Republic of Uganda
Prepared for:
AIR WATER EARTH (AWE) LTD Environmental, Civil Engineers & Project Management Consultants
M1, Plot 27 Binayomba Road, Bugolobi P.O.Box 22428, Kampala, UGANDA. T: 041-4268466, Mob: 078-2580480/ 077-2496451 E: [email protected] W: www.awe-engineers.com
UGANDA NATIONAL ROADS AUTHORITY P. O. Box 28487, Kampala, Uganda. Plot 11, Yusuf Lule Road, Kampala
By:
RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) OF
PROPOSED UPGRADING KAMWENGE–
FORT PORTAL ROAD TO BITUMINOUS
STANDARDS.
(Updated Version, January 2011)
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Document Control
Client: Uganda National Roads Authority, UNRA
Project No: RA/104
Report Title:
Updated resettlement action plan (RAP)
Of proposed upgrading Kamwenge–Fort Portal Road
to bituminous standards
Date: 31 Jan 2011
Doc. No.: unra-kf-004
Revision Description Originator Reviewed
3 Final Report LK TP, FN, DO
Preparation of this report has been undertaken within
agreed terms of reference using all reasonable skill
and care. AWE accepts no responsibility or legal
liability arising from unauthorized use by third parties
of data or professional opinions herein contained.
Distribution
Official
Confidential
Public
Consultants
Eng. Lammeck KAJUBI: BScEng (1.1 Hons) MAK, MEngSc (UQ-Australia), NEMA-CEnvP, REng.
Team Leader
Herbert. M Kalibbala: MSc, Lic PhD (Sweden), NEMA-CEnvP
Civil Engineer
Pamella Tashobya, BA (Env Mgt), MSc (Norway), NEMA-CEnvP
Sociologist-Development Specialist
Dr. Florence Akiiki, PhD Sociologist David Oyen, BEnvEng & Mgt Environmental consultant
P a g e | i
Acronyms, Definitions & Units
Acronyms:
AIDS: Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome
CFR: Central Forest Reserves
CMP: Construction Management Plan
CRMP: Cultural resources management plan
DBST: Double bituminous surface treatment
DIA: Direct Impact Area
ESIA: Environmental & Social Impact Assessment
GoU: Government of Uganda
INDIA: Indirect Impact Area
KNP: Kibale National Park
LC: Local Council
M&E: Monitoring and Evaluation
MoWT: Ministry of Works & Transport
NGO: Non-governmental organization
PCR: Physical cultural resources
PEAP: Poverty Eradication Action Plan
NEMA: National Environmental Management Authority
NGO: Non-Governmental Organization
PAP: Project Affected Persons
RAP: Resettlement Action Plan
UNRA: Uganda National Roads Authority
UWA: Uganda Wildlife Authority
WB: World Bank
Measures:
m: Meter m2: Square meter km: Kilometer (= 1000 m) Ha: Hectare (= 10000 m2 or 2.471 acres) Currency:
UgShs: Uganda Shilling USD: United States Dollar Definitions:
Asset Inventory: A complete count and description of all property that will be acquired by the project. Carriageway: Area of road used by vehicles. It is bounded on either side by road shoulder.
P a g e | ii
Compensation: Payment in cash or in kind at replacement value for an asset or a resource affected by
the project at the time the assets need to be replaced. Displaced Persons: People or entities directly affected by a project through the loss of land and the
resulting loss of residences, other structures, businesses, or other assets. Economic Displacement: Loss of income or means of livelihood resulting from land acquisition or
obstructed access to resources (land, water or forest) caused by the construction or operation of the road.
Economic Rehabilitation: Economic Rehabilitation implies measures taken for income restoration or
economic recovery so that the affected population can improve or at least restore its previous standard of living.
Eligibility: The criteria for qualification to receive benefits under a resettlement program. Eminent Domain: The right of the state to acquire land, using its sovereign power, for public purpose.
National law establishes which public agencies have the prerogative to exercise eminent domain.
Grievance Procedures: The processes established under law, local regulations, or administrative
decision to enable property owners and other displaced persons to redress issues related to acquisition, compensation, or other aspects of resettlement.
Land Acquisition: The process of acquiring land under the legally mandated procedures of eminent
domain. Physical Displacement: Loss of shelter and assets resulting from land acquisition associated with the
project, requiring affected persons to move to other locations. Population Census: A count of the population that will be affected by land acquisition and related
impacts. When properly conducted, the population census provides information necessary for determining eligibility for compensation.
Project Cycle: The process of identifying, planning, approving, and implementing a Bank-supported
development activity. In the World Bank, the project cycle is divided into the following stages: Identification, Preparation, Appraisal, Negotiations, Approval, Loan Effectiveness, and Implementation.
Project-Affected Area: The area subject to a change in use as a result of construction and operation of
the road. Project-Affected Households (PAH): A PAH is a household that includes one or several project-
affected persons and usually comprises of a head of household, their spouses, children and other dependents (e.g., parents, grandchildren).
Project-Affected Person (PAP): Any person who, as a result of the implementation of the project,
loses the right to own, use, or otherwise benefit from a built structure, land (residential, agricultural, pasture or undeveloped/unused land), annual or perennial crops and trees, or any other fixed or moveable asset, either in full or in part, permanently or temporarily. Affected people might be displaced either physically (―Physically Displaced People‖) or economically (―Economically Displaced People‖).
Replacement Value: The rate of compensation for lost assets, that is, the market value of the assets
plus transaction costs (taxes, registration fees and cost associated with registration or
P a g e | iii
transfer of new land). The replacement value of an item must reflect the cost at the time it is due for replacement. For land and structures, ―replacement value‖ is defined as follows:
i) Agricultural land: the market value of land of equal productive use or potential
located in the vicinity of the affected land, plus the cost of preparation to levels
similar to or better than those of the affected land including fees of any
registration and transfer taxes;
ii) Land in urban areas: the market value of land of equal size and use, with similar or
improved public infrastructure facilities and services, preferably located in the
vicinity of the affected land, plus the cost of any registration and transfer taxes;
iii) Household and public structures: the cost of purchasing or building a new
structure, with an area and quality similar to or better than those of the affected
structure, or of repairing a partially affected structure, including labor,
contractors‘ fees and any registration and transfer taxes.
Resettlement Action Plan: A planning document describing measures to address direct social and
economic impacts associated with involuntary land acquisition for the project. Resettlement Assistance: Support provided to people who are going to be physically displaced by the
project. Assistance may include transportation and other services that are provided to affected people during relocation. Assistance may also include cash allowances to compensate affected people for inconveniences associated with resettlement and settle up expenses during transition to a new locale and lost workdays.
Resettlement Entitlements: Resettlement entitlements with respect to a particular eligibility category
are the sum total of compensation and other forms of assistance provided to displaced persons in the respective eligibility category.
Resettlement Strategy: The approaches used to assist people in their efforts to improve (or at least to
restore) their incomes, livelihoods, and standards of living in real terms after resettlement. The resettlement strategy typically consists of payment of compensation at replacement cost, transition support arrangements, relocation to new sites (if applicable), provision of alternative income-generating assets (if applicable), and assistance to help convert income-generating assets into income streams.
Road reserve: Area of land typically extending from the centre line of the road, owned by the road
and within which the roads authority has rights to extend the road and place associated infrastructure. This area can also be used for placing surface or subsurface utilities (water mains, electricity, telephone cables etc).
Stakeholders: A broad term that covers all parties affected by or interested in a project or a specific
issue—in other words, all parties who have a stake in the project. Primary stakeholders are those most directly affected—in resettlement situations, the population that loses property or income because of the project. Other people who have interest in the project such as the UNRA itself, beneficiaries of the project (e.g., road users), etc are termed secondary stakeholders.
Vulnerable Groups: People who may by virtue of gender, ethnicity, age, physical or mental disability,
economic disadvantage or social status get more adversely affected by resettlement than others; and who may have limited ability to claim or take advantage of resettlement assistance and related development benefits.
P a g e | iv
Contents
ACRONYMS, DEFINITIONS & UNITS ..................................................................................... I
LIST OF TABLES .......................................................................................................... VI
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................. VII
1 PROJECT AND RAP BACKGROUND .............................................................................. 1
1.2 OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE OF THE RAP ..................................................................... 2 1.3 METHODOLOGY USED TO UPDATE RAP ................................................................... 3 1.5 SURVEYING AND VALUATION METHODOLOGY ........................................................... 4
1.5.1 SURVEY METHODS ......................................................................................... 4 1.5.2 PROPERTY VALUATION METHODOLOGY ............................................................... 5
2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND ADJUSTMENTS TO MINIMIZE IMPACTS ..................................... 9
2.1 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT ............................................................................ 9 2.1.1 POPULATION OF AFFECTED PEOPLE AND LAND TAKE ............................................... 9
2.2 PROJECT AREA OF INFLUENCE ............................................................................. 9 2.3 ROAD DESIGN ................................................................................................ 13
2.3.1 DESIGN SPEED ........................................................................................... 13 2.3.2 PAVED SHOULDERS ...................................................................................... 13 2.3.3 CARRIAGEWAY ........................................................................................... 15 2.3.4 BUS BAYS ................................................................................................. 15 2.3.5 ROAD AND ROADSIDE DRAINAGE ...................................................................... 15 2.3.6 BRIDGES AND CULVERTS ............................................................................... 15
2.4 CONSTRUCTION & POST-CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES ................................................ 16 2.4.1 CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES ........................................................................... 16 2.4.2 ROAD CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS ................................................................... 17 2.4.3 GRAVEL SOURCES ....................................................................................... 17 2.4.4 AGGREGATE SOURCES .................................................................................. 17 2.4.5 SOURCES OF ROAD CONSTRUCTION WATER ........................................................ 18 2.4.6 WORKER CAMPS, MACHINE WORKSHOPS AND EQUIPMENT YARDS .............................. 18
2.5 PUBLIC UTILITIES AND COMMUNITY RESOURCES ALONG THE ROAD ............................... 19 2.6 PROJECT ALTERNATIVES .................................................................................. 20
2.6.1 ALTERNATIVE 01: RE-GRAVELLING WITH MURRAM ................................................ 20 2.6.2 ALTERNATIVE 02: UPGRADE TO DOUBLE BITUMINOUS SURFACE TREATMENT (DBST) STANDARD .......................................................................................................... 21 2.6.3 ALTERNATIVE 03: UPGRADE TO DBST STANDARD LEAVING KIBALE NATIONAL PARK SECTION AT CURRENT WIDTH AND INSTITUTE SPEED CONTROL FEATURES ........................................ 21 2.6.4 ALTERNATIVE 04: ―DO NOTHING‖ SCENARIO ....................................................... 21 2.6.5 ALTERNATIVE 05: TO REDUCE RESETTLEMENT IMPACTS ......................................... 21
3 POTENTIAL IMPACTS ............................................................................................ 22
3.1 CATEGORY AND IMPACT ON LAND AFFECTED BY THE PROJECT .................................... 22 3.2 IMPACT ON STRUCTURES .................................................................................. 22 3.3 IMPACT ON LIVELIHOODS .................................................................................. 22 3.4 IMPACT ON COMMUNITY FACILITIES ..................................................................... 22 3.5 PROJECT COMPONENTS RELATED TO RESETTLEMENT ............................................... 23
4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC BASELINE ...................................................................................... 24
4.1 PROJECT AFFECTED DISTRICTS .......................................................................... 24 4.2 SOCIAL ORGANIZATION .................................................................................... 24 4.3 SOURCES OF LIVELIHOOD IN PROJECT AREAS ......................................................... 25 4.4 WELFARE OF HOUSEHOLDS ............................................................................... 25
4.4.1 OWNERSHIP OF ASSETS ................................................................................... 25
P a g e | v
4.4.2 FUEL IN HOUSEHOLDS .................................................................................. 26 4.4.3 SOURCES OF DRINKING WATER ....................................................................... 26
4.5 VULNERABLE GROUPS ..................................................................................... 27 4.6 HIV/AIDS AWARENESS...................................................................................... 27 4.8 SOCIAL AND CULTURAL CHARACTERISTICS OF PROJECT AFFECTED COMMUNITIES ................... 27
4.8.1 ETHNICITY ................................................................................................ 27 4.8.2 EDUCATION............................................................................................... 28 4.8.3 CULTURAL CHARACTERISTICS ......................................................................... 28 4.8.4 SETTLEMENT PATTERN AND HOUSING OF THE PROJECT AFFECTED PERSONS ................ 28
5 LEGAL & INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK ...................................................................... 29
5.1 RELEVANT NATIONAL LAWS ............................................................................... 29 5.2 OTHER LAWS ................................................................................................ 30
5.2.1 THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT (1997) ............................................................... 30 5.2.2 LAND ACQUISITION ACT (1965) ....................................................................... 30 5.2.3 THE ACCESS TO ROADS ACT (1965) .................................................................. 31 5.2.4 THE ROADS ACT (1964) ................................................................................ 31 5.2.5 LAND TENURE REGIMES AND TRANSFER OF LAND ................................................. 32
5.3 VALUATION AND COMPENSATION OF ASSETS .......................................................... 33 5.4 WORLD BANK REQUIREMENTS ............................................................................ 34 5.5 INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES ....................................................................... 40
5.5.1 MINISTRY OF WORKS AND TRANSPORT .............................................................. 40 5.5.2 MINISTRY OF LANDS, HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT ..................................... 40 5.5.3 UGANDA NATIONAL ROADS AUTHORITY, UNRA .................................................... 40 5.5.4 DISTRICT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ...................................................................... 41 5.5.5 PRIVATE SECTOR ENTITIES ............................................................................ 41
6 COMPENSATION AND RESETTLEMENT STRATEGY ......................................................... 42
6.1 KEY PRINCIPLES ............................................................................................. 42 6.2 ELIGIBILITY FOR COMPENSATION ........................................................................ 42
6.2.1 ELIGIBILITY, CENSUS AND CUT-OFF DATE ........................................................... 42 6.2.2 SPECULATIVE STRUCTURES ............................................................................ 43
6.3 OVERVIEW OF ENTITLEMENTS ............................................................................ 43 6.3.1 CATEGORIES OF AFFECTED PEOPLE .................................................................. 43 6.3.2 COMPENSATION AND RESETTLEMENT MEASURES .................................................. 44 6.3.3 DESCRIPTION OF ENTITLEMENT MEASURES ......................................................... 45 6.3.4 PAYMENT OPTIONS ...................................................................................... 48
7 CONSULTATION WITH AFFECTED COMMUNITIES .......................................................... 52
8 GRIEVANCE MANAGEMENT AND REDRESS PROCEDURES ................................................. 53
8.1 GRIEVANCE PROCESS ....................................................................................... 53 8.2 GRIEVANCE MECHANISM ................................................................................... 53 8.3 SPECIFIC PROCESS FOR ADDRESSING VALUATION GRIEVANCES ..................................... 57
8.3.1 VALUATION ............................................................................................... 57 8.3.2 VALUATION GRIEVANCE DECISION MAKING PROCEDURES ........................................ 58
9 IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RAP ................................................................................ 59
9.1 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS ...................................................................... 59 9.1.1 RAP IMPLEMENTATION UNIT ........................................................................... 59
9.2 PAYMENT PROCEDURE ..................................................................................... 61 9.2.1 NOTIFICATION OF COMPENSATION ................................................................... 61 9.2.2 COMPENSATION UNDER THE DIFFERENT OPTIONS ................................................. 64 9.2.3 MUTATION OF COMPENSATED LAND ................................................................. 64 9.2.4 IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE .......................................................................... 65
9.3 RESETTLEMENT BUDGET .................................................................................. 65
P a g e | vi
10 MONITORING, EVALUATION AND COMPLETION AUDIT ................................................... 67
10.1 GENERAL OBJECTIVES AND APPROACH ................................................................. 67 10.1.1 INTERNAL MONITORING PROCESS ................................................................. 67 10.1.2 EXTERNAL EVALUATION PROCESS ................................................................. 68 10.1.3 COMPLETION AUDIT ................................................................................. 70
ANNEX 1. REVIEW COMMENTS ADDRESSED IN THIS UPDATED RAP ....................................... 72
ANNEX 2. LOCATION OF COMMUNITY RESOURCES ALONG THE ROAD ................................... 77
ANNEX 3. VULNERABLE PEOPLE IDENTIFIED ALONG THE ROAD .......................................... 80
ANNEX 4: PROJECT AFFECTED PEOPLE SURVEY FORM/ QUESTIONNAIRE .............................. 83
ANNEX 5: PROPERTY VALUATION LISTS (KAMWENGE & KABAROLE DISTRICTS) ....................... 90
ANNEX 6: LIST OF PAPS ...........................................................................................100
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE 6.1: ENTITLEMENT MATRIX ........................................................................................... 49 TABLE 7.1: STAKEHOLDER VIEWS ............................................................................................ 52 TABLE 9.1: LOCAL ADMINISTRATIVE ADVISORS TO THE IMPLEMENTATION UNIT .............................................. 59 TABLE 9: RESETTLEMENT BUDGET ........................................................................................... 66 TABLE 10.1: MONITORING INDICATORS DURING RESETTLEMENT (QUARTERLY BASIS) ......................................... 69
P a g e | vii
Executive Summary
01. With funding from the World Bank, Uganda National Roads Authority (UNRA) plans to upgrade 66.2 kilometer (km) Kamwenge- Fort Portal Road from gravel to bituminous standards. Currently, the existing road is dilapidated and not able to meet current demand for service provision.
02. The road to be upgraded to ―Class II bitumen road‖ is currently a gravel carriageway located in
Western Uganda from Fort Portal in Kabarole District to Kamwenge Town in Kamwenge District. A 13.3 km section of this road traverses Kibale National Park (see Map in Figure ES1). The upgraded road will have a 30 meter reserve in –rural sections and 20 meters in urban areas including trading centers. A shoulder width of 1.5 meters will be provided in rural areas and through Kibale National Park while a 2 meters paved shoulder is planned in urban areas. With a road reserve of 30 meters and total length of 66.2 km, estimated land covered by entire road is 2 km2 but this is mostly the same land area occupied by the existing gravel road. While the upgrade will for most sections follow the existing road alignment, road widening will in some cases affect private land, permanent and semi-permanent residential and commercial structures.
03. Total number of affected persons (PAPs) was determined from property surveys and census to be
1679 people in Kamwenge District and 851 in Kabarole District stemming from effect on land, commercial and residential buildings, all of which will be compensated according to measures proposed in the resettlement action plan (RAP). Total land take by road section through Kamwenge District is 108.7 Ha while section through Kabarole District would lead to land take equivalent to 60.75 Ha. To reduce social-economic impact, the design proposed to have a narrower 20-meter road reserve in densely inhabited areas (such as trading centers along the road). Compensation and resettlement of affected persons PAPs will be carried out in accordance with Ugandan laws and regulations and World Bank Group guidelines. Therefore, this RAP has been prepared to satisfy these two requirements.
ES.1: Summary of project impacts
KAMWENGE KABAROLE Total
Number of affected villages 31 21 52
Number of all PAPs 1679 851 2530
Structures/ assets
Permanent 88 25 113
Semi-permanent houses 62 25 87
Temporary houses (Sheds/grass thatched houses) 18 8 26
Kitchens 2 1 3
Pit latrines 0 0 0
Hedges with barbed wire 25 28 53
Hedges without barb wire 5 2 7
Barbed wire fences 2 1 3
PAPs with crops 900 600 1500
Land lost (Ha) 108.741 60.75 169.491
P a g e | viii
04. The proposed resettlement budget for RAP implementation and monitoring is UgShs 3,721,685,767 as detailed in table below.
ES.2: Summary of RAP budget District Value of
land (UgShs) A
Value of building (UgShs) B
Value of trees, crops (UgShs) C
15% Disturbance Allowance (UgShs) D =15%(A+B+C)
3% of crops value for livelihood restoration due to crop
loss (UgShs)1
E=3%(C)
6% of value of buildings for income restoration due to loss of businesses/ business
structures. 2
F=6%(B)
Total Compensation Award (UgShs)
1 KAMWENGE 629,635,849 804,177,278 276,122,50
0 256,490,344 8,283,675.00 48,250,636.68 2,022,960,283
2 KABAROLE 378,863,478 628,213,326 87,213,326 164,126,155 2,616,399.78 37,692,799.56 1,298,725,484
Subtotal 1 3,321,685,767
Other estimated costs
1 RAP implementation consultant
300,000,000
2 Monitoring & evaluation
100,000,000
3 Provisional sum for special assistance to vulnerable people
50,000,000
Subtotal 2 450,000,000
Grand total (subtotal 1 + subtotal 2) 3,771,685,767
05. This report is an update of an earlier RAP prepared by Consulting Engineering Services (India) Private Limited (CES) in association with KOM Consult LTD (Uganda) in September 2008.
06. Preparation of this updated RAP did not undertake new socio-economic surveys or census different
from ones undertaken by the earlier consultant. However data collected earlier was believed to be valid in this updated RAP for the reasons below:
The short time (less than 2 years) between earlier RAP and this updated version means that no
significant socio-economic changes occurred at both local and households levels. Verification sampling along the road did not encounter changes in PAPs (names or numbers in a
given sampled road stretch) or opportunistic developments targeting resettlement.
Sampling in communities along the road, effort was made to verify existence of PAPs compiled in property surveys and valuation records and, it was established they existed1.During implementation of the RAP, further verification will be made by the implementing agency and changes will be recorded and addressed.
07. Various laws of Uganda provide a framework for resettlement broadly consisting of four
components: (a) eligibility of PAPs for monetary compensation (applicable to legal asset owners); (b) compensation and resettlement assistance for PAPs; (c) grievance redress; and (d) responsibilities of central government and district-level departments and local administration authorities2.
1
Apart from a few misspelt names in the property survey/ valuation records, PAPs recorded existed or were known to live in sampled areas. 2 Chief Government Valuer (CGV) approves the assets valuation report while local council leaders (LCs) are expected to participate in witnessing
and resolution of resettlement grievances. Aggrieved persons resort to courts of law if all other avenues fail to address their disputes.
P a g e | ix
The road project will also trigger World Bank‘s OP 4.12 (Involuntary Resettlement) which provides for equitable compensation of affected people (regardless of legal status of their land tenure) with the aim that the project should not leave them worse off than they lived before.
08. This RAP will be implemented by UNRA in conjunction with respective district local governments
(Kamwenge and Kabarole Districts and village-level local councils) and key implementation
processes will include: (a) payment of compensation to affected people; (b) rehabilitation
assistance to vulnerable people identified in this RAP or by local leaders/RAP implementation unit;
(c) possible jobs as employees on the road rehabilitation project; (d) monitoring and evaluation.
09. After approval of census and valuation reports by the Chief Government Valuer (CGV), a RAP
implementation unit to be formed by UNRA will commence execution of resettlement activities.
The overall implementation responsibility will be with that of Uganda National Road Agency (UNRA)
through the Resident Engineer and appointed consultant.
The Chief Government Valuer (CGV) in the Valuation Division of the Ministry of Lands, Housing and
Urban Development (MLHUD) is responsible for approving the Valuation Roll (a separate detailed document of PAPs, their losses and entitlements). It is understood that valuation for this road was already approved by CGV. The Uganda Land Commission in collaboration with District Land Boards and Local Councils will scrutinize and authorize compensation payment, facilitate applications for acquisition of land and issuance of title deeds.
UNRA will ensure that PAPs have adequate time to replace their assets and will work with such affected persons to ensure they are able to achieve this before expiry of notice to vacate their affected properties. The RAP unit will have representative responsibilities for implementing resettlement requirements according to Uganda laws while UNRA will make available financial resources necessary to meet compensation and resettlement costs, as well as additional actions necessary to satisfy and World Bank guidelines. Details of government-mandated compensation and resettlement costs were provided in the Valuation Report prepared by the earlier consultant team (CES and KOM). Additional resettlement actions to meet World Bank Group (WBG) requirements are outlined in Section 5.4 (Gaps between WB and Ugandan legislation).
10 The cutoff date was the last date of property valuation, i.e. 31 Aug 2009 and this was found to be known by many potentially affected persons during ground-truthing visits undertaken during this RAP updating exercise.
11. The RAP implementation schedule is proposed over a period of 12 months during which monitoring
would be undertaken throughout the construction period and for extra two years after
construction. The RAP implementation unit and local committees would be formed shortly
afterward approval of valuation report by CGV‘s office. Compensation payments, rehabilitation
assistance and grievance redress is anticipated to start at about the same time and extend over 9
months including the 3 -months to vacate.
UNRA, with assistance of the RAP implementation consultant will set up field offices through which
grievances will be settled by a grievance committee to comprise UNRA, Local Council (LC)
chairperson, Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) and a District Land Officer. The Local Council
officials in their own capacity will be part of the registration and notification process and will
participate in resettlement implementation by representing the interests of the affected people.
The local council officials will be facilitated to participate in the entire process.
Monitoring will ensure that the RAP is implemented correctly, Uganda and WBG requirements are
met and all grievances satisfactorily addressed.
P a g e | xi
Figure ES.1: Location of proposed road from Fort Portal to Kamwenge
Existing gravel road (dotted route) to be upgraded.
Kibale National Park
P a g e | xii
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
12. In view of the inter-linking nature of both Ugandan and WB requirements, it is recommended
that UNRA co-ordinates closely with local (district and village-level) authorities in both
Kamwenge and Kabarole Districts to identify and verify vulnerable PAPs and provide
appropriate assistance where applicable1. Additional recommendations include (1) constituting
the RAP unit to include LCIII level local council leaders and already experienced officials from
District departments such as Department of Social Services, Community Development,
Production & Natural Resources who already know local communities/conditions adequately
well and experienced enough to give PAPs advice on skills enhancement where necessary,
during rehabilitation assistance.
13. Since road upgrade will largely follow existing alignment, direct impacts will be fairly benign and limited to the alignment area where road works will be undertaken and extensive displacement of people will not happen. Project benefits include increase in value of agricultural products due to improved access to markets, stimulation and development of roadside economic activities, increased social mobility and access to social services especially easier access to healthcare facilities.
14. Monitoring will aim to ensure that conditions of affected persons are not worse than were in
pre-project conditions. Key focus of monitoring will be to ensure effectiveness of RAP implementation and disbursement of compensation payments, effectiveness of grievance resolution, and success of livelihood restoration.
Monitoring will entail involvement of local government officials at district and sub-country or village level, For external monitoring, UNRA will identify and involve an independent NGO. It is noted that local government structures usually lack required knowledge and skills to support RAP implementation and monitoring, hence UNRA will support them with training, transport and other necessary financial facilitation.
RAP implementation consultant will submit to UNRA quarterly progress reports, which after review would be transmitted to World Bank.
At end of RAP implementation, a Completion Audit will be conducted to establish whether UNRA implemented all activities needed to ensure compliance with proposed resettlement commitments and applicable national and World Bank requirements.
1 It should be noted that vulnerability is not a static condition. For instance PAPs who were normal at the time valuation/ surveys might be
found vulnerable a year later at the time of effecting compensation payments. Others who were found terminally ill with AIDS and therefore
vulnerable during field surveys might have passed on but their heirs healthy and not vulnerable. This situation should therefore be handled on a case-by-case basis during RAP implementation.
P a g e | 1
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
1 PROJECT AND RAP BACKGROUND
The Government of the Republic of Uganda intends to seek funding from the World Bank
towards upgrading to paved (bitumen) standard of the 66.2 km Fort Portal– Kamwenge road.
Environmental impact assessment (ESIA), cadastral survey and Resettlement Action Plan (RAP)
were completed by Consulting Engineering Services (India) Private Limited (CES) in
association with KOM Consult LTD (Uganda) in September 2008 based on African Development
Bank (AfDB) guidelines. This update aimed to review the earlier RAP report and update
information therein so as to develop a resettlement guide that would enable successful
project implementation.
The road is currently a gravel carriageway located in Western Uganda from Fort Portal in
Kabarole District to Kamwenge Town in Kamwenge District. A 13.3 km section of this road
traverses Kibale National Park (see Map in Figure ES1). The upgraded road will have a 30
meter reserve and 20 meters in urban areas including trading centers. A shoulder width of 1.5
meters will be provided in rural areas and through Kibale National Park while a 2 meters
paved shoulder is planned in urban areas. With a road reserve of 30 meters and total length of
66.2 km, estimated land covered by entire road is 2 km2 but this is mostly the same land area
occupied by the existing gravel road. While the upgrade will for most sections follow the
existing road alignment, road widening will in some cases affect private land, permanent and
semi-permanent residential and commercial structures.
Total number of affected persons (PAPs) was determined from property surveys and census to
be 1679 people in Kamwenge District and 851 in Kabarole District stemming from effect on
commercial and residential buildings, all of which will be compensated according to measure
proposed in the resettlement action plan (RAP). Total land take by road section through
Kamwenge District is 108.7 Ha while section through Kabarole District would lead to land take
equivalent to 60.75 Ha. To reduce social-economic impact, the design proposed to have a
narrower 20-meter road reserve in densely inhabited areas (such as trading centers along the
road). Compensation and resettlement of affected persons PAPs will be carried out in
accordance with Ugandan laws and regulations and World Bank Group guidelines. Therefore,
this RAP has been prepared to satisfy these two requirements.
Currently, it is Uganda Government policy that all road development projects comply with
national as well as donor safeguard policies among whose requirements is a RAP. The goal of
this RAP is to minimize economic and social impacts that would arise from involuntary
resettlement resulting in:
relocation or loss of shelter,
loss of assets or inability to access to assets,
loss of income sources and livelihood,
P a g e | 2
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
1.2 OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE OF THE RAP
a) Objectives
In broader terms, the RAP has the following objectives:
To determine the extent of involuntary resettlement impacts associated with the land
acquisition for purposes of construction and alignment of the road, and put in place
measures to mitigate those impacts. The impacts here are to do with land acquisition
and the accompanying losses or interruption of livelihoods of the project affected
people due to the construction activities related to the proposed roads, etc.
To carry out consultations with relevant stakeholders, including potentially affected
persons, to obtain their views and suggestions regarding the social impacts of the
proposed project and measures to cover the losses. The outcome of the consultations
will be reflected in the RAP report and incorporated into the project design as
appropriate. The results of the consultations will be made available to all relevant
stakeholders, including potentially affected persons
The RAP will set the parameters and establish entitlements for project affected people (PAP),
the institutional framework, mechanisms for consultation and grievance resolution, the time
schedule and the budget, and propose a monitoring and evaluation system.
The agreed entitlements package in an entitlements matrix will include both compensation
and measures to restore the economic and social base for those affected. It will address the
requirements of the Government of Uganda and the World Bank Policy on Involuntary
Resettlement. Therefore the RAP shall follow the World Bank policy on Involuntary
Resettlement (OP 4.12) which requires that people who are adversely affected by project
activities receive compensation to the extent that their livelihoods and standard of living is
restored to at least a pre-project level.
Similarly, the resettlement shall be carried out in line with requirements of the legal, policy
and regulatory framework of Uganda. However where there are gaps the World Bank policy
overrides in order to ensure that the losses of the Project Affected Persons (PAPs) are well
addressed.
The specific goal of this revised RAP was to improve earlier RAP document, update
information therein so as to develop a resettlement guide that would enable successful
project implementation.
Cadastral surveys and property valuation that fed into the RAP were carried out covering that
portion of the road to be acquired as ―road reserve‖. The aim of the cadastral survey and
property valuation (completed in September 2008 by CES and KOM) was to:
Delineate private land and properties to be affected,
P a g e | 3
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Compile accurate list of project-affected persons (i.e. owners and land users having an
interest in the road reserve),
Establish monetary worth of all immoveable assets, including structures (permanent or
semi-permanent), perennial and annual crops and trees within the road reserve.
In earlier RAP report (CES & KOM, 2009)1, objectives of the resettlement action plan were
broadly indicated as ensuring compensation for lost property and restoring income earning
potential of people to sustain their livelihoods to match or supersede pre-project conditions.
b) Scope
To achieve the above stated objectives, the following tasks were carried out:
i) Identified persons or groups affected by the project either through destruction of
buildings or crops or loss of land and income,
ii) Identified options for resettlement and compensation of project affected persons
(PAPs), which according to the legal requirements of Uganda Legal Legislation and are
consistent with the relevant policies of UNRA and the African Development Bank,
iii) Raised awareness of the project and its consequences among the public in general and
those that are directly affected by it in particular,
iv) Ensured that all displaced persons receive compensation due to them and are not
disadvantaged by the project; and
v) Prepared a Resettlement and Land Acquisition Plan, setting out strategies and
schedules to mitigate adverse effects.
1.3 METHODOLOGY USED TO UPDATE RAP
The methodology adopted in preparing the original RAP version was consistent with the Government of Uganda policy framework. In updating this report, this was followed together with additional actions necessary to meet World Bank Involuntary Resettlement Policy OP 4.12. In addition, field ground-truthing visits were conducted on entries in the property valuation report and strip maps prepared in September 2008. Specific activities undertaken are provided below: a) Document Review
This involved reviewing original RAP for gaps that generated comments from earlier review. Other secondary datasets were reviewed to update district information. b) Groundtruthing visits
Reconnaissance surveys (valuation and strip maps) were conducted along the alignment to
screen out resources, facilities and services likely to be affected by the project. Analysis of
the field survey data consolidated recommendations for implementation of the resettlement.
1 Resettlement Action Plan for Upgrading Of Nyakahita-Ibanda-Kamwenge-Fort Portal Road CONTRACT No. GOU/HW/S003, by prepared for
UNRA by CES and KOM Consult, Sep 2009, pg13.
P a g e | 4
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Various places along the alignment were visited to provide understanding of the nature of
people to be relocated and community resources to be affected, economic activities and
means of livelihood that could be disrupted by the project.
c) Consultation meetings
Discussions were organized with various people and stakeholders along the road to verify
general perspective of stakeholders earlier documented in the 2009 RAP report. The people
consulted included Local Council (LC) officials, opinion leaders, NGOs and discussions
centered on current development potential to be affected by the resettlement process,
construction and post-construction stages, loss of land and other property. Also discussed
were gender specifics benefits, vulnerable people, income restoration and replacement cost
for lost property.
d) Survey interviews
Interviews and discussions were held with boda-boda1 cyclists, commuter omnibus and taxi
operators who operate at the Fort-Portal/ Kamwenge stage. Most transports were concerned
about the future of their operations in case new road design and hence redevelopment
removed existing bus stops. Discussions were held with along the road and key questions
received were about criteria for compensation of affected assets. Criteria as provided by
Uganda government was explained as well as additional resettlement requirements required
by World Bank such as income restoration and assistance to vulnerable people identified
during resettlement process. Women predicted possibility of domestic violence resulting from
compensation if men deny family fair access to resettlement payments and benefits or
squander it on multiple new marriages. Although solution to this is provided in the Land Act
where spouses must consent to and witness compensation due to the household, local leaders
were encouraged to take active role in grievances management to avoid domestic violence.
The first version of the RAP utilized methodology reproduced in section below.
1.5 SURVEYING AND VALUATION METHODOLOGY
1.5.1 Survey Methods a) Criteria of identifying PAPs The criteria for identifying project-affected people (PAP) was that everybody whose property (land, building, crops) is affected in part or whole by widening the road, would be eligible for compensation. These PAPs were identified by the cadastral surveying team and through follow-up surveys and were included in the census. Employees and tenants were to be established at the stage of disclosing individual household entitlements. Based on cadastral surveys a total 2530 PAPs would be affected by the Project. For households, this would mean losing land, crops or structures (permanent, semi-permanent structures, roadside informal trade wooden shacks, wooden restaurants, timber frame video/cinema halls, and drinking bars). Redeveloping the road will impact 113 structures.
1 In Uganda, boda-boda refers to private passenger commuter motorcycle riders.
P a g e | 5
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Prior to undertaking the detailed social survey, sensitization meetings were held in each village along the 66.2-km road to disclose and explain the forthcoming RAP study, explain the valuation process and how it is conducted according to Ugandan and donor (AfDB) guidelines. These meetings were conducted by social survey teams and a representative of the property valuation consultant. In the meetings, the project planning schedule was disclosed, cut-off for eligibility explained rights of PAPs and grievance procedures outlined. All meetings were chaired by either the village‘s Local Council (LC1) chairperson or LC 3 Council member (Councilor). These meetings aimed to create awareness about upcoming RAP, quell any apprehensions PAPs might have about resettlement hence enable them to provide true household and personal information during the social survey. 1.5.2 Property Valuation Methodology Property valuation, the results of which fed into the RAP, was executed by an independent
chartered surveying and valuation firm.
1.4.2.1 Topographical and cadastral surveys
Land of all people was surveyed and mapped indicating respective tenure systems. Customary
land tenants and registered proprietors were recorded and a strip map produced.
Survey beacons were placed at locations where the cadastral lines cross the road alignment.
This information is presented on a strip map of the road showing the position of the proposed
works on the existing cadastral maps. No land title deed mutations were signed as the
registered proprietors can only sign after compensation. Based on this, acreage of land
affected for both the registered plots and customary interest were calculated and a property
valuer determined the commensurate compensation values for each affected property.
1.4.2.2 Inspection, referencing and valuation
Cadastral surveys of affected properties including referencing of buildings and structures
were finalized in August 2009. Data collected covered registered land, bibanja holdings,
permanent- and semi-permanent structures, crops and economic trees.
This data was entered on the compensation assessment forms. Enumeration of crops and trees
and referencing of property was witnessed by property owners or their representatives and
area local council leaders (LCI officials). This ensured that all queries associated with
ownership, quantity of items and sizes of land are accurately documented. The land surveyors
provided acreage of affected land which was used by property valuers to establish
commensurate compensation conforming to Uganda Government laws.
1.4.2.3 Basis of valuation
The basis of valuation for compensation purposes is provided in the Constitution of Republic
of Uganda 1995 and the Land Act 1998. The value of land and buildings is based on the market
P a g e | 6
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
value i.e. the probable value the property will fetch when offered for sale. In arriving at
market values, the following assumptions were made:
That the owner is a willing seller,
That, prior to the date of valuation, there had been a reasonable period (having
regard to the nature of the property and the state of the market) for the proper
marketing of the interest, for the agreement of price and the completion of the sale,
That the state of the market, level of values and other circumstances were, on any
earlier assumed date of exchange of contracts, the same as on the date of valuation,
That no account is taken of any additional bid by a prospective purchaser with a
special interest,
That both parties to the transaction had acted knowledgeably, prudently and without
coercion.
1.4.2.4 Deriving compensation rates
a) Land
From transaction agreements viewed during surveys there was evidence available on sale of
physical property (land and buildings) and this information provided insight into purchase
prices prevailing in the project area at that time. Although some figures on purchase
agreements might not have reflected market values of the land, they provided the only
available evidence of market value of different interests. These values were analyzed and
adjusted before use because of the heterogeneity of land parcels to which they were applied
to determine the market value.
Affected land was categorized as semi-urban, rural or dry land and hence different rates
applied for each category. Valuation rates used for affected land were ―market values‖ based
on evidence obtained during properly inspection and surveys.
b) Buildings and Structures
Most project-affected residential and commercial buildings are constructed in permanent
materials such as burnt clay bricks and iron roof sheets. However, valuation also encountered
many semi-permanent and temporary structures built in very low-cost materials such as
timber. Buildings and structures were valued on the basis of Replacement Cost Method to
arrive at their market value. World Bank‘s OP 4.12 (Annex A, Endnote 1) stipulates that
depreciation of an asset and value derived from salvaging materials from razed structures
should not be discounted when deriving replacement cost. Additionally the policy (OP 4.12)
requires replacement value to include cost of materials transport to site, labour costs and any
transfer fees or taxes involved in replacing an asset.
For rented commercial properties, Investment Method1 of valuation was used and necessary
adjustments made to derive the final value. For PAPs losing businesses, production or rental
1 “Investment Method” was used for commercial (and residential) property that is producing future cash flows through letting or
renting. The method derives market value of a subject property by reference to observed recent transactions of similar properties
in the same area. Note that this method is really a comparison method, since the main variables are determined in the market.
P a g e | 7
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
income occasioned by loss of commercial structures, additional compensation of 6% was
allowed on top of value of affected building (see Table 9, Section 9.3). Semi-permanent and
temporary structures including pit-latrines were valued using District compensation rates. In
both cases, the design, standard of construction, fittings, finishes and general condition of
repair were taken into consideration in arriving at property values.
c) Crops
District compensation rates were applied to derive compensation values for crops, fruit trees,
flowers and shrubs owned by project-affected persons. According to Ugandan compensation
regulations, annual crops which could be harvested during the period of notice to vacate
given to land landowners/ occupiers are excluded in determining compensation values. The
valuation rates for crops takes into account the possible income generated from crops.
1.4.2.5 Valuation assumptions and limitations
The following assumptions and limitations were encountered during property valuation:
i) Bibanja owners on private Mailo land have legal ownership rights as provided for by
Ugandan law. An apportionment of land value of 60% and 40% share of the market
value was given to the landlord and bibanja owners respectively, depending on
developments invested on the affected land. For example, a kibanja owner who has a
permanent structure such as a house or perennial crops is entitled to a 60% share of
the compensation value while a person with only temporary structures or annual
(seasonal) crops is only entitled to 40%. This is generally adequate for replacement
value, and if a new kibanja ownership agreement was to be sought on a new piece of
land, it would cost the same 60/40 split applied depending on the temporal
permanency of developments thereof.
ii) Acreage of kibanja holdings provided by the land surveyors represents the actual
physical land taken from each kibanja owner.
iii) The acreage on "Private Mailo' titles are assumed to be the correct record as entered
in the Lands and Surveys Department Registry.
iv) The compensation assessed is for land and property as they existed at the time of
inspection and valuation. Subsequent developments and structural improvements after
cut-off date will not be considered for compensation purposes.
v) The property owners expect to be given a 3-month ―notice to vacate‖, hence a 30%
statutory disturbance allowance has been provided in property values.
vi) Buildings which only have portions damaged are assessed as wholly affected and
necessitating full compensation.
vii) Incomplete buildings and structures were been valued in their existing (―as is‖) state.
viii) Where private Mailo land owners could not be identified or verified due to lack of
records in Central Lands Registry, the valuer assessed value of the land taken against
the Plot Numbers on cadastral maps.
P a g e | 8
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Details of valuation assessment of every owner/claimants property are presented in a
separate Valuation Report.
P a g e | 9
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND ADJUSTMENTS TO MINIMIZE IMPACTS
2.1 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT
The proposed project will involve upgrading the existing 66.2 km gravel road from Kamwenge
to Fort Portal town to bituminous standard. The existing road traverses a rolling landscape
characterized by low lying hills typical of the terrain in Western Uganda. Aligned about 25 km
from either lakes Albert and George the existing road traverses Kibale National Park and
straddles districts of Kabarole and Kamwenge as shown in Figure 2.1a. The proposed project
road is categorized as a Class II bitumen road and will have a road reserve of 30m in rural
areas and 20 meter in urban areas including trading centers. The carriageway will be 6m wide
with shoulders of width 1.5 meters.
The project will:
i) Improve the road through enhanced drainage (new & bigger culverts) and pavement
strengthening,
ii) Expand and restore existing bridges,
iii) Construct speed humps and install road signs in protected areas and urban centers.
iv) Provide support for institutional strengthening,
v) Support the process of decentralizing health services delivery as well as reinforcing
healthcare services at district level.
2.1.1 Population of affected people and land take
a) Population of affected persons
Population of project-affected persons as was determined from property surveys and census
in each district traversed by the road is:
i) Kamwenge District: 1679 people.
ii) Kabarole District: 851 people.
This effect will stem from effect on land, commercial and residential buildings, all of which
will be compensated according to measures proposed in this resettlement action plan.
b) Land takes by the road project
Total land take by road sections through each district is:
i) Kamwenge District 108.7 Ha
ii) Kabarole District: 60.75 Ha.
2.2 PROJECT AREA OF INFLUENCE
The area of influence denotes the zone which will be most affected by the project. To
understand potential impacts and design appropriate mitigation measures, the area of
P a g e | 10
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
influence has been divided into the Direct Impact Area (DIA) and the Indirect Impact Area
(INDIA). In defining these impact zones, cognizance was accorded to spatial extent of planned
project activities, duration and intensity of proposed activities both during construction and
road use.
DIA is the area that will receive primary impacts resulting from project activities. The key DIA
areas include: road reserve, temporary camp sites at Bigodi trading centre, road diversions,
borrow pit areas proposed at 8 locations, stone quarry sites proposed at 2 locations and spoil
disposal sites like abandoned existing borrow pits in Bigodi and one after Kibale National Park.
INDIA refers to areas that will receive secondary impacts associated with project activities.
The spatial dimension of the INDIA will consist of sensitive ecosystems like wetlands traversed
by rivers and stream passing through the DIA, Kibale National Park, offsite sources of
materials for construction activities, stimulated demand for agricultural products among
others. Width of a corridor to be studied depends on legal requirements and the predicted
extent of the impacts identified during the project scoping. Corridor widths range from 100m
to 10km for green-field (or new) roads1.
1 Roads and the environment: A Handbook /edited by Christopher Hoban and Koji Tsunokawa. (World Bank technical paper No.
376) 1997. ISBN 0-8213-4031-X, pg5.
P a g e | 11
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Figure 2.1a: Location of proposed road across
Existing gravel road (dotted route) to be upgraded.
Kibale National Park
P a g e | 12
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Figure 2.1b: Location of proposed road project across Kamwenge and Kabarole Districts
Proposed road
P a g e | 13
2.3 ROAD DESIGN
In its present state, the existing road lacks design and safety attributes such as safe design
speed, pedestrian shoulders, culverts in good condition for adequate drainage, climbing lanes
and bus bays. Provision of these features in the new design will be the major difference
between the existing and proposed road.
Sections below describe aspects of the road‘s design, pointing out provisions that would
improve socio-environmental attributes of the project.
2.3.1 Design Speed
The proposed design speed for Kamwenge–Fort Portal road has been defined to fit within the
recommended standards for bituminous Class II roads though with modifications in built-up
areas and sharp curve areas. The main purpose of such modifications is to limit land
acquisition, cut and fill and acquisition of structures. Design speeds (km/hr) of various road
sections are outlined below:
Urban areas 50
Rural flat areas 90
Rural rolling areas 80
Rural Hilly sections 60
Kibale National Park 30-40
Due to lack of speed control provision (for example, humps) on the gravel road through the
forested section of Kibale National Park, the normal speed limit of 40 km/hr recommended by
Uganda Wildlife Authority is rarely complied with by motorists. Kibale National Park is a
forested conservation area with a considerable primate population.
2.3.2 Paved Shoulders
Full-strength paved shoulders are proposed for the entire road but their width will be
modified to suit local traffic conditions but still conforming to Road Design Manual. A shoulder
width of 1.5m will be provided in rural areas and through Kibale National Park while a 2.0m
paved shoulder is planned for urban areas. The smaller shoulder width through Kibale
National Park is meant to utilize existing adjoining clear strips of land devoid of trees hence
avoiding destruction of closed tree canopies used by primates to cross the road. This, as
advised by UWA and other stakeholders, will avoid roadkill1.
1 ―Roadkill‖ is an animal / animals that has/have been struck and killed by motor vehicles along a road.
P a g e | 14
Plate 2.1: Existing gravel road a typical trading centers (left) and a rural area
(top right)
P a g e | 15
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
2.3.3 Carriageway
The existing road will be widened to a 6-m two-lane carriageway. Climbing lanes were
provided in the design to ease traffic flow at locations with steep gradients. The maximum
road width will take into account road and roadside drainage features. As noted, the
existing road lacks climbing lanes, an important safety provision especially considering the
risk posed by old heavily laden trucks on these stretches.
2.3.4 Bus Bays
Bus bays enhance road passenger safety and convenience. Along the road, 18 bus bays
with passenger shelters have been provided in the new design
2.3.5 Road and Roadside Drainage
Roadside drainage channels have been designed to divert runoff from the road pavement
and to avoid ingress of stormwater into the road prism1. Drainage facilities will be
constructed proportionate to carriage specifications in rural sections and section through
Kibale National Park. In urban sections of the road, covered concrete drains will be used
to enhance road safety, aesthetics and reduce land severance. At many locations along
the existing road, the drainage infrastructure is either inexistent or dilapidated (broken-
down or clogged with silt).
2.3.6 Bridges and Culverts There exists a major bridge on Kamwenge–Fort Portal road at chainage Km 36.945. Investigation by the design team confirmed that the bridge is hydraulically adequate and will be retained with only surface improvements. At chainages 21+160 and 29+500, 3 or 5 culverts spaced at 20m distance will be replaced by a box culvert. Other major culverts at chainage 33+920 and 47+955 will be replaced and widened within limits of the carriageway. The locations of key bridges along the road are shown in Figure 2.4. These provisions will improve stormwater drainage, currently lacking on existing road.
1 Road prism is ground area containing the road surface, cut slope and fill slope.
P a g e | 16
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Source: AWE primary field data
Figure 2.4: Location of bridges/major culverts along existing road
2.4 CONSTRUCTION & POST-CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES
Road construction will entail procurement or quarrying of materials and their haulage
from sources to road sites. It ought to be noted that while the design engineer can identify
preliminary borrow or quarry sites for gravel and aggregate, final choice of material
sources rests with the road construction contractor who then would be responsible for
preparing project briefs for borrow sites and full ESIA for quarry sites chosen. Sections
below outline activities that will be undertaken during project development.
2.4.1 Construction Activities
Upgrading the road will entail improvement of the carriageway and associated drainage
and safety infrastructure along the existing alignment. Construction activities planned are:
Stripping away existing wearing gravel surface as per design specifications
Earthworks involving cut and fill operations
Excavation of gravel and soils from borrow areas
Rock blasting and crushing to obtain aggregate
Natural gravel/crushed rock base construction
P a g e | 17
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Bituminous construction
Stone pitching of drains in cut and urban areas
Gabion construction for erosion protection
Planting grass on side slopes/ embankments
Reshaping of borrow pits and decommissioning them
Construction of retaining walls where necessary on steel embankments
Installing road furniture including traffic signs, guard rails and road markings
2.4.2 Road Construction Materials
Materials to be required by the project are:
Gravel for filling will be obtained from borrow areas along the project road.
Crushed rock / aggregate: will be required for base and surface bituminous
courses and concrete works. The rock will be procured from identified quarries
where stones will be crushed to provide stone products.
Sand: for concrete works, 2 sand sources have been identified about 4km off the
project road.
Cement: The cement will be used mainly for concrete works and will be imported.
Steel: The steel will be required mainly for structural work and will be imported.
Bitumen: will be required for bituminous surface and will be imported.
Water: for construction and use in workers‘ camps.
2.4.3 Gravel Sources
While final choice of material source is a responsibility of the road construction
contractor, 8 possible locations of borrow sites were identified along the road by design
engineers. Location of borrow pits and quantities available are indicated in Table 2.1.
Table 2.1: Location of borrow pit and estimated yields
2.4.4 Aggregate Sources
Possible sources of aggregates were identified by design engineers at three locations
indicated in Table 2.2. Samples from these sites were tested for Aggregate Impact Value,
Aggregate Crushing value, Water absorption, bitumen Affinity/Stripping Value, Specific
gravity and soundness using sodium sulphate. All samples were found to be suitable for
road and concrete works. Operations at rock quarry sites will to be undertaken in
accordance with the National Environment Act, Cap 153 after approval of a separate ESIA
prepared by the contractor for each quarry site selected. Additionally, quarry ESIAs should
Location Chainage
Offset from road, km
Estimated yield, m3
Proposed use
0+275 0.5 40,000 Subgrade/subbase
7+839 0.0 10,000 Subgrade/subbase
12+672 0.0 20,000 Subgrade/subbase
20+101 0.4 35,000 Subgrade/subbase
27+614 0.4 51,000 Subgrade/subbase
53+868 0.9 30,000 Subgrade/subbase
56+390 3.0 175,000 Subgrade/subbase
56+390 4.0 600,000 Subgrade/subbase
P a g e | 18
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
recognize requirement of The Mining Act (Cap 148) limiting human settlement to a radius
of not less than 500 meters from active quarry sites.
Table 2.2: Location of possible stone quarries
Chainage Offset from road Estimated area (meters)
-10+300 10,000 200 x 200
8+480 20 100 x 150
32+800 200 100 x 150 Source: Design report
2.4.5 Sources of Road Construction Water
The project area is traversed by a number of rivers and streams including rivers Dura and
Mpanga. These, together with Nyabikere Crater Lake, are possible sources of water for
road construction activities and domestic use in contractors‘ or workers‘ camps.
Contractors shall be required to comply with The Water Act Cap 152 which requires them
to obtain permits for water abstraction during road construction.
2.4.6 Worker Camps, Machine Workshops and Equipment Yards A workers‘ camp, machine maintenance workshop and equipment yard have been
proposed near Bigodi Trading Centre at chainage 27+500 which is approximately midway
along the project length. The trading centre has reasonable infrastructure, commercial
and worship areas to offer acceptable living conditions to construction workers. Before
and during road construction, the contractor will provide facilities outlined below at the
workers‘ camp.
a) Facilities at workers camp
Bore hole: A bore hole will be drilled at the campsite to avoid stress on community
water sources.
Waste management facilities: The camp will have Ventilated Improved Pit (VIP)
latrines at a ratio of 1 stance per 5 employees.
The camp will generate about 0.1 kg of wastes per person per day leading to an estimated
quantity of 25 kg per day for a camp occupancy of 100-250 workers. Most local laborers
are expected to commute from home hence this waste estimate could be lower than
actual operational volumes. For onsite waste collection and temporary storage, bins will
be provided to ensure onsite segregation into recyclable and non-recyclable streams.
Hazardous waste including flammable liquids, explosives or corrosive materials will be
stored in labeled plastic drums at a secure area on the camp. Collection and disposal of
waste from the camp will be contracted to a NEMA-licensed contractor.
b) Maintenance workshop and equipment yard
A maintenance workshop and equipment park yard will be established adjacent to the
workers‘ camp. The site will be equipped with a temporary office block, maintenance
bays, parking yard and materials store.
P a g e | 19
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
2.5 PUBLIC UTILITIES AND COMMUNITY RESOURCES ALONG THE ROAD
There are no significant public utilities along Fort Portal-Kamwenge road that would be
disrupted by the proposed project. While road sections through both Fort Portal and
Kamwenge towns are adjoined by low-voltage 33 kV power lines, these do not exist
outside urban areas. A 33 kV line from near Fort Portal Hospital extends for only 3 km
from the town. Project attributes are summarized in Table 2.3.
Table 2.3: Summary of key project attributes
Project activity Project attributes
1 Duration of pre-construction, construction and design life of the road project
a. Pre-construction/ mobilization: 4 weeks. b. Construction: About 1.5 years c. Design life for the road: 20 years
2 Method of construction Major works are earthworks (cut & fill) and bitumen surface dressing
3 Nature and quantities of materials, goods and services needed during road construction and operation phase as well as their production processes.
Materials and quantities: a. Volume of gravel – 105333 m
3
b. Volume of aggregate – 135750 m3
c. Volume of bitumen – 635 m3
d. Volume of construction water – cannot be ascertained at this point e. Galvanized steel guard rails (Threi beam Type II, Class A, 2.82 mm
thick)– 3615 meters f. Road signs 1760 (warning 1200; regulatory 400; mandatory 100;
information 60) g. Retro-reflective road marking paint- 14501 m
3
h. High-yield stress steel bars (460A)- 998 tonnes
Processes: a. Gravel will be quarried from borrow sites. b. Aggregate will be obtained from stone quarries (involving rock
blasting and crushing). c. Bitumen to be imported. d. Water abstracted from surface water courses with permit from
Water Resources Management Directorate (WRMD). Earthworks volumes (m
3):
Excavations (Total cut : 795,871 m
3 as below):
a. Common excavation to spoil: 147610 b. Common excavation to embankment construction: 575051 c. Common excavation to spoil in swamps: 49280 d. Rock excavation: 23930 Total fill: 1,004,100 m
3
4 Additional services (electricity, emergency services etc)
Contractor will provide own generator for onsite electricity generation at workers camp.
Contractor to provide mobile health clinic for OHS or medical emergencies.
Camp water will be abstracted from onsite borehole.
5 Project‘s potential for accidents, hazards and emergencies (construction and operation)
The road in present form is such bad as to have low-speed traffic. Its improvement will lead to a very good carriageway encouraging high speeds and heightened accident risk (if signs or awareness campaigns are disregarded). Although speeds are expected to increase, there is evidence that overall, paving a gravel road reduces accident rates and fatalities.
P a g e | 20
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Project activity Project attributes
6 Estimated land take up by the road corridor
With a corridor of 30 meters and total length of 66.2 km, estimated land covered by entire road is 2 km
2 but this is mostly the same land
area occupied by the existing gravel road.
7 Estimated number of road construction workers and visitors both construction and operation.
Labour force: 250 workers Visitors : 101 per year as follows:
Employers: 3 No. Every month and 5 No. every quarter Funding Agency: 10 No. every 6 months Others e.g. politicians: 10 No. every quarter
9 Means of transporting construction workers and materials to site.
Workers will be ferried between camps and worksites by truck.
10 Material transport and expected number of haulage trips.
Materials will be hauled by truck. Over 7000 haulage trips are expected for 105,333 m
3 gravel using
trucks each of 15 m3 capacity.
With trucks of same capacity 9000 trips are expected for 135,750 m
3 of aggregate.
11 Estimate of types and quantities of solid waste, water demand and sewage/ sullage from workers camps (method of estimation indicated in brackets).
Solid waste: 25 kg /day (for 250 workers at 0.1 kg of waste per capital per day)
Water demand: 10000 liters/ day (for 250 workers at 40 L /person/day)
Sewage/ sullage: 8000 liters/ day (assuming 80% of water used turns to Sewage/ sullage)
Hazardous waste: Waste oil, unused bitumen/ waste asphalt, spilt fuel.
The effect of all mentioned wastes will be to contaminate local environmental resources (soil, air or watercourses).
12 Proposed waste management including disposal.
Sewage/ sullage: onsite disposal by use of ventilated improved pit latrines (VIP).
Camp waste: all waste sorted, organics buried onsite, plastic stored until collected for recycling, other waste that can be reused, reused and the rest collected by a NEMA-licensed waste contractor.
Source: Road design report
2.6 PROJECT ALTERNATIVES
As discussed in sections below, project alternatives analyzed aimed to reduce socio-
environmental impacts as well as long-term road life and associated maintenance costs.
2.6.1 Alternative 01: Re-gravelling with Murram
At USD 52,963,353 the cost for this alternative was lower compared to upgrading the road
to bituminous standards. However, this alternative is not economically sustainable in
terms of costs and the life of the re-graveled road. A re-graveled road cannot effectively
handle predicted 15% annual traffic volume growth for this region which has high
economic potential. Additionally, heavy rains characteristic of the region will necessitate
road re-gravelling every two (2) years to maintain it in modest motorable state. Re-
gravelling will thus demand a frequent maintenance regime and high demand for murram
(gravel) which, not only is scarce in the project area, but also whose acquisition poses risk
P a g e | 21
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
of environmental deterioration and landscape/ visual blight. The above environmental and
social-economic shortcomings rendered this option untenable.
2.6.2 Alternative 02: Upgrade to Double Bituminous Surface Treatment (DBST) Standard
At USD 69.23 million, this alternative is expensive compared to alternative 01 above but in
the long-term sustainable since major maintenance interventions on the paved road are
expected to begin over 12 years after upgrading. During the 12 years of road use,
environmental conditions affected during the upgrading would have recuperated.
Subsequent environmental impacts associated with maintenance activities will not be
significant as opposed to the re-gravelling option. This option has high public desirability.
2.6.3 Alternative 03: Upgrade to DBST Standard leaving Kibale National Park Section at Current width and Institute Speed Control Features
The current 13.3 km section through Kibale National Park is lined with mature tropical
forest trees whose canopy enables primates to cross the road above carriageway level
which maintains road kill to negligible levels. Widening the road along this section could
destroy the canopy with long-term effect to primates (roadkill).
A recommended option is to maintain the current road width within Kibale National Park
to avoid removal of trees in the mature section of the forest which is about 3-5 km long.
Introduction of speed humps at 0.5 km interval will reduce speed and road kill in the park.
It should be noted that speed humps could considerably increase baseline noise levels
along the forested section with vehicles decelerating and accelerating at speed humps.
2.6.4 Alternative 04: “Do Nothing” Scenario
This option will perpetuate poverty and impede development of the entire sub-region. The
current road attracts incremental costs in repairs as it is already past its project life. The
drainage system and carriageway have deteriorated in many parts. Frequent maintenance
and gravel quarrying poses financial and environmental strain. Due to the bad road, travel
times are unduly long and journeys cumbersome and uncomfortable.
2.6.5 Alternative 05: To reduce resettlement impacts
To reduce social-economic impact, the design proposed to have a narrower 20-meter road
reserve in densely inhabited areas (such as trading centers along the road).
ESIA study considered ―Alternative 03‖ above the most suited project option and is the
basis of this RAP.
P a g e | 22
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
3 POTENTIAL IMPACTS
This section presents PAP categories and inventory of property they lose based on records
in the valuation roll. Wherever applicable, project components and activities leading to
resettlement have been presented and specific sections of road where resettlement shall
occur. Alternatives and measures to minimize resettlement were discussed in the project
alternatives (Section 2.6). A summary of project impacts is presented in Table 3.1.
3.1 CATEGORY AND IMPACT ON LAND AFFECTED BY THE PROJECT
Land to be affected by widening and operation of the road is the road reserve which
measures 10 meters on either side of the road centerline in trading centers and populous
settlements or 15 meters from road centerline elsewhere.
A 13.3 km section of this road traverses Kibale National Park (see Figure 2.1) but UNRA
committed to restricting roadworks within existing road reserve and would not take
additional land or fell any trees in Kibale National Park.
Owners of affected land with perennial crops, timber trees and fruit trees (mango, jack fruit, guava, oranges, oil palm, etc) which are important sources of income for households, shade, timber, building/fencing poles, herbal medicines, etc and would be compensated basing on District property rates. Considering that they can be harvested within the six-month ―notice to quit‖ period, annual crops would not be compensated.
3.2 IMPACT ON STRUCTURES
Within the road reserve, 88 permanent structures along road section in Kamwenge District
will affected. In Kabarole District, the figure is lower at 25. However, none of the PAPs
losing structures will move from their local areas. It was established that 89 PAPs losing
permanent structures will rebuild a few meters back from their existing sites. Twenty
PAPs losing commercial buildings preferred money to invest in alternative income-
generating activities. The remaining four had other plots of land available for construction
of new buildings. Therefore this RAP will not have a component for relocation of PAPs.
3.3 IMPACT ON LIVELIHOODS
Economically-displaced people are people whose livelihoods are affected by the proposed road project and associated land acquisition. This only applies to those whose business are required to be relocated, but also to those employed in a business, or those who lose livelihood (income or subsistence) due to loss of crops. Because buildings in both rural and urban sections of the road are built away from the carriageway, no significant economic displacement is envisaged. Several commercial structures housing income-generating businesses will be affected. According to the valuation report, 46 and 16 structures will be affected in Kamwenge and Kabarole respectively (Table 3.1).
3.4 IMPACT ON COMMUNITY FACILITIES
As indicated in property valuation report, several churches, schools and health centres will
lose strips of land to the road reserve. Many community resources would not lose land to
he project but road redevelopment could cause temporary disruption to their access such
as when overburden is dumped into junctions leading to these faculties such as to render
P a g e | 23
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
them impossible to access by women, children elderly or disabled people. Location of
community facilities (schools, healthcentres, places of worship and water sources) is
shown in Annex 2. A water bowzer from a crater lake at Nyabikere in Kabarole district will
be affected and this, the contractor should replace.
A thematic summary of project impacts is presented in Table below.
Table 3.1: Affected households and type of assets to be damaged
KAMWENGE KABAROLE TOTAL
Number of villages affected 31 21 52
Number of all claimants 1679 851 2530
Structures
Permanent structures
Residential 42 9 51
Commercial 46 16 62
(Subtotal) 88 25 113
Tenants (households) in affected structures 26 11 37
Number who have leases on buildings 0 0 0
Number of in habitants (households) in towns who will lose houses
22 8 30
Other structures
Semi-permanent houses 62 25 87
Temporary houses (Sheds/grass thatched) 18 8 26
Kitchens 2 1 3
Pit latrines 0 0 0
Hedges with barb wire 25 28 53
Hedges without barb wire 5 2 7
Barb wire fences 2 1 3
(Subtotal ) 292 90 382
Affected industries 0 0 0
PAPs losing land with structures 88 25 113
PAPs losing crops 900 600 1500 Source: Valuation report and strip maps by CES and KOM 2009.
3.5 PROJECT COMPONENTS RELATED TO RESETTLEMENT
During preparation of this RAP consideration was given to project components/ activities
that would give rise to resettlement. This mainly included sections of the road where
resettlement would be undertaken and alternatives and mechanisms to avoid or minimize
resettlement were also considered. Considering that the road will follow existing
alignment, trading centers/ townships were identified as areas that would require larger
resettlement than road sections through rural areas. It was noted that construction in new
upcoming trading centers did not conform to building lines from existing road. Therefore
to minimize large-scale resettlement, the design provided for a 30 meter reserve in –rural
sections and 20 meters in urban areas.
P a g e | 24
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC BASELINE
The socio-economic study was confined to the road environment. The aims were to
suggest ways and means to complete the economic rehabilitation of PAPs along the roads
so that they would recover a living standard at least equal to or better than the one they
enjoyed previously and in any case raise their living standards above the poverty line.
The Consultant used earlier data available at UNRA, UBOS and at Kabarole and Kamwenge
district headquarters. The data reviewed was mainly on social-economic characteristics of
population in the project area.
Due to the short time period available for this RAP review, no new household census and socio-economic survey were conducted different from ones in earlier RAP. Generally, data collected earlier was believed to be valid in this updated RAP for the reasons below:
The short time (less than 2 years) between earlier RAP and this updated version means that no significant socio-economic changes occurred at both local and households levels.
Verification sampling along the road did not encounter changes in PAPs (names or numbers in a given sampled road stretch) or opportunistic developments targeting resettlement.
4.1 PROJECT AFFECTED DISTRICTS
The existing road is found in two districts of Kamwenge ad Kabarole, in south-western
Uganda. The 2010 projected population of Kamwenge district is 380,000 with a population
density of 167 persons/ sq.km1. The population comprised of indigenous Batooro,
Banyankole and migrant tribes such as Bakiga, Baganda, Bafumbira and Bahororo. Other
migrants are from surrounding countries of Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania, Kenya and
Democratic Republic of Congo. Estimated population of Kabarole District in 2010 is
455,0002. People living in the area are the same as those in Kamwenge district which was
part of Kabarole before it was given district status. These two districts are renowned for
plantain agriculture, mainly tea estates.
4.2 SOCIAL ORGANIZATION
The project area districts belong to the south western region of Uganda which is among
the better-off regions in Uganda as the economy in the region is not affected by acute
poverty. The four districts have attained remarkable improvements in poverty reduction
and human development indicators compared to the northern and eastern regions of the
country.
Despite some regional and localized differences, poverty in the districts is generally
associated with low incomes at household level, food insecurity, high levels of illiteracy
and low levels of employment. The major causes of poverty being inadequate skills, land
shortage, poor farming methods, gender inequalities, low productivity, morbidity due to
Malaria, HIV/AIDS and climate change
1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamwenge_District
2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kabarole_District
P a g e | 25
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
The nuclear family and to some extent, the clan constitutes significant traditional social
support system for their members especially in times of difficulties. Beyond the family and
the clan, there is currently a socio-political system of organization the LC system that was
introduced in 1986. It starts from the village level up to the District level. The LCs play
important roles in community matters for the development of community infrastructure
such as communal access roads, water sources and in provision of other basis needs of
community wellbeing e.g. the living environment, housing, sanitation, access to public
services and in settlement of disputes.
4.3 SOURCES OF LIVELIHOOD IN PROJECT AREAS
Subsistence farming is the principal source of livelihood in both project districts. Kabarole
district has about 28.1% of households dependent on earned income while Kamwenge has
lower opportunities for earned income. In addition to the agricultural activities there are
other economic activities which are presented in table below.
Table 4.1: Sources of Livelihood in the Districts, 2002-03
Source Kamwenge Kabarole
Subsistence farming 86.03 61.30
Employment Income 4.43 20.29
Business Enterprise 3.18 7.63
Cottage Industry 0.06 0.21
Property Income 0.58 1.11
Family support 3.71 7.73
Organizational support 0.61 0.00
Other 1.40 1.72
Total 100.00 100.00 Source: Uganda Population and Housing Census, 2002
Kamwenge district has high potential of Gold, Lead, Silver, Copper, Base metals,
Columbite, Tantalum, Zinc and Gemstone. There are also large deposits of limestone and
gypsum. Except certain traditional mining of base metals there is no exploitation of
minerals.
4.4 WELFARE OF HOUSEHOLDS
Welfare status of the households in the project districts is presented through selected
parameters of owning assets, usage of fuel for cooking and lights, access to safe drinking
water and uses of basic minimum consumer needs.
4.4.1 Ownership of assets
Ownership of minimum household assets in both districts is presented in Table 4.2. About
one third of the households own bicycles and half of the households owning radios. Owning
television and phones is remarkably low. It is expected that phone ownership in 2010 is far
higher than reported in 2002 statistics.
P a g e | 26
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
Table 4.2: Proportion of Households (%) with Select Assets, 2002
Assets Kamwenge Kabarole
Television 0.6 2.8
Radios 47.2 61.4
Phones (mobile and fixed) 1.3 5.4
Bicycles 30.6 34.3 Source: Uganda Population and Housing Census, 2002
4.4.2 Fuel in households
Firewood is the principal source of cooking fuel in the project districts. There is also usage
of charcoal but limited to a low proportion of households. Proportions of households using
of other types of fuels like paraffin and electricity are almost negligible. Households using
the type of fuel for cooking are presented in table below.
Table 4.3: Cooking fuel types in households
Type of Fuel Kamwenge Kabarole
Firewood 95.3 92.6
Charcoal 2.4 4.4
Paraffin 1.9 1.6
Electricity 0.1 0.9
Others 0.4 0.5
Source: Uganda Population and Housing Census, 2002
Prevalently, households in project districts use paraffin candles for indoor night lighting
and only about 5% of households having access to grid electricity for lighting (Table 4.4).
Table 4.4: Lighting fuel types in households
Type of Fuel Kamwenge Kabarole
Electricity/Gas 0.5 5.4
Lantern 5.6 9.3
Tadooba 88.9 82.1
Others 5.0 3.3
Source: Uganda Population and Housing Census, 2002
4.4.3 Sources of drinking water
It was observed that around 70% of the households in the project districts use other
sources of water other than piped water, borehole, protected wells and gravity flow
sources (GFS). Water source in project areas are presented below.
Table 4.5: Type of drinking water sources in households
Sources Kamwenge Kabarole
Piped water 2.2 10.9
Borehole 3.8 13.3
Protected wells 20.0 27.3
GFS 4.0 3.1
Others 70.0 45.4
Source: Uganda Population and Housing Census, 2002
P a g e | 27
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
4.5 Vulnerable groups
The first RAP surveys identified a number of vulnerable households mainly ones headed by
the terminally ill, widows, elderly, orphan-headed households, women-headed
households, and disabled people. These were identified to face a number of problems
which include
e heavy workload on women, male dominance over women and low participation in
household or community decisions, high levels of girl child school dropout, early marriages
for girls and general poverty. Although no household will be demolished and physically
displaced, such vulnerable homes might need assistance, even if not financial, during
compensation.
4.6 HIV/AIDS awareness
Most people in the project areas were aware of HIV/AIDS and how it spreads with their
main sources of information being health centers, local radio stations and NGOs involved
in HIV/AIDS prevention programs. Nonetheless, risky sexual behaviors prevail and of the
people interviewed, 17% of men reported multiple sexual partners compared to only 4% of
women. Female-headed households were found to be more vulnerable to AIDS than male-
headed counterparts because of poverty which lead them to sexual exploitation for
material favors from men.
Health centers at sub-county levels play a central role in the fight against HIV/and provide
treatment, nutrition, free testing and counseling and other outreach programmes like
community sensitization through drama, music and sports. These include Nyakasharara
Health Centre IV, Kamwenge Town Council Health Centre III, Ishogorero Health Centre IV
and Rukunyu Health Centre IV. However these health centers lack drugs, have inadequate
staff, and lack space to accommodate large patient numbers.
There are also community based groups and NGOs active in community sensitization and
empowering people living with HIV/AIDS by providing them free seeds, bee-keeping skills,
poultry and improved farming methods and find markets for their produce. These include,
UWESO and Bigodi Peanut Butter Womens‘ Group Project. Most project believe that with
an improved road, health centres will be more accessible due to increased numbers of
vehicles and the community health officers will visit the communities more easily.
4.8 Social and cultural characteristics of project affected communities
4.8.1 Ethnicity
Among the project affected persons there are both indigenous people, local and foreign
migrants. Foreign migrants are mainly investors in tea estates. According to 2002
Population census, in Kabarole the Batoro are the largest ethnic group (71%) followed by
Bakiga (16%), Bakhonzo (8%), Banyankole (2%), Baganda (1%), Bafumbira (1%), and other
tribes which altogether make 3%.
In Kamwenge the Bakiga are the largest ethnic group (46%) followed by Bafumbira (16%),
Banyankole (14%), Batagwenda (14%), Batoro (6.4%), and other local tribes which
altogether make 3.7% and foreigners (0.3%).
P a g e | 28
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
4.8.2 Education
Literacy rate in Kabarole district is 68% as per the Population and Housing Census 2002. A
closer look at school attendance shows that 21.4% of the population aged 10 and above
have never attended school while 11.3% completed primary school and only 5% managed to
complete secondary school. 48.2% of the population dropped out of school before
completing primary school while 14.5% dropped out before completing secondary school.
For Kamwenge district, general literacy rate is 64% but 30% of the population aged 10 and
above have never attended school, 48% never completed primary schooling, while 7%
never completed secondary school and only 3% managed to complete secondary school.
4.8.3 Cultural characteristics
The cultural characteristics of the project area are as diverse as the tribes living in the
area. Each migrant tribe comes with its own culture; however there are some cultures
which are universal to all tribes. These include family where households are headed by
men, and marriage which demands that men pay dowry for their brides. Widow
inheritance was common in the past but is slowly dying away mainly because HIV/AIDS.
Polygamy is another practice in the project area which is also dying away.
4.8.4 Settlement pattern and housing of the project affected persons
Settlements along the project area are generally linear especially in trading centres. There is
a mix of residents, small scale industries (maize, mills saw mills, welding) and commercial
buildings including shops and market stalls. All along the road, buildings are located away
from the road, the reason no residential dwelling will be razed during road upgrade.
P a g e | 29
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
5 LEGAL & INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK
The Constitution of the Republic of Uganda and the Land Act Cap 227 require that
compensation is paid if a development project would damage structures or other property,
or take private land. The same requirement is provided by World Bank policies and
guidelines. World Bank‘s Operational Policy 4.12 “Involuntary Resettlement" requires that
displaced persons are compensated at full replacement cost and assisted during the
relocation. While it is noted that no person shall be physically displaced by the is project,
1679 people in Kamwenge District and 851 in Kabarole District will lose strips of land,
crops or have their (non-dwelling) structures affected by the road project.
In section below, national laws and those of WB relevant to this RAP are discussed.
5.1 RELEVANT NATIONAL LAWS
For land take and displacement of people, specific attention is drawn to two Ugandan laws
that are applicable to land tenure, compensation and resettlement, namely:
i) The Constitution of the Republic of Uganda, 1995
ii) The Land Act, Cap 227
a) The Constitution of the Republic of Uganda (1995) creates for government and local
authorities a statutory power of compulsory acquisition of land in public interest, and
makes provision, inter alia, for the ―prompt payment of fair and adequate
compensation‖ prior to the taking of possession of any privately-owned property.
Such compensation is assessed in accordance with the valuation principles laid out in Section 78 of the Land Act (Cap 227), briefly outlined below:
i) The value for customary land is the open market value of unimproved land;
ii) The value of buildings on the land is taken at open market value for urban areas, and depreciated replacement cost for rural areas;
iii) The value of standing crops on the land is determined in accordance with the district compensation rates established by the respective District Land Board. Annual crops which could be harvested during the period of notice to vacate given to the landowner/ occupier of the land are excluded in determining compensation values;
iv) In addition to the total compensation assessed, there is a disturbance allowance paid of 15% or, if less than six months‘ notice to vacate is given, 30% of the total sum assessed.
b) The Land Act principally addresses four issues namely; holding, control, management
and land disputes. As regards tenure, the Act repeats, in Section 3, provisions of
Article 237 of the Constitution which vests land ownership in the citizens of Uganda, to
be held under customary, freehold, mailo or leasehold tenure systems. However, the
Land Act provides for acquisition of land or rights to use land for public works.
Regarding control of land use, the Act reaffirms statutory power of compulsory
acquisition conferred on the government and local authorities under articles 26 (2) and
P a g e | 30
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
237(2) (a) of the Constitution (Section 43). Since the Act does not repeal the Land
Acquisition Act No. 14 of 1965, it is assumed that this legislation, meets requirements
of Article 26(2) of the Constitution that requires a law to be in place for the payment
of compensation and access to the courts. The Act also requires that landowners
manage and utilize land in accordance with regulatory land use planning (Sections 44
and 46). Section 77(2) of the revised edition (2000) of the Land Act 1998 provides for a
disturbance allowance on top of the computed compensation amount as shown below:
i) 30% of compensation amount if quit notice is given within 6 months.
ii) 15% of compensation amount if quit notice is given after 6 months.
The above will be two key legal instruments under which compensation and resettlement
will be implemented in this RAP but there are other relevant laws as discussed below.
5.2 OTHER LAWS
5.2.1 The Local Government Act (1997)
Local Government Act 1997 provides for the system of Local Governments, which is based
on the District. Under both Kabarole and Kamwenge (the districts traversed by the road
project) there are lower local governments and administrative units, namely Local Council
I, II, II, IV and V. Chairperson of LC IV is the political head of a district while the Chief
Administrative Officer (CAO) is its technical head. This system provides for elected
Councils whereby chairmen nominate the executive committee of each council, functions
of which include:
i) Initiating and formulating policy for approval by council;
ii) Overseeing the implementation of Government and Council policies, and
monitoring and coordinating activities of Non-Government Organizations in the
district; and
iii) Receiving and solving disputes forwarded to it from lower local governments.
5.2.2 Land Acquisition Act (1965)
This Act makes provision for procedures and method of compulsory acquisition of land for
public purposes whether for temporary or permanent use. The Minister responsible for
land may authorize any person to enter upon the land, survey the land, dig or bore the
subsoil or any other actions necessary for ascertaining whether the land is suitable for a
given public purpose. However, compensation should be paid to any person who suffers
damage as a result of such actions.
The Land Acquisition Act stops at payment of compensation to affected people. In Uganda,
it is not a legal requirement for a project to purchase alternative land for affected
people. Once affected people are promptly and adequately compensated, the project
proponent‘s obligations stop at this extent and there is no legal requirement or provision
that people should be moved or provided with alternative land. Therefore, in Ugandan
legal context, once people are compensated, they are expected to vacate affected
properties without further claim and in this lies a major contrast with WB requirements.
P a g e | 31
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
5.2.3 The Access to Roads Act (1965)
This Act seeks that a private landowner who has no reasonable means of access to public
highway may apply for leave to construct a road of access to a public highway. This law
also establishes a mechanism of applying for such access. It also establishes a legal regime
to ensure the safety of the neighboring environment.
The Act permits an owner of land who is unable through negotiations to obtain leave from
adjoining land owners to construct a road of access to the public highway, to apply to a
magistrate for leave to construct a road of access over any land lying between his land and
the public highway. This law also provides for means by which an order for the
construction of an access road can be revoked. The Act further provides for maintenance
of the access road in a good and efficient state of repair, and for payment of
compensation in respect of the use of the land, the destruction of crops of trees and such
other property.
It is not know at this point where or by whom this Act might be triggered during or after
upgrade the road, but as it indicates, any person who seeks access to a public road can
invoke this legal instrument.
5.2.4 The Roads Act (1964)
The Roads Act of 1964 is a critical piece of legislation with respect to road development
projects. It defines a road reserve as that area bounded by imaginary lines parallel to and
not more than fifty feet distant from the centerline of any road. The Act prohibits
erection of buildings or planting permanent crops within a road reserve.
The Minister or, with the consent of the Minister, a District Commissioner (currently
referred to as ―Chief Administrative Officer‖), in relation to any road within or passing
through any government town or an administrator in respect of any area not being in a
government town, may by order: -
Prescribe the line in which buildings shall be erected in such town or area, or;
Prescribe distance from the centre of the road within, which no building shall be
erected in such town or area.
The road authority is required to give written notice to the owner or occupier of land on
which prohibited activities have been carried out so as:
To pull down or remove the building or structures; or
To cut down or uproot trees or crops; or
The Act allows a road authority to dig and take away materials required for construction
and maintenance of roads in any part of a road reserve approved by the local government
authority without payment to any person.
P a g e | 32
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
5.2.5 Land Tenure Regimes and Transfer of Land
Article 237 of the Constitution, 1995, vests land ownership in citizens of Uganda and
identifies four land tenure systems, namely: customary; freehold; mailo; and leasehold.
The incidents of these systems are detailed under Section 4 of the Land Act (Cap 227).
These tenure systems are provided relevant to the road project are outlined below:
5.2.5.1 Customary Tenure
This tenure is governed by rules generally accepted as binding and authoritative by
the class of persons to which it applies. In other words customary regime is not
governed by written law.
Land is owned in perpetuity.
Customary occupants are occupant of former public land, and occupy land by
virtue of their customary rights; they have proprietary interest in the land and are
entitled to certificates of customary ownership which may be acquired through
application to the Parish Land Committee and eventual issuance by the District
Land Board.
5.2.5.2 Freehold Tenure
This tenure derives its legality from the Constitution of Uganda and its incidents
from the written law.
It involves the holding of land in perpetuity or for a period less than perpetuity
fixed by a condition.
It enables the holder to exercise, subject to the law, full powers of ownership.
5.2.5.3 Leasehold Tenure
This tenure system is:
Created either by contract or by operation of the law;
A form under which the landlord of lessor grants the tenant or lessee exclusive
possession of the land, usually for a period defined and in return for a rent;
The tenant has security of tenure and a proprietary interest in the land.
Although only these latter forms of tenure are legally defined under the Land Act, the
context of common law also recognizes the statute of ―Licensee‖ or ―Sharecroppers‖,
these terms having similar meanings in practice.
Licensees are persons granted authority to use land within for agricultural production.
Traditionally, such production would be limited to annual crops. Licensees have no legal
security of tenure or any propriety right in the land. Their tenure is purely contractual.
5.2.5.4 Mailo Tenure
Mailo land is owned by Toro Kingdom, private owners who were given land donations from
the Kingdom and other people who subsequently bought mailo land from other owners.
P a g e | 33
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
However according to anecdotal information obtained in project communities, relevancy
of this tenure is gradually phasing out due to low land value.
5.2.5.5 Right of Spouse and Children
The rights of spouse and children are protected under the Constitution of Uganda and the
Land Act (Cap 227). The consent of spouse and children must be acquired prior to any
transaction by the head of household on land on which the family ordinarily resides.
Section 40 of the Land Act, 1998 requires that no person shall:
a. Sell, exchange, transfer, pledge, mortgage or lease any land; or enter into any
contract for the sale, exchange, transfer, pledge, mortgage or lease of any land;
b. Give away any land inter vivos, or enter into any transaction in respect of land:
In the case of land on which the person ordinarily resides with his or her spouse, and from which they derive their sustenance, except with the prior written consent of the spouse;
In the case of land on which the person ordinarily resides with his or her dependent children of majority age, except with the prior written consent of the dependent children of majority age;
In the case of land on which the person ordinarily resides with his or her dependent children below the majority age, except with the prior written consent of the Committee1;
In the case of land on which ordinarily reside orphans below majority age with interest in inheritance of the land, except with prior written consent of the Committee.
As mentioned above, road upgrade will follow existing alignment and no household would
be physically displaced. Compensation will therefore be for loss of strips of land adjoining
the road or crops and this legislation is not expected to be invoked.
5.3 VALUATION AND COMPENSATION OF ASSETS
Land take, compensation and relocation were the most frequent issues of debate
encountered during consultations with PAP. Hence, at the core of this RAP is an aim to
ensure project development embraces equitable and appropriate compensation
approaches that meet Ugandan law and international requirements.
Valuation and compensation are in accordance with rates set at district level for crops and
―non-permanent‖ structures. The rates, which are enacted by District Land Boards, are
established and updated at District level. It should be noted however that, unlike for crops
and semi-permanent structures, land value is not determined by districts. Permanent
structures and land are valued based on market value.
However, to meet World Bank requirements, in some cases, additional compensation
measures were identified in order to ensure that all households improve, or at least
restore, their livelihoods and standards of living. Since no household will be moved by the
1 “Committees “ are defined under Section 65 of the Land Act ; they are Parish Land Committees.
P a g e | 34
AWE Engineers www.awe-engineers.com
project, this applies to income restoration where roadside businesses are temporarily
disrupted or lost.
5.4 WORLD BANK REQUIREMENTS
The proposed road project will trigger World Bank‘s Operational Policy 4.12: ―Involuntary
Resettlement‖ in so far as road upgrade will involve involuntary land acquisition.
World Bank experience is that, if unmitigated during development projects, involuntary resettlement can lead to undesirable economic, social and environmental risks, such as:
production systems are dismantled; people face impoverishment when their productive assets or income sources are
lost; people are relocated to environments where their productive skills may be less
applicable and the competition for resources greater; community institutions and social networks are weakened; kin groups are dispersed; cultural identity, traditional authority and the potential for mutual help are
diminished or lost. OP 4.12 seeks to promote participation of affected people in resettlement planning and
implementation, and its key economic objective is to assist displaced persons in their
efforts to improve or at least restore their incomes and standards of living after
displacement. This policy aims to avoid involuntary resettlement to the extent feasible, or
to minimize its adverse social and economic impacts.
There are some stark gaps between Uganda and WB resettlement requirements. For
example, while WB requires provision of resettlement assistance where needed, according
to Uganda‘s laws project proponents are not legally bound to procure alternative land nor
provide relocation assistance to affected people if they provided fair financial
compensation based on a legally accepted valuation process. Additionally, World Bank OP
4.12 does not recognize ―depreciated value‖ for replacement of assets while Uganda‘s
Land Act Cap 227 (excerpted below) allows depreciated replacement cost in rural areas.
The Land Act, 1998:
1. The District Land Tribunal shall, in assessing compensation referred to in paragraph (b) of subsection (1) of section 77 take into account the following:-
a. In the case of a customary owner, the value of land shall be the Market Value of the unimproved land;
b. The value of the buildings, which shall be taken at market value in urban areas and depreciated replacement cost in rural areas;
c. The value of standing crops on the land, excluding annual crops which could be harvested during the period of notice given to the owner, tenant or licensee.
2. In addition to compensation assessed under this section, there shall be paid as a Disturbance Allowance of fifteen per cent or if less that six months’ notice to give vacant possession is given, thirty present of any sum assessed under subsection (1) of this section.
These gaps are discussed in Tables 5 and 5.1.
P a g e | 35
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Table 5: Gaps between World Bank O.P 4.12 and Ugandan legislation applicable to each impact.
No. Impact World Bank requirement Uganda requirement Gaps and how these will be addressed
1. Project Affected People, PAPs
Compensation for loss of land, property, resources and access to land and resources, and resettlement assistance is provided to all affected users (including those with formal legal rights, those with non-formal customary rights, and those with no legal rights or claims).
Compensation should be provided to legal land owners (including mailo land owners and kibanja owners). No compensation is provided to land users.
Gap. Project will provide compensation to legal and non-legal land owners, and to legal users of affected property.
2. Loss of land and assets
For land owners: Compensate for land and all assets at full replacement cost, OR replacement of land at equal/ greater value and compensation for other assets. World Bank OP 4.12 does not recognize ―depreciated value‖ for replacement of assets (which should be replaced at ―market value‖).
Cash compensation based upon market value of unimproved land + disturbance allowance (15%) if household is moved within 6 months (this rises to 30% if households are moved before 6 months). Uganda‘s Land Act Cap 227 allows depreciated replacement cost in rural areas.
Gap. Market value is based on recent transactions and thus if alternative property is purchased within a reasonable period of the payment of compensation, it is likely that market value will reflect replacement value. However, local inflation in price land or construction materials can affect what is determined as replacement cost. If this is not reflected in recent transactions, market value may not reflect replacement value and hence inflation will be addressed. Replacement of assets affected by this project will be done based on market value.
For tenants (land use holders): Compensated for assets (crops, improvements) other than land and other losses (time it takes to restore livelihood: dead time),
AND
Relocation assistance (including assistance in acquiring replacement land, financial payment for the cost of the relocation),
Entitled to compensation based on the amount of right they hold to the land.
Gap. Land owners and users will be compensated whatever the legal recognition of their tenure/occupancy. If tenants have no legal land title deed, they will compensated for crops or any improvements they have made to the land. Relocation assistance will be provided.
P a g e | 36
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
No. Impact World Bank requirement Uganda requirement Gaps and how these will be addressed
Non- legal land users: Compensated for assets (crops, improvements) other than land and other losses (time it takes to restore livelihood: dead time)
AND
Relocation assistance (including assistance in acquiring replacement land, financial payment for the cost of the relocation)
No compensation is applicable under Ugandan legislation.
Gap. Non-legal land users will be considered eligible under the RAP.
Provide additional targeted assistance and opportunities to restore/ improve livelihood.
Not a legal requirement in Uganda but presumed catered for by the disturbance allowance of 15-30% of the value of property lost.
Gap. Livelihood restoration assistance to be provided.
Provide transitional support based on reasonable estimate of time required to restore income earning capacity.
No legislative requirement, but presumed catered for by the disturbance allowance of 15-30% of the value of property lost.
Gap. Transitional assistance to be provided.
3 Loss of crops and trees
Compensation for crops, trees, and other fixed assets at full replacement cost and should be sufficient to enable affected people to restore their standard of living after resettlement.
Sharecroppers: Not entitled to compensation for land, entitled to compensation for crops. Annual (seasonal) crops: No compensation since the 3 or 6-month notice is supposed to allow people to harvest their annual crops. Perennial crops: Cash compensation based upon rates per square meter /bush/tree/plant established at District level plus disturbance allowance (15% or 30%). Rates are calculated as the one-year net agricultural income. Disturbance allowance is meant to compensate the re-establishment period for these crops.
Gap. For sharecroppers and annual (seasonal) crops, the Project will provide time to enable these to be harvested by households. Once harvested, there will be no further planting. A disturbance allowance will be paid to overcome any time delays and any lost benefit as a result of the delays. For perennial crops, compensation will be based on estimated income lost for 3 years, so as to provide replacement value. A disturbance allowance will be paid as per Uganda law.
P a g e | 37
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
No. Impact World Bank requirement Uganda requirement Gaps and how these will be addressed
4 Loss of structures and other improvements (fences, etc) including communal structures
Compensation for structures should cover full replacement cost exclusive of depreciation and inclusive of all fees (such as construction permits and title charges) and labour costs.
Owners of ―Permanent‖ Buildings: Valuation by valuer + disturbance allowance (15%). Valuation is based on depreciated market value. Walls: classed as permanent structures, but value calculated on investment method. Owners of ―Non-permanent‖ Buildings: Cash compensation based upon rates per square meter established at District level plus disturbance allowance (15%). Note: Rates are based on depreciated market value. Tenants of structures: repayment of unused rent, and 6 months notice to vacate structure. Fences: barbed wire fences valued by government rate, based on the investment method.
Gap. Project will provide compensation based on replacement value. This will include the payment of market value for assets and a disturbance allowance.
5 Loss of business
Compensate the affected business owner for the cost of re-establishing commercial activities elsewhere, for lost net income during the period of transition and for costs of transfer and reinstallation of the business.
No compensation. The 6-month notice is supposed to allow people to re-establish their business.
Gap. The project will provide transition allowance to cover lost income during the period before business is up and running.
P a g e | 38
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
No. Impact World Bank requirement Uganda requirement Gaps and how these will be addressed
6 Loss of dwelling structures
Provide adequate replacement housing OR cash compensation at full replacement value.
Owners of ―Permanent‖ Buildings: Valuation by valuer + disturbance allowance (15%). Valuation is based on depreciated market value. Walls: classed as permanent structures, but value calculated on investment method. Owners of ―Non-permanent‖ Buildings: Cash compensation based upon rates per square meter established at District level plus disturbance allowance (15%). Note: Rates are based on depreciated market value. Tenants of structures: repayment of unused rent, and 6 months notice to vacate structure.
Gap. Project will provide compensation based on replacement value. This will include the payment of asset market value, a disturbance allowance, and a top up allowance (based on the current inflation rate) to compensate for the rise in construction materials.
Provide relocation assistance (cash, food, etc). If provided, determined by private negotiation. To be paid for by disturbance allowance of 15-30%.
Gap. No dwelling will be demolished by the project before any relocation assistance is paid
Provide security of tenure at the new site. No legislative requirement. Gap. Secure tenure will be replaced if lost.
Provide improved living conditions at the new resettlement site.
No legislative requirement. The project will provide replacement value to ensure pre-project conditions to the extent possible.
P a g e | 39
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Table 5.1: Gaps between World Bank OP 4.12 and Ugandan legislation applicable to each process.
No. Impact World Bank requirement Uganda requirement Gaps and how to be addressed
1. Proponent / government involvement post compensation
Resettlement should be properly managed, and carefully planned and implemented (this includes monitoring and evaluation).
It is the ultimate responsibility of the proponent to make sure the resettlement process is consistent with the requirements of WB requirements (even under government -managed resettlement).
No corresponding requirement. Gap The project will conform to WB and best practices during implementation of the RAP. UNRA will actively participate in post compensation activities including monitoring of livelihoods
2. Public Participation
Following disclosure of all relevant information, the proponent will consult with and facilitate informed participation of affected persons and communities, including host communities, in decision-making processes related to resettlement. Consultation will continue during the implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of compensation payment and resettlement.
The Constitution (Articles 231) recognizes right of Ugandans to own land and property and equitable compensation before private property is affected. This recognition is also echoed in by The Land Act. No provisions for detailed comprehensive disclosure
Gap Disclosure is part of the preparation, implementation and monitoring and evaluation of the RAP
Compensation rates should be calculated in consultation with representatives of affected populations.
Compensation rates for crops are determined and fixed by local governments (Districts). If not satisfied, a claimant can challenge in courts of law the total compensation sum derived using these rates.
Gap The project will ensure replacement value.
3. Identification of vulnerable groups
‗Vulnerable‘ groups should be identified from the start and offered specially tailored assistance throughout the resettlement process.
No requirement to specifically identify vulnerable groups, nor to undertake specific measures to provide them special assistance.
The project will identify vulnerable groups and will identify specific measures to accommodate their needs.
P a g e | 40
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
In a number of situations, as shown in table above, WBG requirements are more favorable
to affected persons than Ugandan law. UNRA is committed to undertaking appropriate
compensation approaches to meet both Ugandan law and World Bank requirements such
as;
i) Compensating for loss of income after affected persons are displaced.
ii) Compensation for tenants who might not have legal land rights, but have
undertaken development or farming activities on affected land.
iii) Wherever feasible and acceptable to affected persons, provide land-for-land
compensation.
iv) Provide property owners with cash compensation at full replacement cost.
v) Wherever appropriate, provide skills assistance to affected farmers in areas such as
improved crop and animal husbandry and records keeping.
5.5 INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES
There are three main actors who may be involved in carrying out resettlement and/or
compensation as required in the upgrading of the road. These are UNRA (the developer
responsible for effecting compensation/resettlement) Ministry of Lands, Housing and
Urban Development (approving compensation rates), and Ministry of Works and Transport.
5.5.1 Ministry of Works and Transport
Government of Uganda and development partners requires preparation of a Resettlement
Action Plan for road development projects. This is done to ensure equitable compensation
and minimize social disruptions or negative effects on people‘s livelihoods arising from
construction of roads. Compensations assist those who have lost assets as a result of a
road project to maintain their livelihood through income restoration.
5.5.2 Ministry of Lands, Housing and Urban Development
The Chief Government Valuer in the Valuation Division in the Ministry of Housing and
Urban Development is responsible for approving the Valuation Roll. This demands fair and
transparent compensation and as such all property valued are first inspected by the Chief
Government Valuer. Chief Government Valuer‘s office is also involved in resolving public
complaints that arise from land acquisition valuations and compensation payments.
5.5.3 Uganda National Roads Authority, UNRA
This RAP will be implemented by UNRA in conjunction with respective district local
governments (Kamwenge and Kabarole Districts and village-level local councils) and key
implementation processes will include: (a) payment of compensation to affected people;
(b) rehabilitation assistance to vulnerable people identified in this RAP or by local
leaders/RAP implementation unit; (c) possible jobs as employees on the road
rehabilitation project; (d) monitoring and evaluation.
The overall implementation responsibility will be with that of UNRA through the Resident
Engineer and appointed consultant. UNRA will ensure that PAPs have adequate time to
P a g e | 41
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
replace their assets and will work with such affected persons to ensure they are able to
achieve this before expiry of notice to vacate their affected properties. UNRA will make
available financial resources necessary to meet compensation and resettlement costs, as
well as additional actions necessary to satisfy and World Bank guidelines.
5.5.4 District Local Governments
Both districts traversed by the road (Kamwenge and Kabarole), like all other Uganda
districts, have five levels of local councils (LCs), namely: District, County, Sub-county,
Parish and Village these are referred to as LC5, LC4, LC3, LC2 and LC1 respectively. Local
Councils are responsible for local policy matters, economic development, resolving local
conflicts and providing orderly leadership and democratic practices at the grass roots level
in their respective areas. The system has facilitated mass participation in government
affairs and awakened the rural population to their rights of citizenship and obligations
particularly regarding involvement in development programs and projects. In the project-
affected area LC1s and LC3s are very active and directly interact with the affected
population. These councils will thus be helpful during identification of rightful property
owners and resolving compensation grievances.
5.5.5 Private Sector Entities
RAP implementation will entail involvement of private sector consultants hired by UNRA
for verification and actual payment of compensation to PAPs. These entities are not
known at this time since they will be hired through competitive bidding as per Uganda‘s
procurement laws.
All foregoing institutions are considered to have sufficient skills to undertake their
respective tasks, which for government ministries/ agencies are within their mandate. LCs
however would need facilitation to enable their active participation in project activities.
P a g e | 42
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
6 COMPENSATION AND RESETTLEMENT STRATEGY
6.1 KEY PRINCIPLES
Key principles that the proponent (UNRA) will commit to during resettlement are
presented in box below:
Box 6: Key principles to heed during compensation.
Resettlement and compensation of Project-Affected People (PAP) will be carried out in
compliance with relevant Ugandan laws and WB standards. All physically or economically displaced people shall be adequately and equitably compensated. Wherever possible, UNRA shall assist affected people in restoring their livelihoods by providing transitional assistance, where necessary, if livelihoods are not restored to pre-project level.
Resettlement shall be implemented in a gender-sensitive manner. Consent of spouses shall be sought, as provided by the law (e.g. Section 40 of the Land Act, 1998). In addition, resettlement-based options shall be strongly promoted, since cash compensation to male household heads is often detrimental to women.
Cash compensation, although sought after by heads of households, could be detrimental in the medium term to other household members, particularly female spouses and children. Wherever agreeable, the project should provide ―land-for-land‖ compensation rather than cash compensation.
Compensation shall aim to ensure that people are not worse off after resettlement and attention and should be given to ‗vulnerable‘ categories such as the child-headed and female-headed households.
6.2 ELIGIBILITY FOR COMPENSATION
In resettlement terms, eligibility is defined as the criteria for qualification to receive benefits under a resettlement program. 6.2.1 ELIGIBILITY, CENSUS AND CUT-OFF DATE The cut-off date was considered by the surveying and valuation consultant as the last day of the census of affected people and properties 31 August 2009. No structure or field established in the project-affected area after that date would be eligible for compensation. The cut-off date after which no settlers or developers are eligible for compensation was publicized among potentially affected people. This was explained during the census and valuation exercise to all stakeholders in the area, including:
Project-affected people, identified and individually surveyed, Parish Land Committee (LC2 level), District Land Board (LC5 level), LC officials in which consultations were undertaken
The following categories are eligible for compensation:
People who have been in the surveyed part of the proposed road reserve and
working areas;
Landlords owning land affected by road;
People whose structures are to be affected by the development;
P a g e | 43
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
People who rent land for cultivation (sharecroppers) and their crops or trees are to
be removed or damaged due to land acquisition activities.
Any other group of persons that has not been mentioned above but is entitled to
compensation according to the laws of Uganda and World Bank/Donor policies.
6.2.2 SPECULATIVE STRUCTURES
Opportunistic uninhabitable structures established for the sole purpose of compensation
pose a specific eligibility problem and will be addressed through the use of the following
methods to ascertain the validity of the compensation claim:
i) Inspection of the structure to determine whether it is indeed habited or not;
ii) Consultation with LC chairpersons‘ authorities to ascertain whether the contested
structure existed at the time of the cut-off date or census and whether it was
established in good faith or for an opportunistic compensation purpose.
6.3 OVERVIEW OF ENTITLEMENTS
6.3.1 Categories of Affected People During compensation, an important legal requirement is that contained in Section 40 of the Land Act that makes it compulsory to seek consent of spouses before compensation packages is paid out. As mentioned earlier (Section 6.1, Box 6-iii), cash compensation entails a number of risks for impoverishment of female spouses and children, when for example, a household head decides to marry another wife or buy luxuries instead of rebuilding a new home. Affected persons irrespective of their status (whether they have formal title, legal rights,
non-legal right) are eligible for some kind of assistance if they occupied the land before
cut-off date.
6.3.1.1 Vulnerable people
Vulnerable people are people who by virtue of gender, ethnicity, age, physical or mental
disability, economic disadvantage, or social status, may be more adversely affected by
resettlement than others and who may be limited in their ability to claim or take
advantage of resettlement assistance and related development benefits. In this case,
stakeholders form the PAP identified vulnerable people as the following:
i) Widows;
ii) Orphans;
iii) Disabled or seriously sick people, particularly people living with HIV/AIDS and other
illnesses;
iv) Second or third wives, particularly those where there is a risk that they will be
abandoned by their husbands after compensation;
v) The elderly;
vi) Households whose heads are female and who live with limited resources.
vii) Households whose heads are orphans (child-headed households).
It should be noted that vulnerability is not a static condition. For instance PAPs who were
normal at the time valuation/ surveys might be found vulnerable a year later at the time
P a g e | 44
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
of effecting compensation payments. Others who were found terminally ill with AIDS and
therefore vulnerable during field surveys might have passed on but their heirs healthy and
not vulnerable. This situation should therefore be handled on a case-by-case basis during
RAP implementation.
Based on the above, information provided on vulnerable PAPs (Annex 3) should serve to
inform RAP implementation team to identify nature and state of prevailing vulnerability
and accord special assistance necessary.
6.3.2 Compensation and resettlement measures Two main resettlement packages, the details of which are provided in the section below, have been designed to ensure adequate compensation for PAPs who lose assets or livelihoods when the project is implemented. These packages have been developed in consultation with the affected community, including PAPs and local councilors to give PAPs, depending on their vulnerability categorization, the opportunity to choose options that best suit their relocation needs and circumstances. Entitlement measures were developed basing on facts below:
The majority of PAPs will only lose a small section of land that abuts the road reserve. In some cases, this will also result in the loss of permanent or temporary structures, or crops. If they have room on their remaining land holding, PAPs are likely chose to construct new structures or plant crops on their adjacent land, rather than moving to a new village. As such, current social ties and access to infrastructure or services such as water sources, schools, shops, transport services and places of worship will be maintained.
The majority of PAPs have expressed a strong preference for cash compensation rather than replacement of assets. This is despite their concerns regarding the rising price of land and construction materials;
Some PAPs however, particularly vulnerable groups, demonstrated a preference for replacement assets.
a) Option 1: Primary entitlement measures These measures are designed to be appropriate for the majority of PAPs, who are likely to only lose small strips of land adjoining existing road, some permanent or temporary structures. The measures include a mix of cash compensation for lost assets (including land, structures and crops), other assistance measures such as relocation assistance, and where appropriate, measures to cover any short-term changes in livelihood. It is presumed that cash compensation will be used by PAPs to replace lost assets by purchasing new land where necessary and/or constructing a new structure on remaining portions of their current land plots. Livelihoods will be replaced through development of new structures. b) Option 2: Other entitlement measures (provided to vulnerable groups or those
whose land will become unviable as a result of the Project)
These measures have been developed to assist vulnerable groups, or those whose land will become unviable after the resettlement. In this scenario, land and structures would be replaced (with the same tenure as pre-resettlement), and assistance would be provided to move household or business goods. No cash compensation would be provided for assets,
P a g e | 45
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
but a transition and disturbance allowance shall be provided to overcome any short-term changes in livelihood. c) Measures common to both scenarios
Taxes and charges associated with purchase of new land will be paid directly by the Project. PAPs choosing cash compensation will have a choice of either receiving a cash payment or into a bank account opened by the Project (if a PAP does not have one) covering all associated bank fees and charges associated with opening a new account. The following provides a description of each of the entitlement measures for loss of assets, loss of livelihoods and other entitlement measures. 6.3.3 DESCRIPTION OF ENTITLEMENT MEASURES 6.3.1.1 Compensation for loss of land
Compensation for the loss of land will be offered to all PAPs who currently own or use land, irrespective of legality their tenure. Under the Primary Entitlement Measures (Option 1), cash compensation will be provided, based on market value and disturbance allowance of 30%. This is considered adequate for replacement value. During consultation, households mentioned that they had already begun looking for replacement land and were waiting on the compensation payment to effect the purchases. For vulnerable groups, or those whose land will become unviable, an option will be provided for replacement land of similar size, quality and tenure (freehold or lease). 6.3.1.2 Compensation for Loss of Crops
a) Perennial crops
Cash compensation will be provided for the loss of perennial crops, calculated using the
approved district rates. However, since Uganda government rates do not include provision
for loss of income associated with these crops, a transitional allowance will also be
provided to cover any loss of livelihood during the period between loss of crops and
availability of income from new (replanted) crops.
The purpose of the perennial crop transition allowance is to cover lost income incurred by
households during the transition period until replacement crops are ready for harvest.
Compensation is paid based on assumption that 10% of perennial crops are sold annually.
Farmers are aware of possible future road expansions and do not grow permanent
(perennial) crops in road reserves, or near roads generally. Since perennial crops are
grown away from the road, 10% is suggested as a realistic proportion of potentially
affected perennial crops. PAPs will be paid 10% of their annual crop income for 3 years to
provide a transition allowance while new crops are grown. Considering the small strips of
land to be lost along the road, respective compensation values shall be proportionately
derived for each affected land size.
P a g e | 46
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
b) Annual (seasonal) crops
The project will provide all compensation under the entitlement matrix three months
prior to the commencement of construction. At the time of payment, the timing of the
project will be made clear and instruction provided as to how crops will be managed
during this time. This timeframe provide adequate opportunity for all seasonal (or
―annual‖) crops to be harvested, and thus there is no impact to annual crops. As such, no
direct compensation will be paid for these crops.
A transitional allowance will be provided to ensure that any changes in livelihood derived
from such crops is adequately compensated. Compensation will be paid in the amount of
Ug. Shs 33,000 per household which loses annual crops. This is calculated on the basis of
10% of the average daily income from agriculture, for a period of one month. The
assumptions that underpin this calculation are as follows:
The range of income earned from agricultural products in the project affected areas is
UgShs 2,000-20,000 daily, thus an average of UgShs 11,000 per day. This includes
income derived from livestock, which will not be affected by the Project;
Most households will only lose a small percentage of their land plot, and thus
agricultural activities and income derived from them would mostly remain unaffected
in the remaining land;
Adequate time will be provided for the harvest of crops and compensation for lost land
and other assets will be provided in advance, enabling replacement. Impacts
therefore, are likely to be minimal.
These measures are the same under Option 1 and 2. Compensation rates for crops are
guided by district rates usually updated regularly.
c) Unintentional damage to crops
If there is unintentional damage to crops during road construction whether owned by PAPs or not, compensation will be paid for both annual and perennial crops, based on approved district rates. 6.3.1.3 Compensation for loss of structures
a) Owners of permanent structures For current land owners, under the primary entitlement measures (Option 1), cash compensation for permanent structures will be provided, calculated basing on prevailing market value, and a disturbance allowance of 30%. In addition, a further payment is recommended to cover increase in cost of construction materials from the time government rates were developed in each of the two districts. This will be calculated at the current inflation rate. Those who would prefer non-cash based compensation (Option 2), a new permanent structure (either business or residential) will be provided. This will be of similar size, design and tenure as current structures, and where possible, will be located in the same village as the current structure. This process will be undertaken in consultation with the affected household/business.
P a g e | 47
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
b) Tenants of permanent structures (residential and commercial) Under the primary entitlement measures (Option 1), if tenants of permanent or temporary structures are identified, they will be provided with cash compensation for any fixed assets that cannot be relocated. It is however unlikely that these will exist since tenants are not usually allowed to develop permanent assets on rented premises. c) Owners and tenants of temporary structures Affected persons may salvage building materials at their own cost from old structures to reuse elsewhere. Also, for those moving to a new settlement, or non-adjacent land, transport assistance will be provided by UNRA for households or business goods. In addition, for vulnerable groups only, labor will be provided where necessary to assist with loading and unloading of property, as determined on a case by case basis. This measure is considered unnecessary for non-vulnerable households, as they would prefer this to be done by household members to avoid theft, and maintain privacy about their household or business property. Districts have also established compensation rates for temporary structures that are updated regularly. d) Damage to structures (permanent and temporary)
If there is unintentional damage to structures during the construction process, compensation will be paid for all losses by the contractor. This will be calculated based on approved district rates (for semi-permanent structures) and market value (for permanent structures) and will be available for all structures whether owned by PAPs or not. 6.3.1.4 Compensation for loss of business (owners and tenants)
Compensation will be paid to business owners and tenants for the potential loss of business income. A transition allowance will be provided in the amount of UgShs 240,000, which is calculated on 50% of the average daily income for a period of one month. This measure has been based on the following assumptions:
The range of income earned in businesses in the project affected areas is UgShs2,000-
30,000 per day, thus an average of UgShs16,000 per day (see baseline section);
Most PAPs are likely to choose to relocate their business onto the adjoining portion of
their land, and thus will remain in their current village (see above for compensation
measures for the loss of land);
Much of the trade for retail or restaurant/bar businesses is from within the locality
(town or trading center), and thus is likely to remain constant during the construction
and operation phases of the Project; and
Households are likely to be able to continue to operate their current business from the
old structure while new premises is constructed (using compensation payment),
therefore income will still be generated during this time.
6.3.1.5 Compensation for loss of employment
The number of PAPs who will lose employment as a result of the Project, even in the short term, is very low. Those most likely to be affected are those working in roadside wooden kiosks, shops, bars and restaurants. For those who do lose employment, a transition
P a g e | 48
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
allowance of UgSh77.500 will be provided for workers in all affected business. This is calculated on the basis of the average wage for a period of one month. The assumptions that underpin this calculation include the following: a) Bar or restaurant workers generally earn between UgShs 40,000 per month (when
housed and UgShs 80,000 per month if not housed. Shop workers generally earn slightly more, between UgShs 80,000 per month (when housed) and UgShs 110,000 per month (if not housed). The average income therefore is about UgSh 77,500 per month.
b) Most workers will continue their employment in the new premises, and thus there will be minimal change to livelihoods. However, a transition allowance will provide assurance that their livelihoods are not affected.
6.3.1.6 Payment of bank charges
For households who do not currently have a bank account, but would prefer compensation not to be made in cash, the Project will facilitate opening of a bank account and will pay all associated costs directly to the Bank. This however does not preclude the choice of cash payment for anyone who so wishes. 6.3.2.4 Transport refund when collecting compensation
The project will provide cash compensation in advance for the payment of transport to payment stations for the collection of compensation payments. This will be in the amount of 20,000 per household, based on prevailing average transport costs in the project areas. 6.3.4 Payment options All PAPs will have the option of receiving cash compensation in a lump sum, or in regular installments. The total amount of compensation will remain the same under both options.
A summary of entitlement matrix is shown in Table 6.1 below.
P a g e | 49
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Table 6.1: Entitlement matrix
Impact Description Entitled Compensation Measure Unit
For all Project affected households
Banking fees payment of any bank charges associated with receipt of cash compensation
payment of fees for opening new bank account (if required)
All affected PAPs (per household)
Payment of all relevant fees and charges directly to the bank (cash compensation to individual households is not applicable).
UgSh / household
Transport costs transport to the location where compensation will be provided
All PAPs (per household)
Cash compensation UgSh /household
P a g e | 50
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Impact Description Entitled Compensation Measure Unit
Specific Entitlements
Loss of land no permanent structure on the land
permanent structure will not be demolished
remaining land still viable for current use
Lease Freehold Government
Cash compensation (1)
no permanent structure on the land or permanent structure will not be demolished
Land used or owned by vulnerable households, or
Land owner becomes landless (as defined by Ugandan law) OR land reduction results in food insecurity
Lease Freehold Government
Cash compensation (1)
land on which permanent structure to be demolished is located;
Land used or owned by vulnerable households, or
the remaining land owned by the landowner creates a) food insecurity OR b) landlessness for the PAP
Lease Freehold Government
Cash compensation (1)
Loss of structure permanent dwelling Owner Cash compensation
permanent dwelling Tenant Disturbance allowance
permanent business structure Owner, non vulnerable
Cash compensation
permanent business structure Owner, vulnerable
Cash compensation
permanent business structure Tenant Disturbance allowance
permanent structure used for both dwelling and business
Owner, non vulnerable
Cash compensation
permanent structure used for both dwelling and business
Owner, vulnerable
Cash compensation
permanent structure used for both Tenant Disturbance allowance
P a g e | 51
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Impact Description Entitled Compensation Measure Unit
dwelling and business
temporary structure (e.g. pit latrine, fence etc)
Owner Cash compensation
Loss of perennial crops
Crops with growth period more than a year.
Crop owner Cash compensation
Transition allowance
Payment for damage to crops (if any)
Various amounts dependant on crop/plant.
Loss of annual crops Six months or more notice provided prior to use of the land by the Project
Owner No compensation payable. -
Less that 6 months notice provided prior to use of the land by the Project
Owner Crops that take more than 3 months to grow to harvesting stage are not considered seasonal crops and are eligible for compensation. Transition allowance
Payment for damage to crops (if any)
Set amount
Loss of business Businesses who move to new settlement or to non adjacent land
Owners Tenants
Transport assistance to move business goods.
Transition allowance
UgShs/ trip UgShs/ business
Businesses who move to adjacent land
Owners Tenants
Transition allowance UgShs/ business
Loss of employment Employees in business where structure is to be demolished due to Project activities
Employees Transitional allowance
If feasible ensure continuity of employment of affected persons by contactor providing job on road project (where any PAP is interested in such jobs).
UgShs/ individual
(1) Defined here as the government rates, and disturbance allowance under Ugandan law (15% or30%). All cash compensation will include a disturbance allowance.
Affected people prevalently preferred cash compensation for assets (land and structures) in spite of inherent risks (e.g. squandering resources before rebuilding their livelihoods, theft, inflation, etc). For buildings PAPs would have liberty to salvage construction materials or any material they desire from affected structures.
P a g e | 52
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
7 CONSULTATION WITH AFFECTED COMMUNITIES
Consultations were carried out with project affected people and district officers during preparation of this RAP to provide opportunity for PAPs to know project objectives and implications on them and their assets. The PAPs were also informed of what resettlement options were available to them. Views of the PAPs and their concerns were collected, documented and later integrated in resettlement measures outlined in the RAP. During consultations, it was clearly explained to PAPs that resettlement did not mean displacement and relocation in the literal sense but also loss of physical and economic assets and measures that follow to help restore livelihoods of any affected persons.
Table 7.1: Stakeholder views
Issues/ Concerns Stakeholder suggestions
PAPs were concerned that receiving and keeping cash payments at home could lead to robberies.
To avoid this, people preferred to receive large compensation payments into bank accounts but most PAPs actually did not have them and requested UNRA to facilitate opening up accounts at available banks such as Stanbic, Centenary and Post bank.
Lack of legal title to land and buildings hence a fear that ownership may not be recognised.
The common land tenure systems include customary, leasehold. To avert peoples‘ fears all PAPs have been listed and recorded. All persons irrespective of their ownership status (i.e. with or without title deeds and users) are eligible for some sort of compensation so long as they existed during the evaluation period. New cases after valuation will not be catered for
Lack of letters of administration and family conflicts on who is the right person to be compensated.
Money to be kept by the paying consultant until family grievances are resolved.
On going construction as to whether such activities should stop forth with.
Money to be paid according to initial valuation. Additional constructions would not be compensated.
Compensation date. UNRA should continually communicate to PAPs.
Grievances, where does one go? Grievance committee should be set up comprised of LCs, CBO, NGO, elder, and the consultant
Protection of the basic existing infrastructure e.g. water sources, electricity.
These facilities should be restored or an alternative provided.
Local councils taking 10% from compensation funds.
The local councils are allowed to deduct this money for development purposes but unfortunately not much development is seen.
Gender violence as a result of men becoming rich through compensation.
Separate accounts should be opened for man and wife and each given his or portion of the money.
Wrong names given to the valuers due to the absence of the rightful owner.
The grieved members should inform the valuers as soon as possible for records to be corrected.
P a g e | 53
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
8 GRIEVANCE MANAGEMENT AND REDRESS PROCEDURES
8.1 GRIEVANCE PROCESS
This section describes avenues for PAPs to lodge a complaint or express a grievance against the project, its staff or contractors as part of the RAP implementation. It also describes the procedures, roles and responsibilities for addressing grievances and resolving disputes. In addition, the grievance process will allow the Project to be informed of issues concerning local communities so that it can be pro-active in identifying solutions. This grievance procedure will not replace the existing legal process in Uganda rather it seeks to resolve issues quickly so as to expedite receipt of entitlements and smooth resettlement without resorting to expensive and time-consuming legal action. If the grievance procedure fails to provide a settlement, complainants can still seek legal redress. The grievance system will operate for a total of three years. The project will therefore put in place an extra-judicial mechanism for managing grievances and disputes based on explanation and mediation. Every aggrieved person shall be able to trigger this mechanism, while still being able to resort to the formal judicial system. The objectives of the grievance process are as follows: Provide affected people with avenues for making a complaint or resolving any dispute
that may arise during the course of land and asset acquisition, including during the process of moving homes;
Ensure that appropriate and mutually acceptable corrective actions are identified and implemented to address complaints;
Verify that complaints are satisfied with outcomes of corrective actions; Avoid the need to resort to judicial proceedings.
8.2 GRIEVANCE MECHANISM
The Grievance Mechanism operating at each location will receive inputs from three main sources: Directly from the resettled residents or other members of affected settlements. From the implementation team executing the resettlement. From the Monitoring and Evaluation Officer who will forward issues/concerns identified
in the field. Steps of the grievance process are described below. A flow chart outlining the main actions and decision points is shown in Figure 3.
Step 1: Receipt of complaint
A verbal or in written complaint from a PAP will be received by the Grievance Officer and recorded in a grievance log (electronically if possible) which will be held at UNRA field office. There will be need for the grievance team to hold meetings at sub-county headquarters where grievances are received by a contact person such as the Sub-county chief who would then hand over received complaints to UNRA‘s grievance officer, for entering into the grievance log. The log would indicate grievances, date lodged, actions taken to address or reasons the grievance was not acted on (i.e. the grievance was not related to the resettlement process); information provided to complainant and date the grievance was closed.
P a g e | 54
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Grievances can be lodged at any time, either directly to UNRA office or via the grievance committee member. The process for lodging a complaint is outlined below: i) The Grievance Officer will receive a complaint from the complainant. ii) The Grievance Officer will ask the claimant questions in their local
language, write the answers in English and enter them in English onto the Grievance Form.
iii) A representative of an independent local organization) witnesses translation of the grievance into English.
iv) The Grievance Officer reads the complaint in English and translates it into the complainant‘s local language on the Grievance Form.
v) The local leader and the complainant both sign the Grievance Form after they both confirm the accuracy of the grievance.
vi) The Grievance Officer lodges the complaint in the Grievance Log. Step 2: Determination of corrective action If in their judgement, the grievance can be solved at this stage, the Grievance Officer and a representative of an independent organization will determine a corrective action in consultation with the aggrieved person. A description of the action; the time frame in which the action is to take place and the party responsible for implementing the action will be recorded in the grievance database. Grievances will be resolved and status reported back to complainants within 30 days. If more time is required this will be communicated clearly and in advance to the aggrieved person. For cases that are not resolved within the stipulated time, detailed investigations will be undertaken and results discussed in the monthly meetings with affected persons. In some instances, it may be appropriate to appoint independent third parties to undertake the investigations. Step 3: Meeting with the complainant The proposed corrective action and the timeframe in which it is to be implemented will be discussed with the complainant within 30 days of receipt of the grievance. Written agreement to proceed with the corrective action will be sought from the complainant (e.g. by use of an appropriate consent form). If no agreement is reached, Step 2 will be re-visited.
Step 4: Implementation of corrective action Agreed corrective action will be undertaken by the project or its contractors within the agreed timeframe. The date of the completed action will be recorded in the grievance database. Step 5: Verification of corrective action To verify satisfaction, the aggrieved person will be approached by the Grievance Officer to verify that the corrective action has been implemented. A signature of the complainant will be obtained and recorded in the log and/or on the consent form (see Step 3). If the complainant is not satisfied with the outcome of the corrective action additional steps may be undertaken to reach agreement between
P a g e | 55
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
the parties. If additional corrective action is not possible alternative avenues may be pursued.
Step 6: Action by local leaders and project contractors If the Grievance Officer and independent observer cannot solve the grievance, it will be referred to relevant parties such as local leaders, UNRA – Social and Environmental Officers, Construction Contractor, Valuer and AWE, for consultation and relevant feedback provided. Step 7: Action by Grievance Committee If the complainant remains dissatisfied and a satisfactory resolution cannot be reached, the complaint will be handled by the Grievance Committee. A dedicated Grievance Committee will be established to assess grievances that arise from disputes. This will include the following members: 1. LC3; 2. District Land Officer – Surveyor; 3. Representative of the valuer, 4. Grievance Officer 5. UNRA This committee must have a quorum of at least 3. Decisions will be reached by simple majority. The Grievance Committee should be constituted for as long as no more grievances are lodged. Once the Grievance Committee has determined its approach to the lodged grievance, this will be communicated to the Grievance Officer, who will communicate this to the complainant. If satisfied, the complainant signs to acknowledge that the issue has been resolved satisfactorily. If the complainant is not satisfied however, the complainant notes the outstanding issues, which may be re-lodged with the Grievance Committee or the complainant may proceed with judicial proceedings. Sections below provide key people involved in the grievance redress mechanism and associated actions. Step 8: Action by UNRA management If no satisfactory solution can be provided by the Grievance Committee the complaint will be resolved by UNRA top management. If after management intervention, resolution is not reached the complaint has the option to pursue appropriate recourse via judicial processes.
Sections below provide key people involved in the grievance redress process and associated actions. a) Grievance Officer A Grievance Officer (GO), who is a member of the implementation team, will lead the grievance mechanism. Principal responsibilities of the GO will include:
P a g e | 56
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
i) Recording the grievances, both written and oral, of the affected people, categorizing and prioritizing them and providing solutions within a specified time period.
ii) Discussing grievances on a regular basis with the Working Group and coming up with decision/actions for issues that can be resolved at that level.
iii) Informing the Steering Committee of serious cases within an appropriate time frame.
iv) Reporting to the aggrieved parties about developments regarding their grievances and decisions of the Steering Committee.
v) Providing inputs into the Monitoring and Evaluation process It will be important that all PAPs along the road have access to the grievance process. b) Specific tasks of the GO
i) Set up a systematic process of recording grievances in a register (―Grievance Book‖) as well as electronically. Upon request PAPS may view the log of their grievance.
ii) Record both written and verbally communicated grievances.
iii) Categorize issues in 3-4 broad categories in order to review and resolve them more efficiently. Suggested categories are grievances regarding:
1. Replacement structure or land, and procurement of construction materials; 2. Agriculture and crops; 3. Livelihoods; and 4. Valuation process and payment of compensation.
iv) Prepare a database for recording and keeping track of the grievances and
how they were resolved. The database should be a ‗living‘ document, updated weekly. It should also record the status of each grievance. Access to making entries into the database should be restricted to the implementation team, but the PAP will be able to obtain feedback on the status of his/her grievance at any time.
v) Communicate the grievance procedure to people, process of recording their complaints and timelines for redress. Communication will be provided during household disclosure process and to community leaders. Information will also be provided to affected persons outlining procedures and commitments of the grievance mechanism.
vi) Raise grievances at the regular Implementation Team meeting for discussion.
Some resolutions will require coordination/ interaction with the local authorities, which the GO should follow up, while some would require intervention from UNRA.
c) Capacity building of the GO Since his/her role is crucial in ensuring that the RAP process is transparent, UNRA will select the GO not only based on educational qualifications and experience, but also commitment. A flawed grievance process can disrupt the RAP process, leading to resentment and dissatisfaction among affected communities.
P a g e | 57
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Depending on the GO‘s experience, the capacity building for the GO may require initial orientation and a follow-up training program. In such cases, training should include the following:
Use of computers and maintenance of databases to record and update the Grievance Register,
Effective use of communication mediums and methods to interact with the community as well as for conflict resolution, and
Coordination with relevant stakeholders which may include the implementation team, contract team, or local authorities.
The grievance process to be followed is depicted in figure below. Figure 8.1: Grievance management mechanism
8.3 SPECIFIC PROCESS FOR ADDRESSING VALUATION GRIEVANCES
8.3.1 Valuation In addition to the overall management process for grievances, there are likely to be grievances specifically related to the valuation process. These are likely to come when households consider compensation values for their assets insufficient. This might arise when PAPs doubt if valuation values do indeed provide replacement value. If PAPs misunderstood the compensation process and believe they are entitled to additional compensation, they might lodge complaints. Given this, the Project has developed a dedicated procedure to manage and close out grievances relating to valuation.
Local Leaders, UNRA – SEO, Construction
Contractor, Valuer
Grievance Database
Grievance Officer and Independent Organization
Host Community Affected Residents
Grievances/issues
Response
Key:
File grievance Communicate decision
Yes
No
Can it be resolved?
No Yes
Is it resolved?
Grievance Committee,
UNRA
Can it be resolved?
Executive Director UNRA
Yes
No
P a g e | 58
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
8.3.2 Valuation grievance decision making procedures While some grievances would be resolved by the committee, others might not, such as when the claimant contests District property or crop rates. Therefore the Grievance Officer (―GO‖) will determine whether a complaint can be resolved by the committee or, if not, should be referred to the Chief Government Valuer (―CGV‖). i) If no, the GO refers the complaint to the CGV. ii) The CGV refers then grievance to the valuer who then returns to the surveyor to
obtain clarification. If no settlement is achieved at this stage, the aggrieved person can resort to the judicial process.
iii) If the complaint concerns the road contractor, the Grievance Officer refers such a complaint to UNRA Management.
P a g e | 59
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
9 IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RAP
9.1 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS
9.1.1 RAP IMPLEMENTATION UNIT
For any road works to commence, affected people must be compensated before taking
their land or demolishing structures. Working together with local government officials,
UNRA will put in place a dedicated unit headed by one of its managers, to implement this
RAP. The unit will be responsible for ensuring that affected persons have succeeded in
restoring their livelihoods after relocation.
In addition, the groups that will be involved in the implementation of the RAP include the
following:
a) UNRA (project proponent).
b) Kamwenge and Kabarole District and local administration with regular consultations
and briefings with political and technical offices, as follows:
Political representative of the LC5 Office (District Council Representative).
Social and technical representative of the local administration (District Council
Representative) Local council leaders of affected villages.
Local council leaders of affected villages.
Table 9.1: Local Administrative Advisors to the Implementation Unit
Proposed persons Number Total
Sub-county Chief 1 2
LC 3 Chairperson 1
Town Clerk (or his representative) 1 2
Town Planner 1
Sub-county Chief 1 2
LC 3 Chairperson 1
c) Valuer on ―as-needed‖ basis.
d) Independent Organization (NGO)
Note that the political leadership of the District would mainly serve as witnesses to the
RAP implementation process. A technical representative, preferably from the District
Land Office or Social Development Office could be useful in providing on-the-spot
technical answers to PAPs, at the payment desk, when necessary.
Figure 4 shows the structure of proposed RAP implementation unit. A senior management
committee will generally oversee the resettlement process, to guide and assist day to day
activities undertaken by the main implementation unit. They will work together to ensure
that measures identified in the RAP are acceptable to stakeholders, and that
implementation of the RAP is undertaken in a responsible and efficient manner. Before
P a g e | 60
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
resettlement, the groups will be responsible for planning implementation of the RAP,
communicating compensation measures identified in the RAP to PAPs and dealing with the
day to day activities associated with grievances. After the RAP, the unit will be
responsible for the ongoing monitoring and grievance process, and ensuring that PAPs are
fully assisted in restoring their lives.
Figure 9.1: Proposed RAP implementation unit
The implementation unit will comprise a Core Unit responsible for day-to-day operations
and an Advisory Unit. Composition of respective the units will be as follows:
i) Core Unit will comprise the following:
a) Implementation Team
- Implementation Manager (1)
- Implementation Officer (1)
- Monitoring Officer (1)
- Administrators (3)
b) UNRA Director (1)
c) Valuers (1)
d) Independent Organization/ NGO
Implementation and Advisory Unit
• UNRA representatives
• Local Council Leaders (LC 3 chairpersons, Sub-county chief, Sub-county Accountant)
• Valuer (as needed)
• District Local Government Core Unit
• Implementation Team
•UNRA Director (1)
•Valuers (1)
•Independent Organization/ NGO
Senior Management Unit Includes senior representatives from UNRA, Valuer and local government.
External Consultants (monitoring &
evaluation)
Construction Contractors
Responsibilities include:
Overseeing resettlement and rehabilitation
Allocation of appropriate resources Resolving major grievances Budget control Reviewing monitoring/evaluation
reports
Input from all affected people- both those who are being resettled, and from any other interested parties (e.g. host community)
Responsibilities include:
Consultation with residents Planning and implementing
entitlement measures Payment of compensation Responding to grievances Undertake monitoring activities Regular reporting to the Senior
Management
Key:
Two way flow of information
Reporting Requirements
P a g e | 61
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
In addition, administrative support may be required to support this team.
ii) Advisory Unit will constitute the following:
a) District Administration (2 part time)
b) Local Council Leaders of Affected Villages (6 part time)
Role of the Implementation Officer
The Implementation Officer will be responsible for implementation of the RAP prior to the
move and during the move. The key responsibilities will include:
a) Coordinating and planning to payment of cash compensation (for those who have
chosen Option 1)
b) Coordinating with the construction contractors on scheduling the move (for those who
have chosen Option 2).
c) Organizing and implementing non cash compensation measures such as assistance to
move etc
d) Sensitizing the Contractors about the resettlement process and setting up mutually
acceptable clear guidelines on do‘s and don‘ts.
e) Consultation with the community on a regular basis.
f) Establishing a resettlement database, to be regularly updated and accessible by the
community.
g) Verifying functionality of utilities in houses with home owners (for those who have
chosen Option 2).
h) Assisting in external and internal monitoring and evaluation of the resettlement
process.
Given the construction schedule and the need to have the RAP implemented as soon as
possible, the role of the implementation office could be shared by more than one
individual to ensure that tasks are undertaken in adequate time. However, all members of
the implementation team will need to work together to ensure that tasks are completed in
the most efficient manner.
9.2 PAYMENT PROCEDURE
9.2.1 NOTIFICATION OF COMPENSATION
Before receiving their compensation, each PAP will receive an individual household
entitlement matrix. The household entitlement matrix will indicate details of the final
valuation and compensation, including the following:
i) Confirmation of the choice of options by the PAP.
ii) The amount approved by the Chief Government Valuer.
iii) A description of the methods used, including specifics of the valuation of structures,
crops and land.
iv) The additional measures to be paid by the project, such as transitional or transport
allowance, and also detail the other support offered by the Project, such as relocation
assistance.
P a g e | 62
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
v) The total cash compensation payable.
vi) Information on the grievance procedure.
vii) Information regarding documents required to claim compensation (such as original
documentation or passport photos).
viii) Confirmation that if the PAP chooses to open a bank account to receive compensation,
how, where and when this can be done, and that all charges associated with this will
be paid by the Project.
ix) Upon receiving the individual entitlement matrix, the PAP must sign acceptance of
their entitlement choices. In addition, the claimant will be asked for identification.
Thereafter, all PAPs will be provided a two-week period in which they can modify their
choices.
In cases where the Mailo landowners do not reside in project areas:
UNRA will check with those currently on the land to identify their location.
If this fails, UNRA will place advertisements in national papers or radios etc. in an
attempt to inform the Mailo land owners about their entitlements to compensation.
P a g e | 63
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Payment Logistics a) Payment Days: Days on which PAPs receive payment will depend on payment days assigned to the PAPs‘ respective villages. Payment will be disbursed to PAPS two villages per day (―Village Payment Days‖). Heads of households should be accompanied by spouses to receive compensation payments. However, if a spouse is unable to come along then claimant should carry a letter signed by the spouse to this effect. In the case of polygamous households, UNRA will encourage all their spouses to be present during compensation payments. Complaints arising from such compensation will be addressed under the grievance process. UNRA will ensure that communities are made aware of this during community interactions. If a PAP misses their respective ―Village Payment Days‖ – the PAP must make special arrangements with their LC1s to collect their payment. However, every effort will be made by the Project to ensure that households are available on their allocated payment days and thus it is anticipated that this will apply in very few cases. b) Location Disbursements will be handed out at a local bank (―Disbursement Location‖) and a transport refund provided for all PAPs that travel to receive payment. c) Present at location At least three of the following representatives will present at the Disbursement Location:
UNRA representative Representatives of the local administration A representative of the district administration
d) Tracking payment: To track payments, photographs of all PAPs will taken, which will be entered into the compensation log. e) Payment by Installment Payment will be made by UNRA or its appointed agent. On payment, a receipt will be signed by the payee, payer/ UNRA representative and a local administration witness. Ugandan law requires that compensation be accomplished before entry onto private property. So where payment in several installments is preferred (as a mitigation of the risk of cash misuse, which could affect female spouses and children), this contradiction can be overcome as follows: i) Obtain a written consent from compensation recipients for their payment to be
made in installments rather than as a ―one-off‖. ii) Sign a compensation agreement that clearly indicates a payment schedule rather
than lumpsum payment.
P a g e | 64
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Where payment will be made in installments, compensation certificates and agreements should include the detailed schedule of payments. Signatories of the compensation agreements should the compensation Recipient and UNRA representative, and be witnessed by a member of the parish land committee.
f) Exceptional Situations
Deceased Owners: Up-to-date documentation must be obtained prior to payment of
compensation. All charges for this will be reimbursed by the Project upon receipt of
adequate proof of such costs. PAPs will be informed of the documentation required during
disclosure, so as to prepare them in adequate advance.
Joint Owners: Before compensation is affected to one of joint owners, a signed letter
must be presented showing that the other parties have consented that the said person
receives payment on their behalf.
Disputed Ownership: In case of disputes during RAP implementation, ownership of a
property has to be verified by a letter from the local village council (LC1) and this letter is
one of requirements on compensation day. Ownership of a disputed property is resolved by
a land committee (at Sub-country level) together with local council (LC) leadership of the
village in which the property is located. The structure for resolving such disputes are
already in place within the local government administration system. If these free
structures fail, a person resorts to courts of law.
9.2.2 COMPENSATION UNDER THE DIFFERENT OPTIONS While the nature of compensation is different under both entitlement options, the process for the payment of compensation will be the same in terms of notification to residents, documents required and development of household entitlement matrix. However due to the nature of replacement assets, some different arrangements will need to be made for those who chose Option 2 (replacement assets). At this stage, the number of people who will chose this option is unknown and thus it is difficult to plan a systematic approach to the payment of all compensation. It is envisaged that affected persons are likely to have different needs for the nature of replacement assets and therefore measures need to be developed to meet individual household needs. The Project however, commits to the following principles for replacing assets:
Cash compensation (e.g. transport, transition allowance) will be paid in the same manner as for those choosing Option 1;
The households will be involved in the design of any replacement structures and in the location of replacement land; and
Close communication with each household will be maintained throughout the entire period where assets are to be replaced, to ensure that the timing and arrangement are clear to all PAPs.
9.2.3 MUTATION OF COMPENSATED LAND Upon payment, Mutation Forms will be filled and Letters of Surrender issued to Title Deed holders. From the title deeds, land compensated by the project will be mutated and its ownership henceforth reverts to Uganda Government as a road reserve.
P a g e | 65
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
9.2.4 IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE
The RAP implementation schedule is proposed over a period of 12 months during which monitoring would be undertaken throughout the construction period and for extra two years after construction. The RAP implementation unit and local committees would be formed shortly afterward approval of valuation report by CGV‘s office. Compensation payments, rehabilitation assistance and grievance redress is anticipated to start at about the same time and extend over 9 months including the 3-months to vacate. UNRA will ensure that PAPs have adequate time to replace their assets and will work with them to make sure that they are able to do so before expiry of the notice to vacate affected property. The implementation schedule below covers all resettlement activities from preparation through implementation, including target dates for achievement of expected benefits.
Months
Project actions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
a) RAP approval.
b) RAP disclosure.
c) 3 months notice to leave
d) Grievances management.
e) Compensation payment.
f) RAP monitoring
g) RAP completion audit
Note: “---“ indicates continuous activity. Grievances are expected to arise any time from disclosure through payment, construction and beyond (during monitoring and evaluation). They should thus be treated as such during RAP implementation.
9.3 RESETTLEMENT BUDGET
The compensation and resettlement budget was based on valuation surveyor‘s
computations of value of affected land, structures and businesses, approval by Uganda‘s
Chief Government Valuer, top-up payments to meet World Bank Guidelines and
administrative costs of implementing the Resettlement Action Plan. The resettlement
budget according to Uganda laws is shown in Table 9.
P a g e | 66
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Table 9: Resettlement budget
District Value of land (UgShs) A
Value of building (UgShs) B
Value of trees, crops (UgShs) C
15% Disturbance Allowance (UgShs) D =15%(A+B+C)
3% of crops value for livelihood restoration due to crop loss
(UgShs). 1
E=3%(C)
6% of value of buildings for income restoration due to loss of businesses/
business structures. 2
F=6%(B)
Total Compensation Award (UgShs)
1 KAMWENGE 629,635,849 804,177,278 276,122,500 256,490,344 8,283,675.00 48,250,636.68 2,022,960,283
2 KABAROLE 378,863,478 628,213,326 87,213,326 164,126,155 2,616,399.78 37,692,799.56 1,298,725,484
Subtotal 1 3,321,685,767
Other costs
1 RAP implementation
consultant 3
300,000,000
2 Monitoring & evaluation
100,000,000
3 Provisional sum for special assistance to vulnerable people
50,000,000
Subtotal 2 450,000,000
Grand total (subtotal 1 + subtotal 2)
3,771,685,767
1: Livelihood restoration related to loss of crops but minimal impact on crops will occur since affected land is in existing road reserve. 2: Income restoration in regard to impacted commercial buildings and businesses. 3: provisional sum for RAP implementation. Actual figure to be determined by competitive bidding.
P a g e | 67
10 MONITORING, EVALUATION AND COMPLETION AUDIT
The purpose of monitoring and evaluation for this RAP will be to report about the effectiveness of the implementation of the RAP, covering resettlement, disbursement of compensation and effectiveness of public involvement, amongst others. Monitoring and purposeful evaluation will be key factors for successful resettlement activities. Monitoring will also entail evaluation of effectiveness of the grievance management process. Therefore sections below present the proposed Monitoring and Evaluation Framework for the implementation this RAP, including a plan for monitoring and evaluation of the compensation packages with indicators for measuring performance, impacts and outcomes. This plan also provides for reviews by stakeholders including the World Bank. The Framework includes a review of financial disbursements, compensation complaints and grievance redress, adherence to compensation payment schedule, support of vulnerable PAPs.
10.1 GENERAL OBJECTIVES AND APPROACH
The Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) mechanism provides a basis to assess overall success and effectiveness of various resettlement processes and measures. This mechanism is based on two components:
a) Internal monitoring – undertaken by the implementation unit / Monitoring Officer; and,
b) External evaluations –by WB and other national stakeholders. 10.1.1 Internal monitoring process
10.1.1.1 Overview
Overall objectives and tasks of the internal monitoring process are: Identification of suitable indicators; Measurement of indicators at appropriate intervals; Creation of a mechanism to analyze M&E data against a pre-resettlement baseline; and Set up a system to regularly respond to M&E findings by adapting existing measures or by
modifying implementation processes. This monitoring process will be used to analyze progress and change at regular intervals. It shall be linked to the various stages of the RAP, as follows:- a) During resettlement During resettlement, M&E should focus on resettlement issues such as: Number of families that have been compensated; Number of people who have acquired legal papers to new property, Number of business owners who have restored their businesses, Efficiency and effectiveness of grievance redress mechanism.
P a g e | 68
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
b) After resettlement Post resettlement monitoring should focus on rehabilitation issues and status on each of the measures should be assessed, for example: Success level of restoration of livelihoods Success level of restoration of assets Efficiency and effectiveness of grievance redress mechanism.
10.1.1.2 Key Activities and Responsibilities
i) Set up a system: The RAP implementation team will provide a monitoring form to be
completed monthly by the M&E officer at each sub-county. The forms will cover aspects in Section 10.1.1 above. The information collected will be entered in an existing database at UNRA for further analysis and compilation into quarterly reports.
ii) Ongoing Monitoring: The M&E Officer for each location will be in-charge of regular
monitoring of the implementation process. This will involve:
a) Feedback and inputs from the Implementation Officers. b) Reviewing of the resettlement database. c) Receiving reports from Grievance Officer and of the grievance database. d) Receiving information from local representatives. e) Direct consultation with the resettled community at each location.
iii) Monthly reports: Consolidated monthly reports with key findings from the on-going
monitoring should be submitted to the implementation team and discussed every month and action points determined. This monthly progress review should aim to ensure that important issues are immediately rectified.
iv) Vulnerability assessment: It is essential that vulnerability is closely monitored in
order to provide timely support to susceptible households. A vulnerability assessment shall occur as part of quarterly auditing of all households, and those households that are most vulnerable shall be prioritized for monthly auditing and targeted assistance. This may be undertaken by the implementation Officer. Key activities are:
a) Develop a set of criteria to identify vulnerable households (Note that this is
intended to act as a guideline only and should be modified as appropriate). b) Every three months visit vulnerable households to assess key needs/ issues (e.g.
unemployment) with the rehabilitation process. c) Develop a plan to address these issues in conjunction with the members of the
household.
10.1.2 EXTERNAL EVALUATION PROCESS 10.2.1.1 Overview
In addition to the internal monitoring process, external assessment of the resettlement process should be undertaken through an external evaluation agency appointed by UNRA. The external evaluation process will be informed by internal monitoring reports prepared by
P a g e | 69
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
UNRA, and also through independent surveys and consultation conducted by the evaluation agency. The evaluation system will be based on: a) Process indicators that measure effectiveness of processes (consultation, grievance) and
inputs like people, equipment and materials and identify areas where improvements to existing processes are required. These may include the following:
Transparency of the implementation process. Adequacy of staff and capacity of the implementation agencies. Compliance of the resettlement process with Ugandan law and World Bank
standards. Effectiveness of the Grievance Process. Adequacy and effectiveness of public involvement. Effectiveness of the internal monitoring mechanism.
b) Outcome indicators will assess effectiveness of the resettlement and changes that have
occurred to the communities‘ standard of living. Key indicators are outlined in Table below.
Table 10.1: Monitoring indicators during resettlement (quarterly basis)
Category Indicator
Fund disbursement
Number of PAPs paid Amount of money disbursed Number of PAPs not paid in prescribed time (respective quarter) Reasons for not paying PAPs who are due for payment Projected disbursements in the next quarter
Restoration of and assets livelihoods
Number of PAPs who have reconstructed dwellings Reasons for not reconstructing dwellings Number of commercial buildings replaced Reasons for not reconstructing commercial buildings Number of businesses restored Reasons for not re-establishing businesses
Public involvement
Number of community level meetings Participation of local leaders and community in resettlement process
Grievance management
Number of grievances received Number of grievances resolved (at what level) Number of complaints reported to other government oversight bodies and outcomes
including how grievance was resolved Number of grievances refereed to Uganda Courts of Law Number of outstanding grievances and reasons for not resolving them
Custody of legal documents
Land title deeds received Land title returned to owners
Resettlement of vulnerable PAPs
Number of vulnerable PAPs resettled Kind of special assistance provided
10.2.1.2 Key activities and responsibilities
UNRA will liaise with relevant ministries (MoLGD, MoFPED, World Bank, CGV‘s office) to
undertake external evaluation of resettlement mid-term and at end of resettlement.
These evaluations will focus on reviewing the process to-date and making necessary
recommendations for modification to existing rehabilitation measures and other processes
P a g e | 70
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
(e.g. grievance). This will allow modifications to the process to be benefit the remainder of
the resettlement.
They will also focus on assessing impact and effectiveness of the resettlement. UNRA will
conduct a rapid socio-economic survey, based on a sample of the total number of PAPs to
establish effectiveness of resettlement.
RAP monitoring will also involve Local government offices such as the district Community
Development Officer (CDO) who is mandated to address social issues including community
mobilization. For this role, the district CDO can work with Assistant Community Development
Officer (ACDO) at sub-county level. UNRA will identify and train NGOs to undertake
monitoring of the RAP implementation consultant and report regularly. It is noted however
that local government structures (district and sub-county level) do not usually have the
required knowledge and skills to support RAP implementation and monitoring, hence the
project should them with transport and other necessary financial facilitation. UNRA will
therefore sensitize the concerned district staff and other stakeholders about this RAP and its
implementation requirements. This activity will be catered for under the budget line of RAP
monitoring and evaluation (Table 9.1, Section 9.3).
During RAP implementation UNRA will submit to World Bank quarterly RAP implementation
progress reports.
10.2.1.3 RAP completion report
After completion of resettlement, a final report will be submitted by UNRA to World Bank
prior to preparation of the project implementation report. The report shall indicate
effectiveness of project implementation and disbursement of compensation payments,
effectiveness of public consultations and socio-economic impacts of the road on roadside
communities. This report will give overall assessment of the RAP process indicating activities
undertaken, success of mitigation action and monitoring and well as useful lessons learnt.
10.1.3 COMPLETION AUDIT
A key aim of resettlement is to ensure compensation and other mitigation measures restore or
enhance affected people‘s quality of life and income levels. If affected PAPs quality of life
can be demonstrated to have been restored, the resettlement and compensation process can
be deemed ―complete‖.
The purpose of Completion Audit will therefore be to establish whether UNRA implemented
all activities needed to ensure compliance with proposed resettlement commitments and
applicable national and World Bank requirements.
The completion audit will be based on progress indicators and on outcome evaluation
indicators and shall aim to answer the following questions:
Have the objectives of the RAP been reached in terms of:
P a g e | 71
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Compensation for all impacts of all affected people,
Timely delivery of entitlements and compliance with Uganda‘s and WB resettlement
requirements,
Has compensation been fair and adequate to mitigate social impacts,
Have livelihoods been restored.
P a g e | 72
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Annex 1. Review comments addressed in this updated RAP
Comments on the September 2008 Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) for Kamwenge – Fort Portal. Date: 24th February 2010
Introduction The Resettlement Action Plan for Nyakahita – Ibanda – Fort Portal Road was prepared covering most of the important key parameters of a RAP. A detailed Valuation report and strip maps were submitted together with the RAP. Considering the sensitivity of the issue and the need to efficiently carry out the resettlement during land acquisition, there is need for additional information to beef up the report. It should be noted that cosmpensation for expropriated assets requires little more than the identification of eligible persons, the establishment of compensation rates and a one-time payment process. Resettlement by contrast may require attention to many potentially relevant variables or the synchronized or coordinated action of many agencies over an extended period of time. Therefore the comments presented here below cover the additional information required to ensure the adequacy of the RAP to enable systematic resettlement of PAPs. Please note that particular emphasis to address these comments will be put mainly on the RAP for Kamwenge – Fort Portal Section of the road. 1. Change in title: The road section to be covered is Kamwenge -Fort Portal road only. Hence delete all information and costs related to the Nyakahita - Ibanda section. 2. Executive Summary: Although this section of the RAP is included, it does not mention the salient points of the main reports e.g. the numbers of people affected and budget. 3. List of Acronyms followed by a table of contents: The list of acronyms is presented; however as the report is to be updated, changes should be adequately taken care of. 4. Background of the Project and why the RAP is being prepared: Sections 1.1 and 1.2 on pages 12 & 13 presents the project background and objectives of the RAP; however, it does not give the background to the sector in relation to the policy legal and regulatory framework for undertaking the project as per the WB guidelines. 5. Potential Impacts: The impacts for all categories of people need to be outlined. People lose
various assets as a result of upgrading- realigning, expansion, etc of a road. The categories/ types of
losses need to be well presented in table form and then paragraphs to follow the tables explaining.
Data presented on page 36 and on page 50 shows the numbers who will lose structure/assets per
district. Data presented is desegregated by type e.g. permanent, semi-permanent, grass thatched,
crops, hedges etc. Although data on losses of commercial or residential structures is presented in the
valuation lists, it should have been in the RAP narrative form
6. The RAP should have contained the following information on the PAPs which is not included;
Number of people who will lose residential or commercial land only;
Number of people who will partially lose part of their structure;
Number of people who are tenants in the affected structure;
Number of people who have leases on certain buildings/structures from the owners;
Number of people who will lose of standing crops and trees; this information can be extrapolated from the Valuation list
Number of inhabitants in townships who will lose houses
Number of industries, e.g. milk cooling plants, cotton/coffee stores, ginneries, mines affected
P a g e | 73
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Number of rural teachers, retired people and workers who will lose houses);
Loss of public infrastructure and other community or shared assets nos. of PAPs with permanent land use rights, marginally and severely affected;
Data on sections where resettlement will be practiced although is contained in the strip maps, it should have been included in a narrative form in the RAP.
7. Socio-economic studies (Baseline Information): Broader detailed social-economic data is presented, as captured from secondary documents. However the following information is not included;
There is no census report of the PAPs capturing their specific social economic characteristics.
The survey conducted broadly covered the project area; Specific impact survey on each PAPs livelihood and property was not documented
Physical displacement will be inevitable and therefore relocation/resettlement of these PAPs
will be necessary. And therefore the modalities should have been documented in the report.
A report on Social Impact Assessment (SIA) covering both direct and indirect impacts of the project is contained on pages 41-44 and is also contained in the section reporting on the socio-economic studies however analysis of land allocation mechanisms, issues raised by different tenure systems is lacking.
The impact on patterns of social interaction, social networks and social support systems in the
affected communities was not captured in the report.
Information on Social and cultural characteristics of affected communities presented on Page 38 section 311 lacks socio-economic analysis.
The impact on patterns of social interaction, social networks and social support systems in the
affected communities was not captured in the report.
The socio-economic questionnaire contained in the report is incomplete, it lacks basic details e.g. questionnaire details, household details and basic demographic characteristics (could be the first pages of the questionnaire fell off) contains a lot of irrelevant questions e.g. in sections covering environments etc and omits a lot of relevant information e.g. on gender, employment, markets, HIV/AIDS.
8. Vulnerable PAPs: A description of the vulnerable/disadvantaged groups is presented in section 3.8 page 37 and detailed information on vulnerable individuals and groups is contained in appendix 5 on page 93-97, however, the consultant did not present the data on vulnerable groups in numbers and the nature of vulnerability. Further the RAP should also show how the vulnerable will be assisted. What kind of measures are there for them in addition to what everyone else is getting? This should be including the protection of orphans, women and children during compensation (to avoid men receiving the money and taking off with new wives, etc.)
9. Legal, Policy and Regulatory Framework. The Consultant documented the findings of an analysis of the legal framework, covering, (Section 2 on pages 18-26) including remedies and judicial process available to displaced persons, however, this should be referring to both the national laws that relate to acquisition of land, compensation, the displaced, agencies responsible and the World Bank Policy 4.12 Involuntary Resettlement. The section should also do an analysis of what is applicable and the differences between the national laws and the Bank policy and the actions to fill those gaps that have been identified. Usually this comparison is made in a table form with 3 columns where the third column shows how the differences will be bridged. Please note that the Indigenous Peoples policy, O.P 4.10 is not part of a RAP.
P a g e | 74
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Please note that there are other laws that are applicable in this case e.g. Customary law governing
land ownership is recognized in the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda and it covered under section
2.5, page 27 of the report. It should also be noted that there are no customary laws governing
valuation of assets and losses, compensation and natural resource usage rights, customary personal law
related to displacement and environmental laws and social welfare legislation, however there are
certain by-laws and norms and customary practices that would be applicable in the case of this project
and therefore should have been documented;
No direct laws and regulations relating to the agencies responsible for implementing resettlement activities were analyzed but implementation of resettlement is guided by the relevant policies analyzed in the report; Certain laws such as The Local Government Act that empowers the LC system to carry out their functions relates to this project and the implementation of RAP therefore should have been considered. 10. Iinstitutional Framework /Implementation arrangements: The Institutional framework/implementation arrangement is presented in section 2.2 as institutional responsibility. However, agencies/NGO/civil organizations that could play a critical role in the implementation of the RAP were not identified. There is no information on the assessment of the institutional capacity of such agencies and NGOs; and any steps that are proposed to enhance their institutional capacity to participate in the implementation of the RAP 11. Eligibility Although the affected persons eligible for compensation were identified and documented, there is no definition/explanation in the report 12. Valuation of and Compensation for Losses: The methodology to be used in valuing losses to determine their replacement cost and a description of the proposed types and levels of compensation presented in section 6, pages 48-58. However this should be refined to include more details such as the GOU guidelines for each category. 13. Consultations: These are done with the project affected people and not only district officers for purposes of the RAP. This is when the PAPs get to know the objectives of the project and implications on them and their assets. The PAPs also get to know what options of resettlement are available to them. Further in the report there are no views of the project affected people and it is not clear if any of their concerns have been integrated in the measures outlined in the RAP. Please note that resettlement does not mean displacement and relocation in the literal sense but loss of physical and economic assets and the measures that follow to help restore the affected people's livelihoods. 14. Resettlement Measures This section is missing in the report. This section should provide the entitlements that each category of PAP would receive according to the options available and the informed choices made. An entitlement matrix would also help in clarifying issues in this section There should be a description in the report of the packages of compensation and other resettlement measures that will assist each category of eligible displaced persons to achieve the objectives of the policy.
15. Site Selection, Site Preparation and Relocation: Although only small portions of land and a few building will be acquired, there will be cases where both residential and commercial building will have to be removed, and cases where at least 20% on a persons land is affected, it‘s the requirement of the WB that the total land is compensated. In all these cases, physical displacement will be inevitable and therefore relocation of these PAPs will be necessary. And therefore this should have been documented in the report.
P a g e | 75
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
16. Grievance Procedures: A proposal for settlement mechanism for disputes arising from resettlement is contained in section 2.7 on page 28. However the grievance mechanism needs to be more elaborate bringing in structures and systems that the local people can use in case of a complaint or problem. The issue is not to have the mechanism when the complaint arises but have it outlined following the normal process in the country, including the resorting to the Uganda Courts of Law if everything else fails. 17. Organizational Responsibilities: The consultant did not present the organizational framework for implementing the RAP (Spelling out roles and responsibilities) The Consultant should present the organizational frame work for implementing resettlement , including identification of agencies responsible for delivery of resettlement measures and provisions of services , arrangements to ensure appropriate coordination between agencies and jurisdictions involved in implementation and any measures (including technical assistance) needed to strengthen the implementing agencies 18. Implementation Schedule: The Consultant prepared an implementation schedule however it should cover all resettlement activities from preparation through implementation, including target dates for the achievement of expected benefits 19. Total costs. Revise according to section of road to be upgrade without Nyakahita - Ibanda. Include costs of a monitoring agency as part of the RAP implementation. 20. Monitoring and Evaluation Framework: This is the monitoring of the RAP and not post project monitoring. Therefore the monitoring indicators and the agencies responsible should reflect that. In this section include the reporting, which is quarterly progress reports and the RAP ICR. Although some indicators are included in the report, there is need for more technical input on this section, an M&E framework should have been included clearly indicating the parameters to be monitored, the monitoring indicators and performance/evaluation indicators The purpose of monitoring and evaluation is to report on the effectiveness of the implementation of the RAP, covering physical resettlement, disbursement of compensation and effectiveness of public consultation, amongst others. 21. Other observations
The report does not cover the cutoff date
Important information on land acquisition such as total land to be affected e.g. per district is not included.
Comments from review of updated RAP (Oct-Nov 2010)
Comment Consultant Rejoinder
1 Please ask the consultant to make a list of the 2530 PAPs, i.e. their names, village, sub-county, district and nature of losses, i.e. land or structure or both or crops, etc. This info can be obtained from the larger list that goes to CGV. It is a requirement that the census that gives the Project affected people and their estimated losses is in the RAP. However in this case we have not asked for the entitlements because we know that this is in the detailed report that goes to the CGV of which we get a copy.
The list of PAPs has been provided as Annex 6
2 The consultant is expected to give the current valuation rates for the assets because it is on this that the entitlements and estimated RAP budget is made. Therefore a table indicating these rates in the various districts traversed by the road is very important.
Current valuation rates of Kabarole District have been presented in Annex 5. (It was established from the valuation consultant that these rates were used for
P a g e | 76
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
property valuation in both Kabarole and Kamwenge district since the latter‘s were out of date at that time).
3 There is need for a clarification. Will all structures (commercial and residential) be compensated in money terms only or did the affected also choose other options like getting building materials? They will also be allowed to salvage their materials from the demolished houses.
For ground truthing surveys done during RAP update, affected people preferred cash compensation but yes they would have liberty to salvage construction materials or any material they desire from affected structures. (Refer to Sec below excerpted from RAP report). Section 6.3.1.3 Part c) Owners and tenants of temporary structures Affected persons may salvage building materials at their own cost from old structures for reuse elsewhere.
P a g e | 77
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Annex 2. Location of community resources along the road
a) Places of worship along the road
Waypoint
GPS coordinates*
Altitude (m) Facility Easting Northing
13 197559 71757 1524 Entrance to Full Gospel Church, Kabarole
14 197618 71690 1528 Branch off to Bukwali Catholic Church
20 198891 69305 1532 Entrance to Munazzamat Al-dawa Al-islamiyya Mosque and School
22 198928 69264 1534 Entrance to St. Jude Tadeos Catholic Church
34 200111 67502 1524 Branch off to St. Peter's Catholic Church, Kanyambeho
35 200250 67217 1515 Entrance to Kanyambeho Full Gospel Church
42 200604 64959 1507 Branch off to Kigarama Full Gospel Church
43 200591 64947 1509 Branch off to Kigarama Mosque
44 200515 64591 1502 Branch off to Canon Apolo Core P.T.C & St. Mary Kigarama Catholic Sub parish
47 200451 64095 1497 Entrance to Parish Community Centre
48 200502 63976 1498 Entrance to Kasisi Seventh day Adventist Church
53 202229 61174 1508 Entrance to Kyaibombo Full Gospel Church
57 202580 57212 1471 Branch off to Rweteera Primary School & St. Adolf Rweteera Catholic Church
59 203131 56450 1432 Entrance to Rweteera Christian Fellowship Church
60 203094 55918 1424 Entrance to Seventh day adventist church, Rweteera
79 212289 43201 1250 Branch off to Rwengobe Primary School & St. John C.O.U, Rwengobe
91 213376 38678 1251 Entrance to Rugonjo Seventh day Adventist Church. (Still under construction)
92 213354 38475 1248 Branch off to St. Luke C.O.U. Nyabugando, Kyabenda Parish Church (0.5km)
94 213546 37966 1244 Entrance to Mutamba Catholic Church
100 215472 36092 1254 Entrance to St. George Church & Kyabenda Primary School
101 215460 36084 1254 Entrance to Kahanga Full Gospel Church
106 216029 35539 1231 Entrance to Kahunge Catholic Parish
115 216702 31849 1301 Entrance to Kyakanyemera Catholic Church
134 216361 24996 1248 Entrance to Businge Mosque (Alternate entrance)
135 216374 24950 1253 Branch off to Businge Mosque
138 216449 24554 1256 Entrance to Businge Church of Uganda
151 216944 21230 1308 Entrance to St. Stephen's Cathedral, Church of Uganda
155 216802 20702 1284 Entrance to Kamwenge Catholic Parish. Opposite is the Church social hall
160 216479 20029 1287 Branch off to Mosque & Mirambi K Primary School opposite this is a Clinic
*Global positioning system
P a g e | 78
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
b) Schools along the road
Waypoint
GPS coordinates Altitude (m) Facility Easting Northing
15 197976 71036 1533 Entrance to Bukwali Primary School
20 198891 69305 1532 Entrance to Munazzamat Al-dawa Al-islamiyya Mosque and School
24 198987 69243 1531 Entrance to Shalom Junior School
26 199235 69088 1539 Branch off to Good Shepherd Special School & Ibaale Senior Secondary School
28 199377 68867 1552 Branch off to Haibaale Primary School
34 200111 67502 1524 Branch off to St. Peter's Catholic Church, Kanyambeho
39 201176 65993 1516 Branch off to Kiko Primary School & Kiko Tea Estate
40 200889 65411 1511 Entrance to Divine Mercy Senior Secondary School
44 200515 64591 1502 Branch off to Canon Apolo Core P.T.C & St. Mary Kigarama Catholic Sub parish
46 200497 64428 1501 Branch off to Kigarama Talents High School
57 202580 57212 1471 Branch off to Rweteera Primary School & St. Adolf Rweteera Catholic Church
62 202910 55519 1414 Entrance to Nursery School
64 203150 54563 1423
Major branch off to Iruhuura (5km) & Pere Achte Primary Schools, Pere Achte S.S (31km), St. Luke Iruhuura Health centre III (5km) plus St. Karoli Lwanga Isonga Catholic sub parish and St. Peter's C.O.U Iruhuura Parish
72 211125 45450 1238 Branch off to Nyabubale Primary School (1.5km)
76 211739 44811 1249 Branch off to Bigodi Primary School
78 211862 44152 1237 Branch off to Bigodi Secondary School (4km)
79 212289 43201 1250 Branch off to Rwengobe Primary School & St. John C.O.U, Rwengobe
85 213491 39431 1258 Branch off to Rugonjo Primary School (100m)
86 213484 39368 1257 Branch off to Rugonjo Moslem Primary School & Mosque
87 213456 39159 1261 Entrance to Unique Prime Academy, Rugonjo.(Not registered)
98 214874 36228 1248 Branch off to Nkarakara Pimary School (2km)
99 215208 36131 1254 Entrance to Kyabenda Health Centre III & Branch off to Kyabenda Divinity College
100 215472 36092 1254 Entrance to St. George Church & Kyabenda Primary School
108 216233 34661 1263 Alternate branch off to Nkarakara Primary School (5km)
112 216687 32370 1288 Branch off to Kamwenge Secondary and Vocational Institute plus Mpanga Primary School (8km)
119 215865 28957 1310 Entrance to Rukunyu C.O.U Primary School
120 215848 28835 1313 Branch off to Mirembe Primary School (5km) & Good Samaritan Health Centre IV, Rukunyu.
121 215822 28793 1310 Branch off to Kiziba Primary School (5km)
122 215804 28720 1307 Entrance to Rukunyu Junior School.
128 215538 27318 1246 Branch off to Butemba Primary School, Kamwenge
139 216467 24458 1257 Entrance to Businge Primary School. Opposite is the entrance to a Catholic church
146 216862 22499 1300 Entrance to Kamwenge Secondary School
148 216858 22471 1299 Branch off to Kyabyoma Primary School (1.5km)
150 216917 21520 1312 Entrance to St. Paul's Primary School, Kamwenge
152 216859 20924 1290 Branch off to St. George & St. Thomas Aquinas College. (300m)
154 216815 20742 1285 Entrance to Kamwenge Primary School
157 216473 20388 1267 Branch off to Lawrence High School (300m), Kamwenge
158 216519 20331 1268
Entrance to Little Angels Pre-primary and Primary School, Kamwenge. Next to it is Caltex fuel station & opposite is the Police post plus an alternative route to Kamwenge Modern School
159 216542 20142 1281 Entramce to Kamwenge Junior School
160 216479 20029 1287 Branch off to Mosque & Mirambi K Primary School opposite this is a Clinic
161 216396 19938 1290 Branch off to Kamwenge Modern School (300m) & Kamwenge College School (3kms)
164 216327 19825 1286 Branch off to Kimuli - Kidongo Primary School (3km), Kamwenge
168 215879 35885 1254 Branch off to Kyabenda Senior Secondary School
P a g e | 79
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
c) Water points along the road
GPS coordinates
Waypoint Easting Northing Altitude
(m) Facility
38 201069 66299 1511 Water point - Borehole & Cemetry
45 200513 64415 1502 Water point - Borehole
126 215584 27888 1276 Water point - Tap + Water tank (Gravity flow scheme)
136 216393 24821 1253 Water point - Tap
143 216657 23214 1273 Protected well
167 216409 24732 1246 Water point - Borehole
d) Healthcare centres along the road
Waypoint Easting Northing Altitude
(m) Facility 3 197215 72582 1498 Entrance to the Mental Health Unit 6 197398 72598 1495 Entrance to the referral hospital 7 197546 72427 1494 Entrance to Mortuary
64 203150 54563 1423
Major branch off to Iruhuura (5km) & Pere Achte Primary Schools, Pere Achte S.S (31km), St. Luke Iruhuura Health centre III (5km) plus St. Karoli Lwanga Isonga Catholic sub parish and St. Peter's C.O.U Iruhuura Parish
77 211815 44536 1244 Branch off to Bigodi Health Centre III (100m) & Police post
99 215208 36131 1254 Entrance to Kyabenda Health Centre III & Branch off to Kyabenda Divinity College
120 215848 28835 1313 Branch off to Mirembe Primary School (5km) & Good samaritan Health Centre IV, Rukunyu.
P a g e | 80
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Annex 3. Vulnerable people identified along the road
District Sub-county Village Name Vulnerability Required assistance
KAMWENGE Matama Mary Widow Loses no crops or structure but a strip of land. Will need financial assistance (transport refund) to collect compensation cash payment.
KABAROLE
Ruteete Rurarama George Kaboyo Elderly Will lose a residential house (grass thatched roof, mud/wattle walls, timber doors and windows, earth floor). Will need labour assistance to rebuild his home. Funds for this can be drawn from the provisional sum included in the RAP budget. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Rwamiru Andrew Elderly and blind Will not lose a structure or crops but 0.011 ha (or 0.03 acres) of land. He will need assistance with paperwork (reading/ writing) associated with compensation process. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at home.
Katorogo Elderly Will not lose a structure or crops but 0.04 ha (or 0.1 acres) of land. He will need assistance with paperwork (reading/ writing) associated with compensation process. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Sunday Joseph Orphans Loses no crops or structures but 0.014 ha (0.03 acres) of land worth shs83,000. Will be advised to purchase replacement land with compensation payment.
Ruteete Rurarama
Ahabyona Lawrence Elderly and disabled
Loses no crops or structures but 0.04 ha
P a g e | 81
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
(0.1 acres) of land worth shs238000. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Barinda Serevesta Elderly Will not lose a structure or crops but 0.019 ha (0.05 acres) of land worth Shs113,000. He will need assistance with paperwork (reading/ writing) associated with compensation process. Compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Zahora Tebanagwa Elderly Will lose 10 meters of live hedge (luyenje) and 2 pine trees. He will need assistance with paperwork (reading/ writing) associated with compensation process. Compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at their home.
Burunda Oriva Kanyiginya Widow Will not lose a structure or crops but 0.042 ha (0.1 acres) of land worth Shs249,000. She will need assistance with paperwork (reading/ writing) associated with compensation process.
Byaruhanga Richard Ill with HIV/AIDS Will lose 3 trees and 0.058 ha (0.014 acres) of land. He will need assistance to collect his compensation payment. This can be done with assistance of local council leader of his village. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home. For this category of PAPs payment should be expedited.
Aringanyira Ill with HIV/AIDS Will not lose structures or crops but 0.05 ha of land. He will need assistance to collect his compensation payment. This can be done with assistance of local council leader of his
P a g e | 82
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
village. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home. For this category of PAPs payment should be expedited.
Kaguna John Has physical disability with limited ability to walk
Will lose two residential buildings (mud and wattle with iron roofs) and trees. He will need assistance to collect his payment His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Ihani Cell Mugisha John Sick and poor Will lose a live hedge and crops. Should be provided transport refund to collect compensation payment. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Bukabyarubaho Nyakagongo Kadoba Elderly Loses no structures or crops but 0.045 ha of customary land. Will need assistance with paperwork (reading and writing) associated with compensation process. His compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at his home.
Municipality Bigodi Kanyakore Beatrice Elderly Will not lose structures or crops but 0.01 ha of land worth Shs 59500. Should be provided assistance on paperwork (reading and writing) necessary to obtain her compensation. Compensation payment and associated paperwork should be done at her home.
P a g e | 83
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Annex 4: Project affected people survey form/ questionnaire
(This questionnaire was used to collect data by CES/KOM in the previous RAP report of Sep. 2008) PERSONAL DATA 1. Name of Respondent …………………………………………………………………… 2. Sex of respondent Male Female Interviewer…………………… 3. Age of respondent……………………….. 01. (15-25) 02. (26-35) 03. (36-45) 04. (46-55) 04. (56 and above) 4. Status in the household
Head=01 Spouse=02 Child=03 Other=04
BASIC DEMOGRAPHIC DATA 1. Household size? No. males No. of females No. of children No. of adults 2. Gender of HH head? 01. Female 02.Male 3. Marital status of 01.Married 02.Single Respondent 03.Divorced 04.Widowed 4. Formal education Completed by HH head 01.p.7. 02. O level 03. A level 04.College 05.None 5. Main occupation of 01.salaried 02.business HH head 02.peasant 04.other EDUCATION 6. Have you schools around? 01. Yes 02.No 6.1 How many school going children are in this HH? 6.2 Out of those mentioned how many are in school? 7. Do you have any school age children not going to school?
01. Yes 02.No
P a g e | 84
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
7.1. If yes how many are they? Boys…..Girls…. 7.2 Mention 2 reasons why they are not going to school a…………. b………… 8. How many primary schools do you have? 8.1. What is the distance to the nearest primary school? 9. How many secondary schools do you have? 9.1. What is the distance to the nearest secondary school? INCOME AND FOOD SECURITY 10. What are the main sources of income in the HH?
01. Salaried 02. Casual labor 03. Sale of farm products 04. Business 05. Others 11. Does any member in the HH run a business?
01. Yes 02.No 11.1. If yes give the type of business……….. 11.2. If yes give the gender of the owner of the business.
01. Female 02.Male 12. Do you have some livestock in the HH?
01. =Yes 02.No 13. If yes give the type and number.
01. Cows 02. Goats 03. Sheep 04. Pigs 05. Others 14. Do you own land? 01. Yes 02.No 14.1. If yes how much land is being cultivated?(acres) 14.2. How much land is not being cultivated? 14.3. Who owns the land mentioned above?
01. Wife 02. Husband 03. Husband and wife 04. Others
P a g e | 85
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
15. Have you received any food shortage problems in your HH? 16. What precautions have you ensured to show that there is enough food for your family throughout the year?
01. Saved 02. Food stored 03. Change in livestock mix 04. Change in crop mix 17. Have you received agriculture extension services in the last two months?
01. Yes 02.No 18. Do you practice improved crop and management practices?
01. Yes 02.No 19. What is your HH income per year? 20. Mention the type of food eaten in your HH. 21. Do you have storage instruments for your crops?
01. Yes 02.No WATER AND SANITATION 22. What are the sources of water for domestic use? 01. Gravity 02. Borehole 03. Protected spring 04. Valley tank 05. Unprotected spring 06. Others 23. What is the distance to the nearest source of safe drinking water? Source type……….km………. 24. How long does it take you to fetch water from your home? 25. If the water is improved mention the source of financing it. i………… ii………… iii………… 26. Is the safe water you fetch adequate to all the members in your house hold? 01. Yes 02.No 27. How is domestic garbage disposed? 28. What is the common facility of disposing human wastes by household members? 01=Toilet 02=Pit latrine
P a g e | 86
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
03=Community latrine 04=Open bush O5=Others 29. Do you have a bathroom? Yes 02=No 30. Do you have a kitchen/ 01=Yes 02=No 31. Do you have a rack? 01=Yes 02=No 32. Do you wash your hands after using the toilet? 01=Yes 02=No 33. How do you store your drinking water? 01=Fridge 02= Jerricans 03=Pots 04=Others 34. How do you make water safe for drinking? 01. Boiling 02.Water guard 03.Filtering 04=Chlorine HEALTH SERVICES 35. Is there any health facility in this sub county? 01=Yes 02=No 36. If yes which grade is it? 01=District hospital 02=Health centre 4 03=Health centre 3 04=Health centre 2 05=Private clinic 37. State the type of ownership 01=Government 02=Private 38. Give the distance to the nearest health centre (km) 39. Do you have any immunization services? 01=Yes 02=No 40. Have you completed your immunization vaccines? 01=Yes 02=No 41. Do you have any community health workers? 01=Yes 02=No
P a g e | 87
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
42. How often do they visit the community? 01=Once a month 02=Twice a month 03=Once 3 months 04=Daily 05=Never 43.Do you access antenatal care services in your sub county? 1=Yes 2=No 44. Where do women in your parish go for delivery?
1.Remain at home 2. Visit a recognized traditional birth attendant 3.Visit a nearby P.H.C. 4. Visit a recognized hospital (District hospital) 5.Others 45.Have you heard of HIV/AIDS? 01=Yes 02=No 46.If yes what is the main source of information? 47.What information have you heard about HIV/AIDS? 48.Acccording to you what are some of the STDs common in your area? 1.Syplis 2.Gonorrhea 3.HIV/AIDS 4.Others 49. According to you what are the major causes of HIV/AIDS in your sub county? 1. Irresponsible sexual behavior 2.Blood transfusion 3.Sharing of sharp instruments such as syringes, razorblades etc 4.Mother to child transfusion 5.Others 6. Don‘t know. 50.Do you have any members of your household with chronic diseases? 01=Yes 02=No 51.Do you have an orphan in your HH? 01=Yes 02.No LEADERSHIP 52.Are you a member of any committee? (L.Cs, Church e.t.c) 01=Yes 02=No 53.If yes have you acquired leadership skills through training? 54.If you acquired the skills how do you utilize them? ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES
P a g e | 88
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
55.What is the main source of energy for domestic use? a. Lighting…. b. Cooking… c. Others… 56.Has any family member been involved in environmental activities? 01=Yes 02= 57.What was the source of support for the environmental activity? 01=Government 02=N.G.O 03=Own resources 04=Others 58.Has any child or children in your family been assisted by support programs in the community? 01=Yes 02=No 59.If yes how many children are sponsored? 60.If yes name the organization and type of assistance currently given. Organization Type of support 01……………… …………………… 02……………… ……………………. 03……………… …………………….. DISABILITY ISSUES 61.Do you have any disabled child in your HH? 01=Yes 02=No 62.If yes does she/he receive support from any NGO? 01=Yes 02=No 63. Does this community allow disabled children/people to participate in community programmes? 01=Yes 02=No RESETTLEMENT 64 To what extent will your property/land be acquired for the road project? 64 1 partially (only land/ or crops 64.2 Fully Buildings, structures, land and crops? 65 What is your preferred option for resettlement?
a) No resettlement and no compensation desire b) No resettlement and no compensation to be paid c) Resettlement on existing land d) Resettlement to margins of developed area e) Other(specify)
P a g e | 89
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
66 When is the best time of the year for you to relocate? 67 What sort of assistance would you require during re-housing 68 Can the local administration assist you with relocation? 69 What do you foresee as being the main problem for you during and after relocation/ compensation?
P a g e | 90
Annex 5: Property valuation lists (Kamwenge & Kabarole Districts)
APPROVED COMPENSATION RATES FOR KABAROLE DISTRICT 2009 (*It was established from the valuation consultant that these rates were used for property valuation in both Kabarole
and Kamwenge district since the latter is a new district without own rates).
No. ITEM RATE PER PLANT (UgShs) RATE PER ACRE (UgShs) REMARKS
PART 1: CROPS
1 BANANA
Mature and good 6,000 2,520,000
Mature and average 4,000 1,600,000
Mature and poor 1,000 400,000
Young and good 3,000 1,260,000
2 CASSAVA
Mature To be harvested
Young 1,200
3 SWEET POTATOES
Medium and good 300,000
Young 150,000
4 TURNIPS
Mature 3,750
Young 1,500
5 ENGLISH POTATOES
Mature To be harvested
Young 600,000
6 PINEAPPLES
P a g e | 91
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Mature and good 1,000
Medium 500
Young 500
7 CABBAGE 800
8 PAWPAW
Mature and good 10,000
Medium and average 7,000
Young 2,000
Seedlings 1,000
9 PUMPKIN
Good 5,000
Medium 3,000
Young 1,500
10 TOMATOES
Mature and good 1,000
Average 2,500
Young and good 2,000
Poor 1,000
11 CAULIFLOWER 1,000
12 COFFEE
Arabica (mature and good) 8,000 3,000,000
Arabica (mature and average) 4,000 1,500,000
Arabica (mature and poor) 2,000 800,000
Arabica (young and good) 5,000 2,000,000
Arabica (young and poor) 1,000 400,000
P a g e | 92
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Robusta (mature and good) 6,000 2,000,000
Arabica (mature and average) 3,000 1,200,000
Arabica (mature and poor) 1,000 400,000
Arabica (young and good) 4,000 1,500,000
Arabica (young and poor) 1,000 400,000
13 ORANGE TREES
Mature and good 30,000
Medium/Average 20,000
Young 10,000
14 LEMON TREES
Mature and good 30,000
Medium/Average 20,000
Young 10,000
15 BEANS
Mature To be harvested
Young 200,000
16 PEAS
Medium and good 500,000
Young 250,000
17 SOYA BEANS
Medium and good 500,000
Young 250,000
18 COTTON
Young and good 300,000
P a g e | 93
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
19 GROUNDNUTS 400,000
Young 100,000
Poor
20 CLIMBING NUTS
Mature 50,000
Young 10,000
21 JACKFRUIT
Mature and good 50,000
Medium/Average 30,000
Young 10,000
Seedlings 5,000
22 COWPEAS
Medium and good 500,000
Young 250,000
23 MAIZE
Young and good 300,000
Poor 200,000
24 GUAVA TREES
Mature and good 15,000
Medium 7,000
Poor 1,000
Young 1,500
Seedling 500
25 AVOCADO TREES
Mature and good 40,000
P a g e | 94
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Medium and average 20,000
Young 5,000
26 MANGO TREES
Mature 30,000
Young 20,000
Seedlings 1,000
27 SUGARCANE
Mature per stool 2,000
Young per stool 1,000
28 TEA BUSHES
Mature 3,000,000
Medium 1,000,000
Young 500
29 MILLET
Good 400,000
Average 200,000
Poor 100,000
30 SORGHUM
Good 300,000
Poor 100,000
31 ONIONS
Exotic and good 300,000
Exotic and poor 100,000
Local and good 200,000
Local and poor 100,000
P a g e | 95
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
32 PASSION FRUITS
Mature and good 35,000
Medium 20,000
Young 17,500
Seedling 2,000
33 YAMS (ALL TYPES)
Mature and good 500
Average 300
Young 100
34 PEPPER/ CHILLI PLANTS
Local 1,000
Exotic 2,000
35 EGG PLANT
Mature 2,000
Young 500
36 CASTOR OIL
Mature 750
Young 200
37 GINGER 5,000
P a g e | 96
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
38 PALM TREE
Big and mature 20,000
Medium 10,000
Young 2,000
39 RICE
Good 400,000
Average 200,000
Poor 100,000
40 VANILLA
Mature and good 15,000
Average 7,000
Young 1,000
41 WHEAT
Mature 400,000
Young 100,000
42 BARLEY
Mature 400,000
Young 100,000
43 GARLIC
Mature 3,500
Young 2,000
44 APPLES
Mature 50,000
Young 20,000
P a g e | 97
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
45 MUSAMBYA
Big 20,000
Medium and average 10,000
46 GARDEN TREES
Mature 10,000
Young 2,000
47 OMUSALI
Mature 10,000
Young 2,000
48 IMPROVED PASTURE 300,000
49 FLOWER BUSH 2,500
50 ACACIA TREES
Big and mature 15,000
Medium 10,000
Young 2,000
51 BACKCLOTH TREES
Canoe size 40,000
Medium 20,000
Young and small 3,000
52 CYPRESS TREE
Mature 50,000
Medium (electric pole size) 15,000
Young 5,000
53 PINE
Mature 50,000
P a g e | 98
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
Medium 15,000
Young 5,000
54 EUCALYPTUS TREES
Mature 100,000
Young (electric pole) 50,000
Young (construction scaffolding pole size) 20,000
55 TOBACCO
Mature and good 300,000
Young 150,000
PART 2: SEMI-PERMANENT STRUCTURES
56 CATTLE (FARM STRUCTURES)
Barbed wire 3,705 per meter
Smooth wire 2,700 per meter
Local tree/ hedge fence 700 per meter
Kraal 700 per meter
57 GRANARIES
Mud and wattle 50,000
Thatched/ grass 20,000
Maize rib (grass thatch) 15,000
Silo 50,000
Bee hive 20,000
PART 3: MATERIALS
58 MURRAM 750 per square meter
69 ROCK 3,000 per square meter
P a g e | 99
AWE Engineers
www.awe-engineers.com
PART 4: COMPENSATION FOR SEMI-PERMANENT BUILDINGS
70 Semi-permanent buildings
No Wall type Roof Finish Floor Rate per sq.meter
1 Bee hive 20,000 per unit
2 Mud and wattle (MW) grass/ thatch smooth earth 20,000
3 MW grass/ thatch plaster bare 25,000
4 MW grass/ thatch plaster cement 35,000
5 MW Galvanized iron sheet bare/ rough bare 37,500
6 MW Galvanized iron sheet smooth bare 40,000
7 MW Galvanized iron sheet plaster cement 50,000
8 MW Ddebe plaster bare 25,000
9 MW Ddebe bare/ rough bare 27,000
10 MW Ddebe smooth bare 35,000
11 MW Ddebe cement/ plaster cemented 40,000
12 PIT LATRINE
Covered with poles plaster cement slab 300,000
Covered with poles plaster VIP 600,000
13 BATH ENCLOSURE
Thatched/ grass 4,000
Tins/ ddebe 10,000
Galvanized Corrugated Iron sheet 10,000
Reeds/ wood poles 5,000