ECE 4353
Chemical Process Safety
Introduction to Process Safety
(Lecture 1)
Last Updated:17 September 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 2
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Explain the government-industry’s responsibility for health and
safety
Evaluate the nature of hazards posed by materials which are
flammable, toxic and reactive
Analyze different scenario using appropriate source models.
Identify and quantify common industrial methods to control
hazards.
Carry out a simple QRA
Last Updated:17 September 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 3
Lecture 1
1.1 Importance of process safety
1.2 Risk Assessment
1.3 Acceptable risks
1.4 Risk Management
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 55
Process safety focuses on
preventing fires, explosions and accidental chemical releases in chemical process facilities, plants or production facilities.
Uses various tools / techniques
Eg. Swiss cheese model
LOPA (Layers of Protection Analysis)
QRA (Quantified Risk Assessment)
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 66
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
SafetyAudits
‘What-if’ analyses
FMEAFailure Mode Event &Analysis
Fault Tree Analysis
HAZOPHazard & Operability Studies
Event TreeAnalysis
PROCESS SAFETY TECHNIQUESCheck list
PROCESS HAZARD ANALYSIS
LOPALayer of Protection Analysis
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 77
Process safety techniques employsystematic methods to:• Evaluate a process system• Identify process hazards
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 99
On the night of December 2, 1984, the factory owned by theU.S. multinational Union Carbide Corporation accidentally leaked methyl isocyanate and other highly toxic gases into the air, killing thousands of largely poor Indians in the neighborhoods nearby.
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1010
• Estimated 3000 people died from
thethe sameeffects of the poisonous gas on
night of the disaster.• An estimated 20,000 – 30,000 others havesince died from the
• more than 600,000 –
effects of the
900,000
people
leak
beingdeadly gas cloud thatexposed to the
night. Thegasesground, causing victims throats
stayed low to theand eyes
inducing nausea, and manyto burn, deaths.
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
Bhopal:World's worst industrial incident.
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1111
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1212
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1313
The abandoned former Union Carbide pesticide plant in Bhopal, India.
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1414
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1515
• An explosion and resultingdestroyed Piper Alpha
oil and gason 6 Julyfires
1988.
• Totalinsured loss was about £1.7
billion (US$3.4 billion).
crew; 165 out of• The accident killed 167 220crew members, plus two crew from thestandby vessel Sandhaven.
attributed mainly to• The accidenthuman error,
wasand was a major eye opener
industry regardingto thesafety
offshoreissues.
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
Piper Alpha:Worst Offshore disaster.
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1616
• Following the tragedy, an inquiry intothe accident commenced in Novembe
r1988
headed by Lord Cullen.was conducted in two parts.• The inquiry
The first part studied the causes of thesecond part presentedto avert future
tragedy and the recommendations occurrence.• It presented 106 recommendations forchanges to North Sea safety procedures.
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1717
in the offshore industry withsafety management, regulation
regard toand
training. A majorresponsibility for
impact wasNorth Sea safety
of Energyshifting from to the Health
the Department andSafety Executive.
Also, automatic shut-down valves wereon rigs, to starve a firemade mandatory
of fuel.
1.1 IMPORTANCE OF PROCESS SAFETY• The inquiry brought about great changes
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1818
What is the difference between RISK and
HAZARD?
<video on Risk vs Hazard>
RISK vs HAZARD
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 1919
Risk = Severity x LikelihoodSeverity= ConsequencesMagnitude of LossInjuries, Fatalities, $$ Losses, Environmental Impact
Likelihood= ProbabilityChance of Failure
RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2020
• Risk increases if either likelihood or severity [magnitude of loss] increasesprovided the other component does notdecrease proportionally.
RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2222
Importance of Risk Assessment• Identify hazards• Analyse or evaluate the risk associated with
thathazard.
• Determine appropriate ways to eliminate orcontrol the hazard.
1.2 RISK ASSESSMENT
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2323
What is Risk Assessment?• Identify the hazards• Assess the risks by considering
the severity and likelihood of bad outcomes.
• If the risks are not sufficiently low, then additional controls or alternate methods must be applied.
1.2 RISK ASSESSMENT
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2424
Why is Risk Assessment Important?• Integral part of a good occupational health
and safety management plan.• Create awareness of hazards and risks.• Identify who may be at risk (employees,
cleaners, visitors, contractors, the public, etc).• Determine if existing control measures are
adequate or if more should be done.• Prevent injuries or illnesses when done at the
design or planning stage.• Prioritize hazards and control measures.
1.2 Risk Assessment
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2525
What is the goal of Risk Assessment?• The aim of the risk assessment
process is to remove a hazard or reduce the level of its risk by adding precautions or control measures, as necessary.
• Create a safer and healthierworkplace.
1.2 RISK ASSESSMENT
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2626
• No task is completely without risk• Must develop tailored risk matrix, based upon acceptable risk, in order to identify what is considered sufficiently low
• Must define “acceptable risk”
1.3 ACCEPTABLE RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2727
Acceptable Risk• What is it?
The threshold level below which risk will be tolerated
1.3 ACCEPTABLE RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2828
Risk Class
Example Risk Classification(IEC61508-5)I.Unacceptable
II.Undesirable
III.Action Recommended(ALARP)
IV.Broadly Acceptable
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 2929
1.3 ACCEPTABLE RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 3030
1.3 ACCEPTABLE RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 3131
1.3 ACCEPTABLE RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 3232
1.3 ACCEPTABLE RISK
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 3333
Acceptable Risk
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 3434
Acceptable Risk
LLaasstt UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 SeSepptetemmbbeerr 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group 3535
Acceptable Risk