+ All Categories
Home > Documents > International Dispute Settlement

International Dispute Settlement

Date post: 02-Oct-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 10 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
25
International Dispute Settlement A guide to the techniques and institutions used to solve international disputes, how they work and when they are used. Many, often topical examples place the theory of how things are supposed to work in the context of real-life events so that you can understand the strengths and weaknesses of different methods in practice. The fully updated edition of this successful textbook includes the most recent arbitrations, developments in the WTO and case law from the International Court of Justice. J. G. Merrills has taught international law all over the world for more than forty years. He held visiting posts at the Universities of Auckland and Toronto, twice served as Dean of the Faculty of Law at Sheffield University and for eight years was Alternate Member of the UN Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities. He is the author of various books and journal articles on international law, and is a member of the American Society of International Law and of the British Institute of International and Comparative Law. In 2007 he was elected an Associate Member of the Institut de Droit International. © in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth Edition J. G. Merrills Frontmatter More information
Transcript
Page 1: International Dispute Settlement

International Dispute Settlement

A guide to the techniques and institutions used to solve international disputes,how they work and when they are used. Many, often topical examples place thetheory of how things are supposed to work in the context of real-life eventsso that you can understand the strengths and weaknesses of different methodsin practice. The fully updated edition of this successful textbook includes themost recent arbitrations, developments in the WTO and case law from theInternational Court of Justice.

J. G. Merrills has taught international law all over the world for more thanforty years. He held visiting posts at the Universities of Auckland and Toronto,twice served as Dean of the Faculty of Law at Sheffield University and for eightyears was Alternate Member of the UN Sub-Commission on Prevention ofDiscrimination and Protection of Minorities. He is the author of various booksand journal articles on international law, and is a member of the AmericanSociety of International Law and of the British Institute of International andComparative Law. In 2007 he was elected an Associate Member of the Institutde Droit International.

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 2: International Dispute Settlement

International DisputeSettlementFifth edition

J. G. MERRILLSUniversity of Sheffield

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 3: International Dispute Settlement

cambridge university pressCambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town,Singapore, Sao Paulo, Delhi, Tokyo, Mexico City

Cambridge University PressThe Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK

Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York

www.cambridge.orgInformation on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521199094

c© J. G. Merrills 2011

This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exceptionand to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,no reproduction of any part may take place without the writtenpermission of Cambridge University Press.

First published 2011

Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge

A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library

Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication dataMerrills, J. G.International dispute settlement / J. G. Merrills. – 5th ed.

p. cm.Includes bibliographical references and index.ISBN 978-0-521-19909-4 (hardback)1. Pacific settlement of international disputes. I. Title.JZ6010.M47 2011341.5′2 – dc22 2010051865

ISBN 978-0-521-19909-4 HardbackISBN 978-0-521-15339-3 Paperback

Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence oraccuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred toin this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is,or will remain, accurate or appropriate.

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 4: International Dispute Settlement

Contents

Preface page ixTable of cases xiTable of treaties and agreements xviiList of abbreviations xxivList of websites xxvi

1 Negotiation 1Consultation 2Forms of negotiation 8Substantive aspects of negotiation 11Negotiation and adjudication 16Limitations of negotiation 21

2 Mediation 26Mediators 27Consent to mediation 29Functions of mediation 33The limits of mediation 37

3 Inquiry 41The 1899 Hague Convention 41The Dogger Bank inquiry 42Inquiries under the 1907 Hague Convention 44Treaty practice 1911–40 47The Red Crusader inquiry 48The Letelier and Moffitt case 51The value of inquiry 53

4 Conciliation 58The emergence of conciliation 58The work of commissions of conciliation 60The practice of conciliation 65The place of conciliation in modern treaty law 69Further developments 74The significance of conciliation 79

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 5: International Dispute Settlement

vi Contents

5 Arbitration 83Forms of arbitration 83The selection of arbitrators 86Terms of reference 89Basis of the decision 94Effect of the award 100Private international arbitration 106The utility of arbitration 111

6 The International Court I: organisation and procedure 116Contentious jurisdiction 116Jurisdictional disputes 119Incidental jurisdiction 124Advisory jurisdiction 132Membership of the Court 134Chambers 137

7 The International Court II: the work of the Court 142The Court’s decision 142Extension of the Court’s function 147Legal and political disputes 152The effect of judgments 156The significance of the Court 161

8 The Law of the Sea Convention 167The Convention and its system 167The principle of compulsory settlement 169Exceptions to the principle of compulsory settlement 172Conciliation 174Arbitration 176Special arbitration 179The International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea 181The Sea-Bed Disputes Chamber 183Inaugurating ITLOS 186The significance of the Convention 189

9 International trade disputes 194From GATT (1947) to the World Trade Organization 194The Dispute Settlement Understanding 195Consultations 197Good offices, conciliation and mediation 199Panel proceedings 201Appellate review 205

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 6: International Dispute Settlement

vii Contents

Implementation of rulings and recommendations 210Arbitration 213The WTO system in context 215

10 The United Nations 219The machinery of the Organization 219The Security Council and General Assembly in action 221The role of the Secretary-General 225The political organs and the International Court 231Peace-keeping operations 236Action under Chapter VII 242Are decisions of the political organs open to legal challenge? 247The effectiveness of the United Nations 250

11 Regional organisations 257The range of regional organisations 257The role of regional organisations in disputes 264Limitations of regional organisations 271Regional organisations and adjudication 274Regional organisations and the United Nations 279

12 Trends and prospects 284Dispute settlement today 284A political perspective 286A legal perspective 290Improving the capacity of political methods 295Improving the capacity of legal methods 301Conclusion 308

Appendices 310A. Agreement between Argentina and the United Kingdom

establishing an Interim Reciprocal Information andConsultation System, 1990 310

B. Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Red CrusaderIncident, 1962 (extract) 312

C. Conciliation Commission on the Continental Shelf Areabetween Iceland and Jan Mayen, May 1981 314

D. Arbitration Agreement between the United Kingdom andFrance, July 1975 315

E. Special Agreement for Submission to the International Court ofJustice of the Differences Between the Republic of Hungary andthe Slovak Republic Concerning the Gabcikovo-NagymarosProject (1993) 319

F. Optional Clause Declarations (Peru, Djibouti, Japan, Germany) 322

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 7: International Dispute Settlement

viii Contents

G. WTO: Rules of Conduct for the Understanding on Rules andProcedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (extract) 325

H. Security Council Resolution 915, establishing UNASOG,May 1994 326

I. Terms of Reference of the Trust Fund for the InternationalTribunal for the Law of the Sea (2000) 328

J. Ruling Pertaining to the Differences between France and NewZealand Arising from the Rainbow Warrior Affair (extract) 330

K. CIS: Concept for Prevention and Settlement of Conflicts in theTerritory of States Members of the Commonwealth ofIndependent States (1996) 334

Index 341

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 8: International Dispute Settlement

Preface

Since the fourth edition of this book was published in 2005 there havebeen several developments with a direct bearing on its subject. A newadministration in the United States, the growing influence of China in theworld and political developments in Africa and Europe all have a significantimpact on the activity of both the United Nations and regional organisations.The World Trade Organization, already an established player in 2005, hasmaintained its prominence, and its arrangements for dispute settlementcontinue to be widely used. The complex system set up by the 1982 Law ofthe Sea Convention has been slowly consolidated as cases have been taken tothe International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea or to arbitration, while theInternational Court of Justice is busier now than at any previous time in itshistory. It must, of course, also be noted that solutions to such long-standinginternational problems as Cyprus, Kashmir and Israel/Palestine seem asfar away as ever, reminding us, yet again, of the distance to be travelled,if institutional provisions for dealing with the most serious disputes andsituations are to be effective.

The aim of this new edition is to examine the techniques and institu-tions available to states for the peaceful settlement of disputes, taking fullaccount of recent developments. Chapters 1 to 4 examine the so-called‘diplomatic’ means of settlement: negotiation, where matters are entirely inthe hands of the parties, then mediation, inquiry and conciliation, in eachof which outside assistance is utilised. Chapters 5 to 7 deal with legal means,namely, arbitration and judicial settlement through the International Courtof Justice, where the object is to provide a legally binding decision. Tounderline the interaction of legal and diplomatic means and to show howthey are used in specific contexts, Chapter 8 reviews the arrangements fordispute settlement in the Law of the Sea Convention and Chapter 9 consid-ers the provisions of the World Trade Organization’s remarkable DisputeSettlement Understanding. The final part of the book considers the role ofpolitical institutions, the United Nations (Chapter 10) and regional organ-isations (Chapter 11), while the final chapter reviews the current situationand offers some thoughts for the future.

Those familiar with the previous edition will find significant new materialin almost every chapter, including references to recent arbitrations, to thedeveloping practice of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea,the jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice and practice under

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 9: International Dispute Settlement

x Preface

the WTO system, as well as new political material relating to peace-keepingand other activities of regional organisations and the UN. In discussing thevarious techniques and institutions, my object has remained to explain whatthey are, how they work and when they are used. As before, I have sought toinclude enough references to the relevant literature to enable the reader tofollow up any points of particular interest. With a similar objective I haveretained and updated the appendices setting out extracts from some of thedocuments mentioned in the text.

For permission to quote the material in the appendices I am again gratefulto the editors of the International Law Reports. My thanks are also due toJulie Prescott at the University of Sheffield for preparing the manuscript, toRaihanah Begum and Sinead Moloney at Cambridge University Press, andto my wife, Dariel, whose encouragement, as always, was invaluable.

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 10: International Dispute Settlement

Table of cases

Abyei Arbitration (2009), 106Aegean Sea Continental Shelf Case

Interim Protection (1976), 125, 222 n. 3, 276Judgment (1978), 15, 20, 153, 160, 235

Aerial Incident Case (1996), 161 n. 49Aerial Incident Case (2000), 120–2Air Transport Arbitrations (1983, 1975, 1978), 112Alabama Claims Case (1871/2), 86, 92, 95Aland Islands Inquiry (1921), 55Ambatielos Case (1953), 156AMINOIL Case (1982), 109–10ARAMCO Case (1958), 109Arbitral Award Case (1960), 103, 106, 115, 158, 265, 275Arbitral Award Case (1991), 104Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (DRC v. Rwanda) (2006),

17Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (DRC v. Uganda) (2005),

132, 144, 152Arrest Warrant Case (2002), 117, 146, 164 n. 55Article XXVIII Rights Case (1990), 214Asylum Case (1950), 163Avena Case

Interpretation (2009), 159Merits (2004), 117

Bank for International Settlements Case (2002/3), 108Barbados/Trinidad and Tobago Case (2006), 19 n. 35, 168 n. 4, 179Beagle Channel Award (1977), 27, 30–1, 39, 85, 91, 94, 106, 115Ben Bella Case (1958), 66, 68, 81Bering Sea Arbitration (1893), 98Bolivar Railway Company Claim (1903), 84Border and Transborder Armed Actions Case (1988), 17, 70 n. 31,

119 n. 11, 267 n. 33, 276–8BP v. Libya (1973), 96, 103, 105, 109Brazil – Tyres Case (2007), 208Brcko Arbitration (1999), 98, 111Buraimi Arbitration (1955), 105

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 11: International Dispute Settlement

xii Table of cases

Carthage Case (1913), 44 n. 8Case No. A/18 (Iran–US Claims Tribunal, 1984), 94CERD Case (2008), 136Certain Criminal Proceedings in France Case (2002/3), 118 n. 8Chaco Inquiry (1929), 61, 65, 67–8, 81, 266Chaisiri Reefer 2 Case (2001), 189Channel Arbitration (1977/8), 86–7, 93–4, 100–1, 103, 111, 158, 315–19China – Intellectual Property Case (2009), 205Chorzow Factory Case (1927/8), 53Clipperton Island Case (1931), 84Construction of a Wall Advisory Opinion (2004), 134–5, 136 n. 37,

155 n. 33Copper Case (1987), 200Corfu Channel Case

Merits (1949), 144, 224Denmark v. Turkey (2000), 71Denmark, France, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden v. Turkey

(1985), 71 n. 37Diplomatic Staff in Tehran Case (1980), 19, 153–4, 156, 160–1, 232–5, 288,

294Dogger Bank Inquiry (1905), 42–6, 48, 54, 57Dubai/Sharjah Boundary Arbitration (1981), 89 n. 25, 90 n. 27East African Community Case (1981), 64–70, 81–2East Timor Case (1995), 123EC – Bananas Case (1997), 209EC – Biotech Case (2006), 205EC – Hormones Case (1998), 209, 213ELSI (Elettronica Sicula SpA) Case (1989), 139–40Eritrea–Ethiopia Boundary Commission Case (2002), 94–5, 101, 265Eritrea–Ethiopia Claims Commission Cases (2003–9), 111, 265Eritrea/Yemen Arbitration (1998/9), 86, 91, 93, 95, 99, 105, 111Eurotunnel Case (2007), 108Expenses Case (1962), 249 n. 80Fisheries Jurisdiction Case (1998), 121Fisheries Jurisdiction Cases (1973/4), 23 n. 39, 26 n. 45, 119, 147, 149–51,

160, 290 n. 3Franco-Siamese Frontier Case (1947), 61–2, 65–8, 81Franco-Swiss Internment Case (1955), 63, 66, 68, 81Free Zones Arbitration (1933), 98–100Frontier Dispute Case (Benin/Niger) (2005), 139–40, 159Frontier Dispute Case (Burkina Faso/Mali)

Judgment (1986), 139–40, 148, 150Nomination of Experts (1987), 158Provisional Measures (1986), 124–6

Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Case (1997), 24 n. 43, 118, 142, 146, 159, 319–21

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 12: International Dispute Settlement

xiii Table of cases

Gasoline Standards Case (1996), 207–8Genocide Convention Case (Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Yugoslavia)

Application for Revision (2003), 131, 304Counter-Claims Order (1997), 132Judgment (2007), 144, 304Preliminary Objections (1996), 120, 304Provisional measures (1993), 136 n. 61, 234, 248–9

Genocide Convention Case (Croatia v. Serbia and Montenegro)Preliminary Objections (2008), 304

Gorm and Svava Cases (1952), 62–3, 66, 68, 81Grimm v. Iran (1983), 94Gulf of Maine Case

Constitution of Chamber (1982), 137–8, 182Judgment (1984), 21, 137–41, 149–51, 153, 158

Guyana/Suriname Case (2007), 179Haji-Bagherpour v. United States (1983), 93Haya de la Torre Case (1951), 163Heathrow Airport Arbitration (1992/3), 86, 90, 97, 112Interhandel Case (1959), 80Iran–United States Claims Tribunal

Jurisdiction Decision (1981), 94Iron Rhine Railway Arbitration

Award (2005), 86Interpretation (2005), 101

Island of Palmas Case (1928), 85Italian Property Tax Case (1956), 63, 66, 68, 81Jan Mayen Conciliation (1981), 65–7, 70, 81–2, 191, 314–15Japan – Laver Case (2006), 205Japanese Loan Cases (1955, 1960), 67–8, 81Kasikili/Sedudu Island Case (1999), 118, 148KE 007 Inquiry (1983), 55–7, 289Kosovo Case (2010), 225LaGrand Case (2001), 126 n. 31, 146Lake Lanoux Arbitration (1957), 4, 8, 9, 12, 87, 111Land and Maritime Boundary between Cameroon and Nigeria

Application to Intervene (1999), 129 n. 28Counter-Claims Order (1999), 132Merits (2002), 132, 157 n. 37Preliminary Objections (1998), 278Provisional Measures (1996), 227 n. 20Request for Interpretation (1999), 130, 131 n. 43

Land Reclamation CaseAward (2005), 4, 18, 19, 179Provisional Measures (2003), 118 n. 55

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 13: International Dispute Settlement

xiv Table of cases

Land, Island and Maritime Frontier CaseApplication for Revision (2003), 131, 138–9Application to Intervene (1990), 129, 141 n. 75, 295Composition of Chamber (1989), 138Merits (1992), 139–40

Legality of Use of Force CasesPreliminary Objections (2004), 304Provisional Measures (1999), 125

Letelier and Moffitt Case (1992), 51–4LIAMCO Case (1977), 109 n. 75Libya–Malta Continental Shelf Case

Application to Intervene (1984), 128–9Merits (1985), 130 n. 39, 141, 157, 228

Ligitan and Sipadan CaseApplication to Intervene (2001), 129 n. 28, 130

Lockerbie CasesDiscontinuation (2003), 161 n. 49, 248Preliminary Objections (1998), 17, 247–9Provisional Measures (1992), 247–8

Manouba Case (1913), 44 n. 8Maritime Delimitation and Territorial Questions Case (Qatar and Bahrain)

Judgment (2001), 143Jurisdiction and Admissibility (1994), 16, 120

Maritime Delimitation Case (Guinea and Guinea-Bissau) (1985), 86–7, 90,97 n. 45, 102

Maritime Delimitation Case (Guinea-Bissau and Senegal) (1989), 86,104

Maritime Delimitation Case (1995), 161 n. 49Maritime Delimitation in the Black Sea Case (2009), 136, 151 n. 27Mexico – Taxes Case (2006), 210Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua Case, see

Nicaragua CaseMinquiers and Ecrehos Case (1953), 157Monetary Gold Arbitration (1953), 85Monetary Gold Case (1954), 123, 295Mosul Inquiry (1925), 55MOX Plant Case

Provisional Measures (2001/3), 18, 179, 188 n. 55, 306 n. 39Suspension of Proceedings (2003), 113, 179, 307 n. 42Termination of Proceedings (2008), 179

MV Saiga No. 2 CaseJudgment (1999), 178, 188Provisional Measures (1998), 188

Namibia Case (1971), 135, 136 n. 37, 137, 224, 249 n. 80

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 14: International Dispute Settlement

xv Table of cases

Nicaragua CaseJurisdiction and Admissibility (1984), 121–3, 154–5, 234, 276–7, 294–5Merits (1986), 119, 143, 152, 156, 160–1, 163, 221–3Provisional Measures (1984), 125–6, 276

North Atlantic Coast Fisheries Arbitration (1910), 98North Sea Continental Shelf Cases (1969), 26 n. 44, 151, 156–7Northern Cameroons Case (1963), 11, 163Norwegian Loans Case (1957), 120Nuclear Tests Cases (1974), 164Nuclear Tests II Case (1995), 164Nuclear Weapons Advisory Opinion (1996), 133, 225Oil Platforms Case

Counter-Claims Order (1998), 132Judgment (2003), 132, 143Preliminary Objection (1996), 120

OSPAR (Article 9) Arbitration (2003), 86, 95, 104, 112, 179 n. 32, 306 n. 40Palena Case (1966), 85, 111Passage through the Great Belt Case (1991), 127, 161 n. 49Peace Treaties Case (1950), 88–9, 103, 133, 224Phosphate Lands in Nauru Case (1992), 123, 161 n. 49Pulp Mills on the River Uruguay Case

Judgment (2010), 5Provisional Measures (2006, 2007), 126

Qatar/Bahrain Case, see Maritime Delimitation and Territorial QuestionsCase (Qatar and Bahrain)

Rainbow Warrior Case (1986), 85–91, 99–101, 114, 228–9, 330–4Rainbow Warrior II Case (1990), 102Rann of Kutch Arbitration (1968), 37–8, 88, 94, 96, 111Red Crusader Inquiry (1962), 48–54, 181, 312–14Reparation for Injuries Case (1949), 223 n. 7Rhine Chlorides Case (2004), 112Right of Passage Case (1957), 119Roula Case (1956), 81Saghi v. Iran (1993), 94 n. 36Saint Pierre and Miquelon Case (1992), 93, 111Sapphire Case (1963), 109South West Africa Cases (1962), 10, 17Southern Bluefin Tuna Case

Jurisdiction and Admissibility (2000), 113, 169 n. 6, 178, 306Provisional Measures (1999), 18, 188 n. 55

Sovereignty over Pedra Branca Case (2008), 118Swordfish Case (2000), 178, 188, 306 n. 41Taba Arbitration (1988), 70, 86, 92, 94, 101, 111Tavignano Inquiry (1912), 44–6, 48, 54

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 15: International Dispute Settlement

xvi Table of cases

Temple of Preah Vihear Case (1961), 122, 160Territorial Dispute (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya/Chad) (1994), 158 n. 39, 238,

302Tiger Inquiry (1918), 45–7Tinoco Arbitration (1923), 85TOPCO Case (1977), 109Trail Smelter Arbitration (1938/41), 95–6, 103Tubantia Inquiry (1922), 46–7, 50Tunisia–Libya Continental Shelf Case

Application to Intervene (1981), 127–8Judgment (1982), 92 n. 31, 140, 149, 151, 157, 159Revision and Interpretation (1985), 130–1

UNESCO–France Arbitration (2003), 307 n. 44United Nations Headquarters Agreement Case (1988), 156United States v. Iran (2000), 114 n. 93US – Continued Suspension Case (2008), 209US – Gambling Case (2005), 208US– Shrimp Case (1998), 209US– Stainless Steel (Mexico) Case (2008), 209US – Upland Cotton (Article 21.5) Case (2008), 209Venezuela–British Guiana Boundary Case (1899), 105, 115Vitianu Case (1949), 81Volga Case (2002), 188 n. 54Western Sahara Case (1975), 133, 137, 145, 163, 224Wet Salted Cod Case (1988), 200WHO Regional Headquarters Case (1980), 133, 156 n. 35Youmans Claim (1926), 84Young Loan Arbitration (1980), 112 n. 84

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 16: International Dispute Settlement

Table of treaties and agreements

1794 Jay Treaty, 841814 Treaty of Ghent, 841866 Treaties of Bayonne, 81872 Arbitration Agreement concerning Claims to Delagoa Bay, 981894 Gamez-Bonilla Treaty, 1031899 Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement of International

Disputes, 41–4, 85, 901902 General Treaty of Arbitration (Argentina–Chile), 841904 Declaration of St Petersburg, 43 n. 41907 Arbitration Agreement (Colombia–Ecuador), 98

Hague Convention for the Pacific Settlement of InternationalDisputes, 44–8, 50, 53–4, 57, 90

1911 Taft (Knox) Treaties of Arbitration, 47–81913–40 Bryan Treaties, 48, 51, 60, 661914 Bryan–Suarez Mujica Treaty (Chile–United States), 52–31915 ABC Treaty, 481919 Covenant of the League of Nations, 2791919 Mandate for South West Africa, 10, 11

Treaty of Conciliation (Brazil–Great Britain), 48Treaty of Conciliation (Chile–Great Britain), 48

1920 Treaty of Conciliation (Chile–Sweden), 581921 Treaty of Arbitration and Conciliation

(Germany–Switzerland), 591923 Gondra Treaty, 48, 60–1

Treaty of Washington, 601924 Treaty of Conciliation and Judicial Settlement

(Italy–Switzerland), 631925 Locarno Treaties, 59

Treaty of Conciliation (France–Switzerland), 59, 60, 63, 701927 Treaty of Conciliation, Judicial Settlement and Arbitration

(Belgium–Denmark), 621928 General Act for the Pacific Settlement of International Disputes,

59, 60, 80, 89, 117, 1221929 Inter-American General Convention of Conciliation, 60

Treaty of Conciliation (Czechoslovakia, Rumania, Kingdom ofthe Serbs, Croatians and Slovenes), 60Protocol establishing the Chaco Commission, 61

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 17: International Dispute Settlement

xviii Table of treaties and agreements

1933 Saavedra Lamas Agreement, 60Treaty of Conciliation (Brazil–Poland), 80 n. 64

1935 Arbitration Agreement concerning the Trail SmelterDispute, 95–6

1938 Munich Agreement, 361944 Chicago Convention on Civil Aviation, 561945 Charter of the United Nations

Art. 1, 219Art. 2(3), 1, 2, 168, 220Art. 2(7), 221Arts. 10–14, 221Art. 10, 221Art. 11(2), 221, 224Art. 11(3), 220Art. 12, 233Art. 12(1), 221, 235Art. 14, 221Art. 24, 231Art. 25, 234, 247Chapter VI, 220, 243, 296Art. 33, 2, 20, 25, 279Art. 33(1), 220–1Art. 33(2), 221Art. 34, 162, 220Art. 35(1), 220Art. 35(2), 221Art. 36(1), 220–1Art. 36(3), 224Art. 37(1), 220 n. 2Art. 37(2), 222Art. 38, 220, 222Chapter VII, 220, 224, 234, 240–9, 253–4, 286, 296Art. 39, 243, 249Art. 41, 243, 245Art. 42, 243–4Art. 43, 244Art. 51, 259Chapter VIII, 278, 281Arts. 52–4, 279Art. 52(2), 220Art. 53(1), 280Art. 96(1), 235Art. 98, 221, 225, 230Art. 99, 220–1, 225, 227, 229, 261, 299

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 18: International Dispute Settlement

xix Table of treaties and agreements

Art. 103, 248Statute of the International Court of JusticeArt. 1, 231 n. 28Art. 2, 135Art. 9, 134–5Art. 17, 135, 182Art. 24, 135Arts. 26–9, 137Art. 36(2), 76, 117–18, 120–1, 277Art. 36(5), 121–2Art. 36(6), 119Art. 37(5), 121–2Art. 38(1), 145Art. 38(2), 148Art. 41, 124–7, 130, 234–5, 247–8Art. 50, 144Art. 53, 159–60, 178Art. 59, 129Art. 60, 130–1, 159Art. 61, 130, 131Art. 62, 127–30, 203Art. 63, 127, 203Art 65(1), 235Art. 80, 131

1946 Trusteeship Agreement for the Cameroons, 111947 General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, 211–35

Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance (Rio Treaty),259–60, 269Treaty of Peace with Italy, 63Treaties of Peace with Bulgaria, Hungary and Rumania, 88United Nations Headquarters Agreement, 156 n. 35

1948 American Treaty on Pacific Settlement (Pact of Bogota), 70, 89,117, 119, 260, 275–8Charter of Bogota, 260Genocide Convention, 120, 125, 304

1949 Revised General Act for the Pacific Settlement of InternationalDisputes, 60

1950 European Convention on Human Rights, 71, 171, 2581953 Agreement on German External Debts, 1121956 Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation (United

States–Nicaragua), 1201957 Washington Agreement (Honduras–Nicaragua), 265

European Convention for the Peaceful Settlement of Disputes,70, 89, 117

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 19: International Dispute Settlement

xx Table of treaties and agreements

1958 Geneva Convention on Fishing and Conservation of the LivingResources of the High Seas, 179–80Geneva Conventions on the Law of the Sea, 169

1959 Antarctic Treaty, 13, 141960 Indus Waters Treaty, 361961 Exchange of Notes concerning Fishing (United

Kingdom–Iceland), 12, 14, 23Exchange of Notes concerning the Red Crusader Incident(United Kingdom–Denmark), 49

1963 Charter of the Organization of African Unity, 70Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, 117, 146

1964 Protocol of the Commission of Mediation, Conciliation andArbitration of the OAU, 70, 261

1965 Treaty of Conciliation, Judicial Settlement and Arbitration(United Kingdom–Switzerland), 68Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes betweenStates and Nationals of Other States, 108–9Convention on Transit Trade of Land-Locked Countries, 18International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms ofRacial Discrimination, 71 n. 35, 136 n. 59

1966 Concession Agreement between BP and Libya, 96International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 71 n. 35UN Covenants on Human Rights, 77 n. 57

1969 American Convention on Human Rights, 71Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 72, 175

1971 Agreement for Arbitration of the Beagle Channel Dispute, 91,94Montreal Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Actsagainst the Safety of Civil Aviation, 17

1972 Charter of the Islamic Conference, 2631975 Algiers Accord (Iran–Iraq), 36, 39

Arbitration Agreement concerning Delimitation of theContinental Shelf (United Kingdom–France), 315–19Brussels Communique (Greece–Turkey), 15, 16Convention on the Representation of States in theirRelations with International Organizations of a UniversalCharacter, 72 n. 3, 175 n. 21Helsinki Agreement, 75, 77Statute of the River Uruguay, 6, 126

1976 Special Agreement concerning Delimitation of the ContinentalShelf (Libya–Malta), 157

1977 Air Services Agreement, ‘Bermuda II’ (United Kingdom–UnitedStates), 90, 97

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 20: International Dispute Settlement

xxi Table of treaties and agreements

Special Agreement concerning Delimitation of the ContinentalShelf (Tunisia–Libya), 92 n. 31, 149, 159Treaty between Czechoslovakia and Hungary concerning theConstruction and Operation of the Gabcikovo-NagymarosSystem of Locks, 146

1978 Camp David Agreements, 253Torres Strait Treaty, 12Vienna Convention on Succession of States in respect ofTreaties, 24, 72

1979 Special Agreement concerning Delimitation of the MaritimeBoundary in the Gulf of Maine Area, 21, 150, 158–9

1981 African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, 71 n. 35Agreement on the Continental Shelf between Iceland and JanMayen, 65Declaration of Algeria concerning the Settlement of Claims bythe United States and Iran, 87, 94, 96Treaty Establishing the Organization of Eastern CaribbeanStates, 70

1982 Antitrust Cooperation Agreement (United States–Australia),3 n. 3Law of the Sea Convention, 5, 56, 74, 89, 112, 113, 162, 201,215, 216, 285, 306Art. 187, 184Art. 188, 185Art. 189, 185Art. 190, 185 n. 47Art. 191, 186 n. 49Art. 279, 168Art. 280, 168Art. 281, 113, 169, 179, 193Art. 282, 169, 193Art. 283, 18, 19, 168–9Art. 284, 174 n. 19Art. 287, 170, 191Art. 288, 170, 191Art. 289, 170Art. 290, 171, 179, 184 n. 46, 188Art. 290(1), 179Art. 290(5), 188Art. 292, 171, 188–9Art. 293, 171, 185Art. 294, 171Art. 295, 171Art. 297, 172–4

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 21: International Dispute Settlement

xxii Table of treaties and agreements

Art. 298, 172–4, 190Art. 298(3), 173Art. 299, 174Art. 308, 186Annex V, 175Annex VI, 181, 184–6Annex VII, 113, 177–9, 188, 306Annex VIII, 180Part XI, 169, 184, 186

1983 Special Agreement concerning Frontier Delimitation (UpperVolta/Burkina Faso–Mali), 148–9, 158Special Agreement concerning Maritime BoundaryDelimitation (Guinea–Guinea-Bissau), 87, 102

1984 Treaty of Peace and Friendship (Argentina–Chile), 35 n. 19Agreement concerning the Assets of the East AfricanCommunity, 64–9

1985 Protocol of Cartagena de Indias, 261 n. 11Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer, 73

1986 Agreement to Arbitrate the Boundary Dispute concerning theTaba Beachfront, 70, 92, 101Single European Act, 258

1987 Esquipulas II Accord, 268Montreal Protocol to the Vienna Convention for the Protectionof the Ozone Layer, 78–9

1990 Agreement establishing an Interim Reciprocal Information andConsultation System (Argentina–United Kingdom), 5, 310–12Agreement to Settle Dispute concerning Compensation for theDeaths of Letelier and Moffitt (Chile–United States), 52

1991 Treaty Establishing the African Economic Community, 2621992 Convention for the Protection of the Marine Environment of

the North-East Atlantic (OSPAR Convention), 95, 112Convention on Biological Diversity, 73, 113 n. 88Convention on the Protection and Use of TransboundaryWatercourses and Lakes, 113 n. 88Convention on the Transboundary Effects of IndustrialAccidents, 113 n. 88Framework Convention on Climate Change, 73North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), 108, 216–17Protocol of Washington, 260Stockholm Convention on Conciliation and Arbitration withinthe CSCE, 77–8, 113, 262Treaty of Maastricht, 258

1993 Commonwealth of Independent States Charter, 259 n. 4Commonwealth of Independent States Treaty on Creation ofEconomic Union, 259 n. 4

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 22: International Dispute Settlement

xxiii Table of treaties and agreements

Protocol to the 1976 Convention on the Protection of the Rhineagainst Pollution by Chlorides, 112Special Agreement concerning the Gabcikovo-NagymarosProject (Hungary–Slovak Republic), 159, 319–21

1994 Agreement establishing the World Trade Organization,194–218, 306Antidumping Agreement, 209SPS Agreement, 205TRIPS Agreement, 205Agreement relating to the Implementation of Part XI of the1982 Law of the Sea Convention, 186–7Convention to Combat Desertification, 73

1995 Dayton Peace Agreement, 30, 98Joint Declaration on Cooperation over Offshore Activities inthe South West Atlantic (Argentina–United Kingdom), 13 n. 25Straddling Stocks Agreement, 192

1996 Special Agreement concerning the Kasikili/Sedudu IslandDispute (Botswana–Namibia), 148

1997 Convention on the Law of the Non-Navigational Uses ofInternational Watercourses, 73–4Kyoto Protocol, 79Treaty of Amsterdam, 258

1998 Aarhus Convention, 791999 International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing

of International Terrorism, 1122000 Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, 792001 Constitutive Act of the African Union, 257, 2622002 Special Agreement concerning a Boundary Dispute

(Benin–Niger), 1592006 Southern Indian Ocean Fisheries Agreement, 1922008 Protocol on the Statute of the African Court of Justice and

Human Rights, 2622009 Lisbon Treaty, 258

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 23: International Dispute Settlement

Abbreviations

AFDI Annuaire Francais de Droit InternationalAJIL American Journal of International LawAnnuaire Annuaire de l’Institut de Droit InternationalArchiv des Volk. Archiv des VolkerrechtsAust. Year Book Int. L. Australian Year Book of International LawBYBIL British Year Book of International LawCalif. Western Int. LJ California Western International Law JournalCan. Bar Rev. Canadian Bar ReviewCan. Yearbook Int. L. Canadian Yearbook of International LawCML Rev. Common Market Law ReviewColum. J. Transnat. L. Columbia Journal of Transnational LawDenver J. Int. L. & Pol. Denver Journal of International Law and

PolicyGa J. Int. & Comp. L. Georgia Journal of International and

Comparative LawGlobal Community YBILJ Global Community Yearbook of International

Law and JurisprudenceGrotius Soc. Trans. Grotius Society TransactionsHarv. Int. LJ Harvard International Law JournalICLQ International and Comparative Law QuarterlyILM International Legal MaterialsILQ International Law QuarterlyILR International Law ReportsInd. J. Int. L. Indian Journal of International LawInt. Org. International OrganizationInt. Rel. International RelationsIran–US CTR Iran–United States Claims Tribunal ReportsIsrael L. Rev. Israel Law ReviewJ. World Trade Journal of World TradeLeiden JIL Leiden Journal of International LawMelbourne JIL Melbourne Journal of International LawMich. L. Rev. Michigan Law ReviewNTIR Nederlands tijdschrift voor internationaal

rechtNYUJ Int. L. & Politics New York University Journal of International

Law and Politics

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 24: International Dispute Settlement

xxv List of abbreviations

Ocean Devel. & Int. L. Ocean Development and International LawRev. Egypt. Droit Int. Revue Egyptienne de Droit InternationalRGDIP Revue Generale de Droit International PublicRIAA Reports of International Arbitral AwardsSan Diego L. Rev. San Diego Law ReviewSyr. J. Int. L. & Com. Syracuse Journal of International Law and

CommerceU. Chi. L. Rev. University of Chicago Law ReviewU. Toronto Fac. L. Rev. University of Toronto Faculty of Law ReviewU. Toronto LJ University of Toronto Law JournalUKTS United Kingdom Treaty SeriesUNTS United Nations Treaty SeriesVa JIL Virginia Journal of International LawYBIEL Yearbook of International Environmental LawYearbook of WA Yearbook of World Affairs

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information

Page 25: International Dispute Settlement

Websites

African Union, www.africa-union.orgArab League, www.leagueofarabstates.orgCouncil of Europe, www.coe.intEconomic Community of West African States, www.ecowas.intEuropean Court of Human Rights, www.echr.coe.intEuropean Court of Justice, www.curia.eu.intInter-American Court of Human Rights, www.corteidh.or.crInternational Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes,

www.icsid.orgInternational Court of Justice, www.icj-cij.orgInternational Criminal Court, www.un.org/law/icc/International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, www.ictr.orgInternational Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia,

www.un.org/icty/International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, www.itlos.orgIran–United States Claims Tribunal, www.iusct.orgNorth American Free Trade Agreement Secretariat,

www.nafta-sec-alena.orgOrganization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, www.osce.orgOrganization of American States, www.oas.orgOrganization of the Islamic Conference, www.oic-oci.orgPermanent Court of Arbitration, www.pca-cpa.orgUnited Nations, www.un.orgUN Department of Peacekeeping, www.un.org/Depts/dpko/UN General Assembly, www.un.org/ga/UN Security Council Information, www.un.org/Docs/scinfo.htmWorld Trade Organization, www.wto.org

© in this web service Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-15339-3 - International Dispute Settlement, Fifth EditionJ. G. MerrillsFrontmatterMore information


Recommended