8/2/2019 Letter by U.S. District Judge Mark Wolf to Attorney Gen. Eric Holder re prosecutions April 29, 2009

1/6

_@KXOH VXIXOV HKVXTKFX FL_TXHKVXTKFX LE AIVVIFB_VOXXV

^IVY_IMO DITL@O

. Fk. @l. ;2!999>8!AMZ_@KXOH VXIXOV LE IAOTKFIUK@FO@X EOTTITI

. Fk. @l. >>!995;6!AMZ_@KXOH VXIXOV LE IAOTKFI

LTHOTZLME- H.G. I~tkm 42- 4>>;

Ixxifboh kv i` I~tkm 46K 4>>; moxxot etla xbo flutx xlIxxlt o{ Jo otim Otkf B. Blmhot. Xbo ixxifbao xv xl xbo moxxot ai{do ldxik oh etla xbo flutx ekmov k xbovo fivov.

kmm AITC M. ZLME_@KXOH VXIXOV HKVXTKFX G_HJO

8/2/2019 Letter by U.S. District Judge Mark Wolf to Attorney Gen. Eric Holder re prosecutions April 29, 2009

2/6

I~tkm 46- 4>>;D[ EOHOTIM OR^TOVVXbo Bl`ltidmo Otkf B. BlmhotIxxlt`o{ Jo`otim le xbo _`kxoh Vxixov_`kxoh Vxixov Ho~itxao`x le Guvxkfo;?> ^o``v{mi`ki Io`uo- @.Z.- Tlla 88>>Zivbk`jxl`- H.F. 4>?6>

Ixxo`xkl`7 I``ko Dtihmo{

Hoit Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Blmhot7Xbi`c {lu elt {lut toaitcv l` I~tkm 49- 4>>;- xl xbo FbkoeGuhjov le xbo _`kxoh Vxixov Hkvxtkfx Flutxv. Zo i~~tofkixo {luthoxotak`ixkl` xl ivvuto xbix Ho~itxao`x le Guvxkfo ixxlt`o{v

~otelta xbokt huxkov bl`ltidm{ i`h idm[e i`h xl xico votkluvm{ i`{eikmuto xl hl vl. K ia ztkxk`j k` tov~l`vo xl {lut toyuovx xbix zoflaau`kfixo zkxb {lu hktofxm{ ke zo o`flu`xot xbo x{~o le ~tldmoa{lu zkvb xl ihhtovv.

O`fmlvoh kv a{ Gi`uit{ 4- 4>>2 moxxot- zkxb ixxifbao`xv- xlIxxlt`o{ Jo`otim Akfbiom Aucivo{. Iv {lu zkmm voo- kx hovftkdov xbohkvfk~mk`it{ ~tlfoohk`jv K k`kxkixoh k` 4>>: ijik`vx i` Ivvkvxi`x_`kxoh Vxixov Ixxlt`o{ dofiuvo le xbo Ho~itxao`x le Guvxkfo 9 vk`ihoyuixo tov~l`vo xl bkv akvfl`hufx k` eikmk`j xl hkvfmlvoaixotkim orfum~ixlt{ k`eltaixkl` xbix xbo Flutx le I~~oimv elt xboEktvx Fktfukx fbitifxotkwoh iv $dmixi`x- 99 99eofcmovv- $$ai`k~umixko-$ $homkdotixo-$ i`h $luxtijoluv.$ Eottiti . _`kxohVxixov- 8?5 E.6h 4:2- 4;6 "9vx Fkt. 4>>5+ . Xbix akvfl`hufx toyuktohao xl lthot xbo tomoivo etla ~tkvl` le i Fi~l i`h i` Ivvlfkixo lexbo ^ixtkitfi Eiakm{ le Mi Flvi @lvxti. Voo Eottiti . _`kxohVxixov- 628 E. Vu~~. 4h 628 "H. Aivv. 4>>?+.

Iv or~mik`oh k` a{ ixxifboh Hofoadot 2- 4>>5 moxxot xlIxxlt`o{ Jo`otim Imdotxl Jl`wimov- xbo akvfl`hufx xbix tovumxoh k`xbo tomoivo le xbo hoeo`hi`xv ziv ~itx le i ml`j ~ixxot` le vkakmitakvfl`hufx d{ xbo viao ~tlvofuxlt. Iv or~mik`oh k` a{ ixxifbohGu`o 4;- 4>>: moxxot xl Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Jl`wimov- a{ Gi`uit{ 4-4>>2 moxxot xl Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Aucivo{- i`h a{ ixxifboh Gi`uit{ 4-4>>2 moxxot xl Ivvlfkixo Ho~ux{ Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Hikh Aitjlmkv-

8/2/2019 Letter by U.S. District Judge Mark Wolf to Attorney Gen. Eric Holder re prosecutions April 29, 2009

3/6

xbo 9Kvi`fxkl`9melt xbo orxtoao i.`h k`xo`xkl`i.m akvfl`hufx elu`h d{ao i`h d{ xbo Ektvx Fktfukx ziv i voftox- ztkxxo` to~tkai`h d{ xbo_`kxoh Vxixov Ixxlt`o{ elt xbo Hkvxtkfx le Aivvifbuvoxxv zbl-doelto i`h iexot kvvuk`j kx- ~udmkfm{ ~tikvoh xbo ~tlvofuxlt.

K` a{ moxxot xl Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Aucivo{ K ztlxo xbix7xbo Ho~itxao`x*v ~oteltai`fo k` xbo Stoeoto`fohQ aixxottikvov votkluv yuovxkl`v idlux zboxbot guhjov vblumhfl`xk`uo xl tom{ u~l` xbo Ho~itxao`x xl k`ovxkjixo i`hvi`fxkl` akvfl`hufx d{ eohotim ~tlvofuxltv. Iv l`o zblxllc ~tkho k` ivvkvxk`j Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Ohzith Mok k`ovxidmkvbk`j "xbo Leekfo le ^tleovvkl`im Tov~l`vkdkmkx{Qalto xbi` xbktx{ {oitv ijl- K vihm{ hludx xbix kx kv `lzfi~idmo le votk`j kxv k`xo`hoh ~ut~lvo.

Guhjo Oaaox J. Vummki`*v tofo`x i~~lk`xao`x le i v~ofkim flu`vomxl k`ovxkjixo i`h ~lvvkdm{ ~tlvofuxo bkjb ti`ck`j Ho~itxao`x leGuvxkfo miz{otv elt fl`xoa~x k` xbo Vxoo`v fivo fl`ektav xbixlxbot guhjov vbito a{ fl`fot`.

Iv xbo Vxoo`v fivo imvl k`hkfixov- ~tlvofuxltkim akvfl`hufxkv `okxbot i tito `lt aotom{ bkvxltkfim ~tldmoa. Iv K tofo`xm{ztlxo k` xbo o`fmlvoh hofkvkl` k` _`kxoh Vxixov . Gl`ov- 9KSxGboojtojkluv eikmuto le xbo jlot`ao`x xl hkvfmlvo Sk` 4>>2Q ~mik`m{aixotkim orfum~ixlt{ okho`fo k` SGl`ovQ orxo`hv i hkvaim bkvxlt{le k`xo`xkl`im i`h k`ihotxo`x klmixkl`v le xbo jlot`ao`x*vhuxkov xl hkvfmlvo k` fivov ivvkj`oh xl xbkv flutx. 99 4>>; ZM9?9?2: ix '? "H. Aivv. Gi`. 49- 4>>;+. @k`o `lxozltxb{ oria~mov levufb akvfl`hufx zoto fkxoh. Kh. ix '9:!92.

K` a{ moxxot xl Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Aucivo{ K imvl hovftkdoh xboto~oixoh eikmutov le xbo Ho~itxao`x le Guvxkfo xl do fi`hkh i`hfl`vkvxo`x zkxb flutxv k` aixxotv itkvk`j etla a{ 9;;; hofkvkl`ek`hk`j orxtilthk`it{ akvfl`hufx d{ aoadotv le xbo Eohotim Dutoiule K`ovxkjixkl` "9KEDK9K+fl`fot`k`j kxv k`eltai`x Giaov 9KZbkxo{9mDumjot. Voo _`kxoh Vxixov . Vimoaao- ;9 E. Vu~~. 4h 989 "H. Aivv.9;;;+. Elt oria~mo- iv hovftkdoh k` hoxikm k` xbix moxxot- k` xboeohotim ~tlvofuxkl` le EDK ijo`x Glb` Fl``lmm{ xbo Ho~itxao`x leGuvxkfo ivvotxoh x.bix3 Fl``lmm{ bih xlmh Dumjot le k`hkkhuimv~tlkhk`j k`eltaixkl` ijik`vx Dumjot zbl zoto xbo`- eltovooidm{-authotoh. Fl``lmm{ biv doo` fl`kfxoh le hlk`j guvx xbix k` ivxixo flutx fivo k` Emltkhi xbix ziv ~tlvofuxoh k` ~itx d{ i ftlvv!hovkj`ixoh Ivvkvxi`x _`kxoh Vxixov Ixxlt`o{. K` dlxb ftkak`imfivov- xbo jlot`ao`x ~tovo`xoh xbo kaau`kwoh xovxkal`{ le Dumjot*vivvlfkixo Cok` Zoocv. Zoocv tofokoh i eohotim vo`xo`fo le l`m{vkr {oitv elt flaakxxk`j eko authotv divoh l` xbo Ho~itxao`x leGuvxkfo*v to~tovo`xixkl` xbix Zoocv bih doo` fla~moxom{ xtuxbeumi`h ~tlkhoh vudvxi`xkim ivvkvxi`fo. @ootxbomovv- k` i votkov le

4

8/2/2019 Letter by U.S. District Judge Mark Wolf to Attorney Gen. Eric Holder re prosecutions April 29, 2009

4/6

fivov dtlujbx d{ xbo vutkltv le Dumjot*v kfxkav- ixxlt`o{v etlaxbo Fkkm Hkkvkl` le xbo Ho~itxao`x le Guvxkfo bio u`vuffovveumm{itjuoh xbix Fl``lmm{ hkh `lx moic xbo moxbim k`eltaixkl` xl Dumjoti`h bio ixxoa~xoh xl hkvftohkx Zoocv* xovxkal`{ l` xbkv kvvuo.

A{ mixo flmmoijuo Guhjo Tojk`imh Mk`hvi{ ~udmkfm{ utjoh xboHo~itxao`x le Guvxkfo xl voxxmo xbo fivov itkvk`j lux le xbo EDK*vakvfl`hufx fl`fot`k`j kxv k`eltai`xv. Kx biv `lx hl`o vl. Iv itovumx- hiaijov le alto xbi` (9>>->>>->>> bio doo` izithoh ijik`vxxbo _`kxoh Vxixov k` xzl fivov i`h xbo toaik`k`j vkr ito vfbohumohxl do xtkoh doelto xbo o`h le xbkv vuaaot. Iv xbo ixxifbohitxkfmov k`hkfixo- xbo jlot`ao`x*v i~~tlifb xl xbo toaik`k`jztl`jeum hoixb fivov biv tofo`xm{ ~tllcoh to`ozoh ~udmkf ftkxkfkvale xbo Ho~itxao`x le Guvxkfo. Voo Cok` Fummo`- Eiakm{ @oohv i`Ihlfixo- Dlvxl` Jmldo- Ait. 46- 4>>;- ix Dm "$SXQbo Ho~itxao`x leGuvxkfo xtkoh xl dmiao xbo kfxka. I ~ikt le miz{otv zkxb `kfovukxv i`h `l vftu~mov emoz u~ etla Zivbk`jxl` i`h xtkoh xl vumm{Akfbiom Hl`ibuo k` xbo jtio.$+ k Cok` Fummo`- Zboto kv xboGuvxkfo>;- ix Dm "`lxk`j KKSxQbok`hkfxixko- u`fl`vfkl`idmo i~~tlifb xbo jlot`ao`x kv xick`j zkxbxbo Hl`ibuovmm+k ^oxot Jomwk`kv- Botlkf Tumk`j Vxi`hv- Dux Gut{*vVxkmm Lux L` Eohv- Dlvxl` Botimh- I~t. 9?- 4>>;- ix 9> "GuhjoMk`hvi{ bik`j hkoh iexot ek`hk`j xbo jlot`ao`x mkidmo dux doeltoizithk`j hiaijov- $xbo jlot`ao`x miz{otv zi`xoh xl vxitxoot{xbk`j etla vftixfb.$ Xlaa{ Hl`ibuo KK~to~itoh bkavome xl dodoxti{oh d{ xbo jlot`ao`x bo mlov. KK+.

Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Jl`wimov xlmh ao xbix bo zlumh mllc k`xlxbovo aixxotv zbo` K ektvx tikvoh xboa zkxb bka k` Gu`o- 4>>5. Khkh `lx boit eutxbot etla bka. K fl`fmuhoh a{ Gi`uit{- 4>>2 moxxotxl Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Aucivo{ d{ vxixk`j xbix7

K or~ofx xbix {lu bio toxut`oh xl xbo Ho~itxao`xdofiuvo- mkco vl ai`{ eltaot eohotim ~tlvofuxltv- {lutoxik` i tooto`fo elt kxv akvvkl`. Xbotoelto- K eomxxbix K vblumh dtk`j xbovo aixxotv xl {lut ~otvl`imixxo`xkl` k` xbo bl~o xbix- zkxb {lut moihotvbk~- xbotofo`x ~ivx zkmm `lx do ~tlmljuo- i`h xbo Ho~itxao`x zkmmvll` ijik` hkvfbitjo kxv huxkov k` i ai``ot xbix flaai`hvxbo xtuvx le eohotim guhjov i`h xbo ~ol~mo le xbo _`kxohVxixov.

Blzoot- K hkh `lx tofoko i tov~l`vo etla Ixxlt`o{ Jo`otim Aucivo{okxbot. @ootxbomovv- o`flutijoh d{ xbo k`xo`xkl`v i`h iv~ktixkl`v{lu or~tovvoh xl xbo Fbkoe Guhjov- i`h d{ {lut ifxkl`v iv Ixxlt`o{Jo`otim- K ia vo`hk`j xbkv aovvijo xl {lu zkxb to`ozoh bl~o.

Zkxb dovx zkvbov-

6

8/2/2019 Letter by U.S. District Judge Mark Wolf to Attorney Gen. Eric Holder re prosecutions April 29, 2009

5/6

G9>A .*K p.7`7

8/2/2019 Letter by U.S. District Judge Mark Wolf to Attorney Gen. Eric Holder re prosecutions April 29, 2009

6/6

^udmkvbot K`eltaixkl`@lxo' Xbkv ~ijo kv `lx ~itx le xbo l~k`kl` iv o`xotoh d{ xbo flutx.

Xbo hlfcox k`eltaixkl` ~tlkhoh l` xbkv ~ijo kv elt xbo do`oekxle ~udmkvbotv le xbovo l~k kl v.

^mik`xk ee ^ivyuimo J. Ditl`o to~tovo`xoh d{ ^ivyuimo J. Ditl o99::55!>62_.V. . Moio`zltxbMoio`zltxb- XR 55>82!9>>>^TLVOImdi Hlxl DiffitkMOIH IXXLT@O[IXXLT@O[ XL DO @LXKFOHDot`ith JtlvvdotjDot`ith Jtlvvdotj- Ovy.26 Ixmi`xkf Io uoDlvxl`- AI >499>59::6:!2??2Eir7 59:!:6:!2446Oaikm7 djtlvvdotjNjtlvvdotjmiz.flaMOIH IXKLT@O[IXKLT@O[ XL DO @LXKFOHHodti I. HomUoffbklHomUoffbkl % Bluvoai`Xbo ^ott{ Dukmhk`j9? Etl x VxtooxVimoa- AI >9;:>;:2!:8>!?;;;Eir7 ;:2!:8>!;868Ot`ikm3 hihomoffbklNotkwl`.`oxMOIH IXKLT@O[IXKLT@O[ XL DO @LXKFOHTkfbith A. OjdotxMiz Leekfo le Tkfbith A. Ojdotx;; Vuaaot VxtooxVukxo 92>>Dlvxl`- AI >499>59:!:6:!2444Eir7 59:!:6:!2446MOIH IXXLT@O[IXXLT@O[ XL DO @LXKFOHU .Hoeo`hi`x _VI to~tovo`xoh d{ Giaov E. Mi`j_ kxoh Vxixov Ixxlt`o{*v LeekfoVukxo ;4>>9 Flutxbluvo Zi{Dlvxl`- AI >449>59:!:82!69:?Eir7 59:!:82!6;?8

?