Exe.on Generation.
10 CFR 72.212
RA-14-110
January 23, 2015
The Honorable Gary QuinnMayor, Lacey Township818 West Lacey RoadForked River, NJ 08731
Subject: Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating StationIndependent Spent Fuel Storage Installation Annual Report
Reference: Building Permit; Appeal 93-40 (after remand)
Conditions 10 and 11 of the referenced building permit require the Oyster Creek NuclearGenerating Station (OCNGS) to submit annual reports to Lacey Township concerningthe status and operation of the OCNGS Independent Spent Fuel Storage Installation(ISFSI).
Enclosure 1 provides the OCNGS response to Conditions 10 and 11. Enclosure 2provides the ISFSI 2014 monthly average temperature graphs and Enclosure 3 providesthe most recent ISFSI 2014 semi-annual radiation survey.
f any further information or assistance is needed, please contact Thomas Cappuccino at609-971-4430.
Sincerely,
Mike McKennaRegulatory Assurance Manager
Enclosures 1, 2, and 3
cc: _NRC Region I-, R gi-na-Administato ..........NRC Senior Resident Inspector - Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating StationNRC Document Control Desk
Enclosure 1Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationResponse to Building Permit Conditions 10 and 11
Independent Sper.t Fuel Storage Installation (ISFSI)Building Permit Condition Ten:
"The applicant shall provide to the township on a yearly basis, written records revealingall temperature and radiation measurements. The applicant shall further advise of anyand all repairs made to the concrete modules."
Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station (OCNGS) Reply to Condition Ten:
The temperatures within the loaded concrete Horizontal Storage Modules (HSMs) aremonitored daily and are part of the stations surveillance records. The internaltemperature of loaded HSMs are approximately 160 to 30OF higher than unloadedHSMs, depending on the heat load of the spent fuel loaded into the HSM. On a typical
sunny summer day, the highest HSM temperatures read about 118 0 F. This is well withinthe design limits of the modules and represents a maximum actual heat loading ofapproximately 12 KW.
The graphs in Enclosure 2 provide the average daily temperature data for the periodfrom September 14, 2013 to October 14, 2014, for the following HSMs.
HSM numbers Year loaded1,2,3,4 20025, 6, 7, 8 20039,10,11 200412,13, 14, 15,16 2005.17,18,20 201019,21,22,23 201224-34 Empty
From January 14, 2014 thru February 10, 2014, the South ISFSI temperature monitoringsystem was Out-of-Service on the Plant process computer; during this period, the stationconducted local monitoring of temperatures on a daily basis. All temperatures werewithin the maximum allowable value, with no deviations.
The highest radiation measurements on the front surface of the HSMs are 1.2 mr/hrgamma (i.e., on HSM-1 7) and 1.4 mrem/hr neutron (i.e., on HSM-18). The roof of theHSMs is a posted radiation area and is not readily accessible. These readings are wellwithin the design limits of the modules. Based on environmental TLDs, which areprocessed on a quarterly basis, the highest radiation levels at the ISFSI security fenceare 0.058-mr/hr gamma-andQO.008 mrem/hr-neutron._The most recent semi-annualradiation survey is provided as Enclosure 3.
There were no repairs to the concrete HSMs in the last year. Fourteen (14) additionalmodules were installed in 2012 (i.e., HSM 21 through HSM 34).
-t
Enclosure 1Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationResponse to Building Permit Conditions 10 and 11
The existing OCNGS ISFSI, which was reviewed under Building Permit, Appeal 93-40(after remand) is complete with 34 installed HSMs, of which 23 are loaded with spentfuel. The total number of installed HSMs represents a change from the number in theprevious annual report. In 2012, an additional 14 HSMs were added to the ISFSI (i.e.,HSM 21 through HSM 34)
ISFSI Building Permit Condition Eleven:
"The applicant shall provide to the township on a yearly basis, the specific number ofspent fuel rod assemblies which have been moved into the dry storage facility."
OCNGS Reply to Condition Eleven:
The following table provides the number of fuel assemblies that were transferred to theISFSI for each of the applicable years, starting in 2002. There were no fuel assembliesloaded into the ISFSI prior to 2002. Presently, there are no further transfers planneduntil 2016; however, rescheduling may occur given plant status and future activities.
Year loaded Number ofassemblies
2002 2442003 2442004 1832005 3052010 1832012 244
Totalassemblies
1403
Status of Yucca Mountain Repository
The Department of Energy (DOE) submitted a license application for construction of theYucca Mountain Repository to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission on June 3, 2008.
In testimony to the Senate Budget Committee on March 11, 2009, Dr. Steven Chu, DOESecretary, stated "[B]oth the President and I have made clear that Yucca Mountain is not-a workable option." In accordance with this view, the Administration requested, andCongress appropriated, for FY2010, only enough funds to continue the NRC licenseproceeding, while halting any design or development progress on the actual repository.The Administration's FY2011 budget proposal eliminated all funding for the YuccaMountain project.
r
Enclosure 1Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationResponse to Building Permit Conditions 10 and 11
Shortly before releasing the FY201 1 budget proposal, the Administration directed theDOE to establish a Blue Ribbon Commission on America's Nuclear Future (Commission)to explore, study, and evaluate alternatives to the Yucca Mountain facility for thepermanent storage of spent nuclear fuel. The Commission's goal was to "providerecommendations for developing a safe, long-term solution to managing the nation'sused nuclear fuel and nuclear waste." The Commission would not, however, considerspecific sites for a future repository. The Commission was charged with producing aninterim report within 18 months of the Commission's establishment and a final reportwithin 24 months.
The Commission issued its final report on January 26, 2012. The report did not makeany specific recommendations as to the "suitability" of Yucca Mountain, other than tomake clear that the process of selecting and establishing the Yucca Mountain facility hassuffered from several flaws and should be replaced by a new "consent-based approach"that provides "incentives" and encourages interested communities to "volunteer" as apotential host site for an eventual repository.
While acknowledging that "the future of the Yucca Mountain project remains uncertain,"the Commission did make specific findings that may have significant influence over thefuture of nuclear waste disposal. The Commission concluded that deep geologicdisposal "is the most promising and accepted method [of disposal] currently available,"and therefore recommended that the United States "should undertake an integratednuclear waste management program that leads to the timely development of one ormore permanent deep geological facilities for the safe disposal of spent fuel and high-level nuclear waste." The Commission also reiterated the severe consequences ofcontinued delays and urged Congress and the President to take action to institute theCommission's recommendations "without further delay." Congress has thus far taken noaction to implement the Commission's recommendations.
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 1
TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2002 3.0 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80
OU0
40
20
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 2TEMPERATU RE
Loaded April 2002 3.0 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 __-__________ ____
80
60
.40
0,,
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 3TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2002 3.0KW of Spent Fuel
120
80
soL6
40
20
0
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 4TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2002 - 3.0KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80
U-
41o4141
60
40
20
0
Month
-'eq Aý
I
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZON1TAL STORAGE MODULE # 5TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2003'~ 4.0 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 -- _ __ -
80 .... ......
%a- 6 0 . .. . . .. ..
40
20
0
Mon th
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 6TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2003 4.0 KW of Spent Fuel
120
1 0 0 . . . ..- -
80 -- ------
60
40 _
20
0i
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 7TEMPERATURE
Loaded May 2003 7.5 KW of Spent Fuel
120
'100.
80.
U-
60b.O
40
20
20
Month
I I
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 8TEMPERATURE
Loaded May 2003- 7.5KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 ..... _
80 --
Qj
twt
S 60 . . . . . . .. . ..
40
20
Ul
to .v
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 9TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2004 5.4 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80_____
LL.
2 60
40
20
0 I I I I
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 10TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2004- 3.RKW of Spent Fuel
120
10080 - - - - --- _ _ __ _U-
• 60 -.
40
20
ocy Lqi
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 11
TEMPERATURE
Loaded May 2004 5.2KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80 -_ __ 0J14 __ _ _ _ _ ___
_ _ _ __ _ _ _ _
60
lo60 ___
d) 40 --- --
20
0 I i
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 12
TEMPERATURE
Loaded April Z005 5.0 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80
L6.LA
60
40
20
0 i
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 13TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2005" 6.0KW of Spent Fuel
120 -
100 -- " _ •
80 ............. -
U.
%A
E60-to
40
20
0
Month
H-ORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE# 14TEMPERATURE
Loaded April Z005 -5. 0KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80
I40.
L6
41,.
bO
40
20
0
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 15TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2005- 5.2 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 -- - -_ _ __ _
80
40A
20
80 ____i
Month
NN No
S•HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 16TEMPERATU RE
Loaded May 2005 5.0 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100
80
L6-
to 60
40
20
U
v~v \~&~b~
Month
NO, 100 N!I.
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 17TEMPERATURE
Loaded May 2010- 11 KW of Spent Fuel
140
120
100
GD
toculIn
80
60
40
20
0
Month
I
ISP,-110,
I
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 18TEMPERATU RE
Loaded May 2010 -12 KW of Spent Fuel
14U
120
100
80
60
U-LA
40
20
0 j
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 19TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2012 - 10.39 KW of Spent Fuel
14U
120
100
8041
41"o60
40
20
0
"• -.~.. .M....... ........... . f•
0 I-
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 20
TEMPERATU RE
Loaded May 2010 12 KW of Spent Fuel
1110
120
100 -- _ ___ _....
41
60
/10... . .
20
0Mn
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 21
TEMPERATURELoaded April 2012 10.22 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 -
80 -__-__ -
U-
40
20
0
,o. 0,N. \) S
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 22TEMPERATURE
Loaded April 2012 10.24 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
80 - -- - -- -
-J 60 -
4 0 . . . . . . .. . . . . . .
20
CV VI , VY
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 23TEMPERATURE
Loaded May 2012 10.27 KW of Spent Fuel
120
100 _ _ _"_
80
.. 60a'
40
20
0
Month
."3" NP.
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 24TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90 r
6 0 ... . . . ....a''
.40 M7 . ..
20
10
0 ~~
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 25TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90
80 --- _ __ __ __ -7o __
7060
,A 5040
to
30 ....: A J\.......... ..~40
20
Iu
U
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 26TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90
80
70
60
50tw
w 40
30
20
10
0
I
Month
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 27TEMPERATURE
Empty -Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
9U
80
70 - _
6 0 ... . . . . . . . . . ... . .. . . . . . .
50 .... ............
20
10
0-
11ý50:
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 28TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90
80
70
60
U.
40
10
20
10
U
NIP Month
Month
ýzv :,ýý 1ý0
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 30TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90
80
70
60
UL.u 50
'10
30
20
10
0
Month
Enciosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 31.TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
LAIi44
4C
90
80
70
60
•,50 -
50
40
30
20
10
LI
Month
"0" ý,o 10
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 32TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90
80
60 *----
70
60
10
0
Month
VIINISIIýý' bev -I". 11ý0
Enclosure 2Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station
Independent Spent Fuel Storage InstallationTemperature Monitoring Graphs
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 33TEMPERATURE
Empty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
90
80
70 1-I
, 50 .... v................... . .
Go.
10 ........................ .
40
3 0 I I I - I-I--
Month
HORIZONTAL STORAGE MODULE # 34
TEMPERATUREEmpty - Temperatures Represent Ambient Conditions
9u
80
60 __ _
bO
/10
30
10
0o
)2 ovv c P.1:e P
Month