October 2002 ISSS 1 1 Center for Research on Embedded Systems and Technology (CREST), http://crest.ece.gatech.edu 2 Assistant 3 Professor, 1 Electrical and Computer Engineering 2 Adjunct Assistant Professor, College of Computing Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA USA 4 Tallin Technical University, Tallin, Estonia System Level Power- Performance Trade-Offs in Embedded Systems Using Voltage and Frequency Scaling of Off-Chip Buses and Memory Kiran Kiran Puttaswamy Puttaswamy 1 , , Kyu Kyu-Won Choi Won Choi 1 , Jun , Jun Cheol Cheol Park Park 1 , Vincent J. Mooney Vincent J. Mooney III III 1, 1,2 , , Abhijit Abhijit Chatterjee Chatterjee 1, 1,3 and and Peeter Peeter Ellervee Ellervee 4 { kiranp kiranp, , kwchoi kwchoi , , jcpark jcpark , chat, , chat, mooney mooney}@ece.gatech.ed }@ece.gatech.edu lrv lrv@cc. @cc. ttu ttu. ee ee 2 Hardware/Software Hardware/Software Codesign Codesign Group, http:// Group, http://codesign codesign. ece ece. gatech gatech. edu edu
Transcript
October 2002 ISSS
1
1Center for Research on Embedded Systems and Technology (CREST), http://crest.ece.gatech.edu
2Assistant 3Professor, 1Electrical and Computer Engineering2Adjunct Assistant Professor, College of ComputingGeorgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA USA
44Tallin Technical University, Tallin, Estonia
System Level Power-Performance Trade-Offs in Embedded Systems Using Voltage and Frequency Scaling of Off-Chip Buses and Memory
KiranKiran PuttaswamyPuttaswamy11, , KyuKyu--Won ChoiWon Choi11, Jun , Jun CheolCheol ParkPark11,,Vincent J. MooneyVincent J. Mooney IIIIII1,1,22, , AbhijitAbhijit ChatterjeeChatterjee1,1,33 and and Peeter Peeter EllerveeEllervee44
• Embedded Systems –essential components of living
• Constraining Factor: Power
October 2002 ISSS
4
Motivation
• Limited Battery Capacity
• Battery Energy Supplying Characteristic10 mA , 1.5 volts = 1000 hours100 mA, 1.5 volts = 80 hours
October 2002 ISSS
5
Previous Work
• Three broad approaches to memory optimization for power/energy reduction– Cache optimizations– Memory access reduction (especially of off-chip memory)– Memory sizing/structuring and memory intensive voltage
scaling
October 2002 ISSS
6
Our Contribution
• Combination of an architectural technique (store buffer) and a circuit level technique (voltage and frequency scaling) to realize savings in both power and energy in an embedded system composed of an ARM-like processor chip plus a separate memory chip
• System savings in power from 28% to 36%• System savings in energy from 13% to 35%
October 2002 ISSS
7
Computation Part of an Embedded System
CPU
Datacache
Instruction cache
Off-ChipMemory
64
96
32
32
October 2002 ISSS
8
Power Models
• Verilog RTL model for processor (excluding caches)• Compaq Personal Server PCB Board called “Skiff”• Analytical memory model for caches and off-chip
memory
October 2002 ISSS
9
Framework
Benchmark Programs ( c )
Off-Chip Memory Power Model
Toggle Rate Generation
MARS Simulator
VHX Translation
Processor Core Power Model Off-chip Bus Power Model
System Level Power
October 2002 ISSS
10
Wither the power?• Computation in system
– MARS processor (U. Michigan, www.eecs.umich.edu/~jringenb/power)• ~30K lines Verilog
– synthesized using TSMC .25u std. cell lib. from LEDA Systems
• 4KB Icache, 4KB Dcache
– 0.5MB SRAM memory chip (L2)
• Approximately 50% of the power consumed by processor chip (excluding I/O pads and drivers)
• 50% of the power consumed to drive L2 memory: the 0.5MB memory chip + PCB bus + I/O pads/drivers
• => reduce power to drive L2 memory by 60%, system power reduced 30%
October 2002 ISSS
11
3.3 V -> 2V, SRAMdelay doubles, powerreduces up to 66%
Use TSMC 0.25 utech. param. from
MOSIS
October 2002 ISSS
12
October 2002 ISSS
13
Embedded System
CPU
Datacache
Instruction cache
Off-ChipMemory
64
96
32
32
October 2002 ISSS
14
Embedded System (with Store Buffer)
CPU
Datacache
Instruction cache
Off-ChipMemory
64
96
32
32
Store buffer
October 2002 ISSS
15
Methodology
• Voltage/frequency scaling of L2 memory accesses• Store buffer technique
October 2002 ISSS
16
Voltage/Frequency Scaling
Processor Off-chip Memory
Off-chip Buses
3.3 Volts, 100 Mhz2.75 Volts, 100 Mhz
3.3 V, 100 Mhz
2 Volts, 50 Mhz
2 Volts, 50 Mhz
October 2002 ISSS
17
October 2002 ISSS
18
October 2002 ISSS
19
October 2002 ISSS
20
Conclusion
• Reduction in both power and energy – For an ARM-like processor chip plus a separate memory chip:– System savings in power from 28% to 36%– System savings in energy from 13% to 35%– Increase in execution time from 1% to 29%
• Possible technique for power modulation by user/application
![A Comparison of Five Different Multiprocessor SoC Bus ...mooney.gatech.edu/codesign/publications/kkryu/presentation/ryu_62… · GBIA GBIIA CSBA CCBA [Mbps] CCBA 378,181 4.5382 ms](https://static.documents.pub/doc/80x56/5fdda9861016981d981542ac/a-comparison-of-five-different-multiprocessor-soc-bus-gbia-gbiia-csba-ccba-mbps.jpg)
