Judge Murder Case Patiala

8/13/2019 Judge Murder Case Patiala

1/283

State Vs. Ravdeep Kaur & another 1

IN THE COURT OF VED PARKASH SIROHI

ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGECHANDIGARH.

SESSIONS CASE NO.......002 OF 2006COMPUTER I.D. NO. 36014R0048382006DATE OF INSTITUTION:....22.02.2006DATE OF DECISION:.......28.03.2012

S T A T E

Ve!"!

1 Ravdeep Kaur w/o Sh. Raghvinder Singh, r/o 19-A,

Nihal Bagh, Baradari, Patiala.

2 Manit Singh ! Binu "on o# Sh. Kuldip Singh

Ra$da"ia, r/o %illage Shei&hupur, Near Puna'i

(niver"it), Patiala, Poli*e Station Sadar, Patiala.

....A**u"ed.

F.I.R N#. 321 #$ 14.10.200%.U&'e Se()*#&! 302+34+10,+11%+120-IPC/P#*(e S))*#& : C** L*&e!/P)*.

Pre"ent+ Sh. %ia) Ku$ar Singla, Spe*ial

Pu'li* Pro"e*utor #or State.

A**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur in *u"tod)

repre"ented ') Sh. Baldev Singh,

Senior Advo*ate a""i"ted ') Sh

Ranan upta, Advo*ate.

A**u"ed Manit Singh in *u"tod)

repre"ented ') Sh. Ra'indra Pandit,

Advo*ate.

JUDGMENT

he #a*tual $atri *ul$inating to the trial

are that on 1.10.200, a telephoni* $e""age wa"

re*eived in the Poli*e Station ivil 3ine", Patiala


2/283


#ro$ A$ar 4o"pital, Patiala with regard to $urder o#

Sh. %ia) Singh, 5udge. 6n thi" 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh,

S46, Poli*e 3ine", Patiala along with AS7 Satpal Singh,

4 5a"pal Singh, No. 10, on"ta'le 4ardeep Singh, No.

81, on"ta'le urdial Singh, No. 19, .77 Bahadur

Singh No. 11: in a overn$ent vehi*le No. PB11-AA-1;12

rea*hed A$ar 4o"pital, Patiala where *o$plainant Shiv

Ra Singh "on o# 3ate Aitinder Singh, re"ident o#

Kothi Raa Shivda)al Singh, Raindra arden, Stadiu$

Road, Patiala $et hi$ and got hi" "tate$ent re*orded to

the e##e*t that on 1.10.200 at a'out 12+0 a.$.

Satinder Singh ! hanni, re"ident o# Patiala, a #riend

o# %ia) Singh *a$e to hi" hou"e and in#or$ed that

A'dullah Noori, re"ident o#


3/283


%ia) Singh l)ing on the ground "$eared with 'lood

toward" the lower Mall Road "ide ra*& o# the Polo

round. here were inurie" with "harp edged weapon on

the #a*e and ne*& o# %ia) Singh. here were deep

inurie" on hi" *he"t, "to$a*h, leg" and head. he

'lood wa" oo=ing out o# the inurie". Mo'ile Phone "et

o# hi" 'rother-in-law wa" l)ing near') wherea", the

another $o'ile phone wa" l)ing 'ro&en. he) "hi#ted

the inured to A$ar 4o"pital, Patiala in their *ar

where he wa" de*lared 'rought dead. 4i" 'rother-in-law

%ia) Singh had 'een $urdered ') "o$e un&nown per"on"

and a" and when he #ind" "o$e *lue, he will in#or$ the

poli*e. At a'out 2+0 a.$. the inve"tigating o##i*er

$ade hi" endor"e$ent on the "tate$ent o# the

*o$plainant and "ent a ru>a through on"ta'le urdial

Singh, No. 19 to the poli*e "tation #or regi"tration

o# the *a"e.

2. 6n re*eipt o# the ru>a, a #or$al ?7R under

Se*tion" ;02/119/11/120-B/; o# 7ndian Penal ode wa"

regi"tered. he inve"tigation wa" "et in $otion. he

"enior poli*e o##i*er" al"o rea*hed at A$ar 4o"pital,

Patiala. here were "o$e hair in right hand o# %ia)

Singh whi*h were ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide

"eparate re*over) $e$o. he $o'ile phone o# %ia)

Singh produ*ed ') the *o$plainant, wa" al"o ta&en into


4/283


poli*e po""e""ion vide "eparate re*over) $e$o.

herea#ter, the poli*e part) vi"ited the pla*e o#

o**urren*e. 7n"pe*tor 5a""a Singh, 7n*harge 7A Sta##

and other poli*e o##i*ial" al"o rea*hed there.

Photographer, Movie$a&er and dog ">uad al"o rea*hed at

the "pot. 6ne $o'ile phone "et $a&e No&ia 1100, the

S7M *ard o# whi*h wa" al"o l)ing there, were al"o

re*overed #ro$ the pla*e o# o**urren*e and were ta&en

into poli*e po""e""ion. Blood "tained earth wa" al"o

li#ted #ro$ the "pot. he rough "ite plan o# the pla*e

o# o**urren*e wa" prepared. hen the poli*e part)

along with photographer and video $ovie $a&er rea*hed

A$ar 4o"pital, Patiala. Photograph" o# dead 'od) were

ta&en. 6n poli*e re>ue"t a 'oard *on"i"ting o#


5/283


Servant o#


6/283


the la"t $ore than two )ear" and "he wa" ta&ing help o#

one Manit Singh. 6n one or two o**a"ion", Ravdeep

Kaur had pointed toward" hi$ to Manit Singh. he

photograph" and


7/283


re*overed. ?ro$ hi" per"onal "ear*h one "$all diar),

&ara, diar) *ontaining $o'ile phone nu$'er" 2209999DRE,

2292082 ho"pital, 9819-0:00, 98880-;099 and *a"h o#

R".180/- were re*overed whi*h were ta&en into

po""e""ion ') the poli*e vide "eparate re*over) $e$o".

he rough "ite plan o# the pla*e o# re*over) wa"

prepared. Per"onal "ear*h $e$o and arre"t $e$o o#

a**u"ed were prepared. he hair and 'lood "tained

earth were depo"ited in the o##i*e o# ?oren"i* S*ien*e

3a'orator), handigarh.

. 6n 19.10.200 di"*lo"ure "tate$ent o# a**u"ed

Manit Singh wa" re*orded and in pur"uan*e o# hi"

di"*lo"ure "tate$ent, he got re*overed weapon o#

o##en*e i.e. Kirpan #ro$ Bha&hra Kanal #ro$ hanaur to

Sa$'hu "ide and wa" ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide

"eparate re*over) $e$o. he video $ovie wa" prepared

and the photograph" o# the pla*e o# re*over) were

ta&en. he "ite plan o# pla*e o# re*over) wa" al"o

prepared. 6n 20.10.200 in pur"uan*e o# the di"*lo"ure

"tate$ent $ade ') a**u"ed Manit Singh R". 3a*" were

re*overed #ro$ the 4ar$oniu$ o# the a**u"ed. 6ne 3M3

?reedo$ Motor *)*le 'earing No. PB2-B-212 along with

R, "even photograph" o# di##erent po"ture" and

learnerF" li*en*e were al"o re*overed on 21.10.200.

ar 'earing No. PB11-N-0110, u"ed in the o##en*e along


8/283


with Audio a""ette having photograph o# Manit Singh

a**u"ed were ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion.


9/283


o# %ia) Singh, 'lood "tained "port "hoe" o# Manit

Singh whi*h were ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide

"eparate re*over) $e$o". he rough "ite plan o# pla*e

o# re*over) wa" prepared. 6n 2:.10.200, the S7M *ard

o# 4(4 o$pan) wa" re*overed #ro$ a**u"ed Manit

Singh. he rough "ite plan o# pla*e o# re*over) wa"

prepared. he *all re*ord" o# $o'ile phone No.

98880-099 G 98880;099 were *olle*ted. 6n *o$pletion

o# inve"tigation, the a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur and Manit

Singh were "ent up to #a*e trial #or *o$$i""ion o#

o##en*e puni"ha'le under Se*tion ;02 read with Se*tion

;, 109, 11, 120-B o# 7ndian Penal ode.

. A**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur and Manit Singh were

"ent up to #a*e trial a" $entioned a'ove and the ourt

o#


10/283


1; o# the ode o# ri$inal Pro*edure and other

$aterial on #ile, a pri$a #a*ie *a"e #or the *o$$i""ion

o# the o##en*e puni"ha'le under Se*tion" ;02 read with

"e*tion 120-B o# 7ndian Penal ode wa" $ade out again"t

the a**u"ed, there#ore, the) were *harge "heeted

a**ordingl) vide order dated 1.08.200:. he a**u"ed

pleaded not guilt) to the *harge and *lai$ed trial. he

*a"e wa" a**ordingl) #ied #or pro"e*ution eviden*e.

. 7n order to "u'"tantiate it" *a"e, the

pro"e*ution ea$ined a" $an) a" ?i#t) Seven

witne""e", na$el) A'"5 N##* a" P@-1, S5* R

S*&75 a" P@-2, HC J! S*&75 a" P@-;, HC D*75

S*&75 a" P@-, C. J!9*&'e P a" P@-, SI Re!5

S&e5*a" P@-:, HC G"*&'e S*&75a" P@-, ASI U'5

S*&75a" P@-8, S)*&'e S*&75 Se;5#&a" P@-9, L;5*

S*&75 a" P@-10, R"*&'e S*&75 a" P@-11, D.

K.K.A779a" P@-12, R*&'e P J*)5a" P@-1;,

S#5& S*&75a" P@-1, H&! S*&75a" P@-1, S*&'e

S*&75 Ge9a" P@-1:,Ne!5 K"a" P@-1, Ke!5

a" P@-18, S"&'e L S5a" P@-19, H(5&' S*&75a"

P@-20, V*" P;!5 a" P@-21, G"*) S*&75 a" P@-22,

K"'* S*&75 a" P@-2;, S"*&'e K" a" P@-2,

N*&'e K" K" a" P@-2, D5*) S*&75 a"

P@-2:, I!5) P S*&75a" P@-2, P*&'e P S*&75a"

P@-28, R*&'e S*&75 S*'5"a" P@-29, I&'ee!5 K5&&


11/283


a" P@-;0, D. M#&*;a" P@-;1, C. A& S*&75a" P@-;2,

C. J9*&'e S*&75a" P@-;;, J#7*&'e S*&75a" P@-;,

C. R S*&75 a" P@-;, S). Dee*&'e K"a" P@-;:,

D. A&'ee K" a" P@-;, M";5)* S*&75 a" P@-;8,

K*!5& K" a" P@-;9, HC M&*) S*&75 a" P@-0, HC

Ke! S*&75 a" P@-1, A*) T


12/283


3a'orator), Puna', handigarh dated 29.11.200 a"

.P-21, report o#


13/283



14/283


hi$ in New


15/283


%ia) Singh. 4e a"&ed hi$ to per"onall) go to the

re"iden*e o# %ia) Singh and veri#) the "ituation.

A#ter ;/0 $inute" therea#ter, hanni *alled hi$ 'a*&

on telephone and he wa" weeping. 4e "tated that %ia)

Singh wa" no $ore and "o$e 'od) had a""a""inated hi$

with a "word in Polo round at Patiala. hen he ru"hed

to Patiala #ro$


16/283


when he wa" tal&ing with %ia) Singh on telephone, the

telephone wa" di"*onne*ted a#ter he had heard a *r) o#

%ia) Singh. 4e had not di"*lo"ed hi$ na$e o# that

per"on who wa" tal&ing with %ia) Singh a" a'ove.

4aving heard a'out thi" he rang up Mr". %ia) Singh.

4e en>uired #ro$ her a'out %ia) Singh a" to where he

wa". She di"*lo"ed that %ia) Singh had gone #or a

wal& out"ide and he had not returned ') that ti$e. 4e

and Satinder Singh hanni then rea*hed Polo round ')

hanniF" *ar. 4aving par&ed the *ar out"ide the par&

the) entered into the par& #ro$ lower $all "ide o# the

par&. he) "tarted "ear*hing %ia) Singh there with a

help o# tor*h he wa" holding. he) #ound %ia) Singh

l)ing on the tra*& toward" lower $all/A$ar A"hra$ "ide.

4e wa" in inured *ondition. B) hi" "ide hi" $o'ile

phone #itted with *o$puter wa" l)ing. A "$all $o'ile

in a 'ro&en *ondition wa" al"o l)ing there. Satinder

Singh hanni then 'rought hi" *ar in"ide the ground.

Both o# the$ pi*&ed up %ia) Singh, put hi$ in the *ar

and too& hi$ to A$ar 4o"pital, Patiala ') that *ar.

he) handed over the 'od) o# %ia) Singh to


17/283


dead 'od) o# %ia) Singh in po""e""ion and the) "tarted

ea$ining it. he poli*e re$oved "o$e hair #ound

*lit*hed in the pal$ o# right hand and too& the "a$e

into po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-A/1 a#ter having $ade

the$ into a par*el in a "$all 'o whi*h wa" "ealed with

the "eal 'earing i$pre""ion ISSJ. Seal wa" handed over

to Satpal, a poli*e o##i*ial. he poli*e al"o ta&en

into po""e""ion the $o'ile #itted with *o$puter whi*h

the) had retrieved #ro$ the "ite where %ia) Singh wa"

l)ing, vide $e$o .P-A/2. 4e #urther depo"ed that

having "ta)ed #or "o$e ti$e in ho"pital, the) again

went to the pla*e where %ia) Singh wa" #ound l)ing in

inured *ondition. B) that ti$e dog ">uad had alread)

rea*hed there. Photographer, a $ovie $a&er 'e"ide"

large nu$'er o# poli*e *ontingent were alread) there.

Poli*e had pi*&ed up 'lood "tained earth #ro$ that

"ite. he "a$e wa" put into a "$all 'o. 7t wa" $ade

into a par*el and then "ealed with "a$e "eal i.e. ISSJ

whi*h wa" ta&en 'a*& #ro$ Satpal. A#ter "ealing the

par*el, the "eal wa" again returned to Satpal. he

"aid par*el wa" ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o

.PA/;. he 'ro&en $o'ile phone .P-2 whi*h wa"

l)ing "*attered there wa" al"o ta&en into po""e""ion

vide $e$o .PA/ a#ter a""e$'ling it" part". he

three part" whi*h were a""e$'led were the S7M *ard,


18/283


the lid u"ed #or *overing the 'atter) and re$aining

part o# the $o'ile. herea#ter, the) returned to A$ar

4o"pital. Prior to that "ite plan o# the pla*e o#

o**urren*e wa" drawn there on the "pot ') the poli*e

o##i*ial".

4e #urther depo"ed that hi" "tate$ent wa"

again re*orded in the ho"pital regarding the re*overie"

having 'een e##e*ted a" a'ove. At 9+;0/9+ a.$. the)

had ta&en the dead 'od) to Raindra 4o"pital. he)

were e"*orted ') poli*e. 4o"pital van wa" u"ed #or

*arr)ing the 'od). 7n Raindra 4o"pital, Patiala the

dead 'od) o# de*ea"ed wa" got identi#ied #ro$ hi$ and

in>ue"t report .PA/ wa" prepared. 4i" "tate$ent

.PA/: wa" al"o re*orded there.

1;. P=-3 HC J! S*&75, No. 10 depo"ed on

oath that on 1.10.200 he wa" pre"ent at Mortuar),

Raindra 4o"pital, Patiala. Be"ide" hi$ 7n"pe*tor Sewa

Singh wa" heading the poli*e part) o# whi*h he wa" a

$e$'er. At that ti$e AS7 Satpal pre"ented a par*el

allegedl) *ontaining wearing apparell" o# the de*ea"ed

%ia) Singh to 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh whi*h wa" "ealed

with the "eal i$pre""ion IKKAJ. An i$pre""ion o# "eal

wa" al"o handed over ') AS7 Satpal. he "a$e were

ta&en into po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-B.

1. HC D*75 S*&75, No. 219 te"ti#ied on oath


19/283


that on 1.10.200 he re*eived a telephoni* $e""age at

a'out 2+00 a.$. to rea*h Polo round, Patiala. he

$e""age wa" re*eived #ro$ night M4 #ro$ Poli*e Station

ivil 3ine", Patiala. 4e told hi$ that in Polo round

a 5udge ha" 'een $urdered and he "hould rea*h there

with hi" *a$era a" he wa" a photographer. 4e had

undergone training o# photograph) in the )ear 1988 at

Phillaur. 4e had ta&en along urinder Singh #ro$

Mo'ile ?oren"i* S*ien*e 3a'orator), Patiala, %ideo

a$era and whole &it #or photograph). he) rea*hed the

"ite at a'out 2+;0 a.$.


20/283


too& Snap" o# the do*tor" and the dead 'od) when po"t

$orte$ ea$ination wa" in progre"". urinder Singh

prepared the video #il$ o# that pro*e"". 6n 1.10.200

he handed over the photograph" .P/28 to .P/

along with their negative" .P/1 to .P/2 to 7n"p.

Sewa Singh whi*h were ta&en into po""e""ion vide $e$o

.P-. 4e #urther depo"ed that the photograph" are

#ree #ro$ retou*hing.

1. P=-% C. J!9*&'e P, No. 2::8, tendered

hi" a##idavit .P-< in hi" eviden*e.

1:. P=-6 SI Re!5 S&e5*re*orded the ?7R .P-

and $ade endor"e$ent .P/1 on ru>a whi*h wa" re*eived

#ro$ 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh through on"ta'le urdial

Singh No. 19.

1. P=-> HC G"*&'e S*&75, No. 2:: te"ti#ied

on oath that on 1.10.200 he wa" po"ted a" Movie Ma&er

in


21/283


10+ a.$. and i$$ediatel) therea#ter, po"t$orte$

ea$ination wa" *ondu*ted. 4e videographed the pro*e""

o# po"t$orte$ ea$ination and prepared a video *a""ette

there#ro$ and then #ro$ that *a""ette he prepared a uite o#ten in

the a#ore"aid *lu'. %ia) Singh, de*ea"ed wa" well

&nown to hi$. 6n 1.10.200 at a'out :+00 p.$. a**u"ed

Ravdeep Kaur $et hi$ in the part) at Maharani lu',

Patiala. She too& hi$ a"ide and told hi$ that "he wa"

having an urgent wor& and wanted to tal& to hi$ on that

$atter. She *on#e""ed 'e#ore hi$ that "he had

*o$$itted a 'lunder. She *on#ided in hi$ ') "a)ing

that de*ea"ed wa" her 'e"t #riend "in*e *hildhood and

"he want to $arr) hi$. She al"o told hi$ that he had


28/283


got $arried to "o$e one el"e. She #urther told hi$

that under the pre""ure o# her #a$il) $e$'er" "he wa"

$arried o## to "o$e'od) el"e. She #urther "aid that

de"pite o# all that "he *ould #orget hi$ and "he wa"

having longing #or hi$ at that ti$e a" well. She

#urther told that "he had 'een pre""ing hi$ to divor*e

hi" wi#e in order to $arr) her. She even went to the

etent o# going to ourt" at 3udhiana and pi*&ed up

>uarrel with hi$. She #urther "aid that #or %ia)

Singh de*ea"ed "he had le#t her hu"'and 'ut de"pite o#

that %ia) Singh de*ea"ed did not *o$e to her pre""ure.

6n a**ount o# all that "he 'e*a$e pertur'ed and even

wrote a letter to hie# 5u"ti*e o# Puna' G 4ar)ana

4igh ourt. She even $ade a #al"e *o$plaint again"t

%ia) Singh, de*ea"ed and hi" wi#e "tating that the)

had given 'eating" to her "ervant. 6ut o# #ru"tration

hatred &ept on developing whi*h led to eli$inate %ia)

Singh. herea#ter, "he 'ought a pi"tol to u"e the "a$e

again"t %ia) Singh. She #urther told hi$ that /8

da)" prior to the pre"ent in*ident "he had a Path at

her ho"pital in the na$e o# Ravi 4o"pital. Manit

Singh, ranthi o# village She&hupura *a$e #or

per#or$ing Path. 7n thi" $anner Manit Singh and

Ravdeep a**u"ed *a$e *lo"er and "he parted with a "u$

o# R". to 3a*" #or hi" hou"e and urudwara to Manit


29/283


Singh. She #urther "aid that one da) "he had a tal&

with Manit a**u"ed that %ia) Singh had *heated her

and "he want" to ta&e revenge #ro$ hi$. Manit Singh

a**u"ed de$anded "u$ o# R". 3a*" #or eli$inating

%ia) Singh. Ravdeep a**u"ed #urther told that "he had

developed "o $u*h hatred again"t %ia) Singh de*ea"ed

that "he even 'e*a$e read) to part with a "u$ o# R".

3a*" #or thi" purpo"e in #avour o# Manit Singh,

a**u"ed. She #urther told that "he had ta&en Manit

Singh in her *ar to Polo round and CPS how& and

"howed %ia) Singh, 5udge to hi$ #or identi#i*ation.

@hen "he wa" "howing %ia) Singh to Manit, another

per"on wa" there with %ia) Singh who had "een Ravdeep

Kaur "howing %ia) Singh to Manit. @hen Manit *ould

identi#) %ia) with *ertaint) "he had given a "u$ o#

R". 0,000/- and two 4(4 Mo'ile add-on phone". 6n

the a#ore"aid phone" Manit and Ravdeep a**u"ed had

'een tal&ing ver) o#ten. 6n 1;.10.200 Manit Singh

gave a phone *all to Ravdeep Kaur at a'out 8+00 p.$.

that he would eli$inate %ia) Singh that da). At 11+1

p.$. "he re*eived a telephoni* *all #ro$ Manit that he

had &illed %ia) Singh who had al"o a"&ed to &eep read)

the $one) a" he i" *o$ing to *olle*t the "a$e. a#ter

20 $inute" Manit a**u"ed rea*hed the re"iden*e o#

Ravdeep and gave her the driving li*en*e o# %ia) Singh


30/283


de*ea"ed "o a" to en"ure that he had &illed hi$. A"

the "hoe" o# Manit were "tained with 'lood there#ore,

Ravdeep got hi$ *hanged hi" "hoe" and 'lood "tained

"hoe" were &ept at the re"iden*e o# Ravdeep. ven the

*lothe" o# Manit were 'lood "tained and in order to

*over up the "a$e "he had given tra*& "uit to Manit.

She #urther told that "he had given a "u$ o# R". 2 3a*"

to Manit that ver) night and gave another "u$ o# R".

2,0,000/- to Manit Singh the #ollowing da) at +;0

a.$. at urudwara. She had al"o told hi$ that poli*e

*a$e to &now that "he got &illed %ia) Singh through

Manit Singh and a" "u*h poli*e had 'een raiding the

hou"e" o# Manit Singh and that o# her. She a"&ed hi$

to help her out a" no'od) el"e wa" helping her at that

ti$e. She al"o told hi$ that "in*e hi" #ather wa"

7rrigation Advi"or to hie# Mini"ter and *lo"ed to

Navot Singh Sidhu, Me$'er o# Parlia$ent #ro$ A$rit"ar,

there#ore, he "hould help her. She wa" #earing o#

poli*e torture. She wanted hi$ to have a tal& with

poli*e in that regard with the a""uran*e that "he will

"urrender her"el# and "he "hould 'e helped in that

regard. 4e gave a""uran*e to her to "ave her #ro$

poli*e hara""$ent. 4e $et Sewa Singh 7n"pe*tor in

thi" regard and narrated hi$ the entire "tor).

22. P=-12 D. K.K.A779, 4ead o# ?oren"i*


31/283


Medi*ine, overn$ent Medi*al ollege, Patiala te"ti#ied

on oath that he along with


32/283


pre"ent on -"hirt and pant. he #ollowing inurie"

were pre"ent on the dead 'od) +-

1.hopped in*i"ed wound 1 *$ 1. *$ wa" pre"ent

on right "ide o# #a*e, no"e and etending to

$edial end o# le#t e)e. lotted 'lood wa"

pre"ent. 7t wa" o'li>uel) pla*ed. he underl)ing

#a*ial and na"al 'one "howed *ut #ra*ture.

2.hopped in*i"ed wound 1 2 *$ pre"ent on le#t

"ide o# #orehead and going downward" to angle o#

le#t $andi'le. lotted 'lood wa" pre"ent. he

underl)ing #a*ial 'one" and $andi'le "howed *ut

#ra*ture. 7t wa" verti*all) pla*ed.

;.7n*i"ed wound . *$ pre"ent on le#t upper lid.

lotted 'lood pre"ent. 7t wa" hori=ontall)

pla*ed. he underl)ing or'ital 'one "howed *ut

#ra*ture.

.hopped in*i"ed wound 1 *$ ; *$ pre"ent on

*hin. here wa" #ra*ture o# lower $andi'le.

.7n*i"ed wound 12 *$ 2 *$ pre"ent on 'a*& o# head

over $id and right "ide : *$" a'ove po"terior hair

line. he underl)ing o**ipital 'one "howed *ut

#ra*ture. here wa" "u'ara*hnoid hae$ato$a over

right *ere'eral he$i"phere. 0 * o# *lotted

'lood wa" pre"ent at 'a"e *ranial *avit).

:.7n*i"ed penetrating wound 2 *$ pre"ent on le#t

"ide o# *he"t. *$ 'low tip o# le#t "houlderoint. 7t wa" hori=ontall) pla*ed. lotted 'lood

pre"ent.

.7n*i"ed penetrating wound 1. *$ pre"ent on le#t

"ide o# *he"t 2 *$ lateral #ro$ $id line and 8 *$

'elow and $edial to le#t nipple. lotted 'lood

pre"ent. 6n di""e*tion the wound *o$$uni*ated to

le#t plural *avit) through inter *o"tal "pa*e.

here wa" *ut pre"ent on le#t lung. A'out 1 litre

o# #luid and *lotted 'lood wa" pre"ent in le#t

plural *avit).

8.7n*i"ed penetrating wound 1.2. *$ pre"ent on

right "ide o# a'do$en 1 *$ 'elow right nipple.

lotted 'lood pre"ent. 6n di""e*tion the wound

*o$$uni*ated to a'do$inal *avit). here wa" *ut


33/283


pre"ent on the diaphrag$ and "uperior lo'e o#

liver.

9.7n*i"ed penetrating wound 1.2.8 *$ pre"ent on

right lateral #lan& o# *he"t 1 *$ 'elow and

lateral to right nipple and 1 *$ lateral to $id

line. lotted 'lood pre"ent. 6n di""e*tion there

wa" #ra*ture o# 10th ri' anteril). here wa" *ut

on the anterior lo'e o# liver. A'out 100 o#

#luid and *lotted 'lood wa" pre"ent in the

a'do$inal *avit).

10.7n*i"ed penetrating wound ; 1 *$ pre"ent on le#t

lateral #lan& o# *he"t on interior aillar) line

1 *$ ailla. lotted 'lood pre"ent. 6n

di""e*tion there wa" *ut in diaphrag$ and there

wa" *ut on the "pleen.

11.7n*i"ed penetrating wound 2 *$ . *$ pre"ent on

le#t lateral #lan& o# *he"t 1 *$ a'ove inur) No.

10. 7nur) No. 10 and 11 were hori=ontall) pla*ed

and on di""e*tion there wa" *ut on the diaphrag$

and "pleen.

12.7n*i"ed penetrating wound ; *$ 1. *$ pre"ent on

'a*& o# le#t "ide o# *he"t over po"terior aillar)

line 10 *$ 'elow and lateral to lower end o#

"*apula. he inur) *o$$uni*ated to le#t plural

*avit).

1;.Reddi"h a'ra"ion 2 *$ pre"ent on le#t lateral

#lan& o# a'do$en. 3a*erated wound 1. 1 *$ wa"

pre"ent in the *enter. lotted 'lood pre"ent.

1.7n*i"ed wound 1 *$ pre"ent on le#t thigh

anteriorl) 9 *$ a'ove le#t &nee oint. lotted

'lood pre"ent, hori=ontall) pla*ed.

1.7n*i"ed wound . 1 *$ pre"ent on #ront o# le#t

leg in upper 1/;rd. lotted 'lood pre"ent,

hori=ontall) pla*ed.

1:.7n*i"ed wound 2 *$ pre"ent on le#t #ore ar$ 10

*$ a'ove wri"t oint. 7t wa" hori=ontall) pla*ed.

1.7n*i"ed wound ; 1 *$ pre"ent on pal$er a"pe*t o#

le#t little #inger over la"t phalan. Mud and

*lotted 'lood wa" pre"ent.


34/283


18.7n*i"ed wound ; 1 *$ pre"ent on pal$er a"pe*t o#

ring #inger over la"t phalan. Mud and *lotted'lood wa" pre"ent.

19.7n*i"ed wound 1 . *$ pre"ent on 'a*& o# right

thu$' near 'a"e. lotted 'lood pre"ent.

20.7n*i"ed wound 1. . *$ pre"ent on pal$er a"pe*t

o# right thu$' over di"tal phalan. here wa"

#ra*ture o# underl)ing 'one.

21.7n*i"ed wound 1 *$ pre"ent on right lateral

#lan& o# *he"t on po"terior aillar) line 10 *$

'elow ailla. lotted 'lood pre"ent.

22.7n*i"ed wound 1 . *$ pre"ent on 'a*& o# *he"t

on right "ide 1; *$ #ro$ $id line and 11 *$ 'elow

lower 'order o# "*apula. lotted 'lood pre"ent.

2;.Reddi"h linear "*rat*h 12 *$ .2 *$ pre"ent on

interior a"pe*t o# le#t upper ar$ : *$ 'elow tip

o# "houlder oint. 7t wa" hori=ontall) pla*ed.

2.A'ra"ion reddi"h in *olour 1 1 *$ pre"ent on

'a*& o# right ring #inger over di"tal phalan.

2.Reddi"h a'raded *ontu"ion 2 1 *$ on right "ide

o# #a*e 2 *$ 'elow outer angle o# right e)e.

Re"t o# the organ" were nor$al and "to$a*h

*ontained 10 ** o# "e$i dige"ted #ood *ontent $ied

with 'lood. All inurie" were ante $orte$ in nature.

he 'oard #urther opined that the *au"e o# death in

thi" *a"e wa" hae$orrhage and "ho*& a" a re"ult o#

inurie" and inurie" No. , , 8, 9, 10 and 11 were

individuall) "u##i*ient to *au"e death in ordinar)

*our"e o# nature. he ti$e elap"ed 'etween inur) and

death wa" i$$ediate and 'etween death and po"t$orte$

wa" within 12 to 2 hour". 4e #urther depo"ed that


35/283


therea#ter, the) handed over to poli*e the #ollowing +-

1.Stit*hed dead 'od) a#ter po"t$orte$ ea$inationH

2.ar'on *op) o# po"t$orte$ reportH

;.Poli*e paper" 1 to 22 dul) "igned ') the$H

. A "ealed pa*&et with one "eal *ontaining

'elonging"H

.Sa$ple "eal".

he 'oard wa" *on"tituted on the appli*ation

o# poli*e .P-4 vide order .P4/1 whi*h i" "igned ')

Prin*ipal overn$ent Medi*al ollege, Patiala who"e

"ignature" he identi#ied. 4e #urther te"ti#ied that

the dead 'od) wa" re*eived in the $ortuar) on

1.10.200 vide endor"e$ent .P4/2. 4e al"o proved

the *ar'on *op) o# po"t$orte$ report .P-5, pi*torial

diagra$" "howing "eat o# inurie" .P-5/1 and the

"ignature" o# 'oard $e$'er" on in>ue"t report Dpage" 1

to 22E .P-K. 6n poli*e re>ue"t dated 1.12.200

.P-3 the $e$'er" o# the 'oard opined that po""i'ilit)

o# inurie" $entioned in the re>ue"t letter 'eing

*au"ed ') "hown weapon or "i$ilar t)pe o# weapon *annot

'e ruled out. 4e #urther identi#ied the "ignature" o#

'oard $e$'er" on endor"e$ent .P3/1. he "hown weapon

wa" returned in original with "lip on it 'earing

"ignature" o# 'oard $e$'er" and it wa" dul) "ealed with

#ive "eal", "a$ple o# "eal wa" al"o handed over along

with it. he pa*&et wa" opened a#ter *o$paring with


36/283


"eal o# ?oren"i* S*ien*e 3a'orator) and the opinion wa"

given on 1.12.200 vide endor"e$ent .P3/2. 4e

#urther identi#ied the &irpan .P-;, pat&a .P-, -

Shirt .P-, Pant .P-:, underwear .P-, Pair o#

"o*&" .P-8 G .P-9, pair o# "hoe" .P-10 G .P-11,

'elt .P-12 i.e. 'elonging" o# de*ea"ed in the ourt

al"o.

2;. P=-13 R*&'e P J*)5, hie# Manager,

Puna' National Ban&, 5alandhar te"ti#ied on oath that

on 22.10.200 he wa" po"ted a" Bran*h Manager, Puna'

National Ban&, Phata& No. 22, Patiala and on that da)

on the written re>ue"t o# the poli*e he had handed over

the a**ount "tate$ent .P-M o# a**ount No.

1820001000:::1 #or the period w.e.#. 01.01.200 to

1.10.200 pertaining to Satna$ ru"t whi*h wa"

operated ') ue"t o# poli*e he handed over a**ount" "tate$ent

.P-N G .PN/1 #or the period 01.01.200 to

22.10.200 o# a**ount No. SB088 pertaining to Ravdeep


37/283


Kaur d/o S.


38/283


.P- o# &irpan on whi*h he put hi" "ignature".

Kirpan wa" put into a wooden 'o and therea#ter it wa"

"ealed into a par*el ') 7n"pe*tor and "heath wa"

"eparatel) $ade into a par*el and 'oth the"e arti*le"

were ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-R.

Kirpan and "heath were "tained with 'lood. Kirpan wa"

"tained near handle. 4e identi#ied the &irpan and

"heath in the ourt.

2:. P=-16 S*&'e S*&75 Ge9"tated on oath

that %ia) Singh de*ea"ed wa" &nown to hi$. 6n

1;.10.200 he *a$e to Patiala at the hou"e o# hi"

$aternal grandun*le na$el) 3ate Sh. A$rao Singh,

Retired Prin*ipal. Ra'irender Singh D'rother-in-lawE,

hi" wi#eF" 'rother, Nai' eh"ildar al"o *a$e with hi$.

he) *a$e to Patiala in order to di"tri'ute *ard o# the

'irthda) o# "on o# Ra'irender Singh whi*h wa" to ta&e

pla*e on 19.10.200. @hen the) were *o$ing 'a*& to

Na'ha it wa" a'out 10+;0-10+ p.$., a#ter *ro""ing

Modi ollege *ro""ing toward" lower $all polo ground,

he "aw a $otor*)*le rider *o$ing out o# 'ro&en wall o#

Polo round who wa" driving the $otor*)*le at a great

"peed. hat $otor*)*le rider "lipped and hi"

$otor*)*le then #ell on the ground. hat $otor*)*le

rider wa" Manit Singh ranthi, a**u"ed pre"ent in the

ourt. 4e *a$e to &now a'out hi" na$e on 20.10.200.


39/283


4e wa" o# the age o# 2/2 )ear". 4e wa" thin and wa"

a*tive )oung $an having thin 'eard. 4e "topped hi" *ar

a#ter appl)ing 'ra&e". Manit Singh got up at on*e.

4i" &irpan whi*h had al"o #allen down wa" pi*&ed up ')

hi$. At that ti$e he DManitE wa" wearing 'lue

*oloured Kurta Pa)a$a. hat wa" having 'lood"tain".

4e had "een that in the light o# hi" *ar. 4e

i$$ediatel) "tarted hi" $otor*)*le and had run awa) ')

driving hi" $otor*)*le toward" #ountain *how&. 4e

drove the $otor*)*le at a great "peed and within a

"plit o# "e*ond he di"appeared. 4e thought #ro$ all

thi" that he DManitE $u"t have done "o$ething wrong

and 'e#ore he *ould get down #ro$ *ar Manit had

alread) gone awa). A" the ti$e wa" odd, there#ore, he

never wanted to ta&e the trou'le o# involving hi$"el#

in arduou" wor&. 4e *a$e 'a*& to Na'ha.

4e #urther depo"ed that on the net da) i.e.

1.10.200 he *a$e to &now #ro$ % new" that S. %ia)

Singh had 'een &illed. 4e *a$e to Patiala at A$ar

4o"pital where 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh $et hi$ who wa"

&nown to hi$. 4e wa" having a #ile in hi" hand. 4e

DSarvinder SinghE told hi$ a'out the in*ident o#

1;.10.200 whi*h he wat*hed at a'out 10+;0-10+ p.$.

Poli*e re*orded hi" "tate$ent out"ide A$ar 4o"pital.

6n 20.10.200 he wa" pre"ent at Patiala at the


40/283


re"iden*e o# de*ea"ed. Sewa Singh and other o##i*ial"

were al"o pre"ent there. 6n 19.10.200 he had "een the

photograph o# Manit Singh and Ravdeep Kaur. hen he

identi#ied that Manit Singh, a**u"ed wa" the "a$e

per"on who$ he had "een on the night o# 1;.10.200 a"

the one #ell in #ront o# hi" *ar. 4e had al"o read the

new"paper dated 19.10.200 and "aw the photograph" o#

a**u"ed Manit Singh and Ravdeep. ?ro$ that photograph

al"o he identi#ied a**u"ed Manit Singh a" the one who

had #allen down in #ront o# hi" *ar. 4e had al"o "een

the $otor*)*le #ro$ whi*h Manit had #allen down.

2. P=-1> Ne!5 K", 5unior A""i"tant, ue"t .P-R on whi*h he $ade

endor"e$ent .P-R/1.

28. P=-18 Ke!5, ler&,


41/283


the poli*e re>ue"t .P-S on whi*h "he $ade endor"e$ent

.P-S/1.

29. P=-1, S"&'e L S5, the then Bran*h

Manager, enturian Ban& o# Puna', 3eela Bhawan,

Patiala "tated on oath that on 22.10.200 he had handed

over *o$puteri=ed "tate$ent .P- o# a**ount 'earing

No. 2;SB111; #or the period w.e.#. 01.0.200 to

22.10.200 'elonging to Ravdeep Kaur */o Ravi 4o"pital,

(r'an "tate, Patiala. 4e #urther proved the a**ount

opening #or$ o# the a'ove "aid a**ount whi*h 'ear" the

photograph o# a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur a" A**ount 4older.

;0. P=-20 H(5&' S*&75te"ti#ied on oath that

he wa" &nown to de*ea"ed %ia) Singh. 6n 1;.10.200

%ia) Singh wa" 'eing &illed. 1-20 da)" prior to date

o# death o# %ia) Singh, he had gone to a**u"ed Ravdeep

Kaur with hi" wi#e #or her *he*&-up. 7n the $ain roo$

o#


42/283


a**u"ed. 4e had heard her "a)ing rather a"&ing Manit

li&e thi" that "he had given hi$ a "u$ o# R".0,000/-

and #urther that the $atter had alread) 'een dela)ed

and "he #urther told that "he would 'e pa)ing 'alan*e

a$ount o# R".,0,000/- and then a"&ed Manit ') ta&ing

hi" na$e literall) to do the wor& o# 5udge Sahi'

a""igned to hi$. She had al"o told Manit to tell her

#ran&l) i# he *an do awa) with the li#e o# %ia) Singh

5udge Sahi' or not. herea#ter, he heard a $ale voi*e

who wa" telling her that he *ould not 'e &nown a" Ba'a

Manit Singh in *a"e he would not #ini"h the li#e o#

%ia) Singh 5udge Sahi' within a wee& or ten da)". 4e

al"o heard the a#ore$entioned $ale voi*e o# Manit

Singh who wa" "a)ing to Ravdeep a**u"ed to &eep read)

the 'alan*e a$ount and he "hall 'e *olle*ting the "a$e

a#ter doing the a""igned wor& to hi$. @ithin 1 or 2

$inute",


43/283


in*ident *a$e 'e#ore hi" e)e" and he narrated the "a$e

to the poli*e.

;1. P=-21 V*" P;!5, Bran*h Manager, 4


44/283


a**u"ed a#ter putting the "a$e into a pol)thene 'ag

&ept hidden in the upper *olu$n o# the *up'oard o# her

'ed roo$. She al"o di"*lo"ed that "he had &ept hidden

'la*& *oloured 'ag and pol)thene 'ag under the >uilt

under the a#ore"aid *up'oard. She #urther di"*lo"ed

that "he alone &now" a'out that and *an get the "a$e

re*overed o# her own. 4er di"*lo"ure "tate$ent .P-%

wa" re*orded. 4e #urther depo"ed that a**u"ed then led

the poli*e part) to her hou"e at 4.No. 19-A, Nihal

Bagh, Baradari arden, Patiala. A#ter going to her

hou"e, "he along with poli*e part) went in"ide a 'ed

roo$. She pla*ed one "tool in #ront o# *up'oard o# her

'ed roo$ and a#ter *li$'ing on that "tool too& the

a#ore$entioned 'la*& *oloured 'ag and pol)thene 'ag

#ro$ 'eneath the >uilt l)ing in *up'oard o# her 'ed

roo$ and produ*ed the "a$e 'e#ore poli*e. 6n opening

the 'ag, R".2,00,000/-, one pi"tol .;2 'ore, her ar$

li*en*e and driving li*en*e o# %ia) Singh, de*ea"ed

were re*overed. Rough "&et*h plan .P-@ o# re*overed

pi"tol wa" prepared. AS7 Sat Pal Singh al"o "igned it

a" witne"". R".2,00,000/-, one pi"tol .;2 'ore, ar$

li*en*e o# Ravdeep Kaur and driving li*en*e o# %ia)

Singh were ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-

L. Blood "tained pair o# "hoe" produ*ed 'e#ore the

poli*e ') a**u"ed Ravdeep were $ade into a par*el and


45/283


"a$e wa" dul) "ealed with the "eal o# SS and ta&en into

poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-C. Spe*i$en "eal

i$pre""ion" o# the "eal wa" al"o retained. A#ter u"e,

"eal wa" handed over to AS7 Satpal. 4e #urther

identi#ied the 'la*& 'ag .P-1, pi"tol .P-1,

driving li*en*e o# de*ea"ed %ia) Singh .P-1: and

Ar$" 3i*en*e o# a**u"ed Ravdeep .P-1 in the ourt.

4e al"o identi#ied the *urren*) note" o# R".2,00,000/-

.P-18 to .P-100, "hoe" whi*h were got re*overed ')

a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur .P-101 and .P-102. Rough "ite

plan o# pla*e o# re*over) wa" al"o prepared.

;;. P=-23 K"'* S*&75 Ge9"tated on oath that

he i" pra*ti*ing in 3udhiana #or the la"t ;0 )ear" a"

Advo*ate. 7n Septe$'er, 200; %ia) Singh wa" po"ted a"

Adho* Additional Se""ion" 5udge at 3udhiana. 6n

29.09.200; he wa" "itting in the ourt roo$ o# de*ea"ed

and wa" in wait #or hi" turn in "o$e *a"e 'e#ore hi$.

7t wa" 2+;0 p.$. and Su&hpal Singh ill G Mr. Ko*hhar,

Advo*ate" were al"o "itting with hi$ in the a#ore"aid

*ourt roo$. A**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur entered into the

ourt roo$ o# de*ea"ed and "tarted $i"'ehaving with

%ia) Singh ') "a)ing that he had not $arried her and

had there') "poiled her li#e and he ha" $arried to one

lad)


46/283


hi$"el# wa" doing udge"hip *o$#orta'l). She #urther

told that "he would 'e 'ehaving with hi$ in "a$e

#a"hion a" "he had done that da) and would al"o "poil

hi" li#e in the "a$e $anner a" her li#e wa" "poiled.

he de*ea"ed told her that a" the *ourt pro*eeding"

were going on there#ore, he "ugge"ted her to have a

tal& later-on.


47/283


ha" 'een i""ued on 2;.02.200 in #avour o# Ravdeep Kaur

w/o Ragh'inder Singh, Kothi No. 19-A,Nihal Bagh,

Patiala and the "a$e wa" valid up to 2.02.2008. A"

per re*ord 'rought ') hi$ the pur*ha"e o# a pi"tol

o# .;2 'ore 'earing No. 1;0:19 i" entered.

;. P=-2% N*&'e K" K" "tated on oath

that he i" having a $o'ile "hop in Rapura olon) at

Patiala. Mo'ile phone .P-10; wa" pur*ha"ed ') hi$

#ro$ Mu"&an Agen*ie" on 08.10.200 vide 'ill .P-10.

6n the "a$e da) $o'ile .P-10; wa" "old to a**u"ed

Manit Singh vide 'ill .P-10. he 'ill" .P-10

and .P-10 were produ*ed 'e#ore the poli*e whi*h were

ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-10:. 4e

al"o 'rought the original 'ill 'oo& in the ourt

regarding "ale o# Mo'ile .P-10;.

;:. P=-26 D5*) S*&75, ler&, 6##i*e o#

Se*retar) RA, Patiala proved the driving li*en*e

.P-1 'earing No. 188:/ dated 0;.08.2001 i""ued in

the na$e o#


48/283


Bagh,


49/283


wa" 0119000:11 and the "a$e wa" in the na$e o# Ravdeep

Kaur, ; Ait Nagar, Patiala, Puna'. 4e #urther

proved the *op) o# a**ount "tate$ent a" .P-112.

0. P=-30 I&'ee!5 K5&&depo"ed on oath that he

i" an approved dra#t"$an. 6n 0.12.200 he had vi"ited

"pot/polo ground Patiala with Shivra Singh !


50/283


She #urther proved the *ar'on *op) o# M3R .P-11,

pi*torial diagra$ "howing the "eat o# inurie" .P-11:

and 6P< "lip .P-11. She #urther depo"ed that on

08.11.200 on the re>ue"t o# poli*e "he had opined that

the po""i'ilit) o# inurie" $entioned in M3R a" 'eing

"el# in#li*ted *annot 'e ruled out.

2. P=-32 C.A& S*&75 tendered in eviden*e hi"

a##idavit .P-118.

;. P=-33 C. J9*&'e S*&75tendered in eviden*e

hi" a##idavit .P119.

. P=-34 J#7*&'e S*&75, Se*urit) uard depo"ed

on oath that in Ma) 200 at a'out 8.;0 p$ he wa"

"itting in the "e*urit) roo$ "ituated at the $ain gate

o# Puna'i (niver"it) Patiala. Su&h'ir Singh, "e*urit)

guard wa" al"o "itting with hi$. At that ti$e he

re*eived a telephone *all in#or$ing that one lad) and

one gent" were "itting in a *ar near State Ban& o#

Patiala "ituated in the (niver"it) and al"o advi"ed

the$ to go there and *he*& the$. 6n thi" he along with

Su&h'ir Singh went to that "pot. 6ne 4onda it) *ar wa"

l)ing par&ed. 6n the driving "eat one lad) wa" "itting

and on the #ront "eat o# the "aid *ar one giani "i&h

per"on wa" "itting. 6n their a"&ing the lad) had

di"*lo"ed a'out her identit) that "he wa" do*tor o#

Ravi ho"pital, (r'an "tate Patiala and the gentle$an


51/283


"itting ') her "ide wa" granthi Manit Singh. he)

told the$ that the) *ould not "it in dar& at that

pla*e. 4e al"o told the$ i# the) have to "it together

the) *an par& their *ar in the light and then onl) *an

"it otherwi"e he advi"ed the$ to go ho$e. 6n*e that

lad) re"i"ted ') "a)ing that "he i" a do*tor and he

*annot "top her li&e that 'ut when again he repeated

hi" "a)ing then 'oth o# the$ le#t that pla*e. 4e

#urther identi#ied the lad) who di"*lo"ed her identit)

a" do*tor o# Ravi ho"pital and Manit pre"ent in *ourt.

. P=-3% C.R S*&75 tendered in eviden*e hi"

a##idavit .P-120.

:. P=-36 S). Dee*&'e K" wi#e o# %ia)

Singh de*ea"ed te"ti#ied on oath that "he i" a hou"e

wi#e. B) wa) o# ho'') "he al"o run a 'outi>ue in her

hou"e. 7n the )ear 198 "he got $arried to de*ea"ed.

She have three daughter". 6n 1;.10.200, "he re*eived

telephoni* *all #ro$ Shiv Ra "i"ter-in-law DNanadF"

hu"'andE. 4e en>uired a'out her hu"'and a" to where wa"

he. She had told hi$ that he had gone to Polo ground

#or evening wal& at a'out 10. At the ti$e o# re*eipt

o# a#ore"aid telephone, her hu"'and de*ea"ed %ia)

Singh wa" not at ho$e. herea#ter, her $other-in-law

'e*a$e ten"e. ven "he al"o 'e*a$e ten"e. A#ter "o$e

ti$e, again "he re*eived telephoni* *all #ro$ Shivra


52/283


Singh. 4e told her that at that ti$e "o$e'od) had

*au"ed "evere inurie" to her hu"'and at Polo ground

and he wa" 'eing ta&en to A$ar 4o"pital. She wa" al"o

a"&ed to rea*h A$ar 4o"pital, whereupon, "he alongwith

her $other in law rea*hed A$ar 4o"pital. 6n the wa)

the) had a halt at polo ground. he) had "een Shivra

Singh ta&ing her hu"'and ') *ar to A$ar 4o"pital. A"

"u*h the) #ollowed hi$. She had "een her hu"'and in

the $ergen*) o# the A$ar 4o"pital. 4e wa" 'adl)

inured. A#ter "o$eti$e


53/283


thi" $arriage Ravdeep wa" not happ) and "he had 'een

pur"uing her hu"'and to $arr) her. Ravdeep then

"tarted living with her hu"'and at 4.No.19-A, Nihal

Bagh, Patiala. Ravdeep then had a "on. 4owever,

in#atuation #or her D


54/283


on one da) a#ter *o$ing #ro$ o##i*e her hu"'and had

told that he re*eived a telephoni* *all #ro$ Ravdeep

a**u"ed to the e##e*t that "he had given a threat to

hi$ ') "a)ing that "he had alread) le#t her hu"'and #or

hi$ and now i# de*ea"ed doe" not leave her D


55/283


per"onnel did not allow her to enter hi" retiring roo$.

4er hu"'and had told her a'out thi" in*ident.

4owever, a#ter lun*h "he entered into the ourt roo$ o#

de*ea"ed where "he *reated "*ene and told her hu"'and

that "he will not leave hi$ alive even i# he $a)

e$plo) an) nu$'er o# "e*urit) per"onnel". hi" #a*t

wa" al"o told her at her hou"e ') her hu"'and. She

a"&ed her hu"'and to re$ain alert 'ut he alwa)" too& it

lightl).

herea#ter, on*e when her hu"'and wa" po"ted

at 3udhiana "he alongwith her hu"'and wa" there at

3udhiana 'ut Ravdeep a**u"ed had "ent a "lip through

her "ervant Narain Singh to their hou"e at Patiala 'ut

her $other in law had "ent hi$ 'a*& along with the

"lip. herea#ter, Ravdeep a**u"ed got #iled a *o$plaint

through Narain Singh again"t her and %ia) Singh that

"he and %ia) Singh had given 'eating" to hi$. hat

*o$plaint wa" got #iled in order to $aline her and

%ia) Singh, however, on in>uir) that *o$plaint wa"

#iled. herea#ter Ravdeep a**u"ed $ade an anon)$ou"

*o$plaint again"t her hu"'and to the hie# 5u"ti*e o#

Puna' and 4ar)ana 4igh ourt. 6n a**ount o# a#ore

$entioned a*t" o# Ravdeep Kaur "he u"ed to have ten"ion

'ut alwa)" her hu"'and had 'een *on"oling her ') "a)ing

that "he need not to worr).


56/283


She #urther "tated that one and a hal# $onth

prior to the in*ident 3a&h'ir Singh a *lo"e #riend o#

her hu"'and had told her that he had "een Ravdeep Kaur

along with a Si&h gentle$an "itting in her *ar at a

rounda'out near C.P.S. and polo ground. 4e had al"o

told her that Ravdeep Kaur wa" telling that Si&h

gentle$an "o$ething a#ter pointing toward" de*ea"ed.

3a&h'ir Singh had al"o told her that he had "een on*e

or twi*e that Si&h gentle$an ta&ing round" in the Polo

ground in the late night. 3a&h'ir Singh had al"o told

her that he had even #ollowed that Si&h gentle$an. 4e

$ade in>uir) a'out that Si&h gentle$an whereupon he

*a$e to &now that he wa" re"ident o# %illage Se&hupura

near Puna'i (niver"it), Patiala and hi" na$e wa"

Manit Singh Pathi. 4e al"o *a$e to &now that that

Si&h gentle$an wa" on vi"iting ter$" with Ravdeep in

Ravi 4o"pital, (r'an "tate, Patiala. 3a&hi had al"o

told her that he even had a tal& in thi" regard with

de*ea"ed %ia). 3a&hi had 'een going with %ia)

de*ea"ed on evening wal& u"uall) 'ut on the da) o# the

in*ident he did not go 'e*au"e he wa" not well.


57/283


a#ter giving $one) to Manit Singh Pathi, a**u"ed

pre"ent in the ourt.

. P=-3> D. A&'ee K", uite *lo"e to her

and he "hould 'e given proper *are. She had 'rought

Maneet Singh to her *lini* 2- ti$e". She #urther

proved the pre"*ription "lip . P-121 i""ued #or

Maneet Singh. She #urther te"ti#ied that "he had read


58/283


the new" o# the $urder o# %ia) Singh, 5udge and

therea#ter in .%. "he had "een the photograph" o# 'oth

the a**u"ed. She had identi#ied 'oth the a**u"ed a"

her a'ove "aid patient". She had al"o "een the

photograph o# Maneet Singh, in a new"paper, in the

poli*e "tation and had told a'out it to the poli*e.

8. P=-38 M";5)* S*&75 depo"ed on oath that

he i" trained in at&a pla)ing and had learned a'out it

at the age o# 1 )ear". At the ti$e o# Nagar Kirtan he

u"ed to "how hi" "&ill" in at&a. 4e &now" a**u"ed

Maneet Singh, pre"ent in the *ourt. 4e had given hi$

training in at&a. 4e had "tarted giving hi$ training

when he wa" "tudent o# 8th *la"". 4e had given hi$

training in 2 "hi#t" in ; $onth" ea*h. 4e wa" given

training ') u"ing "ti*& in pla*e o# "word. 4e learnt

at&a "u##i*ientl) 'ut he wa" not well trained.

Maneet a**u"ed had 'een a**o$paning the$ in Nagar

Kirtan and "howing hi" "&ill a" well in at&a with

the$.

9. P=-3,K*!5& K"depo"ed on oath that he

i" a photographer ') pro#e""ion and run" a Studio in

the na$e o#


59/283


poli*e to anal #or ta&ing the photograph". ?ir"tl),

the) had gone to Bu" Stand o# %illage hanaur. here

the) *o$e a*ro"" three per"on" who were diver".

herea#ter, the) rea*hed near S)phon a#ter *ro""ing the

hanaur Bridge *overing a di"tan*e o# a'out

&ilo$eter. Manit Singh a**u"ed wa" al"o with the

poli*e at that ti$e. herea#ter, the), poli*e and

Manit a**u"ed get down #ro$ the vehi*le and therea#ter

Manit a**u"ed pointed toward" a pla*e near Ki&&ar that

pla*e wa" *anal. herea#ter, one o# the diver u$ped

into the *anal and 'rought one Kirpan. 7t wa" within

it" "heath. 4ar'an" diver handed over that Kirpan to

5a""a Singh, 7n"pe*tor. 5a""a Singh too& out the

&irpan #ro$ the "heath and pla*ed the "a$e under the

"un #or dr)ing. he water #ro$ the "heath wa" al"o

re$oved. 4e too& #our photograph" o# a#ore"aid

pro*eeding". So$ Nath prepared the video o# the

a#ore"aid pro*eeding". 4e #urther proved the

photograph" .P-122 to .P-12 whi*h were handed over

to 5a""a Singh 7n"pe*tor. 4e had al"o given the %ideo

a""ette .P-12 alongwith the "aid photograph" to

5a""a Singh 7n"pe*tor, whi*h were ta&en into po""e""ion

vide $e$o .P-12:. 3earned Pu'li* Pro"e*utor

re>ue"ted to *ro"" ea$ine thi" witne"" 'ut de"pite hi"

*ro"" ea$ination he denied having *li*&ed the


60/283


photograph" on 19.10.200.

0. P=-40 HC M&*) S*&75tendered in eviden*e hi"

a##idavit" .P-12 to .P-129.

1. P=-41 HC Ke! S*&75depo"ed on oath that on

2.10.200 he *a$e to Mohali to in>uire a'out the

owner"hip o# the S7M i""ued ') 4ut*h *o$pan), where he

$et Muni"h Sriva"tav, Nodal 6##i*er who handed hi$ over

one letter .P-1;0, *op) o# agree$ent .P-1;1 and

*op) o# driving li*en*e o# Ravdeep Kaur .P-1;2. 4e

#urther depo"ed that a#ter *o$ing to Patiala he handed

over the a#ore"aid do*u$ent" to 7n"pe*tor 5a""a Singh.

2. P=-42 A*) Tuired a'out "ta) o# Ravdeep Kaur on 29.09.200; in

the a'ove "aid 4otel.


61/283


on 21.10.200 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh a"&ed hi$ to rea*h

at 4.No. 19-A Nihal Bagh, Patiala and on rea*hing there

he #ound S7


62/283


4onda it) *ar .P-12, one pre"*ription "lip o# hugh

lini* .P-121 were re*overed whi*h were ta&en into

po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-1;.

. P=-44 SI D5 De, depo"ed on oath that on

18.10.200 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh a"&ed hi$ to rea*h

urdwara


63/283


#ound #ro$ the po""e""ion o# a**u"ed Ravdeep. 6n "ear*h

o# her pur"e two "$all diarie" .P-1 G .P-18, two

$o'ile telephone" 'earing No,9819-0:00 and other

$o'ile No.98880-;099 .P-1, #ive note" o# the

deno$ination o# R".100/- ea*h .P-10 to .P-1, one

driving li*en*e o# Ravdeep .P-10, o'tained #ro$

3i*en"ing Authorit) ?atehgarh Sahi', one "trip o#

*ap"ule" na$el) Neurotrat .P-19 were re*overed. he

a#ore"aid arti*le" were ta&en in po""e""ion vide $e$o

.P1. A**u"ed Ravdeep wa" appri"ed o# the ground" o#

her arre"t vide $e$o .P1. he legal heir" o#

a**u"ed Ravdeep were al"o in#or$ed through $o'ile

telephone vide $e$o .P-1:.

4e #urther depo"ed that on 2;.10.0 7n"p. Sewa

Singh *alled hi$ at 7A "ta## Patiala where a**u"ed

Manit Singh and Ravdeep Kaur were in *u"tod).

?ir"tl) Manit Singh wa" interrogated and therea#ter

a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur wa" interrogated under the

"upervi"ion o# 3/S7 Bindu Bala. 7n"p.Sewa Singh had

alread) o'tained "ear*h warrant" o# Ravi ho"pital

'elonging to a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur and the) all

pro*eeded to Ravi ho"pital along with a**u"ed Ravdeep

Kaur along with 3/S7 Bindu Bala. AS7 %id)a Sagar had

alread) 'een dire*ted to 'ring Parveen Ku$ari having

&e)" o# the ho"pital to 'e pre"ent there. he) rea*hed


64/283


at Ravi ho"pital and oined one Pappu into part) and

*ondu*ted the "ear*h o# the ho"pital. @hen roo$ o#


65/283


.P-1:: and .P-1: whi*h were atte"ted ') Magi"trate

and were ta&en into po""e""ion a#ter "ealing the "a$e

') the *ourt vide $e$o .P-1:8. 4e #urther

identi#ied the "e*ond $o'ile phone re*overed #ro$

a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur a" .P-2: and the pur"e a"

.P-2::.

. P=-4% G"*) S*&75, 5unior A""i"tant, 6##i*e

o# ue"t

.P-1:9.

:. P=-46 SI J!9*&'e S*&75depo"ed on oath that

on 0.11.200 S46, ivil 3ine", Patiala dire*ted hi$

to vi"it the 4onF'le 4igh ourt o# Puna' G 4ar)ana,

handigarh to 'ring original *o$plaint again"t Sh.

%ia) Singh, the then 3d. Addl.


66/283


ivil 3ine", Patiala. S46 had opened the "aid envelope

in hi" pre"en*e, whi*h *ontained one original *o$plaint

again"t Sh. %ia) Singh, 3d. Addl. ue"t o# learned Spe*ial Pu'li* Pro"e*utor #or

the State and in hi" *ro"" ea$ination he ad$itted it

to 'e *orre*t that in the 6/o Regi"trar, "ealed

envelope wa" handed over to hi$ ') Superintendent Sh.

Shiva Nand and "in*e the 6##i*e wa" that o# Regi"trar

there#ore, he had $entioned/"tated toda) that the

"ealed envelope wa" handed over to hi$ ') Regi"trar.

. P=-4> I&!e()# J!! S*&75 depo"ed on oath

that in the intervening night o# 1; and 1.10.200, he

re*eived a $e""age #ro$ S46 ivil 3ine" Patiala that

Sh.%ia) Singh, Addl. Se""ion" 5udge ha" 'een $urdered

in Polo round and he "hould rea*h there. herea#ter,

he alongwith the #or*e went to Polo round. Be#ore hi"

rea*hing to the "pot, 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh,


67/283


"pot. 4e oined the inve"tigation and al"o a""i"ted

7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh in the in"pe*tion o# "pot. he

dead 'od) o# 5udge %ia) Singh had alread) 'een re$oved

to A$ar 4o"pital. herea#ter, he al"o rea*hed A$ar

4o"pital and in"pe*ted the dead 'od) and #ound a'out

two do=en inurie" on the dead 'od) o# 5udge %ia)

Singh in#li*ted ') $ean" o# "harp edged weapon. hen a"

per the in"tru*tion" o# the o##i*er", he went to Polo

round #or "ear*hing o# eviden*e in the Polo round.

hen the) &ept on "ear*hing the Polo round. 6n

1.10.200, a "pe*ial inve"tigation tea$ wa"

*on"tituted *o$pri"ing hi$. 4e interrogated the people

who u"ed to 'e pre"ent in the evening hour" in or near

Polo round. 6n 1:.10.200, again the) &ept on

"ear*hing the per"on involved in the *o$$i""ion o# the

o##en*e. 4e had put "o$e poli*e o##i*ial" in plain

*lothe" near') the hou"e o# a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur a"

well a" near') the ho"pital o# the a**u"ed. 6n

1:.10.200, 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh in#or$ed hi$ that

a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur a" well a" Manit Singh have 'een

no$inated a" a**u"ed in thi" $urder *a"e and #urther

advi"ed hi$ to *ondu*t the inve"tigation again"t

a**u"ed Manit Singh wherea" 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh will

*ondu*t inve"tigation >ua a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur. 6n

1:.10.200, he *ondu*ted raid at the hou"e o# a**u"ed


68/283


Manit Singh at village She&hupura. he hou"e wa" #ound

lo*&ed. 6n 1.10.200, he again &ept on "ear*hing

a**u"ed Manit Singh 'ut he wa" not availa'le. 6n

18.10.200, again he *ondu*ted raid at the hou"e o#

a**u"ed Manit Singh 'ut the hou"e wa" #ound lo*&ed. 6n

en>uir) #ro$ the village She&hupura, he *a$e to &now

that a**u"ed Manit Singh had le#t the village on hi"

vehi*le $a&e ata-20. 6n return, when he rea*hed near

.Point Mahindra ollege Patiala, he re*eived a phone

*all #ro$ 7n"pe*tor Sewa Singh that he had arre"ted


69/283


di"*lo"ed hi" na$e a" Manit Singh. 6n "ear*hing the

vehi*le #ro$ it" da"h 'oard a "u$ o# R".0,000/-

*o$pri"ing o# note" o# deno$ination o# R".00/- ea*h

.P-12, one R .P-1; whi*h wa" in the na$e o#

Manit Singh and one 7.ard .P-1 o# Manit Singh

were re*overed. he"e arti*le" alongwith the vehi*le

were ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-1.

6n #urther "ear*h o# the vehi*le, one pol)thene *arr)

'ag o# red *olour .P-1: wa" re*overed whi*h *ontain"

one parna .P-1, one lower .P-18, one upper

'earing Mar& Adida" .P-19 and one glove o# right

hand .P-180 were re*overed. All the"e arti*le" were

ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-181. 6n

#urther "ear*h o# the vehi*le, one "uite-*a"e *arr)ing

one &a$ee .P-18 G pa)a$a .P-18 o# 'lue *olour

whi*h wa" 'lood "tained were re*overed whi*h were

"ealed into par*el 'earing "eal i$pre""ion 5S and

"a$ple "eal wa" "eparatel) prepared. Seal a#ter u"e wa"

handed over to AS7 ur$ail Singh and the "aid par*el

wa" ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-182.

he "aid par*el dul) "ealed i" .P-18;. 4e #urther

depo"ed that on #urther *he*&ing o# the vehi*le, #ro$

'eneath the driver "eat o# the "aid vehi*le, one e$pt)

*arton .P-18: o# $o'ile phone o# No&ia ;220

*ontaining one 'ill No.; dated 08.10.200 .P-1


70/283


i""ued in the na$e o# Manit Singh #ro$ Ku$ra

o$$uni*ation were re*overed. he "aid *arton a" well

a" the 'ill were having 7M7 nu$'er o# the $o'ile

phone. Both the *arton a" well a" the 'ill were ta&en

into po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-18. 6n

per"onal "ear*h o# the a**u"ed, *urren*) note" o#

R".180/-, one po*&et diar) .P-189 'earing K

*ontaining the addre"" o#


71/283


72/283


into *anal and 'rought out one &irpan with "heath and

handed over to hi$. he photographer a" well a" the

$ovie $a&er too& photograph" and prepared $ovie o# thi"

tran"a*tion and he too& out the &irpan .P-; #ro$ the

"heath .P-1; and $ade it to dr) in the "un light.

he "&et*h .P- o# &irpan wa" prepared and wa" "ealed

into a par*el $ade o# wooden 'o with "eal o#

i$pre""ion 5S wherea" the "heath wa" "eparatel) "ealed

into a par*el in white *loth whi*h wa" al"o "ealed with

"eal i$pre""ion 5S and the "eal a#ter u"e wa" handed

over to AS7 ur$ail Singh. Both &irpan a" well a"

"heath par*el" were ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over)

$e$o .P-R. he dul) "ealed par*el *ontaining &irpan

and Sheath were produ*ed in the ourt. Rough "ite plan

.P-19: wa" prepared at the "pot with *orre*t $arginal

note". he $e$o .P-19 with regard to the #a*t that

the a**u"ed led the poli*e part) to the pla*e o#

o**urren*e and pointed out the pla*e o# o**urren*e o#

thi" *a"e wa" prepared.

4e #urther depo"ed that on #urther

interrogation o# the a**u"ed, the a**u"ed $ade

di"*lo"ure "tate$ent .P-198 that he ha" &ept

*on*ealed a "u$ o# R".+00 la*" in hi" 4ar$oniu$ l)ing

at hi" re"iden*e in the roo$ "ituated at right hand o#

the entran*e whi*h are in hi" e*lu"ive &nowledge and


73/283


po""e""ion and he *an get the "a$e re*overed.

4e #urther depo"ed that therea#ter on

20.10.200, the a**u"ed led the poli*e part) in

pur"uan*e o# hi" di"*lo"ure "tate$ent at the di"*lo"ed

pla*e i.e. hi" re"iden*e and got re*overed one

har$oniu$ .P-210 #ro$ the roo$ "ituated on the right

"ide o# the entran*e and a#ter re$oving one wooden

plan& #ro$ the 'a"e o# har$oniu$ got re*overed a "u$ o#

R".+00 la*" in 8 'undle" o# *urren*) note" o# R".00/-

ea*h, ea*h 'undle *ontained 100 *urren*) note". All

the eight 'undle" were $ar&ed 1 to 8 .P-201 to

.P-208 and the nu$'er o# #ir"t *urren*) note and the

la"t *urren*) note o# ea*h 'undle wa" noted down and

therea#ter all the"e eight 'undle" were put into a

pol)thene paper and therea#ter it wa" "ealed into a

par*el .P-209 with "eal o# i$pre""ion 5S. he

har$oniu$ a" well a" par*el o# *urren*) note" o#

R".+00 la*" were ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over)

$e$o .P-211 whi*h wa" atte"ted ') a'ove "aid

witne""e". he a**u"ed Manit Singh al"o got re*overed

one $otor *)*le No.PB2-B-212 .P-12;, with one


74/283


.P-22 o# a**u"ed Manit Singh #ro$ the 'a*& o# the

'ed whi*h were ta&en into po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o

.P-218. he rough "ite plan o# the pla*e o#

re*over) .P-22: wa" prepared at the "pot with *orre*t

$arginal note". he *a"e propert) with "eal" inta*t

wa" depo"ited with M4 Manit Singh and the a**u"ed wa"

lodged in the lo*& o# 7A Patiala.

4e #urther depo"ed that on 21.10.200 during

inve"tigation o# thi" *a"e, he *alled Narinder Ku$'ra

to 7A Sta##, Patiala who produ*ed one 'ill .P-10

dated 08.10.200 regarding pur*ha"e o# Mo'ile No&ia

whi*h wa" ta&en into po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-10:.

4e al"o re*orded the "tate$ent o# witne"" Narinder.

6n 22.10.200, the "pe*i$en hair o# the a**u"ed Manit

Singh were ta&en a#ter o'taining per$i""ion #ro$ 3d.

5udi*ial Magi"trate 7"t la"" vide appli*ation .P-2;

') *o$'ing hi" hair ') Manit Singh and the hair le#t

out in the *o$' in*luding *o$' wa" put into a pla"ti*

'o and were "ealed into a par*el .P-2; 'earing

i$pre""ion


75/283


.P-2 that one S7M *ard o# 4ut*h o$pan) *arr)ing

phone No. 98880099 whi*h wa" given to hi$ ')


76/283


ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-2:2. 6n

the "a$e da) Kri"han Ku$ar, Photographer al"o produ*ed

#our photograph" .P-122 to .P-12 along with one

video *a""ette" .P-12 whi*h were ta&en into

po""e""ion vide re*over) $e$o .P-12:. 6n 28.10.200

a**u"ed Manit Singh wa" produ*ed 'e#ore 3d. 7lla>a

Magi"trate, a Magi"trate. he "aid "heet" were "ealed into a

par*el ') the 7lla>a Magi"trate with "eal" o#

i$pre""ion


77/283


Kaur wa" "tudent o# their "*hool. 6n 2th Augu"t,

Ravdeep Kaur $oved appli*ation" .P-198 and .P-199

in the "*hool #or i$$igration purpo"e. he "aid

appli*ation" were written ') Ravdeep Kaur in hi"

pre"en*e and "a$e were handed over ') hi$ to AS7 Satpal

Singh vide $e$o .P-200 on the re>ue"t o# SSP,

Patiala.

:0. P=-%0 J"7 K*!5#ete"ti#ied on oath that he

i" having a Printing Pre"" under the na$e and "t)le o#

3eonard Printer" in 3al Bagh Street at Patiala. 7n

Augu"t, 200 a**u"ed Manit Singh had *a$e to hi$ #or

printing o# the ard" #or Freh Parve"hF *ere$on). 4e

had 'rought the *ard" a" well a" the envelope" #or the

purpo"e o# printing. 4e had printed 200 *ard" and

*harged the la'our a" R".;00/- #or the "aid printing.

4e #urther identi#ied the invitation *ard a" .P-22.

:1. P=-%1HC J7) S*&75tendered in eviden*e hi"

a##idavit .P-228.

:2. P=-%2 A*) K", e*utive o# %6


78/283


8991880000000;00. 4e #urther proved the re*ord

pertaining to the relea"ing o# a'ove "aid *onne*tion a"

Mar&-A, *op) o# driving li*en*e Mar&-B, another #or$

#or ad-on *onne*tion Mar&- and *op) o# driving 3i*en*e

Mar&-


79/283



80/283


herea#ter, a**u"ed Manit Singh wa" handed over one

white *o$' #or *o$'ing hi" hair and a#ter *o$'ing hi"

hair, the etra hair le#t in the *o$' in*luding the

*o$' wa" ta&en a" "a$ple and were "ealed into a par*el

'earing i$pre""ion


81/283


82/283


the "pe*i$en hand writing o# Manit Singh wa" o'tained

#ro$ 7n"p. 5a""a Singh vide hi" "tate$ent .P-21.

:. P=-%% ASI G"* S*&75, depo"ed on oath that

on 1.10.200 a Spe*ial 7nve"tigation ea$ wa"

*on"tituted *o$pri"ing o# Sh. Ko"tu' Shar$a, SP it),


83/283


o##i*ial" again raided the hou"e o# Manit Singh in

village She&hu Pura #ro$ where the) *a$e to &now that

Manit Singh had gone out on hi" vehi*le AA 20. 6n

return when the) rea*hed near Mohindra ollege,

Patiala, 7n"p. 5a""a Singh re*eived a phone *all #ro$

7n"p. 5a""a Singh that 7n"p. Sewa Singh had arre"ted


84/283


overta&ing it. he a**u"ed a#ter alighting #ro$ hi"

vehi*le atte$pted to run toward" Sangrur. 4e wa"

apprehended and on a"&ing a'out hi" identit), he

di"*lo"ed hi" na$e a" Manit Singh. hen the vehi*le

No.


85/283


vehi*le one e$pt) *artoon D.P-18:E o# $o'ile phone

$a&e No&ia ;220 *ontaining one 'ill No. ; dated

08.10.200 .P-10 whi*h wa" i""ued in #avour o#

a**u"ed Manit Singh were re*overed. Both the"e

arti*le" were ta&en into po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-18.

hen per"onal "ear*h o# the a**u"ed wa" *ondu*ted and

#ro$ hi" po""e""ion a "u$ o# R".180/- were re*overed

#ro$ the #ront le#t po*&et o# hi" "hirt, one diar)

.P-189 whereon F5)oti Kathuria KF wa" written and

in"ide the "aid diar) addre"" o#


86/283


Singh and during interrogation he $ade di"*lo"ure

"tate$ent that the "word with whi*h he had $urdered

%ia) Singh 5udge, the "aid "word along with "heath

thrown in Bha&hra Kanal Bran*h Kanda Kheri near S)phan

in #ront o# Ki&&ar ree whi*h wa" in hi" e*lu"ive

&nowledge and po""e""ion and he *an get the "a$e

re*overed. he "aid "tate$ent wa" redu*ed into writing

vide $e$o .P-19 whi*h wa" "igned ') the a**u"ed and

witne""ed ') hi$ and 4 4ari hand. herea#ter, the

a**u"ed along with the poli*e part) went to hanaur

own where Kri"han Ku$ar, Photographer and So$ Nath

Movie $a&er were oined in the part). herea#ter, the)

*a$e to Bu" Stand o# hanaur own. 6n re*eipt o#

telephone *all #ro$ the diver" ') 7n"p. 5a""a Singh,

three diver" na$el) 4ar'an" Singh, Sure"h and Malta

had *o$e #ro$ Ropar. he) were al"o oined in the

poli*e part). herea#ter, the a**u"ed Manit Singh

led the poli*e part) at the di"*lo"ed pla*e in #ront o#

Ki&&ar ree a#ter *ro""ing S)phon and pointed out the

pla*e where he had thrown the &irpan with "heath.

4ar'an" diver dived into the &anal and 'rought out one

&irpan .P-; in a "heath .P-1; in a "hort while and

produ*ed the "a$e 'e#ore 7n"p. 5a""a Singh.

Photographer too& photograph and the $ovie $a&er

prepared the $ovie o# the whole tran"a*tion. 7n"p.


87/283


5a""a Singh too& out the &irpan #ro$ the "heath and

"pla"hed the water #ro$ it and $ade it to dr) in "un.

4 Ba&htaur Singh wa" "ent to 'ring the wooden 'o with

white *loth and 7n"p. 5a""a Singh prepared "&et*h o#

"aid &irpan. herea#ter, the &irpan wa" put into a

wooden 'o and $ade into a par*el whi*h wa" "ealed with

"eal i$pre""ion F5SF. Sa$ple "eal wa" "eparatel)

prepared and "eal a#ter u"e wa" handed over to hi$.

"heath wa" al"o "ealed into a par*el with "eal o#

i$pre""ion F5SF and were ta&en into po""e""ion vide

$e$o .P-R. 6n return the a**u"ed al"o pointed out

the pla*e o# o**urren*e and the pla*e where he had

par&ed hi" $otor *)*le and $e$o to thi" e##e*t wa"

prepared whi*h i" .P-19. 6n 19.10.200 7n"p. 5a""a

Singh #urther interrogated the a**u"ed and during

interrogation he $ade di"*lo"ure "tate$ent .P-198

that the a$ount o# R". 3a*" whi*h he had ta&en #ro$

a**u"ed Ravdeep a" *on"ideration to &ill 5udge %ia)

Singh out o# that a$ount he had *on*ealed R". 3a*" in

hi" 4ar$oniu$ a#ter re$oving a pie*e o# wood and the

"aid pie*e wa" again repla*ed at the "a$e pla*e and he

had &ept the "aid 4ar$oniu$ at hi" re"iden*e in a roo$,

"ituated on the right "ide o# the entran*e o# hi" hou"e

whi*h wa" in hi" e*lu"ive &nowledge and po""e""ion and

he *ould get re*overed on pointing out the "a$e pla*e.


88/283


herea#ter, on 20.10.200, he along with

7n"p. 5a""a Singh and other poli*e o##i*ial" had again

"tarted the inve"tigation o# thi" *a"e and a**u"ed

Manit Singh while in poli*e *u"tod) led the poli*e

part) at hi" re"iden*e at village She&hu Pura and in

pur"uan*e o# hi" "tate$ent got re*overed one 4ar$oniu$

#ro$ a roo$ "ituated on the right "ide o# the entran*e

and got re*overed R". 3a*" a#ter re$oving the wooden

pie*e o# hi" 4ar$oniu$ with hi" own hand". here were

total 8 'undle" o# *urren*) note" o# the deno$ination

o# R".00/- ea*h. All the pa*&et" were $ar&ed 1 to 8

and the #ir"t and la"t nu$'er o# *urren*) note" were

noted down o# ea*h pa*&et. All the pa*&et" were "ealed

into one par*el in a pol)thene paper and in a white

*loth and wa" "ealed with the i$pre""ion o# F5SF and

"eal a#ter u"e wa" handed over to hi$. he eight

pa*&et" are .P-201 to .P-208 and "aid par*el along

with 4ar$oniu$ .P-210 were ta&en into po""e""ion vide

$e$o .P-211. 6ne $otor *)*le $a&e 3M3 ?reedo$

'earing PB2-B-212 #ro$ the "tore roo$ o# hi" hou"e

with paper" R o# the $otor *)*le in the na$e o# the

a**u"ed .P-21,


89/283


Singh .P-21 and "even photograph" o# Manit .P-219

to .P-22 were re*overed whi*h were ta&en into

po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-218.

6n 20.10.200, the a**u"ed wa" produ*ed

in the ourt and al"o an appli*ation wa" $oved #or

o'taining the "pe*i$en hair o# the a**u"ed and the "aid

appli*ation wa" adourned ') 3d. 7lla>a Magi"trate to

22.10.200.

6n 21.10.200, he had oined the

inve"tigation o# thi" *a"e with 7n"p. 5a""a Singh.

Narinder Ku$ar Ku$'ra *a$e to 7A Sta## and produ*ed

one invoi*e .P-10 dated 08.10.200 regarding

pur*ha"e o# one No&ia Mo'ile Set and it wa" ta&en into

po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-10:.

6n 22.10.200 he again oined the

inve"tigation o# thi" *a"e with 7n"p. 5a""a Singh and

again a**u"ed wa" produ*ed 'e#ore 7lla>a Magi"trate #or

o'taining "pe*i$en hair o# the a**u"ed. he 7lla>a

Magi"trate a#ter o'taining hi" *on"ent a"&ed the

a**u"ed Manit Singh to *o$' hi" hair with white *o$'

whereupon "o$e o# the hair" o# a**u"ed Manit were

re$oved. he "aid *o$' along with hair wa" put into a

pla"ti* 'o whi*h wa" "ealed a#ter $a&ing into a

par*el, ') the 7lla>a Magi"trate,


90/283


vide $e$o .P-22.

6n 2:.10.200 again he oined the

inve"tigation o# thi" *a"e with 7n"p. 5a""a Singh and

the a**u"ed Manit Singh wa" interrogated and during

interrogation a**u"ed Manit Singh $ade a di"*lo"ure

"tate$ent .P-2 that one S7M *ard o# 4(4 *o$pan)

'earing No. 98880099, whi*h wa" given to hi$ ')


91/283


the "a$e da) Kuldeep Singh, #ather o# a**u"ed Manit

Singh produ*ed two


92/283


ivil 3ine", Patiala. At a'out 1+0 a.$., he re*eived

a telephoni* $e""age #ro$ A$ar 4o"pital, Patiala that

%ia) Singh Additional Se""ion" 5udge had 'een $urdered

and hi" dead 'od) wa" l)ing in A$ar 4o"pital.

hereupon, he along with AS7 Satpal and other o##i*ial"

pro*eeded to A$ar 4o"pital. 6n the gate o# the

ho"pital Shiv Ra Singh $et hi$ and he $ade hi"

"tate$ent .P-A on whi*h he $ade endor"e$ent .P-2:

and "end the "a$e to the poli*e "tation through .

urdial Singh #or the regi"tration o# the *a"e. 4e

al"o dire*ted to in#or$ the higher authoritie" and

*alled #or uad, $ovie $a&er, photographer and

?inger Print pert" at the "pot.

4e #urther te"ti#ied on oath that

therea#ter, he *a"uall) ea$ined the dead 'od) o# %ia)

Singh and #ound there were a'out 20-2 inurie" on hi"

'od) and he wa" having "o$e hair in hi" right hand.

he "aid hair were put in to the pla"ti* 'o and wa"

"ealed with the "eal i$pre""ion FSSF. Sa$ple "eal wa"

"eparatel) prepared and "aid pla"ti* 'o wa" ta&en into

poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-B/1.

herea#ter, Shiv Ra Singh, produ*ed 'e#ore

hi$ one $o'ile $a&e No&ia .P-1 whi*h wa" li&e a 'oo&

alleged to have 'een re*overed ') hi$ #ro$ the "pot and

the S7M nu$'er o# the "aid $o'ile wa" 9822-1002 and


93/283


it wa" ta&en into po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-A/2.

4e #urther depo"ed that a#ter that he

pro*eeded to the "pot at Polo round. he tea$" o#


94/283


on the dead 'od) o# %ia) Singh. he photographer and

$ovie $a&er were dire*ted to get the photograph" and to

prepare the $ovie o# the po"t$orte$. herea#ter, he

re*orded the "tate$ent o# A'dula Noorie in ngli"h and

then in Puna'i.

4e #urther te"ti#ied on oath that therea#ter,

he went to the hou"e o# 5udge %ia) Singh, de*ea"ed and

interrogated the "ervant" o# the "aid hou"e. hen he

again went to Polo ground and interrogated the u'ewell

operator o# Polo round and then again returned 'a*& to

Raindra 4o"pital, Patiala. AS7 Satpal produ*ed 'e#ore

hi$ one par*el with "eal" o# KKA and the "eal wa"

inta*t, along with "a$ple "eal and the "aid par*el

*ontained two "hoe" .P-10 G .P-11, two "o*&" .P-8

G .P-9, underwear .P-, pent .P-:, -"hirt

.P-, Pat&a .P- and Belt .P-12 and the par*el

wa" ta&en into po""e""ion vide $e$o .P-B. State$ent"

o# witne""e" were re*orded. 6n return to the poli*e

"tation, the *a"e propert) wa" depo"ited with M4

Manit Singh with "eal" inta*t. 4e #urther depo"ed

that on 1.10.200 he went to the hou"e o# %ia) Singh,

de*ea"ed where *o$plainant $et hi$ and therea#ter, he

went to 7A Sta## and had interrogated the "u"pe*ted

people.


95/283


Shar$a,


96/283


and hou"e o# Manit Singh. hen he *a$e 'a*& to SSP

6##i*e and too& into po""e""ion the report o# *o$plaint

o# Narain Singh again"t %ia) Singh, de*ea"ed #ro$ 4

(dha$ Singh. 4e veri#ied the "aid report #ro$ Sh.

Ko"tu' Shar$a, the then ASP and he had veri#ied it to

'e the "aid report whi*h he had *on*luded. herea#ter,

he rea*hed near urudwara


97/283


the$ near urudwara


98/283


99/283


100/283


Manit Singh .P-121, R o# the *ar .P-12 were

re*overed and the"e were ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion

vide $e$o .P-1;. Rough "ite plan .P-2:9 with

*orre*t $arginal note" wa" prepared ') hi$.

4e #urther depo"ed that on 22.10.200, he

along with other o##i*ial" went to 7A Sta##, Patiala

and interrogated a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur and *a$e to &now

a'out the 'an& detail" and therea#ter, he went to State

Ban& o# Patiala, Raindra 4o"pital, Patiala and $ade a

re>ue"t to hand over the a**ount detail" o# the a**u"ed

Ravdeep Kaur and a**ount "tate$ent .P-112 wa" handed

over to hi$ whi*h wa" ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion and

the "tate$ent" o# witne""e" wa" re*orded. herea#ter,

he went to Ban& o# Puna' 3eela Bhawan #ro$ where he

got "tate$ent o# Ravdeep Kaur .P- whi*h wa" ta&en

into po""e""ion. hen he pro*eeded to anara Ban&,

3eela Bhawan #ro$ where he o'tained a**ount "tate$ent

o# a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur .P-N and .P-N/1 and the

"aid a**ount wa" in the na$e o# Ravdeep Kaur and her

$other 5a"want Kaur and re*orded the "tate$ent o#

Manager. herea#ter, he went to 4


101/283


into poli*e po""e""ion the A**ount State$ent o# Satna$

ru"t, ;, Ait Nagar, Patiala .P-M. hen on return,

S7


102/283


103/283


the 3d. Magi"trate, Patiala


104/283


"port "hoe" 'lood "tained o# Manit Singh, a**u"ed in a

pla"ti* 'ag under the >uilt in the upper portion on the

*up 'oard in the 'ed roo$ o# her hou"e whi*h wa" in

her e*lu"ive &nowledge and po""e""ion and "he *ould

get the "a$e re*over. herea#ter, the a**u"ed while

in poli*e *u"tod) lead the poli*e part) at the

di"*lo"ed pla*e to her hou"e in her 'ed roo$ and got

re*overed the a'ove "aid arti*le" #ro$ the "aid pla*e

o# *on*eal$ent. a"h R".2 3a*" are .P-18 to .P-20

in three 'undle" and 20 *urren*) note" o# deno$ination

o# R".1000/- .P-21 to .P-0 and :0 *urren*) note"

o# deno$ination o# R".00/- ea*h .P-1 to .P-100,

one pi"tol .;2 'ore .P-1, "&et*h o# whi*h i" .P-@

wa" prepared, ar$" li*en*e .P-1, driving li*en*e o#

%ia) Singh, 5udge .P-1: along with one 'la*& 'ag

.P-1 were ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide $e$o

.P-L. Pair o# "hoe" wa" "ealed into par*el with "eal

i$pre""ion SS and wa" ta&en into poli*e po""e""ion vide

$e$o .P-C. Rough "ite plan .P-21 wa" prepared

with *orre*t $arginal note" and on return to the poli*e

"tation, the *a"e propert) with "eal" inta*t wa" handed

over to M4 Manit Singh.

4e #urther depo"ed that on 2.10.200, he

interrogated 'oth the a**u"ed Ravdeep Kaur and Manit

Singh at 7A Sta## and on 28.10.200 a**u"ed Ravdeep


105/283


Kaur wa" produ*ed in the ourt and wa" re$anded to

udi*ial *u"tod). 6n 0.11.200, he veri#ied the

owner"hip o# *ar it) 4onda 'earing No. PB11-N-0110

#ro$


106/283


:. P=-%> S"&* R&/Nodal 6##i*er, Bharti A7R3

3i$ited, proved on #ile the re*ord pertaining to

allot$ent o# $o'ile nu$'er 98190:00 whi*h wa"

a*tivated on ;1.10.200; and it re$ained a*tivate till

10.11.200. 4e #urther proved it" *o$puteri=ed *all

detail" w.e.#. 1.09.200 to 1.10.200 a" .P@-/A.

4e #urther proved the *o$puteri=ed *all detail" o#

telephone nu$'er 98190:8 w.e.#. 01.10.200 to

1.10.200 a" .P@-/B. hi" re*ord i" prepared in

the o$puter in due *our"e o# the 'u"ine"" #ro$ ti$e to

ti$e.

:8. hi" i" the entire eviden*e led ') the

pro"e*ution.

:9. 6n the other hand, the a**u"ed have ea$ined

in their de#en*eA*) K#5*a" D=-1who "tated on oath

that he i" the Proprietor o# M/".


107/283


108/283


Ravdeep Kaur and S$t. 5a"want Kaur on 2.01.200; #or

*on"tru*tion o# hou"e 'uilding in Man"ahi)a olon),

Patiala. A" per re*ord a "u$ o# R". 2 3a*" wa"

di"'ur"ed on 28.01.200; and another "u$ o# R".; 3a*"

wa" di"'ur"ed on 10.09.200. he "aid a$ount wa"

*redited in the a**ount No. 088 'elonging to


109/283


"on" o# Santo&h Singh, re"ident o# %illage ?atehgarh

Bet and other". he *hallan wa" pre"ented in the *a"e.

he "aid a**u"ed have 'een a*>uitted ') the *ourt o#

Sh. 4arpal Singh, Addl. Se""ion" 5udge, Patiala on

0.0;.2009.

4e #urther proved the photo*op) o# ?7R No. 19

dated 19.0.200 .


110/283


*ited a" a witne"". he *hallan in the "aid *a"e wa"

pre"ented and a#ter trial the a**u"ed have 'een

a*>uitted ') the *ourt o# Sh. .R. Ban"al, ld. Addl.

Se""ion" 5udge DAdho*E, Patiala on ;0.;.2009.

. D=->HC S";5'e S*&75proved the re*ord o# ?7RNo. 18 dated 19.09.200 .


111/283


%illage Sultanpur, P.S. ha$&aur Sahi'.

. D=-, HC R K"proved the re*ord pertaining

to ?7R No. dated 09.01.200; .


112/283


113/283


Kaur al"o &nown a"


114/283


Sidhu Khandaan had urdit Singh who had three "on"

urdhian Singh, urdev Singh and ur"haran Singh. 4e

#urther proved the *erti#ied *op) o# the pedigree ta'le

a" .


115/283


116/283


117/283


8. D=-1, I&'e*) S*&75, Me$'er Pan*ha)at o#

village She&hur Ka$'oa,


118/283


"tate, Patiala wa" allotted to Rainder Singh "on o#

ian Singh vide order .


119/283


there wa" a "ign 'oard o# the re"iden*e o# the do*tor.

Plot" No. 8 G 8: are adoining plot".

89. D=-21 S5. N'ee G"), 4andwriting G ?inger

Print pert depo"ed on oath that he i" a law graduate

and M.S*.

Date post:	04-Jun-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	sampath-bulusu
View:	231 times
Download:	1 times

Judge Murder Case Patiala

Documents