of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
1/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Mathcad Enabled Content Copyright 2011 Knovel Corp.
Building Thermal AnalysisAndreas Athienitis 2011 Parametric Technology Corp.Chapter 12 Analysis of radiant heating systems
12.2 Thermal Analysis of Ceiling Heating
Disclaimer
While Knovel and PTC have made every effort to ensure that the calculations, engineering solutions,diagrams and other information (collectively Solution) presented in this Mathcad worksheet aresound from the engineering standpoint and accurately represent the content of the book on which the
Solution is based, Knovel and PTC do not give any warranties or representations, express or implied,including with respect to fitness, intended purpose, use or merchantability and/or correctness oraccuracy of this Solution.
Array or ig in:
ORIGIN 0
This section presents a model for a space (one zone) heated with a ceiling heating system (gypsum
ceiling panels with embedded electric heating). It is assummed that the heat delivered by the systemis qaux.
The auxiliary heating qaux is proportional to the error between the setpoint Tsp and the actual roomair temperature T1:
qaux Kp Tsp T 1 Kp ...proportional control constant
The explicit finite difference method is employed to model the system and to determine the heatingload and the room temperature variation.
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 1 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
2/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
1. Weather inputs(a) Outside temperature.(b) Solar radiation.
Note that, since heating equipment should be sized based on extreme weather conditions, solarradiation may be excluded from this analysis. However, if a passive solar analysis is to be performed,the solar gains should be considered.
2. Bui ld ing data
NS =number of surfaces contributing to the zone energy balance.
NSe = " " exterior surfaces (walls and roof).
Ai =area of exterior surface i.
Nw: number of windows (=NSe normally) Awi: area of window i
Window type: U-value or thermal resistance, single or double glazing
and kL value (extinction coefficient x thickness)
Adoor: external door area Rdoor: external door R-value
Wall construction: Wall layer properties. For the interior layer, properties for transient analysis arerequired.
ach: infliltration - air changes per hourhi: inside combined surface heat transfer (film) coefficient for surface i
Internal gains:
Qintr: radiative internal gainsQintc: convective internal gains(optional inputs to be added as heat sources in finite difference model)
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 2 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
3/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Example:Consider a house which consists of a basement and a ground level floor. Here we consider theground level zone, heated with ceiling heating.
Hh 10 ft
Lh 50 ft
Wh 33 ft
Surfaces contributing to energy balance: NS 6
i , 1 2 NS 1-4 walls, 5-ceiling, 6-floor se 1 5 exterior surfaces
Nw 4 iw , 1 2 Nw (assume four windows -sum the windowareas on each house side)
Window and door areas:
Aw1
86 ft2 Aw2
43 ft2 Aw3
43 ft2 Aw4
43 ft2
Ad1
20 ft2 Ad2
20 ft2 Ad3
20 ft2 Ad4
20 ft2
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 3 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
4/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Wall net areas: A1
Lh Hh Aw1
Ad1
A2
Wh Hh Aw2
Ad2
A3
Lh Hh Aw3
Ad3
A4
Wh Hh Aw4
Ad4
A5
Wh Lh
A6
A5
Hi 8 ft ...internal height Vol A5
Hi
Door thermal resistance Rd 38.75 ft2
Fwatt
window resistance (double-glazed) Rw 6.588 ft2 F
watt
Film coefficients h1
0.428 wattft2 F
h2
h1
h3
h1
h4
h1
Hot ceiling, hot floor h5
0.361 watt
ft2 Fh
60.48
watt
ft2 F
ach=air changes /hour ach 0.5
Specific heat anddensity of air
cpair 0.239 Btu
lb Fair 0.075
lb
ft3
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 4 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
5/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Calculation of infiltration conductance:
Uinf ach Vol3600 sec
air cpair =Uinf 34.672 wattF
Thermal Resistance of Walls (includ ing air films):
Vertical Walls
1. gypsum board
L1
0.043 ft 1
50 lb
ft3thickness,density.
k1
0.027 watt
ft Fc
10.179
Btu
lb Fconductivityspec. heat
2. insulationRins 60.063 ft
2 F
watt
3. siding +sheathing
Rsid 7.169 ft2
F
watt
4. exterior film ho 1.135 watt
ft2 F
15% of area is framing ff 0.15 ...fraction of area which is framing
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 5 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
6/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
2 by 4 wood stud with R-value: Rf 14.919 ft
2 F
watt
R1
1
+1 ff
++++
L1
k1
Rins Rsid1
ho
1
h1
ff
++++
L1
k1
Rf Rsid1
ho
1
h1
=R1
57.553 F ft2
watt
Calculation of wall conductance excluding interior layerand film (to be used for admittance calculations):
u1
1
R1
L1
k1
1
h1
Assume that all exterior walls are of the same construction:
ii , 1 2 4
Lii
L1
Rii
R1
uii
u1
kii
k1
ii
1
cii
c1
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 6 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
7/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Calculation o f roof -ceiling thermal resistance:
Ceiling 1. gypsum boardwith imbedded electricresistance wires
L5
0.059 ft k5
k1
c5
c1
5
1
2. insulation Rinsc 116.25 ft2 F
watt
3. air-film (attic) ha 0.619 watt
ft2 F
Rc 1
+1 ff
+++
L5
k5
Rinsc1
ha
1
h5
ff
+++
L5
k5
Rf1
ha
1
h5
=Rc 71.939
F ft2
watt
Roof 1. exterior air film ho 1.032 watt
ft2 F
2. shingle backer board Rb 3.681 ft2
F
watt
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 7 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
8/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
3. wood shingles Rsh 3.294 ft2
F
watt
Rr 1
+1 ff
+++Rb Rsh1
ho
1
ha
ff
++++Rf Rb Rsh1
ho
1
ha
=Rr 10.521 ft2 F
watt
Assuming a 30 degree slope for the roof, we calculate the ceiling-roof combined resistance per unitceiling area (assuming no ventilation in the attic) as follows:
Ar
A5
cos 30 degR
5
+RcA
5
RrAr
A5
u5
1
R5
L5
k5
1
h5
...for admittancecalculation=R5
81.051 ft2 F
watt
Floor
1. Concrete blocks 5cmthick (over radiantpanels of low R)
L6
0.164 ft k6
0.288 watt
ft F
6137.342
lb
ft3
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 8 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
9/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
2. Insulation & plywood Rins 69.75 ft2
F
watt
c6
0.191 Btu
lb F
3. Air film (horizontalheat flow upward)
ho 0.48 watt
ft2 F
R6
+++Rins
L6
k6
1
ho
1
h6
u6
1
R6
L6
k6
1
h6
=R6
74.486 ft2 F
watt
Calculation of Wall AdmittancesThis is not required for ceiling heating, but admittances give us an idea about the dynamic thermalproperties of the space.
The self-admittance and the transfer admittance will be calculated for each wall, considering thethermal capacity of the room interior layer. Note that the steady-state value of the admittance is equal tothe wall conductance. We will calculate admittances to the interior surface and to the room airpoint.The analysis will be performed for the mean term and three harmonics of the weather inputs and heatsources.
Admittances:
Steady state admittance tointerior surface is equal to wallU-value (excluding interior film);first subscript indicatesfrequency, second subscriptindicates surface number.
Ys,0 i
Ai
Ri
1
hi
Yt,0 i
Ys,0 i
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 9 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
10/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
...admittances fromoutside to room air(steady state)
Y ,0 i
Ai
Ri
Yta ,0 i Y ,0 i
n , 1 2 3 j 1 ,n i
j
2 n
ki
i
ci
86400 sec
Uii
Ai
hi
Uoi
ho Ai...interior and exterior surfaceconductances
Uwiw
+
Awiw
Rw
Adiw
Rd...conductance of double-glazedwindows and doors;
Ys,n i
Ai
+ui
ki
,n i
tanh ,n i
Li
+
ui
ki
,n i
tanh ,n i
Li
1
Yt,n i
Ai
+
cosh ,n i
Li
ui
sinh ,n i
Li
ki
,n i
Y,n i
Ys ,n i Uii
+Ys,n i
Uii
Yta,n i
Yt,n i
Uii
+Ys,n i
Uii
Wall admittances fromoutside to inside air.
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 10 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
11/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Zone Admittance Yz (from room temperature node):
n , 0 1 3 Yzn
++Uinf iw
Uwiw
i
Y,n i
=||Yz
n||
135.598579.615830.420960.147
watt
FNote that Yz0 is simply the total U-value of the house.
The magnitude |Yz1| for a frequency of one cycle per
day gives us an indication of the daily dynamics of thespace; the higher its value the smaller the room dailytemperature swing.
Outside Temperature
The outside temperature for a day is modeled by a Fourier series based on NTo+1 values that are aninput to the array below. If more detail is required, NTo may be increased. Then, the the Fourier seriesmay be used to generate intermediate values as required by the time step of a finite difference model.
NTo 7 it , 0 1 NTo ...time index tit
it 3 hr ...time
n , 0 1 3 ...harmonics wn
2 n
24 hrj 1
To
10.4
0.43.26.8
12.219.417.615.8
F Tonn
it
To
it
exp j wn
tit
+NTo 1
...Fourier harmoniccoefficients
=Ton0
10.625 F mean daily temperature
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 11 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
12/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Solar Radiation (approximate model)
Solar radiation transmitted through the windows may be modelled by a half-sinusoid from sunrise tosunset time ts. For initial analysis of radiant heating, the solar radiation may be set to a low value(50 watts per sq.m. of window).
Redefine time array: it , 0 1 23 tit
it hr
Let ts 5 hr ...(time from solar noon to sunset)
Smax 4.645watt
ft2...peak solar radiation (at noon)(assume minimal level forcloudy day)
fit
Smax cos
tit
12 hr
2 ts
S
itif
,,>f
it0.0
watt
ft2f
it0.0
watt
ft2
S(t) may be modelled with a discrete Fourier series as follows:
Snn
it
S
it
exp j wn
tit
24
iw
Awiw
we multiply by total windowarea to determine total solarradiation.
We will assume that the fraction of this radiation absorbed by each interior surface is proportional toits area:
is , 1 2 6 Atot is
Ais
Qr,n i
Snn
Ai
Atot
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 12 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
13/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Finite Difference Model
The general form of the explicit finite difference formulation corresponding to node i and time interval p,is:
T ,i +p 1 +
t
Ci
+qi
j
T ,j p T ,i p
R ,i j
T ,i p
where C is capacitance, j represents all nodes connected to node i, and q is a heat source such asauxiliary heating or solar radiation.
Critical time step:
tcritical min
Ci
j
1
R,i j
for all nodes i.(the selected time step should belower to ensure numericalstability)
The thermal network is shown below.The floor is discretized into two layers (one thermal capacitanceand two resistances for each layer). The unheated surfaces are represented by node 6. S representssolar radiation transmitted into the room and absorbed by thesurfaces (a low value is assumed). Resistance R1o represents heat loss by infiltration and through thewindows, doors and vertical walls (their thermal capacity is considered negligible as compared to thefloor).
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 13 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
14/21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
15/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
R1o 1
+Uinf ii
++
Awii
Rw
Adii
Rd
Aii
Rii
...resistance of unheated surfaces(apart from floor) and infiltration
R12
1
A6 h6 h6r 4
watt
ft2 F...radiation heat transfer coefficientbetween floor and ceiling
R26 1
h6r A6
R56
L5
k5
A5
2...this represents the thermal resistanceof half of the ceiling panels
R161
A5
h5
R5o +R56
2
1
A5
u5
Stability Test to Select Time Step
The time step Dt should
be lower than theminimum of the threevalues in the vector TS
TS
C3
+1
R23
1
R34
C4
+1
Ro
1
R34
C5
+1
R56
1
R5o
tcritical min TS =tcritical 215.390 sec t 200 sec
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 15 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
16/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
The simulation will be performed for two days (periodic). Thus, weather data have to be generated for
NT times as follows:
NT 86400sec
t2 =NT 864 ...number of time steps for two days
p , 0 1 NT tp
p t ...times at which simulation is to beperformed.
n1 , 1 2 3
Top
+Ton0
2 n1
Re Tonn1
exp j wn1
tp
Ambient temperature
2
46
8
10
12
14
16
18
-2
0
20
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 450 5 50
Top F
tp hr
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 16 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
17/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Stp
+Sn0
2 n1
Re Snn1
exp j wn1
tp
Solar radiation (total in zone)
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
110
-100
0
1.110
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 450 5 50
Stp watt
tp hr
Tbp 60.8 F...basement temperature
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 17 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
18/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Initial conditions must first be assummed. Also, the size of the heating system qmax has to bedecided together with the proportional control constant Kp. A good estimate for qaux can be
determined by multiplying the zone conductance Yz0 with the maximum indoor - outdoor temperaturedifferential and increasing the result by 50%. Fo example:
qmax ||Yz
0||
30 C 1.5 =qmax 1.098 104 watt
Initial estimates of temperatures:
T,1 0
T,2 0
T,3 0
T,4 0
T,5 0
T,6 0
69.875.278.884.262.664.4
F
qaux0
0 watt Tsp 71.6 F ...setpoint can vary withtime of day if desired.
Kp 2780watt
F...proportional control constant( a good value is qmax/2)
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 18 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
19/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
qaux+p 1
T,1 +p 1
T,2 +p 1
T,3 +p 1
T,4 +p 1
T ,5 +p 1
T,6 +p 1
if ,,>Kp Tsp T ,1 p qmax qmax Kp Tsp T ,1 p
> Tsp T ,1 p
1.0 C
+++T ,2 p
R12
Top
R1o
T ,6 p
R160.7 St
p
++1
R12
1
R1o
1
R16
++
T,3 p
R23
T,6 p
R26
T,1 p
R12
++1
R23
1
R26
1
R12
+t
C3
+
T,4 p
T,3 p
R34
T,2 p
T,3 p
R23
T
,3 p
+
t
C4
+
Tbp
T,4 p
Ro
T,3 p
T,4 p
R34
T ,4 p
+t
C5
++
T,6 p
T,5 p
R56
Top
T,5 p
R5oqaux
p
T
,5 p
+++
T,2 p
R26
T,5 p
R56
T,1 p
R16
0.3 Stp
++1
R56
1
R26
1
R16
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 19 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
20/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Results for second day (first day is affected by assumed initial conditions):
Heating profile Temperatures
210
310
410
510
610
710
810
910
110
0
110
1.110
2 9 31.5 34 36.5 39 41.5 4 4 4 6.524 26.5 49
qauxp watt
tp hr
8.5
17
25.5
34
42.5
51
59.5
68
76.5
-8.5
0
85
29 31.5 34 36.5 39 41.5 44 46.524 26.5 49
T,1 p F
Top F
T,2 p F
T,5 p F
T,6 p F
tp hr
Note: T1 is room air temperature
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 20 of 21
7/30/2019 Radiant PTC CE BTA 12.2 Us Mp
21/21
PTC_CE_BTA_12.2_us_mp.mcdx
Heating energy consumption by
numerical integration for second day:v ,
NT
2+
NT
21 NT 1
Qh v
+++qauxv
||qaux
v||
qaux+v 1
||qaux
+v 1||
4 t
+v 1t
v
=Qh 5.633 105 Btu
A more accurate result may be obtained if another capacitance is added for the walls and the radiantexchanges are modelled more accurately (based on radiation view factors).
References
1. Athienitis, A.K., 1994, "Numerical model for a floor heating system", ASHRAE Transactions, Vol.100, Pt. 1, pp. 1024-1030 .
2. ASHRAE, 1997, Handbook-Fundamentals, Atlanta, GA.
User Notices
Equations and numeric solutions presented in this Mathcad worksheet are applicable to thespecific example, boundary condition or case presented in the book. Although a reasonable effortwas made to generalize these equations, changing variables such as loads, geometries andspans, materials and other input parameters beyond the intended range may make someequations no longer applicable. Modify the equations as appropriate if your parameters fall
outside of the intended range.For this Mathcad worksheet, the global variable defining the beginning index identifier for vectorsand arrays, ORIGIN, is set as specified in the beginning of the worksheet, to either 1 or 0. IfORIGIN is set to 1 and you copy any of the formulae from this worksheet into your own, you needto ensure that your worksheet is using the same ORIGIN.Engineering and construction code values shown in US Customary units are converted fromoriginal values in Metric units. They are NOT obtained from US codes unless specified.
Mathcad Enabled ContentCopyright 2011 Knovel Corp.All rights reserved.
Page 21 of 21