Date post: | 14-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | m-mirac-cicek |
View: | 222 times |
Download: | 1 times |
of 77
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
1/77
6HPLFRQGXFWRUVDQGHOHFWURQLFFRPSRQHQWVIRUGHVLJQHQJLQHHUV
May 9, 2013A Penton Media Publication
Tune in to EngineeringTV.com
Indy 500Simulate,then celebratepage 38
ELECTRICVEHICLES
GO RACING, page 20
SAND CASTING WITHMETAL FOAM, page 44
HYDRAULICS BEATELECTRIC MOTORS FORHIGH TORQUE, page 48
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
2/77
908-806-9400
www.altechcorp.com/HTML/AltechRepPortal.html
,IEHUYEVXIVIHMR*PIQMRKXSR2I[.IVWI]%PXIGLLEWERI\TIVMIRGIHWXEJJSJIRKMRIIVMRKQERYJEGXYVMRKERHWEPIWTIVWSRRIPXSTVSZMHIXLILMKLIWXUYEPMX]TVSHYGXW[MXLWYTIVMSVWIVZMGI8LMWMWXLI%PXIGL'SQQMXQIRX
:MWMXSYV[IFWMXIXSPSGEXI]SYVPSGEP%PXIGL
6ITVIWIRXEXMZIERHJMRI%PXIGL(MWXVMFYXSVW
We have the UL partsin stock at a better price
to fill your panels.
BUSBARAND0OWER$ISTRIBUTIONs#ERAMIC"LOCKSs#IRCUIT0ROTECTION$EVICESs#ONTACTORS/VERLOAD2ELAYS
$IN%NCLOSURESs$).2AIL4ERMINAL"LOCKSs%MERGENCY3TOPSs%UROPEAN&USESs%UROSTRIPSs&ERRULES&OOT3WITCHESs)NDUSTRIAL%NCLOSURESs)NDUSTRIAL2ELAYSs)NTERFACE-ODULESs,IQUID4IGHT3TRAIN2ELIEFS
-ARKING%NGRAVING3YSTEMSs-OTOR$ISCONNECT3WITCHESs0IN3LEEVE$EVICESs0OWER3UPPLIES0RINTED#IRCUIT"OARD4ERMINAL"LOCKSs0USH"UTTONS0ILOT,IGHTSs2ECEPTACLESs3AFETY2ELAYSs3ENSORS
3LIMLINE2ELAYSs3MART2ELAYSs$).2AILs4IMERSs4OWER,IGHTSs7IRE$UCTS
RS# 101
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
3/77
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
4/77
EATURES
MATERIALS
Goodellowsaluminum
oamismadeby
sandcasting.The oam
hasregular,evenly-spaced
10-mmopenpore cells.
University,andthe VirginiaTechFoundryInstituteorRe-searchandEducation(VTFIRE). Andwhattheyre study-ingis mesoscopictopology.Basically,thisis thegeometricarrangement o the solid phases and voids ranging rom0.1to10mm withinamaterialorproduct.Originallytheteam considered direct-metal additive manuacturingmethods to make ordered-cell metal oam. Methods in-cludeselective lasermelting, electronbeam melting,anddirect-metallasersintering.
Thesemethods canabricateparts withcellulargeom-etries,buteachoptionposedsuchlimitationsasalackocompatibleworkingmaterials,theneed orsupportstruc-tureswhicharediiculttoremove,andcost.Attheendothe day, the teamdecided these techniques are incapableoabricatingthemetaloam orlarge-scaleapplications.
Inaddition,the teamlookedintotried-and-truemeth-odso makingordered-celloam. Commonmethodsin-cludestampingorcrimpingthin sheetsometalinto acor-rugatedshapeandjoiningthemtocreateperiodicstruc-tures;joiningand bondingslottedmetalsheets, extrusionandelectrodischargemachining,andweavingandbrazingmetal ilaments to orm a periodic textile. Each methodcreates repeatable part quality, but they limit the macro-structureo partsto planargeometriesand constrainde-signers to use o a speciic homogeneous mesostructurethroughoutapart.
Sand casting o oams is a relatively new method dat-
Metal oams, also called cellular materials, are metallicbodieswith interdispersed voids called cells. They haveareputation or high strength, low density, and absorbingimpact. This combination works well or military vehi-cleswhere lighterpartscan savemoneyand impact cush-ioningcan bethe dierence between lie ordeath.Traditionally-mademetaloamis stochastic,meaningtheoamhasirregularcells thatarespacedunevenly.I thecellstructureinmetal oamisarrangedand regularitis calledordered-cell oam. Stochastic materials reduce weight asdoordered-cellmetal oams.However,ordered-celloamhassuperior strength,stiness,energy absorption,anditmovesheat.
While there are several methods o making ordered-cell oam, one company is seeing consistent results bymaking metallic oam through the process o sand cast-ing.The problemis thatcurrentmethods osand-castingpatterns are rom the age o subtractive machining pro-cesseswhere parteaturesmust berelativelysimple. Now,researchers are testing additive manuacturing to makecomplexsandcastingswhichcouldcreateanewbreedoordered-cellmetaloams.
Mixing old and new techniquesTheresearchersare romtheDesign, Research,&Edu-
cation or Additive Manuacturing Systems (DREAMS)Laboratory at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State
ADDITIVEMANUFACTURINGcomes to metal foam
Authoredby:
LindseyFrick,[email protected],@MaterialShout
Keypoints Sandcasting is a methodusedto
makeo rdered-cell metal foams.
Aluminumordered-cell foamis lightweight,moves heat, andabsorbs impact.
B inder jet3Dprintedsandcastingscouldcreateahybridmethodtomanufacture metal foam.
Resources
Dr.Christopher Williams.Design,Research, andEducationforAdditiveManufacturingSystems LaboratoryDepartmentofMechanicalEngineeringVirginia PolytechnicInstituteandStateUniversity,http://utwired.engr.utexas.edu/lff/symposium/proceedingsArchive/pubs/Manuscripts/2012/2012-11-Meisel.pdf
Goodfellow Corp., goodfellowusa.com
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com44
INDY 500
One o the major changes computers have injected intothe Indianapolis 500 over the past two decades is thewidespreaduse osimulation.No longerdo designersorrace teams have to schedule racetrack time to determinethe eects o a small tweak to the aerodynamics or rontshock absorbers, a costly and time-consuming process.Instead, they can juggle a ew parameters in a detailedcomputer model o the car and then run it over a trulyrealisticmodeloaspeciicracetrack.Theprogramspitsout detailed and reliable results on speeds, uel consump-tion,downorce, andalaundry listo otherrace-carchar-acteristics.It canalso compresshourso tracktimeinto aewminuteso computerruntime.
Simulation has also spread so that the three groupsmostcloselyinvolvedin Indyracingthe designers,raceteams,andgoverningbody allrelyon it,butin dierentways.
Indy-car designersIndyCarracescurrently allowonlyone chassisor car,
the DW12 rom Dallara Automobili,Varano Melegari,Italy.Weusethree generaltypes osimulationwhen de-signing an Indy car, says Dallaras general manager, An-drea Pontremoli. It lets us go rom the design phase totheracetrackin aboutninemonths eightmonthsspentdesigningthecar oncomputers,then amonthto actuallyassembleit.
Theirsttype osimulationletsDallaraengineersbuilda virtual car using carbon composites. We use inite-element-method sotware at this stage to simulate thecarbon-iber components and structural elements, saysPontremoli.Theysubsequentlyadd otherparts tomodeltheentirecar,minus theengine.
Togetthe overallshapeo thecar anditsaerodynam-
Authoredby:
StephenJ.MrazSenior [email protected]
Resources:ChassisSimTechnologies,chassissim.com
DallaraAutomobili,www.dallara.it
IndyCar,www.indycar.com
PantherRacingTeam,www.pantherracing.com
Thecompanygetssimilardata, butroma romadriv-ers perspective, in a motion simulator. In act, the dataromthedrivingsimulatoris cleanerthanactualtrackdatabecauseitcontainsno signalnoiseor calibrationerrors.Itcombines computers and motion control, along with anexactreplicao thecockpitand dashboard.Sodrivers usethesamecontrols acceleratorandbrakepedals,steeringwheel,andsteering-wheelmountedswitches andget toeelthesame leveloeedbackrom thesteeringwheel andbrakepedalsasi theyweredriving anactualracecar.
The motion simulator even has a thermal tire modelthatletsDallara andteams(or clients)checkout dierenttires and setups or qualiying or racing laps i n dierent
weatherconditions.The driver simulator, much like those used to train
military pilots, has 3D motion, courtesy o 1.5-meter-strokehexapodactuators.They cangenerateup to2 gsoacceleration,whilea 3,500-Wsound systemrecreatesthenoiseandvibrationso ridingin anIndycar. Tocompletetheillusion,a180 12-megapixelscreengives thedriver awraparoundviewothe trackandothercars.
To get data on the track, Dallara runs a special cararound the track that uses laser scanners to measure theentire surace o the track with 10-mm resolution. Thisdata, which includes every rough patch, bump, and curbonthetrack,isdigitizedandtransormedintoinputsorthecomputermodelswheelsand suspension.
When Dallara was designing the DW12 or the 2012season,theIndyCarboardwantedto makesuresaetywaspart o the equation. Dallara complied by adding saetyeatures to the model and design, both mechanical andaerodynamic ones. IndyCar also wanted the new car tohave the same speed and perormance despite the act itwouldusea less-powerulengine.
anomalies.Wind-tunnelsimulationletsus seei whatwelearnedinCFD isvalidon ull-sizedcars.
The inal type o simulation kinematics centersonvehicledynamics.Itletsuslookatthebehaviorotheentirecar,including thetires, ondierentracetracks andracingconditions,saysPontremoli.
The roadtotheBorg-WarnerTrophy, giveneachyeartothewinnerothe Indy500,ispavedwithsimulationandmodeling, twoCADpracticesusedbythe IndyCargoverningbody,the race-carmakers,andthe race teams.
Twoareasthatgeta lotoattentionduringmodeling andsimulation are the
rontwingandsuspensions.(Photo:PantherRacingTeam)
icsright,we thenusecomputationalluid-dynamics(CFD)sot-ware to simulate airlow over, under, and around the car, saysPontremoli.
Dallaraalsoreverts toa more-traditionalorm osimulationoneo thecompanystwowindtunnels toensurethe aero-dynamicsareright andthesotware didntmissanydetrimental
Car designers, race teams, even the IndyCar
governing body use simulation to keep theIndy 500 competitive and safe.
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com38 MAY 9, 2013 MACHINE DESIGN.com 39
Simulatingyour way into the
VICTORY CIRCLE
Access our Reader ServiceWeb site to quickly find andrequest information on the
products and services foundin the pages ofMACHINEDESIGN.www.machinedesign.com/rsc
38
44
38
52
48
44
Simulating your wayinto the victory circleSimulation and modeling are helping
race teams, race-carmakers, and the
governing body ofthe Indy 500.
Additive manufacturingcomes to metal foamOrdered-cell metal foamhelpsmove
heat and absorb impact.Researchers
are combining old and newmethods of
sand casting to make the material.
When electricmotors wont doHydraulic motors are a good choice for
applications that demand high torque,
have limited available space, and
operate in rugged environments.
Pumping new lifeinto old machinesMachine retrofitswith advanced
motion controllers boost productivity
and cut costs.
MACHINEDESIGNSLIT EXPRESS
VOLUME 85ISSUE 6
MAY 9, 2013
64
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com2
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
5/77
Buy direct and save on high-quality components
%HVWSULFHVRQSQHXPDWLFV
The NITRA Pneumatics F-Series non-repairable round body stainlesssteel cylinders includes bore sizes from 3/4 to 2 and stroke lengthsfrom 1/2 to 18 to meet a broad range of applications includingwashdown and corrosive environments.
$OO6WDLQOHVV6WHHO3QHXPDWLF&\OLQGHUV)6HULHV
All Stainless Steel Pneumatic Cylinders - F Series
VWDUWDW)'1
v &\OLQGHUERUHVL]HVIURPyWRy
v $LU&\OLQGHUVWURNHOHQJWKVIURPyWRy
v 'RXEOHDFWLQJF\OLQGHUV
v 7KUHHSQHXPDWLFF\OLQGHUPRXQWLQJFRQoJXUDWLRQV
Tubing and Hose
Also available is the A series non-repairablecylinders, with stainless bodies and aluminum end caps.In bore sizes from 7/16 to 2, the A series starts at just $10.50.
Compact Pneumatic
Cylinders - "C" Series
VWDUWDW&'
v &\OLQGHUERUHVL]HVIURPWR
v &\OLQGHUVWURNHOHQJWKVIURPWR
v 'RXEOHDFWLQJPLQLDLUF\OLQGHUV
v ,QWHUFKDQJHDEOHZLWKRWKHUPLQLDFWXDWRU
pDWF\OLQGHURUSDQFDNHF\OLQGHUEUDQGV
Heavy Duty NFPA Tie Rod
Pneumatic Cylinders - "D" Series
VWDUWDW''70
v &\OLQGHUERUHVL]HV
v &\OLQGHUVWURNHOHQJWKV
IURPWR
v 'RXEOHDFWLQJ
F\OLQGHUV
v )ODQJHSLYRWDQG
FOHYLVF\OLQGHU
PRXQWRSWLRQV DYDLODEOH
0RUHF\OLQGHUVHULHVDOVRLQWHUFKDQJHDEOHZLWKSRSXODUEUDQGV
Fittings andAir Couplings
Solenoid Valvesand Manifolds Air Preparation
Digital PressureSwitches/Transmitters
SolenoidValve Cables
Pneumatic AirBlow Guns
www.automationdirect.com
1-800-633-0405
Go online or call to get complete information,request your free catalog, or place an order.
www.automationdirect.com/pneumatic-parts
Dual Rod Guided
Pneumatic Cylinders - "E" Series
VWDUWDW(00'0
v VL]HVDYDLODEOH
v (LJKWERUHVL]HVIURPPP
WRPPv &\OLQGHUVWURNHOHQJWKVIURPPP
WRPP
v 'RXEOHDFWLQJF\OLQGHUV
Also Available
RS# 103
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
6/77
EPARTMENTS
EDITORIALAccountability in the eyes oflegislators
EDITORIAL STAFF
LETTERS
SCANNING FOR IDEASSubminiature switchsurvivessplashes
Simple shaft supports eliminate realignment problems
REPORTERS NOTEBOOK
LOOKING BACK
COMMENTARYNASA pencil whipsgoals to meet budgets
TAVENNER ON SAFET YLookout below
INTERVIEWLocal-for-local strategy drives U.S. expansion Berend Bracht
VANTAGE POINTSuppliermarketplaces come ofage FrankRusso
FE UPDATETwo FEs, one result
PRODUCT SPOTLIGHTBearings & mechanical components
BUSINESS INDEX
AD INDEX
BUSINESS STAFF
BACKTALK
For customized article reprints and permissions,please contact:WrightsMedia, 877-652-5295, ore-mail [email protected].
Editorial content is indexed in the Applied ScienceTechnology Index, the Engineering Index,SciSearchandResearchAlert.Microfilm copiesavailable fromNA Publishing Inc., 4750VentureDr.,Suite 400, AnnArbor, MI 48108, Ph:734-302-6500 or800-420-6272.
Permission tophotocopy isgranted forusersregisteredwith theCopyrightClearanceCenter (CCC) Inc. tophotocopy any article,with the exception ofthose forwhichseparate ownership is indicated on the firstpageofthe article, provided that the base fee of$1.25percopy ofthe article, plus$.60perpage ispaid toCCC,222RosewoodDr.,Danvers, MA 01923 (CodeNo.0024-9114/13$1.25 + .60).
Subscription Policy:MACHINEDESIGN is circulated toresearch, development, and design engineersprimarilyengaged in the design andmanufacture ofmachinery,electrical/electronic equipment, andmechanicalequipment.To obtain a complimentary subscriptionsee ourWebpage atsubmag.com/sub/mn.For changeofaddressfill out a newqualification formatsubmag.com/sub/mn.
Printed in U.S.A.,Copyright 2013.Penton Media, Inc.All rightsreserved.MACHINEDESIGN (ISSN0024-9114) ispublished semimonthly except fora single issue inJanuary, February, April, June, July, August, and Octoberby Penton Media, Inc., 9800 MetcalfAve., Overland Park,KS66212.
Paid subscriptions include issues1-16. IssueNo.17
(OEM HandbookandSupplierDirectory) isavailable atadditional cost.Rates:U.S.:one year,$139; two years,$199;.Canada/Mexico:one year,$159; two years,$239;All other countries:one year,$199; two years,$299.Cost forbackissuesare U.S.$10.00per copyplus tax,Canada$15.00per issueplus tax, and Intl$20.00perissue.OEM HandbookandSupplierDirectory,$50.00plus tax.Prepaidsubscription:Penton Media (MACHINEDESIGN), P.O.Box2100, Skokie IL 60076-7800.PeriodicalsPostage Paid at Shawnee Mission, KS, and at additionalmailingoffices.
Can GST #R126431964.Canadian Post PublicationsMailAgreementNo.40612608.Canada return address: IMEXGlobalSolutions, P.O.Box25542, London, Ont.,N6C6B2.
Digitalsubscription rates:U.S.:one year,$69; two years,$99;.Canada/Mexico:one year,$79; two years,$119; All
other countries:one year,$99; two years,$149.POSTMASTER:Send change ofaddressnotice toCustomerService, MACHINEDESIGN, P.O.Box 2100,Skokie,IL 60076-7800.
ON THE COVERA CFD image ofthe Panther
Racing Team car.
10
12
16
20
26
33
8
35
36
37
60
62
68
69
70
71
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com4
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
7/77
TheTruthAboutCompressedAir!ComparetheseBlowoffsTere are a variety of ways to blow the water from the bottles shown in the photo below, butwhich method is best? o decide, we ran a comparison test on the same application using
four different blowoff methods: drilled pipe, flat air nozzles, Super Air Knife (each usingcompressed air as a power source), and a blower supplied air knife (using an electric motoras a power source). Each system consisted of two twelve inch long air knives. Te followingcomparison proves that the EXAIR Super Air Knife is the best choice for your blowoff,cooling or drying application.
Te goal for each of the blowoff choices was to use the least amount of air possible to get thejob done (lowest energy and noise level). Te compressed air pressure required was 60 PSIGwhich provided adequate velocity to blow the water off. Te blower used had a ten horsepowermotor and was a centrifugal type blower at 18,000 RPM. Te table at the bottom of the pagesummarizes the overall performance. Since your actual part may have an odd configuration,holes or sharp edges, we took sound level measurements in free air (no impinging surface).
DrilledPipe
Tis common blowoff is very inexpensiveand easy to make. For this test, weused (2) drilled pipes, each with (25)1/16" diameter holes on 1/2" centers.
As shown in the test results below, thedrilled pipe performed poorly. Te initialcost of the drilled pipe is overshadowedby its high energy use. Te holes areeasily blocked and the noise level isexcessive - both of which violate OSHArequirements. Velocity across the entirelength was very inconsistent with spikesof air and numerous dead spots.
FlatAirNozzlesAs shown below, this inexpensive airnozzle was the worst performer. It isavailable in plastic, aluminum andstainless steel from several manufacturers.Te flat air nozzle provides someentrainment, but suffers from manyof the same problems as the drilledpipe. Operating cost and noise level areboth high. Some manufacturers offerflat air nozzles where the holes can beblocked - an OSHA violation. Velocity
was inconsistent with spikes of air.
BlowerAir Knife
Te blower proved to be an expensive,noisy option. As noted below, thepurchase price is high. Operatingcost was considerably lower than thedrilled pipe and flat air nozzle, but
was comparable to EXAIRs SuperAir Knife. Te large blower with itstwo 3" (8cm) diameter hoses requiressignificant mounting space comparedto the others. Noise level was highat 90 dBA. Tere was no option forcycling it on and off to conserve energylike the other blowoffs. Costly bearingand filter maintenance along withdowntime were also negative factors.
EXAIRSuperAir KnifeTe Super Air Knife did an exceptional
job of removing the moisture on onepass due to the uniformity of the laminarairflow. Te sound level was extremelylow. For this application, energy use wasslightly higher than the blower but can beless than the blower if cycling on and offis possible. Safe operation is not an issuesince the Super Air Knife can not be dead-ended. Maintenance costs are low sincethere are no moving parts to wear out.
The Super Air Knife is the low cost way to blowoff, dry, clean and cool.
If you think compressed air is too expensive and noisy - read this. The facts will surprise you!
Blowof ComparisonComp. Air Horsepower
Required
SoundLeveldBA
PurchasePrice
AnnualElectrical
Cost*
Approx. AnnualMaintenance
Cost
FirstYearCostType o blowof PSIG BAR SCFM SLPM
Drilled Pipes 60 4.1 174 4,924 35 91 $50 $4,508 $920 $5,478
Flat Air Nozzles 60 4.1 257 7,273 51 102 $208 $6,569 $1,450 $8,227
Blower Air Knie 3 0.2 N/A N/A 10 90 $5,500 $1,288 $1,500 $8,288
Super Air Knie 60 4.1 55 1,557 11 69 $534 $1,417 $300 $2,251
*Basedonnational averageelectricitycosto8.3centsperkWh.Annual costrefects40hoursperweek,52weeksperyear.
FactsaboutBlowersEnergy conscious plants might think ablower to be a better choice due to its slightly
lower electrical consumption comparedto a compressor. In reality, a blower is anexpensive capital expenditure that requiresfrequent downtime and costly maintenanceof filters, belts and bearings. Here are someimportant facts:
Filters must be replaced every oneto three months.
Belts must be replaced every three tosix months.
ypical bearing replacement is at least oncea year at a cost near $1000.
Blower bearings wear out quickly dueto the high speeds (17-20,000 RPM)required to generate effective airflows.
Poorly designed seals that allow dirt andmoisture infiltration and environmentsabove 125F decrease the one yearbearing life.
Many bearings can not be replaced in thefield, resulting in downtime to send theassembly back to the manufacturer.
Blowers take up a lot of space and oftenproduce sound levels that exceed OSHA
noise level exposure requirements. Airvolume and velocity are of ten diffi cult tocontrol since mechanical adjustments arerequired.
o discuss an application, contact:
EXAIR Corporation11510 Goldcoast DriveCincinnat i, Ohio 45249-1621(800) 903-9247Fax: (513) 671-3363email: [email protected]
www.exair.com/45/423b.htm
See the Super Air Knife in action.www.exair.com/45/akvideo.htm
RS# 104
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
8/77
Eliminateubrication.ncrease
ife.
More than 7,000 sizes available.
o minimum order. No surcharges.
ubrication-free. Maintenance-free.
Most materials available in sleeve
nd flange designs, in inch and
metric sizes.
glide plastic bearings can replace
ronze, metal-backed and custom
njection-molded bearings in
most any application. Low-wear,
conomical, dry-running, and best
f all predictable. There are over 30
arious iglide materials to choose
om depending on your unique
pplication requirements.
all for your free catalog or sample
vailable from stock today!
gus.com/iglideO Box 14349 [email protected]
ast Providence, RI 02914 800-521-2747
Plastics for longer life
EDITORSWEBP
ICKS
Whats new online machinedesign.com
New developments in additive manufacturingAn engineerfromEOS discusses the latest developments in additive
manufacturing usingplastics and metals. The technique is increasingly
being used formedical, industrial, and automotive applications to
produce lightweight, high-strengthpartswithspecial engineered
structures. Learn more at
www.engineeringtv.com/
video/New-Developments-in-
Additive-Ma;Pacific-Design-
Manufacturing-20.
App identifies
hydraulic fittingsParker HanniinsTube FittingDiv.hasreleased the free
FittingFinder app that simplifies
hydraulic tube fitting and adapter
identification. Usersselect the
fittingshape, end type, size, and
material or enter the part
number and the appprovides
specs, dimensions, and a linkto
CADfiles.Download FittingFinder
for Android or Apple devices, or
a Web-based version, at www.
parkerfittingfinder.com.
Linear-motiondesign guideHaydon KerkMotion Solutions
has a new catalog and design guide
on linearmotion. Majorsections
coverprecision leadscrew and nut
assemblies; linear actuators and
stepper-motor drives; and motor-
ized and nonmotorized linear-rail
systems.Content includesproduct
information, a technology overview,
sizing charts, and product compari-
sons.Download orrequest a printed
copy atwww.haydonkerk.com.
Sensor site
Omegasredesigned Web site(www.omega.com) provides engi-
neerswith an in-depthresource for
measurement and control. It covers
numeroussensing technologies,
including temperature, pressure,
force, and flow; and applications
such aswireless, test, process con-
trol, and powermonitoring. The site
also includes technical references
and product manuals, numerous
product configurators, and access
to FAQs and online help.Recognizing EE expertsAgilentTechnologieshas
launched its Agilent Certified
Expert recognition program ofin-
dividuals demonstrating expertise
with the companysproduct design
and modeling tools. It provides
certification to formally accredit
theirskills and a forumfor top us-
ers. It also offers access to industry
experts, and the potential for
consulting opportunities. Formoreinformation, see www.agilent.com/
find/eesof-ace.
Free Webcast:CUSTOM COMPOSITES FOR HIGHPERFORMANCE APPLICATIONS
Thursday, May 9, 11:00 a. m. ETThisWebinar, presented by IDI Composites and Norplex-Micarta,will lookatthe many different types ofadvanced composites and illustrate the benefits
they offer in numerousmarkets. The presentation will provide a primer on the
design and manufacture ofhigh-performance prepregs, laminated sheets,
convolute tubing, and compression molded shapes alongwith customizations
to tailorperformance to specific needs. It will also delve into resins,
reinforcement materials, and manufacturingprocesses, aswell as the benefits
ofnewstructural thermoset compounds. Learn more and register, or view the
archived presentation anytime, at http://tinyurl.com/bw3fgyy.
RS# 105 MAY 9, 2013
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
9/77
They save you a bundle.
The engineers choice
Talk about a bundle of advantages! EC technology from ebm-papst not only gives you more control options for advancedapplications than AC technology, but its high efficiency also saves a whole lot of energy. Furthermore, it prolongs the servicelife of air-conditioning and refrigeration systems and makes their operation much quieter. The electronics are completelyintegrated into the motor, making these truly plug and blow fans. One more thing: our EC technology enables you to createan energy-saving bundle of several hundred fans and control them from a single workstation.
For a whole bundle of information, visit www.ebmpapst.us/hyblade
RS# 106
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
10/77
EDITORIAL
Accountability in theeyes oflegislators
Springisoftenthe timewhentalkinthe officeturnstopayraisesandsalaryincreases.Thesameoftenholdstruefortopcompanymanagers.But ifyouare runningacompany,discussions aboutyourpaycan getcomplicated.Thereasonisthatcompanieshavecaughta lotofflackfrompoliticiansovertheyearsabouthowtheypaytheirtoppeople.Whenhewascampaigninginthe 1990s,forexample,Bill Clintonwantedtostopcompaniesfrombeingabletodeductexcessiveexecutivepayfromtheirtaxes. Inthe2008presidential race,bothcandidatesdissed CEOsmakingmoreinonedaythantheirworkersaremakinginayear.
Legislatorshavedisplayedparticularangstoverwhatcompanymanag-ersmakeinthestockmarket. Youcantracethishandwringingbackto
legislationpassedin 1993,whicheliminatedcorporatetaxdeductionsforexecutivepayabove $1 million. Ithadtheunintendedconsequenceofdra-maticallyboostingperformance-basedpayintheformofstockoptions,justasthestockmarkettookoffintheroaring 1990s.
Executiveremunerationskyrocketedasaresult.Butgrantingofstockoptionsthiswaybroughtafocusonmanagingcompaniesforshort-termresultsand,inafewcases,promptedillegal behaviorbyCEOs.
Thatillegal behaviorwasonereasonpolitical rhetoricaboutexecutivepayreachedahighpitchinthe2008presidential race.Thetoneofbothcandidates couldbesummarizedbyonequotefromacampaignspeechofthetime: Itsaboutchangingasystemwherebadbehaviorisrewardedsothatwecanhold CEOsaccountable,andmakesuretheyreactingina
waythatsgoodfortheircompany,goodforoureconomy,andgoodforAmerica,notjustgoodforthemselves,acandidatesaid.Keepthatpronouncementinmindasyouponderrecentdevelopments
tocontrol theperksofanotherhighlycompensatedbunch: membersofCongress.Readersmayrecall thatinNovemberof2011,theTVshow60Minutesdid anexposeabout legislatorsactingoninsideinformationaboutpubliccompanies.Ordinarycitizenscan bejai ledforbenefitingfromsuchinformation,butmembersofCongresswereexemptfromtherules.Manyin Congresshaveaccesstomarket-moving,nonpublicinfor-mationandhavebenefittedhandsomelyfromit,accordingto60Min-utes.AfewmonthsaftertheTVshowaired, CongresspassedtheStockActthatmadeinsider-trading lawsapplyto Congressand Congressionalstaffersaswell.
TheStockActpassedwithgreatfanfare.ButrecentlyCongresspassedabill reversingbigchunksoftheActwithhardlyamention: Thee-mailedannouncementofitwasonesentence long.Specifically, Congressrepealedtherequirementthatitsmembersandstaffersposttheirfinancial transac-tionsonlineinasearchableformat. Congressional insidertradingisstillillega l,butnowthe onlywaytomakesurethishasnottranspiredisbytravelingtoWashington, D.C.,visitingthebasementofthe HouseOfficeBuilding,andaskingtoseethefinancial disclosureformsoftheindividualyouareinterestedin.
Congressclaimspostingthisinformationonline wou ldposeana-tional risk. Cynicssaythe onlynational riskisto Congressional bankaccounts.
Mytake: Congressseemstobea lotbetteratholding CEOsaccountablethanthemselves.
Leland Teschler, Editor
RS# 107
MAY 9, 2013
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
11/77
Make Last-ChanceProtection Your
First Priority.High-strength safety screens from Lee.
Protect critical hydraulic components with screens tough enough to take on
severe transients and complete clogging. Lee Hi-Bar safety screens wont
burst or collapse at pressures up to 7,500 psid in either flow direction.
Make Lee your first choice for last-chance protection.
Call 1-800-LEEPLUG or visit www.TheLeeCo.com today.
One-piece construction from
solid bar stock Hole sizes from 35 to 1,200
microns
7,500 psid pressure capability
Flange, Boss or Fitting mount Bidirectional flow
Custom design capability
Westbrook London Paris Frankfurt Milan Stockholm
The Lee Company2 Pettipaug Road
Westbrook, CT 06498USA
RS# 108
See us at the Paris Air Show, Hall 3 Stand A63
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
12/77
&\OLQORFN%HDULQJ
5HWDLQLQJ&RPSRXQG
$XWRPDWHG'LVSHQVLQJ
6ROXWLRQV
+LJK3HUIRUPDQFH$GKHVLYHV6HDODQWV
DQG3UHFLVLRQ3URFHVVLQJ6ROXWLRQV
,62
KHUQRQFRP VDOHV#KHUQRQFRP
SDP/SI designs, manufactures and modifies metal and plastic power
transmission components such as: gears, timing belts, timing belt pul-
leys, couplings, gearheads, speed reducers and much more. A hugeinventory of 130,000 precision and commercial components provides
convenient solutions to any problem our customers may have.
iV/iUi`i*>]9{
ISO9001R E G I S T E R E D
SDPISO9001UAS9100
R E G I S T E R E DSI
:(:,//.((3xnn
]-
EDITORIAL STAFF
1300 E. 9thSt.Cleveland, OH 44114-1503
EDITOR
Leland [email protected]
MANAGING EDITORKenneth J.Korane
SENIOR EDITORSElisabeth Eitel
Stephen J. [email protected]
ASSOCIATE EDITORLindsey Frick
INDUSTRY COVERAGE:
AUTOMOTIVE,PACKAGING,MEDICAL
Stephen J. Mraz
CAD/CAM, MANUFACTURINGElisabeth EitelLindsey Frick
FASTENING & JOINING,MATERIALSLindsey Frick
FLUID POWERKenneth J.Korane
MECHANICALElisabeth EitelLindsey Frick
Kenneth J.Korane
EDITORIAL PRODUCTION
Denise GrecoEditorialProduction Manager
Randall L. RubenkingArt Director
RS# 109
RS# 110
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
13/77
brawny & brainy.Tough hydraulics with easy-to-use motion control solutions.
Whether its re-positioning a large solar panel to soak up moresun, manipulating individual motion-simulator theater seats or any
application in between, Continental Hydraulics Valves and Motion
Control Solutions simplify machine logic for smarter, more accurate
motion control with an intuitive, easy-to-use interface. Our unique
solutions are fit-for-purpose, allowing you to dictate valve position,
force and flow with exacting precision from a distance.
Continental Hydraulics solutions deliver toughness controlled
by intelligence:
s Proportional Control Valves smooth, precise load control with a
rugged durability thats unparalleled.
s Motion Control Solutions faster, more accurate, user-adjustedvariables all controlled from your Microsoft Windows laptop.
For stronger, smarter solutions that meet your needs, make the move
to Continental Hydraulics.
952. 895. 6400 | www.continentalhydraulics.com
PUMPS VALVES POWER UNITS
RS# 111
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
14/77
Silly orexaggerated?
Readers can relate to the silly specificationsfound on some products,but some readersfind them understandable. And anotherreader ques-tions the number ofengineeringhoursput into a design.
ni ng an object in 3D (Objec tsPrinted from Objec tsScanned,Elisabeth Eitels blog, March 11), itbegs the question: Ifyou scan andprint someonespatented or copy-righted item, are you required topay them a fee? It seems that wereconstantly hearing about intel-
lectual property beingstolen andcheaply reproduced abroad. I won-derhow these companieswouldfeel ifsomebody scanned their de-sign using their own scanner andthen undersold them.
Michael Sweeney
Freelancing it
Youve run through a lot ofthe avail-able optionsforfreelance work
(How to Become a Freelance En-gineer, Lindsey Fricks blog, March7). My hopesfor the industry (or theCAD crowd) is that it moves towardscrowdtestingrather than crowd-sourcing. That could include a smallanalysis ofa buyersproject beforeexclusively hiring a freelancerfor afull project. Ideally, that would putthe emphasis on skilled designersinstead ofcommoditized prices.
MacKenzieBrown
Do those figures add up?
In a recent story on a new type ofrecreational water vehicle (Am-ph ibian Jet Ski hit s 45 mph onLand and Sea, Nov. 20), it says: En-gineers at Gibbsspent more than18 months and 75,000 engineeringman-hours adapting the engine tothe Quadski.
Ifwe take 2,000 hours as a man-year, than 18 months would be
3,000 hr.Dividing that into 75,000means that 25 engineersworked fulltime on this one task(adapting theengine) for a year and a half.
Silly SpecsYour editorial on odd specifications(Silliness at 40 Below, Nov. 20)strucka chord withme.Working on
five continents, Ive seen numerousinstances ofsilly specifications inmany cultures and languages andIm always amazed at how, oncewritten, specsseem to acquire bib-lical respect and authority.Whenpeople were strugglingwith theCadillac ashtray problem, no oneseems to have had the wit to take aviewfrom 10,000 feet and ask:Whyare we doing this? Orperhaps bet-ter, Why are we doing it thisway?
One ofthe silliest specs I had to
deal with involved a fighterplane.The contract mandated that a dis-play needle on an engine instru-ment could only deviate orwigglesomuch.The instrument or displaymetthisspecification by a wide marginwith one exception:Needle excur-sionsslightly exceededspecified lim-itswhen the onboard gun wasfired.
The fact that the pilot washighlyunlikely to be checkinghis engineinstrumentswhile firingweapons
was not considered. The spec wasthe spec.So after a long battle, thecompany and the Air Forceshookhands and mutually agreed to enddeliveries ofthe instrument. The 500units already in the field were neverheard from again.
Richard J.Reilly
I worked for the TandyCorp. in theearly 80s as a quality-control techni-cian. I was told to place computersin the 40F environmental unit for 4hours to simulate a 4-hour truckingshipment in the mountains. I thentested the computers after theywarmed up. I was also instructedto place software/hardware in the120/140F environmental unit for4 hours to simulate a 4-hour truckride through the desert.
Thiskind oftesting alwaysmadesense to me.
MarcusRasco
Can we scan the scanners?
Since we are now at the point ofnot only pr inting, but also scan-
That seems like a lot ofengineersto workon one taskat a small com-pany. Ifwe assume, for argumentssake, that a man-hour costs thecompany $100 (which isprobablylow), then this one taskwould havecost the company $7.5 million. Thatseemshighfor a product that sells
for$40kand has a limited market. Ifthe profit per Quadski is 20% ($8k),they would have to sell almost athousand unitsjust to cover this onecost. Is it possible that the 75,000figure should really be 7,500?
Barry Schwartz
The estimate of 18 monthsand75,000 engineeringman hoursisac-tuallyaconservativeone.
The Quadskis land-and-water
powertrainsystem is much morecomplexthantheaverageautomo-bilespowertrain.
Theengineandtransmission fi-nallyselectedwassignificantlydiffer-entinsize fromtheengineoriginallyunderconsideration. Ithadadiffer-entoutputshaftlocationanddrive-train, alongwith completelydifferenttorqueandhorsepowercurvesthantheengineoriginally underconsider-ation. Thisrequiredareengineeringofthecoolingsystem, the bodytoac-commodatethenewengine, enginemounts, andfuelsystems, thediffer-ential/driveshaftsandknuckles, thewaterjet, andelectronicstointerfacewith theenginecontrolmodule.
Thenewpowerplantalsorequired:EPA enginecertification, testingandvalidation,andamajorchangetotheassemblyprocesses.
Theengineeringsuppor t frompurchasingandqualitydepartmentsisnotincludedinthe75,000-hourses-
timatebutthiswasneededaswell.There are several additiona l
things you mightnothave beenawareof:
LETTERS
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com12
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
15/77
RS# 112
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
16/77
TM
LETTERS TO THE EDITORPlease include your name, address, anddaytime phone number. Lettersmaybe edited for brevity and to focus on
essential points.Mail: Letters, MACHINE DESIGN,1300 E. 9th St., Cleveland, OH 44114-1503, Fax: 216-621-8469
E-mail, Editorial:[email protected]
time. Automated fiberplacement(AFP) automatically placesstripsof composite materials to buildcomposite structuressuch as theBoeing787. In-situ AFP ofthermo-
plastic composites is a truly addi-tive-manu facturingprocess thatbuildshigh-performance compos-ite structures by bonding compos-ite prepreg tapes in a mannersimi-lar to FDM. It has been in existencelonger than what is nowknown asadditive manufacturing.
DaveHauber
Aluminumwith 3DDesign, March21). Assuming both doors (or otherside panels) are lightened, remov-ingweight on the outersides ofthe
vehicle body does not move thecars center ofgravity toward themiddle ofthe vehicle. It may wellimprove handling but that wouldbe because the moment ofinertiawasreduced.
Thinkabout balancing a bar bellon a fulcrum and then sliding theweights inward equally; the centerofgravity doesnt move.
Andrew J. Brislen
Composite RPIn the article, The future ofaddi-tive manufacturing, March7, itsays: Currently, few options existfor carbon-fiberpartsmade withadditive manufacturing. However,in a sense, all composite parts aremade by additive manufacturingas they are built up one ply at a
1.) Theprogramwasnthandledtotally in-house. A numberofengi-neeringprojectswereoutsourcedtosupplierssuchasFEVandMBE.
2.) A high-speedamphibian isnota simpleproductlikeanauto-mobile. Itpresents newengineeringchallenges. Anamphibian-power-trainchangeiscertainlynotthesim-plisticLegoplug-and-playmotorthereaderseemsto believeexists formajorOEMs. Itinvolvesdevelopingadualpowertrain foron landandwa-ter. The Quadskipowertrain ispro-tectedbyseveralpatents.
3.) If you areanengineerandbe-lieve you couldhavecompletedthis
enginechangetaskin lesstimeandwith fewerresources wewanttointerviewyou ASAP! Larry Weis,Gibbs SportsAmphibian
Inertia mix up
I believe there was an error in a re-cent item (Honda LocksSteel to
LETTERS
RS# 113MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com14
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
17/77
Bosch Rexroth Corporation
www.boschrexroth-us.com
Mastering challenges together Rexroth makes it easy to implement automation.
Our many years experience in a wide range of industries has given us extensive application
knowledge. We offer this comprehensive understanding to the tasks you bring us, leadingto ingenious solutions.
Regardless of the drive technology used, we thought ahead and integrated intelligence
throughout. This consistency makes you more efficient from planning to star t-up and
daily operation. Your benefits are real: Increased productivity, improved energy efficiency
and maximum machine safety. You can count on Rexroth to have the appropriate drive and
control solution to meet your needs exactly.
Tough application,
ingenious solution Exactly
RS# 114
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
18/77
SCANNING FOR IDEASEdited by Stephen J. Mraz
Subminiature switch
survivessplashes
Requestfreeinformation vi
aour
ReaderServiceWebsiteat
www.machinedesign.com
/rsc
The DKSeries ofswitchesfromCherry Corp., Pleasant Prairie,
Wis. (www.cherrycorp.com), measurejust 0.579 0.213 0.268 in.and carry ratings ofIP65. (Versionsprotected to IP67 levels arealso available.) The switchesfeature stainless-steel components,gold-plated contacts, and a PBT/ASA housing. These ruggedpartsgive the switches a minimum life of500,000 operations.
The switches are rated for either 5 or 2 mA at 12 Vdc and op-erate at temperaturesfrom 40 to 85C, but can be modified toworkat up to 105C.
RS# 401
Actuating button
Stainless-steelspring
Cover
Stainless-steelinternal actuator
Base
Silver-platedcopper-zinc
terminals
Gold-platedberyllium/copper
moving blade
NC terminal
Commonterminal
NO terminal
Gold crosspointcontacts
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com16
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
19/77
Now Boarding.
Its easy to find all your development boards & accessories at our dev kit headquarters. newark.com/devkits
RS# 115
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
20/77
SCANNING FOR IDEAS
Simple shaft supports eliminate
realignment problemsEngineers often design carriagesthat move backand forth atopofa pair ofparallel nonrotatingshafts. These shaftsmust remainparallel or the carriage will wedgeto a dead stop.So it is importantthat supportskeep the shaftsaligned.
This can be a problemwith traditional support
blocks that keep the shaftlocked into place with acapscrew located aboveand perpendicular to theshaft.With traditional blocks, theshaft has to be inserted through thehole, a taskthat requires extra space on ei-ther end ofthe support.When the shafts, bush-ings, bearings, or carriage need maintenance,the shaft-support blocksmust be removed andthe alignment is lost. Afterservicing, the shafthas to be reinserted and the supportsrealigned,a time-consumingprocess.
To simplify thisprocess, engineers atOndrives US Corp., Freeport, N. Y. (www.ondrivesus.com), developed a shaft support witha removable top. It lets usersremove shafts, aswell as the linear bushings and carriage, withoutupsetting the position ofthe shaft supports. Thiseliminates the need to realign the supports aftermaintenance. It also gives technicians easier ac-cess to shafts in locationswith limited space oneither end ofthe shafts.
The supports are made ofanodized alumi-num, making themsimilar in strength but 70%
lighter than cast-iron shaft supports. They areavailable forshaftsranging in diameterfrom0.25 to 2.0 in. The company makes a standardrange ofsupports that have the same shaftheight and mountingfootprint as the mostpopular industry-standard supports. They alsooffer a line oflow-profile supports that providethe lowest possible carriage heights.
RS# 402
Steelfasteners
Aluminumbase and
top
Available forshaftsfrom 0.25 to 2.0 in.
in diameter
Toppiece getsremoved to assemble,
maintain, orreplaceshaft and bushings
Typical shaftsupport does
not permitthe shaft tobe removed
withoutupsetting
alignment.
MACHINE DESIGN.com18 MAY 9, 2013
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
21/77
,QFUHDVH\RXURSHUDWLRQV
HIILFLHQF\DQGSURILWDELOLW\E\
UHGXFLQJLQVWDOODWLRQHUURUV
PDLQWHQDQFHFRVWVDQG
GRZQWLPH7KH5H[QRUG
=$)VHULHVEHDULQJV
DQGQHZ=/)ODUJHERUH
EHDULQJVDUHGLUHFWGURSLQ
UHSODFHPHQWVWRLQGXVWU\
VWDQGDUG6$)EHDULQJV3UHOXEULFDWHGDQGVKDIWUHDG\
WKHVHEHDULQJVGHFUHDVH
LQVWDOODWLRQDQGUHPRYDOWLPH
E\DVPXFKDVIRXUWLPHV
YHUVXV6$)PRGHOV
$QG\RXFDQILQG5H[QRUG
EHDULQJVDW\RXUORFDO0RWLRQ
,QGXVWULHVORFDWLRQ2XUORFDO
VDOHVDQGVHUYLFHVSHFLDOLVWVDUHH[SHUWVLQDSSOLFDWLRQDQG
WHFKQLFDOVXSSRUWSURYLGLQJWKH
SDUWVDQGWKHNQRZKRZ\RX
QHHGWRVWD\XSDQGUXQQLQJ
7KHEUDQGV\RXFRXQWRQIURP
WKHSHRSOH\RXWUXVWWKDWV
5H[QRUGDQG0RWLRQ,QGXVWULHV
0RWLRQ,QGXVWULHV,QF
IRUWKHORFDWLRQQHDUHVW\RX
0RWLRQ,QGXVWULHVFRP
2YHUORFDWLRQV0RUHWKDQPLOOLRQSURGXFWV
,QGXVWULDOPDLQWHQDQFHWUDLQLQJFRXUVHV&DOO&OLFN9LVLW
RS# 116
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
22/77
REPORTERS NOTEBOOK
Could an electric carsomedayrun at Indy? Its a distinct possibil-ityjudging by developments inFormula 1 racing.Starting nextyear, all-electric carswill have theirown racing classrunning underthe auspices ofthe FdrationInternationale de lAutomobile(FIA), the same organization thathandles Formula 1 racing.
FIA will stage the races on thestreets ofmajor citiesrather thanon closed tracks. The first race is
expected to take place in a yet-unnamed European city. FIA saysit is also talking to cities in boththe U.S. and South America abouthosting Formula E races.
Formula E carswill be able to hittopspeeds in the 200-mphrange
just like their combustion engine-powered cousins.But battery limi-tationsforce the race format to bea little bizarre. After 20 min ofcom-petition, each driverwill hop out
oftheir car andjump into anotherwith a fresh battery to continuethe race. Meanwhile, the first carwill get recharged. After another20 min ofracing, drivershop backinto the recharged carsfor 20 minto take the checkered flag.
There are critics ofthisChinesefiredrill-style setupwho claimsucha format will make it hard forfansto take the whole thingseriously.A more-important criticism is thatthe need for eachracing team toown two carsmakes Formula E anexpensive endeavor. Plans are forraces to host 20-carfieldswhichwould actually be 40-carfieldswithhalfthe cars charging at anygiven time.
But the concept ofan electric-vehicle race serieshas alreadyattracted entries.Drayson Rac-ing Technologies in the U. K. isthe first team to commit to thenewSeries. It has developed a
prototype Formula E racerwhichmay serve as the model for carsin the 2014 season. (FIA plans tomake the racesspec-class events
next year, meaning all carswillbe roughly the same. Formula Ewill then revert to an open classin 2015 and thereafter.) Draysonhas already designed an 850-hpLeMans-style electric car that seta speed record for E vehicles (andplaced 11th overall) in a U. K.hill-climb event.
Drayson officials dont thinktheformat ofFormula E will detractfrom the excitement ofthe event.The carssound a little like theMillennium Falcon in the StarWarsmovies, says Paul (Lord) Drayson,managingpartner ofDrayson Rac-ing.It is a high-techsound, notlike the screaming you get from aracing engine. From the point ofview ofputting on a show, I think
it will be particularly good foryoungerfans.
Drayson, whose teamhas actedas a scientific adviser to the FIA
Formula E Championship duringits initial planning, says the racecarswill also serve as developmentplatformsfor E-vehicle technology.Race rules are set up to emphasizethe electric drivetrain rather thanthe aerodynamics,he emphasizes.
One technology that could
They sound like the Millennium Falcon
Formula E racerswillcompeteon courseslaidouton the streetsofmajorcities.Tohelp promote the Formula E concept, a European Consortiumcalled Formuleccreateda prototype Formula E racercalledthe EF01.The chassis anddrivetraindesign thatwill actuallyrace in Formula E eventsisstillbeing defined.
LordDrayson nexttoaLeMans-style E-racer.
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com20
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
23/77
battery that static systems nowrealize, which is about 90%, saysThompson. We thinkthat figurecan be achieved within certain op-erational constraints.We also hopeto realize full power transfer evenifthe car is 8 inches to eithersideofthe power track.
Unfortunately, a lot ofthetechnical details about the For-mula E cars are either yet to bedetermined orhave not yet beenmade public.Drayson officialssay
the type ofmotor that will powerthe carshas been determined butitsspecificationshave not beenreleased.Similarly, the Formula Ebattery supplierhas yet to be an-nounced.
Electric motorsfor the Serieswill come fromMcLaren Elec-tronic Systems Ltd.,whichsup-plies electric-control units to allFormula 1 teams. McLaren willalso be supplying the transmis-
sions and control electronicsforthe cars. The cars themselveswillbe built by a European companycalled SparkRacing Technology.
And once these cars take to thetrack, the experience isshapingup to be interesting notjust forthe fans but for drivers aswell.
The carswill have a lotofpower, given theirweight. There will be alot ofoversteer and thecourses are likely to bechallengingfor the driv-ers, says Paul Drayson.And because they areracing on city streets,there will be concretewalls all around, so thedriving experience willbe quite intense. Plus,these are all-new courseswhich driverswill havelittle time to learn. Thatwill put a premium on
the ability to quickly be-come familiarwith thelayout so you can put in afast time. MD
that israted at 20 kW.The chargingsystemwaspart ofDraysonspro-totype that earned honors at thehill-climbing event.
The plan for these wireless-chargingsystems is to rechargemoving cars, notjust those sit-ting in the pit. Once the race iscomplete, the inductive-chargingequipment and charging tracksembedded in racecourse road-wayswill stay in place to help ad-vance recharging infrastructure for
ordinary EVs.Moving to that goal, inductive
chargers that recharge vehiclessittingstill are in the early com-mercialization phase. Accordingto Anthony Thompson, vice presi-dent ofbusiness development atQualcomm, the next step issemi-dynamic chargingwhere a vehiclemovesslowly while recharging.
The scenario Thompson envisionsis that oftaxisrechargingwhile
crawling along in a passengerpickup lane.Next will come fullydynamic chargingwhere vehicleszip alongwhile gettingmorejuice.
Thompson says the R&Dforsuchsystems is in full swing.
The goal is to approachpower-transfer efficiency fromgrid to
get a boost from Formula E isinductive charging.Draysonforeseeswireless chargingtracks being embedded in thestreets ofcitieshosting For-mula E eventssuch that racecars could recharge as theypass over designated portionsofthe course.
Once the race is over, thetracks could serve asprototypesfor a recharging infrastructureaimed at ordinary E-street ve-hicles.Thisscheme would freecarsfrom the constraints ofthebattery.We see this as a waymotorracing can pioneer thistechnology,he says.
In that regard, theQualcomm Inc.subsidiaryQualcommEurope Inc.will
sponsorDrayson Racing in For-mula E to help developwireless-charging technology. The charg-ingsystem uses Qualcomm HaloWireless Electric Vehicle Charging(WEVC) technology.Drayson Rac-inghas been evaluating a speciallydeveloped version ofthe system
The QualcommHaloinductive-charging schemewirelessly
beamspowertoreceiving coilson an electricvehicle.The trickypartisdoing itwhile the carismoving attrackspeedsaswillbethe case with Formula E carsspeeding around a citystreetcourse.
Resources:Drayson Racing Technology,http://www.draysonracingfe.com/
Formula Eblog,http://formula-e-news.com/
QualcommHalo,http://www.qualcommhalo.com/
Inductive-charging scheme
Power
supply
Transmitterpads
Receiverpad
Battery
MAY 9, 2013 MACHINE DESIGN.com 21
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
24/77
askTURCK.com
2013 TURCK
Assembled vs.Overmolded
Cordsets: Whichconnectivity solutionis best for your application?
REPORTERS NOTEBOOK
After testing 122commerciallyavailable laserpointers, researchersat the NationalInstitute oStandards andTechnologyfoundthat 90% ofthe greenand 44% ofthe redpointers did not
comply withfederalsafety regulations.In fact, they oftenemitted more powerthan allowed, andgreen lasers also tended to put outunacceptable levels ofIR light aswell.
The tests used randomly selected commercialdevices labeled asClass III or 3R and sold assuitablefor demonstrations in classrooms and otherpublicspaces. These lasers are limited under the Code ofFederal Regulations to 5 mW in the visible portion
oflight and less than 2 mW ofIR light.But halfthepointers exceeded twice that limit at one ormorewavelengths, with one putting out 66 mW, morethan 10 times the legal limit.
According to ANSI, lasers that exceed the federallimitsshould be subject to more rigorous controls,such as user training, to prevent injuries. MD
DANGER:Red and green laserpointers
Measuringthe costs ofelectrical
storageSeveral alternative-energy sourceswillonly be practical ifpower companieshave an economicalway to store harvested energy. AndU.S.grid operatorswill need meth-ods ofstoring electricity to balanceand maintain the national grid ifalternative sources are to provide a
majority ofthe nationspower.Withthat in mind, researchers at Stan-ordUniversitydeveloped a wayto calculate the costs ofbuildingand deploying a variety ofenergy-storage technologies.
The team evaluated pumpedhydroelectric storage aswell aslead-acid, lithium-ion, sodium-sulfur, vanadium-redox, and zinc-bromide batteries. (Pumped hydroinvolvespumpingwater up into a
reservoir usingsurplus electricityduring low-demand times, thenrunningwater down throughgen-erators during times ofhigh de-mand.) The team determined the
Resources:National Instituteof StandardsandTechnology, www.nist.gov
Electricalstoragecontinuedonpage28
Resources:StanfordUniversity,www.stanford.edu
RS# 117
A NIST safetyofficerandthedeviceusedtomeasurethe propertiesofhandheldlaserpointers.
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
25/77
Largest everfiber-optic network
Technicians at Sandia National Laboratoryhavestrungmiles ofhalf-inchfiber-optic cables between13,000 networkports in265 buildings to construct thelargest fiber-optic LAN in theworld. The cables, consisting of288 fibers, replace 4-in. coppercables and provide more secureand reliable capacity that is lessexpensive to maintain and operate. It is estimated theLANwill save $20 million overfive years and reduceenergy use for communications by 65%.MD
DoE fundsprojects to
boost efficiencyResearchers at the DoE-run Paciic Northwest Na-tional Laboratory (PNNL) unveiled some oftheirprojects aimed at reducing energy use in the U.S.
Storing solar power:Solarpower is clean, butwithout a way to store it for at least 8 to 12 hr, itcannot be used at night. One method ofstoringthe suns energy is thermal storage. It usesmoltensalts, but also requires expensive equipment. To
solve that problem, scientistsdeveloped a metal hydride thatstores up to 10 timesmore heat
per unit ofmass than salts andoperates at higher tempera
DoE fundscontinuedonpage 30
Resources:PacificNorthwest
National Laboratory,www.pnl.gov
A Sandiaengineerexaminesfiberopticsina cablebox.
Resources:Sandia NationalLaboratory, www.sandia.gov
RS# 118
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
26/77
REPORTERS NOTEBOOK
A small and ultralight UAV de-veloped by engineers at Festo,Esslingen, Germany, reportedlycan match the highly complexflight capabilities ofa dragonfly.Called the BionicOpter, the roboticinsect can fly in any direction even backwards turn and ac-celerate quickly, hover, and glidewithout beating itswings. Itssaidto be the first aircraft that flies likea helicopter, plane, and glider.
The BionicOpters lightweight
construction, tight integration ofcomponents, advanced controls,and ability to move each ofitsfourwings independently all contrib-ute to its extreme maneuverability.
The bionic dragonfly has a 63-cmwingspan, is 44-cm long, andweighsjust 175 gm. The wingscarbon-fiberframe is coveredwithpolyesterfoil. The structureismade offlexible polyamide anddeep-drawn ABS terpolymer thats
sturdy, but flexible and ultralight.And itssmall rib cage houses a7.6-V LiPo battery, nine servomo-tors, and a high-performance ARMmicrocontroller, alongwith inertia,acceleration, and position sensors,wireless-communication modules,and othermechanisms.
A motor in the bottom ofthehousing drives the fourwings at acommon beat frequency, which isadjustable between 15 and 20 Hz.
Like a real dragonfly, theBionicOpterswings can turnfromhorizontal to vertical. For this,servomotors individually twisteachwing up to 90.
Fourmotors at the wingjointscontrol flapping amplitudes. Lin-earmovement in the wingrootadjusts a crankmechanism to varythe deflection between approxi-mately 80 and 130.
Movements by the head andtail provide fine control. Thedragonfly body isfitted withfourflexible musclesmade ofNitinol a shape-memory alloy (SMA)that contractswhen heated andexpandswhen cooled. Passing anelectric current through the SMAscreates ultralight actuators thatmove the head horizontally andthe tail vertically.
Software controlsflappingfrequency and twisting ofthe indi-vidual wings.Swiveling the wingsdetermines thrust direction, andan amplitude controllerregulatesthrust intensity. The combinationofthe two lets the dragonfly hover,move backwards, and transitionsmoothly fromhovering to for-ward flight. And unlike a helicop-ter, the dragonfly does not need totilt to generate forward thrust. Thismeans that it can fly horizontallyaswell asfloat like a glider.
To correct for any vibrationsand ensure stable flight, data onposition and wing twist are con-tinuously evaluated in real time as
the dragonfly flies. In-ertia sensorsmeasure
the acceleration and tilting angleofthe BionicOpter in space, whileposition and acceleration sensorsdetect speed and spatial direction.
Despite its complexity, theaircraft is controlled with a smart-phone or digital transmitter.Thepilot inputs direction and speed,and an onboard microcontroller
calculates operatingrequirementsbased on recorded flight data andsends commands to servomotorsand actuators.
The BionicOpterwas developedby FestosBionic LearningNet-work. Togetherwithresearchersat universities and developmentfirms, the Networksupportsproj-ects and develops test modelswhose basic technical principles like energy efficiency andlightweight construction arederived from nature. Among otherrecent developments: a SmartBirdwhichmodels bird flight, robotarmsmuch like an elephant trunk,and adaptable grippers based ona fishs tail.
These strategies, say Festoofficials, can be applied to engi-neeringproblems in the industrialworld. For example, the remote-controlled dragonfly demonstrateswirelessreal-time communica-
tion, a continuous exchange ofinformation, aswell as the abilityto evaluate multiple sensor inputsand identify complex events and
Robotic dragonfly takesflight
Resources:Festo, www.festo.com/us RS# 406
See videoofthe BionicOpter at: www.youtube.com/watch?v=nj1yhz5io20
Other articles:
Flexible robotarm, http://machinedesign.com/article/robot-imitates-an-elephant-s-trunk-0913
Fin Gripper, http://machinedesign.com/content/fingrippers-adapt-to-an-object-s-shape-1012
SmartBird, http://machinedesign.com/article/hannover-fair-robotic-bird-demonstrates-efficient-flight-0504
The BionicOptercanfly forward, backward,
hover, andglide.
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com24
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
27/77
critical states. For Festo, the principle ofcontinuousdiagnosticshelps ensure operational reliability andprocessstability whether in bionic flying objects oreveryday industrial machines.
Likewise, industrial networksfigure large in pro-duction systems ofthe future.Centralized plantcontrol will give way to greater use ofdecentralizedoperations. Tasks that are currently performed by amaster computerwill increasingly be done by remotecomponents. Festo believes this digital refinement will
give rise to increasingly intelligent subsystems thatcan actively support production processes, thanksto capabilities like energy autonomy and conditionmonitoring in the smallest ofinstallation spaces.Festo says the BionicOpter illustratessuch integratedfunctions and miniaturization.MD
MEDICAL-DEVICE ADHESIVE SEMINAR
May 21 Henkel Corp.,Rocky Hill, Conn., ishostingthe first 2013 Loctite Medical Device Adhesive Semi-nar in Minneapolis. The programprovides design,
product, and manufacturing engineerswith an over-all knowledge ofadhesive technologies used in thedesign and assembly ofmedical devices.
Topics covered include properjoint design foradhesive assembly, selecting the appropriate adhe-sive technology, and processing-equipment require-ments. Overviews ofeachmajorfamily ofISO 10993biocompatible engineering adhesives, including lightcure, cyanoacrylate, epoxy, polyurethane and siliconetechnologieswill be covered.
The seminar, cosponsored by EllsworthAdhe-sives, Germantown, Wis., will be at the Crown PlazaMinneapolisNorth, starting at 8:30 a.m. and running
until 3:00 p.m. To register, please call Chrys Johnsonat (952) 888-1246, Ext. 2, or e-mail [email protected]
Thedragonflysdirection andspeed are
controlledwitha smartphone.
RS# 119
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
28/77
Phone 1-888-260-7466 Fax 516-771-6444
www.RightAngleBoxes.com
.US Corp.
6LQJOH'RXEOH&RXQWHU5RWDWLQJ2XWSXWV
%HYHO*HDUER[HV
Customizations:
Component Materials
Shaft Modifications
Mounting Features
Sealing
ACME Thre ad
Output
Hex Socket Input
Custom
BGA24
Standard Options:
18 Frame Sizes
Ratio: 1:1 to 24:1
Shafts: 1/8 to 25mm
Torque: up to 4800 in-lb
Custom
BLHT60
Reduced Housing for Space Constraints
440C Shafts, Gears & BearingsBLHMBLH
REPORTERS NOTEBOOKLOOKING BACK
10 YEARS AGO 2003Flythe lonelyskies: U.S. aero-space employment is the lowestits been since 1953, dropping to
just 689,000 at the end oflast year,according to the U. S. Dept.oLabors Bureauo Labor Statis-tics.The industrysworkforce was
cut in halfin 1989 after the ColdWar ended. It tookanothermajorhit after 9/11, at which time aero-
space employment dropped 13%.The 9/11 attacks, combined withwhat the Aerospace IndustriesAssociation calls a civil aviation
and commercial-space business cri-sis, aswell as industry mergers andacquisitions, have contributed to thedecline.
30 YEARS AGO 1983Warrantyclaimsstreamlined: Aswitch to computer-assisted micro-filmretrieval (CAR) issavingspaceat MackTruckInc. and eliminatinglabor-inten-sive filingofpaperdocuments.
The firm ad-opted CARfor itswar-
ranty-claimsprogram; company policy requiresthat claimsfrom 40 branches and200 distributors be kept for threeyears in active files and eight yearsin inactive ones. UsingKodakmicro-graphic equipment, the companytransferred claimforms that filled22 filing cabinets annually to micro-filmkept in one accessfile for eachyear.The accessfile requires about4 sq ft offloorspace and saved
around $102,000 in wages, storagespace, and supplies the first year.
50 YEARS AGO 1963Nucleargeneratorspowering IMP(Interplanetry Monitoring Probe)satelliteswill eliminate problems oforientation and spaceradiation experi-enced by solar-cell systems.Swingingthrough an eccentric orbit apo-gee of150,000 miles andperigee of110miles the satelliteswillplungeinto the natural and artificial radiationbelts, gathering datanecessary for directsupport ofApolloflights.An opera-tional IMP must bein orbit at all timesduring the project.Atomic generators,because oftheir immunity to space ra-diation, may extend the useful lifetimeofthe satellite and, therefore,reducethe number needed.The Martin Co.,
Baltimore,whichhas been contractedto build the generators, estimates thatan IMP with nuclear auxiliary powercould be operational by 1964.MD
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com26
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
29/77
(952) 927-1400www.mnrubber.com
Minnesota Rubber & Plastics
Engineered to improve performance.Designed to reduce costs.
High tolerance components and assemblies are
what we work with everyday at Minnesota Rubber
and Plastics. Our experience in design, sealing and
manufacturing complex devices has made us the
preferred partner for industry leaders throughout
North America, Europe and Asia. The next time
your component or assembly seems impossible,
there's no one better to partner with than Minnesota
Rubber and Plastics. We'll make your tough
application a reality.
We Mold Ideas
Into Reality.
RS# 120
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
30/77
REPORTERS NOTEBOOK
amount ofenergy necessary to build each ofthe fivestorage devices and found that batterieshave signifi-
cantly higher energy costs to be practical compared topumped hydro.This issomewhat intuitive because batteries
are made ofmetal, and sometimesrare metals,
which take a lot ofenergy to acquire and purify,saysresearcherCharlesBarnhart. Whereas apumped hydro facility ismade ofair, water, and dirt.Its basically a hole in the ground withreinforced
concrete.The team next determined howmuch energywould be needed to maintain the devices over30 years. They devised a mathematical term, energy
stored on investment (ESOI),calculated by dividing the amountofenergy a device can store by theenergy needed to build it.So thehigher the ESOI, the better.
Pumped hydro ends upwithan ESOI of210, meaning it canstore 210 timesmore energy thanit needs to build it.Batteries all
had lower ESOIswith lithium-ionbatteries checking in with anESOI of10 and lead-acid versionsbringing up the rearwith an ESOIof2.
The team concluded that thebest way to lengthen batteriesESOI was to lengthen their cyclelife or the number oftimes theycan be charged/discharged.Pumped hydro, for example, canendure 25,000 cycles, equivalent
to 30 years ormore. Lithium-ionbatteriessurvive 6,000 cycles, andlead-acid batteriesgive up theghost after only 700 cycles.
The Stanford scientists thenexamined the materials neededto build these storage devices.
They found that materialswere not as expensive as theenergy requirements, with a fewexceptions. For instance, cobaltfor lithium-ion batteries and thevanadium needed in vanadium-redox batteries are rare andgetting expensive.
The team also consideredcompressed-air energy storage.It entails usingsurplus electricityto compress and pump air into anunderground cavern or aquifer,then releasing it through a turbineto generate electricity whenneeded. Thismethod has thehighest ESOI, 240, and the lowestmaterial costs.But similar to
pumped hydro, researchersfoundthere are a dwindling number ofgeologically well-suited locations.MD
Electricalstoragecontinuedfrompage 22
RS# 121MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com28
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
31/77
Together, we can keep cool when the heats on.
ENGINEERING YOUR SUCCESS.
www.parker.com 1 800 C-Parker
The cost-effective solution for mobile and industrial applications, Parker coolers producehigher cooling capacities with lower pressure drops for improved temperature optimization.Whats more, they create a wealth of economic and environmental benefits; like extendingthe life of the hydraulic oil, increasing the systems operating time (resulting in fewershutdowns), and reducing service/repair costs. All to improve your hydraulic system up timeand life span. And keep the heat off you!
To learn more, contact your Parker distributor or visit www.parker.com/accumulator.
RS# 122
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
32/77
REPORTERS NOTEBOOK
expanded tank can be made toconform to the space available ina car while traditional tanks, look-ing much like scuba tanks, take upmore space and are cumbersometo mount in vehicles. The newtanks should cost about $1,500each and hold 12 MJ/kg, abouttwice the energy density as cur-
rent natural-gas tanks.Magnets without rare-earth
metals: Magnets are critical intodays efficient motors and windturbines, but the most efficientof these currently rely on rare-earth magnets. Dysprosium, forexample, increases a magnetsoperating temperature, which isquite high in advanced motors. Amaterial scientist at PNNL is devel-oping a manganese-based nano-
composite magnet that operatesat up to 200C without using anyexpensive dysprosium.
Better air conditioners: Inhumid climes, air conditioners be-come inefficient. To cut electricaluse for cooling in hot, humid climesby up to 50%, PNNL researchersare designing a new dehumidifierthat relies on a thin membrane thatpulls water out of the air. The mem-brane is based on a thin, foil-likemetal sheet coated with zeolite, awater-attracting material.
Heating and cooling elec-tric cars: Heating and cooling inelectric cars puts a load on thebatteries and can significantlyreduce their range. An alterna-tive approach being evaluated atPNNL involves a molecular heatpump that uses an electrical metalorganic framework to circulateheat or cooling. A 5-lb heat pumpthe size of a two-liter bottle could
theoretically handle the heatingand cooling requirements for anelectrical car with little affect onmileage.MD
tures. A PNNL team is building a demonstration proj-ect that will collect heat from the sun for 6 hr and then
discharge that energy over the next 6 hr.Lighter fuel tanks for natural gas: Natural gas isbecoming more abundant and less expensive, and150,000 vehicle use it in the U. S. (That figure climbs
to 15 million for the entire world.) One problem withnatural gas as a transportation fuel is that it remainsa vapor, so it must be compressed and stored in apressurized tank to boost its energy density. A PNNL
team is developing lightweight fuel tanks made us-ing superplastic forming. The process involves weld-ing metal sheets together then blowing compressedair between them to form internal chambers. This
DoE fundscontinued from page 23
RS# 123MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com30
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
33/77 2013 Banner Engineering Corp., Mpls, MN USA
Banner towerlights are
built-to-order.
why stackyour own? embled,connecthts n yourcolors and
isconnect options
lays up tohts in a single
er, 10 colorsilable
ble versions
1-888-373-6767 | bannerengineering.com
irst
ays
ything
very DayRS# 124
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
34/77
RS# 127
WWW.BOKERS.COM/MD
FREE CATALOG & BROCHURE
Call 1-888-WASHERStTBMFT!CPLFSTDPNt'"9
WASHERS &STAMPINGS
RS# 125RS# 126
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
35/77
Brushless MotorsFerrite Magnet TypeContinuous Duty RatedStandard/High Speed
Custom Motors Explosion-Proof Motors Permanent Magnet Motors SCR Rated MotorsWound Field and More!
Custom Designed AC/DCExplosion Proof MotorsHermetic AC MotorsMilitary MotorsNuclear MotorsApproved for Nuclear PlantsUS Navy SpecifiedSizes from 5 lb. ft. (6.8NM) to
150 lb. ft. (203.4NM) in torqueServo MotorsSpecialty, OEM & More
Brushless (PMAC) MotorsFractional to over 700 HPSmall Size/Bi-DirectionalHigh Torque (4,000 lb-ft)UL Certification, Custom & More
Low Inertia/High Speed MotorsMilitary MotorsNEMA Design Motors
Motor Controllers
Aerospace/Aviation Centrifugal Pumps/Pumps Construction/Mining Energy/Nuclear Plants HVAC Manufacturing/Packaging Transportation/Railroads US Defense and More!
www.ohioelectricmotors.com
www.peerlesselectric.com
www.powertecmotors.com
COMMENTARY
Stephen J.MrazSenior Editor
NASA pencil whipsgoals to meet budgetsIt looks likeNASAmanagersaremanglingtheconceptsofsettinggoalsandfacingbudgetaryrealitiesifreportsaboutafuturemissionare tobebelieved.Sometimeago,NASAdecidedonsendingamannedspacecrafttoget upcloseand personal withanasteroidby2025,aplanendorsedbythecurrentWhite House.Themission
wouldnotonlygatherinformationaboutthemakeupandhistoryofasteroids,itwouldalsogiveNASAachancetocheckoutmuchofitsyet-to-bedesignedmanned-space-travel hardware.Theultimatepur-poseofthishardwarewouldbearoundtriptoMars.
Butmoneystightandtheresnoappetiteforaskingtaxpayerstopayforthisparticularspaceproject.Still,
NASAandtheadministrationwanttogettoanaster-oidby2025 andhitthatmilestone.Whattodo?
Somecleveraerospaceengineercameupwithaso-lution,auniquespinonmovingthegoalposts.NASAwoulddesignandbuildahollow18-tonunmannedspacecraftthatwouldtravel toanearbyasteroid,onemeasuringnomorethan25 ftindiameterandweigh-ingabout 500tons.Thespacecraftwouldmaneuverit-selftosomehowencloseandsecuretheasteroid.Afterusingsolar-electricpropulsiontoflythecelestial pay-loadbacknearEarth,theasteroidwouldbeinjectedintoahigh lunarorbit.ThiswouldgiveNASAacloser
targetforastronautsusingequipmentbeingbuilttoexploretheMoonandtransportcrewandcargototheSpaceStation.NASAfiguresthisschemebeatshavingtodesign longer-rangespacecraftthatcouldcarryas-tronautstoanasteroidsnatural orbit.
Thereare obviouslysomehurdles remaining.NASAmustfirstcompleteastudytoseeiftheideaisevenfeasible.Rumorshaveitthattheres $100millionearmarkedinthe2014 budgetforthisstudy. Itwill alsotakeanother $2.65 billiontobuildandflythesevento 10-yearmissionifthecurrentbudgetandscheduleestimatesarecorrect.Anotherpotential problem: ItwouldntsurprisemeiftheEPAdecidesitsscopeofcontrol extendsat leasttotheedgesoftheSolarSystemanddemandanenvironmental impactstatementbe-
foremovingtheasteroidoutofitsnatural habitatandintoanewone.Theprojectcould letNASAandtheAdministrationsaytheymetthe2025
targetofgettingastronautstovisitanasteroid,butitisntinkeepingwiththespiritoftheoriginal idea.Afterall,theprojectwasoriginallyformulatedtogiveNASAacheckflightonman-ratedhardwaredesignedforatriptoMars. Itwasnottosightseearoundarelativelysmall asteroidtowedintoourbackyard.Whenconfrontedwiththisfact,anAirForceGeneral said,WhenthePresidentannouncedthatanasteroidwouldbethenextdestinationforNASAshumanspaceflightprogram,hedidnotsayNASAhadtoflyall thewaytoanasteroid.Whatmattersistheabilitytoputhumansonanasteroid.
SoifI understandtheGeneral,hedbehappyandthegoalwill havebeenmetifweflyacoupleastronautsviaacommercial flighttotheAmerican Museumof Natural HistoryinNewYorkCitytostandonfragmentsofanasteroidthatcrashedonEarth. MD
NASA would
design
and build
an 18-ton,
unmanned
spacecraft
to travel to
a nearby
asteroid,
maneuver itself
to enclose andsecure the
asteroid, fly it
backtoward
Earth, and
inject it into
a high lunar
orbit.
RS# 128MAY 9, 2013 MACHINE DESIGN.com 33
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
36/77
Paper Tube Company1033 S. Noel Ave., Wheeling, IL 60090
5 - The Original
To receive literature & details fast - www.pptube.comPhone: 847-537-4250 Fax: 847-537-5777 E-Mail: [email protected]
DuPont Co.
420F, 720 VPM!High Temperature - High DielectricNOMEX for Electrical/ElectronicTubing, Bobbins, Fabricated Parts
Widelyspecified for itsexcellentelectrical,
thermal andmechanical propertiesNomex tubing isproducedby Precisionwithan exclusive, special binder to
provideathermallystable class Hinsulating tubing.U/L Recognized.
reMo Than 7 Years
RS# 132
"JS#FBSJOH&RVJQNFOUt-JGU5JMU5BCMFTt5VSOUBCMFTt"TTFNCMZ-JOFT
&SHPOPNJD&RVJQNFOUt5SBOTQPSUFSTt3JHHJOH&RVJQNFOU
800-888-0018XXXBJSGMPBUDPN
'PSUIF5PVHIFTU.PWFNFOU1PTJUJPOJOH$IBMMFOHFT
An"SNBNFOU.BLFSneededawaytorapidlyand
ergonomicallyattacharmorplatingtoitsmine-
resistant fghtingvehicles.Airoatdesignedandbuilt
anair-ridingplatformwithahydraulicarm,enablinggreaterautomationandproductivity.
RS# 129
RS# 131
^^ JLU[YPJP[ UL[ZHSLZ'JLU[YPJP[ UL[
:[H[LVM[OLHY[ZLY]V
KYP]LU[LJOUVSVN
4PJYVZVM[,_JLSIHZLK
ZWYLHKZOLL[ZMVYZPTWSLZL[\W
*VTWSL[LZ`Z[LT
-VYSVHKZMYVTV\UJLZ[V
[LUZVM[OV\ZHUKZVMWV\UKZ
7YPJLKYPNO[
EZ INDEXER
EZ INDEXER
IF YOURE STILL TRYING TO READ A MAP...
,HZ [V0U[LNYH[L9VI\Z[*VUZ[Y\J[PVU5V4HPU[LUHUJL
A MECHANICAL INDEXER.
YOURE PROBABLY STILL USING
RS# 130
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
37/77
([WUHPHO\UREXVW6HQVRUVIRUDQJOHLQFOLQDWLRQ
SRVLWLRQPHDVXUHPHQW
35$69
:%
3&67
3&)3
37$037'0
37$037'0
x0HDVXUHPHQWUDQJH
LQ
x$QDORJP$66,
&$1RSHQ-
x3URWHFWLRQFODVV,3
,3
xDQJOHVHQVRU
x$QDORJLQFUHPHQWDO
66,&$1RSHQ-
x:LWKLQVKDIW
x3URWHFWLRQFODVV,3
,3.
326,7$3(7DSH([WHQVLRQ
3RVLWLRQ6HQVRUV
326,5270DJQHWLF$QJOH6HQVRUV
326,&+5210DJQHWRVWULFWLYH
3RVLWLRQ6HQVRUVx0HDVXUHPHQWUDQJH
LQ
x$QDORJP$66,
&$1RSHQ-
x3URWHFWLRQFODVV,3
,3.
xD[HV
x$QDORJRXWSXW
&$1RSHQ-
x3URWHFWLRQFODVV,3
326,7,/7,QFOLQRPHWHUV
326,&+5210DJQHWRVWULFWLYH
3RVLWLRQ6HQVRUVx
0HDVXUHPHQWUDQJHLQ
x$QDORJP$66,
&$1RSHQ-
x3URWHFWLRQFODVV,3
,3.
xD[HV
x,Q0(06WHFKQRORJ\
x$QDORJRXWSXW&$1RSHQ-
x3URWHFWLRQFODVV,3
,3.
326,7,/7,QFOLQRPHWHUV
R
$606HQVRUV,QFZZZDVPVHQVRUVFRP
LQIR#DVPVHQVRUVFRP
7HO$6086$
TAVENNERON SAFETY
onaskylightandbrokethrough. Hefell 25 feettoacementwarehousefloorandwashospitalizedwithsevereinjuries.
Lookupinalmostanypublicbuildingthesedaysandyouwill seeaskylight.Iftheyarenotguardedproperlyskylightscanbeasourceoffallsanddeaths.The
mostrecentNationalInstitute for OccupationalSafetyand Health(NIOSH)alertonpreventingfallssaysthat808peoplediedintheworkplacefromfalls;ofwhich23werefallsthroughskylights.
Ofcourse,mostpeoplewouldneverintention-allystandorputthemselvesinapositiontofallthroughaskylight. However,mistakeshappen
quicklyandoftenwhennotpayingattentiontothetaskathand.Themost-commonskylightaccidentscenariosinvolveworkersshovelingsnowoffanoverloadedrooforbeingfatiguedafterworkingonahotday.Thereareregulatoryrequirementsforskylightdesignsthatpertaintosafety.Andifyouhappentoworkinafacilitythatcontainsnoncom-pliantskylights,considerpointingouttheproblemtothefacilitymanagerandsuggestingaretrofit.
YoucanbolsteryourcasewithaquickGooglesearch. Youll findmanyexamplesoflargesettle-mentswhereworkershavefallenthroughunpro-
tectedskylights.Several vendorsdesignretrofitkitsthatwill bringexistingskylightsuptospec.OSHAsskylightrequirementsfor general industrycan be foundin
1910.23(e)(8). Itstatesskylightscreensshallbeofsuchconstructionandmount-ingthattheyarecapableofwithstandinga loadofat least200 lbappliedperpen-dicularlyatanyoneareaonthescreen.OSHAalsosaysthatskylightsmustbeofsuchconstructionandmountingthatunderordinaryloadsorimpacts,theywillnotdeflectdownwardenoughtobreaktheglassbelowthem.Andtheconstruc-tionmusthavegrillworkwithopeningsnotmorethan 4-in. longorslatworkwithopeningsnotmorethan2-in.widebutwithanunrestricted length.
Forconstruction,theOSHAstandardcanbefoundin29 CFR1926.501(b)(4)(i). Itstateseachemployeeonwalking/workingsurfacesmustbeprotectedfromthehazardoffallingthroughholes(includingskylights)morethan 6 feet(1.8m)above lower levels,bypersonal fall-arrestsystems,covers,orguardrailsystemserectedaroundsuchholes.
Designersshouldknowaswell thatNIOSH alsorecommendsaddingamarginofsafetytothe200 lbappliedperpendicularlypertheOSHAstandard.NIOSH estimatesthata200-lbpersonfallingagainstaskylightcouldapply400to 500 lbofforce. Inaddition,skylightvendorsaresupposedtoattachadangersignandmakesureinstallationinstructionsidentifyfall hazardsandrequiredprotection.
HerestheNIOSH Guide: www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2004-156/pdfs/2004-156.pdf
Joe Tavenner
Joe Tavenner, CSP, CFPS, is a long-time Certified Safety Professionalwho works in
occupational safety and design forsafety. Got a question about safety? You can reach Joe [email protected].
Edited by LelandTeschler
Look out belowInarecentincidentanemployeewasonaroofconducting
routinepreventivemaintenanceonarefrigerationunit.Ashewalkedaroundontheroof,heaccidentallystepped
If you happen
to work in a
facility that
contains non-
compliant
skylights,
consider
suggesting a
retro fit.
RS# 133MAY 9, 2013
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
38/77
INTERVIEW
Doestodaysworkforcehavethe righteducation andskills?
Whilemanufacturingisonthe
upswing,itsalsomoredependentthaneverontechnologyandau-tomation. Ingeneral,oneofthekeybottleneckstodayisaqualifiedworkforce.Thereisamismatchbetweentheskillsofmanyavailableworkersandthequalificationsneces-saryfortechnicaljobs.
Companieshavearesponsibil-itytoaddressthisproblem.Youcantsitbackandwait,thatdoesntwork.Thatswhywearepartnering
witheducational institutions likeGreenville TechnicalCollegeonanapprenticeshipprogramthattrainsworkersfirstonthebasicsofmanu-facturing,thenonhowtosetupandoperateeverytypeofmachinetool inourplantwhileattendingcollege.Theynotonlyearnafull-timesalary,Rexrothalsocoverstheirtuitionandbooks. Itspatternedafterapprentice-shipprogramsinGermany.Onekeydifference: Germanyrequiresthreeandahalfyears,herewedoitintwo.Butthebasicsareverysimilar.
Itstrulyawin-win.ThegraduateisaDept. of Laborcertifiedmachin-istapprentice,hasatwo-yeartechni-cal degree,andawell-compensatedjob.Wegainaskilled,educated,andmotivatedemployeewhoisalsoanassettoourcommunity.Thissortofapprenticeshipprogramisabsolutelynecessarytoencouragestudentstopursuetechnical careers.Comparedwithuniversitystudentswhosome-
timesstruggletofindemploymentafterfouryears,ourassociateshavehighlysought-afterskills.Thetableshaveturnedabitinthatrespect.MD
OnMarch20,Bosch RexrothAmericasopenedanew260,000-ft2
hydraulicsmanufacturingfacilityinFountain Inn,S.C.The $80millioninvestmentcreatesthecompanyslargestmanufacturingsiteintheAmericas.WehadthechancetodiscussthesignificancewithPresident&CEO,BerendBracht.
Whythe investmentinthe U.S.?
Afewyearsago,BoschRexrothchangedakeystrategy.Previously,thetargetwastoexpandmanu-facturinginso-called low-costcountriesandexportfromtheseregionsintohigh-costcountries. ImyselfspenttwoandahalfyearsasPresident&CEOofBosch RexrothChina,andwhatwe learnedisthatall thecapacityweaddedinChinawasactuallyneededfortheChinesemarket.Wefacedasimilarsituation
inSouthAmerica.Withthatexperience,ourstrategycriticallychangedtolocal for local.Thatis,ourproductioncapabilitiesmustmatch,toasimilardegree,salesinaparticular location. InNorthAmericawereliedtooheavilyonimports.Weneededtoinvest,andthisisakeysteptowardincreasingour localmanufacturingdepth.
TheFountain Innexpansiondoublesthesizeofthefacility.Wereaddingmoremachinetoolsaswerampupcapacity,hiring 160newworkersoverfiveyears, launchinganR&D facility,andexpandingourlocal supplierbase.Wealsoacquiredmore landforfutureexpansion.SowerepositionedforsignificantgrowthintheNorthAmericanmarket.
Whatdoeslocal forlocalmean forthe OEM?
First,OEMsaredealingwith
onesupplier,notseveral aroundtheworld.Second,thesupplychainismuchshorter.Being local letsusreactfastertomarketupsanddowns
andOEMsdonthavethedelaystypicalwithoffshoresuppliers.Third,ontheengineeringside,wecanworkmuch-morecloselywithOEMstodevelopproductssuitingtheirspecificneeds.SomeofourbiggestcustomershaveR&DandproductioninNorthAmerica,soitbenefitsthemtohaveanearbycontacttoprovidesupport.Local forlocal isourstrategybutourcustom-ers, letssay,havegentlypushedusin
thisdirectionaswell.
We constantlyhearthatmanufacturing ison thedecline in the U. S.Whatsyouropinion?
ImovedtotheU.S.in 1993todevelopourmachine-tool hydrau-licsbusinessinDetroit.Sincethen,wevewitnessedthedeclineofin-
dustrialmarkets likemachinetools,presses,andplasticsmachinery.Mobileequipment constructionandagricultural was lessaffected,with largeglobal companies likeCaterpillar, JohnDeere,andCNHcontinuingtobe leadersworldwide.
Now,moreandmoreindustryismovingbacktotheU.S.Beingclosetothemarket letsyouadaptproductstoyourcustomersneeds,whichisdifficultwhenyoureoffshoring.Andmanycompaniesunderestimatedthereal expenseoflogistics. Itsnotonlythetransportationcostsbutalsotheadditional inventoryyouhavetohold. Insomecountries,astrikeatthebordermightdelayyourship-mentsbyweeks.All theseaspectswereunderestimated,andmanycompaniesarenowmovingback.
Inaddition,foreigninvestmentisincreasing.BecauseAsiaisno longerdeliveringthegrowthwewereusedtooverthe last 10years,European
andevenChinesecompaniesarere-focusingonothermarkets,includingtheAmericas. I thinkmanufacturingisbeingrevivedintheU.S.
Local-for-localstrategydrives U.S. expansion
Berend BrachtPresident & CEOBoschRexrothAmericasCharlotte,N.C.
MAY 9, 2013MACHINE DESIGN.com36
7/30/2019 Machine Design 9 May 2013
39/77
VANTAGEPOINT
Frank RussoChiefExecutiveOfficerFabricating.comHoboken, N. J.
Sendmessagestospecificmanu-facturers? Andcommunicateviae-mail,text,orvoicemail?
Supplier information.Themar-ketplaceshouldprovidecomprehen-siveinformationaboutthesuppliers
qualifiedtobidonyourRFQ suchasratingsandcustomerfeedback soyoucanmakeaninformeddecision.
Security and storage.Firstandforemost,yourinformationandcommunicationsshouldbesecureandonlyaccessiblebyyou.StoringyourRFQs,quotes,andall com-munications letsyoukeepanaudittrail ofajobandensurethereisnoambiguityaboutthejobspecifica-
tions.Accesstohistorical informa-tiononpreviousprojectsmakesiteasytosubmitRFQstothesamesupplierwithoutrecreatingtherequirements.
Lastly,takeastepbackand lookforwhatiscritical toadynamicmar-ketplace. Isthesourcingcommunitygrowing? Istheunderlyingtechnol-ogyontheforefrontofcustom-manufacturingsourcing? Pickupthephoneandtalktothemanagersofthemarketplaceyouareconsider-ing. Innovatorsarealwaysincontactwiththeircustomerstounderstandthemarketandprovideavaluableproductthatmeetsthechangingneedsoftheirclientbase.
Bottom line: Pro-activesupplierdiscoveryisagoodthing,anditkeepsyourideasandproductsflowingtowardthecustomerwithoutdelays.Butwhenacriticalsupplierdisappearswithoutnotice,havingyourfingertipsonareliable
sourcingplatformwithaqualifiedsupplierbaseismorethanagoodthing itspriceless.MD
Edited byKenneth J.Korane
selectahighlyqualifiedmanu-facturer.Marketplacescanspeedproductintroductions,andtheyletusersproactivelydiversitytheirsupplychainandexploredifferent,possiblymore-effectivemethodsformanufacturingaproduct.
Theacceptanceofmarketplacesby