1 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
2 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
contact information Dr. Robin W. Spencer [email protected]
Steve Street
Mark Turrell, Tim Woods
Anne Rogers, Kurt Detloff
Jon Bidwell
Howard Smith
Mike Hatrick, Dave Wootten
Employer
Partner
colleagues sharing data
Many Thanks
Outline
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 3
How
Who
Why Why are we using social media?
Who is our audience?
How should we proceed?
Bonafides and Context
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 4 4
• World’s largest pharmaceutical company
• $7 billion annual R&D
• Tightly focused, managed research teams
• Success depends on mastering the intrinsic complexity, uncertainty, and rapid change of the underlying science*
* Gary Pisano (2006) Science Business
• Scientist & manager, 29 years in R&D
• Past 5 years leading innovation initiative
• Retired, 2nd career developing collaborative intelligence systems me
Outline
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 5
How
Who
Why are we using social media ? Why
Why we’re using social media
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 6
Our goals ARE large-scale, flexible participation inside a large corporation, for
• necessities: saving time & money • opportunities: new products & services • processes: scaled, efficient decisions & allocation • matching specific needs with specific knowledge
Our goals ARE NOT • connecting to “friends” • marketing retail products (books, music, clothing,...)
Goals affect what we’re looking for
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 7
For external marketing, we seek the average.
For internal problem solving, we usually seek specifics.
Goals affect what we’re looking for
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 8
We know this works. It’s just another medium, we’re figuring it out.
Social media methods work here too – but with some variations.
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 9
Confusion or disagreement about goals is the major reason why projects fail.
Get this straight up-front! Watch out for tambourine people...
Outline
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 10
How
Who is our audience ?
Why
Who
Digression for Marketing: a Tom Peters Rant
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 11
source: US Census data, at http://www.census.gov/prod/2005pubs/c2kbr-36.pdf http://manyeyes.alphaworks.ibm.com/manyeyes/datasets/
Why are you focusing on Millenials ?
History & Anthropology Lesson
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 12 sources: employed scientists and engineers with PhD degrees, 2006, National Science Foundation,
http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/; M Gladwell, Outliers
+ + =
Half of those with advanced degrees in science and engineering are over age 50. They will soon leave faster than they can be replaced. If you need these skills, target them now.
Outline
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 13
Why
Who
How How should we proceed, based on huge amounts of data and experience?
14 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
The “Idea Farm” is an all-company collaborative innovation and problem-solving system.
We ran 30-50 campaigns every year.
This approach is known to be effective and sustainable.
Pfizer experience
15 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
? ?
Diverge-Converge Model
The diverge-converge model is centuries old, proven effective, and scales perfectly with electronic media.
The classic example is the Longitude Act of 1714; see Dava Sobel’s book Longitude
16 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
The best projects give participants options and use the right tools at the right time.
Collaboration Technologies
meetings
on line
mobile
http://chubbsocialmedia.imaginatik.com
The Long Tail
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 17
There is a Long Tail of large scale collaboration behavior.
It matters because the results are non-obvious, universal, and now predictable.
Chris Anderson’s book tells the story for retail books and music. His observations, conclusions, and advice apply directly to collaborative innovation.
This is Mr Darcy with his long tail.
Classic vs Long Tail Statistics
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 18
What’s the average height of people?
What’s the average number of ideas from
our employees?
ideas per person
how
ofte
n it
occu
rs
• It’s nothing like a bell curve.
• “Average” makes no sense.
• Some people enter no ideas, some enter hundreds. The range is huge.
inches of height per person
how
ofte
n it
occu
rs
• It’s a bell curve.
• “Average” is a useful description.
• The range of values is only a factor of 2.
Log-log graphs reveal the tail
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 19
linear graph
Log-log plots show the tail clearly.
A straight line on a log-log graph has the form y = Cx-b , a power law.
I graph these like Zipf, with the axes are flipped vs the Pareto convention. Slopes here = b = 1/(α-1)
log-log
Pfizer Idea Farm 2006-2009 20,000 entries from 4000 authors in >200 campaigns
Long Tails are everywhere
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 20
• book and music sales
• word usage
• internet hits
• salaries
• avalanches
• wildfires
M. E. J. Newman (2006) Power laws, Pareto distributions and Zipf’s law, http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0412004v3
Four Companies, One Phenomenon
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 21
Each dataset is a single campaign at a different company.
Lines all have α=3.0
22 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
These are huge datasets over 3-4 years and thousands of people each.
These very different businesses show identical behavior patterns.
Cargill and Pfizer
Long Tails in Public Forums
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 23
M. E. J. Newman, Power laws, Pareto distributions and Zipf’s law, at http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0412004v3, 2004.
D. Wilkinson, Strong regularities in online peer production, in Proceedings of the 2008 ACM Conference on E-Commerce, Chicago, IL, July 2008, at http://www.hpl.hp.com/research/scl/papers/regularities/
Long tails (power laws) are the norm for large scale voluntary contributions.
Wikipedia and Digg
The Value of a Contribution
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 24
The value* of an entry from a top contributor is the same as that from a rare contributor.
The huge number of singleton authors puts their value far ahead of the top contributors.
* Value was measured for multiple large internal challenges, assigned by rankings of the sponsoring business unit.
Consequence #1
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 25
Most of your contributions and value come from the occasional contributors.
from authors of 1 idea
of 2 ideas
of 3
Do not bias your system by quantity or “reputation”; you may exclude your best contributors.
Consequence #2
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 26 sources: Twitter: Heil and Piskorski, Harvard Business School October 2009; Digg, Wikipedia: Wilkinson, Hewlett-Packard labs; other, this work
What percent of people put in 80% of the content? 80%
Twitter tweets 5%
Digg votes
9%
comments, star votes
21- 28%
Wikipedia edits
46%
corporate ideas
58- 68%
info
rmat
ion
cont
ent
The simpler the task, the less representative the results.
Dirty Secrets of 5 Star Voting
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 27
• it’s biased
• it’s compressed
• followers drive to extremes
• difficulty drives balance
How public opinion forms, Fang Wu and Bernardo A. Huberman, Social Computing Lab, HP Labs, Palo Alto, CA 94304, http://www.hpl.hp.com/research/scl/papers/howopinions/wine.pdf
Is the crowd’s wisdom biased? A quantitative assessment of three online communities, Vassilis Kostakos, at http://arxiv.org/pdf/0909.0237
“...when people observe previous opinions ... they tend to follow the trend. As a result ... extreme views get reinforced and become increasingly more extreme.
“... where expressing a view is costly, like when writing a book review...people will tend to ... offset the current view by presenting a differing one.”
“This analysis has shown that the wisdom of the crowd is indeed biased.”
Analysis of Amazon: 380,000 reviews of 21,000 books by 134,000 people
Amazon average is 4.4 out of 5
People take different roles
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 28
Ideators Commenters
Voters
46%
25%
7% 8%
4% 5%
5%
Percents are of people (not entries); combined results from 8700 people, 34,000 entries, 20 campaigns, 7 companies
Lurkers = 2.5x all
others combined
29 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
These observations are pervasive and robust, you can’t
change them.
Does it matter?
Do you want to scale up creative collaboration in an
unbiased, representative way?
We can do better !
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 30
Know your history, your data, your options
What this talk has tried to convey !
We can do better !
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 31
Know your history, your data, your options
automated community-of-interest perception
real-time analysis of representation
real-time analysis of participation and actions
Great tools make it easy to watch your events and put it in context.
We can do better !
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 32
Know your history, your data, your options
There are many tactics to have your cake (large scale, open collaboration) and eat it too (with balanced representation and low bias).
• identity control • quantity control • length minima • pay-to-play • professional moderation • decision market rating • rate-the-raters • pairwise evaluation
Join me for a Think Tank on Collaborative
Evaluation Boston, June, hosted by
Swap business cards, or contact me at [email protected]
Take Home
Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010 33
• Know your goals. Do you seek the average or the outliers?
• Adapt the message and medium to your audience. Not the other way ‘round
• Half your content comes from people who contribute just once. Recognize quality, not quantity.
• Don’t dumb it down; welcome length and richness. Beware of bias-by-twits.
• Do better: know your history, your data, and your options. Join me for a workshop.
34 Rob Spencer, Social Media and Marketing, Boston, May 2010
Questions ?