Tilapia Farming in Recirculating Aquaculture SystemsTilapia Farming
in Recirculating Aquaculture Systems
Presented to:
Submitted by:
Nick DeKeyzer
Dustin Hanson
Andrew Nettles
Issue Date:
April 27,2013
a. Economic (2)
.....................................................................................................................................
3
b. Demographic (2)
...............................................................................................................................
4
2. Five forces of competitive strategy in the industry
..................................................................................
7
a. Rivalry among competing firms (2)
...................................................................................................
7
b. Threat of new entrants (2)
................................................................................................................
8
c. Bargaining power of suppliers (1)
.....................................................................................................
9
d. Bargaining power of buyers
(2).......................................................................................................
10
3. Two-dimensional strategic group map for the industry
.........................................................................
12
4. Specific competitors in the industry
.......................................................................................................
14
a. Competitive Environment
...............................................................................................................
14
b. Immediate Competitors
..................................................................................................................
15
c. Impending Competitors
..................................................................................................................
19
d. Invisible Competitors
......................................................................................................................
22
a. Macro Economics and
Competition................................................................................................
27
d. Organic, Halal, Kosher and Made in America
.................................................................................
31
e. Production method: inexpensive energy
........................................................................................
32
f. Production method: inexpensive organic
feed...............................................................................
33
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 1 | P a g e
8. An update on your selected competitor since the case ended.
.............................................................
35
9. Competitor’s current and projected strategy
.........................................................................................
37
10a. Izumi Dai Growth-Share Matrix
..........................................................................................................
38
10b. Our competitor’s growth-share
matrix...............................................................................................
39
a. Opportunity - Changes in consumer habits (2):
..............................................................................
41
b. Opportunity - Natural fish stocks decreasing (1):
...........................................................................
42
c. Opportunity - Technology reducing labor (3):
................................................................................
42
d. External Threat - Regulation and labeling (1):
................................................................................
43
e. External Threat - Adjacent aquaponic industry (3):
........................................................................
43
f. External Threat - Distribution channels (2):
....................................................................................
43
13. Strategy canvas and strategy
curves.....................................................................................................
44
b. Raise supply availability to year-round operation
(1):....................................................................
48
c. Eliminate seasonal fluctuations in supply (2):
................................................................................
48
d. Reduce harmful ecological impacts (3):
..........................................................................................
48
15. Concrete and specific strategic and major tactical actions
..................................................................
49
b. Win all without fighting: Prioritize markets and determine
competitor focus .............................. 51
16. Implementation plan and time line
......................................................................................................
53
17. What do you expect the competitor to do?
.........................................................................................
54
Implication Wheel
...................................................................................................................................
58
a. Phase 2: Pilot stage, proof of concept:
...........................................................................................
59
b. Phase 3&4: Acquisition and Production
.........................................................................................
60
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 2 | P a g e
Tilapia Farming in Recirculating Aquaculture Systems
1. Hitt’s seven external segments of the general environment
affecting the industry
a. Economic (2)
This section will cover key items only, as the economic environment
is covered in great
detail in other sections of this report. The tilapia industry in
the United States relies primarily
on inexpensive imports from South East Asia and Latin America where
labor costs are much
lower compared to the United States. The fish are bred in rivers
and ponds that are often
polluted with nitrates, heavy metals, pesticides and other
carcinogens (The State of World
Fisheries and Aquaculture, 2012). Our research also indicates that
overseas producers are
finding it increasingly difficult to supply tilapia in sufficient
amounts to satisfy U.S. demand.
Local competition is minimal and consists mostly of small
aquaponics companies with
limited reach. Aquaponics is the combination of aquaculture and
hydroponics (cultivating
plants without soil) in a symbiotic environment. Often these
companies have multi-product
strategies that dilute their focus from breeding tilapia.
In closing, demand for animal protein in general and for healthy
animal protein in particular
is rising quickly in the United States. According to the USDA,
organic products are now
available in nearly 20,000 natural food stores and at nearly 75%
conventional grocery stores
(United States Department of Agriculture). The trend is anticipated
to persist well into the
future.
b. Demographic (2)
Izumi Dai’s (our startup company name in this thesis) customer
demographics are
segmented across two groups: 1/ African-Americans, Asian-Americans
and Hispanics with
incomes above $25,000 and with minimal education, and 2/ Caucasian
consumers with
bachelor degrees and higher incomes (Dettmann, July 2008). Research
has also indicated that
households with graduate degrees were less likely to buy organic
foods, while households with
children under 18 were most likely to buy organic foods. Consumers
with 3 or more children or
older than 50 years old are less likely to become Izumi Dai’s
customers.
c. Political / Legal (3)
According to Karen Mitchell, Staff Environmental Scientist for the
California Department of
Fish & Game in Sacramento, with whom we conducted a phone
interview on 11/5/2012, tilapia
farming in recirculating aquaculture systems does not require an
aquaculture registration if
meant for personal use or for proof of concept. In other words, it
is not required for an
operation devoted to the propagation, cultivation, maintenance, and
harvesting of aquatic
plants and animals for non-commercial purposes. Izumi Dai must
register its operation with the
Department of Fish and Game the moment the operation converts to a
commercial business.
Leaflet No. 35 of the State’s Department of Fish and Game provides
the specific information
required to register the aquaculture (California Department of Fish
and Wildlife, 2013).
In addition, restrictions exist with regards to breeding tilapia in
California due to the
resilient, invasive nature of the species itself. Leaflet No. 35
states the following: “tilapia will be
approved only in San Bernardino, Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside,
San Diego, and Imperial
counties. It may be stocked there only in waters approved by the
Department of Fish and
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 4 | P a g e
Game. Only tilapia mossambica and tilapia hornorum may be stocked
and recipient waters
must be approved by the Department. No tilapia may be imported
until the genetic integrity of
the stock has been certified. This certification may be required
for every shipment.”
No additional legal requirements exist outside of the various
certifications that Izumi Dai
would like to pursue.
d. Technological (1)
As described in great detail a bit later in this document, Izumi
Dai does not plan to compete
on price. Instead, we want to adopt a differentiation strategy that
will render competition
irrelevant in the short run, thus allowing us to operate in a Blue
Ocean. We have identified two
main categories of competitors: aquacultures and aquaponics.
Research has indicated that nearby aquaculture companies are very
low tech. Their
seasonal operation relies extensively on manual labor as well as on
the physical environment.
Tanks are located in inland desert areas where the summer heat
warms the water free of cost.
These harsh areas hold few employment opportunities for the local
population. Thus the
aquaculture companies have access to minimum wage workers. As a
result, the aquaculture
owners have few reasons to leverage expensive technology given this
context.
Our interview with Richard Foxx, a local aquaponics company owner,
on 10/4/2012
confirmed that aquaponics operations are usually very high tech
(Farming with Fish
Aquaponics, 2013). Owners use technology to help with all aspects
of the business such as
managing pumps and filters, monitoring water quality, oxygenation
and flow as well as
dispensing nutrients and medication. Technology also helps with
fine tuning the parameters of
the operation to maximize yields. Aquaponics are mostly geared
towards fruits and vegetables
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 5 | P a g e
with fish as a necessary element to process and fertilize the
water. These high tech breeders
sell tilapia in relatively small quantities to the local organic
grocery stores and fish markets.
Izumi Dai’s smaller separate closed loop tanks and modular
equipment design approach is
highly conducive for the implementation of heterotrophic
technology. Such design greatly
mitigates costly disease spread, complex maintenance and repair,
and total kill scenarios. Our
technology strategy also reduces energy consumption by capturing
biogas that originates from
farm detritus and horse manure. In addition, Izumi Dai plans to
minimize costly manual labor
through the implementation of automated supervisory control and
data acquisition
(SCADA) systems (Daneels & W.Salter, 2012).
e. Global (3)
According to the FAO’s “The State of World Fisheries and
Aquaculture 2012”, global
demand for fish has increased 3.2% year over year. World per capita
fish supply increased from
9.9 kg in the 1960’s to 18.6 kg in 2010. Per capita consumption in
the U.S. is 24.1 kg per year.
The rate of growth with regards to fish supply from capture
fisheries and aquaculture is
outpacing the increase in the world population by a factor of
2.
In recent years climate change vulnerabilities and extreme weather
events have particularly
affected fish production in underdeveloped areas. These areas
produce most of the tilapia that
is currently consumed in the United States.
f. Sociocultural (1)
Izumi Dai’s initial findings regarding psychographics about tilapia
farming in recirculating
aquaculture systems were confirmed during an interview with Sage
Hospitality’s Corporate
Senior Vice President of Operations David Marsh (Sage Hospitality,
2010). He deepened our
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 6 | P a g e
belief that tilapia is currently a commodity item that is used as
filler when fish is not the
issue. In his experience, demand for higher quality tilapia is
extremely limited in restaurants,
and organically bred fish will be a really tough sell in the
restaurant arena because tilapia is
seen as one step above junk. Patrons would order halibut, sole,
salmon; not tilapia. David
suggested that if Izumi Dai wanted to sell to restaurants, it had
to become a price leader to
compete against imported fish. “Restaurants just won’t pay more for
this low end product”
said Marsh. “The fact that it is known as a Chinese fish does not
help either.” In addition he
mentioned that we would have to overcome the distrust for farm
raised fish. “People that
want higher quality fish want wild fish as opposed to farm bred.”
David strongly suggested
differentiating ourselves in terms of branding and quality to cater
to a growing demographic of
health conscious consumers that would prepare and consume the fish
at home.
g. Physical (2)
The external environment in Southern California is close to ideal
for the production of
tilapia in recirculating aquaculture systems thanks to the
ubiquitous availability of inexpensive
desert land, the warm climate, utilities and transportation
infrastructure, as well as the
proximity of 37 million potential consumers.
2. Five forces of competitive strategy in the industry
a. Rivalry among competing firms (2)
Small scale competing tilapia farms appear to be dispersed in
Southern California
without an established major player. As demand for fresh tilapia
filets in the various local
markets outpaces seasonal production, the local market does not
appear to be characterized by
major visible rivalry. Rivalry from tilapia imports are a concern
because of their low cost and
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 7 | P a g e
high supply. In a coastal region within a day’s transport from a
major shipping port, Izumi Dai
may be targeted as a competitor by importers. However, the
production levels at Izumi Dai will
most likely not create a disruption in the local industry until a
strong brand is created and
distribution channels are established.
b. Threat of new entrants (2)
Barriers to entry for an aquaculture operation focused on farming
tilapia in a
recirculating system are medium to high. Large initial startup
costs including facilities and
equipment are substantial. Tilapia feed is a major recurring cost
and critical supply chain
component. According to a 2002 report from the North Carolina
Department of Aquaculture
and Consumer Services, a recirculating tilapia farm with
approximately 114,000lb production
capacity would require $301,000 in initial construction and
equipment costs and $78,000 in first
year operating costs (Tilapia Aquaculture in North Carolina,
2002).
Knowledge of tilapia aquaculture processes and fish biology is also
needed. Academics
in the fishery sciences typically focus on species studies, with
fishery students working at
established operations. New entrants into the local market from
outside established
aquaculture operations may occur if a high demand for live fish is
discovered in Southern
California. However, as will be described in Section 5, Major
Competitors, existing firms use
very large scale operations. Therefore, opening a new aquaculture
farm in a new region would
be risky.
c. Bargaining power of suppliers (1)
Aquaculture farms are dependent on several supplier inputs, without
which the fish
growing operations would cease. Tilapia fry, specialized filter
equipment and tanks, control
systems, and, most importantly, feed are typically supplied to
aquaculture firms.
Feed usually represents over 50% of total intensive recirculating
aquaculture costs
(Gjedrem, Robinson, & Rye, 2012). The growing rate of tilapia
is directly related to the feeding
rate and high quality protein rich feed will grow fish to market
size in approximately 6 months.
With fishmeal and feed ingredients becoming more expensive, as well
as regulated for
ecological reasons, fish producers will need to look into
alternative feeds to sustain fish
production demand (The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture,
2012). Feed suppliers have
a high bargaining power and demand large bulk shipments with lead
times for discounts which
enable aquaculture farms to remain profitable.
Purchasing fingerlings or fry from breeders is a common practice in
aquaculture.
Hatcheries hold brood stock mating pairs which produce desired
characteristics of fish. Tilapia
hatcheries have high bargaining power over farms with no internal
breeding. Hatcheries could
convert from supplier to competitor by opening a grow out farm or
partnering exclusively with
an aquaculture farm.
To lessen the power of Suppliers Izumi Dai will be employing a
vertical supply chain
strategy to cultivate feed and breed the supply of fish, thereby
eliminating feed and hatchery
suppliers. As a result of this strategy, additional labor and
infrastructure will be required.
However, the long term feed independence will be a defining
strength of Izumi Dai.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 9 | P a g e
Cultivating feed will allow a sustainable food source and possibly
provide excess feed to
sell to agriculture firms. Specialized hatcheries are a requirement
for some fish species with
complex breeding habits. However, tilapia are aggressive breeders
when provided the correct
conditions. By breeding tilapia internally in dedicated hatcheries,
Izumi Dai will not only cut
supplier power but also decrease fish transportation stress,
disease introduction and
acclimation difficulties, and maintain a consistent proprietary
genetic strain within Izumi Dai
products.
d. Bargaining power of buyers (2)
Buyers for tilapia will be defined as live fish markets, fish
processors, fish distributors,
and local consumers. Izumi Dai anticipates the chokepoint of
distributors to produce the
highest competitor rivalry. Distributors are the second tier of
three between fish supplier and
customer retail, and take a markup between the supplier and retail
price. Distributors that
control access to a large book of restaurants, hotels, and
supermarkets have a high bargaining
power.
Live fish markets allow fish trade and business relations for a
small fee. Fish market and
farmers market buyers have a moderate power due to the lower lot
size and low sales pressure.
Moving customers from fish markets sales to recurring sales will be
the key to sustained sales.
After initial local distribution is established, Izumi Dai will
attempt to focus on associating
quality to branding and become a recognizable niche brand. Pull
marketing would then be used
to increase customer points of sale and restaurants at grocery
stores.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 10 | P a g e
e. Threat of substitute products (3)
Substitutes to organic tilapia exist in the forms of other lean
organic animal proteins
including fish and poultry. However, as populations of wild fish
continue to dwindle and global
demand continues to grow, fish substitutes will inevitably
decrease. Izumi Dai will market the
fish as a healthy alternative to wild caught fish, which is at a
higher risk of containing pollutants,
and imported fish farmed in unknown conditions. By focusing on
these differences Izumi Dai
will distance itself from fish substitutes.
In summary, the combination of an apparent low level of visible
rivals, the medium to
high barriers to entry, Izumi Dai’s vertical integration strategy
and the reduced threat of
substitute products renders tilapia farming in recirculating
aquaculture systems a viable
business opportunity in Southern California.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 11 | P a g e
3. Two-dimensional strategic group map for the industry
Figure 1: Strategic Group Map for the Industry
The two factors evaluated in the strategic group map are output and
quality. Output refers
to the amount of tilapia the farm produces and sells on the market.
Quality deals with the
tilapia product itself. A high quality product is defined as a
tilapia fish which was farmed
without growth or gender reversal hormones, antibiotics, or other
harmful chemicals or
substances. Also taken into account are the overall farming
conditions in which the fish is
raised. A high quality product is raised in a clean, controlled
environment in water which is free
of contaminants or pollutants.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 12 | P a g e
The strategic group map reveals five distinct groups into which the
selected competitors
fall. Group 1 is characterized by high output and low quality. In
this group are the fresh and
frozen tilapia imports, which primarily come from Latin American
and Asian countries. As will
be further examined in this report, such countries, while an
economical choice for lower labor
costs, also have lax standards regarding food and safety
regulation. This has led to various
health concerns regarding the seafood products they produce.
Group 2 is characterized by moderately high levels of output and
similarly high levels of
quality. Even though the companies in this group are categorized by
a moderately high level of
output, their total yield is really quite small, as low as 1%, when
compared to the amount of
tilapia imported into the US by companies in group 1. Companies in
group 2 are local US
companies which boast of a certified organic product grown in a
clean, controlled environment.
It is important to note here that Premier Foods Farms is actually
located in Texas and, based on
market research, presumably does not sell its tilapia in the
California market.
Group 3 is characterized by moderate output and above average
quality. Although these
products are not certified organic, they are produced in a
controlled environment which is
monitored and kept clean of contaminants and pollutants. Another
factor which may preclude
these producers from receiving certification is the type of feed
which they give to the fish.
Organic feed is more costly and, as such, is probably cost
prohibitive for farms operating in this
group.
The companies in group 4 have a mild level of output and a high
level of quality. This is the
group in which Izumi Dai will compete. It is important to note
that, even though it is classified
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 13 | P a g e
in the same group below, Blue Ridge Aquaponics currently operates
solely out of Virginia and
presumably does not have any tilapia coming into the California
market.
The companies in group 5 are characterized by very low levels of
output and a high level of
quality. The reason for the lower levels of output is emphasis or
specialization. Some of these
companies may be aquaponics operations whose primary focus is
produce, and they only use
the tilapia to complete the symbiotic environment. Others, like
Sarasota below, are hatcheries
who do not focus on fish to market operations, rather they breed
and raise their tilapia to sell
as fry and fingerlings.
a. Competitive Environment
The competitive environment in the aquaculture industry is highly
fragmented with
numerous individual companies operating in various countries around
the world. For the
purposes of this report, only companies with a relevant focus in
tilapia production will be
considered and analyzed as competitors. The global competition
presents itself in the form of
imports. America holds the title of the second-largest seafood
importer in the world, with
tilapia being the third most imported seafood product in the United
States. Most of these
imports come from Latin American and South-East Asian countries
where labor costs are low
and food-safety regulations are mostly inexistent. However,
incidences in recent years have
spurred concerns from US consumers regarding the safety and quality
of such products.
Additionally, demand for fish in these countries’ local markets is
increasing due to rapid
population growth. As a result, there is an increasing demand in
the US for safer, higher-
quality, locally farmed seafood products.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 14 | P a g e
“Because of increasing seafood demand and low yields from wild
fishery resources,
aquaculture products in the US market have significant growth
potential over the coming five
years (McBee, 2012).” This is where local competition comes into
play. Our research shows
that tilapia, however, has yet to become a fish of choice for the
larger-scale, US-based
aquaculture farmers. Some aquaculture farmers raise tilapia
seasonally during the summer
months, but have yet to specialize exclusively in tilapia. The most
significant competition on US
territory comes from smaller-scale aquaculture farms and aquaponics
operations. The
distribution reach of these operations tends to be more limited,
thus restricting the tilapia
farmed by these entities to be sold and distributed within a closer
vicinity of the farm’s
operations.
A growing threat comes from the increasing popularity of local
aquaponics operations.
The threat from this growing trend is twofold. First, although
raising tilapia is not the emphasis
of such operations, some of these operations may have a large
enough tilapia output to meet a
portion of our target segment’s needs. Secondly, some firms are
selling aquaponics setups
which would allow our prospective customers to reach protein
independence by growing their
own tilapia as opposed to buying ours.
With this competitive landscape in mind, competitors have been
categorized into three
categories: immediate competitors, impending competitors, and
invisible competitors.
b. Immediate Competitors
Foreign Importer (1)
The US is a net importer of seafood and has a small aquaculture
industry compared to other
countries. Consequently, imports of farm-produced seafood into the
US are large. According to
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 15 | P a g e
the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA),
Americans consume between 6
million and 7 million tons of wild and farmed seafood annually, and
about 84% of that total
comes from imports, half of which is farmed. Total US seafood
production only accounts for
about 2% of the country’s consumption.
Tilapia is imported into the US either frozen or fresh. Both the
fresh and frozen products
are imported as either a whole fish product or a fillet product.
The perishable nature of fresh
fish makes countries closer to the United States more suited for
operating with fresh fish
products, Hence, the majority of fresh tilapia imports are sourced
from Latin America, while
Asian countries, specifically China, continue to dominate the
frozen tilapia import market
(United States Department of Agriculture, 2013).” With the growing
health concerns discussed
earlier and the increasing trend of organic products, it is
possible that a foreign competitor
could diversify into the organic tilapia market and directly
compete with Izumi Dai.
Such a competitor is classified as a very threatening level 1
competitor because of their
established distribution and supply chain operations and economies
of scale. Competing
against such a competitor would be difficult for Izumi Dai.
However, Izumi Dai intends to
position itself not only as an organic tilapia farmer, but as a
local farmer with environmentally
friendly farming operations raising tilapia in the US, a
differentiation strategy that the foreign
competitor would not be able to duplicate.
Grow Foods Inc (1)
Grow Foods’ offices are located in San Marcos, California. It is
composed of four
different divisions: Grow Foods Aquaponic Systems, Grow Foods
Farms, Grow Foods Gardens,
and Grow Foods Water Management Systems. In addition to producing
its own produce and
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 16 | P a g e
seafood for market, Grow Foods also acts as a consulting agency,
designing and manufacturing
a variety of garden and aquaponic systems for homes, businesses,
resorts, and municipalities.
Unfortunately, little is known about Grow Foods Inc. Although
attempts have been
made to acquire additional information regarding their operations
and tilapia output, none has
been provided. In spite of the lack of information available
regarding Grow Foods, it has been
classified as an immediate, very threatening competitor.
Grow Foods Farms, a division of Grow Foods Inc, grows seafood in
“land, river, and
ocean based farms” which it sells to “individuals, restaurants, and
super markets (Grow Foods,
2012).” With its headquarters in San Marcos, California, the
assumption is that these farms are
operating in California and, even more threatening, in Southern
California. With the possibility
of a large, commercial-scale competitor operating within Izumi
Dai’s target market location,
and with little information regarding the specifics of this
competitor’s operations, Izumi Dai
should consider the threat significant until additional information
can be acquired.
Future Foods Farms (2)
Future Foods Farms (FFF) is one of the largest aquaponic farms in
the State of California
(Future Food Farms, 2013). Located on 25 acres in Brea, California,
FFF produces organically
grown produce and tilapia, which is used by FFF creator and Chef
Adam Navidi in his
restaurants and catered events. Some of FFF’s output is also sold
at the local farmers markets.
FFF has been categorized as an immediate, threatening competitor
because of its
geographic location in Southern California and its strategic
alliances with key players in the
aquaponics industry.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 17 | P a g e
FFF is classified as a threatening competitor primarily because its
focus is aquaponics
and not aquaculture and, as such, it has yet to reach a tilapia
output level that presents a
significant threat. However, with FFF operating in the heart of
Izumi Dai’s target market, it still
poses significant threats which have contributed to its “immediate
competitor” classification.
FFF has an ambitious vision and a strategic marketing strategy. In
its mission statement,
FFF states that it is their “mission to create a sustainable farm
concept that will change both
agriculture and the restaurant industry forever and provide our
customers with the ultimate
food experience (Future Food Farms, 2013).” With their evangelical
approach, FFF proselytizes
the benefits and advantages of its sustainable farming practices
and high quality products.
Farm tours and tastings hosted by the Chef himself are available to
the public and can be
booked online via FFF’s website. More of their marketing prowess is
evidenced in their specialty
line of products that certain grocers and restaurants will soon
carry.
FFF’s founder established a strategic alliance early on with
aquaponic guru, Eden
Aquaponics, which is discussed later in this section as a
competitor. An additional strategic
alliance was formed with aquaponic powerhouse, Aquaplanet. In
addition to these strategic
alliances, FFF boasts of several scientists who consult at their
aquaponic garden along with
several college professors and interns who maintain and study the
garden on a daily basis
(Future Food Farms, 2013). These alliances and partnerships give
FFF a competitive advantage
by providing FFF with valuable knowledge and input from leading
industry experts and
academics.
c. Impending Competitors
Blue Ridge Aquaculture (1)
Blue Ridge Aquaculture is located in Martinsville, Virginia and
operates out of a 100,000
square foot facility. It was founded in 1993 and boasts of being
the world’s largest producer of
tilapia using indoor recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS) (About
us, 2013). “Each year, Blue
Ridge Aquaculture produces 4 million pounds of tilapia, shipping
between 10,000 and 20,000
pounds of live tilapia every day. These fish are raised without the
use of antibiotics or
hormones, and are free of mercury (undetectable levels from
independent studies) and other
industrial pollutants (About us, 2013).”
Blue Ridge Aquaculture is classified as a very threatening
competitor because of its
ambitious strategic growth plans. Currently, Blue Ridge ships an
estimated 75,000 pounds of
live tilapia per week from the facility to distributers in major
metropolitan markets in New York,
Boston, Toronto, and Washington D.C. Since Blue Ridge is located on
the East Coast, it would be
costly to transport live tilapia to markets in California, Izumi
Dai’s target market. However, Blue
Ridge is keeping no secrets when it comes to its desire to
grow.
According to the Blue Ridge’s website, Blue Ridge’s vision is “to
become the leading
domestic producer of high quality seafood using indoor
recirculating aquaculture systems
(RAS). The company plans to accomplish this goal by 1) sequentially
expanding its tilapia
production capacity to 10 million pounds (phase I), then to 100
million pounds (phase II), 2)
developing a fresh fillet product which will provide access to
larger markets, and 3) developing
the production of other species in similar systems (Strategic
growth plans, 2013).”
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 19 | P a g e
The threats posed by Blue Ridge’s strategic expansion plans are
twofold. First, although
specifics are not given regarding the markets into which they wish
to expand, Blue Ridge does
mention that its primary customer base is Asian and Hispanic
individuals (About us, 2013). With
this information in mind and considering that it has a strong
presence on the East Coast, there
is substantial risk that Blue Ridge could expand into Izumi Dai’s
target market in California.
However, even if Blue Ridge does not expand its physical operations
into California, it still
has plans to develop a fresh tilapia fillet product. The purpose of
developing a fillet product is
to “provide access to larger markets.” Distributing fresh fillets
is less capital intensive than
distributing a live product. Thus, without ever setting foot in
California, Blue Ridge could
potentially penetrate Izumi Dai’s California market with its fillet
product.
In either of these scenarios, Izumi Dai strategic advantages would
be significantly
undermined. It would be difficult for Izumi Dai to compete with the
economies of scale
achieved by Blue Ridge. Additionally, Blue Ridge Boasts of 20 years
of experience in the
aquaculture arena. They have had the time to fine tune their
operations as a result of their
extensive industry experience. Izumi Dai’s strategy to
differentiate from foreign imports is
closely aligned to Blue Ridge’s strategy. This means that Izumi Dai
would differentiate solely
based on organic certification, something presently not touted by
Blue Ridge.
Premier Farms (2)
Located in Dallas, Texas, Premier Farms is an aquaponics farming
enterprise that
“combines organic growing practices in controlled ecological
environments (Home, 2011).” The
mission statement of Premier farms is “to grow organic tilapia,
organic Butter/Boston lettuce,
and organic herbs through the utilization of environmental and
ecologically balanced farming
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 20 | P a g e
practices (About our tilapia, 2011).” In 2009, Premier became the
largest organic tilapia
producer in the US, producing a half-million pounds of organic
tilapia per week.
Premier has been categorized as an impending, threatening
competitor because of the
possibility that some of its tilapia output may be entering into
Izumi Dai’s California target
market and that it could possibly expand its operations into
California. Additional threat comes
from its business model, which shares a close resemblance to Izumi
Dai’s model. The only
factor limiting Premier’s ranking to only a level 2 competitor is
its geographical location. Had
Premier been located in California, its ranking would be a very
threatening competitor.
Premier sells a fresh tilapia product, harvesting the fish after
six months of growth at an
average weight of 1-1/4 to 2 pounds. The fish are harvested into
tanker trucks and are then
transported “fresh off the boat” to market (Operations, 2011).
Selling a fresh product limits
Premier’s distribution reach. However, the extent of their
distribution reach remains unknown.
Although efforts were made to acquire this information, Premier did
not share it. At this point,
it can be assumed that cost efficiency would preclude Premier from
distributing a fresh product
in the southern California market.
Regardless of whether they have a large distribution reach or not,
California is a popular
state for tilapia farming, and there is a risk that Premier could
expand its current operations
into California soil. While the largest number of tilapia farms
were located in Hawaii (19 farms)
and Florida (18 farms), California (15 farms) ranked first in sales
(over $8.1 million) (tilapia
profile, 2013). This fact, along with the growing number of
specialty and health food markets in
the area, increases the desirability of the California market and
the probability that Premier
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 21 | P a g e
may use their current operations as a template for expansion into
the California market, putting
them in direct competition with Izumi Dai.
If Premier did expand into the California market, its current
business model would
significantly inhibit Izumi Dai from competing with a
differentiation strategy. Currently, Premier
incorporates integral elements of Izumi Dai’s business model like
automated technologies and
remote management, organic certification and quality, and a fresh
tilapia product rather than a
processed fillet, be it frozen or unfrozen. Furthermore, Premier
promotes its tilapia product as
farmed in the US, boasting strict control and quality standards,
another strategy adopted and
employed by Izumi Dai.
d. Invisible Competitors
Eden Aquaponics (2)
Eden Aquaponics is an aquaponics farm located in Vista, California.
They specialize in
custom system design, fabrication, and installation for residential
and commercial applications.
They also offer instructional classes that teach participants how
to use and maintain an
aquaponic system.
Currently, Eden Aquaponics’ focus is not to farm tilapia for
market, but rather to equip
individuals and businesses with their own aquaponic systems in
order to meet their specific
production needs. As is, this business model does not directly
compete with Izumi Dai’s focus of
tilapia farming, but it could possibly pose potential
threats.
Eden Aquaponics is classified as an invisible competitor because of
its current position as a
manufacturer of custom aquaponic systems and not as a farm focused
on tilapia output. It is
classified as a threatening competitor because of its potential to
compete on a commercial
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 22 | P a g e
scale in tilapia production in Southern California and because its
service allows individuals in
Izumi Dai’s target segment to become protein independent.
If Eden Aquaponics decided to move into large-scale tilapia farming
with its aquaponics
systems, it could possibly have an advantage over Izumi Dai because
of its extensive industry
experience. As an example, Tim Eden, co-founder, “brings over 16
years of farming experience,
over nine years of construction contracting, and over three years
of hydroponic gardening” to
the company (Who are we?, 2013). Additionally, Eden Aquaponics has
market presence, brand
recognition, and goodwill that could work in its favor if it were
ever to diversify from its current
position into a position focused on tilapia production.
Eden Aquaponics’ current offerings indirectly compete with Izumi
Dai by providing
individuals within Izumi Dai’s target segment the means to farm
their own organic tilapia. Their
aquaponics systems appeal to the same health conscious consumers
that Izumi Dai is targeting.
Realizing the increasing trend of DIY (do it yourself), this threat
might continue to increase.
Although not every individual in Izumi Dai’s segment has the means
or desire to purchase,
operate, and maintain an aquaponics system, some may, which would
nullify their need to
purchase such a product from a grocery store.
Sarasota Organic Tilapia Farms (3)
Sarasota Organic tilapia Farms is an organic tilapia farm located
in Sarasota, Florida.
Sarasota operates a tilapia hatchery, “which produces tilapia fry
and tilapia fingerlings available
for fish farms worldwide,” and a grow out section, where tilapia
are raised to market size,
“available locally in the Sarasota, Florida area (About us, 2013).”
Sarasota boasts of the best
tilapia available anywhere. They attribute their high quality to
“using organic, low intensity
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 23 | P a g e
methods” and feeding “them organically with a natural diet high in
omega3 fatty acids (About
us, 2013).”
Sarasota is classified as a competitor because of its working
knowledge of tilapia
aquaculture operations and its potential to expand into other
markets, specifically California.
However, it is regarded as a less threatening, invisible competitor
due to its distant geographic
location and because its primary focus is as a hatchery and not as
a distributor of consumable-
grade tilapia.
California’s health conscious segment is a desirable market for
anyone in the health foods
or organic foods industry. A CNN article states that “Californians
in general tend to have
healthier habits, ranking 10th for physical activity, fourth for
healthy blood pressure and fifth
for a diet high in fruits and vegetables compared with other
states, according to America's
Health Rankings (Park, 2012).” As mentioned earlier, California was
number one in sales with
regards to aquaculture tilapia output. Sarasota’s experience in the
aquaculture industry gives it
a strategic advantage over Izumi Dai if it were to expand into
California. Additional threat
comes from their expert tilapia breeding knowledge.
With their primary focus as a tilapia hatchery, Sarasota prides
itself on breeding three
different tilapia species. Their tilapia are “selectively bred for
body form, color, and growth
rates. Consequently, Sarasota would have a significant advantage in
breeding and stocking
tilapia that were only of the highest quality.
Although its focus is as a hatchery and not as a distributor,
Sarasota does offer wholesale
purchases of its tilapia for local restaurants. With such orders,
the purchaser is responsible for
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 24 | P a g e
pickup of the live, unprocessed fish from Sarasota’s grow out
facility. Minimum order size is
50lbs (Wholesale farm pickup, 2013).
Escondido Tilapia Farm (3)
Little is known about the Escondido tilapia farm. An insightful
commentary regarding
one individual’s visit to the farm is given on an internet blog
site and, other than that, no
additional information can be found (Coburn, 2011).
From the blog post, it appears that the Escondido tilapia farm is a
newer operation with
plans to grow and expand. Some of its operations are rather
innovative. For example, in order
to heat the water used in its tanks, the farm uses a two story high
pile of compost whose
internal temperature stays around 140 degrees Fahrenheit. Through
the center of the compost
pile is coiled a plastic irrigation hose. Water from the fish tanks
is pumped through this hose
which then renters the fish tanks around 80 degrees.
They are classified as a less threatening level 3 competitor
because their focus,
according to the blog entry, is as a hatchery and not a fish to
market farm. With their current
assets and industry knowledge, Escondido tilapia Farm could
possibly diversify into a fish to
market position. At this point, however, it is decided that they
are more of a hobbyist,
backyard operation rather than a commercial operator.
5. Major Competitors and their market share
According to the IBISWorld Industry Report of Fish and Seafood
Aquaculture in the US,
there are no major domestic players in the aquaculture industry.
Consequently, “concentration
in the Fish and Seafood Aquaculture industry is minimal. Many small
operations compete for
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 25 | P a g e
the total market share, with no sole operator cornering more than
5.0% of the total market in
2012 (McBee, 2012, p. 24).”
To illustrate this concept, consider the example of Southern Pride
Catfish, a subsidiary of
American Seafoods Group LLC. Southern Pride Catfish operates a
substantial aquaculture
operation, employing about 775 people and processing more than 80
million pounds of farm-
raised catfish each year. However, it is estimated that Southern
Pride Catfish has a market
share of less than 1% (McBee, 2012).
Southern Pride Catfish’s operations are much more sizable compared
to the competitors
analyzed in this report. The reason for this is because the
competitors analyzed in this report
focus solely on tilapia farming. Thus, with tilapia production
being much smaller in terms of
output and volume compared to that of catfish, it is reasonable to
conclude that the market
share held by the tilapia farming competitors is even smaller than
Southern Pride’s, which is still
less than 1%. Therefore, a market share pie chart or other
graphical depiction would be
extremely difficult to produce and would add little to no insights
into competitor or strategic
analysis.
6. Why is our startup a good idea?
From a progress point of view, we have completed our research and
we are now in pre-
startup mode. If all goes as planned, we believe to be able to
produce our first fish 12 to 18
months from now. For additional information, please refer to our
implementation plan and
timeline in section 12 of this document. Currently we are extending
efforts towards the
engineering components of the initiative. We are documenting
processes, establishing
flowcharts and engineering designs to facilitate construction. We
are also designing a small
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 26 | P a g e
scale trial as a proof of concept. At the same time we are meeting
with potential buyers such
as specialized organic distributors, other aquacultures in the area
as well as potential investors
to cautiously validate some of our ideas. When these action items
have been taken care of,
we’ll be sufficiently informed to calculate break-even point, cost
object pricing, and to establish
a viable implementation strategy.
We believe that starting a tilapia aquaculture in San Diego is a
worthwhile business for the
reasons below:
Humanity currently faces numerous interconnected challenges that
range from the impacts
of the ongoing economic crisis, climate change and extreme weather
events, population
growth, armed conflicts and pollution. All of these challenges
impact food production in
general and fish and seafood aquaculture in particular. According
to the Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations, in 2012 the aquaculture
industry supplied the world with
154 million tons of fish of which 131 million tons (18.4kg per
capita) was destined as food.
While capture fisheries production remains stable, aquaculture
production continues to
develop. Aquaculture is one of the fastest-growing animal
food-producing sectors and, in the
next decade, total production from both capture and aquaculture
will exceed that of beef, pork
or poultry.
US aquaculture generated $1.2B in revenues with profits of $59M.
Because of increasing
seafood demand and falling harvests from wild fishery resources due
to overfishing,
aquaculture products in the US market have significant growth
potential over the coming five
years.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 27 | P a g e
Izumi Dai’s analysis of its competitive environment revealed global
and regional
competition. The global competition comes in the form of imports.
Most of these imports
come from Latin American and South-East Asian countries where labor
costs are low and food-
safety regulations are mostly inexistent. However, incidences in
recent years have spurred
concerns regarding the safety and quality of such products.
Additionally, demand for fish in
those local markets is increasing rapidly due to quick population
growth. As a result, in the US
there is a growing demand for safer, higher-quality, locally farmed
seafood products. This trend
is further confirmed by the rise of retailers such as Whole Foods,
Henry’s, Trader Joe’s, Sprouts
and others that have emerged and expanded substantially during the
past 5 years.
Following key insights from blue ocean strategy (Kim &
Mauborgne, 2005), by looking across
time, Izumi Dai has recognized the market growth, the demand for
healthier fish, and the
increasingly limited imports as an opportunity to develop a blue
ocean strategy and to win the
market space without much fighting (McNeilly, 2013).
b. Tilapia itself
Most tilapia in the U.S. market originate with one of three
species: Blue, Mozambique and
Nile. These species have been cross-bred for many years by farmers
trying to maximize fish
size, cold tolerance, desirability of color variations for the
market place, retention (fillet yield is
30 to 35% of the whole body weight) as well as to reduce cycle
times and disease risks. The
differences between the breeds are minute and along the lines of
point of natural origin or
water temperature requirements. Tilapia is a prolific, invasive
species that can take over a
pond or lake in short order. If cultured together, females will be
half the size of the males (0.75
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 28 | P a g e
lbs vs. 1.5 lbs). Males reach marketable size within 5 to 7 months
from birth (Tank Culture of
Tilapia, June 2009).
Tilapia hold certain characteristics that make them suitable for
tank culture. They can
tolerate the fish stocking density that is essential to the
viability of the business. Their slime
coat protects them better from bacterial infections compared to
other fish. Tilapia’s hardy
nature reduces the need for pesticides, antibiotics, drugs and
other added chemicals. They
grow quickly given good water quality and ample food, but can also
thrive in water of variable
quality. They are omnivorous, in that they can be fed vegetable
matter and/or animal protein.
Fingerlings are produced by the females all year long. This in turn
results in the steady
production of new fish which facilitates a year-round tank
operation.
From a nutrient point of view, tilapia contains unsaturated fat
(1.3 g in 4 oz.), saturated fat
(56 mg in 4 oz.), calcium (11.3% of the daily value), potassium
(10% of the daily value) as well as
a large amount of protein (23 g in 4 oz.) (Banna, 2011).
Given the economic, demographic, political, technological, global,
sociocultural and physical
criteria that define demand as discussed on pages 3-7, Izumi Dai’s
diversification strategy
hinges greatly on tilapia’s health and low technology reproduction
characteristics.
c. Tank Design and Technology
Izumi Dai’s modular flow-through tank design allows for scaling to
meet demand in local
markets. It also allows for quick expansion to new markets or to
scale up production to meet
demand. The design is centered around the concept of intensive tank
culture to continuously
produce high yields on small parcels of land. The smaller,
separate, closed-loop tanks and
modular equipment design approach is contrary to the current mass
production customized
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 29 | P a g e
setups or pond systems. Izumi Dai’s design greatly mitigates costly
disease spread, complex
maintenance and repair, and total kill scenarios.
The company’s tank design includes the use of heterotrophic or
“biofloc” technology
(Avnimelech). Through mixing and aeration the nutrients that would
otherwise collect at the
bottom of the tank are brought to a state of saltation, which makes
them available to the fish
as well as to heterotrophic bacteria. The water exchange is limited
to allow organic residues to
accumulate. This creates an ideal environment for these
protein-rich bacteria to develop
profusely in the water. Research has indicated that the application
of biofloc technology
reduces external feed requirements to up to 70%, which represents
substantial cost savings to
the company. Another benefit is the reduction of toxic residues
such as sulphides and
ammonia in the water. This translates to energy savings related to
pumping, oxygenation, and
filtering compared to a regular system in which the volume of water
in the tank is completely
replaced every 90 to 120 minutes. Finally, fish growth and
intensification are positively affected
by biofloc technology and so is Izumi Dai’s bottom line.
Additionally, given the industry’s minimal use of technology, Izumi
Dai’s strategy relies on a
competitive advantage that reduces expensive manual labor through
the implementation of
automated SCADA systems which would control feeding stations,
temperature and water
quality control as well as alarms. The system would be augmented
with day/night cameras and
configured to escalate alarm notifications from onsite personnel to
offsite stakeholders by
phone, text and/or email. Control system parameters can be
monitored centrally on a
dashboard website. System configuration changes can be implemented
on the fly locally or
remotely over the internet.
d. Organic, Halal, Kosher and Made in America
Research has indicated that psychographics surrounding tilapia and
recirculating
aquaculture systems have improved with our target demographic.
Product quality and demand
creation are central to our strategy. We aim to reach beyond
existing demand (3rd principle of
blue ocean strategy) through finer segmentation by tailoring our
offering to better meet
customer preferences for high quality healthy fish. In order to
differentiate ourselves from the
cheap, low quality imports, we intend to brand the product with the
tag line “Made in
America”. In addition, research has indicated that organic, local
farm fresh products have
gained in popularity within agricultural products in Southern
California. Izumi Dai’s plans to
leverage this new trend by breeding fish without pesticides,
herbicides, and artificial additives.
The company will comply with organic production standards regarding
breeding, processing,
storing, packaging and shipping to ensure organic certification by
the US Department of
Agriculture and CCOF (About CCOF Organic Certification,
2013).
Additionally, we intend to apply for Kosher certification by
committing to the Jewish laws of
shechita and nikkur. These laws involve habitat, slaughter
practices, and animal feed mostly.
Given that the Jewish laws don’t represent a departure from Izumi
Dai’s planned operational
processes, obtaining Kosher certification would be achievable with
minimal efforts.
The company’s strategic plan also intends to follow Islamic law to
achieve Halal, which
means permissible. In this context, Halal relates mostly to the
packaging of the fish so that
Muslims are permitted to consume the animal. Since Muslims must eat
halal food regardless of
price (unless not available), Izumi Dai’s fish would have an
advantage compared to the less
expensive imported tilapia.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 31 | P a g e
The organic seal, Hechsher seal, and Halal seal would be applied to
the product packaging
to raise customer awareness.
Given Izumi Dai’s aspirations to certify and label its “healthy”
fish (while avoiding enological
terminology to keep things simple), the company has decided to
minimize customers making
trade-offs across less expensive alternative industries by
competing largely on feelings as our
appeal to buyers is emotional. This strategy represents a blue
ocean in Southern California
because the competition consists of low quality imports from
dubious origin (Kim &
Mauborgne, 2005). Compared to what’s available on the market today,
Izumi Dai’s offering
represents a leap in value which will rapidly earn brand buzz and a
loyal following in the
marketplace (Kim & Mauborgne, 2005). Additionally, this
strategy erects barriers to imitation
as well.
e. Production method: inexpensive energy
Izumi Dai intends to go far beyond its competitor Escondido tilapia
Farm’s use of horse
manure and compost to generate inexpensive farm energy. Hansen
International is making the
manure available to us ubiquitously at no cost beyond pick-up labor
and transportation. We
plan to acquire inexpensive steel shipping containers that are
readily available due to the trade
imbalance between the US and Asia. Shipyards sell these for
approximately $2,500 each.
These containers would be filled with horse manure (and farm waste)
and laced with water
hoses to collect heat. The hermetically sealed containers would be
painted black to attract
heat. They would also be transformed to allow for easy access at
the top and other surface
areas per our proprietary engineering design. The naturally
occurring anaerobic digestion of
the manure by microorganisms would yield energy in the form of heat
and methane, also called
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 32 | P a g e
biogas. Biogas consists of 60 percent methane and 40 percent carbon
dioxide. It burns cleanly,
thus greatly reducing or eliminating the need at the farm for
fossil fuels that produce harmful
greenhouse gases. Biogas would be collected in tanks and used for
electricity generation
(Youtube; Frishberg).
In addition, the water from the aquaculture would be recirculated
through the containers
for heat exchange purposes as well. When the manure has decomposed
to levels of
diminishing returns with regards to energy creation (the organic
nitrogen has been converted
to ammonia) it can be removed from the process and used or sold as
fertilizer.
Our startup’s innovative ideas make the process attractive for
waste management
compliance, especially given the strict California laws regulating
odor, groundwater
contamination, and greenhouse gases. After some time, we might even
become “Green
Business Certified” by the SBA and/or others so that we can apply
the “Eco label” to our
products (Green certification and ecolabeling). Such action would
add to the buyer’s emotional
perception of Izumi Dai as a better choice.
f. Production method: inexpensive organic feed
In nature tilapia will feed mostly on plankton and detritus. The
industrial production of
tilapia in controlled aquaculture environments requires the use of
commercial fish feed. The
use of 40-50% protein feeds increases fish growth up to tenfold
compared to fish bred in ponds
where no supplement feed was given. At $6 per pound, certified
organic pellet fish food for
tilapia that consists of 31% protein is very expensive. Feed cost
is especially relevant when
realizing that each fish requires a daily feed intake of 2-5% of
its body weight. Tilapia’s feed
conversion is at about 2 lbs of feed per pound of gain.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 33 | P a g e
In order to control feed cost, our startup intends to use the
decomposed horse manure as
the main ingredient to feed a renewable source of animal protein
(red worms) in a closed-loop
system (Rasing earth worms, 2013). The only elements of concern for
a red worm habitat are
moisture and temperature. They are very easy to breed and can
double their population every
90 days. They eat half their weight each day which further
processes the horse manure to a
high quality fertilizer (soil humus) that could be resold at
premium pricing (Humus-the
foundation of living soil, 2006). We intend to purchase rice and/or
other inexpensive organic
plant-based feeds to balance the tilapia’s diet to reach maximum
yield.
Izumi Dai’s use of SCADA technology, biogas and horse manure
byproducts to keep costs
low represents a substantial competitive advantage (entry barrier)
towards the company’s local
competition. At the same time, the company’s cost strategy brings
its product pricing closer to
the low quality imports which simplifies the consumer’s decision to
buy our products.
7. Our current and projected strategy
Izumi Dai intends to leverage its tangible and intangible assets,
its capabilities and core
competencies to obtain a competitive advantage and long-term
strategic competitiveness.
As discussed in the previous section, Izumi Dai has free access to
large amounts of horse
manure that can be used for a variety of cost reducing practices.
Other tangible assets that are
currently in our possession are computer equipment, vehicles,
machines, and land in sufficient
quantity for the company’s proof of concept. Intangible assets are
the company partner’s core
capabilities such as newly gained business management knowledge,
our professional
experience in the fields of engineering, technology, and farming,
as well as software necessary
to run back-of-house administration functions.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 34 | P a g e
Izumi Dai’s disruptive strategy of “Organic, Halal and Kosher and
Made in America”
product certification enables a narrow market segment focus. This
initial focused
differentiation will further distinguish the company from its
competitors regarding customer
value.
Soon after inception, we anticipate demand to increase beyond the
aquacultures’
maximum annual output. At that time the company will reinvest
profits towards swift
expansion into other premium markets by leveraging our unique
modular aquaculture design
and technology.
As Izumi Dai’s footprint increases, the company will require a
broader market to sell its
products. The company’s strategy will gradually shift towards cost
leadership thanks to
economies of scale by reaching the highest levels of efficiency in
high cost categories such as
feed, energy, and labor. Reaching a cost leadership position in the
US market space will be
beneficial in the long run given previously described economic
factors, as well as the ongoing
ecological degradation of water quality in Asia and South America.
In short, the projected
increase in demand for healthy sources of animal protein in the US
ensures a successful
outcome for aquaculture companies that are able to produce large
quantities of fish at
affordable pricing to the middle class.
8. An update on your selected competitor since the case
ended.
In light of the market share data discussed earlier in this report,
a single competitor will
not be selected. Instead, imports, representing both frozen and
fresh tilapia, will be
consolidated and categorized as a single competitor, although this
category will be comprised
of various farms from different countries. The logic behind this
choice is that it is near
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 35 | P a g e
impossible to identify any one, single competitor because of the
minimal concentration and
high fragmentation of the competitive landscape.
The bulk of frozen tilapia imports come from China, while Latin
American countries with
a closer proximity to the US dominate the fresh tilapia import
market. Although the products
from these countries are cheaper because of the low cost of labor
and less stringent regulatory
policies, recent incidences have led to growing concerns regarding
the safety of the seafood
products produced in these countries.
One such startling and recent example is published in Bloomberg
Businessweek.
According to the article, the tilapia at an aquaculture farm
located in China’s Guangdong
province are fed partly with feces from hundreds of pigs and geese.
These same fish are
purchased by exporters and sold to US companies. “This practice is
dangerous for American
consumers, says Michael Doyle, director of the University of
Georgia’s Center for Food Safety.
The manure the Chinese use to feed fish is frequently contaminated
with microbes like
salmonella,” says Doyle, who has studied foodborne diseases in
China (Uyen & Bi, 2012).” The
article explains that this is not an isolated incident. In fact, a
purportedly growing number of
farmers are adopting this practice in order to cut costs because of
competition, with some
farmers abandoning commercial feed entirely and switching over to
feces. The FDA only
inspects about 2.7% of food imported into the US. Since 2007, the
FDA has rejected 820
Chinese seafood shipments, 187 of which contained tilapia (Uyen
& Bi, 2012).
Similarly undesirable farming conditions have been practiced in
Latin American
countries, where the bulk of fresh tilapia imports to the US come
from. One practice of concern
is farming tilapia in lakes or ponds where the fish excrement is
unable to be filtered out or
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 36 | P a g e
removed, thus polluting the water. Dr. Jeffrey McCrary, an American
fish biologist who works
in Nicaragua said, “We wouldn’t allow tilapia to be farmed in the
United States the way they
are farmed here, so why are we willing to eat them (Rosenthal,
2011)?”
Further concerns are raised from tilapia’s invasive nature.
Reportedly, tilapia has
“squeezed out native species in lakes throughout the world with its
aggressive breeding and
feeding (Rosenthal, 2011).” In the US, the use of cages to farm
tilapia in lakes is generally
forbidden. If tilapia escape from their enclosures, then they can
potentially destroy the existing
ecosystem within the lake or pond, as was the case with Lake Apoyo
in Nicaragua. When the
tilapia escaped from the cages, they consumed an aquatic plant
called charra, which the other
fish fed off of. As a result, some species of plants and fish that
once inhabited the lake are now
extinct.
With more health concerns and disturbing stories regarding
aquaculture operations
coming to light, foreign farmers are growing more conscientious
with regards to their farming
practices. The importers current and projected strategy focuses on
strengthening consumer
confidence by qualifying for accreditation from industry watchdogs.
Such certifications are
received by complying with specific standards which require farmers
to adopt environmentally
responsible farming practices.
Regal Springs, which operates tilapia farms in Mexico, Honduras,
and Indonesia, is one
such importer who is employing this strategy. Regal Springs
tilapia’s Honduras plant has been
awarded the Global Aquaculture Alliances Best Aquaculture Practices
(BAP) certification (Regal
Springs Honduras Farm Receives BAP Certification, 2013). They are
also the first fish farm to be
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 37 | P a g e
certified by the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC).Such
certifications and practices help
aquaculture farms and processors to do business with large
corporate customers like Costco
(Rosenthal, 2011).
Similar initiatives are improving farming conditions in Chinese
aquaculture farms. In
2012, the ASC began work in China with the objective of “developing
more sustainable methods
of tilapia farming (ASC to help China tilapia farming, 2012).” The
project was planned to last
two years. Its three primary objectives are: first, to make more
details on the tilapia supply
chain in China available; second, to introduce ASC standards to
China and encourage Chinese
tilapia producers to seek ASC certification; and third, drum up
public and consumer support for
ASC-certified tilapia from China (ASC to help China tilapia
farming, 2012).
10a. Izumi Dai Growth-Share Matrix
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 38 | P a g e
Izumi Dai will have an initial focused product of fresh, organic
tilapia. Tilapia
consumption in the US is increasing steadily and will continue to
increase. Izumi Dai and similar
domestic aquaculture firms use the live fish market with higher
market price to circumvent the
Asian and South American importers with low-price, frozen tilapia
fillets. Increasing market
share is critical to moving into the “Star” investment quadrant, as
the industry growth is
expected to continue to increase domestic supply.
Growing demand in developing nations may reduce the supply of
imported tilapia.
Izumi Dai will penetrate the mass frozen fillet market when import
supply decreases and thus
price increases. Operations will need to support not only live
fish, but increase production and
invest in processing and packaging for frozen tilapia. By
increasing the frozen fillet market share
captured from imports Izumi Dai will realize “Cash Cow”
conditions.
10b. Our competitor’s growth-share matrix
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 39 | P a g e
Chinese tilapia farms process and export tilapia to the US in
frozen whole and fillet
portions. In addition to supporting US fish demand, the Chinese
aquaculture industry is seeing
an increase in Chinese domestic demand. Exported US frozen fillets
are currently “Cash Cows”.
Low labor and low regulation allow imports to dominate the US
market share. As more South
American and African aquaculture programs are established, the
market share will decrease
towards the “Dog” quadrant. Chinese farms may see the opportunity
of live or fresh regional
tilapia as more attractive and move the Domestic tilapia category
from “Star” to “Cash Cow”.
With this move, Izumi Dai will attempt to secure US market
share.
11. Critical resources, strengths, core capabilities, core
competencies, and
weaknesses
The competitive analysis in this thesis has identified the imports
from China and South
America as our main competitor. Other competitors described in this
paper represent an
estimated 1% of US tilapia market share only.
Izumi Dai versus overseas imports Izumi Dai Overseas imports
Critical Resources Modular tank des ign, SCADA Technology (1)
Acces s to inexpensive labor (1) Access to inexpensive feed (1)
Access to offshore processors (1)
Strengths
3 MBA students with proven profess ional track records (2) Easy
access to intellectual capital (2) Low local competition (2) 37
million potential consumers locally (2) Made in San Diego (1)
Mas s production and cos t leadership (1) Minimal regulatory
requirements (1) Existing distribution channels (1)
Core Capabilities “Green” energy and feed
Their ability to manage the individual components of the process
from start to finish
C ore Competencies
High volume production
Weaknesses
Price point much higher than imports (3) Reliance on technology (2)
Startup issues: seed funding, dis tribution, plant, equipment,
property, no client-base (3) Need 12-18 months to s tart the
company (2) Never done this before (1) Psychographics (3)
Regulatory requirements and compliance (3) Low volume production
(3)
Inability to provide fresh, organic to the US market (1)
Psychographics of cheap imports from ques tionable origin (3)
Increas ing demand for Tilapia in the respective local markets
affects their ability to supply to the US in sufficient quantities
(3) Water pollution (2) Rising labor rates (2) Reliance on
inexpensive labor (1) Dis tance to market / carbon footprint (2)
Low technology (3) Red ocean (3)
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 40 | P a g e
Izumi Dai versus the weaknesses of overseas imports
Izumi Dai Overseas imports (WEAKNESSES)
Critical Resources Modular tank des ign, SCADA Technology (1)
Rising labor rates (2) Reliance on inexpensive labor (1) Low
technology (3)
Strengths
3 MBA s tudents with proven profes sional track records (2)
Easy access to intellectual capital (2) Low local competition (2)
37 million potential consumers locally (2) Made in San Diego
(1)
Increas ing demand for Tilapia in the respective local markets
affects their ability to supply to the US in sufficient quantities
(3) Psychographics of cheap imports from ques tionable origin
(3)
C ore Capabilities
“Green” energy and feed Water pollution (2) Dis tance to market /
carbon footprint (2)
Core Competencies
Fresh, Organic, Halal, Kosher Cons is tent proprietary genetic s
train
Inability to provide fresh, organic to the US market (1) Red ocean
(3)
Izumi Dai’s weaknesses versus overseas imports
Overseas imports Izumi Dai (WEAKNESSES)
Critical Resources
Access to inexpensive labor (1) Access to inexpensive feed (1)
Access to offshore processors (1)
Reliance on technology (2) Startup is s ues : s eed funding,
distribution, plant, equipment, property, no client-base (3)
Strengths
Mass production and cost leaders hip (1) Minimal regulatory
requirements (1) Existing dis tribution channels (1)
Price point much higher than imports (3) Regulatory requirements
and compliance (3) Need 12-18 months to s tart the company (2)
Psychographics (3)
C ore Capabilities
Their ability to manage the individual components of the process
from start to finish Never done this before (1)
Core Competencies
12. External threats and opportunities in this industry
Opportunities in the eatable fish market sector favor the organic
sustainable product
strategy of Izumi Dai. Changes in consumer habits, global
environments, and natural food
stocks create an immediate need for innovation and growth in the
aquaculture industry.
a. Opportunity - Changes in consumer habits (2):
The US Millennial generation, born between 1982 and 2001, differ in
their food buying
habits from older generations. Millennials are willing to spend
more on fresh, organic, and
healthy food (How 'Millennials' Are Changing Food as We Know It,
2012). Processed and canned
foods are falling out of favor with Millennials who are starting
families and entering into careers
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 41 | P a g e
after schooling. Izumi Dai believes the buy local and organic trend
will grow and steadily
increase fresh tilapia demand. This benefits local aquaculture,
agriculture and aquaponic
companies.
b. Opportunity - Natural fish stocks decreasing (1):
Lower ocean food stocks are at the root of the initial aquaculture
interest from Izumi Dai
team members. Global populations are growing and the per person
fish consumption is
increasing as well. With nearly 85% of global fish stocks
over-exploited, depleted, fully exploited
or in recovery from exploitation, the global population will need
to increase alternative fish
stocks to maintain natural ecosystems (Vince, 2012). In addition,
man-made and natural
disasters are affecting natural fish stocks. Oil spills, El Niño’s
and climate change, along with
hydraulic fracturing pollution are wiping out lake, river, and
coastal environments natural
ecosystems. As a result of decreasing natural food stocks, the
aquaculture industry was
expected to increase 4.6% in 2012 (McBee, 2012).
c. Opportunity - Technology reducing labor (3):
Increased off the shelf technology with internet integration is
changing the way Izumi
Dai is approaching the traditional aquaculture labor resources. Our
research shows that few
competitors have adopted such an off the shelf strategy.
Innovations in residential pond
equipment, home reef aquarium alarm and control systems, as well as
SCADA industrial control
systems will allow Izumi Dai to reduce traditional fish labor
resources. Fish grow out oversight,
including water quality parameters, feeding, and alerts will be
recorded and modified by
automated systems with visible dashboards available to stakeholders
over the internet. Izumi
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 42 | P a g e
Dai will move the saved labor to auxiliary support tasks, which
allow for the vertical integration
of the feed and hatchery operations.
d. External Threat - Regulation and labeling (1):
Izumi Dai’s major differentiator with the major import market is
organic, hormone, and
chemical free. Research indicates no major governmental or academic
agencies monitor the
labeling and claims or organic and hormone use in aquaculture.
Izumi Dai believes tilapia
importers, as well as US competitors, may use the organic and
hormone-free labels without
oversight, thus nullifying a major marketing effort. Izumi Dai will
work with academics and food
agencies to propose and construct food practice oversight in
aquaculture.
e. External Threat - Adjacent aquaponic industry (3):
Aquaponics is a related field to aquaculture. By taking the
effluent from fish populations
and using plants to filter out organic waste, aquaponic operations
produce both fish and plants.
With the organic and fresh food opportunity described in the above
section, Izumi Dai may be
challenged by a stronger, locally grown marketing scheme and
perceived to be more “green”.
Izumi Dai is not initially interested in aquaponics, as the
tradeoffs between fish and plant
population would reduce the density and capacity of fish
production.
f. External Threat - Distribution channels (2):
Farmed tilapia imports, as well as ocean-caught fish, have mature
distribution channels
already in place. High volume grocery chains and restaurants
typically contract food distributors
and do not allow independent suppliers, which overlap with
distributor products. Distributors
of course will stock products that will allow high margins and have
consistent dependable
supply chains. With the low labor costs and economies of scale
farmed imports have
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 43 | P a g e
unbeatable prices, in order for Izumi Dai to break into
distribution it must first work
independently to distribute product and build branding until
distributor clients ask for organic
local tilapia.
Figure 2: Strategic Canvas for the Industry
Izumi Dai created a strategic canvas which covers 6 attributes of
an aquaculture firm:
ease of buying, supply chain risk, responsiveness, health
conscious, sustainability, and price.
The attributes were given values from low to high based on
producing tilapia and selling them
in the southern California region. The players who received values
were Izumi Dai, in the initial
production years, Blue Ridge Aquaculture, a major, large-scale US
aquaculture competitor, and
an East Asian importer of frozen tilapia.
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 44 | P a g e
Ease of buying is defined by the number of point of sale locations
to consumers. Izumi
Dai will initially have a low footprint of retail locations. This
will be a large challenge for Izumi
Dai. Blue Ridge aquaculture was low to moderate ease of buying, due
to limited geographical
range. They have a large portfolio of locations in the Midwest and
East. We believe their
national connections would give them an advantage in Southern
California. Asian importers
have a high ease of buying, as frozen fillets can be packaged by
multiple distributors and
transported through a wide network of buyers.
Tilapia supply chain risk includes supplier product flaws, and
timing and inventory issues
which can affect fish production and quality. Izumi Dai has a low
supply chain risk. By investing
in self-grown sustainable feed, off the shelf equipment, and
tilapia breeding, the exposure to
risk from suppliers is low and internally managed. Blue Ridge has a
moderate supply chain risk
with its large operation. Unique, large-scale filtration systems
are believed to be used along
with commercial feed. Asian importers have a high supply chain risk
based on downstream
partners including shipping and distributors. Packaging and
shipping across the Pacific, along
with lead times, adds risk to the quality and distribution to
customers.
Responsiveness evaluates the time it takes to adjust to customer
requests including
packaging and quantity. Izumi Dai has a moderate responsiveness
score. This is attributed to
the fact that the modular tank systems can be scaled with demand,
although an upper limit for
initial capacity exists. Time to market is low as Izumi Dai is
close to local markets and
customers. Blue Ridge aquaculture has a high responsiveness with
its large production capacity
and experience in growing production levels and distribution. Asian
importers have a low
BA-690 Strategic Management Thesis: Tilapia Farming in
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems 45 | P a g e
responsiveness rating due to long lead times and their model of
offloading frozen fish at full
capacity to lower prices.
Health conscious is a rating assessing the consumer expectation of
pollution and
chemical free, hormone-free, safe and nutritious fish. Izumi Dai
has a high health conscious
rating. Marketed as organic and hormone-free, Izumi Dai will make
quality the differentiator
with imports. Blue Ridge Aquaculture also received a high rating
for health conscious, since it is
marketed as hormone and pollutant free. Feed sources are not
revealed publically. Asian
importers received a low health conscious score. Importers have
been discovered to have
poor, unregulated tilapia raising conditions with measured
pollutant levels found in their fish
(Barboza, 2007).
Sustainability is the effect of the tilapia farm on the
environment, balance of resource
inputs and reuse of outputs. Izumi Dai rated high in sustainability
due to plans to create a
sustainable food source, thus eliminating the demand for protein
feed. Blue Ridge rated
moderate to high. Like Izumi Dai, Blue Ridge uses the recirculating
aquaculture model to
reduce water usage. However, it is unclear whether Blue Ridge uses
a sustainable feed source
or relies on commercial protein feed, which commonly consists of
fishmeal. Asian importers
received a low sustainability score since they typically use
outdoor pond setups which utilize
large amounts of water and runoff. Antibiotic and hormone use have
unknown effects on the
natural ecosystem. Price is the fillet gate price per pound. Izumi
Dai has