1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 1
IES - Institute for Environment and Sustainability
Ispra - Italy
http://ies.jrc.ec.europa.eu/
http://www.jrc.ec.europa.eu/
New Drought Indices –
Introduction to Drought Products
Stefan Niemeyer
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 2
Why drought indices?
- to identify main characteristics of droughts:- onset
- end
- severity
- spatial extent
- to describe and map drought events- to compare drought events in space and time- to quantify droughts- to simplify a complex phenomenon- to provide a basis for drought management
- helping to define thresholds, triggers, alarm levels
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 3
Characteristics of drought indices:
- relation of normal (long-term average, expected) values to current values of a physical parameter
- usually no physical quantity (no units!)
- often a combination and/or integration of various parameters / datasets
- … apparent common sense to use 3-4 letter acronyms with an “I” in the end!
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 4
Evaluation criteria for drought indices(Keyantash & Dracup 2002):
- Robustness (+++)
- Tractability (++)
- Transparency (+)
- Sophistication (+)
- Extendability (+)
- Dimensionality (+/-)
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 5
Drought indicators:
- general observations of elements of the water cycle are often referred to as drought indicators- e.g. lake or reservoir level, groundwater level
- often direct observations, physical quantities
- certainly valuable for operational drought monitoring and the assessment of available water resources
- but: not drought-specific, not to be used stand-alone, not comparable across regions
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 6
Existing drought indices:
NMDC – Normalized Multi-Band Drought IndexVCADI – Vegetation Condition Albedo Drought Index
PDI – Perpendicular Drought IndexMPDI – Modified Perpendicular Drought Index
RDRI – Remote Sensing Drought Risk IndexVegDRI – Vegetation Drought Response IndexADI – Aggregate Drought Index
SMDI – Soil Moisture Deficit IndexETDI – Evapotranspiration Deficit Index
RDI – Reconnaissance Drought IndexRSDI – Regional Streamflow Deficiency Index
SDI – Sperling Drought IndexNDVI – Normalized Difference Vegetation IndexVCI – Vegetation Condition Index
NDVIA – Anomaly of Normalized Difference Vegetation IndexSVI – Standardized Vegetation Index
NDWI – Normalized Difference Water IndexNDII – Normalized Difference Infrared IndexLWCI – Leaf Water Content Index
DTx – agricultural drought indexDFI – Drought Frequency Index TCI – Temperature Condition Index
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 7
… so why NEW drought indices?
motivation:
- not satisfied with currently existing DIs- fail to detect droughts, describe their severity, or insufficient description of
spatio-temporal development
- new applications require better tailored drought indices
- … to create one’s own drought index
- new opportunities emerge- new sources of data available
- new methodologies developed / transferred from other disciplines
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 8
drought indices by categories
- Meteorological:
- routine synoptic network data
- no new data
- innovations essentially application-driven
- typical: SPI – Standardized Precipitation Index (McKee et al. 1992)
- Other:
- Rainfall Anomaly Index RAI (van Rooy 1965)
- Bhalme and Mooly Drought Index BMDI (Bhalme and Mooly 1980)
- Pálfai Aridity Index PAI (Pálfai 1991)
- Drought Severity Index DSI (Bryant et al. 1992)
- Effective Drought Index EDI (Byun and Wilhite 1999)
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 9
drought indices by categories
- Meteorological:
- routine synoptic network data
- no new data
- innovations essentially application-driven
- typical: SPI – Standardized Precipitation Index (McKee et al. 1992)
- New: - RDI – Reconnaissance Drought Index
- Tsakiris, Pangalou, and Vangelis (2007)
- monthly P, ETpot
- characterization of drought severity, analogous to SPI
- meteorological index, towards agricultural applications
- selected river basins in the Mediterranean region
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 10
Tsakiris et al., 2007
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 11
new drought indices by categories
- Hydrological:- predominantly discharge data, time series analysis
- no new data
- new methodologies, threshold derivation
- typical: BFI – Base Flow Index (Institute of Hydrology 1980)
- Other:- Palmer Hydrological Drought Index PHDI (Palmer 1965)
- Surface Water Supply Index SWSI (Shafer and Dezman 1982)
- Reclamation Drought Index RDI (Weghorst 1996)
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 12
new drought indices by categories
- Hydrological:- predominantly discharge data, time series analysis
- no new data
- new methodologies, threshold derivation
- typical: BFI – Base Flow Index (Institute of Hydrology 1980)
- New:- RDI – Regional Streamflow Deficiency Index
- Stahl (2001)
- FDC, Q90
- regionalization, neighbourhood analysis
- river catchments in Europe
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 13
Stahl, 2001
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 14
Stahl, 2001
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 15
new drought indices by categories
- Comprehensive:- water balance, combining meteorology, soil, hydrology, …
- few / some new data- new combination of available datasets- new methodologies- typical: PDSI – Palmer Drought Severity Index (Palmer 1965)
- Other:- Palmer Modified Drought Index PMDI- PDSI-type (“PDSI family”)
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 16
new drought indices by categories
- Comprehensive:- water balance, combining meteorology, soil, hydrology, …
- few / some new data- new combination of available datasets- new methodologies- typical: PDSI – Palmer Drought Severity Index (Palmer 1965)
- New:- ADI – Aggregated Drought Index
- Keyantash and Dracup (2004)- precipitation, discharge, evapotranspiration, soil moisture, snow water content- PCI, first PC normalized by st.dev- based on monthly (measured) input data- California / Western U.S.
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 17
Keyentash and Dracup, 2004
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 18
new drought indices by categories
- Agricultural:- emphasis on soil moisture, actual evapotranspiration
- no new data
- new methodologies, new applications
- specialization, even crop-specific indices
- typical: CMI – Crop Moisture Index (Palmer 1968)
- Other:- Soil Moisture Drought Index SMDI (Hollinger et al. 1993)
- Crop Specific Drought Index CSDI (Meyer et al. 1993)
- Evapotranspiration Deficit Index ETDI (Narasimhan and Srinivasan 2005)
- agricultural drought index DTx (Marletto et al. 2005)
-
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 19
new drought indices by categories
- Agricultural:- emphasis on soil moisture, actual evapotranspiration
- no new data
- new methodologies, new applications
- specialization, crop-specific indices (CSDI, Meyer et al. 1993)
- typical: CMI – Crop Moisture Index (Palmer 1968)
- New:- SMDI – Soil Moisture Deficit Index
- Narasimhan and Srinivasan (2005)
- high resolution input data, local application
- application of water balance modelling (SWAT/HRU)
- SMDI for different soil layers / depths
- reflect short-term dry conditions in crucial phases of plant development- weekly SMDI, allow for fast reaction
- catchment areas in Texas / U.S.
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 20
Narasimhan and Srinivasan, 2005
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 21
Narasimhan and Srinivasan, 2005
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 22
new drought indices by categories
- Remote sensing:- data availability driven by technological development
- continuously new data sources on the market- often experimental character
- characterization of land surface and vegetation- detection of anomalies, but not necessarily drought specific
- optical and thermal bands- typical: VCI – Vegetation Condition Index (Kogan 1990)
- Other:- Temperature Condition Index TCI (Kogan 1995)- Vegetation Health Index VHI by (Kogan 1997, 2000)- Crop Water Stress Index CWSI (Jackson et al. 1985)- Normalized Difference Vegetation Index Anomaly NDVIA
(Anyamba et al. 2001)- Standardized Vegetation Index SVI (Peters et al. 2002)- Vegetation Temperature Condition Index VTCI (e.g. Wan et al. 2004)- (Modified) Perpendicular Drought Index (M)PDI (Ghulam et al. 2007)
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 23
new drought indices by categories
- Remote sensing:- data availability driven by technological development
- continuously new data sources on the market- often experimental character
- characterization of land surface and vegetation- detection of anomalies, but not necessarily drought specific
- optical and thermal bands- typical: VCI – Vegetation Condition Index (Kogan 1990)
- New:- NMDI – Normalized Multi-Band Drought Index- Wang and Qu (2007)- combining information from three bands- 1 nIR + 2 SW-IR reflectances (MODIS bands 2, 6, 7)- simultaneously accounting for soil moisture and vegetation water content- test area in Kansas, Oklahoma / U.S.
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 24
Wang and Qu, 2007
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 25
Wang and Qu, 2007
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 26
new drought indices by categories
- combined- combination of drought indices from different domains- novel approach, new methodology- manual combination so far, mapping- typical: U.S. Drought Monitor
- new:- VegDRI – Vegetation Drought Response Index
- Brown, Wardlow, Tadesse, Hayes, and Reed (2008)- combining NDVI, SPI, PDSI in order to be drought-specific- currently tested in mid/western U.S.- designed for operational, continental application
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 27
Wardlow et al, 2008
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 28
NDMC, USGS, 2008: http://www.drought.unl.edu/vegdri/VegDRI_Main.htm
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 29
many drought indices, many more new …
… but which one to choose?
- strongly depending on YOUR requirements
- field of application- specific boundary conditions- data availability- reliability / robustness- spatial / temporal resolution necessary- resources available
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 30
many drought indices, many more new …
… but which one to choose?
- continental overview application:
- consistent methodologies over large regions
- e.g. remote sensing
- consistent datasets available
- e.g. produced by large national / international agencies
- produce comparable information
- which regions are more affected
- delineate spatial extent of a drought event
- cover droughts in all disciplines
- meteorological, hydrological, agricultural, economic, …
- targeted to a large public audience
- intuitive to understand, limited number of classes / levels, simple colour coding, …
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 31
NAMS, 2008
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 32
combined precipitation & soil moisture anomaly
JRC, 2008
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 33
combined precipitation & soil moisture anomaly
JRC, 2008
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 34
many drought indices, many more new …
… but which one to choose?
- local river authority application:
- specific to hydrology of the catchment area
- e.g. snow melt decisive for spring water availability
- existing reservoirs and their management rules
- taking into account existing measurements / network
- e.g. local groundwater observation network
- consider local, national legislation
- RBMP, DMP, …
- cover the field of application of interest
- e.g. agricultural drought, yield deficits
- targeted to specific audience
- e.g. farmers applying irrigation schemes
- e.g. water managers / agencies to apply restrictions on water use
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 35
http://www.adbpo.it
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 36
Environmental
Administration, Finland
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 37
many drought indices, many more new …
… but which one to choose?
- check existing DIs against your requirements!
- original motivation of authors?
- data availability at creation?
- regional context, spatial validity, valid temporal resolution?
- demonstrated added value as compared to existing DIs?
- extensive testing and comparison of performance / validation?
- explicit mentioning of boundary conditions, limitations?
- operational application already proven?
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 38
Conclusions of 1. XEROCHORE Workshop (Amsterdam, 15.-17. June 2009)
…on drought monitoring and indices:
- Establish science-based guidance on how to use and choose appropriate drought indices. The focus should be on the criteria to be applied on the evaluation of existing drought indices for the application in different application domains, on different spatial scales, etc, rather than recommending single indices directly.
- Assessment of the performance of existing and newly derived drought indices against various climatic and hydrological conditions and on different temporal and spatial scales.
- Research on drought indices should focus on the development of combined and integrated drought indices that comprise information from different disciplines and technologies (e.g. remote sensing) to depict a drought situation in a more comprehensive way.
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 39
… and another new drought index:
Sperling Drought Index
- “easy to understand”- http://www.bestplaces.net/docs/studies/Drought.aspx
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 40
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 41
http://www.bestplaces.net/
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 42
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 43
Conclusions
- there are already many drought indices existing- more drought indices are developed every year
- with RS probably leading the innovation due to technology progress
- important for developers- combined and comprehensive drought indices lead innovation on the
methodological side
- clear purpose and necessity for a new drought index
- boundary conditions for its validity
- extensive testing and validation
- important for potential users- clear definition of scope
- specific user requirements and boundary conditions
1st Joint EARS/IES International Drought Workshop, Ljubljana, 21.-25. September 2009 44
… thank you!