). I, h u Shh hu,u h v h h (K) v u- uh “b” h h uh h/h.
F Vv, h b “fu -gy” (36). Th b g u gug h
, , , h hv h bg, hg . P-g u, hugh g v Hgg’ h b u , , “Th Og h Wk A” h Beiträge, hhhy ( ) h b h Ins-Werk-setzen der Wahrheit (36) – hby Wahrheit b gy -uy, h gy ug (Streit ) g .Th Wahrheitsgeschehen bh k, vy -g-h hkg h “” Geschehen; h y, h physis . I y b, g h 1930, Geschehen, hg, v, ug. I Hgg b v uh “gy” – y genet gy – fu, h h hv vb h R v hu b, hg, hvg h h bg u- h bu u, ug z.
heidegger the ionian
Th h Hgg hk fu vy.B h h 1930, Vv v Hgg’ λόγος h 1920, bg u h bh g bg h uh bg. H Hgg’
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 98/106
94
anene
fu u ubh GA 38. I h uHgg hz hy hugh hgug. Nby, h b hy hugh bg hy hugh , “hkg -u” (116). Dguhg b u h geschichtlich u h -h b h uh Hgg’ u h, h , Hgg h h h. Thu Hgg’ vu Euhy Hgg gh . S, , Vv bHgg’ hhy h vv g v
u h hkg hy g h “hkg u” (117). O gh h Lu-Lbh’ h, hh y h y as h Ey G R h Hgg h h Gy “h” g j.
Vv u GA 39 (1934) h k y - h h Hgg’ hkg h . Th1934 u h h h g Stimmung D g hy, g g Grund . Th 1936 y b h g -y Geschehen, hg. A h gv u hg k h u, hugh h, h hg hg (139). I h h h “-y” u, bu qu Dichtung , gz “gu-g” hh k vu u – one hh b y (137). (A h h h bk’ ub, “ThLy Iv Mg,” b uu.) Th u h g h k hy, Geschichte, qu hugh- “fu gy.” Thu, h uh-v h
hg, bu “gu” , h b uh gu-b Dichtung , h hg, , ., hv bu fuug u. Th y
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 99/106
95
Review: Heidegger and the Romantics
bg Vv h I k b h g h Hgg h bk.
Ag u uh, uh h Beiträge u H-gg’ “ gy,” hh v D, g , bu hh h “ y -” (141). Thg hu bg v h u-, bu hu bg hv h hy hugh h . Wh h uv hz, hy hyh. Th hyh h hBeiträge, u guh uh bg h ubg adjectivally – vby. “T b” ,
bg. Tuh h vb, hu hg b u ( uh) hu g h (bg).“Eg ” u uu “bg,” h h Vv u u uh bg bg,“seiend werden” (GA 65: 293/207). Wh h u u u, h by h hh h y b bg(j.), g bg (j.), unseiend seinlos , bu .My gh, bu y qu , h h hz.
O h h, h b bg (j.) -bg (j.) h “[] h v h bu h v - k hg ug h bg by hg h hg… g h ug…” (144). A y h hz k ug hy bg y, y, fuug -bg bh h . Th h-, hkb, Vv u P u h u λόγος h b fu. Thuh h Hgg’ gy h hy- bg/bg bg uvy.
H b h by fg P b οὐκ ὄν μὴ ὄν. Th ubg h h y bg(μὴ ὄν) h uy bg (οὐκ ὄν). Th “” b-g hu g (151) – hugh h b
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 100/106
96
anene
h gb. Hh, Hgg u b ug hg P h bz P. Bu h b/gbh h k hy? I bg/bg ub byhy ju bu h b vug P? H h hk h vug P h P -, , , Abu Mgu’ hy fu (T 4 De Causis et Processu…) h hughy hy (hugh by vu b/gb) B Über Starres und
Fliessendes ? N h hk y bg h οὐκ ὄν , hy hk h fu h b. A , v, h - h “ gy” ubu.
Th u h u gv y h hv Hgg’ gug, y bugh . Bu h, h h g bg (j.) hg h v (Bewahrung ), u g. Cg seiend unseiend , Wesen and Unwesen, h g v uuby gh, bu h h g bg (j.) g u?Th u b h v u h , bu h V-v’ uh jv bg b bguu, h . I b h u h by hg hh u bu y b bg (j.) (144). Ubgu hv y uuh. Nh, h h Hgg, h , k bg v. I h h g bg, h g gy Ey G R. Th qu gu, Dichtung , h uu -v, u h Wahrheitsgeschehen. Th g h ubg hh h hv, h b gh h fuy bg. Wh
uqu Hgg’ h gug h uu h bu h ug (161). Th gu, h gug, h ubg u, huhkg u y g u h fu.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 101/106
97
Review: Heidegger and the Romantics
Th uh h Vv’ y bk; b hh u vv – Ihv y h u h. Th qu ugg hI hv bugh u y h , bu h uh b. Th h h Vv h u bg . Fy, I u k u hg ugh u by Heidegger and the
Romantics . Th Egh gug Hgg u h b vhgy h h I “hg v.” A hg v u Hgg’ hh y Hgg y bu
h hh, y b y h h Hgg y gh Hgg’ h. Thhh hu k u, , v hg act . S h vy uy Hgg Shg h I k Egh u h Freiheitsschrit – h y Shg. Evy vg Hgg’ b J b u h ’ y “Bkug” ( Holzwege) bg h z by Hgg. Bu h Geschichte Historie? Shu Seinsgeschichte b b bg ug hugh g y, Pu, Sz Fh? D hg h Hgg uh h k h not vy ? P V-v’ bk, , g uv hh u,b Hgg R, g h h h actual h . W b gu h uh hvg , Egh, h hh possible.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 102/106
98
anene
endnotes
1 S, , Pu M, The Resistance to Theory (M-, M: Uvy M P, 1986) Azj Wk, Readings in Interpretation: Hölderlin, Hegel ,Heidegger (M, M: Uvy MP, 1987).
2 Vv u h h qu- by g 50 g h Odyssey h The Task o the Interpreter: Text,
Meaning and Negotiation (Pbugh: Uvy Pbugh
P, 2005), 79–95.3 S W Jhk’ u Früher Idealismus und Frühromantik: der Streit um die Grundlagen der Ästhetik (1795– 1805), vu (Hbug: M, 1990, 1995).
4 A ub h h g Heidegger and the Romantics , h y h u h .
5 S, , Rh Ghé’ FhShg, Philosophical Fragments , by P Fh(M L: Uvy M P, 1991),
v–.6 Vv gy h h u
y by Shg (35). Bu u u b h hhk, y h Philosophy o Art . Th, h h, hhy h h.
7 S Lu-Lbh, Heidegger and The Politics o Poetry , - h u by J F (Ub Chg: U-vy I P, 2007).
8 S, , J-M Nb, Hénologie, Ontologie et Ereignis (Plotin, Proclus, Heidegger) (P: L B L,2001).
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 103/106
99
texts of heidegger cited and abbreviations used
R h k M Hgg vhy h by vu h Gesamtausgabe (Fku M: V K, 1975–), bbv “GA,” hG g v , by h h Eghg ubh h . Th y h Being and Time (GA 2), h Egh g v, bu h Gesamtausgabe g byh G g h g- ubh by Ny:Sein und Zeit , 17h . (Tübg: M Ny Vg, 1993). Th
g h u h g bh Egh Being and Time by h SZ1 SZ2,gy, b. M ubh by “,” h by “.”
from the gesamtausgabe
GA 1 Frühe Schriten. E. Fh-Wh v H. 1978GA 2 Sein und Zeit. E. Fh-Wh v H. 1977.GA 5 Holzwege. 7h . E. Fh-Wh v H.
1994. Egh : Of the Beaten Track. E. . Ju Yug Kh Hy. Cbg:Cbg Uvy P, 2002.
GA 9 Wegmarken. 3 . E. Fh-Wh v H.1996. Egh : Pathmarks . E. W MN.Vu . Cbg: Cbg Uvy P, 1998.
GA 11 Identität und Di erenz. E. Fh-Wh vH. 2006. Egh : Identity and Diference. T. J Sbugh. N Yk: H &R, 1969.
GA 12 Unterwegs zur Sprache. E. Fh-Wh vH. 1985.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 104/106
100
GA 14 Zur Sache des Denkens . E. Fh-Wh vH. 2007. Egh : On Time and Being .T. J Sbugh. N Yk: H & R, 1972.
GA 17 Einührung in die phänomenologische Forschung . E.Fh-Wh v H. 1994. Egh: Introduction to Phenomenological Research .T. D O. Dh. Bg: IUvy P, 2005.
GA 18 Grundbegrife der aristotelischen Philosophie. E. MkMhk. 2002. Egh : Basic Concepts o
Aristotelian Philosophy . T. Rb D. M Mk
B. Tz. Bg: I Uvy P, 2009.GA 19 Platon: Sophistes . E. Igbg Shüß. 1992. Egh
: Plato’s “Sophist.” T. Rh Rjz Aé Shu. Bg: I Uvy P, 1997.
GA 20 Prolegomena zur Geschichte des Zeitbegrifs . E. PJg. 1994. Egh : History o the Concept o Time: Prolegomena. T. Th K. Bg:I Uvy P, 1992.
GA 21 Logik. Die Frage nach der Wahrheit . E. W B.1976. Egh : Logic: The Question o Truth .T. Th Shh. Bg: I UvyP, 2010.
GA 24 Die Grundprobleme der Phänomenologie. 2 . E.Fh-Wh v H. 1989. Egh: The Basic Problems o Phenomenology . Rv. T. Ab H. Bg: IUvy P, 1982.
GA 26 Metaphysische Anangsgründe der Logik im Ausgang von Leibniz. E. Ku H. 1990. Egh : The
Metaphysical Foundations o Logic. T. Mh H.Bg: I Uvy P, 1984.GA 27 Einleitung in die Philosophie. E. O S I
S-S. 1996.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 105/106
101
GA 29/30 Die Grundbegrife der Metaphysik: Welt – Endlichkeit – Einsamkeit . 2 . E. Fh-Wh v H.1992. Egh : The Fundamental Concepts o
Metaphysics: World, Finitude, Solitude. T. WMN Nh Wk. Bg: IUvy P, 1995.
GA 39 Hölderlins Hymnen “Germanien” und “Der Rhein.” 2 .E. Su Zg. 1989.
GA 40 Einührung in die Metaphysik. E. P Jg. 1983.Egh : Introduction to Metaphysics . T.Ggy F Rh P. N Hv: Y
Uvy P, 2000.GA 56/57 Zur Bestimmung der Philosophie. 2 . E. B
Hbüh. 1999. Egh : Towards theDenition o Philosophy. T. T S. N Yk:Cuu, 2008.
GA 58 Grundprobleme der Phänomenologie. E. H-HuhG. 1992.
GA 60 Phänomenologie des religiösen Lebens . E. MhJug, Th Rghy, Cuu Sub. 1995. Egh: The Phenomenology o Religious Lie. T.Mh Fh J A G-F.Bg: I Uvy P, 2004.
GA 61 Phänomenologische Interpretationen zu Aristoteles. Einührung in die phänomenologische Forschung . 2 .E. W Bök Kä Bök-O. 1994
GA 65 Beiträge zur Philosophie (Vom Ereignis). 2 . E.Fh-Wh v H. 1994. Egh: Contributions to Philosophy (O the Event).T. Rh Rjz D Vg-Nu.
Bg: I Uvy P, 2012.GA 66 Besinnung . E. Fh-Wh v H. 1997.Egh : Mindulness . T. Pv E Th Ky. N Yk: Cuu, 2006.
7/29/2019 Gatherings 2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/gatherings-2013 106/106
GA 85 Vom Wesen der Sprache. Die Metaphysik der Sprache und die Wesung des Wortes. Zu Herders Abhandlung “Über denUrsprung der Sprache.” E. Ig Shüß. 1999. Egh: On the Essence o Language: The Metaphysics o Language and the Essencing o the Word; Concerning Herder’s “Treatise on the Origin o Language.” Tby W T Ggy Yv U. Aby:SUNY, 2004.
from other english translations
OWL On the Way to Language. T. P D. Hz. N Yk:H & R, 1971.
PLT Poetry, Language, Thought . T by Ab H.N Yk: H & R, 1971.
SZ1 Being and Time. T. Jh Mqu ERb. N Yk: H & R, 1962.N: by h G g “SZ” bv.
SZ2 Being and Time. T. J Sbugh, v. D J.Sh. Aby: S Uvy N Yk P, 2010.N: by h G g “SZ” bv.