8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

1/37

201056007

!"#$ &'()*"+, "+ "+-)./0+$ *)+("+, +)-1'.$#

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

2/37

!"#$ &'()*"+, "+ "+-)./0+$ *)+("+,

+)-1'.$#

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

3/37

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

4/37

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

5/37

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

6/37

2/#-.03-

45#-)&"3 ."#$ "+ "+-).+0-"'+0* 6"+0+3"0* +)-1'.$ 0."#)# 17)+ 6"+0+3"0* #7'3$

-.08)*# -7.'9,7 /'.().# '6 &0+5 3'9+-.")#: #9/#);9)+-*5 *)0("+, -' 0 ,*'/0* 3."#"#< =+

'.(). -' )#-"&0-) -7) *)8)* '6 -7"# ."#$: 1) 9#) 3'+#'*"(0-)( "+6'.&0-"'+ 6.'& >?

3'9+-.")# '+ /0+$#@ /0*0+3) #7))-# 0+( 3'+#-.93- 0 +)-1'.$ '6 "+-)./0+$ *)+("+,

&0.$)- /0#)( '+ -7) (0-0 '6 &9-90* 3.)("- 3*0"< A7) &0B );90-"'+ ()8)*'B)( /5

!'#80* 0+( C).,#-.'& "# 9#)( -' 8"#90*"D) -7) *)+("+, +)-1'.$< A7) .)#9*- #7'1# 9#

-7) *)8)*# '6 B.'/0/"*"-5 -70- 6"+0+3"0* #7'3$ 1"** /) *'30-)( "+ )037 B0.-"39*0.

3'9+-.5 0- ,"8)+ &'&)+- '6 -"&): 0# 1)** 0# -7) B.'/0/"*"-")# -70- -7"# #7'3$ 1"**

*)08) -7) 3'9+-.5 '. #-05 "+#"()< A7"# 0+0*5#"# 7)*B# 9# -' 9+().#-0+( 175 0 ()609*-

"+ B0.-"39*0. 3'9+-.5 30+ *)0( -' 8).5 *0.,) ,*'/0* 3'+#);9)+3)#: 0# "- 10# (9."+,

>EEF 6"+0+3"0* 3."#"#

?

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

9/37

J

>EEEa #-9("V( 7T1 -7V /W+$"+, #5#-V&

.V#BT+(# -T UT+-W,"T+ 17V+ /W+$# W.V UT++VU-V( 9+(V. ("66V.V+- +V-1T.$

#-.9U-9.V#< =+ W #V--"+, 17V.V UT+#9&V.# 7W8V -7V *";9"("-5 B.V6V.V+UV# "+-.T(9UV(

/5 b"W&T+( W+( b5/8", `?LFJa 17V.V UT+#9&V.# 7W8V .W+(T& *";9"("-5 +VV(#:

/W+$# BV.6VU-*5 "+#9.V W,W"+#- *";9"("-5 #7TU$# /5 VOU7W+,"+, "+-V./W+$ (VBT#"-#EEEa

UT+#"(V.V( -7V UW#V T6 /W+$# -7W- 6WUV *";9"("-5 #7TU$# (9V -T 9+UV.-W"+-5 W/T9-

17V.V UT+#9&V.# 1"** 1"-7(.W1 69+(#< =+ -7V". &T(V*: -7V UT++VU-"T+# /V-1VV+

/W+$# W.V .VW*"DV( -7.T9,7 "+-V./W+$ U.V("- *"+V# -7W- V+W/*V -7V#V "+#-"-9-"T+# -T

7V(,V .V,"T+W* *";9"("-5 #7TU$#< 2# "+ 2**V+ W+( _W*V@# #-9(5: &T.V "+-V./W+$

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

10/37

M

UT++VU-"T+# V+7W+UV -7V .V#"*"V+UV T6 -7V #5#-V& -T -7V "+#T*8V+U5 T6 W BW.-"U9*W.

/W+$< d+V (.W1/WU$ "# -7W- -7"# 1VW$V+# -7V "+UV+-"8V# -T U*T#V "+V66"U"V+- /W+$#EEMa W((.V##V# -7V "##9V T6 TB-"&W* +V-1T.$# 6.T& W

("66V.V+- BV.#BVU-"8VH 7V "# "+-V.V#-V( "+ -7T#V +V-1T.$ W.U7"-VU-9.V# 17V.V

-.W+#6V.# /V-1VV+ /W+$# "&B.T8V (VBT#"-T.#c 9-"*"-5< eV 6"+(# -7W- T+*5 8V.5 (V+#V

+V-1T.$#: 17V.V /W+$# W.V T+*5 W 6V1 *"+$# W1W5 6.T& T+V W+T-7V.: W.V UT&BW-"/*V

1"-7 W fW.V-T TB-"&W* W**TUW-"T+< bW#,9B-W `>EEMa W*#T VOB*T.V# 7T1 *"+$W,V#

/V-1VV+ /W+$#: .VB.V#V+-V( /5 U.T##7T*("+, T6 (VBT#"-#: UW+ /V W #T9.UV T6

UT+-W,"T9# /.VW$(T1+#< A7V #-9(5 VOW&"+V( 7T1 (VBT#"-T.# 17T .VUV"8V W B."8W-V

#",+W* W/T9- /W+$#c 69+(W&V+-W*# &W5 1"#7 -T 1"-7(.W1 -7V". (VBT#"-# "6 -7V5

/V*"V8V -7W- V+T9,7 T-7V. (VBT#"-T.# 1"** (T -7V #W&V< AT V*"&"+W-V -7V &9*-"B*"U"-5

T6 V;9"*"/."W -7V W9-7T. 9#V# -7V UT+UVB- T6 ,*T/W* ,W&V#< bW#,9B-W "#T*W-V( W 9+";9V

V;9"*"/."9&: (VBV+("+, T+ -7V 8W*9V T6 -7V 69+(W&V+-W*#< 2*-7T9,7 -7"# #-9(5

W+W*5DV( T+*5 -1T /W+$#: "- 1T9*( /V "+-V.V#-"+, -T #-9(5 W #V--"+, 17V.V &9*-"B*V

/W+$# W.V UT++VU-V( -7.T9,7 W +V-1T.$EE?a "+8V#-",W-V (V6W9*- /5 6". -7W- W.V BW.- T6 W #"+,*V

U*VW."+, &VU7W+"#&< \".#-: -7V W9-7T.# #7T1 -7V VO"#-V+UV T6 W U*VW."+, BW5&V+-

8VU-T. -7W- (V6"+V# -7V *V8V* T6 UT++VU-"T+# /V-1VV+ 6".< YVO-: -7V5 (V8V*TB W+

W*,T."-7& -7W- W**T1# -7V& -T V8W*9W-V -7V V66VU-# #&W** #7TU$# 7W8V T+ -7V #5#-V&EESa 9#V *W--"UV^-7VT.V-"U &V-7T(# -T #-9(5 *";9"("-5

W+( #5#-V&"U ."#$ "+ 7",7^8W*9V BW5&V+- #5#-V: #9U7 W# 6T. -7V #V--*V&V+- T6

WUUT9+-# .VUV"8W/*V W+( BW5W/*V W&T+, "+(9#-."W* 6".: W+( "+-V./W+$ BW5&V+-

#5#-V< _W" W+( gWBW("W `>EESa (V8V*TB W &T(V* T6 UT+-W,"T+ "+ 6"+W+U"W* +V-1T.$#

W+( 9#V #"&"*W. -VU7+";9V# W# -7V VB"(V&"T*T,"UW* *"-V.W-9.V T+ #B.VW( T6 ("#VW#V "+

+V-1T.$# -T W##V## -7V 6.W,"*"-5 T6 -7V 6"+W+U"W* #5#-V&: (VBV+("+, T+ -7V /W+$#c

UWB"-W* /966V.#: -7V (V,.VV T6 UT++VU-"8"-5: W+( -7V *";9"("-5 T6 -7V &W.$V- 6T. 6W"*V(

/W+$"+, W##V-#< 2# 1"-7 2**V+ W+( _W*V: -7V5 6"+( -7W- ,.VW-V. UT++VU-"8"-5 .V(9UV#

-7V *"$V*"7TT( T6 1"(V#B.VW( (V6W9*-< eT1V8V.: #7TU$# &W5 7W8V W #",+"6"UW+-*5

*W.,V. "&BWU- T+ -7V 6"+W+U"W* #5#-V& 17V+ -7V5 TUU9.< NT.VT8V.: -7V .V#"*"V+UV T6

-7V +V-1T.$ -T *W.,V #7TU$# (VBV+(# T+ #7TU$# 7"--"+, BW.-"U9*W. 6.W,"*V BT"+-#

W##TU"W-V( 1"-7 #-.9U-9.W* 89*+V.W/"*"-"V#a !!!!!"# -7V 1V",7- T+ -7V (".VU-V( *"+$ 6.T& -7V 69+("+, W.& T6/W+$"+, ,.T9B l -T -7V U.V("- W.& T6 -7V /W+$"+, ,.T9B m< A7"# "# -7V

BW-71W5 6T. U.V("- ."#$ /VUW9#V "- .V*W-V# -T -7V V8V+- -7W- /W+$"+,,.T9B l (V6W9*-# T+ "-# *TW+ 6.T& /W+$"+, ,.T9B mh

Ja !!!!! "# -7V 1V",7- T+ -7V (".VU-V( *"+$ 6.T& -7V U.V("- W.& T6/W+$"+, ,.T9B l -T -7V 69+("+, W.& T6 /W+$"+, ,.T9B m< A7"# "# -7V

TW-7 6T. 69+("+, ."#$ /VUW9#V "- .V*W-V# -T -7V V8V+- -7W- /W+$"+,

,.T9B l #-TB# *V+("+, -T /W+$"+, ,.T9B mh

+&,'-. /&01 2 .0 3

+&,'-. /&01 3 .0 2

!! !!

!!

!!

CW+$l

CW+$ m

/45'-56 7&1

/45'-567&1

+&,'-. 7&1

+&,'-. 7&1

8-64&, 9) :;, (-175? =,5'-56 5,.$0&? +05(-(.-56 @4(. 0/ .$0 >75?(

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

17/37

??

`?a

`>a

`Ja

Ma !!!!!

"# -7V 1V",7- T+ -7V (".VU-V( *"+$ 6.T& -7V 69+("+, W.& T6

/W+$"+, ,.T9B m -T -7V U.V("- W.& T6 -7V /W+$"+, ,.T9B l< A7"# "# -7V

BW-71W5 6T. U.V("- ."#$ /VUW9#V "- .V*W-V# -T -7V V8V+- -7W- /W+$"+,

,.T9B m (V6W9*-# T+ "-# *TW+ 6.T& /W+$"+, ,.T9B l? .VBT.-"+, UT9+-."V# W.V "+U*9(V( "+ -7V +V-1T.$H 29#-."W:

29#-.W*"W: CV*,"9&: GW+W(W: -7V GW5&W+ =#*W+(#: 41"-DV.*W+(: _V.&W+5: _.VVUV:

bV+&W.$: 4BW"+: \"+*W+(: \.W+UV: i+"-V( g"+,(T&: =.V*W+(: =-W*5: qWBW+: I9OV&/T9.,:

YV-7V.*W+(#: fT.-9,W*: 41V(V+: W+( -7V i+"-V( 4-W-V#< 2&T+, -7V#V W.V -7T#V

UT9+-."V#: 17"U7 W.V -7V &T#- "&BT.-W+- -T -7V +V-1T.$: W+( &W+5 T6 -7V UT9+-."V#

VOU*9(V( (T +T- 7W8V UT&B*V-V #V."V#< 2** -T,V-7V. -7V #9/#W&B*V UWB-9.V# W/T9-

SJj T6 -T-W* .VBT.-"+, /W+$#@ U*W" T+ /W+$# "+ W** 8"#^W^8"# UT9+-."V# W+( -7V

,.T1-7 .W-V T6 -7V -T-W* U*W" "+ -7V #9/#V- "# 8V.5 #"&"*W. -T -7V ,.T1-7 .W-V "+ -7V

-T-W* W8W"*W/*V -T -7V C=4?EEFr> -T

>EELr?aJ

4"+UV -7V+ -7V &W.$V- "# #-"** "+ .VUT8V.5 k ,.T1-7 .W-V 8W."V# W.T9+( DV.T

BV.UV+-P

17"U7 UT+-W"+# &T(9*V#@ B.V#-",V# W+( *V8V*# T6 UT+-W,"T+ `-7V B.T/W/"*"-"V# T6

UT+-W,"T+ -.W+#&"--"+, -T +V",7/T."+, &T(9*V#aEEP `JPj T+ W8V.W,Va

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

32/37

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

33/37

>S

G'+3*9#"'+

[7)+ 6"+0+3"0* #-.)## 30+ /) 3'+-0"+)( 1"-7"+ 0 6)1 3'9+-.")#: "- 30+ /) &'.)

)0#"*5 ()0*- 1"-7< C9- +'1: -70- -7) "+-).+0-"'+0* /0+$ +)-1'.$ 70# /)3'&) #'"+-).3'++)3-)(: -7) ."#$ /)3'&)# -.9*5 #5#-)&"3< =+ -7"# #"-90-"'+: #'*9-"'+ "# 8).5

3'&B*"30-)(: -7) B.'/0/"*"-")# '6 ()609*- 0.) 7",7). 0+( -7) *'##)# 0.) *0.,).F

!)6).)+3)#

1. Haldane, A G (2009), Rethinking the Financial Network,Bank of England.2. Minoiu, C and Reyes, G A (2010), A network analysis of global banking: 1978

2009,IMF Working Paper.

3. Barabasi, A-L (2002), Linked: The New Science of Networks,Perseus Publishing.4. Barabasi et al. (2000), Error and attack tolerance of complex networks,Nature,

406, 378-382.

5. Easley, D and Kleinberg, J (2010), Networks, Crowds and Markets, CambridgeUniversity Press.

6. Mieghem, P V (2011), Graph Spectra for Complex Networks, CambridgeUniversity Press.

7. May, R M, Levin, S A and Sugihara, G (2008), Ecology for bankers,Nature, 451,893-895.

8. Battison et al. (2009), Liaisons dangereuses: increasing connectivity, risk sharingand system risk,NBER Working Paper.

9. Garatt, R J, Mahadeva, L and Svirudzenka, K (2011), Mapping systemic risk in theinternational banking network,Bank of England Working Paper.

10.Cont, R, Moussa, A and Santos, E B (2010), Network structure and systemic risk inbanking systems,IMF Workshop.

11.Rosvalll, M and Bergstrom, C T (2008), Maps of random walks on complexnetworks reveal community structure,Proceedings of the National Academy of

Sciences of the United Statesof America, Vol. 105, No. 4, January, 11823.

12. Allen, F., and D Gale (2000): Financial Contagion, Journal of Political Economy,108(1), 1-33.

13.Babus, A. (2007): The Formation of Financial Networks, Discussion Paper 06-093,Tinbergen Institute.

14.Barabasi, A., and R. Albert (1999): Emergency of Scaling in Random Networks,Science, 286, 509-512.

15.Boss, M., H. Elsinger, S. Thurner, and M. Summer (2004): Network Topology oftheInterbank Market, Quantitative Finance, 4, 1-8.

16.Castiglionesi, F., and N. Navarro (2007): Optimal Fragile FinancialNetworks,working paper, Tilburg University.

17.Cocco, J., F. Gomes, and N. Martins (2005): Lending Relationships in theInterbankMarket, working paper, London Business School.

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

35/37

>L

18.Dasgupta, A. (2004): Financial Contagion through Capital Connections: A Model ofthe Origin and Spread of Bank Panics, Journal of European Economic Association,

2(6), 1049-1084.

19.DeVries, C. (2005): The Simples Economics of Bank Fragility, Journal of BankingandFinance, 29(4), 803-825.

20.Degryse, H., and G. Nguyen (2007): Interbank Exposures: An EmpiricalExamination of Systemic Risk in the Belgian Banking System, International Journal

of Central Banking.

21.Mistrulli, P. E. (2007): Assessing financial contagion in the interbank market:Maximum entropy versus observed interbank lending patterns,Bank of Italy

Working Paper

22.Censor, Y. and Zenios, S.A. (1997), Parallel optimization, Oxford University Press.

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

36/37

JE

8/13/2019 Risk Modeling in Interbank Lending Networks

37/37

1987 02 28

Z(930-"'+>E?EuEL ] G9..)+- C)"K"+, i+"8).#"-5 '6 =+-).+0-"'+0* C9#"+)## 0+( Z3'+'&"3#

["++). '6 G7"+)#) _'8).+&)+- 437'*0.#7"B

I0#- 5)0. #-9()+-: N0#-). "+ \"+0+3) (),.)) 30+("(0-)

>EELuEL ] >E?EuES C)"K"+, i+"8).#"-5 '6 =+-).+0-"'+0* C9#"+)## 0+( Z3'+'&"3#

G'&B*)-)( "+-).&)("0-) &0+(0."+ G7"+)#) B.',.0&

>EEFuEL ] >EELuEQ 230()&5 '6 Z3'+'&"3 4-9(")# '6 N'*('80

b),.))H N0#-). '6 \"+0+3) `9+3'&B*)-)(h -''$ 0 #0//0-"30* *)08)

06-). 1"++"+, G7"+)#) _'8).+&)+- 437'*0.#7"Ba

>EEPuEL ] >EEFuES 230()&5 '6 Z3'+'&"3 4-9(")# '6 N'*('80

b),.))H C037)*'. "+ Z3'+'&"3#

N0K'.H \"+0+3) 0+( /0+$"+,

_.0(90-)( "+ -7) -'B 79+(.)( '6 QEEFuEL ] >EEFu?? A.0"+)( 0# 0 3).-"6")( #B)3"0*"#- "+ -7) ('&0"+ '6 39#-' 3*)0.0+3)

G7"#"+09: N'*('80

>EEFuEP =+-)+#"8) /9#"+)## -.0"+"+, vC9#"+)## B*0++"+, 0+( /0#"# '6

)+-.)B.)+)9.#7"Bw 9+(). IZ2bZ! B.'K)3- '6 -7) G0+0("0+ !"370.(

=8)5 437''* '6 C9#"+)## `033'.("+, -' -7) 4)B-)&/). >EES )("-"'+ '6

-7) [0** 4-.))- q'9.+0* -7"# "# -7) ?>^-7 /)#- /9#"+)## #37''* "+ -7)

1'.*(a

>EEFuEM =+-).+#7"B "+ -7) N'*('80^2,.'"+(/0+$ 3'&&).3"0* /0+$

>EEFuE> ] >EEFuEJ 2# 0+ 2YA"N &)&/). `2##'3"0-"'+ '6 5'9+, &0+0,).# '6 N'*('80a

1'.$)( 0# 0+ )O)39-"8) 0##"#-0+- "+ '.,0+"D0-"'+ '6 -7) C9#"+)## f*0+

G'&B)-"-"'+ >EEF `GCf>EEF ] 3'&B)-"-"'+ 6'. 5'9+, )+-.)B.)+)9.#h

1"++).# .)3)"8) 69+("+, 6'. -7)". /9#"+)## B*0+#a>EESu?E ] >EESu?? e)0()( &0.$)- .)#)0.37 6'. 0+ =-0*"0+ /9#"+)##&0+: 0"&)( -'

()-).&"+) -7) &'#- 0(80+-0,)'9# *'30-"'+ 6'. -7) 6'.-73'&"+,

3'+#-.93-"'+ '6 -7) #7'BB"+, &0**

>EEQuE> ] >EELuES ['.$)( B0.-^-"&) "+ -7) 17'*)^#0*) 3'&B0+5 v_"0+"#^=&B)Ow 0# 0

&).370+("#) &0+0,). .)#B'+#"/*) 6'. -7) /", .)-0"* #-'.)# "+3*9("+,

NZA!d 0+( \'9.37)--)