Argyll and Bute CouncilDevelopment Services

Delegated or Committee Planning Application Report and Report of handling as required by Schedule 2 of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) (Scotland) Regulations 2008 relative to applications for Planning Permission or Planning Permission in Principle

Reference No: 15/02607/MFFPlanning Hierarchy:

Local Development

Applicant: Dawnfresh Farming LimitedProposal: Modification of fish farm from 10 No. 80m circumference cages to 12

No. 80m circumference cages including increase in extent of mooring area (no increase in biomass).

Site Address: Sailean Ruadh (Etive 6), Loch Etive

SUPPLEMENTARY REPORT NO. 1

(A) INTRODUCTION

This report details additional representation received since the original report to Committee was produced.

(B) CONSULTEE RESPONSE:

Ardchatten Community Council (11.12.15) has voted to object to the proposal on the following grounds:

1) Industrialisation of the loch;2) Impact on the landscape;3) Pollution of the loch & damage to eco-systems;4) Increase of capacity in breach of ICZM plan as there is no proposal to remove

capacity elsewhere on the loch to compensate, as per the original Etive 6 application.

Comment: Ardchatten CC represents the area to the north of Loch Etive which would be exposed to views of the equipment across the loch, whereas the application site lies within the Taynuilt CC area.

(C) REPRESENTATIONS:

Since the production of the original report, additional representations have been

received which total, as of 15th December 2015, 239 of which 120 are objections and 119 are expressions of support. They do not raise further substantive issues beyond those already summarised in the original report. The names and addresses of all persons having made representations are listed in the appendix to this report, which now supersedes the list accompanying the original report.

(C) RECOMMENDATION

It is recommended that permission be refused for the reason stated in the original report.

_________________________________________________________________________

Report Author: Richard Kerr Date: 15th December 2015

Angus GilmourHead of Planning and Regulatory Services

APPENDIX A

REPRESENTATIONS

1 - OBJECTORS Total: 120

Alastair Lockhart Field Cottage 16/11/2015AppinArgyllPA38 4DD

Alex Burns 3 Birchlea Drive 16/11/2015GiffnockG46 6BP

Alexa Tyler-Scott The Hollys 08/12/2015BurnthouseSt GluvaisPenrynCornwalTR10 9AS

Alistair Morison Springfields 20/11/2015StoodleighTivertonDevon

Alistair Nicol The Pines 09/12/2015Bonawe RoadNorth ConnelPA37 1QX

Andrew Hind Elmhurst 12/11/2015Stychens LaneBletchingleySurreyRH1 4LL

Andrew Holder 29 Achlonan 09/12/2015TaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JJ

Andrew K Henderson Birkmoss 11/12/2015North ConnelArgyllPA37 IRE

Ann Dalgaty Rockport 07/12/2015BonaweObanArgyll And ButePA37 1RL

Anna Kenyon 8 Edmeston Close 13/11/2015London E9

Anne Petley Salmon's Leap 08/12/2015EredinePA33 1BP

Annette Hardy 7 Sarson Close 12/12/2015AmportAndoverHantsSP11 8AB

B E Mangan 11 Etive Park 09/12/2015North ConnelPA37 1SJ

Barbara Campbell Shellachan 09/12/2015KilninverObanArgyll And ButePA34 4UU

Barry Sapsford The Croft 13/11/2015Llanvihangel CrucorneyAbergavennyMonmouthshireNP7 8

Brenda Hunt 227 Queen Alexandra Road 09/12/2015SunderlandSR3 1XF

Bryan Watters 12 Queens Road 13/11/2015SalisburyWiltshire

C Thorburn 1 Lethendry Lodge 09/12/201518 The SquareGrantown-on-speyPH26 3HG

Carol Burnside 45 Nant Drive 17/11/2015ObanPA34 4NL

Charles Denvir Ivy Cottage 09/12/2015PandyNr AbergavennyNP7 8HH

Charles Warlow 6 South Gray Street 16/11/2015EdinburghEH9 1TE

Chrissy Stergios Morgenster 13/11/2015Lijnbaansgracht 171015 GN Amsterdam

Christine Turner 39 Loch Aweside Forest Park 13/11/2015DalavichBy TaynuiltArgyllPA35 1HN

D H Rockley Wildwood House 08/12/2015KilchrenanTaynuiltArgyllPA35 1HE

Dale Tucker 8 Newstead Road 08/12/2015OtleyWest YorkLS21 3JB

Darren Browne 6 Sunningdale Drive 13/11/2015PA11 3HX

Dave Blackham The Tea Gardens 12/11/2015Framilode GroucestershireGL2 7LF

David Harris 8 Temple Locks Court 09/12/2015AnnieslandG13 1JS

David Hitchin Herons Reach 08/12/2015North ConnelArgyllPA11 3AJ

Deborah Gillingham Ty Glas 04/12/2015Gipsy Castle LaneHay On WyeHR3 5EG

Derek Worth 26 Achlonan 12/11/2015TaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JJ

Doug Carmichael Ardsheal 13/11/2015Orchy GardensObanArgyllPA34 4JR

Duncan N Macdonald Clachacharra 13/11/2015TaynuiltPA35 1JE

Elaine Grant 15 Bank Street 12/11/2015GlasgowG12 8JQ

Elaine Watters 12 Queens Road 23/11/2015SalisburySP1 3AJ

Etive Brown Baressan 20/11/2015TaynuiltArgyll And ButePA35 1HY

Ewan Kennedy Kinloch 11/12/2015 Degnish RoadKilmelford PA34 4XD

Fiona Davidson Creebeag 09/12/2015North ConnelPA37 1RD

Freya Macmillan Muckairn 08/12/2015TaynuiltPA35 1JA

Friends Of Loch Etive 13/11/2015

George Brew Bettys Meadow 17/11/2015Trewince LanePort NavasFalmouthCornwallTR11 5RH

George Franks The Old Vicarage 12/11/2015Sutton'WoodbrdigeSuffolkIP12 3DT

GM Service Dal Na Traigh 12/11/2015

Airds BayTaynuiltPA35 1JR

Graham Guthrie 86A Springkell Avenue 15/12/2015GlasgowG41 4EH

Hamza Mould 35 Oaklands 09/12/2015Argyle RoadLondonW13 0HG

Hazel Barry The Kestrel 19/11/2015BonaweObanPA37 1RL

Helen Kingsland 44 Sommerville Road 19/11/2015Bristol BS7 9AB

Helena Petre 43 Highfield Road 16/11/2015StroudGlosGL5 1ES

Isla Hannigan 4 Achlonan 12/11/2015Taynuilt

Isla Kerr 4x4 Vehicle Hire 18/11/2015HoodshillFossowayKinrossKY13 0PW

J.F. Stevens An Tearmann 12/11/2015Falls Crescent Connel ArgyllPA37 1NX

James Bolam Jays Farm 16/11/2015

Wisborough GreenWest SussexRH14 0EG

James Grout Ard-Mhor 13/11/2015DeirdreConnelObanArgyllPA37 1PH

James Mewell Dearbhaig 02/12/2015InveraweTaynuiltArgyll And ButePA35 1HU

Jennifer Harris 8 Temple Locks Court 09/12/2015AnnieslandG13 1JS

Jennifer Wade Ben Rhu 13/11/2015DurorAppinPA38 4BS

Jeremy Hopkins Woodlands Croft 20/11/2015FowlershillDyceAberdeenshireAB21 7AQ

Jess Greatrex-Smith 20 Mereway Road 09/12/2015TwickenhamTW2 6RG

Jessica Pohl Selliner Weg 12 08/12/201524266 HeikendorfGermay

Jim Hardie Ceol Na Mara 08/12/2015North ConnelPA37 1RW

Joanna Service Dalnatraigh 13/11/2015Airds BayTaynuiltPA35 1JR

John Macfarlane Brigadier 09/12/2015TighnambarrTaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JQ

John Mottram 12 Frobisher Drive 13/11/2015 SwynnertonStoneST15 0QY

John R Williams 17 Corella Road 09/12/2015Kirrawee2232SydneyAustralia

John Service 6 Rockwell Gardens 30/11/2015London SE19 1HW

John Sinclair No.2 Allt Beg 12/11/2015Glen EtiveBallachulish PH49 4JA

Judith Brew Bettys Meadow 19/11/2015Trewince LanePort NavasCornwallTR11 5RH

Karima Mould 21 Oaklands 08/12/2015Argyle RoadLondonW13 0HG

Kathy Longbottom The Bothie 20/11/2015Airds BayTaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JR

Katryn Mercer 3 Brookside 17/11/2015SuttonElyCambsCB6 2PT

Kay Longbottom Sandbank 09/12/2015Airds BayTaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JR

Lee Foster Sannox 16/11/2015Crannaig A Mhinister ObanPA34 4LU

Lloyd Hutchinson Hillside 13/11/2015140 Grove LaneCamberwellSE5 8BP

Lois Skilleter 36 Skipton Road 11/12/2015IlkleyW.YorkshireLS29 9EP

Lorne Brown Croftlands 12/11/2015St BoswellsMelroseTD6 0AE

M A C MacPhail Dearbhaig 02/12/2015InveraweTaynuiltPA35 1HU

Maggie Brotherston 29 Achlonan 20/11/2015TaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JJ

Maggie Service 24 St Alphonsus Rd 12/11/2015LondonSW4 7AS

Malcolm Young Ivy Cottage 23/11/2015Easdale IslandPA34 4TB

Matthew Hartley 12 Bramfield Place 08/12/2015Hemel HempsteadHertfordshireHP2 7NZ

Maurice Hardy 7 Sarson Close 09/12/2015AmportAndoverSP11 8AB

Melissa Matthias 6 Henley Close 13/11/2015 IsleworthTW7 5DQ

Mike Foster Sannox 13/11/2015Crannaig A MhinisterObanPA34 4LU

Milda Jusciute Erfurto G. 6-51 09/12/2015VilniusLithuaniaLt 047117

Monica Bloor Rhumor 25/11/2015North Connel

Morag Holmes 27 Eastside Drive 09/12/2015WesthillAB32 6QN

Mr Wright 25 Achlonan 23/11/2015 TaynuiltPA35 1JJ

Mrs Wright 25 Achlonan 23/11/2015TaynuiltPA35 1JJ

Naima Mould 83 Mortimer Road 09/12/2015LondonNW10 5TN

Nathalie Drew Service Dal Na Traigh 20/11/2015Airds BayTaynuiltArgyllPA35 1JR

Nick Barberton The Cottage 09/12/2015WoodgreenHampshireSP6 2AR

Nigel Bloor Rhumor 20/11/2015North ConnelObanArgyll

PA37 1QZ Nigel John Petley Salmon's Leap 08/12/2015

EredineBy DalmallyPA33 1BP

R H Clarke Gillean Brighde 20/11/2015KilchrenanTaynuiltArgyll And ButePA35 1HF

Raymond Gatiens 63 Black Road 08/12/2015KettyKY4 0BD

Rhona Young Ivy Cottage 23/11/2015Easdale IslandPA34 4TB

Richard Greatrex Ty Glas 04/12/2015Gypsy Castle LaneHay On WyeHR3 5EG

Robert Holmes 27 Eastside Drive 09/12/2015WesthillAB32 6QN

Roc Sandford Isle Of Gometra 13/11/2015Ulva FerryIsle Of MullPA73 6NA

Roderick Macleod 2 Fox Farm Cottages 12/11/2015Coldblow Lane Maidstone Kent

Ron Walker 23 Devon Street 20/11/2015GrangemouthFK38 8HG

Roy Bartle 17 Peterborough Avenue 13/11/2015OakhamRutlandLE15 6EB

Ruaraidh Petre SSCD Ltd 13/11/2015Igh An T-SiomainArdchattanObanArgyllPA37 1RF

Russ Howe 13 Farrow Road 18/11/2015Whaplode DriveSpaldingLincolnshirePE12 0TS

Russell Bloor Overton 08/12/20152 Whitelands RoadBaildonWest YorkshireBD17 6NL

Sarah Washbrook 54 Edghehead Village 18/11/2015PathheadEdinburghEH37 5RJ

Scott Latimer 31 Williamwood Park West 08/12/2015GlasgowG44 3TE

Sheena Insull Le Clos De La Brague 13/11/20155665 Route De Valbonne06410 Biot France

Sian Griffiths Blarcreen House 09/12/2015ArdchattanObanArgyll And ButePA37 1RG

Steve Letford 33 Lora View 12/11/2015North ConnelPA37 1RR

Stuart D Mackie 4 John Anderson House 23/11/2015ObanPA34 4NT

Susan Jameson Jays Farm 16/11/2015Wisborough GreenWest SussexRH14 0EG

Sylvia Clarke 47 Newlyn Way 23/11/2015Port SolentPortsmouthP06 4TL

Tec Frondirion 08/12/2015Manod Blaenau FfestiniogGwynedd North WalesLL41 4BB

Thomas Middleton 42 Dalavich 09/12/2015PA35 1HN

Tommy Morton 76 Henver Road 08/12/2015NewquayCornwallTR7 3BL

Tony Dalgaty Rockport 09/12/2015BonaweObanArgyll And ButePA37 1RL

Tony Huntington Point Park Cottage 26/11/2015TaynuiltArgyll And ButePA35 1JQ

William Brew Flat 3 17/11/20157 Elm Tree AvenueWest BridgfordNottinghamNG2 7JU

2 - SUPPORTERS Total: 119

Alan Drummond 4 Lorn Rd 04/12/2015DunbegPA37 1QG

Alan Jamieson 7 Mossfield Avenue 11/12/2015ObanPA34 4EH

Alasdair Sutherland 4 Balmanno Entry Auchterarder 09/12/2015PH3 1FW

Alastair Salvesen Bothwellpark Industrial Estate 09/12/2015Uddingston

Alex Skinn 19 C Corran Brae 04/12/2015ObanPA34 5AJ

Alisha Goodwin 3/2 353 Glasgow Harbour Terrace 14/12/2015G11 6DJ

Alison Hutchins 12 Kilmorich 11/12/2015CairndowArgyll And ButePA26 8BA

Alison MacGugan Tarnavie Cottage 10/12/2015RossieDunningPerthshirePH2 0QU

Andrew Cooksey 5 Walls Street 15/12/2015G1 1PA

Andrew Forbes Smith 39 Castle Street 11/12/2015FochabersIV32 7DW

Andrew Kyle Starling Cottage 26/11/2015TaynuiltPA35 1HP

Anna Robertson 2 Shannas Farm Cottages 15/12/2015Clola AB42 5DB

Barbara Lugowska 7 Gullane Road 10/12/2015DundeeDD2 3BA

Ben Wilson Inverlussa Marine Services 11/12/2015By CraignureIsle Of MullPA65 6BD

Berta Rivera 111A George Street 10/12/2015ObanPA34 5NT

C Duke 30 Fairgrove Drive 15/12/2015G75 9FH

Cameron MacFarlane Beechglade 11/12/2015Soroba RoadObanPA34 4SB

Cameron MacFarlane 3A Angus Terrace 11/12/2015ObanPA343 4EG

Cedric Rosier 37 Lady Menzies Place 11/12/2015EdinburghEH7 5BA

Christopher Edmunds 33 Barnton Avenue West 04/12/2015EH4 6DF

Craig Paterson 11 Burnhill Quadrant 10/12/2015RutherglenLanarkshireG73 1ER

Craig Wright 4 Redwell Park 04/12/2015Furnace ArgyllPA31 8RL

Darren Allan 5 Kennedie Park 15/12/2015Mid Calder EH53 0RG

David Gray Keepers Cottage 12/12/2015CargillPerthPH2 6DT

David Haggart 27 Kenmore Cottages 11/12/2015BonaweObanArgyll And ButePA37 1RJ

David Jarron 6 Ravelston Court 14/12/2015EdinburghEH12 6HQ

David Thain Bridgend Cottage 27/11/2015BalgaviesForfarAngus DD8 2SE

Dean Jordan Nursery Cottage 27/11/2015KinnairdBrechinAngusDD9 6TY

Derek Cooper 32 Viewfield Road 11/12/2015AberdeenAB15 7XP

Emma Bubberman Craigloiste 12/12/2015KilchrenanPA35 1HG

Emma Sprott 25 Tamarack Crescent 11/12/2015G71 5LL

Emmanuelle Rey Frandy Fish Farm 10/12/2015FK14 7JZ

Euan Meldrum Dunfraoch 04/12/2015Hall BraeTaynuilt PA35 1JE

Fiona Anderson 7 Orchard Field 10/12/2015LenzieG66 5QW

Frank Ryan 21 Greendykes Steading 15/12/2015EH52 6QX

Geraldine McDade No Address Given 10/12/2015

Gideon Pringle 21 Barnwell Drive 10/12/2015G63 0RG

Gillian Anderson Durran Cottage 15/12/2015By Dalmally PA33 1BT

Gillian Devine 88 Drummore Avenue 15/12/2015ML5 4BZ

Gillian Hutcheson 6 Lilac Hill 10/12/2015 CumbernauldGlasgowG67 3QL

Gordon Reid Rehoboth 11/12/2015QuarffShetlandZE2 9EZ

Graeme O Brien 50 Westhaven Park 15/12/2015CarnoustieDD7 6JZ

Graham Witherington Ivyhurst 11/12/2015Lower WayUpper LongdonStaffordshireWS15 1QG

Gregg Witherington 52 Bishops Meadow 11/12/2015West MidlandsB75 5PQ

Gregor Sutherland Sutherlands And Sterner 11/12/20151 Longman DriveInvernessIV1 1SU

Helen Morgan 16 Burn Brae Place 14/12/2015 InvernessIV2 5TA

Helen Muir 1 Green Acres 15/12/2015Muirhouse SteadingsAuchenheathML11 9ZP

Helen Wilson Inverlussa 14/12/2015CraignureMullPA65 6BD

Iain Cruden Grooms Cottage 14/12/2015UnderdownGloucester RoadLedbury

HR8 2JE

Iain MacQuarrie 66 Old Station Court 09/12/2015BothwellG71 8PE

Ian Campbell 11A Main Road 11/12/2015TA7 0PB

Ian Lawson 16 Trossachs Road 15/12/2015Aberfoyle Stirling FK8 3SW

James Johnston Rowan Apartment Lonan House 11/12/2015TaynuiltPA35 1HY

James Vaughan 79C High Street 02/12/2015MontroseAngusDD10 8QY

Jane Campbell Medowbank 11/12/2015Main RoadMiddlezoy Somerset TA7 0PB

Jane McCusker 109 Hunter Grove 10/12/2015BathgateWest LothianEH48 1NN

Jim King Mohnaqua 14/12/2015Forres

IV36 2AB

Jo Anne Connell Skretting 15/12/2015Inverbreakie Ind EstInvergordonRoss ShireIV18 0QR

Joanne Campbell Barranrioch Farm 26/11/2015 GlencruittenPa34 4QB

John A Keeney 24 Lochness Road 04/12/2015DunbegPA37 1QJ

John Anderson Durran Cottage 10/12/2015By DalmallyPA33 1BT

John Ewing Flat 0/1 2 Dodside Gardens 15/12/2015SandyhillsGlasgow G32 9EH

John Sharp Denburn Cottage 10/12/2015Swan AvenueKY8 5JY

John Williamson Wincham 11/12/2015NorthwichCheshireCW9 6DF

Jonathan Pollock 4 Holly Crescent 25/11/2015BlairgowriePH10 6TX

Karen Kennedy 10 Lyman Drive 15/12/2015WishawML2 8ST

Karolina Syske Skretting 15/12/2015Inverbreakie Ind. Estate Invergordon IV18 0QRUK

Ken MacKenzie Oakwood House 15/12/2015Clyde WyndeAuchterarderPerthshire PH3 1DA

Krzysztof Radzicki 45 Park Terrace 10/12/2015AberuthvenPH3 1HU

Lesley Bridges 10 Jura Gardens 11/12/2015ML8 4HU

Lewis Campbell 34 Achloanan 11/12/2015Taynuilt

Liam Divers 43 Letham Grange 15/12/2015CarrickstoneCumbernauld G68 0HZ

Linda Dryburgh 38 Hutchison Way 15/12/2015KY2 6SJ

Linda Pringle 21 Barnwell Drive 10/12/2015G63 0RG

Lindsay McCrae Inverness 11/12/2015IV2 4PY

M Metselaar 20 A Chalton Road 12/12/2015FK9 4DX

Marcin Perdjon 12 C Breadalbane Street 04/12/2015ObanPA34 5NZ

Marcos Garcia Flat 11 10/12/2015Grange CourtNewtownstewartCo Tyrone

Marie Forsyth MacGregor Industrial Supplies Ltd 11/12/201515-17 Henderson RoadLongman Industrial EstateInvernessIV1 1SN

Mark Kelbrick 29 Claymore Avenue 11/12/2015AB12 4RF

Martin Collins Boathouse Cottage 04/12/2015ArdchattanPA37 1RG

Mary Smith 39 Castle Street 15/12/2015FochabersIV32 7DW

Mathew Laughton 55 Meadow Drive 11/12/2015CambuslangGlasgowG72 6QD

Maureen Erdi 10 Mid Park 11/12/2015East Killbride G75 0BZ

Michael MacLeod 1 Chestnut Court 04/12/2015PA35 1JZ

Morven Anderson Durran Cottage 15/12/2015PA33 1BT

Neil Ferguson Kintra 04/12/2015Castle RoadDunollie ObanArgyllPA34 5AN

Neil Khan 24 Marine Court 04/12/2015DunbegObanPA37 1NU

Neil Lamb 4 Windermere Court 15/12/2015Lonsdale RoadBarnesLondonSW13 9AS

Nicola MacDonald 13 David Drive 15/12/2015AlnessIV17 0ZD

Paul Carter Aspen Lodge 04/12/2015GlencruittenPA34 4QB

Paul Milloy 25 Glen Shee Lane 25/11/2015Carluke ML8 4RX

Phillip Cassidy 5/2 Sinclair Close 15/12/2015EdinburghEH11 1US

Raleigh Salvesen 17A Alva Street 09/12/2015EH2 4PH

Richard May 3 Kinnaird Mill Cottages 25/11/2015BrechinAngusDD9 6TY

Robbie Duncanson 24 Westfield Brae 14/12/2015IV2 5TL

Robert Hughes Wincham 15/12/2015NortwichCheshire CW9 6DF

Russell Donaldson 6 Kensingston Road 15/12/2015G12 9LF

Sandy Edmond Corpach 14/12/2015Fort WilliamPH33 7NB

Scott Fraser 11 Blackford Avenue 10/12/2015EH9 2PJ

Scott Miller The Flat 10/12/2015Frandy Fish FarmFK14 7JZ

Sean Lydon Merlin 23/11/2015

Caulfield Road SouthInvernessIV25BH

Seumas Macfadyen 9 Achinreir 09/12/2015BarcaldineBy ObanPA37 1SL

Shona Aikman 17 Gordon Terrace 11/12/2015InvergordonRoss-shireIV18 0BU

Simon Duffin Lower Stepford 11/12/2015MorrintonDumfriesDG2 0JP

Sine MacFarlane Beechglade 11/12/2015Soroba RoadObanArgyll And ButePA34 4SB

Smaranda Lydon Merlin 24/11/2015Caulfield road southInvernessIV2 5BH

Stephanie Horn 2E North Church Street 10/12/2015CallanderFK17 8EW

Steven Thomas Crabbe 2 Sunnybrae Cottage 10/12/2015PH6 2NE

Sue Machin 4 Windermere Court 15/12/2015Lonsdale RoadLonson SW13 9AS

Susan Barclay 9 Hedge Road 11/12/2015GarmouthIV32 7NU

Suzii Craig 9 McLellan Court 10/12/2015ArbroathDD11 4XD

Thomas Lynch St Blanes Lochearnhead 10/12/2015FK19 8NS

Tony Miller 2 Hill Road 10/12/2015HarthillShottsML7 5RY

Vaclav Petlan 14/4 Red Braes Place 11/12/2015 EdinburghEH7 4LL

Valentina Romano 2 Kinnaird Mill Cottages 26/11/2015BrechinAngusDD9 6TY

Vicky Campbell 24 Achloanan 15/12/2015Taynuilt ArgyllPA35 1JJ

Will Jewison Greencare 14/12/2015

Lintrose Coupar AngusPerthshirePH13 9JF

William Phimister 5 The Square 04/12/2015CladichPA33 1BQ