Specialty Minerals and Metals
Canaccord Genuity is the global capital markets group of Canaccord Genuity Group Inc. (CF : TSX | CF. : LSE)The recommendations and opinions expressed in this research report accurately reflect the research analyst's personal, independent and objective views about any and allthe companies and securities that are the subject of this report discussed herein.
Australian Equity Research16 December 2015
Company Rating Price TargetSpecialty Minerals and MetalsGMM-ASX Spec Buy A$0.20 A$0.40GXY-ASX Spec Buy A$0.09 A$0.16Share price data as of Dec 16, 2015
Reg Spencer | Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Ltd. | [email protected] | +61.2.9263.2701Tim McCormack | Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Ltd. | [email protected] | +61.407.195.774Larry Hill (Associate Analyst) | Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Ltd. | [email protected] | +61.2.9263.2789
Initiation of Coverage
Lithium sector set to chargeLithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries represent the largest and highest-growth segment of thelithium market. They are currently considered the preeminent battery technology in high-growth industries, such as portable electronic devices, hybrid/electric vehicles, andstorage batteries. We expect strong lithium demand growth in the coming years based onthe positive outlook in these industries.Demand growth is compounded by tight supply side conditions. Production issues fromexisting brine producers (poor capacity utilisation, expansion issues, new entrants still inramp-up phase, and the changing dynamics of the lithium mineral (spodumene) marketsupport the potential for significant lithium price increases in the near-medium term, inour view.
Initiating coverage: Galaxy Resources Ltd (GXY:ASX)• GXY is a globally diverse lithium development company. Primary assets include the
Mt Cattlin spodumene project in WA (subject to 50% earn in by GMM), the Sal de Vidalithium brine project in Argentina (100%) and the James Bay spodumene explorationproject (subject to 50% earn in by GMM) in Canada.
• GXY recently re-structured its business, having recently sold its underperforminglithium carbonate (Li2CO3) plant, reduced/re-structured its corporate debt, andestablished a JV with GMM to re-start production at Mt Cattlin in early 2016. Inaddition, GXY's Sal de Vida brine project offers optionality and potential strategic valuein our view, with options to reduce capex and fund a potential staged development nowbeing assessed.
• We value GXY on a NAV basis comprising 50% of our base case NPV10% for Mt Cattlin,our blended DCF/market based value for Sal de Vida, and exploration, net of corporateand other adjustments. We initiate coverage with a SPECULATIVE BUY rating and A$0.16/sh target price.
Initiating coverage: General Mining Corporation (GMM:ASX)Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited was the Lead Manager to the Placement of~40.3 million shares at $0.18 per share to raise ~A$7.3 million in December 2015.• GMM's primary asset is a right to earn 50% of the +15 year, ~110ktpa Mt Cattlin
spodumene project through sole funding a re-start of production (expected early 2016)and cash payments to GXY. GMM is also earning a 50% interest in the James Bayexploration project.
• Previous production issues at Mt Cattlin are being addressed through upgrades of theprocess plant, while project economics benefit from existing infrastructure, low initialstart-up capex (<A$10m), a lower A$ and improved spodumene product pricing.
• We value GMM on a NAV basis, consisting of 50% of our base case NPV10% for MtCattlin, exploration (James Bay), net of corporate and other adjustments. We initiatecoverage with a SPECULATIVE BUY rating and A$0.40/sh target price.
For important information, please see the Important Disclosures beginning on page 44 of this document.
2
Contents
Investment Summary: Galaxy Resources Ltd (GXY:ASX) 3
Initiating coverage with a SPECUALTIVE BUY rating & A$0.16 target price 3
Investment Summary: General Mining Corporation Ltd (GMM:ASX) 5
Initiating coverage with a SPECUALTIVE BUY rating & A$0.40 target price 5
Product Market Overview 7
LITHIUM 7
TANTALUM 10
Peer Comparison 12
Company overview: Galaxy Resources Ltd 14
KEY COMPANY MILESTONES 14
VALUATION 16
CORPORATE & FINANCE 17
Company overview: General Mining Corporation Ltd 19
KEY DEVELOPMENTS 19
VALUATION 20
CORPORATE & FINANCE 21
Asset Overview 22
MT CATTLIN SPODUMENE/TANTALUM PROJECT (GXY 100%, GMM EARNING 50%) 22
SAL DE VIDA LITHIUM BRINE PROJECT (GXY 100%) 31
JAMES BAY LITHIUM PROJECT (GXY 100%; GMM EARNING 50%) 39
Appendix I – Investment risks 43
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 2
3
Investment summary: Galaxy Resources Ltd (GXY:ASX)
Initiating coverage with a SPECULATIVE BUY rating & A$0.16 target price
Globally diverse lithium-development company: GXY is an Australian-based lithium
development company. Its primary assets are the near-term production, Mt Cattlin
spodumene/tantalum project in Western Australia (100% subject to 50% earn in by
GMM), the Sal de Vida lithium brine development project in Argentina (100%) and the
James Bay spodumene exploration project (100% subject to 50% earn in by GMM) in
Canada.
Figure 1: Asset summary & location map
Source: Company reports
Business re-structure to focus on up-stream lithium production: Over the course of the
last 24 months, GXY has undergone a significant transformation of its business to
now focus on the development of its primary lithium production assets. This has
included the sale of its previously troublesome Jiangsu lithium carbonate plant in
China, completion of a corporate debt reduction and restructure program, and the
establishment of a joint venture with General Mining Corporation to fund the re-start
of the Mt Cattlin spodumene operation in Western Australia in 1H’CY16.
Well positioned to capitalise on a favourable outlook for lithium: We consider the
company is now well positioned as a diversified, lithium asset development company
at a time when lithium prices are starting to rise on the back favourable supply and
demand dynamics. In our view, GXY provides diverse exposure to expectations of
increasing lithium demand for use in lithium-ion batteries in the portable electronic
device, hybrid and electric vehicle (EV) and storage battery industries.
Valuation: We value GXY on a net asset valuation basis, comprising a 50% interest in
our base case Mt Cattlin NPV10%, an average of our DCF and market based valuations
for Sal de Vida, 50% of our nominal valuation for James Bay, net of corporate and
other adjustments. While our initial target price of A$0.16/share offers ~75% upside
from current levels, we highlight the potential for further upside to our valuation due
to the potential for increased lithium/spodumene prices, production expansions at Mt
Cattlin, and any firm development pathway and funding solution for Sal de Vida.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 3
4
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 4
5
Investment summary: General Mining Corporation Ltd (GMM:ASX)
Initiating coverage with a SPECULATIVE BUY rating & A$0.40 target price
Low capex, near-term lithium (spodumene) production: GMM is a lithium exploration
and development company focused on the development and re-start of production at
the Mt Cattlin spodumene/tantalum operation in Western Australia. GMM has the
right to earn a 50% interest in Mt Cattlin through A$18m in cash payments to GXY,
and by sole funding a restart of operations with initial start-up capex of <A$10m.
Mt Cattlin re-start expected in MarQ’16: Mt Cattlin was previously placed on care and
maintenance in 2013 due to low lithium prices, a high AUD, poor product quality and
an uneconomic operating cost base. GMM’s planned re-start of Mt Cattlin is expected
to see annual spodumene concentrate production of ~110ktpa over an initial +15-
year mine life, with previous product quality issues planned to be addressed through
upgrades of the current process flow sheet. The project benefits from significant
existing infrastructure (+A$100m in sunk capital), and we see the low capex and short
lead time to re-start operations as a distinct advantage over many other hard rock
lithium development companies.
Improved pricing and costs lead to improved economics: We anticipate project
economics should now benefit from higher spodumene prices (based on a favourable
outlook in both the refined lithium and spodumene markets) and an A$ which is now
~20% lower than when the asset was last in operation. We estimate average costs of
US$340/t of spodumene concentrate product, and based on expectations of further
increases in spodumene prices, we see the potential for solid operating margins once
at targeted production rates.
Valuation: We value GMM on a net asset valuation basis, comprising a 50% interest in
our base case Mt Cattlin NPV10%, 50% of our nominal valuation for James Bay, net of
corporate and other adjustments. We set an initial target price of A$0.40/share
(representing a P/NAV of 0.50x), but note that there is potential for upside in our
valuation through higher spodumene prices, and a potential expansion of production
at Mt Cattlin.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 5
6
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
FINANCIAL SUMMARY General Mining Corporation Ltd ASX:GMM
Analyst: Reg Spencer Rating:
Date: 16/12/2015 Target Price: $0.40Year End: June
Market Information Company Description
Share Price A$ 0.20
Market Capitalisation A$m 60.6
12 Month Hi A$ 0.22
12 Month Lo A$ 0.00
Issued Capital m 310.73
ITM Options m 0.00
Fully Diluted m 310.73 Profit & Loss (A$m) 2015a 2016e 2017e 2018e
Revenue 0.00 18.94 42.34 44.28
Valuation A$m A$/share Operating Costs -0.4 -2.2 -14.8 -17.1
Mt Cattlin NPV10% 126.9 0.38 Corporate & O'heads -0.2 -1.7 -1.6 -1.7
Exploration & Other (James Bay) Estimate 15.0 0.04 Exploration (Expensed) -0.0 -0.6 -0.4 -0.4
Corporate (14.3) (0.04) EBITDA -0.6 14.4 25.5 25.1
Cash 9.7 0.03 Dep'n 0.0 -0.9 -4.5 -4.5
Debt - - EBIT -0.5 13.5 21.0 20.6
Unpaid capital 2.4 0.01 Net Interest 0.0 0.2 0.2 0.5
TOTAL 139.7 0.42 Tax 0.0 -0.2 -4.5 -6.0
Target Price 0.40 NPAT -0.5 13.5 16.6 15.0
P/NAV 0.49x Abnormals 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
NPAT (reported) -0.5 13.5 16.6 15.0
Assumptions 2016e 2017e 2018e
Lithium Carbonate (US$/t) 6,100 6,250 6,400 Cash Flow (A$m) 2015a 2016e 2017e 2018e
Spodumene Concentrate (US$/t) 431 463 474 Cash Receipts 0.0 3.5 36.4 43.5
Tantalum (US$/lb) 75 75 75 Cash paid to suppliers & employees -0.4 -3.5 -16.4 -18.8
AUD:USD 0.71 0.70 0.70 Tax Paid 0.0 -0.2 -4.5 -6.0
Net Interest 0.0 0.1 0.1 0.3
Valuation Sensitivity Operating Cash Flow -0.3 -0.0 15.5 19.0
Exploration and Evaluation -0.2 -1.7 -1.3 -1.2
Capex 0.0 -7.3 -5.3 -1.2
Other -0.1 -1.5 -6.0 -6.0
Investing Cash Flow -0.3 -10.5 -12.6 -8.4
Debt Drawdown (repayment) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Share capital 0.9 15.1 0.0 0.0
Dividends 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Financing Expenses -0.1 -0.4 0.0 0.0
Financing Cash Flow 0.8 14.7 0.0 0.0
Opening Cash 0.1 0.3 4.4 7.4
Increase / (Decrease) in cash 0.2 4.1 3.0 10.6
FX Impact 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Closing Cash 0.3 4.4 7.4 18.1
Balance Sheet (A$m) 2015a 2016e 2017e 2018e
Cash + S/Term Deposits 0.3 4.4 7.4 18.1
Other current assets 0.1 4.0 8.9 9.4
Current Assets 0.4 8.4 16.4 27.5
Property, Plant & Equip. 0.0 7.5 8.2 4.9
Production Metrics 2016e 2017e 2018e Mining, Expl'n & Develop. 0.7 26.8 27.7 28.6
Mt Cattlin (50%) Other Non-current Assets 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Spodumene concentrate (kt) 9.4 92.1 104.4 Payables 0.9 5.7 12.8 13.4
LCE production (kt) 0.0 3.7 7.7 Short Term debt 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Tantalum concentrate (Mlb) 0.3 3.4 4.1 Long Term Debt 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
AISC (A$/tonne) 706 437 419 Other Liabilities 0.0 23.6 15.5 9.4
Net Assets 0.2 13.3 23.9 38.0
Shareholders Funds 13.0 28.0 28.0 28.0
Reserves & Resources Mt Grade (Li2O) Mt LCE Ta2O5 Reserves 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
Mt Cattlin (50%) Retained Earnings -13.2 -15.1 -4.5 9.6
Resources 16.4 1.08% 0.178 5.682 Total Equity 0.2 13.3 23.9 38.0
Reserves 10.0 1.04% 0.104 3.276
Ratios & Multiples 2015a 2016e 2017e 2018e
James Bay (50%) EBITDA Margin nm 76% 60% 57%
Resources 22.2 1.25% 0.278 EV/EBITDA nm 3.7x 1.6x 1.0x
Op. Cashflow/Share $0.00 $0.00 $0.05 $0.06
P/CF -191.1x -6911.6x 4.2x 3.4x
Directors & Management EPS $0.01 $0.04 $0.04 $0.05
Name Position EPS Growth -307% 290% 10% 8%
Michael Fotios Executive Chairman PER 19.2x 4.9x 4.5x 4.1x
Alan Still Non-exec Director Dividend Per Share $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Michael Kitney Non-exec Director Dividend Yield 0% 0% 0% 0%
ROE -218% 101% 69% 39%
ROIC -4% 47% 59% 52%
Substantial Shareholders Shares (m) % Debt/Equity 0% 0% 0% 0%
Investmet 45.00 14.5% Net Interest Cover nm nm nm nm
Book Value/share $0.00 $0.04 $0.07 $0.11
Price/Book Value 341.4x 4.9x 2.7x 1.7x
SPEC BUY
General Mining (ASX:GMM) is operator of the Mt Cattlin spodumene operation in a 50%:50% JV Galaxy
Resources Limited (ASX:GXY). Initial production from the facility will be for ~100ktpa of spodumene
concentrate grading ~6% Li2O with additoinal tantalum credits. GMM also have 50% earn in on the James
Bay hard rock lithium project in Canada.
$0.10
$0.20
$0.30
$0.40
$0.50
$0.60
-30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20% 30%
Change i
n T
arg
et
Price
Spodumene Price (US$/t) Exchange Rate (A$:US$)
Tantalum Price (US$/lb) Discount Rate (@10%)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 6
7
Product market overview
LITHIUM
Lithium is a soft, silver-white metal which under normal conditions is the lightest
of all metals and the least dense solid element. It has a wide range of industrial
applications including ceramics, lubricants and glass, but the largest (and highest-
growth segment) of the global lithium market is its use in the manufacture of
lithium-ion batteries (29% 2014 estimates, Figure 2). Based on expectations for
ongoing high growth rates in the use of lithium-ion batteries in the portable
electronic device, hybrid /electric vehicle and storage battery industries, we
expect the demand for lithium to continue to grow markedly over the coming
years.
Figure 2: Lithium applications
Source: Roskill, 2014
Lithium is produced from two main mineral sources:
Brines: lithium brine deposits are formed through the leaching of volcanic
rocks and basin depositional environments. Lithium is produced from brines
(most often in the form of lithium carbonate (Li2CO3)) via a process involving
the pumping of brine from the sediment basin, concentration via evaporation,
and purification through solvent extraction, filtration and ionic exchange.
Lithium is unusually more soluble at lower temperatures than similar alkali
metals such as sodium and potassium and it is this property that provides the
design basis for most of the processing steps.
Hard rock spodumene deposits: Spodumene is a lithium-bearing aluminium
silicate mineral that mostly occurs in lithium-rich pegmatites (granite-like
igneous rock composed of quartz, feldspar and mica). Spodumene is usually
recovered through conventional open pit mining methods and beneficiated via
conventional gravity techniques where the ore is typically concentrated from
1-2% Li2O to a grade of ~6% Li2O. This concentrate product is then converted
to battery grade lithium carbonate (>99.5% purity) through intensive thermal
and hydrometallurgical processing (roasting, leaching, ion exchange)
conducted at plants mostly located within China.
Supply
It is estimated that global production in 2014 totaled 190kt lithium carbonate
equivalent, or LCE (Figure 3), with global production dominated by several large
producers. Significant consolidation has taken place in the sector in the last
several years, with notable transactions including the acquisition of Tailson
Lithium (operator of Greenbushes) by Sichuan Tianqi (002466-SHE|Not rated) for
29%
14%
12%
9%
8%
6%
5%
5%
2%9%
Rechargeable batteries
Ceramics
Glass ceramics
Greases
Metallurgical powers
Polymers
Air purification
Primary battery
Aluminium
Other
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 7
8
C$848m in Mar’13. Subsequently in May’14 Rockwood obtained a 49%
ownership of Greenbushes for US$475m. Finally in Jan’15 Rockwood was
acquired by Albemarle (ALB-USA | Not rated) as part of a US$6.2B company
takeover.
Figure 3: 2013 Lithium production by company Figure 4: 2014 global LCE production by operation (ex China)
Source: Roskill, 2013
*Acquired by Rockwood in 2014,
** Acquired by Albemarle in Jan’15; 51% of Talison’s Greenbushes mine subsequently sold to Sichuan
Tianqi
Source: Company reports, Roskill, signumBox, USGS, Canaccord Genuity estimates
*49% owned by Albemarle, 51% Sichuan Tinaqi
2014 global production was split approximately 50% (Figure 4) from hard rock
sources (primarily Greenbushes and Kings Mountain in the USA), with the balance
from brine production in Chile and Argentina (Salar de Atacama and Salar de
Hombre Muerto).
Global production capacity is estimated at ~270kt of LCE (Source: signumBOX
2014), which indicates that the industry is operating at only ~60% of capacity. In
terms of new supply, outside of China, only Orocobre (ORE : ASX : A$1.76 | BUY) is
likely to provide new brine-based supply into the market over the next 12 months.
We note that SQM (largest producer at ~48ktpa LCE) in Chile is currently having
environmental and government issues (these are not likely to be resolved anytime
soon and has the operation running at only 50% of capacity). Meanwhile, FMC in
Argentina (capacity of 23ktpa carbonate and hydroxide) is running at ~60%
capacity (14Ktpa), being constrained by technical issues related to un-lined
evaporation ponds and stressed relations with the local government which saw
water supply cut off during 2015. Lastly Albemarle’s La Negra lithium hydroxide
(LiOH) conversion plant in Chile (~15ktpa LCE) remains on standby due to the
hold up in approvals to increase brine pumping from 80,000m3/year to
170,000m3/year at the Salar De Atacama.
Spodumene market
The supply of spodumene is dominated by Albemarle and Tianqi’s Greenbushes
(formally Talison Lithium) operation located in Western Australia. This facility is
estimated to produce ~650ktpa of spodumene concentrate which supplies
~100ktpa (or 92%) of ex. China hard rock derived LCE. The only other meaningful
producers are Albemarle’s Kings Mountain spodumene operation (~8ktpa of LCE)
and the Jiajika project (unknown production) in China.
Spodumene concentrate pricing is more or less benchmarked against prevailing
market prices for the Greenbushes product, given its dominant position in the
market. We note recent tightness in the spodumene market which has resulted
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 8
9
from Li2CO3 demand pressure which has arisen due to the supply issues from the
incumbent brine producers. Furthermore, we understand that Albemarle are
assessing the construction of a ~50ktpa Li2CO3 and LiOH conversion plant, fed
from its share of Greenbushes spodumene production, to be online by 2020
(Source Albemarle Corporate Presentation).
Given an expectation that supply issues from brine producers are not likely to be
resolved in the near term (poor capacity utilisation from existing producers, new
entrants still in ramp up phase), and that a large proportion of Greenbushes
spodumene production could be re-directed from the market to its own conversion
facility, we anticipate that current tight spodumene market conditions could
persist for the near future.
Demand
As illustrated in Figure 2, the rechargeable battery (lithium and lithium-ion) is
currently the greatest source of demand for lithium with ~29% of the total market
in 2014. Figure 5 below shows that Li2CO3 represented ~45% of the market in
2014, with the other dominant form being LiOH. It should be noted that while
LiOH can attract up to a ~40% price premium over L2CO3 (due to its superior
lattice structure), L2CO3 is currently the dominant lithium source for battery
applications.
Figure 5: Lithium demand by compound Figure 6: Projected LCE demand
Source: signumBox 2014 estimates Source: Albemarle company presentation
While demand for lithium in industrial applications could be expected to show
modest growth (in line with global industrial activity, or GDP growth), we anticipate
that growth in demand for battery applications will continue to increase in the
coming years (Figure 6). This growth is expected to be driven by increasing
demand for:
Portable electronic devices
Hybrid and electric vehicles
Renewable energy storage batteries
Companies such as Tesla, Foxconn, BYD and LG Chem have all announced the
development of large Li-ion battery manufacturing facilities to meet the expected
rise in demand for Li-ion batteries from the above industries. In our view, this is
likely to support a significant increase in the demand for lithium in the coming
years.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 9
10
Outlook
Figure 7 below shows lithium carbonate (China, min 99% LCE benchmark) pricing
over the last 6 months. We highlight a significant increase in prices for L2CO3 in
recent weeks, with reports of “spot” pricing for Li2CO3 of +US$10,000/tonne. In
our view, this pricing reflects realisation of downstream lithium consumers of the
current tightness in the market. It should be noted however that L2CO3, like most
industrial minerals, is priced through negotiations with customers with various
influences such as contract terms, review frequency, quantity and product
specification on the price received.
As we noted above, existing producers are currently experiencing a wide range of
issues preventing them from expanding production (technical issues, permitting)
and utilising latent capacity, while new market entrants remain in ramp up phase.
Furthermore, the tightness in the spodumene market is interpreted to reflect the
production issues facing a lot of brine producers, with downstream demand now
putting pressure on carbonate conversion plants.
Figure 7: Lithium carbonate (+99% Li minimum LCE content)
Source: Asian Metal, Canaccord Genuity estimates
Based on expectations for continued supply side tightness (at least in the near
term), and the prospects of significant demand growth, we anticipate lithium
prices to remain at elevated levels versus recent longer run averages.
TANTALUM
Tantalum is a rare, highly corrosion-resistant metal that is an excellent conductor
of heat and electricity. Its melting point is only exceeded by tungsten and rhenium
and it is one of the five major refractory metals. It is primarily found in the mineral
tantalite, which is mostly found in pegmatite ore bodies.
The use of tantalum can be broadly broken down into four product types:
Tantalum powder used in electronics
Tantalum metal has applications in chemical processing, medical devices and
alloys
High-grade tantalum oxide is also used in camera lenses and X-ray equipment
Tantalum carbide used in cutting tools
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
10000
11000
12000
13000
14000
07/15 08/15 09/15 10/15 11/15 12/15
99%
min
LC
E (
US
$/t
)
Daily Price 30 Day Moving Average 90 Day Moving Average
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 10
11
Supply
According to the USGS, global tantalum production totaled ~1,200 tonnes in
2014, with a majority of global production (+79%) coming from Rwanda and the
DRC. Metal production from these countries is widely known to be associated with
illegal mining and conflict minerals.
A majority of production is from hard rock mines and the metal is often traded in
opaque long-term transactions between producers and end-users. Quoted prices
typically refer to spot Ta2O5 (tantalum pentoxide), which over the past decade has
been the subject of erratic highs and lows. The reality is that the spot market is
very thinly traded and term contracts have remained more stable, albeit trending
down over the past couple of years.
Figure 8: World share of global tantalum production (2014) Figure 9: Tantalum pentoxide prices over the past 5 years vs CG forward
assumptions
Source: US Geological Survey Source: SNL Mining, Canaccord Genuity estimates
Demand
Tantalum’s principal use is in high end capacitors (~60% of consumption), which
are found in all electronic devices, however we note that lower-cost ceramic and
aluminum capacitors currently dominate the market. The most up-to-date,
publically available information suggests that tantalum-based capacitors accounts
for ~10% of the total market by value.
Given tantalum’s association with “conflict minerals”, the SEC (US Securities and
Exchange Commission) instituted new rules in 2012 that required US companies
to disclose when they use minerals from conflict zones. This has led number of
Western end users to seek supply from legitimate, Western sources. However,
despite mine production declining (three legitimate mines have been closed in the
last ~6 years including the Wodgina mine in WA), prices for tantalite have actually
decreased markedly since 2010 (Figure 9). This suggests that increased demand
from non-Western end users is being satisfied from undocumented and/or illegal
sources.
Outlook
In our view, the outlook in demand for the metal is subdued and as such we have
taken a conservative view on our forward prices, assuming a flat US$75/lb Ta2O5
versus current market prices of ~US$90/lb (Figure 9).
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
Tan
talu
m (
US
$/l
b)
CGAu estimates
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 11
2
Peer comparison Figure 10: Analysis of current & planned lithium projects
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates, SNL Mining
2.153 5.323 Resource Li Grade
Company Listed Project Location Equity Status Lithium (Mt) ppm (brine) Notes
BRINE PRODUCERS % (h/rock)
Albermarle NYSE:ABLDiversified
Salar de Atacama Chile 100% Production 1.09 700 30ktpa (doing 25ktpa Li2CO3); Process plant in Antofagasta; Issue: Same as SQM. Have out in 5 applications to
expand. The La Negra plant in Chile (20kt) held up
Silver Peak USA 100% Production 0.03 400 As of February 2012, Rockwood was completing a $75 million expansion of its lithium production in the United
States which included an expansion of its brine pond system at Silver Peak, and construction of a battery grade
lithium hydroxide plant at Kings Mountain
SQM NYSE:SQM Diversified Salar de Atacama Chile 100% Production 5.30 700 Capacity: 48ktpa; Issue: licensing arrangement with Chilean govt for brine pumping to 2030; Govt wont issue
permits to pump more brine - permeability issues - salar surrounded by fresh water (could deplete acquifers).
Also a pink flamingo habitat
FMC Corp. NYSE: FMC Diversified Salar de Hombre Meurto Argentina 100% Production 0.85 850 18ktpa Li2CO3, 23ktpa LCE, running at 14ktpa; Issue: Recently expanded but having major technical issues
(new ponds werent lined); no further expansion plans; Poor govt relations; Have been buying LCE to fulfill sales
contracts
Orocobre ASX:ORE Pure play Olaroz Argentina 67% Production 1.20 690 First production from Olaroz in April 2015. Commissioning and plant ramp up delayed. Namplate production of
17.5kt of LCE expected during H2'16.
BRINE DEVELOPERS
Western Lithium WLC:TSX Pure play Cauchari-Olaroz Argentina 90% Feasibility 2.72 630 Using propritary POSCO extraction tech for carbonate and hydroxide production. POSCO finance capex to initial
2500 t rate in late 2016. Ramp up to 20kt expected in 2017.
Sentient Group (Private) n/a Pure play Salar de Rincon Argentina 100% DFS 1.57 400 Admiralty sold to Sentient for $22m in 2008. 2010 - Rincon was producing 1000t/month LCE from a pilot plant.
Sentient have indicated they have a propriertory process to recover LCE direct from brine.
Galaxy ASX:GXY Pure play Sal de Vida Argentina 70% Feasibility 1.57 750 DFS completed in 2013; assessing development & funding options.
International Lithium TSX: ILC Diversified Mariana Argentina 20% Feasibility 1.00 500 Ganfeng hold a 80% stake with TNR Gold Corp a 26%
Rodinia Lithium TSX:RM Pure play Diabilillos Argentina >90% Feasibility 0.53 560
Pure Energy Minerals TSX:PE Pure play Clayton Valley USA 100% Pilot plant 0.15 370 Announced in Feb 2015 test work underway on the application of Tenova Bateman's LiSX and POSCO's RIST
technology. Cornerstone supply agreement with Tesla (initially 5 years).
HARD ROCK PRODUCERS
Albemarle NYSE Diversified King's Mountain USA 100% Production 0.30 0.70% US$30m epxpansion completed in 2012 to produce ~ 5kt of LiOH product
Greenbushes WA 49% Production 0.84 2.10% 30ktpa LCE feeds into converter plants in China; under-utilised capacity. 50kpta LCE conversion plant proposed
HARD ROCK DEVELOPERS
Bacanora Minerals TSX:BCN Pure play Sonora Mexico 70% Feasibility 0.22 0.23% Rare Earth Minerals Plc s(30% owners) aid a new mineral resource estimate for the Sonora lithium project in
Mexico, a joint venture majority owned by Bacanora Minerals Ltd., saw the project's indicated and inferred
mineral resource increase to 8.8 million tonnes of lithium carbonate equivalent.
Galaxy Resources/ ASX:GXY/ Pure play James Bay Canada 100% Exploration 0.13 0.59% Acquired from Lithium One in 2012. In September 2015 GCXY announced a DFS would begin during 2016
General Mining ASX:GMM Mt Catlin Australia 50% Commisioning 0.08 0.50% Originally placed on care and maintenance Jul'13. Restart of operations (+100ktpa spod conc) planned for 1H'16,
A$7-15m capex
Rio Tinto ASX: RIO Diversified Jadar Serbia 100% Exploration 0.96 0.84% Still in early stage development after initial discovery in 200. Will take 6 years to develop according to RIO
European Metals ASX: EMH Pure play Cinovec Czech Republic 100% Scoping 0.17 0.21% Scoping released in 2015, 2mpta, lithium recovery at 70%, 19.4ktpa, opex of US$27/t mined + US$39/t treated.
Pre-production capex of US$326m
Western Lithium WLC:TSX Pure play Kings Valley USA 98% Feasibility 0.12 0.19% In June 2015, Western Lithium announced that it was continuing its optimization studies with Tenova Bateman
Technologies in order to complete an OoM study using solvent extraction technology. Pilot plant test work in
Germany was ongoing
Nemaska Lithium TSX: NMX Pure play Whabouchi Canada Feasibility 0.24 0.72% A feasiblity study indicated a production rate of 5.5Mt of spodumene concentrate per year over 26 years at a
capex of $448m. Environmental permitting is complete enabling construction to commence subject to financing.
RB Energy Receivership Pure play Quebec Canada 100% Care and
Maintenance
0.26 0.56% In receivership. Plant was designed on a capex of US$200m for 15 year mine life for 20kpta LCE at opex of
US$2,600/t. First production shipped to offtake partner Tewoo from July 2014. Funding uncertainty and kiln
issues placed project on C&M in July 2014.
Sichuan Tianqi Group 002466:SHE Pure play Jiajika China 100% Feasibility 0.48 0.59% As of July 2004, Sterling Group reported that the Jiajika lithium deposit could be mined using open pit method.
Using gravity and magnetic processing methods, lithium concentrates could be produced at an estimated 84%
Li2O recovery. Jiajika's initial capacity was estimated at 240,000 mt/y increasing to 900,000 mt/y.
Pilbara Minerals ASX: PLS Diversified Pilgangoora WA 100% Scoping 0.32 0.60% Worlds second largest hard rock depoist at 52Mt at 1.25% Li2. Capex estiamtes of A$100m for 200ktpa of 6%
Li2O spodumene concentrate over 20+ years.
Critical Elements TSX: CRE Rose Canada 100% PEA 0.16 0.44% Offtake signed in June 2015. PEA called for 27ktpa of LCE at capex of C$270 over 17 year mine life
Neometals ASX:NMM Diversified Mt Marion WA 45% Construction 0.32 0.65% 30ktpa LCE develpoment approved in 2010 but shelved due to funding. 2015: NMM and Mineral Resources jointly
owned subsidiary entered into a conditional MoU Jiangxi Ganfeng Lithium Co. Ltd for a 100% offtake and equity
investment of 25%. The offtake deal allowed for a final investment decision, construction started Nov'15 and
production is planned for mid-16.
Altura Mining ASX: AJM Pilgangoora WA 100% Scoping 0.14 0.57% Exploration stage
Lithium Australia ASX:LIT Pure play Lepidolite Hill WA 80% Exploration 0.10 0.60% Exploration stage
Glen Eagle Resources TSX: GER Authier Canada 100% Feasibility 0.04 0.45% Drilling since 2010, PEA highlighted a 103kpta 6% Li2O for 15kpta LCE
Liontown Resources ASX: LTR Diversified Mohanga Tanzania 100% Exploration Very early stage drilling of similar geology to Greenbushes in quartz-schist
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 12
2
Figure 11 below ranks global hard rock lithium development projects according to
resource size and contained lithium grade. Resources at these projects are at
different levels of definition with both Jadar and Jiajika having only reported to the
Inferred level. It should be noted that for most hard rock projects the economic
cut-off grade is ~-0.2% Li with Cinovec, King’s Valley and Sonora projects
considering alternative processing to support project development at lower grade.
In Figure 12, we have ranked the same group of companies/assets according to
development stage, ultimate annual production and capital expenditure required
to develop the project. The chart illustrates that Mt Cattlin is one of the few low-
capex, hard rock projects expected to come on line in the next 12 months.
Figure 11: Hard rock lithium development projects – Grade vs contained
lithium Figure 12: Hard rock development projects – Project status vs capex
vs LCE production
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
*Bubble size relates to LCE production. Note Grey bubbles indicate LCE operating projects
Figure 13 and 14 below ranks global lithium brine deposits according to two key
considerations, in lithium grades (ppm Li) and magnesium: lithium (Mg:Li) ratios.
Higher lithium grades support the potential for lower capex developments and
better operating margins while low impurity levels (i.e. Mg:Li ratios) support lower
production costs. GXY’s Sal de Vida development project ranks well in both
metrics, being second to only FMC’s Salar de Hombre Muerto in terms of grade,
while the project has among the lowest Mg:Li ratios in the peer group.
Figure 13: Brine deposits – ranked by lithium grade Figure 14: Brine deposits – ranked by Mg:Li ratio
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
0.00%
0.10%
0.20%
0.30%
0.40%
0.50%
0.60%
0.70%
0.80%
0.90%
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
1.20
Ja
da
r
Wh
abo
uchi
Mt M
ario
n
Pilg
ang
oo
ra -
Pilb
ara
Le
pid
olit
e H
ill
Jia
jika
Ja
me
s B
ay
Pilg
ang
oo
ra -
Altu
ra
Qu
eb
ec
Mt C
atlin
Auth
ier
Ro
se
Cin
ove
c
Kin
gs V
alle
y
Son
ora
Moh
ang
a
Lith
ium
Gra
de
(%
)
Co
nta
ine
d L
ith
ium
(L
i M
t)
Greenbushes
King's Mountain
Mt Marion
Quebec
Mt Cattlin
Kings Valley
Whabouchi
Authier
SonoraCinovecPilgangoora
Rose
Jadar
Lepidolite Hill
Mohanga
-100
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Capital C
ost
(US
$m
)
Exploration Scoping PFS DFS Dvlpt Operation
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
Sa
lar
de
Ho
mb
reM
eu
rto
Sa
l d
e V
ida
Sala
r de
Ata
ca
ma
Ola
roz
Cau
cha
ri-
Ola
roz
Dia
bili
llos
Ma
ria
na
Sala
r de
Rin
co
n
Silv
er
Pe
ak
Cla
yto
n V
alle
y
Lith
ium
Gra
de
(p
pm
)
Co
nta
ine
d L
ith
ium
(M
t)
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
10.0
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
Sa
lar
de R
inco
n
Sa
lar
de
Ata
ca
ma
Dia
bili
llos
Ca
uch
ari-
Ola
roz
Sa
l d
e V
ida
Ola
roz
Ma
ria
na
Sa
lar
de
Ho
mb
re M
eurt
o
Silv
er
Pe
ak
Cla
yto
n V
alle
y
Ma
gn
esiu
m to
Lith
ium
Ra
tio
Co
nta
ine
d L
ith
ium
(M
t)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 13
3
Company overview: Galaxy Resources Ltd
COMPANY BACKGROUND
GXY is an Australian-based lithium development company. Its primary assets are a
100% ownership (subject to 50% earn-in by GMM:ASX) of the Mt Cattlin
lithium/tantalum operation in Western Australia, 100% of the Sal de Vida lithium
brine project in Argentina, and 100% of the James Bay spodumene project in
Canada ((subject to 50% JV earn-in by GMM:ASX; see Asset Overviews)
A company history summary is detailed below in Figure 15.
Figure15: GXY company history summary
Source: Company reports
KEY COMPANY MILESTONES
Merger with Lithium One Inc – Mar’12
GXY completed a merger with TSX-listed Lithium One Inc, in Mar’12. The 1:8 scrip
offer valued Lithium One at C$112m at the time of the announcement and
represented a 27% premium to Lithium One’s previous trading price.
The merger delivered to the combined group the Sal de Vida lithium brine project
in Argentina, and the James Bay spodumene project in Canada.
Sale of Jiangsu lithium carbonate plant – Apr’15
GXY completed construction of the US$100m lithium carbonate facility, located in
Jiangsu province, China, in 2011. The plant at the time was one of the largest
lithium carbonate converter plants in SE Asia, and was developed in order to take
spodumene concentrate from Mt Cattlin to produce a higher-value lithium
carbonate product for sale into Asian markets.
In 2012, the plant suffered a major disruption with an explosion killing two
workers. Production was halted until 2013.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 14
4
Production at Jiangsu re-commenced in 2013; however, spodumene feed was
sourced from Talison’s (now Albemarle/Tianqi) Greenbushes operation due to the
suspension of spodumene production at Mt Cattlin in 2012.
In 2014, GXY negotiated a sale of the plant to Sichuan Tianqi Lithium Industries
(Tianqi is now a 49% owner of Talison Lithium) for a total value of US$230m
(comprising cash of US$122m and assumption of all Chinese debt of US$108m).
The consideration for the sale was revised in Feb’15 to US$173m (cash of
US$72m and assumption of Chinese debt). The sale process was completed in
Q2’15.
General Mining Mt Cattlin agreement – Sep’15
In Feb’15, GXY executed an agreement with General Mining whereby GMM was
granted the right to recommence production and solely operate Mt Cattlin for
three years, with an option to purchase the asset for A$30m and a 3% NSR
royalty. Under the agreement, GXY was set to receive an annual lease fee of
A$2.5m and a 10% production royalty (on tantalum sales). Under the deal, GMM
had the right to all revenues from the sale of tantalum from Mt Cattlin, with
spodumene sales revenue shared equally.
In Jun’15, the terms of the agreement were revised with GMM given the sole and
exclusive right to earn a 50% equity interest in Mt Cattlin for total consideration of
A$25m (comprising sole funding A$7m of capex to re-start production and three
annual instalments of A$6m payable monthly in arrears from the commencement
of production).
The deal also saw GMM granted the right to earn 50% interest in James Bay
through the expenditure of A$5m over three years.
Corporate debt reduction & restructure – Sep’15
In the last two years, GXY has successfully reduced and re-structured its corporate
debt facilities from a peak of +A$210m (comprised US$118m Chinese debt
facility associated with the Jiangsu carbonate plant, A$60m in convertible bonds,
and +A$30m in other debt) to ~A$35m.
This has been achieved through the sale of the Jiangsu plant and associated debt,
the re-purchase (at a discount to face value) of half of the convertible bonds, and
a terming out of the remaining bonds through a three-year facility. Net debt
reduction is illustrated in Figure 16 below.
Figure 16: GXY net debt (2013-2015)
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
-182.7 -182.5
-213.0-197.9 -202.1
-21.5 -20.3
-250.0
-200.0
-150.0
-100.0
-50.0
0.0
MarQ'14 JunQ'14 SepQ'14 DecQ'14 MarQ'15 JunQ'15 SepQ'15
Ne
t d
eb
t (A
$m
)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 15
5
VALUATION
We have valued GXY using a net asset valuation approach, comprising GXY’s 50%
interest in Mt Cattlin base case (see Mt Cattlin project valuation), an average of
our DCF and market based valuation approaches for Sal de Vida (see Sal de Vida
project valuation), 50% of our nominal valuation for James Bay, net of corporate
and balance sheet adjustments.
As discussed in the Mt Cattlin and SdV project valuation sections of this report, we
note the potential for further upside to our valuation which include:
Higher spodumene (Mt Cattlin) and Li2CO3 (SdV) prices
The potential for an expanded production scenario at Mt Cattlin, which under
our modelled expanded case would add a further A$0.045/share to our NAV.
A firm development scenario and funding plan for SdV.
Figure 17: GXY Net asset valuation estimate
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates. P/NAV Based on 9/12/2015 price
Valuation sensitivity
We have run sensitivity analysis on our GXY NAV estimate based on the metrics as
shown in Figure 18 below. Our analysis shows our GXY valuation to be most
sensitive to the NPV discount rate for Sal de Vida, the prevailing AUD/USD FX rate,
and spodumene prices received at Mt Cattlin.
Figure 18: GXY NAV sensitivity
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates
Valuation A$m A$/share
Mt Cattlin NPV10% 132.6 0.10
Sal de Vida Estimate 130.6 0.10
Exploration & Other (James Bay) Estimate 15.0 0.01
Corporate (53.8) (0.04)
Cash 13.0 0.01
Debt (35.5) (0.03)
TOTAL 201.9 0.16
Target Price 0.16
P/NAV 0.54x
$0.05
$0.10
$0.15
$0.20
$0.25
$0.30
-30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20% 30%
Change in T
arg
et
Price
Spodumene Price Exchange Rate (A$:US$) Tantalum Price
GXY Discount Rate (@10%) Sal de Vida Discount rate (@10%)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 16
6
CORPORATE & FINANCE
Capital structure
GXY’s capital structure is detailed in Figure 19 below:
Figure 19: GXY capital structure
Source: Company reports, Factset, Canaccord Genuity estimates
Cashflow & balance sheet
We estimate GXY has cash balance of ~A$13m as at the end of DecQ’15,
following the re-purchase of A$31m convertible bonds in Nov’15 (completed at a
13% discount to face value).
The balance of the convertible bonds (A$31m) were re-financed in late Nov’15
through the establishment of a secured three-year term facility through OCP Asia.
Other terms include an 8% p.a. interest rate and the issue of 10m warrants with a
floor exercise price of A$0.08.
We also note that GXY has A$189m in accumulated tax losses, which may be
used to offset income tax payable from any profits from Mt Cattlin.
Our forward cashflow and balance sheet forecasts (see Page 4, GXY financial
summary) represents our base case forecasts, and excludes any provision for
development of the Sal de Vida project. Our cashflow forecasts suggest GXY has
sufficient funding to repay current debt but we note that should GXY proceed to
develop Sal de Vida, additional capital will be required (see page 37, Sal de Vida
Project Development, timetable & funding)
Major shareholders
GXY’s substantial shareholders (+5%) are Acorn Capital (6.9%) and Paradice
Investment Management (5.3%).
Board of Directors
Martin Rowley, Non-Executive Chairman
Mr Rowley was a co-founder of TSX and LSE-listed First Quantum Minerals Ltd and is
currently that company’s Executive Director, Business Development. He was
previously non-executive Chairman and director of Lithium One Inc., which was
acquired by Galaxy in July 2012.
Anthony Tse, Managing Director
Mr Tse has 20 years of corporate experience in numerous high-growth industries such
as technology, internet/mobile, media & entertainment, and resource & commodities
– primarily in senior management, capital markets and M&A roles across Greater
China and Asia Pacific in general.
Charles Whitfield, Executive Director
Mr Whitfield is the Principal Investment Officer of Drumrock Capital, an investment
firm providing capital and advisory services to start-up and early round companies. He
Price Expiry
Issued Shares m 1264.4 $0.09
Options 1 m 4.0 $1.11
Options 2 m 2.9 $1.16
Options 3 m 12.0 $0.08 19/09/2016
Options 4 m 25.0 $0.03 1/04/2018
Options 5 m 34.1 Share perf rights
Options 6 m 10.0 $0.08 OCP warrants
Total Options m 88.0
Fully Diluted m 1352.4
Market Cap. A$m 115.1
Market Cap. (Fully diluted) A$m 123.1
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 17
7
was formerly a Managing Director with Citigroup where he held the position of head of
the corporate equity solutions group (Asia Pacific). Prior to this, he worked for
Deutsche Bank where he was head of the strategic equity transactions group (Asia
Pacific) from 2000.
Jian-Nan Zhang, Non-Executive Director
Mr Zhang is the Deputy General Manager of Fengli Group (Australia) Pty Ltd, a
subsidiary of the Fengli Group in China, which is a leading private industrial group in
China, with diversified interests in iron and steel, commodities trading, shipping and
wharf operation related businesses, and is also a shareholder in the company.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 18
8
Company overview: General Mining Corporation Ltd
COMPANY BACKGROUND
GMM is an Australian based lithium development company. Its primary asset is a
right to earn 50% of the Mt Cattlin lithium/tantalum operation in Western
Australia, and right to earn 50% of the James Bay spodumene project in Canada
(see Asset overview, Mt Cattlin & James Bay)
A company history summary is detailed below in Figure 20
Figure 20: GMM company history summary
Source: Company reports
KEY DEVELOPMENTS
Galaxy Resources Mt Cattlin agreement
In Feb’15, GXY executed an agreement with GMM whereby GMM was granted the
right to recommence production and solely operate Mt Cattlin for three years, with
an option to purchase the asset for A$30m and a 3% NSR royalty. Under the
agreement, GXY was set to receive an annual lease fee of A$2.5m and a 10%
production royalty (on tantalum sales). Under the deal, GMM had the right to all
revenues from the sale of tantalum from Mt Cattlin, with spodumene sales
revenue shared equally.
In Jun’15, the terms of the agreement were revised with GMM given the sole and
exclusive right to earn a 50% equity interest in Mt Cattlin for total consideration of
A$25m (comprising expending A$7m of capex to commence production and three
annual instalments of A$6m payable monthly in arrears from the commencement
of production).
The deal also saw GMM granted right to earn 50% interest in James Bay through
the expenditure of A$5m over 3 years.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 19
9
VALUATION
We have valued GMM using a net asset valuation approach, comprising a 50%
equity interest in Mt Cattlin (base case), 50% of our nominal valuation for James
Bay, net of corporate and working adjustments.
Our per share valuation (Figure 21) is based on a diluted share count of 334m
shares, which includes the recent A$7m placement at A$0.18/sh, and 23.7m ITM
options at an average exercise price of A$0.10/share.
As discussed in the Mt Cattlin project valuation section of this report, we note the
potential for further upside to our valuation which includes:
Higher spodumene prices at Mt Cattlin
The potential for an expanded production scenario at Mt Cattlin which under
our expanded case valuation scenario (see page 30) would add a further
A$0.20/share to our NAV.
Figure 21: GMM net asset valuation estimate
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates. . P/NAV Based on 9/12/2015 price
Valuation sensitivity
We have run sensitivity analysis on our GMM NAV estimate based on the metrics
as shown in Figure 22 below. Our analysis shows our valuation to be most
sensitive to the AUD/USD FX rate, and spodumene prices received at Mt Cattlin.
Figure 22: GMM NAV sensitivity
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates
Valuation A$m A$/share
Mt Cattlin NPV10% 126.9 0.38
Exploration & Other (James Bay) Estimate 15.0 0.04
Corporate (14.3) (0.04)
Cash 9.7 0.03
Debt - -
Unpaid capital 2.4 0.01
TOTAL 139.7 0.42
Target Price 0.40
P/NAV 0.49x
$0.10
$0.20
$0.30
$0.40
$0.50
$0.60
-30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20% 30%
Cha
ng
e in
Ta
rge
t P
rice
Spodumene Price (US$/t) Exchange Rate (A$:US$)
Tantalum Price (US$/lb) Discount Rate (@10%)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 20
10
CORPORATE & FINANCE
Capital structure
GMM’s capital structure is detailed in Figure 23 below. :
Figure 23: Capital structure
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
Cashflow & balance sheet
GMM had a cash balance of ~A$2.5m as at the end of SepQ’15, and currently has
no debt. The company raised A$5m through a placement and rights issue at
A$0.05/share in Sep’15, and recently announced the completion of a A$7.2m
placement at A$0.18/share. Following the placement, we estimate GMM will have
cash reserves of ~A$10m (includes proceeds of rights issue which settled in
Oct’15).
We estimate that following this raising, GMM has sufficient liquidity to fund initial
earn-in payments to GXY and the re-start of operations at Mt Cattlin, but note that
a further A$8m in capital is required throughout CY16 to complete process plant
upgrades to reach targeted production rates. We expect a majority of this can be
funded from existing cash and operating cashflow, with any additional
requirements satisfied by the exercise of management options (+A$2m) and
offtake related finance/product pre-payment (expected to be finalised in Jan’16)
totaling US$10m.
Major shareholders
GMM’s substantial shareholder (+5%) is Investmet, which holds ~14% of the fully
diluted capital of the company. Investmet is a company associated with the Executive
Chairman Michael Fotios.
Board of Directors
Michael Fotios, Executive Chairman
Mr Fotios is a geologist with 27 years’ experience in exploration and feasibility for
gold, base metals, tin, tantalum and nickel projects. He previously held roles with
Homestake Australia and Sons of Gwalia, with prior Directorships including Galaxy
Resources (2006-2008). Mr Fotios is also a Director of Northern Star Resources,
Horseshoe Metals, and Pegasus Metals.
Alan Still, Non-Executive Director
Mr. Still is a metallurgist with over 40 years’ experience in a variety of commodities,
including gold and rare earths. Mr Still is also a Director of Horseshoe Metals, Swan
Gold Mining and Pegasus Metals.
Michael Kitney, Non-Executive Director
Mr Kitney is a metallurgist with 40 years of international experience including roles in
mine operations, and project feasibility study management. Mr Kitney has experience
downstream lithium processing, and is currently COO of Kasbah Resources.
Price Expiry
Issued Shares m 269.18 $0.21
Options 1 m 14.25 $0.08 21/09/2017
Options 2 m 11.25 $0.12 21/09/2018
Total Options m 25.50 $0.10
Fully Diluted m 294.677
Market Cap (basic) A$m 55.181
Market Cap (Fully diluted) A$m 60.409
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 21
11
Asset overview
MT CATTLIN SPODUMENE/TANTALUM PROJECT (GXY 100%, GMM EARNING 50%)
Location & access
Mt Cattlin is situated in the Phillips River mineral field, which surrounds the
township of Ravensthorpe, 450km south east of Perth, Western Australia. The
project area (including a number of exploration tenements) covers ~185km2, and
sits on granted mining leases. Access to the property is via sealed highways
and/or direct air routes from Perth to Ravensthorpe.
The project benefits from infrastructure in the immediate Ravensthorpe area,
including roads (potential trucking routes to the ports of Esperance or Bunbury),
as well as skilled labour. Water is currently supplied via bore fields, with base load
power requirements provided by diesel generators. We note that Mt Cattlin also
has real-time solar tracking panels and two wind turbines, providing back-up
power to the project. At capacity, the renewable energy systems provide ~15% of
the mine sites’ daily power requirements.
Figure 24: Project location Figure 25: Ravensthorpe project plan
Source: Google maps Source: Company reports
Project history
The tenements on which the project is located have been owned by numerous
companies since the 1960s, including Western Mining Corp, Pancontinental
Mining (1989-90), Greenstone Resources (1997-99), Sons of Gwalia (1999 and
2002-2006) and Haddington Resources (2000-02). GXY acquired the Mt Cattlin
mining lease from Sons of Gwalia in 2006. A project milestone summary is shown
in Figure 26 below.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 22
12
Figure 26: Mt Cattlin project milestone timeline
Source: Company reports
In Feb’15, GMM executed an agreement with GXY whereby GMM was granted the
right to recommence re-commence production and solely operate Mt Cattlin for
three years, with an option to purchase the asset for A$30m and a 3% NSR
royalty. Under the agreement, GXY was set to receive an annual lease fee of
A$2.5m and a 10% production royalty (on tantalum sales). Under the deal, GMM
had the right to all revenues from the sale of tantalum from Mt Cattlin, with
spodumene sales revenue shared equally.
In Jun’15, the terms of the agreement were revised with GMM given the sole and
exclusive right to earn a 50% equity interest in Mt Cattlin for total consideration of
A$25m (comprising expending A$7m of capex to re-start production and three
annual instalments of A$6m payable monthly in arrears from the commencement
of production).
Geology & resources
The Mt Cattlin project is located within the Phillips River Mineral Field which forms
part of the regional Ravensthorpe Greenstone Belt. The central portion of this belt
hosts the Mt Cattlin deposit with host rocks comprising of intermediate to mafic
volcanoclastic rocks. This sequence comprises approximately 10-20% basalt, 50-
70% andesite and 20-30% dacite. Within this host rock, pegmatites dykes occur.
The pegmatites dykes display a diverse mineralogy with the deposit categorised
on structural and textural grounds as either i) Simple pegmatites, ii) Complex
pegmatites or iii) Albite-spodumene pegmatites. The pegmatites are zoned
vertically and can be quite variable laterally with a single layer of pegmatite
displaying all three lithologies at various locations.
Pegmatite mineralization defined to date covers an area of around 1.6 km east-
west and 1 km north-south. The main pegmatite mineralisation lies between 30 m
and 60 m below the surface, and outcrops in some locations as indicated in
Figure 27 below. However, deeper zones of lithium-mineralised pegmatites occur
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 23
13
over 140m below the surface to the northwest of the main ore body. The ore is flat
lying in orientation with vein thickness approaching 20m in some locations.
Spodumene-bearing pegmatite is the predominant lithium ore mineral, and
several types of spodumene are recognised including light green and white
varieties. Tantalum occurs within manganese-rich locations and is considered to
occur in a ~1:4 ratio with lithium.
Figure 27: Mt Cattlin cross section
Source: Company reports
A revised Mineral Resource and Ore Reserves estimate for Mt Cattlin was
provided by project partner General Mining in August 2015 (Figures 28 & 29). This
was updated to meet JORC 2012 requirements and uses a 0.4% Li2O cut-off
grade assuming a 10% mining dilution and an additional 5% of revenue from
Tantalum sales.
We note that the deposit remains open at depth within the main pegmatite
(Dowling pit), suggesting the potential for further increases in the resource. GMM
are expected to commence resource extension drilling programs later in 2016.
However, we don’t consider the project to be resource constrained with Reserves
sufficient to support a ~10 year project life, while further conversion of Inferred
resources could see an ultimate mining inventory supporting +15 years of
production at the proposed production rate of 800ktpa.
Figure 28: Mt Cattlin resources (2015) Figure 29: Mt Cattlin reserves (2015)
Source: Company reports Source: Company reports
Resources Mt Grade Mt Li2O Ta2O5 Ta2O5
(Li2O) (ppm) (Mlbs)
Mt Cattlin
Meas 2.54 1.20% 0.03 152.0 0.85
Indicated 9.53 1.06% 0.10 170.0 3.57
Inferred 4.34 1.07% 0.05 132.0 1.26
TOTAL 16.42 1.08% 0.18 157.0 5.68
Reserves Mt Grade Mt Li2O Ta2O5 Ta2O5
(Li2O) ppm (Mlbs)
Mt Cattlin
Proven 2.43 1.11% 0.03 152.0 0.81
Probable 7.54 1.02% 0.08 170.0 2.83
TOTAL 9.97 1.04% 0.10 149.0 3.28
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 24
14
Production history
Mt Cattlin historically produced 114kt of spodumene concentrate (at a
concentrate grade of ~6% Li2O) from 2010 to mid’12 when the operation was
suspended. The spodumene product was shipped to China as feed for GXY’s
Jiangsu lithium carbonate plant.
The operation underperformed expectations, with spodumene product recoveries
(averaged 53% versus design recoveries of 70%) impacted by poor crushing
performance and mica removal. GXY did not report production costs during this
period, but lower spodumene prices and a higher AUD also impacted profitability
of the operation.
Figure 30: Historical Mt Cattlin plant performance Figure 31: Historical Mt Cattlin spodumene production
Source: Company reports Source: Company reports
Project development
Mt Cattlin has been on care and maintenance since July 2013, and with only
limited operation, infrastructure remains in excellent condition. In Oct’15 GMM
reported the results of an independent review for a project re-start, based on an
800ktpa project producing 112ktpa of spodumene concentrate and ~500tpa of
tantalite concentrate over a mine life of 17 years (Figure 32 & 33).
Figure 32: Mt Cattlin scoping study outcomes Figure 33: Mt Cattlin scoping study financial inputs
Source: Company reports Source: Company reports
0.0%
0.2%
0.4%
0.6%
0.8%
1.0%
1.2%
1.4%
0
50
100
150
200
250
Dec-10 Mar-11 Jun-11 Sep-11 Dec-11 Mar-12 Jun-12
Reco
very
(x100)
/ L
i2O
Gra
de
(%
)
Ore
Mil
led
(kt)
Ore milled Li Recovery Grade (Li2O)
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
Dec-10 Mar-11 Jun-11 Sep-11 Dec-11 Mar-12 Jun-12
Sp
do
Co
nc (
kt)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 25
15
A re-start of operations will clearly benefit from the established plant and
infrastructure already on site, as well as open pit pre-strip being already 60%
complete (lending itself to a LOM strip ratio of 4:1). While the deposit may not
compare as favourably to some other spodumene projects in Australia in terms of
grade and tonnes, we consider the +A$100m in sunk capital to be a clear
advantage in terms of production lead times.
Furthermore, we consider the fact that historical spodumene product was
successfully used to produce a Li2CO3 product in GXY’s Jiangsu lithium carbonate
plant from 2012-2013, suggest a strong likelihood of acceptance among potential
convert plants, and presents as a de-risking factor for the project.
Figure 34: Mt Cattlin concentrator plant Figure 35: Mt Cattlin open pit
Source: Canaccord Genuity Source: Canaccord Genuity
Initial capex to re-commence production has been estimated at A$7.5m, with key
capital items including refurbishment of the current crushing circuit (~A$3m),
upgrade of fines circuit and installation of new equipment to ameliorate past poor
metallurgical aspects (A$4.5m). GMM have indicated that new and refurbished
equipment within the wet plant will be installed with sufficient redundancy to allow
for any potential expansion of production to ~200ktpa of spodumene concentrate.
Figure 36 overleaf summarises the existing process flowsheet design, previous
plant performance problems, and how GMM plan to resolve these to reach
targeted production rates.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 26
16
Figure 36: Mt Cattlin flowsheet description and proposed modifications
Source: Canaccord Genuity
Previous Limitations Proposed modifications
Cru
sh
ing
an
d S
cre
en
ing
* The plant previously consisted of a four stage
crushing circuit (3 dry and 1 wet stage) to
product a -6mm product from ROM ore at a
design rate of 1M tpa (420tpoh).
*The crushing plant is only operated on day shif t
with suff icent capacity provided in a f ine ore
(-18mm) bin.
*Previously f ine material (-25mm) was wet screened over
6.4mm aperture screens with oversize (-18mm +6mm) going to
quaternary crushers. This resulted in reduced throughput due to
wet feed agglomerat ing and impact ing on the ut ilisat ion of the
quaternary crushers circuit .
*A mobile crusher has been proposed to replace the
quaternary crusher. In addit ion to convert ing this to
a dry applicat ion, crush size can be controlled to target the
correct size for spodumene recovery via f lotat ion.
*The proposed changes along with refurbishment of the
current crushing circuit are expected to cost ~A$3m
*Crushing circuit to come online within 2-3 months of
operat ions commencing
Mic
a S
ep
ara
tio
n
* -6mm crushed ore is pulped and deslimed
at 75µm through a cyclone bank. The f ines are
transferred to the tailings thickener for disposal.
* The +75µm ore is fed over to a ref lux
(cross f low) classif ier to remove mica. Ref lux
classifers use simliar operat ion principles as other
gravity separat ion (up-current
classif ier, jigs etc).
*The dif ference in specif ic gravity of the lighter
mica (2.5 g/t) compared to
spodumene (3.15g/t) is exploited for ef fect ive
separat ion.
* Due to the similar physical propert ies (specif ic gravity, size
fract ion) that mica has with lithium bearing minerals inadequate
liberat ion inf luenced downstream heavy
media separat ion. M ica content within the lithium concentrate of
previous operat ions was ~20%, above the target grade of 5%.
This reduced contained Li2O to 5.2% to 5%.
* The overf low product from the ref lux classif ier was screened at
1.6mm to remove coarse mica f lakes. Control of the supension
water f lowrate and pressure is critcal to maintain effect ive
separat ion.
* The ref lux classif iers x2 are to be arranged to receive feed
from two discrete sizes -1.0+0.5mm
and -6.0+1.0mm. This is aimed at allowing the ref lux
classif iers to more select ively remove mica.
*The crit ical variable will be maintaining a product feed size
from the crushing circuit that enables effect ive separat ion of
mica.
Re
co
ve
ry f
rom
HM
S U
nd
ers
ize
* Prior to spodumene concentrate recovery by
Heavy M edia Separat ion (HM S), undersize (-
0.5mm) is treated through gravity separat ion
(spirals) to recovery tantalum and residual
spodumene.
* Tantalum concentrate at ~4.5% Ta2O5 is
recovered in the spiral sinks. This product is then
dewatered through a thickener and f ilter prior to
stockpiling for product shipment.
* Spiral f loats contain entrained spodumene which
was proposed to be recovered through f lotat ion.
*The tailings stream from the spiral and f lotat ion
circuit are sent back to a tailings dam for
empoundment
* Tantalum recovery was negliable due to poor classif icat ion
within the spiral circuit . This was attributed to a poor control of
the feed size due to poor quarternary crusher performance.
*Contained Li2O within the tailing stream (~0.8%) suggested very
poor recovery and provides the operat ion with supplmentary
plant feed requiring no crushing. It is est imated that ~400kt of
tails at a grade of 0.8% L2O is avaiable for use to commision the
modif ied f ines circuit .
*A series of classif iers (jigs) and gravity shaking (Wilf ley)
tables will be installed to scalp out coarse tantalum
(specif ic gravity of 8.2g/cc vs Li2O of
2.013) prior to the spiral circuit . It is envisaged to
remove 35% of contained Tantalum from this stream.
* Addit ional scavanger stages will be added to the f lotat ion
to improved lithium recovery. This design has been based a
top size of 0.5mm for the HM S undersize feed.
* ~ $4m has been proposed in capital expenditure to
upgrade the f ines circuit .
Re
co
ve
ry f
rom
HM
S O
ve
rsiz
e
*The -6mm material f rom the underf low of
the ref lux classif ier has been seperated from the
majority of mica. It is then fed to the HM S pre-
screen.
*The HM S pre-screen separates out the feed into
0.5 to 3mm and 3 to 6mm size
fract ions.
*Ferrosilicon is recovered from product and waste
streams by screening ahdn magnet ic separat ion.
*Previous operat ions indicated that very coarse (+0.5mm)
Tantalum was affect ing the purity of the primary spodumene
concentrate.
*Overall spodumene recovery of <60% was previously achieved at
a concentrate grade of ~5.2% Li 2O against a design of 75%
*A series of classif iers (jigs) and gravity shaking (Wilf ley)
tables will be installed to scalp out coarse tantalum
(specif ic gravity of 8.2g/cc vs Li2O of
2.013) prior to the spiral circuit . It is envisaged to
remove ~35% of contained Tantalum from this stream.
*Is is proposed to install a second series of cyclones to
improve the purity of the spodumene concentrate product.
*$8m in capital expenditure has been forecast to improve
yields and opt imse the process. Equipment has been
selected with adequete redundancy to accomodate an
expansion in throughput of +200kt
of spodumene concentrate. This equipment has been based
off previous design work from leading Perth f irm M SP
Engineering and can be f it ted into the exisist ing plant
structure with lit t le modif icat ions.
Key Features
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 27
17
Project timetable
GMM’s proposed project timetable is shown in Figure 37. It currently envisages
first concentrate production is due in MarQ’16, following completion of plant
upgrade works. Initial plant feed is expected to be sourced from reclaimed tailings
(400kt at ~1% Li2O) and 70kt of ROM ore currently on the ROM pad.
Upon the commencement of production it is proposed to initially feed reclaimed
tailings exclusively to the wet process plant in order to optimise the circuit, reduce
initial unit operating costs (no mining or crushing) and enable refurbishment of
the crushing circuit to be completed. Reclaimed tailings are then planned to be
blended with crushed ore feed as operations ramp up to steady state.
Figure 37: Mt Cattlin project timetable
Source: Company reports
Offtake, marketing & sales
GMM signed a Sales and Distribution Agreement with Mitsubishi Corporation in
Oct’15, which covers spodumene concentrate production from Mt Cattlin. The
agreement has a term of 4 years (plus an option for a 1 year extension based on
mutual agreement), and gives Mitsubishi the exclusive right to sell up to 100% of
production into China, South Korea, Taiwan and Vietnam.
Mitsubishi will act as principal buyer of the concentrate, and is obligated to use
reasonable endeavours to achieve the best price, Furthermore, Mitsubishi has
priority over spot buyers for Mt Cattlin concentrate, provided it at least matches
the prevailing market price. Quantity and pricing for the agreement is to be agreed
on a quarterly basis in line with market conditions.
The agreement also features two-way exclusivity in that Mitsubishi cannot
distribute spodumene concentrate from any other sources other than Mt Cattlin to
the named countries
We understand GMM is in discussions with a potential offtake partner for the
tantalum production from Mt Cattlin. We expect an update on this front in early
2016.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 28
18
Production
We have derived a project valuation for Mt Cattlin based on an NPV10%, based on
the following assumptions:
Mining inventory of 15Mt at 1.08% Li2O and 150ppm Ta2O5
Total capex of A$15m and annual sustaining capex of A$2.4m
800ktpa open pit mining with an average LOM strip ratio of ~4:1
Recoveries of 72% for spodumene and 65% for tantalite; spodumene
concentrate grades of 6% Li2O and tantalite concentrate grades of 4.5%
Ta2O5.
Based on the above assumptions, we estimate average annual spodumene
concentrate production of 108ktpa and tantalite concentrate production of
~1,800tpa. Our production estimates are shown in Figure 38 below.
Figure 38: CGe production & cost estimates
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates
Key financial assumptions include:
Mining costs of A$4.50/t material moved
Processing & site G&A costs of A$20/t
Product trucking costs (trucking to port of Esperance) A$22/tonne
State royalty of 5% and Greenstone Resources production royalty of A$1.50/t
on tantalum ore
Marketing fees 5% and impurity penalties 5%
We estimate average LOM production costs of US$342/tonne of spodumene
concentrate, net of tantalite by-product credits of US$137/tonne (assumes
tantalite price of US$75/lb and AUDUSD:0.69 from 2020).
Project valuation
Our valuation is based on spodumene and tantalite pricing assumptions as
illustrated in Figure 39 below. Our conservative assumptions see an average
annual price increase of 4% for spodumene concentrate, and conservative
assumptions for tantalite at US$75/lb flat (versus current market prices of
~US$90/lb).
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
600
0.00
20.00
40.00
60.00
80.00
100.00
120.00
2016e 2018e 2020e 2022e 2024e 2026e 2028e 2030e 2032e
Pro
du
cti
on
co
sts
(U
S$/t
co
nc)
Sp
od
um
en
e c
on
c p
rod
'n (
kt)
Spodumene prod'n Cash costs (net of credits) Spod conc 6% Li2O price
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 29
19
Figure 39: CG spodumene and tantalite pricing assumptions
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates
Based on the above assumptions/estimates, we derive a base case, post-tax
NPV10% for Mt Cattlin of A$253m.
We highlight the optionality offered by the potential to expand plant capacity
and production. Noting that the project is not resource constrained (current
assumed mine life of 15 years), and with the likelihood of relatively low capital
costs to expand the plant, we see clear potential for enhanced value for the
operation should production be increased. We note that any expansion would
be reliant on sufficient market demand for spodumene concentrate, but
noting current and expected tightness in the spodumene market, an
expansion could be a distinct possibility in our view.
On this basis, we have also modelled an “expansion case” for Mt Cattlin,
whereby plant throughput is increased 60% to 1.6Mtpa, lifting production to
208ktpa of spodumene concentrate. In this scenario, we have assumed
expansion capex of A$45m (consisting of upgraded crushing circuit, additional
fines recovery capacity and TSF expansion costs), starting 1H’17. An
expanded project would lift our project valuation (NPV10%) 44% to A$364m.
35
45
55
65
75
85
95
350
400
450
500
550
600
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
US
$/lb
US
$/t
onn
eSpodumene 6% Li2O (RHS) Tantalite (RHS)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 30
20
SAL DE VIDA LITHIUM BRINE PROJECT (GXY 100%)
Location & access
The Sal de Vida (SdV) project is located on the northern boundary of the
Catamarca Province and the southern boundary of Salta Province, in the Salar del
Hombre Muerto (Figure 40). The salar is situated ~1,300km NW of Buenos Aries
and 175km SW of Salta city, in the Argentinean Altiplano, and lies at an altitude of
~4,000m.
The project area covers ~420km2, and comprises a number of Mining Licences
(“Minas”) and Mining Claims (“Cateos”). The Minas and Cateos comprising the
project area cover the eastern sub-basin of the salar, proximal to FMC
Corporation’s (FMC:NYSE | Not rated) Fenix lithium brine operation on the
western part of the Salar (Figure 43), and Orocobre’s Tincalayu borate mining
operation to the north west..
Access to the property is via all-weather, sealed and unsealed roads,
approximately 390km from the City of Salta. Infrastructure in the region is
generally considered limited; however, any development is expected to benefit
from a gas pipeline extension running from the town of Pocitos to FMC’s Fenix
operation (24km from GXY’s SdV operations site).
Figure 40: Location map
Source: Google Maps
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 31
21
Figure 41: Salar de Hombre Meurto & Sal de Vida project area
Source: Company reports
Ownership & history
GXY acquired a 100% ownership of SdV through its merger with Lithium One Inc in
2012. Prior to this, Lithium One had acquired the project through an initial
purchase and consolidation of a number of smaller claims throughout the eastern
part of the Salar in 2009 and 2010.
In 2010, Lithium One entered into an agreement with Korea Resources (KORES)
to acquire an initial 4% equity in the project, with an option to earn an additional
26% through the funding and delivery of a feasibility study to a cost of US$15m.
KORES subsequently brought GS Caltex and LG International in as partners in the
joint venture, with each able to earn a 10% interest, and Lithium One retaining
70%. KORES eventually let the option lapse in Jun’13, with GXY reverting to 100%
ownership in Sep’15 following the purchase of KORES’ 4% interest for US$2.5m.
Geology
The SdV project is a lithium-rich salar, situated in the eastern and northern sub
basins of the Hombre Muerto basin (Figure 42). The basin itself is similar to other
salar basins in Chile, Argentina, and Bolivia, with basin formation related to the
volcanogenic origins of the Andes mountain ranges. These mountain ranges act
as natural drainages, with lithium (along with other minerals such as boron,
potassium, magnesium) in the groundwater derived the alteration and weathering
of surrounding volcanic rocks. The mineral rich brines “collect” in these basins,
and subsequently undergo sedimentation. High evaporation rates and limited
precipitation then resulting in the concentration of the lithium and other minerals
within the brine.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 32
22
Figure 42: Project location relative to other basins in the Andean Altiplano
Source: Company reports
Resources/reserves
Brine deposits differ from hard rock mineral deposits due to fluid mobility – brine
is a fluid hosted in an aquifer and thus has the ability to move and mix with
adjacent fluids once extraction starts. An initial in situ resource estimate is based
on knowledge of the geometry of the aquifer, and the variation in drainable
porosity and brine grade within the aquifer. Based on this, flow rates and other
hydraulic properties of the aquifer material are considered as important as the
chemistry and mineral tenor. GXY’s resource methodology consisted of two key
components:
characterisation of the mineral grade dissolved in the brines, and
characterisation of the host aquifer drainable porosity that contains the
resources.
These key parameters were used to estimate the total amount of brine, and
therefore contained lithium and potassium that could be theoretically extracted
from the concession.
GXY last completed a resource estimate for SdV in 2012 (Figure 43). We highlight
that Sal de Vida features a number of favourable characteristics for the
development of a brine deposit including good lithium grades, low Mg:Li ratios
(benefits production costs), elevated Potassium grades (potential by-product
credits) and low sulphate levels (low impurities). The resource has been defined to
a depth of +200m based on drilling undertaken between 2010 and 2012.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 33
23
Figure 43: Sal de Vida resources (2012)
Source: Company reports & Canaccord Genuity estimates
As a pre-cursor to the completion of a Definitive Feasibility Study, GXY released a
maiden Reserve estimate for SdV in Apr’13. The Reserve estimation methodology
differs from that used to estimate the resource, instead focussing on the potential
for recovery of lithium and potassium via well field pumping in selected areas.
Brine pumping tests were completed in Oct’12, with wells drilled to a depth of
160m, and brine pumping rates of 16 L/sec. The tests revealed an average
assayed lithium grade of 760mg/L, with potassium grades of 8,800mg/L. The
Reserve was based on a numerical groundwater flow model projection, which
indicated that the proposed well fields would be able to support an average
annual brine extraction rate of 30,000m3/day (~350L/sec). Based on this, the
Reserve is sufficient to support a +40 year mine life, although we note that the
Resource of +7Mt of contained LCE lends scope for a significantly longer
operation.
Figure 44: Reserves (2013)
Source: Company reports & Canaccord Genuity estimates; NB: assumes 500mg/L Li cut off
Feasibility studies
GXY completed a Definitive Feasibility Study (DFS) for SdV in Apr’13. The study
was based on the 2013 Reserve estimate, and demonstrated the viability of a
+40 year, 25ktpa Li2CO3 and 95ktpa potash project based on the development of
evaporation ponds, a lithium carbonate plant and potash production plant. Key
outcomes of the DFS are shown in Figure 48.
The DFS estimated capital costs totaling US$369m (Figure 47), with direct costs
of US$275m. The DFS estimated operating costs of US$2,200/t net of potash by-
product credits (study based on a Li2CO3 price of US$6,395/t and potash price of
US$500/tonne).
Resources Vol (km3) Li (mg/l) K (mg/l) Li (t) LCE (Mt) K (t)
Sal de Vida
Meas 0.72 787 8,695 566,640 3.015 6,260,400
Indicated 0.26 768 8,534 199,680 1.062 2,218,840
Inferred 0.83 718 8,051 595,940 3.170 6,682,330
TOTAL 1.81 753 8,377 1,362,260 7.247 15,161,570
Concentration Contained
Reserves Vol (km3) Yield (%) Li (mg/l) K (mg/l) Li (kt) LCE (Mt) K (Mt)
Sal de Vida
Proven 0.07 66% 518 5,053 36.2 0.19 0.35
Probable 0.37 63% 483 5,020 178.9 0.95 1.86
TOTAL 0.44 215.1 1.14 2.21
Concentration Contained
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 34
24
Figure 45: 2013 DFS capex breakdown Figure 46: 2013 DFS outcomes
Source: Company reports Source: Company reports
Process flow design
The DFS contemplated the production of a refined Li2CO3, product based on the
“Silver Peak” process (Figure 47), comprising the following key processing stages:
Brine pumping: Well fields are located in two separate locations on the salar,
in the south west and east. Locations were selected based on brine quality,
extent of the aquifer and brine pumping rates. A total of 24 well field pumps
(120-130m depth) will then pump the brine to the pond system for initial
treatment.
Pre-treatment stage: Nearly all magnesium is removed from the brines
through the addition of lime in the pre-treatment stage. The low magnesium
content of the SdV brines makes removal at an early stage of the process
possible, thus benefitting production costs.
Evaporation stage: the clarified brine is pumped to a series of evaporation
ponds, where initial ponds utilise natural evaporation to concentrate the brine
and remove the excess halite (common salt). Subsequent ponds further
concentrate the brine, resulting in the crystallisation of potassium, gypsum
and borate which are then harvested for the production of potash. Excess
calcium and sulphate are removed throughout the system.
Recovery stage: The concentrated brine is pumped to the processing plant at
a rate of 33m3/sec with a minimum Li content of 2% w/w. Processing involves
the removal of boron through solvent extraction, with remaining boron,
magnesium and calcium removed through ionic exchange. Residual impurities
(calcium and magnesium) are further removed through the addition of soda
ash, and passed through a filtration system to remove the precipitated solids.
Heat treatment and further soda ash treatment precipitates out the Li2CO3
and is extracted via centrifuges before purification.
Purification: Purification (targeted purity levels of 99.5% Li) is achieved via
through digestion of the Li2CO3 and addition of CO2, with the resultant liquor
passed through a further ionic exchange step to remove the entrained
impurities. Steam treatment then precipitates out a purified Li2CO3 product
which is then micronized (5 micron) and bagged for transport.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 35
25
Figure 47: SdV process flow diagram
Source: Company reports
The DFS also contemplated the production of a saleable potash product (95ktpa)
through the harvesting of potassium chloride (KCl) from the initial evaporation
ponds. The potash plant uses comminution, flotation and centrifugation to
produce a purified potash product suitable for fertilizer production.
Project development, timetable & funding
GXY commenced a development optimisation assessment of the project in 2013
with a view to reducing the upfront capital costs. The assessment is centered on
the staged development of the asset, utilising a modular project design allowing a
subsequent expansion. The current concept could see development split into two
stages with parameters potentially comprising:
Phase 1: 6-10ktpa Li2CO3, Capex US$100-200m (versus original US$369m)
Phase 2: expansion to 25ktpa Li2CO3
Further options being considered include:
Partial development of the evaporation ponds
Phase I development only seeing the first stages of the plant being built and
producing a lower purity, intermediate product (i.e. deferral of purification
circuit) – we note that the benefit of higher purity production and the margin
it affords is likely to outweigh the benefit of any upfront capital savings. As
such, we consider this option unlikely.
Deferral of Potash production
We note there is currently no defined development timetable for SdV, with
development of the project reliant on finalising a lower capex development and
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 36
26
funding plan for the project. However, based on the DFS construction timetable
(+18months), it is possible that production could commence in 2018.
In our view, GXY’s 100% ownership of SdV affords it some flexibility as to how any
development may be funded. Noting that even if a lower capex staged
development is pursued (capex ~US$100-120m), it would still require a
significant equity contribution against GXY’s current equity value. As such, funding
considerations could include selling down an equity interest in the project to a
strategic JV partner (e.g. Orocobre and Toyota Tsusho at Olaroz), as well as
increased debt funding.
Project valuation
In our view, GXY’s SdV project holds significant option and strategic value, which is
likely to become more evident from 2016 given expectations for continued
tightness in the lithium market and the higher quality nature (Li grades, low
impurities) of the project. However, given the current uncertainty around the
design, capex, development path and funding for the project, we have derived a
range of valuations for SdV. These include:
1. DCF based on a staged development
2. Market based valuation
1. DCF valuation
Our DCF valuation for SdV is based on the following assumptions:
Staged project development comprising 10ktpa Li2CO3 Stage 1, and
subsequent expansion to 25ktpa Li2CO3
40 year mine life based on the 2013 Reserve estimate of 1.14 Mt of LCE
Stage 1 capex of US$120m (plus additional working capital), with project
construction commencing in late 2016, and first Li2CO3 production in late
2018
Stage 2 capex of US$185m to take production to 25ktpa; construction
commences in mid-2020 with Stage 2 production commencing in mid-2022
Our assumed project development includes no potash recovery circuit,
reducing upfront capital (US$26m in the DFS for the potash circuit) but
increasing production costs by virtue of the removal of by-product credits. We
estimate Stage 1 production costs of US$3,915/t LCE and expanded Stage 2
total costs of US$3,418/t LCE.
Conservative Li2CO3 prices of US$7,100/t from 2020.
Figure 48: CG modelled production and costs 2019e-2033e
Source: Canaccord Genuity estimates
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
9,000
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
30.0
2016e 2017e 2018e 2019e 2020e 2021e 2022e 2023e 2024e 2025e 2026e 2027e 2028e 2029e 2030e 2031e 2032e 2033e
US
$/t
on
ne L
i2C
O3
Lit
hiu
m c
arb
on
ate
(ktp
a)
Lithium prod'n Total cash costs (RHS) Lithium carbonate price (RHS)
Steady state production (25ktpa)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 37
27
Our production and cost estimates are illustrated in Figure 48, and based the
above assumptions we derive a post-tax NPV10% (100%) for SdV of US$98m
(A$137m).
2. Market based valuation
We have derived an average market based valuation for SdV based on
“comparable” (i.e. lithium brine deposits) asset transactions in Figure 49.
Figure 49: Comparable transactions valuation summary
Source: Company reports, Canaccord Genuity estimates
Based on the average value of “comparable” transactions, we estimate a market-
based value for SdV of US$92m (A$128m).
Year Asset Acqurier Interest Value (US$m) Implied Project Seller
Value (US$m)
2008 Salar de Rincon Sentient Group 100% 22.0 22.0 Admiralty Res*
2012 Salar de Olaroz Toyota Tsusho 25% 55.0 220.0 Orocobre
2015 Sal de Vida Galaxy Resources 4% 2.5 62.5 KORES
2015 Cauchari-Olaroz Western Lithium 100% 63.0 63.0 Lithium Americas**
Average 91.9
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 38
28
JAMES BAY LITHIUM PROJECT (GXY 100%; GMM EARNING 50%)
Location & Access
The James Bay lithium pegmatite project is located in north-west Quebec, Canada.
The project is readily accessible by sealed roads and is 381km from the town of
Mattagami which provides access to mining infrastructure and a skilled workforce.
The nearest airstrip to the James Bay project is ~15kms away.
The project is exposed to seasonal extremes common in Canada. Winter (October
to April) temperatures range from -45 to 5 degrees generally associated with
significant snow cover, whereas summer months are typically characterized by
temperatures between 15 to 35 degrees. While not prohibitive to commercial
development, we expect the majority of the feasibility work to be completed in the
summer months.
Figure 50: James Bay location map
Source: Google Maps
Project History
The James Bay deposit was first discovered in 1966 and drill tested by the
Canadian government in 1977, where three diamond holes confirmed the
presence of spodumene mineralisation. Little modern exploration was completed
until Lithium One began drilling in 2008. During a two year drilling campaign
which followed targets based on extensive surface mapping, the presence of wide
pegmatite intersections with several hundred metres of lateral extent and a strike
length of >1km was confirmed. Drilling returned consistent grades throughout the
deposit of 1.2-1.8% Li20 which culminated in release of a maiden resource of
22.2Mt at 1.3% Li2O in November 2010.
Shortly after release of the James Bay maiden resource, GXY signed an agreement
with Lithium One to earn up to 70% in the project through C$3m cash payment
and completion of DFS. In March 2012, GXY and Lithium One ended up merging
and GXY currently has 100% ownership of the project.
GXY currently own 100% of the James Bay project. However, in June 2015, the
company executed an agreement that will allow GMM to earn a 50% stake by
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 39
29
spending US$5m over a 3 year period. Part of the agreement will require GMM to
contribute 50% of the expenditure in the first 2 years which it expects to fund from
cashflow from the Mt Cattlin operation.
Figure 51: James Bay project milestone summary
Source: Company reports
Geology & resources
James Bay is situated on the north-eastern part of the Superior geological
province, within the Eastmain greenstone belt. Lithium mineralisation is
concentrated in swarms of pegmatite dykes.
The individual pegmatite dykes vary in width from 60-100m. Generally
outcropping from surface, the pegmatite dykes form a discontinuous “corridor”
with a traced strike length of 4km and width of 300m. Surface mapping has
identified 15 different pegmatite swarms within the deposit, each consisting of up
to seven dykes.
Pegmatites form by the crystallisation of post-magmatic fluids enriched in light
elements such as lithium, boron and beryllium inside the crust. Geological
investigations on the James Bay dykes have indicated that almost all are
spodumene bearing. The mineral spodumene (LiAlSi2O6), in its pure form
contains 8.02% Li2O. Spodumene crystals at James Bay are relatively coarse,
usually more than 5cm in length although some have been recorded at >80cm.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 40
30
Figure 52: James Bay – base line cross section
Source: Company reports
Figure 53: Pegmatite outcrop at James Bay
Source: Company reports
In November 2010, Lithium One announced a maiden resource estimate for
James Bay comprising 22.2 Mt at 1.28% Li2O. The resource was estimated using
a 0.75% Li2O cut off.
Figure 54: James Bay resources (2010)
Source: Company reports
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 41
31
Project development & timetable
GXY has indicated that a DFS will commence in 2016 on the James Bay project.
Given the weather constraints of the Canadian winter, we don’t expect to see field
work meaningfully start before May next year.
At this stage, key deliverables and timing for completion of the DFS are yet to be
outlined. We expect to see follow up drilling to convert Inferred resources into
Measured and Indicated categories, ongoing metallurgical testwork (samples of
James Bay pegmatite are planned to be shipped to Mt Cattlin for processing and
assessment), pit optimizations and advancement of necessary permits to be the
key areas of ongoing work.
While early stage, that geometry of the current resource looks amenable to open
pit mining and we expect the coarse grained pegmatite mineralisation to respond
well to similar processing as Mt Cattlin. Ultimately, given the relative similarity in
orebodies, we expect Mt Cattlin to serve as a blueprint for the development of
James Bay.
Pending the outcomes of a DFS, we expect the scale of the operation to
potentially be similar to that of Mt Cattlin, with the exception of the tantalum
production. The target market would likely be North America which is widely
expected to have a growing appetite for lithium. Given the current earn-in timeline
with GMM, we don’t expect to see a funding and development decision for the
project before late 2018. In terms of priority for GXY, we see James Bay as the
third rank priority, behind Sal de Vida and Mt Cattlin.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 42
32
Appendix I – Investment risks
The key investment risks for GXY and GMM include:
Funding risk
As a pre-production company with no material income, both GXY and GMM are reliant
on equity and debt markets to fund feasibility studies and development of their
various projects. We can make no assurances that accessing these markets will be
done without further dilution to shareholders.
Exploration risks
Exploration is subject to a number of risks and can require a high rate of capital
expenditure. Risks can also be associated with conversion of inferred resources and
lack of accuracy in the interpretation of geochemical, geophysical, drilling and other
data. No assurances can be given that exploration will delineate further minable
reserves.
Operating risks
Once in production, the company will be subject to risks such as plant/equipment
breakdowns, metallurgical (meeting design recoveries within a complex flowsheet),
materials handling and other technical issues. An increase in operating costs could
reduce the profitability and free cash generation from the operating assets
considerably and negatively impact valuation. Further, the actual characteristics of an
ore deposit may differ significantly from initial interpretations which can also
materially impact forecast production from original expectations.
Commodity price and currency fluctuations
As with any mining company, GXY and GMM are directly exposed to commodity price
and currency fluctuations. Commodity price fluctuations are driven by many
macroeconomic forces including inflationary pressures, interest rates and supply and
demand factors. These factors could reduce the profitability, costing and prospective
outlook for the business.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 43
Appendix: Important DisclosuresAnalyst CertificationEach authoring analyst of Canaccord Genuity whose name appears on the front page of this research hereby certifies that (i) therecommendations and opinions expressed in this research accurately reflect the authoring analyst’s personal, independent andobjective views about any and all of the designated investments or relevant issuers discussed herein that are within such authoringanalyst’s coverage universe and (ii) no part of the authoring analyst’s compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to thespecific recommendations or views expressed by the authoring analyst in the research.Analysts employed outside the US are not registered as research analysts with FINRA. These analysts may not be associated persons ofCanaccord Genuity Inc. and therefore may not be subject to the NASD Rule 2711 and NYSE Rule 472 restrictions on communicationswith a subject company, public appearances and trading securities held by a research analyst account.Target Price / Valuation Methodology:General Mining Corporation Limited - GMMTo reach our A$0.40/sh target price, we value GMM on a net asset valuation basis, comprising a 50% interest in our base case MtCattlin NPV10%, 50% of our nominal valuation for James Bay, net of corporate and other adjustments.Galaxy Resources Limited - GXYTo reach our A$0.16/sh target price, We value GXY on a NAV basis comprising 50% of our base case NPV10% for Mt Cattlin, our blendedDCF/market based value for Sal de Vida, and exploration, net of corporate and other adjustments.Orocobre Limited - OREOur target price is derived from a NAV comprising NPV10% for operating assets, interco loan receivables, net of corporate and otheradjustments.Risks to achieving Target Price / Valuation:General Mining Corporation Limited - GMMThe key investment risks for GMM include:Funding riskAs a pre-production company with no material income, GMM is reliant on equity and debt markets to fund feasibility studies anddevelopment of various projects. We can make no assurances that accessing these markets will be done without further dilution toshareholders.
Exploration risksExploration is subject to a number of risks and can require a high rate of capital expenditure. Risks can also be associated withconversion of inferred resources and lack of accuracy in the interpretation of geochemical, geophysical, drilling and other data. Noassurances can be given that exploration will delineate further minable reserves.
Operating risksOnce in production, the company will be subject to risks such as plant/equipment breakdowns, metallurgical (meeting design recoverieswithin a complex flowsheet), materials handling and other technical issues. An increase in operating costs could reduce the profitabilityand free cash generation from the operating assets considerably and negatively impact valuation. Further, the actual characteristicsof an ore deposit may differ significantly from initial interpretations which can also materially impact forecast production from originalexpectations.
Commodity price and currency fluctuations
As with any mining company, GMM is directly exposed to commodity price and currency fluctuations. Commodity price fluctuations aredriven by many macroeconomic forces including inflationary pressures, interest rates and supply and demand factors. These factorscould reduce the profitability, costing and prospective outlook for the business.Galaxy Resources Limited - GXYThe key investment risks for GXY include:Funding riskAs a pre-production company with no material income, GXY is reliant on equity and debt markets to fund feasibility studies anddevelopment of various projects. We can make no assurances that accessing these markets will be done without further dilution toshareholders.
Exploration risks
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 44
Exploration is subject to a number of risks and can require a high rate of capital expenditure. Risks can also be associated withconversion of inferred resources and lack of accuracy in the interpretation of geochemical, geophysical, drilling and other data. Noassurances can be given that exploration will delineate further minable reserves.
Operating risksOnce in production, the company will be subject to risks such as plant/equipment breakdowns, metallurgical (meeting design recoverieswithin a complex flowsheet), materials handling and other technical issues. An increase in operating costs could reduce the profitabilityand free cash generation from the operating assets considerably and negatively impact valuation. Further, the actual characteristicsof an ore deposit may differ significantly from initial interpretations which can also materially impact forecast production from originalexpectations.
Commodity price and currency fluctuations
As with any mining company, GXY is directly exposed to commodity price and currency fluctuations. Commodity price fluctuations aredriven by many macroeconomic forces including inflationary pressures, interest rates and supply and demand factors. These factorscould reduce the profitability, costing and prospective outlook for the business.Orocobre Limited - OREThe key investment risks for ORE include: Geological risk -- the actual characteristics of an ore deposit may differ significantly frominitial interpretations and expectations. We note however the resource is extremely large relative to the forecast extraction rates andmine life, somewhat mitigating geological risk. Technical risk -- the construction and operation of brine based lithium carbonate projectsalthough proven is still in its relative infancy and therefore construction and operating risks are inherently elevated. Mitigating this riskis a pilot plant has been operating on site for in excess of 18 months, producing battery grade lithium carbonate. Financing risk -- theability of ORE to fund its portion of the development of the Olaroz project should also be considered a key investment risk. Equity andcredit markets may not be conducive to securing the required funds to complete construction of the project although we consider withthe Capital expenditure and operating risk -- the risk that capital and or operating costs exceed budget and/or exhaust available fundingbefore project completion, and reduce the profitability and free cash generation of the project. Commodity price and exchange rate risk:As with all mining and mineral exploration companies, commodity price and exchange rate risk should also be considered. In particularlithium and lithium carbonate are not exchange-traded commodities and are relatively small markets. Small and illiquid markets can bemore susceptible to wild fluctuations in prices.
Distribution of Ratings:Global Stock Ratings (as of 12/16/15)Rating Coverage Universe IB Clients
# % %Buy 583 62.55% 31.22%Hold 265 28.43% 13.21%Sell 29 3.11% 3.45%Speculative Buy 55 5.90% 60.00%
932* 100.0%*Total includes stocks that are Under ReviewCanaccord Genuity Ratings SystemBUY: The stock is expected to generate risk-adjusted returns of over 10% during the next 12 months.
HOLD: The stock is expected to generate risk-adjusted returns of 0-10% during the next 12 months.
SELL: The stock is expected to generate negative risk-adjusted returns during the next 12 months.
NOT RATED: Canaccord Genuity does not provide research coverage of the relevant issuer.“Risk-adjusted return” refers to the expected return in relation to the amount of risk associated with the designated investment or therelevant issuer.Risk QualifierSPECULATIVE: Stocks bear significantly higher risk that typically cannot be valued by normal fundamental criteria. Investments in thestock may result in material loss.
Canaccord Genuity Company-Specific Disclosures (as of date of this publication)General Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited currently are, or in the past 12 months were, a client of Canaccord Genuityor its affiliated companies. During this period, Canaccord Genuity or its affiliated companies provided investment banking services toGeneral Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 45
In the past 12 months, Canaccord Genuity or its affiliated companies have received compensation for Corporate Finance/InvestmentBanking services from General Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited .In the past 12 months, Canaccord Genuity or any of its affiliated companies have been lead manager, co-lead manager or co-manager ofa public offering of securities of General Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited or any publicly disclosed offer of securities ofGeneral Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited or in any related derivatives.Canaccord Genuity or one or more of its affiliated companies intend to seek or expect to receive compensation for Corporate Finance/Investment Banking services from Galaxy Resources Limited, General Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited in the next sixmonths.The primary analyst, a member of primary analyst's household, or any individual directly involved in the preparation of this research, hasa long position in the shares or derivatives, or has any other financial interest in Orocobre Limited, the value of which increases as thevalue of the underlying equity increases.
An analyst has visited the material operations of Galaxy Resources Limited, General Mining Corporation Limited and Orocobre Limited.No payment was received for the related travel costs.Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited was the Lead Manager and Bookrunner to the Placement to raise A$32.3m in June'15
Jan 2013 Apr 2013 Jul 2013 Oct 2013 Jan 2014 Apr 2014 Jul 2014 Oct 2014 Jan 2015 Apr 2015 Jul 2015 Oct 2015
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
Galaxy Resources Limited Rating History as of 12/14/2015
Closing Price Target Price
Buy (B); Speculative Buy (SB); Sell (S); Hold (H); Suspended (SU); Under Review (UR); Restricted (RE); Not Rated (NR)
Jan 2013 Apr 2013 Jul 2013 Oct 2013 Jan 2014 Apr 2014 Jul 2014 Oct 2014 Jan 2015 Apr 2015 Jul 2015 Oct 2015
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
General Mining Corporation Limited Rating History as of 12/14/2015
Closing Price Target Price
Buy (B); Speculative Buy (SB); Sell (S); Hold (H); Suspended (SU); Under Review (UR); Restricted (RE); Not Rated (NR)
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 46
Jan 2013 Apr 2013 Jul 2013 Oct 2013 Jan 2014 Apr 2014 Jul 2014 Oct 2014 Jan 2015 Apr 2015 Jul 2015 Oct 2015
4.504.003.503.002.502.001.501.00
Orocobre Limited Rating History as of 12/14/2015
Closing Price Target Price
Buy (B); Speculative Buy (SB); Sell (S); Hold (H); Suspended (SU); Under Review (UR); Restricted (RE); Not Rated (NR)
B:AUD2.5405/02/13
B:AUD2.7008/14/13
B:AUD3.4111/10/13
B:AUD3.2411/13/13
B:AUD3.3502/17/14
B:AUD3.4004/14/14
B:AUD3.6205/01/14
B:AUD3.7507/02/14
B:AUD3.7707/31/14
B:AUD3.9109/30/14
B:AUD4.2010/26/14
B:AUD4.2012/28/14
B:AUD3.7003/18/15
B:AUD3.5506/23/15
B:AUD3.4007/01/15
B:AUD3.1010/21/15
Online DisclosuresUp-to-date disclosures may be obtained at the following website (provided as a hyperlink if this report is being read electronically)http://disclosures.canaccordgenuity.com/EN/Pages/default.aspx; or by sending a request to Canaccord Genuity Corp. Research, Attn:Disclosures, P.O. Box 10337 Pacific Centre, 2200-609 Granville Street, Vancouver, BC, Canada V7Y 1H2; or by sending a requestby email to [email protected]. The reader may also obtain a copy of Canaccord Genuity’s policies and proceduresregarding the dissemination of research by following the steps outlined above.General Disclosures“Canaccord Genuity” is the business name used by certain wholly owned subsidiaries of Canaccord Genuity Group Inc., includingCanaccord Genuity Inc., Canaccord Genuity Limited, Canaccord Genuity Corp., and Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited, an affiliatedcompany that is 50%-owned by Canaccord Genuity Group Inc.The authoring analysts who are responsible for the preparation of this research are employed by Canaccord Genuity Corp. a Canadianbroker-dealer with principal offices located in Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto, Montreal, or Canaccord Genuity Inc., a US broker-dealerwith principal offices located in New York, Boston, San Francisco and Houston, or Canaccord Genuity Limited., a UK broker-dealer withprincipal offices located in London (UK) and Dublin (Ireland), or Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited, an Australian broker-dealer withprincipal offices located in Sydney and Melbourne.The authoring analysts who are responsible for the preparation of this research have received (or will receive) compensation based upon(among other factors) the Corporate Finance/Investment Banking revenues and general profits of Canaccord Genuity. However, suchauthoring analysts have not received, and will not receive, compensation that is directly based upon or linked to one or more specificCorporate Finance/Investment Banking activities, or to recommendations contained in the research.Canaccord Genuity and its affiliated companies may have a Corporate Finance/Investment Banking or other relationship with the issuerthat is the subject of this research and may trade in any of the designated investments mentioned herein either for their own accountor the accounts of their customers, in good faith or in the normal course of market making. Accordingly, Canaccord Genuity or theiraffiliated companies, principals or employees (other than the authoring analyst(s) who prepared this research) may at any time havea long or short position in any such designated investments, related designated investments or in options, futures or other derivativeinstruments based thereon.Some regulators require that a firm must establish, implement and make available a policy for managing conflicts of interest arising asa result of publication or distribution of research. This research has been prepared in accordance with Canaccord Genuity’s policy onmanaging conflicts of interest, and information barriers or firewalls have been used where appropriate. Canaccord Genuity’s policy isavailable upon request.The information contained in this research has been compiled by Canaccord Genuity from sources believed to be reliable, but (with theexception of the information about Canaccord Genuity) no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made by Canaccord Genuity,its affiliated companies or any other person as to its fairness, accuracy, completeness or correctness. Canaccord Genuity has notindependently verified the facts, assumptions, and estimates contained herein. All estimates, opinions and other information containedin this research constitute Canaccord Genuity’s judgement as of the date of this research, are subject to change without notice and areprovided in good faith but without legal responsibility or liability.Canaccord Genuity’s salespeople, traders, and other professionals may provide oral or written market commentary or trading strategiesto our clients and our proprietary trading desk that reflect opinions that are contrary to the opinions expressed in this research.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 47
Canaccord Genuity’s affiliates, principal trading desk, and investing businesses may make investment decisions that are inconsistentwith the recommendations or views expressed in this research.This research is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any designatedinvestments discussed herein in any jurisdiction where such offer or solicitation would be prohibited. As a result, the designatedinvestments discussed in this research may not be eligible for sale in some jurisdictions. This research is not, and under nocircumstances should be construed as, a solicitation to act as a securities broker or dealer in any jurisdiction by any person or companythat is not legally permitted to carry on the business of a securities broker or dealer in that jurisdiction. This material is prepared forgeneral circulation to clients and does not have regard to the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of anyparticular person. Investors should obtain advice based on their own individual circumstances before making an investment decision.To the fullest extent permitted by law, none of Canaccord Genuity, its affiliated companies or any other person accepts any liabilitywhatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from or relating to any use of the information contained in this research.For Canadian Residents:This research has been approved by Canaccord Genuity Corp., which accepts sole responsibility for this research and its disseminationin Canada. Canaccord Genuity Corp. is registered and regulated by the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (IIROC)and is a Member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund. Canadian clients wishing to effect transactions in any designated investmentdiscussed should do so through a qualified salesperson of Canaccord Genuity Corp. in their particular province or territory.For United States Residents:Canaccord Genuity Inc., a US registered broker-dealer, accepts responsibility for this research and its dissemination in the United States.This research is intended for distribution in the United States only to certain US institutional investors. US clients wishing to effecttransactions in any designated investment discussed should do so through a qualified salesperson of Canaccord Genuity Inc. Analystsemployed outside the US, as specifically indicated elsewhere in this report, are not registered as research analysts with FINRA. Theseanalysts may not be associated persons of Canaccord Genuity Inc. and therefore may not be subject to the NASD Rule 2711 and NYSERule 472 restrictions on communications with a subject company, public appearances and trading securities held by a research analystaccount.For United Kingdom and European Residents:This research is distributed in the United Kingdom and elsewhere Europe, as third party research by Canaccord Genuity Limited,which is authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. This research is for distribution only to persons who are EligibleCounterparties or Professional Clients only and is exempt from the general restrictions in section 21 of the Financial Services andMarkets Act 2000 on the communication of invitations or inducements to engage in investment activity on the grounds that it is beingdistributed in the United Kingdom only to persons of a kind described in Article 19(5) (Investment Professionals) and 49(2) (High NetWorth companies, unincorporated associations etc) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005(as amended). It is not intended to be distributed or passed on, directly or indirectly, to any other class of persons. This material is not fordistribution in the United Kingdom or elsewhere in Europe to retail clients, as defined under the rules of the Financial Conduct Authority.For Jersey, Guernsey and Isle of Man Residents:This research is sent to you by Canaccord Genuity Wealth (International) Limited (CGWI) for information purposes and is not to beconstrued as a solicitation or an offer to purchase or sell investments or related financial instruments. This research has been producedby an affiliate of CGWI for circulation to its institutional clients and also CGWI. Its contents have been approved by CGWI and we areproviding it to you on the basis that we believe it to be of interest to you. This statement should be read in conjunction with your clientagreement, CGWI's current terms of business and the other disclosures and disclaimers contained within this research. If you are in anydoubt, you should consult your financial adviser.CGWI is licensed and regulated by the Guernsey Financial Services Commission, the Jersey Financial Services Commission and the Isleof Man Financial Supervision Commission. CGWI is registered in Guernsey and is a wholly owned subsidiary of Canaccord Genuity GroupInc.For Australian Residents:This research is distributed in Australia by Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited ABN 19 075 071 466 holder of AFS Licence No234666. To the extent that this research contains any advice, this is limited to general advice only. Recipients should take into accounttheir own personal circumstances before making an investment decision. Clients wishing to effect any transactions in any financialproducts discussed in the research should do so through a qualified representative of Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited. CanaccordGenuity Wealth Management is a division of Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited.For Singapore Residents:This research is distributed pursuant to 32C of the Financial Advisers under an arrangement between each of the Canaccord Genuityentities that publish research and Canaccord Genuity Singapore Pte. Ltd who is an exempt financial adviser under section 23(1)(d) ofthe Financial Advisers Act. This research is only intended for persons who fall within the definition of accredited investor, expert investoror institutional investor as defined under section 4A of the Securities and Futures Act. It is not intended to be distributed or passed on,directly or indirectly, to any other class of persons. Recipients of this report can contact Canaccord Genuity Singapore Pte. Ltd. (ContactTel: +65 6854 6150) in respect of any matters arising from, or in connection with, the research.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 48
For Hong Kong Residents:This research is distributed in Hong Kong by Canaccord Genuity (Hong Kong) Limited which is licensed by the Securities and FuturesCommission. This research is only intended for persons who fall within the definition of professional investor as defined in the Securitiesand Futures Ordinance. It is not intended to be distributed or passed on, directly or indirectly, to any other class of persons. Recipients ofthis report can contact Canaccord Genuity (Hong Kong) Limited. (Contact Tel: +852 3919 2561) in respect of any matters arising from, orin connection with, this research.Additional information is available on request.Copyright © Canaccord Genuity Corp. 2015. – Member IIROC/Canadian Investor Protection Fund
Copyright © Canaccord Genuity Limited. – Member LSE, authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Copyright © Canaccord Genuity Inc. . – Member FINRA/SIPC
Copyright © Canaccord Genuity (Australia) Limited. – Participant of ASX Group, Chi-x Australia and of the NSX. Authorized and regulatedby ASIC.
All rights reserved. All material presented in this document, unless specifically indicated otherwise, is under copyright to CanaccordGenuity Corp., Canaccord Genuity Limited, Canaccord Genuity Inc or Canaccord Genuity Group Inc. None of the material, nor its content,nor any copy of it, may be altered in any way, or transmitted to or distributed to any other party, without the prior express writtenpermission of the entities listed above.
Specialty Minerals and MetalsInitiation of Coverage
16 December 2015 49