Date post: | 24-Jun-2015 |
Category: |
Education |
Upload: | cbs-competitiveness-platform |
View: | 124 times |
Download: | 2 times |
The impact of firms’ gender diversity targets on the work motivation and
turnover intentions of managers
A research sketch Orsola Garofalo and Georg Wernicke
Questions? Write to: [email protected]
Top management teams back in time…
Nowadays…
Black Rock 2011
17 members (3 not shown)
BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE: BLK) – U.S. investment firm & world's largest asset manager
Executive Committee Carlsberg 2014
Senior Vice President, Group Communications & CSR since 2004
Female Directors around the World
Overview Gender Quotas
Gender Diversity – Business Case • Claim: Gender diversity on boards has a positive effect on firms’
bottom line (e.g. increase firm value/performance…) • Studies supporting this claim often echo well in the media
McKinsey report “Women Matter” 2009 Credit Swiss Report 2014
Media Echo Credit Swiss
But…
1. Measure correlations and not causation 2. Often ignore the most obvious background
variables 3. Fail to differentiate between top management
teams and boards (McKinsey) – but effects are likely to differ
4. Fail to account for other reasons why firms with more gender diverse boards/top management teams perform better (endogeneity)
Selective Research Evidence • Diverse findings (positive, negative, insignificant
impact) using different samples, time periods, econometric approaches
• Endogeneity issue: Adams and Ferreira (2009), based on 1500 largest US firms, long time period, director networks: relationship btw. gender diversity and firm performance is, if at all, negative
• Quota (Norway): Ahern and Dittmar (2012), negative impact on firm value/returns compared to US benchmark driven by firms with no prior female board member
Take-Away • Popular studies often suffer from severe
shortcoming • Conclusions from research are not clear cut,
but point to, if at all, negative effect – …but short vs long term effects (…)
• Indication that boards/TMT: – Matter – Are composed to maximize firm value – Are specific to a firm
Idea in a Nutshell • Diversity targets might affect:
– Employee (female and male) work motivation – Turnover intentions (male)
• Explanation for the short term negative effect on firm value/performance of quotas
• Theoretical basis: tournament theory • Level of observation: top management team • Method: experiment
Deutsche Telekom 30% in 2015
Carlsberg
Tournament
Winner gets promoted to top management position
25% chance to win
Talent Pool for Top Management
Best 1,2,3…get promoted
Diversity Target 30%
Female Manager Male Manager
Gender Quota 30%
Female Manager Male Manager
Experiment
Experiment
No chance of being promoted 50% chance of being promoted
Experiment cont.
30 % chance of being promoted
50 % chance of being promoted
No chance of being promoted
Our Expectations • The higher the diversity target, the lower the
chances of male talents to be promoted, thus: 1. Stronger reduction in their work motivation 2. Increasing willingness to change employers
• Potentially also: – Lower work motivation of female employees as
chances to get promoted are significantly higher (e.g., just need to come in on 3. place)
Expansions
• Level of competitiveness (some males might just work even harder thinking they are better than everybody else anyways)
• Effects of higher diversity in the talent pool (1 vs. 50% females)
• Effect of binding quota vs. diversity target • ….