Date post: | 06-May-2015 |
Category: |
Leadership & Management |
Upload: | raja-bavani |
View: | 451 times |
Download: | 7 times |
7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
25-Jul-13
7TH BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013 JULY 26 & 27 - 2013
Raja Bavani Chief Architect, Mindtree
2 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Good Morning!
• Let us know each other – introduce yourself!
• What do you expect from this session?
• How do you connect with this topic?
• How is this tutorial going to enable you at work?
3 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Key things…
Only once
• Coffee break
Always
• Silent, restful electronic devices
• Conversations and experience sharing
• Questions
4 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
TOC
• Part 1 - Introduction
• Part 2 - Consumers and their needs
• Part 3 - Building an effective dashboard
• Part 4 - Industry trends
• Part 5 - Parting thoughts
5 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Part 1 - Introduction
• What is a dashboard?
Group Activity 1
Give 3 examples of dashboards you come across in daily life. How impressive are they? Why?
6 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
A dashboard is..
“A dashboard is a visual display of the most important information needed to achieve one or more objectives, consolidated and arranged on a single screen so the information can be monitored at a glance.”
- Stephen Few
Author of ‘Information Dashboard Design – The Effective Visual Communication of Data’
7 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Dashboards..
“They provide visibility into key performance indicators (KPIs) through simple visual graphics such as gauges, charts and tables within a web browser. Dashboards are appealing because they: • Present a wide number of different metrics in a single consolidated
view • Roll up details into high-level summaries • Provide intuitive indicators, such as gauges and stoplights, that are
instantly understandable - for example, red bar means problem, green bar means everything is on plan.
In many respects a reporting dashboard can be likened to a dashboard in an automobile. It provides an 'at-a-glance view' of the current operational state of the vehicle.”
- Dan Dubriwny and Kurt Rivards
8 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Why do we need?
• Why do we need dashboards?
• Who needs them?
9 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Effective Dashboards
• What makes a dashboard effective? What are the characteristics?
• Have you come across an effective dashboard? Why do you think it is effective? Was anything missing in that dashboard?
• What about efficiency? What does it mean?
10 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
The Process
IDENTIFY GATHER PROCESS
ANALYZE
ASSEMBLE PRESENT
11 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Benefits
• What are the expected benefits?
• What are the actual benefits? Share your experience.
12 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Measures and Metrics
• Context-specific
• Multi-dimensional
• Seasonal
They are the building blocks of dashboards!
Source: Quantitative Management, Transparency and Trust –Raja Bavani
13 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
The problem with measures and metrics
• Too many - some are not useful
• Too much time to gather, analyze and report
• Data quality - poor
• Lack of baselines
• Lack of time to analyze
• No contribution to decision making and action planning
• Not the priority of Senior leaders and executives
14 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Ineffective Dashboards
• What are the disadvantages?
15 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Part 2 – Consumers and their needs
Different types of consumers
• Project team members
• Program manager
• Business unit head
• Location head
• Quality head
• CEO
16 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Examples
Consumers Dashboard Type
Project team Project dashboard
Program manager Project portfolio dashboard or program dashboard
Business unit head Business unit dashboard
Location head Location dashboard
Quality head Organizational quality dashboard
CEO Organizational quality dashboard*
* Is that sufficient?
17 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Let us try..
Group Activity 2
In your opinion, list the different types of consumers of dashboards in your industry. How are their needs different? If you are responsible for delivering dashboards, how will you decide
the frequency and content?
18 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
What is the right size?
• One page?
• One screen?
The fundamental challenge of dashboard design is to display all the required information on a single screen:
– clearly and without distraction
– in a manner that can be quickly examined and understood
– Stephen Few
19 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Cockpit of a commercial jet
20 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Cockpit of a commercial jet
Years of effort went into its design to enable the pilot to see what’s going on at a glance, even though there is much information to monitor.
Every time I board a plane, I’m grateful that knowledgeable designers worked hard to present this information effectively.
Similar care is needed for the design of our dashboards.
- Stephen Few
21 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Contents of a dashboard
Group Activity 3
List the contents of a dashboard you use most frequently. How important are they? Are they
related? What are the key parameters you have included in your dashboard? How do you want
to represent them? What are the top 3 questions do you want your dashboard to
answer?
22 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Traffic Light
Today’s status is clear. But where is the project headed?
23 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Traffic Lights
“Unlike traffic lights that automatically change, projects don’t change unless the project manager and the team act to change them. Projects tend to continue in the direction the team is heading.”
- Johanna Rothman
24 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Weather Report
25 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Which one do you prefer?
26 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Weather Report
Status Description
Sunny The project schedule is on target
Mostly
Sunny
There is minor project schedule concern, but the
schedule can be met.
Partly
Cloudy
There is schedule concern; the schedule can be
met by putting extra efforts.
Cloudy There will be difficulty meeting the schedule.
Rainy To meet the schedule would take great difficulty.
Severe The schedule cannot be met in any situation.
Source: Sunny Skies or Storms? Project Weather Reports by Johanna Rothman
27 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Do you know?
• Hue – a more precise term for what we normally think of as color (red, green, blue, purple, etc.)
Folks with normal color
vision see the true
colors.
Those who are color-
blind sees it like this.
( 10% of males and 1%
of females)
28 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Why?
“Despite this fact, many vendors actually promote the use of red, yellow, and green stoplight colors as “business intelligence” colors, the most unintelligent choice.”
- Stephen Few
29 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Cool Gadgets
30 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Charts
31 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
What is important?
• Understanding the consumers or customers or the context
• Not exceeding the size
• Providing the right content
• Removing the unwanted
• Visual communication
32 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
So far….
Part 1 - Introduction
Part 2 - Consumers and their needs
• Part 3 - Building an effective dashboard
• Part 4 - Industry trends
• Part 5 - Parting thoughts
33 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Part 3 – Building an effective dashboard
1. Metrics Selection
2. Visual Representation
3. Correctness
4. Accessibility
5. Usability
34 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
3.1 Metrics Selection
• Choose what matters the most
• Do these metrics connect to the project/program/organizational vision?
• Do the consumers of your dashboard understand these metrics?
35 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
GQMM
Goals-Questions-Measures
Goal 1
Question 1
Measure 1 Measure 2
Question 2
Measure 3 Measure 4
Goal 2
Question 3
Ref: “Goal Question Model Paradigm” In Encyclopedia of Software Engineering, 1st edition, John Wiley & Sons, 1994 - Victor R. Basili and Rombach H Dieter
36 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Hierarchy of Goals
Goals are hierarchical !
Goal 1
Question 1 Measure 1
Measure 2
Question 2 Measure 3
Measure 4
Goal 2 Question 3
37 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
3.2 Visual Representation
• Is it easy to understand ?
• Does it communicate the key things?
• Is it intuitive or hard to learn?
• Are the representations effective?
38 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Any examples?
• We discussed some examples before
• Do you want to share your experience?
39 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
3.3 Correctness
• Is the data current?
• Are the metrics reflecting the current challenges?
• Is the data relevant to where you are headed?
40 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
3.4 Accessibility
• Is your dashboard accessible?
• Are people aware?
• Is it simple to access?
• Do people access it at an expected frequency?
41 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
3.5 Usability
• Is it easy to use?
• Is it static or interactive or intelligent?
• Is it simple to use?
• Does it communicate the key things using the right representations, colors, etc.?
42 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
2 more questions
• What can be removed from this dashboard?
• What is missing in this dashboard?
43 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Enablers vs. Drivers
Enablers ‘reinforce’ the Drivers
Drivers ‘ensure’ Results
44 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Do you know?
• What are lagging indicators?
• What are leading indicators?
45 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Lagging Indicators
Lagging indicators are outcome measures that help you gauge progress by examining the final end result or outcomes of your collective efforts.
• Indicates the end result.
• Tells you what occurred, not what is going on.
Examples: Customer Retention, Attrition Rate, Defect Density
46 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Why lagging indicators?
• Lagging indicators have a direct impact on margins.
• Improvement in lagging indicators means enhancing business results!
47 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Leading Indicators
Leading indicators are process measures that help you gauge incremental progress you are making toward key outcome (lagging) measures.
• Immediate feedback or early warning
• Tells what is happening now
• Can be tracked over time to improve end results
Examples: Network Availability, Customer Feedback
48 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Why Leading Indicators?
• Leading indicators have an indirect impact on margins.
• Improvement in leading indicators means enhancing business results over a period of time.
49 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Try this!
Group Activity 4
All of us drive cars. What are the leading and lagging indicators related to driving your car
from one place to another?
At work, what are the leading and lagging indicators?
50 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Balanced Scorecard
• Also known as business scorecard
• Originated by Drs. Robert Kaplan (Harvard Business School) and David Norton
• Performance measurement framework that added strategic non-financial performance measures to traditional financial metrics
• Gives managers and executives a more 'balanced' view of organizational performance.
51 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Balanced Scorecard
Vision and
Strategy
Customer
Financial Internal Business
Processes
Learning and Development
52 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
From Mission to Outcomes
Source: Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton, The strategy focused organization How Balanced Scorecard companies thrive in the new business environment, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, Mass, 2001
53 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Question
How can we apply BSC concepts in designing dashboards?
54 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Try this!
Group Activity 5
Consider a dashboard you create or consume at work. Is it balanced?
How can you apply BSC concepts to your dashboard?
55 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Well-designed dashboards
• Exceptionally well-organized
• Condensed – primarily in the form of summaries and exceptions
• Specific to and customized for the audience and the objectives
• Displayed using concise and often small media that communicate the data and its message in the clearest and most direct way as possible
56 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
So far…
Part 1 - Introduction
Part 2 - Consumers and their needs
Part 3 - Building an effective dashboard
• Part 4 - Industry trends
• Part 5 - Parting thoughts
57 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Part 4 – Industry Trends
• Large electronic visual boards
• Real time data
• Intelligent dashboards
• Interactive dashboards
• Enterprise Application Integration(EAI) & Business Intelligence (BI) adding power to dashboards
• Design and maintenance – a big challenge!
58 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Part 5 – Parting Thoughts
Group Activity 6
What are the 5 things you learned in this tutorial? What are the top 3 takeaways for your
group?
How are you planning to apply this at work?
What are your next steps?
59 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
Q&A
60 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
References
• Information Dashboard Design, The Effective Visual Communication of Data, Stephen Few, O’Reilly, 2006
• Show Me the Numbers, Designing Tables and Graphs to Enlighten, Stephen Few, Analytics Press, 2004
• http://www.prepetualedge.com
• Implementing the IT Balanced Scorecard, Jessica Keyes , Auerbach Publications, 2005
61 7th BSPIN ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2013
THANK YOU!