Monday, April 20, 2009

www.browndailyherald.com 195 Angell Street, Providence, Rhode Island [email protected]

News.....1-4Ar ts........5S p o r t s . . . 9 Editorial..10Opinion...11Today........12

Making WavesMen’s crew swept Northeastern on the Seekonk this weekend

Sports, 9a TasTe of verdeStudents in AmCiv create an exhibit about Cape Verdean immigrants

Arts, 5do your parTAnthony Staehelin ’10 says the success of ADOCH depends on all students

Opinions, 11

insi

deDaily Heraldthe Brown

vol. cxliv, no. 54 | Monday, April 20, 2009 | Serving the community daily since 1891

Lester ’11, wertheimer ’10 finalists for top UCS postBy Ben schreckinger

Senior Staff Writer

Ryan Lester ’11 and Clay Wertheimer ’10 will face each other in a run-off election for president of the Under-graduate Council of Students after receiving the most votes for the po-sition last week. Neither received the 50 percent of the vote needed to win outright.

Jose Vasconez ’10 defeated Salsabil Ahmed ’11 to become chair of the Undergraduate Finance Board.

This year’s elections saw an in-crease from last year in competition

for the top UCS and UFB positions. Voter participation also increased dramatically, with 2,279 ballots cast, up from 1,364 last year, accord-ing to Elections Board Chair Lily Tran ’10.

The vice presidential race for UCS will also go to a run-off, be-tween Harris Li ’11 and Diane Mokoro ’11.

Voting in the run-off elections will begin Monday at 12 p.m. and will close at 6 p.m. Wednesday. As in the regular election, ballots will be cast online through MyCourses.

Sunny, warm Spring weekend delightsBy sydney eMBer

Senior Staff Writer

By the time Of Montreal’s dizzy-ingly psychedelic performance closed with an explosion of feath-ers Saturday Evening, Mother Nature had given little cause for complaint about this year’s Spring Weekend.

Both concerts were held on the Main Green for the first time since 2006, anchoring a weekend marked by warm weather, vibrant perfor-mances and an annual sing-along with acoustic guitarist Dave Binder on Wriston Quadrangle.

“Everything went immaculate-ly,” said Stephen Hazeltine ’09, the Brown Concert Agency’s admin-istrative chair. Almost all of the additional tickets made available after BCA announced the concerts would be held outdoors were sold, said BCA’s booking chair Daniel

Ain ’09. Both shows sold to 90 per-cent capacity, he said — almost 4,500 people per show.

The total count of eight trans-por ts by Emergency Medical Services was slightly less than last year’s. Two transports were reported for Friday night and six for Saturday night, said Vice Presi-dent of Campus Life and Student Services Margaret Klawunn.

She said there were also a num-ber of students who were evaluated by EMS but did not require further aid. There were 10 EMS transports in 2008 and four in 2007, The Her-ald reported last year.

“As far as I know, this year went pretty well,” Klawunn said. “The

Your Brown transcript, off College hillBy nicole friedMan

Senior Staff Writer

At the end of four years, students have surprisingly little physical evidence to show for their time at Brown. Graduating seniors leave with only a transcript, a diploma and lingering questions about how their education will be received by the world beyond College Hill.

Though high school seniors clamor to study under the New Curriculum, its impact on students’ lives after Brown is less clear.

“There’s no way to know what a Brown education does or doesn’t do for someone,” said Associate Professor of Music David Joseph-son P’00, who has taught at Brown

since 1972.Forty years after its implementa-

tion, the New Curriculum is no lon-ger a trial run. Elements that were once shocking — like the option to take any course on a Satisfactory/No Credit basis and the elimina-tion of distribution requirements — are now inseparable from Brown’s identity. Yet current Brunonians find it hard to gauge just how well graduate schools and employers understand the curriculum.

‘forty years of experience’Before the implementation of

the New Curriculum, Brown did not have a nationally recognized identity, said Ira Magaziner ’69 P’06 P’07 P’10, who led the original

Group Independent Study Project that proposed overhauling the Brown education.

The school attracted “brighter people” in the decades after the New Curriculum’s implementa-tion, Josephson said, adding that it was “vital in putting Brown on the map.”

The New Curriculum is now an essential component of Brown’s image. When the Admission Of-fice asks matriculating students their top three reasons for choos-

The New Curriculum at Forty:Part three of four in a series

Student assaulted in showerBy Brian MasTroianni

Senior Staff Writer

A female student was assaulted by an unidentified male while in a Sears House shower on Friday around 6:30 p.m., ac-cording to an e-mail sent to students from the Department of Public Safety Friday night.

The woman –– who did not sustain any injuries –– reported to authorities that the man displayed a knife and shoved her before fleeing the scene, the e-mail said.

“Our detectives were investigating this case (Saturday) ... but I can’t tell you any more than what the crime report men-tioned,” said Mark Porter, Brown’s chief of police and director of public safety.

The Providence Police Department and the Department of Public Safety searched the scene but were unable to identify the woman’s assailant, according to the e-mail.

The incident comes a little more than a month after a female student was pho-tographed by a stranger while she was showering in the first-floor bathroom of Diman House, where the sorority Kappa Alpha Theta is located. That incident is still under investigation.

Sears House is home to Brown’s other sorority, Alpha Chi Omega.

The e-mail to students described the suspect as “a male with a light complexion; possibly white or Hispanic approximately five feet six inches tall, lean build, dark hair, cut short, with a week’s worth of facial hair growth.”

The suspect was seen “wearing a long-hemmed athletic jacket made of swooshy material that was dark in color, light-col-ored blue jeans ... slightly too short so they did not cover his white sneakers properly,” according to the e-mail.

— With additional reporting by Ellen Cushingcontinued on page 2

continued on page 3 continued on page 4

Justin Coleman / HeraldBefore performances by Nas (right) and Of Montreal (below), a student coasted headfirst down a slippery Wriston Quadrangle.

spring Weekend in colorSee photos, pages 6-7

good weather made it an enjoyable weekend.”

Klawunn said the only cause for concern was noise complaints by neighbors during Friday night’s concert. Though Klawunn said ne-gotiations to hold the Friday night concert outside were resolved before 2007’s Spring Weekend,

this year’s concert was the first night concert held on the Main Green. The last two years were relocated to Meehan Auditorium due to rain.

Because of the complaints, Klawunn said there would be evalu-ations this week with Senior Direc-tor for Student Engagement Ricky Gresh to determine next year’s sound volume and concert hours.

Next year’s concerts may start and end earlier, Klawunn said.

The festivities began Thursday afternoon with the annual SPEC Day carnival, which featured snow cones, cotton candy and giant in-flatable structures and games.

Friday’s show opened with lo-cal indie folk band Deer Tick, who entertained the fast-growing crowd with impassioned lyrics and twangy guitars.

Retro soul group Sharon Jones and the Dap-Kings followed with a dynamic and commanding per-formance to prime the audience for hip-hop star Nas and his con-troversial ire.

“This crowd is crazy,” Nas an-nounced in the middle of his set to a wild, feverish audience. “A crowd like this, with it, you don’t want to go home.”

Saturday’s concer t drew a slightly more subdued crowd. Many concert-goers lounged on blankets as the smell of curry from a booth catered by Taste of India flooded the Green.

The student band Doss the Artist and PGA Tour, winners of a battle of the bands competition, featured an eclectic mix of rap, brass, bass and guitar, setting the stage for Toubab Krewe’s world-fusion funk.

The audience packed the center of the Green to see the bombastic and authoritative rhymester Santi-gold, who overwhelmed the crowd with her sleek money-print suit and backup singer-dancers clad in sun-glasses and gold jackets.

Her final number, the insistent dance-infused “Creator,” featured an on-stage dance party with about 10 audience members.

By the time Of Montreal took the stage wearing garish makeup and brightly-colored costumes,

many in attendance were visibly exhausted. The band’s 90-minute set — dampened by an occasional raindrop — featured animal masks, ninjas and frightening silver men parading across the stage in a fre-netic spectacle.

“Santigold rocked it,” said Chris Archuleta ’11. “I just thought the concert was awesome.”

On Friday, with the sun blazing and the temperature approaching a much-appreciated 70 degrees, Aruchuleta participated in an im-promptu race on Wriston, he said. “We put ourselves into the large trash cans and raced down Wris-ton,” he said.

“It was a little out of control, to be honest,” Archuleta said.

Many students also said the weather made the weekend more enjoyable.

“It was super-duper,” Cameron Meyers ’12 said of the concerts. “It was just a lot of fun. I liked seeing

everyone out.”“It was nice to see the trees

blooming,” said Austin Miller ’12. Despite the weather, Miller said he left in the middle of both concerts because he was “bored.”

The only unforeseen circum-stance of the weekend was a wed-ding in Manning Chapel on Satur-day morning when Of Montreal was preparing to have their sound check, according to Hazeltine. But he said everyone — the BCA, Of Montreal and the wedding partici-pants — worked together to coordi-nate the timing of the sound check and the vows.

Next year’s Spring Weekend will be the 50th anniversary of the event, Ain said. He said the BCA hopes to work with the Under-graduate Finance Board to procure additional funding, allowing for an especially popular headliner.

“Our hope is to put on some-thing pretty big,” he said.

sudoku

MONDAy, APRIl 20, 2009THE BROWN DAIly HERAlDPAgE 2

CampUS newS “Emotional balance is for the mediocre and the lazy.”— Sculptor Dave Cole ’00, speaking at a Brown Degree Days event

Degree Days connect department concentrators with alumsBy Juliana friend

Staff Writer

As the last remaining sophomores dropped their concentration forms into the registrar’s unceremonious black bin last week, the University concluded a month-long program intended to help students connect their concentrations to real-world careers.

In the program’s pilot year, Brown Degree Days “exceeded expecta-tions,” hosting over 30 events that attracted high student attendance, said Associate Dean of the Col-lege for Upperclass Studies Karen Krahulik.

For example, at least 72 students attended the Brown Degree Day hosted by the physics department, according to Chung-I Tan, profes-sor of physics and chair of the de-partment. A luncheon with over 30 alums, a roundtable discussion and three guest lectures created “a very interactive environment,” in which students learned about what they could do with a physics degree, said Associate Professor of Physics Meenakshi Narain, who helped or-

ganize the event. The concept for Degree Days was

developed after a successful alumni panel organized by the English de-partment last year, Krahulik said. Last fall, Dean of the College Katherine Bergeron met with members of the Task Force on Undergraduate Educa-tion to discuss hosting a new series of alumni panels to improve the curricu-lar advising system, Krahulik said.

The result was a month of events starting in mid-March with former concentrators in fields from physics to art, designed to get students think-ing about “both the obvious and the not-so-obvious” ways to apply their liberal arts degrees, Krahulik said.

“It’s always comforting to hear the voices of alumni on campus, because they suggest that career pathways don’t have to be so linear,” said Erinn Phelan ’09, who attended and helped organize the second-to-last Brown Degree Day last Tuesday night about careers in public service.

The event, titled “Living an En-gaged Life,” brought together alums from diverse concentrations. Their advice testified to Phelan’s idea that career paths are constantly in flux.

Saeromi Kim ’96, a psychology concentrator who now works as a clinical psychologist at Rhode Island College’s Counseling Center, said the conflict between her personal desires and others’ expectations never quite goes away.

“It took a lot of guts to choose clinical work,” she said during the roundtable discussion Tuesday.

Likewise, Mary-Kim Arnold ’93 MFA’98, an English concentrator as an undergraduate, said her new role as executive director of the Rhode Island Council for the Humanities has sparked a change in perspective.

“I’m on an anti-balance campaign,” Arnold said during the discussion. “Who needs balance when you love what you do?”

While Tuesday’s event suggested that a diverse range of concentra-tions can prepare students for work in the non-profit sector, a panel hosted by the Department of Visual Art demonstrated the diversity of careers that can result from a single concentration.

Dave Cole’s ’00 sculpting career represented a more traditional way of applying a visual arts degree. He

said accomplishing difficult sculp-ture projects — like an enormous fiberglass teddy bear — requires sus-tained effort and intensity, including pulling all-nighters when necessary. “Emotional balance is for the medio-cre and the lazy,” he said.

Clay Rockefeller ’03, who works at the Steel Yard, a public art coop-erative, stressed the importance of risk-taking. “I always had faith in my ability to start over,” he said. “We’re all going to live many different lives in one.”

Will Machin ’00, who produces public art on commission, told cur-rent students that feelings of uncer-tainty and doubt linger even after graduation. “I still wonder if I’m good enough to make art,” Machin said.

This honesty provoked varied reaction among students. Quinn Fenlon ’10.5 said the fact that, even 10 years out of college, professionals do not necessarily have their careers figured out “doesn’t make me feel any better.”

The Career Development Center, which partnered with the Office of the Dean of the College and Alumni Relations to implement the program,

is still in the process of gathering statistics about student attendance at the Degree Days events, said Barbara Peoples, senior associate director of the Career Development Center.

Indeed, Brown Degree Days as-sumed another level of importance for seniors confronting the job market next year. Rachel Moranis ’09, an art history concentrator, said the state of the economy contributed to her interest in the Visual Art panel.

“A lot of my friends are losing their jobs right now,” she said. “I want to hear stories about what people in the art realm are doing.”

The alums’ reflections about their own non-linear career paths helped reassure Phelan, whose future plans were abruptly altered when her job offer was rescinded. She said the lack of job options in the current economy has liberated her from external pres-sure to follow the “standard trajecto-ry” for the first years out of college.

The testimonies of the panelists reinforced Phelan’s belief that “as long as you do something you learn from and are passionate about, that’s enough,” she said. “It’s a very free-ing idea.”

weekend concerts ‘super-duper’continued from page 1

Katherine Regalado / Herald“This crowd is crazy,” rapper Nas shouted during the Friday night show. “A crowd like this, with it, you don’t want to go home.”

Stephen DeLucia, PresidentMichael Bechek, Vice President

Jonathan Spector, TreasurerAlexander Hughes, Secretary

The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serv-ing the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement, once during Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for members of the community. POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Offices are located at 195 Angell St., Providence, R.I. E-mail [email protected]. World Wide Web: http://www.browndailyherald.com. Subscription prices: $319 one year daily, $139 one semester daily. Copyright 2009 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.

editorial phone: 401.351.3372 | Business phone: 401.351.3260Daily Heraldthe Brown

CampUS newSMONDAy, APRIl 20, 2009 THE BROWN DAIly HERAlD PAgE 3

“Brown has not disappointed me for one second.”— Transfer student Miriam Joelson ’11

transfer students embrace life at Brown By alexandra ulMer

Staff Writer

They don’t rave about their fresh-man units and may get lost on parts of campus, but otherwise, transfer students are at home at Brown — at least according to Head Transfer Student Adviser Melea Atkins ’10. A transfer student herself, Atkins acknowledged that while some of her peers may remain isolated, most transfers are very active and integrated on campus.

In addition to her role as an adviser, Atkins is the captain of “Team Tranny,” an intramural soft-ball team, which is symbolic of her view on the evolution of transfer students on campus. Atkins and her close friends created the team as a way to stay in touch after trans-fer orientation.

But now, with 20 members — only half of whom are trans-fers — and the runner-up title in last season’s championship, Team Tranny is representative of transfer students’ initial separa-tion and progressive increase in participation in the larger Brown community.

Alex Vogel ’10, who did not transfer to Brown, joined Team Tranny anyway because he likes “to dabble in the transfer crowd.”

“They are all very indicative of the normal Brown student,” Vogel said. “You wouldn’t be able to tell the difference from anyone else.”

Despite their comfort on cam-pus, the members of the team often burst out with jokes about being transfers. “We perpetually joke that we don’t know what’s going on,” Atkins said. “The ironic part of that joke is that we are pretty involved.”

Atkins transferred from Cornell to Brown as a sophomore in the fall of 2007, principally because she found Cornell too socially and academically intense. “It was definitely a hard decision to make,” she said. “But it was a great decision.”

To make the decision to transfer equally positive for others, Atkins coordinates the Transfer Orienta-tion Programs at the beginning of the fall and spring semesters. Dur-ing the three-day sessions, trans-fer students have meals together, meet with deans and are informed about how to transfer credits.

The University has undergone a “large improvement” in the way it welcomes transfer students, At-kins said. This year, for the first time, every incoming sophomore transfer student was paired with a Faculty Advising Fellow. The fel-lows help transfers as they navi-gate Brown’s unique academic environment.

The workload at Brown was a challenge after transferring from North Virginia Community Col-lege, Keith Sado ’10 said, but he considered Brown his home by the end of his first semester.

“I had the impression it was this hippie, hacky-sack type people,” Sado said. “But the classes have been enjoyable and the people re-ally interesting.”

Sado’s sentiments were echoed by Miriam Joelson ’11, a sopho-more who transferred from Bryn Mawr College last fall. “Many of my relatives were afraid that Brown couldn’t possibly live up to my sky scraping expectations,” she wrote in an e-mail to The Herald. “But Brown has not disappointed me for one second.”

During the summer and fall of 2008, Joelson was in contact with Maitrayee Bhattacharyya, assis-tant dean for diversity programs and the transfer student academic adviser, as well as other deans and academic advisers. As a result, she wrote, the transition was a “breeze.”

After the transition period, Joelson dove into many activities through which she met non-trans-fer students, who today account for many of her friends. “It really boils down to compatibility,” she wrote. “And for that, it doesn’t matter if you’ve transferred or not.”

Transferring internationally can multiply the difficulties, according to Petros Perselis ’10, who trans-ferred to Brown from the National Technical University in Athens this fall. “My first thought was to leave a major Greek engineering school to search for better opportunities here in the U.S. and mature aca-demically,” he wrote in an e-mail to The Herald.

Brown’s engineering program, the New England culture and the opportunity to do research with professors also appealed to Perselis.

He wrote that he felt very welcomed at Brown, especially through the International Men-toring Program. “I met many international students — both freshmen and transfers — and with which I am still friends,” Perselis wrote. But now, Perselis added, “I have friends which do not belong to a single category; freshmen, transfers, Americans or internationals.”

Transfer students cannot be categorized, wrote Sara Wilf ’10 in an e-mail to The Herald, because “each of us has our own, highly individual reasons for being here.” But Wilf highlighted the determi-nation of all transfer students. “We weren’t happy at our old schools, for whatever reason,” she wrote. “But instead of staying there we actually did something about it.”

Wilf transferred from Vassar College this fall because she was displeased with the size and loca-tion of the school and was in search of a more intellectual atmosphere, she wrote. At Brown, Wilf immedi-ately became very close to fellow transfer students during orienta-tion, and she still counts transfer students as her best friends.

“It would be strange not to, considering we’re all in the same position and are all nervous about making new friends,” Wilf wrote. But “every single transfer has expanded outside of the transfer group in some way and has made lots of “real” Brown friends (as we like to call them).”

She praised the involvement of transfer students in extracurricu-lar activities and suggested that this was due to their excitement at being at Brown and their strong determination.

“I am profoundly grateful to be here,” Wilf wrote. “I feel so fortu-nate to have been given this op-portunity that I want to make the most of every single day.”

Candidates need only a plurality of votes to win — nullifying the effect of abstentions.

The Elections Board will an-nounce final election results at the UCS general body meeting Wednes-day at 7:30 p.m. in Petteruti Lounge and submit them to the council for certification.

The winner of the vice chair race for UFB is Juan Vasconez ’10, who ran unopposed after Neil Parikh ’11 withdrew his name from the ballot Wednesday. As a result, Elections Board officials determined Thurs-day night that Vasconez needed only 5 percent of the vote to win, which he received.

On Thursday, Tran confirmed earlier reports that Parikh was caught removing posters belong to both Jose and Juan Vasconez on Tuesday night, and that she and an-other member of the board “sug-gested” that he withdraw his name

from the race. In other voting, Robert Taj

Moore ’11 was elected chair of the UCS Academic and Administrative Affairs Committee.

At-large representatives on UFB will be Herald Senior Staff Writer Mi-tra Anoushiravani ’11, Herald Sales Director Ellen DaSilva ’10, Adam Kiki-Charles ’11, Soobin Kim ’11, Jason Lee ’12 and Herald Opinions Columnist Tyler Rosenbaum ’11.

The three candidates who ran uncontested for UCS Executive Board positions each received at least the necessary 5 percent of the vote necessary to win.

Of those Ben Farber ’12 will be the Campus Life chair, Brady Wyrtzen ’11 has been elected to be Student Activities chair and the Ad-missions and Student Services chair will be Andrew Bergmanson ’11.

The position of UCS treasurer will be vacant because no candidate ran for the position and no write-ins received 5 percent of the vote.

continued from page 1

Vasconez named UFB chair after unopposed race

it’s new. www.browndailyherald.com

ing Brown, they most often cite the curriculum, according to Dean of Admissions Jim Miller ’73.

The “self-selective group” of stu-dents who come to Brown are seen as “intellectually adventurous and more creative in what they’re do-ing” than students at the University’s peer schools, Magaziner said.

Brown students have “never been hurt” by the curriculum in apply-ing to the University of California at Berkeley’s Boalt Hall School of Law, said Edward Tom, its dean of admissions. He added that Brown has a strong reputation as one of the law school’s top feeder colleges, and good grades from Brown stand out more than a “3.8 from the University of the Bahamas.”

Brown transcripts are not viewed any differently in graduate school admissions because of the New Cur-riculum, said Pamela Schirmeister, associate dean of Yale’s Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. Rather than evaluating a student’s under-graduate work as a whole, she said she focuses on students’ perfor-mance in the field for which they are applying.

Even if employers are not familiar with the details of the curriculum, they understand the openness and diversity of ideas that Brown stu-dents offer, said Laura Joshi, man-ager of employer relations for the Career Development Center.

Employers “value what a Brown education represents,” said Barba-ra Peoples, interim director of the CDC. The center sends information packets to employers to explain Brown’s curriculum, but Peoples said not many employers ask for transcripts.

Peoples said she has never known the New Curriculum to be “anything but a positive” for students in their post-college endeavors.

“Graduate schools and faculty elsewhere have long experience, 40 years of experience, with un-dergraduates as products of the so-called ‘New’ — the aging New Curriculum,” Dean of the Graduate School Sheila Bonde said.

“That said, I think people regu-

larly, not just in graduate schools but elsewhere, kind of misunder-stand and assume that there are no requirements” at all, she added. Though there are no distribution requirements, Brown requires that students complete 30 classes, finish a concentration, and demonstrate proficiency in writing.

“By and large, Brown has a very strong reputation as a producer of competitive and creative students,” Bonde said.

‘all of that crap’The original student proposal for

the New Curriculum, produced by Magaziner’s GISP, suggested eventu-ally phasing out grades altogether in favor of written evaluations. This idea was eventually scrapped over concerns that it would impact gradu-ate school admissions, Magaziner said.

The committee that finalized the curricular proposal decided to instead eliminate “the pluses and minuses — all of that crap” and give students the option to take any class on an S/NC basis, he said. That pro-fessors can now grade any class on an exclusively S/NC basis is an option members of that committee envisioned many courses would take advantage of, Magaziner said.

All literary arts workshops and non-fiction writing courses are currently mandatory S/NC. This “makes a lot of sense,” since such courses require qualitative rather than quantitative assessment, and giving students “grades, pluses or minuses defeats the purpose of what I’m trying to do in the class,” said Senior Lecturer in English Catherine Imbriglio, who teaches several small non-fiction classes.

One disadvantage is that students assume S/NC courses will be less work, Imbriglio said, adding that she tells students on syllabi not to take one of her writing courses as a fifth class.

The University generally advises undergraduates to take courses in their concentration for a grade. This is, of course, impossible to do in full for literary arts and non-fiction writ-ing concentrators, which “may pose a little bit of a problem” for students

who want to continue on to gradu-ate school in a discipline other than writing, Imbriglio said.

Though transcripts mark classes that are mandatory S/NC with an as-terisk, Schirmeister, associate dean of Yale’s graduate school, said she was not aware that some courses at Brown required such grading.

Grades of “satisfactory” are “kind of hard to assess,” Schirmeister said. “You’d have to be pretty terrible to fail.”

S/NC grades can make gradu-ate schools rely more on letters of recommendation and personal state-ment essays, Bonde said.

Taking every class S/NC, though possible, would be a “very poor deci-sion on the part of the student,” said Professor of Music Emerita Rose Subotnik, who is retiring in May after teaching at Brown since 1990. “The outside world doesn’t want to work that hard. They don’t want to read all those course reports.”

Course performance reports, which a student can request for any class, include sections written by both the professor and the stu-dent about the student’s work in the course.

Schirmeister and Bonde both said graduate schools read course performance reports carefully.

But professors worry that “they don’t get read nearly so much as a clean grade does,” Josephson said.

Rather than tell graduate schools what grade a student would have received in a course, the reports should function as a dialogue be-tween the student and the professor, Imbriglio said.

Course performance reports were created to make evaluation a part of the educational process, Magaziner said.

“The idea that you’re doing it in order to get graded or sort of clas-sified in some way by a letter — as if a letter could represent the sum total of what somebody is or has accomplished — was offensive to us,” Magaziner said.

‘loading the dice’Forty years later, the freedoms

of the New Curriculum may have had unintended and possibly nega-

tive results, especially for students who prioritize the strength of their transcripts over the quality of their undergraduate experiences.

Because the lack of distribution requirements makes it easier to complete multiple concentrations, around 20 percent of each class completes two concentrations, and a few students each year even com-plete three, according to Registrar Michael Pesta.

Tom, the law school dean, said having two majors does not necessar-ily improve an applicant’s chances.

“A lot of people falsely think that having a double major gives you brownie points,” he said. “It does not.”

Josephson urges the students he advises not to double concentrate just because they can, even if they are only one or two courses away from fulfilling the requirements. “I ask them, ‘What do you mean, if you just take one more (course)?’” he said. “It means you deprive yourself of 150 others.”

But Gale Nelson AM’88, lecturer in literary arts and assistant director of the program, said he encourages the students he advises to “seriously consider” double concentrating — or at least to take clusters of courses in disciplines other than their concen-trations — so as to have as many op-tions after graduation as possible.

Jeremy Goodman ’10 is one of just a few students who have three concentrations, though he acknowl-edged his choice could be a “fail-ing on my part of not exploiting the Brown curriculum to the fullest.”

Goodman, who is concentrating in physics, philosophy and cognitive neuroscience, has only taken two courses that do not count toward any of his concentrations. “It’s been pointed out to me to me that it’s kind of insane,” he said.

“I wanted to take certain classes regardless, so it just ended up hap-pening,” he added. “I didn’t go into this trying to triple concentrate.”

Though the New Curriculum can make it easier for students to add achievements to a transcript, its lack of structure makes it difficult for graduate schools and employers to get a complete view of a student, Josephson said.

Just as there are mandatory S/NC courses, he said, students should be forbidden to take introductory courses that teach essential skills for a discipline on an S/NC basis. Allowing students to take even core

concentration courses S/NC and not recording failing grades denies ex-ternal reviewers a “full, transparent, honest accounting of how you did when you were here,” he said.

For example, Tom said, taking a course S/NC would only hurt an ap-plicant if he or she were to receive an NC, but that situation would never appear on a Brown transcript.

The New Curriculum is “load-ing the dice against the academic standards” in some areas towards the interests of students, Josephson said. While most students do not try to abuse the system, some would choose to fail or drop a course when “faced with a recorded C versus a hidden NC,” he said.

But students are not the only ones who prioritize final grades over educational experience. In the 2007-2008 academic year, over 50 percent of all grades recorded by professors were A’s.

Not having pluses and minuses increases grade inflation, Subotnik said. Teachers “end up knocking that B-plus to an A when it wasn’t really deserved,” she said. “If you can give a kid a B-plus, then it’s clear that the kid was in the top echelon and you don’t feel quite so bad that they didn’t get an A.”

But grade inflation is “so ram-pant” across the country and around the world that not having pluses and minuses could only account for a “minor wrinkle” in that, Bonde said.

Grade inflation can mostly be traced to the “intense” pressure for students to get into graduate institu-tions, which fuels a “natural impulse to give students the benefit of the doubt” in order to see them succeed, said President Ruth Simmons. But because grades are now expected to be high across the board, “they start to fade into the background” in admissions decisions in favor of other methods of evaluation, she said.

“You’re rarely looking at grades anyway,” she added.

People see the curriculum through many lenses, Josephson said. It is its individualistic spirit that makes its effects so hard to under-stand and leads to disagreement about its value.

“This is a Swiss cheese of a cur-riculum,” Josephson said. “And whether you see the cheese or the holes depends on who’s doing the looking.”


CampUS newS “This is a Swiss cheese of a curriculum.”— Associate Professor of Music David Josephson P’00

Herald File PhotoMembers of the Special Committee on Curricular Philosophy spoke to the University’s Curriculum Committee in April 1969.


The new Curriculum, outside the gates

arts & CultureThe Brown Daily Herald

MONDAy, APRIl 20, 2009 | PAgE 5

Seniors’ home-spun podcast spins its own storyBy rosalind schonWald

Staff Writer

The Ladies Village Improvement Society is the next logical step for the maturing MySpace generation. With their online podcasts, Rachel Blatt ’09 and Lacy Roberts ’09 aren’t attempting radical moral “Improve-ment,” but rather are transforming the traditional radio form to fit the do-it-yourself world of open-source Internet platforms. These friendly Internet personalities have charged themselves with weaving together collections of stories, perspectives and happenings in each of their NPR-esque installments.

“Everyone has a story. It’s our way of improving the world,” Blatt

said, as she and Roberts prepared to record their most recent show. The episode included a section featuring Wag’s Revue, a literary journal re-cently started by Brown seniors.

The podcasters have made the most of their local resources, often promoting and using the services of Brown alums and local Providence-dwellers. Blatt and Roberts reached out to friends at Brown to develop their project. Roberts contacted Emma Price ’09, asking her to put her cartooning skills to use to help make illustrations for lvisradio.org, the official Web site for the podcast. Michael Fruta ’09 helped with the technical side of Web site design.

amCiv class studies local Cape Verdeans By aniTa MaTheWs

Staff Writer

Students in Professor Steven Lubar’s AMCV1550: “Methods in Public Humanities” will unveil their col-laborative final project –– an exhibit about the community of Cape Ver-dean immigrants that inhabited the Fox Point region in the 1930s –– on Saturday, May 9 at the John Nicholas Brown center.

The class, which examines the curatorial aspects of public show-cases, puts up an exhibit each year. The students voted to create the Cape Verde project through a partnership with Claire Andrade-Watkins, a professor of visual and media arts at Emerson College and a visiting scholar at Brown’s Center for the Study of Race and Ethnicity. Andrade-Watkins grew up in one of Providence’s tight-knit Cape Verdean communities. The neigh-borhood, once concentrated in the area around Wickenden Street, has since devolved into smaller pockets around the state. The fragmentation of the neighborhood is attributed to many causes, including the con-struction of Interstate-95.

The focus of the exhibit, how-ever, is on the “Golden Age” of this Cape Verdean community from the 1930s to 1950s, not the reasons be-

hind its recent splintering. Andrade-Watkins, whom Dan

Lurie ’11, a student in the class, calls “the driving force behind this proj-ect,” has been the primary link be-tween students and the families who have since moved from Fox Point to East Providence, South Providence, Cranston and other areas. All the artifacts used in the exhibit were provided by these Cape Verdean community members, a change for Lubar’s course from years past when most pieces necessary for the final exhibit could be gathered from the University’s existing collection.

Lurie, who is part of the project’s publishing team, hopes visitors to the exhibit will gain an understand-ing about how much the area has changed, evolving from a residential area to an area that caters almost exclusively to shoppers and restau-rant-goers.

Fox Point “used to be a commu-nity center,” he said. “Now it’s just a place we go on the weekends.”

Lubar echoed Lurie’s senti-ments, saying, “Many Brown stu-dents would be surprised to learn that 50 years ago it was a very differ-ent kind of place. It’s important for students to have an understanding of that local history that disappears too easily.”

Both Lurie and Lubar drew at-

tention to the gentrification of the area and how the restaurants and businesses have taken over spaces which used to house Cape Verdean immigrant families. Utrecht, the art supply store, Lurie pointed out, used to be a hardware store, and a library from that “Golden” era is now an antique store.

Lubar said the port on Narra-gansett Bay, which used to provide most of the jobs for the working men in the Cape Verdean commu-nity, has now almost completely disappeared.

As the students put the final touches on the Fox Point exhibit, Lubar said he hopes it will act as a truthful representation of Fox Point’s Cape Verdean district, be-coming as informative a project for visitors as it has been for his students.

“The challenge in an exhibit like this,” said Lubar, “is that it has to be both a useful educational experience for the students who are doing it, but at the same time respectful and interesting to the community that it is about.”

The exhibit, which will run through October, will be on display in the Carriage House Gallery at the John Nicholas Brown Center for Public Humanities and Cultural Heritage.

continued on page 8

It’s hard to produce self-respecting soul about the enslave-ment of Africans and the genocide perpetrated against Native Americans in the United States. Unless you’re Sharon Jones, in which case you mix together some utterly uninhibited dancing, a killer voice and a communicative impulse so unfettered and sincere that listening to your story becomes everyone’s top priority, no questions asked. Irony would have killed this, so past atrocities were incorporated into a biography written in movement, an ecstatic celebration of the body — feet, knees, hips, arms, neck and head. That doesn’t account for the soul, but never mind — this performance had soul to spare.

The conservative establishment has not been kind to this campus. Just two weeks ago, Rush limbaugh ac-

cused some Brown students of having “spoiled, rotten little skulls full of mush with brains that represent

the arid expanse of the Sahara Desert.” And don’t even get us started on Bill O’Reilly. So thank you, Nas, for

helping us release years of built-up tension and resentment as we sang along to “Sly Fox” on Friday night.

Trust us, we’ll watch what we’re watchin’. That’s why we have MCM.

living on Wriston Quad can be dingy and unpleasant sometimes, but

not on Spring Weekend. Why? Ignore the broken bottles, the beaten-

down plots of grass and the sticky-sweet smell that seems to be

everywhere, and what do you have left? lady gaga, blaring from the

southern wing of Chapin House. So, Thete, here’s to you, for using

your (somewhat unexpected) love of techno remixes to make the lives

of your fellow Patriots’ Court residents a little more fabulous.

Justin Coleman / Herald

Katherine Regalado / Herald





Katherine Regalado / Herald6spring

leading off with driving performances of “you’ll Find a Way” and

“l.E.S. Artistes,” Santigold’s performance was miraculous from the

start. Her undefinable music deftly evades labels, but its essential

nature is, quite simply, irresistible, as we all learned firsthand on

Saturday. Santi White (to use your real name): The jumpsuit made

of money was fierce, but perhaps superfluous. Don’t deny it — you

are money.

Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition. But everyone with half a brain expected Of Montreal to deliver a

Boschian fever dream of a performance that would at once perplex, freak out and exhilarate its audience.

Hypersexualized and so completely post-gender binary, they’ve always been one of the Brown-iest of bands

around — who else would sing about falling in love with a girl because she could “appreciate georges Ba-

taille?” And, oh, Benefit Street homeowners? That caterwauling you heard on Saturday — that was hundreds

of college students vainly attempting to produce the magnificent, cathedral-worthy chords in “gronlandic

Edit.” Sorry. We’ll send you a fruit basket. — Ben Hyman

7






Justin

Colem

an / H

erald



weekend

spring


artS & CULtUre “I feel really happy and really lucky to have found such an awesome collaborative relationship.” — lacy Roberts ’09

“We’ve gotten a lot of help from people from Brown and RISD. Not just Brown but Providence people, too,” Roberts said.

The story of the Ladies Village Improvement Society actually start-ed far from Providence, in Blatt’s hometown of East Hampton, New York.

“There’s a thrift shop there called the Ladies Village Improvement So-ciety, and all the fancy ladies from Long Island donate stuff there,” said Roberts. “It’s great, and it’s cheap and we just thought it was funny. We went through a lot of ideas for names and wound up choosing that one.”

The podcasts are largely home-spun, despite all the help the hosts have in overall production.

In the self-starting spirit so famil-iar at Brown — and with the do-it-yourself approach of the YouTube crowd — Blatt and Roberts do all of the recording, editing and writing themselves, using various locations on campus as their workshops.

“One of the ways that we’ve made this space our own is we’ve hidden thumbtacks in the walls,” said Roberts during their most recent recording session, as Blatt stuck the three-page script to the wall of a clandestine practice room

in Orwig. Their most recent podcast, called

the “Site Specific Show,” revolved around the theme of spaces — their associations, back stories and what makes them special. This theme is particularly relevant to their tran-sition to post-college life and also to the continued existence of the podcast — the future of which is uncertain without a fixed broadcast-ing space.

The two don’t yet have plans for life after graduation but dream of moving to the Bay area, living to-gether in a three-bedroom house and continuing to run their podcasts. The house would have three bed-rooms, of course, because one would be reserved as space for a recording studio, Blatt said.

“Me and Rachel work together really, really well,” Roberts added. “I feel really happy and really lucky to have found such an awesome collaborative relationship. ... We’re graduating in the spring, and we don’t exactly have plans. We’re try-ing to organize moving, hopefully close together.”

Roberts said the best chance for this podcast to thrive in future years is to attract listenership. “The more people who listen to it, the more people are going to listen to it and the bigger a chance we have of keep-ing it going.”


Ladies Village hits Internet through students’ podcasts

Crew sweeps weekend racesBy andreW Braca

SportS editor

In front of a boisterous home crowd, the men’s crew swept four races from Northeastern on Saturday on the Seekonk River.

“It was a really strong showing by all the boats in the program,” said Mike Snyder ’09. “To sweep a crew like Northeastern shows a lot of depth, and I think it’s a testament to how hard we’ve been working this season.”

Sandwiched between three run-aways, the varsity eight battled the Huskies down to the wire before pulling out a win by less than three seconds to win the Dreissigacker Cup for the fourth straight time.

“Northeastern traditionally is a very tough crew,” said Scott Morgan ’10, who was in the sixth seat. “They were able to hang with us and give us a big challenge down the course, but I think that’s the type of race that’s really going to prepare us for the championship season.”

Saturday was a memorable day for the Brown crew program. The men alternated races with the women, who swept Boston University in five contests.

“For both the men and the women to win all the races, that’s something to be proud of,” said men’s Head Coach Paul Cooke ’89. “The strength of the program as a whole was apparent for both squads.”

The afternoon began for the men

with the third varsity four. The Bears pulled away early and kept growing their lead, crossing the line at 6:32.93 — about 12 seconds ahead of the Huskies.

The second varsity eight posted a similarly strong finish, clocking in at 5:36.56, while Northeastern followed at 5:48.94.

The varsity eight faced a tougher challenge. Even though Brown got off to a fast start, the Huskies put up a fight that Cooke said the Bears weathered well.

“They kept their cool,” he said. “There were a couple times in the middle of the race where it seemed like they had some pressure put on them, but I think they handled it well and pulled away at the end.”

Brown crossed the line at 5:30.04, followed by Northeastern at 5:32.76.

“It was a really challenging race,” said coxswain Rob O’Leary ’09. “They really tested us all the way down the course. We expected them to come out and really put a lot of pressure on us, and it’s exciting that we were able to respond well and pull out a win.”

In the final men’s race of the day, the freshman eight cruised to a com-fortable win, crossing the finish line at 5:41.72 — 10.84 seconds ahead of the Huskies — to complete the four-race sweep.

Zack Gazzaniga ’09 said the strong performances across the board would lead to a good atmosphere when the boats train against each other.

“If every boat comes off a win fired

up, then they’re going to train better next week, which will consequently make every boat faster the following week” in competition, he said. “Having a boathouse filled with guys that are fired up and ready to go really makes a difference.”

After the race, both the men’s and women’s crews headed down to Marston Boathouse for a boisterous cookout. Snyder said the men enjoyed racing with the women.

“They’ve clearly been really suc-cessful the past couple of years,” he said. “It’s nice to sort of have them to work with in the boathouse, because we know they’re going fast, and it sort of inspires us, how well they do. It’s fun to get everyone together.”

After winning just two out of five races against Harvard the previous weekend, the clean sweep was an important step forward as the team prepares to face Dartmouth next Sat-urday in Hanover, N.H., in its penulti-mate dual race of the season.

“The guys got some wins under their belt, they bounced back after the loss last week to Harvard in the varsity, and I think they’re eager and looking forward to getting better in the coming week,” Cooke said.

Morgan agreed that the coming week of training would be critical.

“We have a big week of training ahead,” he said. “We know we have another tough opponent, so we’re go-ing to get back to the grindstone and really get to it next week and work hard.”

Strong starts not enough for w. laxBy dan alexander

SportS Staff Writer

Leading 2-1 at halftime against No. 3 Penn (13-0, 7-0 Ivy) Saturday, the women’s lacrosse team (6-7, 2-3) gave up a huge second half, giving the Quakers a 14-4 win and the Bears their second loss of the week.

In their first game of the week on Tuesday, the Bears took an early 3-2 lead at Quinnipiac (12-2) but began their slide with five minutes left in the first half. They ultimately fell 11-6.

Captain Lauren Vitkus ’09 led the Bears with two goals against Quinnipiac, but couldn’t find op-portunities against Penn and she didn’t take a single shot on Saturday. Vitkus was helped by Jesse Nunn ’09, Kelly Robinson ’09, and Paris Waterman ’11, who each scored a goal in both games.

Quinnipiac 11, Brown 6The Bears started strong against

Quinnipiac, gaining a 2-1 lead 8:49 after the opening draw, but it was the Bobcats who were on top after the final whistle.

Quinnipiac came into the game on a hot streak, having won five consecutive games. They shredded defenses over that stretch, averag-ing more than 18 goals per game.

Vitkus said Brown’s defense was one of the only strong points in a tough day for the Bears. “We played terribly,” Vitkus said. “But

our defense did play solid.”The Bears held the Bobcats to

fewer goals than any other team since Quinnipiac began its run on March 29.

Quinnipiac scored its second goal at 19:41, but Brown regained a one-goal lead on Vitkus’s first of the afternoon at 23:27. The Bears were not ahead for long, as the Bobcats scored three goals in under three minutes and never looked back.

The Bobcats extended their lead to 7-3 with two goals early in the second half.

The Bears looked like they might stage a comeback when Nunn scored her first goal of the afternoon at 9:18 and Vitkus added her second just over two minutes later, making it a 7-5 game.

Quinnipiac widened the gap by rattling off four consecutive goals in ten minutes to go ahead, 11-5, with less than eight minutes left on the clock.

Waterman scored one more for the Bears, but the final score ended 11-6 in Quinnipiac’s favor.

When asked what Quinnipiac did well, Vitkus paused before saying, “I think they did a good job capital-izing on our mistakes. I don’t know what they did necessarily — I think we sort of beat ourselves.”

penn 14, Brown 4The Bears returned to Ivy

League play on Saturday when they took on league leader Penn,

which had not lost a league game since 2006.

Penn got off to a slow start in what proved to be its 22nd consecu-tive Ivy League win.

Robinson put Brown on the scoreboard first when she net-ted an unassisted goal 10:40 into the game.

The Bears added another goal 3:21 later when Nunn scored her second of the week and 22nd of the season to put Brown up 2-0 on its home turf.

The two teams combined for only 12 shots in the first half, and the scoring was similarly low.

“They like to slow it down, and we were going to slow it down against them, so it was a 2-1 game in the first half — which is ridicu-lous,” Caldwell said. “They’re used to scoring at will.”

Penn finally got its only first-half goal with less than six minutes re-maining in the half, making it 2-1 Brown going into the break.

“We were pretty pumped up,” Vitkus said. “We knew they were going to come out extremely strong in the second half — we heard their coach kind of yelling at them.”

The Quakers exploded in the second half. They scored 3:09 af-ter halftime, tying the game 2-2 and sparking a 13-1 run over the next 21:44.

Penn had possession for most of the second half. The Quakers led the draw control count by only

9-7, but Caldwell said the statistics were misleading.

“We won a lot of (draw controls) and lost them within a couple of seconds of gaining possession, so we never actually got on offense,” she said.

Caldwell scored Brown’s lone goal during that stretch with a free position shot at 7:30.

The Quakers’ win completed a 7-0 Ivy League season, making them the Ivy League Champions for the third year in a row.

The Bears will continue their Ivy

League campaign when they head to Princeton, N.J., to face the No. 7 Princeton Tigers (11-2, 5-1) next Saturday. The Tigers have taken nine of their last ten contests, in-cluding a 14-4 win over Dartmouth last Saturday. Their lone loss in that stretch was a 10-5 game at Penn.

“You can count on Princeton be-ing extremely cocky and confident always, so I think that we can — I mean I know that we can — really give them a run for their money,” Caldwell said. “But we have to be completely on our game.”

SportsmondayMONDAy, APRIl 20, 2009 | Page 9

The Brown Daily Herald

Justin Coleman / Herald File PhotoThe Bears lost to Penn and Quinnipiac last week.

T-minus 4

editorial & LettersPage 10 | MONDAy, APRIl 20, 2009


F R A N N Y C H O I

Young trustee elections

C O R R E C T I O N S P O L I C YThe Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Correc-tions may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.

C O M M E N T A R Y P O L I C YThe editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.

L E T T E R S T O T H E E D I T O R P O L I C YSend letters to [email protected]. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the author’s identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed.

A D V E R T I S I N G P O L I C YThe Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.

letter to the editors

editorial

senior staff Writers Mitra Anoushiravani, Ellen Cushing, Sydney Ember, lauren Fedor, Nicole Friedman, Britta greene, Sarah Husk, Brian Mastroianni, Hannah Moser, Ben Schreckinger, Caroline Sedano, Melissa Shube, Anne Simons, Sara Sunshine staff Writers Zunaira Choudhary, Chris Duffy, Nicole Dungca, Juliana Friend, Cameron lee, Kelly Mallahan, Christian Martell, Heeyoung Min, Seth Motel, Jyotsna Mullur, lauren Pischel, leslie Primack, Anne Speyer, Alexandra Ulmer, Kyla Wilkessports staff Writers Nicole Stocksenior Business associates Max Barrows, Jackie goldman, Margaret Watson, Ben XiongBusiness associates Diahndra Burman, Stassia Chyzhykova, Caroline Dean, Marco deleon, Katherine galvin, Bonnie Kim, Maura lynch, Cathy li, Allen Mcgonagill, liana Nisimova, Thanases Plestis, Agathe Roncey, Corey Schwartz, William Schweitzer, Kenneth So, Evan Sumortin, Haydar Taygun, Anshu Vaish, Webber Xu, lyndse yessdesign staff Katerina Dalavurak, gili Kliger, Jessica Kirschner, Joanna lee, Maxwell Rosero, leor Shtull-leber, John Walsh, Kate Wilson, Qian yinphoto staff Qidong Chen, Janine Cheng, Alex DePaoli, Frederic lu, Quinn Savit, Min Wucopy editors Sara Chimene-Weiss, Sydney Ember, lauren Fedor, Miranda Forman, Casey gaham, Anna Jouravleva, geoffrey Kyi, Frederic lu, Jordan Mainzer, Kelly Mallahan, Madeleine Rosenberg Web developers Jihan Chao

Jessica Calihan, Leor Shtull-Leber, Designers

Kathryn Delaney, Miranda Forman, Frederic Lu, Copy editors

Hannah Levintova, Brain Mastroianni, Anne Simons, Night editors

the brown daily herald

Ben hymanhannah levintovasophia liemmy lissgaurie TilakMatthew varleygeorge MillerJoanna Wohlmuthchaz kelshJenna starkBenjy asherandrew Bracaalex Mazerovkatie Wood

Chris Jesu LeeStephen LichensteinEunice HongKim PerleyJustin Coleman

graphics editorgraphics editor

Photo editorPhoto editor

Sports Photo editor

Graphics & photos

BuSiNeSS

Kathryn DelaneySeth MotelMarlee BruningJessica CalihanAnna MigliaccioJulien OuelletNeal Poole

ProDuCtioNCopy Desk ChiefCopy Desk Chief

Design editorDesign editor

asst. Design editorasst. Design editor

Web editor

eDitorialArts & Culture EditorArts & Culture Editor

Features EditorFeatures Editor

Higher Ed EditorHigher Ed Editor

Metro EditorMetro EditorNews EditorNews Editor

Sports EditorSports Editor

Asst. Sports EditorAsst. Sports Editor

editor-in-chief

steve delucia

senior editors

rachel arndtcatherine cullenscott lowenstein

associate editors

nandini Jayakrishnafranklin kanin

Michael skocpol

ManaGinG editors

Michael Bechekchaz firestone

oPiNioNS Sarah Rosenthal opinions editor

editorial paGe board

James ShapiroNick BakshiZack BeauchampSara MolinaroWilliam Martin

editorial Page editorBoard memberBoard memberBoard memberBoard member

General ManaGers

alexander hughesJonathan spector

office ManaGer

shawn reilly

directorsellen dasilvaclaire kiely phil Maynardkatie kohJilyn chao

ManaGers

kelly Wesskathy Buialex carrerechristiana stephensonMatt Burrows

Sales DirectorSales DirectorSales Director

Finance Directorasst. Finance Director

local SalesNational Sales

university Salesrecruiter Sales

Credit and Collections

PoSt- magaziNeArthur Matuszewski Kelly McKowen

editor-in-Chiefeditor-in-Chief

At an upcoming meeting this May, the Brown Corporation will likely approve a proposal to reserve a few spaces in its membership for young alumni trustees, according to recent Herald coverage. Under the proposal, young alums, defined as students who left Brown less than seven years ago, would be appointed by the Corporation Committee on Trustee Vacancies and would serve for three-year terms, as opposed to the usual six-year tenure for trustees.

The purpose of the proposal is to make sure that student perspectives are given more weight in Corporation decisions. This is a worthwhile aim for a body that has drawn criticism for its isolation from student concerns. But if the Corporation is truly committed to obtaining input about the undergraduate experience, it should use a more representative selection process. To that end, we recommend making young alumni trustee an elected position.

All and only recent alums — again, those who left Brown under seven years ago — should have a vote. Elections might entail narrowing down the pool of candidates to a reasonable number. We suggest letting anyone run in the first election, and, if too many people enter the race, requiring a minimum number of signatures for eligibility in future elections.

Elections for the young alumni position would best advance the Corpo-ration’s goals. The Corporation cannot adequately take account of student opinion — that’s the basis for designating spaces for young alums in the first place — and it will run into the same problem in trying to pick alums that understand student priorities. No individual can represent the student body, but elections would increase the likelihood that the young alumni chosen are those most in touch with campus affairs.

Some might argue that Corporation members are in a better position than recent alums to choose a young alumni trustee with the right quali-ties. We’re inclined to disagree, but we would encourage the Corporation to provide voters with a description of the trustee’s duties so that they can make a more informed decision.

Elections offer another advantage over appointments. By giving recent alums a bigger stake in University decisions, the Corporation would foster young alumni participation in the Brown community. Increased alumni en-gagement, and the ensuing dialogue about what makes for a good trustee, will ensure that the Corporation gets the full benefit from its newest position.

Editorials are written by The Herald’s editorial page board. Send comments to [email protected].

Bring students to the CorporationTo the editor:

While the Corporation would likely benefit from the addition of younger members, it is precipitate to set any demographic requirements for candidates. The sole criterion for membership should be the likelihood that a candidate will contribute to the effectiveness of the Corporation. Diversity will occur naturally with such a standard. Women and other minority members became an important part of the Corporation because they had something to offer. It would be demeaning and counterproductive to mandate an “African American” position or “Female Hispanic” position — the same logic should apply to age.

I would like to propose an alternative to the ‘young alum’ position on the committee. Perhaps UCS could internally elect a student to become the “Corporation

Liaison.” Not just anybody should be considered — the liaison must be a general body member (meaning he or she must attend two UCS meetings and collect 150 signatures). The liaison could try to coordinate more student and corporation interaction. He or she should lobby to have corporation members come to UCS meetings and for students to attend Corporation dinners; the liaison could pass along the concerns of the student body to Corporation members and foster communication and transparency in the often arcane corporation. What a sweet idea ... I don’t know why we don’t have a Corporation Liaison already.

Will Wray ’10April 15

heI misrepresented To the editor:

Members of the Student Labor Alliance appreciate The Herald’s coverage of our presentation Tuesday to the BUCC. However, we would like to clarify a few facts.

HEI Hospitality is NOT a union, as the article mis-takenly states. HEI is a hotel management company which has taken steps to discourage its workers from forming a union and ignored its employees’ request at several of its properties to choose whether or not to join a union in an environment free from fear and intimidation.

It is because of this behavior that we have called on Brown to:

Write a letter to HEI demanding that the company respect workers’ requests for a fair process to decide

whether to form a union. Make a public statement calling upon HEI to respect

workers’ request for a neutrality agreement and stating that the university will not fund HEI until they do so.

Encourage its peer institutions to do the same, as most of HEI’s capital comes from prestigious University investments like our own.

lily axelrod ‘09andrea dillon ’11

lenora knowles ’11Jesse strecker ’10dani Martinez ’10

Becky fish ’09Members of the Student labor Alliance

April 16

MONDAy, APRIl 20, 2009 | PAgE 11

opinionsThe Brown Daily Herald

When John Yoo, the author of the Bush Administration’s infamous “torture mem-os,” came to Brown in February, he was welcomed as an honored guest. Yoo, who served as an attorney in the Justice Depart-ment’s Office of Legal Counsel from 2001 to 2003, came to campus in order to debate the existence of universal human rights with Larry Cox, executive director of Amnesty In-ternational USA.

As anticipated, there were some protest-ers on the Main Green as students filed into Salomon 101 for the talk, but fewer than many people expected. By most accounts, the event, sponsored by the Political Theory Project’s Janus Forum lecture series, was a success.

I guess the University got its money’s worth. As is customary, the Political Theory Project paid appearance fees to both speak-ers. Though he could not recall the exact amount spent to bring Yoo to campus, Asso-ciate Professor of Political Science and Po-litical Theory Project Director John Tomasi told me his group usually pays Janus speak-ers about $5,000.

The image of John Yoo, a man currently unable to legally enter Spain due to a pend-ing war crimes investigation, cashing a Brown University check disgusts me. I want to be clear: It’s not that I object to Yoo’s mere presence on campus, though Brown did le-

gitimize him by inviting him to the debate; it’s that I object to the Political Theory Proj-ect paying him with University money. The fact that Brown paid a man who is directly responsible for some of the most morally re-pugnant actions in our nation’s history does not, I think, reflect well on our community.

Of course, the issue is complex. It’s both healthy and necessary for the University to host controversial people airing unwelcome opinions on contentious issues. There are compelling reasons to hear Yoo out, and it

is crucial that the nation honestly come to terms with his reprehensible actions. As a largely progressive institution with a politi-cally aware student body, Brown is well-suit-ed to host such a debate.

More broadly, it’s important to bring speakers whose positions conflict with the majority opinion on campus. A number of influential conservatives have visited Brown in the last few years including Former Penn. Senator Rick Santorum, Former Gov. Mike Huckabee, Bjorn Lomborg and Former UN Ambassador John Bolton. I think their lec-tures were valuable additions to campus po-

litical discourse, even though I disagree with their positions.

And though I’m not terribly excited about helping fund Santorum’s family vacations, I don’t have the same moral objections to his lecture that I do in the case of Yoo. Like all moral issues, it’s difficult to establish a clear and universally applicable standard for whom it’s acceptable to pay to speak on campus.

Yet I feel strongly that wherever one might choose to draw that line, Yoo is on the far side of it. Torture is a serious matter;

American interrogation policy was used to justify and then cover up flagrant abuses of human rights that violated both internation-al and domestic law. And through it all Yoo was neither an innocent bystander nor an academic writing journal articles in support of someone else’s policy. He wasn’t even a legislator debating this from a distance. The legal framework for torture was written on this man’s desk. He is not complicit. He is responsible.

So what exactly was Brown paying for? The Political Theory Project invited Yoo to speak because the Janus Forum steering

committee, which is composed of student representatives from various campus politi-cal groups, must have believed that he could best advocate for the continued use of “en-hanced interrogation.” Yoo is profiting off his experience in the OLC, which is unique precisely because he created these policies allowing torture. Had he been something other than a rubber stamp for the vice pres-ident’s office, he certainly wouldn’t be in-vited to speak about human rights. Maybe that’s why we haven’t seen Jack Goldsmith on campus.

By virtue of its privileged position in our campus’ political discourse, the Politi-cal Theory Project must be more reflective when choosing whom to invite. Guided by an ambition to invigorate campus discourse and backed by millions of dollars from right-leaning think tanks (including the Anthem Foundation for Objectivist Scholarship) and wealthy individuals (led by the University’s Chancellor, Thomas Tisch ’76), the Janus Forum will continue to host some of Brown’s most controversial speakers. Together, the Janus Forum Steering Committee and Tomasi should be careful to think about how they use their substantial resources to avoid forking over large amounts of cash to people who are objectionable not for their views or voices, but for their actions.

Nick Werle ’10 is a physics and modern critical philosophy concentrator from

Port Washington, New york.

Think, before you (invite someone to) speak

Tomorrow afternoon, hundreds of prospec-tive students will arrive on campus to regis-ter for A Day On College Hill 2009. As most Brown students know, every April about 600 admitted students and a comparable num-ber of parents pile onto campus for what has become Brown University’s biggest matric-ulation event of the year. ADOCH is a two-day/one-night program designed to give admitted students a preview of Brown Uni-versity and hopefully influence their college decision.

Though ADOCH is extremely important for the admitted students, it is even more critical for the University. One of the key features of the Brown community is our vi-brant, engaged, curious and caring student body. Therefore, year after year, continu-ing to attract classes filled with such amaz-ing students is essential for our school’s success.

After months of reading essays and rec-ommendation letters, comparing GPAs and SATs and learning about each applicant’s ex-tracurricular activities, the Admission Office has selected the best and brightest students who are most compatible with Brown and has granted them admission.

As these are indeed the best students in

the world, most of them have also been ad-mitted to other leading colleges and universi-ties. They are currently making the difficult decisions that many of us had to make only a few years ago: Harvard-Brown? Stanford-Brown? Yale-Brown? ADOCH is the unique opportunity to give admitted students the answer to those questions.

Thankfully, many Brown students realize how important ADOCH is. Although orga-nized under the supervision of the Admis-sions Office, ADOCH is primarily a student-

run program. About 20 students have been working since September, planning this event from start to finish. They have been working with faculty, student leaders and many of Brown’s offices to ensure that ev-ery aspect of ADOCH is a success.

With the goal of constantly improving the program, the ADOCH Committee is imple-menting a few innovative changes this year. One of these improvements is increasing the efforts to welcome students on the first day (tomorrow!). A large welcome barbecue will kick off ADOCH 2009 and give admit-ted students the opportunity to meet their future classmates as well as current Brown

students. A second change to the program this

year is a heightened focus on the parents of admitted students. As parents are instru-mental in the college process and in helping their child decide where to matriculate, the ADOCH Committee has created new events for them. For example, this year, current Brown parents will greet prospective stu-dents’ parents at the parent welcome event. Parents have just as many questions as their children about life at Brown — rightfully so,

given tuition costs — and this is a tremen-dous step toward assuaging those concerns.

So what does any of this have to do with you? The goal of this column is twofold. First, it is an attempt to alert the campus that ADOCH is happening tomorrow. For reasons I still don’t understand, over the last few years the Admission Office has been un-able to obtain permission to send a campus-wide e-mail announcing ADOCH and has limited their announcement to an entry in Brown Morning Mail. (I know the head co-ordinators are still pushing for an e-mail an-nouncement this year, and I hope they are successful.) The second goal of this column

is to explain, as a past ADOCH Coordinator, how important campus-wide involvement is.

Although the ADOCH Committee has done everything in its power to ensure a great ADOCH, ultimately the event’s success is up to all of us, as members of the Brown community. The responsibility is on all fac-ulty, students and staff members to open our campus to the admitted students and wel-come them to Brown. It is our responsibility to help them have an amazing time here and convince them that Brown is the best place to get an undergraduate education. Campus-wide involvement is even more necessary, considering the Admissions Office decision last year to only invite “regular decision” students. Although this measure was neces-sary, it means that we can no longer count on all the “early decision” students, who are committed to Brown, to help convince their fellow admitted students to enroll.

We all care deeply about Brown Universi-ty and we must therefore play an active role in ensuring the students that were chosen by our Admission Office for their achieve-ments and their potential value to Brown, ac-tually end up enrolling here! So answer their questions, tell them why you love Brown and let’s get an amazing Class of 2013!

Anthony Staehelin ’10 is the current vice-president of the Bruin Club and a past ADOCH Coordinator. He can be reached

at [email protected]

a Day on College hill: a campus-wide responsibility!

Although the ADOCH Committee has done everything in its power to ensure a great ADOCH, ultimately the event’s success is up to all of us,

as members of the Brown community.

The image of John yoo, a man currently unable to legally enter Spain due to a pending war crimes investigation, cashing a Brown University check

disgusts me.

NICK WERlEopinions coluMnist

ANTHONy STAEHElIN

opinions coluMnist

got something to say? Now you can comment online!Visit www.browndailyherald.com to comment on opinion and editorial content.

Monday, april 20, 2009 page 12

Today 57

Podcast: ladies Village Improvement Society

Ninjas, tigers and singers, oh my!


47 / 42

Today, april 20

2 pM — A latin American Response to

the Crisis, Joukowsky Forum, Watson

Institute

7:30 pM — Fifth Annual Interlandi

lecture on Contemplative Studies with

Donald Rothberg, Salomon 001

ToMorroW, april 21

4 pM — William Miles — My Afri-

can Horse Problem, Watson Institute

Conference Room

7 pM — An Evening of Javanese Mu-

sic, grant Recital Hall

ACROSS1 Good-sized piece

of meat5 Play-of-color gem9 To the left, at sea

14 Volcanic output15 White House

staffer16 Medium for

FDR’s firesidechats

17 Sign of things tocome

18 Start of many acorny joke

20 O’Hara’s estate21 Flavorful22 Canadian tribe23 Neighbor of Swe.25 Scat singer

Fitzgerald27 Start of a

trucker’scommunication

34 Crude in agusher

35 Sea Worldperformer

36 Heredity units38 “Metamorphoses”

poet40 Like milk on the

floor43 Outside, as a

chance44 Knot again46 Classic grape

soda48 “Fourscore and

seven years __...”

49 Start of a soundman’s mikecheck

53 Cancún cash54 Pampering

place55 Manuscript encl.58 Remove by

percolation61 Kept from

swelling65 Start of a

newsboy’s cry67 City near

Sacramento68 Jewelry fastener69 High-performance

Camaro70 Finished71 Church belief72 Bulletin board

sticker73 Monthly

expense

DOWN1 Opening for a

coin2 Tibet’s Dalai __3 State with

conviction4 Fruit high in

potassium5 Acorn producers6 __ colada7 Big fusses8 Hannibal the

Cannibal9 Genesis craft

10 Breakfast stack11 Olfactory

reception12 Pilaf grain13 Casino gratuity19 NASCAR’s Petty

or Busch24 Gives a

thumbs-up26 Fall behind27 One lacking

manners28 Fastener for

Rosie29 Upper crust30 Music genre in

the ’hood31 Jewelry in the

’hood32 China’s Zhou __33 King’s tenure

37 Unhealthfulskyline obscurer

39 Scatter41 Give permission42 2007 William P.

Young Christian-themedbest-seller

45 Summer inFrance

47 AOL, for one50 Cruise ship stop51 “You can’t get out

this way” sign

52 One whose job isfitting?

55 Religiousoffshoot

56 Wheel shaft57 Ollie’s sidekick59 Gillette razor60 Gator’s cousin62 Sheltered inlet63 Garden site in

Genesis64 Malicious

gossip66 Suitable

By David W. Cromer(c)2009 Tribune Media Services, Inc. 04/20/09

04/20/09

ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE:

RELEASE DATE– Monday, April 20, 2009

Los Angeles Times Daily Crossword PuzzleEdited by Rich Norris and Joyce Nichols Lewis

[email protected]

cabernet voltaire | Abe Pressman

enigma Twist | Dustin Foley

The one about Zombies | Kevin grubb

sharpe refecTory

lunch — Popcorn Chicken with Dip-

ping Sauces, Cheese Raviolis with

Sauce, Italian Vegetable Saute

dinner — Pirate Ship Pork loin,

lemon Rice, Brown Rice garden Cas-

serole, Belgian carrots

verney-Woolley dining hall

lunch — Fried Clam Roll, Manicotti

with Tomato Basil Cream Sauce, Fresh

Sliced Carrots

dinner — Roasted Honey Chili

Chicken, Vegan Vegetable and Tempeh

Saute, Fresh Vegetable Melange

7 96calendar

Menu

crossword

the news in iMaGes

coMics

57 / 47

today toMorrow

paid adverTiseMenT

Date post:	09-Mar-2016
Category:	Documents
Upload:	the-brown-daily-herald
View:	221 times
Download:	0 times

Monday, April 20, 2009

Documents