+ All Categories
Home > Documents > PMSM Drives 1

PMSM Drives 1

Date post: 04-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: leo232
View: 243 times
Download: 7 times
Share this document with a friend

of 51

Transcript
  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    1/51

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    2/51

    Advanced AC Drives

    Permanent Magnet (PM) Machines

    Part I Introduction

    Part II Brushless DC Drives

    Part III Permanent Magnet (PM) AC Drive

    Part IV PM AC Drive Equations

    Part V Alternative Representations

    Part VI Control of PMAC Drive MTPA

    Part VII Control of PMAC Drive Field Weakening

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    3/51

    Advanced AC Drives

    Permanent Magnet (PM) Machines

    Part I

    Introduction

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    4/51

    Characteristics of PM machines

    6-pole permanentmagnet rotor

    PM motors have the fastestgrowing market share

    Magnetic field from PM affixed onrotor

    No current in rotor- no rotor losses

    - most efficient machine

    No magnetising current- more torque per amp

    - converters more efficient

    High magnet flux densities- highest Torque/Power Density

    of all machine types

    Simple rotor, low inertia- very high dynamics

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    5/51

    Characteristics of PM machines

    Relatively simple construction, no brushgear BRUSHLESS MACHINE

    Design flexibility than induction- high pole number machines

    - large radius

    - axial flux machines

    - transverse flux machines

    - concentrated wound machines

    Magnets are expensive- demand for machines pushing up price

    - one country dominates market

    More difficult to construct than IMs

    Magnets lose magnetism at temperatures 150-250C- not suitable for use in high temperature environments

    - higher the temperature, easier to demagnetise magnets

    Cannot be operated without a power converter, cannot operate from mains

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    6/51

    Application Areas

    High Performance servo drives

    - high acceleration, positioning applications

    High efficiency drives

    Automotive applications- Hybrid and electric cars

    - Starter generators

    - Power steering

    Aerospace Applications- Undercarriage actuators

    - Cabin air compressors, air conditioning

    - Future actuators for flight surfaces

    Domestic Applications- Air conditioners

    - Washing Machines

    Aerospace actuation : tens of kW

    Electric & Hybrid Vehicles

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    7/51

    Application Areas

    Ship Propulsion : up to 18MW

    Wind Generation : up to 5MW

    High pole number, large radius drives

    Low speed applications

    Renewable energies- Directly connected wind generator

    - tidal and sea current generators

    Direct drive (no gear box) ship motors

    http://www.ship-technology.com/contractors/propulsion/abb/
  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    8/51

    Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering

    Advanced AC Drives

    Permanent Magnet Machine Drives

    Part II

    The Brushless DC Drive

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    9/51

    BLAC - BrushLess AC PM Machine- also known as PM synchronous machine- sinusoidal back-EMF (open cct voltage)- sinusoidal current excitation

    BLDC - BrushLess DC- also known as Trapezoidal motor- trapezoidal back-EMF

    - square wave current excitation

    BLAC BLDC

    BLAC BLDC

    Magnet flux density in air gap

    BLAC: Sinusoidal back-emf achieved by

    120 elec magnet span and windingsgiving sinusoidal mmf

    BLDC: Trapezoidal back-emf achieved

    by 180 elec magnet span and windings

    square wave mmf

    Types of PM machineTypes of PM machine

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    10/51

    The principle is simple

    The flux lines constant over the 180; flux is maximum at 1, zero at 2 etc Voltage is rate of change of flux

    At 1, current in A-phase as shown; stays like this until field reverses at 3

    At 3 current commutates; a hall sensor gives a logic signal

    Principle of BLDC machinePrinciple of BLDC machine

    1 2 3 4

    A

    2 3 4

    A

    1

    VI

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    11/51

    There are 3 phases, A, B, C

    Each is switched when the change of

    magnet polarity nears the phase

    The switching of the current lasts for

    120 and is provided by a 3-leggedinverter as shown. It is an electronic

    commutator.

    2 devices conduct at any time

    Q1 Q3 Q5

    Q2Q6Q4

    The electronic commutatorThe electronic commutator

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    12/51

    The Torque developed is T = kBI

    To vary the torque, we vary the current; the two conducting devices arepulse width modulated

    The PWM converter voltage is shown below

    IfI Vm, I rises etc; else off

    Control of BLDC machine currentControl of BLDC machine current

    1 2 3 4

    A

    2 3 4

    A

    1

    VI

    2 3 41

    V

    I

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    13/51

    I

    Inverter (power amplifier)BLDC

    I*

    r

    PI

    r *

    r

    counter

    commutatork

    Hall effect devices mounted in the motor detect position. Crude - if greater resolution required a more expensive encoder can be used.

    Position signal pulses can be used to give a speed signal. A speed loop

    feeding a current loop is conventional; current loop is hysteresis control

    Control of BLDC machineControl of BLDC machine

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    14/51

    BLDC machine torque rippleBLDC machine torque ripple

    BLDC drive operation has lot of torque ripple.

    Price paid for simple control and sensing

    Torque ripple has a number of sources, some

    machine related others due to the way the drive

    is operated.

    Sources of torque ripple are:

    Back-EMF Harmonics (machine related).Causes hump in torque waveform

    Switching Ripple (inverter related);proportional to the hf (>5kHz typical) PWMripple. Not a problem because the mechanical

    load inertia filters out its effect on speed.Commutation Ripple (inverter related). Seriousdue to phase current commutations from off-going inverter phase to the next on-coming

    phase at the end of each /3 interval.

    Simulated torque waveform for a BLDC

    drive with PWM-regulated six-step

    current waveform.

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    15/51

    BLDC Drive RequirementsBLDC Drive Requirements

    BLDC motor drives chosen for simple cheap applications.

    Control strategy can easily be implemented using digital circuitry (no

    P). But intelligent control processing becoming ever cheaper

    BLDC output characteristics are however inferior to BLAC drives in

    terms of torque and current smoothness. Torque density is high, potentially higher than BLAC due to better

    utilisation of the magnetic circuit.

    Machine needs to be star-connected since one phase needs to be

    open-circuited at any one time.

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    16/51

    IM vs BLDC vs BLAC

    In the rest of this course we will focus on brushless AC machines

    Also called Permanent Magnet AC machines.

    IM BLDC BLAC

    Motor Efficiency + +++ +++

    Torque Smoothness +++ + +++

    Torque Density + +++ +++

    Open Loop Control +++ - -

    Closed Loop Simplicity + +++ +

    Minimum Control Sensors + +++ +

    Machine design flexibility + ++ +++

    Extended Speed Range ++ + +++

    Motor Robustness +++ + ++

    Cost - motor

    Cost converter, sensors&

    control

    (vector

    drive)

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    17/51

    Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering

    Advanced AC Drives

    Permanent Magnet Machine Drives

    Part III

    The Permanent Magnet AC Drive

    Introduction

    Magnetic propertiesSaliency

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    18/51

    d-q rotating reference frame for PMSM

    f

    d-

    axis

    q-axis

    f

    Flux plot of a 2-Pole PMSM with zero statorcurrent

    Field orientation is in direction of magnet flux.

    Unlike IM the magnet flux in PMSM rotates at the same

    speed as the rotor

    ie. sl = 0; called a synchronous machine since

    Thus the direct or d-axis is aligned with the

    Permanent Magnet flux vector

    This means that the d-axis is fixed to the rotor

    The q-axis bisects the section between

    the permanent magnets.

    er

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    19/51

    Idealised 3-phase, 2-pole Permanent Magnet Machine

    M

    Field will rotate at r = d/dt (electrical rad/s)

    called the flux or rotor angle

    With no id, the torque is: MqkiT

    IfP knows all the time, then:Inject 3-ph currents which

    transforms into id, iq

    iqq

    d

    Currents iq setting up mmf in qdirection is called the torque

    current

    id is field current - Not required since

    machine is magnetised by magnets

    +ve id

    will add to magnet flux

    - but not much (iron will be near saturation)

    - ve id will act against magnet flux (less flux in d-axis)

    id

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    20/51

    IsV*

    V

    Inverter (power amplifier)PM machine

    r

    iq*

    PI

    id* = 0

    d/dt

    iq

    id

    r

    PI

    Ref [8,9]

    rj

    e

    rje

    PI

    2/3

    3/2

    r *

    r

    Basic vector control of PM machinewithout id current

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    21/51

    Permanent Magnet Excitation

    The permeability of a magnet is the

    slope of the straight line which

    intercepts the axis at the remenancepoint (Br). The permeability for

    ferrite and rare earth magnets is

    approximately that of free space

    (r ~1.05 to 1.07)

    Once off the linear part of the curve

    (knee-point), the magnet is wholly orpartially demagnetised and must be

    re-magnetised.

    Permanent Magnets are Hardmagnetic materials: retain

    magnetisation when the

    external field is removed

    Br remanent flux density

    Hc coercive force

    X103

    06.1

    10x720xx104/96.0

    /

    37

    corr HB

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    22/51

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    23/51

    Permanent Magnet Materials

    Example of temperature variation for a particulargrade of NeFeBr magnets

    Metal magnets (Alnico)

    - Oldest and rarely used

    Ceramic magnets (Ferrites Ba, St)- Cheapest and widely used; Max B around

    0.45T Rear Earth magnets (NdFeB and SmCo)

    - Most modern and relatively expensive- Best performance max B around 1.25T

    Magnetism lost at Curie Temperature- NdFeB is low: 120-180C

    Easier to demagnetise as T goes up- Knee point travels up curve- Br and Hc also reduce as shown- Reversible up to Curie T, but still serious

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    24/51

    Permanent Magnet Properties

    A current near the PM can also

    demagnetise it armature reaction

    important since best place to put load

    current in a PM machine! see diagram

    Can thus limit max transient torque

    Option - bury PM inside iron; shields

    magnet from torque current and gives

    good field weakening capability- but field due to iq now much higher

    since it is next to iron and not magnet- some loss of torque per amp

    Load current iq near PM

    d

    q

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    25/51

    Concept of Saliency

    PM machines can be salient - like traditional wound rotor salient synchronousmachines.

    This means that magnetic (iron) path in one direction eg the d-axis, is not thesame as in the q-axis

    In a traditional synchronous machine, the q-axis has a lot of air so that the q-axiscoil (red coil below) has low inductance; seen that Ld >Lq

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    26/51

    In a PM machine, the magnets, may be as shown

    Permeability of the magnets is low compared to that of magnetic steel.(permeability of magnets ~ permeability of air)

    In PMSM the inductance of the d-axis coil is smaller than the inductance of the qaxis coil Ie. LdLq

    Concept of Saliency

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    27/51

    Different types of PM machine

    Salient and non-salient

    (a) Surface Mount PM machine; magnets fixed onto rotor; retaining sleeve forstrength

    In a SM PM machine Ld = Lq since permeability of magnet and air are the same

    (b) Inset PM machine (IPM); magnets set into surface; Lq>Ld - SALIENT

    (c) Interior Magnet (or buried) PM machine: inside iron; Lq>Ld - SALIENT

    c)

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    28/51

    Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering

    Advanced AC Drives

    Permanent Magnet Machine Drives

    Part IV

    The Permanent Magnet AC Drive

    Machine Equations

    Maximum Torque per Amp

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    29/51

    The 3 stator coils A,B,C can be represented by

    TWO stationary coils Each stationary coil has resistance and rate of

    change of flux:

    ssssdt

    dRiv ssss

    dt

    dRiv

    ssssdt

    dRiv

    There are no rotor coils

    Dynamic Equation of PM BLAC machine

    Mr

    S

    S

    r

    )cos( ssrmsss iLdtdRiv

    )sin( ssrmsss iLdt

    dRiv

    )( iLedt

    dRiv s

    j

    msssr

    ssrms

    ssrms

    iL

    iL

    sin

    cos

    The flux in each stator coil is:

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    30/51

    s

    q

    r

    e

    xdxq

    x

    d

    s

    rj

    ssdq evv

    rj

    ssdq eii

    rj

    ssdq e

    rj

    sdqs evv

    rj

    sdqs eii

    rj

    sdqs e

    Now transform into rotating coordinates dq frame rotating at r

    )( ssj

    msss iLedt

    dRiv r

    mrsdqsr

    sdq

    sssdqsdq

    j

    mr

    j

    sdqsr

    jsdqs

    s

    j

    sdq

    j

    sdq

    j

    sdqs

    j

    ms

    j

    sdq

    j

    sdq

    jiLjdt

    diLRiv

    ejeiLjedt

    idLReiev

    eiLedt

    dReiev

    rrrrr

    rrrr

    Dynamic Equation of PM BLAC machine

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    31/51

    r

    r

    M

    sqsrd

    sdd iLdt

    diLRiv

    mrdr

    q

    qq Lidt

    diLRiv

    Dynamic Equation of PM BLAC machine

    qqrd

    ddd iLdt

    diLRiv

    mrddr

    q

    dqq iLdt

    diLRiv

    For a salient machine, Ld Lq, then:

    qqq iL

    mddd iL The flux linking the d-axis coil is magnet+ flux due to any id:

    The flux linking the q-axis coil is flux due to any i q:

    Drop suffix s since only stator coils

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    32/51

    The back-emf of a PMAC machine

    mrddr

    q

    dqq iLdt

    diLRiv

    Spin the rotor at a speed r with nocurrent applied to stator

    - measure voltage at terminals AA

    qqrd

    ddd iLdt

    diLRiv

    0dv mrqv

    mraqd Vvv ~22

    mrI

    a EV 0~

    M

    E

    r

    E is called the motor back-emf. It is easy tomeasure. Hence m is easy to determine

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    33/51

    Torque production in PMSM

    Torque is: 32

    Pk For the rms convention:

    The d and q axis flux linkages are given by :

    1st term is called the magnet alignment torque

    2nd term is proportional to (Ld-Lq) is called the reluctance torque. Define angle called the advance angle from q-axis to the current vector.

    For a negative id, is positive, for a positive id it is negative

    Magnet alignment

    componentReluctance

    component

    qqq

    mddd

    iL

    iL

    )()(

    qdqdqm

    dqqqmqdd

    LLiiikT

    iiLiiiLkT

    d

    q

    iq

    id

    i

    )(dqqd

    iikT

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    34/51

    Express torque as a function of stator current

    Determine the best operating point producing the torque with the minimum stator currentand hence with optimal efficiency.

    Now, if we substitute for id and iq:

    )](cossincos[2

    qdm LLiikT

    )]([qdqdqm

    LLiiikT

    aqd Iiii~22

    cos

    sin

    ii

    ii

    q

    d

    Into the torque expression:

    We get:

    d

    q

    iq

    id

    i

    The magnet flux and Ld, Lq are constant. Therefore, for a given ithere is a value of which will maximize T

    In a SMPM machine, Ld = Lq. Therefore

    and is maximum when

    cosiT m0i.e.0 di

    )(2sin

    2cos

    2

    qdm LLi

    ikT

    Torque production in Salient PMSM

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    35/51

    For a given current, we plot

    Maximum torque/amp occurs in a salient pole PMSM machine for >0

    When =0 , i = Ia = iq and reluctance torque is zero.

    If there is saliency, the required for max torque/amp, varies with current since thesaliency torque increases with i 2 while the magnet torque increases with Ia

    The relative amplitudes of the magnet and reluctance torque terms are set during themachine design in order to vary the relative amplitudes ofLd and Lq.

    )(2sin

    2cos

    2

    qdm

    LLi

    ikT

    ik m

    )(2

    2

    qd LLi

    k

    as a function of

    Torque production in Salient PMSM

    d

    q

    iq

    id

    i

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    36/51

    The plot below shows torque varies as a function of , for various values ofIa.

    The higher the current, the greater the angle of advance needs to be to operateat maximum efficiency.

    To determine the maximum torque point we can differentiate the torque equationwith respect to and equate to zero.

    Torque production in Salient PMSM

    d

    q

    iq

    id

    i

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    37/51

    Maximum Torque per Ampere (MTPA)

    Have

    )(2sin2cos

    2

    qdm LL

    i

    ikT

    0)(2cossin 2 qdm LLiikd

    dT

    02cossin2 Liim

    0)sin21(sin 22 Liim

    0sinsin2222 LiiiL m

    where )( qd LLL

    iL

    LimmT

    4

    8sin

    222

    1

    max

    Which will be used in the vector control of all salient PM machines

    The variation can be more complex since Ld, Lq and hence L vary aresubject to saturation as Ia increases. This can be experimentally obtained .

    02 cbxaxof form

    d

    q

    iq

    id

    i

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    38/51

    Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering

    Advanced AC Drives

    Permanent Magnet Machine Drives

    Part V

    The Permanent Magnet AC Drive

    Alternative representations

    Phasor representation

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    39/51

    PMSM Dynamic model as equivalent circuit

    D-axis equivalent circuit Q-axis equivalent circuit

    qqrd

    dsdd iLdt

    diLRiv

    mrddr

    q

    dsqq iLdt

    diLRiv

    qmqlqqqsq iLLiL )(

    fmddmdld

    mdmdldmddsd

    iLiLL

    iLLiL

    )(

    )()(

    sqe

    sde

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    40/51

    Phasor Representation of PMSM machines

    We have introduced the PMSM equations in terms of space vectors

    In nearly all text books and most papers, PMSM machines are alsorepresented in terms of phasors

    i.e. steady state sinusoidal voltages and currents applied to Phase A(and B and C)

    This is because PMSM has similarities to wound-rotor synchronousmachines which are the main generator in power systems

    Machine designers also analyse their steady state characterisitcs interms of phasors

    The relationship between the phasor tool (for steady state) andspace vector tool (for dynamic) representation is visually very close;

    mathematically it is a little tricky

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    41/51

    If we say that A goes through zero at t=0

    The rms magnitude becomes the magnitude of the complex number

    The phase displacement (degrees or radians) becomes the angle of thecomplex number

    10 B

    80

    A

    4

    B is: 804 tsin 802

    4

    tsin 10 02

    10A is:

    Revision of Phasors 1

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    42/51

    Ammeter 1

    Ammeter 2

    Ammeter 3

    ?1I

    ~

    2I~

    tsin)t(i 31

    0

    2

    31 I~

    tcos)t(i 42

    902

    42 I~

    02

    31 I~

    902

    42 I~ 3

    4tan

    2

    5~~~ 1321

    IIIi1(t) i2(t)

    53

    Revision of Phasors 2

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    43/51

    Difference between a vector and a phasor

    A phasor relates only to steady state quantities

    - phasor magnitude is the rms value of the SS sinusoid

    - phasor direction is arbitrary, the angle between the phasors represents the phase

    difference between sinusoids

    A vector is in direction of mmf

    direction of coil- This defines direction of voltage

    across and current through coil

    - Magnitude is size of voltage, current

    etc

    - For single coil, the vectors are in

    same direction

    C:\ac vector drives\vector ill

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    44/51

    Phasor equations from vector equations

    For 3-phase coils in a machine, the 2-d space can be represented

    as an argand diagram There is then a direct mapping between the steady state space

    vectors and the phasor quantities in the 3-phase coils

    A rotating vector in steady state has a dc value

    Its value projected onto the A-coil axis (or alpha) axis is sinusoidal

    Let rotating vector x (blue) trace/projects sinusoid as shown

    X0

    The vector y (red) traces/projects sine wave 90 aheadY90

    The vector z (green) traces/projects sine wave lagging

    Z-30

    r = e

    A

    A

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    45/51

    r

    r

    M

    Building Phasor equations of PM BLAC machine

    qqrd

    ddd iLdt

    diLRiv

    mrddr

    q

    dqq iLdt

    di

    LRiv

    Let all be in steady state, with r = e

    qqedd iLRiv

    meddeqq iLRiv

    Ridqqe iL

    sdv

    v

    Riq

    dde iL

    Eme d

    q

    qv

    EiLRiv ddeqq

    Dynamic equations of Salient PM machine

    - drop suffix s since no other coil

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    46/51

    sqqesdsd iLRiv

    d

    EiLRiv sddesqsq

    phXx

    2

    1

    As phasors, they are sinusoidal quantities, so we write x them as

    The magnitude is the rms phase quantity

    X~

    RId~

    qqIX~

    sqRI~

    ddIX~

    q

    qV~

    aV~

    dV~

    We also use the impedances ded LX qeq LX

    qqdd IXRIV ~~~

    EIXRIV ddqq~~~~

    dI~ is the Ia current which produces a field in

    parallel with the magnet

    is the Ia current which produces a field

    perpendicular to the magnet

    qI~

    qda III~~~

    22 ~~~

    qda IIINote:

    Eme~~

    Building Phasor equations of PM BLAC machine

    = +

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    47/51

    Phasors are always complex quantities:

    It is conventionalto make the d-axis quantities purely real

    And the q-axis quantities imaginary

    Hence we multiply appropriate phasors by j to make their

    directions consistent with the phasor Argand diagram

    )/(tan~ 122 abbajbaX

    0~ jII dd qq jII 0

    ~

    a d d q qV E I R j I X j I X

    EjXRIjXRIV qqdd~

    )(~

    )(~~

    EIjXRIV ddqq~~~~

    qqdd IjXRIV

    ~~~

    qda III~~~

    qd VVV~~~

    )~~~

    (notq

    Vjd

    VV

    Building Phasor equations of PM BLAC machine

    Ej de~~

    RId~qqIjX

    ~

    RIq~

    ddIjX~

    q

    qV~

    aV~

    dV~

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    48/51

    Phasor diagram for Salient PM with positive Id

    For Id>0, the stator produces MMF

    distribution around the airgap that

    augments the d-axis magnet flux

    The stator current is said to bemagnetising.

    The flux produced by the MMF

    associated with Id induces a voltage jXdIdin the q-axis, which adds to Eas shownin the phasor diagram.

    The d and q axis voltage magnitudes are:

    sind q q d V V I X I R

    cosq d d qV V E I X I R

    EjXRIjXRIV qqdd~

    )(~

    )(~~

    V: Supply Voltage phasor

    E: Back EMF phasor

    Load angle Current Angle Power Factor

    angle

    Phasor Diagram of salient PM machine +ve Id

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    49/51

    For Id

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    50/51

    Phasor Diagram of non-salient PM Machine

    EjXRIV a~

    )(~~

    Phasor diagram for Non-Salient (surface mount)

    PM with general Id

    EjXRIjXRIV qd~

    )(~

    )(~~

    qda III

    ~~~

    Since:

  • 7/29/2019 PMSM Drives 1

    51/51

    Phasor forms of Maximum Torque per Amp

    )(2sin2cos

    2

    qdm LLi

    ikT

    )(2sin

    2cos

    2

    qda

    a

    e

    XXI

    EIk

    T

    ded LX qeq LX meE

    aIi~

    a

    a

    TXI

    XIEE

    4

    8sin

    2221

    maxAnd it's easy to show that:

    EjXRIjXRIV qd~

    )(~

    )(~~

    Note that T and max are independent ofe


Recommended