Date post: | 22-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | charla-golden |
View: | 215 times |
Download: | 0 times |
NBS 2020 – Impact study:Key Excerpted Takeaways
Prepared for 1MBAS - National Biomass Strategy Delivery Unit (execution of NBS 2020)
About Lux Research
Helps clients find new business opportunities from emerging technologies in physical and life sciences
Offers ongoing technology and market intelligence, as well as market data and consulting services
Over 250 clients on six continents – multinational corporations, investors, governments, and SMEs
Global reach, with offices in Boston, New York, Amsterdam, Singapore, and Tokyo
Combines deep technical expertise with business analysis to support strategic decisions
More at www.luxresearchinc.com
2
Coverage areas Advanced Materials Agro Innovation Alternative Fuels Autonomous Systems 2.0 Big Data Bio-based Materials and
Chemicals BioElectronics Connected Objects and
Platforms Energy Electronics Energy Storage Exploration and Production Food and Nutrition Future Computing Platforms Intelligent Buildings Sensors Solar Sustainable Building
Materials Water Wearable and Flexible
Electronics
Lux leveraged a range of sources to ensure the completeness of the outside-in benchmarking activity
Lux leveraged internal data, 50 bespoke primary interviews across all target countries, and additional secondary research to complete the study
Existing Lux data:• Alternative Fuels and Bio-
based Materials & Chemicals capacity trackers
• Policy databases• Prior reports and models• Client-derived insights• Ongoing insights from
briefing targets
Secondary research• Supplement institutional
knowledge with desk research
• Sources include: industry magazines, company announcements, conference proceedings, SEC filings, white papers, government websites, patents, and publications
Primary interviews:• 50+ interviews with
corporations, VC’s, policy-makers, start-ups, and other industry stakeholders to validate benchmarking metrics and relative scoring
Global biomass industry benchmarking
3
The framework measures the inputs and outputs of the entire ecosystem to deliver comprehensive benchmarking
Public financing
Government policy
Presence of centers of excellence; industry
consortia
Mentorship for start-ups
Private funding
Quantity and quality of scientific output
Intellectual property
Local demand / consumption of product
Jobs impact
Total production of product
Concentration of commercial projects
Local industry presence
Inputs are measured as “Robustness of infrastructure”
Outputs are measured as “Commercial impact”
Biomass industries
4
Between 2010-2013, barring Australia and Indonesia, all ten countries have made meaningful strides in the biomass arena
Of the 10 focus countries, 8 made improvements in both of their composite scores
Indonesia improved its “Commercial impact” composite score, but lower oil prices (driven by subsidies) made it more attractive to export the biomass and import fossil fuels
5
1.0
3.0
5.0
1.0 3.0 5.0
Rob
ustn
ess of
Infras
truc
ture
Commercial Impact
US
MYFI
DE
IN
AUID
THCN
BR
2010 2013
Malaysia (MY)
United States (US)
Thailand (TH)
Finland (FI)
India (IN)China (CN)
Indonesia (ID)
Austrialia (AU)Germany (DE)
Brazil (BR)
Indonesia (ID)
1.0
3.0
5.0
1.0 3.0 5.0
Rob
ustn
ess of
Infras
truc
ture
Commercial Impact
An “ecosystem” approach separates the leaders from the laggards; Malaysia truly dominates, especially in ASEAN
Malaysia and Thailand are the only two ASEAN countries making it to the top-quadrant, where India in particular lags behind in the bottom-left quadrant.
Malaysia made a giant leap, especially in robustness of infrastructure, thanks to great improvements in government support (available mentorship, financial support, and mandates).
Indonesia slips behind in robustness of infrastructure compared to the other ASEAN countries. Due to a shift in government incentives, private finance shifted away from biomass towards other renewables.
2010
2013
Malaysia (MY) Thailand (TH)
India (IN)
China (CN)
Austrialia (AU)
MY
TH
IDIN
CN
AU
Thailand exemplifies a country with rich resources that falls short on successfully implementing an ecosystem approach
Thailand proactively incentivizes end products
Thailand also funds clusters such as the BIOTEC research units in Thailand Science Parks, which is coordinated by the NIA, part of the Royal Thai Government
A lack of mentorship and early-stage support for small biotech companies results in a lack of domestic start-ups
Thailand has yet to have tangible scientific impact on the global research community
Overall, the country’s neglect of a few critical infrastructure inputs threatens healthy industry growth
Government financial support
Government mandates
Scientific impact
Scientific outputMentorship
Presence of industry
Private financial support
0
2
4
Infrastructure scores
2014 2010
7
Malaysia has strong gov’t mentorship and scientific output; global impact and private sector growth are the next hurdles
Malaysia’s ease of doing business allows it to attract more FDI than neighbors
Malaysia claims among the fastest-growing volume of scientific output; impact, however, could be improved
Overall, Malaysia has seen great growth in government support (available mentorship, financial support, and mandates) over the past 5 years
Although Malaysia’s private sector activities have yet to bear fruit, recent momentum has proved promising
The Malaysian government has made impressive strides; private sector should quickly mobilize to ensure growth
Government financial support
Government mandates
Scientific impact
Scientific outputMentorship
Presence of industry
Private financial support
0
5
Infrastructure scores
2014 2010
8
Malaysia has several vehicles to support the bioeconomy; streamlining could help accelerate overall impactGovernment agencies and implementation vehicles:
Ministry of Science, Technology, and Innovation (MOSTI)
Malaysian Biotechnology Corporation (BiotechCorp)
Malaysian Investment Development Authority (MIDA)
Agensi Inovasi Malaysia (AIM)
Malaysian Palm Oil Board (MPOB)
Sustainable Energy Development Authority Malaysia (SEDA)
Independent agencies:
Malaysian Industry-Government Group for High Technology (MIGHT)
Malaysian Palm Oil Council (MPOC)
Policies and strategies:
National Biotechnology Policy (NBP)
National Biomass Strategy 2020
National Green Tech Policy
Renewable Energy Act
Economic Transformation Plan - Pemandu NKEA Labs
Biotechnology Transformation Program (BTP)