Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !1
Podcast Episode 61
2014
{Music}
Host: Welcome to PRM, Paleo Magazine Radio, where we bring you Paleo
nutrition, exercise and lifestyle perspectives from both the experts and the
every day. PMR is brought to you by Paleo Magazine, the first and only print
magazine dedicated to the Paleo lifestyle and is hosted by Tony Federico.
Tony Federico: Whether it’s convincing your kids that they should eat like dinosaurs or
tackling a whole hog, Stacy Toth has got you covered. Her books, written with
her husband Matthew McCarry, cover the entire gamut of the Paleo lifestyle.
And their newest book, Real Life Paleo, may be their best book yet. It’s the
most practical guide to Paleo that I have ever found and today Stacy and I are
going to talk about the three-step process that she and Matt used to bring
people into the Paleo lifestyle wherever they might currently be.
We’re also going to talk about her career in the Paleo world and where she’s
going next.
In the second half of the show, Russ Crandall and I are going to talk about a
delicious alternative to a roast turkey just in time for Christmas. Stick around.
Paleo Magazine Radio starts now.
{Music}
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !2
Tony Federico: Alright, everybody, welcome back. We’re here with Stacy Toth; she is one half
of the Paleo Parents. She’s an overall awesome person, the author of Real Life
Paleo, Beyond Bacon, Eat like a Dinosaur. I’m missing something; there’s
more.
{Crosstalk}
Stacy Toth: There’s e-books. {Laughter}
Tony Federico: There’s e-books, Three Step Paleo. You are a mom, a full-time – you have a
job in addition to the Paleo stuff, so an overall Paleo superwoman. Welcome
to the show.
Stacy Toth: Thank you.
Tony Federico: So, let’s just start with if there is somebody out there who hasn’t heard your
story somehow, somewhere, they don’t know who you are, give us the brief
history of Stacy Toth.
Stacy Toth: Sure. So, you can also listen to an earlier episode that I did on PMR if you’re
looking for more information. But thank you, also, for calling me just an all-
around awesome person. {Laughter} I think that’s just going to be my new
tagline.
Tony Federico: You can have that.
{Laughter}
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !3
Stacy Toth: Yes. So, I came to Paleo about four-and-a-half years ago immediately
following the birth of my youngest son—we have three children. I was
knowingly lactose intolerant and I just happened upon a dairy-free ice cream
recipe that was called Paleo ice cream; I had never heard the term before. And
back on those days Loren Cordain’s book was the only Paleo book out. I
know, it’s hard to fathom, {laughter} but back in the “Canola oil and Diet
Coke is okay” Paleo days.
But…
Tony Federico: It’s like the Paleo-Paleo days.
Stacy Toth: Exactly, yes. So, I found his book at the library and that same day—which
was like two days after I gave birth to my son—decided that that absolutely
made so much sense and there were so many symptoms and descriptions of
what was happening in people’s bodies that was happening in my body that he
described as metabolic syndrome.
And it was the first time after a lifetime of morbid obesity and all kinds of
health issues that anyone had framed something for me in a way that helped
me understand what was happening in my body.
And because no amount of Weight Watchers or the Diabetes Diet or all these
things the doctors just kept telling me to do, I short-term would lose weight
and then I’d rebound and gain twice as much and it just was so frustrating to
constantly be starving and frustrating. And I was still unhealthy, I still had
health issues; it just was a mechanism, a starvation diet, so to speak, to help
you lose weight in the short-term.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !4
So, finally I had read something that made sense to me and it just immediately
was like a light bulb went off, I threw things out of the pantry and was like,
“That’s it. I can’t have this in the house; I’m going to do this thing.” And I
thought it would be really easy because I was like, “Well, I already know I
have a dairy intolerance and I don’t mind giving up dairy, I’ve done that
before. Surely I don’t have a gluten intolerance, but I’ll just give it this 30-day
try and see what happens.”
And it turns out that so many of my ailments went away because I ended up
finding out that I had Celiac Disease and so I had high white blood cell count,
the doctors didn’t know what it was happening to me. I had my gall bladder
removed, I had constant irritable bowel syndrome, but they wouldn’t describe
it as that because once you have your gallbladder removed they refuse to
diagnose anything as irritable bowel; they just called it a side effect of a
removed gallbladder.
Tony Federico: Really?
Stacy Toth: Yes. So, I had countless issues from cholesterol to high AC1 blood sugar
testing, just basically the tests would come back and it was not great. I had
good blood pressure and I never had gestational diabetes, so my pregnancies
were really easy, but – relatively speaking, but that was pretty much the only
thing that had gone right in my health.
And so, coming upon this I was like, “I’m going to do this.” And within a
week or two, I remember I no longer had sleep apnea, I no longer had
heartburn and those two things had been keeping me from sleeping for years.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !5
And so immediately I felt so much better because I could sleep and I had
energy and it just was like a snowball and kept getting better.
And so a couple weeks into it was like “Matt and the kids, this is ridiculous,
we’re preparing two meals; I feel so much better and so much healthier. It’s
not going to hurt everybody to have more vegetables in the house. Let’s all
just do this.”
Tony Federico: {Laughter} Nobody’s had health problems because of that.
Stacy Toth: I don’t know. People have a problem with it, I’m sure. {Laughter} There’s
tons of people…
Tony Federico: That’s true, never mind.
Stacy Toth: …I have experience with them. But when you frame it in the context of more
veggies, then people seem to have less of a problem with it.
So, we had been having issues with the boys and I’d also done a lot of reading
about gluten-free, casein-free diet can really help with some of the behavior
issues that our kids were having: ADD and ADHD. Again, almost overnight –
we told the boys we were going to try it for 14 sleeps, that I was asking them
to commit to giving me 14 sleeps just to give it a try.
And within five days or something, my oldest was doing so much better. He
actually went off of a daily inhaler and had such an easier time controlling his
body that we were immediately convinced that it was the right solution for our
family.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !6
And so, four-and-a-half years later we’ve made it our mission to help other
families make it easier on them. So, we wrote our first book, Eat like a
Dinosaur, I think it was 2012 – I think we’ve had a book every year.
{Laughter} So, I’m pretty sure it was 2012 and we actually wrote that book
for our kids.
At that time there were three other Paleo cookbooks out when we started
writing Eat like a Dinosaur. It was really frustrating for us that there was
nothing available that was kid-friendly, that the kids had had these Betty
Crooker kid-friendly magazines where you dip pretzels in chocolate and
whatever…
Tony Federico: Because it’s fun.
Stacy Toth: Because it’s fun and it was and still is a lot of fun to cook with my kids and I
wanted something that was kid-friendly that the kids could feel like “I can
pick anything out of this book” because all the recipe books that we had still
were like nine out of ten pages were things that they couldn’t eat.
And so, we wrote Eat like a Dinosaur with that in mind and had no ambitions
of the blog and Paleo and all of it exploding the way that it did. And so, as our
Paleo journey expanded, so did our interests. And so our second paper book
was Beyond Bacon which was about eating nose-to-tail and humane,
sustainable farming practices and how that’s good for your health and good
for the earth.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !7
And how to cook amazing food if you decide to buy – the most affordable
animal is pastured pig and so if you buy a whole or a half one, it’s intended to
help you figure out how to do that and how to cook your way through it. Also,
pork is delicious.
Tony Federico: It’s a beautiful book, by the way.
Stacy Toth: Thank you. And so, what we’ve ended up doing recently is combining those
two interests and projects and making a really family-friendly book that kids
can love but that’s really for adults. And that book has just come out called
Real Life Paleo and the intention there is to provide a guide book to transition
through your whole journey.
So, it’s from anybody to the family member or the person at the office that
you know that’s just insistent that they can’t figure out how to start or they’re
constantly falling off the wagon and they really want to do it and they know
it’s good, but they just can’t to the person who’s been Paleo for two years and
is interested in taking it to the next level by reducing their nuts or reducing
their chicken and figuring out how to introduce some Paleo super foods like
egg yolk and seafood and broth and vegetables, all those kinds of good things.
So, it’s a three-phased approach which is very unique; there’s nothing like it
out there in the Paleo sphere. Most of the Paleo leadership advocates a 30-day
intro and that’s what I did and it personally worked for me, but it did not work
for my family. And so what we’ve outlined is if you want to make this
sustainable and long lasting, here’s a plan that worked for our family where
we felt good about making better steps as often as we could instead of feeling
guilty that we didn’t do the best thing right off the bat.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !8
Four-and-a-half years later my kids will choose vegetables when we go out to
eat and it didn’t happen overnight {laughter} and this book is supposed to
help people get there.
Tony Federico: Well, it really seems like you really thought through the entire lifestyle
transition and in giving people a way to approach it wherever they are. So, if
we look at the three steps, it’s swap, remove and heal. Can you talk a little bit
more specifically about those steps?
Stacy Toth: Sure. So, swap is intended to swap out the most offensive foods. For us we
define those and we worked closely with Sarah Ballantyne who’s a very good
friend of mine and co-host of the Paleo View. She’s a Ph.D. and very well-
respected in the community writing The Paleo Approach.
In my working with her, we found that the most offensive foods are gluten,
refined sugar and processed chemicals like red food dye. Those are the kinds
of foods that seem to affect people the most: either they’re addicted to it or it
damages their gut the most.
And so, by removing those foods at first, it really allows people to say, “Okay,
I can manage that. These are feasible steps. You can still buy – prepackaged
corn pasta, for example, would still be allowable under those terms. And it
allows people to transition off the foods that they’re used to and figure out
how to make those own spice blends and their own sauces and some of those
kinds of things that feel overwhelming in the beginning because gluten is in
everything and high fructose corn syrup is in everything.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !9
And so, if you figure out these are the worse offenders, I’m just going to
remove those, then it feels a little less overwhelming than remove everything,
which is what Phase Two is. Phase Two is traditional Paleo; it’s what would
be considered a 30-day challenge Paleo, only we’re not calling it 30 days. This
is a self-paced book; you figure out how long it takes you. It could take you
one month, it could take you one year, it could take you several years.
Whatever it takes you or your family to get to the next phase is up to you.
But Phase Two is more traditional Paleo where now we’re eliminating the rest
of the grains, the legumes, the dairy’s kind of a mixed area, but we encourage
everyone to remove it for 30 days and see how they feel reintroducing high-
quality back in. So, that’s the remove portion; you’re removing the rest of the
foods.
And then the third phase is heal because what we get from a lot of people
through our podcasts and our blog is people feeling overwhelmed like, “Oh
my God, I really want to go Paleo in this week. My grocery bill was $8 billion
{laughter} everything was grass fed and then I put liver in the meatballs and
my family wouldn’t eat it and told me it was disgusting and now I’m crying in
a closet.”
Tony Federico: {Laughter} You have had that email, haven’t you?
Stacy Toth: Oh, for sure. I’ve had that email more than once.
Phase Three is intended to help you realize that buying grass-fed and putting
liver in meatballs is something that you really shouldn’t be doing up front, that
there are a lot more bang-for-your-buck things. But that when you’re ready to
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !10
take it to the next level, focusing on grass-fed pastured animals, focusing on
organic, nutrient-rich vegetables that are in-season and local as much as you
can and focusing on what we define as Paleo super foods and adding them to
your diet.
So, you should feel really comfortable with the removing phase before
moving into the adding phase where then you can focus on broth and liver and
the weird stuff that we encourage you to eat.
Tony Federico: So, just looking through this I think that one of the things that’s hopeful is that
there’s the promise of reintroduction of certain things. So, it’s not take these
things away, you’re never going to eat them again, it’s “take it out, allow your
body to adjust, heal, feel how you’re going to feel without it.”
And then, for instance, you mentioned the dairy; that’s a specific item that
might come back into the diet or even certain grains like white rice.
Stacy Toth: Yes.
Tony Federico: I like how the book lays out full meal plans. I think that that’s really a unique
thing where you’re presenting, for instance, a chicken dinner, you’re
presenting Chinese takeout.
What was the genesis of that idea? Were you just looking at the types of meals
you were making for your family or was that a result of podcast listener and
blog reader feedback?
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !11
Stacy Toth: I think all of the above. Definitely the feedback from people that we receive is
that especially in the beginning they have a difficult time understanding what
a table looks like without spaghetti and bread and how much extra vegetables.
Or what do portion sizes look like? Or how are they supposed to create all
those home cooked food without being in the kitchen all the time?
Tony Federico: They can’t really conceptualize that.
Stacy Toth: Yes, there’s a lot of change in the beginning. Those of us who have been doing
it three, four or five years, it’s hard to remember how overwhelming that felt
in the beginning because we’ve adopted it and we’ve made it our lifestyle.
But it is incredibly overwhelming and so I have a fascination with food
photography that’s whole-table settings and when we were talking about how
to show people what this transition looks like, it was really important to me.
And so, I worked with our photographer (Amy Buxton) who came into our
home once a week, Matt, my husband, does all the food cooking and then I
would set up the shot and then (Amy) and I would work together to get the
shots the way that we wanted, both from this is a whole meal together and
then separately the components of each of those dishes that went into it, that
comprised the 175 recipes in the book.
So, not all 175 recipes are incorporated in meals, but what we did do was
make sure that we had at minimum a breakfast, lunch and dinner in every
phase captured as a whole meal so that if you were in breakfast Phase One,
you could see an option of what that looked like versus breakfast in Phase
Two versus a breakfast in Phase Three.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !12
So, it might be you make waffles for breakfast one – actually I think it’s like
granola and a quick banana soufflé in Phase One breakfast. And then in Phase
Two we’re encouraging you to eat eggs and can you move away from the
granola and the breads and that kind of stuff. And in Phase Three it’s you can
have soup for breakfast, you can have leftovers for breakfast.
{Crosstalk}
Tony Federico: It’s kind of like things get a little more hard core…
Stacy Toth: …green salad with a pastured egg yolk on it. Like this is okay to have for
breakfast, but it takes a while to get there.
Tony Federico: It sort of represents that evolution or that transition many people just naturally
go through where when you start out you almost want to recreate everything
that you currently are eating in Paleo form and then eventually let go with
some of those, I guess, requirements that breakfast food is eaten at breakfast
and lunch food is at lunch or whatever that means.
Stacy Toth: Yes. And so, in addition we did provide “regular” meal plans as well where
we’ve written out a whole week’s worth of meal plans for each phase in the
hopes that if someone really wants a full meal plan that they can teach
themselves how to cook an extra chicken one week and then use the leftovers
to make chicken salad later.
It’s trying to show people how in that meal plan if you do some of the things
that we recommend doing with leftovers and that sort of thing that you’re not
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !13
in the kitchen preparing a home cooked meal for every single meal because I
think for a lot of people that’s what ends up happening.
And so, we tried to take it a little more bigger picture, again, real life here.
We’re a very busy family with three children and we do not have the kind of
time to be cooking a two-hour meal three times a day. So, we’ve included a lot
of the recommendations and tips and tricks that we use in terms of leftovers
and some of our on-the-go foods that we have prepared during the week so
that when the kids are hungry we can be like, “Go eat corndog muffins”
because we know that they’re balanced with protein and carbs and we’re not
going to worry about the boys eating them. Or we can whip up a quick
coconut milk smoothie and know that they’re getting really satiating coconut
milk if they’re starving after they’ve been playing outside or whatever the
case is.
So, we’ve tried to really create a book that is useful for every-day use; now,
granted, there are plenty of holiday recipes and that sort of thing, but we
actually did a ratio in the book of 80/20 recipes to treats to savory nourishing
foods on purpose and that’s to really hope that people don’t just jump straight
to the dessert section, {laughter} but that they’re working on creating a
balance in their life of healthy, nourishing foods because what we want is
everybody to be as healthy as possible.
Well, and if we’re eating almond flour cupcakes all the time we’re not going
to be as healthy as we possibly can.
Tony Federico: But what if they’re Paleo almond flour cupcakes?
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !14
Stacy Toth: Yes, no.
{Laughter}
Tony Federico: Ah, darn.
Stacy Toth: It’s better, but we can’t call that healthy.
Tony Federico: Maybe that’s Phase One, I don’t know.
Stacy Toth: Yes.
Tony Federico: I really do appreciate that you guys did that, though, because I think that that’s
one of the common criticisms levied at Paleo cookbooks is that it’s too many
treats and this and that. And so, you’ve really just said, “We’re going to build
in the 80/20 rule for you so you don’t have to worry about that. If you just do
that, it’s going to have the treats in there, it’s going to keep things pleasurable
and fun but at the same time you’re going to get the solid nutrients in as well.
Stacy Toth: That’s the goal.
Tony Federico: I think user-friendly is really the biggest thing that I see just going through
this book, like you said before with the meal plans if somebody’s wondering,
“Well, okay, how does that?” it’s not just an arbitrary selection of recipes; it’s
if you’re eating something on Monday night, there’s a logical place for
leftovers on Tuesday and so on and so forth.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !15
And I think that that really reflects how Paleo is realistically done and I think
that it can be off-putting or overwhelming for people when they’re taking on
this lifestyle and, like you said, they’re thinking that they’re going to have to
cook three meals a deal and it’s really not what it has to involve and it’s really
not what most people actually do.
So, I like how you’ve addressed these things upfront and you’ve provided
solutions to them upfront.
Is there anything in the book that you feel particularly proud of in terms of the
recipes? There’s 170 of them in this book, so I’m wondering what your
favorites are.
Stacy Toth: I think some of my favorites are foods that people probably see in my social
media on a regular basis. They’re the foods that we eat regularly. I feel really
happy and proud of this book in terms of the evolution of where our family
has gone in terms of palate and also introducing people to integrating broth
and vegetables as a base for even things like breads. We make garlic
breadsticks and gnocchi with cauliflower. We incorporate broth and pastured
egg yolks in a ridiculous amount of recipes and that’s intentional because
that’s how we eat.
So, for me my – I east an almost recipe is Stacy’s soup. People ask me every
single day for the recipe for Stacy’s soup.
Tony Federico: #soupwithStacy, I think they should just follow that.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !16
Stacy Toth: It is a hashtag: #soupwithStacy. So, now people can have on paper how Matt
makes my soup every day and it’s not a science; it’s leftovers plus broth
equals soup.
{Laughter}
Tony Federico: Magic.
Stacy Toth: Yes, magic. There’s a cheesy cashew sauce made with…
Tony Federico: Yes, I was wondering about that.
Stacy Toth: …nutritional yeast that we’ve incorporated into a lot of recipes and that stuff
is so good. We had it in large batches around the house as we were recipe
testing and everything that we’d put it in I’d be like, “Oh, my God, this is so
good.” And Matt’s like, “Yes, I put the cheesy sauce in your soup.” I’m like,
“You need to do that everyday.”
{Laughter}
Tony Federico: Yes, the cashew cheese sauce, right?
Stacy Toth: Yes, the cashew cheese sauce, yes. We make meatza with it, we make just a
bunch of stuff with it, lasagna but with vegetables noodles, stuff like that.
The desserts is what people are always fascinated by. There’s a chocolate cake
and we use freeze-dried strawberries as the base for the icing in that Berry
Chocolate Cake and it’s really, really good. Our intern actually requested us to
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !17
send her that recipe before it was even finalized and sent to the publisher
because she wanted to make it for her own birthday cake after helping us here.
And there’s a couple of not-too-sweet recipes in there, I think it was 36 of the
175 are our classic fan favorites from the blog. So, we’re known for waffles,
we’re known for Easy-Peasy Pancakes, we’re known for Creamy Coconut
Chocolate Chip Macaroon Cookies.
The things that are our top recipes that people go to on our blog all the time
we included in this book just because I know that I personally like to have
cookbooks so that I don’t have to go to the website. And so, we did that in
here while still offering a bunch of new recipes.
So, I would say those are probably my favorite. The chicken wings are also
really good.
Tony Federico: Looking at those now. The Crispy Oven-Baked Chicken Wings?
Stacy Toth: Yes. You would never know they’re oven-baked, they’re so good. And so far
the review favorites have been the Bacon Green Onion Macaroni and Cheese
Casserole which is actually made with that cheese cause and butternut squash.
Tony Federico: I don’t know how that cannot be good.
Stacy Toth: Right? {Laughter} I saw someone do a fried egg on top of leftovers of that
casserole and I was like, “Oh my gosh, I need to do that.”
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !18
So, the feedback has been really positive lately which is great and what I
really hope is that people see the book as a tool and can recommend it to their
friends and family who have been really struggling because that’s really who
we wrote it for.
Obviously we think it’s applicable to anybody anywhere in their journey,
especially with so many recipes. But our goal is to really reach out to those
people who just that 30-day challenge really doesn’t work for them and
despite trying to make it work, they kept falling off the wagon; this hopefully
will be the tool that people can recommend and with tear-out guides that you
can put on your fridge and remind yourself of all those things. I mean, we’ve
tried to come up with every idea possible to help people make it work.
Tony Federico: Well, it’s funny because this is a reflection of you and Matt’s evolution as well
and I did a Paleo challenge with a local CrossFit gym recently and I think the
Paleo movement as a whole is evolving and there’s certainly factions that are
still diehard old school Paleo, strict and not really cool with things like white
rice or potatoes {laughter} and that’s fine, I mean, whatever.
But, at the same time, I think the proof is in the pudding and the proof is in the
real-life changes and transformations that people undergo. And I had
somebody come up to me, the challenge just finished, and they’re like, “Yes, I
did a really strict Paleo before and I lost more weight, but I went right back to
eating what I was eating before and I gained all the weight back,” this and
that.
And so this time around he did a “Paleo challenge” that said, “Hey, if you
want to eat a potato, eat a potato, if you want to eat some rice, eat some rice;
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !19
it’s not a deal breaker. Just really focus on the nutrient-dense whole foods and
really just keep focusing on those things.”
And he was like, “Yes, I didn’t lose as much weight, but I think like I’m just
going to keep this thing going.” I’m like, “There you go.”
Stacy Toth: Yes, that’s awesome.
Tony Federico: If you make a change for a lifetime, no matter how “perfect” that month was,
if you’re not going to do it beyond a month, it’s really not a game-changer; it’s
really not doing anything for you.
Stacy Toth: Yes, I would say too it depends a lot on people’s lifestyle. Like, I think the
first three years that we were Paleo, I wasn’t active at all; I was really
metabolically broken. If I would have started off with potatoes and rice and
high-quality dairy, I probably wouldn’t have had as much success as I did.
But after years of nutrient-dense, nourishing goods, I helped heal my body
through the methods described in Phase Three and now because I’m active
one of my favorite foods to eat after I workout is sushi. I literally feel myself
being replenished between the Omega-3s and all the kind of things that are
going in there, it makes me feel good to eat sushi after I work out. I can’t have
sushi every day and I certainly can’t have sushi if I’ve been laying on the sofa
all week, but that’s me.
I was metabolically broken for a really long time, so everybody’s different and
I think that’s what’s really cool about where the Paleo movement is going is
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !20
that people are figuring this stuff out on their own, figuring what works for
them and running with it and that’s I think what we all wanted.
Some people just want to know “What are the rules?” That only works so far.
It depends who you are; what are your goals?
Tony Federico: And I’m thinking less dogmatic and more pragmatic. So, just figuring out
what works for you, look at your context or look at your situation.
I want to take a few minutes to talk about – you mentioned physical activity
{laughter} and I think that that is something following you on Instagram and
Facebook and stuff like that. I’ve seen your physical activity grow and change
and become really a passion of yours and I’d like for you to just talk a little bit
about that.
Stacy Toth: Sure. So, I was a total couch potato my entire life. I was morbidly obese in
high school, so I did not do any sports. I literally had never participated in a
competitive sport and hid in the locker room smoking cigarettes at PE.
{Laughter} I just – it was a bad scene.
Tony Federico: Real Confessions on Paleo Magazine Radio.
Stacy Toth: People know me well enough to know I don’t hide these sort of things. So –
obviously I don’t smoke cigarettes anymore. {Laughter} I decided when I
started feeling better that I wanted to move more. I didn’t have a specific goal
in mind, I was just like “I want to get up and I want to go and I wanted to do
things.”
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !21
And so, we started visiting farms and we started taking walks as a family and
we had this month where we did handstands every single month to see how
we could improve our handstands and we just did random physical things.
And then I decided I wanted to try CrossFit because I felt maybe I could be
more connected to my community and I was really super-nervous {laughter}
because I had never done any physical activity, but I took really well to
CrossFit and I really liked it and to a point I just eat, slept and CrossFitted
between working on the blog and home.
And then I realized that what I really, really, really loved about CrossFit was
the heavy lifting days and that whenever this was jumping or running that I
wanted to cry in a corner.
Tony Federico: Yes. {Laughter}
Stacy Toth: And then I started to actually get anxiety attacks.
Tony Federico: Oh, no.
Stacy Toth: They were really super cardio intensive (sounds like: wads) because I just
didn’t perform well and I’m super-competitive. And so, if I wasn’t going to
perform well, it was giving me anxiety.
At the same time the gym that I was at was opening a Strong Man component
of the gym with classes and with Strong Man there’s definitely still metabolic
conditioning, but it’s more with heavy weights and shorter bursts and things
like that.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !22
And so, I got into Strong Man and really, really it is my sport; I’m super-
obsessed with Strong Man. And within the first year of doing Strong Man, I
qualified for Nationals and won all three competitions that I was in; I tied for
first in my last competition.
Tony Federico: And this is a non-athlete who…
Stacy Toth: Yes.
Tony Federico: …skipped gym class to go smoke cigarettes.
{Laughter}
Stacy Toth: Yes, exactly. And all at the same time writing a book and having a full-time
job and having three kids. And so, what my goal now is that we’re going to
stop writing books and I’ve been saying this publicly, it’s a promise that we’ve
made to the children. We’ve given everything that we have into what we
currently have out there in the print books and we feel very much like if
people want something from us, it’s there already and that we really need to
focus on ourselves and our family.
And one of the things that I have been doing is creating a home gym so that I
can spend more time with the family and not have to be at a specific gym at a
specific time.
Tony Federico: That’s awesome.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !23
Stacy Toth: It’s totally awesome. My kids have been wanting to work out with me which
they’ve always wanted to do, but it’s so exciting that after dinner we’re all
like, “Let’s go work out in the gym” and they’ll pick up a 40-pound dumbbell
which is 70% of their body weight and they’ll dead lift it.
Tony Federico: That’s pretty diesel. {Laughter}
Stacy Toth: Yes, it’s totally awesome and so my little one who’s four, he’s like, “Mommy,
look at my strong muscles” and he’ll hold up his arm and show me his little
tiny bicep. {Laughter}
And there’s joy there for me in that and it’s wonderful knowing that being a
woman who was so overweight and so out of shape for so long and knowing
that I had Celiac Disease that I didn’t treat for a long time and knowing that I
didn’t eat dairy for almost a decade because I was either pregnant or nursing
and was lactose intolerant, the damage that’s been done to my bones from not
having adequate Vitamin C and not being able to properly absorb my food is
probably incredibly detrimental.
Arthritis runs really strongly in my family, gout runs in my family. We just
have a whole bunch of problems in my family. It feels really great to know
that I’m doing something that is actually beneficial for my health that strength
training has a really powerful healing tool for women; it’s also really awesome
that people tell me that I inspire them.
It’s nice to know that losing a combined 200 pounds of my husband and I and
putting my photos out there on the Internet inspired people, but I’ve moved on
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !24
in my life where I just don’t thing that weight loss is the most important thing;
I think health is the most important thing.
And so, to hear that people are saying it helps them be inspired to focus on
healing themselves and getting healthy and getting strong as their own
inspiration to their health journey is one of the most important things in my
life right now. And so, I feel like working on that and also being true to myself
is one of the best things that I can do.
So, I’m super-excited to be able to pursue that as a more primary focus in my
life now that we’re over the hump of all the other commitments that we’d
made.
Tony Federico: Yes. And you started a podcast to talk about your Strong Woman training.
Could you tell us a little bit about that?
Stacy Toth: Yes, sure. So, in addition to the podcast that I’ve with Sarah Ballantyne I
mentioned earlier, The Paleo View, I started a new podcast with one of my
training buddies, Vivian Nguyen, who is a certified CrossFit coach and placed
at Nationals. She’s the eighth strongest woman in the United States.
Tony Federico: Wow.
Stacy Toth: So, Viv and I are doing Strong Woman Radio and you can find it on iTunes. I
think Matt’s trying to get it up on Stitcher; I’m not sure what the status of that
is. But we talk about all things related to lifting heavy with women.
{Laughter} And there’s quite a number of men that listened and they’re
entertained. It’s explicit; it’s not family-friendly. It’s definitely a different side
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !25
of me that people aren’t used to seeing on Paleo Parents, but that’s what
happens when you lift heavy things. It’s the realist in me.
Tony Federico: Yes, well, and you’re a human being and we’re all multi-faceted and we all
have different interests and I think you’re expanding beyond, perhaps, the face
that people have come to know in the Paleo community and I think you’re
courageous in sharing these different facets of yourself and not just sticking to
one particular image and holding onto that and propping that up.
I think being real is an important quality and you certainly do that and I think
you’ve really been an inspiration to me professionally and whenever I’m
sitting there thinking, “Man, I really would rather not work on this blog post,
book chapter, et cetera, well, you know what? If Stacy can work a full-time
job, {laughter} raise three kids, do all these things, well, by golly, I can do it
too.”
So, I think…
Stacy Toth: Oh, thank you.
Tony Federico: In many ways you’re an inspirational person and it’s a real pleasure…
{Crosstalk}
Stacy Toth: Well, you can do a muscle-up, so there’s that.
Tony Federico: Well, I got something. Yes, that’s my one thing.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !26
{Laughter}
Stacy Toth: I love watching those videos too.
Tony Federico: Well, Stacy, thank you so much for coming on the show; it’s been a real
pleasure talking to you. I wish you continued success. I hope Real Life Paleo
is a tremendous seller and we’re going to have links in the show tonight where
people can buy a copy and find all of your other books as well.
Yes, you’re killing it and I think stepping away from writing in books and
investing in your family, that’s super Paleo, so you’re just continuing down
that path of evolving and growing. I’m interesting and I’m sure our listeners
will be interested to see where you go next.
Stacy Toth: Thank you. Thanks for having me.
Tony Federico: That was Stacy Toth, author of Real Life Paleo, host of the Paleo View and
all-around awesome person. Coming up next on the show, The Ancestral Table
with Russ Crandall. We’re going to take a short break and we’ll be right back
with more Paleo Magazine Radio.
{Music}
Tony Federico: Alright, everybody, I’m here with Russ Crandall for another installment of
The Ancestral Table. Russ, welcome back to the show.
Russ Crandall: Hi, thanks for having me on.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !27
Tony Federico: So, we’re heading into Thanksgiving week, everybody’s got roast turkey on
their minds and one of my pet peeves is having roast turkey for Thanksgiving
and then turning around and having roast again for Christmas.
But then you propose that there’s a solution that you have in mind that
sounded pretty amazing. Want to tell us about it?
Russ Crandall: There’s several reasons why I like this, but we like to smoke our turkeys
instead of roasting them in the oven. So, number one is everyone loves
smoked turkey legs, so this is like a smoked turkey leg all over. So, that’s
pretty awesome.
Tony Federico: So, like those big smoked turkey legs you might get at Walt Disney World or
something like that?
Russ Crandall: Right, exactly. So, just imagine an entire turkey of that…
Tony Federico: Sounds amazing.
Russ Crandall: It’s pretty sweet, yes. And then number two is that if you smoke it outside in
your grill or whatever, you don’t have to use your oven up. So, that leaves
your whole oven open so you’re not heating up the house unnecessarily or you
can use your oven for other Paleo projects.
Tony Federico: Oh, yes. Alright, good. So, there’s a space economy as well as a flavor
diversity. Now, walk us through the actual process of smoking a turkey.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !28
Russ Crandall: Sure. So, one thing I have to point out is that it’s a little more time-intensive to
smoke a turkey than it is to do it in the oven. Actually smoking it on the grill
is faster when it comes to actual time on the grill. But you definitely need to
put your turkey in the water and basically soak it for the night before, before
you put it out just because it can dry out on the smoker and so you need to
basically infuse it with a bunch of liquid beforehand.
Tony Federico: Now, would this be a brine or would this just be water?
Russ Crandall: Yes, so just a brine. So, you’d use just salt and if you’re up for it you can add
honey into the water. You want to heat up a little bit of water and mix it in
with the honey until it’s mixed in well and then you can add that to the salt
water as well. Both sugar and salt will deconstruct the meat protein so it’s
really good as far as brining and prepping the turkey for smoking it.
You want the water to be somewhat salty; it’s about a cup of salt for a gallon
of water is basically what you want to do and then maybe half as much honey,
so maybe a half a cup of honey. And it sounds like a lot, but it doesn’t take a
lot of volume of water to submerge an entire turkey.
And then, yes, so then you basically are going to throw it on the smoker or on
your grill. And so, let me walk you through how I like to smoke my turkeys on
the grill. We use a gas grill, actually, just because it’s a lot easier, you don’t
have to worry about running out of charcoal, that kind of thing.
But still, the way you want to do that is you put your wood chips over one side
of the grill and you only turn on that side of the grill. So, you turn on one
burner on high and you get those chips smoking right under the burner.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !29
Tony Federico: Are you using a smoker box or are you making a homemade way to contain
the chips?
Russ Crandall: Usually we’ll just throw in a small aluminum pan and just put them there
usually adding a little bit of water that way it will not smoke too quickly. Or
you can just wrap them in tin foil; you can use a smoker box, any of those
things, anything to really just keep the woodchips or wood chunks together.
So, you want to get that going and then you just throw your turkey on. You
don’t want to truss a turkey which you want to do for other poultry; you don’t
want to do that with turkey because interestingly enough you don’t want the
breast and the thigh meat to be at the same temperature and when you truss a
bird that means it’s all going to be a ball of meat and it’s all going to come to
the same temperature.
So, you actually want to get your dark meat about 175 degrees and your breast
meat at 165 [degrees]. So, in order to do that you just basically leave the
turkey alone, you just let it sit there because that way the legs which stick out
from the body are going to cook faster than the breast.
Tony Federico: What temperature? I think the low-and-slow principle probably applies here.
But what specific temperature are we looking at getting the grill up to?
Russ Crandall: So, you can definitely do low-and-slow, but it would take a long time and
poultry in general doesn’t do very well sometimes with low-and-slow. So, you
actually want to do pretty high heat on a 325 [degrees], 350 [degrees] or so; it
only takes two hours, so you do one hour and then you flip the bird so that the
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !30
other side of the bird is now facing the hot part of the grill because since
you’re having burners on one side on that means that one side’s going to get
hotter than the other.
Tony Federico: Now, would this be the left and right sides are getting flipped or face on and
then, I guess, tail on?
Russ Crandall: So, it’s dependent on what space you have on your grill. It really doesn’t
matter, but I would say, yes, you probably want to put one leg and one breast
against the hot side and then flip it and do the other leg and breast, basically.
That probably would be the easiest thing to do.
Yes, so that’s it. Two hours, then let it sit for 20 minutes, 30 minutes and then
carve it and that’s it.
Tony Federico: That’s actually really quick; it sounds pretty easy, it seems certainly just as
easy as doing it in the oven.
Russ Crandall: Totally.
Tony Federico: And then when you cut into it the breast meat stays juicy, the thighs are done.
What kind of signs would somebody want to look for to make sure that
they’ve hit that sweet spot in terms of cooking temp?
Russ Crandall: So, it’s going to brown pretty quickly depending on how close it is to the heat.
And another thing I forgot to mention is you want to rub it all over with fat, so
ghee, I found, is actually the best fat to use for that or…
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !31
Tony Federico: Yes, we definitely don’t want to forget that. {Laughter}
Russ Crandall: Right. And then duck fat will work too.
Tony Federico: Yes, nice.
Russ Crandall: It’s not actually 100% necessary, but if you really want that crispy skin, just
adding the fat on top really helps.
Tony Federico: In a pretty generous layer, I’d imagine?
Russ Crandall: Yes, just enough to really get it all on there so it’s pretty well-covered; you
don’t want it sopping. But, yes, you can throw stuff inside the cavity if you
want. I’m a big fan of putting citrus peel and maybe half and onion and some
herbs inside. But you don’t really have to do that either.
The big thing is really just brining it overnight and then just rubbing that fat
on and throwing it on the grill and it will get really golden is really the thing
you’re looking for and then testing it with a thermometer is probably your best
way to know that it’s ready or you can just poke it with a fork and if the juices
run clear then you’re probably good to go as well.
Tony Federico: I’m a big fan of the ThermoWorks thermo pan…
Russ Crandall: They’re awesome.
Tony Federico: …as well as the little chef timers that they have where you can just plug it in.
And I think you were talking a couple weeks ago about the remote control
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !32
one; you don’t even need to be in the same room to see what your turkey’s
doing.
Russ Crandall: I’ve got a Bluetooth one that hooks up with my phone {laughter} and it
messages me when it’s ready. It’s like, “Hey, it’s ready.”
Tony Federico: Oh, man. Now, that might not be Paleo grilling, per se, but that’s certainly a
good tool to have in your arsenal. One quick question: what type of
woodchips would you recommend?
Russ Crandall: So, you want to use a mild smoking wood when you use poultry, so apple,
alder or cherry are probably the best. I’m a big fan of apple. You don’t want to
go with something like hickory which is really sharp which is best with
something like beef instead.
Tony Federico: And you’re living in Florida now. Would orangewood be available, by any
chance?
Russ Crandall: {Laughter} I have no idea. That’s a good question. I haven’t seen it around,
but that would be pretty awesome too.
Tony Federico: Well, if your neighbor has an orange tree, you could probably harvest a little
yourself. Well, Russ, man, that sounds amazing. It sounds like a great
alternative to the traditional roast turkey.
I appreciate you taking the time to come on the show and share with us your
holiday trick for a perfect smoked turkey.
Paleo Magazine Podcast Episode 61
2014 Page !33
Russ Crandall: Cool, thanks. Yes, thanks for having me on again.
{Music}
Tony Federico: Alright, everybody, that’s going to do it for today’s episode of Paleo Magazine
Radio. Next time on the podcast Ray Audette, author of Neanderthal, a book
about Paleo that was written before the Paleo diet was even cool.
I’m Tony Federico and on behalf of everyone at Paleo Magazine, thank you
for listening.
Host: If you would like to share your story on PMR, please visit our Facebook page
at Facebook.com/paleomagazine for full transcripts of the show as well as
exclusive online content go to our web page Paleomagonline.com. You can
also talk to us on Twitter at #PMRadio.
THE END