Photo
6.10.2014
Federation of Tax Administrators Cathy Cleek | CIO FTB Project Management Professional (PMP)
Tips for Successful IT Projects
Federation of Tax Administrators
Objectives for Today
1. Understand Why are Projects so Hard 2. Tips for successful projects
3. What should I do as a Executive Sponsor? • Cathy’s Top Five Lists for Executive Sponsors
2
Federation of Tax Administrators
3
Why are Projects so Hard?
Federation of Tax Administrators
4
¡ Solving a problem that you’ve had for years ¡ New work vs. something you’ve done before ¡ Reengineering of Business Processes
¡ New teams working together
¡ Vendor & State; State IT & State Business ¡ New roles for many people
¡ Timeboxed ¡ Many parallel activities ¡ Business needs change over time
Why are Projects So Hard?
Federation of Tax Administrators
State of Project Management
¡ Successful Projects -- 40% ¡ Challenged Projects -- 30% ¡ Failed Projects -- 30%
Source : 2009 Center for Project Management 5
Federation of Tax Administrators
State of Project Management
¡ Most things eventually get done, but: -- Not in the right sequence -- Not by the right people -- Not in the right detail -- Not by the right time -- Not at the right cost ¡ Results: High Challenge/Failure rate on projects Lots of stress for those involved
6
Federation of Tax Administrators
Tips for Successful Projects
7
Federation of Tax Administrators
Project Management Phases
.
Phases and Resources Usage
8
Initiate Plan Execute/Control Close
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
9
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
Ini
. “You’ve got to be very careful if you don’t know where you are going because you might not get there.” – Yogi Berra
- YU10
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
In Tip 1: Start by identifying what the project is really about. -- What problem are you really trying to solve? -- What is your project vision? -- What are your objectives?
. 11
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
Ini
. 12
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
13
Tip 2: Evaluate how ready your organization is to make the needed change. --You will have issues & problems. Who is ready to “go the extra mile” to make the project happen? --Change is hard for people & activities are usually not fully funded --Get buy in from customers and stakeholders.
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
ni Tip 4: Projects are joint ventures. Get ready to say “I do” “til death do we part”
IT/Business “Marriage” Vendor/Department
“Marriage” Divorce is ugly, stressful,
and costly! .
14
Federation of Tax Administrators
Federation of Tax Administrators
Scenarios
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
. 17
Federation of Tax Administrators
Initiate
Ini Tip 5: Have common objectives where ever possible ¡ Vendor payment based upon business outcomes
¡ Additional revenue for State ¡ Additonal webhits for new/improved functions
¡ Penalty relief ¡ Management Performance Payments
. 18
Federation of Tax Administrators
Plan
. 19
Federation of Tax Administrators
Plan
20 Without planning, everything is left to chance.
Federation of Tax Administrators
If I had eight hours to chop down a tree, I'd spend six hours sharpening my ax.
--Abe Lincoln
Plan
21
Federation of Tax Administrators
.
Plan
HOPE
is not a
PLAN
22
Federation of Tax Administrators
Plan
Tip 6: Project Planning is Important – Give the Team Adequate Time.
. 23
Federation of Tax Administrators
Plan
Define Murphy’s Law: ________________________________________________ ________________________________________________ Define Parkinson’s Law: ________________________________________________ ________________________________________________ Murphy’s Law + Parkinson’s Law = ________________________________________________
. 24
Federation of Tax Administrators
Plan
Tip 7: LARGE projects/implementations are harder than small projects/implementations,
Break it up.
¡ Prototype ¡ Phases, Waves ¡ Crawl. Walk. Run
.
25
Federation of Tax Administrators
Plan
Tip 8: Plan but surprises are on the way – count on it and be prepared to make course corrections.
. 26
Federation of Tax Administrators
Execute
27
Federation of Tax Administrators
Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships.
- Michael Jordan
Execute
28
Federation of Tax Administrators
Execute Tip 9: Requirements sign off is one of the most important decisions
you make.
. 29
Federation of Tax Administrators
Execute
Tip 10: Look for ways to reduce the risk at each implementations.
“Risk in itself is not bad; risk is essential to progress, and
failure is often a part of learning. But we must learn to balance the possible negative consequences of risk.”
- Van Scoy, 1992
. 30
Federation of Tax Administrators
Tip 11: Communication is difficult ¡ Communication channels = [n (n-1)]/2 n = number of members on the team
¡ 2 people = 1 channel ¡ 5 people = 10 channels ¡ 20 people = 190 channels ¡ 100 people = 4950 channels ¡ 400 people = 78,000 channels
¡ Communication: 10% words, 30% visual, 60% body language
¡ Executives: Start with conclusion! One page summary. .
Execute
31
Federation of Tax Administrators
Execute
32
Communication -- Vocabulary
Federation of Tax Administrators
Control
Green = On Schedule Yellow = Behind but have agreed upon plan so will be on schedule at next review Red = Behind and no agreed upon plan 33
Communication -- Status
Federation of Tax Administrators
Control
34
Federation of Tax Administrators
Execute
35
Federation of Tax Administrators
Execute Tip 10: Value good process. Without a process, work activity
is adhoc and not repeatable. T
. 36
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3 Step 4
Step 5
Federation of Tax Administrators
Control
37
Federation of Tax Administrators
And we’d like one final change…
We’d like Ronald Reagan instead of Teddy Roosevelt.
- Project Client!
Control
38
Federation of Tax Administrators
Control Tip 13: Scope must be controlled if you ever want to finish!
. 39
Federation of Tax Administrators
Control Tip 14: Use lessons learned! Or you will have lessons “relearned.”
. 40
Federation of Tax Administrators
Close
. 41
Federation of Tax Administrators
Close
Tip 15: Celebrate accomplishments along the way ¡ Hot dog lunch celebrations ¡ Cake & Punch ¡ Met goal—entire team took week off on vacation! ¡ Hat day, Yellow day ¡ Picnic—for staff and family ¡ Peer Celebrations—Certificate “you rock”, “thanks for
making a difference” notes, e-cards ¡ Candy bars for all– “Crunch bars” .
42
Federation of Tax Administrators
I’d rather regret the things I have done than the things I have not.
-Lucille Ball
Close
43
Federation of Tax Administrators
Cathy’s Top Five Lists for Executive Sponsors
44
Federation of Tax Administrators
Top Five Signs a Project Is In Trouble
1. Client/vendor relationship is deteriorating
2. Schedule delays push one or more major milestones
3. High turnover of key staff and/or high volume of staff vacancies
4. Oversight vendor findings and project issues/risks remain open for extended periods
5. Significant data quality issues surface when new functionality is implemented
. 45
Federation of Tax Administrators
1. Workload impacts on the department and the effect on critical processing timeframes
2. Data quality (either newly captured or converted) and the impact on new and legacy systems
3. External interfaces (batch or online) especially with other organizations
4. Thoroughness of implementation planning (ramp up plans) and contingency planning (roll back plans)
5. Production – speed (key for large states), accuracy, and workarounds
.
Top Five Areas to Watch For
46
Federation of Tax Administrators
Top Five “To Dos” for Executive Sponsors
1. Create an environment where candid and honest dialog is the norm - encourage “bad news” early
2. Be strategic - you’ll have the solution for 15+ years
3. Drive change and challenge the status quo
4. Make timely decisions and remove barriers for the project team
5. Ask Project Managers what you can do to help
.
47
Federation of Tax Administrators
Top Five Things to Know When Working With Vendors
1. Everyone has a boss - always know the team’s management chain (names/phone numbers) all the way up to the CEO
2. Know what motivates your vendor – (e.g. good reference, lasting client relationships, new revenue, getting paid timely)
3. Know quarter & fiscal year end dates - actions by these dates can be used as leverage points
4. Communicate clearly and often - be consistent about your top risks, pain points and expectations
5. Know your contracts – your responsibilities & the vendors
. 48
Federation of Tax Administrators
Top Five Things Experienced Executive Sponsors Know
1. Everyone wants to report the project is “green”
2. The following words mean your team is behind: Ø effort words vs result words Ø ‘they’ vs ‘we’
3. Ask for trends - history tends to repeat itself
4. Surprises are on the way – count on it and be prepared to make course corrections
5. Tradeoffs are an unavoidable component of the Project (aka Project Management Matrix )
. 49
Federation of Tax Administrators
Project Management Matrix
Functionality (Scope)
Time Resources/$
Quality
50
Federation of Tax Administrators
Key Take Aways
• Be clear about what you want to achieve on your project. You and your entire team should know. • Have common goals with vendor. • Work to ensure a healthy relationship is present with IT, vendor, oversight groups, and business community. • Start change management activities now. • Ensure tough decisions get made in a timely manner.
51
Federation of Tax Administrators
Your Key Take Aways
• ______________________________________________ • ______________________________________________
• ______________________________________________
52
Federation of Tax Administrators
Questions
53