+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Reviews and Notices of Books

Reviews and Notices of Books

Date post: 04-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: trancong
View: 213 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
2
1263 ROYAL ACADEMY OF MEDICINE IN IRELAND. SECTION OF OBSTETRICS. Rotunda Reports. A MEETING of this section was held on May 19th, Dr GIBBON FITZGIBBON, the President, being in the chair. Sir WILLIAM SMYLY having read the Rotunda Reports, Sir ANDREW HoRrrE congratulated the governors of th hospital in granting Dr. Henry Jellett a further extension c leave to do ambulance work. He regretted there was n mention of the subject of scopolamine-morphine treatmen which has occupied so much attention in the lay press. Dr. BETHEL SOLOMONS said that he had modified his view concerning scopolamine-morphine anaesthesia since the puh lication of Dr. Freeland’s paper on the subject in 1909. H thought that " twilight sleep" was unsatisfactory unless th, method was carried out by trained assistants and nurses- that it was impossible for the ordinary practitioner to give unless he was prepared to devote his whole time to the case He asked Dr. Rowlette to state his opinion of the presen position of sera and vaccines in the treatment of puerpera sepsis. He noted also that two of the patients in the Contracted Pelvis Table were not measured internally. He was awar that the authorities at the Rotunda favoured mensuratiOI by the Skutsch instrument, and he thought it would be good thing if there was a separate table devoted to Skutscl pelvimetry, as this would draw more attention to its use. Dr. R. D. PUREFOY said he was not an enthusiast for scopo, lamine morphine anaesthesia. Amongst the patients who hac died from sepsis he recollected that one had not been able t( lie down for three weeks prior to admission because of greal distress from hydramnios ; the labour was slow, pains n01 ensuing for some days after rupture of the membranes. He] aspect from her admission was that of a woman dying from pernicious ansemia. He was a firm believer in the Skutsct pelvimeter, and regretted that some still relied on the digital method. Dr. R. J. ROWLETTE said he thought that in the treatmeni of puerperal sepsis both vaccines and sera should bE employed. The vaccines should be autogenous, b’1t pending their preparation stock vaccines should be used. The use of these agents did not preclude any other method of treatment which might be considered advisable in a particular case, Sir WILLIAM SMYLY said there had been so many changes in the personnel of the hospital staff during the year that it would be impossible to assign the degree of indebtedness to each member who had helped in compiling it, but Dr. J. T. Simpson had done most of the work in preparing the statistics of the report. Regarding scopolamine-morphine, he had given directions that one dose at least should be given to every patient who was in the first stage of labour, but not that it should be pushed to the degree described as twilight sleep." BRITISH OTO-LARYNGOLOGICAL SOCIETY.-A meeting of this society was held in the rooms of the Medical Society of London, Chandos-street, W., on June 8th, Mr. Charles J. Heath being in the chair. Mr. Heath having introduced the following motion, several members and visitors spoke in its support :- Notwithstanding the evidence contained in the report of the Bryce Commission regarding the brutalitv of the combatant branch of the German army, the Fellows of the British Oto-Laryngological Society did not think it. possible that members of the medical profession could have acted as Oberstabsarzt Dr. Aschenbach and other German surgeons did in abandoning the British prisoners of war at Wittenberg camp during an epidemic of typhus fever. They are not a little surprised that medical opinion on this behaviour has not yet made itself heard in this and in neutral countries. The motion was seconded by Dr. Frederick Spicer and was carried unanimously.—Cases were shown by Dr. Spicer and Mr. Heath. THE LATE SIR JOSEPH FAYRER AND FALMOUTH.- At the last meeting of the Falmouth town council it was reported that the family of the late Sir Joseph Fayrer had presented a handsome marble bust of their father to the town council. It was decided to place the bust in the council chamber, one of the members remarking that no one had done more to make public the natural gifts of Falmouth than the late Sir Joseph Fayrer. Reviews and Notices of Books. Localisation by X Rays and Stereoscopy. By Sir JAMES MACKENZIE DAVIDSON, M.B., C.M. Aberd. London : H. K. Lewis. 1916. Pp. xi. + 72. Price .... 7s. 6d. net. Sir James Davidson has done a good service, particularly’ at the present time, in publishing the well-known and reliable methods of localisation, mostly originated by him- self, in this handy volume. The general subject of radio- graphy is not touched upon, and apart from some special points in the selection and properties of X ray tubes and a chapter on secondary rays and X ray protection, the author proceeds at once with the consideration of stereoscopic radiography. The various steps in technique are clearly described, and here, as all through the volume, the illus- trations are themselves stereoscopic, affording the strongest argument for the more general use of this method in radio-" graphy, so greatly is educational value thus increased’, Rapid localisation, with more or less simple appliances, by triangulation is next described. This method, or some modi- fication of it, is the one most commonly used during the present war, and for a large proportion of cases it answers extremely well. For some cases more precise methods are necessary, and in the following chapter we have the well- known "cross-thread" arrangement explained in detail. Recent modifications have made the practice of this method more easy and rapid, and the results more certain in the hands of those whose experience has been less than that of the author himself. A still further development for she most accurate localisation of foreign bodies in the eye follows, and to this the author directs special attention, )wing to the large increase in such injuries in hand-grenade warfare. Precision is essential if the victim is to have the best chance of saving an eye. In an appendix the author describes the telephone attach- nent in surgery, the electromagnet as an aid to localisation, and other matters of interest, concluding with a number of ;pecial stereoscopic radiographs which are very valuable in Jmphasising the advantages of the author’s contentions. Elementary Text-book of Economic Zoology and Entomology. By V. L. KELLOGG and R. W. DOANE, Professors in Stanford University. London : Constable. 1915. Pup. 532. Price 6s. 6d. net. THIS text- book is the joint work of two American zoologists, eachers of zoology, economic and otherwise, in the Cali- ornian University, and well qualified for their task. Since economic or applied zoology must rest upon a basis of purely cientific zoology, the authors rightly deal first of all with- he general facts of zoology ; in this part of the handbook hey survey the animal kingdom throughout, wisely declining o be drawn into discussion on the differences between nimals and plants, and refraining from committing them- elves to a definition on that matter. A fairly comprehensive ccount of the structure of the frog, grasshopper, hydra, and moeba serves as an introduction to a consideration of the lain subdivisions of the animal world which are dealt with 1 order. This general account is naturally not very full 1 view of the authors’ main object, but what is given 3 us is clearly put and accurate, at any rate so far as egards undisputed facts. In more disputable matters it ; doubtful whether the authorities of the Natural History Iuseum will agree with our authors when they say, and rith the emphasis latent in a footnote, that the British fuseum Catalogue of birds, though tabulating 19,000 pecies, should have left out "about 7000 forms con- dered by most (the italics are ours) ornithologists to be erely varieties." As the title of the book leads the reader to infer, the economic section of zoology is developed more fully on the itomological side. But it must not be supposed from this iat other economic aspects of the science are so curtailed as be useless to the commencing student. Here again, as sewhere in their volume and as with other writers,
Transcript

1263

ROYAL ACADEMY OF MEDICINE INIRELAND.

SECTION OF OBSTETRICS.

Rotunda Reports.A MEETING of this section was held on May 19th, Dr

GIBBON FITZGIBBON, the President, being in the chair.Sir WILLIAM SMYLY having read the Rotunda Reports,Sir ANDREW HoRrrE congratulated the governors of th

hospital in granting Dr. Henry Jellett a further extension cleave to do ambulance work. He regretted there was nmention of the subject of scopolamine-morphine treatmenwhich has occupied so much attention in the lay press.

Dr. BETHEL SOLOMONS said that he had modified his viewconcerning scopolamine-morphine anaesthesia since the puhlication of Dr. Freeland’s paper on the subject in 1909. H

thought that " twilight sleep" was unsatisfactory unless th,method was carried out by trained assistants and nurses-that it was impossible for the ordinary practitioner to giveunless he was prepared to devote his whole time to the caseHe asked Dr. Rowlette to state his opinion of the presenposition of sera and vaccines in the treatment of puerperasepsis. He noted also that two of the patients in the ContractedPelvis Table were not measured internally. He was awarthat the authorities at the Rotunda favoured mensuratiOIby the Skutsch instrument, and he thought it would be

good thing if there was a separate table devoted to Skutsclpelvimetry, as this would draw more attention to its use.

Dr. R. D. PUREFOY said he was not an enthusiast for scopo,lamine morphine anaesthesia. Amongst the patients who hacdied from sepsis he recollected that one had not been able t(lie down for three weeks prior to admission because of grealdistress from hydramnios ; the labour was slow, pains n01

ensuing for some days after rupture of the membranes. He]

aspect from her admission was that of a woman dying frompernicious ansemia. He was a firm believer in the Skutsctpelvimeter, and regretted that some still relied on thedigital method.

Dr. R. J. ROWLETTE said he thought that in the treatmeniof puerperal sepsis both vaccines and sera should bE

employed. The vaccines should be autogenous, b’1t pendingtheir preparation stock vaccines should be used. The use ofthese agents did not preclude any other method of treatmentwhich might be considered advisable in a particular case,

Sir WILLIAM SMYLY said there had been so many changesin the personnel of the hospital staff during the year that itwould be impossible to assign the degree of indebtedness toeach member who had helped in compiling it, but Dr. J. T.Simpson had done most of the work in preparing the statisticsof the report. Regarding scopolamine-morphine, he hadgiven directions that one dose at least should be given toevery patient who was in the first stage of labour, butnot that it should be pushed to the degree described astwilight sleep."

BRITISH OTO-LARYNGOLOGICAL SOCIETY.-Ameeting of this society was held in the rooms of theMedical Society of London, Chandos-street, W., on June 8th,Mr. Charles J. Heath being in the chair. Mr. Heath havingintroduced the following motion, several members andvisitors spoke in its support :-Notwithstanding the evidence contained in the report of the Bryce

Commission regarding the brutalitv of the combatant branch of theGerman army, the Fellows of the British Oto-Laryngological Societydid not think it. possible that members of the medical profession couldhave acted as Oberstabsarzt Dr. Aschenbach and other German surgeonsdid in abandoning the British prisoners of war at Wittenberg campduring an epidemic of typhus fever. They are not a little surprisedthat medical opinion on this behaviour has not yet made itself heard inthis and in neutral countries.

The motion was seconded by Dr. Frederick Spicer and wascarried unanimously.—Cases were shown by Dr. Spicer andMr. Heath.

THE LATE SIR JOSEPH FAYRER AND FALMOUTH.-At the last meeting of the Falmouth town council it wasreported that the family of the late Sir Joseph Fayrer hadpresented a handsome marble bust of their father to thetown council. It was decided to place the bust in the councilchamber, one of the members remarking that no one haddone more to make public the natural gifts of Falmouth thanthe late Sir Joseph Fayrer.

Reviews and Notices of Books.Localisation by X Rays and Stereoscopy.By Sir JAMES MACKENZIE DAVIDSON, M.B., C.M. Aberd.London : H. K. Lewis. 1916. Pp. xi. + 72. Price ....

7s. 6d. net.

Sir James Davidson has done a good service, particularly’at the present time, in publishing the well-known andreliable methods of localisation, mostly originated by him-self, in this handy volume. The general subject of radio-graphy is not touched upon, and apart from some specialpoints in the selection and properties of X ray tubes and achapter on secondary rays and X ray protection, the authorproceeds at once with the consideration of stereoscopicradiography. The various steps in technique are clearlydescribed, and here, as all through the volume, the illus-trations are themselves stereoscopic, affording the strongestargument for the more general use of this method in radio-"graphy, so greatly is educational value thus increased’,Rapid localisation, with more or less simple appliances, bytriangulation is next described. This method, or some modi-fication of it, is the one most commonly used during thepresent war, and for a large proportion of cases it answers

extremely well. For some cases more precise methods arenecessary, and in the following chapter we have the well-known "cross-thread" arrangement explained in detail.Recent modifications have made the practice of this methodmore easy and rapid, and the results more certain inthe hands of those whose experience has been less thanthat of the author himself. A still further development forshe most accurate localisation of foreign bodies in the eye follows, and to this the author directs special attention,)wing to the large increase in such injuries in hand-grenadewarfare. Precision is essential if the victim is to have thebest chance of saving an eye.In an appendix the author describes the telephone attach-

nent in surgery, the electromagnet as an aid to localisation,and other matters of interest, concluding with a number of;pecial stereoscopic radiographs which are very valuable inJmphasising the advantages of the author’s contentions.

Elementary Text-book of Economic Zoology andEntomology.

By V. L. KELLOGG and R. W. DOANE, Professors inStanford University. London : Constable. 1915. Pup. 532.Price 6s. 6d. net.

THIS text- book is the joint work of two American zoologists,eachers of zoology, economic and otherwise, in the Cali-ornian University, and well qualified for their task. Sinceeconomic or applied zoology must rest upon a basis of purelycientific zoology, the authors rightly deal first of all with-he general facts of zoology ; in this part of the handbookhey survey the animal kingdom throughout, wisely decliningo be drawn into discussion on the differences betweennimals and plants, and refraining from committing them-elves to a definition on that matter. A fairly comprehensiveccount of the structure of the frog, grasshopper, hydra, andmoeba serves as an introduction to a consideration of thelain subdivisions of the animal world which are dealt with1 order. This general account is naturally not very full1 view of the authors’ main object, but what is given3 us is clearly put and accurate, at any rate so far as

egards undisputed facts. In more disputable matters it; doubtful whether the authorities of the Natural HistoryIuseum will agree with our authors when they say, andrith the emphasis latent in a footnote, that the Britishfuseum Catalogue of birds, though tabulating 19,000pecies, should have left out "about 7000 forms con-

dered by most (the italics are ours) ornithologists to beerely varieties." As the title of the book leads the reader to infer, theeconomic section of zoology is developed more fully on theitomological side. But it must not be supposed from thisiat other economic aspects of the science are so curtailed asbe useless to the commencing student. Here again, as

sewhere in their volume and as with other writers,

1264

Professors Kellogg and Doane have been confronted withthe pressing, but not easily soluble, problem of what to putin and what to leave out. Economic zoology embraces a greatvariety of subjects, all of which form the material of manyspecial treatises. But we think that the authors have atleast touched upon and extracted some essentials from all ofthese subdivisions of economic zoology in their very usefullittle treatise. It may be pointed out, in conclusion, thatthe illustrations are numerous and to the point. As thebook is admittedly an introductory work, dealing only withthe elements of zoology, no list of literature is given.

JOURNALS.

The Journal of Physiology, Edited by J. N. LANGLEY,Sc.D., F.R.S. Vol. L., No. 4. Cambridge University Press.1916. Pp. 217-264. Price 3s. 6d.--To this issue ProfessorJ. N. Langley, professor of physiology in the University ofCambridge, contributes an admirable sketch of the progressof discovery in the eighteenth century as regards theautonomic nervous system. Professor Langley, who himselfhas added so largely to our knowledge of what used to becalled the sympathetic nervous system, and for which hecoined the title "autonomic nervous system," gives a mostinteresting historical account of this system, excluding,however, the work of Bichat, as his theory was developedchiefly in 1801. Early in last century it was the prevalentbelief that all the nerves of the body had their origin in thebrain and that the brain was the sole source of nervous influ-ence. The nerve described as "intercostal" until 1732 is nowknown as the sympathetic chain. It was Winslow who intro-duced the term "great sympathetic." Only a few of theganglia in the cranial nerves had been described. Thoseinterested in the dates of discovery of the best known gangliawill find the facts on p. 253. Two main functions wereattributed to the intercostal nerve. It was the means bywhich the brain influenced the viscera, and it was the chiefmeans of nervous connexion between different parts of thebody. The views of Willis, Ridley, Vieussens, and othersare passed in review. Then follows a summary of thesuccessive steps from 1727, when Petit contested the cerebralorigin of the intercostal nerve, the work of Winslow beingpublished in 1732, and that of Monro in 1732. From 1732 to1750 discovery in relation to the sympathetic system followedan uneventful course. In 1751 Robert Whytt, of Edinburgh,published an essay " On the Vital and other InvoluntaryMovements of Animals." His conclusions were largelydrawn from clinical experience and critical examination ofthe accounts of others. The chief point of importancein the essay was that it laid the foundation for the

subsequent more explicit statement that the great sym-pathetic was not specially concerned with the sympathies.1752 brings the author to Haller’s paper on the sensibilityand irritability of the different parts of the body. Haller

taught that contraction could be brought about by stimuliwithout the intervention of nerves, or of any other inter-mediary agent. He considered that contractility was theinherent property of the glutinous as distinct from the

earthy portion of muscle. His theory of the independentirritability of muscles depended chiefly on his metaphysicalconceptions. The relative claims of Haller and Glissonregarding the doctrine of irritability are analysed, and themodifications of Haller’s theory by Fontana and Caldani arestated. From 1764 to 1771 the functions of the ganglia beganto be discussed, a beginning being made in 1764 by JamesJohnstone. Unzer in 1771 gave an analysis of the voluntaryand involuntary movements based on the data contained inHaller’s "Elementa Physiologica," dealing with reflectedactions." Procharka in 1784 followed much the same line I

as Unzer. From 1772 to 1799 there were a considerablenumber of anatomical observations upon the intercostalnerve and its branches, chiefly on the connexions of the I

several cranial nerves with the intercostal. In 1781 Fontanamade a step forward in regard to the finer structure of nerveand muscle fibres. His figures, Professor Langley pointsout, show indistinctly what were afterwards called the

axis-cylinder and the medullary sheath. Experimentalresults new in kind were scanty during the eighteenthcentury. Although the galvanic method of stimulationwas introduced towards the end of the century, it was notat this time applied in a way that gave decisive results.No differences were recognised structurally between skeletal

muscles and those of the viscera. A muscle was somethingwhich contracted in virtue of inherent properties, but it wasgenerally held that this could only be set in motion by nerves.Mechanical and chemical stimuli were applied to various

parts of the body during life and after death. A most

striking new observation, however, was the contraction ofthe pupil and other effects on the eye following section ofthe intercostal nerve-i.e., the cervical sympathetic nerve-by Petit, an experiment no one seems to have repeatedin the 70 years or so after the publication of Petit’s

paper in 1727.

New Inventions.A NEW WALKING-STICK CRUTCH.

THE ordinary type of crutch with its head in the armpithas certain drawbacks. If used continuously the crutchtends to set up irritation frequently leading to the formation

of boils or, what is more serious, the com-pression of the large nerves may lead totroublesome palsies. Even if these are

avoided by special care, the use of thecrutch inevitably tends to a deformation ofthe thorax and to atrophy of the arms, whichare hardly called upon for any muscularaction. The injured lower limb, too, isunable to make any active effort in pro-gression and becomes increasingly stiff anduseless. A French engineer, M. Schlick,of Nancy, had the ingenious idea of doinga, way with the armpit leverage and replacingit by a support for the forearm and hand.The "forearm lever walking-stick crutch "is the result. The invention has had the

support of Professor Michel, of Nancy (NancyMedical Society, April 7th, 1915), and of ProfessorTuffier, chief surgeon to the Beaujon Hospital, whobrought the crutch to the notice of the SurgicalSociety on June 30th, 1915.The Schlick walking-stick crutch consists of an

almost horizontal handle, which is grasped in thepalm of the hand, and of a slightly sloped springwhich supports the forearm from the wrist to theelbow-when the arm hangs naturally. The greaterpart of the weight of the body bears on the handand the wrist, while the forearm resting upon thespring and the elbow which fits into the semi-bracelet play rather an accessory part. In walkingthe forearm is partially flexed, but is almost fullyextended when taking the weight of the body andthrusting it forward ; at the same time thewounded limb bears more or less on the ground,helping to carry the weight of the body. Thereis thus a compensatory action, considerable work

falling on the arms, and the remainder on the legs"

in proportion to their ability to do it.The Schlick walking-stick crutch therefore protects the

user from the results of pressure on the armpit with itsrisk of paralysis of the arms. Its use compels the activeeffort of hand, forearm, arm, and shoulder, and is thus anexcellent exercise for the upper limb. On its part, thewounded lower limb functions as much as its strengthallows it; the voluntary muscular contractions assist in

restoring an impeded or sluggish circulation and in pre-venting atrophy and stiffness.We have seen this crutch and submitted it to a careful

;rial and can confirm the claims made on its behalf. Anaval officer who has been using the crutch for more than ayear, on account of a leg rendered nearly useless by injury,inds that it is possible to move about much more quicklyand dexterously than with an ordinary crutch; he can coverialf a dozen miles or more without fatigue, climb stairs,,ross the streets, and enter tramcars and omnibuses with:ase. His attitude is erect, and to the casual observer heappears to be using two sticks and not crutches at all.rhe novice can become proficient in the use of the stickswithin half an hour. The invention has been patented inFrance, and Messrs. S. Maw, Son and Sons are prepared tosupply it in this country.


Recommended