ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings
of the
Shropshire Geological Society
No. 5 1986
Contents
1. Bassett, M.G.: Silurian to Scandinavian …………….…..………………………...………... 1
2. Pannett, D.: The geomorphology of the Stiperstones area …....…………..……….………... 4
3. Torrens, H.S.: The biology of ammonites ….……………………………………………...…. 7
4. Jenkinson, A.: Geology and conservation ………….……………………….………………… 9
5. Dolamore, L.: Field Meeting Report: Charnwood Forest, led by Anthony Evans 18th May 1985 11
6. Smith, D.M.: Shropshire Observed ……………………………………………….…...……… 18
7. Addison, K.: Arctic to Alpine Snowdonia ………………………………….………………… 19
Available on-line: http://www.shropshiregeology.org.uk/SGSpublications
Issued March 1986 Published by the Shropshire Geological Society
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 1─3 1 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Silurian to Scandinavian
Mike Bassett1
BASSETT, M.G. (1986). Silurian to Scandinavian. Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 1─3. The
account of a lecture describing the Anglo-Baltic area, which formed a single faunal regime in Silurian times. The
principles used in correlating Silurian rocks across that area are discussed in terms of the types of rocks and fossils
present.
1affiliation: National Museum of Wales, Cardiff
The lecture focussed on the Anglo-Baltic area
which formed a single faunal area in Silurian
times, extending from the Eastern Appalachians
through Britain to Scandinavia. The principles
used in correlating Silurian rocks across that area
were discussed in terms of the types of rocks and
fossils present.
Roderick Impey Murchison joined The
Geological Society in 1825 and became greatly
influenced by its President, William Buckland
(later to become Dean of Westminster), in the
importance of field work. In 1830 Murchison
decided with Sedgwick to map the rocks of Wales
and the Welsh Borderland, which were then
virtually unknown below the Mesozoic and
Palaeozoic cover. Murchison's task was to map
the Borderland to the Welsh Basin, and he saw his
first Silurian rocks in the spring of 1831 near
Llandeilo.
In the gorge of the River Wye alongside the
Brecon-Hereford road, Murchison saw "low
terraced shaped ridges of grey rock dipping
slightly to the south east, rising out conformably
from beneath the Old Red of Herefordshire." He
found these rocks "replete with Transition fossils
afterwards identified with those at Ludlow". He
realised that identifying those fossils was the key
to his mapping. By the end of the summer of
1831, Murchison had essentially solved the
problem of the correlation of the Transition rocks,
while Sedgwick laboured away in North Wales
for another 20 years.
By 1837 Murchison had mapped the
Cambrian, Ordovician, Silurian and some
Carboniferous and Devonian, of the whole of the
Welsh Borderland and South Wales and by 1839
he published "The Silurian System", which is still
the key on which all Silurian correlation is based
throughout the world.
Today the base of the Silurian is defined in
Scotland, the top near Prague, and the boundaries
in between are defined in Shropshire ─ the
Llandovery/Wenlock boundary in Hughley
Brook, the Wenlock/Ludlow boundary in Pitch
Coppice in the core of the Ludlow anticline, and
the Ludlow/Downtonian at Ludford Corner.
The best method of correlation involves the
use of different groups of fossils. Microfossils
such as acritarchs, chitinozoa, ostracods,
collodonts and dinoflagellates are increasingly
used, but the use of graptolites is more common.
Shelly fossils are also becoming more useful.
Murchison used assemblages of brachiopods and
trilobites.
It is now realised that assemblages of fossils
are controlled by both the environment and time.
Ziegler has conducted a classic study of
evolutionary sequences in what was thought to be
a single species of Eocoelia in the Llandovery.
This has demonstrated a progressive loss of ribs
through time, so now rather than identifying a
single species, there is a tool for finer subdivision.
Thus recognition of evolving lineages has
become an important principle of correlation.
Such changes take place despite changes in the
type of rock fossils are collected from. Therefore
the environment does not seem to affect
evolutionary change. What has to be done is to tie
the keys from shelly faunas against graptolite
zones and then erect a whole scale for the system,
based in part on the evolution of shelly fossils.
Wenlock Edge was visited by Murchison in
1831 when he erected the three-fold lithological
divisions of Llandovery, Wenlock Shale and
Wenlock Limestone. In the late 1960's it became
M.G. BASSETT
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 1−3 2 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
clear that there was international need for a more
refined correlation and a definitive description of
the type sequences of these rocks. The Geological
Society of London set up a Working Group to
investigate their potential. Subsequently a
borehole was sunk near Much Wenlock, at Hill
Farm, from the top of the Wenlock Shale into the
Llandovery purple shales. This passed into the
Lower Wenlock Shale where there are thick
bands of bentonite, blocky mudstone and shale
extending for 1000 m, then through Tickwood
Beds and into the 90 feet thickness of Wenlock
Limestone, which includes the massive reef
structures which Murchison called ballstones.
Until the early 1970's the rich shelly fossils of this
90 foot unit provided the faunas on which
correlations were based, because the Wenlock
Shale was apparently poorly fossiliferous.
The Working Group produced a new map on
which correlations could be based. This refined
Murchison's work by the use of modern
techniques and defined four subdivisions of the
Wenlock: the Buildwas, Coalbrookdale,
Tickwood and Much Wenlock Limestone
Formations. Through this work it became clear
that there was a great deal of potential for
correlation using graptolites and some shelly
faunas. Suddenly the type Wenlock fauna was
shown to be 90% graptolitic and not mainly
shelly.
It is possible to trace Silurian rocks from
Wenlock Edge along the Towey Anticline into
South Pembrokeshire. These are of Llandovery
age with shallow water sandstone facies having
quite different fossils from those in Shropshire.
The rocks there are well exposed but tipped
almost on end and in shallow folds. At the top of
the sequence there is an unconformity which was
missed by Murchison. This is identified by
reddened beds associated with uplift, emergence
and weathering, followed by a further marine
sequence. The question is: what time does the gap
represent? Above that sequence Hercynian
folding has produced cleavage in mudstones with
bentonite rich in shelly faunas including
Stricklandia. At the top the sequence goes from
marine rocks through fluvial rocks to red
sandstones. Murchison assumed this to be
Downtonian age Old Red Sandstone and therefore
the sequence would be below the Upper Ludlow.
The early 1970's re-survey and correlation
showed two species of Euceta missing at the
unconformity, which must thus be missing three
beds. Above that is a complete sequence of
marine rocks, through sandy fluvial beds to red
sandstone. In Pembrokeshire the junction between
fluvial and red sandstone is not the junction
between Ludlow and Downtonian, but the
junction between two parts of Upper Wenlock.
Therefore, in South Wales, the Old Red
Sandstone continental conditions were introduced
in Wenlock times and not Downtonian. Fossil
evidence shows that there is no trace of Ludlovian
in Pembrokeshire. This means that the Old Red
Sandstone event was not a single event, but
developed at different times. The red beds in
South Wales were derived from a landmass in the
Bristol area in late Wenlock times, whereas those
at Ludlow were derived from the north in late
Ludlow/early Downtonian times. It is therefore
clear that the ORS is a facies type and not an age
indicator.
This work helps to reconstruct events in earth
history by reference to palaeogeography. During
the early Wenlockian in the South Wales
borderland, across the Usk/Bristol Channel area
there was a great embayment of sandstone with
volcanoes in the Mendips. Limestone started to
spread across the south Welsh Borderland with a
mud-dominated area covering Wenlock Edge and
down into South Wales, and a graptolite basin
across central Wales with turbidites being pushed
along the Welsh trough into North Wales. By
Upper Wenlockian the embayment had gone and
a limestone platform built out westwards.
Wenlock Limestone began to develop one
graptolite zone earlier in the Dudley region,
taking one graptolite zone to reach Wenlock.
In 1844 and 1845 Murchison went to southern
Sweden, where he confirmed the presence of
Silurian rocks in the Oslo region. When he wrote
his paper on this he used the term Llandovery for
the first time ─ rocks of this age were previously
called Caradoc Sandstone. Murchison was able to
correlate the rocks in Oslo Fjord with those in the
Welsh Borderland using Eocelia and Stricklandia
pentameroides. Murchison saw a sequence of
reefs and equated them with Wenlock Limestone
reefs, but these are actually of Lower Wenlock
age showing that limestone development started
earlier in this region than in the Welsh
Borderland.
At the top of the Scandinavian sequence great
mats of algae are evidence of sabkhas such as are
SILURIAN TO SCANDINAVIAN
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 1−3 3 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
now found in the Persian Gulf. These are overlain
by red-beds confirming a shallow water
environment in a hot dry climate. Murchison
interpreted these red-beds as ORS of Downtonian
age, just as he had in Pembrokeshire and therefore
thought the sabkhas to be of Ludlow age. The red-
beds are fluviatile and similar to those in
Pembrokeshire. The sabkhas and red-beds are in
fact both within the Wenlockian, so ORS
conditions were introduced into Oslo prior to their
onset in the Welsh Borderland.
On Gotland, the rocks in the north are of
Llandovery age, those in the south of uppermost
Ludlow age. The Swedish geologists thought the
reverse was true, but Murchison proved them
wrong by examining the faunas. The paper he
wrote is still the basis of Gotland stratigraphy.
Murchison brought his fossil collection back with
him, which was a rare thing to do, justified by the
complete sequence of limestone occurring on
Gotland. The exposures are sequences of marine
platform limestone and marls rich in fossils, with
reefs in the Lower Wenlock. Underlying the reef
beds are very weak marls into which the reefs sag.
This has resulted in a line of circular structure
(called Phillip Structures after the archaeologist
who first saw them), below sea level and visible
from the air, indicating the former line of the reef
belt.
Higher in the Wenlock sequence sandstone
beds were swept over the limestone platform from
the rising Caledonian mountains to the west. In
the Middle Ludlow, reef conditions were
established once again. Stromatoporoids can be
observed in life position because of the
remarkable state of preservation in Gotland
exposures. At the top of the sequence red
sandstone beds developed in the Upper Ludlow.
The sandstone sags down into the mud in the
same way as the limestone reefs. At the top of the
island, late Ludlow age red-beds can be found
containing ostracods, which also occur just below
the Ludlow Bone Bed at Ludford.
It has now been proposed that this is not such a
simple stacked system. In places they are lateral
equivalents representing an evolving lineage of
ostracods. If the fossils zones are mapped out,
they run obliquely across the rock units so that
there is a complex facies variation migrating with
time, younging SE to NW.
Because of Murchison's work in Scandinavia,
Czar Nicholas I invited him to look at the rocks of
Estonia. Murchison subsequently went there in
1841, 1844 and 1845, mapping the whole area on
three short visits. He was assisted by a Prussian,
Kaiserling, and a French palaeontologist, Vernai.
Mrs. Murchison produced the drawings. In 1845
they published "The Geology of Russia in
Europe", a book which rivals "The Silurian
System" in its quality and content. It describes the
Silurian geology of the western Soviet Union and
again later investigations have proved Murchison
was right. The Czar insisted that Russian
geologists send Murchison fossils from other
parts of Russia and Murchison was therefore able
to identify Silurian rocks throughout that country.
In his book on Russian geology, Murchison
concluded "of Silurian fossils of Russia, a few
only are it is true, absolutely identical with forms
in the British Isles, but the mass of them is the
same as that of the mainland of Scandinavia,
which region being intermediate between England
and Russia, is found to contain a considerable
number of forms common to deposits occupying
the same position in both the other countries". He
had therefore established his chain of correlation
and all that has been done in the last 140 years has
been to refine his early pioneering work.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Based on notes by Joan Jones prepared during a lecture
given by Dr Mike Bassett to the Shropshire Geological
Society on 14th November 1984.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 4─6 4 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
The geomorphology of the Stiperstones area
David Pannett1
PANNETT, D. (1986). The geomorphology of the Stiperstones area. Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological
Society, 5, 4─6. The account of a lecture describing the geomorphology of the Stiperstones area within the South
Shropshire Hills.
1affiliation: Member of the Shropshire Geological Society
When looking at the shape of any ground, its
geomorphology cannot be divorced from the
general pattern of landscape evolution. Therefore
the South Shropshire Hills form part of the
general pattern which occurs across Britain as a
whole.
During the early Tertiary the landscape was
undergoing a great deal of change. Chalk had
been deposited over very wide areas and there
was exceptionally high sea level, the reason for
which is not clear. Consequently deep water
deposits were laid down over the chalk. 60
million years ago there was a return to normality
as that sea withdrew from this area, away from
large areas of chalk. During high sea level it is
thought that much of the chalk was planed off to
low level.
In the Miocene in Britain there were large
areas of dry land with a warm dry climate and
chemical weathering. At that time continental
drift brought Antarctica into the South Pole
region, introducing a cold period during which
geological reduction of sea level was exacerbated
by climatic reduction. As a result the landscape
was suffering from two events in the later Tertiary
and into the Quaternary: it was suffering incision
of valleys down to lower sea levels as well as
rapid erosion of valley systems due to the growth
of ice sheets. Because of the emphasis on valley
incision, many of the old land surfaces lie on the
crests of hills forming plateau surfaces.
Today there are both glaciated and non-
glaciated landscapes. In the glaciated areas there
are heavily glaciated uplands, but the remnants of
the old surfaces remain although deeply cut into
by valleys. The lowlands have been scoured by
glaciers and have had material dumped on them.
In non-glaciated areas there is valley incision
without the brutal influence of glaciation.
Remnants of the old tropical landscapes appear on
tops of such places as Dartmoor and The Downs,
where there is evidence of tropical weathering
disturbed by periglaciation.
During this period there was tilting in which
the west was rising and Cardigan Bay was
collapsing. This produced maximum erosion of
younger rocks in the west, but their preservation
in the east. In the mid Tertiary the landscape was
an African-type plain tilted west to east. This
tropical plain was subject to chemical weathering
arising from high temperature, heavy rainfall and
high evaporation rates. Igneous rocks in particular
are affected by this. On Dartmoor chemical
weathering of the granite took place through the
joints. During the Ice Age when periglacial
conditions prevailed, the resulting fine weathered
material was washed out through mechanical
freeze/thaw weathering, leaving only the 'bare
bones'.
Characteristic of Wales are plateaux at about
2000 feet, deeply dissected by valleys and isolated
uplands of hard rocks up to 3000 feet. In
Shropshire upland surfaces of the Longmynd are
up to 1500 feet. The Cotswolds stand at about
1000 feet and on the Chalk Downs, there are high
level surfaces at 600-700 feet. Because of
lowering sea level the weaker rocks have been
eroded out and the harder rocks stand out as lines
of hills.
The Shropshire Plain is a structural basin filled
with soft Permo-Triassic sandstone which had
been eroded from the underlying older and harder
rocks. The view from Caer Caradoc shows this
situation well with Precambrian, Longmyndian
and Uriconian overlooking weaker Cambrian
shales, Ordovician sandstone and Silurian
sandstone forming a succession of scarp systems,
which in turn overlook the Permo-Triassic basin.
STIPERSTONES
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 4−6 5 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
It is notable that some of the ramparts of Caer
Caradoc use rocks from elsewhere because that
on the summit was too rotten. Is this rotten state
the result of tropical chemical weathering?
The Stiperstones area comprises ribs of land
formed by strong rocks where the incision of
valleys has eaten out the weaker rocks, so it
conforms to the general national model. But some
questions arise, for example why are the crags
only on the summit and not along the whole
outcrop of the Stiperstones Quartzite? Why don't
the valleys conform to the norm ─ why, for
example, is Hope Valley so narrow? Essentially
the answers require us to look at the drainage
pattern and the relationships between Ordovician
and younger rocks.
The south and north of the area are in different
drainage systems. The northern system descends
very quickly to the Shropshire Plain and has dug
itself in very deeply. The southern system drains
to the head-waters of the River Teme and, since it
has a lower angle, it takes longer to reach the
Plain at Bishops Castle which is higher than the
Shropshire Plain, and so it is less deeply incised.
The northern drainage system has been more
aggressive in wearing back slopes and therefore
the landscape is not merely worn down, but also
worn back. In addition ice damming has caused
overflow of water across the watershed leading to
capture of streams across the watershed.
In this area the hill tops were not glaciated.
Normally it would be expected that in the Anglian
if not the late Devensian glaciation, the ice would
override the hills, but it went round them.
Consequently the outcrops of very strong rock
were subjected to severe periglacial conditions
and erosion of surrounding weaker material,
producing the tors on the Stiperstones ridge.
Glacial overflow channels caused water to flow at
higher levels than it would normally do. There
should therefore be old overflow channels from
previous glaciations which did not operate in later
glaciations.
Most of the changes that have taken place have
been on the valley slopes, while the tops are left
virtually unchanged. The south-facing slopes in
particular suffer greater erosion because of
increased freeze-thaw action. On the top, the tors
have been shattered by frost and boulders spread
out on the slopes. These have been loosely sorted
into stripes and polygons.
At Pontesbury the outcrops suggest that the
Upper Carboniferous was deposited on an eroded
landscape. Can we assume that all the erosion of
valleys and hills was done in the last 5 million
years or is something more ancient being
presented to us? Where strong and weak rocks
occur together, there may be old erosion surfaces,
once buried by surrounding weaker rocks, now
revealed again through erosion. This could be an
important feature when considering that when the
Shropshire Plain was laid down, the South
Shropshire Hills were being eroded so that their
lower slopes became buried by erosion material
from higher up.
The distribution of coal, which has been well
studied and analysed, shows coal swamps around
St. Georges Land, which included the Shropshire
Hills. Most Coal Measures were deposited north
of the Shropshire Hills and only the Upper Coal
Measures were deposited against an eroded
surface of the Shropshire Hills. So, as the
Stiperstones plunge underneath the Carboniferous
at Pontesbury, is this showing an exhumed sub-
Carboniferous surface? Are there rocks at Nills
Hill Quarry showing evidence of anything
washed down from overlying Carboniferous
rocks?
In Silurian times there was also a large land
area, but the deposition of the Llandovery is
irregular. After certain earth movements affecting
the Stiperstones, there was erosion and the next
rocks deposited were of Llandovery age. Many of
the Lower Silurian rocks in the eastern
Longmynd, east of the Stretton Hills and Wrekin,
show grits formed by erosion of underlying rocks,
which are recognisable in the pebbles. Studies
show that the Silurian covered an eroded
landscape is the Longmynd-Stiperstones area. As
these rocks erode back, is a sub-Silurian surface
being revealed? Is there, for example, an exhumed
Silurian sea cliff above Callow Hill Quarry? The
Silurian forms low ground around the
Stiperstones, but there are also patches in hollows
on the higher ground.
So the Stiperstones area is a very complex
landscape and the problem is sorting out what
forces are contributing to it. The closer one looks,
the more forces that can be found.
D. PANNETT
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 4−6 6 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Based on notes by Joan Jones prepared during a lecture
given, at very short notice, by David Pannett to the
Shropshire Geological Society on 16th January 1985.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 7─8 7 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
The biology of ammonites
Hugh Torrens1
TORRENS, H.S. (1986). The biology of ammonites. Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 7─8.
The account of a lecture describing the evolution and occurrence of ammonites.
1affiliation: Keele University
In 1796 William Smith discovered that strata
could be identified by the fossils they contained
and ammonites were one of the two groups for
which he produced a stratigraphic distribution.
Using the Cornbrash as an example, Smith in
1815 realised that the faunas of the Upper and
Lower Cornbrash were different. The
Macrocephalites zone, for example, can also be
traced in rocks in Bulgaria, Switzerland, Sicily
and Iran. We are therefore looking at rocks of the
same age and using a very sharp and accurate
tool, achieving a resolution equivalent to half a
million years or less 150 million year ago.
Ammonites are therefore twice as good as
trilobites in terms of accuracy.
Ammonites are often very common and
possess very thin shells. This helps in identifying
strata because the internal cast is just as good as
the whole shell. Ammonites also possess an
incredible range of morphological features,
producing an enormous diversity even at a
specific level. This indicates that the group must
have evolved very rapidly and characterised very
short time ranges. It is also clear that many
ammonites had a very wide geographical
distribution.
Trying to infer the mode of life of ammonites
is very difficult because of their distribution,
which arises from their free swimming life style,
resulting in only rare trace fossils. Also we are
dealing with a totally extinct species and modern
comparisons cannot be made. It is necessary
therefore to start from first principles and make
sure these are soundly founded and not based on a
misconception.
Such trace fossils that do exist tell us that the
shell was external and that the swimming attitude
was with the coils above and the aperture just
above the horizontal. To maintain this attitude, it
must have been floating using the internal septate
portion of the shell to divide gas chambers which
were regulated by the siphuncle. So how did
ammonites regulate their buoyancy? Some clues
are given by studying epifaunas. Ammonites have
been found with such things as serpulid worms
and oysters attached. Normally ammonites are
perfectly plainly spiral, with an iso-symmetrical
coil. With a hitch-hiker attached, the symmetry of
subsequent growth is disrupted in order that
buoyancy can be maintained and the centre of
gravity is in equilibrium with the centre of
balance. Serpulids have been found which have
been overgrown by the shell. Because serpulids
are extant, it is possible to calculate their rate of
growth and hence that of ammonites. This
suggests a life span of 6-7 years.
It would be wrong to assume that all
ammonites had the same ecology. Taking the
simple question of size, the largest found would
have been some ten feet across, that is a coiled
animal some 60 feet long and weighing 1½ tons.
At the opposite extreme, the smallest known has a
diameter of only 2.8 mm. Is it reasonable to
assume therefore that these two ammonites shared
the same ecology? There is a range of shapes such
as uncoiling types and others looking more like
gastropods. There was therefore an enormous
range of ecologies and special adaptations for
micro-ecologies. To this diversity must be
coupled the diversity of geological range over
which they operated, between 380 million and 80
million Ma. During this time ammonites were
brought to the edge of extinction several times ─ at
the end of the Permian, only one was carried
across. Again at the end of the Triassic, a period
with greatest diversity of ammonites, only one
line survived to create the diversity in the Jurassic
and Cretaceous. These were not sudden,
catastrophic ends, since the decline began way
back before the end of the period in question.
H.S. TORRENS
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 7−8 8 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Most text books mention that there are three
sub classes of cephalopods: belemnites with an
internal balanced shell, similar to squids;
nautiloids, an extent group which is becoming
better known, and live in deep water. They have
buoyancy chambers and are highly evolved with
well-developed brains, very effective eyesight and
the longest nerve fibres in the animal kingdom.
The third class is the ammonites which some
suggest belong to the same class as the nautiloids.
Because of similarities between Nautilus and
ammonites, a close look at the former is useful.
Much research is being directed to the former in
the hope that it will reveal clues to ammonite
biology. Nautilus has divisions into gas chambers
with a central siphuncle which controls the gas
pressure and therefore the attitude. The body
chamber is shorter than in ammonites. There are
two pairs of gills which are almost unique among
molluscs. Although the number of gills in
ammonites is almost unknowable, nevertheless
Richard Owen the vertebrate palaeontologist has
suggested that ammonites should be placed with
the other tetrabrachs because of other similarities.
A new classification has arisen in the last few
years by means of careful analysis of fossils for
the first time. This allows a lot to be said about the
soft anatomy of these fossils. Workers in
Germany developed the technique, looking first at
the ink sac, not found in Nautilus but present in
belemnites and octopods, and now in ammonites.
Another feature of ammonites as well as
gastropods, is that they have a jaw arrangement
which includes radulae. These are used to classify
gastropods at a high level. It was found that the
number of rows of denticles in the radulae of
ammonites places them with more biological
affinity with belemnites, squids and cuttlefish,
rather than Nautilus. The jaw of ammonites was
originally misidentified as an opercula device.
This was because only one part of the jaw usually
survives. The upper jaw is made of chitin and
does not fossilise easily. The lower jaw is
calcified and is therefore more likely to survive in
the fossil record.
Tentacles will not be found in the same way as
jaws for example, but other evidence can be used.
A paper written by a German researcher in the
1950's and forgotten until recently, remarks that
amongst trace fossils associated with ammonites
are eight marks which could only be caused by
tentacles extending out of the aperture.
Ammonites were therefore octopods. Nautilus on
the other hand has over 900 tentacles with groups
having specialized functions such as feeding, food
gathering and movement. Recent work has
resulted in successful x-ray photographs of
ammonites. These show a septate portion, body
portion and tentacles.
Because ammonites and cephalopods in
general are highly evolved, they show very well
developed sexual dimorphism. Nautiloid males
are broader than females. In living octopods, the
female is much longer than the male. Mature
ammonites also show the females to have been 4,
5 or 6 times larger than the male.
Recent research therefore suggests that
ammonites have more in common with other
cephalopods than Nautilus and that other research
on the biology of Nautilus will yield little of direct
relevance to the understanding of the biology of
ammonites.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Based on notes by Joan Jones prepared during a lecture
given by Dr Hugh Torrens to the Shropshire Geological
Society on 13th February 1985.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 9─10 9 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Geology and conservation
Andrew Jenkinson1
JENKINSON, A. (1986). Geology and conservation. Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 9─10.
The account of a lecture describing the development of geological conservation.
1affiliation: Member of the Shropshire Geological Society
The Shropshire Geological Society provides
advice and expertise to the Shropshire Trust for
Nature Conservation, who own a number of
geologically important sites.
Geological conservation hinges almost entirely
on site management. There are twin problems of
access and exposures. Geological conservation
conserves for academic and educational purposes
and does not therefore attract as much general
interest as is generated by some biological
problems.
The problems of conservation are particularly
acute in Shropshire for two main reasons. Firstly
because much of the early work, e.g. by
Murchison et al., produced sites from which
systems, periods, formations etc. are named and
are therefore internationally important. Secondly
the county has been good collecting ground for a
long time, so much so that now it requires hard
hunting to find perfect specimens.
The Shropshire landscape is not rocky. Natural
exposures thus tend to be rare and this leads to
'student erosion'. This is particularly noticeable at
vulnerable and important sites such as the Upper
Millichope stream section. Streams often provide
the only exposures of a rock type and banks can
be quickly undermined and stream courses
dammed.
Large numbers of exposures need conserving
for academic interest, especially the type localities
such as Soudley Quarry (Caradoc) and Comley
Quarry. In 1979 Comley Quarry, which is a
classic location for the lowest Cambrian fauna,
was almost completely filled in and had a "fossil
mine" at the top into the hillside under a farmer’s
field. This was a time of active research into the
Cambrian and its classification, which aroused
new interest in Comley, which had been
examined by Lapworth and Cobbold. The
Shropshire Trust for Nature Conservation bought
the quarry from Shropshire County Council,
excavated the lower levels, cleared the face and
filled in the dangerous 'mine'. This was a positive
move to conserve a classic locality.
Other sites then received similar treatment, all
of them fossiliferous and with restricted access,
e.g. the Onny Valley unconformity and the Hope
Bowdler unconformity. The latter was exposed by
new road works, and the opportunity was taken to
exploit this gift and substitute it for the only
previously known exposure, which was under a
nearby barn. The Society re-exposed the
surrounding Harnage Shales in early 1985.
Road works sometimes provide new
exposures, but the public and engineers have a
dislike for bare rocks, so often these are regraded
and grassed. More should be done to influence a
change in this policy, sufficient to allow time for
geologists to study what is there. This was done
successfully when the Craven Arms to Bishops
Castle road was realigned through Horderley
Sandstone.
The Hope Valley unconformity provided a
similar situation to Hope Bowdler. Here there are
Ordovician Hope Shales and Silurian Llandovery
Sandstone with fossiliferous beds overlying them.
These can now be collected from, have an
information board and are receiving an annual
clear up.
At Hope Rectory (Hope Shales) a poor
situation was improved through negotiation with
the owner, when some woodland was removed
from above the exposure. Taskers Quarry
(Stapeley Volcanics) was donated to the
Shropshire Trust for Nature Conservation by
Lady More and became their first geological
reserve. Here the problem of fly tipping requires a
regular clean-up and fence repairs.
In the west of Shropshire, mineral waste tips
create the same problem of access, trespass and
A. JENKINSON
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 9−10 10 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
danger as well as a public desire to clear them. It
is therefore difficult to make a case for their
preservation as witness the clearance of the Bog
Mine in 1984. Cottages at the Bog contained
stone blocks of Silurian Bog Quartzite, thought to
have been quarried nearby from a now
disappeared quarry. These blocks were very
fossiliferous and a number of them were
transferred to the adjoining Stiperstones Field
Study Centre when the cottages were demolished
─ another way to conserve important material!
It is of course possible to over-tidy. The West
Shropshire Lead mining area would lose much of
its character and an important link with the past if
wholesale clearance and landscaping were carried
out. But it must be remembered that the area
contains yet-to-be-located and dangerous shafts,
and easy access adits which are equally
dangerous. This is also the case at the Ogof
Copper Mine at Llanymynech.
At Lincoln Hill, Ironbridge, is a limestone
mining area not mentioned in the literature. Here
an unconformity between Silurian and Coal
Measures could be developed into a good
teaching area. Still in east Shropshire, there are a
number of working quarries and, although not a
great deal can be done to preserve exposures,
these could make very good teaching sites. Some
investigations were carried out by the Shropshire
Geological Society at Ercall Quarry, but working
is continuing there. The adjoining Maddocks Hill
Quarry is of considerable geological importance
including, as it does, mineralogically important
camptonite and the contact of sill-baked Shineton
Shales with Dictyonema.
On Wenlock Edge the situation has worsened
over recent years. The Wenlock Limestone is of
course a classic Salopian locality. It is highly
fossiliferous and contains such features as reef
formations. A very restrictive access policy is
now operated by the owners, and the working
methods have changed for the worse. Because of
structural slips (landslides), the faces are now
exposed for a short time only before being
buttressed up. As a result, superb teaching sites
are now lost.
Promoted by the work of the Ludlow Research
Group, which led to reclassification of beds in the
Ludlovian on palaeontological grounds, more
interest was focused on sites in the Ludlow
Anticline. Some sites had long running problems,
such as the Ludlow Bone Bed "slot" at Ludford,
where excavations led to highway problems. This
was a typical conservation problem where there is
a very restricted exposure of an important bed
which really requires massive excavation to solve
it. Also, around the same time, classic sites along
the Mortimer road section were opened by the
Forestry Commission in conjunction with the
Nature Conservancy Council, and a very
successful trail formed.
There is an obvious temptation for geology
teachers to take students to those sites where they
went as students or to follow well established
routes, irrespective of their educational value.
There is a current re-assessment of the
management of geological sites. This will decide
to whom they are of interest and will ensure they
are published appropriately. In that way it will be
possible to dissuade a coachload of junior school
children away from a site of higher academic
interest, when all they want is to collect a few
fossils.
A major problem in geological conservation is
to persuade non-geologists that sites are
important. There is a clear need for a distinct
educational role in order to change attitudes over
what others may regard simply as waste ground.
There is need for compromise over access and
safety especially where quarries and mines are
concerned. Although here the narrow view of the
Mines and Quarries Act steers some companies
towards inflexible access policies. Above all there
is a need to identify and publicise more alternative
teaching sites and thereby take pressure off the
more precious sites.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Based on notes by Joan Jones prepared during a lecture
given by Andrew Jenkinson to the Shropshire Geological
Society on 13th March 1985.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11─17 11 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Field Meeting Report: Charnwood Forest, led by Anthony Evans 18th
May 1985
Les Dolamore1
DOLAMORE, L. (1986). Field Meeting Report: Charnwood Forest, led by Anthony Evans 18th May 1985.
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11–17. The purpose of the field meeting was to visit key
exposures within the Precambrian inlier of Charnwood Forest, at Bradgate Park, Woodhouse Eaves and Beacon
Hill.
1affiliation: Member of the Shropshire Geological Society
The group assembled at the car park adjacent to
Hallgate Farm and the Cropston reservoir, by
Bradgate Park. The area to be visited lies within
Bradgate Park and is open to the public park.
However, no hammers are allowed. We arrived
at 10.30 am after a two hour car drive from
Shrewsbury. The weather was fine and warm and
the bluebells were out in the woods.
The stratigraphical succession in the
Charnwood Forest is shown in Tables 1 and 2.
Broadly speaking the Precambrian rocks of
Charnwood Forest form a plunging anticline,
much faulted, and obscured by the over-lying
mantle of Triassic rocks (Keuper Marl). As shown
on the maps (Figures 1 and 2), the oldest rocks
(Blackbrook Group) crop out in the centre of the
anticline, while the younger rocks appear on the
north-east, south-east and south-west, forming a
horseshoe distribution around the Blackbrook
Group.
The Brand Group consists of sedimentary
rocks. The rocks of the lower two groups are
wholly or partially composed of pyroclastic
material. The rocks of all three groups are usually
well bedded. Besides sedimentary and pyroclastic
rocks, there are intrusions of dacite (a type of
rhyolite, sometimes called "porphyroid"). These
are often strongly sheared and cleaved. Later
comparatively non-sheared intrusions of
granophyric diorite (markfieldite, formerly
referred to as syenite) are especially well
developed in the south-western part of the Forest.
In addition to the large anticlinal fold affecting
the Charnian rocks, there are a number of other
secondary structures. These include small folds, a
cleavage (very well developed in the finer grained
rocks) and jointing. The cleavage does not show a
close relationship to the major anticline, but
usually crosses the fold axis obliquely. In the
south-east, however, it strikes parallel to the fold
axis. The cleavage may therefore represent a later
phase of deformation than that during which the
fold was formed.
On entering Bradgate Park, the first outcrops
encountered – marked 'A' on the second map
(Figure 2) – are of banded pyroclastic rocks: tuffs
and lapilli-tuffs, with some intermixed
sedimentary material. Stratigraphically they are
near the top of the Hallgate Member of the
Bradgate Formation. These are in The Maplewell
Group and are low grade metamorphosed tuffs or
lithic greywackes. They are very fine grained,
probable subaqueous sediments, well jointed
some quartz veined but all intensively cleaved.
The exposure at 'B' is in two parts, the upper
showing well defined folding but the lower was a
mixture of a fine sediment and a conglomerate
which showed the filling in by coarse material of
a small channel, the pebbles of which showed
having been rotated by the pressures with their
long axes in the direction of cleavage.
The next exposure 'C' showed that the cleavage
running through the greywacke changed direction
slightly in places, this change is associated with
change in the grain size. Also in this exposure
other changes in cleavage direction are thought to
be due to folding after metamorphism which has
dragged the cleavage over in varying directions
combined with the well marked differential
cleavage.
A short walk brought us to an old quarry at site
'D', where the cleavage was less intensive and the
jointing blocky. The feature illustrated here was
plumose (feathery) markings on the joint faces,
showing tension breaks. We then walked on past
some buildings in the local stone, some converted
to public conveniences, past the door enclosures
to the ruins of Bradgate House.
L. DOLAMORE
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11−17 12 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
The house was built ca. 1490-1505 by Thomas
Grey, Marquis of Dorset and father of Lady Jane
Grey, who was born here. Bradgate House was
one of the first great country houses to be built of
brick. It did not suffer in the Civil War, but was
left to decay after 1739. The only part which has
been completely preserved is the chapel in which
occasional services are held.
To the south of the house, we crossed the
stream to examine exposure 'E' of the Stable Pit
Quartz Arenite. This is a medium-grained
indurated quartzite which weathers to a dark
purple colour. It is cut by many quartz veins and a
dyke of very much altered markfieldite. Cross
bedding can be seen in these exposures.
Slickensides in two directions showed that the
quartzite formed a small syncline. The outcrop is
possibly part of an exhumed Triassic landscape.
Close by the side of the ruined house we looked at
exposure 'F' which is part of a laccolithic intrusion
of markfieldite or a granophyric diorite of
andesite and hornblende with usually 10% quartz
and alkaline feldspar, all subjected to
hydrothermal alteration. This "markfieldite" is
identical to the intrusion at Nuneaton, thus
indicative of a Precambrian age. Recent
anomalies in the Rb-Sr dating have cast doubts on
the accuracy of the figures given.
We then had a long trek uphill to the War
Memorial area where the view is splendid in clear
weather, but the day was rather misty so bad luck
for us! We ate our lunch here as it gradually
clouded over.
After lunch we looked at exposure 'G' in the
Bradgate Formation, dipping steeply southwards.
The large exposure of the single bedding plane
contains examples of the fossil Charnia discus.
The frond-like structure found in 1952 is not
present here but the associated discs were present,
not too difficult to see and of varying sizes.
The next exposure 'H' by the side of the folly
"Old John", still in the Maplewell Group,
illustrates slumping in the sediment – quite small
in extent but the slightly coarser sediment, semi-
lithified, had broken into a breccia in a matrix of
finer sediment lying in the beds above and below
which had maintained coherence in the
disturbance.
Further exposures at 'I' showed up as very
coarse lumps of breccia in the dacite tuffs and the
whole was structureless. The lumps were often
long contorted irregular pieces, typical of
slumping.
The last exposure 'J' we looked at in Bradgate
Park was a small group of large rocks in the
Tuffaceous Pelites Member showing a structure
described as "pull apart" and "sedimentary
boudinage", thought to occur as the pyroclastic
sediment was subjected to down-slope tension
whilst still unlithified.
Woodhouse Eaves is a village shown on the
last map (Figure 3) and here we looked at two
sites. The first was a small quarry beneath the
church, probably slates were extracted from here.
These were interbedded with sub-greywackes –
there were no special features seen within this
Swithland Formation of the Brand Group.
We then walked out of the village, up
Windmill Hill, where the outcrop is an ignimbrite
in the Beacon Hill Formation. This rock appears
to be a devitrified pumice-tuff in which flattened
chloritized pumice fragments can be seen. It was
presumably deposited by a glowing avalanche
(nuée ardente) such as engulfed St. Pierre, in
Martinique, during the 1902 eruption of Mount
Pelée. No stratification is visible in the exposure.
The last site visited was the Type Locality for
the Beacon Hill Formation. This is the second
highest hill (818 feet) in Charnwood Forest. From
it we can see other parts of the Forest including
the highest point – Bardon Hill (912 feet) – Ives
Head (660 feet), the town of Loughborough, the
Castle Donnington Power Station, etc. On clear
days Boston "Stump" is visible from here.
At Beacon Hill we saw the main formation of
the Maplewell Group. The rocks are laminated
green or buff siliceous tuffs which weather white
or cream. They showed the well-cleaved nature of
the rocks, the "refraction" of the cleavage as it
traverses bands of differing grain size, the lines on
bedding surfaces due to the intersection of
cleavage and bedding. These lines are
approximately parallel to the fold-axis and are
therefore called b-lineations.
Most of the folding in Charnwood Forest is
concentric in type, (synonyms: flexural or buckle
folding). This is the type of fold produced by
buckling a pack of cards. Towards the end of the
phase of concentric folding the cleavage was
developed and minor cleavage folding then
occurred. This folding took place by shearing
along the cleavage planes. It has produced the
CHARNWOOD FOREST
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11−17 13 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
numerous puckers to be seen in many of the
exposures.
Disclaimer - The information contained in this account
has been prepared from notes taken during the field
meeting. Its sole aim is to provide a record of what was
seen and provide an insight into the diversity of
Precambrian geology exposed within Charnwood Forest.
It should not be used for any other purpose or construed
as permission or an invitation to visit the sites or
localities mentioned.
Table 1. Stratigraphical succession within Charnwood Forest.
Post-Glacial Alluvium
Glacial Boulder Clay
Trias
Sands and Gravels
Keuper Marls, Sandstones and Breccia
Carboniferous Basic dykes in Mountsorrel Granodiorite
Silurian
Limestone at Grace Dieu
Mountsorrel and Granodiorite and associated
Ordovician
hypabyssal and plutonic rocks
Microgranite dyke at Lubscloud
Rb-Sr date = 433 ±17 m.y.
Late Precambrian
Tremadocian sediments known just east of the
Thringstone Fault in the Merry Lees Colliery
and in boreholes in Leicester.
Possibly hornfelsed Cambrian in aureole of
Mountsorrel Grandiorite
Granophyric diorites of Bradgate, Groby, Markfield
Late Precambrian
Rb-Sr date = 552 ±58 m.y.
The Charnian Supergroup (formerly the
to (?) Cambrian Charnian System)
L. DOLAMORE
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11−17 14 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Table 2.
CHARNWOOD FOREST
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11−17 15 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Figure 1: Geological map of Charnwood Forest.
L. DOLAMORE
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11−17 16 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Figure 2: Geological map of Bradgate Park within Charnwood Forest.
CHARNWOOD FOREST
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 11−17 17 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Figure 3: Location map for Charnwood Forest.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 18 18 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Shropshire Observed
Diana M. Smith1
SMITH, D.M. (1986). Shropshire Observed. Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 18. An account
of the 150th anniversary of the founding of the Shropshire and North Wales Natural History and Antiquarian
Society. This was celebrated by a morning of talks and an afternoon of walks, organised to recreate the Victorian
spirit of enquiry in the environment.
1affiliation: Member of the Shropshire and North Wales Natural History and Antiquarian Society
On Sunday 14th July 1985 the 150
th anniversary of
the founding of the Shropshire and North Wales
Natural History and Antiquarian Society was
celebrated. A morning of talks and an afternoon
of walks was organised to recreate the Victorian
spirit of enquiry in the environment.
About seventy people attended the morning
talks where the early 19th century industrial,
scientific and social scene was set by Dr Barrie
Trinder of the Ironbridge Gorge Museums Trust.
The Society was established on 26th June 1835
and the first donation on that day was eight
specimens of minerals and fossils from Thomas
du Gard. A large collection was rapidly amassed
and the Society rented the building which is now
the Borough rates office in Dogpole as a museum.
In 1836 a Mr Gilbert was appointed curator and
given accommodation in the building.
Unfortunately Gilbert resigned within a year due
to the consternation caused by his wife joining
him in Shrewsbury. Gilbert emigrated to Australia
where he made a very important contribution to
natural history.
Between 1835 and 1845 several plans for a
new building were proposed but were never built
as sufficient funds were not available. The
museum remained a private one until the early
1880's when the Society formed a joint committee
with the Borough and a public museum opened in
the Old School in Castle Gates in 1885, one
hundred years ago. These early events in the
history of the Society were outlined by Dr Hugh
Torrens of Keele University.
James Lawson, librarian to Shrewsbury
School, went on to describe how the Society
developed from 1887 to 1985. The Society
changed its name several times and, in 1887, it
was known as the Shropshire Archaeological and
Natural History Society. Interest in natural history
was waning and being replaced by more
enthusiasm for archaeology. By the 1940's the
natural history responsibilities had been dropped
from the constitution and the Society is now
called the Shropshire Archaeological Society,
with James Lawson as the present chairman.
The final speaker was Bruce Bennison of
Rowley's House Museum, who summarised the
development of the museums in Shrewsbury.
From the first private one in Dogpole, to the joint
Society and Borough one in the Old School, and
now the Borough Museums including Rowley's
House and Clive House. He pointed out that
Gilbert, the first paid curator appointed in 1836,
was never replaced except by honorary curators.
The next paid curator was not appointed until the
1970's, a gap of about 130 years! Today there is
no natural historian on the staff despite the very
important botanical, zoological and geological
collections.
In the afternoon about 120 people joined the
organised walks based at Grinshill. Six leaders
took groups off to look at the geology and
quarrying, or the botany, local history, mining or
landscape of the area. It was a very enjoyable and
instructive afternoon which ended up with cream
scones at the Elephant and Castle in Grinshill.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Based on notes by Diana M Smith on Sunday 14th July
1985, the 150th anniversary of the founding of the Shropshire
and North Wales Natural History and Antiquarian Society.
The occasion was celebrated by a morning of talks and
an afternoon of walks, organised to recreate the Victorian
spirit of enquiry in the environment.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x
ISSN 1750-855X (Print)
ISSN 1750-8568 (Online)
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 19─20 19 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
Arctic and Alpine Snowdonia
Ken Addison1
ADDISON, K. (1986). Arctic and Alpine Snowdonia. Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5,
19─20. The account of a lecture describing the Late Quaternary evolution of Snowdonia.
1affiliation: St Peter’s College, Oxford, and Wolverhampton Polytechnic
The most familiar glaciers are the cirque glaciers
as found in the Alps today. These sometimes
coalesce and form valley glaciers and it was
generally believed that glaciers of this sort
excavated the principal features of the
Snowdonian mountains. But in the last Ice Age
the Snowdonian glaciers extended 80 miles to
Wolverhampton, an impossible feat for a valley
glacier. Only glaciers extending from large ice
fields as found in Alaska could travel such
distances.
Looking at accumulation and ablation of ice
(growth and decay), we find that in polar systems
the rate of accumulation is extremely slow,
perhaps 10 metres per sq metre per year. Alpine
glaciers accumulate at something like ten times
that rate. For glaciers to be in a steady state,
obviously the same amount of ice must melt each
year as is formed. An important characteristic of
this input/output of ice is that the storage element
of the glacier is massive ─ in polar ice in the order
of 10 cu km of ice; in alpine glaciers 102 cu km.
The most important characteristic is the
thermal system of the glacier. Polar ice sheets are
frozen to their base, at least in the central zone,
and are not able to move very quickly.
Correspondingly alpine glaciers do move quickly
because they are poly thermal. That is, they are at
pressure melting point throughout their depth and
therefore move easily over their base. Polar
glaciers therefore move by internal deformation
of ice crystals. Alpine glaciers slip along on a
water base. Polar systems are relatively stable;
some ice is known to have been there for 75,000
years. On the other hand, alpine ice has a life of
only about 100 years.
In Europe the last ice age, that is the cold
period of the last 100,000 years, is now known as
the Devensian. During the last ice maximum, a
consequence of the large Scandinavian ice sheet is
that the atmospheric circulation over Britain
would have been radically different from now.
The ice dome, by reflecting most of the incident
radiation, would refrigerate the atmosphere and
create a glacial anticyclone bringing very cold air
over Britain.
The last advance of the Devensian ice, some
18,000 years ago, did not quite reach Shrewsbury,
which was the focus of a pincer movement of
Irish Sea ice flowing through the Cheshire Gap
and Welsh ice coming due east. Sand and gravel
pits around Shrewsbury reveal English ice
deposits (sand, chert and other erratics), overlying
Welsh deposits 50 or 10 [sic. ? 100; Ed.] feet
down.
The Welsh ice cap was 1400 metres thick at its
centre between Bala and Snowdonia, comparable
to the present Greenland ice sheet. So Snowdonia
was not the centre of glaciation, but mountains on
the periphery. The valleys through them were
breached by ice on an enormous scale, as found
on the east coast of Greenland today.
Turning to land forms attributable to alpine
and arctic glaciers in Snowdonia. In the
Carneddau between Ogwen Falls and Conway,
most of the cirques are small and don't always cut
through to the plateau summits at about 3000 feet.
These cirques, although a common landform,
were relatively unimportant, being the smallest of
the glacial basins. They are also very susceptible
to climate change and can advance into valley
glaciers in a few decades, or disappear over a
similar period.
Seen from a distance, The Carneddau do not
show evidence of major glaciation, being
subdued, soft landscapes, but there are major
troughs excavated through the mountains with a
total depth over 2000 feet. Valley glaciers do not
do this. Again, a view from the Glyders shows a
mountain torn in two. In the valley floor are a
K. ADDISON
Proceedings of the Shropshire Geological Society, 5, 19−20 20 1986 Shropshire Geological Society
string of lakes as the watershed, a feature not
found in river dissected landscapes. The same
type of glaciated land forms is seen looking from
Snowdon to the Glyders.
Further island are the more subdued plateaux
between Snowdonia and Bala. Here there are
excavated troughs without any cirques around
them. This is similar to the ice centre regions in
Labrador and Scandinavia. So here is evidence of
the whole area being buried by a massive ice
sheet. Some of the best evidence of ice sheet
glaciation in Snowdonia is that it hardly exists!
That is, there are no strong land forms, but a
rather subdued ice abraded landscape. However
when the massive ice sheets melted, the massive
quantities of melt water left behind huge deposits
of delta material known as kames, such as at
Betws-y-Coed.
There is an anomaly between those areas of
Snowdonia where there is clear evidence of alpine
type glaciation and those areas subjected to ice
sheet glaciation. Around the central peak of
Snowdon are a number of radiating rock basins.
In the passes such as Nant Ffrancon, there is a
different pattern. There is no central mountain,
instead the entire flanks of the Nant Ffrancon are
incised by some 13 rock basins, some of which
have joined up. In the Carneddau region, if the
area above the assumed snow line is plotted, 3000
feet above sea level, only a relatively small
percentage of the mountain area is covered by
cirque basins.
A similar landscape in the Glyder range shows
that nearly half of the scene, above the snow line,
is decimated by a long chain of cirques. These do
not radiate out in all directions but are definitely
linear, facing north-east and exploiting the
fractures formed by the Caledonian Orogeny.
Therefore in Snowdonia, where major outlet
glaciers from the ice sheet erupted through the
mountains, cirque basins collected at a later stage
along the opened up flanks. Where the mountains
were protected by being more remote from these
outlets, they developed an alpine environment.
So what was the chronology of events? The
Ice Age began at the base of the Quaternary at 1.6
million years before present. 26,000 years ago the
last ice sheets began to develop in Western
Europe. At this time the lowlands around
Caernarvon for example were clothed in
coniferous northern forests. In the mountains,
semi-permanent snow bodies and small glaciers
were beginning to form. [The previous main
glaciation had been 100,000 years ago; in
between had been warmer periods and periods of
intensive, dry cold]. These cirque glaciers
coalesced quite quickly and sent down glaciers to
the valleys. This was a period of alpine glaciation
but, in a short period of time influenced by the
cold anticyclone, the main ice cap formed on the
land plateau and began to develop outlet glaciers.
At the ice maximum, about 18,000 years before
present, the summit of Snowdon would have
formed nunataks in the ice sheet.
As ice breached the mountains and moved into
the lowlands, a composite outlet glacier formed.
As the ice moved, about 13,000 years before
present, the cirque glaciers predominated once
again. For a brief period there was no ice in
Snowdonia, but the Loch Lomond re-advance re-
established the cirque glaciers. Even so, by 10,000
years before present the cirques were again ice
free.
The Idwal bogs inside the moraines in inner
Cwm Idwal filled just after the beginning of the
Neolithic period. The valley lake in Nant
Ffrancon filled 3000 years ago, coinciding with
The Bronze Age.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Based on notes by Joan Jones prepared during a lecture
given by Dr Ken Addison to the Shropshire Geological
Society on 13th November 1985.
Copyright Shropshire Geological Society © 1986.
ISSN 1750-855x