+ All Categories
Home > Documents > LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD

LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD

Date post: 04-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: dangngoc
View: 212 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
1783 Public Health and Poor Law. LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD. REPORTS OF INSPECTORS OF THE MEDICAL DEPARTMENT OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD. THE SANITARY CIRCUMSTANCES AND ADMINISTRATION OF VARIOUS RURAL AND SMALLER URBAN DISTRICTS. DURING the last few months the Local Government Board has issued a large number of reports which give detailed accounts of the results of visits by medical inspectors to rural districts and smaller urban districts in different parts of the country. These reports have in the main a local interest but it is impossible to look through the series without realising how frequently the system of sanitary government by district councils of these areas is found altogether inefficient in practice. The inspectors, after reporting on defective conditions of housing, undesirable or dangerous water-supplies, neglect to supervise cowsheds and milling, and many other matters which become almost monotonous by repetition, nearly always point to the unsatisfactory circumstances of the local public health service as the first matter on which reform is necessary. In many of these reports, combination of a number of adjoining districts for the purpose of securing a single specially qualified medical officer is advocated but unless the Local Government Board can be induced to abandon its well-known objections to compelling the combina- tion of unwilling districts for this purpose it is to be feared that much of the labour expended on these inspections and reports will have been thrown away. In regard to "inspectors of nuisances," or sanitary inspectors as they are generally called, the Board can indirectly bring about improvements by exercising its power of allowing or refusing repayment of half this officer’s salary from county funds. But it would appear from these reports that this is often an ineffective weapon, and obviously a district which elects to pay its inspector a merely nominal sum for nominal services has little to lose if the repayment of salary is refused by the Board. From the following reports a few matters of more than local interest have been noted for comment. Sherborne Rural District,1 by Dr. R. W. JOHNSTONE.-This is an important milk-producing district in Dorsetshire. Nearly all the cowkeepers dispose of their produce as milk ; few of them make either butter or cheese. About 6000 gallons of milk a day are sent out of this district for retail in London, Aldershot, and other places. In addition, about 1000 gallons a day are made into milk powder at a factory in Sherborne. Little or no attempt is made by the district council to enforce the regulations adopted under the Dairies, Cowsheds, and Milkshops Order. The water available for cooling the milk at the farms often fails to reduce the temperature of the milk below 600 F., and many of the cooling sheds are ramshackle affairs which readily permit the contamination of the milk by dust. "The surroundings are often so filthy that the dairyman has to pass through a quagmire to reach the cooling shed." In one cowshed the normal method of cleansing the shed was to shovel the manure through the windows, leaving the walls inside caked with filth. Uncleanliness and faulty construction of walls and floors of cowsheds were everywhere met with. Milkers as a rule do not wash their hands or cleanse the cows’ udders before milking. The large London dairies which deal with farmers in this district usually insist, in their printed agree. ments, upon the wearing of a clean blouse by the milker, cleansing of hands and udder, and like matters. But nc attempt seems to be made to find out if the farmer is fulfilling the conditions of his contract. Dr. Johnstone found that thE dairy farmers were more opposed to reform in the personal methods of their milkers than to any proposition in the wa of improved ventilation and drainage of the cowsheds. SomE of them said that if the regulations on this matter were insisted upon they would abandon dairy-farming. He add., that the sooner men with these ideas abandon dairy-farming the better it will be for the health of the children and others who consume the milk. 1 London: Wyman and Sons, Fetter-lane; Edinburgh : Oliver and Boyd; Dublin: E. Ponsonby. No. 285. Price 3d. Aberayron Registration District,2 by Dr. W. W. E. FLETCHER.-Inspection of the three districts comprised in this registration area (Aberayron urban and rural and New Quay urban) brought out the fact that the councils concerned completely neglected their elementary duties as to drainage, water-supply, closet accommodation, and other matters, and resulted in Dr. Fletcher raising the question of improving the public health service of the whole of Cardigan- shire by the combination of all its contained districts for the purpose of appointing a single medical officer of health. Dr. Fletcher points out that Westmorland has a combination of districts of this kind and that the results contrast favourably with those of Cardigan, in which there are no fewer than 13 medical officers of health who between them receive no . more than .B380 per annum. , Tregaron Rural District,3 by Dr. E. P. MANBY.-The shortcomings of sanitary administration in Cardiganshire are also brought out by this report. Public water-supplies are urgently needed in many parts of the district but the district council has refused to take action even in cases where the cost of carrying out the recommendations of the medical officer of health for this purpose would have been almost negligible. The council has recently appointed as its inspector of nuisances a draper’s assistant at a salary of lls. 6d. a week. The population of the district is about 8000 and its area is 189 square miles. Dr. Manby takes occasion to point out that the Dairies, Cowsheds, and Milk- shops Order applies to all cowkeepers whether they sell milk or only make cheese and butter, although in the latter case there is exemption from regulations made under the Order. Misconception on this matter appears to be prevalent, as reference is made to it in several reports of this series. Bourne Urban District,4 by Dr. F. ST. GEORGE MmART.- The abundance of water which is obtained in this district wherever the Lincolnshire limestone is bored into has incidentally given rise to some serious difficulties. An artesian well with an abundant yield can be made almost anywhere by sinking a shaft, and owners of houses and business premises naturally prefer this method of supply to resorting to the public service. A great many of these bores are not sealed properly and leakage is freely and constantly taking place into the ground in their neighbourhood. Among other objections to this leakage is the effect upon the sewage of the town. This amounts to more than 60 gallons per head of population in dry weather and the high degree of dilution greatly interferes with the satisfactory purification of the sewage at reasonable cost. Hicntingdon Rural District,5 by Dr. R. D. SWEETING.- The sanitary condition of a portion of this district has been adversely affected by neglect to cleanse streams and water- ways. In some places, such as Alconbury, serious floods appear to be increasingly common. This frequent flooding causes serious discomfort and inconvenience, and, as Dr. Sweeting points out, it obviously tends to foster the preva- lence of rheumatism, bronchitis, and various diseases asso- ciated with dampness of sites and dwellings. The streams in question are backwaters of the Ouse and there seems to be no public authority upon which their cleansing depends. The county council disclaims any such duty. The neglected con- dition of the streams, however, is not confined to the back- waters but extends to the river Ouse itself. After a prolonged litigation on the subject of repair of locks, which terminated by a decision in the House of Lords in 1904, all navigation on the Ouse above St. Ives has come to a complete standstill; the river is ceasing to be navigable and in the absence of dredging and weeding and repairs to the locks a fertile cause of local flooding is created. It may be hoped that the Royal Commission on Canals and Waterways may be able to make effective recommendations to improve the very unsatisfactory conditions which this report discloses. Hartley Wintney -Rural District,6 by Dr. J. S. Low.-In this district of Hampshire, which adjoins Farnborough, it has lately been the custom to receive town children sent by charitable persons for a country holiday. Dr. Low shows that the houses in which these children are received are often insanitary and become grossly overcrowded as a consequence 1 of their visit. He recommends that the local agent who arranges for the housing of the children should be required to give an undertaking that no dwelling should be used for the 2 Ibid., No. 283. Price 5d. 3 Ibid., No. 284. Price 3d. 4 Ibid., No. 289. Price 3d. 5 Ibid., No. 278. Price 6d. 6 Ibid., No. 288. Price 4d.
Transcript
Page 1: LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD

1783

Public Health and Poor Law.LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD.

REPORTS OF INSPECTORS OF THE MEDICAL DEPARTMENT OFTHE LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD.

THE SANITARY CIRCUMSTANCES AND ADMINISTRATION OFVARIOUS RURAL AND SMALLER URBAN DISTRICTS.

DURING the last few months the Local Government Boardhas issued a large number of reports which give detailedaccounts of the results of visits by medical inspectors torural districts and smaller urban districts in different partsof the country. These reports have in the main a localinterest but it is impossible to look through the serieswithout realising how frequently the system of sanitarygovernment by district councils of these areas is foundaltogether inefficient in practice. The inspectors, after

reporting on defective conditions of housing, undesirable ordangerous water-supplies, neglect to supervise cowsheds andmilling, and many other matters which become almostmonotonous by repetition, nearly always point to the

unsatisfactory circumstances of the local public healthservice as the first matter on which reform is necessary.In many of these reports, combination of a number ofadjoining districts for the purpose of securing a singlespecially qualified medical officer is advocated but unlessthe Local Government Board can be induced to abandonits well-known objections to compelling the combina-tion of unwilling districts for this purpose it is tobe feared that much of the labour expended on theseinspections and reports will have been thrown away. In

regard to "inspectors of nuisances," or sanitary inspectorsas they are generally called, the Board can indirectly bringabout improvements by exercising its power of allowing orrefusing repayment of half this officer’s salary from countyfunds. But it would appear from these reports that this isoften an ineffective weapon, and obviously a district whichelects to pay its inspector a merely nominal sum for nominalservices has little to lose if the repayment of salary is refusedby the Board. From the following reports a few matters ofmore than local interest have been noted for comment.

Sherborne Rural District,1 by Dr. R. W. JOHNSTONE.-Thisis an important milk-producing district in Dorsetshire. Nearlyall the cowkeepers dispose of their produce as milk ; few ofthem make either butter or cheese. About 6000 gallons ofmilk a day are sent out of this district for retail in London,Aldershot, and other places. In addition, about 1000 gallonsa day are made into milk powder at a factory in Sherborne.Little or no attempt is made by the district council toenforce the regulations adopted under the Dairies, Cowsheds,and Milkshops Order. The water available for cooling themilk at the farms often fails to reduce the temperature ofthe milk below 600 F., and many of the cooling sheds areramshackle affairs which readily permit the contamination ofthe milk by dust. "The surroundings are often so filthythat the dairyman has to pass through a quagmire to reachthe cooling shed." In one cowshed the normal method ofcleansing the shed was to shovel the manure throughthe windows, leaving the walls inside caked with filth.Uncleanliness and faulty construction of walls and floorsof cowsheds were everywhere met with. Milkers as a

rule do not wash their hands or cleanse the cows’ uddersbefore milking. The large London dairies which deal withfarmers in this district usually insist, in their printed agree.ments, upon the wearing of a clean blouse by the milker,cleansing of hands and udder, and like matters. But ncattempt seems to be made to find out if the farmer is fulfillingthe conditions of his contract. Dr. Johnstone found that thEdairy farmers were more opposed to reform in the personalmethods of their milkers than to any proposition in the waof improved ventilation and drainage of the cowsheds. SomEof them said that if the regulations on this matter wereinsisted upon they would abandon dairy-farming. He add.,that the sooner men with these ideas abandon dairy-farmingthe better it will be for the health of the children and otherswho consume the milk.

1 London: Wyman and Sons, Fetter-lane; Edinburgh : Oliver andBoyd; Dublin: E. Ponsonby. No. 285. Price 3d.

Aberayron Registration District,2 by Dr. W. W. E.FLETCHER.-Inspection of the three districts comprised inthis registration area (Aberayron urban and rural andNew Quay urban) brought out the fact that the councilsconcerned completely neglected their elementary duties asto drainage, water-supply, closet accommodation, and othermatters, and resulted in Dr. Fletcher raising the question ofimproving the public health service of the whole of Cardigan-shire by the combination of all its contained districts for thepurpose of appointing a single medical officer of health. Dr.Fletcher points out that Westmorland has a combination ofdistricts of this kind and that the results contrast favourablywith those of Cardigan, in which there are no fewer than13 medical officers of health who between them receive no .more than .B380 per annum.

, Tregaron Rural District,3 by Dr. E. P. MANBY.-Theshortcomings of sanitary administration in Cardiganshireare also brought out by this report. Public water-suppliesare urgently needed in many parts of the district but thedistrict council has refused to take action even in caseswhere the cost of carrying out the recommendations of themedical officer of health for this purpose would have beenalmost negligible. The council has recently appointed as itsinspector of nuisances a draper’s assistant at a salary oflls. 6d. a week. The population of the district is about8000 and its area is 189 square miles. Dr. Manby takesoccasion to point out that the Dairies, Cowsheds, and Milk-shops Order applies to all cowkeepers whether they sell milkor only make cheese and butter, although in the latter casethere is exemption from regulations made under the Order.Misconception on this matter appears to be prevalent, as

reference is made to it in several reports of this series.Bourne Urban District,4 by Dr. F. ST. GEORGE MmART.-

The abundance of water which is obtained in this districtwherever the Lincolnshire limestone is bored into has

incidentally given rise to some serious difficulties. Anartesian well with an abundant yield can be made almostanywhere by sinking a shaft, and owners of houses andbusiness premises naturally prefer this method of supply toresorting to the public service. A great many of these boresare not sealed properly and leakage is freely and constantlytaking place into the ground in their neighbourhood. Amongother objections to this leakage is the effect upon the sewageof the town. This amounts to more than 60 gallons per headof population in dry weather and the high degree of dilutiongreatly interferes with the satisfactory purification of thesewage at reasonable cost.

Hicntingdon Rural District,5 by Dr. R. D. SWEETING.-The sanitary condition of a portion of this district has beenadversely affected by neglect to cleanse streams and water-ways. In some places, such as Alconbury, serious floodsappear to be increasingly common. This frequent floodingcauses serious discomfort and inconvenience, and, as Dr.Sweeting points out, it obviously tends to foster the preva-lence of rheumatism, bronchitis, and various diseases asso-ciated with dampness of sites and dwellings. The streams inquestion are backwaters of the Ouse and there seems to be nopublic authority upon which their cleansing depends. The

county council disclaims any such duty. The neglected con-dition of the streams, however, is not confined to the back-waters but extends to the river Ouse itself. After a prolongedlitigation on the subject of repair of locks, which terminatedby a decision in the House of Lords in 1904, all navigationon the Ouse above St. Ives has come to a complete standstill;the river is ceasing to be navigable and in the absence ofdredging and weeding and repairs to the locks a fertile cause .

of local flooding is created. It may be hoped that the RoyalCommission on Canals and Waterways may be able to makeeffective recommendations to improve the very unsatisfactoryconditions which this report discloses.

Hartley Wintney -Rural District,6 by Dr. J. S. Low.-Inthis district of Hampshire, which adjoins Farnborough, ithas lately been the custom to receive town children sent bycharitable persons for a country holiday. Dr. Low showsthat the houses in which these children are received are ofteninsanitary and become grossly overcrowded as a consequence

1 of their visit. He recommends that the local agent whoarranges for the housing of the children should be required togive an undertaking that no dwelling should be used for the

2 Ibid., No. 283. Price 5d.3 Ibid., No. 284. Price 3d.4 Ibid., No. 289. Price 3d.5 Ibid., No. 278. Price 6d.6 Ibid., No. 288. Price 4d.

Page 2: LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD

1784

purpose until the sanitary inspectors are satisfied as to thEadequacy of the accommodation for the number proposed t(be received. The report also draws attention to the pollutiolof watercress beds at Crondall and Crookham by overflows aoakage from neighbouring cesspits.

Wineheombe Rural District,7 by Dr. S. W. WHEATON.-Inthe course of this report Dr. Wheaton refers to the building’which has lately taken place on the slopes of Cleeve Hill,,near the well-known golf course there. Some of thesedwellings are served by cesspools the contents of which soakaway into the ground, and this method of disposal of sewage isopen to considerable risk. The water supply of the houses isobtained from a number of wells of varying depth sunk in

..gardens or by the roadsides in close proximity to the dwellings.The underlying soil is formed of tumbled masses of rock(inferior oolite) mixed with lias clay. There has been.a succession of landslips hereabouts and as a result wateris found at varying depths as it is seeking its way tothe surface through the debris. In such conditions there isspecial risk in the proximity of the local wells to leakingcesspools. An outbreak of enteric fever in the autumn of1906 appears to have been due to specific infection of thedrinking water furnished by certain wells which were liable,to pollution in this way. Steps are being taken to providesewers for houses in this part of the district but Dr. Wheatonpoints out that the risk of recurrence of the disease in

,existing circumstances is considerable.

VITAL STATISTICS.

HEALTH OF ENGLISH TOWNS.

IN 76 of the largest English towns 7503 births and 4954’deaths were registered during the week ending Dec. 14th.The annual rate of mortality in these towns, which had been15’3, 16’6, and 16’0 per 1000 in the three precedingweeks, rose again to 16 1 per 1000 last week. During thefirst 11 weeks of the current quarter the death-rate has

.averaged 15 4 per 1000, the rate in London during the’same period being 14’ 8 per 1000. The lowest ratesilast week in the 76 towns were 7’ 4 in Grimsby, 7 - 8 inDevonport, 8 3 in King’s Norton, 9’ 3 in Hornsey, and 9’ 5in Walthamstow ; the highest rates were 23’ 3 in Newcastle-- on-Tyne, 24-0 in Merthyr Tydfil 1, 24 . 1 in West Bromwich,26 - 6 in Stockton-on-Tees, 27.6 in Rhondda, and 28’ 9 inPreston. The 4954 deaths in these towns were 32 in excess ofthe number in the previous week, and included 374 whichwere referred to the principal epidemic diseases,.against 397, 424, and 388 in the three preceding weeks ;’these deaths included 107 from measles, 95 from whooping-<cough, 57 from diphtheria, 47 from diarrhoea, 40 from scarletfever, and 28 from "fever" (principally enteric), but notany from small-pox. No death from any of these epidemicdiseases was registered last week in Tottenham, Norwich,Stockport, Huddersfield, or in nine other of the 76 towns;the death-rates from these diseases, however, ranged upwardsto 3’ 6 in Newcastle-on-Tyne, 3’ 8 in Tynemouth, 4’ 5 in WestBromwich, 4 -7 in Bootle, 4’ 9 in York, 5’ 5 in Merthyr Tydfil,and 5’9 9 in Barrow-in-Furness. The fatal cases of measles,which had been 91, 105, and 112 in the three precedingweeks, declined again to 107 in the week under notice, and,caused death-rates ranging upwards to 2’ 0 in Stockton-on-’Tees, 2 - 3 in Bootle, 2 - 7 in Merthyr Tydfil, 2’ 9 in Tyne-"mouth, 4’ 3 in York, and 5’ 9 in Barrow-in-Furness. Thedeaths from whooping-cough, which had been 72 and 106 inthe two previous weeks, fell last week to 95, the highest death-rates from this disease being 1 - 1 in Northampton, 1 - 2 in- Gateshead, 1 . 5 in Hastings and in Warrington, 1 .6 in

Bootle, and 1 - 9 in Newcastle-on-Tyne. The fatal cases of

diphtheria, which had been 70, 82, and 60 in the three pre-ceding weeks, further declined to 57 in the week under notice;the death-rates from this cause ranged upwards to 1 - 1 in-East Ham, 1 - 4 in Newport (Mon.), and 1 .9 in Halifax.Diarrhoea, which has shown a continuously declining mor-tality since the first week of the quarter, caused 47 deaths;last week, the highest death-rate being 2’ 3 in WestBromwich. Scarlet fever was proportionally most fatal inWalsall, where the rate was 1 - 1 per 1000 ; while thedeaths referred to "fever" " did not give a rate of morethan 1 - 0 per 1000 in any of the 76 towns. The numberof scarlet fever patients under treatment in the Metro-

-,-p3litan Asylums Hospitals and the London Fever Hos-pital, which had been 5686, 5676, and 5581 at the end

7 Ibid., No. 291. Price 3d.

, of the three preceding weeks, had further fallen to 5352. at the end of last week ; 500 new cases were admitted duringithe week, against 597, 623, and 554 in the three preceding. weeks. The deaths in London referred to pneumonia and

other diseases of the respiratory organs, which had risenfrom 204 to 355 in the five preceding weeks, fell again last

. week to 348, and were 72 below the number in the correspond-ing periods of the five preceding years 1902-06. The causes of32, or 0’6 per cent., of the deaths in the 76 towns last weekwere not certified either by a registered medical practitioneror by a coroner. All the causes of death were duly certifiedin Leeds, Bristol, West Ham, Salford, Portsmouth, and in53 other of the 76 towns; six uncertified deaths were

registered in Birmingham, five in Liverpool, three inLondon, and two each in Sheffield, Preston, and SouthShields.

____

HEALTH OF SCOTCH TOWNS.

The annual rate of mortality in eight of the principalScotch towns, which had been 16 - 7, 19 - 3, and 20 - 6 per 1000in the three preceding weeks, declined again to 20’ 0 per1000 in the week ending Dec. 14th, but was 3’ 9 per 1000above the mean rate during the same period in the76 large English towns. Among these Scotch towns thedeath-rates ranged from 14’ 3 in Aberdeen and 16’ 9 inEdinburgh to 25’2 in Dundee and 25.6 in Leith. The696 deaths registered in these eight towns were 20 fewerthan the number in the preceding week, and included127 which were referred to the principal epidemic diseases,against 75, 111, and 132 in the three preceding weeks ;of these, 71 resulted from measles, 24 from whooping-cough, 18 from diarrhoea, eight from diphtheria, three fromscarlet fever, two from enteric fever, and one from cerebro-spinal meningitis. These 127 deaths were equal to a

rate of 3 - 7 per 1000, which was 2’ 5 per 1000 abovethe mean rate last week from the principal epidemicdiseases in the 76 large English towns. The fatal cases ofmeasles,which had been 33, 43, and 79 in the three precedingweeks, declined last week to 71, of which 43 occurredin Glasgow, 19 in Dundee, six in Greenock, and two inPaisley. The deaths from whooping-cough, which hadbeen 23 and 13 in the two preceding weeks, rose to 24in the week under notice, and included 10 in Glasgow, five inLeith, three in Dundee, and three in Perth. The fatal cases ofdiarrhoea, which had been 36 and 21 in the two precedingweeks, further declined last week to 18, of which 11 wereregistered in Glasgow, three in Dundee, and two in Edinburgh.The eight deaths from diphtheria showed a slight dechnefrom the number in the previous week, and includedfour in Glasgow, two Dundee, and two in Aberdeen.The three fatal cases of scarlet fever occurred re-

spectively in Glasgow, Edinburgh, and Paisley, the twoof enteric fever in Glasgow and Aberdeen, and thedeath from cerebro-spinal meningitis in Edinburgh.The deaths in these eight towns referred to diseases ofthe respiratory organs, including pneumonia, which hadbeen 106, 137, and 167 in the three preceding weeks,declined again last week to 161, but were 28 in excessof the number in the corresponding period of last year.The causes of 24, or 3’ 4 per cent., of the deaths in theseeight towns last week were not certified or not stated; inthe 76 English towns the proportion of uncertified deaths didnot exceed 0’ 6 per cent.

-

HEALTH OF DUBLIN.

The annual rate of mortality in Dublin, which had beenequal to 18 4, 21’ 6, and 26 ’ 7 per 1000 in the three pre-ceding weeks, declined again to 22: . 3 per 1000 in the weekending Dec. 14th. During the first 11 weeks of the currentquarter the death-rate has averaged 21 ’4 per 1000, the ratesduring the same period being 14.8 in London and 14’1 1in Edinburgh. The 167 deaths of Dublin residents registeredduring the week under notice were 33 fewer than thenumber in the preceding week, and included six whichwere referred to the principal epidemic diseases, against10, four, and nine in the three preceding weeks ; ofthese, three resulted from diphtheria, and one eachfrom measles, whooping-cough, and diarrhoea, but not

any from small-pox, from scarlet fever, or from "fever."These six deaths were equal to an annual rate of 0 8per 1000, the death-rate during the same week from theprincipal epidemic diseases being 0’ 9 in London and0 8 in Edinburgh. The 167 deaths from all causes in


Recommended