11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Solar-Electric Power:Road to a Clean, Secure Energy
FutureJames Gee1 and Roland Hulstrom2
1Sandia National Laboratories2National Renewable Energy Laboratory
1Sandia National Laboratories is a multi-program laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company, for the U. S. Department of Energy under contract DE-ACO4-94AL85000.2NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy operated by Midwest Research Institute, Battelle, and Bechtel, Contract # DE-AC36-99GO10337.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Outline
1. Concentrating Solar Power2. Roadmap of the U.S. Photovoltaic Industry
Technology and Industry RoadmapsVision, Strategies, GoalsMarket and Technical Barriers
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Solar Two:A dispatchablesolar technology.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Advanced DishDevelopment:10-kW system with improved optics, structure,control system, sterlingengine, and receiver.Systems runs autono-mously, and future improvements will allow system to run off grid and be hybridized.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
SEGS
354 MW25% natural gasDispatchableTechnology around $0.12/kWh.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
What does a roadmap provide?
• Establish a Vision for the industry.• Establish a strategic plan towards realizing the Vision.• Instill confidence in decision makers, investors, and
customers. • Identify and guide opportunities for shared
development.• Clarify barriers and coordinate response within the
community.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Roadmap Process
VISION
Strategizing
Roadmap
Vision to establish destination.
Workshop(s) to identify barriers, needs, and strategic actions.
Roadmap organizes and synthesizesworkshop information into coherentpresentation.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
VISIONU.S. Photovoltaic Industry
“… to provide the electrical energyconsumer competitive and environmentally friendly energy products and services from a thrivingUnited States-based solar-electricpower industry.”
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Strategies
• Maintain U.S. PV industry’s worldwide technological leadership.
• Achieve economic competitiveness with conventional technologies.
• Maintain a sustained market and PV production growth.
• Make the PV industry profitable and attractive to investors.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Target and Goals
Target: For the U.S. photovoltaic industry to provide up to 15% (about 3000 MW) of new U.S. electricity generation capacity expected to be required in 2020. The U.S. cumulative PV shipments will be about 30 GW at this time.
Goals:• A growth rate of 25% in PV production capacity is required to
meet the roadmap targets for U.S. and international markets.• PV system costs to the end user of $3.00/Wac and $1.50/Wac by
2010 and 2020, respectively. Total manufacturing costs will be about 60% of the system cost.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Reduction in Module Price vs Cumulative Shipments1980 thru 1999 History(total world)
1
10
100
10 100 1000 10000Cumulative Worldwide Shipments MWp
$[19
99]/W
p
28.5% reduction in price forevery doubling of cumulative shipments
Source of Shipments & Current Year Price Data: Paul Maycock
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Projected Installed PV System Price vs Cumulative Shipments
$1.50
$7.00
1.00
10.00
100 1,000 10,000 100,000Cumulative Shipments MWp
Syst
em P
rice
$/W
p 22% Price Decrease PerDoubling of CumulativeShipments
Estimates U.S. Industry's CumulativeShipments Prior to 2000 to be
400 MWp, then Roadmap25% Annual Growth Curve
2020 Target
2000
2010 Target
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
PVMaT History and Projections for "Average" Module Manufacturing Costs
1.00
10.00
10.00 100.00 1000.00Total Manufacturing Capacity (MWp)
Mod
ule
Man
ufac
turin
g C
osts
$/W
p[$1
999]
1999
Actual
Projected:By PVMaTIndustry Participants.
Independent of the20% "model"
2005
1992
20% reduction in costsfor every doubling of capacity
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Comparison of Forecasts of Total World PV Module Shipments
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012Year
GW
p A
nnua
l Sh
ipm
ents
25% Growth Rate
15% Growth Rate
Maycock BAU
Strategies Unlimited BAU
Maycock Accelerated
Strategies Unlimited Accelerated
25%
15%
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Market Barriers and Solutions• Value: Full value of solar electricity as distributed, clean, renewable energy
must be described and captured for policy makers, investment and financial communities, and consumers.
• Products: Products must be easier to use.– Not a “techie” project – more like a household appliance– Reliability comparable to (or much better than!) other electricity options– Standards and codes
• Policies: Public policies must reflect value and importance of solar electricity– National interconnection standards– National net metering legislation– Electricity restructuring should promote renewable energy introduction– Financial incentives to stimulate market expansion in early stage
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Technical Barriers and Solutions
• Infrastructure: Greater cooperation between material and equipment vendors, PV module manufacturers, and system component manufacturers.
• Technical: – Higher performance– Higher throughput – Module materials
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Conclusion
• Solar-Electric Power has very attractive features that make it a natural component of a sustainable energy future for the U.S. and the world.
• The U.S. PV Industry is completing development of a roadmap that will delineate a path towards achieving a prominent role in energy generation. Anticipated completion of the roadmap is early 2001.
11/29/00 – 12/01/00 NSF Workshop on Sustainable Energy Technologies
Acknowledgements• PV Industry Roadmap has been developed by over
40 specialists from across the PV community, with additional comments from across the community.
• NCPV Advisory Board has served as the Executive Committee for the roadmap.
• NCPV Management Team has helped guide the NCPV facilitation role in the generation of the roadmap.
• CSP viewgraphs provided by Craig Tyner (SNL).