+ All Categories
Home > Documents > S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ......

S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ......

Date post: 27-Mar-2018
Category:
Upload: ledung
View: 214 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
35
An EDISON INTERNATIONAL® Company (U 338-E) 2015 General Rate Case APPLICATION Workpapers Results of Operations (RO) Plant, Taxes, Depreciation Expense and Reserve, Rate Base, and Productivity SCE-10 Volume 02, Chapter III November 2013
Transcript
Page 1: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

An E D IS O N IN TERN AT IO N A L® Company

(U 338-E)

2015 General Rate Case APPLICATION

Workpapers

Results of Operations (RO)Plant, Taxes, Depreciation Expense and Reserve, Rate Base, and Productivity SCE-10 Volume 02, Chapter III

N ovem ber 2013

Page 2: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION1

III.

DEPRECIATION STUDY

A. Purpose and Scope

T his section o f the R esu lts o f O perations presents SC E ’s proposed depreciation param eters and

rates p roposed for the 2 0 1 5 -2 0 1 7 period. SCE retained D ane W atson from A llian ce C onsu lting Group

to conduct and support the depreciation study for S C E ’s 2015 G R C , w h ich is presented in SC E -10,

V olu m e 3, “D irect T estim on y o f D ane A . W atson” and the accom panying D epreciation Study.

T here are depreciation param eters that are n ot d iscu ssed in Mr. W atson ’s testim ony, w h ich w ill

b e d iscu ssed in th is chapter. T hese parameters are related to the fo llow ing:

• San O nofre N u clear G enerating Station (SO N G S )

• Four Corners G enerating Station

• M ohave G enerating Station

• Solar 2 D ecom m ission in g

• M ountainview U nits 1 and 2 D ecom m ission in g

T hese assets are not addressed in Mr. W atson’s testim ony due to the unique circum stances

surrounding them , the depreciation param eters for th ese assets w ill be d iscu ssed in Section E b elow .

B. Summary of Proposal

O verall, SCE is proposing changes in depreciation rates that w ill result in a total increase o f

S19743 m illion b ased on 20 1 2 plant.44

43 $88 million o f the increase is associated with SONGS. The non-SONGS related increase in proposed depreciation expenseis $108 million.

44 See Deprecation Forecast in Chapter II o f this volume, for the total forecast o f depreciation expense for 2015, 2016 and 2017.

24

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 3: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

See WP p.4

Figure III-2Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class o f Plant

Based on Year-End 2012 Plant Balances

D

A uthorized Ra tes SO N G S Proposed Rates

1,800

88

1,500

1,450

1,400G&I

T he decrease in annual depreciation exp en se for production p lant is driven by the ex ten sion o f

the licen se life at the P alo V erde N u clear G eneration Station. Increases in annual depreciation expense

for transm ission and distribution assets are due to , increasing rem oval co sts, m itigated by som e

lengthen ing serv ice life expectations. T ransm ission and distribution im pacts are d iscu ssed in m ore

detail b e low . T he increases in annual depreciation exp en se for general and intangib le assets is largely

due to changes in lives.

1. Overview of Transmission and Distribution

P roposed increases in depreciation rates for transm ission and distribution assets is driven

b y increases in n et sa lvage costs (co sts to retire assets), m itigated by lon ger average serv ice liv e s , as

show n b e lo w in F igure III-3.

25

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 4: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION3

S e e W P p . 1 6

Figure III-3 Depreciation Expense Im pact o f

Transmission & Distribution Parameter Updates

Authorized Rates Life Updates N et Salvage Updates Proposed Rates

SC E ’s proposal results in a transm ission and distribution com p osite depreciation rate o f

4.02% . T his is a reasonable increase com pared to past proposed levels:

S e e W P p . 1 8 " I "

26

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 5: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

4Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

S e e W P p . 1 8

Figure III-4 Proposed and Authorized

Transmission & Distribution Composite Depreciation Rates Based on Year-End 2012 Plant Balances

6.0%

5.5%

f» 5.0%-W

g 4.5% •J=.g

u 4.0%Mau

O

Proposedc

E

4.14%

3.5%

3.0%

General Rate Case

T he increase in net sa lvage costs (typ ica lly expressed as a percent o f plant b e in g retired)

is not a recent d iscovery . SC E has b een requesting larger n egative net sa lvage rates for over a decade

n ow , but authorized param eters have not kept pace. Figure III-5 b e lo w sh ow s proposed net sa lvage and

authorized n et sa lvage for S C E ’s transm ission and distribution assets as a percent o f plant over the last

four G eneral R ate C ases.45

45 D.12-11-051 requested that SCE provide testimony in asset accounts where SCE’s proposed net salvage rate is at least 25% more than comparable industry averages. SCE does not possess nor is it aware of any industry statistics that provides recorded net salvage ratios to make such a comparison possible.

27

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 6: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION5

Figure III-5 Proposed and Authorized

Transmission & Distribution Composite Net Salvage Rates Based on Year-End 2012 Plant Balances

General Rate Case

1 In each o f the cases, SCE has proposed m oderate increases over the then current

2 authorized lev e ls . W hile the p roposed net sa lvage percentages m ay appear sign ifican t, includ ing the

3 proposed am ounts over 2 0 1 2 authorized lev e ls , the actual recorded lev e ls o f n et sa lvage are far greater,

4 as show n in Figure III-6 b elow .

28

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 7: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

6Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Figure III-6 Transmission & Distribution Recorded N et Salvage Rates

Compared to Proposed and Authorized Levels

a

MSS

73V I

160%

140%

120%

100%

80%

60%

40%

20%

0%

146%

113%

101%

See WP p.20

Proposed (64%)

Authorized (47%)

1998 2012 2003 2012 2008 2012

Recorded Period

T he gap b etw een authorized net sa lvage and recorded net sa lvage is deferred to future

ratepayers, w h o w ill bear the cost. T he am ount deferred is not static-it continues to accum ulate w ith

each p assin g year that a gap exists.

E ven on a dollar b asis, w h en com paring the total net sa lvage experienced relative to plant

retirem ents to the future proposed am ounts, the request is m od est and reasonable. Figure III-7 b e low

sh ow s 15 years o f recorded retirem ent experience, w here SCE has incurred approxim ately $1 .6 b illion in

net sa lvage costs from $2.3 b illion in retirem ents. SC E ’s proposal is to have recovered approxim ately

$15.1 b illion over the rem aining life s o f $ 2 3 .4 b illion in retirem ents ($2 .7 b illion o f w h ich has been

recovered through the end o f 2012).

B

A

AE - See

D WP p. 12A,B,C,D - See WP p.20

29

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 8: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION7

S e e W P p . 2 0

Figure III-7 Recorded and Future

Transmission & Distribution Plant Retirements and Net Salvage

sc

$25

$20

$15

$10

$5

$0

23.4

□ R etirem ents

■ N et Salvage

15 Years Recorded Future (All Current Assets)

C. Depreciation Background

1. Purpose of Depreciation

To provide serv ice to its custom ers, SCE incurs both exp en ses and capital expenditures.

G enerally A ccep ted A ccou n tin g P rincip les, sp ec ifica lly the M atching Principle,46 govern w hether a

particular cost should be cap italized or expensed . W hile the return on SC E ’s capital assets is m ade by

applying an authorized rate o f return (cost o f capital) to its net investm ent, the return o f in vestors’ capital

investm ent is m ade through depreciation expense. D epreciation is a m ajor exp en se representing the

recovery o f the original cost o f fixed capital le ss estim ated n et sa lvage over an a sset’s u sefu l life . SC E ’s

investors are entitled to recover costs they in vested to provide electric serv ice to S C E ’s custom ers. The

depreciation rates SCE proposed in th is exh ib it are d esign ed to accom plish that objective.

46 The matching principle states that each expense item related to revenue earned must be recorded in the same accounting period as the revenue it helped to earn.

30

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 9: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

2. CPUC’s Standard Practice U-4

SC E fo llo w s the C o m m ission ’s Standard Practice U -4 , D eterm ination o f Straight-Line

R em ain ing L ife D epreciation A ccruals (“U -4 ,” or “ Standard Practice U -4 ”), dated January 3, 1961.

Standard Practice U -4 “sets forth various factors in fluencing the determ ination o f depreciation accruals

and describes m ethods o f calcu lating th ese accruals” w ith the purpose o f assisting “the C om m ission sta ff

in determ ining proper depreciation exp en ses.”47 A lthou gh over 4 0 years old , the Standard Practice U -4

represents conventional u tility depreciation practices and the C PU C continues to adhere to this standard.

3. Current Gap to Accomplishing Depreciation Objectives and Meeting Requirements

in Standard Practice U-4

A s sum m arized above and addressed in detail in Mr. W atson ’s testim on y,48 the

depreciation study addresses the gap that ex ists betw een recorded net sa lvage and authorized net sa lvage

for SC E ’s transm ission and distribution assets. For several o f SC E ’s accounts, the authorized net

sa lvage rates are sign ifican tly low er than w hat SCE continues to experience and w hat w e reasonably

exp ect to occur in the future. Standard Practice U -4 ’s requirem ent is to u se the exp ected future net

sa lvage to m eet the objective o f depreciation. T he disparity b etw een our exp ected future net sa lvage and

the authorized am ounts prevents SCE from properly m atching asset costs to the periods custom ers are

receiv in g the serv ice o f that asset, w h ich is the fundam ental objective o f depreciation. C ost m atching

ensures that future custom ers aren’t burdened w ith a disproportionate share o f costs or costs for assets

from w h ich they receive no benefit. T he longer the disparity ex ists, the greater the burden future

custom ers w ill have to bear.

D. Depreciation Study Results

1. Summary of Results

SC E retained D ane W atson o f A llian ce C onsulting Group to conduct the depreciation

study to d evelop and support proposals for serv ice lives and net sa lvage for SC E ’s assets (w ith the

excep tion o f the assets d iscu ssed in Section E b e lo w ).49 T able III-9 (b e low ) sum m arizes the authorized

depreciation rates for SC E ’s m ass assets and rem aining liv es o f certain generation assets:

47 Standard Practice U-4 “sets forth various factors in influencing the determination of depreciation accruals and describes methods of calculating these accruals to assist the Commission staff in determining proper depreciation expenses.”

48 See Exhibit SCE-10, Volume 3.

49 Id.

31

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 10: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION9

S e e W P p p . 2 - 1 1

Table III-9 Transmission, Distribution, and General Plant

Depreciation Accrual Rates Years 2012-2017

Account No. Account Description 2012 2014 2015 2017Authorized (%) Proposed (%)

Transmission Plant350 Easements 1.67 % 1.67 %352 Structures and Improvements 2.38 % 2.53 %353 Station Equipment 2.89 % 3.04 %354 Towers and Fixtures 2.54 % 3.17 %355 Poles and Fixtures 3.43 % 4.38 %356 Overhead Conductors & Devices 3.57 % 3.67 %357 Underground Conduit 1.70 % 1.73 %358 Underground Conductors & Devices 2.81 % 2.65 %359 Roads and Trails 1.69 % 1.52 %

Distribution Plant360 Easements 1.67 % 1.67 %361 Structures and Improvements 3.20 % 3.04 %362 Station Equipment 3.13 % 3.28 %364 Poles, Towers and Fixtures 7.06 % 7.81 %365 Overhead Conductors & Devices 4.61 % 5.15 %366 Underground Conduit 2.16 % 2.45 %367 Underground Conductors & Devices 3.35 % 3.90 %368 Line Transformers 3.68 % 3.93 %369 Services 4.76 % 5.76 %370 Meters Non SmartConnect 6yr RL 6yr RL370 Meters SmartConnect 5.35 % 5.30 %373 Street Lighting & Signal Systems 2.73 % 3.43 %

General Plant389 Easements 1.67 % 1.67 %390 Structures and Improvements 1.80 % 2.74 %

391.1 Office Furniture 5.00 % 5.00 %391.2 Personal Computers 20.00 % 20.00 %391.3 Mainframe Computers 20.00 % 20.00 %391.4 DDSMS Security Monitoring System 16.31 % 12.90 %391.5 Office Equipment 20.00 % 20.00 %391.6 Duplicating Equipment 20.00 % 20.00 %391.7 PC Software 20.00 % 20.00 %393 Stores Equipment 5.00 % 5.00 %394 Tools & Work Equipment 10.00 % 10.00 %395 Laboratory Equipment 6.67 % 6.67 %397 Telecommunication Equipment 7.57 % 9.77 %398 Misc Power Plant Equipment 5.00 % 5.00 %

Production PlantMohave Generating Station 3yr RL 3yr RLFour Corners Generating Station 2yr RL 5yr RLSan Onofre Nuclear Generating Station Used and Useful 9.2yr RL 9.5yr RLSan Onofre Nuclear Generating Station Not Required 9.2yr RL 5yr RLPalo Verde Nuclear Generating Station 12.7yr RL 33.5yr RLPeakers 19.4yr RL 20.6yr RLMountainview Units 3&4 19.1yr RL 23.0yr RLSolar Photvoltaic 17.2 yr RL 18.6yr RLFuel Cell N/A 10yr RL

32

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 11: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

2. Use of Aged Data

A s part o f the d ecision in SC E ’s 2 0 1 2 GRC, the C om m ission d irected that “ SCE should

inform the C om m ission w hether it u sed any aged data and i f not, w h en su ffic ien t data is exp ected to be

availab le .”50 SCE began co llectin g aged data in the m idd le o f 2 0 0 8 , and does not have su ffic ien t aged

data to perform an e ffec tiv e actuarial life analysis. SC E expects that aged data m ay b ecom e u sefu l in 10

years or so.

E. Select Generation Assets

SC E has five generation plants that h ave already b een or w ill be shut dow n during the years

2 0 1 5 -2 0 1 7 . T he circum stances surrounding th ese assets and the proposed cost recovery o f the

rem aining unrecovered investm ent w ill be addressed in this section . T he five plants are: 1) San Onofre

G enerating Station; 2 ) Four Corners G enerating Station; 3 ) M oh ave G enerating Station; 4 ) Solar 2

D ecom m ission in g; and 5) M ou nta inview U nits 1 & 2 D ecom m ission in g .

1. San Onofre Generating Station

SC E announced the perm anent shutdow n o f SO N G S U n its 2and 3 on June 7, 2 013 . SCEP p .22is proposing to retain the current authorized life for SO N G S plant that is c la ssif ied as u sed and usefu l

and am ortize the unrecovered investm ent through the rem aining life o f 9 .5 years (through June 2022 ).

For SO N G S plant that is no longer required SC E is proposing a 5 year rem aining life b eg in n ing June

2013.

In addition to the fix ed asset costs, the balance o f m aterials and supplies is approxim ately

$1 0 0 m illion at year-end 2 0 1 2 . SC E is proposing to am ortize this balance along w ith capital investm ent

over the rem aining life starting 2015 .

2. Four Corners Generating Station

Four Corners is assum ed to cease operations in July 2 0 1 6 and initiate d ecom m ission in g

activ ities. B ased on the depreciation life authorized in SC E ’s 2 0 1 2 G R C , SCE w ill have fu lly

depreciated the net investm ent through 20 1 4 in addition to $37 m illion authorized for d ecom m ission in g .

There is $28 m illion o f additional capital and d ecom m iss ion in g costs exp ected in the 2 0 1 5 -2 0 1 7 period

above w hat w ill have b een accrued for through 2 0 1 4 .51 SC E is proposing to am ortize th ese costs over

the 2 0 1 5 -2 0 1 7 period.

50 D .12-11-051.

51 See Exhibit SCE-02, Volume 6, Part 2.

33

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 12: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION11

3. Mohave Generating Station

T he M ohave G enerating Station w as shut dow n on 1 2 /3 1 /2005 . Pursuant to D .1 2 -1 1 -

051 , SCE w ill continue to am ortize the net investm ent and d ecom m ission in g costs through 2 015 . The

balance o f th ese costs is $23 m illion as o f 1 2 /3 1 /2012 . In addition, there are capital costs related to

continued operations and the aquifer study w h ich have not b een c lo sed to plant and depreciated. SC E is

proposing to retain the authorized a llocation period and depreciate the balance o f th ese costs ($26

m illion ), in 2015 .

4. Solar 2 Decommissioning

SC E w as authorized to accrue approxim ately $3 m illion in d ecom m ission in g costs for its

Solar 2 generating facility .52 SCE has sin ce com pleted the d ecom m ission in g at a total cost o f

approxim ately $1 m illion . SCE is prop osing to am ortize the balance o f depreciation accrued, but not

spent, back to custom ers over the 2 0 1 5 -2 0 1 7 GRC period.

5. Mountainview Units 1 and 2 Decommissioning

SC E w as authorized to accrue approxim ately $11 m illion in d ecom m ission in g costs for

its M oun tainview U nits 1 and 2 generating facility .53 SC E has since com pleted the d ecom m ission in g at

a total cost o f approxim ately $3 m illion . SCE is proposing to am ortize the balance o f depreciation

accrued, but not spent, back to custom ers over the 2 0 1 5 -2 0 1 7 GRC period.

52 D.12-11-051.

53 Id.

34

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 13: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

2015 General Rate Case - APPLICATION INDEX OF WORKPAPERS

EXHIBIT SCE-10, Volume 2

DOCUMENT PAGE(S)Comparison of Depreciation Accrual Rates Straight Line Remaining Life Method 1-4

Annual Accrual Rate Determination Straight Line Life Method 5-14Account Impact of Life and Net Salvage Parameters 15-16Transmission and Distribution Composite Rate Calculations 17-20SONGS Materials & Supplies Recorded Balance 21-22

Page 14: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION1

S C E - 1 0 , V o lu m e 2 , R e s u l t s o f O p e r a t io n s

D e p r e c ia t i o n S t u d y

Witness: Rick Fisher

C o m p a r is o n o f D e p r e c ia t i o n A c c r u a l R a te s

S t r a ig h t L i n e R e m a i n i n g L i f e M e t h o d

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 15: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

2Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Southern California Edison Comparison of Depreciation Accrual Rates

Straight Line Remaining Life Method For Estimated Year 2015 ($ 000's)

PRESENT PRESENT PROPOSED PROPOSEDANNUAL ANNUAL ANNUAL ANNUAL INCREASE

GROSS PLANT FUTURE RESERVE ACCRUAL ACCRUAL ACCRUAL ACCRUAL (DECREASE)Production Jan. 1, 2013 DECOMM Jan. 1, 2013 RATE/LIFE AMOUNT RATE/LIFE AMOUNT IN ACCRUALNuclear Production

PVNGS Production 1,786,975 1,464,327 12.7 25,405 33.5 9,619 (15,786)PVNGS DBD & Debits 26,547 24,017 13.1 193 33.5 75 (118)SONGS Used and Useful 2,381,540 2,045,980 9.2 36,474 9.5 35,321 (1,153)SONGS - Retires 2,418,299 1,996,619 9.2 45,835 5.0 84,336 38,501SGRP 584,172 25,048 9.2 60,774 5.0 111,825 51,050

Total Nuclear Production 7,197,533 5,555,991 9.7 168,681 6.8 241,176 72,495

Steam ProductionMountainview 698,273 (9,493) 165,077 19.1 28,413 23.0 23,596 (4,817)Four Corners 589,434 (36,581) 547,310 2.0 39,393 2.0 39,393 0Mohave - Production 312,317 (32,711) 321,838 3.0 7,727 3.0 7,727 0

Total Steam Production 1,600,024 (78,786) 1,034,225 8.5 75,533 9.1 70,715 (4,817)

Other ProductionProduction - Pebbly Beach 41,242 (655) 16,201 18.7 1,371 18.7 1,371 0Production - Peakers 298,986 (7,423) 59,923 19.4 12,705 20.6 11,946 (759)Production - Solar PV 338,868 (27,175) 34,616 17.2 19,269 18.6 17,781 (1,487)

Total Other Production 679,096 (35,252) 110,741 19.1 33,345 19.4 31,099 (2,247)

Change in Decommissioning EstimatesMountainview - 3&4 (6,824) 23.0 297 297Four Corners (20,960) 3.0 6,987 6,987Mohave (2,511) 1.0 2,511 2,511Pebbly Beach (5,951) 18.7 318 318Peakers (4,680) 20.6 227 227Solar PV (54,729) 18.6 2,936 2,936

Total Change in Decomm Estimates (95,654) 13,275

Depreciation Expense RefundsOriginal Mountainview 1&2 Decomm Estimate (10,600) 10,923 3.0 (108) 3.0 (108) 0Solar 2 Original Decomm Estimate (4,639) 3,732 2.0 454 2.0 454 0Difference Between Recorded and Estimate 11,142 3.0 (3,714) (3,714)

Total Refund Accrual (3,714)

Hydro Production330 Land and Land Rights 3,311 2.84% 94 2.69% 89 (5)331 Structures and Improvements 157,619 1.63% 2,569 2.24% 3,531 961332 Reservoirs, Dams and Waterways 513,023 1.85% 9,491 2.36% 12,107 2,616333 Water Wheels, Turbines & Genera 149,324 1.72% 2,568 2.38% 3,554 986334 Accessory Electric Equipment 178,936 3.94% 7,050 4.22% 7,551 501335 Misc. Power Plant Equipment 12,389 1.61% 199 2.48% 307 108336 Roads, Railroads & Bridges 11,947 2.48% 296 4.73% 565 269

Total Hydro Production 1,026,548 2.17% 22,268 2.70% 27,704 5,436

Total Production 10,503,201 (213,789) 6,715,611 300,174 380,602 80,428

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 16: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION3

Southern California Edison Comparison of Depreciation Accrual Rates

Straight Line Remaining Life Method For Estimated Year 2015 ($ 000's)

PRESENT PRESENT PROPOSED PROPOSEDANNUAL ANNUAL ANNUAL ANNUAL INCREASE

GROSS PLANT ACCRUAL ACCRUAL ACCRUAL ACCRUAL (DECREASE)Transmission and D istribu tion Jan. 1, 2013 RATE/LIFE AMOUNT RATE/LIFE AMOUNT IN ACCRUAL

Transmission Plant350.2 Easements 148,017 1.67% 2,472 1.67% 2,472 0

352 Structures and Improvements 376,680 2.38% 8,965 2.53% 9,530 565353 Station Equipment 3.981.958 2.89% 115.079 3.04% 121,052 5,973

Total Transmission Substations 4,358,638 2.85% 124,044 3.00% 130,582 6,538

354 Towers and Fixtures 772,204 2.54% 19,614 3.17% 24,479 4,865355 Poles and Fixtures 603,692 3.43% 20,707 4.38% 26,442 5,735356 Overhead Conductors & Devices 706,021 3.57% 25,205 3.67% 25,911 706357 Underground Conduit 48,517 1.70% 825 1.73% 839 15358 Underground Conductors & Devices 208,167 2.81% 5,850 2.65% 5,516 (333)359 Roads and Trails 43,039 1.69% 727 1.52% 654 iZ i iTotal Transmission Lines 2,381,640 3.06% 72,927 3.52% 83,842 10,914

Total Transmission 6,888,295 2.90% 199,443 3.15% 216,895 17,452

Distribution Plant360.2 Easements 56,250 1.67% 939 1.67% 939 0

361 Structures and Improvements 436,831 3.20% 13,979 3.04% 13,280 (699)362 Station Equipment 1,761,038 3.13% 55,120 3.28% 57,762 2,642Total Distribution Substations 2,197,869 3.14% 69,099 3.23% 71,042 1,943

364 Poles, Towers and Fixtures 1,655,027 7.06% 116,845 7.81% 129,258 12,413365 Overhead Conductors & Devices 1,195,653 4.61% 55,120 5.15% 61,576 6,457366 Underground Conduit 1,389,563 2.16% 30,015 2.45% 34,044 4,030367 Underground Conductors & Devices 4,402,044 3.35% 147,468 3.90% 171,680 24,211368 Line Transformers 3,022,096 3.68% 111,213 3.93% 118,768 7,555369 Services 1,172,062 4.76% 55,790 5.76% 67,511 11,721370 Meters 888,759 5.35% 47,549 5.30% 47,104 (444)373 Street Lighting & Signal Systems 753,721 2.73% 20,577 3.43% 25,853 5,276Total Distribution Lines 14,478,925 4.04% 584,576 4.53% 655,794 71,218

Total Distribution 16,733,043 3.91% 654,614 4.35% 727,775 73,160

Total Transmission and Distribution 23,621,337 3.62% 854,057 4.00% 944,670 90,613

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 17: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

4Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Southern California Edison Comparison of Depreciation Accrual Rates

Straight Line Remaining Life Method For Estimated Year 2015 ($ 000's)

General and IntangibleGeneral Plant

389.2 Easements

390 Structures and Improvements 391.x Furniture & Equipment

391.x Computers 391.4 Security Monitoring (DDSMS) 391.x Stores/Lab/Miscellaneous 397.x Telecommunications 39x General OtherTotal General Plant

GROSS PLANT Jan. 1, 2013

PRESENTANNUALACCRUALRATE/LIFE

PRESENTANNUALACCRUALAMOUNT

PROPOSEDANNUALACCRUALRATE/LIFE

PROPOSEDANNUALACCRUALAMOUNT

Intangible PlantHydro Relicensing Radio Frequency Other Intangibles

Cap Soft 5yr*Cap Soft 7yr*Cap Soft 10yr*Cap Soft 15yr*

Total Cap Soft Total Intangible

Catalina PlantTotal General and Intangible

*Includes reserve adjustments

SONGS

Generation (Non-SONGS)

Transmission

Distribution

General and Intangible

Total Company

F i g u r e 111-2

38,084,982 1,582,523 1,779,122

INCREASE (DECREASE) IN ACCRUAL

3,269 1.6 7% 55 1.67% 55 0

843,141 1.8 0% 15,177 2.74% 23,097 7,921181,866 3.34% 6,074 4.62% 8,410 2,335

497,349 19.35% 96,237 20.99% 104,416 8,17924,282 16.31% 3,960 12.90% 3,133 (827)92,684 8.1 3% 7,535 6.54% 6,064 (1,471)

579,144 7.57% 43,841 9.77% 56,564 12,72386,287 15.22% 13,133 11.42% 9,854 (3,279)

2,308,023 8.0 6% 186,012 9.17% 211,592 25,580

124,930 2.64% 3,295 2.52% 3,143 (152)18,723 2.5 0% 468 2.50% 468 0

511 5.00% 26 5.00% 26 0144,165 2.6 3% 3,789 2.52% 3,637 (152)

449,749 21.41% 96,285 20.58% 92,578 (3,707)861,861 14.71% 126,746 14.93% 128,686 1,940

71,434 10.00% 7,143 12.45% 8,893 1,750124,571 6.6 7% 8,303 6.78% 8,449 145

1,507,614 15.82% 238,478 15.83% 238,605 1271,651,779 14.67% 242,267 14.67% 242,242 (25)

642 1.9 6% 13 2.57% 16 43,960,443 10.82% 428,292 11.46% 453,851 25,559

5,384,010 143,083 231,481 88,399

5,119,191 157,091 149,120 (7,971)

6,888,295 199,443 216,895 17,452

16,733,043 654,614 727,775 73,160

3,960,443 428,292 453,851 25,559

196,600

^ — \A _

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 18: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION5

S C E - 1 0 , V o lu m e 2 , R e s u l t s o f O p e r a t io n s

D e p r e c ia t i o n S t u d y

Witness: Rick Fisher

A n n u a l A c c r u a l R a te D e t e r m in a t i o n

S t r a ig h t L i n e R e m a i n i n g L i f e M e t h o d

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 19: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

CD

Sou

ther

n C

alifo

rnia

Edi

son

Ann

ual A

ccru

al R

ate

Det

erm

inat

ion

Str

aigh

t Li

ne R

emai

ning

Life

Met

hod

For

Est

imat

ed Y

ear

2015

DEP

REC

IATI

ON

D

EPR

ECIA

BLE

GR

OSS

PLA

NT

EST.

FU

TUR

E N

ET S

ALVA

GE

RES

ERVE

BALA

NC

ER

EM.

ANN

UAL

% G

RO

SSJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3%

AMO

UN

TJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3LI

FEAC

CR

UAL

PLAN

T *

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(10)

(11)

(12)

STE

AM P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

- M

OH

AVE

311

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts33

,849

,962

0%-

36,3

12,2

67(2

,462

,304

.7)

3.0

(820

,394

)31

2B

oile

r Pla

nt E

quip

men

t18

2,35

5,02

40%

-16

6,54

7,26

315

,807

,760

.63.

05,

266,

850

314

Turb

ogen

erat

or U

nits

60,4

39,4

560%

-55

,703

,986

4,73

5,47

0.5

3.0

1,57

7,77

031

5A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

30,3

34,4

870%

-26

,572

,545

3,76

1,94

1.5

3.0

1,25

3,40

931

6M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

5,14

4,08

00%

-4,

345,

849

798,

231.

53.

026

5,95

631

xD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

(35,

222,

233)

33,4

80,3

971,

741,

836.

83.

058

0,34

739

xG

ener

al P

lant

194,

129

0%-

(1,1

23,9

64)

1,31

8,09

3.0

3.0

439,

164

39x

Gen

eral

Oth

er P

lant

-0%

--

-3.

0-

35x

Gen

erat

ion-

Rel

ated

Tra

nsm

issi

on (

GR

T)-

0%-

--

3.0

-To

tal M

ohav

e31

2,31

7,13

8(3

5,22

2,23

3)32

1,83

8,34

225

,701

,029

.2

|3.

0 |

8,56

3,10

2 |I

2.74

%

|

STEA

M P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

~ F

OU

R C

OR

NER

S31

1St

ruct

ures

and

Impr

ovem

ents

23,6

96,6

610%

-21

,218

,155

2,47

8,50

5.8

2.0

1,24

0,52

731

2B

oile

r Pla

nt E

quip

men

t44

9,24

6,17

00%

-39

9,55

8,16

949

,688

,001

.02.

024

,869

,534

314

Turb

ogen

erat

or U

nits

58,3

08,2

140%

-50

,434

,632

7,87

3,58

2.4

2.0

3,94

0,83

731

5A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

22,0

23,9

220%

-15

,127

,849

6,89

6,07

2.6

2.0

3,45

1,58

031

6M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

26,8

53,9

770%

-22

,411

,142

4,44

2,83

5.3

2.0

2,22

3,70

131

xD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

-0%

(57,

541,

000)

33,9

47,8

2923

,593

,170

.52.

011

,808

,709

39x

Gen

eral

Pla

nt1,

866,

614

0%-

1,00

9,67

185

6,94

3.5

2.0

428,

912

35x

Gen

erat

ion

Rel

ated

Tra

nsm

issi

on (

GR

T)7,

366,

645

0%-

3,56

5,85

33,

800,

792.

02.

01,

902,

349

303

Inta

ngib

les

71,7

620%

-36

,940

34,8

22.0

2.0

17,4

29To

tal F

our C

orne

rs58

9,43

3,96

5(5

7,54

1,00

0)54

7,31

0,24

099

,664

,725

.0

|2.

0 |

49,8

83,5

78

|I 8.

46%

|

NU

CLE

AR P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

- S

AN O

NO

FRE

320.

2Ea

sem

ents

1,10

4,05

80%

-60

1,52

250

2,53

5.7

9.5

52,8

9732

1St

ruct

ures

& Im

prov

emen

ts1,

229,

060,

869

0%-

1,08

5,34

7,23

614

3,71

3,63

2.6

9.5

15,1

27,2

0632

2R

eact

or P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

1,70

9,73

9,43

70%

-1,

387,

854,

731

321,

884,

706.

19.

533

,881

,380

322

Stea

m G

ener

ator

Rep

lace

men

t (SG

RP)

584,

171,

634

0%-

25,0

47,7

8255

9,12

3,85

1.7

9.5

58,8

53,0

2232

3Tu

rbog

ener

ator

Uni

ts62

3,49

7,00

00%

-51

2,58

1,31

611

0,91

5,68

3.7

9.5

11,6

74,9

1532

4A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

740,

949,

852

0%-

653,

638,

010

87,3

11,8

42.4

9.5

9,19

0,38

932

5M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

306,

075,

114

0%-

286,

090,

937

19,9

84,1

76.9

9.5

2,10

3,52

2D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

-0%

-10

,666

,295

(10,

666,

295.

0)9.

5(1

,122

,727

)M

arin

e M

itiga

tion

64,2

50,4

150%

-17

,619

,378

46,6

31,0

37.1

9.5

4,90

8,35

3To

tal S

ON

GS

Prod

uctio

n5,

258,

848,

380

-3,

979,

447,

209

1,27

9,40

1,17

1.3

|9.

5 |

134,

668,

956

|| 2.

56%

|

182

Des

ign

Bas

is D

ocum

enta

tion

(DBD

)2,

122,

502

0%.

1,12

7,05

199

5,45

0.8

9.5

104,

781

182

Def

erre

d D

ebits

30,9

98,5

410%

-28

,901

,174

2,09

7,36

7.1

9.5

220,

768

Tota

l SO

NG

S D

BD &

Deb

its33

,121

,043

-30

,028

,225

3,09

2,81

7.9

9.5

325,

548

|I 0.

98%

|

39x

Gen

eral

Pla

nt42

,842

,196

0%.

22,2

98,6

7520

,543

,520

.19.

52,

162,

398

35x

Gen

erat

ion-

Rel

ated

Tra

nsm

issi

on (

GR

T)34

,131

,640

0%-

26,2

66,4

717,

865,

169.

89.

582

7,88

330

3In

tang

ible

s15

,067

,054

0%-

9,60

6,77

45,

460,

280.

29.

557

4,74

6To

tal S

ON

GS

Gen

eral

and

Oth

er92

,040

,890

-58

,171

,920

33,8

68,9

70.0

|

9.5

|3,

565,

026

Tota

l SO

NG

S Pl

ant

5,38

4,01

0,31

3 -

4,06

7,64

7,35

4 1,

316,

362,

959.

1 13

8,55

9,53

0 I

2.57

%

1

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 20: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Sou

ther

n C

alifo

rnia

Edi

son

Ann

ual A

ccru

al R

ate

Det

erm

inat

ion

Str

aigh

t Li

ne R

emai

ning

Life

Met

hod

For

Est

imat

ed Y

ear

2015

DEP

REC

IATI

ON

DEP

REC

IABL

EG

RO

SS P

LAN

TES

T. F

UTU

RE

NET

SAL

VAG

ER

ESER

VEBA

LAN

CE

REM

.AN

NU

AL%

GR

OSS

Janu

ary

1, 2

013

%AM

OU

NT

Janu

ary

1, 2

013

Janu

ary

1, 2

013

LIFE

ACC

RU

ALPL

ANT

*(1

)(2

)(3

)(4

)(5

)(1

0)(1

1)(1

2)N

UC

LEA

R P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

~ P

ALO

VE

RD

E32

0.2

Ease

men

ts-

0%-

--

33.5

-

321

Stru

ctur

es &

Impr

ovem

ents

543,

695,

218

0%-

403,

903,

139

139,

792,

079.

233

.54,

167,

633

322

Rea

ctor

Pla

nt E

quip

men

t70

6,92

6,52

30%

-58

5,96

2,56

212

0,96

3,96

0.6

33.5

3,60

6,30

832

3Tu

rbog

ener

ator

Uni

ts25

4,86

7,59

80%

-21

3,33

7,77

041

,529

,828

.333

.51,

238,

132

324

Acc

esso

ry E

lect

ric E

quip

men

t18

1,78

3,85

40%

-16

6,37

4,08

015

,409

,774

.933

.545

9,41

332

5M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

97,9

57,0

250%

-92

,089

,056

5,86

7,96

9.0

33.5

174,

942

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g-

0%-

2,11

3,29

6(2

,113

,296

.5)

33.5

(63,

004)

Tota

l PVN

GS

Prod

uctio

n1,

785,

230,

219

1,46

3,77

9,90

332

1,45

0,31

5.5

I 0.

54%

182

Des

ign

Bas

is D

ocum

enta

tion

182

Def

erre

d D

ebits

Tota

l PVN

GS

DBD

& D

ebits

To

tal P

VNG

S Pl

ant

7,77

2,58

818

,774

,769

26,5

47,3

571,

811,

777,

576

0% 0%7,

076,

070

16,9

40,5

0224

,016

,572

1,48

7,79

6,47

5

696,

518.

51,

834,

266.

9

323,

981,

100.

8

33.5

33.5

2,53

0,78

5.3

| 33

.5

| '

20,7

6554

,685

75,4

51~ |

0.

53%

HY

DR

O E

LEC

TRIC

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N33

0.2

Ease

men

ts3,

310,

851

0%-

696,

533

2,61

4,31

7.9

36.0

89,0

19

|2.

69%

331

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts15

7,61

9,11

3-7

%(1

1,56

6,48

1)54

,218

,981

114,

966,

613.

439

.63,

528,

353

2.24

%33

2R

eser

voirs

, Dam

s an

d W

ater

way

s51

3,02

2,66

6-4

%(1

9,21

6,82

3)22

9,11

5,03

530

3,12

4,45

4.0

34.8

12,1

15,6

922.

36%

333

Wat

er W

heel

s, T

urbi

nes

& G

ener

ator

s14

9,32

3,72

5-6

%(8

,351

,827

)58

,487

,821

99,1

87,7

30.7

36.4

3,54

8,70

62.

38%

334

Acc

esso

ry E

lect

ric E

quip

men

t17

8,93

5,50

8-2

0%(3

6,33

1,40

2)31

,010

,561

184,

256,

349.

130

.67,

544,

174

4.22

%33

5M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

12,3

89,3

92-7

%(8

93,7

88)

6,40

6,03

76,

877,

143.

537

.630

6,88

72.

48%

336

Roa

ds, R

ailro

ads

& Br

idge

s11

,946

,663

-25%

(2,9

34,2

47)

4,73

7,80

510

,143

,105

.231

.356

4,95

74.

73%

Tota

l Hyd

ro E

lect

ric P

rodu

ctio

n1,

023,

237,

066

(79,

294,

569)

383,

976,

239

718,

555,

395.

9 |

26.0

|

27,6

08,7

702.

70%

Tota

l Hyd

ro E

lect

ric1,

026,

547,

917

(79,

294,

569)

384,

672,

773

721,

169,

713.

827

,697

,789

2.70

%

OTH

ER

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N ~

PE

BB

LY B

EA

CH

340

Land

and

Lan

d R

ight

s-

0%-

--

18.7

-

341

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts2,

217,

206

0%.

532,

305

1,68

4,90

1.9

18.7

89,9

0134

2Fu

el H

olde

rs, P

rdcr

s &

Acc

ssrs

1,31

4,44

70%

-10

3,55

81,

210,

889.

318

.764

,609

343

Prim

e M

over

s20

,412

,167

0%-

9,34

5,05

711

,067

,109

.218

.759

0,50

534

4G

ener

ator

s9,

577,

611

0%-

3,73

6,83

85,

840,

773.

118

.731

1,64

434

5A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

7,21

6,51

30%

-2,

157,

649

5,05

8,86

4.5

18.7

269,

924

346

Mis

c. P

ower

Pla

nt E

quip

men

t50

4,14

40%

-16

2,48

434

1,66

0.2

18.7

18,2

3034

xD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

-0%

(6,6

05,1

01)

163,

481

6,44

1,62

0.2

18.7

343,

704

Tota

l Oth

er P

rodu

ctio

n41

,242

,089

(6,6

05,1

01)

16,2

01,3

7131

,645

,818

.3

|18

.7

|1,

688,

517

|0.

00%

OTH

ER

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N -

PE

AK

ER

S34

0La

nd a

nd L

and

Rig

hts

526,

948

0%-

58,0

0346

8,94

5.0

20.6

22,7

2834

1St

ruct

ures

and

Impr

ovem

ents

11,4

14,2

020%

-1,

242,

435

10,1

71,7

67.0

20.6

492,

995

342

Fuel

Hol

ders

, Prd

crs

& A

ccss

rs1,

942,

003

0%-

422,

192

1,51

9,81

0.9

20.6

73,6

6134

3Pr

ime

Mov

ers

220,

748,

844

0%-

44,0

50,5

4717

6,69

8,29

6.9

20.6

8,56

4,04

334

4G

ener

ator

s15

,080

0%-

1,22

313

,857

.520

.667

234

5A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

61,3

15,3

400%

-12

,587

,458

48,7

27,8

82.2

20.6

2,36

1,69

634

6M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

3,02

3,96

90%

-35

7,83

42,

666,

134.

820

.612

9,22

034

xPe

aker

s D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

-0%

(12,

103,

028)

1,26

1,64

010

,841

,388

.220

.652

5,45

0To

tal P

eake

rs29

8,45

9,43

8(1

2,10

3,02

8)59

,923

,329

250,

639,

137.

5 |

20.6

|

12,1

47,7

36

|0.

00%

-nI

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 21: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Sou

ther

n C

alifo

rnia

Edi

son

Ann

ual A

ccru

al R

ate

Det

erm

inat

ion

Stra

ight

Lin

e R

emai

ning

Life

Met

hod

For E

stim

ated

Yea

r 201

5

STEA

M P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

- M

OU

NTA

INVI

EW

OTH

ER P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

- F

uel C

ell

343

Prim

e M

over

s

Tota

l Oth

er P

rodu

ctio

n

GR

OSS

PLA

NT

Janu

ary

1, 20

13

(1)

341

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts45

,397

,387

342

Boi

ler P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

7,40

3,71

334

3Pr

ime

Mov

ers

435,

100,

878

344

Turb

ogen

erat

or U

nits

76,8

83,0

2534

5A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

85,1

06,8

6334

6M

isc.

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

3,73

1,53

034

xM

ount

ainv

iew

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g 3&

4To

tal M

ount

ainv

iew

Pro

duct

ion

653,

623,

396

301

Org

aniz

atio

n 2,

796,

617

303

Mis

c. In

tang

ible

s

41,8

53,2

00M

ount

ainv

iew

Inta

ngib

les

44,6

49,8

17

OTH

ER P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

- S

OLA

R 2

DEC

OM

MIS

SIO

NIN

G34

x M

ount

ainv

iew

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g 1&

234

x S

olar

2 D

ecom

mis

sion

ing

OTH

ER P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

- S

OLA

R P

V34

1 St

ruct

ures

and

Impr

ovem

ents

11

,887

,910

343

Prim

e M

over

s 31

9,98

4,87

634

5 A

cces

sory

Ele

ctric

Equ

ipm

ent

6,99

4,92

134

x S

olar

PV

Dec

omm

issi

onin

g

-S

olar

Pro

duct

ion

338,

867,

708

00

DEP

REC

IATI

ON

DEP

REC

IABL

EES

T. F

UTU

RE

NET

SAL

VAG

ER

ESER

VEBA

LAN

CE

REM

.AN

NU

AL%

GR

OSS

%AM

OU

NT

Janu

ary

1, 20

13Ja

nuar

y 1,

2013

LIFE

ACC

RU

ALPL

ANT

*(2

)(3

)(4

)(5

)(1

0)(1

1)(1

2)

0%.

9,74

5,63

135

,651

,755

.723

.01,

550,

122

0%-

1,73

9,96

55,

663,

748.

623

.024

6,25

70%

-10

3,28

0,59

833

1,82

0,27

9.7

23.0

14,4

27,3

980%

-18

,114

,506

58,7

68,5

19.2

23.0

2,55

5,22

90%

-18

,298

,338

66,8

08,5

24.9

23.0

2,90

4,80

50%

-34

6,10

73,

385,

422.

823

.014

7,19

70%

(16,

316,

775)

1,85

3,32

714

,463

,448

.023

.062

8,86

4(1

6,31

6,77

5)15

3,37

8,47

251

6,56

1,69

8.8

|23

.0

|22

,459

,873

0%.

657,

042

2,13

9,57

5.2

23.0

93,0

280%

-11

,041

,110

30,8

12,0

90.9

23.0

1,33

9,69

611

,698

,151

32,9

51,6

66.1

|

23.0

|

1,43

2,72

4 |I

3.21

%

0%(3

,150

,723

)10

,922

,516

(7,7

71,7

92.5

)3.

0(2

,590

,597

)0%

(946

,457

)3,

731,

825

(2,7

85,3

68.3

)3.

0(9

28,4

56)

(4,0

97,1

80)

14,6

54,3

41(1

0,55

7,16

1)

|3.

0 |

(3,5

19,0

54)

0%84

4,33

911

,043

,571

.118

.659

2,50

30%

-26

,252

,825

293,

732,

051.

118

.615

,759

,132

0%-

551,

917

6,44

3,00

4.3

18.6

345,

676

4.93

%0%

(81,

903,

634)

6,96

7,27

574

,936

,359

.318

.64,

020,

440

1.19

%(8

1,90

3,63

4)34

,616

,356

386,

154,

985.

8 |

18.6

|

20,7

17,7

51

|| 6.

11%

0%10

.0

1,21

5,16

7,93

8.3

| 21

.1

| 57

,518

,144

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 22: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Sou

ther

n C

alifo

rnia

Edi

son

Ann

ual A

ccru

al R

ate

Det

erm

inat

ion

Str

aigh

t Li

ne R

emai

ning

Life

Met

hod

For

Est

imat

ed Y

ear

2015

DEP

REC

IATI

ON

D

EPR

ECIA

BLE

GR

OSS

PLA

NT

EST.

FU

TUR

E N

ET S

ALVA

GE

RES

ERVE

BALA

NC

ER

EM.

ANN

UAL

% G

RO

SSJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3%

AMO

UN

TJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3LI

FEAC

CR

UAL

PLAN

T *

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(10)

(11)

(12)

TRA

NS

MIS

SIO

N P

LAN

T35

0.2

Ease

men

ts14

8,01

7,30

00%

-12

,855

,282

135,

162,

017.

160

.02,

466,

955

| 1.

67%

352

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts37

6,68

0,05

3-3

5%(1

31,8

38,0

18)

90,8

28,8

5141

7,68

9,21

9.5

43.8

9,53

7,35

12.

53%

353

Stat

ion

Equi

pmen

t3,

981,

957,

655

-15%

(597

,293

,648

)51

4,21

7,87

44,

065,

033,

429.

433

.612

1,11

9,19

53.

04%

Tota

l Tra

nsm

issi

on S

ubst

atio

ns4,

358,

637,

708

(729

,131

,667

)60

5,04

6,72

64,

482,

722,

648.

813

0,65

6,54

6|

3.00

%

354

Tow

ers

and

Fixt

ures

772,

203,

666

-100

%(7

72,2

03,6

66)

421,

305,

615

1,12

3,10

1,71

7.7

45.9

24,4

56,2

543.

17%

355

Pole

s an

d Fi

xtur

es60

3,69

2,25

4-8

5%(5

13,1

38,4

16)

174,

800,

929

942,

029,

740.

835

.726

,418

,216

4.38

%35

6O

verh

ead

Con

duct

ors

& D

evic

es70

6,02

0,71

1-1

00%

(706

,020

,711

)53

7,69

6,38

587

4,34

5,03

7.1

33.8

25,8

93,7

763.

67%

357

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duit

48,5

17,0

330%

-15

,274

,840

33,2

42,1

93.9

39.6

839,

077

1.73

%35

8U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

208,

167,

367

-15%

(31,

225,

105)

78,2

44,9

5216

1,14

7,51

9.6

29.2

5,51

2,36

82.

65%

359

Roa

ds a

nd T

rails

43,0

38,5

830%

-13

,980

,865

29,0

57,7

17.6

44.5

653,

680

1.52

%To

tal T

rans

mis

sion

s Li

nes

2,38

1,63

9,61

5(2

,022

,587

,898

)1,

241,

303,

586

3,16

2,92

3,92

6.6

83,7

73,3

71|

3.52

%To

tal T

rans

mis

sion

Pla

nt6,

888,

294,

622

(2,7

51,7

19,5

65)

1,85

9,20

5,59

57,

780,

808,

592.

521

6,89

6,87

23.

15%

DIS

TRIB

UTI

ON

PLA

NT

360.

2Ea

sem

ents

56,2

49,5

580%

-6,

219,

477

50,0

30,0

80.6

60.0

937,

493

I 1.

67%

361

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts43

6,83

0,74

9-2

5%(1

09,2

07,6

87)

159,

481,

896

386,

556,

540.

129

.113

,288

,609

3.04

%36

2St

atio

n Eq

uipm

ent

1,76

1,03

7,88

3-3

0%(5

28,3

11,3

65)

281,

581,

641

2,00

7,76

7,60

7.2

34.8

57,7

36,2

693.

28%

Tota

l Dis

tribu

tion

Subs

tatio

ns2,

197,

868,

632

(637

,519

,052

)44

1,06

3,53

72,

394,

324,

147.

471

,024

,878

| 3.

23%

364

Pole

s, T

ower

s an

d Fi

xtur

es1,

655,

027,

118

-225

%(3

,723

,811

,016

)62

3,81

1,48

84,

755,

026,

646.

236

.812

9,29

5,91

27.

81%

365

Ove

rhea

d C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

1,19

5,65

3,26

2-1

25%

(1,4

94,5

66,5

78)

520,

102,

755

2,17

0,11

7,08

4.7

35.2

61,6

35,8

415.

15%

366

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duit

1,38

9,56

3,20

0-4

0%(5

55,8

25,2

80)

424,

307,

681

1,52

1,08

0,79

7.9

44.7

34,0

14,7

072.

45%

367

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duct

ors

& D

evic

es4,

402,

043,

706

-80%

(3,5

21,6

34,9

65)

2,03

0,29

3,63

45,

893,

385,

036.

534

.317

1,80

5,72

23.

90%

368

Line

Tra

nsfo

rmer

s3,

022,

095,

507

-20%

(604

,419

,101

)68

4,57

6,06

62,

941,

938,

541.

624

.811

8,75

7,60

83.

93%

369

Ser

vice

s1,

172,

062,

087

-125

%(1

,465

,077

,609

)68

3,57

5,16

61,

953,

564,

529.

629

.067

,467

,357

5.76

%37

0M

eter

s88

8,75

9,13

2-5

%(4

4,43

7,95

7)73

,310

,362

859,

886,

726.

318

.247

,142

,307

5.30

%37

3S

treet

Lig

htin

g &

Sig

nal S

yste

ms

753,

720,

538

-40%

(301

,488

,215

)26

7,63

3,25

578

7,57

5,49

7.9

30.5

25,8

59,6

003.

43%

Tota

l Dis

tribu

tion

Line

s14

,478

,924

,549

(11,

711,

260,

720)

5,30

7,61

0,40

820

,882

,574

,860

.965

5,97

9,05

4|

4.53

%To

tal D

istri

butio

n Pl

ant

16,7

33,0

42,7

39(1

2,34

8,77

9,77

2)5,

754,

893,

422

23,3

26,9

29,0

88.9

727,

941,

424

4.35

%

370

(LM

)Le

gacy

Met

ers

71,9

77,2

680%

-(1

73,4

89,8

17)

245,

467,

085.

25.

049

,093

,417

68.2

1%

CD

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 23: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Sou

ther

n C

alifo

rnia

Edi

son

Ann

ual A

ccru

al R

ate

Det

erm

inat

ion

Str

aigh

t Li

ne R

emai

ning

Life

Met

hod

For

Est

imat

ed Y

ear

2015

DEP

REC

IATI

ON

DEP

REC

IABL

E

Tota

l Gen

eral

Pla

nt

GR

AND

TO

TAL

INTA

NG

IBLE

S

2,30

8,02

2,50

7(6

2,74

2,40

0)74

9,81

4,98

91,

620,

949,

917.

6

35,0

94,6

88,8

66(1

5,34

5,05

5,36

3)15

,200

,303

,076

35,2

39,4

41,1

52.7

Cap

Sof

t1,

507,

614,

331

676,

568,

645

232,

072,

449.

0

GR

OSS

PLA

NT

EST.

FU

TUR

E N

ET S

ALVA

GE

RES

ERVE

BALA

NC

ER

EM.

ANN

UAL

% G

RO

SSJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3%

AMO

UN

TJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3LI

FEAC

CR

UAL

PLAN

T *

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(10)

(11)

(12)

GE

NE

RA

L P

LAN

T38

9.2

Ease

men

ts3,

269,

367

0%-

378,

977

2,89

0,38

9.4

60.0

54,4

89|

1.67

%

390

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts84

3,14

1,41

7-1

0%(8

4,31

4,14

2)28

5,17

3,08

364

2,28

2,47

5.2

27.8

23,0

97,2

41|

2.74

%39

1.x

Furn

iture

& E

quip

men

t18

1,86

6,31

50%

-70

,387

,823

111,

478,

492.

313

8,40

9,51

14.

62%

391.

xC

ompu

ters

497,

348,

874

0%-

183,

123,

482

314,

225,

392.

23

104,

415,

662

20.9

9%39

1.4

Sec

urity

Mon

itorin

g (D

DSM

S)24

,282

,044

0%-

6,60

4,33

317

,677

,710

.16

3,13

2,92

512

.90%

391.

xSt

ores

/Lab

/Mis

cella

neou

s92

,683

,712

0%-

40,1

56,6

4652

,527

,065

.89

6,06

4,48

06.

54%

397.

xTe

leco

mm

unic

atio

ns57

9,14

3,81

20%

-16

3,89

1,26

241

5,25

2,54

9.7

756

,563

,806

9.77

%39

xG

ener

al O

ther

86,2

86,9

6725

%21

,571

,742

99,3

8364

,615

,842

.97

9,85

4,14

411

.42%

211,

592,

258

1,38

9,89

1,34

9 |

3.96

%

|

Hyd

ro R

elic

ensi

ng12

4,93

0,43

60%

29,7

71,9

2695

,158

,510

.534

.63,

143,

089

Rad

io F

requ

ency

18,7

23,3

400%

8,28

4,52

310

,438

,817

.122

.346

8,08

4O

ther

Inta

ngib

les

510,

832

0%10

2,16

740

8,66

5.1

16.0

25,5

42

Cap

Sof

t 5yr

449,

748,

553

0%14

5,09

6,19

630

4,65

2,35

6.9

3.4

89,9

49,7

11C

ap S

oft 7

yr86

1,86

0,60

50%

380,

239,

122

481,

621,

482.

27.

012

3,12

2,94

4C

ap S

oft 1

0yr

71,4

34,2

850%

41,0

42,1

3430

,392

,151

.34.

37,

143,

429

Cap

Sof

t 15y

r12

4,57

0,88

90%

110,

191,

193

14,3

79,6

96.0

1.7

8,30

4,72

6C

ap S

oft C

ap S

oft (

5 yr

)Ac

c. D

ep. A

djus

tmen

t(5

,210

,988

)5,

210,

988.

22.

02,

628,

325

Cap

Sof

t Cap

Sof

t (7

yr)

Acc.

Dep

. Adj

ustm

ent

(20,

909,

536)

20,9

09,5

35.6

3.8

5,56

2,57

7C

ap S

oft C

ap S

oft (

10 y

r)Ac

c. D

ep. A

djus

tmen

t(8

,612

,753

)8,

612,

752.

84.

91,

749,

749

Cap

Sof

t Cap

Sof

t (15

yr)

Acc.

Dep

. Adj

ustm

ent

(764

,807

)76

4,80

7.3

5.3

143,

923

238,

605,

382

2.52

%2.

50%

5.00

%

20

.00

%14

.29%

10.0

0%6.

67%

CA

TA

LIN

A C

OM

MO

NG

ENER

AL39

0St

ruct

ures

and

Impr

ovem

ents

602,

224

-10%

(60,

222)

233,

236

429,

210.

226

.016

,497

2.74

%39

1O

ffice

Fur

nitu

re a

nd E

quip

men

t26

,443

0%-

26,4

43-

0.0

-4.

62%

393

Stor

es E

quip

men

t6,

668

0%-

6,66

8-

0.0

-5.

00%

397

Com

mun

icat

ion

Equi

pmen

t6,

638

0%-

6,63

8-

0.0

-9.

77%

Tota

l Gen

eral

641,

973

(60,

222)

272,

985

429,

210.

216

,497

2.57

%

GEN

ERAL

OTH

ER

394

Tool

s, S

hop

& G

arag

e Eq

uipm

ent

GR

AND

TO

TAL

CO

MM

ON

29,5

40

671,

513

0%

(60,

222)

29,5

40

302,

526

0.0

I 0.

00%

I

16,4

97

| 2.

46%

1

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 24: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Sou

ther

n C

alifo

rnia

Edi

son

Ann

ual A

ccru

al R

ate

Det

erm

inat

ion

Str

aigh

t Li

ne R

emai

ning

Life

Met

hod

For

Est

imat

ed Y

ear

2015

DEP

REC

IATI

ON

D

EPR

ECIA

BLE

GR

OSS

PLA

NT

EST.

FU

TUR

E N

ET S

ALVA

GE

RES

ERVE

BALA

NC

ER

EM.

ANN

UAL

% G

RO

SSJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3%

AMO

UN

TJa

nuar

y 1,

201

3Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3LI

FEAC

CR

UAL

PLAN

T *

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(10)

(11)

(12)

lOM

POSI

TE D

EPR

ECIA

TIO

N R

ATES

391.

1O

ffice

Fur

nitu

re17

9,39

5,31

30%

.63

,580

,463

115,

814,

849.

98,

969,

766

5.00

%39

1.5

Offi

ce E

quip

men

t1,

469,

373

0%-

787,

110

682,

262.

229

3,87

520

.00%

391.

6D

uplic

atin

g Eq

uipm

ent

1,00

1,62

90%

-15

7,59

384

4,03

6.5

200,

326

20.0

0%Ac

c. D

ep. A

djus

tmen

t5,

862,

656

(5,8

62,6

56.4

)5.

6(1

,054

,455

)Fu

rnitu

re &

Equ

ipm

ent

181,

866,

315

0%-

70,3

87,8

2311

1,47

8,49

2.3

13.3

8,40

9,51

1 ||

4.62

%

391.

2Pe

rson

al C

ompu

ters

69,6

59,2

240%

.35

,839

,294

33,8

19,9

29.9

13,9

31,8

4520

.00%

391.

3M

ainf

ram

e C

ompu

ters

427,

689,

651

0%-

169,

510,

633

258,

179,

017.

985

,537

,930

20.0

0%39

1.7

PC S

oftw

are

-0%

--

--

20.0

0%Ac

c. D

ep. A

djus

tmen

t(2

2,22

6,44

4)22

,226

,444

.44.

54,

945,

887

Com

pute

rs49

7,34

8,87

40%

-18

3,12

3,48

231

4,22

5,39

2.2

3.0

104,

415,

662

|| 20

.99%

391.

4D

DSM

S - C

PU &

Pro

cess

ing

7,61

5,92

30%

.1,

924,

924

5,69

0,99

8.2

1,08

8,31

514

.29%

391.

4D

DSM

S - C

ontro

llers

, R

ecei

vers

, Com

m.

8,66

0,59

20%

-3,

340,

524

5,32

0,06

8.5

866,

059

10.0

0%39

1.4

DD

SMS

- Tel

emet

erin

g &

Syst

em76

0,43

10%

-45

7,82

530

2,60

6.4

50,7

216.

67%

391.

4D

DSM

S - M

isce

llane

ous

6,71

1,28

30%

-3,

940,

488

2,77

0,79

5.0

335,

564

5.00

%39

1.4

DD

SMS

- Map

Boa

rd53

3,81

40%

-25

5,27

827

8,53

6.3

21,3

534.

00%

Acc.

Dep

. Adj

ustm

ent

(3,3

14,7

06)

3,31

4,70

5.7

4.3

770,

913

Sec

urity

Mon

itorin

g (D

DSM

S)24

,282

,044

0%-

6,60

4,33

317

,677

,710

.15.

63,

132,

925

|I 12

.90%

393

Stor

es E

quip

men

t9,

443,

528

0%.

5,30

8,46

84,

135,

060.

347

2,17

65.

00%

395

Labo

rato

ry E

quip

men

t67

,396

,651

0%-

28,7

50,6

0938

,646

,042

.34,

495,

357

6.67

%39

8M

isc

Pow

er P

lant

Equ

ipm

ent

15,8

43,5

320%

-7,

266,

264

8,57

7,26

8.5

792,

177

5.00

%Ac

c. D

ep. A

djus

tmen

t(1

,168

,695

)1,

168,

694.

83.

830

4,77

0S

tore

s/La

b/M

isce

llane

ous

92,6

83,7

120%

-40

,156

,646

52,5

27,0

65.8

8.7

6,06

4,48

0 ||

6.54

%

397.

xD

ata

Net

wor

k Sy

stem

s11

8,05

6,25

00%

.41

,239

,922

76,8

16,3

27.5

23,6

11,2

5020

.00%

397.

xTe

leco

m S

yste

m E

quip

men

t52

,416

,842

0%-

5,93

7,67

646

,479

,166

.17,

490,

367

14.2

9%39

7.x

Net

com

m R

adio

Ass

embl

y16

5,01

8,39

90%

-61

,814

,460

103,

203,

939.

616

,501

,840

10.0

0%39

7.x

Mic

row

ave

Equi

p. &

Ant

enna

Ass

embl

y24

,969

,669

0%-

8,94

8,05

616

,021

,613

.11,

665,

477

6.67

%39

7.x

Tele

com

Pow

er S

yste

ms

8,96

7,55

50%

-3,

809,

244

5,15

8,31

0.5

448,

378

5.00

%39

7.x

Fibe

r Opt

ic C

omm

unic

atio

n C

able

s10

6,93

2,73

10%

-30

,822

,008

76,1

10,7

23.1

16.5

4,61

2,77

16.

06%

397.

xTe

leco

m In

frast

ruct

ure

102,

782,

366

0%-

1,77

2,67

310

1,00

9,69

2.7

26.7

3,78

3,13

53.

75%

Acc.

Dep

. Adj

ustm

ent

9,54

7,22

3(9

,547

,223

.0)

6.2

(1,5

49,4

11)

Tel

ecom

mun

icat

ions

579,

143,

812

0%-

163,

891,

262

415,

252,

549.

77.

356

,563

,806

||

9.77

%

392

Tran

spor

tatio

n Eq

uip.

11,2

76,4

590%

.3,

268,

449

8,00

8,00

9.7

1,61

1,40

614

.29%

394.

4G

arag

e &

Shop

-- E

quip

.5,

627,

790

0%-

2,28

9,78

13,

338,

008.

256

2,77

910

.00%

394.

5To

ols

& W

ork

Equi

p. -

- Sho

p68

,704

,221

0%-

19,9

23,1

0548

,781

,116

.26,

870,

422

10.0

0%39

6P

ower

Ope

r Equ

ip67

8,49

825

%16

9,62

499

,383

409,

490.

845

,256

6.67

%Ac

c. D

ep. A

djus

tmen

t(4

,757

,731

)4,

757,

731.

06.

276

4,28

1G

ener

al O

ther

86,2

86,9

670%

169,

624

20,8

22,9

8765

,294

,355

.96.

69,

854,

144

|| 11

.42%

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 25: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Sout

hern

Cal

iforn

ia E

diso

n A

nnua

l Acc

rual

Rat

e D

eter

min

atio

n S

traig

ht L

ine

Rem

aini

ng L

ife M

etho

d Fo

r E

stim

ated

Yea

r 201

5

EST.

FU

TURE

CO

ST O

F RE

MO

VAL

CO

R D

EPR

CO

R D

EPR

ANN

UAL

CO

RC

OR

% O

GR

OSS

PLA

NT%

$R

ESER

VEBA

LAN

CEAC

CRU

ALG

RO

SS P

L/Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3

TR

AN

SM

ISS

ION

PL

AN

TU

J

350.

2Ea

sem

ents

148,

017,

300

0.0%

0.00

%

352

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts37

6,68

0,05

335

.0%

(131

,838

,018

)27

,931

,061

103,

906,

957

2,37

2,57

10.

63%

353

Stat

ion

Equi

pmen

t3,

981,

957,

655

20.0

%(7

96,3

91,5

31)

410,

007

795,

981,

524

23,7

16,5

680.

60%

Tota

l Tra

nsm

issi

on S

ubst

atio

ns4,

358,

637,

708

(928

,229

,549

)28

,341

,068

899,

888,

481

26,0

89,1

390.

60%

354

Tow

ers

and

Fixt

ures

772,

203,

666

120.

0%(9

26,6

44,3

99)

181,

517,

328

745,

127,

071

16,2

25,6

162.

10%

355

Pole

s an

d Fi

xtur

es60

3,69

2,25

411

0.0%

(664

,061

,479

)84

,945

,925

579,

115,

554

16,2

40,6

762.

69%

356

Ove

rhea

d C

ondu

ctor

s &

Devic

es70

6,02

0,71

114

5.0%

(1,0

23,7

30,0

31)

333,

088,

628

690,

641,

404

20,4

53,3

832.

90%

357

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duit

48,5

17,0

330.

0%(7

,284

)7,

284

184

0.00

%35

8U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

ctor

s &

Devic

es20

8,16

7,36

735

.0%

(72,

858,

578)

26,3

54,0

5346

,504

,525

1,59

0,77

90.

76%

359

Roa

ds a

nd T

rails

43,0

38,5

830.

0%(6

,415

)6,

415

144

0.00

%To

tal T

rans

mis

sion

s Li

nes

2,38

1,63

9,61

5(2

,687

,294

,489

)62

5,89

2,23

52,

061,

402,

253

54,5

10,7

812.

29%

Tota

l Tra

nsm

issi

on P

lant

6,88

8,29

4,62

2(3

,615

,524

,038

)65

4,23

3,30

35,

022,

692,

988

80,5

99,9

20

DIS

TR

IBU

TIO

N P

LA

NT

360.

2Ea

sem

ents

56,2

49,5

580.

0%(3

,298

)3,

298

550.

00%

361

Stru

ctur

es a

nd Im

prov

emen

ts43

6,83

0,74

925

.0%

(109

,207

,687

)18

,526

,076

90,6

81,6

113,

117,

351

0.71

%36

2St

atio

n Eq

uipm

ent

1,76

1,03

7,88

340

.0%

(704

,415

,153

)28

,046

,119

676,

369,

034

19,4

49,9

721.

10%

Tota

l Dis

tribu

tion

Subs

tatio

ns2,

197,

868,

632

(813

,622

,840

)46

,572

,196

767,

050,

645

22,5

67,3

231.

03%

364

Pole

s, T

ower

s an

d Fi

xtur

es1,

655,

027,

118

255.

0%(4

,220

,319

,151

)37

7,20

4,48

43,

843,

114,

667

104,

499,

733

6.31

%36

5O

verh

ead

Con

duct

ors

& De

vices

1,19

5,65

3,26

214

5.0%

(1,7

33,6

97,2

30)

324,

330,

782

1,40

9,36

6,44

840

,028

,940

3.35

%36

6U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

it1,

389,

563,

200

45.0

%(6

25,3

03,4

40)

79,9

12,7

6554

5,39

0,67

412

,196

,133

0.88

%36

7U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

4,40

2,04

3,70

690

.0%

(3,9

61,8

39,3

35)

775,

175,

958

3,18

6,66

3,37

892

,898

,563

2.11

%36

8Li

ne T

rans

form

ers

3,02

2,09

5,50

735

.0%

(1,0

57,7

33,4

27)

(12,

936,

275)

1,07

0,66

9,70

343

,219

,860

1.43

%36

9Se

rvic

es1,

172,

062,

087

140.

0%(1

,640

,886

,922

)32

1,05

1,63

71,

319,

835,

285

45,5

81,1

913.

89%

370

Met

ers

888,

759,

132

5.0%

(44,

437,

957)

(16,

249,

291)

60,6

87,2

483,

327,

109

0.37

%37

3St

reet

Lig

htin

g &

Sign

al S

yste

ms

753,

720,

538

85.0

%(6

40,6

62,4

57)

140,

350,

143

500,

312,

315

16,4

27,4

742.

18%

Tota

l Dis

tribu

tion

Line

s14

,478

,924

,549

(13,

924,

879,

919)

1,98

8,84

0,20

211

,936

,039

,717

358,

179,

004

2.47

%To

tal D

istri

butio

n Pl

ant

16,7

33,0

42,7

39(1

4,73

8,50

2,76

0)2,

035,

409,

100

12,7

03,0

93,6

6038

0,74

6,38

2

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 26: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

SOU

TH

ER

N C

AL

IFO

RN

IA E

DIS

ON

CO

MPA

NY

G

EN

ER

AT

ION

RE

MA

ININ

G L

IFE

DE

TER

MIN

AT

ION

Rem

aini

ng L

ife A

s Of

Moh

ave

Rem

aini

ng L

ife S

pan:

UN

IT 1 2

LO

CN

DE

SCR

IPTI

ON

DA

TE

OF

FIR

M

OPE

RA

TIO

ND

AT

E F

UL

LY

D

EPR

EC

IATE

DW

EIG

HTI

NG

TO

TAL

LIF

E S

PAN

AG

E(Y

RS) 42

.042

.0

RM

NG

L

IFE

SPA

NW

TD

RE

M

LIF

E S

PAN

WT

DA

GE

1320

1320

Moh

ave

Moh

ave

01/0

1/71

01/0

1/71

01/0

1/16

01/0

1/16

50%

45.0

45.0

3.0

3.0

1.50

11.

501

20.9

9920

.999

50%

100%

45

.0

Four

Com

ers R

emai

ning

Life

Spa

n:

42.0

3.0

3.00

141

.999

DA

TE

OF

FIR

MD

AT

E F

UL

LY

TO

TAL

AG

ER

MN

GW

TD

RE

MU

NIT

LO

CN

DE

SCR

IPTI

ON

OPE

RA

TIO

ND

EPR

EC

IATE

DW

EIG

HT

ING

LIF

E S

PAN

fYR

S)L

IFE

SPA

NL

IFE

SPA

NW

TD

AG

E4

1330

Four

Com

ers

07/0

1/69

07/0

1/14

50%

4543

.51.

50.

749

21.7

515

1330

Four

Com

ers

07/0

1/70

07/0

1/15

50%

4542

.52.

51.

249

21.2

5110

0%43

.02.

01.

998

43.0

02

Pebb

ly B

each

Rem

aini

ng L

ife S

pan:

DA

TE

OF

FIR

MD

AT

E F

UL

LY

TO

TAL

AG

ER

MN

GW

TD

RE

MM

WH

. Whi

tman

OPE

RA

TIO

ND

EPR

EC

IATE

DW

EIG

HT

ING

LIF

E S

PAN

(YR

S)L

IFE

SPA

NL

IFE

SPA

NW

TD

AG

EU

nit 7

Die

sel

1.00

8019

5820

034.

4%45

54.5

0.0

0.00

02.

389

Uni

t 8 D

iese

l1.

5067

1963

2008

5.5%

4549

.50.

00.

000

2.72

6U

nitl

0 D

iese

l1.

1071

1966

2011

4.3%

4546

.50.

00.

000

1.99

0U

nitl

2 D

iese

l1.

6014

019

7620

2112

.3%

4536

.58.

51.

043

4.48

0U

nit 1

4 D

iese

l1.

4026

119

8620

3120

.0%

4526

.518

.53.

704

5.30

5U

nit 1

5 D

iese

l2.

8034

919

9520

4053

.5%

4517

.527

.514

.723

9.36

99.

4010

0.0%

26.2

619

.519

.470

26.2

58

Mou

ntai

nvie

w R

emai

ning

Life

Spa

n:D

AT

E O

F FI

RM

DA

TE

FU

LL

YT

OTA

LA

GE

RM

NG

WT

DR

EM

UN

ITL

OC

ND

ESC

RIP

TIO

NO

PER

AT

ION

DE

PRE

CIA

TED

WEI

GH

TIN

GL

IFE

SPA

NfY

RS)

LIF

E S

PAN

LIF

E S

PAN

WT

DA

GE

3M

ount

ainv

iew

12/3

1/05

12/3

1/35

50%

307.

023

.011

.500

3.50

04

Mou

ntai

nvie

w12

/31/

0512

/31/

3550

%30

7.0

23.0

11.5

003.

500

100%

7.0

23.0

22.9

997.

001

Peak

er G

ener

atio

n R

emai

ning

Life

Spa

n:D

AT

E O

F FI

RM

DA

TE

FU

LL

YT

OTA

LA

GE

RM

NG

WT

DR

EM

UN

ITL

OC

ND

ESC

RIP

TIO

NO

PER

AT

ION

DEP

RE

CIA

TED

WEI

GH

TIN

GL

IFE

SPA

N(Y

RS)

LIF

E S

PAN

LIF

E S

PAN

WT

DA

GE

13x

xxPe

aker

s08

/01/

0707

/31/

3220

%25

5.4

19.6

3.91

61.

084

23x

xxPe

aker

s08

/01/

0707

/31/

3220

%25

5.4

19.6

3.91

61.

084

33x

xxPe

aker

s08

/01/

0707

/31/

3220

%25

5.4

19.6

3.91

61.

084

43x

xxPe

aker

s08

/01/

0707

/31/

3220

%25

5.4

19.6

3.91

61.

084

53x

xxPe

aker

s11

/01/

1211

/01/

3720

%25

0.2

24.8

4.96

70.

033

100%

4.

4 20

.63

20.6

33

4.36

7

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 27: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

SON

GS

Rem

aini

ng L

ife S

pan:

UN

IT 2 3

LO

CN

DE

SCR

IPTI

ON

DA

TE

OF

FIR

M

OPE

RA

TIO

ND

AT

E F

UL

LY

D

EPR

EC

IATE

DW

EIG

HT

ING

RM

NG

L

IFE

SPA

NW

TD

RE

M

LIF

E S

PAN

SON

GS

Uni

t 2

SON

GS

Uni

t 302

/16/

2250

%9.1 9.

94.

564

4.93

611

/15/

2250

%10

0%

PVN

GS

Rem

aini

ng L

ife S

pan:

9.5

9.50

0

UN

IT 1 3 3

LO

CN

DE

SCR

IPTI

ON

P VN

GS

Uni

t 1

P VN

GS

Uni

t 2

P VN

GS

Uni

t 3

DA

TE

OF

FIR

M

OPE

RA

TIO

ND

AT

E F

UL

LY

D

EPR

ECIA

TED

WEI

GH

TIN

GR

MN

G

LIF

E S

PAN

32.4

33.3

34.9

WT

DR

EM

L

IFE

SPA

N10

.805

11.1

0411

.633

06/0

1/45

33.3

333%

04/2

4/46

33.3

333%

11/2

5/47

33.3

333%

100%

Sola

r PV

Rem

aini

ng L

ife S

pan:

33.5

33.5

42

DA

TE

OF

FIR

MD

AT

E F

UL

LY

TO

TAL

AG

ER

MN

GW

TD

RE

MU

NIT

MW

Esca

latio

n Fa

ctor

OPE

RA

TIO

ND

EPR

EC

IATE

DW

EIG

HT

ING

LIF

E S

PAN

fYR

S)L

IFE

SPA

NL

IFE

SPA

NW

TD

AG

ESP

VP0

02 -

Chi

no1.

221.

560

09/2

4/09

09/2

4/29

1.3%

203.

316

.70.

220

0.04

3SP

VP0

03 -

Ria

lto1.

221.

643

07/1

9/10

07/1

9/30

1.4%

202.

517

.50.

243

0.03

4SP

VP0

05 -

Redl

ara

3.40

1.68

612

/27/

1012

/27/

304.

0%20

2.0

18.0

0.71

30.

080

SPV

P006

- O

ntar

io2.

551.

643

01/1

0/11

01/1

0/31

2.9%

202.

018

.00.

522

0.05

7SP

VP0

07 -

Red

lara

3.20

1.68

612

/29/

1012

/29/

303.

7%20

2.0

18.0

0.67

20.

075

SPV

P008

- O

ntar

io2.

851.

643

12/3

0/10

12/3

0/30

3.2%

202.

018

.00.

583

0.06

5SP

VP0

09 -

Ont

ario

1.41

1.64

301

/10/

1101

/10/

311.

6%20

2.0

18.0

0.28

90.

032

SPV

P010

- Fo

ntar

c2.

251.

731

05/1

8/11

05/1

8/31

2.7%

201.

618

.40.

495

0.04

4SP

VP0

11 -

Red

lara

5.02

1.73

111

/10/

1111

/10/

316.

0%20

1.118

.91.

133

0.06

9SP

VP0

12 -

Ont

ario

0.77

1.64

312

/29/

1012

/29/

300.

9%20

2.0

18.0

0.15

70.

018

SPV

P013

- Re

dlar

a4.

931.

731

09/1

5/11

09/1

5/31

5.9%

201.

318

.71.

104

0.07

6SP

VP0

15 -

Font

arc

4.69

1.73

112

/19/

1112

/19/

315.

6%20

1.0

19.0

1.06

40.

058

SPV

P016

- Re

dlar

a1.

751.

731

05/1

8/11

05/1

8/31

2.1%

201.

618

.40.

385

0.03

4SP

VP0

17 -

Fon

tarc

4.50

1.73

112

/14/

1112

/14/

315.

4%20

1.0

19.0

1.02

00.

056

SPV

P018

- Fo

ntar

c1.

941.

686

05/2

3/11

05/2

3/31

2.3%

201.

618

.40.

416

0.03

6SP

VP0

22 -

Redl

ara

3.09

1.64

311

/15/

1011

/15/

303.

5%20

2.1

17.9

0.62

80.

075

SPV

P023

- Fo

ntar

c3.

861.

731

05/1

2/11

05/1

2/31

4.6%

201.

618

.40.

848

0.07

6SP

VP0

26 -

Ria

lto8.

601.

731

08/2

6/11

08/2

6/31

10.3

%20

1.3

18.7

1.92

00.

139

SPV

P027

- R

ialto

2.62

1.73

111

/27/

1211

/27/

323.

1%20

0.1

19.9

0.62

40.

003

SPV

P028

- Sa

nBei

4.86

1.73

112

/20/

1112

/20/

315.

8%20

1.0

19.0

1.10

40.

060

SPV

P032

- O

ntar

io1.

741.

731

12/2

2/11

12/2

2/31

2.1%

201.

019

.00.

394

0.02

1SP

VP0

33 -

Ont

ario

1.27

1.73

112

/12/

1112

/12/

311.

5%20

1.118

.90.

289

0.01

6SP

VP0

42 -

Porte

rv:

6.77

1.68

612

/28/

1012

/28/

307.

9%20

2.0

18.0

1.42

10.

159

SPV

P044

- Pe

rris

10.1

51.

731

09/1

4/12

09/1

4/32

12.2

%20

0.3

19.7

2.39

40.

036

84.6

5 10

0.0%

1.

36

18.6

18

.639

1.

361

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 28: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION15

S C E - 1 0 , V o lu m e 2 , R e s u l t s o f O p e r a t io n s

D e p r e c ia t i o n S t u d y

Witness: Rick Fisher

A c c o u n t I m p a c t o f L i f e a n d N e t S a lv a g e P a r a m e te r s

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 29: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

16Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Southern C alifo rnia Edison Calculation o f Expense Impact

Transmission and D istribution ($ 000's)

Authorized Change due Change due ProposedTRANSMISSION PLANT Accrual to Life to Net Salvage Accrual

350.2 Easements 2,472 - - 2,472

352 Structures and Improvements 8,965 142 430 9,537353 Station Equipment 115,079 (5,824) 11,864 121,119

Total Transmission Substations 124,044 (5,681) 12,294 130,657

354 Towers and Fixtures 19,614 (202) 5,045 24,456355 Poles and Fixtures 20,707 3,172 2,539 26,418356 Overhead Conductors & Devices 25,205 (3,493) 4,182 25,894357 Underground Conduit 825 14 - 839358 Underground Conductors & Devices 5,850 19 (356) 5,512359 Roads and Trails 727 (74) - 654

Total Transmissions Lines 72,927 (564) 11,410 83,773Total Transmission Plant 199,443 (6,245) 23,704 216,902

DISTRIBUTION PLANT360.2 Easements 939 - - 939

361 Structures and Improvements 13,979 (690) - 13,289362 Station Equipment 55,120 (2,448) 5,064 57,736

Total Distribution Substations 70,038 (3,138) 5,064 71,964

364 Poles, Towers and Fixtures 116,845 (3,300) 15,751 129,296365 Overhead Conductors & Devices 55,120 1,422 5,094 61,636366 Underground Conduit 30,015 (2,215) 6,215 34,015367 Underground Conductors & Devices 147,468 (1,329) 25,666 171,806368 Line Transformers 111,213 (16,854) 24,399 118,758369 Services 55,790 (4,514) 16,191 67,467370 Meters 47,549 (406) - 47,142373 Street Lighting & Signal Systems 20,577 333 4,950 25,860

Total Distribution Lines 584,576 (26,862) 98,265 655,979Total Distribution Plant 654,614 (30,000) 103,329 727,943

Total Transmission and Distribution 854,057 (36,245) 127,033 944,845

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 30: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION17

S C E - 1 0 , V o lu m e 2 , R e s u l t s o f O p e r a t io n s

D e p r e c ia t i o n S t u d y

Witness: Rick Fisher

T r a n s m is s io n a n d D i s t r i b u t i o n C o m p o s i t e R a te C a lc u la t io n s

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 31: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

GR

OS

S P

LAN

T Ja

nuar

y 1,

201

3 (1

)T

RA

NS

MIS

SIO

N P

LAN

T35

2S

truct

ures

and

Impr

ovem

ents

376,

680,

053

353

Sta

tion

Equ

ipm

ent

3,98

1,95

7,65

5To

tal T

rans

mis

sion

Sub

stat

ions

4,35

8,63

7,70

8

354

Tow

ers

and

Fixt

ures

772,

203,

666

355

Pol

es a

nd F

ixtu

res

603,

692,

254

356

Ove

rhea

d C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

706,

020,

711

357

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duit

48,5

17,0

3335

8U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

208,

167,

367

359

Roa

ds a

nd T

rails

43,0

38,5

83To

tal T

rans

mis

sion

s Li

nes

2,38

1,63

9,61

5To

tal T

rans

mis

sion

(ex

cl la

nd)

6,74

0,27

7,32

2S

TR

IBU

TIO

N P

LAN

T36

1S

truct

ures

and

Impr

ovem

ents

436,

830,

749

362

Sta

tion

Equ

ipm

ent

1,76

1,03

7,88

3To

tal D

istri

butio

n S

ubst

atio

ns2,

197,

868,

632

364

Pol

es, T

ower

s an

d Fi

xtur

es1,

655,

027,

118

365

Ove

rhea

d C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

1,19

5,65

3,26

236

6U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

it1,

389,

563,

200

367

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duct

ors

& D

evic

es4,

402,

043,

706

368

Line

Tra

nsfo

rmer

s3,

022,

095,

507

369

Ser

vice

s1,

172,

062,

087

370

Met

ers

888,

759,

132

373

Stre

et L

ight

ing

& S

igna

l Sys

tem

s75

3,72

0,53

8To

tal D

istri

butio

n Li

nes

14,4

78,9

24,5

49To

tal D

istri

butio

n (e

xcl l

and)

16,6

76,7

93,1

81To

tal T

&D

(exc

l lan

d)23

,417

,070

,503

00

Pro

pose

d an

d A

uth

ori

zed

SC

E G

RC

T

&D

De

pre

ciat

ion

Rat

es__

____

_D

ep

reci

atio

n R

ates

2003

2006

2009

2012

2015

Pro

pose

d | A

utho

rized

Pro

pose

d | A

utho

rized

Pro

pose

d | A

utho

rized

Pro

pose

d (A

utho

rized

Pro

pose

d

2.49

%3.

23%

2.56

%2.

56%

2.50

%2.

50%

2.38

%2.

38%

2.53

%2.

70%

1.40

%2.

78%

2.45

%2.

85%

2.54

%3.

04%

2.89

%3.

04%

2.68

%

|1.

56%

2.76

%

|2.

46%

2.82

%

|2.

54%

2.98

%

|2.

85%

3.00

%

3.27

%3.

30%

2.80

%2.

42%

2.81

%2.

41%

3.24

%2.

54%

3.17

%4.

85%

2.83

%4.

20%

3.78

%4.

32%

3.90

%4.

29%

3.43

%4.

38%

4.94

%3.

48%

4.11

%3.

53%

4.19

%3.

61%

3.76

%3.

57%

3.67

%1.

93%

1.96

%1.

92%

1.67

%1.

94%

1.69

%1.

70%

1.70

%1.

73%

3.31

%3.

55%

3.90

%3.

90%

3.87

%3.

87%

2.81

%2.

81%

2.65

%1.

56%

1.46

%1.

56%

1.56

%1.

70%

1.70

%1.

69%

1.69

%1.

52%

4.11

%

|3.

20%

3.60

%

|3.

19%

3.66

%

|3.

24%

3.56

%

|3.

06%

3.52

%3.

19%

2.14

%3.

06%

2.72

%3.

12%

2.79

%3.

19%

2.92

%3.

18%

3.05

%2.

96%

3.30

%3.

30%

3.15

%3.

15%

3.20

%3.

20%

3.04

%2.

74%

1.03

%3.

03%

2.89

%3.

04%

2.90

%3.

13%

3.13

%3.

28%

2.80

%

|1.

41%

3.08

%

|2.

97%

3.06

%

|2.

95%

3.14

%

|3.

14%

3.23

%

6.17

%4.

13%

8.52

%6.

86%

8.68

%7.

05%

8.47

%7.

06%

7.81

%5.

50%

4.63

%4.

70%

4.12

%4.

83%

4.26

%5.

57%

4.61

%5.

15%

3.07

%2.

60%

2.90

%2.

18%

2.16

%2.

16%

2.16

%2.

16%

2.45

%3.

93%

7.33

%5.

32%

4.85

%5.

34%

4.88

%5.

04%

3.35

%3.

90%

6.03

%2.

65%

5.01

%4.

47%

4.85

%4.

32%

4.16

%3.

68%

3.93

%5.

95%

4.05

%6.

37%

5.33

%6.

48%

5.43

%5.

29%

4.76

%5.

76%

4.69

%2.

80%

4.41

%4.

41%

4.46

%5.

50%

5.34

%5.

35%

5.30

%2.

26%

2.58

%2.

86%

2.86

%3.

57%

3.01

%3.

05%

2.73

%3.

43%

4.79

%

|4.

52%

5.24

%

|4.

59%

5.22

%

|4.

68%

4.95

%

|4.

04%

4.53

%4.

53%

4.14

%

A A

4.11

%3.

54%

A B

4.95

%4.

41%

A4.

38%

3.90

%

A D

4.93

%4.

41%

A

4.46

%3.

98%

A

4.71

%4.

27% A

3.92

%3.

63% A

4.36

%4.

02% A

Figu

re I

II-4

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 32: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. Ill Witness: R. Fisher

Pas

t and

Cur

rent

SC

E G

RC

Pro

pose

d T&

D N

et S

alva

ge R

ates

TRAN

SMIS

SIO

N P

LAN

T35

2 S

truct

ures

and

Im

prov

emen

ts35

3 S

tatio

n E

quip

men

tTo

tal T

rans

mis

sion

Sub

stat

ions

354

Tow

ers

and

Fixt

ures

355

Pol

es a

nd F

ixtu

res

356

Ove

rhea

d C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

357

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duit

358

Und

ergr

ound

Con

duct

ors

& D

evic

es35

9 R

oads

and

Tra

ilsTo

tal T

rans

mis

sion

s Li

nes

Tota

l Tra

nsm

issi

on (

excl

land

) D

ISTR

IBU

TIO

N P

LAN

T36

1 S

truct

ures

and

Im

prov

emen

ts36

2 S

tatio

n E

quip

men

tTo

tal

Dis

tribu

tion

Sub

stat

ions

364

Pol

es, T

ower

s an

d Fi

xtur

es36

5 O

verh

ead

Con

duct

ors

& D

evic

es36

6 U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

it36

7 U

nder

grou

nd C

ondu

ctor

s &

Dev

ices

368

Line

Tra

nsfo

rmer

s36

9 S

ervi

ces

370

Met

ers

373

Stre

et L

ight

ing

& S

igna

l Sys

tem

sTo

tal

Dis

tribu

tion

Line

s To

tal

Dis

tribu

tion

Pla

nt (

excl

land

) To

tal T

&D

(ex

cl la

nd)

GR

OSS

PLA

NT

Net

Sal

vage

Rat

esJa

nuar

y 1,

201

320

0320

0620

0920

1220

15(1

)Pr

opos

ed |

Aut

horiz

edPr

opos

ed |

Auth

oriz

edPr

opos

ed |

Auth

oriz

edPr

opos

ed |

Aut

horiz

edPr

opos

ed

14,4

78,

16,6

76,

23,4

17,92

4,54

979

3,18

107

0,50

3-5

7%-5

1“ A A

-36%

-29% A B

-66%

-57% A

-52%

-43% A D

-66%

-57% A

-52%

-43% A

-58%

-52% A

-54%

-47% A

-74%

-64% A

376,

680,

053

-35%

-30%

-40%

-40%

-40%

-40%

-30%

-30%

-35%

3,98

1,95

7,65

5-5

%15

%-5

%5%

-5%

5%-1

0%-5

%-1

5%4,

358,

637,

708

-8%

I 11

%

|-8

%I

1%

I-8

%I

1%

I-1

2%I

-7%

I

-17%

|

772,

203,

666

-85%

-60%

-85%

-70%

-85%

-70%

-85%

-70%

-100

%60

3,69

2,25

4-1

15%

-50%

-85%

-70%

-85%

-70%

-85%

-70%

-85%

706,

020,

711

-95%

-50%

-95%

-80%

-95%

-80%

-85%

-80%

-100

%48

,517

,033

0%0%

-10%

0%-1

0%0%

0%0%

0%20

8,16

7,36

7-3

0%-3

0%-3

0%-3

0%-3

0%-3

0%-2

0%-2

0%-1

5%43

,038

,583

0%0%

0%0%

0%0%

0%0%

0%2,

381,

639,

615

-87%

I -5

0%

|-8

0%I

-67%

|

-80%

I -6

7%

|-7

6%I

-66%

|

-85%

|

6,74

0,27

7,32

2-3

6%-1

0%-3

3%-2

3%-3

3%-2

3%-3

4%-2

8%-4

1%

436,

830,

749

-20%

-10%

-20%

-20%

-20%

-20%

-25%

-25%

-25%

1,76

1,03

7,88

3-1

5%25

%-1

5%-1

0%-1

5%-1

0%-2

0%-2

0%-3

0%2,

197,

868,

632

-16%

I 18

%

|-1

6%I

-12%

|

-16%

I -1

2%

|-2

1%I

-21%

|

-29%

|

1,65

5,02

7,11

8-1

75%

-100

%-2

50%

-190

%-2

50%

-190

%-2

00%

-190

%-2

25%

1,19

5,65

3,26

2-1

20%

-110

%-1

20%

-100

%-1

20%

-100

%-1

10%

-110

%-1

25%

1,38

9,56

3,20

0-3

0%-2

5%-2

0%-2

0%-2

0%-2

0%-2

0%-2

0%-4

0%4,

402,

043,

706

-60%

-55%

-70%

-60%

-70%

-60%

-60%

-60%

-80%

3,02

2,09

5,50

7-1

0%10

%-1

0%0%

-10%

0%-1

0%0%

-20%

1,17

2,06

2,08

7-1

00%

-60%

-100

%-7

5%-1

00%

-75%

-100

%-8

5%-1

25%

888,

759,

132

-25%

-25%

-10%

-10%

-10%

-10%

-5%

-5%

-5%

753,

720,

538

-5%

-15%

-30%

-15%

-30%

-15%

-30%

-20%

-40%

| -6

3%

| -4

5%

| -7

4%

| -5

8%

| -7

4%

| -5

8%

| -6

4%

| -5

9%

| -8

1%

|

Figu

re II

I-5

CD

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

Page 33: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

20Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

g § a? §; si § * §

? S. § I a § 3

S 'i 'S 'i.' 1g*-' «* co

I § 1 1 § £ § S

i S M l ^

i

§ §

s : . 3 m . sSSigSiSsSS £ 8 S 8 tf S3 S S3

5 1 I ! g g !S S s s l ^ s !S3 | Sf e § § ? 3

111 lip ­

s' i S' I I t | S

s H S s t f g si i m i i i ;

::..

s 's

f j .

g i.:...Ss‘

s j .i" kIs

8 5

S i

! !

1... ..1'.. .

... '.. § g... ' .

n

.2I§ it 1 1

I s £ 8

s 'X u

S' u

s 'X < .

s '\ QJ

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 34: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION21

S C E - 1 0 , V o lu m e 2 , R e s u l t s o f O p e r a t io n s

D e p r e c ia t i o n S t u d y

Witness: Rick Fisher

S a n O n o f r e N u c le a r G e n e r a t in g S t a t io n

M a t e r i a l s & S u p p l ie s R e c o r d e d B a la n c e

Y e a r - E n d 2 0 1 2

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher

Page 35: S02V02P01 - APP - Southern California · PDF file• Four Corners Generating Station ... Depreciation Rate Proposal Impact by Class of Plant ... SCE retained Dane Watson of Alliance

22Workpaper - Southern California Edison / 2015 GRC - APPLICATION

SONGS M&S Inventory(Nominal 2012 EOY Balance, SCE Share)(000)

Storage Location Description Company Code Amount

SONGS K-60 2001 50SONGS - MAIN 2001 26,044SONGS 2001 58SONGS K-60 2002 2,598SONGS - MAIN 2002 86,974SONGS REFURBISHM 2002 8,157Total 123,881

Particiapant ShareSCE (2001) (3,090)EMS (2002) (20,309)

SONGS - SCE Share 100,482

Exhibit No. SCE-10 / Results of Operations / Vol. 02 / Ch. IIIWitness: R. Fisher


Recommended